Está en la página 1de 23

Boletín de la Sociedad Geológica Mexicana / 74 (3) / A010422/ 2022 / 1

Comparative study of pre-Hispanic and colonial adobes in Mexico. Preliminary


inferences on the effects of the granulometric distribution and used recycled
materials in the state conservation of earth architecture

Estudio comparativo de adobes prehispánicos y coloniales en México. Inferencias preliminares sobre

ABSTRACT
los efectos de la distribución granulométrica y materiales reciclados en el estado de conservación
de la arquitectura de tierra
María Jesús Puy-Alquiza1,*, Velia Yolanda Ordaz-Zubia2, Omar Cruces-Cervantes3, Antonio Bello-Sandoval3,
Raúl Miranda-Avilés1, Ma. del Carmen Salazar-Hernández4, Gilberto Carreño-Aguilera5, Gabriela A. Zanor6, Yanmei Li1

1
Departamento de Minas, Metalurgia y Geología,
División de Ingenierías, Universidad de Guanajuato,
ABSTRACT RESUMEN
Campus Guanajuato, 36000, Guanajuato, Mexico.
The characterization of the pre-Hispanic and Se realizó la caracterización de los adobes prehis-
2
Departamento de Arquitectura, División de Arqui- colonial adobes used in the construction of
tectura, Arte y Diseño, Universidad de Guanajuato,
pánicos y coloniales utilizados en la construcción de
Campus Guanajuato, 36000, Guanajuato, Mexico. buildings in Mexico was carried out to know edificaciones en México para conocer las diferencias
the differences between their processes and entre sus procesos y manufacturas. Las ocho muestras
3
Instituto de Antropología e Historia (INAH), Centro, manufactures. The eight samples obtained cor- obtenidas corresponden a bloques de adobe de 0.45 m
36000, Guanajuato, Mexico. respond to adobe blocks 0.45 m long x 0.35 m de largo x 0.35 m de ancho y 0.12 m de espesor, que
wide and 0.12 m thick, which were part of the formaban parte de los interiores de las casas, estructura
4
UPIGG-IPN, Av. Mineral de Valenciana No. 200,
interiors of houses, the structure of fences, and
Col. Fraccionamiento. Industrial Puerto Interior, Si- de cercos y galeras de hacienda. Estas muestras se
lao de la Victoria, 36275, Guanajuato, Mexico. hacienda galleys. These samples were investigated
investigaron utilizando técnicas de difracción de rayos
using X-ray Diffraction, X-ray Fluorescence,
5
Departamento de Geomática e Hidráulica, División and Scanning Electron Microscopy techniques X, fluorescencia de rayos X y microscopía electrónica de
de Ingenierías, Universidad de Guanajuato, Campus
to determine the morphometry of the material barrido, para determinar la morfometría del material y
Guanajuato, 36000, Guanajuato, Mexico.
and its chemical and mineralogical composition. su composición química y mineralógica. Asimismo, se
6
División Ciencias de la vida, Universidad de Guana- Likewise, some analyzes were performed to realizaron algunos análisis para determinar sus propie-
juato, Campus Irapuato, 36824, Guanajuato, Mexico determine their mechanical properties (simple dades mecánicas (resistencia a la compresión simple),
compressive strength), physical properties (gran- propiedades físicas (granulometría, densidad sólida,
* Corresponding author: (M. J. Puy-Alquiza) cohesión, índice de plasticidad, porosidad y contenido de
ulometry, solid density, cohesion, plasticity index,
yosune.puy155@gmail.com
porosity, and moisture content), and biological humedad) y biológico (contenido de materia orgánica).
(organic matter content). The results obtained in Los resultados obtenidos en cuanto a la distribución
terms of the granulometric distribution indicate granulométrica indican que el adobe prehispánico tiene
that pre-Hispanic adobe has a higher content of un mayor contenido de arena, limo-arcillas y gravas,
sand than silt-clay and gravel, while the colonial

Comparative study of adobes in Mexico: granulometric distribution


mientras que los adobes coloniales presentan un bajo
adobes present a low or null content of gravel o nulo contenido de gravas con un mayor contenido
with a higher content of silt-clays. Regarding the de limo-arcillas. En cuanto al contenido de materia
How to cite this article: organic matter content, the colonial adobe pres- orgánica, el adobe colonial presenta los porcentajes
Puy-Alquiza, M.J., Ordaz-Zubia, V.Y., Cruces- ents the highest percentages compared to those of
más altos en comparación con los de los adobes pre-
Cervantes, O., Bello-Sandoval, A., Miranda-Avilés, the pre-Hispanic adobes. Taking into account the
hispánicos. Teniendo en cuenta lo anterior los adobes
R., Salazar-Hernández, M.C., Carreño-Aguilera, G., above the pre-Hispanic adobes have better resis-
tance and durability than colonial adobes due to prehispánicos tienen mejor resistencia y durabilidad que
Zanor, G.A., Li, Y., 2022, Comparative study of pre-
their granulometric distribution, low organic mat- los adobes coloniales debido a su distribución granu-
Hispanic and colonial adobes in Mexico. Preliminary
ter content, good cohesion, high plasticity index, lométrica, al bajo contenido de materia orgánica, a la
inferences on the effects of the granulometric
and the use of materials found in their natural buena cohesión, al alto índice de plasticidad y al uso
distribution and used recycled materials in
environment, while the colonial used recycled de materiales que se encuentran en su medio natural,
the state conservation of earth architecture:
materials, coming from the economic activity to mientras que los adobes coloniales, su materia prima
Boletín de la Sociedad Geológica Mexicana,
which the hacienda was dedicated, for example, deriva de materiales reciclados, provenientes de la
74 (3), A010422. http://dx.doi.org/10.18268/
agriculture, mining, livestock, this has given rise to actividad económica a la que se dedicaba la hacienda,
BSGM2022v74n3a010422
different manufacturing techniques and construc- por ejemplo agrícola, minera, ganadera, esto ha dado
tion styles that reflect the state of conservation of lugar a diferentes técnicas de manufactura y estilos
Manuscript received: December 7, 2021. buildings throughout the pre-Hispanic and colo- constructivos que reflejan el estado de conservación de
Corrected manuscript received: February 20, 2022. nial times. The granulometric distribution that las edificaciones a lo largo de la época prehispánica y
Manuscript accepted: March 29, 2022.
pre-Hispanic adobe provides favorable physical colonial. La distribución granulométrica que presenta el
and mechanical qualities for any construction adobe prehispánico brinda cualidades físicas y mecáni-
technique, so it is recommended to use this for- cas favorables para cualquier técnica constructiva, por
Peer Reviewing under the responsibility of mula to manufacture resistant and durable adobe.
Universidad Nacional Autónoma de México.
lo que se recomienda utilizar esta fórmula para fabricar
Keywords: pre-Hispanic period, colonial adobes resistentes y duraderos.
This is an open access article under the CC BY-NC-SA period, adobes, manufacture, technical,
license(https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-sa/4.0/) conservation. Palabras clave: época prehispánica, época
colonial, adobes, manufactura, técnica,
conservación.
http://dx.doi.org/10.18268/BSGM2022v74n3a010422

2 / Boletín de la Sociedad Geológica Mexicana / 74 (3) / A010422/


A010422 /2022
2022
INTRODUCTION

1. Introduction position and regular granulometry (Yuste, 2016).


The addition to the mixture of vegetable matter
Throughout the history of Mexico, the soil has depended on the type of soil; if it was very clayey,
been used as the construction material for pub- the plasticity increased, which is why the addition
lic buildings and foundations by pre-Hispanic of vegetable fibers was necessary. The size of the
cultures (Chevalier, 1963; Perez et al., 2016). The blocks varied from region to region, so there was
Maya of Mexico and Central America developed a wide diversity in terms of shape, composition,
adobe bricks before the arrival of the Spanish in color, and texture (Barbeta, 2002; Guillaud et al.,
the early XVI century (Punzo-Díaz, 2005; Daneels 2008). The Olmeca, Mixteca, Zapotec, Maya,
and Guerrero, 2012; Daneels, 2015; Mateu et al., Teotihuacan, Tolteca, and Mexica-Azteca groups,
2022), while the native Americans of the south- to name a few, developed different construction
western United States did not use adobe until the systems; for example, the larger buildings were
Spanish introduced it in the seventeenth century. raised on top of solid foundations using structured
The adobe technique used in pre-Hispanic times fillings, adobe fillings, while the walls were built
consisted of making a solid block of mud which with adobes, poured mud (formwork), or blocks
was obtained by mixing clay soil, sand, gravel, and of moist earth (Gama-Castro et al., 2012; Daneels,
often vegetable matter. The adobe architecture 2013). As for public buildings, the most used mate-
was associated with alluvial soils, clay-rich soils, rial was adobe in walls, columns, and stairways,
or sandy-clayey soils with a domain of sand com- before the arrival of the Spanish, at the beginning
Comparative study of adobes in Mexico: granulometric distribution

Figure 1 Location of study area.


http://dx.doi.org/10.18268/BSGM2022v74n3a010422

INTRODUCTION / STUDY AREA


Boletín de la Sociedad Geológica Mexicana / 74 (3) / A010422/ 2022 / 3

of the 16th century. Whereas, during the Span- 2014). Due to cultural change and the loss of
ish colonial period, most of the adobe buildings indigenous traditions, much of the manufacturing
erected were used for domestic purposes, combin- knowledge was lost. Based on this, the objective
ing mixed technologies such as block technique of this research work was to compare the different
(adobe) and formwork technique (Tapia). The physical, mechanical, chemical, and biological
adobe architecture was associated with sandy soils, (organic matter content) properties of two periods
adding vegetable matter in most cases. Most of the of earthen construction (pre-Hispanic and Colo-
buildings raised corresponded to mixed technolo- nial), to understand the evolution of construction
gies where stone, adobe, wood, and masonry were systems over time, and to be able to select adequate
used for development or exploitation purposes, as strategies for its conservation, contributing at the
is the case of the farms where agriculture, mining, same time to the knowledge of manufacturing
and livestock were developed (Wolf and Mintz, techniques.
1957; Van Young, 1983; Jarquin, 1990; Fourni-
er-García and Mondragón, 2003).
The construction techniques have been chang- 2. Study area
ing during each period modifying manufacturing
processes to give rise to different architectural A set of eight samples of different types of adobe
elements (Morner, 1973). The construction tech- construction was selected: two belonging to the
niques and the ways of materializing architectural pre-Hispanic and Middle Classic period and the
elements have been subject to different changes rest from the colonial period (17th and 18th centu-
throughout history and this is largely due to the ries). The pre-Hispanic adobes were collected in the
needs and possibilities of each epoch (Ledesma, state of Guanajuato, while the colonial adobes were

Comparative study of adobes in Mexico: granulometric distribution

Figure 2 Location of study area.


http://dx.doi.org/10.18268/BSGM2022v74n3a010422

4 / Boletín de la Sociedad Geológica Mexicana / 74 (3) / A010422/


A010422 /2022
2022

collected in the states of Queretaro, Tlaxcala, and Na, and K (FAO, 1998). The state of Tlaxcala is
STUDY AREA

Guanajuato. Based on this, two representatives to included within the physiographic province of the
the pre-Hispanic adobe from the archaeological Trans-Mexican Volcanic Belt, dominated by out-
sites of Coporo (municipality of Ocampo), and crops of volcanic rocks such as andesites, rhyolites,
La Nopalera (municipality Comonfort), from the basalts, tuffs, and volcanic breccias, characterized by
Classic period in the state of Guanajuato, two ado- Cambisol-type soils, which have little clay content,
bes from an agricultural estate, coming from the organic matter, aluminum, and iron compounds.
Hacienda de Santiago Tochac in the state of Tlax- They mostly come from colluvial, alluvial, and aeo-
cala and Las Carretas in the state of Querétaro of lian deposits. Their use is mainly agricultural (FAO,
the 17th and 18th centuries and finally four miners 1998).
adobe, two of the 17th century (Durán and San
Clemente) and two of the 18th century (Dolores de 2.2. DESCRIPTION OF THE PRE-HISPANIC BUILDINGS
(CLASSIC AND MIDDLE CLASSIC PERIODS)
Barrera and El Patrocinio) of the state of Guana-
juato (Figures 1, and 2). The adobe blocks studied
2.2.1. THE ARCHAEOLOGICAL ZONE OF COPORO
have dimensions of 0.45 m long x 0.35 m wide x
The archaeological zone of Coporo is in the
0.12 m thick, they belong to fences, interiors of
municipality of Ocampo, northwest of the state of
houses, and hacienda galleys.
Guanajuato, on the foothills of the Sierra de Santa
2.1. GEOLOGICAL SETTING Barbara and next to the community of San Jose del
Torreon. The predominant type of climate is tem-
The states of Queretaro, Tlaxcala, and Guana- perate semi-dry, with maximum temperatures of up
juato are located within the Cenozoic Trans-Mex- to 40°C, with minimum temperatures of 8°C. The
ican Volcanic Belt (TMVB) and the Mesa Central average annual temperature is 17 °C. The rainfall
provinces (Raisz, 1964). The municipalities of is 433 millimeters on average per year. Coporo is
Comonfort and Ocampo are located in the state of a ceremonial center with housing units. Its archi-
Guanajuato, in the physiographic province of the tecture is mixed of earth and stone, highlighting
Comparative study of adobes in Mexico: granulometric distribution

Mesa Central, on its border with the province of the stone and adobe walls, the latter being the most
the Trans-Mexican Volcanic Belt. In these munici- abundant. Its extension is great, conserving hun-
palities outcrop rocks are of marine origin covered dreds of houses with the religious civic part at the
by volcanic rocks (tuff, ignimbrite), domes of rhy- base of the hill and the religious part at the top of
olitic to rhyodacitic composition, with intercalated the hill. The occupation in this archeological zone
andesite. As for the types of soils, Phaeozems type was during the classic Mesoamerican period (400
soils predominate, they are porous, dark soils rich to 600 dc). It is an ancient city made up of three
in organic matter, they are used for agriculture. neighborhoods: Coporo neighborhood (at the top
The Phaeozems are distributed in lacustrine and of the hill), Gotas neighborhood (lower part of the
fluvial-alluvial plains or on volcanoclastic. and northwest slope), and Montes neighborhood (lower
alluvial-colluvial deposits in temperate and humid and southwest part of the hill). The Coporo can be
zones (Garrido-Pérez et al., 2006). The state of considered as a civic and ceremonial site. The lower
Querétaro is among the physiographic provinces part was occupied by individuals associated with
of the Mesa Central, Sierra Madre Oriental, and administrative activities as indicated by the differ-
the Trans-Mexican Volcanic Belt. The rocks that ent housing units, while the Coporo neighborhood
outcrop in the state are metamorphic, igneous, located on the top/summit of the hill can be a cer-
and sedimentary, predominantly Leptosol-type emonial space due to its proximity to divine beings
soils. These soils are characterized by a dark color (Castañeda-Lopez et al., 2007). Remains of ancient
since they contain a good percentage of organic housing units are located between the northwest
matter (more than 1%), and a content of Ca, Mg, slope and the valley, from which adobe samples were
http://dx.doi.org/10.18268/BSGM2022v74n3a010422

Boletín de la Sociedad Geológica Mexicana / 74 (3) / A010422/ 2022 / 5

obtained. The adobe samples correspond to the 1960), establish the presence of humans in the

STUDY AREA
floors of the houses. Structural pathologies such valleys of the Lerma, Laja, Turbio, and Guana-
as minor cracks and loss of material are observed. juato rivers, since times as remote as 350 years
The adobes are exposed to the environment since before Christ. A study by Howell (2002), proposes
their excavation in 2006, have an orange-brown that there was a gradual depopulation between
color, are rectangular, and do not have any type the years 900 and 1150, possibly due to two rea-
of coating. Lichens grew on the adobe bricks, pre- sons environmental problems, which led to food
senting orange and grayish colorations on the sur- shortages since other tribal groups attacked the
face, in the same way, black scabs are observed. No settlements and stole their belongings. It is difficult
mineralogical alterations nor internal degradation to specify when the first Pames tribes arrived in
conditions due to bioturbation are observed. this region, what is already known is that they have
already found a territory populated by primitive
2.2.2. THE ARCHAEOLOGICAL ZONE LA NOPALERA agricultural, gatherer, and hunter tribes, a region
La Nopalera archaeological site is located at the rich in natural resources and a climate pleasant
foot of the Orduña hill in the municipality of enough to live. The Nopalera archaeological site
Comonfort Guanajuato, near the community of corresponds to small sites with a marked presence
La Nopalera. The climate is temperate, with a of mounds as main elements, there are refer-
maximum temperature of 38.0ºC and a minimum ences to burials in flat areas. It is represented by
of 10ºC. The average annual precipitation is 776.8 stone walls, earth fills, and adobe foundations.
mm. The first data of population settlements in The adobe sample corresponds to the walls of a
that area, according to data from Kirchhoff (1946, basement. They have a brown color. Structural

Comparative study of adobes in Mexico: granulometric distribution

Figure 3 Description of the pre-Hispanic buildings (Classical and medium classical period). The archaeological zone of Coporo.
http://dx.doi.org/10.18268/BSGM2022v74n3a010422

6 / Boletín de la Sociedad Geológica Mexicana / 74 (3) / A010422/


A010422 /2022
2022

pathologies such as vertical cracks, inclined walls, Tochac, San José Piedras Negras, and the Concep-
STUDY AREA

minor cracks, detachment, or loss of material ción Zacazontetla. In later years, due to abuses,
are not observed. The adobe block is exposed to the lands came into the power of the caciques
environmental factors since 2019, covered with without income, donations, or any form of legal
vegetation roots being observed on the surface. No alienation, and the peasants, therefore, became
mineralogical alterations or internal conditions of part of their labor force, in the cultivation of wheat
degradation due to bioturbation are observed. and maguey, to extract pulque. In January 1869,
the Santiago Tochac hacienda, located in the
2.3. DESCRIPTION OF THE COLONIAL PERIOD: Huamantla was put up for sale, the property was
AGRICULTURAL HACIENDA (17TH AND 18TH put in the auction and announced to the public so
CENTURIES)
that people who wanted to make a posture would
attend the Fifth court Civil to receive instructions
2.3.1. SANTIAGO TOCHAC HACIENDA (Santibañez-Tijerina, 2010). The adobe block was
The Santiago Tochac hacienda located in the obtained from the wall of the main house corre-
municipality of Xaloztoc, Tlaxcala, was founded sponding to the room, built-in 1800. The color of
in December 1533 and it is unknown who its first the adobe is dark brown. The wall is covered with
owners were. The climate is temperate sub-hu- lime mortar. It is not exposed to environmental
mid. the maximum temperature is 25.1°C, the factors or humidity. Structural pathologies such as
minimum being 4.0°C. The average annual pre- minor cracks or loss of material are not observed.
cipitation is 758.5 mm. The peasants dedicated
themselves to working the lands that belonged 2.3.2. CARRETAS HACIENDA
to the town, which initially formed a whole; then The Carretas hacienda corresponds to the historic
they were divided into three parts called Santiago center of the city of Queretaro, located next to
Comparative study of adobes in Mexico: granulometric distribution

Figure 4 Description of the pre-Hispanic buildings (Classical and medium classical period). The archaeological zone La Nopalera.
http://dx.doi.org/10.18268/BSGM2022v74n3a010422

Boletín de la Sociedad Geológica Mexicana / 74 (3) / A010422/ 2022 / 7

Los Arcos. The climate is dry to semi-dry. The donkeys, and cows, among others (Garcia-Ugarte,

STUDY AREA
maximum temperature is 35°C and the minimum 2015). The adobe block was obtained from the
5°C. The average annual precipitation is 600 to main facade of the house, built in 1860. The color
700 mm. By 1531 the place where the Carretas of the adobe is dark brown. The wall is covered
hacienda exists today was a lagoon. Before the with lime mortar. It is not exposed to environ-
property was considered as Heritage, it func- mental factors or humidity. Structural pathologies
tioned as intermediate whereabouts established by such as minor cracks or loss of material are not
Blessed Sebastian de Aparicio in the year 1547, for observed.
his oxcart carts in which he transported the silver
of Zacatecas minerals to be melted and minted 2.4. DESCRIPTION OF THE COLONIAL PERIOD:
in Mexico. Later in the year 1562, Don Diego de MINER´S HACIENDA (17TH AND 18TH CENTURIES)
Saldívar built accommodation for travelers with
dumps, pens, and everything necessary to service The miner’s haciendas are localized in the center
the carts. Later in that place and with nearby lands and south of the city of Guanajuato. The climate
the “Hacienda de Carretas” was founded. The of the city of Guanajuato is dry to semi-dry. The
Carretas hacienda estate is in front of the Arches, maximum temperature is 30°C, and the minimum
at a height with Avenida Bernardo Quintana. is 5.2°C. The average annual precipitation is 650
Approximately by the years 1588 and 1604 the mm. The discovery in the sixteenth century of the
owner of carts (García Urbano) was dedicated to silver vein in the Mineral de la Luz initiates the
moving large volumes of wool, from Querétaro to exploitation of the mineral wealth in the Mining
the cities of Mexico and Texcoco. This indicates District of Guanajuato (Antúnez, 1964). This
that the Carretas hacienda was dedicated to cat- discovery led to the formation of haciendas built
tle-raising the raising of sheep, sheep, rams, mares, for the sole purpose of mining, smelting, or amal-

Comparative study of adobes in Mexico: granulometric distribution

Figure 5 Description of the Colonial period: agricultural hacienda (seventeenth and eighteenth century). Santiago Tochac hacienda.
http://dx.doi.org/10.18268/BSGM2022v74n3a010422
STUDY AREA / METHODOLOGY

8 / Boletín de la Sociedad Geológica Mexicana / 74 (3) / A010422/


A010422 /2022
2022

gamation of silver. These haciendas were in fact were obtained from fences, workmen’s galleys,
the first buildings in various parts of New Spain. and hacienda facades. The color of the adobe is
In Guanajuato, the morphology of the settlement gray. The adobe blocks were covered with lime
was determined by the route that followed both mortar. There was no moisture or degradation in
the main river and other currents that in times the material. The adobe blocks were covered with
of rain became important. The haciendas then lime mortar.
emerged in the sixteenth century, promoting the
development of local mining by means of silver
amalgamation. The haciendas in their beginnings 3. Methodology
occupied what nowadays is the center of the city;
by the eighteenth century, they had moved them To carry out this investigation, the following activ-
outside of the city being located on the banks of ities were carried out: physics characterization,
the main river. The Bourbon reforms (1765-1808) physics, (granulometry, cohesion, solid density,
caused the proliferation of haciendas throughout porosity, moisture content, plasticity index); bio-
the mining district of Guanajuato, concentrat- logical characterization (organic matter content,),
ing mainly in an industrial corridor that began and mechanical characterization (resistance to
towards the north of the city and continuing simple compression) of the sampled materials.
towards the east with the hacienda of Duran, Subsequently, the chemical characterization and
Dolores de Barrera, El Patrocinio, and San Clem- morphological analysis were carried out using the
ente (Puy-Alquiza et al., 2019). The adobe blocks techniques of X-ray Diffraction (XRD), X-ray
Comparative study of adobes in Mexico: granulometric distribution

Figure 6 Description of the Colonial period: agricultural hacienda (seventeenth and eighteenth century). Carretas hacienda.
http://dx.doi.org/10.18268/BSGM2022v74n3a010422

Boletín de la Sociedad Geológica Mexicana / 74 (3) / A010422/ 2022 / 9

LABORATORY TESTS
Fluorescence (XRF), and Scanning Electron out according to ASTM D2487-11. The samples
Microscopy (SEM-EDS). Macroscopically, the were classified considering the Unified Soil Clas-
degree of conservation of the adobes was deter- sification System (USCS). Another of the param-
mined highlighting structural pathologies such eters studied was the cohesion tests where it was
as vertical cracks, inclined walls, minor fissures, applied the European Standard Norm UNE-EN
detachment or loss of material, and alteration of 13880-10:2004. Solid density test was carried
the form. out, applying the ISO 17828:2015. Porosity test
was carried out on eight specimens, applying the
European Standard Norm UNE-EN 1936:2006.
4. Laboratory tests Total porosity was calculated using the relation-
ship between the volume of the pores (open and
4.1. MECHANICAL AND PHYSICAL closed) and the apparent volume of the specimen
CHARACTERIZATION (Equation 1).

4.1.1. PHYSICAL TEST p= (1 – pb / pr) X 100 (Equation 1)


The physical tests consisted of determining the
granulometry, cohesion, solid density, porosity, Where (pb) is apparent density and (pr) real den-
moisture content and plasticity index. The gran- sity. To determine the moisture content, a piece
ulometry consisted in the determination of the of adobe was cut and weighed. Subsequently, the
distribution of the size of the particles applying cut piece was placed into the oven at a constant
the sieving method. Sieve analysis was carried temperature of 105 ± 5°C for 24 hours. After

Comparative study of adobes in Mexico: granulometric distribution

Figure 7 Description of the Colonial period: miner’s hacienda (seventeenth and eighteenth century). a) Duran Hacienda; b) Dolores de
Barrera Hacienda; c) El Parocinio Hacienda; d) San Clemente Hacienda.
http://dx.doi.org/10.18268/BSGM2022v74n3a010422

10 / Boletín de la Sociedad Geológica Mexicana / 74 (3) / A010422/


A010422 /2022
2022
LABORATORY TESTS

this time, the sample was removed from the oven, (1367 kN). Load and strain were continuously
allowed to cool, and weighed. The moisture con- registered; sampling time interval was between 2
tent was calculated considering the relative weight and 6 min.
change between the initial weight and the dry
weight of the sample. The plasticity index test was 4.4. CHEMICAL CHARACTERIZATION AND
carried out on eight species, applying the Atterberg MORPHOLOGY ANALYSIS
method. This method determines the humidity
range in which a clay mass is moldable, defining The samples studied were analyzed using XRD
a plasticity index, IP, as the difference of humidity model Rigaku, ULTIMA IV diffractometer at
between the liquid limit, LL, or humidity above of mineral research and characterization laboratory
which a mass does not have enough consistency to (LICAMM), laboratory of the Guanajuato Uni-
be moldable, and the plastic limit, LP, or minimum versity, with CuKα radiation. A first fraction of
percentage of water to make a dough moldable. eight powder samples of 0.0625 mm was obtained
by sieving, which allowed the partial removal
4.2. TOTAL ORGANIC MATTER of the quartz. Subsequently, a fine fraction of
0.044 mm (Wentworth-Udden particle scale) was
The total organic matter content was carried obtained, as described above. Both fractions were
out applying the Mexican Standard Norm investigated by X-ray diffraction between 3° and
NMX-AA-21-1985, which makes a relationship 90° 2θ, with a step width of 0.02 and 2 s data
between the volume of potassium dichromate, the collection per step. To determine the composition
ferrous sulfate, and the sample weight (Equation chemical, the samples studied were analyzed using
2). X-ray fluorescence (XRF) Spectrometer Rigaku
NEX CG, using energy dispersion (EDXRF). The
Organic matter (%) = (V1. N1- VNF) K /P spectrometer has a Pd anode X-ray tube, maxi-
(Equation 2) mum power of 50W with maximum voltage of
50KV-2mA, and in He atmosphere. The samples
Comparative study of adobes in Mexico: granulometric distribution

Where V1 = Volume of potassium dichromate studied were ground using an agate mortar and
solution used in the sample cm3. N1 = Normality then passed through a 230-mesh screen to have
of the solution of potassium dichromate. V = a homogeneous particle size. The morphological
volume of ferrous sulfate solution used in the titra- aspects of the adobe bricks were investigated by
tion of the sample in cm3. N = Normality of the SEM observation without any metal coating. The
solution of ferrous sulfate. P = weight of sample. SEM instrument (JEOL, JSM- 6010 PLUS/LA)
K= 0.003. was operated at 15 kV in a low vacuum, while the
energy dispersion scanner spectrometer (EDS),
4.3. MECHANICAL TEST attached to the SEM, was used for semi-quanti-
tative chemical analysis. The SEM-EDS analyses
Simple compressive strength (UCS) tests were were carried out in the laboratory LICAMM of
carried out on eight specimens, applying the the Guanajuato University.
European Standard Norm UNE-EN1926:2006.
The cubic samples (8 cm x 8 cm x 8 cm) were
parallelly and perpendicularly cut to the sediment
5. Results
bedding in order to obtain information about 5.1. PHYSICAL CHARACTERIZATION OF PRE-
mechanical isotropy. The testing device (Universal HISPANIC AND COLONIAL ADOBES
Press Forney apparatus) allowed a maximum axial
load of 1471 kN. The axial load was increased The granulometry (grain size) is an essential aspect
continuously at a rate within the limits of rupture to be considered when characterizing adobe since
http://dx.doi.org/10.18268/BSGM2022v74n3a010422

Boletín de la Sociedad Geológica Mexicana / 74 (3) / A010422/ 2022 / 11

it provides insight into the type of raw material 2.6 g/cm3 to 2.8 g/cm3 and the porosity is 47% to
originally used to make the adobes. The pre-His- 48%. The miner’s adobe has a density that varies
panic produced adobe contains 9 to 13 wt% grav- from 2.5 g/cm3 to 2.7 g/cm3 and the porosity var-

RESULTS
el-size grains, 21 to 73 wt% sand-size grains, and ies from 49% to 62%. The moisture and organic
16 to 65wt% silt-clay size grains. For the adobes matter content are shown in Table 2. Of all the
agricultural hacienda there are no gravel-size adobes studied the moisture content varies (0.97%
grains (0 wt%), but 18 to 40 wt% sand-size grains to 10.61%) as well as the organic matter content
and 59 to 81wt% silt-clay size grains. While the (0% to 8.90%). Considering the plasticity index,
miner’s adobe contains 0.20 to 2 wt% gravel-size the Coporo pre-Hispanic adobe presents higher
grains, 5 to 17 wt% sand-size grains, and 81 to plasticity index (34.42) than that of La Nopalera
94 wt% silt-clay size grains. Table 1 shows the (11.33), while the Carretas agricultural adobe
size distribution of the particles that make up the shows the highest plasticity index (39.38) with
adobe’s matrix studied. According to the USCS, respect to the adobe of Santiago Tochac (5.51).
the adobes studied correspond to the three types The mining adobes show a plasticity index that
of soil: Pre-Hispanic adobe (SM: poorly graded, varies from 12.66 to 17.23, (Table 2).
sands and gravelly sands, little or no fines, and
ML: Inorganic silts and very fine sands, rock flour, 5.2. TOTAL ORGANIC MATTER CONTAINED IN
silty or clayey fine sands or clayey silts with slight ADOBES

plasticity); agricultural adobe (ML: Inorganic


silts and very fine sands, rock flour, silty or clayey The highest percentage of organic matter is pre-
fine sands or clayey silts with slight plasticity), sented in agricultural and miners adobes, which
and miner adobe (CL: Inorganic clays of low to vary from 4.09% to 8.90%, (Table 2).
medium plasticity, gravelly clays, sandy clays, silty
5.3. MECHANICAL CHARACTERIZATION OF ADOBES
clays, lean clays), (Table 1).
The cohesion soils according to Mitchell and The results of the mechanical tests are given in
Soga (2005), are fine-grained, low-strength, and

Comparative study of adobes in Mexico: granulometric distribution


Table 2. These tests were conducted on specimens
easily deformable soils that have a tendency for using perpendicular orientations. The results
particles to adhere. The soil is classified as cohesive showed that the eight bricks samples exhibited
if the number of fines (silt and clay-sized material) different behavior. Pre-Hispanic adobes: Coporo
exceeds 50% by weight. Considering the above, (66.05kg/cm2) and La Nopalera (4.73kg/cm2).
the pre-Hispanic adobe El Coporo presents a Agricultural adobes: Santiago Tochac (3.28kg/
better cohesion followed by La Nopalera, later the cm2) and Carretas (6.09 kg/cm2). Miners adobes:
agricultural adobe Las Carretas, Santiago Tochac, Dolores de Barrera (1.18 kg/cm2), El Patrocinio
and finally the adobe miners (Table 2). (1.1 kg/cm2), Duran (5.48 kg/cm2) and San Cle-
Regarding the density and porosity data of the mente (7.11 kg/cm2). Where the pre-Hispanic
solids, these are shown in Table 2. The pre-His- adobe the Coporo presents greater resistance to
panic adobe samples showed similar density and uniaxial compression.
porosity values in terms of bulk density, the range
of values shown by the bricks studied is 2.2 g/cm3 5.4. MINERALOGICAL AND CHEMICAL
to 2.7 g/cm3. Porosity is an important parameter CHARACTERIZATION
due to its influence on properties, such as chemical
reactivity, mechanical strength, durability, and the The analyzed samples contain different types of
overall quality of the brick. The porosity of the crystalline minerals (Table 3). Pre-Hispanic adobes
pre-Hispanic adobe bricks studied varies from present the following mineral phases which have
31% to 40%. The same is not the case with agri- been grouped into silicates (quartz, albite, anor-
cultural adobes where the solid density varies from thite, sanidine, microcline, lazurite), phyllosilicates
http://dx.doi.org/10.18268/BSGM2022v74n3a010422

12 / Boletín de la Sociedad Geológica Mexicana / 74 (3) / A010422/


A010422 /2022
2022

Table 1. Granulometry of adobe bricks samples.

Granulometry
Adobe bricks samples Gravel (wt%) Sand (wt%) Silt-Clay (wt%) Classification (USCS)
RESULTS

CLASSICAL Coporo 9.54 73.76 16.70 SM: poorly graded, sands and
Pre-Hispanic PERIOD gravelly sands, little or no fines
MIDDLE La 13.33 21.49 65.19 ML: Inorganic silts and very fine
CLASSIC Nopalera sands, rock flour, silty or clayey
PERIOD fine sands or clayey silts with slight
plasticity.
XVII Santiago 0.00 40.33 59.67 ML: Inorganic silts and very fine
century Tochac sands, rock flour, silty or clayey
Agricultural fine sands or clayey silts with slight
plasticity.
XVIII Carretas 0.00 18.21 81.79 ML: Inorganic silts and very fine
century sands, rock flour, silty or clayey
fine sands or clayey silts with slight
plasticity.
XVIII Dolores de 1.41 12.02 86.56 CL: Inorganic clays of low to
Century Barrera medium plasticity, gravelly clays,
sandy clays, silty clays, lean clays.

Miners El 0.20 5.73 94.07 Cl: Inorganic clays of low to


Patrocinio medium plasticity, gravelly clays,
sandy clays, silty clays, lean clays.
XVII Durán 0.25 17.87 81.87 Cl: Inorganic clays of low to
century medium plasticity, gravelly clays,
sandy clays, silty clays, lean clays.
San 2.05 10.01 87.94 CL: Inorganic clays of low to
Clemente medium plasticity, gravelly clays,
sandy clays, silty clays, lean clays.

(halloysite and montmorillonite), zeolites (gismon- 5.5. SEM-EDS ANALYSIS


dine), and secondary minerals (calcite). Agricul-
Comparative study of adobes in Mexico: granulometric distribution

tural adobes present silicates (quartz, albite, anor- In pre-Hispanic, agricultural, and miners’ adobes,
thite, obertiite, kyanite, magnesium-hornblende, the SEM examination revealed silicon/aluminum
cristobalite), phyllosilicates (montmorillonite), (Si/Al)-rich particles (silicates), clay minerals
and zeolites (epistilbite). Miner’s adobes present (phyllosilicates), and zeolites in all adobe bricks.
silicates (quartz, anorthite, albite), phyllosilicates Phosphates, mercury sulfates, and sulfides are
(montmorillonite, vermiculite, volkonskoite), only observed in mining adobes. The presences of
chlorite group (clinochlore- chromian), mercury spores, dry grass, and vegetal fibers are common in
sulfate (schuetteite), sulfides (fizelyite, zinkenite), agricultural, and mining adobes. As for the metals,
phosphates (brushite), zeolites (erionite, faujasite), it can be observed that most of the adobes of the
and sulfates (parnauite, gypsum). miner’s haciendas studied have Fe, Cu, As, Hg, Pb,
The pre-Hispanic adobes as well as the Colonial Sn, Zn, S, and Se (Figure 8).
agricultural ones present high concentrations of Si,
Al, Na, K, Ba, Ca, and Fe, observing absence in ele-
ments such as P, As, Se, Sb, Hg, and Ag. While min- 6. Discussion
ing adobes show high concentrations in Pb, As, Se,
Ag, Sb, and Hg, (Table 4). As for the oxides present 6.1. PHYSICAL, MECHANICAL, AND ORGANIC
in pre-Hispanic and agricultural adobes, we can MATTER CONTENT CHARACTERIZATION OF PRE-
mention that SiO2, Al2O3, Na2O, K2O, Fe2O3, and HISPANIC AND COLONIAL ADOBES
CaO present high concentrations in percentages,
unlike P205, which is common in mining adobes Adobe bricks are one of the oldest and most com-
apart from those already mentioned (Table 5). monly used materials in construction. The use of
Table 2. Simple compressive Strength, Cohesion, Solid density, Porosity Moisture content, Plastic index, and Organic material content of adobe bricks samples.

Mechanical Properties Physical Properties Samples


Adobe bricks samples Simple compressive Cohesion Solid Porosity Moisture Plasticity Organic material
Strength (kg/cm2) Density (%) content index content
(Kg/cm2) g/cm3 (%) (%)
CLASSICAL Coporo 66.05 33.02 2.7 40 1.73 34.42 0.00
PERIOD
Pre-Hispanic

MIDDLE La 4.73 2.37 2.2 31 10.61 11.33 2.18


CLASSIC Nopalera
PERIOD

XVII Santiago 3.28 1.38 2.6 47 1.59 5.51 4.09


Agricultural century Tochac

XVIII century Carretas 6.09 2.19 2.8 48 4.55 39.38 8.90

Dolores de 1.18 0.60 2.5 60 1.73 15.01 7.26


XVIII century Barrera
http://dx.doi.org/10.18268/BSGM2022v74n3a010422

Miner

El 1.1 0.55 2.6 62 0.97 12.66 2.27


Patrocinio

Durán 5.48 0.75 2.5 49 1.9 17.23 5.21


XVII
century

San 7.11 0.65 2.7 54 2.18 14.86 7.18


Clemente
Boletín de la Sociedad Geológica Mexicana / 74 (3) / A010422/ 2022 / 13

Comparative study of adobes in Mexico: granulometric distribution RESULTS


Comparative study of adobes in Mexico: granulometric distribution RESULTS

Table 3. Mineralogical phases (XRD) of adobe samples.


Adobe Tectosilicates Phyllosilicates Aluminosilicates Inosilicates Carbonates Chlorite Sulfates Sulfides Phosphates XRD-DIFFRACTOGRAM
samples
6000
CLASSICAL Coporo Quartz Halloysite
5000
PERIOD Anorthite ---- ---- ---- ---- ---- ----
4000
Pre- Albite Montmorillonite
Hispanic 3000

2000

1000

0
10 20 30 40 50 60
Two-Theta (deg)
Two-Theta (deg)
MIDDLE La Quartz
CLASSIC Nopalera
750
PERIOD Sanidine Montmorillonite Microcline ---- Calcite ---- ---- ---- ----
500

Gismondine 250

0
Lazurite 10 20 30 40 50 60 70
Two-Theta (deg)

XVII Santiago 1250

Agricultural century Tochac Albite Anorthite Obertiite 1000


---- ---- ---- ---- ---- ---- 750
Kyanite Magnesio- 500
hornblend-, 250
Cristobalite ferroan 0
10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80
Two-Theta (deg)

XVIII Carretas Quartz Montmorillonite Anorthite 4000

century ---- ---- ---- ---- ---- ----


3000
Cristobalite Epistilbite
2000

Epistilbite
1000

0
10 20 30 40 50 60
Two-Theta (deg)

2500
Dolores Quartz Volkonskoite
2000
XVIII de Barrera Anorthite Calcite Clinochlore Parnauite -
century Albite Montmorillonite ---- chromian ---- ---- 1500

Miner 1000

Vermiculite 500
0
10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80
Two-Theta (deg)

El Quartz 2500

Patrocinio Anorthite Calcite 2000


14 / Boletín de la Sociedad Geológica Mexicana / 74 (3) / A010422/
http://dx.doi.org/10.18268/BSGM2022v74n3a010422

Albite ---- ---- ---- ---- ---- ---- 1500

1000
Sanidine-
500
A010422 /2022
2022

0
10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80
Two-Theta (deg)

Durán Quartz,
2500
XVII Faujasite- Dickite Gypsum Fizelyite Brushite
2000
century K, Faujasite- ---- ---- ---- ----
1500
Na, Schuetteite
1000
Erionite-K
500
0
10 20 30 40 50
Two-Theta (deg)
San Quartz 3000
2500
Clemente ---- ---- ---- Calcite ---- Gypsum Zinkenite ----
2000
Faujasite-
1500
Na Schuetteite 1000
500
0
10 20 30 40 50 60

Two-Theta (deg)
http://dx.doi.org/10.18268/BSGM2022v74n3a010422

Boletín de la Sociedad Geológica Mexicana / 74 (3) / A010422/ 2022 / 15

Table 4. Chemical compositions (FRX) of adobe samples.

DISCUSSION
CHEMICAL PRE-HISPANIC ADOBES AGRICULTURAL ADOBES MINER´S ADOBES
ELEMENTS
(ppm)
Classical Middle XVII XVIII XVIII XVIII XVII XVII
period Classic period century century century century century century
COPORO LA HACIENDA CARRETAS DOLORES EL DURAN SAN
NOPALERA SANTIAGO DE PATROCINIO CLEMENTE
TOCHAC BARRERA
Si 294000 224000 265000 24400 215000 267000 251000 231000
Al 80400 67400 72400 71500 34600 23700 22200 59400
Ba 109 548 353 531 170 178 128 206
Na 6820 3390 15700 7020 ---- 9880 ---- 8180
P ---- ---- ---- ---- 1200 ---- 162 ----
Mg ---- 5380 3760 4260 12500 8800 12600 5220
S 149 469 436 715 6690 10300 10600 528
Cl 69.4 80.7 245 268 2570 296 1450 216
K 24900 17400 9660 16900 18500 13100 13200 16400
Ca 3840 19900 19100 16100 36700 33400 33300 15100
Mn 517 592 829 599 1120 1030 1180 352
Cr 16.2 33.5 67.6 40.7 36.8 17 25.5 34.2
Fe 17000 25700 28500 25000 21000 16300 13600 20500
Ni ---- 16.6 33.7 12.7 19.6 12.4 ---- ----
Cu 11.5 15.4 21.4 17.2 1190 2420 1450 32
Zn 68.7 71.3 63.9 58.4 317 714 635 82.6
As ---- ---- ---- ---- 36.3 28 47.6 4.19
Sn 17.9 22.7 17.4 16.3 ---- 18.1 ---- 7.12
Pb 21.9 19.4 25.7 13.3 231 557 406 25.9
Sr 36.5 147 317 210 71 47.1 34.2 186
Se ---- ---- ---- ---- 35.1 65.8 34 ----
Ag ---- ---- ---- ---- 56.2 98.6 90.4 ----
Sb ---- ---- ---- ---- 23.8 52.5 22.8 ----
Hg ---- ---- ---- ---- 819 1460 1000 17
Ti 2060 3350 3550 4210 1660 899 ---- 4200

Comparative study of adobes in Mexico: granulometric distribution


V 31.4 82.4 96.1 66.9 74.1 42.5 ---- 65.2

adobe is very common in Latin America, Africa, low percentage of gravel-sand and a high content
the Indian subcontinent and other parts of Asia, of silt-clay. With this relationship, the adobe does
the Middle East, and Southern Europe (Sharma not need to be stabilized with any binder or ele-
et al., 2015; Rincon et al., 2019; Vega et al., 2011; ment such as gravel, sand, or vegetable matter due
Costa et al., 2021; Mauricio et al., 2021). The results to its natural cohesion. Taking into account the
of this study indicate that pre-Hispanic adobe has climatic conditions of the place, the pre-Hispanic
a better granulometric distribution than colonial areas studied have a temperate to semi-dry climate,
adobes since it contains low gravel-sand content, which favors the resistance to erosion of the earthen
and high clay-silt content, which makes it more walls since they have been protected by remaining
resistant to the passage of time. The percentage buried under a collapse layer for a long time. The
of clay-silt and its plasticity index indicate that the pre-Hispanic adobes have different mechanical
manufacture of the adobe could be exposed to the properties in terms of resistance, this is due to the
environment (Morales, 2007). The lack of addition different manufacturing techniques used, derived
of vegetable matter indicates that the material and from the different periods of occupation in said
manufacturing technique of pre-Hispanic adobe archaeological zones (Liberotti and Daneels, 2012).
provided solid physical and mechanical qualities. On the other hand, the agricultural adobe of the
According to Jiménez Delgado and Caña Guer- 17th and 18th centuries buildings in Guanajuato
rero (2007), a good adobe soil must have a very city present physical, mechanical, and organic
http://dx.doi.org/10.18268/BSGM2022v74n3a010422

16 / Boletín de la Sociedad Geológica Mexicana / 74 (3) / A010422/


A010422 /2022
2022

Table 5. Oxides compositions (FRX) of adobe samples.


DISCUSSION

OXIDES PRE-HISPANIC ADOBES AGRICULTURAL ADOBES MINER´S ADOBES


(%)
Classical Middle XVII XVIII XVIII XVIII XVII XVII
period Classic period century century century century century century
COPORO LA SANTIAGO CARRETAS DOLORES EL DURAN SAN
NOPALERA TOCHAC DE PATROCINIO CLEMENTE
BARRERA
SiO2 72.3 67.9 69.6 68.7 71.7 78 77.1 70
Al2O3 15.4 14.4 13 16 9.85 7.21 5.78 6.29
MnO 0.0655 0.0797 0.105 0.0799 0.166 0.159 0.273 0.369
Na2O 5.04 4.83 6.97 3.77 ---- ---- ---- 3.45
MgO ---- 1.98 0.923 1.56 3.1 2.15 3.04 3.19
K2 O 3.65 2.52 1.28 2.35 2.77 1.98 1.88 1.99
CaO 0.576 3.36 2.96 2.61 6.35 4.78 5.6 3.51
P2O5 0.0664 0.0325 0.128 0.0872 0.417 0.144 0.133 0.082
SO3 0.0365 0.0601 0.102 0.145 2.35 2.53 3.43 3.74
Fe2O3 2.52 4.07 4.29 3.86 3.55 2.85 2.6 3.38
TiO2 0.385 0.73 0.687 0.873 0.342 0.186 0.206 0.2

material content properties similar, indicating that 18th centuries have greater particle size diversity,
manufacturing techniques did not change much and according to the USCS, they correspond to
between the 17th and 18th centuries. The analysis CL types of soil (Table 1). The different values of
of particle size indicates that sizes, silt, and clay compression are explained by the different per-
are the predominant component in the matrix of centage content in clays and silts (Table 2).
the adobes studied, the percentages of silt-clay All samples contain a greater amount of
are high, exceeding 59.67%, sand (40.33%), and aluminum and silicon, have a higher content of
have no gravel. Have a higher content of vegetable silty- clays. Porosity results are related to the use of
matter compared to pre-Hispanic adobes (Tables vegetable fibers as a supplement in the mixture of
1 and 2). The addition of vegetable matter in this soil and water. Organic matter plays an important
Comparative study of adobes in Mexico: granulometric distribution

type of adobes was to achieve the stabilization role in the above variables (porosity and density);
of the adobe and increase its resistance (Sharma as in a sample with high content of organic matter,
et al., 2015) since based on the data obtained, it increases the porosity and aeration capacity of
agricultural adobes have very slight plasticity, low clayey soils, better tolerating the mechanical effects
cohesion, and low resistance to compression. They caused by time (Sharma et al., 2015). Based on this,
are adobes that show a greater deterioration over the adobes of 17th and 18th centuries haciendas
time. For the case of mining adobes, the particle (Dolores de Barrera and San Clemente) have a
size analysis indicates that the sizes, silt, and clay higher content of organic matter, which explains
are the predominant components in the matrix its percentage of porosity and resistance to uniax-
of said adobes, the silt-clay percentages are high, ial compression. Mixing dry grass with clay allows
exceeding 81.87% (Table 1); the fact that fine, very proper agglutination, great weather ability and
fine and silty sand fractions predominate, with a prevents the blocks once solidified from cracking.
moderate amount of organic matter (Table 2), The presence of these elements provides insight
which gives these materials a high erodibility and a into the construction history of the building.
potential risk of being eroded by water, especially
in the rainier areas. The similarity of these mate- 6.2. XRD, XRF, AND SEM-EDS ANALYSIS
rials in their distribution and particle size, suggests
that there was a careful selection of raw materials The morphological observation by SEM-EDS
to produce adobes and control in production. Sim- and results obtained from the X-ray diffraction
ilarly, we can see that the buildings of the 17th and in pre-Hispanic adobe show the presence of eight
http://dx.doi.org/10.18268/BSGM2022v74n3a010422

Boletín de la Sociedad Geológica Mexicana / 74 (3) / A010422/ 2022 / 17

major minerals grouped in silicates (quartz, albite, val et al., 2004; Avrami et al., 2008). Differences

DISCUSSION
anorthite, sanidine microcline), phyllosilicates are observed with the colonial period in terms of
(halloysite, montmorillonite), and zeolites (gis- the type of phyllosilicates and zeolites present.
mondine). From a geological point of view, these Pre-Hispanic adobes present phyllosilicates of the
groups of minerals derive mainly from existing montmorillonite and halloysite type, while in the
volcanic rocks in the area. X-ray fluorescence colonial period the phyllosilicates are of various
analysis shows that the elemental composition types between montmorillonite, volkonskoite, ver-
of pre-Hispanic adobes is different from that of miculite, and dickite. The presence of phyllosili-
colonial adobes, with variations in the percentage cates marks a secondary origin, which derives from
of element content (Si, Al, P, Fe, Pb, As), and in the alteration of primary minerals or other silicates
the concentrations mainly related to iron oxide from volcanic rocks. From the point of view of the
(Fe203) and phosphorus (P205). These variations deterioration in buildings, montmorillonite could
may explain the dissimilarity in color, ranging cause deterioration in buildings because it allows
from orange-brown, brown, dark brown, and gray, water ingress, has high absorption, and high sus-
especially in the colonial period (Acevedo-Sando- ceptibility to contraction and expansion. Regard-

Comparative study of adobes in Mexico: granulometric distribution

Figure 8 Images obtained with the scanning electron microscope in the samples of the adobes studied. a), b), c), d) presence of spores
and vegetal fibers are common in agricultural and miners adobes; e), f), g) metals observed in miners adobes; h) silicates mineral
observed in all adobes; i) erionite in miners adobes.
http://dx.doi.org/10.18268/BSGM2022v74n3a010422

18 / Boletín de la Sociedad Geológica Mexicana / 74 (3) / A010422/


A010422 /2022
2022

ing the presence of zeolites, pre-Hispanic adobes is local, derived from the type of soil in the area
DISCUSSION

present gismondine as a mineral, while colonial and the method of benefit applied at the time for
adobes present several types among them fauja- the extraction of gold and silver, derived from the
site, erionite, and epistilbite, these are formed by mining of the time (Orozco, 1921; Antunez, 1964;
the transformation of the volcanic glass contained Echegoyen-Sánchez et al.,1970; Puy-Alquiza et al.,
in the tuffs of intermediate to acid composition, 2019). An important element within the colonial
and ignimbrites, they are also usually the product adobes is the presence of erionite-K. The erion-
of secondary alteration in cavities and vesicles of ite-K is a natural fibrous zeolite found in certain
igneous rocks. In the case of gismondine, this is volcanic tuffs (e.g. rhyolite tuff) and a wide range
usually the product of hydrothermal alteration. of geological settings. Erionite-K has been used
According to Avrami et al (2008), zeolites indicate as a noble metal-doping catalyst in a hydrocarbon
the existence of high silica activity in aqueous cracking process and studied for its use in agricul-
solutions, affecting the crystallization of the sili- tural applications (i.e. in fertilizers and odor control
cate. From the point of view of the deterioration in livestock production), (IARC, 1987; NTP, 2004).
in buildings, zeolites can hydrate and dehydrate, The characteristics that define these bricks units
when dehydrated the crystal develops a porous are variable. This may be due to the presence of
structure, forming cavities that can be occupied by the materials used; manufacturing processes; and
ions and water molecules, allowing ion exchange dominant conditions (Rivera-Torres and Muñoz-
and dehydration, thus causing the deterioration of Díaz, 2005).
the building.
Another disparity between pre-Hispanic and 6.3. CONSTRUCTIVE TYPOLOGIES, AND STRATEGIES
colonial adobe is that in colonial adobe, specifi- FOR ITS CONSERVATION
cally in agricultural haciendas, amorphous phases
such as cristobalite associated with volcanic glass The architecture of the pre-Hispanic sites studied
and opal have been observed. According to Pérez is characterized by its simple aesthetics related
et al (2016), the content of amorphous phases to the environment and the available resources.
Comparative study of adobes in Mexico: granulometric distribution

influences the resistance, plasticity, contraction, Adobe represents the important manufacturing
and expansion behavior of adobes. Although we element at both sites (Coporo, La Nopalera) where
did not quantify the content of amorphous phases the most common dimensions found are 10 cm x
in this study, we could think, according to the 15 cm x 35 cm and 10 cm x 32 cm x 20 cm. The
existing geology in the area, the existence of these reason for this heterogeneity is probably related
in the composition of the soil. Another difference to traditions, natural resources, and the type of
between pre-Hispanic and colonial adobe is that soil, influencing the size of the blocks that vary
pre-Hispanic adobe has a concentration of Si, Al, according to the place, the type of use, and the
Na, K, Ba, Ca, and Fe, which indicates a domain historical period of construction (Ferrada and
of silicates and aluminosilicates, these elements Segovia, 2007; Baudouin, 2021). On the other
correspond to the essential constituents of the hand, the colonial haciendas represent industrial
soils (Perez et al., 2016), this indicates that the complexes whose dimensions were directly related
materials used for the manufacture of the pre-His- to their economic activity, the wealth, and the
panic adobe derive from the soil generated by the capital of their owners. The hacienda is made up
weathering of the volcanic rocks that outcrop in of a set of buildings interrelated in their functions
the surroundings of the archaeological sites stud- so that generally the layout of the buildings was
ied, while the colonial adobes present elements related to an architectural patio, with which the
such as Ni, Cu, Co, Zn, Cr, Pb, As, Se, Ag, Sb, other buildings were built, contemplating the
V, and Hg, which indicates that the origin of the link that existed with the other spaces. The Haci-
raw materials used for the manufacture of adobe endas housed within their territorial extensions
http://dx.doi.org/10.18268/BSGM2022v74n3a010422

Boletín de la Sociedad Geológica Mexicana / 74 (3) / A010422/ 2022 / 19

various architectural elements such as the main resources, and technical and cultural reasons. The

DISCUSSION
house, where the patron and the administrative geological characteristics of the studied areas rep-
staff lived, the processing patios, the galleys, the resent an extraordinarily favorable scenario for the
laundries, ovens, stables, sheds, water wells, and exploitation of raw materials such as clay, for the
troughs. The most used materials were wood, manufacture of adobes. Clay is mined close to set-
stone, brick, adobe inside as well as outside. The tlement and/or production sites to reduce the time
size of the adobes and their composition was a and cost of acquisition and transportation. Proof
function of the type of soil, the natural resources, of this is that the pre-Hispanic adobe presents a
and the economic activity of the hacienda. Based good granulometric distribution between the con-
on this, the colonial adobes present a great variety tent of gravel, sand, silt, and clay, in addition to
of dimensions: 10 cm x 27 cm x 30 cm, 10 cm this it presents a low or null amount of organic
x 30 cm x 37 cm, and 15 cm x 35 cm x 45 cm, matter, and high plasticity index, making it one
indicating that each owner of the hacienda had of the most durable adobes studied. The quality
his own technique for the preparation of bricks of the material and the percentages used show a
and this was subject to the type of soil and the wide knowledge of the selection of materials and
contribution of organic matter content in the case masonry. During the colonial period, the materials
of agricultural bricks, and for mining bricks, the used linked to soils with little clay content and
raw material represented the waste product of the sandier caused low plasticity and cohesion, for
metallurgical process. One of the problems with which the addition of organic matter was neces-
the use of adobe in construction is the presence of sary. The clay soils caused too much shrinkage and
pathologies (alteration and degradation) derived fractures, while the sandy soils did not have enough
from the abandonment of the construction system interaction between the particles, so the adobes
and exposure to the elements (Gomez-Patrocinio et crumble, on the other hand, soils with excessive
al., 2020). Various techniques have been proposed content of organic matter had low resistance and
to avoid accelerated degradation of the material short duration against humidity. It is considered
(healing, ochratization, stapling, injection of epoxy that an adequate mix of the four granulometric

Comparative study of adobes in Mexico: granulometric distribution


resin, injection with cement pastes and micro-con- components (gravels, sands, silt, and clay) and the
crete, post-tensioning systems, sealing of cracks material origin are the keys for the manufacture
or fissures, among others). (Monjo-Carrió and of resistant and durable adobes over time, as is the
Maldonado-Ramos, 2001). In recent years, the case of pre-Hispanic adobes compared to colonial
use of consolidants has been proposed to prevent adobes. Two sources of materials used for the man-
the deterioration of adobe (Salazar-Hernández et ufacture of adobes can be identified in this study,
al., 2021). one related to the geological materials and the
type of soil which is characteristic of pre-Hispanic
adobes and another material related to the use
7. Conclusions of waste materials from the economic activity of
agricultural and mining haciendas. The changes
Construction techniques have changed over time in manufacturing techniques can be caused by
to make better use of existing natural and anthro- the presence of new groups with different cultural
pogenic materials. This has led to changes in and technical backgrounds. Similarly, this change
the manufacturing and manufacturing processes could also be explained from the perspective of an
that have characterized each period. The adobes exchange of ideas between different communities,
from the different periods studied showed that the over time.
chosen materials and techniques were determined The biggest problem for the repair, mainte-
by the environmental conditions, the available nance, and correct execution of adobe buildings
http://dx.doi.org/10.18268/BSGM2022v74n3a010422

20 / Boletín de la Sociedad Geológica Mexicana / 74 (3) / A010422/


A010422 /2022
2022
CONTRIBUTIONS OF AUTHORS /

is the loss of an ancient tradition, passed down Conflicts of interest


from generation to generation, creating a gap in
REFERENCES

the construction culture, losing know-how, and The authors declare that there is no conflict of
generating problems that can be fatal., especially interest.
in the case of seismic countries with ancestral
heritage. Knowing the manufacturing techniques
and processes will help to apply more effectively References
the conservation and restoration strategies of
buildings from different times. Acevedo-Sandoval, O., Ortiz-Hernández, E.,
Cruz-Sánchez, M., Cruz-Chávez, E., 2004,
El papel de óxidos de hierro en suelos: Terra
Acknowledgments Latinoamericana, 22(4), 485-497.
Antúnez, F., 1964, Monografía histórica y minera
Our thanks to the laboratory LICAMM for its sup- sobre el Distrito de Guanajuato: Distrito
port in the realization of the analysis of X-ray dif- Federal, Consejo de Recursos Naturales no
fraction, and Scanning Electron Microscopy. Also, Renovables, 588p.
acknowledge Cristina Daniela Moncada Sánchez ASTM, 2011, Norm. D2487-11, Standard
and Jesús René Báez Espinoza for their technical Practice for Classification of Soils for
support in this work. The samples from the archae- Engineering Purposes (Unified Soil
ological sites were obtained with the permission of Classification System): Pennsylvania, ASTM
the director of the archaeological sites, co-author International.
Omar Cruces, an archaeologist from Centro Gua- ASTM, 2006, Norm. D2434-68, Standard Test
najuato of the National Institute of Anthropology Method for Permeability of Granular Soils:
and History (INAH), who in 2006 was in charge Pennsylvania, ASTM International.
of the El Cóporo restoration project, and in 2019 Avrami, E., Guillaud, H., Hardy, M., 2008, Terra
of the collection campaign at La Nopalera. The literature review an overview of research
Comparative study of adobes in Mexico: granulometric distribution

characterization of materials, carried out by the in earthen architecture conservation: Los


Department of Geology of the University of Gua- Angeles, The Getty Conservation Institute,
najuato, was done in collaboration with INAH. 174p.
Bacoup, P., Prévost-Dermarkar, S., 2021,
Contributions of authors Climatic conditions and technical choices
in earthen architecture: the example of Late
(1) conceptualización: MJPA, (2) análisis o Neolithic Dikili Tash (Eastern Macedonia,
adquisición de datos: MJPA, (3) desarrollo met- Northern Greece), in Earthen Construction
odológico/técnico: MJPA, (4) redacción del manu- Technology: Proceedings of the XVIII
scrito original: MJPA, (5) redacción del manuscrito UISPP World Congress, 4-9 June 2018: Paris,
corregido y editado: VYOZ, RMA, GAZ, MCSH, France, Archaeopress Publishing Ltd, 1-55.
(6) diseño gráfico: GAZ, MCSH, GCA, YL, (7) Baudouin, E., 2021, Spread and independent
trabajo de campo: MJPA, VYOZ; OCC, ABS, technical invention of the Earthen material
(8) interpretación: MJPA; RMA; GAZ, GCA; in the Southern Caucasus and Northern
MCSH, YL. Mesopotamia during the sixth millennium
BCE, in Earthen Construction Technology:
Financing Proceedings of the XVIII UISPP World
Congress, 4-9 June 2018: Paris, France,
This research work was carried out without Archaeopress Publishing Ltd, 15-54.
funding. Barbeta Solà, G., 2002, Mejora de la tierra
http://dx.doi.org/10.18268/BSGM2022v74n3a010422

Boletín de la Sociedad Geológica Mexicana / 74 (3) / A010422/ 2022 / 21

estabilizada en el desarrollo de una (WRB): World Soil Resources, 84: Roma, Italia,
arquitectura sostenible hacia el siglo XXI: FAO, 109p.
Barcelona, Universidad Politécnica de Fournier-García, P., Mondragón, L., 2003,

REFERENCES
Cataluña, P.hD Dissertation, 226 p. Haciendas, ranchos, and the Otomí way of
Castañeda-López, C., García Moreno, G.Z., life in the Mezquital Valley, Hidalgo, Mexico:
Cardenas García, E., Torreblanca Padilla, Ethnohistory, 50(1), 47-68. https://doi.
C.A., 2007, Zonas arqueológicas en org/10.1215/00141801-50-1-47
Guanajuato. Cuatro casos: Plazuelas, Gama Castro, J. E., Cruz y Cruz, T., Pi Puig, T.,
Cañada de la Virgen, Peralta y El Coporo: Alcalá Martínez, R., Cabadas Báez, H., Jasso
Mexico, Editorial La Rana, 302p. Castañeda, C., Díaz Ortega, J., Sánchez Pérez,
Costa, C., Arduin, D., Rocha, F., Velosa, A., 2021, S., López Aguilar, F., Vilanova de Allende,
Adobe blocks in the center of Portugal: R., 2012, Arquitectura de tierra: el adobe
Main characteristics: International Journal como material de construcción en la época
of Architectural Heritage, 15(3), 467-478. prehispánica: Boletín de la Sociedad Geológica
https://doi.org/10.1080/15583058.2019.1 Mexicana, 64(2), 117-188. http://dx.doi.
627442 org/10.18268/BSGM2012v64n2a3
Chevalier, F., 1963, Land and society in colonial García-Ugarte, M.E., 2015, Impacto de las
México; the great hacienda: Berkeley, fundaciones piadosas en la sociedad queretana
University of California Press, 334 p. (siglo XVIII), Serie Historias Novohispana:
Daneels, A., 2015, Los sistemas constructivos México, UNAM, 247-262.
de tierra en el México prehispánico. In Garrido-Pérez, A., Cotler-Ávalos, H., Enríquez-
Tierra, sociedad, comunidad, en 15° Guadarrama, C., 2006, Geomorfología y
Seminario Iberoamericano de Arquitectura suelos, en Cotler-Ávalos, H., Mazari-Hiriart,
y Construcción con Tierra, Bolivia, M., de Anda-Sánchez, J. (eds), Atlas de la
Universidad de Cuenca, 219-232. Cuenca Lerma-Chapala, construyendo una
Daneels, A., Guerrero, L., 2012, La Joya, visión conjunta, 1ª ed.: México D.F., INE-

Comparative study of adobes in Mexico: granulometric distribution


Veracruz, un sitio prehispánico construido SEMARNAT, 9-20.
con tierra: sistemas constructivos y pruebas Gómez-Patrocinio, F. J., Mileto, C., García-Soriano,
de preservación en trópico húmedo: L., López-Manzanares, F.V., 2020, Material
Intervención Revista Internacional de weathering and structural damage in historic
Conservación, Restauración y Museología, adobe constructions in Spain: Preliminary
3(6), 34-43. https://doi.org/10.30763/ results of a quantitative approach: Studies in
Intervencion.2012.6.72 Conservation, 65(8), 450-464. https://doi.org/
Daneels, A., Guerrero Baca, L. F., Liberotti, G., 10.1080/00393630.2020.1727695
2013, Monumental earthen architecture in Echegoyen-Sánchez, J., Romero-Martínez,
the humid tropics of Mexico: archaeological S., Velázquez-Silva, S., 1970, Geología y
evidence of a millenary tradition: WIT yacimientos minerales de la parte central del
Transactions on the Built Environment, distrito minero de Guanajuato: Boletín Consejo
131, 457-468. https://doi.org/10.2495/ de Recursos Minerales no renovables, 75, 1–35.
STR130381 Guillaud, H., Graz, C., Correia M., Mileto C.,
Ferrada, K., Segovia, D., 2007, Agua, tierra y Vega F., 2008, Terra Incognita: discovering
paja. Construcciones de adobe en el Limarí: and preserving European earthen architecture:
Santiago, CNCA, 36p. European Union, Culture Lab Éditions, 250 p.
Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO), 1998, Howell, K.W., 2002, In the Wake of Conquest:
World Reference Base for Soil Resources A global perspective on the depopulation
http://dx.doi.org/10.18268/BSGM2022v74n3a010422

22 / Boletín de la Sociedad Geológica Mexicana / 74 (3) / A010422/


A010422 /2022
2022

of indigenous peoples of Latin America: W., 2021, The earliest adobe monumental
REFERENCES

Diálogos Latinoamericanos, 5, 58-72. architecture in the Americas: Proceedings of


International Agency for Research Cancer (IARC), the National Academy of Sciences, 118, 48.
1987, IARC Monographs on the Evaluation https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.2102941118
of the Carcinogenic Risk of Chemicals to Mitchell, J.R., Soga, K., 2005, Fundamentals of
Humans, Silica and some silicates, Vol. 42: soil behavior: 3rd ed.: New Jersey, Wiley,
USA, IARC, 239p. 561p.
International Organization for Standardization Monjó Carrió, J., Maldonado Ramos, L.,
(ISO), Norm.17828:2015.,Defines a method 2001, Patología y técnicas de intervención
of determining the bulk density of solid en estructuras arquitectónicas: Madrid,
biofuels by the use of a standard measuring Munilla-Lería, 302p.
container: Switzerland, International Morales Gamarra, R., 2007, Arquitectura
Organization for Standardization. prehispánica de tierra: conservación y uso
Jarquín, M.T., 1990, Origen y evolución de social en las huacas de moche, Perú: Apuntes
la hacienda en México, siglos XVI al Revista de Estudios Sobre Patrimonio
XX, en memorias del simposio realizado Cultural, 20(2), 256-279.
del 27 al 30 de septiembre de 1989, 1a Morner, M., 1973, The Spanish American
edition. Zinacantepec, Edo. de México: Hacienda: A Survey of recent research
México, Colegio Mexiquense; Universidad and debate: Hispanic American Historical
Iberoamericana: Instituto Nacional de Review, 53(2),183-216. https://doi.
Antropología e Historia, 263 p. org/10.2307/2512251
Jiménez Delgado, M.C., Cañas Guerrero, I., 2007, National Toxicology Program, Department of
The selection of soils for unestablished earth Health and Human Services (NTP), 2004.
building: a normative review: Construction Erionite: Report on Carcinogens, 14, III114–
Building Matter, 21(2), 237–251. https://doi. III115, PMID: 21089873.
org/10.1016/j.conbuildmat.2005.08.006 Norma Mexicana NMX-AA-21, 1985. Protección
Comparative study of adobes in Mexico: granulometric distribution

Ledesma, P.J.J., 2014, La técnica constructiva en la al ambiente-contaminación del suelo –


arquitectura: Revista Legado de Arquitectura residuos sólidos municipales - determinación
y Diseño, 15, 21-37. de materia orgánica. Diario Oficial de la
Liberotti, G., Daneels, A., 2012, Adobes en Federación de fecha 6 de Noviembre de 1992.
arquitectura monumental: análisis químico- Norma UNE-EN 1936, 2006, Métodos de ensayo
físicos, arqueología y reconstrucción 3D para piedra natural. Determinación de la
para determinar las técnicas constructivas densidad real y aparente y de la porosidad
en los sitios La Joya (México) y Arslantepe abierta y total.
(Turquía): Boletín de la Sociedad Geológica Norma UNE-EN1926, 2006, Métodos de ensayo
Mexicana, 64 (1), 79-89. http://dx.doi. para piedra natural. Determinación de la
org/10.18268/BSGM2012v64n1a7 resistencia a la compresión.
Mateu, M., Fernández, H., Daneels, A., Norma UNE-EN 13880-10:2004, Métodos
Cabadas, H., Piña, S., 2022, Earthen de ensayo para la determinación de la
architecture in the Mesoamerican classic adherencia y de la cohesión después del
period: A micromorphological approach alargamiento y compresión continuados.
to its manufacture process: Journal of Orozco, R., 1921, La industria minera de
Archaeological Science, 137, 105525. México: Distrito de Guanajuato: México,
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jas.2021.105525 Secretaria de Industria, Comercio y Trabajo,
Mauricio, A. C., Grieseler, R., Heller, A. R., Kelley, Departamento de Exploraciones y Estudios
A. R., Rumiche, F., Sandweiss, D. H., Viveen, Geológicos, 163 p.
http://dx.doi.org/10.18268/BSGM2022v74n3a010422

Boletín de la Sociedad Geológica Mexicana / 74 (3) / A010422/ 2022 / 23

Pérez, N. A., Bucio, L., Bokhimi, X., Lima, C.D., del Ángel-Soto, J., 2021, Comparative

REFERENCES
E., Soto, E., 2016, Quantification of study of TEOS-consolidants for adobe
amorphous phases in the silt fraction of building conservation: Journal of Sol-
Mexican pre-Hispanic adobe earth bricks: Gel Science and Technology, 97(3),
Journal of Applied Crystallography, 685-696. https://doi.org/10.1007/
49(2), 561-568. https://doi.org/10.1107/ s10971-020-05461-2
S1600576716002806 Santibañez-Tijerina, B. E., 2010, Industria
Punzo Díaz, J. L., 2005, El uso de la arquitectura y trabajadores textiles en Tlaxcala:
de tierra en sitios arqueológicos de la Sierra Convergencias y Divergencias en los
Madre de Durango, en Anuario de estudios movimientos sociales 1906-1918: Puebla,
de arquitectura de tierra: México, UAM, Benemérita Universidad Autónoma de
21-30. Puebla, 267 p.
Puy-Alquiza M.J., Miranda-Avilés, R., Ordaz- Sharma, V., Vinayak, H. K., Marwaha, B. M.,
Zubia, V.Y., Moncada C.D., Zanor G.A., 2015, Enhancing the sustainability of
Salazar-Hernández, M. C., Li, Y., Loza- rural adobe houses of hills by addition
Aguirre, I., 2019, The mine tailings as of vernacular fiber reinforcement:
construction material in the viceregal period: International Journal of the Sustainable
case study in Guanajuato city, Mexico: Boletin Built Environment, 4(2), 348-358. https://
de la Sociedad Geologica Mexicana, 71 doi.org/10.1016/j.ijsbe.2015.07.002
(2), 543-564. http://dx.doi.org/10.18268/ Van Young, E., 1983, Mexican rural history
BSGM2019v71n2a18 since Chevalier: The historiography of
Raisz, E., 1964, Physiographic provinces landforms the Colonial Hacienda: Latin American
of Mexico: U.S.A. Geographic Branch of the Research Review 18(3), 5-61. https://doi.
Office of Naval Research, Cambridge Mass. org/10.1017/S0023879100021026
Rincón, L., Carrobé, A., Martorell, I., Medrano, Vega, P., Juan, A., Guerra, M. I., Morán, J. M.,
M., 2019, Improving thermal comfort of Aguado, P. J., Llamas, B., 2011, Mechanical

Comparative study of adobes in Mexico: granulometric distribution


earthen dwellings in sub-Saharan Africa characterization of traditional adobes
with passive design: Journal of Building from the north of Spain: Construction
Engineering, 24, 100732. https://doi. and Building Materials 25(7), 3020–
org/10.1016/j.jobe.2019.100732 3023. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.
Rivera-Torres, J.C., Muñoz-Díaz, E.E., 2005, conbuildmat.2011.02.003
Caracterización estructural de materiales Wolf, E.R., Mintz, S., 1957, Haciendas and
de sistemas constructivos en tierra: el Plantations in Middle America and the
adobe: Revista Internacional de Desastres Antilles: Social and Economic Studies 6(3),
Naturales, Accidentes e Infraestructura Civil, 380-411.
5, 135-148. Yuste,B., 2016, Arquitectura de tierra.
Salazar-Hernández, C., Puy-Alquiza, M. J., Caracterización de los tipos edificatorios:
Miranda-Avilés, R., Salazar-Hernández, M., España,Universidad Politécnica de
Mendoza-Miranda, J. M., Mocada-Sánchez, Cataluña, 122 p.

También podría gustarte