Documentos de Académico
Documentos de Profesional
Documentos de Cultura
KOLIE CRUTCHER
LA LE Y DE LA
ATRACCI ON
para escepticos
-$ -!% "!
-$ $')$##/D,
*$)$
!(#;*'/#+(
.+-/! #)&'#0!)
("$!%#
C&I-*)+$!$)KGJH# ### ### ### ### ### ## ### ### ### ### ## ### ..
9KGIJ*F++$RK #### #### #### #### #### #### #### #### #### #### .3
?R!J "))I &% -!" #! -% %')%$$./, *%)% !($1*'.$+( ## >.
%#$'&#" %"#!&
?5721;609P6
A+15=A=5‘/
4FHDBRGANgG
>j
XVg[imU ^m ^gLo gUSm UgeQcVŒ ZkQVVcg[iZT Uc[ g\lmV2
eZo UgeQVm\g[Sg mkSQmVŒ g[ SQ kZ[SVmD 1m kZ\XVg[2
Uc“[ gU Q[ XVZkgUZD ;U Q[m Vg^mkc“[ WQg Ug igUmVVZ^^m
g[SVg g^ kZ[ZkgiZV L g^ ZlbgSZ ig g[Sg[ic\cg[SZD
;USm Vg^mkc“[ c\X^ckm WQg g^ kZ[ZkgiZV Scg[g kmXm2
kcimigU L mXScSQigU UQˆkcg[SgU g[ Vg^mkc“[ m^ Zlbg2
SZ ig kZ[Zkc\cg[SZ XmVm fmPZVgkgV Q[ kZ\XZVSm2
\cg[SZ c[Sg^ceg[SgD )gkQgVim@ [Z XQgigU km\lcmV
gUSm ^gLo UZ^Z XQgigU g[Sg[igV^m XmVm kZ\g[KmV m
m^c[gmVSg kZ[ g^^m ig Sm^ fZV\m WQg mkS…g g[ SQ lg[g2
ˆkcZD
7DJNVXVNgG
>>
jD 1m kZ[kcg[kcm kVgmD
>D 'ZiZ gU g[gVe{mD
pD 1m 5[Sg^ceg[kcm c[fc[cSm gU Z\[cXZSg[Sgo XgVZ
^ZU dQ\m[ZU Scg[g[ ^clVg m^lgiV{ZD
nD 1m \g[Sg UQlkZ[Ukcg[Sg gU ^m kZ\lc[mkc“[ ig^
XVc\gV L g^ SgVkgV XVc[kcXcZD
>p
Um\cg[SZT gUSg ’WQ€‚ XVZiQkg Q[ km\XZ g^gk2
SVZ\me[€SckZ "=;0. WQg XQgig UgV \giciZD
‡ 3B@R8ŠC@ “Vem[Z f{UckZ ig[SVZ ig^ kQgVXZ dQ2
\m[Z WQg eg[gVm g^ ’Ug[Sc\cg[SZ‚ Z ^mU g\Z2
kcZ[gU ig^ Xg[Um\cg[SZT gUSg Ug[Sc\cg[SZ XVZ2
iQkg Q[ km\XZ g^gkSVZ\me[€SckZ "=;0. WQg
XQgig UgV \giciZD
‡ (MC>M ?<QPBC?PIMC>M !>RDQIdC PBCBPINR PBDB
DMC>MT PB@R8ŠC AMC?RC>M&@ kZ\lc[mkc“[ ig^
XZigV ig ^m 5[Sg^ceg[kcm c[fc[cSm kZ[ ^m kZ[kcg[2
kcm dQ\m[mD 1m \g[Sg UQlkZ[Ukcg[Sg [Z gU Q[
“Vem[Z f{UckZ kZ\Z g^ kgVglVZ Z g^ kZVmK“[D 1m
\g[Sg UQlkZ[Ukcg[Sg [Z eg[gVm UQ XVZXcZ Xg[2
Um\cg[SZ "cigmU L g\ZkcZ[gU.o Uc[Z WQg Ug Pg
kZ[ickcZ[mim L kZ[SVZ^mim ig fZV\m c[icVgkSm
XZV ^m VgXgSckc“[ ig^ Xg[Um\cg[SZ kZ[USm[Sg L
iZ\c[m[Sg WQg gU eg[gVmiZ XZV g^ kgVglVZ L g^
kZVmK“[ dQ\m[ZD 1m ^gL ig ^m mSVmkkc“[ mkS…m m
SVmP€U ig ^m \g[Sg UQlkZ[Ukcg[Sg ig ^m gUXgkcg
dQ\m[mD A SVmP€U ig ^m \g[Sg UQlkZ[Ukcg[Sg g^
XZigV ig ^m 5[Sg^ceg[kcm c[fc[cSm gU eQcmiZ L ic2
VceciZ XZV g^ Xg[Um\cg[SZ dQ\m[ZD
‡ ,C>MFIKMCPIR ICLICI>R !>RDQIdC PBCBPINR PBDB
#BNM@ ICLICI>B&@ g^ kZ[Zkc\cg[SZ mlUZ^QSZ g c[2
fc[cSZD
‡ 1CM@K_R@ SZiZ gU g[gVe{m WQg PclVm g[ icfgVg[2
SgU fVgkQg[kcmUD 'ZimU ^mU kZUmU mXmVg[Sg\g[Sg
icfgVg[SgU ig^ Q[cPgVUZ UZ[ Uc\X^gU kZ\lc[m2
>n
kcZ[gU L XVgUg[SmkcZ[gU icPgVUmU ig ^m \cU\m
g[gVe{mo UZlVg ^m WQg Ug dm mkSQmiZ L m ^m WQg
Ug ^g dm imiZ fZV\mD 'ZimU ^mU kZUmU WQg gMcU2
Sg[ Scg[g[ Q[m fZV\m L Q[m XZUckc“[ kZ[kVgSm
XZVWQg Q[m fQgVKm dm mkSQmiZ UZlVg g^^mU L ^gU
dm imiZ gUm fZV\m L XZUckc“[ gUXgk{fckmD 0cg[2
SVmU ^ggUo kZ\g[KmVŒU m Xg[UmV ig \m[gVm [mSQ2
Vm^ g[ ^ZU ZlbgSZU L ^mU kZ[ickcZ[gU WQg WQcgVgU
mSVmgV m SQ Pcim \gicm[Sg ^m ^gL ig ^m mSVmkkc“[D
=Qm^WQcgV ZlbgSZ Z kZ[ickc“[ WQg igUggU [Z gU
\ŒU WQg g[gVe{mD +cg[Um g[ g^^Z kZ\Z Sm^D
‡ 0<M@8R@ c[f^Qg[kcm WQg XVZPZkm g^ km\lcZD
‡ *M9@ kZVVgUXZ[ig m Q[m fQgVKmo g c\X^ckm WQg
gUm fQgVKm Ucg\XVg gUSŒ mkSQm[iZD
‡ 3BDA@MC?IŠC@ Vg^mkc“[ g[SVg g^ kZ[ZkgiZV L g^
ZlbgSZ ig g[Sg[ic\cg[SZT gUSm Vg^mkc“[ c\X^ckm
WQg g^ kZ[ZkgiZV icUXZ[g ig ^mU kmXmkcimigU
L mXScSQigU migkQmimU kZ[ VgUXgkSZ m^ ZlbgSZ
ig kZ[Zkc\cg[SZ XmVm fmPZVgkgV Q[ kZ\XZVSm2
\cg[SZ c[Sg^ceg[SgD
2J HXDX ARVBR@F
>,
eQcmV{m kZ[ mlUZ^QSm XVgkcUc“[ m UQ XZUggiZV dmUSm
^mU VcWQgKmU \ŒU c[c\mec[ml^gUo XgVZ kZ[ Q[m kZ[2
ickc“[@ igl{m XmUmV Q[m XVQglmD ;^ \QkdmkdZ gVm
m\lckcZUZo mU{ WQg igkcic“ XmVScV g[ lQUkm ig^ UmlcZ
m[kcm[Z XmVm XmUmV ^m XVQglm L kZ[UgeQcV g^ \mXm
UgkVgSZ WQg ^g kZ[iQkcV{m m ^m VcWQgKmD
;^ kdckZ Ug g\lmVk“ g[ Q[ ^mVeZ Pcmbg dmkcm mWQg2
^^m ^gbm[m Vgec“[o WQg Ug g[kZ[SVmlm m PmVcZU i{mU ig
Pcmbgo ^Z kQm^ [Z \Z^gUS“ m^ \QkdmkdZD (Z^Z XZi{m
Xg[UmV g[ ^mU VcWQgKmU WQg clm m kZ[UgeQcVD 0cg[SVmU
Pcmbmlm L Ug mXVZMc\mlm m ^m Vgec“[ ig^ UmlcZ m[kcm2
[Zo Xg[U“ g[ WQ€ XZiV{m kZ[UcUScV ^m XVQglmD s(gV{m
Q[m XVQglm f{Uckma s'g[iV{m WQg VgUZ^PgV Q[ mkgVSc2
bZa s'g[iV{m WQg ^^gPmV^g Q[ Vgem^Z m^ PcgbZ UmlcZa
9QgVm ^Z WQg fQgVmo gUSmlm UgeQVZ ig WQg XmUmV{m ^m
XVQglmT mig\ŒUo „Sg[{m ^m fZVSQ[m kmUc m^ m^km[kg ig
^m \m[ZE
=Qm[iZ ^^ge“ m ^m Vgec“[ iZ[ig Ug VQ\ZVgmlm WQg
PcP{m g^ m[kcm[Zo g^ \QkdmkdZ g[SV“ g[ Q[m XgWQg‰m
kmlm‰m VgX^gSm ig dgV\ZUZU ZlbgSZU XVZkgig[SgU ig
SZiZ g^ \Q[iZD ;Vm Q[m kZ^gkkc“[ \me[{fckmD ;[ g^
\Z\g[SZ g[ WQg m^mVe“ Q[m \m[Z XmVm SZkmV Q[Z
ig ^ZU ZlbgSZU iZVmiZUo gUkQkd“ Q[m PZKD
ts;[ WQ€ XQgiZ mLQimVSga tXVgeQ[S“ ^m PZKD
t;USZL lQUkm[iZ m^ UmlcZ m[kcm[Z WQg XZUgg g^
\mXm UgkVgSZ WQg kZ[iQkg m ^m VcWQgKm tVgUXZ[ic“
g^ \QkdmkdZD
ts'g VgfcgVgU m gUSZa tkZ[SgUS“ g^ m[kcm[ZD
>I
<g UQ kmXm gMSVmbZ Q[ XgVem\c[Z g[PQg^SZ kZ[ Q[
^mKZ VZbZD ;^ kdckZ Ug \ZUSV“ gMQ^Sm[Sg kQm[iZ UQ
\cVmim Ug XZU“ g[ g^ \mXmD
t„({E tVgUXZ[ic“D
t1g dg imiZ g^ \mXm m \QkdmU XgVUZ[mU ticbZ
g^ UmlcZ m[kcm[ZtD s;U gUZ ^Z WQg WQcgVgUa
t({ tVgUXZ[ic“ g^ kdckZtD r XmVScV€ g[UgeQcimD
ts;USŒU UgeQVZa
t({D ;UZ gU SZiZ tVgX^ck“ g^ kdckZD
t0QL lcg[ tVgUXZ[ic“ g^ UmlcZ m[kcm[ZtD 'g ^Z
imV€o XgVZ UZ^Z kZ[ Q[m kZ[ickc“[D <glgU XVZ\gSgV2
\g WQg gUXgVmVŒU dmUSm WQg VgeVgUgU m SQ m^igm XmVm
^ggV^ZD
t„<g mkQgViZE tmkkgic“ g^ \QkdmkdZtD ;Ug gU
g^ \mXm WQg kZ[iQkg m ^m VcWQgKmo sPgVimia
t({ tkZ[SgUS“ g^ m[kcm[ZtD ;USg \mXm \QgUSVm
g^ km\c[Z dmkcm ^m VcWQgKmD
t;USQXg[iZD ;[SZ[kgU \g XZ[iV€ g[ \mVkdm
mdZVm \cU\ZD
t0QL lcg[ tVgUXZ[ic“ g^ UmlcZ m[kcm[ZD
;^ \QkdmkdZ mlm[iZ[“ ^m Vgec“[ L VgeVgU“ m UQ
m^igm g[ ^m \cSmi ig Scg\XZo Lm WQg gUSmlm m[UcZUZ
XZV PgV g^ \mXmD A \gicim WQg g^ \QkdmkdZ igUg[2
VZ^^mlm g^ XgVem\c[Zo UQ g[SQUcmU\Z fQg g[ mQ\g[2
SZD =Qm[iZ \cV“ g^ \mXmo PcZ WQg gUSmlm igUkVcSZ
kZ[ SZiZ igSm^^gD (c[ g\lmVeZo dml{m Q[ XVZl^g\mD
;^ \mXm gUSmlm gUkVcSZ g[ Q[m m[SceQm ^g[eQm XgVic2
im WQg g^ \QkdmkdZ [Z XZi{m kZ\XVg[igVD (g ^g dm2
>7
l{m kZ[kgiciZ g^ \mXm UgkVgSZo XgVZ [Z Sg[{m [c[e…[
Pm^ZV XmVm €^ XZVWQg [Z ^Z g[Sg[i{mD
>_