Documentos de Académico
Documentos de Profesional
Documentos de Cultura
www.elsevier.es/rx
HUMANITIES IN RADIOLOGY
KEYWORDS Abstract Marie Curie was born in Warsaw in1867. She graduated first in her class in her under-
Radiology; graduate programs in physics and mathematics at Sorbonne University, and she was one of the
X-rays; first women to earn a PhD. She was the first woman to win a Nobel prize (in physics, together
Radiography; with her husband, Pierre Curie), and she was also the first person to win a second Nobel prize
First World War in another category (chemistry).
Her life is an example of dedication to science based on altruism, personal growth, and
tenacity. Being the first woman to break through so many barriers in a totally male-dominated
science makes her an emblematic figure in the fight for equal opportunities and human rights.
This article reviews her most important contributions to science in general and to diagnostic
radiology in particular through her participation in the French military’s radiological plan during
the First World War.
© 2021 SERAM. Published by Elsevier España, S.L.U. All rights reserved.
PALABRAS CLAVE Marie Curie: Cómo romper el techo de cristal en la ciencia y en la radiología
Radiología;
Rayos X; Resumen Marie Curie nació en Varsovia en 1867, se licenció en Física y Matemáticas en la
Radiografía; Universidad de la Sorbona, siendo la primera de su promoción, y fue una de las primeras mujeres
Primera Guerra en tener un doctorado. Fue la primera mujer en ganar un premio Nobel, en Física, junto a su
Mundial marido Pierre Curie, y también la primera persona en obtener un segundo Nobel y en otra
categoría: Química.
Su vida es un ejemplo de dedicación a la ciencia desde el altruismo, de superación personal
y tenacidad. Fue la primera mujer en romper tantas barreras, en una ciencia hasta entonces
masculina, que su figura constituye un hito en la lucha por la igualdad de oportunidades y los
derechos humanos.
夽 Please cite this article as: Sánchez-Oro R, Torres Nuez J, Fatahi Bandpey ML, Martínez-Sanz G. Marie Curie: Cómo romper el techo de
cristal en la ciencia y en la radiología. Radiología. 2021;63:456---465.
∗ Corresponding author.
2173-5107/© 2021 SERAM. Published by Elsevier España, S.L.U. All rights reserved.
Radiología 63 (2021) 456---465
Origins, childhood and youth It was also founded by a woman: teacher, writer and activist
Jadwiga Szczawinska-Dawidowa.3
Maria Sklodowska-Curie was born in Warsaw on 7 Novem- As the name suggests, the Flying University was con-
ber 1867 and spent her entire childhood in that city, then stantly relocating its clandestine classrooms, hidden in
occupied by Imperial Czarist Russia. Since 1795, Poland had private homes, as a risky form of resistance to suffocating
ceased to exist as a state. The internal destabilisation of the Russian cultural oppression. The university taught classes
Commonwealth of Nations that it had upheld with Lithuania in Polish and instilled in its students ideas such as gender
for two centuries gave way to anarchy and territorial vulner- equality in education and abolition of class privileges. This
ability. After several partitions, it was ultimately annexed, institution taught thousands of students without resources
carved up and distributed among Russia, Austria and Prussia. and, in particular, women who had no other access to higher
The Russian Czarist regime exercised despotic power over education. The Flying University and the courage of its
the Polish population, whose autonomy was reduced to a instructors had a great impact on Maria, in particular on
minimum; efforts were even made to wipe the country’s the development of her intellectual and philosophical ide-
name off the map and replace it with Vistula Land. The Polish ology, helping to shape an enlightened and positivist spirit
language was forbidden, and Russian was imposed as the of activism for equal opportunities, without discrimination
language of administration, justice and secondary school.1 based on class or gender.4
With this attempt at cultural assimilation, a strong Pol- In other countries in Europe, universities as illustrious as
ish nationalist sentiment arose with historicist and religious Sorbonne University in Paris, the University of Edinburgh and
(Catholicism) hallmarks deeply rooted in intellectuals and the Martin Luther University of Halle-Wittenberg had barely
the middle classes, including the Sklodowski family. begun to accept women. Sorbonne University, founded in
Maria was the youngest of five siblings. Her mother, Bro- 1257 by Robert de Sorbonne and reformed by Cardinal Riche-
nislawa, studied education and came to direct an important lieu, did not open the doors of its then five faculties to
boarding school for young ladies. She had to leave this posi- women until 1860, six centuries after men.
tion following the birth of the oldest of her daughters. Her Maria aspired to study in Paris to become a scientist,
father, Wladislaw, who had studied sciences at the University while her sister Bronia leaned towards medicine. As their
of Warsaw and directed two important secondary schools for family could not cover the costs of university and living
boys in the capital, was tried in 1866 for his connection to outside of Warsaw for the two daughters, Maria and Bro-
nationalist circles that instigated the 1863−64 anti-Russian nia hatched a plan. First, Maria would remain in Warsaw
January Uprising. Accused of rebellion, he was relieved of and work as a private tutor to help pay for her older sister’s
any position of significance and relegated to a job as a degree. Then, once Bronia had completed her studies, she
physics and mathematics teacher at a secondary school in would use her own earnings to help cover the costs of Maria’s
Warsaw. This represented a substantial loss of earnings for studies.5
the family.2
The death of Maria’s sister Zofia in 1876, two years after
that of her mother, from tuberculosis, spurred her to grow First years in France and research beginnings
up quickly. Her mother’s death submerged her in a profound
crisis of faith and led her to declare herself agnostic. Following this plan, Maria arrived in Paris in autumn 1891
The young Sklodowski siblings completed their primary (Fig. 1), six years after Bronia had moved there and earned
education at a semi-clandestine school where, alongside her degree in medicine with a specialisation in obstetrics and
their required studies, they learned the Polish language as gynaecology. Maria was one of seven women enrolled that
well as Polish history and culture. In 1878, Maria was admit- year in the Faculty of Sciences at Sorbonne University. Of the
ted to the Sikorska boarding school. Later on, she studied 1800 students at the university, 23 were women and most
at the Warsaw III Lyceum, where she graduated with highest of these were studying medicine. She therefore entered a
marks (she was awarded a gold medal) in June 1883, a year world that was doubly restricted for women: that of the
early. university, and that of the sciences.
In the Russian Empire, women were barred from access Just two years of study later, in July 1893, with her given
to university. Maria was able to circumvent this ban through name already gallicised, Marie not only became the first
the Flying University (Uniwersytet Latajacy) of Warsaw, a woman to receive a degree in physics from Sorbonne Univer-
private institution of higher education that had exclusively sity, but also graduated at the top of her class. Not satisfied
Polish teachers and students, and admitted female students. with that, and aware that a solid approach to any research
457
R. Sánchez-Oro, J. Torres Nuez, M.L. Fatahi Bandpey et al.
458
Radiología 63 (2021) 456---465
Figure 2 Marie and Pierre Curie working in the laboratory. Source: Wikipedia,
https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Pierre and Marie Curie at work in laboratory Wellcome L0001761.jpg.
radioactive metal element. Marie and Pierre gave an With her work, Marie Curie earned not only a doctorate
account of their finding at the French Academy of Sciences degree, but also the Nobel Prize. She defended her doctoral
(Académie des sciences) in Paris in July 1898, and proposed dissertation in June 1903 and earned the degree of Doctor of
that it be named polonium, in honour of Marie’s native Physics cum laude. The telegram from Stockholm announc-
country.16 ing that they and Becquerel had been awarded the Nobel
The Curies carried on with their efforts to chemically sep- Prize in Physics for their work on radioactivity reached the
arate pitchblende, and in early November they recognised Curies’ home in November of that year. Marie was the first
the presence of a second unknown substance with radioac- female scientist to be awarded a Nobel Prize by the Royal
tivity thousands of times greater than that of uranium. Swedish Academy of Sciences.18
They called the new element radium (from the Latin radius, Pierre Curie died on 18 April 1906 when he was run over
meaning ray) and reported its existence to the Academy in by a carriage. His daughters Irène and Ève were eight and
December 1898.17 two years old, respectively.19
459
R. Sánchez-Oro, J. Torres Nuez, M.L. Fatahi Bandpey et al.
World War I and radiology Mónico Sánchez, born in Piedrabuena (Ciudad Real) in
1880, was an electrical engineer and a prolific inventor
When World War I began in 1914, the altruistic Polish who broadened his professional training and experience
researcher, who, like Röntgen, had decided not to patent in New York and became head engineer of the Collins
her experiments so that any interested party could make use Wireless Telephone Company. He and his company par-
of them freely, wondered how a scientist like her could help ticipated in international fairs alongside Edison’s General
now. Between two possible pathways, seeking new scien- Electric and Tesla’s Westinghouse. He eventually returned
tific applications to war needs and contributing to efforts to to Spain and founded his own company. Despite being lit-
organise already available resources, she chose the latter.21 tle known, Sánchez shares with these figures a prominent
This decision inaugurated a new, frenetic stage in her life place among the pioneers of wireless telecommunications
and led her to figure among the memorable pioneers of diag- and electromedicine.
nostic radiology, in addition to her above-mentioned merits. The La Mancha engineer’s most outstanding invention was
The French Ministry of War named Marie director of the Radi- a portable X-ray device that owed its worldwide success to
ology Department of the Red Cross; in that capacity, she both its qualities and the historical circumstances of the
decided to comb Paris for all the radiology equipment she time. The device, which was easy to transport and handle
could find. Her work was to consist of organising radiology and weighed barely 10 kg, was capable of powering a con-
departments in war hospitals.22 ventional X-ray tube. In 1914, France commissioned more
At the beginning of the last century, surgeons at field hos- than 50 of them to be installed in the ambulances that served
pitals did piecework, attempting to operate blindly on truly the front lines during World War I.
gory wounds in a race against the clock. The benefits of X- Marie grasped their enormous potential for diagnosing
rays in war were obvious from the outset. Thanks to X-rays, wounds on the front lines and endorsed, extended and sys-
surgeons knew, before beginning the operation, the location tematised their use. In September, the first X-ray unit cared
and type of bone lesion, and the number and location of bul- for wounded soldiers in the First Battle of the Marne against
lets and pieces of shrapnel without first probing the soldiers’ the German army (in which 400,000 died). In an affectionate
wounds. This reduced intraoperative time, minimised harm nod and tribute to Madame Curie, those peculiar trucks were
and decreased mortality. called ¨petites Curie¨(little Curies) (Fig. 3). The vehicles,
The problem was that it was very difficult to move X-ray simple, light and easy to drive, were fitted with X-ray equip-
equipment to the front lines, as Antoine Béclère, another ment, a darkroom for processing and a dynamo to generate
pioneer of radiology remembered for his work on fluo- the electricity required using the truck’s petrol engine. Fully
roscopy and for having coined the term r̈adiologieïn France, loaded, their top speed was no more than 30 km/h.
explained to Marie in 1914. For that reason, and because Between October 1914 and late 1916, Marie visited
there was not enough X-ray equipment to cover all the front dozens of hospitals with her petites Curie. However, radi-
lines, its use was limited.23 ology departments lacked qualified technicians. This new
Installation of radiology equipment at rear hospitals and hurdle started to come down in 1916, when she got the
even at field hospitals was also not a solution for many green light from the Health Department to begin training
wounded soldiers, especially the most seriously injured, who technical personnel. After a few months at a provisional
were at risk of losing their lives in transfer. These soldiers centre, classes were then taught at the Radium Institute.
had to be cared for on the front lines themselves; this This institute, planned shortly before World War I, had been
required not only moving equipment to the trenches, but reconverted thanks to Marie’s hard work and grace into
also connecting it to electricity for it to work. The inven- a radiology school, where she taught lessons on X-rays.
tiveness of a Spanish engineer proved opportune in resolving Another effect of the conflict was that the hospital---school
this double bind. was filled with women, since most men had been drafted.
460
Radiología 63 (2021) 456---465
Figure 5 Curie with a group of nurses and radiology technicians. Source: Wikipedia, https://commons.wikimedia.org/
wiki/File:Marie Curie with nurses and physician.jpg.
461
R. Sánchez-Oro, J. Torres Nuez, M.L. Fatahi Bandpey et al.
Figure 6 X-ray of a shoulder from the book L̈a radiologie et la Figure 8 X-ray of a forearm. Radius fracture with loss of
guerre¨. The book describes the image thus: "The parts closest substance.28
to the plate produce sharp, narrow shadows; the parts farthest
from the plate produce less sharp, broad shadows."28
the accident. [. . .] This creates a wonderful opportunity
for diagnosis by direct visualisation, which benefits the
of the human body without the help of surgery. [. . .] If patient and relieves the physician of some responsibil-
a metal object has entered the body after an injury (a ity."
bullet or shrapnel), the presence of this object inside
the body is revealed on fluoroscopic or X-ray imaging Later, she reiterated the importance of removing foreign
through the shadow that it casts. [. . .] If a broken bone bodies to prevent complications and anticipated the role of
appears on the image, the X-ray will reveal the details of radiological imaging in planning surgical procedures:
Figure 7 X-ray of a leg in a cast. Fracture of both bones (tibia and fibula) with displacement.28
462
Radiología 63 (2021) 456---465
"In fact, foreign bodies in the body are a common cause "To arrive at a correct opinion on bone fractures, it is
of abscesses, either because they carry infectious germs useful to take two X-rays on different planes----for exam-
or contaminated dirt or debris from clothing, or even ple, a frontal view and a lateral view, when the injured
simply because contact with them irritates tissue and can be moved. The X-rays obtained are stored as docu-
prevents healing. On the other hand, when the wound is ments. It is also useful to take a new X-ray from time to
new, the open path often makes removal very easy; the time to monitor the progress of healing, or to demon-
surgeon can follow the path without further damage, strate the outcome of surgery in clearing the fracture
aided by radiological examination; in many cases, the site of foreign bodies and to correct the position of the
surgeon can remove one or more foreign bodies from the bones. All of these X-rays reproduce the history of the
wound within a couple of minutes." injury. Sometimes it is painful history, but more often it
is comforting because persistent effort greatly improves
She also mentioned technical matters, such as the use- seemingly hopeless cases."
fulness of two orthogonal projections in bone X-rays, and
touched on organisational considerations, such as the utility Ultimately, based on this application of radiology to a
of image archiving and radiological monitoring over time: specific area, she reached a general conclusion that the pas-
463
R. Sánchez-Oro, J. Torres Nuez, M.L. Fatahi Bandpey et al.
Authorship
464
Radiología 63 (2021) 456---465
13. Quinn S. Marie Curie: A Life. 1.a ed. Boston: Da Capo Press; 22. Muñoz Páez A. Marie Curie. 1.a ed. Madrid: Debate; 2020.
1995. 23. Curie M. Marie-Irène Curie Correspondance Choix De Lettres.
14. Pasachoff N. Marie Curie and the Science of Radioactivity. 1.a 1.a ed. París: Les Editeurs Francais Reunis; 1974.
ed. Oxford: Oxford University Press; 1996. 24. Curie M. Marie Curie y sus hijas. Cartas. 1.a ed. Madrid: Clave
15. Boudia S. Marie Curie et son laboratoire. 1.a ed. París: Éditions Intelectual; 2015.
des Archives Contemporaines; 2001. 25. Curie M. Escritos biográficos. 1.a ed. Bellaterra: Ediciones UAB;
16. Calvo Pérez E. Yo fui Pierre Curie: Mis dos vidas. Google Books 2011.
(Independently Published); 2018. 26. Curie E. Madame Curie: a biography. 1.a ed. Boston: Da Capo
17. Gordon M. Marie Curie, descubridora del radio. 1.a ed. Press; 2001.
Barcelona: Casals; 2011. 27. Pflaum R. Grand Obession: Madame Curie and Her World. 1.a
18. Muñoz Páez A. Marie Curie, una vida por la ciencia. 1.a ed. ed. New York: Doubleday; 1989.
Barcelona: RBA libros; 2018. 28. Curie M. La Radiologie et la guerre. 1.a ed. París: HardPress
19. Boudia S. Marie Curie and women in science. Chem Int. Publishing; 2016.
2011;33:12---5, http://dx.doi.org/10.1515/ci.2011.33.1.12. 29. Yuste B. Sklodowska Curie, una polaca en París. 1.a ed. Madrid:
20. The Nobel Prize, Marie Curie Facts. https://www.nobelprize. Edicel; 2011.
org/prizes/physics/1903/marie-curie/facts/, 2020. [Accessed 30. Chiu MJ, Gilmer PJ, Treagust DF. Celebrating the 100th Anniver-
1 January 2021]. sary of Madame Marie Sklodowska Curie’s Nobel Prize in
21. Muñoz Puelles V. El rayo azul. Marie Curie descubridora del rayo. Chemistry. 1.a ed. Rotterdam: SensePublishers; 2011.
1.a ed. Madrid: Anaya; 2014.
465