Documentos de Académico
Documentos de Profesional
Documentos de Cultura
Kiehl says he's heard all this before: All psychopaths claim they feel
terrible about their crimes for the benefit of the parole board.
"But then you ask them, 'What do you mean, you feel really bad?' And
Brian will look at you and go, 'What do you mean, what does it mean?'
They look at you like, 'Can you give me some help? A hint? Can I call a
friend?' They have no way of really getting at that at all," Kiehl says.
Kiehl says the reason people like Dugan cannot access their emotions
is that their physical brains are different. And he believes he has the
brain scans to prove it.
Brain Scanning In A Mobile MRI
On a crystal clear June morning at Albuquerque's Youth Diagnostic and
Development Center, juveniles who have been convicted of violent
offenses march by, craning their necks as a huge trailer drives through
the gates. This is Kiehl's prize a $2 million mobile MRI provided by
the Mind Research Network at the University of New Mexico. Kiehl
transports the mobile MRI to maximum-security prisons around the
state, and over the past few years, he has scanned the brains of more
than 1,100 inmates, about 20 percent of whom are psychopaths.
For ethical reasons, Kiehl could not allow me to watch an inmate's brain
After a few minutes of preparation, researcher Kevin Bache settles into
the brain scanner, where he can look up and see a screen. On the
screen flashes three types of pictures. One kind depicts a moral
violation: He sees several hooded Klansmen setting a cross on fire.
Another type is emotional but morally ambiguous: a car that is on fire
but you don't know why. Another type of photo is neutral: for example,
students standing around a Bunsen burner.
The subjects rate whether the picture is a moral violation on a scale of
1 to 5. Kiehl says most psychopaths do not differ from normal subjects
in the way they rate the photos: Both psychopaths and the average
person rank the KKK with a burning cross as a moral violation. But
there's a key difference: Psychopaths' brains behave differently from
that of a nonpsychopathic person. When a normal person sees a
morally objectionable photo, his limbic system lights up. This is what
Kiehl calls the "emotional circuit," involving the orbital cortex above the
eyes and the amygdala deep in the brain. But Kiehl says when
psychopaths like Dugan see the KKK picture, their emotional circuit
does not engage in the same way.
"We have a lot of data that shows psychopaths do tend to process this
information differently," Kiehl says. "And Brian looked like he was
processing it like the other individuals we've studied with psychopathy."
Kiehl says the emotional circuit may be what stops a person from
breaking into that house or killing that girl. But in psychopaths like
Dugan, the brakes don't work. Kiehl says psychopaths are a little like
people with very low IQs who are not fully responsible for their actions.
The courts treat people with low IQs differently. For example, they can't
get the death penalty.
"What if I told you that a psychopath has an emotional IQ that's like a 5year-old?" Kiehl asks. "Well, if that was the case, we'd make the same
argument for individuals with low emotional IQ that maybe they're
not as deserving of punishment, not as deserving of culpability, etc."
i