CARPER LAD Form No.

70-B
Republic of the Philippines
DEPARTMENT OF AGRARIAN REFORM
Province of Masbate
Region No. V

FIELD VALIDATION REPORT FOR EXISTING COLLECTIVE CLOA (CCLOA)

Date of Actual Field Investigation :

Barangay : Matagbac
City/Municipality : Milagros
Province : Masbate

A. COLLECTIVE CLOA HOLDER

1. Name of Registered/Cooperative/Association/Organization:

Name of ARB in the

Address Present Status Remarks
existing CCLOA (i.e. Actual
tiller/occupant
farmworker, deceased,
transfer action)
VICENTE PERALTA Sitio Aguilar, Matagbac, Actual Tiller
MORENO Masbate
ROLANDO ESPAÑOL Sitio Aguilar, Matagbac, Actual Tiller
ALMOGUERA Masbate
ANATALIO ROCEL Sitio Aguilar, Matagbac, Actual Tiller
ARINGALO Masbate

ALLAN FRANCISCO Matagbac, Milagros, Actual Tiller

DACDAC Masbate
DOMINADOR TOLEDO Sitio Aguilar, Matagbac, Actual Tiller
DACDAC Masbate
MARIETA VERDIDA Sitio Aguilar, Matagbac, _____
DACDAC Masbate
MARKLESTER VERDIDA Sitio Aguilar, Matagbac, Actual Tiller
DACDAC Masbate
MARLYN MARANGI Sitio Aguilar, Matagbac, Actual Tiller
DACDAC Masbate
WILFREDO BILIORENTE Sitio Aguilar, Matagbac, Actual Tiller
DACDAC Masbate
DANTE ALBAÑO DEJUMO
Sitio Aguilar, Matagbac, Actual Tiller
Masbate
LOURDES REBADOMIA Sitio Aguilar, Matagbac, Actual Tiller
FAJARDO Masbate
LUVIMIN REBADOMIA Sitio Aguilar, Matagbac, Actual Tiller
FAJARDO Masbate
REYNALDO REBADOMIA Matagbac, Milagros, Actual Tiller
FAJARDO Masbate
VIVIAN REBADOMIA Matagbac, Milagros, Actual Tiller
FAJARDO Masbate
ANTONIO RIVERA Matagbac, Milagros, Actual Tiller
FRANCISCO Masbate
JESSIE ROSALES Sitio Aguilar, Matagbac, __________
Page 1 of 5
 CARPER LAD Form No. 70-B
FRANCISCO Masbate
JOSEPH ROSALES Sitio Aguilar, Matagbac, Actual Tiller
FRANCISCO Masbate
JUNREY FLORES Matagbac, Milagros, Actual Tiller
FRANCISCO Masbate
ROLITO RIVERA Matagbac, Milagros, Actual Tiller
FRANCISCO Masbate
SOMBING RIVERA Matagbac, Milagros, Actual Tiller
FRANCISCO Masbate
JUAN TOLEDO GARGANTA
Sitio Aguilar, Matagbac, Actual Tiller
Masbate
AGUSTIN RODRIGO GOMEZ
Sitio Aguilar, Matagbac, __________
Masbate
ALEJANDRO RODRIGO Sitio Aguilar, Matagbac, Actual Tiller
GOMEZ, JR. Masbate
ANALYN RICO GOMEZ
Sitio Aguilar, Matagbac, Actual Tiller
Masbate
JUANITO RODRIGO GOMEZ
Sitio Aguilar, Matagbac, Actual Tiller
Masbate
NIÑO RICO GOMEZ
Sitio Aguilar, Matagbac, Actual Tiller
Masbate
ZOSIMO RODRIGO GOMEZ
Sitio Aguilar, Matagbac, Actual Tiller
Masbate
FEDERICO DACDAC Sitio Aguilar, Matagbac, Actual Tiller
IRENEA Masbate
CAMAL MONTEALEGRE Sitio Aguilar, Matagbac, __________
MARANGI Masbate
TERESITA VASCO Sitio Aguilar, Matagbac, ___________
MARANGI Masbate
EDWIN DACDAC San Ramon, Matagbac, Actual Tiller
MONTEALEGRE Masbate
SANNY ALOTAYA Sitio Aguilar, Matagbac, Actual Tiller
MONTEALGRE Masbate
RENE GOMEZ MORENO
Sitio Aguilar, Matagbac, Actual Tiller
Masbate
LUCIANO CORARATON Sitio Aguilar, Matagbac, __________
NEPA Masbate

Matagbac, Milagros ____________

DARIO FRANCISCO RICO
Masbate
Sitio Aguilar, Matagbac, Actual Tiller
ERNESTO DACDAC RICO
Masbate
Matagbac, Milagros Actual Tiller
FRANCO FRANCISCO RICO
Masbate
Matagbac, Milagros Actual Tiller
GABRIEL DACDAC RICO
Masbate
RENANTE FRANCISCO Sitio Aguilar, Matagbac, ___________
RICO Masbate
Sitio Aguilar, Matagbac, Deceased/Actual Tiller
JUAN SALVADOR RIVERA
Masbate
Sitio Aguilar, Matagbac, Actual Tiller
ROSENDO SONET RIVERA
Masbate
Sitio Aguilar, Matagbac, Actual Tiller
VILMA BONGOT RIVERA
Masbate
Sitio Aguilar, Matagbac, Actual Tiller
ROLITO CAIRO ROCIA
Masbate
GREGORIO CASENILLO Sitio Aguilar, Matagbac, Actual Tiller
TOÑACAO Masbate
Sitio Aguilar, Matagbac, Actual Tiller
DIMPLE PILAPIL VERDIDA
Masbate
Page 2 of 5
 CARPER LAD Form No. 70-B
WILLIAM MORALES Sitio Aguilar, Matagbac, Actual Tiller
VERDIDA Masbate
ZACARIAS MORALES Matagbac, Milagros, Actual Tiller
VERDIDA Masbate
XX NOTHING FOLLOWS XX

2. Total Number of ARBs :

B. DESCRIPTION OF COLLECTIVE CLOA

CLOA TCT or Date Date Date Lot Survey

Total Area Location of
No. OCT Generated Registered Issued No. No. Property
(has.)
No.
00272252 CLOA T- December 17, December 23, December 4840-F Psd-05- 156.5508 Matagbac,
1530 1996 1996 17, 1996 19946(AR) Milagros, Masbate
(Use additional sheets if necessary)

C. DESCRIPTION OF LAND

1. Topography Area (has)

/ below 18% slope

/ 18% slope and above

2. Present Physical Status of Land

_ _/ Presently being cultivated
/ Presently idle
/ Has never been cultivated
/ Agricultural in nature

3. Type of Farm
/ Commercial Farm (Plantations planted to high value crops like Cavendish banana, pineapple,
rubber, oil palm, citrus, papaya, sugarcane, etc.)
/ Regular Farms or other than Commercial

4. Accessibility to/Availability of (Check appropriate box)

● Transportation
/ Bus / Boat/Banca / Others (specify)
/ Jeep / Tricycle

Motorcycle

● Road (appropriate distance)

Page 3 of 5
 CARPER LAD Form No. 70-B
/ National Road kms. / Provincial Road kms.
/ Municipal Road kms. / Barangay Road kms.
● Water Supply

/ NIA / Deep Well

/ Canal
/ Others (Specify)

Page 4 of 5
 CARPER LAD Form No. 70-B

D. PERMANENT IMPROVEMENT

1. Permanent Crops

Income Producing/ Non-Income

CROPS Fruit Bearing Producing Non-
Fruit Bearing
Quantity Ave. Age Quantity Ave. Age.

Source/s of above information :

2. Common-Service Facilities

Introdu
Estimated ced
Present By/Fun
TYPE Size/Capacity/Length Remaining
Condition ded By
Useful Life _______
(yrs) __

Source/s of Information

3. Common Use Areas

Introdu
Estimated ced
Present By/Fun
TYPE Size/Capacity/Length Remaining
Condition ded By
Useful Life _______
(yrs) __

E. PRODUCTION AND INCOME

1. Production Data

No. of Ave. Production

No. of Crop
Months Per Per Crop Cycle
Producti Cycle Per Year
Crops/Trees Planted Crop Per or Years Per
ve Area or Per Harvest
Cycle or Ha. Or Per
(Has.) (e.g.
Years Per Harvest of
commercial Trees Per
Harvest of
trees) Tre Ha.1
es

AGP = Total Production / no. of months in 1 complete cycle x 12 months

a. For crops with less than one (1) cropping season or production cycle, the formula shall be:

Page 5 of 5
 CARPER LAD Form No. 70-B
AGP = TP1 + TP2 + . . . .TPn / no. of months in 1 complete cycle x 12 months
Where: TP1 = Total Actual Production for the 1st crop cycle
TP2 = Total Actual Production for the 2nd crop cycle
TP3 = Total Actual Production for the 3rd crop cycle

2. Net Income Data

Annual Total Value Cost of Net

Crop/Trees Planted Gross Selling Price in Pesos Per Production Income
Producti Per Unit Hectare or Per Hectare Per
on Per (Farmgate)\ Per or Per Hectare
Hectare a Production Production or
Unit Unit Producti
\ on
b Unit
\c

a. The average of the latest available 12-months selling price

b. Refer to cash value of average gross production times the selling (farm gate) per hectare or per production unit (i.e., kilogram, can,
etc)
c. Refers to farm income only

3. Other Income Specify, if any

Remarks (Source of Information)

F. OTHER LIENS/ENCUMBRANCES ANNOTATED IN THE CLOA

G. MEANS OF COMMUNICATION (Please check the appropriate box. If more than one (1) means of
communication, check all appropriate boxes.)
☐ Radio, specify station:
☐ Television (TV), specify channel:
☐ Newspaper, specify name:
☐ Social Media, specify platform:

Community Leaders as source of relevant information. (Please specify three (3) names, position/nature
of work, address, and contact number.)

Name Position/ Address Contact Number,

Nature of Work if any
1.
2.
3.

Page 6 of 5
 CARPER LAD Form No. 70-B
H. REMARKS/COMMENTS/RECOMMENDATION

Upon field validation, only the following ARBs were present namely; Rolando Almoguera,
Antonio Francisco, Jessie Francisco, Lito Francisco, Sombing Francisco, Juanito Gomez, Camal
Marangi, Luciano Nepa, Renante Rico, Rolito Rocia, Joseph Francisco. The other ARBs were absent
despite due notice.
During the said validation, the FVT found out that some names in the CCLOA were
mispelled. CCLOA ARB Sombing Rivera Francisco real name was Zombing Rivera Francisco as
reflected in his Voter’s ID. A photocopy of his Voter’s ID is hereby attached.

The FVT concerned took notice that this landholding is subject for redocumentation and that
some of the ARB’s that were already reported was not touched by the said FVT. Moreover, ARBs
with a reported status came to the consultation meeting just to verify their status. Antonio Francisco,
Juanito Gomez, Rolito Rocia and Sombing Francisco were on a reported status. Rolando Almoguera,
Jessie Francisco, Lito Francisco, Camal Marangi, Luciano Nepa, Renante Rico and Joseph Francisco
are ARBs named in the CCLOA. This CCLOA is subject for individual titling

I. CERTIFICATION

We hereby certify that the true information and data contained in this report are based on ocular
inspection of the land covered by existing collective CLOA and that the same are true and correct to the
best of our knowledge.

JOHN MARK M. MASAMOC

FVT Team Leader/Coordinator Date
(Signature over Printed Name)

OMEGA C. AGARAP
Municipal Agrarian Reform Program Officer/ Date
Designated Personnel
(Signature over Printed Name)

Copy Distribution:

Page 7 of 5
 CARPER LAD Form No. 70-B
Original - DARPO
Duplicate - MARO/Designated Personnel
Triplicate - Field Validation Team

I, ORESTES L. MOTITA Jr., of legal age, Filipino and a resident of Barangay Poblacion District No. 2, Mobo,
Masbate, after having been duly sworn in accordance with law hereby depose and say, that:

1. I am the accused in the above-entitled case.

2. On February 24, 2023, I have received an Order from this Honorable Court to submit may Counter- affidavit
and affidavits of my witnesses as well as any evidence in my behalf not later than ten (10) days from receipt
of the said order. Thus, I have until March 6, 2023 within which to file the same.

3. I vehemently deny all the allegations contained in the affidavit-complaint of Imelda L. Motita and her
witnesses, the truth of the matter are as follows.

4. On the early morning of December 17, 2022, I was suddenly awakened by the noise coming from a
neighboring house. It was then to my surprise that some of my furniture that I stored in complainant’s house
(chairs and tables) were intentionally destroyed by the complainant. The reason that I kept my furniture in the
latter’s house is that I intend to set a boundary between the two of us because the land where the complainant
build her house is still subject to partition as it was the land that our late mother and father left for us.

5. I intend to pacify the situation but my efforts proved futile. While continuing the destruction of the furniture I
stored, the complainant continued shouting and uttering defamatory words that prompted me to grab a piece
of wood and start smashing their wooden walls

6. Contrary to the allegations of the complainant and her witness, it was not my deliberate intent to cause
damage upon the complainant’s door or any wooden walls or remove the steel mathing cover of the
complainant’s store. The complainant’s uttered words and expressions that completely degraded my
reputation and the fact that I saw her intentionally destroying my furniture prompted me to do so.

7. The lot where the complainant built her house was still subject to partition as it was inherited by us, 11
siblings from our late parents. The respondent and the complainant in this case are brother and sister.

8. As alleged by the complainant in her complaint-affidavit, that the respondent committed an act that will
justify as a malicious michief penalized under the Revised Penal Code does not hold water. The crime of
malicious mischief under the Revised Penal Code has the following elements;

a. That the offender deliberately caused damage to the property of another,

b. That such act does not constitute arson or other crimes involving destruction,
c. That the act of damaging another’s property be committed merely for the sake of damaging it.

The essential element of “deliberately causing damage to the property of another” to justify the crime of
malicious mischief which is punishable under the Revised Penal Code is lacking. The respondent did not intent to
deliberate cause to damage to the property of the complainant, it was on his sudden impulse that he did so
because the respondent saw the complainant destroying his chairs and tables first. The respondent does not have
the specific desire to cause damage to the property.

9. Even assuming but without conceding, that the respondent is probably guilty of the offense of malicious
mischief under the Revised Penal Code, still the complaint is dismissible on its face because of its
insufficiency. The complaint to be sufficient among others must state the designation of the offense given by
the statute and the act or omissions complained of as constituting the offense. The complaint stated Article
Page 8 of 5
 CARPER LAD Form No. 70-B
328 of Revised Penal Code called Special cases of malicious mischief, such was not the allegation embodied
in complaint that will constitute the offense.

10. The complaint-affidavit does not also show the basis for them to declare the amount of the wooden wall, a
single wooden door, and the steel mathing cover of the store to be worth
P 30, 000. The respondent doubt that it is not worth that amount considering that it was only a piece of thin
ply wood that consist the wall and the single door and as to the steel mathing cover of the store, it was a used
metal wielded for such purpose. The amount of damages alleged are exorbitant considering the materials
involved.

11.

Page 9 of 5