Documentos de Académico
Documentos de Profesional
Documentos de Cultura
SOBRETENSIONES DE
RESONANCIA ARMÓNICA DEL
SEIN SOBRE LÍNEAS DE
TRANSMISIÓN DE 500KV
Ing. Manuel Juan Casas Salazar
Ing. Dennis Casas Chero
manueljuancasas@gmail.com
denniscasas@gmail.com
La Impedancia del Circuito del Sistema de
Potencia en función de la frecuencia, es una
magnitud importante para determinar los puntos
resonantes paralelo y serie en las subestaciones
de 500kV
RESUMEN
Investigación:
- SSRr
- HOVR
- SOV
Objetivos:
- Demostrar la Validez del método “Dip de Reactancia”
- Estudio de puntos resonantes serie y paralelo (SEs 500kV)
- Cálculo TOV con EMTP
1
INTRODUCCIÓN
- 2002: transformador siniestrado de 138kV-SE HUÁNUCO (medición
de alto contenido armónico en L-Paragha-Huánuco 138kV.
2
CONTEXTO Y MOTIVACIÓN
3
ANÁLISIS DE RESULTADOS
3.1
RESONANCIA SUBSÍNCRONA (SSR)
DIP DE REACTANCIA CT FÉNIX POWER
(Es2018min)
DIgSILENT
0.15
0.12 Y 0.593
0.081 Ohm
0.09
DIP DE REACTANCIA
(Y-X)/ Y =
2.5%
0.06 0.630
X 0.079 Ohm
0.03
0.00
0.0000 0.2200 0.4400 0.6600 0.8800 [-] 1.1000
FENIX 18C: CAP F/S
FENIX 18C: CAP E/S
CASOS Es2018min
0.0135
% DIP DE REACTANCIA
Caso N 2.5
0.0110
Fuera de servicio AutoTR Chilca 500/220/33kV 7.2
Fuera de servicio Línea: Chilca-Carabayllo
0.0085
11.6
Fuera de servicio Línea Chilca-Termochilca 4.9
0.0060
0.0035
0.0010
0.0000 0.2200 0.4400 0.6600 0.8800 [-] 1.1000
FENIX 18C: CAP F/S
FENIX 18C: CAP E/S
DIP X Date:
Annex: /36
Caso A: Capacitores serie de la L-5032/4/6 -ON
Caso B: Capacitores serie de la L-5032/4/6 -OFF
DIgSILENT
0.15
0.12
0.09
0.06
0.03 CHILCA
0.00
0.0000 0.2000 0.4000 0.6000 0.8000 [-] 1.0000
FENIX 18B:
FENIX 18B:
CAPACITORES SERIE F/S
CAPACITORES SERIE F/S
L5032
FENIX 18B: Network Resistance in Ohm
POROMA
FENIX 18B: Network Reactance in Ohm
0.125
0.153 0.312
L5034
0.025 Ohm 0.054 Ohm
0.100 0.160 REACTANCE DIP= 32% 0.360 REACTANCE DIP= 43%
0.017 Ohm 0.031 Ohm
0.345
0.075
OCOÑA
REACTANCE DIP= 18% < 20% LIMIT
0.049 Ohm
0.050
0.377
0.040 Ohm
0.025
L5036
0.000
0.0000 0.2000 0.4000 0.6000 SAN JOSÉ 0.8000 [-] 1.0000
PB1: CAPACITORES SERIE F/S
PB1: CAPACITORES SERIE F/S
PB1: Network Resistance in Ohm
PB1: Network Reactance in Ohm
0.125
0.100
0.075
0.050
›
0.025
0.000
0.0000 0.2000 0.4000 0.6000 0.8000 [-] 1.0000
CHILCA UNO 16A: CAPACITORES SERIE F/S
CHILCA UNO 16A: CAPACITORES SERIE F/S
CHILCA UNO 16A: Network Resistance in Ohm
CHILCA UNO 16A: Network Reactance in Ohm
DIgSILENT
1.09
8.503 s
1.070 p.u.
1.04
0.006 s
0.994 p.u.
0.99
0.94
MODELO INEXACTO
GOV FENIX POWER
0.89
0.84
0.00 40.00 80.00 120.00 160.00 [s] 200.00
Fenix G1: Mechanical Torque in p.u.
Fenix G1: Electrical Torque in p.u.
2.00
1.00
0.00
DIgSILENT
210.00
PRUEBA DE ESCALÓN
200.00 -1.00 179.074 s
6.498 s -0.336 Hz
190.00
-0.742 Hz
-2.00
0.001 s
170.00
-2.685 Hz
-3.00
160.00
-1.50 -1.00 -0.50 0.00 0.50 [s] 1.00
0.00 40.00 80.00 120.00 160.00 [s] 200.00
PuertoBravo G1: Active Power in MW
Fenix G1: Turbine Power in p.u.
0.87 Fenix G1: Deviation of the El. Frequency in Hz
-0.967 s
0.852 p.u.
0.85
-0.003 s
0.815 p.u. 1.000
0.83
0.77
-1.50 -1.00 -0.50 0.00 0.50 [s] 1.00
PuertoBravo G1: Turbine Power in p.u.
0.992
104.812 s 150.282 s
195.840 s
1.01 0.993 p.u. 0.993 p.u. 0.993 p.u.
0.988
›
1.00
0.99
-0.003 s 0.984
0.98
0.998 p.u.
5.933 s
0.985 p.u.
0.97
0.980
0.96 0.00 40.00 80.00 120.00 160.00 [s] 200.00
-1.50 -1.00 -0.50 0.00 0.50 [s] 1.00
PuertoBravo G1: Speed in p.u.
Fenix G1: Speed in p.u.
Plots Date: 3/19/2018
Annex: /1
3.2
RIESGO DE SOBRETENSIÓN ARMÓNICA
HOVR
DIgSILENT
4th
2000.00 625.00 625.00
5.802
1979.057 Ohm PUNTOS DE RESONANCIA PARALELA 4.717
709.454 Ohm
PUNTOS DE RESONANCIA PARALELA
1600.00 500.00 500.00 0.332 POTENCIALMENTE PELIGROSOS
5.497 59.889 Ohm
1451.870 Ohm 0.602
5th
98.961 Ohm
3.387
1260.002 Ohm
1200.00 375.00 375.00
PUNTOS DE RESONANCIA PARALELA
POTENCIALMENTE PELIGROSOS
0.018
1.000 3.687 Ohm
3th
800.00 250.00 133.728 Ohm 250.00
3.005 0.997
713.506 Ohm 46.831 Ohm
SET HUÁNUCO; (a) OPERACIÓN NORMAL (línea continua) - (b)TRANSFORMADOR HUÁNUCO 500/220/33KV 600MVA FUERA DE SERVICIO (línea discontinua) SET HUÁNUCO Y PIURA EN OPERACIÓN NORMAL SET SAN JOSÉ; (a) ANILLO CERRADO (línea continua) - (b)ANILLO ABIERTO: f/s L5037 (línea discontinua)
6.993
199.254 Ohm
1000.00 250.00 6.668 400.00
23.051 Ohm
HUANUCO Date:
Annex: /3
1000.0 PREVIO A RESTAURACIÓN DE TRANSFORMADORES
500.00
3.627
500.00
675.187 Ohm
0.007 3.433
4.960 Ohm 411.284 Ohm
1.000
800.00 81.232 Ohm 400.00
400.00 3.042 3.730
1.5th
1.682 301.941 Ohm
333.106 Ohm
358.853 Ohm
1.7th 2.4th
6.135 1.533
903.785 Ohm 188.716 Ohm
600.00 1.942 300.00
300.00 2.423
378.414 Ohm
170.205 Ohm
1.010 1.000
400.00 67.983 Ohm 200.00 36.346 Ohm
0.462 CASO N-1 200.00
121.057 Ohm
1.312
130.694 Ohm 100.00
200.00 3.683 N
100.00
248.860 Ohm N-1
CASO N
0.0000
0.0000 0.0017 1.4013 2.8010 4.2007 5.6003[-] 7.0000
-0.0000 1.4000 2.8000 4.2000 5.6000[-] 7.0000 0.00
0.0000 1.6000 3.2000 4.8000 6.4000
[-] 8.0000 YANA500: Network Impedance, Magnitude in Ohm
TRUJILLO 500\TRUJILLO 500A: Network Impedance, Magnitude in Ohm YANA500: NetworkinImpedance, Magnitude in Ohm
CHIMBOTE 500\CHIMBOTE 500B: Network Impedance, Magnitude Ohm
TRUJILLO 500\TRUJILLO 500A: Network Impedance, Magnitude in Ohm
3.3
MANIOBRA DE SOBRETENSIONES
SOV
Fuente de Armónicos del TR Open-circuit with 115% Vn
600 MVA
TOV Im (% of In), In= 693 A
500 kV
❸ 692.8 A of In
27.7 A of Im (Eq to I1)
❺
20.8 A of 3th
❼ 14.4 A of 5th
8.9 A of 7th
Armónicos 3th 5th 7th
Fase a: h*0° 0 0 0
Fase b: h*-120° -360 -600 -840
Fase c: h*+120° 360 600 840
SA SeTo
SA linTo
SA SeFrom
YananHuan5 YananHuan.. YananHuan..
Shunt/Filter
Tower YananHuan Tower Yan.. Tower Yan..
CB L
CB R
Breaker/S..
Yanango5
Huánuco5
Breaker/S..
TR3 HV AT3 HV
Cap SeFrom
Cap SeTo
SA TR3
SA AT3
TR3 AT3
TR3 AT3
TR3- AT3-
TR3 MV AT3 MV
Corrientes, tensiones del TR-lado HV y energía del SA
F 1PH LT Yanango-Huánuco 500kV. Resultados de Simulación
desde t=0.0s hasta t=1.1s (AR en t=0s)
5.00 300.00 0.40
2.50 200.00 0.30
1.002 s RECIERRE
216.827 %
65.755 Hz
0.00 100.00 60.00 63.241 %
77.710 Hz
18.301 %
-50.00 0.00 40.00
AR Date: 4/1/2018
Annex: /2
4
EFECTOS NEGATIVOS DE
DESBALANCES DE CORRIENTE
DESBALANCES DE CORRIENTE EN 60KV-DATOS SCADA
Time U12_SV2U23_SV2U13_SV2I1_SV2I2_SV2I3_SV2kW_SV2kVAR_SV2kWh_SV2 fP_SV2 f_SV2 Max_SV2promedio min max D_min D-max DESBALANCE
03/30/2018 01:02:10 58210 58070 58090 45 48 47 -4710 320 1.06E+08 -0.9977 59.96 100 46.6666667 45 48 1.66666667 1.33333333 3.57142857
03/30/2018 01:02:12 58250 58100 58110 44 47 47 -4630 330 1.06E+08 -0.99747 60.02 100 46 44 47 2 1 4.34782609
03/30/2018 01:02:14 58250 58100 58110 44 47 47 -4630 330 1.06E+08 -0.99747 60.02 100 46 44 47 2 1 4.34782609
03/30/2018 01:02:16 58250 58100 58110 44 47 47 -4630 330 1.06E+08 -0.99747 60.02 100 46 44 47 2 1 4.34782609
03/30/2018 01:02:18 58250 58100 58110 44 47 47 -4630 330 1.06E+08 -0.99747 60.02 100 46 44 47 2 1 4.34782609
03/30/2018 01:02:20 58250 58100 58110 44 47 47 -4630 330 1.06E+08 -0.99747 60.02 100 46 44 47 2 1 4.34782609
03/30/2018 01:02:22 58250 58100 58110 44 47 47 -4630 330 1.06E+08 -0.99747 60.02 100 46 44 47 2 1 4.34782609
03/30/2018 01:02:26 58190 58060 58050 43 46 46 -4520 320 1.06E+08 -0.997503 59.98 100 45 43 46 2 1 4.44444444
03/30/2018 01:02:28 58190 58060 58050 43 46 46 -4520 320 1.06E+08 -0.997503 59.98 100 45 43 46 2 1 4.44444444
03/30/2018 01:02:30 58190 58060 58050 43 46 46 -4520 320 1.06E+08 -0.997503 59.98 100 45 43 46 2 1 4.44444444
03/30/2018 01:02:32 58190 58060 58050 43 46 46 -4520 320 1.06E+08 -0.997503 59.98 100 45 43 46 2 1 4.44444444
03/30/2018 01:02:34 58190 58060 58050 43 46 46 -4520 320 1.06E+08 -0.997503 59.98 100 45 43 46 2 1 4.44444444
03/30/2018 01:02:36 58190 58060 58050 43 46 46 -4520 320 1.06E+08 -0.997503 59.98 100 45 43 46 2 1 4.44444444
03/30/2018 01:02:38 58250 58110 58090 42 45 44 -4410 340 1.06E+08 -0.997041 60.03 100 43.6666667 42 45 1.66666667 1.33333333 3.81679389
SOBRETEMPERATURAS EN EL TR (AV2018MIN 30 MARZO)
ONAN/ONAF UL I L (A) UL IL (A) Temp. Dev. AT Dev. MT
* * T AP P Q EN 138 kV 138 kV EN 60 kV 60 kV Aceite 138 kV 60 kV
FANS
Nª 7 S FP EN EN
HO RA 22.5 20/25 0.9 92/116 60.0 192/240 HO RA 67° 77° 77° L O C. / AUT O
36.0
30.0
24.0
18.0
12.0
6.00
-48.0 -42.0 -36.0 -30.0 -24.0 -18.0 -12.0 -6.00 6.00 12.0 18.0 24.0 30.0 36.0 42.0 48.0 54.0 60.0 66.0 72.0 [pri.Ohm]
-6.00
-12.0
-18.0
-24.0
-30.0
LOCALIZACIÓN DE FALLA TERMINAL 1PH fase B
(Línea de 138kV, 60km, sin transposición)
36.0 36.0
30.0 30.0
24.0 24.0
18.0 18.0
12.0 12.0
-12.0 -12.0
-18.0 -18.0
-24.0 -24.0
-30.0 -30.0
IMPEDANCIA DE FALLA NO-LINEAL
Calculating de arc resistance 0.0
Warringtong formula
293.4
293.8
HUANUCO500
F 1PH-G
Rp Huan-Yan
3.01559607 PACHA
Arc length in meters L 5.5 677.68
2.348
0.000 A COLCABAMBA
Fault current in Amperes I fa ul t 2348
Ctes 3
0.8 297.02
Rp Yan-Colc
1.029
0.000
Cs Yan-Colc
647.88
Rp Yan-Huan
2.244
0.000
Zo 46.56+141.08i
YANA500
180.459
Z1 5.692+57.06i 20.84
285.939
151.02 277.928
0.072 0.523
0.000 0.000
ZN 13.6226666666667+28.0066666666667i
Rf 3.01559607370103Rp Yanan500Tr3 Yanango 500/220 kV
The set value for the relay: complejo:
0.00
100.75
0.793
Zset = 0.8*(Z1+ZN + Rf) 17.8642101922942+68.0533333333334i 0.000
NUEVA YANANGO220
LT 220 kV Yanango-NuevaYanango
95.358
68.0533333 = jX1set
17.8642102 = R1set
Arco eléctrico durante pruebas sobre la torre
-falla bifásica
5
ASPECTOS ECONÓMICOS
COMPARACIÓN LF-DC ENTRE CAP BY-PASS ON VS OFF
(Es24min)
Desde Colcabamba
L-5013
0.0
INDEPENDENCIA220/INDEPE..
$
126MW : CAP ON
-0.7
INDEPENDENCIA220/INDEPE.. -35.8
-0.7
264MW : CAP OFF
2.4
By-Pass -100.0
109.1
109.1
492MW : CAP ON
316MW : CAP OFF -100.0 0.0..
109.1
L-5032
0.0..
0.0..
-35.8 0.0
0.0
0.0
POROMA500/PORO..
-38.6
11.3
-32.8
-38.6
0.0 POROMA500/PORO..
50.2
10.5
0.0..
0.0
CHILCACTM500/CH.. 11.3
SSR
-4.0
-4.0
-4.0
0.0
15.3
58.9
15.3
0.0 0.0
lod Ssaa_Fenix
-8.5
-7.4 0.0..
0.0..
~ ~ ~ 0.0..
G G G
0.0
❶$ 0.0..
L-5011
0.0..
0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 AUT-5371 -0.0
0.0
0.0.. -8.5
FENIX18.. FENIX18.. FENIX18.. -8.5 POROMA220/PORO..
0.0..
7.4 7.3 7.7 8.2
POROMA220/PORO..
AT72-52
0.0 0.0 0.0
-3.7 8.2
Tr2 Fenix..
Tr2 Fenix..
Tr2 Fenix..
EPO FÉNIX POWER:
“El costo del equipo de la subestación de 500kV es el
triple que una a 220kV”.
All costs are $x1,000
s"
Proposed 2018 SDG&E Generator Interconnection Unit Cost
ge
69 kV 138 kV 230 kV 500 kV
Guide
ta
ol
"V
Equipment Categories Units
❶ $ x3
New Substation Equipment
Complete Loop-in Substation, equipped with one line position to 3,946 6,846 13,417 40,108
terminate a single gen-tie
New Substation Equipment
Transformer Banks:
500/230 kV 4-1 Phase per unit 39,799
500/230 kV 3-1 Phase per unit 33,730
230/138 kV per unit 8,560
230/69 kV per unit 6,836
138/69 kV per unit 6,331
(Add additional options) per unit
Double Operating Bus Sections - 2 new buses, spanning 2 positions per unit 1,016 1,353 1,738 2,213
Double Operating Bus Sections - 2 new buses, spanning 4 positions per unit 1,751 2,633 3,468 4,337
Double Operating Bus Sections - 2 bus extensions, spanning 2 positions per unit n/a n/a n/a n/a
Double Operating Bus Sections - 2 bus extensions, spanning 4 positions per unit n/a n/a n/a n/a
EL BY-PASS DEL CAPACITOR SERIE DE LA L5032,
REPRESENTA UNA INVERSIÓN FONDEADA DE
64 MILLONES DE DÓLARES
❶
El by-pass del Capacitor Serie de la L5032 incrementa
PÉRDIDAS DE TRANSMISIÓN a un costo de
1.72 MILLONES DE DÓLARES-AÑO.
Sistema de potencia de
5,124MVA con efecto
Ferranti de -6,446MVAr
(26% adicional)
$ 1.7M
0.138 12.40
0.087 12.40
By-Pass
-0.051 0.00
-8.40
3.33 -100.00
3.33 -100.00
0.00 0.00 12.40
-8.96 -100.00 12.40
0.00
-8.40
-100.00
-100.00
-100.00 12.40
-100.00 0.0.. 12.40
12.40
0.00 -8.40
0.00
0.0..
0.0..
0.00
L-5032 0.00
-8.45
-8.45
-8.45
-8.45
-8.45
-8.45
-8.45
-8.45
-32.57
-55.79 -32.57 POROMA500/PORO..
-55.79 0.00 -10.53
0.00 POROMA500/PORO..
-57.17
-57.17
-57.17
-10.51
-23.23
-24.22
0.0..
-8.45
CHILCA CTM 500/CH.. 0.000
-3.756 -8.45
-8.45
-8.45
6.06
6.06
0.00
6.06
6.06
0.00
-8.45
-8.45
-8.45
-8.45
-8.45
-8.45
6.06
6.06
6.06
-3.422
-62.93
-62.93
-25.00
-49.00
-49.00
-24.01
-62.93
-62.93
-25.00
-8.45
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00 -8.45
0.00 -8.45
-4.72 0.00 -8.45
lod Ssaa_Fenix -4.72 0.0.. 0.00 -8.45
-45.07 5.43 -4.72
-45.07 5.43 -8.45
-35.18 0.00 -32.88 5.43 0.0.. 0.0..
-35.18 -23.82 -32.88 Fenix G1 Fenix G2 Fenix TV -8.45
0.0..
0.0..
G G G
0.00 -35.98 -35.98 -36.03 -3.33 -8.45
0.00 -35.98 -35.98 -36.03 -3.33 0.0.. -8.45
L-5011
ERROR DE CONEXIÓN
SR
Características de Barras SEIN
IEC60076-5 INDIA PERU- 2024
SYSTEM Poroma5 Chilca5 › SCC menor que 20%
CHILCA y
HUÁNUCO
Voltage, kV 40%
400 del CB500 500
SCC. kA 7.8 15.1
MVAscc
X/R kA 16.7 38.5
› 40000
X/R alta en Chilca5 4031
13262 por
SCC, 57.74 15.31 4.65
cercanía de TPPs:
System
Xo/X1 impedance, 1.9 Zth (Ω) 0.7 Fasy=1.7,
4 Fpot=2.5,62.02
18.85 alto
POWER8000
TRANSFORMER, MVA componente
600 600 DC. Poroma5
600
Transformer
6000 impedance, Ztr% Fasy=1.6,
16 Fpot=5.7
16 16
Transformer
4000
impedance, Ztr (Ω) 42.7
iac
66.7 66.7
2000
Transformer test current, its › Xo/X1
idc
4.9 alto3.4en Poroma5,
2.2
induce a TOVs
0 i
0 0.3 0.6 0.9 1.2 1.5 1.8 2.1 2.4 2.7 3
Test-2000
current drawl from system 0.1 0.2 0.5
-4000
t / tau strong weak very weak
If the test current drawl from the system its one tenth of the three phase
short circuit file level, then the testing impact on the system may not be severe
Características de Barras-Área Sierra
Yanango5 Huánuco5 › SCC menor que 20% y
12% del CB
SCC. kA 7.7 4.7
X/R 20 9.4
› X/R normal
❶
R S T
R S T R´ S´ T´