Documentos de Académico
Documentos de Profesional
Documentos de Cultura
De Mussy Luis Y Valderrama Miguel - Historiografia Posmoderna PDF
De Mussy Luis Y Valderrama Miguel - Historiografia Posmoderna PDF
De Mussy Luis Y Valderrama Miguel - Historiografia Posmoderna PDF
POSTMODERNA
Luis G. De Mussy
Miguel Valderrama
RIL editores
bibliodiversidad
2
Historiografa postmoderna
Historiografa postmoderna
3
Historiografa postmoderna
,UIS ' $E -USSY s -IGUEL 6ALDERRAMA
Historiografa postmoderna
Conceptos, guras, maniestos
5
-VJT(%F.VTTZr.JHVFM7BMEFSSBNB
254Q23DN*4#/978-956-284-771-1
1 Historiografa 2 Postmodernismo.
6OJWFSTJEBE'JOJT5FSSBF
Historiografa postmoderna.
$
ii
iUPrinted in Chile
Derechos reservados.
6
Historiografa postmoderna
-VEXJH8JUUHFOTUFJO
-VDJFO'FCWSF
7
Historiografa postmoderna
Agradecimientos ...................................................................13
Advertencia ..........................................................................15
*)
*)JTUPSJPHSBGBQPTUNPEFSOB
VONBOJFTUP .................19
**$
1PSVOBOVFWBHSBNUJDBEFMBIJTUPSJPHSBGB..................39
"DPOUFDJNJFOUP.........................................................43
"SDIJWP ....................................................................47
"DUVBMJEBE ................................................................50
"OUJOPNJB ................................................................53
"QPSB ......................................................................55
"OBDSPOJTNP ............................................................57
#JPHSBGB ...................................................................61
#JPQPMUJDB ................................................................65
$BOPO ......................................................................70
$PNQSFOTJOIJTUSJDB..............................................80
%FDPMPOJ[BDJO QFOTBNJFOUPEFDPMPOJBM
.................85
%FDPOTUSVDDJO .........................................................88
&TUSVDUVSBMJTNP ........................................................93
'FNJOJTNP FTDSJCJSMBIJTUPSJBEFMBTNVKFSFT
..........99
)JTUPSJDJTNP ...........................................................104
.BSDP FONBSDBNJFOUP
.........................................110
***'
y$JUBSBMPTHSBOEFTPQSFTDJOEJSEFMPTOPNCSFT .........123
1BVM7FZOF .............................................................126
&MJ[BCFUI%FFET&SNBSUI .......................................129
%PNJOJDL-B$BQSB .................................................132
'SBOL"OLFSTNJU....................................................135
)BZEFO8IJUF .......................................................138
,FJUI+FOLJOT .........................................................142
9
-VJT(%F.VTTZr.JHVFM7BMEFSSBNB
.JDIFMEF$FSUFBV .......................................................145
"MVO.VOTMPX .............................................................149
+PBO8BMMBDI4DPUU ......................................................151
*7.
y&TMBDPOEJDJOQPTUNPEFSOB
MBDPOEJDJOEFMPTNBOJFTUPT ....................................157
)JTUPSJPHSBGBZQPTUNPEFSOJTNP
Frank Ankersmit .....................................................159
.BOJFTUPJOBVHVSBM
Grupo de Estudios Subalternos ..............................185
-BPQDJOEFDPMPOJBM6ONBOJFTUP
Walter Mignolo ......................................................199
5JFNQPEFNBOJFTUPT
Hayden White ........................................................235
10
Historiografa postmoderna
11
Historiografa postmoderna
"
13
Historiografa postmoderna
"
15
-VJT(%F.VTTZr.JHVFM7BMEFSSBNB
BRVFMMPRVFJOUFSSVNQFFODBEBDBTPMBTNFNPSJBTZHFPHSBGBT
MBTHVBTZDPOUSBGVFSUFTDPORVFTFCVTDBQSFQBSBSVOWJBKF
BVO-
RVFTFBFMEFMBMFDUVSB UBMWF[
FMNTQFMJHSPTPEFUPEPT
$PNPTFBMEFUSDPFTUBBEWFSUFODJBRVJ[SFRVJFSBEFPUSP
DPNJFO[P
EFPUSBJNBHFODPORVEFTUBDBSFMDBSDUFSQSPWJTJP-
OBMZGSBHNFOUBSJPEFFTUFPUSPQPTJDJPOBNJFOUPIJTUPSJPHSDP
&MWJBKF
TJOEVEB
FTVOBJNBHFOQPEFSPTBQBSBJMVTUSBSFMNP-
WJNJFOUPEFQFOTBSBRVFRVFSFNPTEBSMVHBS1FSP
FMWJBKFOP
TMPFTNPWJNJFOUP
OPTMPFTUSBWFTB
UBNCJOFTTJOOJNPEF
DBSHBZTPCSFQFTP-BUBSFBEFQPOEFSBSBRVFMMPRVFTFIBEFMMF-
WBSBDVFTUBTOPTJFNQSFFTGDJM
FMDMDVMPTFDPOGVOEFNVDIBT
WFDFTDPOMBBGFDDJO
FMpathosZMBDPONPDJO/PQPSOBEBMB
WJFKBSFUSJDBFOTFBCBRVFMPTPCKFUJWPTEFMBMJUFSBUVSBOPTMP
FSBO DBVTBS QMBDFS delectare
F JOTUSVJS docere
B MPT MFDUPSFT
TJOPUBNCJODPONPWFSMPT movere
1PSFTUBSB[O
ZBUFOEJFO-
EPBMNPWJNJFOUPRVFCVTDBNPTJNQVMTBS
UBMWF[TFBOFDFTBSJP
PGSFDFS PUSP QVOUP EF QBSUJEB
PUSP QVFSUP EF FNCBSRVF EFTEF
EPOEFBDUJWBSGVUVSBTSFWVFMUBTFJOUFSWFODJPOFT
OVFWBTGVHBTZ
SFTJTUFODJBT
&OPUSBTQBMBCSBT
MPTBVUPSFTEFFTUBTMFDDJPOFTEBSBOQPS
DVNQMJEB TV UBSFB
TJ
B MB NBOFSB EFM MFDUPSJEFBM RVF -VEXJH
8JUUHFOTUFJOQSFHVSBQBSBFMTractatus logico-philosophicus
FM
MFDUPSPMFDUPSBEFFTUBHVBEFWJBKFQPSMB Historiografa post-
moderna TJOUJFSB MB JSSFTJTUJCMF OFDFTJEBE EF FNQSFOEFS PUSPT
SFDPSSJEPT
EF EBS MVHBS B OVFWPT NPWJNJFOUPT
BSSPKBOEP BT
jMB FTDBMFSB EFTQVT EF IBCFS TVCJEP QPS FMMBv -B JNBHFO FT
SFDVSSFOUF
DBTJVOMVHBSDPNOFOMBEPYBDPOUFNQPSOFB
QFSP
OPIFNPTQPEJEPOJRVFSJEPEFTQSFOEFSOPTEFFMMBFODBEBNP-
NFOUPEFMBFMBCPSBDJOEFFTUFJUJOFSBSJPEFWJBKF-BJNBHFO
TJOEVEB
ZBQFSUFOFDFBMBSDIJWPDVMUVSBMEFMBTIVNBOJEBEFT
QPSFTUBSB[OOPFTUEFNTWPMWFSBFMMBPUSBWF[BMDPNJFO[P
FTEFDJS
BMOBM
16
Historiografa postmoderna
*
Historiografa postmoderna
17
Historiografa postmoderna
*)
1
"OUIPOZ (JEEFOT
Modernidad e identidad del yo
#BSDFMPOB
1FOOTVMB
1994.
19
-VJT(%F.VTTZr.JHVFM7BMEFSSBNB
UFNQPSOFBTFMBWBODFEFVOQSPDFTPBDFMFSBEPEFWJSUVBMJ[BDJO
ZNFEJBUJ[BDJOmWJODVMBEPBVOFTUBEJPEFMBDVMUVSBFOMBDVBM
MPTQSPDFTPTEFEFTJHOBDJOZEFTJHOJDBDJOTFTVCPSEJOBOBMB
MHJDBEFMTJHOJDBOUFm
CJFOQVFEFTFSBQVOUBEBBRVDPNPVOB
JOUFSQSFUBDJOQMBVTJCMFEFMBDSJTJTEFSFQSFTFOUBDJORVFBGFDUB
IPZBMBTDJFODJBTTPDJBMFT
"QBSUJSEFFTUFDPOUFYUPEFEJTDVTJPOFT
DPOTUJUVJEPQPSVO
FTUJMPEFQFOTBNJFOUPRVFEFTDPOGBEFMBTOPDJPOFTDMTJDBTEF
WFSEBE
SB[O
JEFOUJEBE
PCKFUJWJEBEZVOJWFSTBMJEBE2
MBQSFPDV-
QBDJOQPSMBTJHOJDBDJOBMJOUFSJPSEFMBTDJFODJBTTPDJBMFTIB
EBEPMVHBSBVOFYUFOTPEFCBUFTPCSFMPTMNJUFTEFMBSFQSFTFOUB-
DJOZTPCSFFMUJQPEFEFUFSNJOBDJPOFTFTUSVDUVSBMFTRVFDPOEJ-
DJPOBOZMJNJUBOUPEBQSPEVDDJOEFDPOPDJNJFOUP&OFTUFTFO-
UJEP
OPTMPTFIBWVFMUPBFYBNJOBSDSUJDBNFOUFFMDPNQMFKPEF
SFMBDJPOFTRVFMBNPEFSOJEBEFTUBCMFDJCBKPMBTTJHOJDBDJPOFT
EFjTBCFSvZjQPEFSv
TJOPRVF
BMNJTNPUJFNQP
TFIBQVFTUP
FODVFTUJOMBQSPQJBEJTUJODJOFOUSFBQBSJFODJBZSFBMJEBE
FOUSF
JOUFSJPS Z FYUFSJPS
RVF TVCZBDB B MPT BOMJTJT NPEFSOPT EF MB
NRVJOBEFSFQSFTFOUBDJOEFMBJOWFTUJHBDJOTPDJBM
5BM WF[
QPS FMMP
QPS MB JNQPSUBODJB RVF FTUBT EJTUJODJPOFT
UJFOFO BM JOUFSJPS EF UPEP NPEFMP SFQSFTFOUBDJPOBM EF DPOPDJ-
NJFOUP
FTRVFIBTJEPFOFMNCJUPEFMBIJTUPSJPHSBGBFOEPOEF
MBDSJTJTEFMBTDJFODJBTTPDJBMFTTFIBQSFTFOUBEPDPONBZPSSB-
EJDBMJEBE&MOVFWPIJTUPSJDJTNP
MBWVFMUBEFMBOBSSBUJWB
ZMBT
OVFWBTGPSNBTEFFTDSJUVSBEFMBIJTUPSJB
TPOTMPBMHVOPTEFMPT
JOEJDJPTNTFWJEFOUFTEFMBDSJTJTRVFBGFDUBIPZBMBEJTDJQMJOB
1VFT
FOFGFDUP
EFTEFIBDFZBEPTEDBEBTFMQSPCMFNBDFOUSBMEF
MBIJTUPSJPHSBGBOPIBTJEPPUSPRVFSFTQPOEFSBMBQSFHVOUBQPS
MBQPTJCJMJEBEEFSFQSFTFOUBSFMQBTBEP4VCZBDFBFTUBQSFHVOUB
MBTPTQFDIBEFRVFTJFMEJTDVSTPTFDPOTUSVZFFOWJSUVEEFMBJN-
QPTJDJOEFVOBFTUSVDUVSBEFSFMBUPBVOEFUFSNJOBEPDPOKVOUP
EFBDPOUFDJNJFOUPT
MBFMFDDJOEFMUJQPEFSFMBUPOPFTFYUFSOBP
FYUFSJPSBMTJHOJDBEPEFMPTBDPOUFDJNJFOUPT
.TBMMEFMDPOTFOTPRVFFYJTUFFOMBBDUVBMJEBEBMNPNFO-
UPEFJEFOUJDBSMPTNPUJWPTQSJODJQBMFTEFMBMMBNBEBjDSJTJTEF
MBTDJFODJBTTPDJBMFTv
MPDJFSUPFTRVFDPJODJEFOUFNFOUFBQBSUJS
2
5FSSZ &BHMFUPO
Las ilusiones del posmodernismo
#VFOPT "JSFT
1BJET
1997.
20
Historiografa postmoderna
EFMPTBPTTFUFOUBEFMTJHMPQBTBEPTFIBQSPEVDJEPVOEFTQMB-
[BNJFOUPFOFMNCJUPEFMBTQSFPDVQBDJPOFTEFMBMPTPGBZMB
FQJTUFNPMPHBEFMBIJTUPSJB&TUFEFTQMB[BNJFOUPIBTJEPDBSBD-
UFSJ[BEP
NVDIBT WFDFT
CBKP FM USNJOP EF jHJSP MJOHTUJDPv
FOSB[OEFMBDSFDJFOUFBUFODJORVFFMMFOHVBKFZMBOBSSBDJO
UJFOFO FO MPT BOMJTJT NFUBIJTUPSJPHSDPT EF MB EJTDJQMJOB 4JO
EVEBBMHVOB
FTUFHJSPPWJSBKFIBDJBFMUFYUPZMBOBSSBDJOOP
FT FYDMVTJWP EF MB EJTDJQMJOB IJTUPSJPHSDB
Z QVFEF NVZ CJFO
TFSDBSBDUFSJ[BEPDPNPFMTOUPNBEFVOBNVUBDJOPGSBDUVSB
FOFMQFOTBNJFOUPMPTDPZTPDJBMEFMTJHMPXX&OMBIJTUPSJP-
HSBGB
TJOFNCBSHP
FMHJSPMJOHTUJDPOPTMPIBTVQVFTUPVOB
DSJTJTQBSBEJHNUJDBFOMBEJTDJQMJOB
FOFMDBNQPEFQSPCMFNUJ-
DBTRVFPSHBOJ[BCBOTVTPQFSBDJPOFTEFDPOPDJNJFOUP
TJOPRVF
BEFNTIBTVQVFTUPVOBHSBOBNFOB[BBMBJEFOUJEBEEJTDJQMJOBS
EFMBIJTUPSJB*EFOUJEBEDPOTUJUVJEBBQBSUJSEFVOBGVFSUFBMJBO[B
DPOMBTDJFODJBTTPDJBMFT&TUBBMJBO[BDBCFSFDPSEBSMPQFSNJUJ
FTUBCJMJ[BSMBJEFOUJEBEEJTDJQMJOBSEFMBIJTUPSJBDPNPjDJFODJB
IJTUSJDBv
BMFKOEPMB EF MB MPTPGB
MB MJUFSBUVSB Z MB MPMPHB
RVFBOBMFTEFMTJHMP9*9QBSFDBODPOGPSNBSTVFTQBDJPOBUVSBM
EFFOVODJBDJO-BQSPQJBEJTUJODJOFOUSFDJFODJBTOPNPUUJDBT
ZDJFODJBTJEJPHSDBT
BDVBEBQPSFMOFPLBOUJTNPBMFNOEF
OFT EFM TJHMP 9*9
EB DVFOUB EF FTUB BMJBO[B QSJNJHFOJB FOUSF
IJTUPSJBZIVNBOJEBEFT"MJBO[BRVFGVFSPUBBNFEJBEPTEFMPT
BPTDVBSFOUBEFMTJHMPQBTBEP
BQBSUJSEFMBDSFDJFOUFIFHFNP-
OBEFMBFTDVFMBEFAnnalesFOMBIJTUPSJPHSBGBNVOEJBM$BCF
SFDPSEBSRVFFTUBIFHFNPOBFTUOUJNBNFOUFBTPDJBEBBMEFTB-
SSPMMPRVFMBTDJFODJBTTPDJBMFTUVWJFSPOEVSBOUFFMDPSUPTJHMPXX
ZRVFOPFTJOEJGFSFOUFBMQBQFMRVFFTUBTDJFODJBTCVTDBSPOKVHBS
FOMBTHVFSSBTDVMUVSBMFTEFMTJHMP
4JFMTJHMP XXUFSNJOBDPOMBDBEBEFMNVSPEF#FSMO
UBMZ
DPNP BSNB &SJD )PCTCBXN
P TJ
QPS FM DPOUSBSJP
FTUF TJHMP
UFSNJOBDPOFMOBMEFMBMBSHBEDBEBEFMPTTFTFOUB
DPNPQJFO-
TBOFOUSFPUSPT'SFESJD+BNFTPOZ"MBJO#BEJPV
MPDJFSUPFTRVF
DPJODJEFOUFNFOUFFMOBMEFMTJHMPXXQBSFDFDPJODJEJSDPOFMO
EF MB NPEFSOJEBE"UFOJOEPOPT B FTUB UFTJT
QPESB BEWFSUJSTF
RVFIJTUPSJPHSDBNFOUFFMOEFTJHMPTVQPOFVOBUSJQMFSVQUVSB
FOFMPSEFOEFMQFOTBNJFOUPNPEFSOP3VQUVSBEFMBTBMJBO[BT
RVFPSHBOJ[BSPOMBQSPEVDDJOEFDPOPDJNJFOUPDJFOUDPFOMB
21
-VJT(%F.VTTZr.JHVFM7BMEFSSBNB
NPEFSOJEBESVQUVSBEFMBTVOJEBEFTEFQSPEVDDJORVFPSHBOJ-
[BSPOUBOUPMBEJWJTJOTPDJBMEFMUSBCBKPFOFMDBNQPDJFOUDP
DPNPMPTQSPDFTPTEFMFHJUJNBDJOEFMBQSPEVDDJOEFFTFDPOP-
DJNJFOUPSVQUVSBEFMBDBEFOBEFDBUFHPSBTRVFFTUSVDUVSBCBO
MBT QSPYJNJEBEFT Z EJTUBODJBT FOUSF QPEFS Z DPOPDJNJFOUP
FO-
USFSB[OZFNBODJQBDJO&TUBUSJQMFSVQUVSBQVFEFTFSUBNCJO
BQSFIFOEJEBDPNPVOBNVUBDJOPUSBOTGPSNBDJO
QFSPMPDJFS-
UPFTRVFFMMBTFBMBVODBNCJPEFQPDBRVFIPZTFBTPDJBmZB
TJOEJTDVTJOmDPOMBQPTUNPEFSOJEBE
-JNJUBOEPFMBOMJTJTBMPSEFOEFMBIJTUPSJPHSBGB
DBCFEFT-
UBDBSRVFFMHJSPMJOHTUJDPFOMBEJTDJQMJOBDPJODJEFUFNQPSBM-
NFOUFDPOFMOEFTJHMPZDPOFMOEFMBNPEFSOJEBE&OFGFDUP
QVFEFEFDJSTFRVFMPTPSHFOFTEFMBIJTUPSJPHSBGBQPTUNPEFSOB
FTUOOUJNBNFOUFBTPDJBEPTBMBQVCMJDBDJOEFUSFTMJCSPTGVO-
EBNFOUBMFTRVFUFOESOFGFDUPTEFWBTUBEPSFTTPCSFFMDBOPOEF
MB SFQSFTFOUBDJO IJTUPSJBEPSB NPEFSOB 5SFT MJCSPT RVF EFTEF
EJTUJOUPTQVOUPTEFWJTUBBCSJSOMBEJTDVTJOFQJTUFNPMHJDBEF
MBIJTUPSJBOPTPMPBMBQSPCMFNUJDBEFMDBOPOIJTUPSJPHSDP
TJOPRVFBUSBWTEFFTUBQSPCMFNUJDB
FOVOUSBCBKPEFQFSGPSB-
DJOPEFDBQUVSBEFMFMFNFOUPJNQFOTBEPEFMBNJTNB
BCSJSO
EJDIB EJTDVTJO BM QSPCMFNB EF MB QSPEVDDJO EF WBMPS FO IJT-
UPSJPHSBGB
BMPRVFQPESBMMBNBSTFFMUSBCBKPEFWBMPSJ[BDJO
IJTUPSJPHSDBEFMPTPCKFUPTZMBUFNQPSBMJEBE&MQSJNFSPEF
FTUPTMJCSPTQFSUFOFDFB1BVM7FZOF
ZMMFWBQPSUUVMPComment
on crit lhistoire. Essai depistmologie
&MTFHVOEPMJCSP
GVF QVCMJDBEP FO JOHMT
B DPNJFO[PT EF MPT BPT TFUFOUB
Z FT
PCSB EF VO IJTUPSJBEPS FTUBEPVOJEFOTF EF NFEJBOB FEBE DVZB
UFTJT EPDUPSBM TF IBCB DFOUSBEP FO MPT QSPCMFNBT EFM QBQBEP
SPNBOPEFDPNJFO[PTEFMTJHMP9**
ZFOMBJOVFODJBRVFHVSBT
DPNP#FSOBSEPEF$MBJSWBVYIBCBOUFOJEPFOMBSFGPSNBEFMB
JHMFTJBSPNBOB&MMJCSPFTMetahistory. The Historical Imagina-
tion in Nineteenth-Century Europe
ZTVBVUPS)BZEFO
8IJUF"QFOBT DPO EPT BPT EF EJGFSFODJB
QFSP FTDSJUP FO VO
VOJWFSTPJOUFMFDUVBMQBSBMFMPBMEF)BZEFO8IJUF
FMIJTUPSJBEPS
ZQTJDPBOBMJTUBGSBODT
.JDIFMEF$FSUFBV
EBBMBTQSFOTBTFO
1BST
Lcriture de lhistoire
-BQVCMJDBDJOEFFTUPTUSFT
MJCSPTDPJODJEFDPOFMOEFMBMBSHBEDBEBEFMPTBPTTFTFOUB
FTEFDJS
DPOFMUSNJOPEFMMUJNPDJDMPEFNPWJMJ[BDJPOFTZNP-
22
Historiografa postmoderna
WJNJFOUPTSFWPMVDJPOBSJPTRVFDJFSSBOFMTJHMP XXZMBNPEFSOJ-
EBE3.
%FBIRVFEFTEFDJFSUBQFSTQFDUJWBMBQVCMJDBDJOEFFTUPT
USBCBKPTQVFEBMFFSTFDPNPBOUJDJQBEPSBEFVODBNCJPEFQBSB-
EJHNBFOFMBOMJTJTEFMBUSBEJDJODSUJDB
FTEFDJS
DPNPUFYUPT
RVF
BTVNPEP
CVTDBODPOEJWFSTBTIFSSBNJFOUBTBUSBWFTBSMB
GBOUBTBJEFPMHJDBEFMBIJTUPSJBQBSBBEFOUSBSTFFOMPTNPEPT
EFQSPEVDDJOZSFQSPEVDDJOEFTVSFQSFTFOUBDJO
&TUFNPWJNJFOUPOPFTVONPWJNJFOUPBJTMBEPFOMBEJTDJQMJ-
OB
QVFT
QPESBBEWFSUJSTFRVFMPTPSHFOFTEFMB/VFWB)JTUPSJB
FOQBTFTDPNP$IJMFP*OHMBUFSSB
UJFOFDPNPQVOUPEFQBSUJEB
MBNJTNBDBUTUSPGFIJTUSJDBRVFDBSBDUFSJ[FTFTJHMPEFFYUSF-
NPTSFMBUBEPQPS)PCTCBXN2VJ[TMPEJTUJOUJWPEFFTUPTUSFT
USBCBKPT
EFTEFFMQVOUPEFWJTUBEFTVMJBDJOJOUFMFDUVBM
TFB
MBJNQPSUBODJBRVFUVWPFODBEBVOPEFFMMPTMBPCSBEF.JDIFM
'PVDBVMU &O FGFDUP
FTUB BSNBDJO FT WMJEB OP TMP QBSB MB
PCSBEF1BVM7FZOF
RVJFOEFTMVNCSBEPQPSFMQFOTBNJFOUPEF
'PVDBVMUFTDSJCJSBMHVOPTBPTNTUBSEF
BQSPQTJUPEFMBQV-
CMJDBDJOEFLArchologie du savoir
VOFOTBZPUJUVMBEP
Foucault rvolutionne lhistoire4TJOPRVFUBNCJOQVFEFBQMJ-
DBSTFDPOQSPQJFEBEBMUSBCBKPEF.JDIFMEF$FSUFBV
PCSBRVF
QVFEFMFFSTFDPNPVOEJMPHPJOJOUFSSVNQJEPDPOFMQFOTBNJFO-
UPGPVDBVMUJBOP&OFGFDUP
ZBEFTEFFMQSJNFSZFYUFOTPDPNFO-
UBSJPRVF%F$FSUFBVEFEJDBSBBLes mots et les choses
IBTUB BRVFM UFYUP RVF FM IJTUPSJBEPS FTDSJCJFSB FO IPNFOBKF BM
BNJHPEFTBQBSFDJEPBNFEJBEPTEFMPTBPTPDIFOUB5
TFPCTFSWB
VOBQSFPDVQBDJOBGOQPSJOUFSSPHBSMBTQSDUJDBTZEJTQPTJUJWPT
EFMBJOTUJUVDJOIJTUPSJBEPSB
QPSEFTDSJCJSMPTQSPHSBNBTEFQP-
3
'SFESJD+BNFTPO
j1FSJPEJ[JOHUIFv
The Ideologies of Theory: Essays
1971-1986
WPM
The Syntax of History
.JOOFBQPMJT
6OJWFSTJUZPG.JO-
OFTPUB
QQ
4
-BQSPYJNJEBEDPOMBTUFTJTGPVDBVMUJBOBTFTUBMRVF7FZOFBBEFBMBSF-
FEJDJOEFTVPCSBEFCPMTJMMP
FO
FMFOTBZPFTDSJUPVOUJFNQPBOUFT
TPCSF'PVDBVMU7BTF
1BVM7FZOF
j'PVDBVMUSWPMVUJPOOFMIJTUPJSFv
Com-
ment on crit lhistoire
1BST
-F4FVJM
1PJOUTIJTUPJSF
QQ
"TJNJTNP
FT EF HSBO JOUFST TV SFDJFOUF QSFTFOUBDJO EF 'PVDBVMU DPNP
jun penseur sceptiquev"M SFTQFDUP
1BVM7FZOF
Foucault. Sa pense, sa
personne
1BST
"MCJO.JDIFM
5
.JDIFMEF$FSUFBV
j-FSJSFEF.JDIFM'PVDBVMUv
Histoire et psychanalyse
1BST
EJUJPOT(BMMJNBSE
QQ
23
-VJT(%F.VTTZr.JHVFM7BMEFSSBNB
EFSZWFSEBERVFFTUBTQSDUJDBTBDUVBMJ[BOZMPTFGFDUPTRVFFTUPT
QSPHSBNBTUJFOFOTPCSFMBWJEBZMPTDVFSQPT-BPCSBEF)BZEFO
8IJUF
QPSPUSBQBSUF
TJCJFOQPSNPNFOUPTQBSFDFPSHBOJ[BEBB
QBSUJSEFVOBDPOWFSTBDJOBCJFSUBDPOMBHSBOUSBEJDJOFVSPQFB
RVF WB EF7JDP B .BSY
EF $SPDF B $PMMJOHXPPE
EF"VFSCB-
DIB#BSUIFT
JHVBMNFOUFQBSFDFJODPODFCJCMFTJOMBSFGFSFODJBBM
NBSDPEFMBOMJTJTGPVDBVMUJBOP-PTMBSHPTFTUVEJPTRVF8IJUF
DPOTBHSBB'PVDBVMUFOThe Content of the Form6ZFOTropics of
Discourse7EBODVFOUBEFMBJNQPSUBODJBRVFFMMTPGPGSBODT
UJFOFFOFMQSPZFDUPUSPQPMHJDPEFMetahistory&TNT
KVHBOEP
VOQPDPDPOMPTTJHOJDBOUFTZMPTEFTQMB[BNJFOUPT
QPESBEF-
DJSTFRVF'PVDBVMUSFQSFTFOUBQBSB8IJUFMBQPTJCJMJEBENFUPO-
NJDBEFVOQVOUPEFOPSFUPSOPFOFMBOMJTJTEFMBTQSDUJDBTEF
MBJOTUJUVDJOIJTUPSJBEPSB
FMSFMFWPBQPUSPQBJDPRVFQFSNJUJSB
JONVOJ[BSFMUSBCBKPEFEFDPOTUSVDDJOEFMBTFTUSBUFHJBTUFYUVB-
MFTEFMBQSDUJDBIJTUPSJBEPSB
GSFOUFBDVBMRVJFSUFOUBDJOEFMB
EJTDJQMJOBQPSSFUPSOBSBMBDPODJFODJBIJTUSJDBEFMTJHMP9*9.
-B SFMFWBODJB EFM NFUBUFYUP GPVDBVMUJBOP FO MBT USFT PCSBT
TFBMBEBTTFBEWJFSUFDMBSBNFOUFFOMBjBQFSUVSBBSRVFPMHJDBv
RVF MBT USFT PCSBT QPTJCJMJUBO B VO QSPHSBNB QPTUNPEFSOP EF
EFDPOTUSVDDJO EF MB JOTUJUVDJO IJTUPSJBEPSB 4FB DVBM TFB TV
BMDBODF
TFB DVBMFT GVFSFO MPT GVOEBNFOUPT FOVODJBEPT FO FTF
QSPHSBNBEFEFDPOTUSVDDJOEFMBIJTUPSJPHSBGB
MPDJFSUPFTRVF
TVEFTBSSPMMPIBQFSNJUJEPBEWFSUJSMBTMJNJUBDJPOFTEFUPEPUSB-
CBKPDSUJDPBMJOUFSJPSEFMPRVF(BZBUSJ$IBLSBWPSUZ4QJWBLIB
EFOPNJOBEPMBjNRVJOBQFEBHHJDBv
&OPUSBTQBMBCSBT
FMDVFTUJPOBNJFOUPBMBJOTUJUVDJORVFTF
BEJWJOBFOMBQSDUJDBEFMBIJTUPSJPHSBGBQPTUNPEFSOB
FOUFO-
EJEBFTUBDPNPQSDUJDBEFDPOTUSVDUJWB
FTEFDJS
DPNPQSDUJDB
QBSBTJUBSJBZTVQMFNFOUBSJBBMPTEJTQPTJUJWPTEFTBCFSEJTDJQMJ-
OBS
OPUJFOFPUSBOBMJEBERVFMBEFEFTNPOUBSMBTFTUSVDUVSBT
EFQPEFSRVFPSHBOJ[BOMPTNPEPTEFFOVODJBDJOZEFSFQSFTFO-
6
)BZEFO 8IJUF
j'PVDBVMUT %JTDPVSTF 5IF )JTUPSJPHSBQIZ PG "OUJ)V-
NBOJTNv
The Content of the Form: Narrative Discourse and Historical
Representation
#BMUJNPSF
5IF+PIOT)PQLJOT6OJWFSTJUZ1SFTT
QQ
104-141.
7
)BZEFO8IJUF
j'PVDBVMU%FDPEFE/PUFTGSPN6OEFSHSPVOEv
Tropics of
Discourse. Essays in Cultural Criticism
#BMUJNPSF
5IF+PIOT)PQLJOT6OJ-
WFSTJUZ1SFTT
QQ
24
Historiografa postmoderna
UBDJOEFMB)JTUPSJB&TUPTEJTQPTJUJWPTOPTPMPFTUOGVOEBEPT
FOSFMBDJPOFTEFQPEFSFKFSDJEBTDPOCSVUBMJEBEPSFOBNJFOUPBM
JOUFSJPSEFMBJOTUJUVDJOIJTUPSJBEPSB
TJOPRVF
BEFNT
PSHBOJ-
[BOTVFDBDJBBQBSUJSEFDJFSUBDFHVFSBTPCSFMPTQSPQJPTFGFDUPT
QFSGPSNBUJWPTEFMBSFQSFTFOUBDJOIJTUPSJBEPSB&TUBBSNBDJO
PCMJHB B MFFS B 'PVDBVMU KVOUP DPO %FSSJEB8 &YUSBB QPS FMMP
RVF,FJUI+FOLJOT
UBMWF[VOPEFMPTQSJODJQBMFTJNQVMTPSFTFO
MFOHVB JOHMFTB EF VO QSPHSBNB EF IJTUPSJPHSBGB QPTUNPEFSOB
HVBSEFTJMFODJPTPCSFMBJNQPSUBODJBEFMBPCSBGPVDBVMUJBOBFO
MBSFEFOJDJOEFMPTBOMJTJTEFMBTJOTUJUVDJPOFTZQSDUJDBTEFM
TBCFS NPEFSOP9 &TUF TJMFODJP
TJOUPNUJDP EF DJFSUB MFDUVSB EF
MBQSPCMFNUJDBQPTUNPEFSOBFOIJTUPSJPHSBGB
QVFEFTFSJOUFS-
QSFUBEP DPNP VOB DFHVFSB GSFOUF B MBT USBOTGPSNBDJPOFT EF MB
SFMBDJOQPEFSDPOPDJNJFOUPFOFMDBNQPEFMBQPTUNPEFSOJEBE
&YQSFTBEPFOPUSPTUSNJOPT
MPRVFWJFOFBTPNFUFSTFBVOBEF-
DPOTUSVDDJOSBEJDBMFOMBIJTUPSJPHSBGBQPTUNPEFSOBOPFTTPMP
MBQSPQJBOPDJOEF)JTUPSJB DPOTUJUVJEBTUBQPSGVFSBEFUPEP
USBCBKPEFSFQSFTFOUBDJO
TJOPRVFFTQPSTPCSFUPEPMBNBRVJ-
OBSJB SFQSFTFOUBDJPOBM RVF PSHBOJ[B FM DVFSQP EF TBCFSFT EF MB
IJTUPSJPHSBGB&TUBEFDPOTUSVDDJOQBSBEKJDBNFOUFTVQPOFVOB
IJTUPSJ[BDJOSBEJDBMEFMBTQSDUJDBTIJTUPSJBEPSBT
EFMBTDBUF-
HPSBTRVFMBDPOGPSNBO
ZEFMKVFHPEFPQPTJDJPOFTZSFMBDJPOFT
RVFPSHBOJ[BOFMUSBCBKPEFWBMPSJ[BDJOPEFDSFBDJOEFWBMPS
FO MB JOTUJUVDJO IJTUPSJBEPSB 1VFT
MB QSPQJB JEFB EF )JTUPSJB
TVQPOFEFTEFVOQSJODJQJP
VOQSPDFTPEFWBMPSJ[BDJOEFMBWJEB
VOUSBCBKPEFDSFBDJOEFWBMPSRVFOPFTFYUFSOPBMBNRVJOB
BOUSPQPHOJDBEFQSPEVDDJOEFMPIVNBOP
6OBOMJTJTEFDPOTUSVDUJWPEFMBTSFMBDJPOFTEFQPEFSZDP-
OPDJNJFOUP BM JOUFSJPS EF MB IJTUPSJPHSBGB SFRVJFSF
QPS UBOUP
FYBNJOBS FM UNQBOP RVF SFHVMB MP FOVODJBCMF Z MP BVEJCMF FO
FMFTQBDJPEFMBEJTDJQMJOB
DPNPEFTNPOUBSFMDPOKVOUPEFDBUF-
HPSBTRVFPSHBOJ[BOFTFNJTNPUSBCBKPEFDSUJDBZBOMJTJT
EF
DMOJDBZFTDVDIB
8
(BZBUSJ$IBLSBWPSUZ4QJWBL
j.PSFPO1PXFS,OPXMFEHFv
Outside in the
Teaching Machine
-POESFT
3PVEUMFEHF
Q
9
,FJUI +FOLJOT
Why History? Ethics and postmodernity
-POESFT
3PVU-
MFEHF
25
-VJT(%F.VTTZr.JHVFM7BMEFSSBNB
10
'SFESJD +BNFTPO
The Political Unconscious
*UIBDB
$PSOFMM 6OJWFSTJUZ
1SFTT
26
Historiografa postmoderna
11
+BDRVFT3BODJSF
Le partage du sensible
1BST
-B'BCSJRVF
12
)BZEFO8IJUF
j.BOJGFTUP UJNFv ,FJUI +FOLJOT
4VF .PSHBOE BOE"MVO
.VOTMPX FET
Manifestos for History
-POESFT
3PVUMFEHF
QQ
220-231.
27
-VJT(%F.VTTZr.JHVFM7BMEFSSBNB
UFDJNJFOUP DPNP BMHP OP QSFTFOUF
QFSP RVF CVTDB EBSTF FO MP
RVFFTUQSFTFOUF
ZBTFMPEFOBDPNPDPOUSBSJPBMPTIFDIPT
QFSPSFBMJ[OEPTFFOFMMPT
BERVJSJFOEPBDUVBMJEBEZQSFTFODJBFO
FMMPT
QFSPJOWBSJBCMFNFOUFEFGPSNBQSPWJTJPOBMZNPEJDBCMF
TJFNQSFTFUSBUBEFFMBCPSBSVODPODFQUPEFBDPOUFDJNJFOUPQPS
GVFSBEFMBMFZEFMBUFNQPSBMJEBE
EFVOBDPOUFDJNJFOUPTJFNQSF
QPSWFOJS
TJFNQSFTVTQFOEJEPFOFMNPNFOUPEFTVSFBMJ[BDJO
-B BOHVTUJB RVF QSPEVDF MB SFQSFTFOUBDJO EFM BDPOUFDJNJFOUP
FOMBQPTUNPEFSOJEBEFTUOUJNBNFOUFBTPDJBEBBMQSPCMFNBEF
MBJOTDSJQDJOEFMBDPOUFDJNJFOUP
BMBMJUFSBSJFEBEQPSWFOJSRVF
PSHBOJ[BSMPTNPEPTEFTVSFQSFTFOUBDJO
.T BO
DPNP FTDSJCF )BZEFO 8IJUF FO Tropics of Dis-
course
FMBDPOUFDJNJFOUPIJTUSJDP
USBEJDJPOBMNFOUFDPODFCJEP
DPNPVOBDPOUFDJNJFOUPRVFGVFOPTPMPPCTFSWBCMFTJOPUBN-
CJOPCTFSWBEP
FTQPSEFOJDJOVOBDPOUFDJNJFOUPRVFZBOPFT
NTPCTFSWBCMFZ
QPSUBOUP
OPQVFEFTFSWJSDPNPPCKFUPEFVO
DPOPDJNJFOUPUBOTFHVSPDPNPFMEFMPTBDPOUFDJNJFOUPTQSFTFO-
UFT
MPTDVBMFTBOQVFEFOTFSPCTFSWBEPT1FSPFTBRV
DPOUJOVB
8IJUF
EPOEF MB EJTUJODJO FOUSF IFDIP Z BDPOUFDJNJFOUP EFCF
TFSTVCSBZBEB-BOPDJOEFBDPOUFDJNJFOUPIJTUSJDPIBTVGSJ-
EPVOBUSBOTGPSNBDJOSBEJDBMDPNPSFTVMUBEPEFMBPDVSSFODJB
FOFMTJHMP XXEFBDPOUFDJNJFOUPTEFVOBMDBODF
FTDBMBZQSP-
GVOEJEBEJOJNBHJOBCMFTQBSBIJTUPSJBEPSFTEFPUSPTUJFNQPT%F
JHVBMNPEP
FMTJHMPXXIBTJEPUFTUJHPEFVOEFTNBOUFMBNJFOUP
EFM DPODFQUP EF BDPOUFDJNJFOUP DPNP PCKFUP EF DPOPDJNJFOUP
FTQFDDBNFOUFDJFOUDP13-BTUSBOTGPSNBDJPOFTUFMFUFDOPNF-
EJUJDBTEFMBTPDJFEBEDPOUFNQPSOFBTVQPOFO
OFDFTBSJBNFO-
UF
USBOTGPSNBDJPOFTPGSBDUVSBTJOJNBHJOBCMFTFOMPTNPEPTEF
SFHJTUSP
DPOTJHOBDJO
HVSBDJO
MFDUVSBFJOUFSQSFUBDJOEFMPT
BDPOUFDJNJFOUPT &TUB BSNBDJO JODVNCF QSJODJQBMNFOUF B MB
IJTUPSJB
TJTFIBEFBEWFSUJSRVFMBEJTDJQMJOBIJTUPSJPHSDBOPFT
TJOPFMSFTVMUBEPEFVOBSFWPMVDJOUFMFUFDOPNFEJUJDB
1PSPUSBQBSUF
MBQSPQJBEJTUJODJOFOUSFMPTBTQFDUPTGFOP-
NOJDPTEFMBDPOUFDJNJFOUP TVFYUFSJPS
ZTVTFOUJEPPTJHOJDB-
EP TVJOUFSJPS
IBTJEPTFSJBNFOUFDVFTUJPOBEBFOMBTEJTDVTJPOFT
DPOUFNQPSOFBT&MTJHOJDBEPEFMPTBDPOUFDJNJFOUPTOPQVFEF
13
)BZEFO8IJUF
Tropics of Discourse
#BMUJNPSF
+PIOT)PQLJOT6OJWFSTJUZ
1SFTT
QQ
28
Historiografa postmoderna
EJTUJOHVJSTF EF TV PDVSSFODJB
QFSP FTUB FT JOFTUBCMF
VJEB
FT-
QFDUSBM5BO FTQFDUSBM DPNP FM NPWJNJFOUP FO DNBSB MFOUB
FM
OHVMPJOWFSTP
FMzoomZMBSFJUFSBDJOEFMBTSFQSFTFOUBDJPOFT
FOWJEFPEFMBUBRVFBMBT5PSSFT(FNFMBTFO/VFWB:PSLPEFM
CPNCBSEFPBM1BMBDJPEFMB.POFEBFO4BOUJBHPEF$IJMF
4J FTUB EFTNBUFSJBMJ[BDJO EFM BDPOUFDJNJFOUP NPEFSOP FT
BOMPHBBMBEFTNBUFSJBMJ[BDJOEFMBPCSBEFBSUF
TJFMMBFTQSP-
EVDUP EF MBT USBOTGPSNBDJPOFT UFMFUFDOPMHJDBT Z EF MBT USBOT-
GPSNBDJPOFT FO MB MJUFSBSJFEBE RVF MB MJUFSBUVSB BEFMBOUB DPNP
SHJNFOEFMPTFOTJCMF
FTBMHPRVFBOFTUQFOEJFOUFFOMBEJTDV-
TJO4JOEVEB
FO$IJMFMPTBDUVBMFTEFCBUFTTPCSFMBTSFMBDJPOFT
FOUSF BSUF
QPMUJDB F IJTUPSJB
TPCSF MB SFMBDJO FOUSF BDPOUFDJ-
NJFOUPFJOTDSJQDJO TJUPEBWBDBCFIBCMBSFOFTUPTUSNJOPT
UJFOFO QPS DFOUSP FTUBT DVFTUJPOFT14 2VJ[ QPS FMMP DPOWFOHB
USBFSBMBNFNPSJBVODPNFOUBSJPEF8JMMZ5IBZFSTPCSFFMBDPO-
UFDJNJFOUPFOFMUJFNQPUFMFUFDOPNFEJUJDPEFMBFTQFDUSBMJEBE
EFM QSFTFOUF j-B GPUPHSBGB DPO RVF FM ONFSP FTQFDJBM EF El
MercurioEFMEFTFQUJFNCSFEFMIJ[PDJSDVMBS
VOBWF[
NT
MBJNBHFOUFMFEJHJUBMEFMDJFMPEF/VFWB:PSLRVFNBOEPMBT
QBOUBMMBTZMBTQPSUBEBTEFMQMBOFUB
JNBHFORVFEVSBOUFUPEPFTF
BPOPEFKBNPTEFWFSVOBZPUSBWF[FOMB 57EFMFTDBQBSBUFP
EFMSFTUBVSBOUF
PFOFMTPGEFMBDBTB
PFOMBJNBHJOBDJOUBM
GPUPHSBGBOPDJUBUBOUPFMFTUBMMJEPEFMBTUPSSFT
TJOPFMFWFOUPEF
TVNFEJBDJO
FMBDPOUFDJNJFOUPDPNPNFEJBDJO
MBNFEJBDJO
DPNPBDPOUFDJNJFOUP w
&TUPOPRVJFSFEFDJSRVFZBOPIBZ
NTBDPOUFDJNJFOUPBMRVFEBSTUFTVCTVNJEPFOMBNFEJBDJO
2VJFSFEFDJSRVFMBNFEJBDJOBDPOUFDF
OPDFTBEFBDPOUFDFS
OP
EFKBEFDPJODJEJSMBNFEJBDJOFOFMBDPOUFDJNJFOUPZFMBDPOUF-
DJNJFOUPFOMBNFEJBDJOv15.
-PTQSPCMFNBTPBQPSBTRVFFTUBTDVFTUJPOFTQMBOUFBOBMB
EJTDJQMJOB
PCMJHBBIJTUPSJBEPSFTFIJTUPSJBEPSBTBSFJOJDJBSVOB
DPOGSPOUBDJO DSUJDB DPO FM DPOKVOUP EF MB USBEJDJO IJTUPSJP-
HSDBPDDJEFOUBM&TUBDPOGSPOUBDJOOFDFTBSJBNFOUFTJUBBMB
14
/FMMZ3JDIBSE
Fracturas de la memoria
#VFOPT"JSFT
4JHMP99*&EJUPSFT
.JHVFM7BMEFSSBNB
Modernismos historiogrficos
4BOUJBHPEF$IJMF
1BMJOPEJB
8JMMZ5IBZFS
Tecnologas de la crtica
4BOUJBHPEF$IJMF
&EJDJPOFT.FUBMFTQFTBEPT
15
8JMMZ5IBZFS
El fragmento repetido
4BOUJBHPEF$IJMF
&EJDJPOFT.FUBMFT
QFTBEPT
QQ
29
-VJT(%F.VTTZr.JHVFM7BMEFSSBNB
16
-VJT(EF.VTTZ FE
Balance historiogrfico chileno. El orden del discur-
so y el giro crtico actual
4BOUJBHPEF$IJMF
&EJDJPOFT'JOJT5FSSBF
17
1BSBFTUBDSUJDB
WBTF
/TUPS(BSDB$BODMJOJ
j&TUVEJPT$VMUVSBMFTyVO
TBCFS FO FTUBEP EF EJDDJPOBSJP v
/FMMZ 3JDIBSE FE
En torno a los es-
tudios culturales. Localidades, trayectorias y disputas
4BOUJBHP EF $IJMF
$-"$40&EJUPSJBM"3$*4
QQ
30
Historiografa postmoderna
18
-BJEFBEFVOQSPHSBNBEFSFTQPOTBCJMJEBETPDJBMFIJTUSJDBQBSBMBEJT-
DJQMJOB
FO UBOUP jDJFODJB TPDJBMv
TF SFWFMB QSPGVOEBNFOUF DPOTFSWBEPSB
BMOPDVFTUJPOBSFMTVQVFTUPBOUSPQPMHJDPRVFMBSJHFZEFUFSNJOB MBJEFB
EFIVNBOJEBE
ZBMOPSFWJTBSDSUJDBNFOUFMPTEJTQPTJUJWPTJOTUJUVDJPOBMFT
RVFMBTPQPSUBO6OFMSFQSFTFOUBOUFEFFTUBQPTJDJODPOTFSWBEPSBFOMB
IJTUPSJPHSBGBDIJMFOBFT(BCSJFM4BMB[BS7BTF
(4BMB[BS
j)JTUPSJPHSBGB
DIJMFOBTJHMP99*USBOTGPSNBDJO
SFTQPOTBCJMJEBE
QSPZFDDJOv
-VJT(EF
.VTTZ FE
Balance historiogrfico chileno
PQDJU
QQ
31
-VJT(%F.VTTZr.JHVFM7BMEFSSBNB
19
1BSB VOB EFDPOTUSVDDJO EF MB USBEJDJO FQJTUFNPMHJDB EPNJOBOUF FO MB
IJTUPSJPHSBGBNPEFSOB
.JHVFM7BMEFSSBNB
Posthistoria. Historiografa y
comunidad
4BOUJBHPEF$IJMF
1BMJOPEJB
-VJT(EF.VTTZ
j)JTUP-
SJPHSBGBT DPNQBSBEBT &MAUPUBM DFSP EF MB IJTUPSJPHSBGB DIJMFOB BDUVBMv
ARBOR. Ciencia, pensamiento y cultura
$-999***
/
.BESJE
QQ
32
Historiografa postmoderna
20
$MFNFOU(SFFOCFSH
j5IF$SJTJTPGUIF&BTFM1JDUVSFv
The Collected Essays
and Criticism
WPM
Arrogant Purpose, 1945-1949
$IJDBHP
5IF6OJWFS-
TJUZPG$IJDBHP1SFTT
QQ1BSBVOBFYQPTJDJODSUJDBEFMBT
UFTJTEF(SFFOCFSH
WBTF
"SUIVS%BOUP
j.PEFSOJTNBOEUIF$SJUJRVFPG
1VSF"SU5IF)JTUPSJDBM7JTJPOPG$MFNFOU(SFFOCFSHv
After the End of
Art. Contemporary Art and the Pale of History
1SJODFUPO
1SJODFUPO6OJ-
WFSTJUZ1SFTT
QQ
21
"SUIVS %BOUP
j.PEFSOJTN BOE UIF $SJUJRVF PG 1VSF"SU5IF )JTUPSJDBM
7JTJPOPG$MFNFOU(SFFOCFSHv
After the End of Art
PQDJU
Q
33
-VJT(%F.VTTZr.JHVFM7BMEFSSBNB
22
'SBOL "OLFSTNJU
j4UBUFNFOUT
5FYUT BOE 1JDUVSFTv
'SBOL "OLFSTNJU Z
)BOT ,FMMOFS FET
A New Philosophy of History
$IJDBHP
5IF 6OJWFS-
TJUZ PG $IJDBHP 1SFTT
QQ 'SBOL "OLFSTNJU
Experiencia
histrica sublime
4BOUJBHPEF$IJMF
1BMJOPEJB
34
Historiografa postmoderna
"QFTBSEFMBTJMVNJOBEPSBTDPOFYJPOFTRVFQSPNFUFFMBO-
MJTJT EF"OLFSTNJU
FTUF FO MUJNB JOTUBODJB EFCF TFS TVQFSBEP
QVFT
OPBEWJFSUFDPODMBSJEBEMBTDPOTFDVFODJBTRVFFMHJSPBCT-
USBDUPNBUFSJBMUFOESBQBSBMBQJOUVSBZMBIJTUPSJPHSBGB&OMB
QJOUVSBMBTDPOTFDVFODJBTEFFTUFHJSPZBIBOTJEPBNQMJBNFOUF
TFBMBEBTZEJTDVUJEBT
BMQVOUPEFRVF"SUIVS%BOUPIBMMFHBEP
BBTPDJBSFMTVSHJNJFOUPEFMNPEFSOJTNPFOMBQJOUVSBDPOjMB
NVFSUFEFMBQJOUVSBv&OIJTUPSJPHSBGB
FNQFSP
MBTDPOTFDVFO-
DJBTEFMHJSPIBDJBMBBCTUSBDDJOZMBNBUFSJBMJEBEBOOPIBO
TJEPTVDJFOUFNFOUFUFNBUJ[BEBTFOMPTEFCBUFTEFMBQSDUJDBZ
MBUFPSBIJTUPSJPHSDB&TUPTEFCBUFTTJCJFOFTUOOUJNBNFOUF
BTPDJBEPTBMBSFWPMVDJONFEJBMFODVSTP
ZBMBBUFODJOSFOP-
WBEB RVF MBT USBOTGPSNBDJPOFT UFMFUFDOPMHJDBT QSPEVDFO FO MB
JEFB EF IJTUPSJB EFM QFOTBNJFOUP IJTUPSJPHSDP NPEFSOP
BO
OPQFSDJCFOMPTRVJFCSFTFQJTUFNPMHJDPTRVFTVQPOFJOUFSSPHBS
FMUFYUPZMBFTDSJUVSBFOIJTUPSJPHSBGB
4JO EVEB BMHVOB
FM O EFM QSPHSBNB NJNUJDP UFSNJOBS
UBSEFPUFNQSBOP
QPSQPOFSFOFMDFOUSPEFMBEJTDVTJOIJTUPSJP-
HSDBMBIJTUPSJDJEBEEFMBIJTUPSJB&TUBQSFHVOUBSFOPWBEBQPS
MBIJTUPSJDJEBEEFMBEJTDJQMJOBFTVOBEFMBTDPOTFDVFODJBTNT
WJTJCMFTEFMHJSPBCTUSBDUPNBUFSJBMFOIJTUPSJPHSBGB
HJSPRVFBM
DPMPDBSFOFMGPOEPEFMBEJTDVTJOMBNBUFSJBMJEBEEFMBTQSD-
UJDBTEFMBJOTUJUVDJOIJTUPSJBEPSB
BMJOUFSSPHBSQBDJFOUFNFOUF
MPTFGFDUPTRVFFTUBTQSDUJDBTQSPEVDFO
MPTSFHNFOFTEFWFSEBE
BRVFEBOMVHBS
OPTPMPCVTDBJOUFSSPHBSFMNBSDPRVFPSHBOJ[B
FTUBTQSDUJDBTEFTJHOJDBDJO
TJOPRVFBWBO[BOEPVOQBTPNT
BMM
FTGPS[OEPTFQPSWJTJCJMJ[BSFMNBSDPJOWJTJCMFRVFPSHBOJ-
[BUPEPNBSDPWJTJCMF
CVTDBOBMNFOUFJOUFSSVNQJSZBMUFSBSMB
QSDUJDBIJTUPSJPHSDBEFMBSFQSFTFOUBDJOIJTUSJDB
&M HJSP DSUJDP FO IJTUPSJPHSBGB
FO TOUFTJT
OP FT NT RVF
PUSPNPEPEFOPNCSBSFTUBBUFODJOEFTWFMBEBTPCSFMPTHFTUPT
NTTJNQMFTEFMPDJP"UFODJORVFIBEFWVFMUPBMBDJFODJBIJT-
USJDBBMBFEBEEFTVJOPDFODJB
PCMJHOEPMBBQMBOUFBSOVFWB-
NFOUFUPEBTFTBTQSFHVOUBTRVFEFTFONBTDBSBOTVJOPDFODJB
MBT
TJNQMFTQSFHVOUBTEFTVJOPDFODJByRVFTMFFS
yRVFTFTDSJCJS
1MBOUFBSFTUBTQSFHVOUBTOPTVQPOFBSNBSVOBFTFODJBjNT
SFBMvEFMBIJTUPSJB
OPFOUSBBPGSFDFSVOBSFTQVFTUBQPTUNPEFS-
OBBMBDMTJDBQSFHVOUBqu es la historia?1MBOUFBSFTUBTQSF-
35
-VJT(%F.VTTZr.JHVFM7BMEFSSBNB
HVOUBTFTTJNQMFNFOUFPUSPNPEPEFWFMBSMBWPDBDJOJONVOJ-
UBSJBEFMBSB[OIJTUPSJBEPSB1MBOUFBSFTUBTQSFHVOUBTFTRVJ[T
TPMPVOBNBOFSBEJGFSFOUFEFJOJDJBSFMUSBCBKPEFEFDPOTUSVDDJO
EFMBQPMUJDBJEFOUJUBSJBRVFNPOUBHVBSEJBFOMBTGSPOUFSBTJOUF-
SJPSFTEFMBEJTDJQMJOB
WJHJMBOEPZSFQSJNJFOEPUPEPBRVFMMPRVF
BNFOB[BBDUVBMPQPUFODJBMNFOUFFMPSEFOEFTVTBCFS
36
Historiografa postmoderna
**
$
37
Historiografa postmoderna
1
*QPTUNPEFSOBFOIJTUPSJPHSBGBFT
JOUFOUBS EBS DVFOUB EF MBT NVUBDJPOFT EFM QBSBEJHNB QPMUJDP
MPTDPIJTUPSJPHSDPTPCSFMBIJTUPSJB&TUBTNVUBDJPOFTEF-
NBOEBOOFDFTBSJBNFOUFMBFMBCPSBDJOEFVOWPDBCVMBSJPIJTUP-
SJPHSDPDBQB[EFBQSFIFOEFSMPTRVJFCSFTZUSBOTGPSNBDJPOFT
RVFMBEJTDJQMJOBTVGSFDVBOEPZBOPQVFEFBQPZBSTFFOMPTTV-
QVFTUPT FQJTUFNPMHJDPT Z POUPMHJDPT RVF PSHBOJ[BSPO TV USB-
CBKPFOMBNPEFSOJEBE%JTDVUJFOEPFTUBTDFTVSBTZNVUBDJPOFT
JOUFOUBOEPQFOTBSFMDBNQPEFQSPCMFNUJDBTRVFMBQPTUNPEFS-
OJEBEJNQPOFBUPEPQFOTBNJFOUPEFMPQPMUJDP
"OUPOJP/FHSJ
IBEFTDSJUPFTUFUJFNQPDPNPVOUJFNQPEFUSBOTJDJORVFFYJHF
MBFMBCPSBDJOEFDPODFQUPTZDBUFHPSBTDBQBDFTEFWJTMVNCSBS
MBTUSBOTGPSNBDJPOFTRVFIPZBGFDUBOBMBTTPDJFEBEFTDPOUFN-
QPSOFBT1&OFMPSEFOEFMBTIVNBOJEBEFT
JOWFTUJHBEPSBTDPNP
.JFLF#BM2P%POOB)BSBXBZ3SFDMBNBO
EFJHVBMNPEP
MBOFDF-
TJEBEEFGPSKBSOVFWBTIFSSBNJFOUBTDPODFQUVBMFTQBSBMPTDBN-
CJPTFODVSTP
-BUBSFBFTJONFOTBZEFNBOEBHJHBOUFTDPTFTGVFS[PTDPMFD-
UJWPTEFJOWFTUJHBDJO
DSVDFTEFGSPOUFSBT
WJBKFTFOUSFDPODFQ-
UPT
GPSNBT JOEJUBT EF DPOUBHJP FOUSF EJTDJQMJOBT
NVUBDJPOFT
JOTPTQFDIBEBT
SJUVBMFT EF QBTP
TBDSJDJPT Z USBOTHVSBDJPOFT
ZUBNCJOFYUJODJPOFT-BUFBUSBMJEBERVFFYJHFOFTUBTSFQSFTFO-
1
"OUPOJP/FHSJ
La fbrica de porcelana. Una nueva gramtica de la poltica
#BSDFMPOB
2
.JFLF#BM
Conceptos viajeros en las humanidades. Una gua de viaje
.VS-
DJB
$FOEFBD
3
%POOB )BSBXBZ
The Companion Species Manifesto. Dogd, People, and
Significant Otherness
$IJDBHP
1SJDLMZ1BSBEJHN1SFTT
39
-VJT(%F.VTTZr.JHVFM7BMEFSSBNB
4
(BZBUSJ$IBLSBWPSUZ4QJWBL
Muerte de una disciplina
4BOUJBHPEF$IJMF
1BMJOPEJB
40
Historiografa postmoderna
41
Historiografa postmoderna
"
43
-VJT(%F.VTTZr.JHVFM7BMEFSSBNB
del sentido
"MBJO#BEJPV QSJO- GVODJO EFM TJHOJDBEP BTJH-
DJQBMNFOUF TPCSF UPEP TVT EPT OBEP B MPT BDPOUFDJNJFOUPT
Z
jHSBOEFTvMJCSPTTPCSFFMBDPO- OP VO EBUP QSJNBSJP RVF EF-
UFDJNJFOUPEl ser y el aconteci- UFSNJOB RV TJHOJDBEPT QVF-
miento y Lgica de los mundos
EB UFOFS VO BDPOUFDJNJFOUP
Z +BDRVFT %FSSJEB Fuerza de .TBO
DPNPFTDSJCF8IJUF
ley y Espectros de Marx
&OMB FM BDPOUFDJNJFOUP IJTUSJDP
EJTDVTJOIJTUPSJPHSDB
QVFEF USBEJDJPOBMNFOUF DPODFCJEP
DPOTJEFSBSTF RVF MB SFFYJO DPNP VO BDPOUFDJNJFOUP RVF
QSJODJQBM EF )BZEFO 8IJUF Z GVF OP TPMP PCTFSWBCMF TJOP
'SBOL "OLFSNJTU IB HJSBEP FO UBNCJOPCTFSWBEP
FTQPSEF-
MPT MUJNPT BPT FO UPSOP B MB OJDJOVOBDPOUFDJNJFOUPRVF
QSFHVOUBQPSFMBDPOUFDJNJFOUP ZBOPFTNTPCTFSWBCMFZ
QPS
FO MB OBSSBDJO IJTUPSJPHSDB UBOUP
OP QVFEF TFSWJS DPNP
&O FTUF TFOUJEP
DFOUSBMFT B MB PCKFUPEFVODPOPDJNJFOUPUBO
EJTDVTJOIJTUSJDBTFSBOMPTFO- TFHVSPDPNPFMEFMPTBDPOUF-
TBZPTEF)BZEFO8IJUFDPOUFOJ- DJNJFOUPTQSFTFOUFT
MPTDVBMFT
EPTFOFigural Realism
BO QVFEFO TFS PCTFSWBEPT
ZFMUFYUPQJPOFSPEF"OLFSTNJU
1FSP FT BRV
DPOUJOVB 8IJUF
Narrative Logic
EPOEFMBEJTUJODJOFOUSFFMIF-
&O PUSBT QBMBCSBT
CJFO DIP Z FM BDPOUFDJNJFOUP EFCF
QVFEF BSNBSTF RVF MB EJTUJO- TFS TVCSBZBEB -B OPDJO EF
DJO FOUSF IFDIPT Z TJHOJDB- BDPOUFDJNJFOUP IJTUSJDP IB
EPT
VTVBMNFOUF DPOTJEFSBEB TVGSJEPVOBUSBOTGPSNBDJOSB-
DPNPVOBCBTFEFMSFMBUJWJTNP EJDBMDPNPVOSFTVMUBEPEFMB
IJTUSJDP
OPUJFOFPUSPPCKFUJ- PDVSSFODJBFOOVFTUSPTJHMPEF
WP FO )BZEFO 8IJUF Z 'SBOL BDPOUFDJNJFOUPTEFVOBMDBODF
"OLFSTNJU RVF EBS MVHBS B MB FTDBMB Z QSPGVOEJEBE JOJNBHJ-
QSFHVOUB QPS FM BDPOUFDJNJFO- OBCMFT QBSB IJTUPSJBEPSFT EF
UP FO MB IJTUPSJB 1VFT
FT MB PUSPTUJFNQPTZEFMEFTNBOUF-
NJTNB OBUVSBMF[B BONBMB MBNJFOUPEFMDPODFQUPEFBDPO-
EF MPT BDPOUFDJNJFOUPT
TV FT- UFDJNJFOUPDPNPPCKFUPEFVO
UBS GVFSBEFMBMFZ EF MB TJUVB- UJQP FTQFDDBNFOUF DJFOU-
DJO MB RVF PCMJHB B QMBOUFBS DP EF DPOPDJNJFOUP )BZEFO
MB QSFHVOUB QPS MB GVODJO 8IJUF
El texto histrico como
EFM TJHOJDBEP BTJHOBEP B MPT artefacto literario
-BT USBOT-
BDPOUFDJNJFOUPT %FTEF FTUB GPSNBDJPOFT UFMFUFDOPNFEJ-
QFSTQFDUJWBMPTIFDIPTTPOVOB UJDBTEFMBTPDJFEBEDPOUFNQP-
44
Historiografa postmoderna
45
-VJT(%F.VTTZr.JHVFM7BMEFSSBNB
46
Historiografa postmoderna
"
47
-VJT(%F.VTTZr.JHVFM7BMEFSSBNB
48
Historiografa postmoderna
49
-VJT(%F.VTTZr.JHVFM7BMEFSSBNB
"
50
Historiografa postmoderna
WFOJS -B EJTDVTJO TF DPNQMJ- DJP FO RVF DPOVZFO
NFUPO-
DBTJTFJOUFOUBEFUFSNJOBSMBT NJDBNFOUF
QSFTFOUFT
NPEPT
EJGFSFODJBT FOUSF MB BDUVBMJEBE EF QSPEVDDJO NFUPONJDPT
ZMPDPOUFNQPSOFP
MBBDUVB- BTVWF[
EFEJWFSTPPSEFO"M
MJEBEZMPOVFWP
MBBDUVBMJEBE FTUBS DPOTUJUVJEB QPS UJFNQPT
ZFMQSFTFOUF
PMBBDUVBMJEBEZ EFEJWFSTPPSEFO
MBBDUVBMJEBE
MBNPEB OP QVFEF DPOTUJUVJSTF DPNP
"QFTBSEFFTUBTDPNQMJDB- QSFTFOUF $VBOEP EFTDSJCJNPT
DJPOFT
Z EFM WSUJHP RVF QVF- MB BDUVBMJEBE DPNP FTQBDJP
EFO QSPEVDJS
FT UJM SFUFOFS FO RVF DPOVZFO UJFNQPT EF
FM VTP DPNO EFM WPDBCMP BD- EJWFSTP PSEFO
UBNQPDP DPN-
UVBMJEBE TJ MP RVF TF CVTDB FT QSFOEFNPT FM FTQBDJP DPNP
BEWFSUJSFMDBSDUFSDPOTUSVJEP VOTVFMPDPNOQSFWJPFORVF
EFMBNJTNB
FMFOPSNFUSBCB- EJWFSTPT UJFNQPT RVFEBO DPO-
KPJOWFSUJEPFOFMBDUPEFUPEB UFOJEPT -B BDUVBMJEBE OP FT
BDUVBMJEBE -B BDUVBMJEBE FT VOBQSJPSJFTQBDJBMRVFBDPHF
IFDIB 1PS FMMP
FT JNQPSUBOUF JMJNJUBEBNFOUF UFNQPSBMJEB-
TBCFS EF RV FTU IFDIB
QFSP EFT NMUJQMFT -B BDUVBMJEBE
BONTJNQPSUBOUFFTSFDPOP- QMVSJUFNQPSBMOPFTQSFWJBBMB
DFSRVFFTUIFDIB-BBDUVBMJ- NVMUJUVEKBMPOBEBEFUJFNQPT
EBEOPFTBMHPEBEP
TJOPBMHP EFMNJTNPNPEPRVFFMDVFSQP
BDUJWBNFOUF QSPEVDJEP &MMB EF'SBOLFOTUFJOOPFTBOUFSJPS
FT PSEFOBEB
JOWFTUJEB Z QFS- BMPTUSP[PTRVFMPDPNQPOFO
GPSNBUJWBNFOUF JOUFSQSFUBEB -BBDUVBMJEBEOPQSFDFEFBMPT
QPSVOBTFSJFEFQSPDFEJNJFO- BSDIJWPT RVF MB QVFCMBO Z TF
UPT KFSBSRVJ[BOUFT Z TFMFDUJWPT DPOTUJUVZF EFTEF MB QMUPSB EF
RVF TJFNQSF FTUO BM TFSWJDJP QSFTFOUFT
MFKBOPT FOUSF T MF-
EFQPEFSFTFJOUFSFTFTEJWFSTPT KBOPT UBNCJO EF T NJTNPT
-BjSFBMJEBEvEFMBBDUVBMJEBE RVF DPJODJEFO BDUJWBOEP NF-
TPMPMMFHBBMQSFTFOUFNFEJBOUF NPSJBT
BCSJFOEP QBTBKFT RVF
EJTQPTJUJWPTEFDDJO
BSUFGBD- TF EJTHSFHBO TJO DFOUSP 'SBH-
UPTEFDBQUVSBZSFDPOPDJNJFO- NFOUPTEJTQVFTUPTFOVOKVFHP
UP RVF PSHBOJ[BO FM jBIPSBv EFBDFMFSBDJPOFTRVFBMDIPDBS
IJTUSJDP
DPNPMBOPDJONJT- PSP[BSTFQSPEVDFONFNPSJBT
NBEFBSDIJWP EJTZVODJPOFT
QFOTBNJFOUPT
-P RVF MMBNBNPT BDUVBMJ- NTWFMPDFTRVFMBTOUFTJT
RVF
EBE
FTDSJCF 8JMMZ 5IBZFS
OP FYDFEFO VO PSEFO SFTVFMUP EF
FT VO QSFTFOUF
OJ TJRVJFSB VO SFQSFTFOUBDJO &TB BDUVBMJ-
UJFNQPj.TCJFOFTVOFTQB- EBE PQFSB BOUFT DPNP TVQFS-
51
-VJT(%F.VTTZr.JHVFM7BMEFSSBNB
52
Historiografa postmoderna
Antinomia
53
-VJT(%F.VTTZr.JHVFM7BMEFSSBNB
54
Historiografa postmoderna
Apora
55
-VJT(%F.VTTZr.JHVFM7BMEFSSBNB
56
Historiografa postmoderna
"
57
-VJT(%F.VTTZr.JHVFM7BMEFSSBNB
58
Historiografa postmoderna
59
-VJT(%F.VTTZr.JHVFM7BMEFSSBNB
60
Historiografa postmoderna
61
-VJT(%F.VTTZr.JHVFM7BMEFSSBNB
MB CJPHSBGB jIBDF WFS DNP QPSUBEBT EF MPT MJCSPTv .BSD
MBWJEBFOUFSBEFVOJOEJWJEVP 'VNBSPMJ
Des Vies la bio-
FTU QSFTFOUF FO VOB EF TVT graphie: le crpuscule du Par-
PCSBT
FOVOPEFTVTIFDIPT<Z> nasse
&M QSJNFS QFSJPEP RVF
DNPFOFTBWJEBFTUQSFTFO- TF WJODVM B MBT j7JEBTv UJFOF
UFVOBQPDBFOUFSBv 8BMUFS DPNPVOJEBEEFNFEJEBFMDJ-
#FOKBNJO
Tesis sobre la his- DMP WJUBM DPNQMFUP RVF WB EFM
toria
OBDJNJFOUPBMBNVFSUF
ZFTU
&M USNJOP CJPHSBGB OP PSHBOJ[BEPTFHOFMNPEFMPEF
BQBSFDF TJOP UBSEBNFOUF FO MBTWJEBTFKFNQMBSFT
EFNPEF-
MBT MFOHVBT FVSPQFBT
B OFT MPT EF WJSUVE P TBOUJEBE &TBT
EFMTJHMP 97**
MPRVFFWJEFOUF- jWJEBTvQBSFDFOSFGFSJSTFBMBT
NFOUFOPTJHOJDBRVFMBQSD- WJWFODJBT EF UPEP VO JOEJWJ-
UJDB CJPHSDB OP TF IVCJFSB EVPZ
TJOFNCBSHP
TFPSHBOJ-
BUFTUJHVBEPNVDIPBOUFT [BOBQBSUJSEFMBJEFBEFRVF
4JHVJFOEP MPT USBCBKPT EF jDVBMRVJFSEFTUJOP
QPSMBSHPZ
.BSD 'VNBSPMJ TPCSF MB CJP- DPNQMJDBEPRVFTFB
DPOTUBFO
HSBGB
FTQPTJCMFEJTUJOHVJSEPT SFBMJEBEEFVOTPMPNPNFOUP
HSBOEFTQFSJPEPTFOFMHOFSP FMNPNFOUPFORVFFMIPNCSF
%FMB"OUJHFEBEBMTJHMP 97** TBCF QBSB TJFNQSF RVJO FTv
GVFMBQPDBEFMBFTDSJUVSBEF 1BCMP DBNJOP B %BNBTDP OP
j7JEBTv
NJFOUSBT RVF
B QBS- FTU MFKPT EF BRV
BT DPNP
UJS EF MB SVQUVSB NPEFSOB
TF UBNQPDP TV DBEB EFM DBCBMMP
JNQVTPMBCJPHSBGB-PRVFTF ZMBDPOWFSTJOBMDSJTUJBOJTNP
NPEJDEFNBOFSBGVOEBNFO- -BTFOUFODJB
EFSB[BSDBJ[BO-
UBMGVFFMNPEPEFFMFDDJOEF UF
QFSUFOFDFB+PSHF-VJT#PS-
MPTHSBOEFTIPNCSFT
EFBRVF- HFT
ZFOTVDPODJTJOEFTDSJCF
MMPTRVFMMFHBOBTFSMPTUFNBT MB FTUSVDUVSB EF TJHOJDBDJO
EF MBT CJPHSBGBT )PZ FO EB
FKFNQMBS RVF PSHBOJ[B MB OB-
FMFOUVTJBTNPQPSMBCJPHSBGB SSBDJO EF FTDSJUVSBT EF7JEBT
QBSFDF IBCFS SFNJUJEP MB OP- DPNPMBTEF1MVUBSDPPMBT7J-
DJO EF j7JEBTv BM PMWJEP -B EBT &KFNQMBSFT EF MPT 1BESFT
QBMBCSBj7JEBTvFTUDIBQBEB EFMB*HMFTJB
BMBBOUJHVB
FTDSJCF'VNBSPMJ
&M TFHVOEP QFSJPEP
QSP-
FTVOQBSJFOUFQPCSFDPOEFOB- QJBNFOUF FM EF MB CJPHSBGB
EPBMPTBTJMPTZBMPTDFNFOUF- TF DBSBDUFSJ[B QPS DFOUSBS MB
SJPT %FTBQBSFDJ
B QBSUJS EFM BUFODJO FO MB JOUFSWFODJO
QFSJPEPEFFOUSFHVFSSBT
EFMBT EF MPT IPNCSFT EF MB IJTUPSJB
WJUSJOBTEFMBMJCSFSBTZEFMBT &TFMQFSJPEPEFMBTCJPHSBGBT
62
Historiografa postmoderna
63
-VJT(%F.VTTZr.JHVFM7BMEFSSBNB
64
Historiografa postmoderna
65
-VJT(%F.VTTZr.JHVFM7BMEFSSBNB
66
Historiografa postmoderna
67
-VJT(%F.VTTZr.JHVFM7BMEFSSBNB
Bos
1PS VOB QBSUF
QPSRVF NPEFSOB EFM NVOEP -B DPO-
FOTVTFOPBMCFSHBVOUSNJOP RVJTUBEF"NSJDB
ZMBQSPQJB
bos
RVFBNFOB[BDPOEJTUPS- DPOGPSNBDJO EF MB TPDJFEBE
TJPOBSTVSBTHPNTQSFHOBOUF DPMPOJBM
DPO TV EPCMF NBUSJ[
QPMUJDB
ZQPSMBPUSB
QPSRVF FVSPQFBBNFSJDBOB
TFSBO MPT
FOMUJNBJOTUBODJBSFNJUFBVO QSPDFTPT IJTUSJDPT QSJODJQB-
FYUFSJPS EF MB WJEB MB EJNFO- MFT RVF PSHBOJ[BSBO CJPQP-
TJOEFMBzo
BVOBTVFSUFEF MUJDBNFOUF
MB NPEFSOJEBE
EJNFOTJOJNQPTJCMFFOEPOEF 5SBCBKPT EF SFGFSFODJB PCMJHB-
MB WJEB TF QSFTFOUBSB BCTPMV- EPT EFTEF FTUB MOFB EF BOMJ-
UBNFOUFOBUVSBM
EFTQPKBEBEF TJT TPO MPT EF &OSJRVF %VTTFM
UPEP PSEFO EF TJHOJDBDJO P Z 4BOUJBHP $BTUSP(NF[
FT-
SBTHP GPSNBM " QFTBS EF FTUB QFDJBMNFOUF
EFFTUFMUJNP
TV
EJDVMUBE EF EFUFSNJOBDJO MJCSPLa hybris del punto cero.
DPODFQUVBM
DBCF QSFHVOUBS- Ciencia, raza e ilustracin en la
TF IPZ DPO 3PCFSUP &TQPTJUP Nueva Granada (1750-1816).
TJ OP FYJTUF VOB WJEB OBUVSBM 0USB PSJFOUBDJO IJTUP-
RVF OP TFB
B MB WF[
UBNCJO SJPHSDB CJPQPMUJDB
QBSF-
UDOJDB TJ MB SFMBDJO EF EPT DF GBWPSFDFS VOB QFSTQFDUJWB
FOUSFbos y zoEFCFJODMVJSB EF BOMJTJT NT DFOUSBEB FO
MBtchneDPNPUFSDFSUSNJOP MPT QSPCMFNBT EF MB IJTUPSJB
DPSSFMBDJPOBEP
PUBMWF[EFCJ EFM UJFNQP QSFTFOUF
EPOEF
JODMVJSMPEFTEFTJFNQSF MPT EJTQPTJUJWPT EF TFHVSJEBE
&O FM NCJUP EF MB IJTUP- DPOUSPM Z HPCFSOBCJMJEBE UJF-
SJPHSBGBQPTUNPEFSOB
MBSFT- OFOVOBBUFODJOQSJWJMFHJBEB
QVFTUBBMBEJTZVOUJWBQMBOUFB- &TUPTUSBCBKPTQVFEFOTFSBN-
EB QPS &TQPTJUP OP FT OJDB QMJBNFOUFPSHBOJ[BEPTCBKPMB
"T
FTQPTJCMFFODPOUSBSPSJFO- DBEFOB EF NBOEP GPVDBVMUJB-
UBDJPOFTBOBMUJDBTRVFQBSFDJF- OB seguridad, territorio, po-
SBO GBWPSFDFS VO USBUBNJFOUP blacin &O $IJMF
.BSB "O-
EFMBTSFMBDJPOFTEFQPEFSFOMB HMJDB *MMBOFT QBSFDF BWBO[BS
TPDJFEBE EFTEF VOB QFSTQFDUJ- FO TVT MUJNPT MJCSPT FO FTUB
WB CJPQPMUJDB RVF QPESBNPT EJSFDDJO
QSJODJQBMNFOUF FO
MMBNBS FYUFOEJEB %FTEF FTUB Cuerpo y sangre de la poltica
QFSTQFDUJWB
MB QSPCMFNUJDB
%FJHVBMNBOFSB
QVF-
CJPQPMUJDB TFSB DPOTUJUVUJWB EF SFDPOPDFSTF FO MBT JOWFTUJ-
EFMBNPEFSOJEBE
ZTFSFUSBF- HBDJPOFT EFTBSSPMMBEBT QPS
SB BM TJHMP 97* Z B MPT QSPDF- +PT .PMJOB TPCSF KVWFOUVE Z
TPT EF DPOTUJUVDJO EF MB JEFB EJTQPTJUJWPTFTUBUBMFT
BTDPNP
68
Historiografa postmoderna
69
-VJT(%F.VTTZr.JHVFM7BMEFSSBNB
70
Historiografa postmoderna
EFMBQSFHVOUBIPOFTUBZOPFO EFIJTUPSJBZEFTVDPSSFTQPO-
MBQSFDJTJOEFMBSFTQVFTUBJO- EJFOUFGPSNBEFFTDSJCJSFMQB-
NFEJBUB%FFTUBGPSNB
MBIJT- TBEPDPNPIJTUPSJBEVSBOUFMPT
UPSJBmZDVBMRVJFSBEFTVTWFS- MUJNPT BPT %F MP BO-
TJPOFTHSDBTmQVFEFJOUFOUBS UFSJPS
QPEBNPT TVQPOFS RVF
TFQBSBSTF EFM NFSP FKFSDJDJP IBMMFHBEPMBIPSBEFBTVNJSMB
EF NBODIBSTF MBT NBOHBT DPO OFDFTJEBEEFSFWJTBSZSFDPOP-
MBUJOUBEFPUSPTFOFMHFTUPEF DFSMPTOFDFTBSJPTBKVTUFTEFMB
FUFSOPT FTDSJCJFOUFT
FSVEJUPT NBUSJ[EJTDJQMJOBS
Z BNBOVFOTFT &O FTUB MOFB %FTBGPJODFSUJEVNCSF
EF BOMJTJT
QVFEF BEWFSUJSTF RVF OPT PCMJHB B MB BQVFTUB P
RVF MB QSPQPTJDJO TFB FOUFO- DPNQSPNJTPQPSVODVFTUJPOB-
EFS RVF MPT NUPEPT EF DPO- NJFOUPOPTUMHJDPZBVUPDSUJ-
USPM IJTUPSJPHSDPT BTPDJBEPT DPRVFFYQMPSFMBTJNQMJDBODJBT
B MB BVUPQTJB EF )FSEPUP
B RVF TF HFOFSBO BM WJODVMBS MPT
MBTSFGFSFODJBTQTJDPMPHJTUBTEF DPODFQUPT EF UFPSB
DBOPO F
5VDEJEFT
B MB FSVEJDJO Z MB IJTUPSJPHSBGB DIJMFOB
FO VO
HSBNUJDBIJTUSJDBEF+.BCJ- HFTUPBOBMUJDPTPCFSBOPGSFOUF
MMPO
BMIJTUPSJDJTNPEF3BOLF
BMEFWFOJSPVKPQPTUNPEFSOP
)VNCPMU
.POPE
-BWJTTF Z ZTVHJHBOUFTDPDBVEBMEFNP-
.FJOFDLF
BM FTUSVDUVSBMJTNP WJNJFOUPTZEVEBT&TBTDPNP
EF-WJ4USBVTTZEFMBFTDVFMB EFOUSPEFFTUFOVFWPFODVBESF
EF Annales
B MB IJTUPSJB UPUBM DPODFQUVBMTFOPTIBDFQPTJCMF
ZMBMBSHBEVSBDJOEF'FSOBOE QMBOUFBS MB EJTDVTJO TPCSF MB
#SBVEFM
B MB OBSSBDJO EFO- QPTUNPEFSOJEBE DPNP MB EJT-
TB EF $MJGPSE (FFSU[
BM UFYUP DVTJOQPSFMcanon
DVBMRVJF-
IJTUSJDP DPNP BSUFGBDUP MJ- SBRVFFTUFTFB1PSEFQSPOUP
UFSBSJP EF )BZEFO 8IJUF
B MB VUJMJEBE EF VTBS FM DSJUFSJP
MB UJM DBUFHPSB EF HOFSP EF regla DPNP QSPCMFNUJDB
TF
+PBO 4DPUU
B MPT FTUVEJPT DVM- FOUJFOEFFOMBNFEJEBRVFQFS-
UVSBMFTEF3BZNPOE8JMMJBNT
NJUFFTUSVDUVSBSVOjDBNQPEF
B MB PQFSBDJO IJTUPSJPHSDB GVFS[BvDUJDJPZFTFODJBMNFO-
EF.JDIFMEF$FSUFBV
BMBIJT- UFJOFTUBCMFQFSPNVZUJMBMB
UPSJBDPODFQUVBMEF,PTFMMFDL
IPSB EF IBDFS VO CBMBODF EF
Z B MB FYQFSJFODJB IJTUSJDB MP RVF TPO Z QVFEFO MMFHBS B
TVCMJNF EF 'SBOL "OLFSTNJU TFS
MBT PQFSBDJPOFT IJTUPSJP-
QPS OPNCSBS TMP B MPT NT HSDBT FO VO GVUVSP OP NVZ
JNQPSUBOUFT
DPOTUJUVZFOTMP MFKBOP &O PUSBT QBMBCSBT
MB
una/otra WFSTJO EFM DPODFQUP CTRVFEB EF DVBMRVJFS canon
71
-VJT(%F.VTTZr.JHVFM7BMEFSSBNB
72
Historiografa postmoderna
73
-VJT(%F.VTTZr.JHVFM7BMEFSSBNB
74
Historiografa postmoderna
75
-VJT(%F.VTTZr.JHVFM7BMEFSSBNB
CJO
IBO TJEP MPT TVDFTJWPT MPMBSHPEFMPTQFSNBOFOUFTJO-
NPWJNJFOUPT EF MB DPODJFODJB UFOUPTQPSEFOJSZBQMJDBSmZB
IJTUSJDBEFTEFVOBEFOJDJO
TFBFOMBBDBEFNJBDPNPFOMB
P NBUSJ[ QSFMJNJOBS
B VOB WJEB DPUJEJBOBm VO DPODFQUP
PUSB
SFWJTJO
Z OBMNFOUF B EFIJTUPSJB&OQPDBTQBMBCSBT
VO PUSP
BKVTUFEFMPTTVQVFT- SFFYJOTPTUFOJEBTPCSFMBDB-
UPT Z DVFTUJPOBNJFOUPT
DPNP QBDJEBE EF QSFHVOUBSOPT QPS
EF MBT QFSNBOFOUFT GSJDDJPOFT MP RVF RVFSFNPT Z EFCFNPT
FOUSF MBT FYQFSJFODJBT IJTUSJ- TBCFS BDFSDB EF OPTPUSPT Z FM
DBTZMBTECJMFTSFTQVFTUBTFQJT- NVOEPRVFOPTSPEFB
UFNPMHJDBT%JONJDBRVFSF- "TVWF[
IFNPTDPOTJEFSB-
BSNBOVFTUSBJOUVJDJOTPCSF EP UJM SFDVSSJS BM IJTUPSJBEPS
VOQPTJCMFgesto provocacinP BMFNO 3FJOIBSEU ,PTFMMFDL
SPNBOUJDJTNP IJTUPSJPHSDP RVJFO TFBMB RVF MB JNQPS-
RVF FO FM DBTP QBSUJDVMBS DIJ- UBODJB EF MB UFPSJ[BDJO QBSB
MFOP
GSFOUF B MPT EFGFDUPT EF MB IJTUPSJB DPNP EJTDJQMJOB OP
OVFTUSP FYDFTJWP QPTJUJWJTNP TF EFCF BM HVTUP EFM IJTUPSJB-
Z TV OFDFTJEBE ZB PCMJHBUP- EPS
OJBMBDFMFCSBDJOEFVOB
SJB
EFWPMDBSTFBMBGPSNBDJO NPEB BDBENJDB Z QBTBKFSB
NTQSFPDVQBEBEFMPBTQFDUPT TJOPRVFTFEFCFBWBSJBTSB[P-
UFSJDP ZP MPTDPT %F BI OFTEFQFTPZRVFTPOMBTRVF
RVFTFBUBOVSHFOUFTFBMBSMB WFSEBEFSBNFOUFQFSNJUFOQFO-
MFHUJNB OFDFTJEBE EF WJODV- TBSVOGVUVSPQBSBFMIJTUPSJB-
MBSGVFSUFNFOUFMBIJTUPSJBDPO EPS &OUSF FMMBT TF NFODJPOBO
VO UJQP EF SFFYJO BQMJDBEB MBTTJHVJFOUFTSB[POFTQBSBKVT-
WJODVMBDJO RVF OP EFCF FT- UJDBSMBOFDFTJEBEEFMBUFPSB
UBS PSJFOUBEB FO EFTUBDBS FTUB B
QBSB FTUBCMFDFS DVBMRVJFS
MUJNB FO T NJTNB
TJOP QBSB UJQPEFQFSJPEJ[BDJO
C
QBSB
RVFMBQFSNBOFOUFSFWJTJOEF EFOJS TFSJFT UFNQPSBMFT Z MBT
MPT TVQVFTUPT Z DPNQPOFOUFT QPTJCMFT DSPOPMPHBT FTQFD-
FQJTUFNPMHJDPTEFUPEPDPOP- DBT
D
QBSB FM BKVTUF FO MPT
DJNJFOUPIJTUSJDPQVFEBIBDFS EFCBUFTFUJNPMHJDPT
E
QBSB
GSFOUFEFGPSNBIPOFTUBZTJO- MBIJTUPSJBFTUSVDUVSBM
F
QBSB
DFSB B MB WPMVOUBEFTOFDFTJEB- MB EJWFSTJEBE EF JOUFSQSFUB-
EFTEFTBCFSQPSFMQBTBEPRVF DJPOFT FO UPSOP B DPOJDUPT Z
OPTDPOTUJUVZF"DUPDPHOJUJWP FYQFSJFODJBTFYUSFNBT
G
QBSB
RVF
BEFNT
JOUVJNPT
EFCJFSB FTUBCMFDFSMBTEJTDPOUJOVJEBEFT
TFSDBQB[EFJNQMFNFOUBSTFEF P BQPSBT RVF MJNJUBO FM IPSJ-
GPSNB QSDUJDB Z BVUOPNB B [POUF EF FYQFDUBUJWBT FQJTUF-
76
Historiografa postmoderna
NPMHJDBT
H
QBSB FWJUBS MB RVF OPT SPEFB O
1BSB FMMP
Z
NPOPDBVTBMJEBE
Z I
QBSB DPNPZBMPTFBMBCB.JDIFMEF
EJNFOTJPOBSMBUFMFPMPHB $FSUFBV FO TV OPUBCMF FOTBZP
&T EFDJS
TJO UFPSB OP IBZ La operacin historiogrfica
QPTJCJMJEBE EF QFOTBNJFOUP MB MBCPS EFM IJTUPSJBEPS
P MP
OJ
NVDIP NFOPT
EF VOB SF- RVF IBDF FM IJTUPSJBEPS DVBO-
FYJOIJTUSJDB&OUPEPDBTP
EP IBDF IJTUPSJB
DPNJFO[B FO
MB SB[O NT JNQPSUBOUF RVF FMNPNFOUPFORVFUPEPTVKFUP
FTUF BVUPS QMBOUFB TF EFCF B RVF RVJFSF JORVJSJS FM BZFS
FT
MB CTRVFEB EF VOB TBMJEB EFM DBQB[ EF TFQBSBS Z PSHBOJ[BS
BJTMBNJFOUPBDBENJDPZTPDJBM MPT USP[PT EF NFNPSJB P MPT
EFMBIJTUPSJBZTVQPTJCMFSFEF- SFTUPTSFTJEVBMFTRVFMFTPOTJH-
OJDJOBQBSUJSEFMUSBCBKPEF OJDBUJWPT%FMPBOUFSJPSRVF
KVTUBNFOUFFTPTUFNBTPBTVO- TFBUBOJOUFSFTBOUFMBEJTUJODJO
UPTRVFOFDFTJUBOEFUFPSBPFO EF -B$BQSB TPCSF BRVFMMPT
BRVFMMPT DBTPT RVF QSPNFUFO UFYUPT en MPT DVBMFT TF QVFEF
QSPZFDDJPOFTUFSJDBT QFOTBS
QFSPQPSTPCSFUPEP
MP
"IPSBCJFO
TJZBTBCFNPT EFUFSNJOBOUF TFSB MB DBQBDJ-
QPSRV MB UFPSB QVFEF TFS EBEEFSFDPOPDFSBRVFMMPTUFY-
VO QSJNFS FTQBDJP EF JOUFST
UPTconMPTDVBMFTFTQFSUJOFOUF
yDNPQPEFNPTQFOTBSVODB- SFFYJPOBS EF GPSNB NT DVJ-
OPO UFSJDP &O QSJNFS MVHBS
EBEPTBZBUFOUB4FMFDDJORVF
FT NVZ UJM DPOTJEFSBS DNP QFSNJUJSB GPSNBS VO DBOPO
-B$BQSB EJGFSFODJB FOUSF FM DPOUFTUBUBSJPEFUFYUPTDPOMPT
QSPDFTP DPOTFSWBEPS EF DB- RVF TF QPESB SFQFOTBS mBVO-
OPOJ[BS
Z MB JNBHFO CFOKBNJ- RVFTFBNPNFOUOFBZUSBOTJ-
OJBOBRVFJHVBMBMBTFMFDDJOZ UPSJBNFOUFmMPTQVOUPTDJFHPT
BTJHOBDJOWBMSJDBEFMPTSFGF- EF MB NBUSJ[ FQJTUFNPMHJDB Z
SFOUFTZMBTGVFOUFTDPOFMFKFS- MBTDPOTJHVJFOUFTGBMFODJBTBMB
DJDJP EF jDFQJMMBS MB IJTUPSJB B IPSBEFMMFWBSBMBQSDUJDBMPT
DPOUSBQFMPv &O OVFTUSP DBTP
TVQVFTUPTEFUPEBEJTDJQMJOB
FM OJNP FT FM NJTNP CVTDBS &OPUSBTQBMBCSBT
EFMPRVF
BRVFMMPT UFYUPT P BSUFGBDUPT TFUSBUBFTEFBDUJWBSFMDVFTUJP-
RVFQFSNJUBOSFQFOTBSMBIJT- OBNJFOUP DPNP DBSBDUFSTUJDB
UPSJB DPNP EJTDJQMJOB BDBE- DFOUSBMEFMQFOTBNJFOUPDSUJDP
NJDBQFSPUBNCJO
SFQFOTBSMB ZRVFTUBDBQBDJEBEQVFEBTFS
DPNP VO habitus IVNBOP UBO BQMJDBEB UBOUP BM PCKFUP RVF
FTFODJBM DPNP MB DBQBDJEBE TFRVJFSFDPNQSFOEFSDPNPBM
EF BQSFIFOEFS MBT SFBMJEBEFT TVKFUP RVF FTU JOUFOUBOEP MB
77
-VJT(%F.VTTZr.JHVFM7BMEFSSBNB
78
Historiografa postmoderna
RVF FM HFTUP EF FTDSJCJS FM QB- TV IJTUPSJDJEBE P DBOPOJDJEBE
TBEP DPNP IJTUPSJB QVFEB TFS FOUSNJOPTEFFTUJNVMBDJOEF
DPOTJEFSBEPFTFODJBMNFOUFQPS MBDPODJFODJB
r-FDUVSBTTVHFSJEBT%PNJOJDL-B$BQSB
Representar el
Holocausto. Historia, teora, trauma
#VFOPT"JSFT
1SP-
NFUFP
<DBQj$BOPOFT
UFYUPTZDPOUFYUPTv>.BS-
UJO+BZ
Campos de Fuerza. Entre la historia intelectual y
la crtica cultural
#VFOPT"JSFT
1BJET
<DBQjy$J-
UBS B MPT HSBOEFT P QSFTDJOEJS EF MPT OPNCSFT .PEPT
EFMFHJUJNBDJOFOFMDBNQPUFMBTIVNBOJEBEFTv>'SBOL
,FSNPEF
Historia y valor
#BSDFMPOB
1FOOTVMB
'SBOL,FSNPEF
Formas de Atencin
#BSDFMPOB
(FEJTB
-VJT(EF.VTTZ
j&MUPUBMDFSPFOMBIJTUPSJPHSB-
GBDIJMFOBv
ARBOR
$99---
99
.BESJE
'SBOL"OLFSTNJU
Historia y tropologa. Ascenso y cada
de la metfora
.YJDP
'POEP EF $VMUVSB &DPONJDB
-VJT ( EF .VTTZ FE
Balance historiogrfico
chileno. El orden del discurso y el giro crtico actual
4BO-
UJBHPEF$IJMF
&EJDJPOFT6OJWFSTJEBE'JOJT5FSSBF
)BSPME#MPPN
El canon occidental
.BESJE
"OBHSBNB
79
-VJT(%F.VTTZr.JHVFM7BMEFSSBNB
$
80
Historiografa postmoderna
81
-VJT(%F.VTTZr.JHVFM7BMEFSSBNB
82
Historiografa postmoderna
83
-VJT(%F.VTTZr.JHVFM7BMEFSSBNB
84
Historiografa postmoderna
%
85
-VJT(%F.VTTZr.JHVFM7BMEFSSBNB
86
Historiografa postmoderna
87
-VJT(%F.VTTZr.JHVFM7BMEFSSBNB
88
Historiografa postmoderna
89
-VJT(%F.VTTZr.JHVFM7BMEFSSBNB
90
Historiografa postmoderna
FOUJFOEFMBFYJTUFODJBDPNPMB EFRVFFTUFQFMJHSPEFTQVTEF
BQBSJDJO EF BMHP B VOB DPO- UPEPTFBEFUFOJEP
FOUPODFT
MB
DJFODJB RVF QVFEF BTFHVSBSTF QPTJCJMJEBE EF TJHOPT QPUFO-
EF TV QSPQJB FYJTUFODJB Z FT DJBMNFOUFDFSSBEPTZNVEPTmZ
JHVBMNFOUF DVFTUJPOBCMF TJ VO VOB WF[ NT
UPEPT MPT TJHOPT
EJTDVSTPBDFSDBEFFTUPTTJHOPT BMCFSHBOFTUBQPTJCJMJEBEmTJH-
QVFEF IBDFS BMHP RVF OP TFB OJDBRVFMBIJTUPSJBFTQPUFO-
USBJDJPOBSMPT
BM DPOWFSUJSMPT
DJBMNFOUFJNQPTJCMF
QPS FKFNQMP
FO TJHOPT EF VO #VTDBOEP EFTNBSDBS TV
jQFOTBNJFOUPvBCTPMVUBNFOUF QPTJDJO EF DVBMRVJFS JOUFS-
EFTMJHBEPPEFVOQFOTBNJFOUP QSFUBDJO JEFBMJTUB P GFOPNF-
DPOTJHOBEP B OJOHVOB EFTUJ- OPMHJDB USBTDFOEFOUBM EF MB
OBDJO EJTDFSOJCMF &M QFMJHSP IJTUPSJB
%FSSJEB BEWFSUJS FO
QMBOUFBEP QPS MPT TJHOPT DF- EJWFSTPT NPNFOUPT Z UFYUPT
SSBEPT Z NVEPT OP QVFEF EF- RVF MB jIJTUPSJDJEBE NJTNB
UFOFSTF%FIFDIP
UPEBGPSNB FTUMJHBEBBMBQPTJCJMJEBEEF
EF EFUFODJO mMB BSUJDVMBDJO MB FTDSJUVSB B MB QPTJCJMJEBE
EF VOB QBMBCSB
MB GPSNBMJ[B- EFMBFTDSJUVSBFOHFOFSBM w
DJOEFVOQFOTBNJFOUP
MBJO- "OUFTEFTFSPCKFUPEFVOBIJT-
WFODJO EF VO OVFWP TJTUFNB UPSJBmEFVOBDJFODJBIJTUSJDBm
EF TJHOJDBDJPOFTm FT UBNCJO MBFTDSJUVSBBCSFFMDBNQPEFMB
VO QFMJHSP
QVFT DBEB VOB EF IJTUPSJB
EFM EFWFOJS IJTUSJDP
FMMBT DPNQFOTB VOB DBSFODJB De la gramatologa
&TUBBS-
Z
FOUBMNFEJEB
PUSPNPEPZ NBDJO WVFMWF B DPMPDBS FO FM
NPNFOUP EF FTDSJUVSB %FUF- DFOUSPEFMBIJTUPSJBMBQSPCMF-
OFS FM QFMJHSP QBSB FM TJHOJ- NUJDBEFMTJHOPQFSPFOUFOEJ-
DBEP TMP FYBDFSCB FM QFMJHSP
EB B QBSUJS EF MB NBUFSJBMJEBE
Z DBEB FYBDFSCBDJO EB MVHBS EFMBFTDSJUVSB
FOUFOEJEBFOVO
B OVFWBT WFSTJPOFT EF EFUFO- TFOUJEPBNQMJP
FTEFDJS
DPNP
DJO
RVF
BTVWF[
FYBDFSCBO JOTDSJQDJO
FMQFMJHSPZBTTVDFTJWBNFOUF 1PSPUSBQBSUF
IBCSBRVF
&M jBOUEPUPv P FM jGSNBDPv BEWFSUJSRVFMBEFDPOTUSVDDJO
QBSBMBQPUFODJBMNVEF[EFMPT FTU OUJNBNFOUF BTPDJBEB B
TJHOPT DPOTJTUF FO MB QSPEVD- VO QSPHSBNB GFOPNFOPMHJDP
DJO EF NT TJHOPT
DBEB VOP RVFFODVFOUSBFOMBIJTUPSJBZ
EFMPTDVBMFTFTQPUFODJBMNFO- MBUFNQPSBMJEBETVTQSFPDVQB-
UF NVEP 4J MB IJTUPSJB FT QP- DJPOFT QSJODJQBMFT %F IFDIP
TJCMF TMP B DPOEJDJO EF RVF UBMZDPNPSFDVFSEB4QJWBL
FM
FMTJHOJDBEPFTUFOQFMJHSPZ USNJOP jEFDPOTUSVDDJOv FT
91
-VJT(%F.VTTZr.JHVFM7BMEFSSBNB
92
Historiografa postmoderna
&
93
-VJT(%F.VTTZr.JHVFM7BMEFSSBNB
94
Historiografa postmoderna
95
-VJT(%F.VTTZr.JHVFM7BMEFSSBNB
EFM FTUSVDUVSBMJTNP 4J FM FT- TF FKFSDFSB FO MP SFBM Z FO MB
USVDUVSBMJTNP TF IB FYUFOEJEP QFSDFQDJO-BFTUSVDUVSB
QPS
SQJEBNFOUFBPUSPTEPNJOJPT FMDPOUSBSJPTFEFOJSBQPSMB
FTQPSRVF
FOSFBMJEBE
OPIBZ OBUVSBMF[B EF DJFSUPT FMFNFO-
NTFTUSVDUVSBRVFEFBRVFMMP UPT BUNJDPT RVF QSFUFOEFO
RVF FT MFOHVBKF 4J FM JODPOT- EBS DVFOUB
BM NJTNP UJFNQP
DJFOUF TF FTUSVDUVSB DPNP VO EFMBGPSNBDJOEFMPTUPEPTZ
MFOHVBKF
TJMBIJTUPSJBFODVFO- EF MB WBSJBDJO EF TVT QBSUFT
USBFOMBTFTUSVDUVSBTTVUJFNQP 4FUSBUBEFFMFNFOUPTGPSNBMFT
EFTJHOJDBDJONTQSPQJB
TJ RVFOPUJFOFO
FODVBOUPUBMFT
MB TPDJFEBE QVFEF TFS EFTDSJUB OJ GPSNB
OJ TJHOJDBDJO
OJ
DPNP VO KVFHP EF JOUFSDBN- SFQSFTFOUBDJO
OJ DPOUFOJEP
CJPT TJNCMJDPT
FT QPSRVF OJ SFBMJEBE FNQSJDB EBEB
OJ
UBOUPFMDVFSQP
MBIJTUPSJBZMB NPEFMP GVODJPOBM IJQPUUJDP
TPDJFEBETFPSHBOJ[BOBMBNB- OJ JOUFMJHJCJMJEBE USBT MBT BQB-
OFSBEFTJTUFNBTEFTNCPMPT SJFODJBT
"IPSB CJFO
QFSUFOFDF BM &O TOUFTJT
FM PCKFUP FT-
FTUSVDUVSBMJTNP FM EFTDVCSJ- USVDUVSBM
FM FMFNFOUP TJNC-
NJFOUPZFMSFDPOPDJNJFOUPEF MJDP EF MB FTUSVDUVSB FT OJDB
MPTJNCMJDP.TBMMEFMBQB- Z OFDFTBSJBNFOUF jQPTJDJOv
MBCSB
FO TV SFBMJEBE Z FO TVT /PTFUSBUBEFVOMVHBSFOVOB
QBSUFTTPOPSBT
NTBMMEFMBT FYUFOTJO SFBM OJ EF FTQBDJPT
JNHFOFT Z DPODFQUPT BTPDJB- FO FYUFOTJPOFT JNBHJOBSJBT
EPTBMBTQBMBCSBT
FMMJOHJTUB TJOP EF MVHBSFT Z TJUJPT EF VO
FTUSVDUVSBM EFTDVCSF VO FMF- FTQBDJP QSPQJBNFOUF FTUSVDUV-
NFOUP EF OBUVSBMF[B DPNQMF- SBM
FTEFDJS
UPQPMHJDP-BTSF-
UBNFOUF EJGFSFOUF
VO PCKFUP MBDJPOFTFOUSFMPTFMFNFOUPTOP
FTUSVDUVSBM&TUFPCKFUPFTUSVD- FTUBSBO NFEJBEBT QPS VO FT-
UVSBM DPOTJTUF FO MB QPTJDJO QBDJPQSFFYUFOTJWPPJOFYUFO-
EF VO FMFNFOUP FO VO PSEFO TJUP
TJOPQPSVOFTQBDJPRVFFT
TJNCMJDP #VTDBOEP BDMBSBS BOUFUPEPPSEJOBM
SFEEFSFMB-
MBOBUVSBMF[BEFFTUFFMFNFOUP DJPOFT%FBIRVFMBBNCJDJO
FTUSVDUVSBM
%FMFV[FPCTFSWBS EFMFTUSVDUVSBMJTNPTFBUPQPM-
RVF
FOQSJODJQJP
FTUFFMFNFO- HJDBZSFMBDJPOBM "MBJO#BEJPV
UP OP FT VOB GPSNB
QVFT
MB FTIPZ
TJOEVEB
FMHSBOIFSF-
FTUSVDUVSB OP TF EFOF QPS MB EFSPEFFTUBUSBEJDJO
BVUPOPNBEFMUPEP
QPSFMQSJ- %FFTUFDSJUFSJPMPDBMPQP-
NBEPEFMUPEPDPOSFTQFDUPB TJDJPOBMTFEFSJWBOWBSJBTDPO-
TVTQBSUFT
QPSVOBGestaltRVF TFDVFODJBT&OQSJNFSMVHBS
TJ
96
Historiografa postmoderna
97
-VJT(%F.VTTZr.JHVFM7BMEFSSBNB
98
Historiografa postmoderna
'
99
-VJT(%F.VTTZr.JHVFM7BMEFSSBNB
100
Historiografa postmoderna
101
-VJT(%F.VTTZr.JHVFM7BMEFSSBNB
FO FTUF DBTP MB NVKFS
OP QP- MB DSFBDJO EF PUSBT IBCMBT
EB IBCMBS EJS RVF MP RVF DBTJ TJFNQSF EF MPT TFOUJNJFO-
SFBMNFOUFRVFSBFYQSFTBSDPO UPT
IBCJUBOEP
QPS MUJNP
BRVFMMBQPMNJDBQSFHVOUBFSB FOMPTNSHFOFTEFMQPEFS FO
RVFFMBDUPEFUPNBEFQBMBCSB MB DSFFODJB EF QPMUJDBT EF MB
ZFOVODJBDJOQPSQBSUFEFMPT EJGFSFODJB
/P FT QPTJCMF FM
TVKFUPT TVCBMUFSOPT FTUBCB ZB
EJTDVSTP GFNJOJTUB
UBM DPNP
EF BMHO NPEP
FTUSVDUVSBEP MP SFDPOPDF ,JSLXPPE
TMP
QPS VO DJFSUP UJQP EF QTJDP- Z FO MB PCTUJOBEB
jOFHBDJO
CJPHSBGB
EFBIRVFMBQSPQJB BCTPMVUBv &T QPS FMMP RVF TV
FOVODJBDJOTFSBJOUFSQSFUBEB QPMUJDBFTDSJUVSB GFNJOJTUB OP
EFMBNBOFSBFORVFIJTUSJDB- EFTJTUJS EF MBT SFUSJDBT EF MP
NFOUFIBTJEPQSFHVSBEB VOJWFSTBM-BQPMUJDBEFMGFNJ-
&ODPOTFDVFODJB
OPTFUSB- OJTNP TF FMBCPSBS
NT CJFO
UBS QVFT EF VO QVSP BDUP EF FOVODPNQMFKPKVFHPFOUSFMP
OFHBDJOPEFJOWFODJOEFMPT FYDMVJEP Z MP JODMVJEP
FOUSF
OPNCSFTEFMBNVKFSQPSGVFSB
MPQBSUJDVMBSZMPVOJWFSTBM
FO
FO MPT NSHFOFT /P TF QVFEF VO NPWJNJFOUP RVF JS EFTEF
FTDSJCJS FM GFNJOJTNP mZ FO MPT NSHFOFT IBDJB FM DFOUSP
FTUP $JYPVT UJFOF SB[Om TMP Z FO FTF HFTUP JOUFOUBS MB SF
IBCJUBOEP FO MPT NSHFOFT JOWFODJO
OPTMPEFMBNVKFS
IBCJUBOEP MB USBORVJMJEBE EFM TJOPRVFEFMBIJTUPSJBZEFMB
NBSHFOEFMBIJTUPSJB FOMBFT- EFNPDSBDJB
DSJUVSB EF MB jPUSB IJTUPSJBv
IBCJUBOEP FO MPT NSHFOFT EF <"MFKBOESB$BTUJMMP>
MB MFOHVB FO MB BVEBDJB EF
102
Historiografa postmoderna
<DBQj&MHOFSPVOBDBUFHPSBUJMQBSBFMBOMJTJTIJTU-
SJDPv> /FMMZ 3JDIBSE
Feminismo, gnero, diferencia(s)
4BOUJBHP EF $IJMF
1BMJOPEJB
+VMJFUB ,JSLXPPE
Feminarios
4BOUJBHP EF $IJMF
%PDVNFOUBT
(B-
ZBUSJ$IBLSBWPSUZ4QJWBL
j$BOUIF4VCBMUFSO4QFBL v
FO$BSZ/FMTPOZ-BXSFODF(SPTTCFSH DPNQT
Marx-
ism and the Interpretation of Culture
6SCBOB
5IF6OJ-
WFSTJUZPG*MMJOPJT1SFTT
)MOF$JYPVT
Deseo de
escritura
#BSDFMPOB
3FWFSTP&EJDJPOFT
<DBQj-B
SJTBEFMB.FEVTBv>(FOFWJWF'SBJTTF
La diffrence des
sexes
1BSJT
16'
"MFKBOESB$BTUJMMP
La repblica
masculina y la promesa igualitaria
4BOUJBHPEF$IJMF
1B-
MJOPEJB
(BZBUSJ$IBLSBWPSUZ4QJWBL
j)JTUPSZv
A
Critique of Postcolonial Reason. Toward a History of the
Vanishing Present
$BNCSJEHF
)BSWBSE6OJWFSTJUZ1SFTT
1999.
103
-VJT(%F.VTTZr.JHVFM7BMEFSSBNB
104
Historiografa postmoderna
105
-VJT(%F.VTTZr.JHVFM7BMEFSSBNB
106
Historiografa postmoderna
107
-VJT(%F.VTTZr.JHVFM7BMEFSSBNB
EFVOBNBOFSBEFQFOTBSZEF MBBSNBDJOEFVOGVOEBNFO-
VO QFOTBNJFOUP OBEB NPEFS- UP POUPMHJDP EF MB IJTUPSJB
OPT F JOOPWBEPSFT
Z NFOPT &O PUSBT QBMBCSBT
SFWJTBOEP
BOSFWPMVDJPOBSJPT&TUFQFO- TVNBSJBNFOUF FTUPT QSPCMF-
TBNJFOUP TF SFNPOUBSB IBTUB NBT TF UFOESB FO TFHVJEB VO
)FSDMJUP Z 1MBUO
Z B USBWT DVBESPEFMPTNPUJWPTQPSMPT
EF)FHFMZ.BSY
IBCSBEBEP RVF FM IJTUPSJDJTNP JEFBMJTUB
MVHBSBMBTGPSNBTEFUPUBMJUB- PNBSYJTUB
JUBMJBOPPBMFNO
SJTNP NPEFSOP RVF DPOPDJ DSUJDPPBCTPMVUP
UFSNJOBQPS
FM TJHMP XX &O TOUFTJT
QBSB DPOHVSBS TJFNQSF VO FTQBDJP
1PQQFS FM IJTUPSJDJTNP TFSB FTQFDVMBUJWP IPNPHOFP P FT-
FTFODJBMNFOUFVOBEPDUSJOBEF USVDUVSBEP
MBOFDFTJEBEEFMEFTBSSPMMPIJT- -B DSJTJT EFM IJTUPSJDJTNP
USJDP QVFEFTFSBTQSFTFOUBEBDPNP
.TBMMEFMPTOGBTJTFY- VOB DSJTJT EF DPOBO[B FO MB
DFTJWPT EF MB QFSTQFDUJWB QP- IJTUPSJB -B QFSEJEB EF MFHJUJ-
QQFSJBOB
SFTVMUBUJMPCTFSWBS NJEBE EF MPT NFUBSSFMBUPT FT-
RVF CBKP TV MV[ QVFEFO EFT- QFDVMBUJWPT EF MB NPEFSOJEBE
UBDBSTF BMHVOPT EF MPT SBTHPT FTU OUJNBNFOUF BTPDJBEB B
QSJODJQBMFT EFM IJTUPSJDJTNP EJDIB DSJTJT -B QPTUNPEFSOJ-
FVSPQFP "T
QVFEF PCTFSWBS- EBE
EFTEFFTUBQFSTQFDUJWB
OP
TF RVF FGFDUJWBNFOUF FO BMHV- QVFEF TFS DPOTJEFSBEB DPNP
OBT WFSTJPOFT JEFBMJTUBT Z NB- VOBSBEJDBMJ[BDJOIJTUPSJDJTUB
UFSJBMJTUBT EFM IJTUPSJDJTNP MB /PBMNFOPT
EFTEFMBQFSTQFD-
IJTUPSJDJEBE FTU GVFSUFNFOUF UJWBRVFBCSFMBDSUJDBQPTUQP-
EFUFSNJOBEB QPS BMHVOPT EF QQFSJBOBEFMIJTUPSJDJTNP
MPT SBTHPT RVF EFTUBDB MB DS- "OUFTEFDPODMVJSFTUBQSF-
UJDB QPQQFSJBOB 1BSB GVOEB- TFOUBDJOTJOQUJDBEFMPTVTPT
NFOUBS FTUB BSNBDJO CBTUB- EF MB QBMBCSB jIJTUPSJDJTNPv
SB DPO TFBMBS B MB EJBMDUJDB RVJ[T DPOWFOHB TFBMBS VOB
FO TVT EJTUJOUBT UFPSJ[BDJPOFT MUJNB QSFDJTJO DPODFQUVBM
P SFDPSEBS FM QSPCMFNB EF MPT &OFMNCJUPEFMBTEJTDVTJPOFT
WBMPSFTFOTVDPNQMFKBEJDVM- BOHMPBNFSJDBOBT DPOUFNQPS-
UBE
P BEWFSUJS JODMVTP MBT DP- OFBT TF TVFMF EJTUJOHVJS
DBEB
OFYJPOFT PCKFUJWPTVCKFUJWP
WF[ DPO NBZPS JOTJTUFODJB
FO-
FTUSVDUVSBTVQFSFTUSVDUVSB
USF jIJTUPSJTNPv historism
F
MHJDPGFOPNFOPMHJDP
OFDF- jIJTUPSJDJTNPv historicism
TJEBEDPOUJOHFODJB
B MBT RVF -B EJTUJODJO JOHMFTB TVSHF EF
BMHVOBTUFPSBTIBOSFNPOUBEP VOB EFDJTJO EF USBEVDDJO
108
Historiografa postmoderna
109
-VJT(%F.VTTZr.JHVFM7BMEFSSBNB
.
110
Historiografa postmoderna
111
-VJT(%F.VTTZr.JHVFM7BMEFSSBNB
112
Historiografa postmoderna
113
-VJT(%F.VTTZr.JHVFM7BMEFSSBNB
114
Historiografa postmoderna
115
-VJT(%F.VTTZr.JHVFM7BMEFSSBNB
116
Historiografa postmoderna
117
-VJT(%F.VTTZr.JHVFM7BMEFSSBNB
118
Historiografa postmoderna
r-FDUVSBTTVHFSJEBT.JHVFM7BMEFSSBNB
Modernismos
historiogrficos. Artes visuales, postdictadura, vanguar-
dias
4BOUJBHPEF$IJMF
1BMJOPEJB
<DBQj&MQSPC-
MFNBEFMNBSDPv>+VEJUI#VUMFS
Marcos de Guerra. Las
vidas lloradas
#VFOPT"JSFT
1BJET
&SWJOH(PGG-
NBO
Frame Analysis. Los marcos de la experiencia
.B-
ESJE
4JHMP99*
/BODZ'SBTFS
Escalas de justicia
.BESJE
)FSEFS
.FZFS4DIBQJSP
Theory and Phi-
losophy of Art: Style, Artist, and Society
-POEPO
(FPSHF
#SB[JMMFS
<DBQj0O4PNF1SPCMFNTJOUIF4FNJPUJDT
PG7JTVBM"SU'JFMEBOE7FIJDMFJO*NBHF4JHOTv>'SBOL
"OLFSTNJU
Historia y tropologa. Ascenso y cada de la
metfora
.YJDP
'POEP EF $VMUVSB &DPONJDB
<DBQj&MFGFDUPEFSFBMJEBEFOMBFTDSJUVSBEFMBIJTUPSJB-B
EJONJDBEFMBUPQPMPHBIJTUPSJPHSDBv>+BDRVFT%FS-
SJEB
La verdad en pintura
#VFOPT"JSFT
1BJET
.JLJF#BM
Conceptos viajeros en Humanidades
.BESJE
$FOEFBD
<DBQ FONBSDBNJFOUP> 7JDUPS 4UPJDIJUB
La invencin del cuadro. Arte, artfices y artificios en los
orgenes de la pintura europea
#BSDFMPOB
&EJDJPOFTEFM
4FSCBM
)BZEFO8IJUF
Figural Realism. Studies in
the Mimesis Effect
#BMUJNPSF
5IF+PIOT)PQLJOT6OJ-
WFSTJUZ 1SFTT
<DBQ j-JUFSBSZ5IFPSZ BOE )JTUPSJ-
DBM8SJUJOHv>'SBOL"OLFSTNJU
j4UBUFNFOUT
5FYUTBOE
1JDUVSFTv
JO 'SBOL"OLFSTNJU Z )BOT ,FMMOFS FET
A
New Philosophy of History
$IJDBHP
5IF6OJWFSTJUZPG
$IJDBHP1SFTT
"SUIVS%BOUP
The Transfiguration
of the Commonplace. A Philosophy of Art
$BNCSJEHF
.BTTBDIVTFUUT
)BSWBSE6OJWFSTJUZ1SFTT
119
Historiografa postmoderna
***
'
121
Historiografa postmoderna
$
&RVHVSBTQFSNJUFOSF-
FYJPOBSZFTDSJCJSOVFTUSPQBTBEPDPNPIJTUPSJB
FTJNQPSUBOUF
SFWJTBSDNPMFTBTJHOBNPTWBMPSBEJDIBTWPDFT
ZDNPFOUFO-
EFNPTBTVNJNPT MB USBOTGFSFODJB WBMSJDB TVFSUF EF QBSCBTJT
IJTUPSJPHSDB
EFTEFFTBTPUSBTTPOPSJEBEFTFOOVFTUSBTQSPQJBT
MJNJUBDJPOFTJOEJWJEVBMFTIBDJBFTFBZFSRVFTFOPTEFWFMBZBCSF
FOMPTWFTUJHJPTPQSFHVOUBTRVFDPOTJEFSBNPTDPNPQFSNJUFOUFT
&OFTBMOFB
EPTGPSNBTEFFOUFOEFSDNPTFQVFEFVTBSZ
DBSBDUFSJ[BSFMDPODFQUPEFBKVTUFPTFMFDDJOWBMSJDBFOMBEJTDJ-
QMJOBIJTUSJDB
TPOMBTUSBCBKBEBTQPS'SBOL,FSNPEFZ.BSUJO
+BZ&OTVTMJCSPTFormas de atencin e Historia y valor
,FSNP-
EFFTUBCMFDFVOBQSFHVOUBFOFMDBNQPEFMBIJTUPSJBEFMBSUFZ
EFMBMJUFSBUVSBRVFTFBKVTUBQMFOBNFOUFBMPRVFOPTPUSPTFTUB-
NPTJOUFOUBOEPQMBOUFBSjy1PSRVNFEJPTBUSJCVJNPTWBMPSB
MBTPCSBTEFBSUFZEFRVNBOFSBOVFTUSBTFWBMVBDJPOFTBGFDUBO
OVFTUSB GPSNB EF FOUFOEFSMBT v1 $PNP SFTQVFTUB
TF QSPQPOF
VOBTVFSUFEFWJUBMJEBEZNPWJNJFOUPBMJOUFSJPSEFMPTDOPOFT
MJUFSBSJPZFTUUJDP"ENJUF
BEFNT
RVFQBSBFOUSBSFOFMKVFHP
DPODFQUVBM
FTOFDFTBSJPFOUFOEFSRVFIBZEPTMNJUFTGVOEBNFO-
1
j&M QMBOUFBNJFOUP FT BNQMJBNFOUF IJTUSJDP CVFOB QBSUF EF MP RVF EJHP
FTU SFMBDJPOBEP DPO MPT QSPDFTPT QPS MPT DVBMFT FTUBCMFDFNPT VOB CVFOB
PQJOJOQBSBVOUSBCBKPPVOBSUJTUBRVFQPSMPHFOFSBMQSFDFEFMPTFTGVFS-
[PTNTFOSHJDPTEFDSUJDBFJOUFSQSFUBDJO
FTEFDJS
MBOBUVSBMF[BEFMBT
GVFS[BTIJTUSJDBTRVFDFSUJDBORVFBMHVOPTUSBCBKPTZOPPUSPTSFRVJFSFO
PNFSFDFOFTUBTGPSNBTEFBUFODJOFTQFDJBMFTw-BIJTUPSJBEFFTUPTPCKFUPT
JOVTVBMFTRVFEFTBQBSFDFOEFMDBOPO
FOSFBMJEBEEFTBQBSFDFOEFMBWJTUB
QFSPTPOSFTUJUVJEPTEFTQVTEFMBSHPTQFSPEPTEFOFHMJHFODJB
NFQBSFDF
VOBCVFOBNBOFSBEFFOUSBSFOEJTDVTJOv'SBOL,FSNPEF
Formas de
atencin
#BSDFMPOB
(FEJTB
Q
123
-VJT(%F.VTTZr.JHVFM7BMEFSSBNB
UBMFT VOP RVF WF FM DBOPO DPNP VO DPOKVOUP P VOB TFMFDDJO
SHJEB
FTUBCMFDJEBZTJOQPTJCJMJEBEEFDVFTUJPOBNJFOUP DBOPO
EVSP
ZPUSPRVFDPSSFTQPOEFBVOBWFSTJONTFYJCMF DBOPO
CMBOEP
1PSPUSBQBSUF
,FSNPEFSFDPOPDFRVFUBNCJOTFQVF-
EFFOUSFHBSWBMPSBQBSUJSEFQSPDFTPTEFSFMFDUVSBRVFEJTUJOHBO
RVWBSJBCMFTZRVNBOJGFTUBDJPOFT
jRVUSP[PTEFNFNPSJBv
QPSDJFSUPJOVTVBMFT
QVFEFOZEFCFORVFEBSEFOUSPEFMorden
del discursoZQPSFOEFSFDJCJSjGPSNBTEFBUFODJOFTQFDJBMFTv
QPSQBSUFEFMBDSUJDBZMPTIJTUPSJBEPSFT1BSBFMMPNFODJPOBEPT
FTUSBUFHJBT B
FMFTUBCMFDJNJFOUPEFDOPOFTEFPCSBTQBSUJDVMB-
SFTZ C
BQBSUJSEFMBJOWFODJOEFQFSPEPTIJTUSJDPT"TVWF[
VOPUBNCJOQPESBQFOTBSRVFPUSBTGPSNBTEFJOTUBVSBSDSJUF-
SJPTEFTFMFDUJWJEBEQVFEFOTFSMBHFOFSBDJOEFIJQUFTJTGVFSUFT
MBT JOUFSQSFUBDJPOFT UFOEFODJPTBT
MB DFMFCSBDJO EF QFSTPOBKFT
DBSFOUFTEFTJHOJDBODJB
MBFYDMVTJOCJCMJPHSDB
MBTQSFGFSFO-
DJBTJEFPMHJDBTFYUSFNBT
FUDUFSB&OTOUFTJT
UPEBTBRVFMMBTFT-
USBUFHJBTRVFQFSNJUFOQPUFODJBSMBGBMTFEBEBQBSUJSEFMNBOFKP
EFMBNFNPSJB2.
-BTFHVOEBGPSNBEFFOUFOEFSFMEFCBUFQPSVOBTVFSUFEF
DBOPO IJTUPSJPHSDP QPTUNPEFSOP
FT DPOTUBUBS DPNP MP IBDF
FM IJTUPSJBEPS FTUBEPVOJEFOTF .BSUJO +BZ MPT QFMJHSPT GSFOUF BM
DPOPDJEP Z SFQFUJEP ICJUP IVNBOJTUB EF MFHJUJNBS FM USBCBKP
QSPQJPDJUBOEPHSBOEFTOPNCSFTEFMBEJTDJQMJOBBMBRVFTFQFS-
UFOFDFFTEFDJS
IBDJFOEP NBM
VTPEFMBTFMFDDJOEFBVUPSFTZ
EFCBUFTRVFTPOSFDPOPDJEPTDPNPMFHUJNPTZDPOTVDJFOUFIJT-
UPSJDJEBEDPNPQBSBTFSEFCBUJEPTZQPTUFSJPSNFOUFJODPSQPSB-
EPTPUSBOTGFSJEPTTPDJBMNFOUF1BSBFMMP
+BZTFBMBRVFFTDMBWF
UFOFSTJFNQSFQSFTFOUFMBTQSFUFOTJPOFTEFWBMJEF[ZMBTBSHVDJBT
USPQPMHJDBTRVFOPSNBMNFOUFTFVOFODPOMBTZBDPOPDJEBTWP-
MVOUBEFTEFQPEFSEFUPEPFOGPRVFNFUEJDPRVFTFNBUFSJBMJ[B
FYDMVTJWBNFOUFFOFMOPNCSBSDOPOFTEFDVBMRVJFSPSEFOZDPO
2
j5BMWF[MBNFKPSJNBHFOQBSBMBNBOFSBFORVFJOGVOEJNPTWBMPSBTUFZ
OPBBRVFMUSP[PEFNFNPSJBTFBMBOPWFMBEF1SPVTUTVSHJFOEPEFMPTJO-
EFUFSNJOBEPT
EFTNFNCSBEPTIFDIPTEFMB)JTUPSJB
FMODMFPEFMSFDVFSEP
DPOWFSUJEPFODBOPOTVSHJFOEPEFMB)JTUPSJB
FMWBMPSv
'SBOL,FSNPEF
Historia y valor
#BSDFMPOB
1FOOTVMB
QQ
124
Historiografa postmoderna
FTPTFFWJUBMBWFSJDBDJOSJHVSPTBEFMBTQPTJCJMJEBEFTZBSHV-
NFOUPTTFBMBEPT3.
-PJNQPSUBOUFTFSB
FOUPODFT
BTVNJSRVFMBJOTQJSBDJOZP
MBBVUPSJEBEEFDVBMRVJFSUFYUPVBSUFGBDUPIJTUSJDPmTVMFHUJ-
NB IJTUPSJDJEBEDBOPOJDJEBEm FTUBSB EFOJEB FO VOB QSJNFSB
JOTUBODJBQPSMBDBQBDJEBESFGFSFODJBMEFMBVUPS TVJOUSOTFDBWJ-
HFODJBEJBMHJDB
ZFOVOBTFHVOEBFUBQBQPSVODPOUSPMFTUSJDUP
QFSPMEJDPmQPSQBSUFEFMIJTUPSJBEPSmEFMBPQBDJEBEMJOHTUJDB
ZEFMBTWPMVOUBEFTEFQPEFSFODVFTUJOMBTVZBZMBEFTVTSF-
GFSFOUFT
3
j&O PUSBT QBMBCSBT
yQPESB OVFTUSB FNCBSB[PTB EFCJMJEBE QPS MFHJUJNBS
OVFTUSBTJEFBTSFDPOPDJFOEPRVFQSPDFEFOEFBVUPSFTBOUFSJPSFTBOPTPUSPT
BODVBOEPQSPDMBNFNPTTQFSBNFOUFMBNVFSUFEFMBVUPS
FYQSFTBSMBEJ-
NFOTJO JOFWJUBCMFNFOUF QFSTPOBM EF OVFTUSP JOUFST QPS MB DPNQSFOTJO
IVNBOJTUB
RVFOPTJNQJEFJEFOUJDBSOPTUPUBMNFOUFDPOFMTVKFUPEFMBFT-
QFDJF QSPQVFTUP QPS MB UFPSB v
.BSUJO +BZ
Campos de fuerza. Entre la
historia intelectual y la crtica cultural
#VFOPT"JSFT
1BJET
Q
125
-VJT(%F.VTTZr.JHVFM7BMEFSSBNB
17
/EFFO1SPWFODF
'SBODJB%FTEFTV
JOGBODJBZKVWFOUVETJOUJGBTDJOBDJOQPSMBBSRVFPMPHB
QSJO-
DJQBMNFOUFMBSPNBOB
BMBRVFUFOBBDDFTPHSBDJBTBMNVTFPEF
MBDJVEBE%FCJEPBTVTDPOTUBOUFTWJTJUBTBMNVTFPEF/JNFT
FM
DVSBEPSEFMMVHBSEFDJEJUPNBSMPDPNPBQSFOEJ["MPTWFJOUJO
BPTEFKTVDJVEBEOBUBMQBSBUSBTMBEBSTFB1BST
EPOEFJOHSFTB
BMB&TDVFMB4VQFSJPSEF1BSJT"MMUVWPVOJODJQJFOUFEFTBSSP-
MMPQPMUJDPMMFHBOEPBVOJSTFBM1BSUJEP$PNVOJTUBQPSBMHVOPT
BPT6OBWF[UFSNJOBEPTTVTFTUVEJPT
SBUJDTVQBTJOQPSMB
IJTUPSJBBOUJHVB
VOJOEPTFBMB&TDVFMBGSBODFTBEF3PNBFOUSF
MPT BPT Z %FK FTUB BHSVQBDJO QBSB WPMWFS B TV
DJVEBEOBUBM
EPOEFFOTFBSBFOMB6OJWFSTJEBEEF1SPWFODF
&TJNQPSUBOUFTFBMBSRVF
EFCJEPBMNPNFOUPFORVF7FZOF
DPNJFO[BTVGPSNBDJO
MBIJTUPSJPHSBGBGSBODFTBTFFODPOUSBCB
EPNJOBEBQPSMBMMBNBEB&TDVFMBEFMPTAnnales&OTVTQSJNF-
SPTBPT
MBPCSBEF7FZOFFTUBCMFDFVOJNQPSUBOUFEJMPHPDPO
MB USBEJDJO DSUJDB BMFNBOB
FTQFDJBMNFOUF DPO +SHFO )BCFS-
NBT&OQBSUFFTUFEJMPHPTFSFFKBFOTVQSJNFSBPCSBQVCMJ-
DBEBCmo se escribe la historia: un ensayo de epistemologaFO
"MM
7FZOF MMFWB B DBCP VOB SFFYJO FQJTUFNPMHJDB FO
UPSOPBMBEJTDJQMJOBIJTUSJDB1MBOUFBRVFMBIJTUPSJBQPTFFMNJ-
UFTNVZUFOVFTDPOSFTQFDUPBMBDDJO
ZRVFVOPEFMPTQVOUPT
RVFMBWJODVMBODPOMBMJUFSBUVSBFTMBOBSSBUJWB&OFTUFTFOUJEP
TVTQSJODJQBMFTQSPQVFTUBTTPORVFMBIJTUPSJBOPFTVOBDJFODJB
TJOPNTCJFOVOBOPWFMBQPSFOEF
DBSFDFEFNFUPEPMPHBZOP
FOUSFHBFYQMJDBDJPOFT&OFTUFTFOUJEP
TFBQSFDJBRVFVOPEFMPT
QSJODJQBMFTDPOUSBQFTPTEFMBQSPQVFTUBEF7FZOFFTMBIJTUPSJB
EFMBjMBSHBEVSBDJOvZMBIJTUPSJBjDVBOUJUBUJWBvRVFFTUBCBO
EFTBSSPMMBOEPMPTIJTUPSJBEPSFTEFAnnales.
126
Historiografa postmoderna
)BDJB
ZHSBDJBTBMBJOWJUBDJOFYUFOEJEBQPSFMMTP-
GP3BZNPOE"SPO
7FZOFFOUSBMCollge de FranceDPNPQSP-
GFTPSEFMBDUFESBEF)JTUPSJBSPNBOB"MHVOPTBPTNTUBSEF
FO
SFFEJUBSBTVMJCSPJOJDJBMTPCSFFQJTUFNPMPHBIJTUSJDB
QFSP FTUB WF[ JOUSPEVDJSB VOB NPEJDBDJO OP NFOPS BM UUV-
MPCmo se escribe la historia. Foucault revoluciona la historia.
$PO FTU NPEJDBDJO7FZOF QSFUFOEF EFTUBDBS MPT BQPSUFT EF
'PVDBVMUBMFTUVEJPEFMBIJTUPSJB
EFKBOEPVOQPDPEFMBEPTV
NQFUVJOJDJBMQPSMBOBSSBUJWJ[BDJOEFMBIJTUPSJB
6OBEFTVTQSJNFSBTQVCMJDBDJPOFTDFOUSBEBTFOMPTFTUVEJPT
DMTJDPTEF7FZOFFTLes Grecs ont-ils cru leurs mythes?. Este
QFRVFPMJCSPFTVOBHSBOQSPWPDBDJO
QVFTTJTUFNBUJ[BTVDS-
UJDBBMBIJTUPSJPHSBGBQPTJUJWJTUB DSUJDBNVZPSJFOUBEBQPSMPT
USBCBKPTEF'PVDBVMU
ZMBPSJFOUBBMBOMJTJTEFMNVOEPHSJFHP"
TVKVJDJP
FMNVOEPHSJFHPOPQVFEFTFSFOUFOEJEPEFTEFMHJDBT
ZQBSNFUSPTQPTJUJWJTUBT&OFTUFTFOUJEP
SFBMJ[BVOBTVFSUFEF
JOWJUBDJOBFTUVEJBSBMPTHSJFHPTEFTEFTVTQSPQJPTQBSNFUSPT
ZUSBUBSEFFOUFOEFSEFTEFBIDVOEPZQPSRVMPTHSJFHPTEFKB-
SPOEFDSFFSFOTVTQSPQJPTNJUPT
&O 7FZOF QVCMJDB Historia de la vida privada. De la
Roma pagana hasta Bizancio. &MMJCSP
DPOVOQSFGBDJPEF(FPS-
HF%VCZ
CVTDBVOBDFSDBNJFOUPDPOMBFTDVFMBEFAnnales
QSJO-
DJQBMNFOUF DPO TVT FOGPRVFT EF QSPDFTPT EF MBSHB EVSBDJO Z
DPOMBIJTUPSJBEFMBTNFOUBMJEBEFT"EFNT
FMMJCSPTFQSFTFOUB
DPNPVOQSPZFDUPEFUSBCBKPJOUFSEJTDJQMJOBSJPRVFDPNCJOBMB
EJTDJQMJOBIJTUSJDBDPOMBBSRVFPMPHB
&OMPTBPTTJHVJFOUFT
7FZOFDPOUJOVTVQSPEVDDJOFOUPS-
OPBMB"OUJHFEBE
TJOFNCBSHP
TVQVCMJDBDJONTSFDJFOUFFT
VOBCJPHSBGBJOUFMFDUVBMEF.JDIFM'PVDBVMU
RVFMMFWBQPSUUVMP
Foucault. Sa pense, sa personneQVCMJDBEBFOFMBP
Bibliografa
127
-VJT(%F.VTTZr.JHVFM7BMEFSSBNB
1BVM7FZOF
Les Grecs ont-ils cru leurs mythes
1BSJT
4FVJM
1BVM7FZOF
Sexe et pouvoir Rome
1BSJT
5BMMBOEJFS
1BVM7FZOF
Quand notre monde est devenu Chrtien (312-394)
1BSJT
"MCJO.JDIFM
1BVM7FZOF
Foucault. Sa pense, sa personne
1BSJT
"MCJO.JDIFM
128
Historiografa postmoderna
&%&
&QPTUNPEFSOBTNTSFDPOPDJEBT
BDUVBMNFOUF/BDJEBZDSJBEBFOMPT&TUBEPT6OJEPT
SFBMJ[TVT
FTUVEJPT EF QSFHSBEP $BSMFUPO $PMMFHF 1PTUFSJPSNFOUF
SFBMJ[
TVTFTUVEJPTEFNBHTUFSFOMB6OJWFSTJEBEEF$BMJGPSOJB
#FSLMFZ
ZTVEPDUPSBEPMPPCUVWPEFMB6OJWFSTJEBEEF$IJDBHP4VQSP-
EVDDJO
RVFIBTJEPQVCMJDBEBFOMJCSPTZSFWJTUBTBDBENJDBT
DPNFO[BNFEJBEPTEFMBEDBEBEFMPTTFUFOUB
QFSPTFNBTJD
ZBFOMPTPDIFOUB
4VUSBCBKPIBTJEPEFTBSSPMMBEPFO[POBTEFJOUFSEJTDJQMJOB-
SJFEBE"CBSDBOEP EFTEF FTUVEJPT TPCSF MJUFSBUVSB
FM HOFSP
F
JODMVTPMBUFPSBIJTUPSJPHSDBFOFMDPOUFYUPEFMBQPTUNPEFSOJ-
EBE&TQSFDJTBNFOUFFOFTUFQVOUPRVFRVJTJSBNPTEFUFOFSOPT
%FOUSPEFMEFTBSSPMMPEFMBUFPSBIJTUPSJPHSDBEFMBTMUJNBT
EDBEBT
&SNBSUIIBTJEPVOBEFMBTNVKFSFTNTBDUJWBT"MP
MBSHPEFTVTPCSBT
BTVNFFMFTUBSFOVODPOUFYUPQPTUNPEFSOPZ
SFFYJPOBTPCSFMBEJTDJQMJOBIJTUSJDBZMBTJNQMJDBODJBTRVFIBO
FKFSDJEPTPCSFFTUB
4VQSJNFSMJCSPMMFWBQPSUUVMPRealism and Consensus in the
English Novel: Time, Space and Narrative
&OM
EFTBSSP-
MMBVOBDVDJPTPBOMJTJTTPCSFMBMJUFSBUVSBSFBMJTUBQSJODJQBMNFOUF
EFMPTTJHMPT97*** y 9*9"MM
BSHVNFOUBRVFFMSFBMJTNPFTUUJDP
FTVOBGPSNBEFDPOTFOTP4VQJFESBEFUPQFFTFMBDVFSEPFOUSF
MPTEJWFSTPTQVOUPTEFWJTUBRVFTPOQVFTUPTBEJTQPTJDJOQPSVO
UFYUP$POFMOEFFYQPOFSFTUBUFTJTTFJOUSPEVDFFOMBMFDUVSB
EFBVUPSFTDMTJDPTDPNP+FBO"VTUFOZ$IBSMFT%JDLFOT
FOUSF
PUSPT"FTUFMJCSPMFTJHVJGeorge Eliot
FO&MRVFFTRVJ-
[TTVUFYUPNTJNQPSUBOUF
GVFQVCMJDBEPFOCBKPFMUUVMP
EFSequel to History: Postmodernism and the Crisis of Represen-
tational Time
&TFOFTUFUSBCBKPEPOEFTFQVFEFFODPO-
129
-VJT(%F.VTTZr.JHVFM7BMEFSSBNB
USBSFMODMFPQSJODJQBMEFTVQSPQVFTUBUFSJDB
ODMFPRVFIB
TJEPDPNFOUBEPZEJTDVUJEPQPSEJWFSTPTBVUPSFT&OEJDIPUFYUP
Z DPNP MB BVUPSB NJTNB MP TFBMB
FM O FT FM EF NPTUSBS RVF
MBQPTUNPEFSOJEBEJNQMJDBVOBUSBOTGPSNBDJOEFMBUFNQPSBMJ-
EBE&OQBMBCSBTEF&SNBSUI
MBUFTJTRVFEFFOEFSequel to His-
toryFTRVFjFMMFOHVBKFOBSSBUJWPQPTUNPEFSOPNJOBFMUJFNQP
IJTUSJDPZMPTVTUJUVZFQPSVOBOVFWBDPOTUSVDDJOUFNQPSBMRVF
EFOPNJO DPNP UJFNQP SUNJDP &TUF UJFNQP SUNJDP NPEJDB
EFGPSNBSBEJDBMPCJFOBCBOEPOBQPSDPNQMFUPMBEJBMDUJDB
MB
UFPMPHB
MBUSBTDFOEFODJB
ZMBOFVUSBMJEBEQVUBUJWBEFMUJFNQP
IJTUSJDPZSFFNQMB[BFMcogitoDBSUFTJBOPQPSVOBTVCKFUJWJEBE
EJGFSFOUFDVZPNBOJFTUPQPESBTFSMBGSBTFEF$PSUB[BS
APTDJMP
MVFHPTPZv%FTEFVOQVOUPEFWJTUBTJTUFNUJDP
QVFEFBEWFS-
UJSTFRVFSequel to HistorySFUPNBZSBEJDBMJ[BDJFSUPTFMFNFOUPT
QSFTFOUFT FO Realism and Consensus in the English Novel &O
USNJOPT NFUPEPMHJDPT
FM MJCSP TJHVF QSJWJMFHJBOEP BSUFGBDUPT
MJUFSBSJPTjDMTJDPTv
SFDVSSJFOEPBBVUPSFTDPNP+VMJP$PSU[BS
Z7MBEJNJS/BCPLPWBMNPNFOUPEFEJTDVUJSMBTSFMBDJPOFTFOUSF
UJFNQPZOBSSBDJO
&OEFOJUJWB
MBDSUJDBTFDFOUSBQSJODJQBMNFOUFFOEPTBTQFD-
UPT1PSVOMBEP
MBCTRVFEBQPSjEFTFDIBSvMBTDPODFQDJPOFT
NPEFSOBTEFMUJFNQP WBMFEFDJSMJOFBMJEBEZQSPHSFTP
MBTRVF
QPESBOTFSFSSBEJDBEBTQPSNFEJPEFMBTIFSSBNJFOUBTRVFFO-
USFHBMBQPTUNPEFSOJEBEZQPSPUSP
QSFPDVQBSTFQPSFMjTVKFUPv
RVFBCBOEPOBMBNPEFSOJEBE
FMRVFBTVKVJDJP
IBTJEPVOPEF
MPTHSBOEFTNBSHJOBEPTEFUPEBTMBTUFPSJ[BDJPOFTDPOSFTQFDUPB
MBQPTUNPEFSOJEBE6OBJOUFSFTBOUFMFDUVSBTPCSF)FSNBSUIIB
TJEPSFBMJ[BEBQPSFMIJTUPSJBEPSCSJUOJDP,FJUI+FOLJOT
RVJFO
SFTDBUBZEJTDVUFMBTQSJODJQBMFTUFTJTEFFTUFMJCSP
"FTUFUFYUP
MFTJHVJThe English Novel in History 1840-
1895EF"MM
)FSNBSUIWVFMWFTPCSFMPTFTUVEJPTMJUFSBSJPT
RVFBTVWF[WJODVMBDPOMBOBSSBUJWBZMBIJTUPSJB%FFTUBGPSNB
MPHSBHFOFSBSVOBSFFYJOJOUFSEJTDJQMJOBSJBFOUPSOPBMBOPWF-
MBIJTUSJDBJOHMFTBEFMBTFHVOEBNJUBEEFMTJHMP9*9&OFM
)FSNBSUIQVCMJDDPNPFEJUPSBVOMJCSPDPNQJMBUPSJPUJUVMBEP
Rewriting Democracy: Cultural politics in postmodernity.&OTV
JOUSPEVDDJOSFFYJPOBKVOUPBPUSPTJOUFMFDUVBMFTDPNP&EXBSE
4BJEZ$IBOUBM.PVGGF
TPCSFMPTBDUVBMFTEFTBGPTRVFFOGSFOUB
130
Historiografa postmoderna
MBQPMUJDBFOVODPOUFYUPEFQPTUNPEFSOJEBEZMBJOVFODJBRVF
IB FKFSDJEP FTUB MUJNB FO MB EFNPDSBDJB &M BSUDVMP DPO RVF
)FSNBSUIQBSUJDJQBFOFMMJCSP
UJUVMBEPj%FNPDSBDZBOE1PTU-
NPEFSOJUZ5IF1SPCMFNv
CVTDBFYUFOEFSFODJFSUBNFEJEBUPEB
TVSFFYJOUFSJDBFOUPSOPBMBQPTUNPEFSOJEBE
ZRVFIBTUBFM
NPNFOUPQBSFDFIBCFSTFDFOUSBEPQSJODJQBMNFOUFFOMBIJTUPSJB
ZMBMJUFSBUVSB"IPSB
DPNPFMNJTNPUUVMPMPJOEJDB
CVTDBEJBH-
OPTUJDBSEFRVGPSNBFTUFDPOUFYUPQPTUNPEFSOPIBTVQFSBEP
MBTCBSSFSBTBDBENJDBTZIBMPHSBEP
FONBZPSPNFOPTNFEJEB
BGFDUBSFOMBFTGFSBEFNPDSUJDBBMBTQFSTPOBT
Bibliografa
131
-VJT(%F.VTTZr.JHVFM7BMEFSSBNB
%-$
/&6FO4VTFTUVEJPTEFQSF-
HSBEPMPTSFBMJ[FOMB6OJWFSTJEBEEF$PSOFMM
ZMVFHPPCUVWP
TV EPDUPSBEP FO MB 6OJWFSTJEBE EF )BSWBSE 4V DBSSFSB DPNP
BDBENJDP VOJWFSTJUBSJP DPNFO[ FO BM FOUSBS B USBCBKBS
BM EFQBSUBNFOUP EF IJTUPSJB EF MB VOJWFSTJEBE EF $PSOFMM "D-
UVBMNFOUF FT #SZDF BOE &EJUI #PXNBS 1SPGFTTPS PG )VNBOJT-
UJD 4UVEJFT EF MB 6OJWFSTJEBE EF $PSOFMM
BM UJFNQP RVF EJSJHF
MB4DIPPMGPS$SJUJDJTNCE5IFPSZ
VOBEFMBTFOUJEBEFTUFSJDBT
NTJNQPSUBOUFTEFMNVOEP
4VT MOFBT EF USBCBKP TPO CBTUBOUF WBSJBEBT 6OP EF TVT
QSJODJQBMFTJOUFSFTFTIBTJEPMBIJTUPSJBJOUFMFDUVBM
DVZPEFTB-
SSPMMP GVF EF HSBO JNQPSUBODJB QBSB MB EJTDJQMJOB FO HFOFSBM
6OPEFTVTUFYUPTDFOUSBMFTFOFTUBNBUFSJBFTj3FUIJOLJOH*OUF-
MMFDUVBM)JTUPSZBOE3FBEJOH5FYUTv
QVCMJDBEPFOHistory and
TheoryFO"MMPGSFDF
FOUSFPUSBTDPTBT
VODPOKVOUPEF
SFFYJPOFTTPCSFMBIJTUPSJBJOUFMFDUVBMRVFQFSNJUFOTPMVDJPOBS
EJWFSTBT QSPCMFNUJDBT Z USBCBT B MBT RVF TF WFB FOGSFOUBEB
MB EJTDJQMJOB FO BRVFM NPNFOUP
NVZ EF MB NBOP EF MPT MMB-
NBEPT jUFYUVBMJTNPTv Z jDPOUFYUVBMJTNPTv 4V QSPQVFTUB FO
FTUBNBUFSJBBQVOUBBDPOTUJUVJSVOBjTVCEJTDJQMJOBEFMBIJT-
UPSJBJOUFMFDUVBMRVFFOBMHVOPTBTQFDUPTJNQPSUBOUFTFTUSBOT-
EJDJQMJOBSJBvMBRVFBTVWF[jJOTUBBMIJTUPSJBEPSJOUFMFDUVBMB
QPOFSTFBMUBOUPEFMBTFMBCPSBDJPOFTFOPUSBTEJTDJQMJOBTRVF
BCPSEBO MPT QSPCMFNBT EF MB JOUFSQSFUBDJO
FO FTQFDJBM EF MB
DSUJDBMJUFSBSJBZEFMBMPTPGB"EFNT
-B$BQSBQSPQPOFVO
OVFWP BDFSDBNJFOUP B MPT jHSBOEFT UFYUPTv
RVF IBO TJEP EF-
KBEPTEFMBEPQPSMBTIJTUPSJPHSBGBT
QFSPFTUBWF[
EFTEFVOB
QFSTQFDUJWB DSUJDB &O FTUF TFOUJEP
JOTJTUF FO RVF FT FTFODJBM
132
Historiografa postmoderna
MMFWBSBDBCPVOBjSFFWBMVBDJOvEFMDBOPO&OFTUBMOFB
-B-
$BQSB IB QVCMJDBEP QVCMJDBDJPOFT JOFMVEJCMFT QBSB FM DPSQVT
EFMBIJTUPSJBJOUFMFDUVBM&OUSFFMMBTTFQVFEFOOPNCSBSEmile
Durkheim: Sociologist and Philosopher
A Preface to
Sartre
Z Madame Bovary on Trial
$BCF TFB-
MBSRVFFTUFJOUFSTTFDPODFOUSFOMPRVFQPESBNPTEFOPNJ-
OBSDPNPVOBjQSJNFSBFUBQBvEFOUSPEFTVUSBCBKP
FMRVFJS
DBNCJBOEPEFGPDPDPOFMQBTPEFMPTBPT
0USBWFSUJFOUFJOUFSFTBOUFEFTBSSPMMBEBQPSFMBVUPS
ZMBRVF
MFIBWBMJEPRVJ[TNBZPSSFDPOPDJNJFOUP
IBTJEPFMJOUFSTFO
MPTFTUVEJPTTPCSFFM)PMPDBVTUP&TUBBQSPYJNBDJOIBUFOJEP
VO GVFSUF DPNQPOFOUF QTJDPBOBMUJDP
Z FT QSPCBCMFNFOUF FTUB
BQSPYJNBDJOVOPEFMPTFMFNFOUPTNTMMBNBUJWPTEFTVOVF-
WPUSBCBKP&OFTUFNBSDPEFTUBDBORepresenting the Holocaust:
History, Theory, Trauma
Z History and Memory after
Auschwitz
&TJNQPSUBOUFTFBMBSRVFFOFTUPTUFYUPTMB
UFNUJDBDFOUSBMOPFTFM)PMPDBVTUPKVEP
PFMNJTNP"VTDIXJU[
FOT
TJOPNTCJFO
MBSFQSFTFOUBDJOZMBOBSSBDJORVFTFIBDF
EF FMMP &T B USBWT EF FTUPT UQJDPT RVF -B$BQSB JOTUBMB VOB
QBSUFDMBWFZQPUFOUFEFTVQSPQVFTUBUFSJDB"TVWF[
QVFEFEF
JHVBMNPEPDPOTJEFSBSTFDPGVOEBEPSEFMPTBDUVBMFTFTUVEJPTEF
MBNFNPSJB&OHistory and Memory after Auschwitz SFFYJPOB
MBSHBNFOUFFOUPSOPBMBNFNPSJBZTVVUJMJ[BDJODPNPGVFOUF
IJTUSJDB&OUPSOPBFTUPTFBMBRVFjFMSFDJFOUFHJSPEFMBNF-
NPSJBQVFEFTJHOJDBSNTRVFVOTOUPNB
BMNFOPTDVBOEPMB
QSFPDVQBDJO JODMVZF FM EFTFP EF PDVQBSTF EFM QSPCMFNB EF MB
IJTUPSJBFOMBNFEJEBFORVFQFTBTPCSFFMQSFTFOUFZFMGVUVSP
BCBSDBOEPMBOFDFTJEBEEFVOFYBNFOBVUPDSUJDPEFMBQSPQJB
JNQMJDBDJOEFMQSPCMFNBRVFFODBSBNPTv"EFNTBSNBRVF
MBNFNPSJBBQVOUBBQSPCMFNBTRVFTJHVFOWJHFOUFTPRVFFTUO
JOWFTUJEPTEFWBMPSFTPEFFNPDJPOFT
0USBJEFBDBSEJOBMFYQVFTUBFOFMMJCSPFTMBSFMBDJORVF-B-
$BQSBFTUBCMFDFFOUSFIJTUPSJBZQTJDPBOMJTJT/PFTMBJOUFODJO
QSPGVOEJ[BSFOUPSOPBMBTDPODFQDJPOFTUFSJDBTEFFTUBEJTDJQMJOB
OPPCTUBOUFOPTEFUFOESFNPTFOVOPEFMPTBTQFDUPTDSVDJBMFTRVF
-B$BQSBEJTDVUF"MDPNFO[BSFMTFHVOEPDBQUVMPEFFTUFMJCSP
TFBMBRVFjMPTDPODFQUPTGVOEBNFOUBMFTEFMQTJDPBOMJTJT DPNP
USBOTGFSFODJB
SFTJTUFODJB
OFHBDJO
SFQSFTJO
QBTBKFBMBDUPZFMB-
133
-VJT(%F.VTTZr.JHVFM7BMEFSSBNB
CPSBDJO
BUSBWJFTBOMBPQPTJDJOCJOBSJBFOUSFJOEJWJEVPZTPDJF-
EBEv"MQMBOUFBSFTUP
-B$BQSBFTUBCMFDF
DPNPMNJTNPTFBMB
RVFFYJTUJSBVOjFSSPSvQPSQBSUFEFMQTJDPBOMJTJTFOBQMJDBSFTUBT
DPODFQDJPOFT FTUSJDUBNFOUF B MP JOEJWJEVBM
EFKBOEP EF MBEP jMP
DPMFDUJWPv5BSFBRVFFMIJTUPSJBEPSOPSUFBNFSJDBOPQSFUFOEFEF-
TBSSPMMBSDPOTVUSBCBKP
BMNFOPTEFGPSNBUFSJDB
&OMPTMUJNPTBPT
-B$BQSBIBEFEJDBEPQBSUFEFTVPCSB
BMBSFFYJOUFSJDBEFMBEJTDJQMJOB
UFNUJDBRVFZBIBCBEF-
TBSSPMMBEPFODJFSUBNFEJEBFOMBEDBEBEFMPT
ZQSJODJQJPT
EF MPT &KFNQMP EF FTUP TPO History and 3FBEJOH: Tocque-
ville, Foucault, French Studies
Writing History, Writing
Trauma
ZHistory in Transit: Experience, Identity, Criti-
cal Theory
&OFTUFMUJNPMJCSP
-B$BQSBSFUPNBBMHVOB
EFTVTQSJODJQBMFTUFNUJDBT
DPNPMBUFPSBDSUJDBZFMUSBVNB
Bibliografa
134
Historiografa postmoderna
'"
135
-VJT(%F.VTTZr.JHVFM7BMEFSSBNB
UFT QVCMJD BMHVOPT MJCSPT FO TV JEJPNB NBUFSOP
FM IPMBOET
Z FO QVCMJD VOB SFDPQJMBDJO EF FOTBZPT RVF MMFW QPS
UUVMP History and Tropology. The Rise and Fall of Metaphor
Z
RVFGVFUSBEVDJEPBMFTQBPMZQVCMJDBEPQPSFM'POEPEF$VMUVSB
&DPONJDBFOFMBP&OEJDIPUFYUP
"OLFSTNJUSFQBTBTVT
SFFYJPOFTFOUPSOPBMBFTDSJUVSBIJTUSJDBZTVTJNQMJDBODJBTMP-
TDBT
BMBWF[RVFBEKVOUBVOBSFFYJOFOUPSOPBMBTJUVBDJO
IJTUPSJPHSDBEFMNPNFOUPFOj)JTUPSJPHSBGBZ1PTUNPEFSOJT-
NPv"MM
BCPSEBMBTJUVBDJOBDUVBMEFMBTPCSFQSPEVDDJOFOMB
EJTDJQMJOBIJTUPSJPHSDB"EFNT
SFFYJPOBFOUPSOPRVFBMBTSF-
MBDJPOFTFOUSFDJFODJBZQPTUNPEFSOJEBE&OFTUFTFOUJEP
FMBVUPS
CVTDBEFSSJCBSVOBTFSJFEFNJUPTZDPODFQDJPOFTTVQVFTUBNFOUF
FSSBEBTFOUPSOPBMBQPTNPEFSOJEBE
DPNPQPSFKFNQMPMBDSFFO-
DJBEFRVFFTTJOOJNPEFMSFMBUJWJTNPBCTPMVUP
&T QSFDJTBNFOUF FO FM BSUDVMP BOUFSJPSNFOUF TFBMBEP RVF
"OLFSTNJU FYQPOF TV GBNPTB jNFUGPSB EFM SCPMv QBSB QFOTBS
FM BWBODF EF MB IJTUPSJPHSBGB j-B USBEJDJO FTFODJBMJTUB EFOUSP
EFMFTDSJUPIJTUSJDPPDDJEFOUBMmTFBMBmDFOUSMBBUFODJOEFMPT
IJTUPSJBEPSFTFOFMUSPODPEFMSCPMv
DPOFMDBNCJPEFMBTDPODFQ-
DJPOFTUFSJDBTZFQJTUFNPMHJDBT
QSJODJQBMNFOUFEFMBNBOPEFMB
IJTUPSJBFDPONJDB
FMGPDPTFDFOUSFOMBTSBNBTEFMSCPM
UPEB
WF[RVFTFIVCPEFOJEPVOUSPODP/PPCTUBOUF
DPOMBMMFHBEB
EFMBQPTUNPEFSOJEBE
jMBFMFDDJOZBOPSFDBFFOFMUSPODPOJFO
MBTSBNBT
TJOPFOMBTIPKBT w
FMPCKFUJWPZBOPFTMBJOUFHSBDJO
TOUFTJTPUPUBMJEBE
TJOPFTPTUSP[PTIJTUSJDPTRVFTPOFMDFOUSPEF
BUFODJOv4JOFNCBSHP
"OLFSNJTUOPTFRVFEBBI"BEFRVFFT
DBSBDUFSTUJDBQSPQJBEFMBTIPKBTTVGSBHJMJEBE
TVGBMUBEFSNF-
[BSFTQFDUPEFMBTSBNBT
Z
QPSFOEF
FTMHJDPZOPSNBMRVFFO
FMPUPPFTUBTDBJHBO&OSB[OEFFMMP
SFFYJPOBFMIJTUPSJBEPS
IPMBOETjFMPUPPIBMMFHBEPBMBIJTUPSJPHSBGBPDDJEFOUBMv+VO-
UPDPOMPBOUFSJPS
TFBMBUSBTMBGVFSUFUFNQFTUBERVFTVQPOFMB
QPTUNPEFSOJEBE
MPTFVSPQFPTIBOUFSNJOBEPQPSEFTDVCSJSRVF
FM SCPM EF MB IJTUPSJBFVSPQFBPDDJEFOUBMFTTPMP VOP NT FO FM
JONFOTPCPTRVFEFMBIVNBOJEBE
&OMPTBPTTJHVJFOUFT"OLFSTNJUTJHVJQVCMJDBOEPMBNBZP-
SBEFTVUSBCBKPFOIPMBOET
IBTUBRVFFOFMBPQVCMJD
FOJOHMTHistorical Representations y Political Representations.
-VFHP
FO FM BP QVCMJD Sublime Historical Experien-
136
Historiografa postmoderna
ce
RVF TF DPOWJSUJ FO TV TFHVOEP MJCSP USBEVDJEP BM FTQBPM
&TUBWF[CBKPFMDVJEBEPEFMBFEJUPSJBM1BMJOPEJB
ZDPOFMUUVMP
EF Experiencia histrica sublime &O EJDIP UFYUP
RVF B KVJDJP
EFM BVUPS HVBSEB VOB JNQPSUBOUF SFMBDJO DPO TV QSJNFS MJCSP
"OLFSTNJUCVTDBJEFOUJDBSZEJTDVUJSBBRVFMMPTBVUPSFTRVFFO
MBNPEFSOJEBEEJFSPOGPSNBBMBJEFBEFFYQFSJFODJBIJTUSJDB
$POUBMQSPQTJUP
EJTDVUFGVOEBNFOUBMNFOUFMBTJEFBTEFQFOTB-
EPSFTBMFNBOFTDPNP&JDIFOEPSGG
#VSDLIBSEUP/JFU[TDIF
DPO
FMOEFFYQPOFSMPTjGSBHNFOUPTQBSBVOBIJTUPSJBEFMBFYQF-
SJFODJBIJTUSJDBv&TUFSFDPSSJEPTFFTUBCMFDFDPOMBOBMJEBEEF
MMFHBSBFOUFOEFSMPRVF"OLFSTNJUEFOPNJOBMBOPDJOEFjFY-
QFSJFODJBIJTUSJDBTVCMJNFv
MBDVBMTPMPTFBMDBO[BNFEJBOUFMB
EJGFSFODJBDJOEFMTVKFUPEFTVQSPQJBFYQFSJFODJB
MPHSBOEPBT
VOB FYQFSJFODJB TJO TVKFUP %FCFNPT BHSFHBS BEFNT RVF FTUB
SFFYJOUJFOFQPSPCKFUJWPDFOUSBMFMBCPSBSVOOVFWPDPNJFO[P
UFSJDPDBQB[EFTVQFSBSMBTBQPSBTZQBSBEPKBTEFMBMMBNBEB
jDSDFMEFMMFOHVBKFv
"MBGFDIB
'SBOL"OLFSTNJUIBQVCMJDBEPNTEFWFJOUJDJO-
DPMJCSPTFOEJWFSTPTJEJPNBT
ZTJHVFEFTFNQFBOEPGVODJPOFT
DPNPBDBENJDPFOMBVOJWFSTJEBEEF(SPOJOHFN
Bibliografa
137
-VJT(%F.VTTZr.JHVFM7BMEFSSBNB
)8
FTUSVDUVSBMJTUBTZEFMMMBNBEPjHJSPMJOHTUJDPvFOFMDBNQPEF
MB IJTUPSJPHSBGB
MP RVF SFTVMU TJO EVEB BMUBNFOUF QPMNJDP
1BSB BMHVOPT DPNFOUBEPSFT EFM EFCBUF IJTUPSJPHSDP DPOUFN-
QPSOFP
8IJUFSFQSFTFOUBVOBFTQFDJFEFIJTUPSJBEPSjCJTBHSBv
FOUSFMPTDBNQPTEFMBIJTUPSJPHSBGBZMBMJUFSBUVSB
)BZEFO8IJUFOBDJFOFOFMTVSEFMPT&TUBEPT6OJ-
EPT 4VT QBESFT FSBO USBCBKBEPSFT RVF GVFSPO BGFDUBEPT QPS MB
(SBO%FQSFTJO
QPSMPRVFTFWJFSPOGPS[BEPTBNJHSBSB%F-
USPJU
.JDIJHBO&TFOFTUBDJVEBEEPOEF8IJUFDVSTBTVTFTUV-
EJPT VOJWFSTJUBSJPT FO MB 8BZOF 4UBUF 6OJWFSTJUZ 4VT FTUVEJPT
GVFSPOJOUFSSVNQJEPTFOQBSUFQPSMB4FHVOEB(VFSSB.VOEJBMZ
TVTDPOTFDVFODJBT
MMFHBOEPFMGVUVSPIJTUPSJBEPSBGPSNBSQBSUF
EFMPTDVFSQPTEFHVFSSBEFMBNBSJOBBOFTEFMBEDBEBEFM
DVBSFOUB-VFHPEFMTFSWJDJPNJMJUBS
8IJUFSFUPNBMPTFTUVEJPT
VOJWFSTJUBSJPTFOMB8BZOF4UBUF6OJWFSTJUZ
QBSBQPTUFSJPSNFOUF
DPOUJOVBSMPT FO MB 6OJWFSTJEBE EF .JDIJHBO
EPOEF PCUJFOF FM
EPDUPSBEPFOFMBP&TJNQPSUBOUFEFTUBDBSRVFTVUFTJTEF
EPDUPSBEPOPUJFOFQPSPCKFUPMBUFPSBPMPTPGBEFMBIJTUPSJB
TJOP MPT FTUVEJPT NFEJFWBMFT &O FGFDUP
TV UFTJT EF EPDUPSBEP
WFSTTPCSF4BO#FSOBSEPEF$MBJSWBVYZFMDJTNBQBQBMEF
4JCJFOTVTJOUFSFTFTFOVODPNJFO[PGVFSPOMPTFTUVEJPTNF-
EJFWBMFT
8IJUF IB EFDMBSBEP FO SFQFUJEBT PDBTJPOFT RVF EFTEF
NVZUFNQSBOPMFJOUFSFTMBIJTUPSJBDPNPQSPCMFNBjyDNPTF
IBDFMBIJTUPSJB v
jyDVMFTMBNFKPSGPSNBEFIBDFSMB v
jyQBSB
RVFTUVEJBSFMQBTBEP v.JFOUSBTGVFFTUVEJBOUFFO.JDIJHBO
138
Historiografa postmoderna
USBCBKDPOFMQSPGFTPS.BVSJDF.BOEFMCBVN
RVJFOQPSBRVFMMB
QPDB
FSB EF MPT QPDPT IJTUPSJBEPSFT RVF DVMUJWBO DPO BMHVOB
TJTUFNBUJDJEBEMBMPTPGBEFMBIJTUPSJB
/PPCTUBOUFTVUFNQSBOBGPSNBDJOBDBENJDB
TVFOUSBEB
USJVOGBMFOFMNVOEPBDBENJDPOPSUFBNFSJDBOPUVWPMVHBSUSBT
MB QVCMJDBDJO EF Metahistory
UFYUP RVF FT DBMJDBEP
QPS 'SBOL"OLFSTNJU DPNP jFM MJCSP EF MPTPGB EF MB IJTUPSJB
NTSFWPMVDJPOBSJPEFMPTWFJOUJDJODPBPTSFDJFOUFTvMetahis-
toryTVSHJDPNPSFTVMUBEPEFMBQSPGVOEJ[BDJOEFVOBSUDVMP
QVCMJDBEPFOMBSFWJTUBHistory and Theory
CBKPFMUUVMPj5IF
#VSEFO PG )JTUPSZv FO 5SBT MB QVCMJDBDJO
SFDJCJ VOB
DBSUBFORVFTFMFJOTUBCBBFTDSJCJSVOQFRVFPMJCSPFOUPSOPB
FTFUFNB4VFEJUPSMPSFDIB[
ZMFEJKPRVFFTDSJCJFSBBMHPNT
FYUFOTP
BTOBDJMetahistory.
&OEJDIPMJCSP
8IJUFDFOUSBTVSFFYJOFOUPSOPBMBOBSSB-
DJO NJTNB EF MPT EJTDVSTPT IJTUPSJPHSDPT &TUP RVFEB DMBSP
EFTEFVODPNJFO[P
DVBOEPFMBVUPSTFBMBRVFjDPOTJEFSBSMB
PCSBIJTUSJDBDPNPMPRVFNTNBOJFTUBNFOUFFTFTEFDJS
VOB
FTUSVDUVSB WFSCBM FO GPSNB EF EJTDVSTP EF QSPTB OBSSBUJWB RVF
EJDFTFSVONPEFMP
PJNBHFO
EFFTUSVDUVSBTZQSPDFTPTQBTBEPT
DPOFMOEFFYQMJDBSMPRVFfueron representndolos. &TJNQPS-
UBOUFFOUFOEFSBTVWF[
RVFFTUFUFYUPOBDFFOQMFOBEDBEBEF
MPTTFUFOUB
WBMFEFDJS
FOVODPOUFYUPFORVFFMFTUSVDUVSBMJTNP
GSBODT UJFOF VO GVFSUF JNQBDUP FO MB BDBEFNJB OPSUFBNFSJDB-
OB&TFMNJTNPBVUPSRVJFOTFBMBRVFFTUFUFYUPTVSHFFOVO
NPNFOUP QBSUJDVMBS EFM PSJHFO EF MB EJTDVTJO FO MPTPGB EF
MB IJTUPSJB F IJTUPSJPHSBGB FM NPNFOUP EF Metahistory FSB FM
NPNFOUPEFMFTUSVDUVSBMJTNP&TUFFTVOUSBCBKPFTUSVDUVSBMJTUB
&M IJTUPSJBEPS BNFSJDBOP SFDPHF FMFNFOUPT EF MB USBEJDJO
MJUFSBSJBZCVTDBMBGPSNBFORVFFTUPTTPOBQMJDBCMFTBMNCJ-
UPIJTUPSJPHSDP1BSBFTUP
SFTDBUBMPTQPTUVMBEPTUFSJDPTEF
/PSUISPQ'SZF
FTQFDJBMNFOUFEFTVMJCSPAnatomy of Criticism
4JHVJFOEP B 'SZF
8IJUF QSPQPOF RVF FYJTUFO jQPS MP
NFOPT DVBUSP NPEPT EJGFSFOUFT EF USBNBS FM SPNBODF
MB USB-
HFEJB
MBDPNFEJBZMBTUJSBv&TUPTDVBUSPjUSPQPTvMPTJEFOUJ-
DBDPODVBUSPEJGFSFOUFTIJTUPSJBEPSFTEFMTJHMP9*9FVSPQFP
.JDIFMFUIBCSBVUJMJ[BEPFMSPNBODF
3BOLF
MBGPSNBDNJDB
5PDRVFWJMMF
MBUSBHFEJBZ#VSDLIBSEUMBTUJSB4VJEFBDFOUSBMFT
139
-VJT(%F.VTTZr.JHVFM7BMEFSSBNB
FTUBCMFDFSRVFjUPEBIJTUPSJB
IBTUBMBNTjTJODSOJDBjPjFT-
USVDUVSBMv
FTUUSBNBEBEFBMHVOBNBOFSBv+VOUPDPOEJTDVUJS
ZDPNFOUBSBMPTBVUPSFTBOUFTNFODJPOBEPT
8IJUFEFEJDBQBSUF
JNQPSUBOUFEFMBOMJTJTBJOEBHBSFOUPSOPBJNQPSUBOUFTMTP-
GPTEFMBIJTUPSJBEFMNJTNPTJHMP
FOQBSUJDVMBS
/JFU[TDIF
.BSY
Z$SPDF4JOEVEB
FTUFUFYUPGVFBMUBNFOUFSFWPMVDJPOBSJPFOFM
NVOEPBOHMPTBKO
BVORVFTFEFCFSFDPOPDFSRVFBMQBSFDFSTV
JOVFODJBGVFNFOPSFOPUSBTBDBEFNJBT
DPNPQPSFKFNQMPMB
GSBODFTB
4JCJFO MetahistoryGVFVOBEFTVTPCSBTNTJOVZFOUFT
OP
GVF MB OJDB &O QVCMJD Tropics of Discourse. Essays in
Cultural Criticism"MM
8IJUFBHSVQBVOBTFSJFEFFOTBZPTTPCSF
UFPSBEFMBIJTUPSJBRVFGVFQSPEVDJFOEPFOMPTMUJNPTBPT4JO
EVEB
VOPEFMPTNTJNQPSUBOUFTFTFMBSUDVMPj5IF)JTUPSJDBM
5FYBT-JUFSBSZ"SUJGBDUv
USBEVDJEPBMFTQBPMDPNPj&MUFYUP
IJTUSJDPDPNPBSUFGBDUPMJUFSBSJPv
FOMBBOUPMPHBEFUFYUPTRVF
7FSOJDB5P[[JSFVOJZQVCMJDCBKPFMNJTNPUUVMP
ZRVFDPN-
QJMBUSBCBKPTEFTropics of Discourse. Essays in Cultural Criti-
cism
ZEFFigural Realism. Studies in the Mimesis Effect
&OFMFOTBZPTFBMBEP
8IJUFDSJUJDBBMPTIJTUPSJBEPSFT
NTjUSBEJDJPOBMFTv
QVFTUPRVF
BTVKVJDJP
jIBOTJEPSFUJDFOUFT
BDPOTJEFSBSMBTOBSSBUJWBTIJTUSJDBTDPNPMPRVFTPODDJPOFT
WFSCBMFTDVZPTDPOUFOJEPTTPOUBOUPinventados DPNPencontra-
dos Z DVZBT GPSNBT UJFOFO NT FO DPNO DPO TVT IPNMPHBT
FO MB MJUFSBUVSB RVF DPO MBT EF MBT DJFODJBTv &T RVJ[T FTUB MB
JEFBDFOUSBMEFMBQSPQVFTUBUSPQPMHJDBEFMetahistory$PNP
BSHVNFOUBNTBEFMBOUF
MPTBDPOUFDJNJFOUPTTPOincorporados
FOVOSFMBUPNFEJBOUFMBTVQSFTJOZTVCPSEJOBDJOEFBMHVOPT
EFFMMPTZFMOGBTJTFOPUSPTv&TFOFTUBMOFBRVFFMBVUPSFY-
QPOF TVT JEFBT TPCSF MBT OPDJPOFT EF jUSBNBEPv Z jTPCSFUSB-
NBEPv emplotment
7BMFEFDJS
UPEPEJTDVSTPIJTUPSJPHSDPFT
jUSBNBEPv
BDPSEFBVOBEFMBTDVBUSPFTUSVDUVSBTQSFHFOSJDBT
EFOBSSBDJOFTUBCMFDJEBTQPS'SZF&TUBTDPSSFTQPOEFOBMBTZB
QMBOUFBEBTFOMetahistory SPNBODF
USBHFEJB
DPNFEJBZTUJSB
4JOFNCBSHP
BKVJDJPEF8IJUF
FMIJTUPSJBEPSQPTFFBEFNTMB
DBQBDJEBEEFjTPCSFUSBNBSvMPTBDPOUFDJNJFOUPTEFOUSPEFMSFMB-
UPIJTUPSJPHSDP&TUPJNQMJDBRVF
TJCJFOFMIJTUPSJBEPSQVFEF
PSHBOJ[BSFMUFYUPEFMBGPSNBRVFHVTUF
OPQVFEFmPOPEFCFm
140
Historiografa postmoderna
Bibliografa
141
-VJT(%F.VTTZr.JHVFM7BMEFSSBNB
,+
)RVFIBEFEJDBEPTVWJEBBMFTUVEJPZ
EFTBSSPMMPEFMBUFPSBEFMBIJTUPSJB4FEFTFNQFBBDUVBMNFOUF
DPNP QSPGFTPS EF MB FTDVFMB EF QPTHSBEP EF MB VOJWFSTJEBE EF
$IJDIJTUFSFOFM3FJOP6OJEP)BTJEPVOPEFMPTUFSJDPTNT
JNQPSUBOUFT EF MPT MUJNPT WFJOUF BPT
Z TVT USBCBKPT MF IBO
WBMJEPVOJNQPSUBOUFSFDPOPDJNJFOUPBOJWFMJOUFSOBDJPOBM
4V QSJNFS MJCSP
Re-thinking History EF
FT DPOTJE-
FSBEPDPNPVOBEFMBTNFKPSFTBQSPYJNBDJPOFTBMEFCBUFQPTU-
NPEFSOPEFMBEJTDJQMJOBIJTUPSJPHSDB&OEJDIPUFYUP
+FOLJOT
CVTDBEBSVOBOVFWBSFTQVFTUBmRVJ[TBNPEPJOUSPEVDUPSJPmB
MBDMTJDBQSFHVOUBjyRVFFTMBIJTUPSJB v&MQSJNFSDBQUVMPEF
Re-thinking HistoryMMFWBQSFDJTBNFOUFQPSUUVMPj8IBUIJTUPSZ
JTv j-P RVF MB IJTUPSJB FTv
&O EJDIP DBQUVMP +FOLJOT CVTDB
FMBCPSBSVOOVFWPDPODFQUPEFIJTUPSJB
QBSBFMMPEFTBSSPMMBVOB
BQSPYJNBDJO RVF DPNCJOB FMFNFOUPT UFSJDPT Z QSDUJDPT 4J
CJFO
TFQVFEFBDVTBSEFGBMUBEFQSPGVOEJEBEBMBIPSBEFCVTDBS
VOB EFOJDJO
TF EFCF FOUFOEFS RVF MP RVF FM BVUPS CVTDB FT
VOBQSJNFSBBQSPYJNBDJOIBDJBFMDPODFQUP
MPRVFTFSEFTBS-
SPMMBEPBMPMBSHPEFUPEBTVPCSB%FFTUFMJCSP
FTJOUFSFTBOUF
FWJEFODJBSTVTQSJNFSPTBDFSDBNJFOUPTBMPRVFTFSBVODPOUFYUP
QPTUNPEFSOPQBSBFMFKFSDJDJPEFMBQSPEVDDJOIJTUPSJPHSDB
&O FTUF TFOUJEP
DPNJFO[B TV MJCSP EJTUJOHVJFOEP MBT OPDJPOFT
EFjQBTBEPvFjIJTUPSJBv&TUPFTBMUBNFOUFSFMFWBOUF
QVFT
MPT
DPOTJEFSBBBNCPTDPNPOPDJPOFTUPUBMNFOUFMJCSFTFJOEFQFOEJ-
FOUFTFOUSFT%FFTUBGPSNB
EFTEFFMNPNFOUPHFSNJOBMEFTV
PCSB ZFOQBSUJDVMBSEFFTUB
+FOLJOTEJTUJOHVFFOUSFFMFKFSDJDJP
IJTUPSJPHSDPZFMQBTBEP
OFHBOEPBRVFMWODVMPJOFMVEJCMFRVF
NVDIPT IJTUPSJBEPSFT BSNBO DPO GFSWPS"M USB[BS FTUB EJTUJO-
142
Historiografa postmoderna
DJO +FOLJOT CVTDB USBUBS MB IJTUPSJB DPNP VOB EJTDJQMJOB FO T
NJTNB
NVDIPNTWJODVMBEBBMBTOBSSBDJPOFTZBMPTIJTUPSJBE-
PSFTRVFBMQBTBEPNJTNP
" FTUB QVCMJDBDJO MF TJHVJ On What is History: From
Carr and Elton to Rorty and White
&TUFFTVOUFYUPGVO-
EBNFOUBM
QVFTUP RVF FM BVUPS TF QSPQPOF DPOGSPOUBS MB WJTJO
jNPEFSOBvEFMBIJTUPSJPHSBGBBMBWBSJBCMFjQPTUNPEFSOBv&M
EFCBUFMPFODBSOBOFODVBUSPHVSBT1PSVOMBEP
FMIJTUPSJBEPS
CSJUOJDP &EXBSE $BSS Z FM JOUFMFDUVBM BMFNO (FPGGSFZ &MUPO
1PSPUSP
VOPEFMPTjGVOEBEPSFTvEFMMMBNBEPjHJSP-JOHTUJ-
DPv
3JDIBSE3PSUZZFMIJTUPSJBEPSOPSUFBNFSJDBOPRVFWJODVM
MBT QFSTQFDUJWBT MJOHTUJDBT BM BOMJTJT IJTUPSJPHSDP
)BZEFO
8IJUF/PPCTUBOUF
FOFTUFUFYUPFMBVUPSWFVOBTVFSUFEFDPO-
UJOVBDJOEFTVPCSBBOUFSJPS
MPRVFTFFWJEFODJBNTBMMEFTVT
QSPQJBTQBMBCSBT
FOMBDPOUJOVBDJOEFMBSFFYJOFOUPSOPBMB
TFQBSBDJOFOUSFFMQBTBEPZMBIJTUPSJB
%FTVJOUFSFTBOUFPCSB
TMPTVQVCMJDBDJOEF
UJUVMB-
EBWhy History? Ethics and Postmodernity
IBTJEPUSBEVDJEB
BMFTQBPM#BKPFMUUVMPEFPor qu la historia?
FM'POEPEF
$VMUVSB &DPONJDB USBEVKP FM MJCSP FO FM BP "MM
+FO-
LJOT WVFMWF OVFWBNFOUF TPCSF BMHVOPT EF MPT IJTUPSJBEPSFT
-
MTPGPTZUFSJDPTNTSFMFWBOUFTEFMBTMUJNBTEDBEBT&OUSF
FMMPTDBCFEFTUBDBSB'SBOL"OLFSTNJU
+BDRVFT%FSSJEB
)BZEFO
8IJUF
+FBO'SBOPJT -ZPUBSE Z &MJ[BCFUI %FFT &SNBUI
FOUSF
PUSPT4JHVJFOEPMBMOFBEFTVTUFYUPTBOUFSJPSFT
+FOLJOTDVFT-
UJPOB OVFWBNFOUF MB EJTDJQMJOB IJTUPSJPHSDB FO FM NBSDP EFM
EFCBUFQPTUNPEFSOP&OFTUFTFOUJEP
VOBEFTVTUFTJTDFOUSBMFT
FTRVFFMQFOTBNJFOUPQPTUNPEFSOPQVFEFTJHOJDBSFMOEFMB
IJTUPSJB4JOFNCBSHP
BMBSNBSFTUP
EJTUJOHVFFOUSFMPRVFM
EFOPNJOBDPNPMB)JTUPSJB DPONBZTDVMB
ZMBIJTUPSJB DPO
NJOTDVMB
$PO SFTQFDUP B MB QSJNFSB
MP FOUJFOEF DPNP jMB
DPOTJEFSBDJOEFMQBTBEPFOUSNJOPTRVFBTJHOBOTJHOJDBDJO
PCKFUJWBBBDPOUFDJNJFOUPTRVFFOSFBMJEBETPODPOUJOHFOUFT-P
IBDFBMJEFOUJDBSTVMVHBSZTVGVODJOEFOUSPEFVOFTRVFNB
HFOFSBMEFEFTBSSPMMPVUJMJ[BFMQBTBEPQBSBJNQVMTBSVOQVOUP
EFWJTUBEFUFSNJOBEPv1PSIJTUPSJBDPONJOTDVMB
+FOLJOTFO-
UJFOEFFMjFTUVEJPjEFTJOUFSFTBEPvEFMQBTBEPQPSTNJTNP
FO
TVTQSPQJPTUSNJOPT
MPNTPCKFUJWPFJNQBSDJBMNFOUFmZQPS
143
-VJT(%F.VTTZr.JHVFM7BMEFSSBNB
UBOUPABDBENJDBNFOUFmQPTJCMFv"MSFFYJPOBSFOUPSOPBMO
EFMBIJTUPSJB
TVQFOTBNJFOUPTFFODBNJOBQSFDJTBNFOUFFOUPS-
OPBFTUBMUJNBBDFQDJO-PRVF+FOLJOTQSPQPOF
FOEFOJUJWB
FTFMBMFKBNJFOUPEFOJUJWPEFBRVFMMBTGPSNBTjPCKFUJWJ[BOUFTv
RVFFOWVFMWFOBMBIJTUPSJPHSBGB
QMBOUFBOEP
NVZFOMBMOFBEF
.JDIFMEF$FSUFBV
RVFFTUBFTJEFPMHJDB
QPTJDJPOBEBZEJSJHJEB
BBMHVJFO&OFTUFTFOUJEP
BSNBRVFjMBIJTUPSJBIBUFSNJOBEP
DPNP VO EJTDVSTP FQJTUFNPMHJDPPOUPMHJDP
GVOEBNFOUBCMF
Z OPTPUSPT RVFEBNPT FO VOB TJUVBDJO RVF QFSNJUF P JNQPOF
OJDBNFOUFFTUJMJ[BDJPOFTUFNQPSBMFTJOGVOEBNFOUBCMFTad infi-
nitumv&TUBBTFSDJOTFDPNQMFNFOUB
TJOEVEB
DPOMBUFTJTRVF
BEWJFSUFRVFjFMQBTBEPOPFYJTUFjIJTUSJDBNFOUFvGVFSBEFMBT
BQSPQJBDJPOFTUFYUVBMFTZDPOTUSVDUJWBTEFMPTIJTUPSJBEPSFTv
1BSB+FOLJOTOPTPMPFMOEFMBIJTUPSJBUFOESBMVHBSFOMB
QPTUNPEFSOJEBE
TJOPUBNCJOFMOEFMBUJDB1MBOUFBRVFjOPT
FODPOUSBNPTFOVOBTJUVBDJOFOMBRVFQPEFNPTWJWJS ZFGFDUJ-
WBNFOUFWJWJNPT
fueraEFMBjUJDBvQFSPdentroEFMBNPSBMJ-
EBEv1BSBFTUPTFGFDUPT
TFBQPZBFOMBTJEFBTEF%FSSJEBTPCSF
MBBQPSB
TPCSFMBTRVFJOEBHBFOFMNJTNPMJCSP
Bibliografa
144
Historiografa postmoderna
.$
145
-VJT(%F.VTTZr.JHVFM7BMEFSSBNB
0USPTEFMPTJNQPSUBOUFTQVOUPTEFJOFYJOFOMBWJEBEF
.JDIFMEF$FSUFBVFTFMjNBZPEFMv.PNFOUPEFGVFSUFT
QSPUFTUBT FTUVEJBOUJMFT RVF FYJHFO QSPGVOEBT USBOTGPSNBDJP-
OFT FO FM TJTUFNB VOJWFSTJUBSJP Z TPDJBM &TUBT QSPUFTUBT Z FM
TFOUJNJFOUP RVF MBT BDPNQBP UFSNJOBSO QPS HFOFSBS VOB
QSPGVOEBSVQUVSBDPOMBHFOFSBDJOQSFDFEFOUFEFMBTFHVOEB
HVFSSBNVOEJBM.JDIFMEF$FSUFBV
BEJGFSFODJBEFMBBDUJUVE
RVF UPNBCB MB JHMFTJB FO HFOFSBM Z MB DPNQBB FO QBSUJDV-
MBS
OP TMP QSFTU BUFODJO B MPT IFDIPT RVF PDVSSBO FO FM
QBT
TJOP RVF UBNCJO UPN QBSUF FO FMMPT EFTEF MB SFWJTUB
tudes, EPOEF GFTUFKB FM NPWJNJFOUP" USBWT EF TVT QVCMJ-
DBDJPOFT
EF $FSUFBV DSJUJDB MB QFSDFQDJO FYJTUFOUF EF FTUPT
jBDPOUFDJNJFOUPTvQPSQBSUFEFMBTJOTUJUVDJPOFT
FOTVDBTP
QSJODJQBMNFOUFMBJHMFTJB&OQBMBCSBTEF%PTTF
j.BZPEFM
SFQSFTFOUBQBSB$FSUFBVMBPQPSUVOJEBEEFIBDFSVOBOMJTJT
FO DBMJFOUF
DPOUFNQPSOFP EF MP RVF ZB IBCB QFSDJCJEP FO
FM MFOHVBKF NTUJDP DPNP TPO MPT GFONFOPT EF SFVUJMJ[BDJO
EFMPBOUJHVPFOMPOVFWPv&OFTUFTFOUJEP
DSJUJDBBBRVFMMPT
BDBENJDPTRVFBOTFSFTJTUFOBWFSFOMPTBDPOUFDJNJFOUPT
FMFNFOUPTJNQPSUBOUFEFVOBSVQUVSBIJTUSJDB
ZTVFMFODPO-
DFCJSMPDPNPVOBDPOUFDJNJFOUPNT
&TBQBSUJSEFFTUPTBPTRVFFMIJTUPSJBEPSGSBODTDPNJFO[B
BQVCMJDBSTVTQSJNFSPTUSBCBKPT4BMFBMBMV[La solitude, une
vrit oublie de la communication
FTDSJUPDPO'SBOPJT3PVT-
UBOH Z PUSPT BVUPSFT FO Z La prise de parole. Pour une
nouvelle cultureFOQPSOPNCSBSBMHVOPT4JCJFOTVQSP-
EVDDJOOPGVFUBOFYUFOTBDPNPPUSPTJOUFMFDUVBMFTEFMBQPDB
TVSFMFWBODJBOPFTNFOPS$BCFEFTUBDBSFOFMNBSDPEFMBUFP-
SBIJTUPSJPHSDB
TVUFYUPLEcriture de lhistoire QVCMJDBEPFO
&OEJDIPUFYUP
FOQBSUJDVMBSFOFMDBQUVMPUJUVMBEPj-B
PQFSBDJOIJTUPSJPHSDBv
FMIJTUPSJBEPSTFQSFHVOUBjy2Vfa-
bricaFMIJTUPSJBEPSDVBOEPIBDFIJTUPSJB y&ORVUSBCBKB y2V
QSPEVDF *OUFSSVNQJFOEPTVEFBNCVMBDJOFSVEJUBQPSMBTTBMBT
EFMPTBSDIJWPTTFBMFKBVONPNFOUPEFTVFTUVEJPNPOVNFOUBM
RVFMPDMBTJDBSFOUSFTVTQBSFT
ZTBMJFOEPBMBDBMMFTFQSFHVOUB
y%FRVTFUSBUBFTUFPDJP .FIBHPQSFHVOUBTTPCSFMBSFMB-
DJOFOJHNUJDBRVFNBOUFOHPDPOMBTPDJFEBEQSFTFOUFZDPOMB
NVFSUFBUSBWTEFBDUJWJEBEFTUDOJDBTv
146
Historiografa postmoderna
4PORVJ[TFTUBTQBMBCSBT
MBTRVFTJOEVEBEFOFOVOBTEF
MBTQSJODJQBMFTMOFBTRVFIBCSEFTFHVJSMBUFPSBIJTUPSJPHSDB
DPOUFNQPSOFB4VWPMVOUBEjNFUBIJTUSJDBvFTBRVFMMBRVFMP
IBMMFWBEPBJOUFSSPHBSTFQPSMBEJTDJQMJOBNJTNBFOUPEPTTVT
BTQFDUPT
ZRVFTJOEVEBIBHFOFSBEPQSPGVOEBTFJNQPSUBOUFT
SFFYJPOFT1BSBFMBVUPS
MBPQFSBDJOIJTUPSJPHSDBSFQSFTFOUB
VOB DPNCJOBDJO EF USFT FMFNFOUPT FM MVHBS TPDJBM
MB QSDUJDB
DJFOUDB Z MB FTDSJUVSB -B PQFSBDJO IJTUPSJPHSDB CVTDB FT-
UBCMFDFSRVFMBQSPEVDDJOEFMIJTUPSJBEPSOPFTMJCSF
TJOPRVF
NVZQPSFMDPOUSBSJP
TFFODVFOUSBMJHBEPBMBTJOTUJUVDJPOFTRVF
MP DPCJKBO UBOUP B M DPNP B TV USBCBKP &O FTUF TFOUJEP
MMFHB
JODMVTP B BSNBS RVF jVOB TJUVBDJO TPDJBM DBNCJB B MB WF[ FM
NPEP EF USBCBKP Z FM UJQP EF EJTDVSTPv 4V QSPQVFTUB FT WJUBM
QVFTUPRVFFTEFMPTQSJNFSPTIJTUPSJBEPSFTFOQPOFSFOUFMBEF
KVJDJPMBPCKFUJWJEBEEFMIJTUPSJBEPSZMBDJFOUJDJEBEEFTVUSB-
CBKP
4FMFFBUSBWTEFMBPCSBEFFTUFBVUPSVOGVFSUFJOVKPEFM
MMBNBEP FTUSVDUVSBMJTNP
Z UBNCJO RVJ[T EF MP RVF TVFMF EF-
OPNJOBSTFDPNPQPTUFTUSVDUVSBMJTNP*OUSPEVDFMBJEFBFTFODJBM
BMBIJTUPSJPHSBGBEFMBTMUJNBTEDBEBT
EFRVFMBIJTUPSJBFT
VOEJTDVSTP FOVOBMOFBDMBSBNFOUFGPVDBVMUJBOB
ZQPSFOEF
USBFBQBSFKBEPVOQSPDFTPEFFTDSJUVSBJOFMVEJCMF&OFTUFTFOUJ-
EP
FMEJTDVSTPIJTUPSJPHSDPOPQVFEFFTDBQBSBMPTQSPDFTPT
EF OBSSBUJWJ[BDJO
Z B MBT PQFSBDJPOFT EF DDJPOBMJ[BDJO RVF
FTUPTQSPDFTPTDPNQPSUBO%JDIPFOPUSPTUSNJOPT
.JDIFMEF
$FSUFBVVCJDBBMMFOHVBKFFOVOBTJUVBDJOQSJWJMFHJBEB&TUPFT
WJUBMQBSBFMDBTPEFMIJTUPSJBEPS
ZBRVFFTBUSBWTEFMMFOHVBKF
RVFMPHSBFMDPOUBDUPjDPOMPTNVFSUPTv
ZBTVWF[
DPOTVMVHBS
TPDJBMZTVTMFDUPSFT
&MMVOFTEF&OFSPEF
MPTSFTUPTEF.JDIFMEF$FS-
UFBVTPOEFTQFEJEPTFOMBJHMFTJBEF4BO*HOBDJP
FO1BST#BKP
MB WP[ EF &EJUI 1JBG
UBM DPNP M MP IBCB RVFSJEP
VOP EF MBT
HVSBTFNCMFNUJDBTEFMBIJTUPSJPHSBGBEFMBTMUJNBTEDBEBT
TFEFTQJEJEFTVTBNJHPT
GBNJMJBSFTZBENJSBEPSFT
147
-VJT(%F.VTTZr.JHVFM7BMEFSSBNB
Bibliografa
148
Historiografa postmoderna
".
149
-VJT(%F.VTTZr.JHVFM7BMEFSSBNB
Bibliografa
150
Historiografa postmoderna
+84
)OBDJEBFOZRVFIBMP-
HSBEPQPTJDJPOBSTFDPNPVOBEFMBTNYJNBTSFQSFTFOUBOUFTEF
MBUFPSBFIJTUPSJPHSBGBEFHOFSPFOFMFTDFOBSJPBDUVBMEFMB
EJTDJQMJOB $PNFO[ TV GPSNBDJO FO MB VOJWFSTJEBE EF #SBO-
EFJT
FHSFTBOEPFMBP-VFHP
PCUVWPTVEPDUPSBEPFOMB
VOJWFSTJEBE EF 8JTODPOTJO.BEJTPO
FO %FTEF BRVFMMPT
BPTIBFKFSDJEPMBEPDFODJBVOJWFSTJUBSJBFOEJWFSTBTVOJWFSTJ-
EBEFT EFOUSP EF MPT &TUBEPT 6OJEPT &O FM BP GVOE FM
1FNCSPLF$FOUFSGPS5FBDIJOHBOE3FTFBSDIPO8PNFO
VOPEF
MPTQSJNFSPTDFOUSPTEFFTUVEJPEFHOFSPFJOWFTUJHBDJOTPCSF
MBTNVKFSFT
DPOTFEFFOMB6OJWFSTJEBEEF#SPXO4DPUUOPTPMP
IBFNQSFOEJEPVOBTFSJFEFFTUVEJPTFOMPTDVBMFTIBUSBUBEPMB
IJTUPSJBEFMBTNVKFSFTZMBTDPOTUSVDDJPOFTEFHOFSP
%FTEFTVTQSJNFSPTBPTDPNPIJTUPSJBEPSB
+PBO84DPUUTF
JOUFSFTQPSMBTUFNUJDBTEFHOFSP%FIFDIPTVQSJNFSMJCSP
The
Glassworkers of Carmaux: French Craftsmen and Political Action
in a Nineteenth Century City
FYQSFTBDPODMBSJEBEFTUPT
JOUFSFTFT"MM
BOBMJ[BMBTJUVBDJOEFMPTUSBCBKBEPSFTEFWJESJPFO
$BSNBVY
'SBODJB
FOVOFTGVFS[PEFQMBOUFBSVOBIJTUPSJBEFTEF
BCBKP
FOMBDVBMMBTNVKFSFTPCSFSBTZEJSJHFOUBTQPMUJDBTDPCSBO
VOBWJUBMJNQPSUBODJB"MHVOPTBPTNTUBSEF
FO
QVCMJD
Women, Work and Family KVOUPDPO-PVJTF5JMMZ&TUFFTRVJ[T
TVQSJNFSUFYUPDVZPGPDPFYDMVTJWPTPOMBTNVKFSFTZTVIJTUPSJB
-BT BVUPSBT SFBMJ[BO VO SFDPSSJEP RVF DPNJFO[B BOBMJ[BOEP MBT
SFMBDJPOFTGBNJMJBSFTFOMB'SBODJBF*OHMBUFSSBQSFJOEVTUSJBM
QB-
TBOEPQPSFMSPMEFMBNVKFSFOMBFDPOPNBGBNJMJBSZMPTDBNCJPT
EFNPHSDPT
QBSBUFSNJOBSFOMBTJNQMJDBODJBTRVFUSBKPQBSBMBT
NVKFSFTMBTFHVOEBHVFSSBNVOEJBM
151
-VJT(%F.VTTZr.JHVFM7BMEFSSBNB
&OQVCMJDVOPEFTVTMJCSPTNTSFMFWBOUFT
UJUVMBEP
Gender and the Politics of History -JCSP EF UFPSB F IJTUPSJB
FOM4DPUUFYQSFTBZQMBTNBUPEBTVSFFYJOUFSJDBZFQJTUF-
NPMHJDBTPCSFMPTFTUVEJPTEFHOFSP"MMTFFODVFOUSBVOPEF
MPT BSUDVMPT NT DPOPDJEPT EF 4DPUU
Z RVF IB TJEP USBEVDJEP
BMFTQBPMCBKPFMUUVMPj&MHOFSPVOBDBUFHPSBUJMQBSBFM
BOMJTJTIJTUSJDPv&OFTUFBSUDVMPMBIJTUPSJBEPSBFTUBEPVOJEFO-
TFBCPSEB
FOUSFPUSBTDPTBT
VOBDSUJDBBMPRVFTFIBUFOEJEP
BFOUFOEFSQPSMBJEFBEFHOFSP
JHVBMOEPMBDPOjIJTUPSJBEF
MBT NVKFSFTv 3FQBTB MPT FOGPRVFT QBUSJBSDBMJTUBT
NBSYJTUBT Z
QTJDPBOBMJTUBTEFMQSPCMFNB
IBDJFOEPVOCBMBODFEFMPRVFDBEB
VOPEFFMMPTIBBQPSUBEPBMBUFPSBGFNJOJTUBZBMHOFSP"EF-
NT
EJTUJOHVFFOUSFMBTOPDJPOFTEFHOFSP
TFYPZTFYVBMJEBE
WJODVMOEPMBTBVOFTFODJBMDPNQPOFOUFDVMUVSBMZQSJWOEPMPT
EFUPEBFTFODJBMJEBE&OSFTVNFO
TVDSUJDBBQVOUBBMBOFDFTJ-
EBE EF jSFDIB[BS MB DBMJEBE KB Z QFSNBOFOUF EF MB PQPTJDJO
CJOBSJB
MPHSBSVOBIJTUPSJDJEBEZVOBEFDPOTUSVDDJOHFOVJOBT
EFMPTUSNJOPTEFMBEJGFSFODJBTFYVBMv
4DPUUMMFWBDBCPUBNCJOUSBCBKPTEFFEJDJOFODPOKVOUP
DPOPUSBTEFMBTGFNJOJTUBTNTFNCMFNUJDBTEFMBBDUVBMBDB-
EFNJB OPSUFBNFSJDBOB
+VEJUI #VUMFS &TUF MJCSP GVF QVCMJDBEP
FOCBKPFMUUVMPEF Feminist Theroize the PoliticalEPOEF
SFVOJFSPOVOBTFSJFEFBSUDVMPTEFJOUFMFDUVBMFTGFNFOJOBTTPCSF
MPTNTWBSJBEPTUFNBT%FTEFSFFYJPOFTTPCSFFMBCPSUPIBT-
UBFMGFNJOJTNPFOVODPOUFYUPQPTUNPEFSOPOVUSFOVOBEFMBT
PCSBTDPNQJMBUPSJBTNTJOUFSFTBOUFTTPCSFUFPSBGFNJOJTUBZEF
HOFSP
&OQVCMJDOnly Paradoxes to Offer: French Feminists
and the Rights of Man -JCSP FO FM RVF BOBMJ[B MBT QSPGVOEBT
EFTJHVBMEBEFT TFYPHOFSP RVF DBSBDUFSJ[BO B MB 'SBODJB QPTU
SFWPMVDJPOBSJB"MJHVBMRVFFOTVTBOUFSJPSFTFTUVEJPT
FYQPOFZ
BOBMJ[BMBMVDIBEFMBTNVKFSFTQPSMBPCUFODJOEFMBDJVEBEBOB
6OMBSHPDBNJOPRVFDPNJFO[BDPOMBSFWPMVDJOGSBODFTBZRVF
UFSNJOBFOMBTQPTUSJNFSBTEFMB4FHVOEB(VFSSB.VOEJBM"M
QBSFDF
'SBODJBFTVOPEFMPTUQJDPTRVFNTHFOFSBJOUFSTFOMB
BVUPSB
BMPTMJCSPTBOUFTNFODJPOBEPTDBCFBHSFHBSParit: Sex-
ual Equality and the Crisis of French Universalism EPOEFBCBO-
EPOB QPS VO NPNFOUP FM TJHMP 9*9 QBSB FTUVEJBS MB TJUVBDJO
152
Historiografa postmoderna
EF MB MVDIB QPS MB QBSJEBE TFYVBM FO MB 'SBODJB EF MBT MUJNBT
EDBEBTEFMTJHMPXX.
4VMUJNPMJCSPGVFQVCMJDBEPFOFMBPZTFUJUVMThe
Politics of the Vail&OM
4DPUUFYUJFOEFFMBOMJTJTEFMPTQSPCMF-
NBTEFMHOFSP4JCJFONBOUJFOFB'SBODJBDPNPGPDPEFJOUFST
QSJODJQBM
EFKBEFMBEPTJOFNCBSHPMBTUFNUJDBTEFMTJHMP9*9
Z
FMWODVMPEFMBTNVKFSFTGSBODFTBTDPOMBQPMUJDBZTVTEFSFDIPT
-B UFNUJDB DFOUSBM EFM MJCSP
UBM DPNP TF JOFSF EF TV UUVMP
HJSB FO UPSOP B MBT NVKFSFT JTMNJDBT RVF IBCJUBO FO UFSSJUPSJP
FVSPQFP
QSJODJQBMNFOUF'SBODJB&TUVEJBMBTSFMBDJPOFTEFFTUBT
DPOFM&TUBEPZMBTMFZFT
MBTDVBMFTIBOCVTDBEPJOUFSWFOJSFOMB
DVMUVSB NVTVMNBOB EF VOB GPSNB NVDIP NT BHSFTJWB RVF FO
PUSPTQBTFTEF&VSPQB
"DUVBMNFOUF 4DPUU TF EFTFNQFB DPNP JOWFTUJHBEPSB Z EP-
DFOUFFOFM*OTUJUVUPEF&TUVEJPT"WBO[BEPTEF1SJODFUPO
&TUB-
EPT6OJEPT
Bibliografa
153
Historiografa postmoderna
*7
Manifiestos
155
Historiografa postmoderna
&
6FOGPSNBTMJUFSBSJBTOVFWBT
&TMPRVFFYQMJDBMBBENJSBDJOEF"OUPOJP(SBNTDJQPSFMGPS-
NBUP Z FM FTUJMP EF El Prncipe
EF /JDPMT .BRVJBWFMP 1BSB
JOWPDBSBMQSODJQFOVFWP
VOOVFWPGPSNBUP
VOOVFWPFTUJMP
VO
OVFWPSJUNP
TPOOFDFTBSJPT
&MNBOJFTUPOPFTTPCFSBOP
OPFTVOBEFDMBSBDJO/PQVF-
EF TFSMP /P EFCF 4V FTUBUVUP FT FM EF MB JOUFSSVQDJO
FM EFM
QBSUJEP &M PCKFUP EFM NBOJFTUP FT BRVFMMP RVF TF TVTUSBF BM
QSFTFOUF
QFSP RVF SFDMBNB BM NJTNP UJFNQP MB QPTJCJMJEBE EF
VOB FNFSHFODJB
MB JOUFSSVQDJO EF VO UJFNQP Z FM QBTP EF VO
QPSWFOJS&TQBDJPFORVFVOBQSDUJDBTFQSFHVSBFOVOUFYUP
FM NBOJFTUP FT VO BDUP QPMUJDP
VO FMFNFOUP EF USBOTGPSNB-
DJOQSDUJDBEFVOFTUBEPZUJFNQPQSFTFOUF&TUFFMFNFOUPEF
USBOTGPSNBDJOFTUEPNJOBEPQPSMBTJUVBDJORVFEFTDSJCF
TF
FODVFOUSB BTFEJBEP QPS MB VSHFODJB EF VO UJFNQP RVF TF WJWF
TJFNQSFEFTBKVTUBEP
FOUSOTJUP
BSSVJOBEP&MNBOJFTUPFTVO
JOUFOUPEFSFTQPOEFSBMBFYJHFODJBEFBTJSFTFUJFNQP
EFBQSF-
IFOEFSMP QCMJDBNFOUF QBSB USBOTGPSNBSMP
QBSB QSPEVDJS VO
OVFWPFTUBEPEFTJUVBDJO
"T
MBUFNQPSBMJEBEEFun es tiempo de decirWJFOFBDPJO-
DJEJSDPOMBUFNQPSBMJEBEEFun decir el tiempoEFMNBOJFTUP
#BKP MB NPEBMJEBE QFSGPSNBUJWB EF MB NBOJGFTUBDJO
FM NBOJ-
FTUPCVTDBBSNBSMBPTBEBZMBBVEBDJBEFVOQFOTBNJFOUP
JOUFOUBBQMFOBMV[
ZFOMBQMB[BQCMJDB
EBSMVHBSBVOBQBTJO
RVFSFDMBNBQBSBTOJDBNFOUFMBOPDPOUFNQPSBOFJEBEenMP
DPOUFNQPSOFP
4JOUPNUJDBNFOUF
MB QPTUNPEFSOJEBE TF IB DBSBDUFSJ[BEP
QPSTFSMBQPDBEFMPTNBOJFTUPT
`ZEFMPTNBOJFTUPTIJTUPSJP-
157
-VJT(%F.VTTZr.JHVFM7BMEFSSBNB
HSDPT&MUJFNQPFTUGVFSBEFRVJDJPZFTOFDFTBSJPSFDPNQP-
OFSMP/VFWBTFTDSJUVSBT
OVFWPTGPSNBUPT
OVFWPTtemposJOWP-
DBO
TJOEVEB
FTPTNBOJFTUPTEFMBIJTUPSJBQPSWFOJS
"RVDVBUSPNBOJFTUPTRVFSFDMBNBOVSHFOUFBUFODJO
158
Historiografa postmoderna
)1
Frank Ankersmit
.FOFTUFBSUDVMPFTMBTPCSFQSPEVDDJOBD-
UVBMFOOVFTUSBEJTDJQMJOB5PEPTDPOPDFNPTFMIFDIPEFRVFFO
UPEBSFBJNBHJOBCMFEFMBIJTUPSJPHSBGB
EFOUSPEFDVBMRVJFSFT-
QFDJBMJEBE
TFHFOFSBVOBDBOUJEBEBCSVNBEPSBEFMJCSPTZBSU-
DVMPTBMBP
MPRVFJNQPTJCJMJUBVOBSFWJTJOFYIBVTUJWB4VDFEF
FTUPJODMVTPFOMPTUFNBTTFQBSBEPTEFOUSPEFMBNJTNBFTQFDJB-
MJEBE*MVTUSBSFTUPDPOVOFKFNQMPEFMBUFPSBQPMUJDB
DBNQP
RVFDPOP[DPNVZCJFO2VJFORVJFSBRVF
IBDFVOPTWFJOUFBPT
EFTFBSBUSBCBKBSDPOMBMPTPGBQPMUJDBEF)PCCFTTPMPOFDFTJ-
UBCBEPTDPNFOUBSJPTJNQPSUBOUFTTPCSFMMPTFTUVEJPTRVFFT-
DSJCJFSPO8BULJOTZ8BSSFOEFS1PSTVQVFTUP
IBCBNTJODMVTP
FOUPODFT
QFSPUSBTMFFSFTUPTEPTMJCSPTZBTFUFOBVOBJEFBjQB-
OPSNJDBvCBTUBOUFBDFQUBCMF4JOFNCBSHP
RVJFORVJFSBRVF
FO
19942
UFOHBFMWBMPSEFUSBUBSEFEFDJSBMHPTJHOJDBUJWPBDFSDB
EF)PCCFT
UFOESRVFMFFSVOBQJMBEFWFJOUFPWFJOUJDJODPFY-
UFOTPTFTUVEJPTFTDSJUPTDPONVDIPDVJEBEPMFBIPSSBSBMMFDUPS
MBMJTUB.TBO
FTUPTFTUVEJPT
QPSMPHFOFSBM
TPOEFUBOCVFOB
DBMJEBERVFQPSDJFSUPVOPOPTFQVFEFEBSFMMVKPEFQFSESTFMPT
)BZEPTBTQFDUPTEFMSFTVMUBEPOPEFTFBEPEFFTUBTPCSFQSP-
EVDDJO&OQSJNFSMVHBS
FMBOMJTJTEF)PCCFTUJFOEFBBTVNJS
MBOBUVSBMF[BEFVOBOMJTJTEFMBinterpretacin NTRVFEFTV
PCSBen s-BPCSBNJTNB
FOBMHVOBTPDBTJPOFT
QBSFDFTFSQPDP
NTRVFMBSB[ODBTJPMWJEBEBEFMBHVFSSBEFJOUFSQSFUBDJPOFT
FODVSTP
FOMBBDUVBMJEBE&OTFHVOEPMVHBS
EFCJEPBTVFWJEFO-
1
'SBOL"OLFSTNJU
QVCMJDBEPPSJHJOBMNFOUFFOHistori and Theory, WPM
O
7FSTJOEF-VJT(EF.VTTZZ.JHVFM7BMEFSSBNB
2
'FDIBEFMBQVCMJDBDJOEFMBSUDVMPFOFMMJCSPEF"OLFSTNJU
History and
Tropology, #FSLFMFZ
6OJWFSTJUZPG$BMJGPSOJB1SFTT
</PUBEFFEJDJO>
159
-VJT(%F.VTTZr.JHVFM7BMEFSSBNB
UFQPMJGPOB
FMUFYUPPSJHJOBMEF)PCCFTQPDPBQPDPQFSEJTV
DBQBDJEBEEFGVOHJSDPNPSCJUSPFOFMEFCBUFIJTUSJDP%FCJEP
BUPEBTFTUBTJOUFSQSFUBDJPOFT
FMUFYUPen sTFUPSOBWBHP
VOB
BDVBSFMBFOMBRVFMBTMOFBTVZFOVOBEFOUSPEFPUSB&TUPTJH-
OJD RVF MB GF JOHFOVB FO RVF FM UFYUP NJTNP GVFSB DBQB[ EF
PGSFDFSVOBTPMVDJOBOVFTUSPTQSPCMFNBTEFJOUFSQSFUBDJOTF
UPSOBSUBOBCTVSEBDPNPMBGFFOVOMFUSFSPKVOUPBVOBWFMFUB
EFMDMJNB&MSFTVMUBEPQBSBEKJDPEFUPEPFTUPFTRVFFMUFYUP
FOTZBOPUJFOFBVUPSJEBEOJOHVOBFOVOBJOUFSQSFUBDJOZRVF
JODMVTP
TFOUJNPT HBOBT EF BEWFSUJS B OVFTUSPT FTUVEJBOUFT RVF
OPMFBOLeviatnEFGPSNBJOEFQFOEJFOUFFTUBSONFKPSTJUSBUBO
QSJNFSPEFUSB[BSVOBSVUBBUSBWTEFMBKVOHMBEFJOUFSQSFUB-
DJPOFT&OSFTVNFO
ZBOPUFOFNPTUFYUPT
OJQBTBEP
TJOPTPMP
JOUFSQSFUBDJPOFTEFFMMPT
$VBOEPMFPMBTSFTFBTZBWJTPTEFMBTOPWFEBEFTFEJUPSJBMFT
FOFMTimes Literary Supplement
FMNew York Review of Books
PFOQVCMJDBDJPOFTQSPGFTJPOBMFTRVFEFNBOFSBBMBSNBOUFQSP-
MJGFSBODBEBWF[NT
OPEVEPRVFMBTDPTBTTPONVZQBSFDJEBT
FOPUSBTSFBTEFMFTDSJUPIJTUSJDP1BSFDFRVFMBTJUVBDJORVF
/JFU[TDIFUFNB
IBDFNTEFDJFOBPT
MBTJUVBDJOFORVFMB
IJTUPSJPHSBGBNJTNBFOUPSQFDFSBOVFTUSBWJTJOEFMQBTBEP
TF
IJ[PSFBMJEBE/PTPMPFTUFDBVEBMEFMJUFSBUVSBIJTUSJDBOPTEB
VO JOUFOTP TFOUJNJFOUP EFTDPSB[POBEPS
TJOP RVF FT JOOFHBCMF
RVF IBZ BMHP JODJWJMJ[BEP FO FTUB TPCSFQSPEVDDJO"TPDJBNPT
MBDJWJMJ[BDJO
FOUSFPUSBTDPTBT
DPOVOTFOUJEPEFNPEFSBDJO
EFVOBGFMJ[NFEJBOBFOUSFFMFYDFTPZMBFTDBTF[4JOFNCBSHP
UPEPTFOUJEPEFMBNPEFSBDJOQBSFDFQFSEJEPFOOVFTUSPBDUVBM
BMDPIPMJTNPJOUFMFDUVBM&TUBDPNQBSBDJODPOFMBMDPIPMJTNPFT
UBNCJONVZBEFDVBEB
QPSRVFFMMJCSPPBSUDVMPNTSFDJFOUF
TPCSF VO UFNB QBSUJDVMBS TJFNQSF QSFUFOEF TFS FM MUJNP USBHP
JOUFMFDUVBM
1PSTVQVFTUP
FTUBTJUVBDJOOPFTOVFWBZ
QPSUBOUP
OPIBO
GBMUBEPMPTJOUFOUPTEFSFUFOFSBMHVOPTQSPTQFDUPTUSBORVJMJ[BEP-
SFTQBSBFMGVUVSPEFMPTEFTDPSB[POBEPTIJTUPSJBEPSFT&MIJTUP-
SJBEPS IPMBOET 3PNFJO WJP FO FTUB TPCSFQSPEVDDJO VOB UFO-
EFODJBIBDJBMBFTQFDJBMJ[BDJOQPSUBOUP
EFNBOEVOBIJTUPSJB
UFSJDBRVFBOVMBSBMBQVMWFSJ[BDJOEFOVFTUSBDPNQSFOTJOEFM
QBTBEPRVFMBFTQFDJBMJ[BDJODBVT-BIJTUPSJBUFSJDBTFSBDB-
160
Historiografa postmoderna
QB[EFMMFWBSOPTBVOQVOUPEFWJTUBNTFMFWBEPEFTEFFMDVBM
EFOVFWPQPESBNPTDPOUFNQMBSZPSEFOBSFMDBPTRVFDBVTBSPO
MBFTQFDJBMJ[BDJOZMBTPCSFQSPEVDDJO31FSPFMMJCSPEF3PNFJO
TPCSFFMNPNFOUPEFDJTJWPEFEPTFSBTFTMBQSVFCBEFRVFFTUB
jIJTUPSJBUFSJDBvOPGVFMBSVUBTFHVSBIBDJBMBJOUFHSBDJOEF
MPT SFTVMUBEPT EF MB JOWFTUJHBDJO FTQFDJBMJ[BEB RVF QFOT RVF
TFSB 4PCSF UPEP
QBSFDF RVF FM QSPCMFNB FT RVF FO FTUF OJWFM
UFSJDPNTFMFWBEPRVFQPTUVM3PNFJOBOFTEJGDJMFGFDUVBS
VOBJOUFSBDDJOSFBMFOUSFMBTEJWFSTBTFTQFDJBMJEBEFT&MFTDSJUP
IJTUSJDPJOUFHSBMJTUBHFOFSBVOBFOVNFSBDJONTRVFVOBJO-
UFHSBDJO
0USB TBMJEB BM EJMFNB FT MB FTUSBUFHJB RVF BEPQUBSPO MPT
IJTUPSJBEPSFT EF MB FTDVFMB EF MPT Annales. &TUPT EFEJDBSPO TV
BUFODJOTPCSFUPEPBMEFTDVCSJNJFOUPEFOVFWPTPCKFUPTEFFT-
UVEJPFOFMQBTBEPDPOFTUBFTUSBUFHJBEFIFDIPTFQFSNJUJFSPO
DBNCJBSVOBWF[NTFMSVNCPEFMBIJTUPSJBIBDJBVOUFSSJUPSJP
OVFWP
TJOFYQMPSBS1PSTVQVFTUP
FTUPPGSFDFVODPOTVFMPTPMP
QBTBKFSPBOUFTEFRVFQBTFNVDIPUJFNQP
JODPOUBCMFTIJTUPSJB-
EPSFT
GSBODFTFTPOP
TFBCBMBO[BSOTPCSFFTUPTOVFWPTUFNBT
ZQSPOUPMPTDVCSJSOUBNCJODPOVOBHSVFTBZPQBDBDBQBEF
JOUFSQSFUBDJPOFT2VFEB
TJOFNCBSHP
NTQPSEFDJSBDFSDBEF
DVOUJMFTMBFTDVFMBEFMPTAnnalesQBSBFODPOUSBSUFNBTOVF-
WPTZFNPDJPOBOUFT&OFMDVSTPEFFTUFDBQUVMPSFHSFTBSBFTUF
BTVOUP
-B QSFHVOUB DSVDJBM BIPSB FT RV BDUJUVE EFCFNPT UPNBS
SFTQFDUPEFFTUBTPCSFQSPEVDDJOEFMJUFSBUVSBIJTUSJDBRVFTF
EJTFNJOBDPNPVODODFSFOUPEBTMBTSFBT6OBOPTUBMHJBSFBD-
DJPOBSJBEFMQVMDSPNVOEPIJTUSJDPEFIBDFDJODVFOUBBPTFT
VOBSFTJHOBDJOTJOTFOUJEPZEFTFTQFSBO[BEB%FCFNPTEBSOPT
DVFOUBEFRVFOPIBZGPSNBEFWPMWFSBUST4FDBMDVMBRVFFO
FTUFNPNFOUPIBZNTIJTUPSJBEPSFTRVFFGFDUBOJOWFTUJHBDJP-
OFTIJTUSJDBTRVFMBDBOUJEBEUPUBMEFIJTUPSJBEPSFTEFTEF)F-
SEPUP IBTUB MB EDBEB EF 4PCSB EFDJS RVF FT JNQPTJCMF
QSPIJCJSMBQSPEVDDJOEFMPTMJCSPTZBSUDVMPTOVFWPTRVFFTUO
FTDSJCJFOEP UPEPT FTUPT FSVEJUPT 2VFKBSOPT QPS MB QSEJEB EF
VOWODVMPEJSFDUPDPOFMQBTBEPOPOPTMMFWBBOJOHOMBEP4JO
3
+3PNFJOj)FUWFSHSVJTEFCFFMEvZj5IFPSFUJTDIFHFTDIJFEFOJTv
FO.$
#SBOET DPPSE
Historische lijnen en patronen
NTUFSEBN
161
-VJT(%F.VTTZr.JHVFM7BMEFSSBNB
FNCBSHP
MP RVF T BZVEB Z UJFOF TFOUJEP FT EFOJS VO WODVMP
OVFWPZEJTUJOUPDPOFMQBTBEPDPOCBTFFOVOSFDPOPDJNJFOUP
DPNQMFUPZIPOFTUPEFMBQPTJDJOFOMBRVFBIPSBOPTWFNPTB
OPTPUSPTNJTNPTDPNPIJTUPSJBEPSFT
.TBO
IBZPUSBSB[OQBSBJOUFOUBSBWBO[BSFOFTBEJSFD-
DJO-BTPCSFQSPEVDDJOBDUVBMEFMJUFSBUVSBIJTUSJDBEFIFDIP
QVFEFEFOPNJOBSTFNPOTUSVPTBTJOVFTUSPQVOUPEFQBSUJEBTPO
MBT JEFBT tradicionales BDFSDB EF MB UBSFB Z FM TJHOJDBEP EF MB
IJTUPSJPHSBGB &M FTDSJUP IJTUSJDP IPZ SPNQJ TV TBDP UFSJDP
USBEJDJPOBM Z BVUPMFHJUJNJ[BEPS Z
QPS UBOUP
OFDFTJUB VO USBKF
OVFWP&TUPOPUJFOFFMQSPQTJUPEFFOTFBSBMIJTUPSJBEPSDNP
EFCFIBDFSTVUSBCBKP
OJFMEFEFTBSSPMMBSVOBUFPSBOJFU[TDIFB-
OBBDFSDBEFMPTVTPTZEFTWFOUBKBTEFMBIJTUPSJBQBSBMBWJEB
3FTQFDUPEFMPTVTPTEFMBIJTUPSJB
OPIBZMVHBSGVFSBEFMFTDSJUP
IJTUSJDPNJTNPEFTEFFMDVBMTFFYUSBJHBOMBTSFHMBTEFMNUPEP
EFMUSBCBKPEFMIJTUPSJBEPSTJBMHPFTTJHOJDBUJWPBKVJDJPEFMPT
IJTUPSJBEPSFT
FOUPODFTTFSTJHOJDBUJWP
ZFTPFTUPEP:SFTQFD-
UPEFMBTEFTWFOUBKBT
OPDSFPRVFFMFTDSJUPIJTUSJDPTFBUJMOJ
RVFUFOHBVOBEFTWFOUBKBWJTJCMF$POFTUPOPRVJFSPEFDJSRVFFM
FTDSJUPIJTUSJDPTFBJOUJM
TJOPRVFMBDVFTUJODPODFSOJFOUFBMB
VUJMJEBEZMBTEFTWFOUBKBTEFMBIJTUPSJPHSBGBOPFTPQPSUVOBFT
VOBcategora errnea
TFHOMBFYQSFTJOEF3ZMF+VOUPDPOMB
QPFTB
MBMJUFSBUVSB
MBQJOUVSBZEFNTMBTBSUFT
MBIJTUPSJBZMB
DPODJFODJBIJTUSJDBQFSUFOFDFOBMBDVMUVSB
ZOPQVFEFOQMBO-
UFBSTFQSFHVOUBTTJHOJDBUJWBTBDFSDBEFMBVUJMJEBEEFMBDVMUVSB
-BDVMUVSB
EFMBDVBMGPSNBQBSUFFMFTDSJUPIJTUSJDP
FTNTCJFO
FM GPOEP desde el cual o respecto del cual QPEFNPT GPSNBSOPT
VOBPQJOJOBDFSDBEFMBVUJMJEBE
QPSFKFNQMP
EFDJFSUBTDMBTFT
EF JOWFTUJHBDJO DJFOUDB P DJFSUPT PCKFUJWPT QPMUJDPT 1PS FTB
SB[O
MBDJFODJBZMBQPMUJDBOPQFSUFOFDFOBMBDVMUVSBTJBMHP
UJFOF BMHVOB VUJMJEBE P EFTWFOUBKB
P OPT QFSNJUF NBOJQVMBS FM
NVOEP
OPGPSNBQBSUFEFMBDJWJMJ[BDJO-BDVMUVSBZMBIJTUPSJB
EFOFOMBVUJMJEBE
QFSPKVTUBNFOUFBDBVTBEFFTUPOPQVFEFO
EFOJSTF FO USNJOPT EF VUJMJEBE 1FSUFOFDFO BM EPNJOJP EF MBT
suposiciones absolutas4
FOUFSNJOPMPHBEF3($PMMJOHXPPE
&TUBFTUBNCJOMBSB[OQPSMBRVFMBQPMUJDBOPEFCFJOUFSGFSJS
DPOMBDVMUVSB
4
3($PMMJOHXPPE
An Essay on Metaphysics
0YGPSE
$FMFEPO1SFTT
162
Historiografa postmoderna
1PSFTUP
TJRVJTJSBNPTCVTDBSVOBOVFWBWFTUJEVSBQBSBFM
FTDSJUPIJTUSJDPDPOUFNQPSOFP
DPNPMOFBTBUSTTFDPOTJEFS
OFDFTBSJP
FMQSPCMFNBNTJNQPSUBOUFTFSBTJUVBSMPEFOUSPEF
MBDJWJMJ[BDJOBDUVBMFOTVDPOKVOUP&TUFQSPCMFNBFTEFOBUV-
SBMF[B DVMUVSBMIJTUSJDB P JOUFSQSFUBUJWB
Z FT DPNQBSBCMF DPO
MBDMBTFEFQSPCMFNBRVFFOPDBTJPOFTOPTQMBOUFBNPTDVBOEP
DPOTJEFSBNPTFMMVHBSZTJHOJDBEPEFVOTVDFTPQBSUJDVMBSEFO-
USP EF MB UPUBMJEBE EF MB IJTUPSJB EF OVFTUSB WJEB &O HFOFSBM
FTFYUSBPRVFMPTIJTUPSJBEPSFTZMTPGPTEFMBIJTUPSJBIBZBO
QSFTUBEPUBOQPDBBUFODJOEVSBOUFMPTDVBSFOUBBPTSFDJFOUFT
BMPTQBSBMFMJTNPTFOUSFFMEFTBSSPMMPEFMFTDSJUPIJTUSJDPBDUVBM
QPSVOBQBSUF
ZFMEFMBMJUFSBUVSB
MBDSUJDBMJUFSBSJBZMBTQVCMJ-
DBDJPOFTmFOSFTVNFO
MBDJWJMJ[BDJOm
QPSPUSB&OBQBSJFODJB
FM
IJTUPSJBEPSOPWJPOJOHVOBSB[OQBSBTPTQFDIBSMBFYJTUFODJBEF
UBMFTQBSBMFMJTNPTNTRVFFMRVNJDPPFMBTUSOPNP
/PQSFUFOEPBRVEFUFSNJOBSFMMVHBSEFMFTDSJUPIJTUSJDPEF
FTUBGPSNB&OWF[EFFTP
JSNTBMMQBSBBWFSJHVBSTJMBQSP-
EVDDJOEFFTDSJUPTIJTUSJDPTUJFOFTVDPOUSBQBSUFFOVOBQPS-
DJODPOTJEFSBCMFEFMBDJWJMJ[BDJOZTPDJFEBEBDUVBMFTy2VJO
OP DPOPDF FM DMJDI EF RVF WJWJNPT FO VOB FSB DPO FYDFEFOUFT
EFJOGPSNBDJO &OFMUSBOTDVSTPEFUPEBFTUBUFPSJ[BDJOTPCSF
JOGPSNBDJOmRVFFTNTQSPGVOEBFOBMHVOBTPDBTJPOFTRVFFO
PUSBTmTFEFTUBDBOEPTDPTBTJNQPSUBOUFTQBSBFMSFTUPEFMBFY-
QPTJDJO&OQSJNFSMVHBS
FTFYUSBPRVF
BNFOVEP
TFIBCMFEF
MBJOGPSNBDJODPNPTJTFUSBUBSBEFBMHPDBTJGTJDP-BJOGPSNB-
DJO jVZFv
jTF NVFWFv
jTF EJWVMHBv
jTF JOUFSDBNCJBv
jTF
BMNBDFOBvPjTFPSHBOJ[Bv-ZPUBSEIBCMBEFM&TUBEPDPNPVO
PSHBOJTNPRVFMJNJUBZEJTQFSTBMPTVKPTEFJOGPSNBDJO5-B
JOGPSNBDJOSFTVMUBVOBFTQFDJFEFMRVJEPEFFTDBTBWJTDPTJEBE
OPTSPEFBZFTUBNPTFOQFMJHSPJONJOFOUFEFRVFOPTBIPHVF&O
TFHVOEPMVHBS
BMIBCMBSEFMBJOGPSNBDJO
FTUBBTVNJDPNPUBM
VOMVHBSQSPNJOFOUFZOPUPSJPSFTQFDUPEFMUFNBSFBMEFEJDIB
JOGPSNBDJO1PSMPHFOFSBM
FTUBSFMBDJOUFOBVOTFOUJEPJOWFS-
TP7FBNPTVOBEFDMBSBDJORVFJOGPSNBBMHPDPNPMPTJHVJFOUF
j&O3POBME3FBHBOGVFFMFHJEPQSFTJEFOUFEFMPT&TUBEPT
6OJEPTv&TUBEFDMBSBDJOJOGPSNBUJWBEFJONFEJBUPSFNJUFBMB
TJUVBDJORVFEFTDSJCF4JOFNCBSHP
FOOVFTUSBGPSNBBDUVBMEF
5
+'-ZPUBSE
La condition postmoderne
1BSJT
.JOVJU
Q
163
-VJT(%F.VTTZr.JHVFM7BMEFSSBNB
IBCMBSBDFSDBEFMBJOGPSNBDJOUJFOEFBRVFEBSSFMFHBEBFOFM
USBTGPOEP-BSFBMJEBEFTMBJOGPSNBDJONJTNB
ZBOPMBSFBMJ-
EBEEFUSTEFFTBJOGPSNBDJO&TUPEBBMBJOGPSNBDJOVOBBV-
UPOPNBQSPQJB6OBTVTUBODJBMJEBEQSPQJB"TDPNPIBZMFZFT
RVFEFTDSJCFOMBDPOEVDUBEFMBDPTBTFOMBSFBMJEBE
QBSFDFSB
QPTJCMFUBNCJORVFFYJTUJFSBVOTJTUFNBDJFOUDPQBSBEFTDSJCJS
MB DPOEVDUB EF FTF FYUSBPSEJOBSJP MRVJEP RVF MMBNBNPT JOGPS-
NBDJO1PSDJFSUP
BRVNFHVTUBSBBBEJSRVF
EFTEFMBQFST-
QFDUJWBEFMBUFPSBEFMBDUPEFIBCMBEF"VTUJO
UBNCJOQPESB
EFDJSTFRVFMBJOGPSNBDJOFTQVSBNFOUFQFSGPSNBUJWBPOPFTFO
BCTPMVUPQFSGPSNBUJWB&TUFFTDPODFSUF[BVOPEFMPTBTQFDUPT
GBTDJOBOUFTEFMGFONFOPEFMBJOGPSNBDJO6.
&OBPTSFDJFOUFT
NVDIBHFOUFPCTFSWFMDBNCJPEFBDUJUVE
IBDJB FM GFONFOP EF MB JOGPSNBDJO 4F FMBCPSBSPO UFPSBT BM
SFTQFDUPZMPTUFSJDPTJOWPMVDSBEPT
DPNPQPSMPHFOFSBMTVDF-
EF
FMJHJFSPOVOOPNCSFQBSBTVBDUJWJEBE&OFTUFDPOUFYUP
B
NFOVEP IBCMBNPT EF QPTUNPEFSOPT P QPTUFTUSVDUVSBMJTUBT
FO
DPOUSBTUF
EFGPSNBDPNQSFOTJCMF
DPOMPTNPEFSOPTPMPTFTUSVD-
UVSBMJTUBTEFMQBTBEPSFDJFOUF&OTFEFEJDVOBJOUFSFTBOUF
DPOGFSFODJBFO6USFDIUBMQPTUNPEFSOJTNP
ZUPEPTMPTQSFTFOUFT
FOMBTQPOFODJBTFTUBSOEFBDVFSEPFORVFOPFTTFODJMMPEFOJS
MPT DPODFQUPT postmodernismo P postestructuralismo EF NPEP
TBUJTGBDUPSJP7/PPCTUBOUF
FTQPTJCMFEJTDFSOJSVOBMOFBHFOF-
SBM
DPNPIJ[P+POBUIBO$VMMFS8-BDJFODJBGVFFMBMGBZPNFHBEF
MPTNPEFSOPTZFTUSVDUVSBMJTUBTWJFSPOMBDJFODJBOPTPMPDPNP
MPNTJNQPSUBOUFRVFEJPMBNPEFSOJEBE
TJOPBMNJTNPUJFNQP
DPNPMPNYJNPRVFEJP-BSBDJPOBMJEBEDJFOUDB
DPNPUBM
OPQMBOUFBOJOHOQSPCMFNBQBSBMPTQPTUNPEFSOPTZMPTQPTUFT-
USVDUVSBMJTUBTMBWFO
QPSBTEFDJSMP
EFTEFGVFSBPEFTEFBSSJCB
/P DSJUJDBO B MB DJFODJB OJ MB SFDIB[BO OP TPO JSSBDJPOBMJTUBT
6
-BJOGPSNBDJOFTQFSGPSNBUJWB
UJFOFVOBGVFS[BQVSBNFOUFilocucionaria
y perlocucionaria
EFCJEPBRVFTFQFSEJFMFMFNFOUPDPOTUBUBUJWPMBJOGPS-
NBDJOOPFTQSFGPSNBUJWBQPSRVFFTUTVKFUBBTVTQSPQJBTMFZFTZOPBMBT
EFMBDPNVOJDBDJOIVNBOBMBJOUFSDPNVOJDBDJOFTTMPVOBQBSUFEFMB
WJEBEFMBJOGPSNBDJO
7
8WBO3FJKFO
j1PTUTDSJQUVNv
QQ
Z8)VETPO
j5IF2VFTUJPOPG
1PTUNPEFSO1IJMPTPQIZ v
QQ
FO8)VETPOZ8WBO3FJKFO DP-
PSET
Modernen versus postmodernen
6USFDIU
8
+ $VMMFS
On Deconstruction: Theory and Criticism alter Structuralism
-POESFT
3PVEMUMF
QQZTT
164
Historiografa postmoderna
QFSP NVFTUSBO MB NJTNB GSJBMEBE SFTQFDUP EF MB DJFODJB RVF MB
RVFPCTFSWBNPTMOFBTBSSJCBFOOVFTUSBBDUJUVEQSFTFOUFIBDJBMB
JOGPSNBDJO&TUBOPFTVOBDVFTUJOEFNFUBDSUJDBEFMBJOWFT-
UJHBDJODJFOUDBPEFMPTNUPEPTDJFOUDPT
DPNPTFBDPTUVN-
CSBFOMBMPTPGBEFMBDJFODJB-BMPTPGBEFMBDJFODJBBOFTU
QSFTFOUFFOFMDJFOUJDJTNPEFMPTNPEFSOJTUBTMPTMTPGPTEFMB
DJFODJBTJHVFOMBMOFBEFQFOTBNJFOUPEFMPTDJFOUDPTZFTUV-
EJBOFMDBNJOPRVFSFDPSSJFSPOFOUSFFMEFTDVCSJNJFOUPEFEBUPT
FNQSJDPTZMBUFPSB1BSBMPTQPTUNPEFSOPT
UBOUPMBMPTPGB
EFMBDJFODJBDPNPMBDJFODJBNJTNBTPOFMQVOUPEFQBSUJEBEF
TVTSFFYJPOFT:MPTQPTUNPEFSOPTTFJOUFSFTBOUBOQPDPFOMB
DVFTUJOTPDJPMHJDBEFMBGPSNBFORVFSFBDDJPOBOMPTJOWFTUJHB-
EPSFTDJFOUDPTFOUSFT
DPNPMPIBDFOFOMBSFMBDJORVFFYJTUF
FOUSFDJFODJBZTPDJFEBE-BBUFODJOEFMPTOPTFDPODFOUSBFOMB
JOWFTUJHBDJODJFOUDBOJFOMBNBOFSBFORVFMBTPDJFEBEBDFQUB
MPT SFTVMUBEPT EF MB JOWFTUJHBDJO DJFOUDB
TJOP TMPTPMP FOFM
GVODJPOBNJFOUPEFMBDJFODJBZEFMBJOGPSNBDJODJFOUDBFOT
1BSBFMQPTUNPEFSOJTNP
MBDJFODJBZMBJOGPSNBDJOTPOPC-
KFUPT EF FTUVEJP JOEFQFOEJFOUFT RVF TF SJHFO QPS MFZFT QSPQJBT
-BQSJNFSBMFZGVOEBNFOUBMEFMBUFPSBQPTUNPEFSOBEFMBJO-
GPSNBDJOFTMBEFRVFMBJOGPSNBDJOTFNVMUJQMJDB6OBEFMBT
DBSBDUFSTUJDBTQSJODJQBMFTEFMBJOGPSNBDJOFTRVFMBJOGPSNB-
DJO FO SFBMJEBE JNQPSUBOUF OVODB FT FM O EF VOB HFOFBMPHB
EFMBJOGPSNBDJO
TJOPRVFTVJNQPSUBODJBEFIFDIPTFFWBMB
TFHOMBQPTUFSJPSJEBEJOUFMFDUVBMRVFPSJHJOB&MFTDSJUPIJTUSJ-
DPFOTFTVOBJMVTUSBDJOFYDFMFOUFEFFTUP-BTHSBOEFTPCSBT
EFMBIJTUPSJBEFMBIJTUPSJPHSBGB
BRVFMMBTEF5PDRVFWJMMF
.BSY
#VSDLIBSEU
8FCFS
)VJ[JOHBP#SBVEFMEFNPTUSBSPOEFGPSNB
SFQFUJEB TFS FM FTUJNVMBOUF NT QPEFSPTP EF VOB OVFWB PMB EF
QVCMJDBDJPOFT
FOMVHBSEFDPODMVJSVOBHFOFBMPHBEFJOGPSNB-
DJODPNPTJVOQSPCMFNBQBSUJDVMBSUVWJFSBRVFDPODMVJSTFEF
VOB WF[ QPS UPEBT j1BSBEKJDBNFOUF
NJFOUSBT NT QPEFSPTB
Z BVUPSJ[BEB FT VOB JOUFSQSFUBDJO
NT UFYUPT HFOFSBv9 &O MB
WJTJONPEFSOB
MBNBOFSBFORVFQSFDJTBNFOUFMBJOGPSNBDJO
JOUFSFTBOUFHFOFSBNTJOGPSNBDJOFT
QPSTVQVFTUP
JOBCBSDB-
CMF1BSBMPTNPEFSOPT
MBJOGPSNBDJOTVTUBODJBMFTMBRVFQPOF
OBMFTDSJUPOPQVFEFOFYQMJDBSQPSRVKVTUBNFOUFMPRVFFT
9
Ibid.
Q
165
-VJT(%F.VTTZr.JHVFM7BMEFSSBNB
EFCBUJCMFFTGVOEBNFOUBMQBSBFMQSPHSFTPEFMBDJFODJB
QPSRV
DPNPFTDSJCJ(BTUPO#BDIFMBSE
MPTIFDIPTdebatiblesTPOMPT
IFDIPT verdaderos.
&TJNQPSUBOUF
EFOUSPEFMNBSDPEFFTUFBSUDVMP
WFSDPONT
EFUBMMFFTUFQPTUNPEFSOJTNP
RVFFTBDJFOUDPNTRVFBOUJDJFO-
UDP1SJNFSP
OPTFOTFBMPRVFEFCFNPTFOUFOEFSQPSFTDSJUP
IJTUSJDP QPTUNPEFSOP Z
TFHVOEP
RVF FM FTDSJUP IJTUSJDP
EF
GPSNBTPSQSFOEFOUF
TJFNQSFIBUFOJEPBMHPEFQPTUNPEFSOP6O
CVFOFKFNQMPEFDSJUFSJPQPTUNPEFSOPEFMBDJFODJBFTMBrecons-
truccinmQBSBFNQMFBSFMUSNJOPOPBEFDVBEPmEFMBDBVTBMJEBE
EF/JFU[TDIF
BMRVFNVDIPTDPOTJEFSBOVOPEFMPTQJMBSFTNT
JNQPSUBOUFTEFMQFOTBNJFOUPDJFOUDP$POUFSNJOPMPHBDBVTB-
MTUJDB
MBDBVTBFTFMPSJHFO
ZFMFGFDUPMPTFDVOEBSJP
/JFU[TDIF
TFBMBRVFTMPDPOCBTFFOOVFTUSBPCTFSWBDJOEFMFGFDUPFTUB-
NPTFOQPTJCJMJEBEEFWFSMBTDBVTBTZRVF
QPSUBOUP
FMFGFDUP
es de hechoMPQSJNBSJPZMBDBVTBMPTFDVOEBSJPj4JFMFGFDUPFT
FMDBVTBOUFEFRVFMBDBVTBTFDPOWJFSUBFOMBDBVTB
FOUPODFTFM
FGFDUP
ZOPMBDBVTB
EFCFDPOTJEFSBSTFFMPSJHFOv102VJFORVJFSB
RVF GPSNVMF MB PCKFDJO EF RVF /JFU[TDIF DPOGVOEJ FM PSEFO
EFMBTDPTBTFOMBJOWFTUJHBDJOZMBSFBMJEBE
QJFSEFEFWJTUBFM
QVOUPEFNJSBEFMQFOTBNJFOUPEF/JFU[TDIFFTEFDJS
FMQVOUP
FTKVTUBNFOUFMBBSUJDJBMJEBEEFMBKFSBSRVBUSBEJDJPOBMEFDBV-
TBZFGFDUP/VFTUSBDBQBDJUBDJODJFOUDBOPTjFTUBCJMJ[v
QPS
EFDJSMP BT
QBSB TVTDSJCJS FTUB KFSBSRVB USBEJDJPOBM
QFSP NT
BMMEFFTUBDBQBDJUBDJOJOUFMFDUVBMOPIBZOBEBRVFOPTPCMJHVF
BIBDFSMP-PNJTNP
TJCJFOOP ms
QVFEFEFDJSTFBGBWPSEF
SFWFSUJSFTUBKFSBSRVB
TUB FT MB NBOFSB FO RVF TJFNQSF TPO MBT DPTBT FO FM QPTU-
NPEFSOJTNP 4F jEFTFTUBCJMJ[Bv MB DJFODJB
TF MF DPMPDB GVFSB EF
TV QSPQJP DFOUSP TF EFTUBDB MB SFWFSTJCJMJEBE EF MPT QBUSPOFT Z
DBUFHPSBT EF QFOTBNJFOUP
TJO TVHFSJS OJOHVOB PQDJO EFOJEB
&TVOBTVFSUFEFDSUJDBEFTMFBMEFMBDJFODJB
VOHPMQFCBKPRVJ[
JOKVTUP
QFSP RVF QPS FTB NJTNB SB[O MF EB B MB DJFODJB EPOEF
NT EVFMF -B SBDJPOBMJEBE DJFOUDB OP FT MB aufgehoben IFHF-
MJBOBSFTQFDUPEFPUSBDPTB
OJFTWFSEBEEFDJSRVFDBEBPQJOJO
BVUPNUJDBNFOUFFWPDBBTVBOUUFTJTTFUSBUBNTCJFOEFMSFDP-
OPDJNJFOUPEFRVFDBEBPQJOJOUJFOF
KVOUPBTVJOUFSJPSBQSPCB-
10
*bid.,Q
166
Historiografa postmoderna
EPEFNBOFSBDJFOUDB
VOFYUFSJPSRVFMBDJFODJBOPBEWJFSUF&O
su Tractatus
8JUUHFOTUFJOZBTVHFSBBMHPQBSFDJEPSFTQFDUPEF
DBEBMOFBWMJEBEFSB[POBNJFOUP&TEFIFDIPMBMOFBWMJEBEF
SB[POBNJFOUPMBRVFQSFUFOEFTFSTVQFSVB
MPRVF
QPSUBOUP
FT
TJFNQSFVOBUSBWFTBQPSFMUFSSJUPSJPEFMPOPWFSEBEFSPFTEFDJS
MBUSBWFTBEFTEFMBJEFBGBMTBJOJDJBMBMBDPSSFDUB&ODPOTFDVFODJB
MPRVFFTWFSEBEFSPTJFNQSFDPOTFSWBMBNBODIBEFMPRVFOPMPFT
1VFEFBHSFHBSTFVOBDPODMVTJOUBOUPMHJDBDPNPPOUPMHJ-
DBBFTUBUFTJTKVOUBTEBOVOBJEFBEFMBOBUVSBMF[BSFWPMVDJPOB-
SJBEFMQPTUNPEFSOJTNP7FBNPTQSJNFSPMBMHJDB1BSBFMQPTU-
NPEFSOP
MBTDFSUF[BTDJFOUDBTTPCSFMBTDVBMFTMPTNPEFSOPT
DPOTUSVZFSPOTJFNQSFTPOWBSJBOUFTEFMBQBSBEPKBEFMFNCVTUF-
SPFTEFDJS
MBQBSBEPKBEFMDSFUFOTFRVFBSNBRVFUPEPTMPTDSF-
UFOTFTNJFOUFOP
FOGPSNBCSFWF
MBQBSBEPKBEFMBEFDMBSBDJO
jFTUBEFDMBSBDJOOPFTWFSEBEFSBv
FOMBRVFFTUBEFDMBSBDJOFT
VOBEFDMBSBDJOBDFSDBEFTNJTNB1PSTVQVFTUP
UPEPFMESBNB
EFMQPTUNPEFSOJTNPFTUFOMBJEFBEFRVFFTUBTQBSBEPKBTEFCFO
DPOTJEFSBSTF JSSFTPMVCMFT : BRV EFCFNPT UFOFS FO NFOUF RVF
MB TPMVDJO EF MB QBSBEPKB EFM FNCVTUFSP mRVF 3VTTFMM
DPO TV
UFPSBEFMPTUJQPT
ZTVEJTUJODJOFOUSFQSFEJDBEPTZQSFEJDBEPT
EF QSFEJDBEPT
QSPQVTP FO Los principios de matemticasm UP-
EBWBIPZTFSFDPOPDFDPNPVOBEFMBTCBTFTNTJNQPSUBOUFT
EFMBMHJDBDPOUFNQPSOFB111PSUBOUP
MBQSFUFOTJOQPTUNP-
EFSOJTUBFTUJSBSMBBMGPNCSBEFEFCBKPEFMPTQJFTEFMBDJFODJBZ
EFMNPEFSOJTNP5BNCJOBRVMBNFKPSJMVTUSBDJOEFMBUFTJT
QPTUNPEFSOBFOSFBMJEBETFFODVFOUSBFOFMFTDSJUPIJTUSJDP-BT
JOUFSQSFUBDJPOFTIJTUSJDBTEFMQBTBEPTFIBDFOSFDPOPDJCMFTQPS
WF[QSJNFSBmBERVJFSFOTVJEFOUJEBEQPSQSJNFSBWF[mNFEJBOUF
FMDPOUSBTUFDPOotrasJOUFSQSFUBDJPOFTTPOMPRVFTPOTMPDPO
CBTFFOMPRVFnoTPO5PEBQFSTPOBRVFDPOP[DBTMPVOBJO-
UFSQSFUBDJOEF
QPSFKFNQMP
MBHVFSSBGSBOPDPOPDFOJOHVOB
JOUFSQSFUBDJOFOBCTPMVUPEFFTFGFONFOP1PSUBOUP
UPEBIJT-
UPSJBUJFOFEFGPSNBJOUSOTFDBVOBOBUVSBMF[BQBSBEKJDB124JO
EVEB)BZEFO8IJUF
FOTVMetahistoriamFMMJCSPEFMPTPGBEF
11
+WBO)FJKFOPPSU
j-PHJDBM1BSBEPYFTv
FO1&EXBSET FE
The Enciclope-
dia of Philosophy
WPM
-POEPO
QQ
12
' 3 "OLFSTNJU
Narrative Logic: A Semantic Anlisis of the Historians
Language
-B)BZB
QQ
167
-VJT(%F.VTTZr.JHVFM7BMEFSSBNB
MBIJTUPSJBNTSFWPMVDJPOBSJPEFMPTWFJOUJDJODPBPTSFDJFOUFTm
QFOTBCBEFFTUBGPSNBDVBOEPDBSBDUFSJ[UPEPFTDSJUPIJTUSJDP
DPNPGVOEBNFOUBMNFOUFIJTUSJDP13.
7FBNPT BIPSB MB POUPMPHB &O TV SFDPOTUSVDDJO EF MB KF-
SBSRVBUSBEJDJPOBMEFDBVTBZFGFDUPT
/JFU[TDIFPQPOBOVFTUSB
NBOFSBEFIBCMBSEFMBSFBMJEBEDPOUSBMPTQSPDFTPTEFMBSFBMJ-
EBENJTNB-BEJTUJODJOBDUVBMFOUSFMFOHVBKFZSFBMJEBEQJFSEF
BT TV raison detre. &O QBSUJDVMBS
FM MFOHVBKF DJFOUDP ZB OP
FT VO jFTQFKP EF MB OBUVSBMF[Bv
TJOP VOB QBSUF EFM JOWFOUBSJP
EFMBSFBMJEBEEFMBNJTNBGPSNBRVFMPTPCKFUPTEFMBSFBMJEBE
RVFFTUVEJBMBDJFODJB&MMFOHVBKF
DPNPTFFNQMFBFOMBDJFODJB
FT VOB DPTB Z
DPNP TPTUVWP )BOT #FSUFOT FO MB $POGFSFODJB
EF6USFDIUTPCSFQPTUNPEFSOJTNP14
MBTDPTBTFOMBSFBMJEBEBE-
RVJFSFOVOBOBUVSBMF[BjQBSFDJEBBMMFOHVBKFv6OBWF[NT
FM
FTDSJUPIJTUSJDPPGSFDFMBNFKPSQBOPSNJDBEFUPEPFTUP$PNP
WFSFNPTEFOUSPEFQPDP
FTFMMFOHVBKFIJTUSJDPFMRVFUJFOFMB
NJTNBPQBDJEBERVFBTPDJBNPTDPOMBTDPTBTEFMBSFBMJEBE.T
BO
UBOUPB)BZEFO8IJUFDPNPB1BVM3JDPFVS BRVJFOQPS
DJFSUP OP QSFUFOEP MMBNBS QPTUNPEFSOP
MFT HVTUB EFDJS RVF MB
SFBMJEBE QBTBEB EFCB DPOTJEFSBSTF VO UFYUP FMBCPSBEP FO VO
JEJPNB FYUSBOKFSP DPO MBT NJTNBT EJNFOTJPOFT MYJDBT
HSBNB-
UJDBMFT
TJOUDUJDBT Z TFNOUJDBT EF UPEP UFYUP15 &T EFM NJTNP
NPEPDBSBDUFSTUJDPRVFMPTIJTUPSJBEPSFTFOTVTSFFYJPOFTUF-
SJDBTBNFOVEPNVFTUSFOVOBNBSDBEBUFOEFODJBBIBCMBSTPCSF
FMMFOHVBKFIJTUSJDPDPNPTJGPSNBSBQBSUFEFMBNJTNBSFBMJEBE
ZWJDFWFSTB"T
.BSYIBCMEFMBcontradiccinFOUSFMBTGVFS[BT
EFQSPEVDDJOZMBTSFMBDJPOFTEFQSPEVDDJODPNPTJBOBMJ[BSB
MBT declaraciones BDFSDB EF MB SFBMJEBE FO MVHBS EF BTQFDUPT EF
FTUBSFBMJEBE%FGPSNBQBSFDJEB
BMPTIJTUPSJBEPSFTNVZBNF-
13
)8IJUF
Metahistory: The Historical Imagination in Nineteenth- Century
Europe
#BMUJNPSF
+PIO)PQLJOT
Q
14
) #FSUFOT
j)FUAUBMJHF DBSDUFS WBO EF QPTUNPEFSOF XFSLFMJKLIFJEv
FO
#FSUFOT DPPSE
Modernen versus postmodernen,QQm-BQPT-
UVSBEF#FSUFOTFTFOSFBMJEBEBONBTNPEFSOBTVUFTJTEFRVFFMMFOHVBKF
OVODBQVFEFSFQSFTFOUBSMBUPUBMJEBEEFMBSFBMJEBEMPIBDFFMFHJSVOBQPTJ-
DJOdentroEFMBQPMBSJEBEEFMFOHVBKFZSFBMJEBEFOMVHBSEFVOBFYUFSJPS
DPNPQFEJSBOMPTQPTUNPEFSOPT
15
)8IJUF
Metahistory,Q13JDPFVS
j5IF.PEFMPGUIF5FYUP.FBO-
JOHGVM "DUJPO $POTJEFSFE BT B 5FYUv
FO 1 3BCJOPX BOE 8 . 4VMMJWBO
FET
Interpretative Social Science
-POESFT
3PVUMFEHF
Q
168
Historiografa postmoderna
OVEPMFTHVTUBSBWFSMBNJTNBQFDVMJBSJEBEEFMMFOHVBKFIJTUSJ-
DPDPNPDBSBDUFSTUJDBEFMGFONFOPIJTUSJDP16.
$VBOEPTFBUBDBMBEJDPUPNBFOUSFMFOHVBKFZSFBMJEBEOPFT-
UBNPTMFKPTEFMFTUFUJDJTNP5BOUPFMMFOHVBKFEFMOPWFMJTUBDPNP
FMEFMIJTUPSJBEPSOPTEBOMBJMVTJOEFMBSFBMJEBE
TFBDUJDJBP
HFOVJOB"ONTJNQPSUBOUF
(PNCSJDIOPTFOTFFOWBSJPT
UFYUPTRVFMBPCSBEFBSUF
FTEFDJS
FMMFOHVBKFEFMBSUJTUB
OPFT
VOB representacin mimtica EF MB SFBMJEBE TJOP VO SFFNQMB[P
PTVTUJUVUPEFFMMB17&MMFOHVBKFZFMBSUFOPFTUOPQVFTUPTBMB
SFBMJEBE
TJOPRVFTPOFMMPTNJTNPTVOBQTFVEPSFBMJEBEZ
QPS
UBOUP
TFTJUBOdentroEFMBSFBMJEBE%FIFDIP
.FHJMM
FOTVCSJ-
MMBOUFHFOFBMPHBEFMQPTUNPEFSOJTNP
NPTUSFMHSBEPBMRVFMPT
QPTUNPEFSOPTmEFTEF/JFU[TDIFIBTUB%FSSJEBmEFTFBOFYUFOEFS
FMFTUFUJDJTNPQPSFMEPNJOJPDPNQMFUPEFMBSFQSFTFOUBDJOEF
MBSFBMJEBE18.
&TUFFTUFUJDJTNPUBNCJOFTUFOBSNPOBDPOMBTJEFBTIBDF
QPDP BERVJSJEBT BDFSDB EF MB OBUVSBMF[B EFM FTDSJUP IJTUSJDP
FTEFDJS
FMSFDPOPDJNJFOUPEFTVEJNFOTJOFTUJMTUJDB1BSBMPT
NPEFSOPTFMFTUJMPFSBVOBOBUFNBP
DVBOEPNT
BMHPTJOJN-
QPSUBODJB$JUPB(1#FSUFMTj&MFTDSJUPOP
FMEFTQMJFHVFEF
FTUJMPMJUFSBSJP
OPBBEFVOBHPUBEFWFSEBEBMBJOWFTUJHBDJO
IJTUSJDBOJBOJOHVOBPUSBJOWFTUJHBDJODJFOUDBv19-PRVFJN-
QPSUBFTFMDPOUFOJEPMBGPSNB
FMFTUJMPDPORVFTFFYQSFTB
OPFT
JNQPSUBOUF4JOFNCBSHP
EFTEF2VJOFZ(PPENBO
FTUBDNPEB
EJTUJODJOFOUSFGPSNBPFTUJMPZDPOUFOJEPOPQVFEFEBSTFZBQPS
EFTDPOUBEB 4V BSHVNFOUP QVFEF SFTVNJSTF DPNP TJHVF TJ WB-
SJPTIJTUPSJBEPSFTTFPDVQBOFOWBSJPTBTQFDUPTEFMNJTNPUFNB
EFJOWFTUJHBDJO
MBEJGFSFODJBSFTVMUBOUFFOUSFcontenidosQVFEF
EFTDSJCJSTFNVZCJFODPNPVOBEJGFSFODJBEFestilos FOFMUSBUB-
NJFOUPEFMUFNBEFJOWFTUJHBDJOjLo queTFEJDF w
RVJ[TFB
VOBGPSNBEFIBCMBSEFPUSBDPTBQPSFKFNQMPFTDSJCJSBDFSDBEF
16
7POEFS%VOL
De organisatie von her verdecen, #VTTVN
vase QPS
FKFNQMPQQ
17
&)(PNCSJDIj.FEJUBUJPOPOB)PCCZ)PSTF
PSUIF3PPUTPGUIF"SUJT-
UJDBM'PSNv
FO1+(VEFU DPPSE
Aesthetics Today, /VFWB:PSL
18
".FHJMM
Prophets of Extremity: Nietzsche, Heidegger, Foucault, Derrida,
#FSLFMFZ
WBTFFOQBSUJDVMBS
19
$1#FSUFMT
j4UJKMFFOWFSLFFSEFDBUFHPSJFJOEFHFTDIJFEXFUFOTDIBQv
Gro-
vide
Q
169
-VJT(%F.VTTZr.JHVFM7BMEFSSBNB
MBTCBUBMMBTEFM3FOBDJNJFOUPZFTDSJCJSTPCSFMBTBSUFTEFM3FOB-
DJNJFOUPTPOEJTUJOUBTGPSNBTEFIBCMBSEFM3FOBDJNJFOUPv200
FOQBMBCSBTEF(BZ
MBmanera, FMFTUJMP
JNQMJDBBMNJTNPUJFNQP
VOB EFDJTJO SFTQFDUP EF MB materia
EFM DPOUFOJEP21. : EPOEF
TF EJTUJOHVFO FOUSF T FM FTUJMP Z FM DPOUFOJEP QPEFNPT JODMVTP
BUSJCVJSBMFTUJMPVOBQSJPSJEBETPCSFFMDPOUFOJEPEFCJEPBMB
JODPONFOTVSBCJMJEBEEFMBWJTJOIJTUSJDBmFTEFDJS
FMIFDIPEF
RVFMBOBUVSBMF[BEFMBTEJGFSFODJBTEFPQJOJPOFTIJTUSJDBTOP
QVFEBEFOJSTFEFGPSNBTBUJTGBDUPSJBFOUSNJOPTEFUFNBTEF
JOWFTUJHBDJOmOPOPTRVFEBNTRVFDPODFOUSBSOPTFOFMFTUJMP
QSFTFOUF FO DBEB WJTJO IJTUSJDB P GPSNB EF WFS FM QBTBEP
TJ
WBNPTBHBSBOUJ[BSFMQSPHSFTPTJHOJDBUJWPEFMEFCBUFIJTUSJDP
&MFTUJMP
RVFOPFMDPOUFOJEP
FTFMUFNBEFFTUPTEFCBUFT&MDPO-
UFOJEPTFEFSJWBEFMFTUJMPFOFMNCJUPEFMEFCBUFIJTUPSJPHSDP
DPNPSFTVMUBEPEFMEFCBUFIJTUSJDP
&MSFDPOPDJNJFOUPQPTUNPEFSOPEFMBOBUVSBMF[BFTUUJDBEFM
FTDSJUPIJTUSJDPQVFEFEFTDSJCJSTFDPONTQSFDJTJODPNPTJHVF
FOMBMPTPGBBOBMUJDBFYJTUFFMGFONFOPEFMMMBNBEPjDPOUFYUP
EFDPOUFOJEPv6OFKFNQMPFTMBEFDMBSBDJOj+VBODSFFRVFpv
Pj+VBOFTQFSBRVFpv EPOEFpTJHOJDBVOBEFDMBSBDJOQBSUJ-
DVMBS
&MQVOUPFTRVFFOVODPOUFYUPEFDPOUFOJEPDPNPTUF
pOVODBTFQVFEFSFFNQMB[BSDPOPUSBEFDMBSBDJO
BVORVFFTUB
PUSB EFDMBSBDJO FRVJWBMHB B p P TFB SFTVMUBEP EJSFDUP EF FMMB
%FTQVTEFUPEP
OPTBCFNPTTJ+VBOEFIFDIPFTUDPOTDJFOUFEF
MBTDPOTFDVFODJBTEFTVTDSFFODJBTPFTQFSBO[BEFp.&TQPTJCMF
RVF+VBODSFBRVFFMBHVBFTUIJSWJFOEP
QBSBEBSVOFKFNQMP
TJOTVDSFFODJBEFRVFMBUFNQFSBUVSBEFMBHVBTFBEFDJFOHSB-
EPTDFOUHSBEPT&OPUSBTQBMBCSBT
MBGPSNBFYBDUBFOMBRVFTF
GPSNVMVOBEFDMBSBDJOFOVODPOUFYUPEFDPOUFOJEPFTVOPEF
MPTSFRVJTJUPTQBSBFTUBEFDMBSBDJO-BPSBDJOBUSBF
QPSEFDJSMP
BT
MBBUFODJOBFMMBNJTNB"T
MBforma EFMBEFDMBSBDJOFT
FOWFSEBEBRVUBOJNQPSUBOUFDPNPFMcontenido&OVOMJCSP
FOQBSUJDVMBSJOUFSFTBOUF
"SUIVS%BOUPTFBMRVFFTUBOBUVSB-
MF[BEFDPOUFOJEPEFMBTEFDMBSBDJPOFTZUFYUPT PBMNFOPTEF
BMHVOPTEFFMMPT
FOOJOHVOBFTUBODMBSBDPNPFOMBMJUFSBUVSB
20
/(PPENBO
j5IF4UBUVTPG4UZMFv
FO/(PPENBO
Ways of Worldmak-
ing, )BTTPDLT
Q
21
1(BZ
Style in History,-POEPO
1FOHVJO
Q
170
Historiografa postmoderna
j2VJ[FOOJOHOMVHBSQPEBNPTWFSFTUP FTUFFMFNFOUPEFDPO-
UFOJEP
DPONTDMBSJEBERVFFOFTPTUFYUPT
FOMPTRVF
BEFNT
EFDVBMFTRVJFSBEFMPTIFDIPTEFMBVUPSRVFEFTFFFTUBCMFDFS
FM
P FMMB elige las palabras DPO RVF MPT FTUBCMFDFv
Z MB JOUFODJO
MJUFSBSJB EFM FTDSJUPS jGSBDBTBSB TJ FNQMFBSB PUSBT QBMBCSBTv22.
%FCJEPBTVOBUVSBMF[BEFDPOUFOJEP
FMUFYUPMJUFSBSJPUJFOFVOB
DJFSUBPQBDJEBE
VOBDBQBDJEBEEFBUSBFSMBBUFODJOBMNJTNP
FOMVHBSEFIBDFSMPBMBSFBMJEBEDUJDJBIJTUSJDBEFUSTEFMUFYUP
:TUBFTVOBDBSBDUFSTUJDBRVFFMUFYUPMJUFSBSJPDPNQBSUFDPOFM
FTDSJUPIJTUSJDPMBOBUVSBMF[BEFMBWJTJOEFMQBTBEPRVFTFQSF-
TFOUBFOVOBPCSBIJTUSJDBTFEFOFFYBDUBNFOUFDPOFMMFOHVBKF
RVF FNQMF FM IJTUPSJBEPS P IJTUPSJBEPSB FO TV PCSB IJTUSJDB
%FCJEPBMBSFMBDJOFOUSFMBWJTJOIJTUSJDBZFMMFOHVBKFRVF
FNQMFBFMIJTUPSJBEPSQBSBFYQSFTBSFTBWJTJOmSFMBDJORVFFO
OJOHOMBEPTFFOUSFDSV[BDPOFMEPNJOJPEFMQBTBEPm
FMFTDSJUP
IJTUSJDPQPTFFMBNJTNBPQBDJEBEZEJNFOTJOEFDPOUFOJEPRVF
FMBSUF
1PSUBOUP
FMBSUFZFMFTDSJUPIJTUSJDPTFDPOUSBTUBODPOMB
DJFODJB&MMFOHVBKFDJFOUDPBMNFOPTUJFOFMBQSFUFOTJOEFTFS
USBOTQBSFOUFTJJNQJEFOVFTUSBWJTJOEFMBSFBMJEBE
IBCSRVF
SFOBSMPPFMVDJEBSMP&TDJFSUPRVFBMHVOPTMTPGPTEFMBDJFO-
DJB EFTFBO BUSJCVJS JODMVTP B MB DJFODJB MBT ZB NFODJPOBEBT EJ-
NFOTJPOFT FTUUJDB Z MJUFSBSJB 1PS TVQVFTUP
FTP EBSB VO QPDP
NTEFBENJTJCJMJEBEBNJSFDMBNPSFTQFDUPEFMFTDSJUPIJTUSJDP
QFSP WFP MBT EJGFSFODJBT FOUSF MBT DJFODJBT FYBDUBT Z FM FTDSJUP
IJTUSJDPDPNPalgo msRVFVOBDVFTUJOEFNBUJDFT%POEFMB
DPNQSFOTJOFOVOBEJTDJQMJOBUJFOFVOBOBUVSBMF[BNVDIPNT
TJOUDUJDB RVF TFNOUJDB mDPNP FT FM DBTP EF MB DJFODJBT FYBD-
UBTm
IBZFODPNQBSBDJONFOPTFTQBDJPQBSBMPTDPOUFYUPTEF
DPOUFOJEP%FTQVTEFUPEP
TMPEFTEFMBQFSTQFDUJWBEFMBTF-
NOUJDBFTTJHOJDBUJWPQMBOUFBSMBQSFHVOUBEFTJIBZTJOPOJNJB
POP ZFTUFFTFMQSPCMFNBNTJNQPSUBOUFFOMPTDPOUFYUPTEF
DPOUFOJEP
4JFTUBNPTEFBDVFSEPDPOMPBOUFSJPSmFTEFDJS
DPOMBBQMJDB-
CJMJEBEEFMBDPNQSFOTJOQPTUNPEFSOBEFMFTDSJUPIJTUSJDPmNF
HVTUBSBFTCP[BSWBSJBTDPODMVTJPOFTBOUFTEFUFSNJOBSFMUFYUP
22
" $ %BOUP
The Transfiguration of the Commonplace, $BNCSJEHF
."
)BSWBSE6OJWFSTJUZ1SFTT
Q
171
-VJT(%F.VTTZr.JHVFM7BMEFSSBNB
1BSBFMNPEFSOP
EFOUSPEFMBWJTJODJFOUDBEFMNVOEPZEFO-
USPEFMBWJTJOEFMBIJTUPSJBRVFUPEPTFOQSJODJQJPBDFQUBNPT
MBFWJEFODJBFT
FTFODJBMNFOUF
MBFWJEFODJBEFRVFBMHPTVDFEJ
FOFMQBTBEP&MIJTUPSJBEPSNPEFSOPTJHVFVOBMOFBEFSB[POB-
NJFOUPEFTEFTVTPSHFOFTZFWJEFODJBTIBTUBVOBSFBMJEBEPDVMUB
USBT MPT PSHFOFT 4JO FNCBSHP
FO MB WJTJO QPTUNPEFSOJTUB
MB
FWJEFODJBOPTFBMBBMpasadoTJOPBPUSBTinterpretacionesEFM
QBTBEPEFIFDIP
FTQBSBFTPRVFFNQMFBNPTMBFWJEFODJB1BSB
FYQSFTBSMPQPSNFEJPEFJNHFOFTQBSBFMNPEFSOP
MBFWJEFODJB
FTVOBCBMEPTBRVFSFDPHFQBSBWFSMPRVFIBZEFCBKP
ZQBSBFM
QPTUNPEFSOP
QPSFMDPOUSBSJP
FTVOBCBMEPTBRVFQJTBQBSBJSB
PUSBTCBMEPTBTIPSJ[POUBMJEBEFOMVHBSEFWFSUJDBMJEBE
&TUPOPFTTMPDPNQSFOEFSMPRVFFOSFBMJEBETVDFEF
TJOP
DPNQSFOEFSBMHPFOMPRVFMPTIJTUPSJBEPSFTEFCFODPODFOUSBSTF
FOFMGVUVSP-BTVHFSFODJBTFEFTDSJCFNFKPSDPNPVOBBCTPS-
DJOEFMBGVFOUFIJTUSJDBFOFMQSFTFOUF-BFWJEFODJBOPFTVO
MFOUFEFBVNFOUPBUSBWTEFMDVBMTFFTUVEJBFMQBTBEP
TJOPRVF
HVBSEBNTQBSFDJEPDPOMBTQJODFMBEBTEFMQJOUPSQBSBDPOTF-
HVJSVOFGFDUPEFTFBEP-BFWJEFODJBOPOPTFOWBEFSFHSFTPBM
QBTBEP
TJOP RVF HFOFSB MB QSFHVOUB SFTQFDUP EF MP RVF QVFEF
IBDFSDPOFMMBVOIJTUPSJBEPSBRVZBIPSB(FPSHFT%VCZJMVT-
USBFTUBOVFWBBDUJUVEIBDJBMBFWJEFODJB$VBOEPTVJOUFMJHFOUF
FOUSFWJTUBEPS(VZ-BSESFBVMFQSFHVOUBRVFFTQBSBM
%VCZ
MB
FWJEFODJB NT JOUFSFTBOUF
SFTQPOEF RVF QVFEF FODPOUSBSTF FO
MPRVFOPFTUEJDIP
FOMPRVFVOQFSJPEPno EJKPBDFSDBEFT
NJTNPZ
QPSUBOUP
DPNQBSBTVPCSBIJTUSJDBDPOFMEFTBSSPMMP
EFVOOFHBUJWP23*HVBMRVFFMQF[OPTBCFRVFOBEBFOFMBHVB
MP
RVFFTNTDBSBDUFSTUJDPEFVOQFSJPEP
MPRVFFTNTPNOJQSF-
TFOUFFOVOQFSJPEP
FTEFTDPOPDJEPQBSBFMNJTNP/PTFSFWFMB
IBTUBRVFFMQFSJPEPUFSNJOB-BGSBHBODJBEFVOQFSJPEPTPMP
QVFEFJOIBMBSTFFOVOQFSJPEPTVCTJHVJFOUF1PSTVQVFTUP
)FHFM
Z'PVDBVMUIJDJFSPOZBNVDIPTDPNFOUBSJPTJOUFSFTBOUFTBFTUF
SFTQFDUP4JOFNCBSHP
FMQVOUPBRVFTMBPCTFSWBDJOEF%VCZ
EFMBFTFODJBEFVOQFSJPEPFTEFUFSNJOBEBQPSTVdestinataire,
QBSBFNQMFBSFMUSNJOPEFMPTQPTUNPEFSOPTGSBODFTFT
QPSFM
IJTUPSJBEPS RVF UJFOF RVF EFTBSSPMMBS BRV Z BIPSB TV OFHBUJWP
23
(%VCZZ(-BSESFBV
Geschichte und Geschichtwissenschaft: Dialogue,
'SBODGPSUEFM.FOP
QQ
172
Historiografa postmoderna
EFVOQFSJPEPEFMRVFOBEBTFIBIBCMBEPPTVTVSSBEP
PEFMRVF
TFFYQSFTBTPMPFOEFUBMMFTJOTJHOJDBOUFT&MIJTUPSJBEPSFTDPNP
connoiseurRVFSFDPOPDFBMBSUJTUBOPQPSMPRVFFTDBSBDUFSTUJDP
EFM Z
FODPOTFDVFODJB
JNJUBCMF
TJOPQPSRVF
QPSEFDJSMPBT
FTQPOUOFBNFOUFjTFMFFTDBQ. Le style, cest lhomme
DPNP
EJKP #VGGPO
Z OVFTUSP FTUJMP FTU EPOEF FTUBNPT OPTPUSPT TJO
QFOTBS FO OPTPUSPT NJTNPT &T QPS FTUB SB[O QPS MB RVF UBO
QPDBTQFSTPOBTUJFOFOFTUJMPFOOVFTUSBOBSDJTJTUBFSB&OCSFWF
MBGPSNBEFUSBUBSDPOMBFWJEFODJBDPNPTVHJSJ%VCZFTFTQF-
DJBM
OP UBOUP QPSRVF BQVOUB B BMHP RVF TF PDVMU USBT FMMB FO
FMQBTBEP
TJOPQPSRVFBERVJFSFTVTJHOJDBEPTMPNFEJBOUFMB
DPOGSPOUBDJODPOMBNFOUBMJEBEEFMQFSJPEPQPTUFSJPS
FOFMRVF
WJWFZFTDSJCFFMIJTUPSJBEPS-BNFOUBMJEBEEFVOQFSJPEPRVFEB
BMEFTDVCJFSUPTPMPFOMBEJGFSFODJBFOUSFFMMBZMBEFVOQFSJPEP
QPTUFSJPSMBEJSFDDJOFORVFBQVOUBMBFWJEFODJBTFTPNFUFEF
FTUFNPEPBVODBNCJPEFOPWFOUBHSBEPT$PNPUBOBNFOVEP
TVDFEF
)VJ[JOHBUBNCJOBOUJDJQFTUP"MFTDSJCJSTPCSFMBTFO-
TBDJOIJTUSJDB
BSNB
&TUFDPOUBDUPDPOFMQBTBEP
RVFTFBDPNQBBEFMB
DPOWJDDJODPNQMFUBEFMPHFOVJOP
EFMBWFSEBE
QVFEF
FWPDBSTFDPOVOBMOFBEFVONBQBPEFVOBDSOJDB
DPO
VOJNQSFTP
VOBTDVBOUBTOPUBTEFVOBWJFKBDBODJO/P
FTVOFMFNFOUPRVFFMFTDSJUPS FOFMQBTBEP
JODMVZFSBFO
TV PCSB QPS NFEJP EF DJFSUBT QBMBCSBT w
El lector lo
toma para conocer al escritorFTTVSFTQVFTUBBMMMBNBEP
EFMTFHVOEP24 MBTDVSTJWBTTPONBT
/PTPSQSFOEFRVF%VCZZ-BSESFBVTFBMFOFOFTUBDPOFYJO
MBSFMBDJOFOUSFIJTUPSJPHSBGBZQTJDPBOMJTJT255BOUPFOFMFTDSJ-
UPIJTUSJDPDPNPFOFMQTJDPBOMJTJTBUFOEFNPTBMBJOUFSQSFUB-
DJO
FOFMTFOUJEPNTGVOEBNFOUBMEFMBQBMBCSB&OFMFTDSJUP
IJTUSJDP
FTUBGPSNBEFBCPSEBSMPTSBTUSPTEFMQBTBEP
DPNPTV-
HJSJ%VCZ
nos obliga a abstenernos de buscar alguna mquina
al principio invisible en el pasado mismo RVFIBZBDBVTBEPRVF
FTUPTSBTUSPTTFBOEJTDFSOJCMFTFOMBTVQFSDJF%FMNJTNPNPEP
FMQTJDPBOMJTJT
BQFTBSEFMBTOPUBTQPTJUJWJTUBTRVFJNQSFTJPOB-
24
+)VJ[JOHB
j%FUBBLEFSDVMUVSHFTDIJEFOJTv
FOJ. Huizinga: Verzallole...,
WPM
)BBSMFN
QQ
25
%VCZZ-BSESFBV
Geschichte, QQ
173
-VJT(%F.VTTZr.JHVFM7BMEFSSBNB
SPOBMNJTNP'SFVE
FTEFIFDIPVOSFQFSUPSJPEFFTUSBUFHJBTEF
JOUFSQSFUBDJO&MQTJDPBOMJTJTOPTFOTFBBFOUFOEFSMPRVFEJDF
FMOFVSUJDPZOPEFTWBOVFTUSBBUFODJOBMPTFGFDUPTDBVTBMFT
EF EJWFSTPT IPNODVMPT FMFNFOUBMFT F JOEJWJTPT FO TV NFOUF26.
5BOUPFMQTJDPBOBMJTUBDPNPFMIJTUPSJBEPSUSBUBOEFQSPZFDUBSVO
QBUSOsobreMPTSBTUSPTZOPCVTDBOBMHPdetrsEFMPTSBTUSPT
&OBNCPTDBTPT
MBBDUJWJEBEEFMBTJOUFSQSFUBDJPOFTTFFOUJFOEF
EFVOBGPSNBFTUSJDUBNFOUFOPNJOBMJTUBOPIBZOBEBFOMBSFB-
MJEBEIJTUSJDBOJFOMBNFOUFEFMOFVSUJDPRVFDPSSFTQPOEBBM
DPOUFOJEPEFMBTJOUFSQSFUBDJPOFT27.
4JOFNCBSHP
FYJTUFVOQBSBMFMJTNPBONTFOMBJOUFSQSFUB-
DJOQTJDPBOBMUJDB1PSTVQVFTUP
FTPCWJPRVFMBUFTJTEF%VCZ
EF RVF FM IJTUPSJBEPS EFCF QPOFS BUFODJO B MP RVF OP TF EJDF
Z B MP RVF TF TVQSJNF mMPDVSB
GBMTFEBE Z UBC
TFHO MPT DSJ-
UFSJPT EF 'PVDBVMUm TF SFMBDJPOB DPO FM NUPEP EF USBCBKP EFM
BOBMJTUB*HVBMRVFTPNPTMPRVFOPTPNPT
POPRVFSFNPTTFS
FODJFSUPTFOUJEPFMQBTBEPFTUBNCJOMPRVFOPGVF5BOUPFOFM
QTJDPBOMJTJTDPNPFOMBIJTUPSJB
MPRVFTFTVQSJNFTFNBOJFTUB
TPMP FO EFUBMMFT NFOPSFT Z FO BQBSJFODJBT TJO JNQPSUBODJB &O
FMQTJDPBOMJTJT
FTUPEBQPSSFTVMUBEPMBDPNQSFOTJOEFRVFFM
IPNCSFOPUJFOFVOTFSPFTFODJBPCTFSWBCMFDPOGBDJMJEBEDPO
CBTF B MB DVBM QVFEB DPNQSFOESTFMF
TJOP RVF FM TFDSFUP EF MB
26
&TUFFTFMMFNBEF%14QFODF
Narrative Truth and Historical Truth; Mean-
ing and Interpretation in Physcoanalysis, /VFWB:PSL
27
-BSESFBVFYQSFTFTUPSFTQFDUPEFMFTDSJUPIJTUSJDPEFMBTJHVJFOUFGPSNB
j1PSFMMP
OPIBZNTRVFEJTDVSTPTTPCSFFMQBTBEP
RVFOPFTPUSBDPTB
RVFFTUPTEJTDVSTPT
FOMPTRVFTFNPWJMJ[BOMPTJOUFSFTFTEFMQSFTFOUF#BMMFU
EF NBTDBSBT SJHVSPTBNFOUF FTDFOJDBEP RVF TF PGSFDFO B SFQSFTFOUBS MPT
JOUFSFTFTMPTDPOJDUPTEFMQSFTFOUF
FOFMDVBMDBNCJBOMPTQBQFMFTQFSPOP
MPTMVHBSFTMBIJTUPSJBFTFMHVBSEBSSPQBEFJOTDSJQDJPOFTJNBHJOBSJBT
ZFM
IJTUPSJBEPS FT FM TBTUSF RVF BSSFHMB MPT USBKFT RVF OVODB IBO TJEP OVFWPT
-B IJTUPSJB FTU IFDIB EF MB NJTNB UFMB RVF MPT TVFPT
OVFTUSB QFRVFB
NFNPSJB FTU FOWVFMUB FO VO TVFPv %VCZ Z -BSESFBV
Geschichte
QQ
$PNP FM NJTNP -BSESFBV FMBCPSB
FT EFDJS
BOUFT RVF OBEB
VOB
JOUFSQSFUBDJOQPUJDBEFMOPNJOBMJTNPIJTUSJDPTPMPUFOFNPTQBMBCSBTZ
OPNCSFTZEFCFNPTEFTDPOBSEFUPEPJOUFOUPEFFTUBCMFDFSSFMBDJPOFTKBT
FOUSF MBT QBMBCSBT Z MB SFBMJEBE %F IFDIP
FTUF OPNJOBMJTNP IJTUSJDP FT
VOBDPOUJOVBDJOEFMTFOUJEPEFMIJTUPSJBEPS
EFTVEFTFPEFDVFTUJPOBSDBEB
JOUFOUPjEFQPOFSFMQBTBEPFOQBMBCSBTvNTRVFMPSFMBUJWPBMMFOHVBKFP
BMJEFBMJTNPUFYUVBMRVFUBOBNFOVEPTFBTPDJBDPOM%FCFPCTFSWBSTFMB
BOJEBEEFDPOUSBTUFFOUSFFTUFOPNJOBMJTNPIJTUSJDPZFMJOTUSVNFOUBMJTNP
DPOFMOEFQFSDBUBSOPTEFDVBOUPTFBKVTUBFMOPNJOBMJTNPIJTUSJDPBVOB
BCTUJOFODJBMPTDBZTFOUJEPDSUJDP
174
Historiografa postmoderna
QFSTPOBMJEBE
ZBDF FO MP RVF TPMP SBSBT Z GVHBDFT PDBTJPOFT TF
WVFMWFWJTJCMFUSBTTVQSFTFOUBDJODPNO/VFTUSBQFSTPOBMJEBE
FT
DPNP QVOUVBMJ[ 3PSUZ
VO collage NT RVF VOB TVTUBODJB
j-BDBQBDJEBEEFQFOTBSFOOPTPUSPTNJTNPTDPNPcollages GPS-
NBEPTEFNBOFSBJEJPTJODSUJDBNTRVFDPNPTVTUBODJBIBTJEP
VOGBDUPSJNQPSUBOUFFOOVFTUSBDBQBDJEBEEFEFTIBDFSOPTEFMB
JEFBEFRVFUFOFNPTVOZPWFSEBEFSP
VOPRVFDPNQBSUJNPTDPO
MPTEFNTTFSFTIVNBOPT w
'SFVEIJ[PEFMQBSBEJHNBEFMBV-
UPDPOPDJNJFOUPFMEFTDVCSJNJFOUPEFQFRVFPTBDDJEFOUFTJEJP-
TJODSUJDPTNTRVFFMEFFTFODJBv28.
&TUFFTUBNCJOFMDBTPFOFMFTDSJUPIJTUSJDPDPOUFNQPS-
OFP
BMNFOPTFOMPRVFNFHVTUBMMBNBSIJTUPSJBQPTUNPEFSOB
EFMBTNFOUBMJEBEFT
1BSBGPSNVMBSFTUPEFMBGPSNBQBSBEKJDB
RVFUBOUPBHSBEBBMPTQPTUNPEFSOPTMBFTFODJBEFMQBTBEPOP
FT
POPZBDFFO
MPRVFVOBHFOFSBDJOBOUFSJPSEFIJTUPSJBEPSFT
SFDPOPDJDPNPMBFTFODJBMEFMQBTBEP&TFOFMB[BSBQBSFOUF
MPTEFTMJDFTEFMBMFOHVB
FMFehlleistungenEFMQBTBEP
MPTSBSPT
NPNFOUPTFORVFFMQBTBEPjTFEFKBJSv
EPOEFEFTDVCSJNPTMP
RVFFTFOSFBMJEBEJNQPSUBOUFQBSBOPTPUSPT4PTQFDIPRVFTUB
FTBMNFOPTVOBFYQMJDBDJOQBSDJBMEFMPRVFNFODJPOBCB+PSO
3VTFODPNPFMcambio de paradigmaFOFMFTDSJUPIJTUSJDPEF
IPZFOEB
VODBNCJPEFQBSBEJHNBRVFFOTVPQJOJODPOTJT-
UF NT RVF OBEB FO JOUFSDBNCJBS makrohistorische Strukturen
QPSmikrohistorische Situationen und Lebensverhaltnisse DPNP
FM PCKFUP EF MB BUFODJO EFM IJTUPSJBEPS29 -P RVF FTUBNPT QSF-
TFODJBOEPRVJ[TFBOBEBNFOPTRVFFMBEJTEFOJUJWPBUPEBT
MBTBTQJSBDJPOFTFTFODJBMFTRVFFOSFBMJEBEEPNJOBSPOFMFTDSJUP
IJTUSJDPEVSBOUFUPEBTVFYJTUFODJB-PTIJTUPSJBEPSFTTJFNQSF
IBO CVTDBEP BMHP RVF QVEJFTFO FUJRVFUBS DPNP MB FTFODJB EFM
QBTBEP
FMQSJODJQJPRVFEBCBTFOUJEPBUPEPFOFMQBTBEP PB
VOBQBSUFEFM
ZDPOCBTFBMPDVBM
FODPOTFDVFODJB
UPEPQP-
ESBDPNQSFOEFSTF$POFMQBTPEFMPTTJHMPT
FTUFFTFODJBMJTNP
EFM FTDSJUP IJTUSJDP TF NBOJGFTU EF JODPOUBCMFT NBOFSBT 1PS
TVQVFTUP
FM FTFODJBMJTNP FTUVWP QSFTFOUF EF GPSNB OPUPSJB FO
MPTEJWFSTPTTJTUFNBTFTQFDVMBUJWPTRVFEJSJHJFSPOFMQFOTBNJFOUP
28
33PSUZ
j'SFVEBOE.PSBM3FFDUJPOv
FO3PSUZ
Essays on Heidegger and
Others: Philosophical Papers
WPM
$BNCSJEHF
Q
29
Programmaboek Congres Balans en Perspectief,6USFDIU
Q
175
-VJT(%F.VTTZr.JHVFM7BMEFSSBNB
EFMIPNCSFPDDJEFOUBMBDFSDBEFFTUFQBTBEP&MDPODFQUPUFPM-
HJDP BHVTUJOJBOP EF MB IJTUPSJB
Z TVT WBSJBOUFT TFDVMBSJ[BEBT30
MBJEFBEFQSPHSFTP
DPOTVGFDJFHBFOFMQSPHSFTPEFMBDJFODJB
Z MB CFOEJDJO TPDJBM RVF TF FTQFSB HFOFSF
GVFSPO TJFNQSF MBT
metanarraciones
QBSBVTBSFMUSNJOPEF-ZPUBSE
QPSNFEJPEF
MBTDVBMFTTFMFHJUJNBSPOOPTMPFMFTDSJUPIJTUSJDPTJOPUBNCJO
PUSPTBTQFDUPTGVOEBNFOUBMFTEFMBDJWJMJ[BDJOZMBTPDJFEBE31.
-MFHEFTQVTFMIJTUPSJDJTNP
RVF
DPOVOBFYUSBBJOHFOVJ-
EBEWJPMBFTFODJBEFMQBTBEPFODBSOBEBFOVOBDVSJPTBNF[DMB
EF IFDIP F JEFB -B JOHFOVJEBE FQJTUFNPMHJDB EF MB EPDUSJOB
IJTUPSJFUBEFMBTJEFBTIJTUSJDBTTMPGVFQPTJCMFFOVOBQPDB
FOMBRVFMBDSFFODJBZMBGFFOMBQFSDFQDUJCJMJEBEEFMBFTFODJB
EFMQBTBEPTFEJFSPOQPSTFHVSBTDPOUBOUBGBDJMJEBERVFOBEJF
UVWPMBNTWBHBJEFBEFTVBSSPHBODJBPOUPMHJDB-BIJTUPSJB
TPDJBMRVFBOBMJ[3VTFOGVFFMMUJNPFTMBCOFOFTUBDBEFOBEF
WJTJPOFTFTFODJBMJTUBTEFMBIJTUPSJB-BOPUBUSJVOGBOUFDPORVF
IJ[PTVFOUSBEBMBIJTUPSJBTPDJBM
FOQBSUJDVMBSFO"MFNBOJB
FT
MBQSVFCBNTTPSQSFOEFOUFEFMBPQUJNJTUBBVUPTPCSFFTUJNBDJO
EFM QBTBEP QPS QBSUF EF FTUB FTDVFMB IJTUSJDB
RVF TJFOUF RVF
ZB FODPOUS MB UBO CVTDBEB MMBWF RVF BCSJS UPEBT MBT QVFSUBT
IJTUSJDBT2VJFOTFBRVFFTUDPOTDJFOUFEFMBOBUVSBMF[BFTFO-
DJBMJTUBEFFTUBIJTUPSJBTPDJBMZEFMBFOFNJTUBEUSBEJDJPOBMFOUSF
FMFTFODJBMJTNPZMBDJFODJBOPQVFEFEFKBSEFOPUBSMBOBUVSBMF[B
BCTVSEB EF MBT QSFUFOTJPOFT EF MPT IJTUPSJBEPSFT TPDJBMFT 1FSP
BVO IBZ RVF CVTDBS B MPT QFPSFT NPEFSOPT FOUSF MPT MTPGPT
EFMBIJTUPSJB
MPRVF
QPSDJFSUPOPFTUBOTPSQSFOEFOUFBOJNBO
UPEBPTUFOUBDJOQTFVEPDJFOUDBDPONTQSFTUF[BJODMVTPRVF
MPT IJTUPSJBEPSFT
UBO QSPOUP DPNP QJFOTBO RVF WFO FO FMMB MB
DPOSNBDJOEFTVTBHPUBEBTJEFBTQPTJUJWJTUBT
.FHVTUBSBBDMBSBSFMNPWJNJFOUPEFMBDPODJFODJBIJTUSJDB
RVFNFODJPOBNPTMOFBTBUSTQPSNFEJPEFMBJNBHFOTJHVJFO-
UF$PNQBSFNPTMBIJTUPSJBDPOVOSCPM-BUSBEJDJOFTFODJB-
MJTUBEFOUSPEFMFTDSJUPIJTUSJDPPDDJEFOUBMDFOUSMBBUFODJO
EFMPTIJTUPSJBEPSFTFOFMUSPODPEFMSCPM1PSTVQVFTUP
FTUF
GVFFMDBTPEFMPTTJTUFNBTFTQFDVMBUJWPT
EFOJFSPO
QPSEFDJSMP
30
1PSTVQVFTUP
FTUPTFSFFSFBMBUFTJTEF,-PXJUIFOTVPCSBMeaning in
History
$IJDBHP
31
-ZPUBSE
Condition
QQ
176
Historiografa postmoderna
BT
MBOBUVSBMF[BZMBGPSNBEFTVUSPODP&MIJTUPSJDJTNPZFM
FTDSJUP IJTUSJDP Z DJFOUDP NPEFSOP
DPO TV BUFODJO CTJ-
DBNFOUFFODPNJBCMFBMPRVF
EFIFDIP
TVDFEJFOFMQBTBEP
Z TV GBMUB EF SFDFQUJWJEBE IBDJB MPT FTRVFNBT BQSJPSTUJDPT TF
TJUVBSPOFOMBTSBNBTEFMSCPM4JOFNCBSHP
EFTEFFTBQPTJ-
DJOTVBUFODJOQFSNBOFDJDFOUSBEBFOFMUSPODP*HVBMRVF
TVTQSFEFDFTPSFTFTQFDVMBUJWPT
UBOUPMPTIJTUPSJDJTUBTDPNPMPT
QSPUBHPOJTUBT EFM MMBNBEP FTDSJUP IJTUSJDP DJFOUDP BMCFSHB-
CBOBVOMBFTQFSBO[BZMBQSFUFOTJOEFTFS
FOMUJNBJOTUBODJB
DBQBDFT EF EFDJS BMHP BDFSDB EFM USPODP EFTQVT EF UPEP -PT
FTUSFDIPT MB[PT FOUSF MB MMBNBEB IJTUPSJB TPDJBM DJFOUDB Z FM
NBSYJTNPTPOTJHOJDBUJWPTFOFTUFDPOUFYUP4FBRVFTFIBZB
GPSNVMBEP DPO VOB UFSNJOPMPHB POUPMHJDB P NFUPEPMHJDB
FMFTDSJUPIJTUSJDPEFTEFFMIJTUPSJDJTNPTJFNQSFQVHOQPSMB
SFDPOTUSVDDJO EF MB MOFB FTFODJBMJTUB RVF DPSSF B USBWT EFM
QBTBEPP
QPSQBSUFEFM
$POFMFTDSJUPIJTUSJDPQPTNPEFSOPmRVFTFFODVFOUSB
FO
QBSUJDVMBS
FOMBIJTUPSJBEFMBTNFOUBMJEBEFTmTFSPNQJQPSQSJ-
NFSBWF[DPOFTUBUSBEJDJOFTFODJBMJTUBEFTJHMPTEFWJEBmBMP
RVFBBEPEFJONFEJBUP
QBSBFWJUBSDVBMRVJFSQBUFUJTNPPFYB-
HFSBDJO
RVFNFSFFSPBRVBUFOEFODJBTZOPBSPNQJNJFOUPT
SBEJDBMFT-BFMFDDJOZBOPSFDBFFOFMUSPODPOJFOMBTSBNBT
TJOP FO MBT IPKBT EFM SCPM 4FHO MB WJTJO QPTUNPEFSOB EF MB
IJTUPSJB
FMPCKFUJWPZBOPFTMBJOUFHSBDJO
TOUFTJTZUPUBMJEBE
TJOP FTPT USP[PT IJTUSJDPT RVF TPO FM DFOUSP EF BUFODJO 5P-
NFNPTQPSFKFNQMPMontaillou ZPUSPTMJCSPTRVFFTDSJCJEFT-
QVT-F3PZ-BEVSJF
MBTNJDSPIJTUPSJBTEF(JO[CVSH
Sunday of
Bowines
EF%VCZ
PEl Regreso de Martn Guerre, EF/BUBMJF
;FNPO%BWJT)BDFRVJODFPWFJOUFBPTOPTIBCSBNPTQSFHVO-
UBEPDPOBTPNCSPDVMTFSBFMDBTPEFFTUBDMBTFEFFTDSJUPIJT-
USJDP
RVUSBUBCBEFQSPCBS:FTUBUBOPCWJBQSFHVOUBTFIBCSB
PSJHJOBEP FOUPODFT
DPNP TJFNQSF
FO OVFTUSP EFTFP NPEFSOP
EFTBCFSDNPGVODJPOBMBNRVJOBEFMBIJTUPSJB4JOFNCBSHP
FOMBWJTJOBOUJFTFODJBMJTUBZOPNJOBMJTUBEFMQPTUNPEFSOJTNP
FTUBQSFHVOUBQFSEJTJHOJDBEP4JEFTFBNPTBEIFSJSOPTEFUP-
EPTNPEPTBMFTFODJBMJTNP
QPEFNPTEFDJSRVFMBFTFODJBOPFTU
FOMBTSBNBT
OJFOFMUSPODP
TJOPFOMBTIPKBTEFMSCPMIJTUSJDP
177
-VJT(%F.VTTZr.JHVFM7BMEFSSBNB
&TUPNFMMFWBBMQVOUPQSJODJQBMEFNJFYQPTJDJO&TDBSBD-
UFSTUJDPEFMBTIPKBTRVFFTUOTVKFUBTDPOSFMBUJWBQSFDBSJFEBE
BMSCPM
ZRVFDVBOEPMMFHBFMPUPPPFMJOWJFSOPTFMBTMMFWFFM
WJFOUP1PSEJWFSTBTSB[POFT
QPEFNPTBTVNJSRVFFMPUPPMMFH
BMBIJTUPSJPHSBGBPDDJEFOUBM&OQSJNFSMVHBS
FTUQPSTVQVFT-
UPMBOBUVSBMF[BQPTUNPEFSOBEFOVFTUSBQSPQJBQPDB/VFTUSP
BOUJFTFODJBMJTNPmP
DPNPQPQVMBSNFOUFTFMMBNBFOFTUPTEBT
antifundacionalismomSFEVKPOVFTUSPDPNQSPNJTPDPOMBDJFODJB
Z MB IJTUPSJPHSBGB USBEJDJPOBM -B EJTUJOUB QPTJDJO EF &VSPQB
FOFMNVOEPEFTEFFTVOTFHVOEPJOEJDBUJWPJNQPSUBOUF
-B IJTUPSJB EF FTUF BBEJEP BM DPOUJOFOUF FVSBTJUJDP ZB OP FT
IJTUPSJB NVOEJBM &M USPODP EFM SCPM EF MB IJTUPSJB PDDJEFOUBM
OPTHPMQFBBIPSBDPOFMIFDIPEFRVFTPMPFTQBSUFEFVOCPT-
RVF FOUFSP -PT meta-recits RVF OPT HVTUBSB SFMBUBSOPT BDFSDB
EFOVFTUSBIJTUPSJB
FMUSJVOGPEFMB3B[O
MBMVDIBHMPSJPTBQPS
MB FNBODJQBDJO EFM QSPMFUBSJBEP EF MPT USBCBKBEPSFT EFM TJHMP
9*9
UJFOFO TPMP VOB JNQPSUBODJB MPDBM Z QPS FTUB SB[O ZB OP
TPONFUBOBSSBDJPOFTBEFDVBEBT&MWJFOUPGSPRVFmEFBDVFSEP
DPO3PNFJOmTPQMBMSFEFEPSEFBMNJTNPUJFNQPUBOUPFO
0DDJEFOUFDPNPFO0SJFOUF32
BMOBMTFMMFWMBTIPKBTEFOVFT-
USPSCPMIJTUSJDPUBNCJOIBTUBMBTFHVOEBNJUBEEFMTJHMPXX.
-PRVFTJHVFBIPSBQBSBMBIJTUPSJPHSBGBPDDJEFOUBMFTSFVOJS
MBTIPKBTRVFTFDBZFSPOZFTUVEJBSMBT
TJOJNQPSUBSTVTPSHFOFT
&TUP TJHOJDB RVF OVFTUSB DPODJFODJB IJTUSJDB
QPS EFDJSMP BT
FTUEFDBCF[B"MSFDPHFSMBTIPKBTEFMQBTBEPEFMBNJTNBGPSNB
RVF-F3PZ-BEVSJFP(JO[CVSH
MPJNQPSUBOUFZBOPFTFMMVHBS
RVFPDVQBCBOFOFMSCPM
TJOPFMQBUSORVFQPEBNPTGPSNBSEF
FMMBTahora, MBNBOFSBFORVFFTUFQBUSOQVFEFBEBQUBSTFBPUSBT
GPSNBTEFDJWJMJ[BDJOFYJTUFOUFTIPZ&TDSJCJ3PSUZj%FTEFMPT
EBTEF(PFUIF
.BDBVMBZ
$BSMZMFZ&NFSTPO
TFEFTBSSPMMVOB
DMBTFEFFTDSJUPRVFOPFTMBFWBMVBDJOEFMPTNSJUPTSFMBUJWPT
EF MBT QSPEVDDJPOFT MJUFSBSJBT
OJ IJTUPSJB JOUFMFDUVBM
OJ MPTP-
32
+3PNFJOOp het breukvlak van twee eeuwen
WPM
"NTUFSEBN
%FCJEP B RVF FM NBSYJTNP DPNQBSUJ EJWFSTPT JEFBMFT QPMUJDPT Z TPDJBMFT
JNQPSUBOUFTDPOFM0DDJEFOUF
FMNBSYJTNPGVFFMEFTBGPNTTFSJPRVFFO-
GSFOU0DDJEFOUFEVSBOUFFTUFTJHMP1PSUBOUP
FTQPTJCMFRVFMBEFSSPUBEFM
NBSYJTNPFTUJNVMFEFOVFWPMBDPOBO[BEF0DDJEFOUFFOTNJTNPZFOTV
EFTBSSPMMPIJTUSJDP&TUPRVJ[QSPEV[DBVOSFOBDJNJFOUPEFMFTFODJBMJTNP
IJTUSJDPZUSJVOGBMJTNPFTUJMP'VLVZBNB
178
Historiografa postmoderna
GB NPSBM
OJ FQJTUFNPMPHB
OJ QSPGFDB TPDJBM
TJOP UPEBT FMMBT
NF[DMBEBTFOVOHOFSPOVFWPv33&OTVDPNFOUBSJPTPCSFFTUB
EFDMBSBDJOEF3PSUZ
$VMMFSTFBMBMBJOEJGFSFODJBDPOTJEFSBCMF
SFTQFDUPEFMPSJHFOZFMDPOUFYUP
IJTUSJDPPEFPUSBOEPMF
RVF
FTUBODBSBDUFSTUJDPEFjFTUBOVFWBDMBTFEFFTDSJUPv
33
$JUBEPFO$VMMFSDeconstruccin
Q
34
Ibid.
35
7BTF3),PTTNBO
De Functie van een Alpha- Faculteit
(SPOJOHB
,SPTTNBOPCTFSWBBTNJTNP
RVFMPTJEFBMFTEFMBildungEFOBMFTEFMTJHMP
179
-VJT(%F.VTTZr.JHVFM7BMEFSSBNB
97***ZEFM9*9ZBOPTFQVFEFOTPTUFOFSFOOVFTUSBQPDB%FTQVTEFUPEP
FTFWJEFOUFRVFVOJEFBMEFM#JMEVOHFOMBTJUVBDJOBDUVBMOPQVFEFTFSVO
QBUSOIPNPHOFP
QSFDFQUJWPEFFTUOEBSFTUJDPTZFTUUJDPTZFODPOEJ-
DJO KB .BT CJFO TFS MB GPSNB EF VO JOWFOUBSJP EF QPTJCMFT FTUOEBSFT
UJDPTZFTUUJDPT
EFPCKFUJWPTRVFTFBOQPTJCMFTZRVFBMNJTNPUJFNQPFO
MBIJTUPSJBMBIVNBOJEBEIBZBSFBMJ[BEP&MJEFBMQSFTFOUFEFMBildung
OPFT
QFSDFQUJWPTJOPEFTDSJQUJWP
OPFTDFSSBEP
TJOPBCJFSUPv<Q>
180
Historiografa postmoderna
PFODPOGPSNJEBEDPOFMQBTBEP
TJOPBQSFOEFSBKVHBSOVFTUSP
KVFHP DVMUVSBM DPO M 3PVTTFBV EFTDSJCJ MP RVF TJHOJDB FTUB
EFDMBSBDJOFOUSNJOPTDPODSFUPTQBSBFMJOEJWJEVPFOTVPCSB
Las ensoaciones del paseante solitario
)BZVOFTUBEPFORVFFMBMNBFODVFOUSBVOBTJFOUP
MP TVDJFOUFNFOUF TMJEP QBSB EFTDBOTBS UPEB FOUFSB Z
SFVOJSBMMUPEPTVTFS
TJOUFOFSOFDFTJEBEEFSFDPSEBSFM
QBTBEPOJEFTBMUBSTPCSFFMQPSWFOJS
FOFMRVFFMUJFNQP
OPTFBQBSBFMMB
PFOFMRVFFMQSFTFOUFEVSFTJFNQSFTJO
NBSDBS
OP PCTUBOUF TV EVSBDJO Z TJO IVFMMB BMHVOB EF
TVDFTJO36.
36
iUBUPVMBNFUSPVWFVOFBTTJFUUFBTTF[TPMJEFQPVSTZSFQPTFSUPVUFOUJFSF
FUSBTTFNCMFMBUPVUTPOFUSF
TBOTBWPJSCBTPJOEFSBQQFMFSMFQBTTOJEFO-
KBNCFSTVSMBWFOJSPVMFUFNQTOFTPJUSJFOQPVSFMMF
PVMFQSFTFOUEVSF
UPVKPVSTTBOTOBONPJOTNBSRVFSTBEVSFFUTBOTBVDVOFUSBDFEFTVDDFT-
TJPOv
+ + 3PVTTFBV
Les reveries du promeneur solitaire
1BSJT
Q
101.
37
Ibid.
181
-VJT(%F.VTTZr.JHVFM7BMEFSSBNB
182
Historiografa postmoderna
38
4'SFVEj5IF6ODBOOZvFO'SFVE
The Standard edition of the complete
Psycological norms of Sigmund Freud
-POESFT
Q
183
Historiografa postmoderna
.1
&
-PTMNJUFTEFMBIJTUPSJPHSBGBFMJUJTUBFOSFMBDJOBMTVCBM-
UFSOPOPDPOTUJUVZFOVOBTPSQSFTBUFSJDBQBSBMPT&TUVEJPT-B-
UJOPBNFSJDBOPT
RVF EFTEF IBDF NVDIP UJFNQP IBO USBCBKBEP
DPO FM TVQVFTUP EF RVF MB OBDJO Z MP OBDJPOBM TPO DPODFQUPT
UPUBMJ[BOUFTEFDBSDUFSOPQPQVMBS&MDPODFQUPZMBSFQSFTFOUB-
DJOEFMBTVCBMUFSOJEBEEFTBSSPMMBEPTQPSFM(SVQP4VEBTJUJDP
EF &TUVEJPT 4VCBMUFSOPT OP FODPOUSBSPO WJBCJMJEBE TJOP IBTUB
MPT BPT PDIFOUB
NJFOUSBT RVF MPT &TUVEJPT -BUJOPBNFSJDBOPT
IBCBOFTUBEPUSBCBKBOEPDPODPODFQUPTTJNJMBSFTEFTEFTVFT-
UBCMFDJNJFOUP DPNP SFB EF JOWFTUJHBDJO FO MPT BPT TFTFOUB
-BDPOTUJUVDJOEFFTUFDBNQPEFFTUVEJPT ZEFMB"TPDJBDJOEF
&TUVEJPT-BUJOPBNFSJDBOPTmLASAmDPNPTVTPQPSUFJOTUJUVDJP-
OBM
FO UBOUP RVF GPSNBDJO OFDFTBSJBNFOUF JOUFSEJTDJQMJOBSJB
DPSSFTQPOEFBMNPEPFORVFFMHSVQPTVEBTJUJDPDPODFQUVBMJ[B
BMTVCBMUFSOPDPNPVOTVKFUPRVFFNFSHFFOMPTJOUFSTUJDJPTEFMBT
EJTDJQMJOBTBDBENJDBT
EFTEFMBDSUJDBMPTDBEFMBNFUBGTJDB
PMBUFPSBMJUFSBSJBZDVMUVSBMDPOUFNQPSOFBT
IBTUBMBIJTUPSJB
ZMBTDJFODJBTTPDJBMFT4JOFNCBSHP
EFUSTEFMQSPCMFNBEFMTVC-
BMUFSOPTFFODVFOUSBMBOFDFTJEBEEFSFDPODFQUVBMJ[BSMBSFMBDJO
1
&TUF.BOJFTUPGVFQVCMJDBEPJOJDJBMNFOUFQPSMBSFWJTUBBoundary 2 WPM
ONFSP
ZSFJNQSFTPQPTUFSJPSNFOUFFOFMWPMVNFODPMFDUJWPThe Pos-
modernism Debate in Latin America
DPOFMUUVMPj'PVOEJOH4UBUFNFOUv
"HSBEFDFNPTB4BOUJBHP$BTUSP(NF[MBBVUPSJ[BDJOQBSBJODMVJSFOFTUB
TFDDJOTVUSBEVDDJODBTUFMMBOBEFj'PVOEJOH4UBUFNFOUv&ODBTUFMMBOP
MB
USBEVDDJOEF$BTUSP(NF[GVFQVCMJDBEBFOTeoras sin discplina
.YJ-
DP
1PSSB
185
-VJT(%F.VTTZr.JHVFM7BMEFSSBNB
FOUSFFMFTUBEP
MBOBDJOZFMjQVFCMPvFOMPTUSFTNPWJNJFOUPT
RVFIBOJOTQJSBEPZEBEPGPSNBBMPT&TUVEJPT-BUJOPBNFSJDB-
OPT ZB-BUJOPBNSJDBNJTNB
MBTSFWPMVDJPOFTNFYJDBOB
DV-
CBOBZOJDBSBHFOTF
2VJTJSBNPTFTCP[BSMBSFMBDJOFOUSFMBFNFSHFODJBEFMPT
&TUVEJPT -BUJOPBNFSJDBOPT Z FM QSPCMFNB EF MB DPODFQUVBMJ[B-
DJOEFMBTVCBMUFSOJEBEFOUSNJOPTEFUSFTHSBOEFTFUBQBT
EFT-
EFIBTUBFMQSFTFOUF
&
$PNPFTCJFOTBCJEP
BVORVFMBNBZPSBEFMPTQBTFTMBUJOPB-
NFSJDBOPTHBOBSPOTVJOEFQFOEFODJBFOFMTJHMP9*9
MPT&TUBEPT
OBDJPOBMFT SFTVMUBOUFT GVFSPO HPCFSOBEPT QSFEPNJOBOUFNFOUF
QPS DSJPMMPT CMBODPT RVF FTUBCMFDJFSPO SFHNFOFT DPMPOJBMFT JO-
UFSOPT DPO SFTQFDUP B MPT JOEJPT
MPT FTDMBWPT EFTDFOEJFOUFT EF
BGSJDBOPT
FMDBNQFTJOBEPNFTUJ[PZNVMBUP
PMPTOBDJFOUFTQSP-
MFUBSJBEPT -B SFWPMVDJO NFYJDBOB NBSD VOB EFTWJBDJO DPO
SFTQFDUPBFTUFNPEFMPCMBODP
QBUSJBSDBM
PMJHSRVJDPZFVSPDO-
USJDPEFEFTBSSPMMP
QVFTTFGVOEBCBFOMBBHFODJBEFMPTJOEJPTZ
MPTNFTUJ[PT
OPTPMPDPNPTPMEBEPTTJOPUBNCJODPNPMEFSFT
ZFTUSBUFHBTEFMMFWBOUBNJFOUPSFWPMVDJPOBSJP/PPCTUBOUF
EV-
SBOUFFM.YJDPQPTUSFWPMVDJPOBSJP
FOVOQSPDFTPRVFIBTJEP
BNQMJBNFOUFFTUVEJBEP
FTUFQSPUBHPOJTNPGVFCMPRVFBEPBOJ-
WFMFDPONJDP
QPMUJDPZDVMUVSBMmFOGBWPSEFMBFNFSHFOUFDMBTF
NFTUJ[B
BMUBPNFEJBmNFEJBOUFMBTVQSFTJOEFMBTDPNVOJEBEFT
ZMEFSFTJOEJPT
BTDPNPQPSMBSFTVCBMUFSOJ[BDJOEFMJOEJP
RVF
EFKEFTFSWJTUPDPNPVOTVKFUPIJTUSJDPQPMUJDPQBSBDPOWFS-
UJSTFFOBSUFGBDUPDVMUVSBMvWJODVMBEPBMOVFWPBQBSBUPFTUBUBM Q
FFOFMNVSBMJTNPNFYJDBOP
-B SFWPMVDJO DVCBOB SFQSFTFOU VOB SFDVQFSBDJO QBSDJBM
EFM JNQVMTP IBDJB MB FNFSHFODJB EFM TVCBMUFSOP
FO QBSUJDVMBS
HSBDJBTBMBDFOUPRVFPUPSHBMQSPCMFNBEFMDBSDUFSOPFVSPQFP
PQPTUFVSPQFP
EFMPTTVKFUPTTPDJBMFTFO"NSJDB-BUJOBFOFM
DPOUFYUPEFMBEFTDPMPOJ[BDJO
MFWBOUOEPTFBTGSFOUFBMBQSJ-
NBDBEFMBIJTUPSJPHSBGBFVSPDOUSJDBZGSFOUFBMPTQBSBEJHNBT
DVMUVSBMFTFTUBCMFDJEPT-BSFMFDUVSBRVFIJ[P3PCFSUP'FSOOEF[
186
Historiografa postmoderna
3FUBNBSEF'SBO['BOPOZEFMEJTDVSTPEFMJCFSBDJOOBDJPOBMFO
TVFOTBZP$BMJCOFTFKFNQMPEFVOBOVFWBDPODFQUVBMJ[BDJOEF
MBIJTUPSJBZMBJEFOUJEBEMBUJOPBNFSJDBOBT&TUFJNQVMTPBGFDU
OPTPMBNFOUFBFTDSJUPSFTEFMBoomDPNP.BSJP7BSHBT-MPTB
$BSMPT'VFOUFTZ(BCSJFM(BSDB.SRVF[
TJOPUBNCJOBDJFOU-
DPTTPDJBMFTDPNP"OES(VOEFS'SBOLZMPTUFSJDPTBMJBEPT
BMBFTDVFMBEFMBEFQFOEFODJB"NCPTHSVQPTDSFBOFOMBWJB-
CJMJEBEEFFTUBCMFDFSFO"NSJDB-BUJOBFDPOPNBTZTPDJFEBEFT
RVF jSPNQJFSBOv SBEJDBMNFOUF DPO MBT FTUSVDUVSBT EFM TJTUFNB
EPNJOBOUFVOBSVQUVSBRVF
BMNFOPTFOUFPSB
EFKBSBDBNQP
QBSBFMQSPUBHPOJTNPEFMPTTVKFUPTTVCBMUFSOPT
-BSFWPMVDJODVCBOBHFOFSQSDUJDBTDVMUVSBMFTZQPMUJDBT
JOTBUJTGFDIBTDPOMBSFQSFTFOUBDJOEFMBDMBTFNFEJBPBMUBDPNP
TVKFUP TPDJBM QPS FYDFMFODJB EF MB IJTUPSJB MBUJOPBNFSJDBOB &M
OVFWPQSFTUJHJPRVFMBSFWPMVDJOPUPSHBMNBSYJTNPFOUSFMPT
JOUFMFDUVBMFT MBUJOPBNFSJDBOPT Z MPT USBCBKBEPSFT DVMUVSBMFT HF-
OFSVOHSBOPQUJNJTNPZVOBDFSUF[BFQJTUFNPMHJDBSFTQFDUP
BMBTQPTJCJMJEBEFTEFMBTVCKFUJWJEBEIJTUSJDB&MDPODFQUPEFM
QVFCMPDPNPjNBTBUSBCBKBEPSBvTFDPOWJSUJFOFMOVFWPDFOUSP
EFMBSFQSFTFOUBDJO&OUSFMPTSFTVMUBEPTNTBQSFDJBCMFTEFFTUF
DBNCJP<FQJTUFNPMHJDP>FOMBFTGFSBEFMBDVMUVSBTFFODVFOUSBO
MPTEPDVNFOUBMFTEFMBFTDVFMBEF4BOUB'FDSFBEBFO"SHFOUJOB
QPS'FSOBOEP#JSSJ
MBTQFMDVMBTEFM$JOFNB/VPWPCSBTJMFPZ
EFM *$"*$DVCBOP
FMDPODFQUPEFMjDJOFQPQVMBSvEFTBSSPMMBEP
FO #PMJWJB QPS +PSHF 4BOKJOT Z FM HSVQP 6LBNV
FM jUFBUSP EF
DSFBDJODPMFDUJWBvFO$PMPNCJB
FMUFBUSP&TDBNCSBZFO$VCBZ
NPWJNJFOUPTBOFTFOMPT&TUBEPT6OJEPT
DPNPFMUFBUSPDBN-
QFTJOP
$POUPEP
BVODVBOEPFTUPTUSBCBKPTQSPCMFNBUJ[BCBOBTVO-
UPT EF HOFSP
SB[B Z MFOHVBKF
TV BDFOUP SFDBB FO MB FYJTUFO-
DJBEFVOTVKFUPDMBTJTUBVOJUBSJPZFOTVBTJNJMBDJOEFMPTUFY-
UPT UFSJDPTMJUFSBSJPT QSPEVDJEPT QPS VOB MJUF JOUFMFDUVBM RVF
TF JEFOUJDBCB DPO FTF TVKFUP
MP DVBM WFMBCB MB EJTQBSJEBE EF
OFHSPT
JOEJPT
DIJDBOPTZNVKFSFT
MPTNPEFMPTBMUFSOBUJWPTEF
TFYVBMJEBEZEFDPSQPSBMJEBE
BTDPNPMBFYJTUFODJBEFMjMVN-
QFOvZEFBRVFMMPTRVFOPIBCBOFOUSBEPFOQBDUPDPOFM&TUBEP
SFWPMVDJPOBSJP 6OBCVFOBESBNBUJ[BDJOEFFTUFQSPCMFNBRVF
TJOFNCBSHP
FTQBSUFEFMQSPCMFNBQPSTVGPSNBEFQSFTFOUBSMP
187
-VJT(%F.VTTZr.JHVFM7BMEFSSBNB
GVFFMFYBNFORVFIJ[PMBDVCBOB4BSB(NF[FOTVQFMDVMBDe
cierta maneraEFBTVOUPTSFGFSFOUFTBMBDMBTF
MBSB[BZFMHOFSP
FO MB $VCB QPTUSFWPMVDJPOBSJB
&M TVKFUP EF MB IJTUPSJB OP GVF
QVFTUP KBNT FO EVEB
DPNP UBNQPDP MB JEPOFJEBE EF TVT SF-
QSFTFOUBDJPOFT UBOUPFOFMTFOUJEPNJNUJDPDPNPQPMUJDP
QPS
QBSUFEFMBTTFDUBTSFWPMVDJPOBSJBT
QPSMBTOVFWBTGPSNBTEFBSUF
ZDVMUVSB
PQPSMPTOVFWPTQBSBEJHNBTUFSJDPTDPNPMBUFPSB
EFMBEFQFOEFODJBPFMNBSYJTNPBMUIVTFSJBOP
4
188
Historiografa postmoderna
&OFMDBNQPEFMBQSPEVDDJODVMUVSBM
MBFNFSHFODJBEFGPS-
NBT EPDVNFOUBMFT P UFTUJNPOJBMFT EFTQMB[ MPT QBSNFUSPT EF
SFQSFTFOUBDJO GVOEBEPT FO MB BDUJWJEBE EF MPT FTDSJUPSFT Z MBT
WBOHVBSEJBT"EJGFSFODJBEFMBBNCJDJONPTUSBEBQPSMPTOPWF-
MJTUBTEFMBoomEFjIBCMBSQPSv"NSJDB-BUJOB
MPTTVKFUPTTVC-
BMUFSOPTSFQSFTFOUBEPTFOMPTUFYUPTUFTUJNPOJBMFTTFDPOWJSUJFSPO
FOQBSUFNJTNBEFMBDPOTUSVDDJOUFYUVBM-BJOTBUJTGBDDJODPO
MBFTUSBUFHJBNFUBDDJPOBMZNBTDVMJOBEFMPTBVUPSFTEFMBoom,
DPOEVKPBVOOVFWPOGBTJTFOMPDPODSFUP
FOMPQFSTPOBM
FOMBT
jQFRVFBT IJTUPSJBTv
FO MB FTDSJUVSB P MBT QFMDVMBT
QSPEVDJ-
EBTQPSNVKFSFT
MVNQFO
IPNPTFYVBMFTZQSJTJPOFSPTQPMUJDPT
HFOFSOEPTFFOFTUFQSPDFTPMBQSFHVOUBEFRVJOSFQSFTFOUBB
RVJO4JNVMUOFBNFOUF
FOFMNCJUPEFMBDSUJDBMJUFSBSJBOBDJ
MBQSPQVFTUBEFDPOTUSVJSVOBjIJTUPSJBTPDJBMvEFMBMJUFSBUVSB
MBUJOPBNFSJDBOB
DPODSFUJ[BEBFOQSPZFDUPTUBMFTDPNPFMHSVQP
EF MJUFSBUVSB F JEFPMPHB FO MB 6OJWFSTJEBE EF .JOOFTPUB Z FM
$FOUSPEF&TUVEJPT-BUJOPBNFSJDBOPT3NVMP(BMMFHPTFO$B-
SBDBT
BNCBTJOJDJBUJWBTGVFSPOBQPZBEBTQPSMBHSBOEJTQPSBEF
JOUFMFDUVBMFTEFJ[RVJFSEBQSPWFOJFOUFTEFM$POP4VSFOMPTBPT
QPTUFSJPSFTB
&TUB FUBQB NBSDB UBNCJO MB JOUSPEVDDJO FO -BUJOPBNSJ-
DBEFMQPTUFTUSVDUVSBMJTNPGSBODT
FMNBSYJTNPHSBNTDJBOPZMB
&TDVFMBEF'SBOLGVSU
RVFTJSWJFSPOQBSBEFTFTUBCJMJ[BSBMHVOPT
QSFTVQVFTUPTWJHFOUFTFOFMNBSYJTNPPSUPEPYPEFMPTTFTFOUB
Z
UBNCJOFOMPTQBSBEJHNBTEFjNPEFSOJ[BDJOvHFOFSBEPTQPS
MBTDJFODJBTTPDJBMFTOPSUFBNFSJDBOBT-BSFDFQDJOMBUJOPBNFSJ-
DBOBEFMBPCSBEF#BLIUJO
7PMPTIJOPW
-PUNBOZMB&TDVFMBEF
5BSUV
BTDPNPEFMPTFTUVEJPTDVMUVSBMFTQSPWFOJFOUFTEF(SBO
#SFUBBZMPT&TUBEPT6OJEPT
TJSWJFSPOQBSBSFTQPOEFSBMGPSNB-
MJTNPEFMBTFNJUJDBFTUSVDUVSBMJTUB
BDFOUVBOEPMBIFUFSPHMPTJB
FMEJBMPHJTNPZMBNVMUJQMJDJEBEEFMPTEJTDVSTPTZEFMBTQSDUJ-
DBTTJHOJDBOUFT
5
189
-VJT(%F.VTTZr.JHVFM7BMEFSSBNB
GVFOUFTQSJNBSJBTEFSFGFSFODJBEVSBOUFFTUBFUBQB-BTQBMBCSBT
DMBWFT GVFSPO jDVMUVSBv
jEFNPDSBUJ[BDJOv
jHMPCBMJ[BDJOv Z
BMHVOPTjQPTUv QPTUNBSYJTNP
QPTUNPEFSOJTNP
QPTUFTUSVDUV-
SBMJTNP
'PSNBTFTUBCMFDJEBTEFMBDVMUVSBBMUB
DPNPQPSFKFN-
QMPMBMJUFSBUVSB
GVFSPODVFTUJPOBEBTQPSMBDSUJDBRVFEFTBSSP-
MMBSPO MB EFDPOTUSVDDJO
FM GFNJOJTNP Z MPT FTUVEJPT OFHSPT Z
DIJDBOPT FO MPT &TUBEPT 6OJEPT
TJFOEP SFFNQMB[BEBT QPS VOB
WJTJO BOUSPQPMHJDB EF MB DVMUVSB DPNP jFYQFSJFODJB WJWJEBv
&ODPODPSEBODJBDPOMBFNFSHFODJBEFQSPZFDUPTDPNPFM(SV-
QPEF&TUVEJPT4VCBMUFSOPTPFM$FOUSPEF&TUVEJPT$VMUVSBMFT
FO#JSNJOHIBNEJSJHJEPQPSFMKBNBJRVJOP4UVBSU)BMM
MPTMBUJ-
OPBNFSJDBOJTUBTFNQF[BSPOBDSJUJDBSMBQFSTJTUFODJBEFTJTUFNBT
DPMPOJBMFTPOFPDPMPOJBMFTEFSFQSFTFOUBDJOFO"NSJDB-BUJOB2.
4FUFOBMBTFOTBDJOEFRVFMBTEJONJDBTQPMUJDBTZDVMUVSBMFT
IBCBODPNFO[BEPBGVODJPOBSFOVODPOUFYUPHMPCBM
RVFUPS-
OBCBQSPCMFNUJDPFMNPEFMPDFOUSPQFSJGFSJBEFMBUFPSBEFMB
EFQFOEFODJB
BTDPNPMBTFTUSBUFHJBTOBDJPOBMJTUBTRVFMPBDPN-
QBBCBO FMOBMEFMDJDMPEFDSFDJNJFOUPEFMPTTFTFOUBZMBDSJ-
TJTEFMFOEFVEBNJFOUPGVFSPO
EFIFDIP
MPTFWFOUPTFDPONJDPT
QSFEPNJOBOUFTEVSBOUFUPEBMBEDBEB
&MSQJEPEFTBSSPMMPZFYQBOTJOEFMPTNFEJPTEFJOGPSNB-
DJO GVF MB DBSBDUFSTUJDB UFDOPMHJDB NT JNQPSUBOUF EVSBOUF
FTUBFUBQB
QFSNJUJFOEP
FOUSFPUSBTDPTBT
MBFOUSBEBZEJGVTJO
FOMPTOVFWPTDJSDVJUPTHMPCBMFTEFUFYUPTZQSDUJDBTDVMUVSBMFT
QSPWFOJFOUFTEFSFBTRVFBOUFSJPSNFOUFQFSUFOFDBOBMNVOEP
DPMPOJBM MBQVCMJDBDJO
SFDFQDJOZDFOUSBMJEBEBMDBO[BEBQPSFM
MJCSPEF3JHPCFSUB.FODIFOFMEFCBUFFTUBEPVOJEFOTFTPCSFFM
NVMUJDVMUVSBMJTNPFTUBOTPMPVOQFRVFPFKFNQMPEFMBTOVFWBT
GPSNBTFORVFMPTPCKFUPTDVMUVSBMFTTPODSFBEPTZBENJOJTUSB-
EPT
(SBDJBTBMBQSPMJGFSBDJOEFMBUFMFWJTJO
MBUFMFOPWFMBTF
DPOWJSUJFOMBGPSNBDVMUVSBMEPNJOBOUFFO"NSJDB-BUJOBZMBT
DJFODJBTEFMBDPNVOJDBDJOJSSVNQJFSPODPNPFMSFBEFNBZPS
DSFDJNJFOUPBDBENJDP
&TUFFTQSFDJTBNFOUFFMNPNFOUPFORVFFNFSHFOMPTFTUV-
EJPTDVMUVSBMFTFOMBVOJWFSTJEBEBOHMPBNFSJDBOB
JNQVMTBEPT
QPS MB DPOKVODJO FOUSF FM GFNJOJTNP
MB DSUJDB EFM EJTDVSTP
DPMPOJBM
OVFWBT GPSNBT EF NBSYJTNP Z UFPSB EF MB TPDJFEBE
2
OHFM3BNB
La ciudad letrada
)BOPWFS
&EJDJPOFTEFM/PSUF
190
Historiografa postmoderna
$
191
-VJT(%F.VTTZr.JHVFM7BMEFSSBNB
-PRVFRVFEBDMBSPFOFMUSBCBKPEFM(SVQP4VEBTJUJDPEF
&TUVEJPT4VCBMUFSOPTFTFMBYJPNBEFRVFMBTMJUFTSFQSFTFOUB-
EBTQPSMBCVSHVFTBOBDJPOBMZPMBBENJOJTUSBDJODPMPOJBMTPO
SFTQPOTBCMFT EF IBCFS JOWFOUBEP MB JEFPMPHB Z MB SFBMJEBE EFM
OBDJPOBMJTNP4VGPSNBEFNJSBSMBTDPTBTTFVCJDBFOFMQVOUP
EFJOUFSTFDDJODSFBEPFOUSFFMBOUJHVPQPEFSDPMPOJBMZFMGVUVSP
TJTUFNBQPTDPMPOJBMEFM&TUBEPOBDJO
FOEPOEFFMMBTPDVQBSBO
VOQBQFMIFHFNOJDP&MQSPCMFNBDFOUSBMEFMBQPTDPMPOJBMJEBE
FT MP RVF (VIB MMBNBTF jMB JODBQBDJEBE IJTUSJDB EF MB OBDJO
QBSB SFBMJ[BSTF B T NJTNBv3
JODBQBDJEBE EFCJEB BM MJEFSB[HP
JOBEFDVBEPEFMBTMJUFTHPCFSOBOUFT-BOVFWBFDPOPNBQPM-
UJDBHMPCBMUSBFDPOTJHPMBOFDFTJEBEDPODFQUVBMEFEFDPOTUSVJS
MPTQBSBEJHNBTEFMBOBDJOZMBJOEFQFOEFODJB
MPDVBMFYQMJDB
MPTDBNCJPTRVFWJFOFFYQFSJNFOUBEPMUJNBNFOUFMBUFSNJOPMP-
HBEFMBTDJFODJBTTPDJBMFT$PODFQUPTUBMFTDPNPjQMVSBMJTNPv
jEFNPDSBDJBv
jDPOTFOTPv
jTVCBMUFSOJEBEv
jEFTQMB[BNJFOUPT
EFQPEFSv
jOVFWPPSEFONVOEJBMvZj(SBOSFBvTPOFKFNQMPT
EF UBM NVUBDJO &MMPT IBO TVTUJUVJEP B DPODFQUPT DPNP jNP-
EFSOJ[BDJOv
jEJDUBEVSBv
jQBSUJEPv
jSFWPMVDJOv
jDFOUSPQF-
SJGFSJBv
jEFTBSSPMMPv
jOBDJPOBMJTNPvZjMJCFSBDJOOBDJPOBMv
6OPEFOVFTUSPTQSPQTJUPTDFOUSBMFTFTSBTUSFBSFMNPEPFORVF
MPTDPODFQUPTNVEBO
ZMPRVFTJHOJDBMBVUJMJ[BDJOEFVOBEF-
UFSNJOBEBUFSNJOPMPHB
"EFNTEFDPODFQUVBMJ[BSMBOBDJODPNPVOFTQBDJPEVBM
MJUFT NFUSPQPMJUBOBT MJUFT DSJPMMBT MJUFT DSJPMMBT HSVQPT
TVCBMUFSOPT
FM FTUVEJP EF MB TVCBMUFSOJEBE FO "NSJDB -BUJ-
OBJODMVZFPUSBTEJDPUPNBTFTUSVDUVSBMFT"MTFSVOFTQBDJPEF
DPOUSBQPTJDJOZDPMJTJO
MBOBDJODPOUJFOFNMUJQMFTGSBDUVSBT
EFMFOHVB
SB[B
FUOJB
HOFSP
DMBTF
ZMBTUFOTJPOFTSFTVMUBOUFT
FOUSFBTJNJMBDJO EFCJMJUBNJFOUPEFMBTEJGFSFODJBTUOJDBT
IP-
NPHFOJ[BDJO
ZDPOGSPOUBDJO SFTJTUFODJBQBTJWB
JOTVSHFODJB
NBOJGFTUBDJPOFTEFQSPUFTUB
UFSSPSJTNP
&MTVCBMUFSOPBQBSFDF
FOUPODFT DPNP VO TVKFUP jNJHSBOUFv
UBOUP FO TVT QSPQJBT SF-
QSFTFOUBDJPOFT DVMUVSBMFT DPNP FO MB OBUVSBMF[B DBNCJBOUF EF
TVTQBDUPTDPOFM&TUBEPOBDJO%FBDVFSEPBMBTOBSSBUJWBTEFM
3
3BOBKJU (VIB
j1SFGBDFv
3BOBKJU (VIB BOE (BZBUSJ $IBLSBWPSUZ 4QJWBL
FET
Selected Subalternal Studies
/VFWB:PSL
0YGPSE6OJWFSTJUZ1SFTT
1988.
192
Historiografa postmoderna
193
-VJT(%F.VTTZr.JHVFM7BMEFSSBNB
TFHVOEBNFUSQPMJNTHSBOEFEF.YJDP y0TJDPOTJEFSBNPT
BMBQPCMBDJOBGSPBNFSJDBOBZBOHMPQBSMBOUFEFMBDPTUBOPSUF
EF/JDBSBHVB
RVFTFDPOTJEFSBOBTNJTNPTjDSJPMMPTvZDVZBT
QSFGFSFODJBTDVMUVSBMFTJODMVZFOMBNTJDBcountryOPSUFBNFSJDB-
OBZFMreggaeKBNBJRVJOP
&TUBJOTJTUFODJBFONJSBSBMTVCBMUFSOPEFTEFFMQVOUPEFWJTUB
EFMBQPTNPEFSOJEBE
OPTJHOJDBRVFSFIVTFNPTQFSTFHVJSMPT
SBTUSPT RVF IBO EFKBEP BOUFSJPSFT IFHFNPOBT DVMUVSBMFT FO MB
GPSNBDJOEFMTVCBMUFSOPZEFMBTDPSSFTQPOEJFOUFTMJUFTMPDBMFT
1PEFNPT IBMMBS BM TVCBMUFSOP OJDBNFOUF FO MPT MJOEFSPT BSUJ-
DVMBEPT QPS BOUJHVBT QSDUJDBT TPDJPDVMUVSBMFT
FQJTUFNPMHJDBT
Z BENJOJTUSBUJWBT
FO MB IJCSJEBDJO IJTUSJDB EF NFOUBMJEBEFT
DVMUVSBMFTZFOMPTQBDUPTDPOUJOHFOUFTRVFTFEBODBEBWF[RVF
PDVSSFVOFNQBMNFUSBOTJDJPOBM%FBDVFSEPBMBOBSSBUJWBEFMBT
FMJUFT
FMOBDJPOBMJTNPFTVOBBWFOUVSBJEFBMJTUBDPOEVDJEBQPS
FMMBTNJTNBT
HVJBEBFOQBSUFQPSFMJEFBMjMJUFSBSJPvEFMBOB-
DJPOBMJEBE1SFUFOEJFOEPBMUSVJTNPZBVUPBCOFHBDJO
MBTMJUFT
DSJPMMBT
DPOTVBOUBHPOJTNPGSFOUFBMDPMPOJ[BEPS
JOWPDBSPOMB
CPOEBEEFMQVFCMPZEFMBTDMBTFTTVCBMUFSOBT
FOMVHBSEFCVTDBS
MPTNFEJPTQBSBTVQSPNPDJOTPDJBM-BIJTUPSJBEFMBTCVSHVF-
TBT OBDJPOBMFT TF DPOWJFSUF BT FO MB BVUP
CJPHSBGB FTQJSJUVBM
EFMBTMJUFT
IFDIPRVFDPOUSJCVZFEFDJTJWBNFOUFBMBGPSNBDJO
QPMUJDBZDVMUVSBMEFMPTTVCBMUFSOPT FTFMDBTP
QPSFKFNQMP
EF
MBSFTJTUFODJBGSFOUFBMBDVMUVSBMFUSBEBEFMJEJPNBFTQBPMFOBM-
HVOBTSFBTJOEHFOBT
ZGSFOUFBMBjDVMUVSBBMUBvFOHFOFSBMQPS
QBSUFEFMPTHSVQPTTVCBMUFSOPT
&MOPSFDPOPDJNJFOUPEFMBDPO-
USJCVDJOEFMTVCBMUFSOPBMBDSFBDJOEFTVQSPQJBIJTUPSJBSFWFMB
MB QPCSF[B EF MB IJTUPSJPHSBGB <JMVTUSBEB> Z TFBMB MBT SB[POFT
QPSMBTDVBMFTGSBDBTBSPOMPTQSPHSBNBTOBDJPOBMJTUBTEFQSPNP-
DJOQPQVMBS&MUSBOTOBDJPOBMJTNPEFMTVCBMUFSOPFTSFHJTUSBEP
TPMPDPNPVOQSPCMFNBEFMFZZPSEFOP
QPTJUJWBNFOUF
DPNP
VOBSFTQVFTUBBMDBSJTNBEFMPTMEFSFTEFMBMJUF
FTEFDJS
DPNP
VOBNPWJMJ[BDJOWFSUJDBM BUSBWTEFMBNBOJQVMBDJOmassme-
diticaZQPQVMJTUB
QPSQBSUFEFDJFSUPTHSVQPTZGBDDJPOFT
3FQSFTFOUBSTFMBTVCBMUFSOJEBEFO"NSJDB-BUJOB
DVBMRVJF-
SBRVFTFBMBGPSNBFORVFFMMBBQBSFDF OBDJO
IBDJFOEB
MVHBS
EFUSBCBKP
IPHBS
TFDUPSJOGPSNBM
NFSDBEPOFHSP
FODPOUSBSFM
locusFOEPOEFFMMBIBCMBDPNPTVKFUPQPMUJDPZTPDJBM
SFRVJFSF
194
Historiografa postmoderna
VOBFYQMPSBDJOEFMPTNSHFOFTEFM&TUBEP*OTJTUJNPTFOOVFT-
USB QSFNJTB CTJDB MB OBDJO
DPNP FTQBDJP DPODFQUVBM
OP FT
JEOUJDBBMBOBDJODPNP&TUBEP/VFTUSPBQBSBUPDPODFQUVBM
BERVJFSF
QPSFMMP
VOBDPOOPUBDJONTHFPHSDBRVFJOTUJUV-
DJPOBM:OVFTUSBFTUSBUFHJBEFJOWFTUJHBDJOOPTPCMJHBBSFBMJ[BS
VOUSBCBKPBSRVFPMHJDPFOMPTJOUFSTUJDJPTBCJFSUPTQPSMBTGPS-
NBTEFEPNJOBDJO MFZZPSEFO
QPEFSNJMJUBSPQPMJDJBM
FJOUF-
HSBDJO BQSFOEJ[BKFZFTDPMBSJEBE
&NQFSP
EFTEFMBQFSTQFDUJ-
WBEFMTVCBMUFSOPBNCBTDPTBT
MBQPMJDBZFMNBFTUSP
QVEJFSBO
BQBSFDFSDPNPFTUSBUFHJBTNVZCJFODPPSEJOBEBTBMJOUFSJPSEF
VOQSPZFDUPUSBOTOBDJPOBMEFFYQSPQJBDJOFDPONJDBZBENJ-
OJTUSBDJO UFSSJUPSJBM "M DPODFQUVBMJ[BS MB TVCBMUFSOJEBE EFCF-
NPT
QPSFMMP
UFOFSNVDIPDVJEBEPFOOPDPMPDBSOPTBOPTPUSPT
NJTNPTFOMBQPTJDJOEFMFUSBEPTTVCBMUFSOPT NVZDPNOFO
BSUJDVMBDJPOFTQSFWJBTEFMEJTDVSTPEFjMJCFSBDJOOBDJPOBMv
QPS
FKFNQMP FO BMHVOBT GPSNBT EFM OBDJPOBMJTNP QVFSUPSSJRVFP P
EFMBSJFMJTNPMJUFSBSJPMBUJOPBNFSJDBOP
FTEFDJS
FOMBQPTJDJO
EF USBOTDSJQUPSFT
USBEVDUPSFT
JOUSQSFUFT P FEJUPSFT EF FWJUBS
FO PUSBT QBMBCSBT
MB DPOTUSVDDJO EF VOB intelligentsia QPTDP-
MPOJBMVCJDBEBFOMPTDFOUSPTDVMUVSBMFTIFHFNOJDPT$POFTUP
OPRVFSFNPTPCWJBSFMQSPCMFNB
TJOPTJNQMFNFOUFJOEJDBSRVF
QFSNBOFDFSFOGPDBEPTFOMBBDUJWJEBEEFMBintelligentsiaZFOTVT
QSDUJDBTDBSBDUFSTUJDBT DFOUSBEBTFOFMDVMUJWPEFMBFTDSJUVSB
MB
DJFODJB
FUD
OPTEFKBSBUPEBWBFOBRVFMFTQBDJPEFjDFHVFSBv
ZEFQSFKVJDJPIJTUPSJPHSDPRVF(VIBDSJUJDBSBFOTVTFTUVEJPT
TPCSFMBJOTVSSFDDJODBNQFTJOB4.
&OMBNFEJEBFORVFMBOBDJOZMPOBDJPOBMTFBOSFQFOTB-
EBTDPNPDBUFHPSBTWBSJPQJOUBTRVFPTDJMBOFOUSFFMDSJPMMPZFM
NFTUJ[P
FOUSFFMNFTUJ[PZFMNVMBUPIBTUBFMOFHSPPFMJOEJP
FOUSFFMIPNCSFZMBNVKFS
OPTBDFSDBSFNPTNTBMBJEFBEFUF-
SSJUPSJBMJEBE FTQBDJPT
SFBT
HFPHSBGBT
RVFCVTDBNPTEJCVKBS
&OPUSBTQBMBCSBT
FMTVKFUPTPDJBMEFTJOTUJUVDJPOBMJ[BEPFJOUFS-
OBDJPOBMJ[BEPFTFMRVFDPOSNBMBTFTUSVDUVSBTEFHMPCBMJ[BDJO
Z EF DPOUSPM EF MB QPCMBDJO UBOUP QPMUJDP DPNP CJPMHJDP
3FDPOPDFSMBQSFTFODJBEFFTUFTVKFUPFTJNQPSUBOUFQBSBWFSEF
4
3BOBKJU(VIB
j0O4PNF"TQFDUTPGUIF)JTUPSJPHSBQIZPG$PMPOJBM*OEJBv
3BOBKJU(VIBBOE(BZBUSJ$IBLSBWPSUZ4QJWBL FET
Selected Subalternal
Studies
PQDJU
QQ
195
-VJT(%F.VTTZr.JHVFM7BMEFSSBNB
5
$BSMPT 7JMBT
The Sandinista Revolution: National Liberation and Social
Transformation in Central America
/VFWB:PSL
.POUIMZ 3FWJFX 1SFTT
1986.
196
Historiografa postmoderna
VO TVKFUP RVF MPT MFUSBEPT OP IBCBNPT SFDPOPDJEP Z RVF OPT
JOUFSQFMB QBSB NPTUSBSOPT RV UBOUP FTUCBNPT FRVJWPDBEPT
EFCFDPOGSPOUBSTFDPOMBSFTJTUFODJBEFMTVCBMUFSOPGSFOUFBMBT
DPODFQUVBMJ[BDJPOFTEFMBMJUF/PTFUSBUB
QPSFMMP
EFEFTBSSP-
MMBSOVFWPTNUPEPTQBSBFTUVEJBSBMTVCBMUFSOP
OVFWBTZNT
FDBDFTGPSNBTEFPCUFOFSJOGPSNBDJO
TJOPEFDPOTUSVJSOVFWBT
SFMBDJPOFT FOUSF OPTPUSPT Z BRVFMMPT TFSFT IVNBOPT RVF UPNB-
NPTDPNPPCKFUPEFFTUVEJP-BTQBMBCSBTEF3JHPCFSUB.FODI
BMOBMEFTVGBNPTPUFTUJNPOJPTPOSFMFWBOUFTFOFTUFDPOUFYUP
j$POTFSWPUPEBWBTFDSFUPTRVFOBEJFQVFEFDPOPDFS/JTJRVJFSB
MPTBOUSPQMPHPTZMPTJOUFMFDUVBMFT
OPJNQPSUBDVOUPTMJCSPT
IBZBOFTDSJUP
QVFEFOEFTDVCSJSUPEPTOVFTUSPTTFDSFUPTv6.
5SBEVDDJO4BOUJBHP$BTUSP(NF[
6
3JHPCFSUB.FODI
I Rigoberta Mench: An Indian Woman in Guatemala
-POESFT
7FSTP
197
Historiografa postmoderna
-
Un manifiesto*
Walter Mignolo
1
&TUFBSUDVMPFTQSPEVDUPEFMBJOWFTUJHBDJOSFBMJ[BEBFOMB6OJWFSTJEBEEF
%VLF
TPCSF QFOTBNJFOUP EFTDPMPOJBM
UFPSB QPMUJDB EFTDPMPOJBM Z HFP
QPMUJDBEFMDPOPDJNJFOUP
FOFMNBSDPEFMBNPEFSOJEBEDPMPOJBMJEBEZMB
FQJTUFNPMPHBGSPOUFSJ[B
199
-VJT(%F.VTTZr.JHVFM7BMEFSSBNB
2
&MFNQMFPEFEFDPMPOJBM
FOWF[EFEFTDPMPOJBM DPOPTJOHVJO
MPQSP-
QVTP $BUIFSJOF 8BMTI DPNP NBOFSB EF EJTUJOHVJS FOUSF MB QSPQVFTUB EF
DPMPOJBMEFMQSPZFDUPNPEFSOJEBEDPMPOJBMJEBE
QPSVOMBEP
EFMDPODFQUP
EFjEFTDPMPOJ[BDJOvFOFMVTPRVFTFMFEJPEVSBOUFMB(VFSSB'SB
Z
QPS
PUSP
EFMBWBSJFEBEEFVTPTEFMDPODFQUPEFjQPTUDPMPOJBMJEBEv1SFTVQPO-
HP RVF FM QFOTBNJFOUP EFDPMPOJBM FT DSUJDP EF QPS T
QFSP DSUJDP FO VO
TFOUJEPEJTUJOUPBMRVFMFEJP*NNBOVFM,BOUBMBQBMBCSBZ
FOFTBUSBEJDJO
MBSFUPN.BY)PSLIFJNFSBUSBWTEFMMFHBEPNBSYJTUBj%FTDPMPOJBMvFT
FMDPODFQUPRVFUPNBFMMVHBS
FOPUSBHFOFBMPHBEFQFOTBNJFOUPRVFFTVOP
EFMPTPCKFUJWPTEFFTUFBSUDVMPEFMDPODFQUPjDSUJDPvFOFMQFOTBNJFOUP
NPEFSOP EF EJTFOTP FO &VSPQB &TUB EJTUJODJO RVF NPUJW QSFDJTBNFOUF
FMFODVFOUSPFO%VLFBMRVFBMVEJSFOTFHVJEBTFWFSNTDMBSPFOFMSFTUP
EFMBSHVNFOUP&MQSPZFDUPEFDPMPOJBMEJFSFUBNCJOEFMQSPZFDUPQPTU
DPMPOJBM
BVORVFNBOUJFOFDPOFMQSJNFSPCVFOBTSFMBDJPOFTEFWFDJOEBSJP
-BUFPSBQPTUDPMPOJBMPMPTFTUVEJPTQPTUDPMPOJBMFTFTUOBDBCBMMPFOUSF
MBUFPSBDSUJDBFO&VSPQB 'PVDBVMU
-BDBOZ%FSSJEB
TPCSFDVZPQFOTB-
NJFOUPTFDPOTUSVZMBUFPSBQPTUDPMPOJBMZPFTUVEJPTQPTUDPMPOJBMFT
ZMBT
FYQFSJFODJBTEFMBFMJUFJOUFMFDUVBMFOMBTFYDPMPOJBTJOHMFTBTFO"TJBZGSJDB
EFM/PSUF
200
Historiografa postmoderna
3
&MDPOUSBBSHVNFOUPQPMUJDBNFOUFDPSSFDUPFTPCKFUBSFMTJOHVMBSZFOGBUJ[BS
FMQMVSBM1PSDJFSUP
FMDSJTUJBOJTNP
ZNVDIPTFKFNQMPTTFNFKBOUFT
FTEJWFS-
TP
WBSJBEP
DPOUSBEJDUPSJP
DPONVDIPTDPMPSFT
FUD
QFSPIBZVONPNFOUP
FORVFFMDSJTUJBOJTNPOPTFDPOGVOEFOJDPOFMJTMBNJTNPOJDPOFMKVEBTNP
-BEJWFSTJEBEZQMVSBMJEBEDSJTUJBOBUJFOFTVQVOUPTJOHVMBSFMQVOUPFORVF
FTQPTJCMFEJGFSFODJBSTFOPTPMPDPOFMJTMBNJTNPZFMKVEBTNP
TJOPUBNCJO
DPOFMDSJTUJBOJTNPPSUPEPYP
4
6OFKFNQMPDPOUVOEFOUFDSUJDBEFDPMPOJBMBMPTNJUPTEFMBDJFODJB
TPOMPT
BSHVNFOUPT EF7JOF +S %FMPSJB OBUJWP BNFSJDBOP EFM HSVQP TJPVY
BCP-
HBEP
MTPGP Z BDUJWJTUB
EFTNPOUBOEP MPT BSUJDJPT FO MPT EFCBUFT FOUSF
jDSFBDJPOJTUBTv Z jFWPMVDJPOJTUBTv 4V DPOPDJNJFOUP EFM DPOPDJNJFOUP EF
TVTBODFTUSPT
PEFMBFQJTUFNPMPHBBODFTUSBM```RVOPTFEFSJWBEFMBFQJTUF-
NPMPHBHSJFHB
MFQFSNJUFFOUSBSFOEFCBUFBSHVNFOUBOEPBQBSUJSEFOPS-
NBTEFMDPOPDFSEFTQSFOEJEBTEFMBTSFHMBTBVUPJNQVFTUBTQPSDSFBDJPOJTUBT
ZFWPMVDJPOJTUBT&MSFTVMUBEPFTVOBSHVNFOUP QFOTBNJFOUP
EFDPMPOJBM
&TUPFT
EFDPMPOJ[BDJOEFMDPOPDJNJFOUPDJFOUDPZMJCFSBDJOEFGPSNBT
EFDPOPDFSTJMFODJBEBTZNBSHJOBMJ[BEBTQPSMBSFUSJDBNPEFSOBPDDJEFOUBM
ZFQJTUNJDBJNQFSJBM
EFMBjDJFODJBv7BTF
7JOF+S%FMPSJB
Evolution,
Creationism and Other Modern Myths
(PMEFO $PMPSBEP
'VMDSVN 1V-
CJTIJOH
201
-VJT(%F.VTTZr.JHVFM7BMEFSSBNB
*1
&ONBZPEFM"SUVSP&TDPCBSZZPSFVOJNPTBMDPMFDUJ-
WPEFMQSPZFDUPNPEFSOJEBEDPMPOJBMJEBEFO%VLF
6OJWFSTJEBE
EF$BSPMJOBEFM/PSUF
FO$IBQFM)JMM&MUFNBEFFTUBSFVOJO
GVFj5FPSB
DSUJDBZEFTDPMPOJ[BDJOv-PTQBSUJDJQBOUFTGVFSPO
JOWJUBEPTDPOBOUFMBDJOBSFFYJPOBSTPCSFFMBTVOUPTJHVJFOUF
yRVOPTQBSFDFIPZFMQSPZFDUPEF)PSLIFJNFSEFVOBjUFPSB
DSUJDBv
DVBOEPFTUOUFOJFOEPMVHBSjSFWPMVDJPOFTvHMPCBMFTZ
QMVSJWFSTBMFT
BQBSUJSEFMBEJWFSTJEBEZQMVSJWFSTJEBEEFMBTNV-
DIBTIJTUPSJBTMPDBMFT
RVFFOMPTMUJNPTBPT BMHVOBTFO
MPTMUJNPTPRVJ[TPMPDJODVFOUBBPT
OPQVEJFSPOFWJUBS
FMDPOUBDUP
FMDPOJDUPZMBDPNQMJDJEBEDPO0DDJEFOUF FTEFDJS
DPOFMDSJTUJBOJTNPPDDJEFOUBM
TVTFDVMBSJ[BDJOZSFMBDJODPO
FMDBQJUBMJTNPZTVBOWFSTP
FMNBSYJTNP
y$VMEFCJFSBTFSFM
PCKFUJWPEFMBjUFPSBDSUJDBvDVBOEPMPTdamns de la terreTPO
JODMVJEPT FO FM QBOPSBNB
KVOUP B MPT QSPMFUBSJPT EF )PSLIFJ-
NFSPMBUSBEVDDJOBDUVBMEFMQSPMFUBSJBEP
MBTNVMUJUVEFT y2V
USBOTGPSNBDJPOFTTPOOFDFTBSJBTFOFMQSPZFDUPEFMBjUFPSBDS-
UJDBvTJFMHOFSP
MBSB[BZMBOBUVSBMF[BIBOEFTFSQMFOBNFO-
UF JODPSQPSBEPT FO TV NBSDP DPODFQUVBM Z QPMUJDP : BM OBM
yDNP QVFEF TFS TVCTVNJEB MB jUFPSB DSUJDBv FO FM QSPZFDUP
EF MB NPEFSOJEBEDPMPOJBMJEBE Z MB EFTDPMPOJ[BDJO y0 FTUB
TVCTVODJO TVHFSJSB RVJ[ MB OFDFTJEBE EF BCBOEPOBS MBT GPS-
NVMBDJPOFTEFMTJHMPXXTPCSFVOQSPZFDUPEFUFPSBDSUJDB y0
TVHFSJSBBDBTPFMBHPUBNJFOUPEFMQSPZFDUPEFMBNPEFSOJEBE 5
5
1PSJ[RVJFSEBTFVSPBNFSJDBOPDFOUSBEBTOPTPMPNFSFFSPBMBJ[RVJFSEB
TPDJBMJTUBNBSYJTUBRVFTFPSJHJOBFO&VSPQBZTFFYUJFOEFBQBTFTJOEVTUSJB-
MJ[BEPTDPNP&TUBEPT6OJEPT
TJOPUBNCJOBMBTJ[RVJFSEBTFVSPDFOUSBEBT
EFM5FSDFS.VOEP"TDPNPMBTJOEFQFOEFODJBTFO"NSJDBEFM4VSZEFM
$BSJCFFOFMTJHMP9*9
PMBTEFTDPMPOJ[BDJPOFTFOGSJDBZ"TJBEVSBOUFMB
(VFSSB'SBHFOFSBSPOVOBFMJUFEFEFTDFOEFODJBFVSPQFB DPNPFO"NSJDB
EFM4VSZEFM$BSJCF
PFMJUFTOBUJWBT DPNPFOGSJDBZ"TJB
RVFMJHBSPO
DPO MPT EJTFPT JNQFSJBMFT MJCFSBMFT
UBNCJO TVSHJFSPO FMJUFT TPDJBMJTUBT
NBSYJTUBTRVFJNQVMTBCBOMPTEJTFPTJNQFSJBMFTEFMBJ[RVJFSEBFOMPTQB-
TFTJOEFQFOEJ[BEPTPEFTDPMPOJ[BEPT+PSHF"CFMBSEP3BNPTBOBMJ[BFMDBTP
EF"NSJDBEFM4VS7BTF
+PSHF"CFMBSEP3BNPT
El marxismo de indias
.BESJE
1MBOFUB
.F SFNJUP UBNCJO B MBT PCTFSWBDJPOFT EF /JOB
1BDBSJ
TPCSFMBTSFMBDJPOFTEFMNBSYJTNPCMBODPJEFFO&DVBEPSDPOMBOB-
DJOZFMQFOTBNJFOUPJOEHFOBT"MHPTFNFKBOUFIBPDVSSJEPDPOMBOBDJO
BGSP
DPOTUJUVJEBEFTEFFMTJHMP97*FOEJTUJOUBTQBSUFTEF"NSJDBEFM4VS
202
Historiografa postmoderna
203
-VJT(%F.VTTZr.JHVFM7BMEFSSBNB
EFMBNPEFSOJEBE-BNPEFSOJEBEFTVOBIJESBEFUSFTDBCF[BT
BVORVFTPMPNVFTUSBVOBMBSFUSJDBEFTBMWBDJOZQSPHSFTP-B
DPMPOJBMJEBE
VOBEFDVZBTGBDFUBTFTMBQPCSF[BZMBQSPQBHBDJO
EFM TJEB FOGSJDB
OP BQBSFDF FO MB SFUSJDB EF MB NPEFSOJEBE
DPNPTVOFDFTBSJBDPOUSBQBSUF
TJOPDPNPBMHPEFTQSFOEJEPEF
FMMB 1PS FKFNQMP
FM 1MBO EFM .JMFOJP EF MBT /BDJPOFT 6OJEBT
MJEFSBEPQPS,P"OOBO
ZFM&BSUI*OTUJUVUFOMB6OJWFSTJEBEEF
$PMVNCJB
MJEFSBEPQPS+FGGSFZ4BDIT
USBCBKBOFODPMBCPSBDJO
QBSBUFSNJOBSDPOMBQPCSF[B
DPNPMPBOVODJBFMUUVMPEFMMJCSP
EF4BDIT61FSPFOOJOHONPNFOUPTFDVFTUJPOBMBJEFPMPHBEF
MBNPEFSOJEBEOJMPTQP[PTOFHSPTRVFPDVMUBTVSFUSJDB
DPOTF-
DVFODJBTEFMBOBUVSBMF[BNJTNBEFMBFDPOPNBDBQJUBMJTUBmFO
MB DVBM UBM JEFPMPHB TF BQPZBm FO TVT WBSJBEBT GBDFUBT EFTEF
FM NFSDBOUJMJTNP EFM TJHMP 97*
FM MJCSF DPNFSDJP EF MPT TJHMPT
TJHVJFOUFT
MB SFWPMVDJO JOEVTUSJBM EFM TJHMP 9*9
MB SFWPMVDJO
UFDOPMHJDBEFMXX
TJOPTVTEFTBGPSUVOBEBTDPOTFDVFODJBT1PS
PUSB QBSUF
UPEP FM EFCBUF FO MPT NFEJPT TPCSF MB HVFSSB DPO-
USB FM UFSSPSJTNP Z UPEP UJQP EF MFWBOUBNJFOUPT EF QSPUFTUBT Z
NPWJNJFOUPTTPDJBMFT
FOOJOHONPNFOUPJOTJOBORVFMBMHJ-
DBEFMBDPMPOJBMJEBE
RVFTFFTDPOEFCBKPMBSFUSJDBEFMBNP-
EFSOJEBE
HFOFSBOFDFTBSJBNFOUFMBFOFSHBJSSFEVDUJCMFEFTFSFT
IVNBOPTIVNJMMBEPT
WJMJQFOEJBEPT
PMWJEBEPT
NBSHJOBEPT-B
EFDPMPOJBMJEBEFT
FOUPODFT
MBFOFSHBRVFOPTFEFKBNBOFKBS
QPSMBMHJDBEFMBDPMPOJBMJEBE
OJTFDSFFMPTDVFOUPTEFIBEBTEF
MBSFUSJDBEFMBNPEFSOJEBE4J
FOUPODFT
MBEFDPMPOJBMJEBEUJF-
OFVOBWBSJBEBHBNBEFNBOJGFTUBDJPOFTmBMHVOBTOPEFTFBCMFT
6
*OTJTUBNPTFOMBHFPQPMUJDBEFMTBCFSPEFMDPOPDJNJFOUP)PSLIFJNFSZMB
&TDVFMBEF'SBOLGVSUTFQVFEFOMFFSEFEJTUJOUBTNBOFSBT
OPFOFMTFOUJEP
EFMBQMVSBMJEBEIFSNFOVUJDBEFDBEBMFDUVSBTJOP
DPNPMPBDBCPEFEFDJS
FOMBEJTUSJCVDJOHFPQPMUJDBEFMBMBCPSJOUFMFDUVBMBUSBWTEFMBEJGFSFODJB
DPMPOJBM ZUBNCJOEFMBEJGFSFODJBJNQFSJBM
(FPQPMUJDBNFOUF
VOUJQPEF
JOUFSQSFUBDJODPSSFTQPOEFSBBMMVHBSRVFMB&TDVFMBEF'SBOLGVSUPDVQBFO
MBHFOFBMPHBEFMQFOTBNJFOUPFVSPQFP0USBTMFDUVSBTFTUBSBOPSJFOUBEBT
QPS Z B USBWT EF MB EJGFSFODJB FQJTUNJDB DPMPOJBM FO MB HFOFBMPHB QMVSJ-
WFSTBMEFMQFOTBNJFOUPEFTDPMPOJBM DPNPMPQSFTFOUPBRVNJTNP
$MBSP
QVFEFPDVSSJSPUSBDPTBUBNCJORVFMB&TDVFMBEF'SBOLGVSU ZFRVJWBMFO-
UFT
TFBFNQMFBEBQPSMBinteligentsiaMPDBMFOMBTFYDPMPOJBTDPNPTJHOP
EFEJTUJODJO FVSPDFOUSBEB
TPCSFTFDUPSFTEFMBQPCMBDJOQSFTVOUBNFOUF
BUSBTBEPT DPOSFTQFDUP BMBTMUJNBTJEFBTNFSDBODBT QSPWFOJFOUFT EF MBT
GCSJDBTEF&VSPQBPEF&TUBEPT6OJEPT&OFTUFMUJNPSVCSPIBZUPEBVOB
DPNQMFKBHBNBEFQPTJCJMJEBEFT
204
Historiografa postmoderna
**&
-BUFTJTFTMBTJHVJFOUFFMQFOTBNJFOUPEFDPMPOJBMFNFSHJ
FOMBGVOEBDJONJTNBEFMBNPEFSOJEBEDPMPOJBMJEBEDPNPTV
DPOUSBQBSUJEB:FTPPDVSSJFOMBT"NSJDBT
FOFMQFOTBNJFOUP
JOEHFOBZFOFMQFOTBNJFOUPBGSPDBSJCFP$POUJOVMVFHPFO
"TJBZGSJDB
OPSFMBDJPOBEPTDPOFMQFOTBNJFOUPEFDPMPOJBMFO
MBT"NSJDBT
QFSPTDPNPDPOUSBQBSUJEBBMBSFPSHBOJ[BDJOEF
MB NPEFSOJEBEDPMPOJBMJEBE DPO FM JNQFSJP CSJUOJDP Z FM DPMP-
OJBMJTNPGSBODT6OUFSDFSNPNFOUPEFSFGPSNVMBDJPOFTPDVSSJ
FOMBTJOUFSTFDDJPOFTEFMPTNPWJNJFOUPTEFEFTDPMPOJ[BDJOFO
"TJBZGSJDB
DPODVSSFOUFTDPOMB(VFSSB'SBZFMMJEFSB[HPBT-
DFOEFOUFEF&TUBEPT6OJEPT%FTEFFMOEFMB(VFSSB'SBFOUSF
&TUBEPT6OJEPTZMB6OJO4PWJUJDB
FMQFOTBNJFOUPEFDPMPOJBM
DPNJFO[B B USB[BS TV QSPQJB HFOFBMPHB &M QSPQTJUP BRV FT
DPOUSJCVJSBFMMB&OFTUFTFOUJEP
FMQFOTBNJFOUPEFDPMPOJBMTF
EJGFSFODJBEFMBUFPSBQPTUDPMPOJBMPFTUVEJPTQPTUDPMPOJBMFTFO
RVFMBHFOFBMPHBEFFTUPTTFMPDBMJ[BFOFMQPTUFTUSVDUVSBMJTNP
GSBODTNTRVFFOMBEFOTBIJTUPSJBEFMQFOTBNJFOUPQMBOFUBSJP
EFDPMPOJBM
&MHJSPFQJTUNJDPEFDPMPOJBMFTVOBDPOTFDVFODJBEFMBGPS-
NBDJOFJOTUBVSBDJOEFMBNBUSJ[DPMPOJBMEFQPEFSRVF"OCBM
2VJKBOPEFOVODJBFOVOBSUDVMPQJPOFSPFOFMRVFTFSFTVNFMB
QMBUBGPSNBEFMQSPZFDUPNPEFSOJEBEDPMPOJBMJEBEjMBDSUJDBEFM
QBSBEJHNBFVSPQFPEFMBSBDJPOBMJEBENPEFSOJEBEFTJOEJTQFO-
TBCMF.TBO
VSHFOUF1FSPFTEVEPTPRVFFMDBNJOPDPOTJTUB
FOMBOFHBDJOTJNQMFEFUPEBTTVTDBUFHPSBTFOMBEJTPMVDJO
205
-VJT(%F.VTTZr.JHVFM7BMEFSSBNB
EFMBSFBMJEBEFOFMEJTDVSTPFOMBQVSBOFHBDJOEFMBJEFBZEF
MBQFSTQFDUJWBEFUPUBMJEBEFOFMDPOPDJNJFOUP-FKPTEFFTUP
FT
OFDFTBSJPEFTQSFOEFSTFEFMBTWJODVMBDJPOFTEFMBSBDJPOBMJEBE
NPEFSOJEBEDPOMBDPMPOJBMJEBE
FOQSJNFSUSNJOP
ZFOEFOJ-
UJWBDPOUPEPQPEFSOPDPOTUJUVJEPFOMBEFDJTJOMJCSFEFHFOUFT
MJCSFT&TMBJOTUSVNFOUBMJ[BDJOEFMBSB[OQPSFMQPEFSDPMP-
OJBM
FOQSJNFSMVHBS
MPRVFQSPEVKPQBSBEJHNBTEJTUPSTJPOBEPT
EFDPOPDJNJFOUPZNBMPHSMBTQSPNFTBTMJCFSBEPSBTEFMBNP-
EFSOJEBE-BBMUFSOBUJWBFODPOTFDVFODJBFTDMBSBMBEFTUSVDDJO
EFMBDPMPOJBMJEBEEFMQPEFSNVOEJBMv7.
"VORVF MB NFUBSSFFYJO TPCSF FM HJSP FQJTUNJDP EFDP-
MPOJBM FT EF GBDUVSB SFDJFOUF
MB QSDUJDB FQJTUNJDB EFDPMPOJBM
TVSHJ jOBUVSBMNFOUFv DPNP DPOTFDVFODJB EF MB JNQMBOUBDJO
EFFTUSVDUVSBTEFEPNJOBDJO
MBNBUSJ[DPMPOJBMEFQPEFSPMB
DPMPOJBMJEBEEFMQPEFS
RVF"OCBM2VJKBOPEFWFMIBDJBOBMFT
EFMPTPDIFOUBZTPCSFMBDVBMDPOUJOBUSBCBKBOEP1PSMPUBOUP
OPFTOBEBTPSQSFOEFOUFRVFMBHFOFBMPHBEFMQFOTBNJFOUPEF
DPMPOJBM FTUPFT
FMQFOTBNJFOUPRVFTVSHFEFMHJSPEFDPMPOJBM
MP FODPOUSFNPT FO jMB DPMPOJBv P FM jQFSJPEP DPMPOJBMv
FO MB
KFSHBDBOOJDBEFMBIJTUPSJPHSBGBEFMBT"NSJDBT&TFQFSPEP
EFGPSNBDJO
FOFMTJHMP97*
OPJODMVZFUPEBWBMBTDPMPOJBTJO-
HMFTBTOJFOFMOPSUFOJFOFM$BSJCF
OJUBNQPDPMBTGSBODFTBT4JO
FNCBSHP
FMHJSPEFDPMPOJBMSFBQBSFDFFO"TJBZFOGSJDBDPNP
DPOTFDVFODJBEFMPTDBNCJPT
BEBQUBDJPOFTZOVFWBTNPEBMJEB-
EFTEFMBNPEFSOJEBEDPMPOJBMJEBEHFOFSBEBTQPSMBFYQBOTJO
JNQFSJBMCSJUOJDBZGSBODFTBBQBSUJSEFOBMFTEFM97***ZQSJO-
DJQJPTEFM9*9.
%FNPEPRVFMBTQSJNFSBTNBOJGFTUBDJPOFTEFMHJSPEFDPMP-
OJBMMBTFODPOUSBNPTFOMPTWJSSFJOBUPTIJTQOJDPTFO"OIVBDZ
5BXBOUJOTVZV
FOFMTJHMP97*ZDPNJFO[PTEFM97**:MPFODPO-
7
+FGGSFZ4BDIT
The End of Poverty. Economic Possibilities for our Time
/VF-
WB:PSL
5IF1FOHVJO1SFTT
-PTEPDVNFOUPTSFMBDJPOBEPTDPOFMMMB-
NBEP1MBOEFM.JMFOJPTFQVFEFODPOTVMUBSFOIUUQXXXHMPCBMQPMJDZPSH
NTVNNJUNJMMFOOJVOEPDJOEFYIUN SFWJTBEPFMEFEJDJFNCSFEF
&M
QSPZFDUPJNQFSJBMDPMPOJBM
BSUJDVMBEPFOMBNPEFSOJEBEDPMPOJBMJEBEDVCSF
UPEPTMPTBODPT&M1MBOEFM.JMFOJPJOWJUBBRVFOPTRVFEFNPTTFOUBEPTZ
WFBNPTDNPMPTHSBOEFTQFOTBEPSFTEFMPTQSPZFDUPTJNQFSJBMFTTPODPO-
TDJFOUFT EF MBT JOKVTUJDJBT JNQFSJBMFT $PNP -BT $BTBT BZFS
MPT (VBNO
1VNBEFIPZTPOJOWJUBEPTBTVQFEJUBSTFBMBTCVFOBTNBOFSBTEFMBSB[O
JNQFSJBMDSUJDB
206
Historiografa postmoderna
USBNPTUBNCJOFOUSFMBTDPMPOJBTJOHMFTBTZMBNFUSQPMJ
FOFM
TJHMP97***&MQSJNFSDBTPMPJMVTUSB'FMJQF8BNBO1VNBEF"ZB-
MBFOFMWJSSFJOBUPEFM1FS8
RVFFOWJTVPCSBNueva crnica y
buen gobiernoB'FMJQF***FOFMTFHVOEP0UBCCBI$VHPB-
OP
VOFTDMBWPMJCFSUPRVFQVEPQVCMJDBSFO-POESFT
FOmFT
EFDJS
EJF[BPTEFTQVTEFMBJOEFQFOEFODJBEF&TUBEPT6OJEPTZ
EFMBQVCMJDBDJOEFThe Wealth of Nations
EF"EBN4NJUIm
TV
Thoughts and Sentiments on the Evil of Slavery
"NCPT
TPOUSBUBEPTQPMUJDPTEFDPMPOJBMFTRVF
HSBDJBTBMBDPMPOJBMJEBE
EFM TBCFS
OP MMFHBSPO B DPNQBSUJS MB NFTB EF EJTDVTJPOFT DPO
.BRVJBWFMP
)PCCFT P -PDLF 3FJOTDSJCJSMPT IPZ FO MB HFOFB-
MPHBEFMQFOTBNJFOUPEFDPMPOJBMFTVOBUBSFBVSHFOUF4JOFTUB
HFOFBMPHB FM QFOTBNJFOUP EFDPMPOJBM TFSB OBEB NT RVF VO
HFTUPDVZBMHJDBEFQFOEFSBEFBMHVOBEFMBTWBSJBTHFOFBMPHBT
GVOEBEBTFO(SFDJBZ3PNB
RVFGVFSPOSFJOTDSJUBTFOMBNPEFS-
OJEBEJNQFSJBMFVSPQFBEFTQVTEFM3FOBDJNJFOUPFOBMHVOBTEF
MBTTFJTMFOHVBTJNQFSJBMFTZBNFODJPOBEBTJUBMJBOP
DBTUFMMBOP
QPSUVHVT
QBSB FM 3FOBDJNJFOUP GSBODT
JOHMT
BMFNO
QBSB
MB*MVTUSBDJO8BNBO1VNBZ$VHPBOPQFOTBSPOZBCSJFSPOMB
SBOVSBEFMPJNQFOTBCMFFOMBHFOFBMPHBJNQFSJBMEFMBNPEFS-
OJEBE
UBOUP FO TVT GBDFUBT EF EFSFDIB DPNP FO TVT GBDFUBT EF
J[RVJFSEB
FTEFDJS
FOMBHFOFBMPHBJNQFSJBMEFMBNPEFSOJEBE
DSJTUJBOB
MJCFSBMZTPDJBMJTUBNBSYJTUB
8BNBO1VNBZ$VHPBOPBCSJFSPOMBTQVFSUBTBMQFOTBNJFO-
UP
BMjQFOTBNJFOUPGSPOUFSJ[Pv9BQBSUJSEFMBFYQFSJFODJBZNF-
NPSJB EFM5BXBOUJOTVZV
Z EF MB FYQFSJFODJB Z NFNPSJB EF MB
CSVUBMFTDMBWJUVEOFHSBEFM"UMOUJDP
SFTQFDUJWBNFOUF/JOHVOP
EFMPTRVFEFGFOEJFSPOBMPTJOEHFOBTFOFMTJHMP 97*
OJEFMPT
RVFTFNBOJGFTUBSPODPOUSBMBFTDMBWJUVEFOFMTJHMP97***MMFHBSPO
BQFOTBSEFTEFFMFTQBDJPZMBTFYQFSJFODJBTEFMBIFSJEBDPMPOJBM
JOGSJOHJEBBJOEJPTZOFHSPT
UBMDPNPMBFQJTUFNPMPHBJNQFSJBM
DMBTJD MB EJWFSTJEBE EFM /VFWP .VOEP -B UFPSB QPMUJDB FO
&VSPQB EFTEF/JDPMT.BRVJBWFMPIBTUB$BSM4DINJUU
QBTBOEP
QPS)PCCFTZ+PIO-PDLF
TFDPOTUSVZTPCSFMBTFYQFSJFODJBTZ
8
"OCBM2VJKBOP
j$PMPOJBMJEBEZNPEFSOJEBESBDJPOBMJEBEv
FO)#POJMMB
DPNQ
Los conquistados. 1492 y la poblacin indgena de las Amricas
&DVBEPS
-JCSJ.VOEJ5FSDFS.VOEP&EJUPSFT
QQ
9
4FVTBFMOPNCSFFTDSJUPFORVFDIVBFOWF[EFMDBTUFMMBOP'FMJQF(VBNO
1PNBEF"ZBMB
207
-VJT(%F.VTTZr.JHVFM7BMEFSSBNB
MBNFNPSJBEFMPTSFJOBEPTZQSJODJQBEPT .BRVJBWFMP
MBGPS-
NBDJOEFMPT&TUBEPTMJCFSBMFT )PCCFT
-PDLF
ZMBDSJTJTEFM
&TUBEPMJCFSBM 4DINJUU
y$NP JOUFSQSFUBS MB NFUGPSB EFM QSSBGP BOUFSJPS
jyy"CSJFSPOMBTQVFSUBTBMQFOTBNJFOUPPUSP v$PNPEFTQSFO-
EJNJFOUPZBQFSUVSB102VJ[TDPOPUSBNFUGPSBRVFDPPQFSFB
MBJOUFMJHJCJMJEBEEFMUJQPEFQVFSUBTEFMRVFIBCMPFOFTUFDBTP
:BOPTFUSBUBEFMBTQVFSUBTRVFDPOEVDFOBMBWFSEBE aletheia
TJOPBPUSPTMVHBSFTBMPTMVHBSFTEFMBNFNPSJBDPMPOJBMBMBT
IVFMMBTEFMBIFSJEBDPMPOJBMEFTEFEPOEFTFUFKFFMQFOTBNJFOUP
EFDPMPOJBM111VFSUBTRVFDPOEVDFOBPUSPUJQPEFWFSEBEFTDVZP
GVOEBNFOUP OP FT FM TFS TJOP MB DPMPOJBMJEBE EFM TFS
MB IFSJEB
DPMPOJBM&MQFOTBNJFOUPEFDPMPOJBMQSFTVQPOF
TJFNQSF
MBEJGF-
SFODJBDPMPOJBM ZFODJFSUPTDBTPT
RVFOPWPZBBOBMJ[BSBRV
MB
EJGFSFODJBJNQFSJBM
&TUPFT
MBFYUFSJPSJEBEFOFMQSFDJTPTFOUJEP
EFMBGVFSB CSCBSP
DPMPOJBM
DPOTUSVJEPQPSFMBEFOUSP DJWJMJ[B-
10
j1FOTBNJFOUP GSPOUFSJ[Pv FT FM NUPEP EFM QFOTBNJFOUP Z MB PQDJO EF
DPMPOJBMy1PSRV (VBNO1VNBEF"ZBMBFTUBOCVFODBTPDPNPUBOUPT
PUSPT"QBSUJSEFMBWJPMFODJBFQJTUNJDBJNQFSJBM FOFTUFDBTPMBUFPMPHB
DSJTUJBOB
ZB FT JNQPTJCMF FO MPT"OEFT Z FO DVBMRVJFS QBSUF EFM NVOEP
QFOTBNPTFOMB*OEJBCSJUOJDBPFMJTMBNBQBSUJSEFJOUFSWFOJSFOMBT
SFMBDJPOFTEFQPEFSBJTMOEPTFFOVOQVSJTNPZBJNQPTJCMF4FIBDFOFDFTB-
SJP
FOUPODFT
EFTQSFOEFSTFEFMBTSFHMBTJNQFSJBMFT FOFMDPOPDJNJFOUP
MB
QPMUJDB
MBTVCKFUJWJEBE
FUD
ZSFPSHBOJ[BSMBTFODPTNPMPHBTRVFQSPWJFOFO
EFNFNPSJBTZDBUFHPSBTEFQFOTBNJFOUPBKFOBTBMBDPTNPMPHBHSJFHB
B
MBDPTNPMPHBDSJTUJBOBZBMBDPTNPMPHBTFDVMBSEF0DDJEFOUFBQBSUJSEFMB
*MVTUSBDJO&WP.PSBMFTOPQSFUFOEFJNQPOFSMBEFNPDSBDJBEFBZMMVZCP-
SSBSMBEFNPDSBDJBZMBFDPOPNB OFP
MJCFSBM4VQSPZFDUPFTBCTPSCFSMBFO
MBEFNPDSBDJBEFBZMMV
FTEFDJS
FTOFDFTBSJPVOQFOTBNJFOUPGSPOUFSJ[PQBSB
EFDPMPOJ[BSMBFDPOPNB
FM&TUBEPZMBTVCKFUJWJEBE FMSPMEFMBFEVDBDJO
FTBRVGVOEBNFOUBM
11
.FSFFSPBMBOPDJOEFjEFTQSFOEJNJFOUPFQJTUNJDPvFOMBDJUBBOUFSJPS
EF2VJKBOP&TUFEFTQSFOEJNJFOUPFQJTUNJDPEJFSF
FOFMTFOUJEPEFMBEJGF-
SFODJBDPMPOJBM
EFMVTPRVF4BNJS"NJOMFEJPBMUSNJOPjMBEFTDPOFYJOv
"NJOTFNBOUVWPFOMBCVSCVKBEFMBFTQUFNFNPEFSOBZTVjEFTDPOFYJOv
TVHJSJVODBNCJPEFDPOUFOJEP
OPEFMPTUSNJOPTEFMBDPOWFSTBDJO&M
jEFTQSFOEJNJFOUPFQJTUNJDPv
FODBNCJP
TFBMBFMNPNFOUPEFRVJFCSBZ
EFGSBDUVSB
NPNFOUPEFBQFSUVSB&OFTUFTFOUJEP
jBQFSUVSBvEJFSFUBN-
CJOEFMTFOUJEPRVFVODPODFQUPTJNJMBS
jMPBCJFSUPvUJFOFFO"HBNCFO
7BTF
(JPSHJP"HBNCFO
Lo abierto
#VFOPT"JSFT
"ESJBOB)JEBMHP
&O FM QFOTBNJFOUP EFDPMPOJBM MB BQFSUVSB FT FM EFTQSFOEJNJFOUP
QSFDJTB-
NFOUF
EFEJDPUPNBTOBUVSBMJ[BEBTDPNPjFMIPNCSFZFMBOJNBMv5BMEJT-
UJODJOOPTFSBQFOTBCMFDPNPQVOUPEFQBSUJEBOJQBSB(VBNO1VNBOJ
QBSB0UUBCBI$VHPBOP
208
Historiografa postmoderna
EP
JNQFSJBM
VOBEFOUSPBTFOUBEPTPCSFMPRVF$BTUSP(NF[
SFWFMDPNPMBhibrisEFMQVOUPDFSP12
FOMBQSFTVOUBUPUBMJEBE
UPUBMJ[BDJO
EF MB HOPTJT EF 0DDJEFOUF GVOEBEB
SFDPSEFNPT
VOBWF[NT
FOFMHSJFHPZFMMBUOZFOMBTTFJTMFOHVBTNPEFSOBT
JNQFSJBMFT&VSPQFBT&MHJSPEFDPMPOJBMFTMBBQFSUVSBZMBMJCFS-
UBEEFMQFOTBNJFOUPZEFGPSNBTEFWJEB FDPOPNBTPUSBT
UFP-
SBTQPMUJDBTPUSBT
MBMJNQJF[BEFMBDPMPOJBMJEBEEFMTFSZEFM
TBCFSFMEFTQSFOEJNJFOUPEFMFODBOUBNJFOUPEFMBSFUSJDBEFMB
NPEFSOJEBE
EFTVJNBHJOBSJPJNQFSJBMBSUJDVMBEPFOMBSFUSJDB
EFMBEFNPDSBDJB&OEJMPHPDPOMBSB[OJNQFSJBMDSUJDB
EJSB
MP TJHVJFOUF .BSUO )FJEFHHFS USBEVKP aletheia WFSEBE
DPNP
jMPBCJFSUPZMJCSFFOMBSFTUJUVDJOEFMTFSv&OMBNFEJEBFORVF
FMFNQPEFSBNJFOUPFTFMIPSJ[POUFEFMQFOTBNJFOUPEFDPMPOJBM
ZOPMBjWFSEBEv
jFTMPBCJFSUPZMJCSFFOMBEFDPMPOJBMJEBEEFM
TFSv/PJNQPSUBDVOUBTDSUJDBTIBHBNPTBMPTJNQFSJPT
BMJN-
QFSJBMJTNPPBMJNQFSJP4POUPEBTFMMBTHJSPTFOSFEPOEP
NPS-
EJTDPTFOMBDPMB-BTDSUJDBTFOMBMFOHVBEFMJNQFSJPDPOUJOBO
PDVMUBOEPMBQVFSUB
MBBQFSUVSBZMBMJCFSUBEBMBTDVBMFTBQVOUB
FMQFOTBNJFOUPEFDPMPOJBM.FUGPSBTUBMFTDPNPjVONVOEPFO
FMRVFRVFQBONVDIPTNVOEPTvZjPUSPNVOEPFTQPTJCMFvTPO
MBTNFUGPSBTRVFNVFTUSBOEPOEFFTUMBQVFSUB
&MQFOTBNJFOUPEFDPMPOJBMUJFOFDPNPSB[OEFTFSZPCKF-
UJWPMBEFDPMPOJBMJEBEEFMQPEFS FTEFDJS
EFMBNBUSJ[DPMPOJBM
EF QPEFS
&TUF QSPHSBNB GVF UBNCJO EJTFBEP QPS 2VJKBOP
FOFMBSUDVMPDJUBEPj&OQSJNFSUSNJOP
<FTOFDFTBSJB>MBEFT-
DPMPOJ[BDJO FQJTUFNPMHJDB
QBSB EBS QBTP MVFHP B VOB OVFWB
DPNVOJDBDJO JOUFSDVMUVSBM
B VO JOUFSDBNCJP EF FYQFSJFODJBT
ZEFTJHOJDBDJPOFT
DPNPMBCBTFEFPUSBSBDJPOBMJEBERVFQVF-
EBQSFUFOEFS
DPOMFHJUJNJEBE
BBMHVOBVOJWFSTBMJEBE1VFTOBEB
NFOPTSBDJPOBM
OBMNFOUF
RVFMBQSFUFOTJOEFRVFMBFTQFDDB
DPTNPWJTJOEFVOBFUOJBQBSUJDVMBSTFBJNQVFTUBDPNPMBSBDJP-
OBMJEBEVOJWFSTBM
BVORVFUBMFUOJBTFMMBNF&VSPQB0DDJEFOUBM
12
&MDPODFQUPEFIFSJEBDPMPOJBMQSPWJFOFEF(MPSJB"O[BMEB
FOVOB
EFTVTGSBTFTZBDMFCSFTj5IF64.FYJDBOCPSEFS FTVOBIFSJEBBCJFSUB
XIFSFUIF5IJSE8PSMEHSBUFTBHBJOTUUIFSTUBOECMFFETv0CWJBNFOUF
MB
FYQSFTJOUJFOFWBMPSEFDBNCJPFOUPEBTBRVFMMBTTJUVBDJPOFTFOMBTDVBMFT
&VSPQBZ&TUBEPT6OJEPTJOJOHJFSPOZDPOUJOBOJOJOHJFOEPMBGSJDDJO
EFMBNJTJODJWJMJ[BEPSB
EFTBSSPMMJTUBZNPEFSOJ[BEPSB"MSFTQFDUP
(MPSJB
"O[BMEB
Borderlands/La Frontera
4BO'SBODJTDP
"VOU-VUF#PPLT
209
-VJT(%F.VTTZr.JHVFM7BMEFSSBNB
13
4BOUJBHP$BTUSP(NF[
La hybris del punto cero. Ciencia, raza e ilustra-
cin en la Nueva Granada (1750-1816)
#PHPU
*OTUJUVUP1FOTBS
210
Historiografa postmoderna
211
-VJT(%F.VTTZr.JHVFM7BMEFSSBNB
IBDFSTFPS1FSPFTPTBOMJTJTEFEJTFOTPEJTJFOUFOFOFMDPOUFOJ-
EPZOPFOMPTUSNJOPTEFMBDPOWFSTBDJO&MQFOTBNJFOUPEF
DPMPOJBMOPBQBSFDFUPEBWB
OJTJRVJFSBFOMBTQVCMJDBDJPOFTEF
MBNTFYUSFNBJ[RVJFSEB:MBSB[OFTRVFFMQFOTBNJFOUPEF
DPMPOJBMZBOPFTJ[RVJFSEB
TJOPPUSBDPTBFTEFTQSFOEJNJFOUP
EFMBFQJTUFNFQPMUJDBNPEFSOBBSUJDVMBEBDPNPEFSFDIB
DFOUSP
FJ[RVJFSEBFTBQFSUVSBIBDJBPUSBDPTB
FONBSDIB
CVTDOEPTF
FOMBEJGFSFODJB
$POEFOBSMBWJPMFODJBUFSSPSJTUBOPRVJFSFEFDJSSFOEJSOPTBM
QFOTBNJFOUP &TF MVKP TF MP QVFEFO EBS QFSTPOBT DPO JOUFSFTFT
QBSUJDVMBSFTmZFODJFSUPTDBTPTDPOMJNJUBDJPOFTQBSBFOUFOEFS
MBTJUVBDJOHMPCBMm
DPNPFMQSFTJEFOUF(FPSHF8#VTIZFMQSJ-
NFS NJOJTUSP 5POZ #MBJS 1PS PUSB QBSUF
FOUFOEFS MB WJPMFODJB
FOFMNBSDPJOUFSQSFUBUJWPDPNOBMB(VFSSB'SB
FTUPFT
VO
PDDJEFOUBM MJCFSBM
DBQJUBMJTUB Z DSJTUJBOP QSPUFTUBOUF DPOUSB VO
PDDJEFOUBMPSJFOUBM &VSBTJB
TPDJBMJTUBFOQPMUJDB
DPNVOJTUBFO
FDPOPNBZDSJTUJBOPPSUPEPYPFOSFMJHJOmFOBNCPTDBTPT
FM
DPOJDUPFOUSFTFDVMBSJTNPZSFMJHJOOFDFTJUBEFVOBOMJTJTNBT
EFUFOJEPOPPCTUBOUF
BNCBTNFNPSJBTSFMJHJPTBTFTUOBI
SF-
QSJNJEBTZQSFTFOUFTEFEJTUJOUBNBOFSBm
JOWJTJCJMJ[BEFOVFWP
MBBQFSUVSBIBDJBMBMJCFSUBERVFFTUBCBFOPUSBQBSUFZOPFOMB
DPOGSPOUBDJOEFMPTPQVFTUPTFOFMNJTNPTJTUFNBJEFPMHJDP
MJCFSBMJTNPWTTPDJBMJTNPy%OEF
FORVQBSUF &OMPTNPWJ-
NJFOUPTQPMUJDPTEFEFTDPMPOJ[BDJOFOUSFZBQSPYJ-
NBEBNFOUF
QPSFKFNQMP4JOEVEB
FTUPTNPWJNJFOUPTGSBDBTB-
SPOBTDPNPGSBDBTFMTPDJBMJTNPDPNVOJTNPFO3VTJB1FSP
BNCPTEFKBSPOIVFMMBT%PTTBMWFEBEFTBOUFTEFTFHVJSBEFMBOUF
QBSB
FOSFBMJEBE
JSIBDJBFMQBTBEP
6OB EF MBT SB[POFT QPS MBT DVBMFT MPT NPWJNJFOUPT EF EFT-
DPMPOJ[BDJOjGSBDBTBSPOvFTRVF
DPNPFOFMTPDJBMJTNPDPNV-
OJTNP
DBNCJBSPOFMDPOUFOJEPQFSPOPMPTUSNJOPTEFMBDPO-
WFSTBDJO4FNBOUVWJFSPOFOFMTJTUFNBEFMQFOTBNJFOUPOJDP
EFOVFWP
HSJFHPZMBUOZTVTTFDVFMBTNPEFSOPJNQFSJBMFT
-BT
FMJUFTOBUJWBTTFBQSPQJBSPOEFM&TUBEPFO"TJBZFOGSJDB
DPNP
BOUFTIBCBOIFDIPFOMBT"NSJDBTMBTFMJUFTDSJPMMBTm)BJUFT
VODBTPQBSUJDVMBSRVFOPQVFEPBOBMJ[BSBRVmEFBTDFOEFODJB
JCSJDBFOFMTVSZCSJUOJDBFOFMOPSUF5BOFTBTRVFFODJFSUPT
DBTPTMPT&TUBEPTEFTDPMPOJ[BEPTTJHVJFSPOMBTSFHMBTEFMKVFHP
212
Historiografa postmoderna
MJCFSBM
DPNP FO *OEJB
NJFOUSBT RVF FO PUSPT DBTPT JOUFOUBSPO
VOBBQSPYJNBDJOBMNBSYJTNP
DPNPFOFMDBTPEF1BUSJDF-V-
NVNCB QSJNFSNJOJTUSPEFMB3FQCMJDB%FNPDSUJDBEFM$PO-
HP
-BFOPSNFDPOUSJCVDJOEFMBEFTDPMPOJ[BDJO PJOEFQFO-
EFODJB
UBOUPFOMBQSJNFSBPMFBEBFOMBT"NSJDBTDPNPFOMB
TFHVOEB FO "TJB Z GSJDB
FT IBCFS QMBOUBEP MB CBOEFSB EF MB
QMVSJWFSTBMJEBEEFDPMPOJBMGSFOUFBMBCBOEFSBZMPTUBORVFTEFMB
VOJWFSTBMJEBEJNQFSJBM-PTMNJUFTEFUPEPTFTUPTNPWJNJFOUPT
GVFSPOFMEFOPIBCFSFODPOUSBEPMBBQFSUVSBZMBMJCFSUBEEFVO
QFOTBNJFOUPPUSP
FTUPFT
EFVOBEFDPMPOJ[BDJORVFMMFWBSB
FO
USNJOPTEFMPT[BQBUJTUBT
BVOjNVOEPEPOEFRVFQBONVDIPT
NVOEPTv QPSFKFNQMP
MBQMVSJWFSTBMJEBE
RVFFOFM'PSP4PDJBM
.VOEJBM TF SFBSNB FO MB DPOWJDDJO EF RVF jPUSP NVOEP FT
QPTJCMFv&TJNQPSUBOUFPCTFSWBSRVFMBTBQFSUVSBTIBDJBMPRVF
3BNO(SPTGHVFMIBEFOPNJOBEPjTFHVOEBEFTDPMPOJ[BDJOv
PDVSSFOEFTQVTEFMBDPODMVTJOEFMB(VFSSB'SBOPTPMPMPT
[BQBUJTUBTZFM'PSP4PDJBM.VOEJBM
TJOPUBNCJO)VHP$IWF[
-BQMBUBGPSNBFQJTUNJDBQPMUJDBEF)VHP$IWF[ NFUBGSJDB-
NFOUF
MBSFWPMVDJOCPMJWBSJBOB
ZBOPFTMBNJTNBQMBUBGPSNB
FOMBRVFTFBSN'JEFM$BTUSP NFUBGSJDBNFOUF
MBSFWPMVDJO
TPDJBMJTUB
4POPUSBTMBTSFHMBTEFMKVFHPRVFFTUOQMBOUFBOEP
$IWF[FO7FOF[VFMBZ&WP.PSBMFTFO#PMJWJB%FVOBNBOFSB
QFEBHHJDB
QPESBNPT WFS B -VMB EB 4JMWB
/TUPS ,JSDIOFS Z
5BCBS7[RVF[DPNPjNPNFOUPTEFUSBOTJDJOvFOUSFMBQMBUB-
GPSNBFQJTUNJDBQPMUJDBEF$BTUSPQPSVOMBEPZEF$IWF[Z
.PSBMFTQPSPUSP
-PRVFRVJFSPEFDJSFTRVFjFTFPUSPNVOEPvRVFFNQF[B-
NPTBJNBHJOBSZBOPQVFEFTFSTPMPMJCFSBM
DSJTUJBOPPNBSYJTUB
PVOBNF[DMBEFMPTUSFTRVFBTFHVSBSBRVFMBCVSCVKBNPEFSOP
DPMPOJBM
DBQJUBMJTUBFJNQFSJBM
USJVOGBSBZFTFUSJVOGPHBSBOUJ[B-
SBMPRVF'SBODJT'VLVZBNBDFMFCSDPNPFMOEFMBIJTUPSJB
"T
NFJNBHJOPRVFQFOTBSB'VLVZBNBRVFUPEBMBQPCMBDJO
EF$IJOB
UPEBMBQPCMBDJOJTMNJDBEFTEFFM0SJFOUF.FEJPBM
"TJB$FOUSBMZEFTEFFM"TJB$FOUSBMIBTUB*OEPOFTJB
UPEPTMPT
JOEHFOBTEFMBT"NSJDBTEFTEF$IJMFB$BOBEIBTUB"VTUSBMJB
Z/VFWB;FMBOEB
UPEBMBQPCMBDJOBGSJDBOBBMTVSEFM4BIBSB
NTMBEJTQPSBFOMBT"NSJDBT
RVFUPEPTMPTMBUJOP BT
ZPUSBT
NJOPSBTFO&TUBEPT6OJEPT
FOO
RVFUPEPTFTPTNJMMPOFTEF
213
-VJT(%F.VTTZr.JHVFM7BMEFSSBNB
QFSTPOBTRVFDVBESVQMJDBOPRVJOUVQMJDBOMBQPCMBDJOEF&VSP-
QBBUMOUJDBZ"NSJDBEFM/PSUF
TFSFOEJSBOBMPTQJFTEFMBNP
Z EFM NPEP EF WJEB QBSBEJTBDP EFM 0DDJEFOUF DBQJUBMJTUB Z FM
&TUBEPMJCFSBMEFNPDSUJDP
FOUSFUFOJEPQPSVOBJOEVTUSJBUFMFWJ-
TJWBZNVTJDBMTJOQBSBOHO
NPNJDBEPQPSVOBUFDOPMPHBRVF
DBEBNJOVUPDSFBVOOVFWPtrickEFFNCFMFTBNJFOUPZKCJMP
TF
QSPZFDUBTPCSFVOYJUPTJOMNJUFT
VOBFYDFMFODJBTJOGSPOUFSBTZ
VODSFDJNJFOUPUFDOPJOEVTUSJBMHFOUJDPRVFBTFHVSBFMQBSBTP
QBSBUPEPTMPTNPSUBMFT&OFTFQBOPSBNB
FMNBSYJTNPDPOUJ-
OVBSB DPNP MB OFDFTBSJB PQPTJDJO QBSB FM NBOUFOJNJFOUP EFM
TJTUFNB&MOEFMBIJTUPSJBTFSBBTFMUSJVOGPEFMMJCFSBMJTNP
TFDVOEBEPQPSMBDSJTUJBOEBEDPOTFSWBEPSBGSFOUFBMBDPOTUBOUF
QSPUFTUBEFMBJ[RVJFSEBNBSYJTUBZEFMBMPTPGBEFMBMJCFSBDJO
"TTFSB
IBTUBFMOEFMPTUJFNQPT/PTHVTUFPOP
EFTQVTEFM
OEFMBIJTUPSJB
MMFH"GHBOJTUO
*SBL
,BUSJOB
'SBODJB
-JUFSBMNFOUF
FNQF[PUSBIJTUPSJB
MBIJTUPSJBFOMBRVFFMQFO-
TBNJFOUPDPMPOJBM
HFTUBEPEFTEFFMNPNFOUPGVOEBDJPOBMEFMB
NPEFSOJEBEDPMPOJBMJEBE
DPNJFO[BBUPNBSFMMJEFSB[HP
3FQFOTFNPTEFTEFFMQVOUPBMRVFBDBCBNPTEFMMFHBSFOFTUF
BSHVNFOUP
MBJOUFSQSFUBDJOBMBRVFGVFSPOSFEVDJEBTMBTJOEF-
QFOEFODJBTEFTDPMPOJ[BEPSBT4FJOUFSQSFUBSPODPNPQSPDFTPTEF
MJCFSBDJOJNQFSJBMFOFMTJHMP9*9*OHMBUFSSBZ'SBODJBBQPZBSPO
BMBEFTDPMPOJ[BDJOEFMBTDPMPOJBTEF&TQBBZ1PSUVHBMFOFM
TJHMP XX&TUBEPT6OJEPTBQPZMBEFTDPMPOJ[BDJOEFMBTDPMP-
OJBTEF'SBODJBF*OHMBUFSSB&OSFBMJEBE
GVFMBMJCFSBDJOEFVO
JNQFSJPQBSBDBFSFONBOPTEFMPUSPRVFBQPZBCBMPTNPWJNJFO-
UPTEFJOEFQFOEFODJBFOOPNCSFEFMBMJCFSUBE-BQPTJCJMJEBEEFM
QFOTBNJFOUPEFDPMPOJBMGVFTJMFODJBEBQPSMBTJOUFSQSFUBDJPOFT
PDJBMFT-BTEFOVODJBTEF"NJMDBS$BCSBM
EF"JN$TBJSF
EF
'SBOU['BOPOGVFSPOBENJSBEBTQBSBTFSEFTDBMJDBEBT
JHVBMRVF
TFDFMFCSBSPOMPTMPHSPTEF1BUSJDF-VNVNCBEFTQVTEFDPSUBSMF
FMDVFSQPFOQFEB[PT3FQFOTBSMPTNPWJNJFOUPTEFMBTJOEFQFO-
EFODJBT EFTDPMPOJ[BEPSBT mFO TVT EPT NPNFOUPT IJTUSJDPT
FO
"NSJDBZFO"TJBGSJDBmTJHOJDBQFOTBSMPTDPNPNPNFOUPT
EFEFTQSFOEJNJFOUPZBQFSUVSBFOMPTQSPDFTPTEFEFDPMPOJ[BS
FM TBCFS Z FM TFS NPNFOUPT RVF GVFSPO WFMBEPT QPS MB NBRVJ-
OBSJB JOUFSQSFUBUJWB EF MB SFUSJDB EF MB NPEFSOJEBE
FM PDVMUB-
NJFOUPEFMBDPMPOJBMJEBEZ
FODPOTFDVFODJB
MBJOWJTJCJMJ[BDJO
214
Historiografa postmoderna
***5
"$
jvjv
&MQFOTBNJFOUPEFDPMPOJBMTVSHJZDPOUJOBHFTUOEPTFFO
EJMPHPDPOJDUJWPDPOMBUFPSBQPMUJDBEF&VSPQB
QBSB&VSPQB
ZEFTEFBIQBSBFMNVOEP FH
MBFNFSHFODJBEFMPTOFPDPO-
TFSWBEPSFT FO &TUBEPT 6OJEPT RVF TJHOJDBO MB DPOUJOVJEBE FO
"NSJDB
EJSFDUBFJOEJSFDUBNFOUF
EFMBTUFPSBTQPMUJDBTEF4DI-
NJUU
%FFTFEJMPHPDPOJDUJWPTVSHFFMQFOTBNJFOUPGSPOUFSJ[P
RVFTFSBSFEVOEBOUFMMBNBSDSUJDPmBVORVFBWFDFTFTOFDFTBSJP
QBSBFWJUBSDPOGVTJPOFTmEFTQVTEFMFFSB8BNBO1VNBZ$V-
HPBOP&OUPEPDBTP
TJMFMMBNBNPTDSUJDPTFSBQBSBEJGFSFODJBS
MBUFPSBDSUJDBNPEFSOBQPTUNPEFSOB &TDVFMBEF'SBOLGVSUZ
TVTTFDVFMBT
QPTUFTUSVDUVSBMJTNP
FUD
EFMBUFPSBDSUJDBEFDP-
MPOJBM
RVFCJFONVFTUSBOFOTVHFTUBDJOMPTBVUPSFTNFODJPOB-
EPT&MQFOTBNJFOUPEFDPMPOJBM
BMEFTQSFOEFSTFEFMBUJSBOBEFM
UJFNQPDPNPNBSDPDBUFHPSJBMEFMBNPEFSOJEBE
FTDBQBUBNCJO
BMBTUSBNQBTEFMBQPTUDPMPOJBMJEBE-BQPTUDPMPOJBMJEBE UFP-
SBPDSUJDBQPTUDPMPOJBM
OBDJFOUSBNQBEBDPOMB QPTU
NP-
EFSOJEBE%FBIRVF.JDIFM'PVDBVMU
+BDRVFT-BDBOZ+BDRVFT
%FSSJEB IBZBO TJEP MPT QVOUPT EF BQPZP QBSB MB DSUJDB QPTU
DPMPOJBM 4BJE
#IBCIB
4QJWBL
&MQFOTBNJFOUPEFDPMPOJBM
QPS
FMDPOUSBSJP
TFSBTDBFOPUSPTQBMFORVFT&OFMDBTPEF8BNBO
1VNB
MBTMFOHVBTZMBTNFNPSJBTJOEHFOBTDPOGSPOUBEBTDPOMB
NPEFSOJEBEOBDJFOUFFOFMDBTPEF$VHPBOP
MBTNFNPSJBTZFY-
QFSJFODJBTEFMBFTDMBWJUVEDPOGSPOUBEBTDPOFMBTFOUBNJFOUPEF
MBNPEFSOJEBEUBOUPFOMBFDPOPNBDPNPFOMBUFPSBQPMUJDB
&MQFOTBNJFOUPEFDPMPOJBMIPZ
BMBTFOUBSTFTPCSFFYQFSJFODJBT
ZEJTDVSTPTDPNPMBTEF8BNBO1VNBZ$VHPBOPFOMBTDPMP-
215
-VJT(%F.VTTZr.JHVFM7BMEFSSBNB
216
Historiografa postmoderna
NFOUFEJGFSFOUFBMBHFOFBMPHBEFMBUFPSBQPTUDPMPOJBMm
RVF
TFFODVFOUSBFO.BIBUNB(BOEIJ
8&#%VCPJT
+VBO$BS-
MPT .BSJUFHVJ
"NJMDBS $BCSBM
"JN $FTTBJSF
'SBOU[ 'BOPO
'BVTUP 3FJOBHB
7JOF %FMPSJB
+S
3JHPCFSUB .FODI
(MPSJB
"O[BMEB
FM.PWJNJFOUPEFMPT4JO5JFSSBFO#SBTJM
MPT[BQB-
UJTUBTFO$IJBQBT
MPTNPWJNJFOUPTJOEHFOBTZBGSPTFO#PMJWJB
&DVBEPS P $PMPNCJB
FM 'PSP 4PDJBM .VOEJBM Z FM 'PSP 4PDJBM
EF MBT"NSJDBT -B HFOFBMPHB EFM QFOTBNJFOUP EFDPMPOJBM FT
QMBOFUBSJBZOPTFMJNJUBBJOEJWJEVPT
TJOPRVFTFJODPSQPSBFO
NPWJNJFOUPTTPDJBMFT MPDVBMOPTSFNJUFBNPWJNJFOUPTTPDJBMFT
JOEHFOBTZBGSPTQPSFKFNQMP
5BRJ0OLPZ
UBNCJODPOPDJEB
DPNPMB4VCMFWBDJO(FOFSBMEFMTJHMP97***PMBSFCFMJOEFMPT
XJMMDBT
QBSBMPTQSJNFSPT
FMDJNBSSPOBKFQBSBMPTTFHVOEPT
Z
FOMBDSFBDJOEFJOTUJUVDJPOFT
DPNPMPTGPSPTRVFTFBDBCBOEF
NFODJPOBS
8BNBO1VNBFTUSVDUVSMBUFTJTHFOFSBMEFMNBOVT-
DSJUPRVFMFFOWJB'FMJQF***FOFMUUVMPNJTNPNueva crnica y
buen gobierno-BUFTJTQBSUF
FOQSJNFSMVHBS
EFMBJEFBEFRVF
VOBOVFWBDSOJDBFTOFDFTBSJBQPSRVFUPEBTMBTDSOJDBTDBTUF-
MMBOBT UJFOFO TVT MNJUFT &M MNJUF RVF UJFOFO
TJO FNCBSHP
OP
FTVOMNJUFFOFMNJTNPQBSBEJHNBUFPMHJDPDSJTUJBOPEFTEFFM
DVBMTFOBSSBO QPSFKFNQMP
MBEJGFSFODJBRVFQVFEFIBCFSFOUSF
VOKFTVJUB
VOEPNJOJDPPVOTPMEBEP
OJUBNQPDPFTDVFTUJOEF
TJFMDSPOJTUBDBTUFMMBOPGVFUFTUJHPQSFTFODJBMmyUFTUJHPQSFTFODJBM
EF RV
yEF TJHMPT EF IJTUPSJB BJNBSB P OIVBUM m P OP EF MB
DPMPOJ[BDJO:FTRVFBQFTBSEFRVFBMHVOBTEJTQVUBTJOUFSOBT
TFQSPEVDBOFOUSFRVJFOFTTVTUFOUBCBOFMQSJWJMFHJPEFMjZPMP
WJvGSFOUFBBRVFMMPTRVFSFFYJPOBCBOTPCSFMBT*OEJBTFO$BT-
UJMMB MVHBSGTJDP
ZEFTEFFMQFOTBNJFOUPHSFDPMBUJOPDSJTUJBOP
MVHBSFQJTUNJDP
DPNP-QF[EF(NBSBGSFOUFB#FSOBM%B[
EFM$BTUJMMP
FTPTMNJUFTOPGVFSPOSFDPOPDJEPTmRVJ[TUBNQPDP
QFSDJCJEPTmFOUSFMPTDBTUFMMBOPT2VJFOQPEBWFSMPTFSB8BNBO
1VNB/PTFUSBUBTPMPEFRVFMPTDBTUFMMBOPTOPQFSDJCJFSBOFMMPT
NJTNPTMPRVFQFSDJCJ8BNBO1VNB
TJOPRVFUBNQPDPFTUBCBO
FODPOEJDJPOFTEFDPNQSFOEFSMPRVF8BNBO1VNBQFSDJCBZFM
BSHVNFOUPRVFMFQSPQVTPB'FMJQF***&ODPOTFDVFODJB
8BNBO
1VNBGVFjOBUVSBMNFOUFvTJMFODJBEPQPSDVBUSPDJFOUPTBPT:
DVBOEPTFMPjEFTDVCSJvBQBSFDJFSPOUSFTMOFBTJOUFSQSFUBUJWBT
6OB
MBEFMPTDPOTFSWBEPSFTRVFJOTJTUJFSPOFOMBGBMUBEFJOUFMJ-
217
-VJT(%F.VTTZr.JHVFM7BMEFSSBNB
HFODJBEFVOJOEJP0USB
MBQPTJDJOBDBENJDBQSPHSFTJWBRVF
DPNQSFOEJUBOUPMBDPOUSJCVDJOEF8BNBO1VNBDPNPTVTJ-
MFODJBNJFOUPQPSQBSUFEFMPTIJTQBOPTQFOJOTVMBSFTZMPTDSJPMMPT
EF"NSJDBEFM4VS14-BUFSDFSBGVFMBJODPSQPSBDJOEF8BNBO
1VNBFOFMQFOTBNJFOUPJOEHFOBDPNPVOPEFTVTGVOEBNFOUPT
FH
DPNP1MBUOZ"SJTUUFMFTQBSBFMQFOTBNJFOUPFVSPQFP
"T
FOMPTEFCBUFTBDUVBMFTEFMB"TBNCMFB$POTUJUVZFOUFFO#P-
MJWJB
MBQPTJDJOJOEHFOBQSJWJMFHJBMBQSFTFODJBZSFJOTDSJQDJO
EFM5BXBOUJOTVZVZMPTMFHBEPTEFMQFOTBNJFOUPEFDPMPOJBMFO
MBPSHBOJ[BDJOTPDJBMZFDPONJDBEF#PMJWJBNJFOUSBTRVFFM
&TUBEPMJCFSBMQSJWJMFHJBMBDPOUJOVBDJOEFMNPEFMPFVSPQFPEF
&TUBEP-B6OJWFSTJEBE*OUFSDVMUVSBMEFMPT1VFCMPTZ/BDJPOFT
*OEHFOBTEFM&DVBEPS
"NBXUBZ8BTJ
GPSKTVDVSSDVMVNZPC-
KFUJWPT EF FOTFBO[B TVQFSJPS FO FM5BXBOUJOTVZV Z FO FM RVJ-
DIVB
BVORVFUBNCJOTFjVTFvFMDBTUFMMBOP15NJFOUSBTRVFMB
VOJWFSTJEBE FTUBUBM DPOUJOB MB SFQSPEVDDJO EF MB VOJWFSTJEBE
OBQPMFOJDB
FODFSSBEB FO MPT MFHBEPT EFM HSJFHP
FM MBUO Z MBT
TFJTMFOHVBTJNQFSJBMFTFVSPQFBTNPEFSOBT
ZFOFTUFDBTP
FMDBT-
UFMMBOP
DPOUPUBMEFTNFESPZPMWJEPEFMRVJDIVB
&M QPUFODJBM FQJTUNJDP Z EFDPMPOJ[BEPS FTU QSFTFOUF FO MB
jOVFWB DSOJDBv 8BNBO 1VNB NJSBCB Z DPNQSFOEB EFTEF MB
QFSTQFDUJWBEFMTVKFUPDPMPOJBM FMTVKFUPGPSNBEPZGPSKBEPFOFM
5BXBOUJOTVZVZFOFMkeswaymaraDPOGSPOUBEPDPOMBQSFTFODJB
SFQFOUJOBEFMDBTUFMMBOPZEFMNBQBNVOEJEF0SUFMJVT
ZOPEFM
TVKFUPNPEFSOPRVFFO&VSPQBDPNFO[BQFOTBSTFFOTNJTNP
DPNP TVKFUP B QBSUJS EFM 3FOBDJNJFOUP5FOB UBNCJO BDDFTP B
JOGPSNBDJPOFT B MBT RVF OP UFOBO BDDFTP MPT DBTUFMMBOPT QPDPT
DBTUFMMBOPTEPNJOBCBOFMBJNBSBZFMRVJDIVB
ZRVJFOFTMMFHBSPO
BDPNQSFOEFSMPFOTVTBOEBO[BTQPSMPT"OEFT
RVFEBSPOUPEBWB
MFKPTEFMBFOUFSBDPNQSFOTJOEFVOBMFOHVBZVOBTVCKFUJWJEBE
EFJHVBMBSTVTBPTEFFTDPMBSJEBEFOMBUOZHSJFHPZEFWJWFODJB
FO MB QFOOTVMB y*NBHJOBO VTUFEFT B 8BNBO 1VNB FO $BTUJMMB
DPOUBOEPMBTIJTUPSJBTEFMPTDBTUFMMBOPTZTVTBOUJHFEBEFTHSFDP
MBUJOBT 1VFT FO CVFOB Z KVTUB IPSB MPT DBTUFMMBOPT TF IVCJFSBO
14
"OCBM 2VJKBOP
j$PMPOJBMJEBE Z NPEFSOJEBESBDJPOBMJEBEv
) #POJMMB
DPNQ
Los conquistados. 1492 y la poblacin indgena de las Amricas
PQDJU
Q
15
'SBOLMJO1FBDFFO1FS
3PMFOB"EPSOPFO&TUBEPT6OJEPT
.FSDFEFT-QF[
#BSBMUFO1VFSUP3JDP
P3BRVFM$IBOH3PESHVF[
FO1FS&&66
218
Historiografa postmoderna
TFOUJEPIVNJMMBEPTZMFIVCJFSBOEJDIPBFTUFTFPSRVFFOSFB-
MJEBEOPFOUJFOEFNVZCJFOEFRVTFUSBUB
RVFFMMBUOZRVFFM
HSJFHPZRVFMBDSJTUJBOEBEOPTPODPTBTRVFTFDPNQSFOEBOFOVO
QBSEFBPT%FNPEPRVFTJCJFOFMOBUJWP BOEJOPPDBTUFMMBOP
OPUJFOFQSJWJMFHJPTFODVBOUPBMBWFSEBEEFMBIJTUPSJB
BNCPTT
UJFOFO VOB TVCKFUJWJEBE Z VOB MPDBMJ[BDJO HFPIJTUSJDB TJOHVMBS
MFOHVBT
USBEJDJPOFT
NJUPT
MFZFOEBT
NFNPSJBT
FOMBTDVBMFTTF
CBTBTVNBOFSBEFDPNQSFOEFSTFBTNJTNP
BMPTPUSPTZBMNVO-
EP:FTUBTJOHVMBSJEBEEFFYQFSJFODJBZEFWJWFODJBTOPMFQVFEF
TFSOFHBEBOJBMPTVOPTOJBMPTPUSPT FSBOUPEPTIPNCSFTFOFTUF
DPOUFYUP
BVORVFMPTDBTUFMMBOPTBTVNBOBMNJTNPUJFNQPVOB
VOJWFSTBMJEBERVFMFTFSBQSPQJBZRVFOPQFSUFOFDBBOJOHOPUSP
IBCJUBOUFEFMQMBOFUBRVFOPGVFSBDSJTUJBOP
"EFNT
DPNPTVKFUPDPMPOJBM
8BNBO1VNBUVWPVOBTVC-
KFUJWJEBEEFGSPOUFSB EPCMFDPODJFODJB
DPODJFODJBNFTUJ[BFOMB
UFSNJOPMPHBEFIPZ
TVCKFUJWJEBEEFMBRVFOPQVEJFSPOQBSUJDJ-
QBSOJOHVOPEFMPTDBTUFMMBOPT
JODMVJEP+VBOEF#FUBO[PTRVFTF
IBCBDBTBEPDPOVOBQSJODFTBJODB&MQFOTBNJFOUPGSPOUFSJ[P
TVSHFEFMBEJGFSFODJBJNQFSJBMDPMPOJBMEFQPEFSFOMBGPSNBDJO
EF MBT TVCKFUJWJEBEFT %F BI RVF FM QFOTBNJFOUP GSPOUFSJ[P OP
TFBDPOOBUVSBMBVOTVKFUPRVFIBCJUBMBDBTBEFMJNQFSJP
QFSP
RVFTMPTFBFOMBGPSNBDJOEFTVKFUPTRVFIBCJUBOMBDBTBEFMB
IFSJEBDPMPOJBM-BjOVFWBDSOJDBvFT
QSFDJTBNFOUF
FTPVOSF-
MBUPEPOEFMBDPTNPMPHBBOEJOB keswaymara
DPNJFO[BBSFIB-
DFSTFFOEJMPHPDPOJDUJWPDPOMBDPTNPMPHBDSJTUJBOB
FOUPEB
TVEJWFSTJEBENJTJPOFSBDBTUFMMBOB EPNJOJDPT
KFTVJUBT
GSBODJT-
DBOPT
Z DPO MB NFOUBMJEBE CVSPDSUJDB EF MPT PSHBOJ[BEPSFT
EFM &TUBEP CBKP MBT SEFOFT EF 'FMJQF *** 8BNBO 1VNB Z MPT
DSPOJTUBTDBTUFMMBOPTFTUOTFQBSBEPTQPSMBEJGFSFODJBDPMPOJBM
FQJTUNJDBJOWJTJCMFQBSBMPTDBTUFMMBOPT
WJTJCMFDPNPVOBHSBO
NVSBMMBQBSB8BNBO1VNB&TFODPOGSPOUBDJODPOFTBNVSBMMB
RVF8BNBO1VNBFTDSJCF&MIFDIPEFRVFQBSBMPTDBTUFMMBOPT
ZQBSBRVJFOFTWFOMBTDPTBTEFTEFMBTEJWFSTBTMPDBMJ[BDJPOFTEF
MBDPTNPMPHBFVSPQFB
FTBNVSBMMB MBEJGFSFODJBFQJTUNJDBDP-
MPOJBM
GVFSBJOWJTJCMF
MMFWBMBOPDPNQSFOTJOEFMBQSPQVFTUB
EF8BNBOZBTVTJMFODJBNJFOUP
y2VFQSPQPOB8BNBO1VNB 6OjCVFOHPCJFSOPvCBTBEP
FO VOB jOVFWB DSOJDBv /BUVSBM RVF BT GVFSB &M IJTUPSJBEPS
219
-VJT(%F.VTTZr.JHVFM7BMEFSSBNB
DBUBMO+PTFQ'POUBOBEJKPFOBMHONPNFOUP
OPIBDFNVDIP
UJFNQP
jIBZ UBOUBT IJTUPSJBT DPNP QSPZFDUPT QPMUJDPTv16 -B
EJWFSTJEBEEFQSPZFDUPTQPMUJDPTEFMPTDBTUFMMBOPTTFBVOBCBO
FOVODPODFQUPEFMBIJTUPSJB
DVZBTGVFOUFTFTUBCBOFO(SFDJBZ
3PNB )FSEPUP
5JUP-JWJP
5BTTP
&MQSPZFDUPQPMUJDPRVF
FKFNQMJDBO8BNBO1VNBPFM5BRJ0OLPZ MBTVCMFWBDJOHF-
OFSBMEFMTJHMP97***
UBNCJODPOPDJEBDPNPMBSFCFMJOEFMPT
XJMMDBT
OP /P TF BQPZBO FO MB NFNPSJB EF (SFDJB Z 3PNB
EFNT FTU EFDJS RVF OP IBCB BCTPMVUBNFOUF OJOHVOB SB[O
QBSBRVFBTGVFSB
ZQSFDJTBNFOUFFTPGVFPUSPFMFNFOUPEFMB
JOGFSJPSJEBEEFMPTJOEJPTRVFOPDPOPDBOOJMB#JCMJBOJMPTQFO-
TBEPSFTHSFDPSSPNBOPT
y$NP QSPQPOB8BNBO 1VNB FTUF jCVFO HPCJFSOPv &O
QSJNFSMVHBS
FTUSVDUVSFMSFMBUPIJTUSJDPDPOVOBDPOTUBOUFZ
DPIFSFOUFDSUJDBUJDPQPMUJDB$SJUJDQPSJHVBMBMPTDBTUFMMB-
OPT
BMPTJOEJPT
BMPTOFHSPT
BMPTNPSPTZBMPTKVEPT-B[POB
EFM$V[DP
FOMBTFHVOEBNJUBEEFMTJHMP97*
FSB
TJOEVEB
VOB
TPDJFEBEjNVMUJDVMUVSBMv EJSBNPTIPZ
1FSPOPVOBTPDJFEBE
jNVMUJDVMUVSBMv FO FM JNQFSJP TJOP FO MB DPMPOJB y)BZ BMHVOB
EJGFSFODJB j.VMUJDVMUVSBMJTNPvFTjNVMUJDVMUVSBMJTNPvOPJN-
QPSUBEOEF
TFBSHVNFOUBSBEFTEFVOBFQJTUFNPMPHBEFTJODPS-
QPSBEB Z EFTMPDBMJ[BEB 4F QVFEF QFOTBS
DPNP TJNQMF DPSSFMB-
DJO
FOMBTPDJFEBEjNVMUJDVMUVSBMvEFMBQFOOTVMBDSJTUJBOPT
NPSPT
KVEPT Z DPOWFSTPT RVF QPOBO FO NPWJNJFOUP MBT USFT
DBUFHPSBTSFMJHJPTBT&OMBTDPMPOJBT
FODBNCJP
MPTQJMBSFTFSBO
JOEJPT
DBTUFMMBOPTZBGSJDBOPT
TPCSFUPEPEFTEFOBMFTEFMTJHMP
97* FO BEFMBOUF "EFNT
FO MBT DPMPOJBT BQBSFDF MB DBUFHPSB
EFNFTUJ[BKFZMPTUSFTNFTUJ[BKFTjCTJDPTvBQBSUJSEFMPTUSFT
QJMBSFTEFMUSJOHVMPFUOPSSBDJBMNFTUJ[PB
NVMBUPBZ[BNCPB
-BUFPSBQPMUJDBEF8BNBOTFBSUJDVMBFOEPTQSJODJQJPTMB
DSUJDBBUPEPTMPTHSVQPTIVNBOPTJEFOUJDBCMFTFOMBDPMPOJBZ
16
-BTNPUJWBDJPOFTQPMUJDBT
MPTPGBFEVDBUJWB
DPODFQUVBMJ[BDJOEFMDVSS-
DVMVNZFTUSVDUVSBEFMPTDJDMPTEFBQSFOEJ[BKF ZEFEFTBQSFOEFSMPBQSFO-
EJEPFOFMQSPDFTPEFDPMPOJBMJEBEEFMTBCFS
QBSBEFTDPMPOJ[BSFMTBCFSZFM
TFS
FTUOFYQMJDBEBTFOEFUBMMFFOMBPCSBEF+PSHF(BSDB
"MGSFEP-P[BOP
+VMJP 0MJWFSB Z $TBS 3VJ[ FET
Sumak yachaypi, alli kawsaypipash ha-
chakuna (Aprender en la sabidura y el buen vivir)
2VJUP
6OJWFSTJEBE*O-
UFSDVMUVSBM"NBXUB8BTJm6/&4$0
1BSUFEFMQSPDFTPEFHFTUBDJO
QVFEFWFSTFFOFM#PMFUO*DDJ3JNBJ
EFM
FOIUUQJDDJOBUJWFXFCPSH
CPMFUJO SFWJTBEPFMEFEJDJFNCSFEF
220
Historiografa postmoderna
MBQSPQVFTUBEFVOjCVFOHPCJFSOPvEFMPTWJSUVPTPT
JOEFQFO-
EJFOUFNFOUF EF TV PSJHFO 4FHO FM QSJNFS QSJODJQJP
MB DSUJDB
B UPEPT MPT HSVQPT IVNBOPT JEFOUJDBCMFT FO MB DPMPOJB TFHO
MBTDBUFHPSBTDMBTJDBUPSJBTEFMNPNFOUP
OBEJFTFTBMWBEFMBT
DSUJDBT EF8BNBO 1VNB y1FSP DVM FT FM DSJUFSJP RVF FNQMFB
8BNBOQBSBTVDSUJDB &MDSJTUJBOJTNPjy$NP v1SFHVOUVO
FTUVEJBOUFFOMBUFSDFSBDMBTFTPCSF8BNBO1VNB
jyDNPQVFEF
TFSQFOTBNJFOUPEFDPMPOJBMTJBCSB[FMDSJTUJBOJTNP v4JOFN-
CBSHP
TMPFT3FFYJPOFNPT"OBMFTEFMTJHMP97*ZQSJODJQJPT
EFM 97** OP FYJTUB %JEFSPU
OJ 3PVTTFBV
OJ ,BOU
OJ 4QJOP[B
OJ .BSY
OJ 'SFVE &T EFDJS
MB DSUJDB TFDVMBS OP FYJTUB UPEB-
WB8BNBO1VNBBTVNFMBDSJTUJBOEBEIJTUSJDBZUJDBNFOUF
)JTUSJDBNFOUF
FOMBNFEJEBFORVFBSHVNFOUBMBDSJTUJBOEBE
EF MPT BOEJOPT BOUFT EF MB MMFHBEB EF MPT DBTUFMMBOPT &TUF BS-
HVNFOUPUJFOFEPTOJWFMFT6OP
FMOJWFMIJTUSJDPTFHOFMDVBM
8BNBO1VNBBQBSFDFSBDPNPVONFOUJSPTPQVFTUPRVFOPIBZ
DSJTUJBOJTNPBOUFTEFMBMMFHBEBEFMPTDBTUFMMBOPT&MPUSPOJWFM
FTMHJDPFQJTUNJDP&OFTUBMFDUVSB
FMDSJTUJBOJTNPFO&VSPQB
OPTFSBTJOPMBWFSTJOSFHJPOBMEFDJFSUPTQSJODJQJPTRVFBGFDUBO
BMBDPOEVDUBIVNBOBZRVFFTUBCMFDFODSJUFSJPTQBSBMBDPOWJ-
WFODJB
QBSBFMjCVFOWJWJSv&MBSHVNFOUPEF8BNBO1VNBEFCF
MFFSTF FO FTUF TFHVOEP OJWFM Z OP FO FM QSJNFSP -B MFDUVSB EFM
QSJNFSOJWFMFTFVSPDOUSJDBZMFPUPSHBBMBDSJTUJBOEBEPDDJEFO-
UBMFVSPQFBmRVFNTUBSEFTFFYQBOEFB"NSJDBmMBQPTFTJO
EFQSJODJQJPTVOJWFSTBMFTCBKPFMOPNCSFEFDSJTUJBOJTNPj$SJT-
UJBOJTNPv FO FM BSHVNFOUP EF8BNBO 1VNB FT FRVJWBMFOUF BM
EFjEFNPDSBDJBvFOMBQMVNBZMBQBMBCSBEFMPT[BQBUJTUBTMB
EFNPDSBDJBOPFTQSPQJFEBEQSJWBEBEFMQFOTBNJFOUPZMBUFPSB
QPMUJDBEF0DDJEFOUF
TJOPVOQSJODJQJPEFDPOWJWFODJB
EFCVFO
WJWJS
RVFOPUJFOFEVFP8BNBO1VNBTFBQPEFSEFMPTQSJODJ-
QJPTDSJTUJBOPTBQFTBSEFZDPOUSBMPTNBMPTDSJTUJBOPT
JHVBMRVF
MPT[BQBUJTUBTTFBQPEFSBOEFMBEFNPDSBDJBBQFTBSEFZDPOUSB
FM (PCJFSOP NFYJDBOP FO DPOUVCFSOJP DPO MB DPNFSDJBMJ[BDJO
EF MB EFNPDSBDJB FO FM NFSDBEP EF8BTIJOHUPO &TUB BOBMPHB
UJFOFVOBEPCMFGVODJOQFEBHHJDB
QBSBFOUFOEFSMBTJUVBDJO
EF8BNBO1VNBIBDFDVBUSPTJHMPTZNFEJP
ZQPMUJDBZFQJTU-
NJDB
QBSBSFDPSEBSMBDPOUJOVJEBEEFMQFOTBNJFOUPEFDPMPOJBM
BUSBWTEFMPTTJHMPT
FOTVTEJWFSTBTNBOJGFTUBDJPOFT
221
-VJT(%F.VTTZr.JHVFM7BMEFSSBNB
&MTFHVOEPQSJODJQJPEFMBUFPSBQPMUJDBEF8BNBO1VNB
USBTIBCFSSFBMJ[BEPMBDSUJDBBUPEPTMPTHSVQPTIVNBOPTFJEFO-
UJDBEPUBNCJOTVTWJSUVEFT
FTMBQSPQVFTUBEFVOjCVFOHP-
CJFSOPvEFMPTWJSUVPTPT
OPJNQPSUBTFBOJOEJPTBT
DBTUFMMBOPT
BT
NPSPBTPBGSJDBOPBTOFHSPBT&MjCVFOHPCJFSOPv
FOPUSBT
QBMBCSBT
TF QSPQPOF DPNP FM MVHBS EF MB DPOWJWFODJB Z EF MB
TVQFSBDJOEFMBEJGFSFODJBDPMPOJBM-PTEPTHSVQPTGVFSUFTmQP-
MUJDBZEFNPHSDBNFOUFmFSBO
TJOEVEB
MPTDBTUFMMBOPTZMPT
JOEJPT
ZFTVOBEFMBTQPTJCJMJEBEFTMHJDBTRVF8BNBO1VNBOP
PDVMUFTVJEFOUJDBDJODPOMPTJOEJPT
BVORVFQPESBIBCFSPQ-
UBEPQPSJEFOUJDBSTFDPOMPTDBTUFMMBOPTBTVNJFOEPRVFOVODB
TFSBVODBTUFMMBOPFOUSNJOPTEFTVCKFUJWJEBEBVORVFMPGVFSB
QPSMFHBMJEBE&OMBNFEJEBFORVFFMQFOTBNJFOUPEFDPMPOJBM
TVSHF EF VO HJSP HFP Z DPSQPQPMUJDP GSFOUF B MB UFPQPMUJDB
EFTJODPSQPSBEBZEFTMPDBMJ[BEBP
NFKPS
MPDBMJ[BEBFOFMOP
MVHBSEFFTQBDJPRVFNFEJBFOUSF%JPTZTVTSFQSFTFOUBOUFTFOMB
5JFSSB
jMBFQJTUFNPMPHBEFMQVOUPDFSPvFTJODPOHSVFOUFDPOFM
QFOTBNJFOUPEFDPMPOJBMMBFQJTUFNPMPHBEFMQVOUPDFSPGVOEB
ZTPTUJFOFMBSB[OJNQFSJBM UFPZFHPQPMUJDBNFOUF
17.
8BNBO 1VNB DPOTUSVZ MB JEFB EF jCVFO HPCJFSOPv FO FM
5BXBOUJOTVZV"MDPOUSBSJPEFMBTVUPQBTPDDJEFOUBMFTNPEFS-
OBTRVFJOJDJ5PNBT.PSP
VOTJHMPBOUFT
MBVUPQBEF8BNBO
1VNB OP TF VCJDB FO VO OPMVHBS EFM UJFNQP mMBT VUPQBT PD-
DJEFOUBMFT NPEFSOBT TF BODBO FO VO OPFTQBDJP EF VO GVUVSP
TFDVMBSm
TJOPFOMBSFJOTDSJQDJOEFVOFTQBDJPEFTQMB[BEPQPS
MPTDBTUFMMBOPT&OWFSEBE
MPRVFQSPQPOF8BNBO1VNBFTVOB
jUPQBv EF MB SB[O GSPOUFSJ[B Z EFM QFOTBNJFOUP EFDPMPOJBM
3B[OGSPOUFSJ[BQPSRVFTVjUPQBvTFFTUSVDUVSFOFM5BXBO-
UJOTVZV$PNPTFTBCF
5BXBOUJOTVZVTJHOJDBBQSPYJNBEBNFO-
UFjMPTDVBUSPMBEPTPSJODPOFTEFMNVOEPv1BSBRVJFOOPFTU
GBNJMJBSJ[BEPB DPO FM EJBHSBNB EF5BXBOUJOTVZV
JNBHJOF MBT
EJBHPOBMFTEFVODVBESBEP TJOMPTDVBUSPMBEPT
TPMPMBTEJBHP-
OBMFT
-PTDVBUSPFTQBDJPTGPSNBEPTQPSMBTEJBHPOBMFTTPOMPT
DVBUSPTVZPT
FTQBDJPTTJHOJDBUJWPTFOMBFTUSVDUVSBZKFSBSRVBT
TPDJBMFT&MDFOUSP
FOFMJODBOBUP
MPPDVQBCB$V[DP
ZFOMBT[P-
OBTPQVFCMPTEFMJODBOBUP
UPEPTFMMPTPSHBOJ[BEPTFO5BXBOUJO-
17
0EPEFRVJFOFTFTDVDIBSPOVOBDPOGFSFODJBFOMBDVBMMPFYQSFT:TJOP
MPIVCJFSBEJDIP'POUBOB
IBCSBRVFEFDJSMP
222
Historiografa postmoderna
18
-B FHPQPMUJDB EFTQMB[
QFSP OVODB FMJNJO MB UFPQPMUJDB "NCBT TF SF-
OFO
FOUSFPUSPTNVDIPTMVHBSFT
FOFMQFOTBNJFOUPQPMUJDPEF$BSM4DI-
NJUU
FKFNQMBSNFOUF
FOTVTeologa poltica
223
-VJT(%F.VTTZr.JHVFM7BMEFSSBNB
19
%VSBOUFMBTTFTJPOFTEFMQSPHSBNBEFEPDUPSBEPFO&TUVEJPT$VMUVSBMFT
FO
MB6OJWFSTJEBE"OEJOB4JNO#PMWBS
FO2VJUP KVMJP
EJTDVUJNPTFO
VOBEFMBTDMBTFTEF$BUIFSJOF8BMTIMBDSUJDBEF8BNBO1VNBBMPTBGSJDB-
OPT&EJTPO-FOQVTPFODVFTUJOMBQPTJCJMJEBEEFDPOTJEFSBSEFDPMPOJBMB
8BNBO1VNB
QSFDJTBNFOUFQPSFTBTDSUJDBT&OFTFNPNFOUPNJMFDUVSBEF
8BNBO1VNBFTUBCBVOQPDPPMWJEBEB
QFSPQFOTBCBSFUPNBSMBKVTUPQBSB
VOTFNJOBSJPRVFEJDUBSBFOFMPUPPEFM
FO%VLF1VFTCJFO
MBSF-
MFDUVSBEF8BNBO1VNBSFWFMBTQFDUPTmDPNPTJFNQSFFOMBMFDUVSBEFFTUF
DPNQMFKPZSJDPUFYUPm
BMPTRVFOPIBCBQSFTUBEPBUFODJOBOUFSJPSNFOUF
-PRVFBRVTPTUFOHPFTQBSUFEFDPOWFSTBDJPOFTDPO$BUIFSJOFZ&EJTPOZ
EFNJSFMFDUVSB
QPTUFSJPSBMBTDPOWFSTBDJPOFT
TPCSFFMBTVOUP
224
Historiografa postmoderna
225
-VJT(%F.VTTZr.JHVFM7BMEFSSBNB
TVTOVFWPTZUFSSJCMFTJOWBTPSFTRVFIBCBOEFTPMBEPZEFWBTUBEP
TVQBT20.
&O FM QSSBGP NF JOUFSFTB TVCSBZBS WBSJBT DPTBT FM NBOFKP
EFMBMFOHVB
DPNPZBEJKFFMDPOPDJNJFOUPZMBTPMJEBSJEBEDPO
MB QPCMBDJO JOEHFOB CBKP MB DPMPOJ[BDJO DBTUFMMBOB
RVF $V-
HPBOPBTFNFKBBMBEFTIVNBOJ[BDJOEFBNCPT
EFMJOEJPZEFM
OFHSPMBDSUJDBEJSFDUB
CSVUBM
EFVOOFHSPFTDMBWPBMPTDPNFS-
DJBOUFTZFYQMPUBEPSFTCMBODPT UBOEJSFDUBZCSVUBMDPNPMBEF
8BNBO1VNB
&TUBTDSUJDBT $VHPBOPZ8BNBO1VNB
ZBOP
TFTJUBOFOFMNJTNPOJWFM QBSBEJHNB
RVFMBDSUJDBEF-BT$B-
TBTBTVTQSPQJPTDPNQBUSJPUBT-BDSUJDBEF$VHPBOPZ8BNBO
1VNBTFVCJDBFOPUSBQBSUF
FOFMFTQBDJPEFMHJSPEFDPMPOJBM
&OFTUFTFOUJEP
FMQSSBGPFTVOPEFUBOUPTPUSPTTFNFKBOUFTFO
MPT RVF MB DSUJDB WB EJSJHJEB B MBT GPSNBT EF HPCJFSOP Z B MB
DPNVOJEBE JNQFSJBM GPSNBEB QPS &TQBB
1PSUVHBM
'SBODJB F
*OHMBUFSSB 1BSB $VHPBOP MB EJTUJODJO FOUSF OBDJPOFT JNQFSJB-
MFTOPUJFOFTFOUJEP-BEJGFSFODJBDPMPOJBMOPTFEFUJFOFFOMBT
GSPOUFSBTJOUFSJNQFSJBMFT1BSBMBEJGFSFODJBJNQFSJBM
FODBNCJP
MB GPSNBDJO OBDJPOBM FTU FO KVFHP
Z FT BT RVF EFTEF
*TBCFM * EF *OHMBUFSSB UFKJ FO TV JNQFSJP CSJUOJDP MB MFZFOEB
OFHSB DPOUSB MPT BCVTPT EF MPT DBTUFMMBOPT FO"NSJDB
HSBDJBT
BMBJOGPSNBDJOZMBTDSUJDBTTVNJOJTUSBEBTQPS#BSUPMPNEF
MBT $BTBT %F FMMP TF IBDF FDP $VHPBOP
QFSP DBTUJHBOEP B TV
WF[ B MPT JOHMFTFT QPS TVT CSVUBMJEBEFT DPO MPT FTDMBWPT OFHSPT
TFNFKBOUFTPQFPSFTBMBTEFMPTDBTUFMMBOPTDPOMPTJOEJPT*TBCFM
*
PDVQBCB UPEBWB FM USPOP EF *OHMBUFSSB DVBOEP
QVCMJD $VHPBOP TV MJCSP
Z MP PDVQ DBTJ RVJODF BPT NT B
QBSUJSEFMBGFDIBEFQVCMJDBDJO4JOFNCBSHP
*TBCFM*OPIJ[P
DPNFOUBSJPTTFNFKBOUFT
DSJUJDBOEPMBNJTNBCSVUBMJEBEFONB-
OPT EF MPT JOHMFTFT RVF FMMB IBCB DPOEFOBEP FO NBOPT EF MPT
DBTUFMMBOPT-BDSUJDBEF$VHPBOPTFVCJDBZTFQJFOTBFOZEFTEF
MBEJGFSFODJBDPMPOJBM-BMFZFOEBOFHSBTFVCJDBZTFQJFOTBFOZ
EFTEFMBEJGFSFODJBJNQFSJBM$VHPBOPOPTFFOHBBOJTFEJTUSBF
DPOMBTQPMNJDBTJNQFSJBMFT1BSBVOFYFTDMBWPUPEPTMPTHBUPT
TPOQBSEPTj&TFWJMOFHPDJPEFTFDVFTUSBSZSPCBSIPNCSFTGVF
DPNFO[BEP QPS MPT QPSUVHVFTFT FO MB DPTUB EFGSJDB <> -PT
20
4PCSFFTUFBTVOUP
WFSQPSFKFNQMP
IUUQSFTFBSDIIJTUPSZPSH)JTUPSJDBM@
3FTFBSDI3FTFBSDI@5IFNFT5IFNF&OTMBWF4PNFSTFUDGN
226
Historiografa postmoderna
21
&M QSSBGP FOUSFDPNJMMBEP QSPWJFOF EF History of America
EF8J-
MMJBN3PCFSUTPO
-BDJUBEF$VHPBOPFTUUPNBEBEFMBFEJDJO
Thoughts and Sentiments of the Evil and Wicked Traffic of the Slavery and
Commerce of the Human Species, Humbly Submitted to the Inhabitants
of Great Britain <>
-POESFT
1FOHVJO
Q5PEBTMBTDJUBTEF
$VHPBOPQSPWJFOFOEFFTUBFEJDJO
227
-VJT(%F.VTTZr.JHVFM7BMEFSSBNB
PTJNQMFNFOUFOPUPDBTVTVCKFUJWJEBEFMQFOTBNJFOUPEF"JN
$TBJSF
DBOOJDPFOMBHFOFBMPHBEFMQFOTBNJFOUPJNQFSJBM&O
$TBJSFQPEBWFSMPRVFRVJ[TQPDPT TJFTRVFBMHVOPT
QFOTBEPSFTFVSPQFPTQPEBOjWFSv
UBOEFTQPTFEPTRVFFTUBCBO
ZFTUOEFMBSDIJWPDPOTUSVJEPQPSMBIFSJEBDPMPOJBM0CTFSWBCB
$TBJSFj4
WBMESBMBQFOBFTUVEJBS
DMOJDBNFOUF
DPOEFUBMMF
MBTGPSNBTEFBDUVBSEF)JUMFSZEFMIJUMFSJTNP
ZSFWFMBSMFBMNVZ
EJTUJOHVJEP
NVZIVNBOJTUB
NVZDSJTUJBOPCVSHVTEFMTJHMPXX
RVFMMFWBDPOTJHPVO)JUMFSZRVFMPJHOPSB
RVF)JUMFSMPIBCJUB
RVF )JUMFS FT TV EFNPOJP
RVF
TJ MP WJUVQFSB
FT QPS GBMUB EF
MHJDB
ZRVFFOFMGPOEPMPRVFOPMFQFSEPOBB)JUMFSOPFTFM
DSJNFOFOT
FMDSJNFODPOUSBFMIPNCSF
OPFTMBIVNJMMBDJO
EFMIPNCSFFOT
TJOPFMDSJNFODPOUSBFMIPNCSFCMBODP
FTMB
IVNJMMBDJOEFMIPNCSFCMBODP
ZIBCFSBQMJDBEPFO&VSPQBQSP-
DFEJNJFOUPT DPMPOJBMJTUBT RVF IBTUB BIPSB TF IBCBO SFTFSWBEP
QBSBMPTSBCFTEF"SHFMJB
MPTDPPMJFTEFMB*OEJBZMPTOFHSPTEF
GSJDBv22.
"JNBSBT Z RVFDIVBT DPNP UBNCJO MBT DPNVOJEBEFT EF
"OIVBDZ"CZB:BMB
OPEJTQPOBOEFVODPODFQUPUBMDPNPFM
BDUVBMEFjWJEBv vie
life
vita
PachaFSBVODPODFQUPDPNQMFKP
FOFMRVFTFBHSVQBCBOOPDJPOFTEFFTQBDJPZUJFNQPFOFMDPSSFS
EFMBTFTUBDJPOFT
FOFMNPWJNJFOUPEFM4PMZMB-VOB
FMDSFDFS
EFQMBOUBTZBOJNBMFT
MBDBEBEFMBTIPKBTFOJOWJFSOP
FMOEFM
NPWJNJFOUP FO TFSFT WJWJFOUFT FO DJFSUP NPNFOUP EF TV BDPO-
UFDFS EFTEF FM OBDJNJFOUP
MB DBEB EF MB MMVWJB
FM NPWJNJFOUP
EF MBT OVCFT
FUD j7JEBv
FO MB DPTNPMPHB FVSPQFB NPEFSOB
QPESBUSBEVDJSTFBMBTDPTNPMPHBTOBUJWBTDPNPFMNPWJNJFO-
UPRVFOPTJODMVZFEFMBDPOUFDFSEFMDPTNPT&MFODVFOUSPDPO
MPTFVSPQFPTMFTQSPEVKPVOpacha-kuti
VOWVFMDPSBEJDBMFOFM
BDPOUFDFS
FO TV NBOFSB EF FTUBS FO FM DPTNPT
EF QFSNBOFDFS
DPO BRVFMMPT DVFSQPT RVF FO VO NPNFOUP EFUVWJFSPO FM NPW-
JNJFOUPZFMBDPOUFDFS
QFSPOPEFKBSPOEFFTUBSFOMPTNJFNCSPT
EF MB DPNVOJEBE 1PS FTP
FO NVDIPT EJTDVSTPT [BQBUJTUBT
TF
JOWPDBOQSFTFODJBTZDPOWFSTBDJPOFTDPOjMPTNVFSUPTv-PTRVF
EFKBSPOEFNPWFSTFOPEFKBSPOEFFTUBSFOTFSFTRVFDPOUJOBO
NPWJOEPTFj7JEBNVFSUFvFSBVODPODFQUPBKFOP
DPNPMPFSB
UBNCJO FM EBSTF DVFOUB EF RVF TVT jWJEBTv FSBO EFTFDIBCMFT
22
Ibd
Q
228
Historiografa postmoderna
QBSBMPTBENJOJTUSBEPSFTZDPORVJTUBEPSFTFVSPQFPT"MBNJTNB
DPODMVTJO MMFHBSPO BGSJDBOPT FTDMBWJ[BEPT Z TVT EFTDFOEJFOUFT
$PNPMPEJS&SJD8JMMJBNTNVDIPEFTQVT
MBTjWJEBTvEFDV-
FSQPTFTDMBWJ[BEPTFSBOEFTFDIBCMFTQPSRVFMBTDPOWJSUJFSPOFO
NFSDBEFSBT/PFSBOTJNQMFNFOUFjWJEBTEFTOVEBTv DJVEBEBO-
PTEFTQPKBEPTEFTVCKFUJWJEBEZDPOWFSUJEPTFOONFSPEFEPDV-
NFOUPTZFOEJSFDDJPOFTQPTUBMFTFOFMDFOTPEFMPTFTUBEPT
&SBO
NT RVF FTP
GVFSPO Z TJHVFO TJFOEP jWJEBT EFTFDIBCMFTv -BT
WJEBTEFTFDIBCMFTIBOTJEPZTJHVFOTJFOEPMBTSBDJBMJ[BEBT
MBT
EFMPTTVKFUPTNPEFSOPTDPMPOJBMFT
FTEFDJS
NBOJQVMBEPTQPSMPT
QSPZFDUPTZEJTFPTJNQFSJBMFT-BTjWJEBTEFTOVEBTvTPOMBTEF
MPTTVKFUPTNPEFSOPT
TVKFUBEPT
QFSPOPEFTFDIBEPT1PSFTP
FO
MBDPNQPTJDJOEFMPTFKSDJUPTRVF&TUBEPT6OJEPTFOWBB*SBL
FMONFSPEFTPMEBEPTEFDPMPSFTNBZPSBMEFTPMEBEPTCMBODPT
"T
MBjWJEBEFTOVEBvRVFjEFTDVCSJv"HBNCFOZRVFUBOUP
FOUVTJBTNBBMBNFOUBMJEBECMBODBEFMB&VSPQBPDDJEFOUBMZEF
&TUBEPT6OJEPT
FTUBSEBNFOUFMPRVFJOEJPTZOFHSPTTBCBOEF
PUSBNBOFSBEFTEFFMTJHMP97*2VFWJEBTEFHFOUFCMBODBGVFSBO
EFTFDIBCMFTGVFVOBOPWFEBEQBSB&VSPQBZ"OHMP"NSJDB&TB
OPWFEBEFTUBNCJOQBSUFEFMBDFHVFSBEFMjIPNCSFCMBODPv
VOB
DFHVFSB FO MB RVF FM EFTDVCSJNJFOUP EF MB EFTFDIBCJMJEBE EF MB
WJEBIVNBOBQFSNJUFBIPSBDPOTUSVJSBSHVNFOUPTjDSUJDPTvCB-
TBEPTFOMBIVNJMMBDJOEFMIPNCSFCMBODP&MQFOTBNJFOUPEF
DPMPOJBM
RVFUBNCJOBUJFOEFBMPTIPSSPSFTEFM)PMPDBVTUP
MPT
BUJFOEF B USBWT EF TV HFTUBDJO IJTUSJDB FO FM TJHMP 97* FO TVT
IJTUPSJBTQBSBMFMBT
FO&VSPQB
BMBFYQMPUBDJOEFJOEJPTZOFHSPT
FO"NSJDBZGSJDB
QFSPUBNCJOBMBTQPCMBDJPOFTEF"TJB
-MFHBEPTBFTUFQVOUPOPTDPOWJFOFWPMWFSBMBVCJDBDJOOP
TPMP HFPIJTUSJDB TJOP UBNCJO FQJTUNJDB mZ FM DPSSFMBUP FOUSF
BNCPTmEFMEFDJS&OMBIJTUPSJBEFMBTJEFBT
EFMBMPTPGB
EFMB
DJFODJB FO &VSPQB Z EF &VSPQB FTUF BTVOUP TF EJP QPS TFOUBEP
QPSRVFTFBTVNJRVFMPJNQPSUBOUFFTBRVFMMPRVFZTPCSFMPRVF
TFQJFOTBZOPEFTEFEOEFZBQBSUJSEFEOEFTFQJFOTB7FBNPT
VOCPUOEFNVFTUSB$POHMPSJPTBQSPTBRVFSFDVFSEBMBNTJDB
EF8BHOFS
+FBO+BDRVFT3PVTTFBV
FOFMDiscurso sobre el origen
y los fundamentos de la desigualdad entre los hombres
BOVODJBTVVCJDBDJOFQJTUNJDB
UJDBZQPMUJDBEFFTUBNBOFSB
j3FSJOEPTFNJUFNBBMIPNCSFFOHFOFSBM
QSPDVSBSCVTDBSVO
229
-VJT(%F.VTTZr.JHVFM7BMEFSSBNB
MFOHVBKFRVFDPOWFOHBBUPEBTMBTOBDJPOFTNFKPSBO
PMWJEBOEP
MPTUJFNQPTZMPTMVHBSFTQBSBQFOTBSUBOTPMPFOMPTIPNCSFTB
RVJFOFTIBCMP
TVQPOESRVFFTUPZFOFMMJDFPEF"UFOBTSFQJUJFOEP
MBTMFDDJPOFTEFNJTNBFTUSPT
UFOJFOEPQPSKVFDFTBMPT1MBUOZ
MPT+FODSBUFTZBMHOFSPIVNBOPQPSPZFOUFv23.
8BNBO1VNBZ0UUBCBI$VHPBOPEJGDJMNFOUFJNBHJOBSBO
FM-ZDFVNEF"UFOBTDPNPFTDFOBSJPEFTVQBMBCSB
OJTFPMWJ-
EBSBO EFM UJFNQP Z EFM FTQBDJP 4 EJSBO
FO DBNCJP mNF QV-
FEP JNBHJOBSm
RVF TVT QSFPDVQBDJPOFT TPO EF JOUFST QBSB MB
IVNBOJEBE FO HFOFSBM
QVFTUP RVF TF USBUB EF VOB DJWJMJ[BDJO
RVFIBMMFHBEPBEFTFDIBSWJEBTIVNBOBT1FSPQVOUVBMJ[BSBOMB
EJGFSFODJBDPMPOJBMRVF
BQBSUJSEFMTJHMP97*
SFPSHBOJ[MBjSB[B
IVNBOBDPNPQPTJCMFBVEJFODJBvZPDVMURVFFOMBSB[BIVNB-
OBIBZWJEBTRVFOPUJFOFOWBMPS
FYQSFTJOEFMQSPQJP$VHPBOP
3PVTTFBVFTDSJCJVOQSSBGPRVFSFWFMBFMFODBOEJMBNJFOUPEFM
EFTFPZWPMVOUBEEFIBCMBSQPSMBSB[BIVNBOB
FOVONPNFOUP
FORVFMBUSBOTGPSNBDJONBTJWBEFMBWJEBIVNBOBFONBUFSJB
EFTFDIBCMFmRVFQPSQSJNFSBWF[DPNFO[BPDVSSJSFOMBIJTUP-
SJBEFjMBSB[BIVNBOBvFOFMTJHMP97*m
MMFWBCBZBNTEFEPT
TJHMPTEFIJTUPSJB$PNP$VHPBOPVOPTWFJOUFBPTEFTQVT
Z
8BNBO 1VNB VOPT EPT TJHMPT BOUFT
3PVTTFBV FTUBCB QSFPDV-
QBEPQPSMBEFTJHVBMEBE0CTFSWBOEPMBFTDFOBFVSPQFB
FOTV
QSFTFOUFZFOTVIJTUPSJB QFSPEFTBUFOUPBMBTEFTJHVBMEBEFTZMB
IFSJEBJOGSJOHJEBQPSMBEJGFSFODJBDPMPOJBM
3PVTTFBVPCTFSW
j$PODJCPFOMBFTQFDJFIVNBOBEPTDMBTFTEFEFTJHVBMEBEVOB
RVFMMBNPOBUVSBMPGTJDBQPSRVFIBTJEPFTUBCMFDJEBQPSMBOB-
UVSBMF[BZRVFDPOTJTUFFOMBEJGFSFODJBEFFEBEFT
EFTBMVE
EF
MBT GVFS[BT EFM DVFSQP Z MBT DVBMJEBEFT EFM FTQSJUV P EFM BMNB
PUSB
RVFQVFEFEFOPNJOBSTFEFTJHVBMEBENPSBMPQPMUJDB
QVFT
EFQFOEFEFVOBFTQFDJFEFDPOWFODJOZFTUFTUBCMFDJEB
PDV-
BOEPNFOPTBVUPSJ[BEB
QPSFMDPOTFOUJNJFOUPEFMPTIPNCSFT
&TUBMUJNBDPOTJTUFFOMPTEJGFSFOUFTQSJWJMFHJPTEFMPTRVFHP[BO
VOPTFOEFUSJNFOUPEFMPTPUSPT
DPNPFMTFSNTSJDPT
NTIPO-
SBEPT
NTQPEFSPTPTRVFFMMPTP
JODMVTP
IBDFSTFPCFEFDFSv24.
23
"JN$TBJSF
Discurso sobre el colonialismo
.BESJE
"LBM
Q
24
+FBO+BDRVFT 3PVTTFBV
Discurso sobre el origen y los fundamentos de la
desigualdad entre los hombres y otros escritos, .BESJE
&EJUPSJBM5FDOPT
Q
230
Historiografa postmoderna
1BSB3PVTTFBVQSFHVOUBSTFQPSMBGVFOUFEFMBEFTJHVBMEBE
OBUVSBMOPUFOBTFOUJEPQVFTUPRVFFTBQSFHVOUB
TFHOM
FTUB-
CBZBSFTQPOEJEBEFBOUFNBOPQPSMBTJNQMFEFOJDJOEFMBQB-
MBCSBMBEFTJHVBMEBEFTOBUVSBM
ZOPIBZOBEBNTRVFQSFHVO-
UBS&TBONTTJOTFOUJEPQSFHVOUBSTFmDPOUJOB3PVTTFBVmTJ
IBZBMHVOBDPOFYJOFTFODJBMFOUSFMBTEPTEFTJHVBMEBEFT
QVFTUP
RVFIBDFSFTUBQSFHVOUBTJHOJDBSB
TFHO3PVTTFBV
QSFHVOUBS
TJRVJFOFTFTUOFOFMQPEFSZFOQPTJDJOEFPSEFOBSTPOOFDF-
TBSJBNFOUFNFKPSFTRVFBRVFMMPTRVFPCFEFDFO&TUFUJQPEFQSF-
HVOUBT
DPODMVZF 3PVTTFBV
TFSBO BEFDVBEBT FO VOB EJTDVTJO
EF MPT FTDMBWPT FO VOB BVEJFODJB DPO TV BNP
QFSP UPUBMNFOUF
JODPOEVDFOUF F JODPSSFDUB TJ UBMFT QSFHVOUBT GVFSBO EJSJHJEBT B
IPNCSFTSB[POBCMFTZMJCSFTFOCTRVFEBEFMBWFSEBE253PVT-
TFBV
QPSDJFSUP
DPOEFOMBFTDMBWJUVE
QFSPEFUBMDPOEFOBOP
TFEFSJWBCB
FOTVUJFNQPmDPNPMPNVFTUSBOUBOUPTPUSPTIPN-
CSFTEFMTJHMP97***
,BOUFOUSFFMMPTmRVFTFBDFQUBSBTJONTMB
JHVBMEBEEFMPTOFHSPTBGSJDBOPT-BEFTJHVBMEBEOBUVSBMFTVO
QSJODJQJPTVDJFOUFQBSBEJTUJOHVJSMPJOKVTUPEFMBFTDMBWJUVEZMB
JOGFSJPSJEBEEFMPTOFHSPTBGSJDBOPTEFMNJTNPQMVNB[P
0UUBCBI$VHPBOPEJPVOHJSPEFDJFOUPPDIFOUBHSBEPT FH
VOBGSBDUVSBZPQDJOEFDPMPOJBM
BMPTEFCBUFTTPCSFEFSFDIPZ
MFZOBUVSBMRVFPDVQBSPOBIPNCSFTZNVKFSFTCMBODBTEFMTJHMP
97***.JFOUSBTRVF8BNBO1VNBSFTQPOEBBMEFCBUFJNQFSJBM
FOQMVNBTEFUPEBVOBQMZBEFEFNJTJPOFSPTZIPNCSFTEFMF-
USBT -BT$BTBT
"DPTUB
.VSB
BRVJFOFTNFODJPOBBMOBMEFMB
/VFWB$SOJDBw
$VHPBOPSFTQPOEBBJEFBTFOCPHBEVSBOUF
MB*MVTUSBDJOZFOVONPNFOUPEFBTDFOEFODJBJOUFMFDUVBMFO*O-
HMBUFSSB
"MFNBOJBZ'SBODJB&OUSFMPTOPNCSFTRVFEPNJOBCBO
FM UFSSFOP JOUFMFDUVBM
MPTDP Z QPMUJDP
FTUO MPT EF (FPSHF
#FSLFMFZZTVPrincipios de conocimiento humano
"MFY-
BOEFS1PQFZTVEnsayo sobre el hombre
%BWJE)VNFZ
su Investigacin sobre el entendimiento humano
P&X-
QISBJN -FTTJOH Z TV Educacin de la raza humana
&M
USBUBEPQPMUJDPFT
BMBWF[
FDPONJDP-PTBOMJTJTFDPONJDPT
EFMBTSFMBDJPOFTFOUSFMBFTDMBWJUVEZFMNFSDBEPRVFPGSFDF$V-
HPBOP
UBNCJOEBOVOHJSPEFDJFOUPPDIFOUBHSBEPTBMUSBUBEP
EF"EBN4NJUILa riqueza de las naciones
QVCMJDBEPVOPTEJF[
25
Ibid
Q
231
-VJT(%F.VTTZr.JHVFM7BMEFSSBNB
BPTBOUFTRVFFMEF$VHPBOP.TBO
FMIBCFSUJUVMBEPTVEJT-
DVSTPPensamientos y sentimientos
$VHPBOPBMVEFEJSFDUBNFOUF
BMUSBUBEPEF4NJUILa teora de los sentimientos morales
&O SFTVNFO
FM USBUBEP EF $VHPBOP FT VOB CSVUBM DSUJDB UJDB
B MPT EFQSFEBEPSFT JNQFSJBMFT Z SPCBEPSFT EF IPNCSFT FYQSF-
TJPOFTRVFBQBSFDFOSFQFUJEBTWFDFTFOTVEJTDVSTP
FOOPNCSF
EFMBUJDBDSJTUJBOBVOBOMJTJTEFMBFDPOPNBZMBFTDMBWJUVE
JOTJTUJFOEPDPOTUBOUFNFOUFFOMBEFTFDIBCJMJEBEEFMBWJEBEFMPT
OFHSPT jOur lives are accounted of no valuev $VHPBOP DPO-
DMVZFTVEJTDVSTPDPOQSPQVFTUBTDPODSFUBTQBSBUFSNJOBSDPOMB
FTDMBWJUVE
DPNQFOTBSBMBTOBDJPOFTBGSJDBOBTQPSMPTEBPTJO-
JOHJEPTZMFHBMJ[BSFMUSBCBKP*OEFQFOEJFOUFNFOUFEFRVFFTUBT
DVFTUJPOFTRVFQMBOUFB$VHPBOPFTUOUPEBWBIPZBCJFSUBT
MP
JNQPSUBOUFQBSBNJBSHVNFOUPFTJEFOUJDBSFMHJSPEFDPMPOJBM
"OUIPOZ #PHVFT TJO VTBS FM MFOHVBKF EF GSBDUVSB EFDPMPOJBM
NBSDBTJOUSFQJEBSFMEFTFOHBODIFZMBBQFSUVSBEF$VHPBOPFOFM
NCJUPEFMBUFPSBQPMUJDB%JDF#PHVFT
FOSFMBDJODPOMPTEF-
CBUFTZUFNBTFOEJTDVTJOFOUSFMTPGPTZUSBUBEJTUBTQPMUJDPT
FVSPQFPTEF*OHMBUFSSB
"MFNBOJBZ'SBODJBj&MEJTDVSTPQPMUJDP
EF$VHPBOPTVHJFSFMBFYJTUFODJBEFPUSBDPSSJFOUFRVFBSUJDVMB
OPDJPOFTTPCSFMBMJCFSUBEOBUVSBMZMPTEFSFDIPTOBUVSBMFT1BSB
$VHPBOP
FMEFSFDIPOBUVSBMGVOEBNFOUBMFSBFMEFSFDIPEFMJO-
EJWJEVP B TFS MJCSF F JHVBM
OP DPO SFMBDJO BM HPCJFSOP TJOP B
PUSPTTFSFTIVNBOPTv26.
#PHVFTBHSFHBRVFFMBSHVNFOUPEF$VHPBOP
RVFSFDMBNBMB
JHVBMEBEEFMPTOFHSPTFOVONVOEPFOFMDVBMMBUFPSBQPMUJDB
ZFMDPODFQUPEFIVNBOJEBEFTUBCBFONBOPTEFMPTCMBODPT F
H
MB EFTJHVBMEBE OBUVSBM
DPNQMFNFOUB FM HJSP EFDPMPOJBM BM
QMBOUFBS BQBSUJSEFMBFYQFSJFODJBEFMBFTDMBWJUVEOFHSPBGSJ-
DBOB
RVFMPTTFSFTIVNBOPTTPOJHVBMFTZMJCSFTGSFOUFBPUSPT
TFSFTIVNBOPTZOPGSFOUFBM&TUBEP&MBSHVNFOUPEF3PVTTFBV
BTFHVSB
FODBNCJP
MBJHVBMEBEGSFOUFBM&TUBEPZNBOUJFOFMB
EFTJHVBMEBEOBUVSBMFOUSFMPTIPNCSFT&TUFHJSPFTFMRVFTFQBSB
B$VHPBOPEFMSFTUPEFMPTBCPMJDJPOJTUBTCMBODPT
RVJFOFTBSHV-
NFOUBODPOUSBMBFTDMBWJUVEQFSPNBOUJFOFOMBJOGFSJPSJEBEEFM
OFHSP"T
jDVBOEPKVOUBNPTFTUBTDPTBT
OPQPEFNPTFTDBQBS
EFMBDPODMVTJORVFFYJTUBFOMBOBSSBUJWBFTDMBWBEF$VHPBOP
26
Ibid
Q
232
Historiografa postmoderna
VOBDPOUSBOBSSBUJWBQPMUJDBRVFTFNPWBFOVOBEJSFDDJOEJGF-
SFOUFBMBEFMPTIPSJ[POUFTQPMUJDPTEFMB*MVTUSBDJOv27.
-B EJSFDDJO EJGFSFOUF RVF UPNB $VHPBOP FO FM IPSJ[POUF
QPMUJDP EF MB *MVTUSBDJO
FT QSFDJTBNFOUF MP RVF BRV JOUFOUP
EFTDSJCJSDPNPMBPQDJOEFDPMPOJBMZMBHFTUBDJOEFMQFOTBN-
JFOUP EFDPMPOJBM FO MB GVOEBDJO NJTNB EFM NVOEP NPEFSOP
DPMPOJBMZ
QPSFOEF
EFMDBQJUBMJTNPDPNPMPFOUFOEFNPTIPZ-B
GVFS[BZMBFOFSHBEFMQFOTBNJFOUPEFDPMPOJBMFTUVWPTJFNQSF
BI
FOMBFYUFSJPSJEBE
FOMPOFHBEPQPSFMQFOTBNJFOUPJNQF-
SJBMDPMPOJBM
*7$
27
"OUIPOZ #PHVFT
Black Heretics, Black Prophets: Radical Political Intel-
lectuals
/VFWB:PSL
3PVUMFEHF
Q
233
-VJT(%F.VTTZr.JHVFM7BMEFSSBNB
28
Ibid
Q
234
Historiografa postmoderna
51
Hayden White
&1SFTVQPOFVOUJFNQPEF
DSJTJTZ
BEFNT
RVFMBDSJTJTTFBFYQMDJUB
FWJEFOUFQBSBUPEPT
:VTVBMNFOUFMMBNBBMBBDDJO PFOFMDBTPEFMPTNBOJFTUPT
SFMJHJPTPT
VODBNCJPEFDPSB[O
QBSBTVQFSBSPNFKPSBSMBTJ-
UVBDJOFODVFTUJO
&MUJFNQPEFMNBOJFTUPFTFMQSFTFOUF ZFMGVUVSPJONFEJB-
UP
FMUJFNQPjBIPSBv FMJetztzeitEF#FOKBNJO
EFMBEFDJTJO
&MNBOJFTUPOPUJFOFJOUFSTBMHVOPFOFMQBTBEPFYDFQUPDPNP
QBSUF EFM QSPCMFNB B SFTPMWFS &M NBOJFTUP
DPNP OPT SFDVFS-
EB%FSSJEBFOEspectros de Marx
OPTEJDFUQJDBNFOUFRVFjFM
UJFNQPFTUGVFSBEFRVJDJPv
RVFjZBFTUJFNQPvEFRVFBSSFHMF-
NPTMBTDPTBT
ZMVFHPQSPQPOFVODVSTPEFBDDJOPVODBNCJP
EF DPSB[O DPO FM O EF BWBO[BS IBDJB UJFNQPT NFKPSFT FO FM
GVUVSP%FSSJEBTFBMBUBNCJORVFFMQBSBEJHNBEFMNBOJFTUP
NPEFSOPTFIBMMBFOMBTBOUJHVBTGPSNBT CCMJDBT
EFMBQSPGFDB
QPSVOBQBSUF
ZFOFM&WBOHFMJP evangelion
QPSPUSB-BQSJ-
NFSB
QPSTVQVFTUP
QSPNFUFDBTUJHPTQBSBBRVFMMPTRVF
BUBEPT
QPSFM1BDUP
WJPMBOTVTUSNJOPTUJFOEFIBDJBMPBQPDBMQUJDP&M
TFHVOEP
QSPDMBNBMBWFOJEBEFVOOVFWPUJFNQP jFMUJFNQPTF
SFBMJ[Bv
DPOVOBOVFWBMFZ
ZOVFWPTQSPTQFDUPTEFDPNVOJEBE
UJFOEF IBDJB MP SFWPMVDJPOBSJP &M NBOJFTUP QPMUJDP NPEFSOP
QVFEF DPNCJOBS BNCPT NPEPT
NF[DMBOEP GVFHP Z B[VGSF
Z
BNPSZMV[FOJHVBMNFEJEB&MNBOJFTUPBSUTUJDPmQJOTFTFFO
MPTEFMPTGVUVSJTUBTZMPTTVSSFBMJTUBTmDPNCJOBMBBNFOB[BZMB
QSPNFTBFOVOTJNVMBDSPEFSFWFMBDJO&MNBOJFTUPDJFOUDP
1
1VCMJDBEP PSJHJOBMNFOUF FO MB BOUPMPHB EF ,FJUI +FOLJOT
4VF .PSHBOE
Z"MVO .VOTMPX FE
Manifestos of History
-POESFT
3PVUMFEHF
5SBEVDDJOEF1BCMP"CVGPN
235
-VJT(%F.VTTZr.JHVFM7BMEFSSBNB
236
Historiografa postmoderna
EJTUJOHVJSTFEFMPTUJQPTEFNBOJFTUPTQSPEVDJEPTFOMBNPEFS-
OJEBE "M NFOPT
UFOESB RVF TFS VO NBOJFTUP postmoderno
VOBQBSPEJBEFVONBOJFTUPP
TJBDFQUBNPTMBJEFBEF+BNFTPO
TPCSFFMQPTUNPEFSOJTNP
VOjQBTUJDIFvEFPUSPT
EFBOUFSJPSFT
NBOJFTUPT
4PCSFUPEP
VONBOJFTUPQPTUNPEFSOPOPQPESBTFSVONB-
OJFTUPsincero3PTFOTUPOFMPEJDFBCJFSUBNFOUFDVBOEPTFBMB
BQSPQTJUPEFMQSPZFDUPEFMPTFEJUPSFT
RVFjUJFOFORVFFTUBS
CSPNFBOEPv:-B$BQSBMPJOTJOBDVBOEPFTQFSBDPOTFWFSJEBE
RVF IBZB QBTBEP MB QPDB FO RVF VO JOEJWJEVP UFOESB MB JO-
UFODJOEFMFHJTMBSQSPDFEJNJFOUPTQBSBDVBMRVJFSEJTDJQMJOBRVF
QSFUFOEFDJFOUJDJEBEHFOVJOB"T
OVFTUSPTSFOVFOUFTNBOJGFT-
UBEPSFTTFBDFSDBOBMNBOJFTUP
OPFYBDUBNFOUFNBOJGFTUOEPTF
ZOPFYBDUBNFOUFnoNBOJGFTUOEPTF
y2VFOUPODFT y.BOJFTUPTJSOJDPT y.BOJFTUPTQPTUNP-
EFSOPT &TUP QPESB RVFSFS EFDJS RVF FO WF[ EF TFBMBS MP RVF
FTUjNBOJFTUPvFOMBBDUVBMTJUVBDJOEFOVFTUSBEJTDJQMJOBZMP
RVFjNBOJFTUBNFOUFvEFCFDBNCJBSTFFOM
QPESBNPTFTQFSBS
VONBOJFTUPQPTUNBOJFTUP
TFBMBOEPMPRVFOPFTPCWJPFO
MBTJUVBDJOBDUVBM
ZFOFTQFDJBMBRVFMMPRVFFTUFOFMQSFTFOUF
RVF FO SFBMJEBE QFSUFOFDF BM QBTBEP
MP RVF IB EF TFS devela-
do
PEFTSFWFMBEPDPNPQBTBEPUPEBWBQSFTFOUFFOFMQSFTFOUF
QBSB RVF TF MP TVQFSF: DVBOEP TF USBUB EF MB jIJTUPSJBv
FTUF
QSPDFTPEFEFWFMBNJFOUPZEFTSFWFMBNJFOUPTFSBMMFWBEPBDBCP
UBOUPFOFMNJTNPDPODFQUPNPEFSOJTUBEFjIJTUPSJBvDPNPFO
BRVFMMPT BTQFDUPT EFM QSFTFOUF RVF DPOUJOBO BDFDIBOEP B MPT
WJWPT BVORVF NFSFDFO TFS QVFTUPT B EFTDBOTBS P TFQVMUBEPT P
NFKPS
BSDIJWBEPT&TFTUFUJQPEFEPCMFZUSJQMFQFOTBSMPRVF
QPESB EBS DVFOUB EFM UPOP EF JSPOB RVF QFSNFB FM MJCSP2. De
JHVBMNBOFSBQPESBEBSDVFOUBEFMBSFDVSSFODJBEFMBTOPDJPOFT
EFcriticismo y crticaQSFTFOUBEBTFOWBSJPTNBOJFTUPT FTQFD-
DBNFOUFFOMPTEF&SNBSUI
%PNBOTLB
4DPUU
+PZDF
1PTUFSZ
-B$BQSB
DPNPTPMVDJOBMPTQSPCMFNBTEFMBIJTUPSJBFOVOB
QPDBQPTUNPEFSOB
2
)BZ EJTUJOUPT UJQPT EF JSPOB UBNCJO KPDPTB FO FM DBTP EF 3PTFOTUPOF
FOUVTJBTUBFOFMDBTPEF%FOJOH
ZBHSJEVMDFFOFMDBTPEF-PXFOUIBM:FO
EPTDBTPT
MPTEF4PVUIHBUFZ"OLFSTNJU
IBZ TJOPNFFRVJWPDP
VOBCVFOB
DBOUJEBEEFQBSPEJBQBSPEJBEFBOUJHVPTQSPHSBNBTQSFNPEFSOPT
IVNB-
OJTUBFIJTUPSJDJTUB
SFTQFDUJWBNFOUF
237
-VJT(%F.VTTZr.JHVFM7BMEFSSBNB
"IPSB
FTQPTJCMFRVFVOHSVQPEFFTUVEJBOUFTQSPGFTJPOBMFT
EFIJTUPSJB FTDPHJEPTDPNPTFB
OPTFBOMPTNFKPSFTDBQBDJUB-
EPT QBSB MB UBSFB EF WJTVBMJ[BS VOB jIJTUPSJB QBSB FM GVUVSPv
-PTNJFNCSPTEFMBQSPGFTJORVFTFMMBNBOBTNJTNPTjIJT-
UPSJBEPSFTBDUJWPTv yFOPQPTJDJOBjIJTUPSJBEPSFTOPBDUJWPTv
PjOPIJTUPSJBEPSFTBDUJWPTv
UJFOFOJOUFSJPSJ[BEBVOBBWFSTJO
QPSFMUJQPEFQFOTBNJFOUPQSPZFDUJWPRVFSFRVJFSFFMNBOJFT-
UP"EFNT
TFSVOQSPGFTJPOBMPBMNFOPTFTUBSjEJTDJQMJOBEPv
TJHOJDBFWJUBSUPEPUJQPEFQFOTBNJFOUPFYUSFNJTUB$SFPRVF
%PNJOJDL-B$BQSBIBCMBDPNPhistoriador QSPGFTJPOBMDVBOEP
BEWJFSUF BDFSDB EFM FYUSFNJTNP EFM jDPOTUSVDUJWJTNP SBEJDBMv
QPSVOBQBSUF
ZEFMPRVFMMMBNBjQBSBEJHNBEFJOWFTUJHBDJO
BVUPTVDJFOUFv
QPSPUSB&OTVEFTFPEFjSFTJTUJSFMBQPDBMJQTJTv
TJO FNCBSHP
QPESB FTUBS TPCSFTUJNBOEP MP RVF FTU FO KVFHP
FOFMFTGVFS[PQPSSFGPSNBSPFONFOEBSOVFTUSBEJTDJQMJOB5BM
DPNPQSFHVOUB3PCFSU3PTFOTUPOF
yRVJONTRVFFMIJTUPSJB-
EPS QSPGFTJPOBM TF QSFPDVQB QPS FM GVUVSP EF MB IJTUPSJPHSBGB
QSPGFTJPOBM &OTVDSFDJFOUFFTQFDJBMJ[BDJOZBMFKBNJFOUPEFMBT
QSFPDVQBDJPOFT EFM QSFTFOUF
DPNP TFBMB %BWJE )BSMBO
IBDF
NVDIPRVFMFIBOEFKBEPEFJNQPSUBSBDVBMRVJFSBRVFUSBCBKF
GVFSBEFTVTDBNQPTFTQFDJBMJ[BEPTEFJOUFST&MQCMJDPHFOFSBM
BQSFOEFNTEFIJTUPSJBFOMPTNFEJPTZHSBDJBTBMPTFTDSJUPSFT
QPQVMBSFTEFCJPHSBGBT
CBUBMMBTZDSNFOFT
5PEB FTUB QSFPDVQBDJO TPCSF DVBMRVJFS QPTJDJO RVF WBZB
jNVZMFKPTvPQSFUFOEBjEFNBTJBEPvTVHJFSFRVFOVFTUSPTNB-
OJGFTUBEPSFT manifesters
RVJFSFOSFTJTUJSUPEPFTQSJUVSBEJDBMZ
FTUO TBUJTGFDIPT DPO SFDPNFOEBS SFWJTJPOFT DPTNUJDBT
DPNP
BHSFHBSOVFWPTDBNQPTEFJOWFTUJHBDJOPOVFWBTGPSNBTEFQSF-
TFOUBDJOBMPTQSPDFEJNJFOUPTZQSDUJDBTFTUBCMFDJEBTEFMBIJT-
UPSJPHSBGBjDPOWFODJPOBMvPjUSBEJDJPOBMv"T
&XB%PNBOTLB
TVHJFSF RVF BHSFHVFNPT VO FRVJWBMFOUF EF MB DSUJDB MJUFSBSJB B
MBGPSNBFORVFMFFNPTUFYUPTIJTUPSJPHSDPT
QFSPOPTVHJFSF
mDPNPIBTVHFSJEPFOTVPUSPUSBCBKPmRVFFTUPQVFEBSFRVFSJS
UBNCJOVODBNCJPFOFMNPEPFORVFescribimosIJTUPSJB&MMB
FTQFSB RVF MB DSUJDB IJTUPSJPHSDB QVFEB EJTDFSOJS NPNFOUPT
jQSPGUJDPTv FO MPT FTDSJUPT IJTUSJDPT
NPNFOUPT RVF BQVOUBO
BMGVUVSPTJOQSFTDSJCJSMBGPSNBRVFQVFEBOUPNBS.BSL1PTUFS
QSFEJDFRVFEFBMHONPEPUFOESFNPTRVFUPNBSFODPOTJEFSB-
238
Historiografa postmoderna
DJOMBSFWPMVDJOEFMPTNFEJPTZFMJNQBDUPEFMPTTJTUFNBTEF
BMNBDFOBNJFOUPZSFDVQFSBDJOEFJOGPSNBDJOEJHJUBMJ[BEBFO
MBFTDSJUVSBEFMBIJTUPSJBFOFMGVUVSP4VTVHFSFODJBEFRVFQP-
ESBNPTUFOFSRVFFYQBOEJSOVFTUSBOPDJOEFMPSFBMQBSBJODMVJS
MPjWJSUVBMvFTBUSBDUJWB
QFSPOPNFRVFEBDMBSPMPRVFJNQMJ-
DBSBFTUFOVFWPDPOUFOJEPEFMBFYQPTJDJOIJTUSJDBFODVBOUP
BMNPEPFORVFMBjIJTUPSJBvQPESBQSFTFOUBSTFQPSFTDSJUPPFO
JNHFOFT#FWFSMZ4PVUIHBUFQJEFRVFFWBMVFNPTMBQPTJCJMJEBE
EFBTVNJSVOBWF[NTmBVORVFFOVOSFHJTUSPMFWFNFOUFEJTUJO-
UPmFMBOUJHVPQSPHSBNBIVNBOJTUBEFFTUVEJBSMBIJTUPSJBDPOFM
OEFEJTDFSOJSjMPRVFTJHOJDBTFShumanov
BVORVFFTQPDP
FWJEFOUFQPSRVEFCJFSBQFOTBSTFRVFMPTIJTUPSJBEPSFTFTUBSBO
NFKPSQSFQBSBEPTRVFMPTQSPGFTJPOBMFTEFPUSBTEJTDJQMJOBTQBSB
PGSFDFSVOBSFTQVFTUBBEJDIBQSFHVOUB)BDFTFUFOUBBPT
0SUF-
HBQMBOUFFTUBDVFTUJODVBOEPFTDSJCJRVFFMIPNCSFOPUJFOF
OBUVSBMF[BMPRVFUJFOFFTIJTUPSJB&TUPTVHJFSFRVFOPTJSBNF-
KPSFTUVEJBOEPMBOBUVSBMF[BQBSBEFTDVCSJSQPSRVFMIPNCSF
UJFOF IJTUPSJB
RVF FTUVEJBOEP IJTUPSJB QBSB MMFHBS B TBCFS TJ FM
IPNCSFUJFOFVOBOBUVSBMF[B
'SBOL "OLFSTNJU
FO MP RVF FO NJ PQJOJO SFTVMUB TFS VO
TPSQSFOEFOUF QSPHSBNB EF EPTQBTPTBUSTQBSBEBSVOQBTP
BEFMBOUF
BDPOTFKB VO SFUPSOP B MPT BOUJHVPT Z CVFOPT NPEPT
EF3BOLFZFMIJTUPSJDJTNPUSBEJDJPOBM
DPOFMOEFSFQPOFSMB
IJTUPSJBFOTVUSBEJDJPOBMUBSFBEFFOTFBSMPTPGB QPMUJDB
DPO
FMFKFNQMP/PTQJEFRVFVUJMJDFNPTMBATBCJEVSBEFMQBTBEP sic
QBSB DSJUJDBS QFMJHSPTPT FYQFSJNFOUPT QPMUJDPT RVF SFQJUFO TJO
TBCFSMP DJFSUPT QSPHSBNBT RVF EFNPTUSBSPO TFS JNQSBDUJDBCMFT
FO UJFNQPT BOUFSJPSFT .FODJPOB B 1PDPDL Z B 4LJOOFS DPNP
HVBTIBDJBEJDIPQSPHSBNBZFTUPUJFOFTFOUJEP
ZBRVFBNCPT
TPOQMFOBNFOUFIJTUPSJBEPSFT
MPRVFTJHOJDBRVFFTUVEJBOUFY-
UPTEFMPTPGBQPMUJDB
MFZFTZUJDBQBSBNPTUSBSDVOJODPNQB-
SBCMFTTPODPODVBMRVJFSQPDBQPTUFSJPS PBOUFSJPS
*ODMVTPMB
TVHFSFODJBBQBSFOUFNFOUFjFYUSFNBvEF3PCFSU3PTFOTUPOFEF
EFKBSBMHPEFFTQBDJPFOOVFTUSBTFYQPTJDJPOFTEFMQBTBEPQBSB
FMKVFHPEFMBJNBHJOBDJOBSUTUJDBEFWVFMWFMBIJTUPSJBBTVan-
teriorBMJBO[B ySPNOUJDB
DPOMBjMJUFSBUVSBv&TUBTVHFSFODJB
FTDPIFSFOUFDPOMBQSPQVFTUBEF"OO3JHOFZEFVOUJQPEFjGF-
EFSBMJTNPvEFMBTEJTDJQMJOBT
DBEBDVBMSFBMJ[BOEPTVUBSFBUSB-
239
-VJT(%F.VTTZr.JHVFM7BMEFSSBNB
EJDJPOBMNFOUFBTJHOBEBFOVOBBUNTGFSBEFUPMFSBODJBNVUVB
JOUFSDBNCJPZDJWJMJEBE
BVORVFFMMBTBCFRVFBDBCBNPTEFQBTBS
QPSVOBTFDVFODJBEFjHVFSSBTEFMBDVMUVSBvRVFIBOEFKBEPIF-
SJEBTFOMBTEJTDJQMJOBTEFMBTIVNBOJEBEFTUSBEJDJPOBMFT
RVJ[T
NTBMMEFUPEBSFQBSBDJO
:BOBTUPEPTFTUPTNBOJGFTUBEPSFTSFUJDFOUFTJOEJDBO
NT
PNFOPTBCJFSUBNFOUF
MBOFDFTJEBEEFVOBFYQBOTJOEFMBJNB-
HJOBDJO FO MPT FTUVEJPT IJTUSJDPT
TJ FT RVF FTUPT
FTP T
IBO
EFTFSEFWVFMUPTBFTBSFMFWBODJBDPOSFTQFDUPBMBTPMVDJOEF
QSPCMFNBTactualesRVFFOQPDBTBOUFSJPSFTTFQFOTRVFIBCBO
UFOJEP1VFTUPRVFTFSFRVJFSFJNBHJOBDJOQBSBSFDPOPDFSRVF
NVDIPEFMPRVFRVFETJOEFDJSFOUJFNQPTNPEFSOPTEFCFTFS
SFWJTBEP
SFDIB[BEPPTJNQMFNFOUFjBSDIJWBEPvFOMPTUJFNQPT
QPTNPEFSOPT:BRV
FOSFBMJEBE
FMBTVOUPUJFOFRVFWFSDPOTJ
BDBTPVOPDSFFRVFMBQPDBFORVFWJWJNPTFTUBOEJGFSFOUFEF
MBRVFWJOPBOUFT PMPRVFBMHVOBWF[TFQFOTRVFWFOBBOUFT
RVFFTOFDFTBSJPVOSFPSEFOBNJFOUPGVOEBNFOUBMEFMBTDJFODJBT
IVNBOBTZTPDJBMFT
1VFTCJFO
UPEPTOVFTUSPTNBOJGFTUBEPSFTQBSFDFODSFFSRVF
algoMFIBPDVSSJEPBMBTPDJFEBEPDDJEFOUBM
BMBTIVNBOJEBEFT
FOHFOFSBM
ZBMPTFTUVEJPTIJTUSJDPTFOQBSUJDVMBS4JBDBTPQJFO-
TBORVFMPRVFIBPDVSSJEPFRVJWBMFBVODBNCJPGVOEBNFOUBM
FOMPRVF)BOOBI"SFOEUMMBNjMBDPOEJDJOIVNBOBvFTBMHP
RVFOPRVFEBDMBSP1FSPQBSFDFPCWJPRVFQBSBBRVFMMPTEFOP-
TPUSPTRVFDSFFNPTWJWJSFOVOBQPDBFORVFMBTSFHMBTEFMKVFHP
TPDJFUBM IBO DBNCJBEP
WPMWJFOEP QSPCMFNUJDB OVFTUSB BDUVBM
DPNQSFOTJOEFRVJOFTTPNPTZIBDJBEOEFOPTEJSJHJNPT
TF
SFRVJFSFBMHOUJQPEFSFQFOTBNJFOUPSBEJDBM-PTIJTUPSJBEPSFT
TFPDVQBOEFMDBNCJPZEFCJFSBO
QPSMPUBOUP
TFSNTSFDFQUJWPT
DPOMBTQPTJCJMJEBEFTEFDBNCJPTGVOEBNFOUBMFTFOOVFTUSBTBSUFT
ZDJFODJBTRVFBRVFMMPTRVFQJFOTBORVFMBIJTUPSJBTFUSBUBTJFN-
QSFEFDPOUJOVJEBEFTNTRVFEFEJTDPOUJOVJEBEFT$VBMRVJFSB
TFBMBEJTUBODJBFOUSFMBTEJTUJOUBTPQJOJPOFTTPCSFMPTEFUBMMFT
VO
IFDIP T
hecho
BHSBOUFTFFSJHFBOUFOPTPUSPTDPOJOOFHBCMF
DMBSJEBEFTUFIFDIPFTMBFYQMPTJOEFNPHSDB
FMNPWJNJFO-
UP EF QPCMBDJPOFT Z FM JNQBDUP RVF FTUBT NVMUJUVEFT EFTQMB[B-
EBTUJFOFOTPCSFMBTDPNVOJEBEFT
MBTJOTUJUVDJPOFTTPDJBMFTZMBT
JEFPMPHBTUSBEJDJPOBMFTZjNPEFSOBTv$PNPIBPCTFSWBEP'SF-
240
Historiografa postmoderna
ESJD+BNFTPO
CJFOQPESBTFSRVFEJDIPTGFONFOPTIJTUSJDPT
BQBSFOUFNFOUFjOVFWPTvDPNPMBTEPTHVFSSBTNVOEJBMFT
MBEF-
QSFTJO
FMHFOPDJEJPNBTJWPNBOVGBDUVSBEPZFMBSNBNFOUJTNP
BUNJDPTFBO
FOFGFDUP
jDPONFOTVSBCMFTv
FODJFSUPOJWFM
DPO
TVTQSPUPUJQPTIJTUSJDPT1FSPFTBTNBTBTEFQFSTPOBTRVFIPZ
QVFCMBOFMHMPCPSFRVJFSFODBNCJPTFOOVFTUSBTOPDJPOFTTPCSF
FTBjOBUVSBMF[BIVNBOBvFOMBRVFUPEPTFTUBNPTJOUFSFTBEPTZ
TPCSFFTBjIJTUPSJBvRVFQSFWJBNFOUFDSFBNPTFSBTVDSFBDJO
&OUPODFT
OPFTTPMPVOBTVOUPEFJODPSQPSBSBMBTNVKFSFT
MPTTVCBMUFSOPT
MPTQSJNJUJWPT
MPTIPNPTFYVBMFT
MBHFOUFEFDP-
MPS
MPTJONJHSBOUFTZBDVBMRVJFSPUSPHSVQPRVFBIPSBSFDMBNF
VOMVHBSFOjOVFTUSBvIJTUPSJBPNTCJFOFOOVFTUSBTFYQPTJDJP-
OFT DPO jOVFTUSBTv NF SFFSP B jPDDJEFOUBMFTv
EF MB jIJTUP-
SJBv"IPSBTFUSBUBmQBSBOPTPUSPT
IJTUPSJBEPSFTmEFSFQFOTBS
MBIJTUPSJBFOUSNJOPTBEFDVBEPTBMBFSBBDUVBM&TUPTJHOJDB
SFQFOTBSMPRVFFTOVFWPFjJOBVEJUPvFOFMDPOUFYUPTPDJBMBD-
UVBMFOWF[EFCVTDBSMBBDPNPEBDJOEFBOUJHVBTDBUFHPSBTEF
FYQMJDBDJOZQSFTFOUBDJOBMPRVFFTNBOJFTUBNFOUFOVFWPZ
EJTUJOUPFOVONVOEPWJTUPTPMPjBUSBWTEFPKPTPDDJEFOUBMFTv
&TEFDJS
TJQPSIJTUPSJBOPRVFSFNPTEFDJSTPMBNFOUFjFMQBTBEPv
TJOP MB SFMBDJO FOUSF FM jQSFTFOUFv FOUFOEJEP DPNP VOB QBSUF
EFMBjIJTUPSJBvZFMjQBTBEPv
FOUPODFTOPTJODVNCFQFOTBSMB
QPTJCJMJEBEEFMQSFTFOUFcomoIJTUPSJB
1FSP
DPNPQPESBQSFHVOUBS,FJUI+FOLJOT
yQPSRVMBIJT-
UPSJB y2VSB[POFTIBZQBSBBTJHOBSMFFTUBUBSFBBMFTUVEJPEFMB
IJTUPSJB .JSFTQVFTUBBEJDIBQSFHVOUBFTRVF
EFTQVTEFMOEF
MBSFMJHJOZMBNFUBGTJDB
MBIJTUPSJBFTBIPSBUPEPMPRVFUFOF-
NPT/PTHVTUFPOP
UPEBTMBTDJFODJBTTPDJBMFTZIVNBOBTBIPSB
UJFOFOTVTGVOEBNFOUPTFOFMEFTPSEFOEFMSFHJTUSPIJTUSJDP
MBT
EFCJMJEBEFTEFMBTMMBNBEPNUPEPIJTUSJDP
ZMPRVF%PNBOT-
LBMMBNBMBjBQFSUVSBvEFMBJNBHJOBDJOIJTUSJDB
7BSJPT EF MPT NBOJFTUPT DPOUFOJEPT BRV mBRVFMMPT EF
$IBLSBCBSUZ
%FOJOH
&SNBSUI
-B$BQSB
+PZDF
)BSMBO Z 4DP-
UUmTFFOGSFOUBOBFTUFUJQPEFDPOTJEFSBDJPOFT
FTEFDJS
yRVIBZ
FOFMQSFTFOUFRVFSFRVJFSFSFWJTJOPSFGPSNBEFMPTjBQBSBUPTv
RVF "MUIVTTFS MMBN MPT dispositif
IJTUSJDPT DPOWFODJPOBMFT
&TUPT NBOJGFTUBEPSFT
FO HFOFSBM Z FO HSBO QBSUF
OPT TFBMBO
FOMBEJSFDDJOEFVOBSFGPSNVMBDJOEFMQFOTBNJFOUPIJTUSJDP
241
-VJT(%F.VTTZr.JHVFM7BMEFSSBNB
242
Historiografa postmoderna
mFOQu es la Ilustracin?mIBCMEFEBSjVODPOUFOJEP
NTQPTJUJWPBMPRVFQPESBTFSVOethosMPTDPRVF
DPOTJTUBFOVOBDSUJDBEFMPRVFEFDJNPT
QFOTBNPTZIB-
DFNPT
BUSBWTEFVOBPOUPMPHBIJTUSJDBEFOPTPUSPTv
'PVDBVMUMVFHPTFBMBRVFMBDSUJDBZBOPTFSQSBDUJDBEB
FOCTRVFEBEFFTUSVDUVSBTGPSNBMFTDPOWBMPSVOJWFSTBM
TJOPDPNPJOWFTUJHBDJOIJTUSJDBEFMPTBDPOUFDJNJFOUPT
RVFOPTIBOMMFWBEPBDPOTUJUVJSOPTZSFDPOPDFSOPTDPNP
TVKFUPTEFMPRVFIBDFNPT
QFOTBNPT
EFDJNPT&OFTF
TFOUJEP
FTUB DSUJDB FT HFOFBMHJDB FO TV EJTFP Z BS-
RVFPMHJDBFOTVNUPEP:FTUBDSUJDBTFSHFOFBMHJDB
FOFMTFOUJEPEFRVFTFQBSBS
EFFTBDPOUJOHFODJBRVF
OPTIBIFDIPMPRVFTPNPT
MBQPTJCJMJEBEEFEFKBSEFTFS
IBDFSPQFOTBSMPRVFTPNPT
IBDFNPTPQFOTBNPT
3
'SFESJD+BNFTPO
The Political Unconscious: Narrative as Socially Symbolic
Act, *UIBDB
$PSOFMM6OJWFSTJUZ1SFTT
Q
243
-VJT(%F.VTTZr.JHVFM7BMEFSSBNB
EF RVF FM IPZ
FM BIPSB
P FM NPNFOUP QSFTFOUF SFRVJFSFO RVF
FM FTUVEJP TFB NFOPT DPNP FM SFTVMUBEP EF BMHO QBTBEP
RVF
DPNPVOBTJOHVMBSJEBERVFQPESBEBSOPTJEFBTTPCSFMPTUJQPT
EFDPOPDJNJFOUPRVFOFDFTJUBNPTEFMQBTBEPmZTPCSFUPEPEFM
QBTBEPSFDJFOUFPJONFEJBUPmQBSBjFTDBQBSEFMvZQSPTFHVJS
IBDJBPUSBTGPSNBTNTDSFBUJWBTEFJOEJWJEVBMJEBE
DPNVOJEBE
ZSBDJPOBMJEBE
"IPSB
FTUBJEFBEFFTDBQBSEFMQSFTFOUFDPOTUJUVZFVOBHSBO
EJGFSFODJBFOUSFOVFTUSPTNBOJGFTUBEPSFTQPTNPEFSOPTZNPEFS-
OPT&TUBEJWJTJOFTNTJNQPSUBOUFEFMPRVFQPESBTFSDVBM-
RVJFS PUSB EJWJTJO FOUSF QSPHSFTJTUBT Z DPOTFSWBEPSFT
QPSRVF
DPNPQMBOUFB$IBLSBCBSUZFOTVFOTBZP
TPOMPTIJTUPSJBEPSFT
EFVOBUFOEFODJBHFOFSBMNFOUFjMJCFSBMv
DPNP&WBOT
(JOTCVSH
)PCTCBXN
"QQMFCZZ
T
EFCPBHSFHBSMPT
-PXFOUIBM
%PNBO-
TLB
-B$BQSB Z 4PVUIHBUF
EF FOUSF OVFTUSPT NBOJGFTUBEPSFT
Z
PUSPTJODPOUBCMFT
QFSTPOBTEFCVFOBWPMVOUBEZFTQSJUVHFOF-
SPTP
MPTRVFTJHVFODSFZFOEPRVF
TPMPDPOVOMFWFBKVTUF
MPT
BOUJHVPTWBMPSFTEFMBPCKFUJWJEBE
FMFNQJSJTNPZMBDBVTBMJEBE
FNFSHFOUFQVFEFOTFSWJSUPEBWBQBSBIBDFSRVFMPTFTUVEJPTIJT-
USJDPTTFBOWBMJPTPTZSFMFWBOUFTQBSBMBTPMVDJOBMPTQSPCMF-
NBTEFOVFTUSBNPEFSOJEBE
1FSPFTPOPWBBSFTVMUBS-BIJTUPSJPHSBGBPCKFUJWB
FNQSJDB
ZDBVTBMJTUBOVODBDPOWFODJBOBEJFEFOBEBRVFOPDSFZFSBO
EFBOUFNBOP-BEJTPDJBDJOFOUSFQBTBEPZQSFTFOUFUBNQPDP
QVFEFTBMWBSEFEJTUPSTJPOFTJEFPMHJDBTFMFTUVEJPEFOJOHVOPEF
MPTEPTy1PSRV 1PSRVFMBEJTPDJBDJOFOUSFQBTBEPZQSFTFO-
te esMBEJTUPSTJOJEFPMHJDBRVFQFSNJUFRVFMBjIJTUPSJBvTFB
QVFTUBBMTFSWJDJPEFDVBMRVJFSDBVTBQPMUJDB
ZBTFBEFEFSFDIB
J[RVJFSEBPDFOUSP
ZIBDFQPTJCMFRVFMPTIFDIPTTFBOTFQBSBEPT
EFTVEFTDSJQDJO
QPSVOMBEP
ZEFMPTBDPOUFDJNJFOUPTEFMPT
RVFTPOQSFEJDBEPT
QPSPUSP
7BSJPT EF OVFTUSPT NBOJGFTUBEPSFT TVHJFSFO RVF EF MP RVF
DBSFDFMBIJTUPSJPMPHBBDUVBMFTEFJNBHJOBDJOPEFJNBHJOB-
UJWJEBE
PmQBSBQPOFSMPVOQPDPEJGFSFOUFmEFMBDBQBDJEBEEF
BQSFDJBSFMWBMPSDPHOJUJWPEFMQFOTBNJFOUPEFJNHFOFT
TPCSF
UPEPFOVOBQPDBEFNFEJBUJ[BDJOZEFFMFWBDJOEFMBJNBHFO
QPSTPCSFMBQBMBCSBDPNPFMTJHOPRVFTFSFFSFBMBSB[OZ
BMPTTFOUJEPTTJNVMUOFBNFOUF.BSL1PTUFSTFFOGSFOUBBFTUB
244
Historiografa postmoderna
245
-VJT(%F.VTTZr.JHVFM7BMEFSSBNB
QVOUPTEFWJTUBRVFQBSFDFOWJMFT
EFTBHSBEBCMFTFJOIVNBOPT
FOMBNFEJEBFORVFOPDPODVFSEBODPOMPTIBMMB[HPTPCKFUJWPT
QVUBUJWPTEFDBEBIJTUPSJBEPSFOQBSUJDVMBS
1PS TVQVFTUP
OP FT UBO TFODJMMP $PNP JOTJTUF -B$BQSB FO
BMHOPUSPMVHBS
FMEJTDVSTPIJTUSJDPTJFNQSFJOWPMVDSBVOBQSF-
UFOTJOEFWFSEBEEFBMHOUJQP PNTCJFOEFWBSJPTUJQPT
Z
BEJGFSFOUFTOJWFMFTEFMEJTDVSTPNJTNP:BRVMBDSUJDBDPNP
IJTUPSJBZMBIJTUPSJBDPNPDSUJDBUJFOFORVFDPOGSPOUBSBMBQSF-
HVOUBEFTJBDBTPMBWFSEBEFTVOBQSPCMFNUJDBFQJTUFNPMHJDB
VOBQSPCMFNUJDBTFNOUJDB
PBNCBT-BJEFBEFRVFMBWFSEBE
FTVOQSPCMFNBTFNOUJDPFTFMjDBCBMMJUPEFCBUBMMBvEFMMTPGP
+FSSZ'PEPS
ZDSFPRVFOPTPGSFDFVONPEPEFQFOTBSFMQSPCMF-
NBEFMBSFMBDJOFOUSFMBIJTUPSJBZMBMJUFSBUVSBQMBOUFBEPQPS
WBSJPTEFOVFTUSPTNBOJGFTUBEPSFT
&OHSBONFEJEB
MBQSPCMFNUJDBEFMBSFMBDJOFOUSFIJTUP-
SJB Z MJUFSBUVSB GVF DSFBEP QPS FTF jQPTUFTUSVDUVSBMJTNPv RVF
DPNPBSHVNFOUBO+PBO4DPUUZ&MJ[BCFUI&SNBSUI
GVFQSPEVDUP
EFMPRVFBMHVOPTMMBNBOjFMHJSPMJOHTUJDPvZPUSPTjFMHJSP
EJTDVSTJWPv FO MBT DJFODJBT IVNBOBT 4J
DPNP TFBMB &SNBSUI
FMMFOHVBKFFTVOTJTUFNBDPNQMFKPEFTJHOPTDPEJDBEPT
DVZPT
FMFNFOUPT OP HVBSEBO VOB SFMBDJO OFDFTBSJB OBUVSBM
DPO MBT
DPTBTEFMNVOEPBMBTRVFTFSFFSFO
FOUPODFTMPTTJHOJDBEPT
BETDSJUPT B MBT DPTBT Z TVT SFMBDJPOFT FO MPT EJTDVSTPT TPO NT
VOBGVODJOEFMPTDEJHPTVTBEPTQBSBJOEJDBSMPTRVFEFBMHVOB
TVTUBODJB P FTFODJB EF MB RVF MBT DPTBT TPO EJGFSFOUFT UJQPT EF
NBOJGFTUBDJPOFT$VBOEPTFUSBUBEFTJTUFNBTDPNQMFKPTEFTJH-
OPT TFDVFODJBTPDPOKVOUPTRVFFOTVBMDBODFTPONBZPSFTRVF
VOBTJNQMFPSBDJO
OPTWFNPTDPNQSPNFUJEPTFOFMUSBCBKPEF
DPODFEFSMFFTUSVDUVSBTDPNQMFKBTEFTFOUJEPBDVFSQPTDPNQMFKPT
EFGFONFOPT-BBSCJUSBSJFEBEEFMBFMFDDJOEFMDEJHPPMPT
DEJHPTBTFSVTBEPTTVNBEBBMBJOIFSFOUFBNCJHFEBEEFMBSF-
GFSFODJB FOFMEJTDVSTPOPBMHPSUNJDP
FOFMRVFMPTTJHOJDBEPT
EFMPTUSNJOPTVOJEBEFTTPOFTUJQVMBEPTQPSBEFMBOUBEP
TPNF-
UFOUPEPFMQSPCMFNBEFMBWFSEBEEFMBUPUBMJEBEEFMDPOKVOUP
PMBTFDVFODJBBMEPNJOJPEFMBTFNOUJDBNTRVFBBRVFMEFMB
FQJTUFNPMPHB&TFTUPZOPMBTEJGFSFODJBTZTJNJMJUVEFTHFOSJDBT
MPRVFDPOTUJUVZFMBTQFSUVSCBEPSBTTJNJMJUVEFTFOUSFBMHVOPTUJ-
QPTEFEJTDVSTPGBDUVBM DPNPMBTIJTUPSJBT
QPSFKFNQMP
ZBMHV-
246
Historiografa postmoderna
247
-VJT(%F.VTTZr.JHVFM7BMEFSSBNB
QPFTB
Z
NTBMMEFFTP
UFOFSFMEFTFPEFEBSMFBMPTFWFOUPT
ZFOUJEBEFT
RVFIBOMMFHBEPBDPOPDFSNFEJBOUFMBJOWFTUJHB-
DJO
MPTUJQPTEFTJHOJDBEPTBMPTRVFFMEJTDVSTPQPUJDPTFIB
EFEJDBEPEFTEFFMUJFNQPEFMBQJDB TJOPBOUFT
"RVTFUSBUB
EFWJTVBMJ[BSVOBJNBHFODPNQMFKBPVOFTQFDUDVMPDPNQMFKP
EFBDPOUFDFSRVFFYQSFTFMBWFSEBETPCSFFMUJQPEFTJHOJDBEPT
RVFDVBMRVJFSBSFDPOPDFDPNPQSPQJPTEFVOFOVODJBEPQPUJ-
DPTFSJP&TVOBTVOUPEFDBNCJPEFDEJHPTTPCSFFMBSDPEFM
EJTDVSTPNTRVFEFJNQPOFSVOBFTUSVDUVSBDDJPOBMEFTFOUJ-
EPTPCSFMPTBDPOUFDJNJFOUPTSFBMFT
&MJ[BCFUI&SNBSUI
+PBO4DPUU
"OO3JHOFZ
3PCFSU3PTFOTUP-
OF
%BWJE)BSMBO
&XB%PNBOTLBZ(SFH%FOJOHBTFWFSBOBMHP
BTP
BMNFOPT
OPTDPOEVDFOFOFTBEJSFDDJODPOTVTFKFNQMPT
&O UPEPT FTUPT DBTPT
TJO FNCBSHP
OVFTUSPT NBOJGFTUBEPSFT QP-
OFO MB DPOFYJO IJTUPSJBMJUFSBUVSB FO USNJOPT EF MB OFDFTJEBE
EFMBJNBHJOBDJODPNPVOTVQMFNFOUPEFMBSB[OBOBMUJDBEFM
FTUVEJPTPQSPGFTJPOBM&TBRVRVFTFQMBOUFBFMQSPCMFNBEFMPT
jPUSPTvUSBEJDJPOBMFTEFMBIJTUPSJBBRVRVFMBQSPCMFNUJDBEFMB
SFMBDJOFOUSFFMIJTUPSJBEPSQSPGFTJPOBMZFMamateurPEJMFUBOUFTF
WVFMWFQBUFOUFZBRVMBDVFTUJOEFMBTVCKFUJWJEBEPCKFUJWJEBEFT
QPSNTQFSFOUPSJBNFOUFRVFTFB
MMFWBEBBMBUVNCB
-PT FTUVEJPT IJTUSJDPT QSPGFTJPOBMFT Z NPEFSOPT BMCFSHBO
VOBTJOHVMBSTPTQFDIBDPOSFTQFDUPB
QPSOPEFDJSVOBBCJFSUB
IPTUJMJEBEIBDJBFMBSUF MJUFSBSJPZWJTVBM
mFTQFDJBMNFOUFIBDJB
FMBSUFNPEFSOJTUB UBOUPFMBCTUSBDUPDPNPFMFYQSFTJPOJTUB
mZ
TVTDPOUSBQBSUFTQPTUNPEFSOJTUBT%PDVNFOUBSQPSRVFTUPFT
BT UPNBSB NVDIP UJFNQP
QFSP FO HFOFSBM B MPT IJTUPSJBEPSFT
OPMFTHVTUBFMBCBOEPOPEFMBSUFNPEFSOJTUBEFMQSPHSBNBNJ-
NUJDPZTVDPNQSPNJTPDPOMBJOWFODJOGPSNBMMJCSF&OUPODFT
FOMBNFEJEBFORVFIBZBMHOFMFNFOUPBSUTUJDPFOFMEJTDVSTP
IJTUSJDP QSPGFTJPOBM
FT BMHVOB WFSTJO EFM SFBMJTNP NJNUJDP
DPOFMRVFQFSNBOFDFDBTBEP&TUFSFBMJTNPKVTUJDBVOBDSFFODJB
FOVOBUFPSBEFMBSFQSFTFOUBDJOCBTBEBFOMBJNBHFOZFOMB
UFPSBEFMBWFSEBECBTBEBFOMBDPSSFTQPOEFODJBDPOMBTDVBMFT
MBNBZPSBEFMPTIJTUPSJBEPSFTFTUDPNQSPNFUJEB1FSPFMBSUF
NPEFSOJTUBZQPTNPEFSOJTUBFTUODPOHVSBEPTQPSVOBJEFBEF
WFSEBECBTBEBFOMBDPIFSFODJBZVOBJEFBEFSFGFSFODJBMJEBERVF
FTNTQFSGPSNBUJWBRVFNJNUJDBPDPOTUBUBUJWB
248
Historiografa postmoderna
249
-VJT(%F.VTTZr.JHVFM7BMEFSSBNB
SFT
TPOSFBMJTUBT"NFOVEPTFTFBMBRVFMBFOVODJBDJOQPUJDB
OPFTGBDUVBMOJDDJPOBMQPSRVFTVTQFOEFMBGVODJOSFGFSFODJBM
QBSBMMBNBSMBBUFODJOTPCSFFMQPEFSEFDSFBSVOTFOUJEPBQBS-
UJSEFTPOJEPTRVF
UPNBEPTJOEJWJEVBMNFOUF
OPUJFOFOTFOUJEP
FO MP BCTPMVUP 1FSP FTUP OP IBDF RVF FM EJTDVSTP FO FM RVF MB
GVODJOQPUJDBTFFYQSFTBTFBNTPNFOPTTVCKFUJWPVPCKFUJWP
1PSRVFFMUFYUPQPUJDPOPUJFOFQSFUFOTJPOFTEFWFSEBEEFMUJQP
RVFQPESBOTFSDPOSNBEBTPEFTNFOUJEBTQPSSFDVSTPBMBPC-
TFSWBDJOPMBFWJEFODJBEPDVNFOUBM&MUFYUPQPUJDPUJFOFVOB
QSFUFOTJOEFTFOUJEPBMNPTUSBSDNPFTQPTJCMFBMHOBTQFDUP
EFMNVOEPSFBM-PTMTPGPTEFMBDSUJDBOPTEJDFORVFEFCFNPT
CVTDBSjMBTDPOEJDJPOFTEFQPTJCJMJEBEvEFDVBMRVJFSDPTBDVZB
SFBMJEBE FTUFNPT USBUBOEP EF JEFOUJDBS &TUB CTRVFEB QVFEF
MMFWBSTFBDBCPDPOVOBWBSJFEBEEFNFEJPT
VOPEFMPTDVBMFT
FTFMQFOTBNJFOUPDPODFQUVBM1FSPFMQFOTBNJFOUPHVSBUJWPP
FOSFBMJEBEFMQFOTBSHVSBUJWPFTPUSPNFEJP
ZMBFOVODJBDJO
QPUJDBFTTVJOTUSVNFOUP
-BT QSFUFOTJPOFT EF MB JNBHJOBDJO TPO QFSUJOFOUFT QBSB
PUSPT QSPCMFNBT QMBOUFBEPT QPS OVFTUSPT NBOJGFTUBEPSFT 1BSB
MBQSPGFDBEF1PTUFSEFRVFjMPTIJTUPSJBEPSFTEFMGVUVSPFTDSJCJ-
SOVOBIJTUPSJBEFMPWJSUVBM<RVF>SFRVJFSFVOSFQFOTBNJFOUP
GVOEBNFOUBMEFMPTFMFNFOUPTCTJDPTEFMPTUFYUPTIJTUSJDPT
MPT
QSPDFEJNJFOUPT EF JOWFTUJHBDJO IJTUSJDB
MPT NBSDPT UFSJDPT
FUDv1BSBMBTSFDPNFOEBDJPOFTRVFIBDFO$IBLSBCBSUZZ+PZDF
EFSFQFOTBSMBOBUVSBMF[BEFMBSDIJWPRVFUFOESORVFVTBSMPT
IJTUPSJBEPSFTEFMGVUVSPmUBOUPFMBSDIJWPRVFTFIBEJHJUBMJ[BEP
DPNPFMBSDIJWPRVFIBTJEPDPOHVSBEPQBSBPCMJUFSBSMBNF-
NPSJBEFMBTWDUJNBTEFMBDPMPOJ[BDJOZMBFYQMPUBDJOJNQF-
SJBM1BSBMBEFGFOTBRVFIBDFO)BSMBOZ3JHOFZEFMBEJHOJEBEEF
MBOPWFMBZFMMNFIJTUSJDP
ZFOFTQFDJBMQBSBFMBSHVNFOUPEF
)BSMBOEFRVFFTMBjWP[vMPRVFDBQUVSBNPTFOOVFWPTHOFSPT
DPNPjFMSPNBODFIJTUSJDPQPTNPEFSOPvUBMDPNPFTBOBMJ[BEP
QPS "NZ &MJBT FO TV MJCSP Sublime Desire: History and Post-
1960s Fiction [Deseo sublime: Historia y Ficcin despus de los
60s>
"RVFOUSBFOFTDFOBVOTFHVOEPOPNCSF
FRVJWBMFOUFBMEF
'PVDBVMUFOTVBVUPSJEBEQPTNPEFSOB&MOPNCSFFTFMEF8(
4FCBME
BVUPSEFVOBWBSJFEBEEFPCSBTRVFPDVQBOMPTlimines
250
Historiografa postmoderna
251
-VJT(%F.VTTZr.JHVFM7BMEFSSBNB
IJTUPSJBEPSFT4JFTUBNPTJOUFSFTBEPTFOEBSMFTFOUJEPBMNVOEP
SFBM
OPQVFEFTFSEFPUSPNPEP1FSPOPFTUBNPTBUBEPTBFTUBS
BUBEPTQPSMBTDPOWFODJPOFTRVFBUBOBMIJTUPSJBEPSQSPGFTJPOBM
BTVQSDUJDBUSBEJDJPOBMFOFMFTUVEJPEFMQBTBEP5BMDPNPFM
#BSEPIBDFEFDJSB$PSJPMBOPFOMBWTQFSBEFTVFYJMJPj)BZVO
NVOEPFOPUSPMVHBSv
252
-VJT(%F.VTTZr.JHVFM7BMEFSSBNB
RIL editores
Telfono: 225-4269 / ril@rileditores.com
Santiago de Chile, noviembre de 2010
Se utiliz tecnologa de ltima generacin que reduce el
impacto medioambiental, pues ocupa estrictamente el
papel necesario para su produccin, y se aplicaron altos
estndares para la gestin y reciclaje de desechos en toda
la cadena de produccin.
254
HISTORIOGRAFA
POSTMODERNA
-
-
,
-
-
&
-
,-
-
-
-
-
W,