Documentos de Académico
Documentos de Profesional
Documentos de Cultura
Dental health; the relationship between tooth decay and food consumption
Ángel Miguel González Sanz1, Blanca Aurora González Nieto2 and Esther González Nieto2
1
Senior Lecturer in Preventative Dentistry and Gerodontology. University Rey Juan Carlos. Madrid. 2 Associate Professor
of the University’s ‘Expert in Advanced Dentistry for General Practice Dentists’. University Rey Juan Carlos. Madrid.
3
Collaborating Honorary Professor in Preventative Dentistry and Gerodontology. University Rey Juan Carlos. Madrid.
Spain.
Introduction
Corresponding author: Ángel-Miguel González Sanz.
Senior Lecturer in Preventative Dentistry and Gerodontology.
University Rey Juan Carlos. In general, the dietary factors in the aetiology of
C/ Lavanda, 53. tooth decay are currently being played down, in favour
28050 Madrid. Spain. of promoting hygiene and the adequate use fluoride.
E-mail: amgonzalezsanz@gmail.com / angel.gonzalez@urjc.es
Since the widespread use of fluoride, some authors
64
07. Salud dental_Nutr Hosp 25/06/14 12:33 Página 65
have even questioned the relationship between high enamel’s sub-surface, which is able to progress
sugar consumption and the incidence of tooth decay. through the dentine and reach the dental pulp,
However, it should be taken into account that in young producing a chalky lesion on the surface of the enamel.
children dental hygiene and the use of fluoride is often If treatment is not carried out to remineralise the initial
unsatisfactory and/or insufficient, and therefore, it is lesion, it could progress and turn into a cavity1.
during this phase of dental development that dietary Demineralisation is the disorganisation of miner-
habits seem to be more important when it comes to alised dental tissues due to the action of bacterial
preventing the appearance of tooth decay. Something metabolism products and as a result of biochemical
similar occurs in the elderly, where there is a reduction interchanges which take place in three phases: saliva,
in salivary secretion, which is secondary to the multi- plaque bacteria and enamel.
medication and multiple pathologies that are associ- The causes of tooth decay are multifactorial,
ated with this age group1-4. although there are three key factors which will be
Diet is not just important for general health, but also added to in time: the host, microorganisms and diet.
for oral health. If an appropriate diet is not followed. Environmental factors include, among other things, the
it’s more likely that we will develop tooth decay and presence or absence of health services and oral health
gum disease. This applies at any stage in life, for programmes, socio-economic class, stress, ethnicity,
example, acquiring healthy eating habits is essential to culture, bio-dental engineering factors (biomechanical,
prevent the development of tooth decay, amongst other biochemical and bioelectrical). The risk of tooth decay
things, in children. Similarly, pregnant women need a is due to socio-demographic, behavioural, physical/
suitable diet so that their children develop normal teeth. environmental and biological risk factors.
Socio-economic factors and even obesity are identified Diet plays a pivotal role in the development of tooth
as risk factors for developing tooth decay5. decay, particularly in people at risk. Usually, a combi-
In children there is a particular relationship risk nation of the high consumption of fermentable carbo-
between the presence of malnutrition, tooth decay and hydrates and the failure to include fluoride is associ-
the timeline of its appearance. Malnutrition adversely ated with the increased incidence of tooth decay,
influences craniofacial growth and development, and however, there is no reason why it should occur in
an adverse precedent that can have various conse- developed societies that have adequate exposure to
quences, including: changes in the quality and texture fluoride and a history of low levels of tooth decay.
of certain tissues (bone, periodontal ligament and Although there is no direct relationship between
teeth). There is a significant connection between oral protein-energy malnutrition and tooth decay, vitamin
health and nutritional status (failure to thrive) which (A, D), calcium and phosphorus deficiencies can cause
could determine higher rates of tooth decay, a higher changes in tooth development and delayed eruption.
prevalence of gingivitis in children and an increase in In protein-energy malnutrition, which is so prevalent
the frequency of malocclusions. There are enamel in developing countries, a reduction in saliva
defects associated with endocrine protein malnutrition, immunoglobulin A has been detected, which could
hypocalcaemia, vitamin and mineral deficiencies, in increase susceptibility to tooth decay (mucosal immu-
the context of enteropathies (coeliac disease, non- nity has an impact via a reduction in secretory IgA).1
specific diarrhoea). Dental enamel defects have also Nevertheless, there are many epidemiological
been reported secondary to an excess of, or poisoning studies that correlate sugar consumption with the
by vitamin D, fluoride or other minerals6. prevalence of tooth decay and which show a clear asso-
Morbid obesity or its associated conditions or co- ciation between the frequency of consumption, eating
morbidities (gastro-oesophageal reflux, antidepres- between meals and developing tooth decay. Further-
sants, high blood pressure, etc), cause increased inci- more, there are a variety of food characteristics that
dences of tooth decay, changes in periodontal indices, may have an influence on their cariogenic potential,
the need for dental prostheses and monitoring of sali- such as sucrose concentration, consistency, oral
vary flow (quantity and quality). rinsing, the combination of foods, sequence and
Tooth decay is one of the most prevalent infectious frequency of ingestion and food pH1,7.
disease in humans and one of the main public health Foods are a chemical mixture of organic and inor-
issues on a global scale. It is a disease where the teeth’s ganic substances that provide the human body with the
hard tissues are modified and eventually dissolved, a nutrients necessary for its maintenance, growth and the
process where localised destruction of these tissues development of its functions. Carbohydrates are
occurs due to the action of bacteria that are involved. currently seen as the cornerstone of a healthy balanced
Molecular decomposition occurs in the teeth’s hard diet, followed by fats, whose consumption has
tissues through a histochemical and bacterial process decreased to prevent cardiovascular disease, and
that ends in the progressive decalcification and dissolu- finally proteins. The current methods for preparing
tion of inorganic materials and the disintegration of its high carbohydrate foods have a great impact on their
organic matrix. The formation of dental cavities starts physical and chemical structure. The carbohydrates
in the form of small demineralised areas on the found in foods are primarily: monosaccharides
65
07. Salud dental_Nutr Hosp 25/06/14 12:33 Página 66
(glucose, fructose and galactose), disaccharides and qualities of the saliva, etc. It is very important to
(sucrose = glucose + fructose, maltose = glucose + limit the frequency of cariogenic carbohydrate
glucose, lactose = glucose + galactose), oligosaccha- consumption outside of meals.
rides (3 to 8 glucose molecules) and polysaccharides So, foods that contain between 15 and 20% of
(starch). The cooking and preparation of foods affects sugars, especially sucrose, are the most cariogenic,
the carbohydrate composition of foods and has an particularly if they are eaten between meals. There are
influence on its cariogenic potential8. other carbohydrates such as fructose, that have greater
The frequency of consuming cariogenic foods, sweetening properties than complete sucrose, but are
particularly between meals, has a strong relationship less cariogenic. Similarly, Xylitol is not cariogenic as it
with the risk of tooth decay, because it favours changes is not used by bacteria to produce acid, and can even
in pH and lengthens the oral rinse time which increases have an anti-caries effect as it increases saliva flow,
the likelihood of enamel demineralisation. With regard raises the pH and reduces Streptococcus mutans levels
to consistency and oral rinse there are various studies because it interferes with its metabolism.
which have observed that certain foods, even those Furthermore, there are different foods that can have
with a high sugar content, may have a greater solubility cariostatic effects. In animal studies it was observed
and are eliminated more quickly from the mouth, that foods that contain high levels of fat, protein,
whereas foods that are high in starch (bread, cereals, calcium and fluoride can protect against tooth decay.
potatoes) may increase acid production and are elimi- Fats cover the tooth, reducing sugar and plaque reten-
nated more slowly from the mouth. tion, and may have toxic effects on bacteria. Proteins
Epidemiological studies show that breast milk and increase saliva’s buffering capacity and have a protec-
breast feeding helps physical and nutritional develop- tive effect on enamel. Fats and proteins jointly raise pH
ment in children, and has psychological, social, following the consumption of carbohydrates. Another
economic and environmental advantages, at the same type of food that has this protective profile are those
time as significantly reducing the risk of developing a that, through chewing, stimulate saliva flow and
large number of acute and chronic illnesses. So, breast thereby buffer pH acid and stimulate the remineralisa-
feeding, and as such, breast milk itself, is not cario- tion of enamel1.
genic. However, various studies have shown that, in Sugar free chewing gums use non-caloric sweet-
combination with other carbohydrates or administered eners that can help prevent tooth decay. The sweet taste
more frequently at night or on demand, it is associated and chewing stimulates saliva flow, which contributes
with early tooth decay. Tooth decay that develops as to the prevention of tooth decay. These chewing gums
soon as the tooth erupts, on smooth surfaces, and which can contain minerals such as calcium, phosphate and
progresses quickly until it has had an extensive fluoride to improve the teeth’s remineralisation
destructive impact on the teeth. For this same reason, process. Some studies have reported that sugar free
the frequent use of bottles of juice or carbohydrates chewing gums, that are consumed after a meal, accel-
should be avoided. They can be filled with water, erate the cleaning of food debris and reduce the rate of
for example, using them more for soothing than developing tooth decay in children and adolescents.
feeding1,8-10. It is important that adolescents reduce their elevated
Tooth decay in preschool children is due to a combi- and frequent consumption of sugary drinks, as they are
nation of many factors, including the colonisation of a factor that is particularly associated with tooth decay.
cariogenic bacteria on teeth, the type of foods Since diet is a factor that determines the develop-
consumed as well as the frequency of the cariogenic ment of tooth decay, adequate information needs to be
bacteria’s exposure to these foods, and sensitive teeth. provided to patients. It’s also worth remembering that
The risk of developing tooth decay is greater if sugars an increase in sugar doesn’t just involve an increased
are consumed very often and are in a form that means risk of tooth decay but also a growing risk of obesity,
the food stays in the mouth for long periods of time. and therefore a greater disposition for adults to suffer
Sucrose is the most cariogenic sugar as it can form illnesses such as diabetes, cardiovascular (hyperten-
glucan, a substance that enables bacteria to adhere sion, cholesterol), respiratory (apnoea, asthma),
better to the teeth and that diffuses plaque acid and orthopaedic (fractures) and liver diseases11,12.
buffers. The frequent, elevated consumption of drinks Establishing dental care in children, even during
that have been sweetened with sugar and the absence of pregnancy and afterwards in newborns, is one of the
normal tooth brushing are considered to be the factors most suitable strategies for preventing tooth decay,
that most associated with developing tooth decay. including dietary recommendations and instructions on
It is advisable to avoid snacking between meals and how to practice proper dental hygiene once the first
to limit sugar consumption for during meal times, milk teeth have erupted. The predisposition to devel-
when saliva flow is greater and enables quick oral oping tooth decay varies among individuals and
rinsing. This rinse period depends on the consistency between different teeth in the same mouth. The shape
of foods and the solubility of particles, as well as other of the jaw and oral cavity, the structure of the teeth and
individual characteristics such as chewing, the amount the quantity and quality of saliva are important in deter-
66
07. Salud dental_Nutr Hosp 25/06/14 12:33 Página 67
67
07. Salud dental_Nutr Hosp 25/06/14 12:33 Página 68
pH
habits, and therefore oral health. A large number of Critical pH
microorganism in the mouth, particularly in hard-to- 5.5
reach-areas; the production of different acids during
bacterial metabolism with the ability to dissolve
mineral salts which are part of the tooth’s structure, 5.0
retaining factors (open cavities, overflowing tooth fill- 5 10 15 20
ings, fixed or removable prostheses, orthodontic appli- Time in minutes
ances, gingival recession, etc) are part of a series of
Figure 1 illustrates what can happen to dental plaque once a meal containing fer-
threats that healthy teeth are regularly exposed to. The mentable carbohydrates (CH) had been consumed. After a few minutes of eating a
frequency and correct brushing of teeth, the use of meal that is high in fermentable carbohydrates, pH drops to a critical level, i.e. a level
where the enamel starts to demineralise (pH: 5.5-6.3). There is an increase in hydro-
additional hygiene devices such as dental floss or inter- gen ion concentration in the plaque bacteria: the onset of the tooth enamel demineral-
proximal brushes are also determining factors. The isation process1.
frequency of brushing and being an immigrant have a
Fig. 1.—Stephan Curve (prepared by the author).
significant association with the incidence and preva-
lence of tooth decay1.
The truth is that diet plays an important role in the (rinsing or clearance), intake during or between
development of tooth decay (closely linked to the meals, protective factors (cheese, phosphates),
frequent consumption of carbohydrates and high cari- consumption frequency (Critical pH: (5.2-5.5) that is
ogenic activity) and the fact is that frequency is more expressed graphically by the Stephan curve, which
important than the amount consumed; there are relates the frequency of meals to the exposure time1
authors who claim that sugar is not a causal factor in (Fig. 1).
the etiopathogenic process of tooth decay, but it is a In addition to carbohydrates, there is also a connec-
risk modifier. We found a statistically significant tion with: nutritional deficiencies, protein, vitamin and
relationship (P<0.05) between the colonisation of mineral deficiencies, a diet that reduces saliva secre-
streptococcus mutans and feeding bottles containing tion and composition, hypoplasia caused by nutritional
sugary drinks6. The stickiness and retention of food, deficiencies and widespread tooth decay.
in the hard and soft tissues, depends on the type of Controlling high sucrose diets, the frequency of
foods consumed. Fats in food reduce the oral reten- tooth brushing and social class are predictors for devel-
tion period; liquid foods are eliminated a lot faster oping tooth decay. Regular brushing (2 times/day) with
than solid foods. The food retention parameters and fluoride toothpaste may have a bigger impact in young
acid formation are important in the development of people than restricting sugary foods.1
tooth decay, but they are not a good epidemiological Physical and environmental factors such as previous
indicator of tooth decay. Therefore, it is difficult to experience of tooth decay (which we have also
relate the cariogenicity of foods to an individual commented on under weaknesses), the areas at risk and
physical property, such as its buffering capacity or the arch form should also be taken into consideration.
acid production. The physical form, the consistency In this section, with regards to tooth decay, we
and the frequency of consumption, as well as the highlighted that: primary teeth, a previous history of
sugar content (particularly sucrose, which is the stan- treated or untreated tooth decay, numerous unmoni-
dard), are major determinants of the cariogenic tored initial caries lesions, the presence of initial
potential of foods. Sucrose and starch are found in caries lesions or white spots, rare cases of tooth decay
many products we eat that are not related to their in previous groups, more than three new lesions per
presence (examples are fruit, milk, bread, cereals and year, poor or non sealing of specified pits and fissures
even vegetables). The key to eating properly is not to are good risk indicators for the future development of
avoid these products, but to know how to eat the right tooth decay
amounts of them and at the right times of day We have highlighted areas at risk and the dental
(avoiding snacking between meals). It’s not just what arch form: premature dental extractions, multiple
you eat, but when you eat that makes a big difference restorations, positioning of teeth in the arch (over-
to dental health1,6,8. crowding, malocclusions,...), the composition of dental
The characteristics of foods that have an increased tissues and enamel maturation with fluoride uptake and
potential for causing tooth decay are: texture (the carbonate, magnesium and sodium release, the tooth’s
consistency of foods), taste, carbohydrate content and surface texture (cracks and/or flakes, developmental
composition (direct, indirect or ‘hidden’, cariogenic abnormalities, wear on the tooth’s surface (for
potential (CPI of Sucrose = 1), prolonged retention example, prosthesis retainers).
68
07. Salud dental_Nutr Hosp 25/06/14 12:33 Página 69
The locations where tooth decay occurs most often oral rinsing, along with the muscles and soft tissues of
in deciduous teeth are: the pits and fissures, the the mouth, antimicrobial action (children and adults
occlusal surfaces: in molars (primarily occlusal- with immunological disorders are more susceptible to
buccal); buccal in canines and mesial in the incisors. tooth decay), its buffering effect, its viscosity and its
The most affected areas are usually in the lower poste- effect on reducing enamel solubility. Secretion may be
rior molars, the upper posterior molars, the upper and spontaneous (primarily from the submandibular and
lower anterior incisors. In permanent teeth the most sublingual glands) and/or stimulated by chewing
common locations are the occlusal surface (buccal and paraffin for five minutes (mainly from the glands
lingual), especially the molars and subsequently the previously mentioned plus the parotid gland). We talk
premolars. about low levels of stimulated saliva when saliva
Tooth decay in the pits and fissures is relatively easy production is lower than 0.7 millilitres per minute, and
to prevent with the use of sealants, which once they low levels without stimulation when it is lower than
have been ‘filled’ prevent nutrients from entering and 0.25 millilitres per minute1.8.
creating a bacterial biofilm. If the fissures are in the The sensation of a dry mouth is called xerostomia,
shape of a ‘U’, ‘Y’ and ‘YK’ there is an increased risk and may or may not be accompanied by hyposaliva-
of tooth decay. Those that are in the shape of a ‘V’ and tion (reduced saliva production). Hyposalivation
‘Y’ pose less of a risk. may be caused by systemic, local or medicine-
A white spot represents the first, clinically visible, induced disorders so, for example, we have high-
stage of enamel demineralisation and is the main lighted certain medications: antipsychotics, antihist-
warning sign for putting a comprehensive strategy in amines, diuretics, antihypertensives; anorexia,
place to prevent tooth decay, by promoting a healthy, episodes of depression and their treatment, diabetes
balanced diet as well as monitoring dental hygiene and mellitus, etc.
using topical fluoride treatments, and assistance with
monitoring from the dentist (Table II).
One of the most important factors in developing tooth Strengths
decay, along with diet and time, are microorganisms, as
without their presence in the mouth there would be no Included in the internal analysis are the strength of
tooth decay. The most frequently involved microorgan- different capabilities, the natural advantages and the
isms are: Streptococcus mutans (associated with the superior resources.
onset of tooth decay: occlusal and smooth-surface) and Historically race has been talked about, observing
Lactobacillus spp. (it appears once the lesion has been that pure ethnic groups suffer with tooth decay less
established, particularly in undercut areas and root often. Curiously, Afro-Americans have a higher inci-
caries). Other lactobacilli that should be considered are dence than Africans. Undoubtedly, an individual’s
casei and acidophilus. An increase in salivary enzymes genetic predisposition has an influence on tooth size,
has been noted in individuals with poor oral hygiene its crystal formation and immunity (natural immunity
and is associated with an increase in tooth decay. Once to tooth decay seems to be connected to HLA-DR locus
these microorganisms have been counted, we consider activity located in chromosome 6 and in individuals
S Mutans levels to be high if there are more than that are decay resistant: HLA-DR W6 generates
1,000,000,000 colony-forming units per millimetre, activity in the helper T lymphocytes, increasing the
and for lactobacillus if it is higher than 100,000 colony- number of antibody-forming cells. Certain HLA class
forming units per millimetre in saliva. II (DR) alleles are related to oral salivary microor-
Salivary secretion is essential due to the different ganism populations such as S. Mutans and Lacto-
functions it performs such as mechanical sweeping and bacilli.
The genetic factors aren’t fully known yet. It is also
due to cultural and socio-economic factors (dietary
Table II habits, hygiene, health and dental education).
Characteristics for diagnosing white spots Gender, referring to women, is also a protective
(prepared by the author) factor. This is explained by the earlier eruption of
permanent teeth in females, by better dental hygiene
Visibility Opaque when dry
habits and greater concern about preventing tooth
Close to the gingival, sulcus decay. Hormonal changes during the menstrual cycle,
Location
symmetrical or asymmetrical breastfeeding and pregnancy can alter saliva composi-
Affected teeth
Primary molars both tion and encourage bacterial growth, especially if
dentitions adequate teeth cleaning is forgotten and the consump-
Shape Kidney or oval-shaped tion of sugary foods is increased, and therefore encour-
Related to plaque bacteria Yes ages tooth decay.
The possibility of using public and private
Related to fluoride consumption No
resources with professionals that have a high level of
69
07. Salud dental_Nutr Hosp 25/06/14 12:33 Página 70
Social media
Key individuals or leaders (imitation)
Families
Schools
Vocational training Political and health organisations
Universities Other
Other training
70
07. Salud dental_Nutr Hosp 25/06/14 12:33 Página 71
71