Documentos de Académico
Documentos de Profesional
Documentos de Cultura
www.elsevier.com/locate/enbuild
Abstract
This article is about a study on glass window and glass window with film of different types in aspect of thermal comfort and heat
transmission. Different types of glass window, clear glass, tinted glass, reflective glass, double pane glass, and low-e glass were investigated.
Films with different spectral optical properties were then adhered to the glass windows of different types and studied. The analysis was done
based on the outside design weather condition which selected from 12 years of Bangkok meteorological data. Predicted percentage of
dissatisfied (PPD) was selected as the thermal comfort index. The relative heat gain (RHG) based on local weather condition was selected as
the heat transmission index. The PPD can be subdivided into the PPD due to surface temperature effect and the PPD due to solar radiation
effect. The analysis indicated that, for most of the glass windows considered except the reflective glasses, the values of PPD due to solar
radiation effect were much larger than the values of PPD due to surface temperature effect. And the most discomfort condition occurred when
using a clear glass as window. Adhered films to the glass windows caused the PPD due to surface temperature effect increase and cause the
PPD due to solar radiation effect decrease. It was also found that the PPD values due to solar radiation effect for glass windows and glass
windows with films were varied linearly with the total transmittance of glass windows and glass windows with films. The PPD values due to
surface temperature effect were varied with the total absorptance of glass windows and glass windows with films in an almost linear fashion.
The heat transmission index, RHG, based on chosen design weather condition can be subdivided into the RHG due to conduction effect and
RHG due to solar radiation effect. The analysis indicated that the values of RHG due to solar radiation effect were larger than the values of
RHG due to conduction effect for all glass windows and glass windows with films considered in this study. Adhered film to the glass windows
resulted in lowering the relative heat gain due to solar radiation in the amount corresponding to the film properties. But the film had very few
effect on the relative heat gain due to conduction. The relative heat gain values were varied linearly with the total transmittances of the glass
windows and glass windows with films. The relative heat gain values were also varied inversely with the absorptances of glass windows and
glass windows with films in a linear fashion.
# 2004 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
Keywords: Glass windows; Films; Thermal comfort; Heat transmission; Performance rating
1. Introduction And since Thailand is located in the tropical zone near the
equator. The weather is hot and humid for most of the year.
Large office and commercial buildings in Thailand Therefore, besides the advantage of the glass windows as
usually have large amount of glass windows installed as the described above, the glass windows installed in buildings in
building envelopes. The glass windows are installed to serve Thailand also act as a means to admit solar radiation into
as physical and visual connection to outsiders, as well as buildings and convert it into building heat gain and then
to make the appearance of buildings look more aesthetic. building cooling load, respectively. Such buildings which
are air conditioned will usually consume more energy from
* Corresponding author. Tel.: +66 22186610; fax: +66 22522889. the air conditioning system to take care of the cooling load
E-mail address: fmescy@eng.chula.ac.th (S. Chaiyapinunt). due to large amount of solar radiation passing through glass
0378-7788/$ – see front matter # 2004 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/j.enbuild.2004.10.008
726 S. Chaiyapinunt et al. / Energy and Buildings 37 (2005) 725–738
can be predicted in several ways. One way to describe the the effect from surface temperature and solar radiation. Such
state of thermal comfort is to use predicted mean vote mean radiant temperatures can be written as
(PMV) index and predicted percentage of dissatisfied (PPD)
Ttmrt ¼ ½ðts1 þ 273Þ4 Fp1 þ ðts2 þ 273Þ4 Fp2 þ
very well with the experimental results especially on clear Most of the mathematical models used for calculating
glass. Small discrepancy on the maximum value of the heat thermal comfort parameters came from the empirical
gain on the coated glass is observed. This discrepancy is formulae adopted from many experimental works by Fanger
suspected to come from the use of the coated emittance as [5]. One of the parameters that has major effect on the
0.042 in the simulation which could be different from the thermal comfort index in this study would be the mean
real coated used in the tested glass. The second set of radiant temperature especially the one due to surface
measurement values obtained from the work done by Morya temperature and solar radiation (Tsmrt). The experimental
[16] at AIT (Asean Institute of Technology, Pathumthani, results on the thermal comfort index due to high solar
Thailand). The measurement was performed at the facility radiation passing through the glass windows are quite
on the campus by measuring the air inside and outside limited. In this study, the results measured by Sullivan [7]
temperature, glass inside and outside surface temperature, are chosen to perform the validation task. Sullivan [7] has
solar radiation on direct normal, diffuse, and global conducted some measurement in a room with solar radiation
component that incident on glass surface and transmitted passing through the glass window. The measurement values
solar radiation. The air temperature inside and outside of the are operative temperature, air temperature, and solar
tested room, and glass surface temperature of the tested radiation. The solar radiation was measured by Epply
room were measured by type K thermocouple. The pyranometer. The operative temperature was measured by
transmitted and reflected solar radiation through the room the comfort meter. The air temperature was measured by the
was measured by solarimeter. The measurement in this case climate analyzer. Then the mean radiant temperature due to
was not performed with calorimetric room concept as surface temperature and solar radiation in a room was then
MoWiTT. The inside condition in the tested room was not determined using the measured operative and measured air
controlled. The data were instantaneous collected and then temperature with the air velocity of 0.15 m/s by using the
calculated to obtain the heat gain by using mathematical relation given in ISO 7730 [3]. The mean radiant
model. The experimental results from Morya [16] were temperature due to surface temperature for this case was
expected to have less accuracy when compared to the results assumed to be equal to air temperature. The data are given in
from MoWiTT. The measured results chosen for this study Table 1. Then the mean radiant temperature due to surface
which done on different days are the heat gain per unit area temperature and solar radiation (Tsmrt) is then calculated by
through a 6 mm clear glass window and through a 6 mm using the relation in Eq. (4) setting the air velocity as 0.15 m/
tinted glass window. The simulated results under same s, and the projected area factor as 0.3. The simulated results
operating condition and using same mathematical model for and the experimental results on the mean radiant tempera-
inside and outside surface film coefficient as ones used in the ture are shown in Table 1. The difference in values are within
results obtained from measured data are shown in Fig. 2 with 10% which could be considered acceptable for most general
the measured results. The trend of the heat gain from the experiment. The difference could be come from the
simulated results and the measured results are in the same uncertainty and some error from measurement. With these
pattern. Some discrepancies are found. These discrepancies results of validation, the mathematical models for determin-
are expected to be the effect of error in the measurement as ing glass window performance can be use in this study with
mentioned by Morya [16]. confidence.
4. Design condition
Table 1
Measured room temperature, operative temperature and solar radiation and
mean radiant temperature from measured data and from the simulation
Room Operative Solar MRT from MRT from
temperature temperature radiation operative simulation
(8C) (8C) (W/m2) temperature (8C) (8C)
21.5 30.0 562 38.5 38.05
21.5 31.3 588 41.1 38.76
23.0 31.8 603 40.6 40.43
21.0 30.2 577 39.4 38.04
21.0 31.1 596 41.2 38.57
Fig. 2. Comparison between the heat gain through selective glass windows
21.0 31.5 598 42.0 38.61
from measurement at AIT facility and from the simulation.
730 S. Chaiyapinunt et al. / Energy and Buildings 37 (2005) 725–738
dependent on the outside and inside condition of the bronze glass, reflective gray glass, and reflective green glass.
considered enclosure. For this study, the design outside Double pane glass chosen in this study are composed of
condition is chosen based on 12 years (1988–1999) of outside glass and inside glass which are separated by 6 mm
Bangkok weather data collected by the meteorological air gap. The outside glasses of the double pane glasses
department. The selection is done based on considering chosen in this study are clear glass, bronze glass, gray glass,
the most influencing parameters on the thermal perfor- green glass, reflective clear glass, reflective bronze glass,
mance and thermal comfort of the glass windows and reflective gray glass, reflective green glass, low-e clear glass,
glass windows with films. Such parameter is the solar low-e bronze glass, low-e gray glass, and low-e green glass
radiation. The 0.4% annual cumulative frequency of while the inside glass is a clear glass. The data of spectral
occurrence for global radiation as suggested by ASHRAE properties of the glasses and films chosen are obtained from
[8] is selected. The design outside condition is then the library of program OPTIC 5 [9].
chosen as: The spectral properties of glass and film, the transmit-
tance, absorptance, and reflectance, are the main properties
direct normal solar radiation on glass windows and glass that affect on the thermal performance of glass windows and
windows with films = 658 W/m2; glass windows with films. But since the summation of the
diffuse solar radiation on glass windows and glass three properties (transmittance, absorptance, and reflec-
windows with films = 111 W/m2; tance) is equal to one. One property of glass will affect the
outside air dry bulb temperature = 35 8C; other two (i.e. glass with high transmittance will have low
outside wind velocity = 3.8 m/s. absorptance and reflectance). With the limitation of space
for this article, the transmittance is chosen to be the main
The room that used for the study shall be 4 m 4 m spectral property to represent the characteristics of glass and
and 3 m height with one external wall and three internal film. The detail of the other two spectral properties of glasses
partitions. There shall be glass window or glass window with and films are listed in Ref. [10]. Fig. 3 shows the normal
film installed the whole area of the external wall and facing incidence spectral transmittances of clear glass with
west. The person in this study shall sit turning sideway to the different thickness. Fig. 4 shows the normal incidence
glass window with a distance of 1 m. The typical working spectral transmittances of 6 mm clear and tinted glasses.
condition for office in Bangkok are chosen as design con- Fig. 5 shows the normal incidence spectral properties of
dition. The inside design condition in this study is then 6 mm reflective clear glass. Fig. 6 shows the normal
chosen as: incidence spectral transmittances and reflectances of 6 mm
reflective glasses which illustrated the effect of different
inside air dry bulb temperature = 25 8C; reflective glass types on the spectral transmittances and
inside air velocity = 0.15 m/s; reflectances of the reflective glasses. Fig. 7 shows the normal
relative humidity = 50%; incidence spectral transmittances of some double pane
clothing insulation = 0.5 clo; glasses. Fig. 8 shows the normal incidence spectral
metabolic rate for activity = 1.2 met (1 met = 58 W/m2). properties of double pane low-e glasses. Some nomencla-
tures used in Figs. 4–8 are as the following: CL = clear,
5. Glass and film BR = bronze, GY = gray, GN = green, RCL = reflective
clear, RBR = reflective bronze, RGY = reflective gray,
To accurately analyze the thermal performance of the
glass windows and glass windows with films, one needs to
know the spectral properties of the individual glass and glass
with film. Therefore the data of spectral properties which
varied with the wavelength are required. The solar radiation
shall have spectral range from about 0.38 to 3.5 mm. The
range of wavelength of the solar radiation spectrum can be
divided into the visible range (0.38–0.76 mm) and the
infrared range (0.76–3.5 mm). Different types and thickness
of glass are chosen in this study. They are clear glass, tinted
glass, reflective glass, double pane glass, and low-e glass
(low emittance coated glass, e = 0.04). Clear glass chosen
has different thickness ranged from 2 to 19 mm. Tinted
glasses chosen are bronze glass, gray glass, and green glass.
Reflective glasses are clear and tinted glasses coated with
reflective coating which gave the total reflectance values
around 60% and the total transmittance values less than Fig. 3. The comparison of the normal incidence spectral transmittance of
10%. They are referred as reflective clear glass, reflective clear glass for different thicknesses.
S. Chaiyapinunt et al. / Energy and Buildings 37 (2005) 725–738 731
Fig. 5. The normal incidence of different spectral properties of typical Fig. 7. The normal incidence spectral transmittance of different types of
reflective clear glass of 6 mm thickness. double pane glasses.
732 S. Chaiyapinunt et al. / Energy and Buildings 37 (2005) 725–738
6. Analysis
Fig. 11. The comparison between the heat transmission index values for Fig. 12. The normal incidence spectral transmittance of clear glass adhered
different types of glass windows. with four different types of film.
734 S. Chaiyapinunt et al. / Energy and Buildings 37 (2005) 725–738
Fig. 13. The normal incidence spectral transmittance of bronze glass Fig. 15. The normal incidence spectral transmittance of green glass adhered
adhered with four different types of film. with four different types of film.
that the films adhered; CL = clear glass, BR = bronze glass, The results of heat transmission analysis for glass
GY = gray glass, GN = green glass, C2 = double pane clear windows with films are shown in Figs. 18 and 19. It is found
glass. All glasses adhered with type A film shall have the that the films that applied to the glass windows can reduce
smallest value of the overall spectral transmittance compare relative heat gain values when compared to the bare glass
to glasses adhered with other types of film considered. The window of the same kind. The amount of reduction in heat
spectral transmittance of double clear glass adhered with gain is dependent on the characteristics of film itself. The
films are in the same pattern with single clear glass with lower spectral transmittance the film has, the lower value of
films but have the smaller values. Among the tinted glasses heat gain through the window it shall be.
with films considered the green glass have the highest value Finally all the results obtained are grouped together and
of the transmittance in the visible range. Then, the thermal analyzed to find some relationship between the thermal
comfort index and heat transmission index for glass comfort index and properties of glass window and glass
windows with films can be obtained and some of the results window with film and between the heat transmission index
are shown in Figs. 17–19. Fig. 17 shows the effect of films on and properties of glass window and glass window with film.
the thermal comfort condition by comparing the thermal And to be able to use the results from this study for practical
comfort index of a bare glass with glass window with films. application in glass window thermal performance rating, the
Every film will cause the values of PPD due to surface total optical properties of glass windows are chosen as
temperature to increase and cause the values of PPD due to the representing parameters instead of the spectral proper-
solar radiation to decrease. The amount of PPD values ties. Fig. 20 shows the relationship between the thermal
changed by the film is primary related to the spectral comfort index in the solar part (PPD(solar)) and the total
properties of the film applied. transmittance (sometimes called solar transmittances) of
Fig. 14. The normal incidence spectral transmittance of gray glass adhered Fig. 16. The normal incidence spectral transmittance of double pane clear
with four different types of film. glass adhered with four different types of film.
S. Chaiyapinunt et al. / Energy and Buildings 37 (2005) 725–738 735
Fig. 17. The comparison between the values of the thermal comfort (PPD) of different types of glass windows adhered with films and bare glass windows.
glass windows and glass windows with films in a linear above. One can see that the glass windows and glass
fashion. The relationship can be divided into two groups. windows with films shall give more discomfort condition
The first group is the single pane glasses, single pane glasses due to solar beam striking the occupant when the total
with films, double pane clear glass, and double pane clear transmittance is increasing.
glass with films. The second group is the double pane glasses For another thermal comfort index which is the PPD due
with the outer pane glasses are tinted glasses, reflective to surface temperature (PPD(surface temperature)), its
glasses, and low-e glasses. Therefore the following relation- relationship with the total absorptance of the glass windows
ships between the PPD(solar) and glasses transmittance can and glass windows with films can be shown in Fig. 21. In this
be expressed as the following: case the relationship can be divided into three groups. The
PPDðsolarÞ ¼ 96:807tT 0:6517 (17) first group is the single pane glasses and single pane glasses
with films. The second group is the double pane glasses. The
PPDðsolarÞ ¼ 75:167tT 2:8995 (18) third group is the double pane glasses with films. Therefore
where tT is the total transmittance (solar transmittance) of the relationship between the PPD(surface temperature) and
the glass windows and glass windows with films. glass absorptance can be expressed as the following:
Eq. (17) is applied to the first group of glasses and
Eq. (18) is applied to second group of glasses as mentioned PPDðsurface temperatureÞ ¼ 5:1988 e1:5063AT (19)
Fig. 18. The comparison between the heat transmission index values for different types of glass windows adhered with films and bare glass windows.
736 S. Chaiyapinunt et al. / Energy and Buildings 37 (2005) 725–738
Fig. 19. The comparison between the heat transmission index values for different types of glass windows and double pane glass windows adhered with films and
bare glass windows.
PPDðsurface temperatureÞ ¼ 3:258AT þ 5:4373 (20) windows and glass windows with films under Thailand
design weather condition for the purpose of the performance
PPDðsurface temperatureÞ ¼ 45:284AT 10:119 (21) rating to choose the proper glass windows and glass
where AT is the total absorptance (solar absorptance) of the windows with films in aspect of thermal comfort.
glass windows and glass windows with films. For the heat transmission study, the relationship between
Eq. (19) is applied to the first group of glasses, Eq. (20) is the heat transmission index (relative heat gain) and the
applied to the second group of glasses, and Eq. (21) is properties of the glass windows and glass windows with
applied to the third group of glasses. From Fig. 21, one can films can be obtained and displayed in Figs. 22 and 23.
see that the larger values of the total absorptance of glass Fig. 22 shows the relationship between the relative heat gain
windows chosen the more discomfort condition from the values and the total transmittance of the glass windows and
effect of glass windows surface temperature will be except glass windows with films. Fig. 23 shows the relationship
the bare double pane glass windows. One more interesting between the relative heat gain and the total absorptance of
point is that when applied film to the double pane glass the glass windows and glass windows with films. One can
windows the effect of discomfort due to surface temperature conclude that the heat transmission through the glass
will be increased with the rate higher than the single pane windows and glass windows with films is primarily
glass windows.
With the relationship of thermal comfort index and
properties of glass windows and glass windows with films as
shown in Figs. 20 and 21, one can find the total thermal
comfort index (state of discomfort) for any types of glass
Fig. 20. The relationship between the PPD due to solar radiation and the Fig. 21. The relationship between the PPD due to surface temperature and
total transmittance of glass windows and glass windows with films. the total absorptance of glass windows and glass windows with films.
S. Chaiyapinunt et al. / Energy and Buildings 37 (2005) 725–738 737