Está en la página 1de 19

pp • 89-107

Resilience in families of the Colombian


army with a member deprived of liberty6

Ricardo A. Jaramillo Moreno


PhD. Psicología
Universidad Santo Tomás, Colombia
Correo electrónico: ricardojaramillo@
usantotomas.edu.co

Juan Carlos Cuervo Ríos


Ms. en Asesoría Familiar
Universidad de La Sabana, Colombia
Correo electrónico: juan.cuervo2@unisabana.edu.co

Rosana Cecilia Andrade Fuentes


Ms. en Psicopedagogía
Dirección de Familia y Bienestar
Ejercito Nacional, Colombia
Correo electrónico: rosana16@hotmail.com

Diana Patricia Pérez Pineda


Ms. en Asesoría Familiar y Gestión
de Programas para la Familia
Dirección de Familia y Bienestar Recibido: 17/09/2019
Ejercito Nacional, Colombia Evaluado: 15/10/2019
Correo electrónico: dipapepits@gmail.com Aceptado: 06/12/2019

Abstract
A qualitative study of resilient resources was carried out in families of the Colombian army with a
member deprived of liberty for reasons of service. 16 families that attended the army detention centers
participated in the study. Overall results showed that the imprisonment experience transformed the
family’s identity and functioning in terms of cohesion, horizontal communication, bonds of affection,
attachment and cooperation, maternal leadership, the cooperation of the extended family, and
extension of support to other family systems. Moreover, resilient resources such as creative adaptation
to the crisis, self-confidence, positive attitude, sense of humor, creativity, collaboration, commitment,
emotional self-regulation, and the strengthening of spirituality arose in the face of crisis.

Keywords
Family Resilience, Deprivation of Liberty, Army.

6 Para citar este artículo: Jaramillo-Moreno, R.A., Cuervo-Rios, J.C., Andrade, R.C., y Perez, D. (2021). Resilience
in families of the Colombian army with a member deprived of liberty. Informes Psicológicos, 21(2), pp. 89-107
http://dx.doi.org/10.18566/infpsic.v21n2a06

Informes Psicológicos
Vol. 21 No. 2 • Julio-Diciembre • 2021
ISSN – e: 2422-3271 89
pp • 89-107 Ricardo A. Jaramillo Moreno, Juan Carlos Cuervo Ríos, Rosana Cecilia Andrade Fuentes y Diana Patricia Pérez Pineda

La resiliencia en familias del ejército colombiano


con un miembro privado de la libertad

Resumen
Se realizó un estudio cualitativo de recursos resilientes en familias del ejército colombiano con
un miembro privado de la libertad por motivos de servicio. En el estudio participaron 16 familias
que acudieron a los centros de detención del ejército. Los resultados generales mostraron que la
experiencia del encarcelamiento transformó la identidad y el funcionamiento de la familia en términos
de cohesión, comunicación horizontal, lazos de afecto, apego y cooperación, liderazgo materno,
cooperación de la familia extensa y extensión del apoyo a otros sistemas familiares. Además, ante
la crisis surgieron recursos resilientes como la adaptación creativa a los momentos de crisis, la
autoconfianza, la actitud positiva, el sentido del humor, la creatividad, la colaboración, el compromiso,
la autorregulación emocional y el fortalecimiento de la espiritualidad.

Palabras clave
Resiliencia familiar, privación de la libertad, ejército.

Resiliência em famílias do exército colombiano


com um membro privado de liberdade
Resumo
Um estudo qualitativo de recursos resilientes foi realizado em famílias do exército colombiano
com um membro privado de liberdade por motivos de serviço. Participaram do estudo 16 famílias que
frequentavam os centros de detenção do exército. Os resultados gerais mostraram que a experiência
do aprisionamento transformou a identidade e o funcionamento da família em termos de coesão,
comunicação horizontal, laços de afeto, apego e cooperação, liderança materna, cooperação da família
extensa e extensão do apoio a outros sistemas familiares. Além disso, recursos resilientes como
adaptação criativa à crise, autoconfiança, atitude positiva, senso de humor, criatividade, colaboração,
compromisso, autorregulação emocional e fortalecimento da espiritualidade surgiram diante da crise.

Palavras chave
Resiliência Familiar, Privação de Liberdade, Exército.

Informes Psicológicos
Vol. 21 No. 2 • Julio-Diciembre • 2021
90 ISSN – e: 2422-3271
Resilience in families of the Colombian army with a member deprived of liberty pp • 89-107

I
affect families with a member deprived of
ntroduction liberty. It was also a challenge to explore
the resources and generativity that emer-
ged from families to face the negative im-
pacts of loss of freedom, in other words,
One of the permanent purposes of family resilience.
the Family and Welfare Management of
the National Army (FWMNA) of Colombia The present investigation identified li-
has been to ensure the welfare and family mitations and evidenced a voide of stu-
unity of the Military, through the develop- dies that address issues such as: the loss
ment of programs of psychosocial care, of freedom due to service actions, sce-
social assistance, recreation, culture, narios with a long history of conflict, the
sports and material an inmaterial benefits. inclusion of the family as part of the mili-
These programs are also aimed at their tary family and, especially, of resilience as
families, as they are part of their vital, re- family resilience. In addition to identifying
lational and survival context. This purpose a knowledge gap, it allowed recognizing a
becomes more relevant in the context of potential field for further studies in Psycho-
the conflict that the country has experien- logy, the Family and Welfare Management
ced for more than 50 years and recent of the Army, and the Faculty of Psycholo-
negotiations. gy of the Santo Tomás University, Bogotá.
These findings will provide represent input
Soldiers, non-commissioned officers for future research carried out in the Co-
and officers may experience side effects lombian post-conflict framework.
associated with active duty. In these si-
tuations, the Family and Welfare Mana- However, the context of the Colom-
gement provides support to their family, bian conflict responds to a complex histo-
social and community life, which can rical phenomenon dating back at least 60
increase their sense of accompaniment years. Some academics have identified
and well-being, as well as their sense of its roots even in the nineteenth century,
belonging. These initiatives demonstrate since the establishment of the Republic
the Army´s institutional sense of respon- and the institutionalization of political par-
sibility for its members and their families. ties, later through a series of riots called
“El Bogotazo” (1948), until the emergence
The present study investigated the of the agreement between political parties
resilient resources in the families of the called “El Frente Nacional” (1958-74) as a
military deprived of Liberty by service ac- response to such facts. The complexity is
tions. The institution considers them and also due to the subsequent convergence
their families as a sensitive population of events such as the installment of drug
that requires permanent attention which trafficking, drug trafficking terrorism and
results from the pain that this situation re- the presence of new actors who used the
presents for all members. pathways of violence as a mechanism to
transform society. For its part, the State,
Likewise, it was of great value to inves- in compliance with its constitutional duty,
tigate beyond the mere description of the has acted as a leading actor in the pre-
adverse and adjacent experiences that servation of the Republic against all these

Informes Psicológicos
Vol. 21 No. 2 • Julio-Diciembre • 2021
ISSN – e: 2422-3271 91
pp • 89-107 Ricardo A. Jaramillo Moreno, Juan Carlos Cuervo Ríos, Rosana Cecilia Andrade Fuentes y Diana Patricia Pérez Pineda

changes or exercises considered illegi- More precisely, the crisis situation, in


timate (Center for International Affairs of this case deprivation of liberty for actions
Barcelona, 2019, CIDOB). of service in military families within the fra-
mework of the conflict and post-conflict,
Thus, to understand the Colombian represents the rupture, the transformation,
conflict, the huge number of victims must the limit, because it means discomfort
be considered, which according to the and is present in the form of mood disor-
Historical Memory Center (2013) cited by ders, adjustment in the family system, be-
CIDOB (2019) refers that between 1958 havioral problems in the parent-child rela-
and 2012: tionship, or double-engaging dialogues in
the parental system (Jaramillo-Moreno &
[…] The conflict caused the death of Cuervo, 2016).
40,787 fighters and 177,307 civilians. The
number of missing persons between 1981 Furthermore, the loss of liberty de-
and 2010 was 25,000, the number of kid- pends on actions of service, where the
napped 27,023 and 150,000 the number military that meets his duty gets in con-
of murders. Of this last figure, 38.4% were flict with the law, and therefore is depri-
the responsibility of the paramilitaries, ved of liberty. He loses his rights partially
16.8% of the guerrillas and 10.1% of the or completely and is detached physically.
Public Force. This creates a crisis. However, the level
of discomfort will always depend on the
Now, just as the Military Forces (Public meaning of this event, or in other terms,
Force), particularly the Army was respon- the narrative or meaning of the crisis.
sible, it was also the victim of a negative
impact, reflected in casualties in combat On the other hand, resilience can be
and deprivation of liberty due to service. considered an onto- and phylogenetic hu-
This last negative impact, of the interest man property because one can highlight
of this investigation and denominated ad- that it has a genetic correlate (Bradley, Da-
verse collateral situation or event, affected vis, Wingo, Mercer & Ressler, 2013). This
not only the military but their families, but would indicate precisely that it is possible
also led both to be resilient to this painful to learn to be resilient only because we
situation. are endowed with this ability.

Resilience can be conceptualized, fo- This ability is perceptible based on


llowing Werner and Smith (1982), as the what we could call Resilient Resources
ability that people have to cope with, over- that can be used by individuals or by fa-
come, learn, resist, even transform them- milies. They are cognitive: search for in-
selves, in a constructive and generative formation, resignifying the crisis, problem
way, in light of the experience and the im- solution, among others; affective: affec-
pact, in many cases negative, of adverse tion dissociation, belief and assurance of
and traumatic events, derived from condi- being loved, and behavioral: response to
tions of vulnerability, accidents, social or a crisis, network creation, search for help,
natural tragedies, to name a few, that test or operative solutions in light of the conse-
people, communities, or even society. quences of the crisis (Mrazek & Mrazek,
1987).

Informes Psicológicos
Vol. 21 No. 2 • Julio-Diciembre • 2021
92 ISSN – e: 2422-3271
Resilience in families of the Colombian army with a member deprived of liberty pp • 89-107

In a nutshell, one learns not only to represented in the military context (Solar-
be resilient, but the human being per se te & Lozano, 2015)
is resilient and creates identity resilient
narratives. Thanks to this fact, one can Therefore, even if the previous condi-
adapt to the environment where this abili- tions come from a wide context, and also
ty, together with other demands, is tested. from the links and form of relationships
In this way, one learns to cope with these between people, families, communities,
demands, to build on them, despite them. and society, it is necessary to underline
the ecological, systemic, inter-relational,
Furthermore, even though one can ob- social, political, and historical position;
serve that resilience is present in people in other words, the identity position of
and communities alike, in order to deploy resilience.
it, it is necessary to have access to con-
ditions such as the existence of a link and One may conclude initially that pre-
a secure attachment with a tutor, a men- cisely because of the gaps or relational,
tor or a resilient community, the existence affective, economic, social, and political
of social networks and supporting cultu- absences, one could be resilient as long
ral networks that foster the support, and as one is immersed in an adverse or ag-
the feeling of cohesion, containment, life gressive context. In this case, one inherits,
enrichment, bond of affection, and love learns or shares a resilient identity and, at
(Cyrulnik, 2013; Rutter, 1993; Werner & the same time, develops protection factors
Smith, 1982). Moreover, one also requires that facilitate the emergence and possible
access to the satisfaction of needs, the return to the initial form or, alternatively, a
possibility of participating socially, and in a successful and generative transformation
community, the existence of relations that may take place when faced with trauma,
enhance the autonomy, approval, and so- violence, adversity, or vulnerability.
cial acceptance (Pereira, 2007).
Furthermore, and given the existence
Thus, one may conclude that even if and visibility of this network of relations-
family resilience refers to an ability that is hips and fabrics, of continuous changes,
facilitated by previous protection factors, and the adaptive and generative ability
it should also be considered as an emer- of people, one can also understand that,
gent quality that indicates how families based on them, alternative narratives or
organize their lives around “events” or performativity may emerge in light of ma-
“problems” that have been experienced cro- or micro-transformations or impacts.
and solved, and represent a conversa- Precisely this would allow people, that
tional and dialectic dynamics, i.e., reader- face the limit, the proof, and the adver-
writer-reader; in other words, it is a form sity, to propose possible worlds (Bruner,
of narrative, constructive, generative and 2004), answers to questions initially unsol-
transforming with a set of meanings (Whi- vable, or to implement creativity to solve
te & Epson, 1993). They refer not only to a overwhelming problems.
text but also to the identity of the military
family, to its relationship to social identi- Specifically, the family as an ecosystem
ty, in this case, a communitarian identity, unit of survival (Hernández, 2008), where
one finds the relational interweaving that

Informes Psicológicos
Vol. 21 No. 2 • Julio-Diciembre • 2021
ISSN – e: 2422-3271 93
pp • 89-107 Ricardo A. Jaramillo Moreno, Juan Carlos Cuervo Ríos, Rosana Cecilia Andrade Fuentes y Diana Patricia Pérez Pineda

creates a world vision and marks the economic and socio-political causes, and
forms and bonding rituals with oneself specifically because of the communitarian
and others, is the place where the pillars identities, with which they are related and
of resilience are erected, and resilience is that model their initial formation.
deployed in several forms. They include
protection factors or resilient resources As an additional element, as long as
proper such as creativity to solve pro- particular dynamics are concerned, the
blems, relationships based on bonding Colombian army, in contrast with other
love, tenderness and love, spirituality, abi- armed forces in the world and specifically
lity to provide new meanings to adversity soldiers, is the only military that remains
and their actors, regulation of the resul- more than 10 years continuously in war
ting affection in the adverse situation, the zones (Pedraza, 2015).
generative adaptation to crisis situations,
cohesion and family protection in light of This situation generates particularities
adverse or traumatic events, the transfor- not only in the individual who lives the ex-
mational forms in the relationship, roles perience, but also in the dynamics of the
and underlying meanings, the exchan- military families in each of these spheres,
ge and permeability with other human in which they develop, and in the way that
systems in order to improve one’s own they cope with and adapt to crises.
resources, together with the social sup-
port, maturity, family evolution and one’s The fact that Colombian soldiers have
identity, the ability to forgive, to feel em- no contact or communication with their
pathy and compassion concerning per- families becomes a factor that creates
petrators, people or families in a similar complex emotional situations (Pedraza,
situation. 2015). These conditions, according to the
network of family, institutional and social
However, and in order to make a few support, may be problematic or, on the
clarifications, it is important to underline contrary, a protection factor for structu-
that they are not exclusive resources of ring family resilience. In Colombia, there
a family or its identity, but they emerge are records of investigations that account
among people and extended systems for training made with military and police
(Imber-Black, 1988), and they transcend personnel (Cabrera-García, Casas, Pardo
communitarian, social, and regional & Rodríguez, 2017).
spheres.
In this same sense, García-Silgo (2013)
As regards the family and its relations has identified efforts in different armed
with other systems, in the Colombian forces in the world in order to implement
National Army, family identities respond training programs in resilience, such as
to particular dynamics (Cabrera, Cuervo the Comprehensive Soldier and Family
& Martínez, 2016), the history, evolution Fitness (CSF2) in the United States, and
cycles, and the experience of normati- other similar efforts in countries such as
ve and non-normative stressors. They Canada, Australia, South Africa, United
are not disconnected from relationships Kingdom, Holland, New Zealand, Norway,
that affect them unintentionally, such Czech Republic, Israel, and Spain.
as the transformation of families due to

Informes Psicológicos
Vol. 21 No. 2 • Julio-Diciembre • 2021
94 ISSN – e: 2422-3271
Resilience in families of the Colombian army with a member deprived of liberty pp • 89-107

On the other hand, also in terms of re- and penetrates into the families at the nu-
silience, when one analyzes the military clear or extended levels.
model by demands-resources, based on
the theory of resource conservation by Therefore, from an ecosystem po-
Hobfoll (1989), and proposed by Bates et sition, these family and communitarian
al. (2010), one identifies that the psychoso- formations are related to non-normative
cial problems associated with the mission circumstances or stressors such as the
of the military, or caused by the service, internal conflict, and the consequences
produce the increase of mental diseases derived from service.
as well as work absenteeism. This trans-
lates itself into a decrease in welfare and Thus, one can observe that the identity
health in the military and his family. These of the military family, its vulnerability, and
problems are explained partly based on resilience are conditioned not only by mi-
variables such as family support that mo- cro- and mesosystemic aspects, but also
dulates the result of stressors on health. by missionary factors that are dependent
on the exo- and macro-systemic levels
In general, the resilience models de- that concretize at present by complying
veloped for the armies usually consider a orders from their commanders, for they
wide and complex range of variables that, are related to the rupture of the norma-
when taken together, affect the military tivity that regulates the army’s missionary
and his family. work of the national army.

This means that if we can talk about


the Colombian family, it would be neces-

M
sary to establish the region of origin, the
inter-and transculturality as well as the ethod
identity of the military family, more speci-
fically of the national army because it may
have similarities with other forces such
as the Navy, the Air Force, or the national
police. However, from the identity point of A qualitative study was carried out
view, they are unique because they are (Hernández, Fernández & Baptista, 2010)
related to aspects that derive from the mi- according to the narrative topic model
litary mission itself such as continued mo- (Conelly & Clandinin, 1990), and a semis-
bility of family systems between regions in tructured interview was also used as a
the country or even abroad, the deploy- research tool (Denzin & Lincoln, 2005).
ment derived from actions of service, the Intentional (León & Montero, 2003) and
rituals, roles, and forms of interaction that by convenience sampling (Strauss &
are socialized and anchored historically. Corbin, 2002) taking advantage of the
They also include the context of housing typical cases (those which matched the
and relationships, official and fiscal hou- inclusion requirements of the research)
ses where they get together and create a (Hernández, Fernández & Baptista, 2010)
sense of community, together with the or- was applied to 16 families, represented
ganizational climate that goes beyond the by the wives of professional soldiers,
boundaries of the barracks and offices non-commissioned officers, and officers,

Informes Psicológicos
Vol. 21 No. 2 • Julio-Diciembre • 2021
ISSN – e: 2422-3271 95
pp • 89-107 Ricardo A. Jaramillo Moreno, Juan Carlos Cuervo Ríos, Rosana Cecilia Andrade Fuentes y Diana Patricia Pérez Pineda

members of the Army who had been de- are located in the batallions described
prived of liberty by causes of the service, below (See Table 2).
and who attended Family Centers of the
National Army (in Spanish CEFAB), atta- The semi-structured interview had 31
ched to Family and Welfare Management open questions. So the questions man-
of the National Army (FWMNA). All of the tained correspondence to the categories,
CEFAB of the Country participated, who the sense matrix strategy was used.

Table 1.
Sense Matrix: Triangulation Categories and Interview Outline

Questions:
Definition of the Category or Code: Has the current situation motivated you to look for information that
Characteristics of families, individuals allows you to learn and become informed about the process? How ac-
and communities, of an emergent na- curate was this information? What was the intention in carrying it out?
ture, that is to say, situations arising What good did this information provide? Information search.
Resilient from experience and situations: con-
Sources flictive, adverse and traumatic. Before your family was deprived from liberty what was your perspective
on life, and how do you see it today? Pardon-reconcilliation.
Subcategories: Information Search,
Forgiveness Reconciliation, Resignifi- How is your reaction when you receive adverse news or find out pro-
cation of Events. blems you cannot solve, related to your relative who is deprived of Li-
berty? Re-signification of events.

Source: Authors elaboration.

Interviews were carried out by a team a. To have a legal marital connection.


of professionals affiliated with FWMNA, b. At least one member of the family
and composed by a psychologist, social should be detained.
workers, and lawyers, previously trained c. Voluntary participation in the process.
in qualitative research, and interview te-
chniques for a sensitive population (with In all cases, the husband in detention
difficulties or any level of vulnerability), due was informed and agreed on the partici-
to causes of service of the military mis- pation of his family in the process. The
sionary work. Participating families were participants were distributed as follows:
selected based on the following criteria:

Table 2.
Distribution of participants by a unit of location in the families.

Number Denomination City of Origin

CEFAB BR13
1 Bogotá
Brigade 13

CEFAB BRLOG
2 Bogotá
Logistics Brigade No. 1

CEFAB CSUR
3 Bogotá
Southern Canton

CEFAB BRCOM
4 Bogotá
Brigade of Communications

Continúa

Informes Psicológicos
Vol. 21 No. 2 • Julio-Diciembre • 2021
96 ISSN – e: 2422-3271
Resilience in families of the Colombian army with a member deprived of liberty pp • 89-107

Continuación

Number Denomination City of Origin

CEFAB CEMIL
5 Bogotá
Center for Military Education

CEFAB ESMIC
6 Bogotá
Military School of Cadets

CEFAB DAAVA
7 Bogotá
Aviation Brigade No. 33

CEFAB
8 Bogotá
Visitation Rooms

CEFAB BR02
9 Barranquilla
Brigade 02

CEFAB BR04
10 Medellín
Brigade 04

CEFAB BR05
11 Bucaramanga
Brigade 05

CEFAB BR 07
12 Villavicencio
Brigade 07

CEFAB BR10
13 Valledupar
Brigade 10

CEFAB BICAZ
14 San Vicente del Caguán
BICAZ

CEFAB BR16
15 Yopal
Brigade 16

CEFAB FUTZE
16 Chaparral
Joint Task Zeus

For the interpretation and analysis of the For the identification of the topics, a
interviews, the software Atlas Ti was used previous content analysis was performed
as well as the following analysis codes: Fa- and the topics were identified through the
mily Identity, Meaning of the Crisis, Resi- recurring patterns analysis (Miles & Huber-
lient Resources. man, 2015) which referred to the words
“patterns that can often be found under
For the analysis and interpretation of the heading of repeated themes, causes
data, the process of: open coding was ca- / explanations, interpersonal relationships
rried out because it was intended to com- and theoretical constructions" (p.216).
bine techniques such as: a) “search for
people, sites or events where data related Regarding the recognition of the topics,
to categories, their properties and dimen- Family Identity, Meaning of the Crisis, Re-
sions can be collected” (p.227) and also b) silient Resources, a reflective interpretive
“proceed in a systematic way, going from analysis was carried out that sought re-
person to person or from place to pla- cognition of the relationships between ca-
ce (…) sampling based on convenience” tegories and their link to experience (Denzin
(Strauss & Corbin, 2002, p.227) (The italics and Lincoln, 1998 cited by Gibbs, 2007),
are ours). in this case of resilient resources and the

Informes Psicológicos
Vol. 21 No. 2 • Julio-Diciembre • 2021
ISSN – e: 2422-3271 97
pp • 89-107 Ricardo A. Jaramillo Moreno, Juan Carlos Cuervo Ríos, Rosana Cecilia Andrade Fuentes y Diana Patricia Pérez Pineda

adverse situation of the loss of freedom, in transform their identity to a great extent,
such a way that validity was preserved. whereas the family roles indicate that:

According to the ethical and bioethi- The father is seen as a moderator


cal considerations, the research was ap- and generator of spaces for dialogue
proved by the center of Research Mana- and family unity, and despite his
gement of the Faculty of Psychology at physical distance, he acquires a
Santo Tomás University. It was developed position of virtuality that renders him
within the framework of Law 1090, 2006, present, even if he is far away. The
according to which the exercise of the pro- mother is considered the main actor
fession of a psychologist is regulated and because she is present, regulating,
the Deontological and Bioethical Code executing, and managing the family.
is issued. In accord with the resolution She is the one that assumes the
008430 of 1993 that regulates research on functions traditionally assigned to
humans, a minimum risk was established. the father, and she also assumes
Therefore, an open and voluntary call was the type of paternity-maternity role
made. The terms, the goals and the ma- that demands the transposition of
nagement of information were explained tasks that are sometimes shared
to the participants. Informed consent was by grandmothers or by any other
signed. Later, the results were presented relative in the extended family and,
to the participants. according to the life cycle, with
the children (Jaramillo-Moreno &
Regarding the application and possible Cuervo, 2016, p. 230).
consequences, and concerning a possible
maleficence, all participants continue with Additionally, and in relation to the family
the process of psychosocial assistance communication, they reflect, to a great ex-
at CEFAB in the corresponding cities and tent, cooperative dynamics because, due
municipalities of origin. to the deployment or mobility of the father
on account of the conflict or the missio-
nary work of the military, the father leaves
an empty space within the family system.

R
This would imply that the mother has to
esults use TICS as frequent mediators in order
to channel or supply the link between the
father and his family. In other terms, it is
like a "distance command" that delegates

Family identity the father’s responsibilities or statements.


This implies not only the transmission of
and crisis due to instructions, but also to carry out some
deprivation of liberty kind of parental control, to channel affec-
tion, and to show interest for the mem-
To talk about the military families with bers of the family, their welfare as well as
a member deprived of liberty, it is neces- the inclusion of other social roles that are
sary to acknowledge from their own expe- required institutionally for understanding
rience that deprivation of liberty does not his family.

Informes Psicológicos
Vol. 21 No. 2 • Julio-Diciembre • 2021
98 ISSN – e: 2422-3271
Resilience in families of the Colombian army with a member deprived of liberty pp • 89-107

Thus, one can see the type of extension possibility to improve relationships. The
of the channels and forms of connection deprivation of liberty also allows for the
with the military missional work that repre- emergence of new dialogues, and emotio-
sents the best way to connect the families. nal experiences concerning the family, its
history, roles, rules, individual and familiar
However, the military families are not projects, even when that confinement site
always distanced by the actions of ser- is not nearby.
vice and in this respect, one should add
that, concerning the communication and Concerning the connection and com-
its meanings, even if being present enri- munication in the family, due to the mobili-
ches the family life, it is characterized by ty of the father, they tend to be supported
functional dialogues that, as said before, by the extended family, even if one should
are loaded with instructions and exercises take into consideration that families tend
of verification related to the roles and tasks to function initially somehow disconnected
socially, and institutionally established. The because they look for a natural way of indi-
resignifying and reconfiguration of the- vidualization and autonomy with respect to
se forms of relationships are associated the rest of the system. This situation chan-
with aspects of rank, position, and unit, ges dramatically when families have a child
to which the father is assigned. It should because, due to the mobility of the family
be noted that only when they get to be system or the father, the extended family
high officers, Major, Lieutenant Colonel, is included as part of the support network.
and Colonel, they may appeal to exerci- This takes place especially when depriva-
se more physical and affective closeness tion of liberty occurs because economic,
that facilitate the construction of meanings social, moral, and emotional support is re-
and connections with the family members. quired, and alternative possibilities about
These meanings are channeled basically the family imaginary are presented. This is
in everyday places, living together, in pri- reflected in the functional dialogue, where
vacy, and conversation. The latter is gai- big questions seem to be hidden but are
ned in the dialogic meaning, when having asked: What does it mean to be father,
breakfast, lunch, and dinner, together in mother, son, grandson, grandfather?
academic activities, entertainment, cultural Also, in relation to how to be of support in
spaces, and spirituality. everyday life in light of normative and non-
normative crises such as deprivation of
Moreover, one can observe in particular liberty.
that deprivation of liberty implies surprisin-
gly closeness in the family at the communi-
cative level because, despite confinement,
the families may have access more easily
The meaning of the
to these dialogic spaces due to their close- crisis derived from
ness. Even if they are limited, one should
remember the differences between de-
deprivation of liberty
privation of liberty for the military and the for the families
civilians because, in the former case, they As regards the experience and re-
have a more extended basis for interaction signifying of the deprivation of liber-
with their families, and they are given the ty, the person is not deprived of liberty.

Informes Psicológicos
Vol. 21 No. 2 • Julio-Diciembre • 2021
ISSN – e: 2422-3271 99
pp • 89-107 Ricardo A. Jaramillo Moreno, Juan Carlos Cuervo Ríos, Rosana Cecilia Andrade Fuentes y Diana Patricia Pérez Pineda

Hologrammatically, it is the family that is (by the father), and going to school. In
deprived of liberty or by the same token, case the wife works or if she’s dealing
has very limited liberty that is relative. As with everyday life, she’s always in anguish
they are connected and share psycholo- because of the ongoing process and its
gical, affective, social, and spiritual move- resolution.
ments, they are also related and experien-
ced together by means of family accounts, Even if there is information about the
and alternative particular narratives that process, the family takes a position about
contradict family memories. They are fa- a positive resolution because the repre-
ced in an adaptive way according to the sentation of the father/military, his honor,
cultural, communitarian, social, and politi- and values, are oriented to a feeling of
cal contexts, and their own family identity. hope that is eliminated by the shock pro-
duced by the arrest warrant or the infor-
Therefore, this event can be unders- mation, according to which the military
tood in two different spheres, a factual appears before the authorities. This expe-
one, where facts or events are narrated, rience is known as a shock because the
and a meaningful one that builds the fa- father is detained by the military and civil
mily system concerning the situation. authorities, and is taken into custody. This
breaks the traditional scheme of honor,
Thus, initially it is necessary to talk not pride and value of authority in society so
exclusively of deprivation of liberty, but that it is considered precisely a process of
about the conflict with the law, and, at trauma or fracture.
that time, about the “information” concer-
ning the actions derived from service, and Moreover, if the anguish for the expec-
the civil norms or the military norms that tation is distanced in time, it is replaced by
are at stake within the context of the ar- emotional detachment and negation con-
med conflict in Colombia, that, even in the cerning the true nature of this situation to
post-conflict stage, still represents a situa- the point of thinking that this is a tempo-
tion of great social, and family demand. rary situation or even a mistake.

This corresponds to the fact that, from Besides the feeling of negation and
the very beginning of the action derived shame on account of the arrest of the
from service, the military, and to some ex- father, and by the situation itself, it is ne-
tent his family, are informed formally or in- cessary to remember the meaning of ho-
formally about the administrative process, nor, value, and pride of being military in
and its possible implications. Even if there the society. With the capture of the sus-
is a presumption of innocence, there are pect, one goes to the opposite pole of
always high expectations regarding the humiliation, the least valuable, the feeling
results, as well as anguish. Furthermore, of shame. As one of the participants said:
considering the time that it takes to sol- “He looked like a homeless person”.
ve such processes, there is some type
of conditioning of liberty, or somehow Furthermore, concerning the pro-
limited or relative liberty, in which some cess of deprivation, when the families
routines by the children have to continue, experience that the father is in this situa-
such as going to mass, following orders tion, they consider it shocking not only

Informes Psicológicos
Vol. 21 No. 2 • Julio-Diciembre • 2021
100 ISSN – e: 2422-3271
Resilience in families of the Colombian army with a member deprived of liberty pp • 89-107

because of the transformation of his look becomes the villain, and now the father
but also because of the meaning of being becomes the victim, the effective contai-
“incarcerated”. This is a conception that is ner, and, as much as possible, the figure
only related to “delinquents” and doesn’t of permissiveness. All this is represented
correspond to someone in uniform. This affectively as guilt and overcompensation
generates sadness, pain, and fear to lose by the father; anguish, saturation, and
their rights and their prestige because discomfort by the mother. There are also
they do not know what is going to happen adaptive changes by the children such as
to them after the deprivation of liberty. emotional and behavioral problems.

This situation can generate detach-


ment from the construction of their life
projects such as buying a house, a vehi-
Resilient resources in
cle, or metaphorically speaking, they feel light of deprivation of
that they are not the owners of their family,
individual, and professional projects.
liberty
Concerning the resilient resources in
One should underline that one addi- military families, one can observe how the
tional consequence concerns the effect transformation of identity and family dy-
on economic income, and the way they namics facilitate the emergence of family
will satisfy the needs of the family mem- resilience. As regards the communication,
bers. Additionally, there is an increase in structure, and roles, the military families
family expenditure because they have to with deprivation of liberty changed. They
pay lawyers, and they do not have military display now higher family cohesion even
discounts because their father has been in the extended family. They have the fee-
accused or sentenced. In this case, the ling that they are not alone to face adver-
wife or the extended nuclear family should sity, but there is cooperation in everyday
assume additional activities that allow tasks; even in the resolution of problems
them to supply for such demands. This of children upbringing, the parental care
represents an overload of activities that and control, and generativity, understood
generate resources, the neglect or dele- as creative ways to acquire resources to
gation of activities related to children’s up- satisfy economic and affective needs, as
bringing, and parental control, the over- well as social support.
lapping roles and responsibilities in the
extended families. With regard to roles, the mothers con-
sidered that they were crucial inside the
In these cases, the mother is the one family organization. They are now percei-
that has to assume now greater promi- ved as the center of all responsibilities,
nence than previously, or even before the which represents more anguish and fati-
deprivation of liberty occurred. She be- gue. They are empowered and their role
comes a relativized or deficient version of is seen as one of support and leadership;
the father, and an antagonist of the mea- now they experience being of more es-
nings of the father and mother, i.e., a ver- teem, and confidence. This is perceived
sion of the mother as an authority, limit, not only by the family, but also by their
and norm enforcer. In other words, she partners to the extent that now they have

Informes Psicológicos
Vol. 21 No. 2 • Julio-Diciembre • 2021
ISSN – e: 2422-3271 101
pp • 89-107 Ricardo A. Jaramillo Moreno, Juan Carlos Cuervo Ríos, Rosana Cecilia Andrade Fuentes y Diana Patricia Pérez Pineda

become models of tolerance, strength, communication, and active hearing in or-


and righteousness. This also facilitates der to transcend functional dialogues.
the rediscovery of their identities in the
couple or, in other words, the strengthe- Moreover, in these families, one can
ning of the marital relationship as well as observe the ability to adapt creatively to
the bond with their children. adversity, for example by focusing their
attention on enjoying the spaces for con-
Such repositioning was extended to nection and enjoyment, initially described,
other family systems, generating support that are limited in everyday missionary
networks, and cooperation with families work. Here they can be perceived as ga-
who were in a similar phase or were ini- mes, dinner, and conversational spaces
tiating a process of deprivation of liberty. even in the place of deprivation of liberty.
This could translate into better alternatives
to obtain resources to satisfy needs, emo- Additionally, to trust each other and
tional support, or providing information to their own resources facilitates a positive
handle the legal process. attitude, sense of humor, creativity, co-
llaboration, commitment, and especia-
In terms of their relationships and fa- lly emotional self-regulation, having the
mily identity, one can observe that even if ability to cope with difficulties or crises
there is a boundary between the nuclear without victimhood, thereby weakening
and the extended family, which is com- negative emotional responses.
mon in consolidating and differentiating
families, deprivation of liberty facilitated its
resignifying so that now it is not concei-

D
ved as an extension controlled by the ex-
tended family, but as a support network iscussion and
that helps to cope with adversity without
alienating their identity.
conclusions
This transformation in the identity and
functioning of families allowed for the Concerning the crisis derived from
emergence of resources such as resigni- experiencing an adverse event of de-
fying crises due to deprivation to the point privation of liberty, two aspects can be
that it could be conceived as proof of their highlighted. First, it can be considered
identity structure as well as the discovery as a mourning situation (Greeff, & Van
of family values connected to empathy, at- der Walt 2010). Second, deprivation of li-
titude, endurance, and hope with a more berty can be strengthened or weakened
realistic perception of the process, and of according to aspects connected to mili-
the family therein, as well as self-knowled- tary rank, educational level of the family,
ge. This would be equivalent to measure the partner and her job, and the family
their limits concerning the coping or de- identity. The latter may represent by itself
ploying in diverse situations, the ability to a resilient identity, by spirituality, emotio-
establish a close connection, the expe- nal self-regulation, the ability to find pa-
rience of love and consideration, impro- rallel generative narratives to adversity,
vement despite the deprivation of liberty, and the social-affective support. Some

Informes Psicológicos
Vol. 21 No. 2 • Julio-Diciembre • 2021
102 ISSN – e: 2422-3271
Resilience in families of the Colombian army with a member deprived of liberty pp • 89-107

differences were also found between the tutors or communities and family identi-
families that could cope better with ad- ties with such characteristics.
versity and had such conditions because
they acted as support. This should be complemented in the
sense that even if, from the individual
At the same time, and regarding the perspective, the support can be seen as
crisis derived from deprivation of liberty, a mentor, here it could be understood as
one could observe that in line with the stu- support networks through which one can
dies by Chapin (2011); Lester et al. (2010); facilitate the deployment of resilience. It
Paley, Lester & Mogil (2013) and MacDer- can correspond to the development of al-
mid (2010), there is a bigger perception of ternative narratives of the adverse event,
crisis or shock due to the mobility. This the transformation of the family identity,
is connected to the missionary work of the improvement of communication and
the military, or the deployment derived its meanings. Even without access to
from actions of public order or war be- TICS, new connections can be created
cause phenomena such as difficulties to in relation to cooperation, support and
adapt, family dysfunction, psychological creativity, the development of a positive
adjustment, and mental health disorders and hopeful attitude, family self-esteem
are also observed (Riggs & Riggs, 2011). and self-confidence, self-regulation, and
family generativity.
This allows us to conclude that fami-
lies respond better to deprivation of liberty Specifically, in terms of exposure to
than to mobility or deployment (McCubbin non-facilitating environments or contexts,
& McCubbin, 2013; Seidl, Lurdes, Benetti, or in the case of existence of deficient
& Pereira, 2011). family systems, family resilience can be
deployed because adverse events, trau-
It also implies the urgent need to gene- matisms or vulnerability conditions produ-
rate working plans oriented to mitigating ce generative connecting movements as
these effects within the framework of res- long as there are basic conditions such
ilience because the benefit can be obser- as support, cohesion, spirituality, and
ved in terms of family functioning, coping educational bases. It should be noted
with adversity, improvement of mental that this exercise can be optimized if po-
health, and the positive and resilient eco- licies and institutional actions per se are
logical relation with other family or com- developed and their ecosystem actions
munitarian systems (Gottman, Gottman & (Bronfenbrenner, 1987) facilitate commu-
Atkins, 2011; Paley et al., 2013). nitarian environments, even if they can be
developed naturally, by working as sup-
One could also confirm that resilience port (Distelberg & Taylor, 2015; Juliano &
is a quality that one learns and to some Yunes, 2014) and implementing resilient
extent inherits (Bradley et al., 2013). It de- resources.
velops in the most adverse conditions and
under non-facilitating social communita- In the case of the military families,
rian environments. It also results from an one could observe the recognition of re-
emergent competency, derived precisely silient resources by FWMNA through the
from the network of the relationships with functioning of the Family Centers at the

Informes Psicológicos
Vol. 21 No. 2 • Julio-Diciembre • 2021
ISSN – e: 2422-3271 103
pp • 89-107 Ricardo A. Jaramillo Moreno, Juan Carlos Cuervo Ríos, Rosana Cecilia Andrade Fuentes y Diana Patricia Pérez Pineda

national level. They carry out the Program For, as described in the introduction, the
for the Military Deprived of Liberty and families of all victims of the armed conflict
their Families that becomes an additional would benefit from understanding and
support network that facilitates the disco- appropriating these resources. Another
very of resources to overcome the crisis potential benefit arises from an opportu-
and soothe the feeling of abandonment nity of co-responsibility of all the actors to
experienced by families. develop programs oriented towards the
promotion of family resilience.
As regards the ecosystem actions and
back-actions, one can observe a dyadic Likewise, there is concern about how
relationship that promotes generativity collateral effects of the conflict can signi-
between the nuclear and the extended fa- ficantly affect families, accentuating pain
mily as long as individuation and differen- and affecting their quality of life, well-being
tiation of the extended family occur, even and health. These effects would consti-
by showing rigid limits; however, when tute a similar adverse situation or one of
the adverse event takes place, they be- greater impact to the armed conflict.
come permeable without destroying their
identity and facilitating the deployment of The National Army will benefit from this
resilience. study, taking into account the findings of
the exploration of resilient resources, not
The study presents limitations of only in all its members and their respective
methodological order. Despite having families, but also in which situations they
easy access to the participants, becau- are resilient. In this way it will be easier for
se they have relative deprived of liberty, the National Army and on their behalf the
the eventual mobility of the family, (some Family and Welfare Directorate, to fulfill its
move to accompany their family member) mission.
made it difficult to have an agile contact
with them. Another limitation arose from
the impact it represents for them to talk

R
about a situation that represents great
pain. eferences
Possibilities and challenges that arise
from this study can be highlighted. It re-
presents a starting point for the design
and subsequent implementation of resi- Barcelona Centre For International Affairs.
lience-oriented programs by the DIFAB of (2014). Conflicto en Colombia: antecedentes
the National Army and their extension to históricos y actores. Recuperado de https://
other Forces such as the Navy, Air Force www.cidob.org/publicaciones/documen
and National Police. tacion/dossiers/dossier_proceso_de_paz_
en_colombia/dossier_proceso_de_paz_
On the other hand, in the post-conflict en_colombia/ conflicto_en_colombia_
scenario, the need to promote research antecedentes_historicos_y_actores.
not only of resilience in a descriptive sen-
se, but of family resilience is highlighted.

Informes Psicológicos
Vol. 21 No. 2 • Julio-Diciembre • 2021
104 ISSN – e: 2422-3271
Resilience in families of the Colombian army with a member deprived of liberty pp • 89-107

Bates, M.J., Bowles, S., Hammermeister, J., Cyrulnik, B. (2013). Los Patitos Feos. La
Stokes, C., Pinder, E., & Moore, M. (2010). Resiliencia. Una Infancia Infeliz no
Psychological fitness. Military Medicine, Determina la Vida. Barcelona: Gedisa.
15, 8-21. Retrieved from https://www.
researchgate.net/publication/233572718_ Chapin, M. (2011). Family resilience and the
Psychological_Fitness fortunes of war. Social work in health care,
50(7), 527-542. http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/0
Bradley, B., Davis, T.A., Wingo, A.P., 0981389.2011.588130
Mercer, K.B. & Ressler, K.J. (2013).
Family environment and adult resilience: Denzin, N. K. & Lincoln, Y. S. (2005). The Sage
contributions of positive parenting and the Handbook of Qualitative Research. Third
oxytocin receptor gene. European Journal Edition. Thousand Oaks: Sage Publications.
of Psychotraumatology, 4, 1-10. doi:
10.3402/ejpt.v4i0.21659 Distelberg, B., & Taylor, S. (2015). The roles
of social support and family resilience in
Bronfenbrenner, U. (1987). La ecología del accessing healthcare and employment
desarrollo humano. Madrid: Paidós, Ibérica. resources among families living in
traditional public housing communities.
Bruner, J. (2004). Realidad Mental y Mundos Child & Family Social Work, 20(4), 494-506.
Posibles: Los actos de la imaginación que Retrieved from http://onlinelibrary.wiley.
le dan sentido a la experiencia. Barcelona: com/doi/10.1111/cfs.12098/abstract
Gedisa.
García-Silgo, M. (2013). Revisión de programas
Cabrera, V., Cuervo, J., Martínez, Z., & Cabrera, de resiliencia basados en la evidencia en
M. (2016). Estrategias de afrontamiento los ejércitos. Sanidad Militar, 69(3), 182-194.
frente al divorcio en personas de las fuerzas
militares de Colombia. Revista Científica Gibbs, G. (2007). El análisis de datos
“General Jose María Cordova”, 14(17), 135- cualitativos en investigación cualitativa.
154. Recuperado de http://www.scielo.org. Madrid: Editorial Morata.
co/pdf/recig/v14n17/v 14n17a06.pdf
Gottman, J., Gottman, J. &, Atkins, C. (2011).
Cabrera-García, V., Casas, K., Pardo, S. The Comprehensive Soldier Fitness
& Rodríguez, D. (2017). Análisis de la Program: Family skills component.
resiliencia en personas divorciadas, American Psychologist, 66(1), 52-57. doi:
según su nivel educativo e ingresos 10.1037/a0021706.
económicos. Psicogente, 20(37), 160-171.
http://doi.org/10.17081/psico.20.37.2425 Greeff, A. P., & Van der Walt, K. J. (2010).
Resilience in families with an autistic child.
Connelly, F., & Clandinin, D. (1990). Stories Education and Training in Autism and
of Experience and Narrative Inquiry. Developmental Disabilities, 45(3), 347-
Educational Researcher, 19(5), 2-14. 355. Retrieved from http://www.jstor.org/
Recuperado de http://www.jstor.org/ stable/23880109
stable/1176100

Informes Psicológicos
Vol. 21 No. 2 • Julio-Diciembre • 2021
ISSN – e: 2422-3271 105
pp • 89-107 Ricardo A. Jaramillo Moreno, Juan Carlos Cuervo Ríos, Rosana Cecilia Andrade Fuentes y Diana Patricia Pérez Pineda

Hernández, A. (2008). Vínculos, individuación Resilience in U.S. Military Families (pp. 149-
y ecología humana. Hitos para una 173). New York: Springer.
psicología clínica compleja. (Maestría en
Psicología Clínica y de Familia). Universidad McCubbin, L. & McCubbin, H. (2013). Resilience
Santo Tomás. Bogotá, Colombia. in ethnic family systems: A relational theory
for research and practice. In D.S. Becvar
Hernández, R., Fernández, C., & Baptista, P. (Ed.). Handbook of Family Resilience (pp.
(2010). Metodología de la investigación. 175-195). New York: Springer.
México D.F.: McGraw-Hill.
MacDermid, S. M. (2010). Family Risk
Hobfoll, S.E. (1989). Conservation of resources: and Resilience in the Context of
a new attempt at conceptualizing stress. War and Terrorism. Journal of
American Psychologist, 44(3), 513-524. Marriage and Family, 72, 537-556.
doi:10.1111/j.1741-3737.2010.00717.x
Imber-Black, E. (1988). Familias y sistemas
amplios: en terapeuta familiar en el laberinto. Miles, M., & Huberman, A. (2015) Qualitative
Buenos Aires: Amorrortu editores. Data Analysis, A source of new Methods.
Beverly Hills, CA. Sage, Publications.
Jaramillo-Moreno, R. & Cuervo, J. (2016). El
resurgir de las familias militares frente a la Mrazek, P. J., & Mrazek, D. (1987). Resilience in
adversidad. Exploración de los recursos Child Maltreatment Victims: A Conceptual
resilientes en familias frente a la privación Exploration. Child Abuse and Neglect, 11,
de la libertad por acciones del servicio. En 339-362.
D. Muñoz (ed.). Mi casa Territorio de Paz,
Memorias del VIII internacional de la familia Paley, B., Lester, P., & Mogil, C. (2013). Family
2 y 3 de Septiembre de 2016. Bogotá, systems and ecological perspectives on the
Colombia: Ed. Universidad de la Sabana. impact of deployment on military families.
Clinical Child and Family Psychology
Juliano, M, & Yunes, M. (2014). Reflexões Review, 16(3), 245-265. doi: 10.1007/
sobre rede de apoio social como s10567-013-0138-y.
mecanismo de proteção e promoção
de resiliência. Ambiente & Sociedade, Pedraza R. (2015). Resiliencia y combate: Un
17(3), 135-154. https://dx.doi.org/10.1590/ estudio con soldados colombianos. (Tesis
S1414-753X2014000300009 doctoral). Universidad de Palermo. Buenos
Aires, Argentina
León, O. & Montero, I. (2003). Métodos de
investigación en psicología y educación. Pereira, R. (2007). Resiliencia individual, familiar
Madrid, España: Mc Graw Hill. y social. Interpsiquis. Recuperado de
http://www.psiquiatria.com/tratamientos/
Lester, P., Leskin, G., Woodward, K., Saltzman, resiliencia-individual-familiar-y-social/#
W., Nash, W., Mogil, C., Paley, B., &
Beardslee, W. (2010). Wartime Deployment Riggs, A. & Riggs, D. (2011). Risk and resilience
and Military Children: Applying Prevention in military families experiencing deployment:
Science to Enhance Family Resilience. In the role of the family attachment network.
S. Mac Dermid & D. Riggs (eds.). Risk and

Informes Psicológicos
Vol. 21 No. 2 • Julio-Diciembre • 2021
106 ISSN – e: 2422-3271
Resilience in families of the Colombian army with a member deprived of liberty pp • 89-107

Journal of Family Psychology, 25(5), 675- vitela.javerianacali.edu.co/bitstream/


687. doi: 10.1037/a0025286. handle/11522/3592/Identidad_familiar_
familias.pdf?sequence=1
Rutter, M. (1993). Resilience: Some conceptual
considerations. Journal of Adolescent Strauss, A. & Corbin, J. (2002). Bases de
Health, 14, 626-631. la investigación cualitativa: Técnicas y
procedimientos para desarrollar la teoría
Seidl, A., Lurdes, M., Benetti, D. & fundamentada. Medellín, Colombia:
Pereira, S. (2011). Resiliencia familiar: Universidad de Antioquia.
nuevas perspectivas en la promoción
y prevención en salud. Diversitas: Werner, E. & Smith R. (1982). Vulnerable but
Perspectivas en Psicología, 7(1), 43-55. invincible: a study of resilient children. New
Recuperado de http://www.scielo.org.co/ York: McGraw-Hill.
scielo.php?script=sci_arttext&pid=S1794-
99982011000100004&lng=en&tlng= White, M. & Epston, D. (1993). Medios
es. Narrativos para fines terapéuticos.
Barcelona, España: Paidós.
Solarte, M. y Lozano, P. (2015). Identidad
familiar en familias ensambladas. (Tesis de
posgrado). Pontificia Universidad Javeriana
de Cali. Colombia. Recuperado de http://

Informes Psicológicos
Vol. 21 No. 2 • Julio-Diciembre • 2021
ISSN – e: 2422-3271 107

También podría gustarte