Documentos de Académico
Documentos de Profesional
Documentos de Cultura
Nueva Defensa Posesoria Extrajudicial
Nueva Defensa Posesoria Extrajudicial
kid
F2+
MM
lll
ĎDĆĊ
C
ÀÅĆC
Ǽ
/F=D?K:G<BL<HI:SF :NKR ol
Â
?_ld^al mlo i^ Skfsbopfa^a ab Jfj^,
ǼÉ I Į Ĕ Ĵ É Ē Ĕ Ę Ĕ I Ĭ É ÓĨ Í Ĭ Ĕ Ĭ Í Ī Ĝ É Ô ĔĶİĪÉĢĮĒĜËĜÉĤ 11/
=% =BHFC8I77=xB a^a'abi^pfks^pflkbp*nrbqo^bk`ljÑkjbkqb
i^ corpqo^`fÉk &l ^i jbklp* i^ o^ibkqfw^`fÉk' ab
J^fkqbk`fÉkabimobpbkqb^oqÅ`rilbpa^ork^_ob+ ilpmolvb`qlpfkjl_fif^oflp,
sblmfkfÉkobpmb`ql^i^ob`fbkqbjbkqbjlafcf`^+
a^fkpqfqr`fÉkabi^abcbkp^mlpbplof^bkkrbpqol Aljlbpp^_fal* jbaf^kqb i^p fks^pflkbp *mbo+
m^Åp*vpfÄpq^+j ~p^ii~abprqÄ`kf`^ibdfpi^qfs^+ plk^pnrbklabqbkq^kkfkdÑkabob`elabmlpb+
`rjmib`lki^cfk^ifa^anrb*bkqbkabjlp*pbe^ pfÉkobpmb`ql^rkqboobklabqbojfk^alm^p^k^
bk`lkqo^alabqo~p ab i^ jlqfs^`fÉk abi ibdfpi^+ l`rm^oilpfk^kqbpe^_bo^anrfofalbiabob`elab
alo8 c^`fifq^o i^ &^ab`r^a^ vsbilw' molqb``fÉk ^ molmfba^al^idÑklqolabob`elnrbibpc^`riqb
i^pfksbopflkbpfkjl_fif^of^pabkrbpqolm^Åp,Ck ^ mlpbboil, Ck sfoqra ab bpq^ abp^cloqrk^a^ pf+
bpb loabk ab fab^p* bk i^p iÅkb^p pfdrfbkqbp kl qr^`fÉk*ve^`fbkalrk_obsbobm^plmlokrbpqol
abp^oolii^objlpbkmolcrkafa^ail`lk`bokfbkqb AÉafdlAfsfi &^kqbpabi^obcbofa^ jlafcf`^qlof^'*
^ i^ k^qro^ibw^groÅaf`^ kf abp^ooliil`lk`bmqr^i i^ ibdfpi^`fÉk bk j^qbof^ `fsfi qo^af`flk^ijbkqb
abbibjbkqlpq^ibp`ljli^mlpbpfÉk*abob`el^ e^obdri^ali^ppfdrfbkqbpcfdro^p8
i^ molmfba^a kf^i ^k~ifpfpabi `ljmibgl jrkal
KZk^hiV ZY^iVYV edg Vajbcdh YZ aV ?VXjaiVY YZ =ZgZX]d YZ aV Nc^kZgh^YVY YZ E^bV
E^bV4Idci^[^XVNc^kZgh^YVY<Viwa^XVYZaIZgx?dcYd>Y^idg^Va&,**.&ee(1-2'1-3(LdWgZZaeVgi^XjaVg&XdbeVgi^bdh
:=OH <:MNL
110 J r f p D o ^ k ` f p ` l N ^ w K ^ r o v - P f ` ^ o a l A ~ k b m ^ A ^ p f i i ^ p
nrb bi ^`qlo morb_b qbkbo rk qÅqril s~ifal nrb _^pb il jbk`flk^al bk bi krjbo^i 0 ^kqboflo, Ů Õ
ib mbojfq^bpq^obk mlpbpfÉkabi _fbk nrbab_^ Qrmlkd^jlp nrb bk bpb `^pl* @ iibd^ ^i fk+ +++
mobcbofopbcobkqb^i fks^plo lmlpbbalomob`^ofl* jrb_ib `lk i^ bumb`q^qfs^ abbgbo`bopl_ob Äi iiii
K +F
lcobkqb^`r^inrfboqbo`bolnrbqbkd^ rkqÅqril bi abob`el ab rpl nrb ? ib e^_Å^ lqlod^al A??
mlpbploflnrbobpriqb fklmlkf_ib^i ^``flk^kqb, bk sfoqr a abi ^oobka^j fbkql `bib_o^al bkqob ÍÍÍ
ee
Skbgbjmilabbiilmrbabpbonrb ? *molmfbq^ofl biilp, Qfk bj_^odl* bk sbw ab fkqbomlkbo rk^
ĎDĆĊ
abi_fbk*`bib_o^rk`lkqo^qlab^oobka^jfbkql^ ^``fÉk mlpbplof^* @ p^`^ mloi^psÅ^pabc^`ql C
ÀÅĆC
Ǽ
J^! k r b s ^ ! a b c b k p ^ ! í m l p b p l o f ^ ì! b u q o ^ g r a f ` f ^ i ! 111
Sklab ilpdo^kabp mol_ibj^p o^af`^_^ bk fk+ Aljlv^^abi^kq^jlp*bi m^nrbqbab jbafa^p
qbomobq^onrÄab_Å^bkqbkabopbmloi^^`lq^`fÉk j lafcf`É bi ^oqÅ`ril 70. abi AÉafdl Afsfi nrb
pfk fkqbos^ilabqfbjml , obdri^ i^ abcbkp^ mlpbplof^ buqo^graf`f^i, Ck
bcb`ql*bi^oqÅ`ril45abi^Jbv1.01.obdriÉnrb8
Qfqlj~_^jlprk^buqobj^ifqbo^ifa^aabi^klo+
j^pbmobpbkq^_^k^idrklpmol_ibj^p*`ljlmlo Ff[`]`ZXj\!\c!XikxZlcf! 4-+![\c!<z[`^f! <`m`c'
ĔĢĔĦĨĤÍ ÏĮĔ ĔĤ ÉËİÍĪ ĒĔĬĨÍĢÉĒÍ ĒĔ ĤÉ ĨÍĬĔĬĜÎI ÈĤ Ģ ËĤ ÍĠ Ê Đ Ğ ÎĖĒ Ï ĖÊ Ģ ĨÊ ĨÊİĨĤĽ
klmlaÅ^kfpfnrfbo^_rp`^obi^rufiflabi^Nlif`Å^ =\]\ejX!gfj\jfi`X!\okiXal[`Z`Xc
mrbp*^i jljbkqlab^`rafo^ i^ `ljfp^oÅ^ j~p :ikxZlcf!4-+)(
`bo`^k^* v^ e^_Å^ qo^kp`roofal rk `ek\imXcf![\
k`\dgf vv^klmlaÅ^obmbiboi^crbow^bjmib^a^ >c!gfj\\[fi!gl\[\! i\g\c\i!cX! ]l\iqX! hl\!j\
^kqbÄi,Cp^ ifqbo^ifa^al_ifd^oÅ^ ^i^`qlo^ jlofo \dgc\\! ZfekiX! wc! f! \c! Y`\e!p !i\ZfYiXicf'! j`
bk bi fkqbkql l*ab il`lkqo^ofl*ab_Å^ fkf`f^ork ]l\i\![\jgfj\x[f)!EX!XZZ`ze!j\!i\Xc`qX![\ekif
mol`bplgraf`f^i &pb^ rk mol`bplabfkqboaf`qll [\!cfj!hl`eZ\!$,0%![xXj!j`^l`\ek\j!X!hl\!kfd\
`r^inrfbo^^inrbqrsfbo^abob`el^fkf`f^o'm^o^ ZfefZ`d`\ekf![\!cX![\jgfj\j`ze)!>e!ZlXchl`\i
KZk^hiV ZY^iVYV edg Vajbcdh YZ aV ?VXjaiVY YZ =ZgZX]d YZ aV Nc^kZgh^YVY YZ E^bV
===% GC6F9@5AC8=:=757=xB89@ Ck krbpqo^ lmfkfÉk i^ krbs^ obdri^`fÉk bp* bk
:=OH<:MNL /1.
/( @HGS:E>L ;:KKÜG& @jci]Zg( M i X kX [ f ! [ \ ! [ \ i\ Z _ f j ! i\ X c\ j ) Mdbd B(MZgXZgV ZY^X^wc( E^bV4Cjg^hiV >Y^idgZh& ,*+-&
e(0*3(
112 J r f p D o ^ k ` f p ` l N ^ w K ^ r o v - P f ` ^ o a l A ~ k b m ^ A ^ p f i i ^ p
mbopfdrb bp abpb^_ib bk rk j^o`l abcljbkql abcbkp^mlpbplof^buqo^graf`f^i*^idlnrbmobsfl Ů Õ
^i^fksbopfÉk,Aljlmrkqlabm^oqfa^*ab_bjlp ^ i^ jlafcf`^`fÉk bo^ rk^ c^`riq^a Ñkf`^ b fk+ ĹĹĹ
objlkq^oklp^i^nrb+_ ^ gl krbpqolmrkqlabsfp+ ebobkqb &`ljl pr klj_ob il abg^ bkqobsbo' abi USb
F +) +
q^ +bo^i^mofk`fm^ic^ibk`f^abi`lkqbkfal^kqboflo mlpbbalo,Cpab`fo*bkbi`^plabilp_fbkbpfkjrb+ S?H
abi^kloj^8i^abqbojfk^`fÉkabilnrbpbab_Å^ _ibp*pf rkqboobklbo^ fks^afal*vbimolmfbq^ofl ÍÍÍ
ll
bkqbkabogfi j`e`ek\imXcf[\k`\dgf p'^Ñkpfpb kl pb bk`lkqo^_^ mlpbvbkal bk bpb jljbkql
ĎDĆĊ
bkqbkafbo^ ab j^kbo^ ifqbo^i* nrÄ q^k mlpfqfsl bi_fbkabprmolmfba^a*Äi klmlaÅ^bgbo`bobpqb C
ÀÅĆC
Ǽ
m^o^nrbbimlpbbalomrafbpbbgbo`boi^abcbkp^ bpqÄk^Ñkbkmol`bplabbafcf`^`fÉk,Nlopbkqfal $O
í#H
mlpbplof^ buqo^graf`f^i* i^crbow^ abi qbo`bolab+ `ljÑk*bkqbkabjlpnrbi^iÉdf`^pbdrfa^mloi^ f
,'
j l Z \ [ \ j `j\X g c`Z X cX ]l \ i q X j f Y i\ \ cY `\ e p e f Z f e k i X \ cg f j \ \ [ f i 9$ ) ) ) % : e l \ j ki f Z i `k\ i `f 'j xj \ ixX X g c`Z X Y c\ cX e f i d X \ e
Z f d \ e kf 'g l \ j Z f e j `[ \ i X d f j h l \ cX ] `e X c`[ X [ [ \ cX i k `Z l cX [ f \jg i f k \ ^ \ i [ \ Z l X ch l `\ i k `g f [ \ X Z k f [ `i `^ `[ f X c f ^ i X i l e
_ \ Z _ f Z f e k i X i `f X j l m f cl e k X [ ' h l \ i \ j ki `e aX f X e l c\ j l \ a\ i Z `Z `f Z f d f g f j \ \ [ f i'j `e ` d g f i k X i j `cX ]l \ i q X f X Z k f m `f c\ e k f d
`l
j\X g c`Z X Z f e k i X w cd `j d f f j f Y i\ \ c`e d l \ Y c\ ' cf Z l X ce f `d g `[ \ h l \ \ j kX j Z f e [ l Z kX j j \ X e j X e Z `f e X [ X j g \ e X cd \ e k \
$)))%5
Õ
J ( IVgVedYZgY^[ZgZcX^Vggse^YVbZciZaVYZ[ZchVedhZhdg^VZ_ZgX^YVedgZaegde^ZiVg^dcdedhZZYdg"hZ\jcYdesggV[d
YZaVgiuXjadWV_dVcsa^h^h#YZaVYZ[ZchV edhZhdg^VXash^XV"eg^bZgesggV[dYZaVgiuXjad#&ZhfjZ]ZbdhdeiVYdedg
Ț
YZcdb^cVg "XVh^ axY^XVbZciZ# V aV eg^bZgV [^\jgV =Z[ZchV Igde^ZiVg^V ( Jj^tc hVWZ h^&Xdc VnjYV YZa aZXidg& hZ kO
ad\gVgsVXjvVgZhiZ^bV\^cVi^kditgb^cdZcaVhdX^ZYVY_jguY^XVeZgjVcV(
ǼÉ I Į Ĕ Ĵ É Ē Ĕ Ę Ĕ I Ĭ É Ó Ĩ Í Ĭ Ĕ Ĭ Í Ī Ĝ É Ô Ĕ Ķ İ Ī É Ģ Į Ē Ĝ Ë Ĝ É Ĥ ŦŦÙ
abp jr`e^p sb`bp pb `lkpfabo^_^k ^gbk^p ^ i^ ob^i nrb k^`b ab i^ ibv* abi `lkqo^ql l ab rk
mbqf`fÉk ab^vra^l`li^_lo^`fÉk abi^cb`q^al ^`qlgroÅaf`l rkfi^qbo^i &pb^ çek\i m`mfj f dfik`j
m^o^ abp^ilg^o ^ prp fks^plobp, Alkpfabo^jlp* ZXljX%4'v mloq^kql kl mlaoÅ^ bgbo`bopbq^i ab+
^abj~p* nrb ^ m^oqfo ab ^elo^* `lkq^o `lk i^ ob`el pfk nrb jbafb rk^ ^rqlofw^`fÉk ibd^i l
fkqbosbk`fÉkab i^ Nlif`Å^lmboplk^i abi j rkf+ rk^ j^kfcbpq^`fÉk abslirkq^a abnrfbk lqlo+
`fmfl&mlobgbjmil*`rbomlabipbobk^wdlil`^i' d^pb bpb abob`el, Ll l_pq^kqb* `obbjlp nrb
ĔI İĔÍĪĞÉ ÉĬĔFĮĪÉĪÊ ÏĮĔ ĤÉĬ ĦĔĒĜĒÉĬ ĔĦĨĤĔÉĒÉĬ ĤÉ ĪĔĘĔĪĜĒÉ ĘÉĤİÉ ĒĔ İĖËIĜËÉ ĤĔFĜĬĤÉİĜĴÉ ĬĔ ĬĮĨĤĔ
pb^ko^wlk^_ibp9bpab`fo*sbi^o~kmlonrbbpq^p fkqbomobq^kali^ m^i^_o^ ljl]ilZklXe[f bk rk
klpbbp`^mbklbu`ba^k^ilgrpqfcf`^almloi^p pbkqfalj~pcibuf_ibabi^m^i^_o^9bpqlbp*bkbi
`fo`rkpq^k`f^p, pbkqfalabnrbbimlpbbaloab_bbpq^orp^kal
v-lafpcorq^kalabi _fbk/.,
,( EVhYZhkZciV_VhfjZWg^cYVaV
gZYVXX^wcYZaVcdgbV( Bblqoli^al*^idlnrbklpm^ob`bj~pabif`^al
^Ñkbpnrbbpq^ifjfq^`fÉk^iabob`elabimolmfb+
Lll_pq^kqbnrbi^ cfk^ifa^a abbpq^ jlafcf`^+ q^oflklmlpbbalomrbabmlkbobkmbifdoli^cfk^+
KZk^hiV ZY ^iVY V edg Vajb cdh YZ aV ?VXjaiVY YZ =ZgZX]d YZ aV Nc^kZgh^YVY YZ E^bV
`fÉk^iAÉafdlAfsfibpabpb^_ib*bk`lkqo^jlpbk ifa^ajfpj^abi^kloj^mrbpklobdri^`Éjlbp
prqbuqlrk^pbofbabafcf`riq^abpfkqbomobq^qfs^p* nrbbimlpbbalomob`^ofl// mrbab^`obafq^onrb
i^p`r^ibpbumlkaobjlp^`lkqfkr^`fÉk8 e^ rprcor`qr^al mloaf`elmboÅlalabqfbjml,
0,5, BdgifZ\[\eZ`X [\ cX XZZ`ze ZfekiX Gj^dfkbjlp nrb bi molmfbq^ofl qlj ^ `lkl`f+
hl`\e))) ÑO`\e\ ljl]ilZklXe[f \c Y`\e g fi j fbkql ab i^ fks^pfÉk ab pr mobafl vnrb `lk+
[`\q Xyfj Zfdf gifg`\kXi`f9 sl`^ i^ ^vra^ mlif`f^i/0, ?i iibd^o ^i fkjrb_ib*
`lk bi molmÉpfql ab kl pbo abpmlg^al ab pr
Aljl pb abpmobkab ab i^ kloj^* bi molmfbq^+ mlpbpfÉk*bimlpbbalo^sfs^slwbu`i^j^8 ÖH_'
ofl kl mlpbbalo kl mrbab bgbo`bo i^ abcbkp^ ef' ef gl\[\e \a\iZ\i \jkX XZZ`ze ZfekiX d x gfi(
mlpbplof^ buqo^graf`f^i `lkqo^ bi mlpbbalonrb hl\ cc\mf ljl]ilZklXe[f \c Y`\e gfi5+ Xyfj" )?kqb
_X ljl]ilZklX[f \c Y`\e Zfdf gifg`\kXi`f gfi cf biil*çnrÄmrbabe^`bobimolmfbq^oflvi^Nlif`Å^=
d\efj [`\q $ ,+% Xyfj ) çAobbo bk pr m^i^_o^ v `^k`bi^o bi lmbo^qfsl=
çTbofcf`^oi^sbo^`fa^aabi^fkcloj^`fÉk^qo^sÄp
Aljl mrkql ab m^oqfa^* `lkpfabo^jlp nrb i^ abjbaflpmol_^qloflpnrb^`obafqbkbirprcor`+
co^pb ljl]ilZklX[f \c Y`\e bp abp^cloqrk^a^ qllmlpbpfÉkmlobpbmi^wl=Alkpfabo^jlpnrb
abpabrkmrkqlabsfpq^qÄ`kf`lmrbpab^`rbo+ bpq^ obpqof``fÉk mrbabpbork^c~`fibp`^m^qlof^
al ^i AÉafdl Afsfi bi rprcor`ql bp rk abob`el m^o^bimlpbbalomob`^ofl`lkbicfkabbsfq^o^pÅ
++( IjcidVeVgiZbZgZXZZkVajVgadedh^i^kddcZ\Vi^kdYZfjZZahZ\jcYdesggV[dYZacjZkdVgiuXjad3,*YZa<wY^\d
<^k^a gZXd_V& Xdbd gZfj^h^id eVgV aV Vea^XVX^wc YZ ZhiV cjZkV [^\jgV YZ YZ[ZchV& fjZ Za edhZZYdg "^ckVhdg# hZV
:=OH<:MNL /1.
ŦŦÚ J r f p D o ^ k ` f p ` l N ^ w K ^ r o v - P f ` ^ o a l A ~ k b m ^ A ^ p f i i ^ p
biabpmlglabpr mlpbpfÉk*il`r^i klpiibs^^ i^ af`el mi^wl m^o^ nrb pb ib aÄ bi _bkbcf`fl ab Ü 7
`lk`irpfÉk ab nrb i^ kloj^ mb`É ab ljfpfÉk i^ara^ vnrb ? klmrba^v^abpmlpbboilmlo jjj
bk i^ obdri^`fÉkabbpqbprmrbpqlmrbpfk`irpl i^p sÅ^p ab eb`el, Bb bpq^ cloj^* bi ibdfpi^alo XZXX
F +) +
ĨÍĒĪĞÉĦÍĬ ËĮĔĬİĜÍIÉĪIÍĬ ĤÉ ĜĒÍIĔĜĒÉĒ ĒĔ ÏĮĔ ÉĤĜĴĜÉ ĤÉ ËÉĪFÉ ĒĔŖAŖĒĔ ÍĚİĔIĔĪ ĔĤ İĞİĮĤÍ ĘÍĪĦÉĤ rrr
rkbcb`qfsl mlif`f^iprmi^ i^p i^_lobpabigrwd^+ ab molmfba^a m^o^ bsfq^o nrb pb^ abpmlpbÅal MMM
ÆÆÆ
alobk i^s^ilo^`fÉkab ilp jbaflp mol_^qloflp abi _fbk mlobpq^ sÅ^* ^pÅ `ljl q^j _fÄk ^ifsf^
ĎDĆĊ
mobpbkq^alpmlobi mlpbbalomob`^ofl, pr`^od^mol_^qlof^^iklqbkbonrb^`obafq^o*`e C
ÀÅĆC
Ǽ
j`klvmol_^_ibj bkqbbk`rbpqfÉkabjfkrqlpr
Qfk mbogrf`fl ab il ^kqboflo* `lkpfabo^jlp nrb elo^p*nrb e^ bgbo`fal pr mlpbpfÉk ab j^kbo^
q^jml`lnrba^ abiqlal`i^ol`r~i bp i^cfk^if+ `lkqfkr^*mÑ_if`^vm^`Åcf`^,
a^anrb_rp`Ébiibdfpi^alo`lkbpq^obpqof``fÉk
l*af`elablqoljlal*`r~ibpbifkqboÄpnrbfk+ Lll_pq^kqb*`lkpfabo^jlpnrbbpq^obpqof``fÉk
qbkqÉqrqbi^o,Jrbdlab^k^ifw^o^idrk^pmlpf_ibp bp ml`l abpb^a^ mrbp pb bpq~ mobjf^kal ab
lm`flkbp*rk^p^k^bumif`^`fÉk^i^nrbebjlp fdr^icloj^^i mlpbbalomob`^oflnrbkle^p^+
mlafaliibd^o^ m^oqfoabrk mofj bo^k~ifpfpabi kb^alprabob`elabmolmfba^a^anrfofalmlo _\
klsbalpl ^oqÅ`ril bp i^ nrb bumif`^objlp `lk mobp`ofm`fÉk &bkpr jla^ifa^a i^od^',Alkpfab+ Â
bipfdrfbkqbbgbjmil8 o^jlpnrber_fbo^pfaljbglonrbbi ibdfpi^alo ^f
sf
kl er_fbo^ fk`irfalbpq^ obpqof``fÉkvnrb pÉil (X
_\
Gj^dfkbjlp nrb ? bp bi molmfbq^ofl obdfpqo^i pb moleÅ_^ ^i molmfbq^ofl kl mlpbbalo bgbo`bo L.
abrkfkjrb_ib, @ bprkmlpbbalomob`^oflab i^krbs^abcbkp^mlpbplof^buqo^graf`f^i`lkqo^ ^9
<
j^i^cbnrbbpqrslbk mlpbpfÉk`lkqfkr^*m^`Å+ ^nrbi nrbv^ l_qrsl rk^ ab`i^o^`fÉk ab mobp+ .
o<
cf`^* mÑ_if`^ v `ljl molmfbq^ofl abi fkjrb_ib `ofm`fÉk^anrfpfqfs^/1*mrbpbiil8&f'abpfk`bkqfs^+ ]ol
abmolmfba^aab ? mlorkmboÅlalab/.^Çlp, oÅ^ ^Ñk j~p i^ mlpbpfÉk mob`^of^abfkjrb_ibp ^g
M
&nrbbkqbkabjlpbprk^abi^pcfk^ifa^abpabi^ M
(X
?mbp^oabnrb @ `rjmib`lk ilpobnrfpfqlpabi kloj^'9&ff'cljbkq^oÅ^bip^kb^jfbkqllmloqrkl r
-2
^oqÅ`ril73.abiAÉafdlAfsfim^o^i^mobp`ofm`fÉk ab i^ molmfba^a9 v* &fff' bsfq^oÅ^ ilp mol_ibj^p X`
^
i^od^* @ kl`rbkq^`lkqÅqrilbj fqfalmloi^^r+ mol_^qloflpv^`ljbkq^alpnrbpbprp`fq^k`lk `s
L.
qlofa^a`ljmbqbkqbnrbilab`i^ob`ljlkrbsl i^^`qr^i obdri^`fÉk, L.
ol
molmfbq^ofl*mloilnrbprqfqri^ofa^aklbplmlkf+ 1
_ib^kqb ? &l^kqb`r^inrfboqbo`bol'*`loofbkal 0,0, Ć Ĥ E Í Ê ĞĐ Î Ê Ē Ï Ģ É Đ Í Ê Î Ĩ Í ĖÈ È ĖĦ Ģ Ľ ĞĐ r
_\
JJ,
biofbpdlabnrb ? ib^mifnrb i^ krbs^ abcbkp^ ĖĠ I Í Ĥ È Ê É Ê Ģ È ĖĐ É Ê ĞĐ É Ê ËÊ Ģ Î Đ I Ĥ Î Ê Î Ĥ Í ĖĐ ]ol
mlpbplof^buqo^graf`f^ivilabpmlgbabifkjrb_ib Ê İ Ĩ Í Đ GÏ É ĖÈ ĖĐ Ğ È Ĥ Ģ Ĩ Í Đ Ê Ğ I Í Ĥ I ĖÊ Ĩ Đ Í ĖĤ Ļ ^f
R1
abinrb^elo^bpgroÅaf`^jbkqbmolmfbq^ofl, id
M
.
Ckbi Ñiqfj l m~oo^clabi krbsl^oqÅ`ril70.abi á
?kqbq^ipfqr^`fÉk*bufpqbi^mlpf_fifa^aabnrbbi B
AÉafdl Afsfi bk`lkqo^jlp rk^ krbs^ fj m ol + _\
ibdfpi^aloe^v^obdri^alrk^prboqbabmobprk+ `babk`f^ ab i^ abcbkp^ mlpbplof^ buqo^graf`f^i M
-
`fÉkobi^qfs^abmolmfba^a^c^sloab @ pfbjmob i^ `r^i* `ljl bumif`^objlp* klp qo^b krbslp _\
nrb @ mrba^^`obafq^ocbe^`fbkqbjbkqbvmlo R1
alilobp ab `^_bw^, Ci qbuql _^gl ^k~ifpfp bp bi ol
jbaflpnrb kl obnrfbo^k ab j^vlo^`qr^`fÉk* pfdrfbkqb8 Cke`e^{e ZXjf gifZ\[\ cX [\]\ejX gf( L
-1
bk bi jlj bkql bk nrb ib bpq~k bgbo`fbkal i^ j\jfi`X ZfekiX \c gifg`\kXi`f [\ le `edl\Yc\ o^
85
abcbkp^mlpbplof^buqo^graf`f^i*birplvafpcorqb <
-1
abi _fbk mloafbw^Çlp, Pbpmb`ql ab biil* bufpqbk alp do^kabp fk qb o+ ĆĀ
mobq^`flkbp8&f'nrbbpq^obpqof``fÉkbp^_plirq^
Bbbpq^cloj^*obmbqfjlp*_^pq^o~n r b %\ m or b + v nrb i^ abcbkp^ mlpbplof^ b uqo^graf`f^i kl
M
_b bi rprcor`ql abi _fbk `ljl molmfbq^ofl mlo mol`babo~ `lkqo^ kfkdÑk molmfbq^ofl _^gl kfk+ AM
Õ
+
q
+-( >hXZcVg^dZc ZaXjVa&Zc gZVa^YVY&Za VXX^dcVciZnV cdhZguV_jguY^XVbZciZZakZgYVYZgd egde^ZiVg^dYZa egZY^d&Va O
]VWZgdWiZc^YdY^X]dYZgZX]dZaiZgXZgdVigVkthYZaVjhjXVe^wc(
ǼÉ I Į Ĕ Ĵ É Ē Ĕ Ę Ĕ I Ĭ É ÓĨ Í Ĭ Ĕ Ĭ Í Ī Ĝ É Ô ĔĶİĪÉĢĮĒĜËĜÉĤ ŦŦÛ
drk^`fo`rkpq^k`f^9v*&éf'nrbbpq^obpqof``fÉkbp mlaoÅ^k _ ofk a^ o ilp abcbkplobp ab bpq^
obi^qfs^vnrbi^ Bbcbkp^ Nlpbplof^ klmol`bab qbloÅ^pboÅ^nrb8&f'bpq^pobpqof``flkbpklpb
Ñkf`^jbkqb `lkqo^ bi molmfbq^ofl nrb e^ bgbo+ ^mif`^k^imolmfbq^oflnrbbgbo`bi^abcbkp^
`fal mobsf^jbkqb bi abob`el `lkqbkfal bk bi mlpbplof^buqo^graf`f^ibksfoqraabipbdrk+
pbdrkalm~oo^clabikrbsl^oqÅ`ril70.abiAÉ+ alm~oo^clabi^kloj^mrbpbi^oqÅ`rilklil
afdlAfsfi,?`lkqfkr^`fÉk rk _obsbabp^ooliil8 af`bbumobp^jbkqb9l*&ff'nrbi^fkl_pbos^k+
`f^ abbp^p obpqof``flkbpa^o~k ird^o^ rk^
^, J^ mofjbo^ mlpqro^ bpq~ prpqbkq^a^ bk alp fkabjkfw^`fÉk mlo a^Çlp v mbogrf`flp &r
`ofqboflp fkqbomobq^qfslp8 &f' nrb bi m~oo^cl lqo^p^``flkbp ibd^ibp`ljl i^pmbk^ibp'^
bjmfbw^`lkrkmlpqri^al^_plirql& CLLGL+ c^sloabimlpbbalo*mbolkliba^kabob`el
EôLA?QM '9v*&ff'nrbbpq^kloj^cljbkq^i^ ^ob`rmbo^oi^mlpbpfÉkjbaf^kqbi^abcbkp^
fksbopfÉkv_rp`^bjmlabo^o^imolmfbq^ofl, mlpbplof^buqo^graf`f^i,
116 J r f p D o ^ k ` f p ` l N ^ w K ^ r o v - P f ` ^ o a l A ~ k b m ^ A ^ p f i i ^ p
Aljl pb mrbab abpmobkaboab il ^kqboflo* bkbpbm~oo^clabj^kbo^q^inrb pÅmol`babi^ Ů Õ
bpq^ fk qbomobq^ `fÉ k mrbab obpriq^o j~p abcbkp^mlpbplof^bgbo`fa^mlorkmlpbbalonrb EEE
o^wlk^_ib ^rknrb m^oqb ab rk^ mobjfp^ ^anrfofÉ bi _fbk mlo mobp`ofm`fÉk ^anrfpfqfs^ UWUWS
K ë(z
ÉIİÉFÎIĜËÉ ËÍI ĤÉ ĔĶĨĤĜËÉĒÉ ĔI ĔĤ ĤĜİĔĪÉĤPÉÞ ËÍIİĪÉ ĔĤ ÉIİĔĪĜÍĪ ĨĪÍĨĜĔİÉĪĜÍŖO SJH
^kqboflo8nrbilpobnrfpfqlpabimofjbom~oo^cl ll
k j
abikrbsl^oqÅ`ril70.abiAÉafdlAfsfipÅplk Cpq^bu`bm`fÉkbpiÉdf`^mrbp*`ljljbk`flk^+
ĎDĆĊ
^mif`^_ibpm^o^i^mol`baf_fifa^aabiabob`el jlp^kqboflojbkqb*pfbpnrbbimlpbbalov^bp C
ÀÅĆC
Ǽ
Õ
M
+.( :]dgV W^Zc&Zc XVhdYZfjZZa edhZZYdgVaZ\jZ"n egjZWZ# fjZaaZkV +*Vvdh jhj[gjXijVcYdZa BcbjZWaZnVxc
GV
Vhu Za egde^ZiVg^d ji^a^oV aVhkuVh YZ ]ZX]d& ZcidcXZh Za egde^ZiVg^d ZhiVguV VXijVcYd [jZgV YZ adh VaXVcXZh YZ
ǼÉ I Į Ĕ Ĵ É Ē Ĕ Ę Ĕ I Ĭ É Ó Ĩ Í Ĭ Ĕ Ĭ Í Ī Ĝ É Ô Ĕ Ķ İ Ī É Ģ Į Ē Ĝ Ë Ĝ É Ĥ 117
=J% 7CA9BH5F=C:=B5@ mob`babkqbp+ `ljl rk^ Bbcbkp^ Nolmfbq^of^
Cuqo^graf`f^i ,
? m^oqfoab ilbumrbpqlbk i^p iÅkb^p mob`babk+
qbp*mrbabmlpqri^opbnrbi^abcbkp^ mlpbplof^ Qfk bj_^odl* j~p^ii~ abbiil &bpab`fo*ab i^ fk+
buqo^graf`f^i e^ abg^al ab pbo &^rknrb prbkb `lebobk`f^ qÄ`kf`^ nrb `lkqbkaÅ^ i^ obdri^`fÉk
` l k qo^ a f`ql ofl ' bpqof`q^j bkqb mlpbplof^, Jl ab ^j_^p cfdro^p bk rk plil ^oqÅ`ril' vab i^p
^cfoj^al* ab_fal ^ nrb bi krbsl ^oqÅ`ril 70. ĒĔĬĴĔIİÉĢÉĬ ÏĮĔ ÍĨĜIÉĦ ÍĬ ĨĪĔĬĔIİÉ ĔĤ IĮĔĴÍ
abi AÉafdl Afsfi kl plil `lkqbj mi^ jbglo^p qbuqlkloj^qfsl*`lkpfabo^jlpnrbbpqb^mloqb^
prpq^k`f^ibp bk il obcbofal ^ i^ obdri^`fÉk v fkf`f^qfs^abiNlaboCgb`rqfslab_bpbop^ira^al*v^
^mif`^`fÉkabi^`i~pf`^cfdro^abi^abcbkp^mlpb+ nrbobpmlkab^rkgrpqfcf`^alob`i^jlabipb`qlo
plof^buqo^graf`f^i*pfklnrbbikrbsl^oqÅ`rile^ fkjl_fif^ofl*vbpq^jlppbdrolpnrb`lkbiqfbjml
`ob^alrk krbslfkpqorj bkqlababcbkp^bkbi i^jlafcf`^`fÉkl_gbqlab`ljbkq^ofl`l^avrs^o~
~j _fqlfkjl_fif^ofl*bi`r^ifk`irpfsbmlaoÅ^pbo ^afk^jfw^oi^fksbopfÉkbkmolvb`qlpfkjl_fif^oflp
`^q^ild^al +`l j l plpi^v^jlp bk ilp m~oo^clp bkkrbpqolm^Åp,Sk^sbwj~p*plilbiqfbjmlilafo~,
KZk^hiV ZY^iVYV edg Vajbcdh YZ aV ?VXjaiVY YZ =ZgZX]d YZ aV Nc^kZgh^YVY YZ E^bV
+-* :=OH <:MNL