Documentos de Académico
Documentos de Profesional
Documentos de Cultura
141 - 2011
ORIGINAL
ANLISIS DE LA INGESTA ENERGTICA Y NUTRICIONAL DE JUGADORES DE DIFERENTES POSICIONES EN UN EQUIPO DE FUTBOL
Volumen XXVIII
Nmero 141
2011
Pgs. 29-35
CORRESPONDENCIA:
Jos M. Soriano
Av. Vicent Andrs Estells s/n, 46100 Burjassot, Spain
E-mail: jose.soriano@uv.es
29
AMD
ARCHIVOS DE MEDICINA DEL DEPORTE
CONEJOS, C
et al.
30
AMD
VOLUMEN XXVIII - N. 141 - 2011
TABLE 1.
Forwards Midfielders Defenders Goalkeepers Mean values and
standard deviations
Energy of the energy,
macronutrients,
Per day (MJ day-1) 12.72.9 14.06.2 14.82.6 12.24.6 fibre and of profile
of fat intake of
kJ/kg body weight 193.626.5 200.332.1 213.115.8 80.231.5 the studied young
soccer players
Protein
Per day (g) 138.727.5 144.856.9 144.519.9 142.8100.1
Energy ratio (%) 18.4 17.8 16.9 17.9
Fat (g)
Per day (g) 120.359.6 131.662.6 124.536.1 109.845.3
Energy ratio (%) 34.7 35.6 32.2 34.9
Carbohydrate
Per day (g) 342.592.9 382.1187.2 419.198.3 320.311.9
Energy ratio (%) 45.7 44.8 48.4 44.2
Dietary fibre (g) 16.36.0a 24.717.5 27.23.4a 21.813.1
MUFA (g)
Per day (g day-1) 36.024.9 53.024.9 50.318.5 42.714.9
Energy ratio (%) 10.7 14.4 13.1 13.7
PUFA (g)
Per day (g day-1) 28.621.4 19.56.4 22.66.0 23.016.5
Energy ratio (%) 8.1 5.5 5.9 6.9
SFA (g)
Per day (g day-1) 41.219.4 47.928.2 40.416.9 33.212.0
Energy ratio (%) 11.9 12.7 10.5 10.8
PUFA/SFA 0.7 0.4 0.6 0.6
(PUFA+MUFA)/SFA 1.6 1.6 1.9 1.9
Cholesterol (mg) 363.0 183.1 383.9209.6 450.5248.9 223.0131.6
a
p<0.005 for differences between forwards and defenders
31
AMD
ARCHIVOS DE MEDICINA DEL DEPORTE
CONEJOS, C
et al.
TABLE 2.
Mean values and Forwards Midfielders Defenders Goalkeepers
standard deviations
of vitamin and
mineral intakes of Thiamin (mg) 2.10.4 3.11.4 2.40.8 2.91.9
the studied young
soccer players
Riboflavin (mg) 2.70.9 2.80.8 2.90.9 2.82.0
according to their
playing positions
Niacin (mg) 51.310.3 53.321.1 58.212.8 51.343.8
Panthotenic ac. (mg) 7.32.2 7.03.9 7.31.7 8.58.0
Vitamin B6 (mg) 2.90.5 3.41.8 3.60.9 3.82.4
Biotin (g) 54.635.4 32.325.5 39.119.4 71.756.8
Folate (g) 250.065.7a 345.7213.3 390.727.9a 448.7276.5
Vitamin B12 (g) 4.12.4 7.24.1 7.63.1 6.13.3
Vitamin C (mg) 63.830.1a 85.159.9 b
162.244.0 a,b
185.5121.6
Vitamin A (g) 517.5126.2 1245.3669.7 1488.6827.2 1864.7900.5
Vitamin D (g) 5.64.9 15.512.7 14.96.1 15.410.2
Vitamin E (mg) 24.611.6 19.25.8 20.46.5 30.424.7
Vitamin K (g) 50.631.5 182.0142.8 144.459.4 163.7119.3
Sodium (mg) 3492.01556.2 4745.81872.5 3556.51295.7 4085.72498.3
Potassium (mg) 3352.0368.7a 4501.02023.7 4582.0425.5a 4970.72467.9
Calcium (mg) 1361.5549.0 1592.3996.1 1208.4457.1 1499.71035.9
Magnesium (mg) 477.5183.4 429.6242.7 437.572.7 484.0301.2
Phosphorus (mg) 1822.2395.8 2497.31040.2 2304.6371.9 2482.71993.9
Iron (mg) 13.43.7 18.99.7 22.66.8 15.510.2
Zinc (mg) 11.13.1 15.65.9 14.53.8 13.510.9
Selenium (g) 51.316.4 99.677.6 118.358.8 126.2115.3
Iodine (g) 109.954.6 113.773.8 106.127.1 100.598.1
a
p<0.005for differences between forwards and defenders; bp<0.005 for differences between midfielders and defenders
32
AMD
VOLUMEN XXVIII - N. 141 - 2011
Inocencio da Silva Gomes, et al.8 reflected these moderate training, rising to about 10 g kg-1 du-
values in defenders and midfielders, respectively. ring intense training or match play. Our study
Ruiz, et al.15 found a value of energy intake per ki- is carried out in intense training being the intake
logram of body mass for young soccer (228.4 kJ of carbohydrates lower than the suggestion of
kg-1) higher than old player (171.5 kJ kg-1). Rico- FIFA/F-MARC Consensus Conference9. Accor-
Sanz10 suggest that energy expenditure for males ding to our values (Table 1), several studies15,29
soccer players should be about 16.7 and 15.9 MJ reflected a deficiency in dietary fibre intake,
day-1 on training days and on match day, respec- except in the study of Iglesias-Gutierrez, et al.20
tively, in contrast Maughan and Burke16 ranged which obtained a higher fibre intake (24 g day-1).
this value from 8.5 and 17 MJ in soccer players
during training periods needs. Our results (Table Villegas and Zamora (1991)13 suggested for total
1) on training days show that is less than the fat, 30% of daily energy intake including 10%
Rico-Sanzs value but is situated in the range of saturated fatty acids (SFA), 20% of monoun-
of Maughan and Burke16. Recently, the FIFA/F- saturated fatty acids (MUFA) and 5% of polyun-
MARC Consensus Conference9 indicated that saturated fatty acids (PUFA). Fat in our study
the typical energy costs of training or match-play (Table 1) shows higher than this value, being one
in elite men players are about 6 MJ. of the most important negative factors related to
performance7. Iglesias-Gutierrez, et al.20 obtained
Lemon 17 suggests protein intake should be 38% of total energy intake for fat, but a lower value
around 1.4-1.7 g kg-1 day-1 and, recently, the of SFA (9%) in comparison with our date (Table
study of Boisseau, et al.18 reflected an estimated 1). Clark22 suggested consuming less than 30% of
average requirement of 1.2 g kg-1 day-1 and a re- total fat for soccer players for training diet. In our
commended daily allowance of 1.4 g kg-1 day-1 of study, all soccer players consumed an excess of
soccer players aged 14 years being these values fat being the highest value obtained in midfielders
below that our studied protein intake (Table 1). in contrast with defenders (Table 1). Our sugges-
Several authors15,19-21 obtained, for protein, a 15, tion is recommended the PUFA/SFA ratio higher
15.2, 14.4 and 16%, respectively, of daily energy than 0.5 and the (PUFA+MUFA)/SFA ratio
intake for soccer players. Clark22 clarified that the should be >2. In our study (Table 1), this idea of
training diet should be comprised of 12-15% of PUFA/SFA is reflected in forwards, defenders and
daily energy intake but in match-play, the oxida- goalkeepers. According to current Spanish gui-
tion of proteins contributes less than 10% of the delines30, the fat quality of the diet, judging from
total energy production, according to Bangsbo23, the (PUFA+MUFA)/SFA ratio, was satisfactory
Lemon17 and Escanero, et al.24. (recommended:> 2). Because fat quality was
acceptable, the diet of this soccer players could be
Literature15,25-27 reflects that diets of soccer pla- improved by only a small reduction in fat intake
yers with low carbohydrate content have made a and enhancing the carbohydrate rich food. For the
great impact on performance during a competi- cholesterol, forwards, midfielders and defenders
tion since players with depleted muscle glycogen (Table 1) exceed the value of 300 mg/day.
stored have lower average speed and cover less
distance during the second half of the match. In our micronutrient intake assessment (Table
Schokman, et al.28 suggest that carbohydrate 2), most of the analyzed nutrients were ingested
recommendations for soccer players are more in adequate amounts, which are sixteen out of
appropriately expressed as g kg-1 rather than a twenty-two micronutrients examined. The lowest
percentage of total energy intake. According to intake of vitamin A and K are established in
the FIFA/F-MARC Consensus Conference9 and forwards (Table 2). Vitamin A is an antioxidant
the American Dietetic Association/Dietitians of nutrient important in protecting the cell mem-
Canada/American College of Sports Medicine12, branes from oxidative damage. Furthermore, the
the soccer players require 5-7 g of carbohydrate folate intake (Table 2) is below in for forwards,
per kilogram of body mass during periods of midfielders and defenders. According to our
33
AMD
ARCHIVOS DE MEDICINA DEL DEPORTE
CONEJOS, C
et al.
B I B L I O G R A P H Y
1. Reilly T, Bangsbo J, Franks A . Anthropometric 5. Wisloff A, Helgerud J, Hoff J. Strength and endurance of
and physiological predispositions for elite soccer. elite soccer players. Med Sci Sport Exer 1998;30:462-7.
J Sport Sci 2000;18:669-683.
6. Cometti G, Maffiuletti NA , Pousson M, Chatard
2. Stolen T, Chamari K , Castagna C, Wisloff U. JC, Maffulli N. Isokinetic strength and anaero-
Physiology of soccer-an update. Sports Med bic power of elite, subelite and amateur soccer
2005;35:501-536. players. Int J Sports Med 2001;22:45-51.
3. Bangsbo J, Norregaard L, Thorsoe F. Activity 7. Gil SM, Gil J, Ruiz F, Irazusta A , Irazusta J.
profile of competition soccer. Can J Sport Sci Physiological and anthropometric characteristics
1991;16:110-116. of young soccer players according to their playing
position: Relevance for the selection process. J
4. Di Salvo V, Baron R, Tschan H, Calderon Montero Strength Cond Res 2007;21:438-445.
FJ, Bachl N, Pigozzi F. Performance characteristics
according to playing position in elite soccer. Int 8. Innocencio da Silva Gomes A, Gonalves Ribeiro
J Sports Med 2007;28:222-7. B, de Abreu Soares E. Nutritional profile of the
34
AMD
VOLUMEN XXVIII - N. 141 - 2011
17. Lemon P W. Protein requirements of soccer. J 30. Aranceta J, Serra-Majem Ll. Estructura general
Sport Sci 1994;12:S17-S22. de las guas alimentarias para la poblacin es-
paola. Declogo para una dieta saludable. En:
18. Boisseau N, Vermorel M, Rance M, Duch P, Sociedad Espaola de Nutricin Comunitaria.
Patureau-Mirand P. Protein requirements in male Guas alimentarias para la poblacin espaola.
adolescent soccer players. Eur J Appl Physiol Madrid: IM&C, 2001;183-194.
2007;100:27-33.
31. de Sousa EF, Da Costa TH, Nogueira JA, Vivaldi
19. Ebert TR . Nutrition for the Australian Rules LJ. Assessment of nutrient and water intake among
football player. J Sci Med Sport 2000; 3: 369-382. adolescents from sports federations in the Federal
District, Brazil. Brit J Nutr 2008;99:1275-1283.
20. Iglesias-Gutirrez E, Garca-Rves P, Rodrguez
C, Braga S, Garca-Zapico P, Patterson AM. Food 32. C o n e j o s C , G i n e r A , M a e s J, S o r i a n o J M .
habits and nutritional status assessment of ado- Dietary intake of nutrients of great interest in
lescent soccer players. A necessary and accurate inmunonutrition to prevent muscle damage in
approach. Can J Appl Physiol 2005;30:18-32. soccer players. P Nutr Soc 2008;67:E33.
35
AMD