SiHelenahubieraestadoenIlin.

Lareferencialidadespacial
dekhraytposcomoelementoepistemolgicodelaHistoria
griegaantigua
IfHelenahadbeeninIlion.TheSpatialReferencingofkhra
andtposasanEpistemologicalElementofAncientGreek
History
RenCecea

En-claves del Pensamiento, vol. VIII, nm. 16, julio-diciembre, 2014, pp. 177-201.
Instituto Tecnolgico y de Estudios Superiores de Monterrey Campus Ciudad de
Mxico Distrito Federal, Mxico

En-claves del Pensamiento,

ISSN (Versin impresa): 1870-879X
dora.garcia@itesm.mx
en-claves.ccm@servicios.itesm.mx
Instituto Tecnolgico y de Estudios Superiores de
Monterrey Campus Ciudad de Mxico
Mxico

SI HELENA HUBIERA ESTADO EN ILIN

La referencialidad espacial de khra y tpos como
elemento epistemolgico de la Historia griega antigua
REN CECEA*

Resumen

"#$%&'()*$#+'#',('#-.(/01"$#',#'23")0-.#'"#3-3'"#'3),('4$"56)0$#71'#&1'6-8#"-,#
!"#$"!%&'(%')*+,'-!"#$%.'/%0$1!2'3'(%'45678'-&'()*9#"16-.:#0$4$#'"'4'8(',#
0'8(.-"',#+'#"-#('4-();-0)58#+'"#',3-0)$#'8#"-#0$8,(.100)58#+'"#+),01.,$#<),(5.)=
0$#'8#"-#>.'0)-#-8()61-?#@.'('8+'4$,#'8#',('#,'8()+$#0$43"'4'8(-.#$(.$,#(.-=
%-&$,# '8# "$,# 71'# <'4$,# 0$8,(-(-+$# '"# -14'8($# +'# "-# .'01..'80)-# +'# +)0<-,#
8$0)$8',#'8#"$,#('2($,#<),(5.)0$,#+'#"-#A8()6B'+-+#C.'8('#-#"$,#('2($,#4/()0$=
3$D()0$,#E#(.F6)0$,G#18-#.'01..'80)-#71'#0$8,)+'.-4$,#%1,0-#0$8,(.1).#'"#4-.0$#
+'#.'C'.'80)-#+'#"$,#-0$8('0)4)'8($,#.'"-(-+$,#3$.#"-#H),($.)-?#!"#3.','8('#-.(/01=
"$#3$8'#3$.#,1#3-.('#'"#-0'8($#'8#"-#0$..',3$8+'80)-#'8(.'#"-#0$8,(.100)58#+'#
',('#4-.0$#+'#.'C'.'80)-#,)68)C)0-+$#3$.#!"#$%#E#&'()*#E#'"#01',()$8-4)'8($#+'"#
C18+-4'8($#,$0)-"#0-.-0('./,()0$#+'#"-#()+,*I#E#-,/I#0$8#'"#+',-..$""$#+'"#+),01.,$#
-.614'8(-()*$?#J'#%1,0-#+'#',(-#4-8'.-#4$,(.-.#71'#"-,#8$0)$8',#+'#!"#$%#E#
&'()*#-+71)'.'8#'"#0-.F0('.#+'#.'01.,$#'3),('4$"56)0$#'8#'"#3.$0',$#+'#C18+-=
4'8(-0)58#-.614'8(-()*-#+'"#0$8$0)4)'8($#<),(5.)0$#'8#(-8($#71'#0$8$0)4)'8($#
3.$+10($#+'#"-#()+,*#E#0$8,0)'8('4'8('#-"('.8-()*$#-"#4)($#E#'8#3-.()01"-.#-#"-#
!"#$1!'(%'9:+;8'--.$/*9#-43")(1+:I#',($#',I#0$4$#0$8$0)4)'8($#.',1"(-+$#+'#
"-#'2)6'80)-#-.614'8(-()*-#+'#"-#()+,*#'8#'"#01-"#'"#3.)4'.#.'C'.'8('#'3),('4$=
"56)0$#+'"#<'0<$#8-..-+$#"$#0$8,()(1E'#,1#4-.0$#+'#.'C'.'80)-9#!"#$%#E#&'()*?
0%+%1$%*23+%4-5#!"#$%I#&'()*I#-.$/*I#'3),('4$"$6/-I#H),($.)-I#4)($?
K# A0-+D4)0$#+'#()'43$#0$43"'($#+'#"-#L-01"(-+#+'#L)"$,$C/-#E#M'(.-,I#N8)*'.,)+-+#O-0)$8-"#

A1(58$4-#+'#PD2)0$I#PD2)0$I#.0'0'8-Q18-4?42
177

EN-CLAVES DEL PENSAMIENTO, ao VIII, nm. 16, julio-diciembre 2014, pp. 177-201.

178

Ren Cecea

Abstract

"#$ %&'$ ()$ *"&+$ %,*&-.#$ &+$ *($ #/0.%&1$ *"#$ #0&+*#'(.(2&-%.$ ,(.#$ 0.%3#4$ 53$ *"#$
!"#$"!%&"'&()*+&,!"#$%-&./0$"!1&23456&,&6'()7$0.%-#8$%+$-#1*,%.$#.#'#1*+$()$
*"#$*"#'%*&9%*&(1$()$+0%-#$&1$*"#$-(1+*,:-*&(1$()$"&+*(,&-%.$4&+-(:,+#$&1$;1-&#1*$
7.//8/9&:!&#;$%&%/!%/&</&%//=&#"&8">?@/>/!#&"#;/.&%#AB$/%&$!&<;$8;&</&'"A!B&
%1$&1-,#%+#4$,#-:,,#1-#$()$+:-"$1(*&(1+$&1$;1-&#1*$"&+*(,&-%.$*#/*+$&1$-('0%,&+(1$
#"&>C#;$8D?"/#$8E@&E!B&#.E0$8&#/F#%G&"!/&<;$8;&%//=%&#"&HA$@B&#;/&'.E>/<".=&"'&
,#)#,#1-#$)(,$*"#$#<#1*+$%--(:1*#4$53$=&+*(,3>$!"&+$0%0#,$0:*+$%1$#'0"%+&+$(1$
#;/&8"../%?"!B/!8/&H/#<//!&#;/&8"!%#.A8#$"!&"'&#;$%&'.E>/<".=I&%$0!$'$/B&HC&
!"#$%$%14$&*'()?$%14$*"#$'(+,)@$-"%,%-*#,&+*&-$A:#+*&(1&12$()$*"#$+(-&%.$)(:14%B
*&(1?$ %14$ +(?$ C&*"$ *"#$ 4#<#.(0'#1*$ ()$ %1$ %,2:'#1*%*&<#$ 4&+-(:,+#>$ =#1-#$ &*$
%//=%&#"&%;"<&#;E#&#;/&!"#$"!%&"'&!"#$%$%14$&*'()$*:,1$&1*($%1$#0&+*#'(.(2&-%.$
./%"A.8/&$!&#;/&?."8/%%&"'&E.0A>/!#E#$J/&'"A!BE#$"!&"'&;$%#".$8E@&=!"<@/B0/&E%&
%$0,(4:-*$()$*"#$'(+,)$%14$-(1+-&(:+.3$%.*#,1%*&<#$*($*"#$'3*"$%14$*"#$1(*&(1$()$
KL*M6&,-.$/)-&'E.D./E8;$!01I&#;E#&$%I&E&=!"<@/B0/&#;E#&./%A@#%&'.">&#;/&E.0A>/!B
*%*&<#$ 4#'%14$ ()$ *"#$ '(+,)$ &1$ C"&-"$ *"#$ )&,+*$ #0&+*#'(.(2&-%.$ ,#)#,#1-#$ *($ *"#$
!E..E#/B&'E8#&$%&$#%&'.E>/<".=-&!"#$%$%14$&*'()>
0-123($4)5$!"#$%?$&*'()?$-.$/)?$#0&+*#'(.(23?$=&+*(,3?$'3*">
D.$(5E#*&<($4#$#+*#$*,%5%E($#+$-(1*,&5:&,$#1$.%$#/0.&-%-&61$4#.$0%0#.$#0&+*#'(.6B
0$8"&NA/&OA/0E!&@E%&!"8$"!/%&B/&()*+&,!"#$%-&./0$P!1&C&23456&,&*'()7$.:2%,8?$
-('($0,&1-&0&(+$4#$,#)#,#1-&%.&4%4$4#$.($,#.%*%4(?$#1$.%$*#'%*&9%-&61$4#.$#+0%-&($
A:#$+#$(0#,%$#1$.%$-(1+*,:--&61$4#.$4&+-:,+($"&+*6,&-($#1$.%$F,#-&%$%1*&2:%>G$
H#2I1$"#'(+$+#J%.%4($#1$(*,(+$*#/*(+?$.%$"&+*(,&%$2,&#2%$"%-#$4#.$6%$7(2-)'%8
7,%+24-2$-9-$-:7,%$+&21&)&-%4($0(,$.%+$1(-&(1#+$4#$!"#$%$3$&*'()$#.$0,&1-&0&($4#$
-(1+*%*%-&61$4#$.(+$"#-"(+$":'%1(+$4#$A:#$*,%*%$-(1+*&*:3K14(.($#1$:1$+(0(,B

G$ H&21&)&-%'(+$-(1$!"#$%$3$&*'()$%.$-(1E:1*($4#.$-%'0($+#'L1*&-($4#$.%$#+0%-&%.&4%4$A:#$
,#'&*#$%$.%$,#2&61$3$%.$.:2%,?$"(,&9(1*#+$4#1*,($4#$.(+$-:%.#+$+#$:5&-%$3?$4#$#+*%$)(,'%?$0,#-&+%$
ENA/@@"&B/&@"&NA/&%/&BE&8A/!#E&/!&@E&!E..E8$P!9&Q&B/8$.&B/&RA@$/!&B/&S"A8;/#I&!"#$%&,8">"&()*T1&
C&(U*56&%/&?./%/!#E!&CE&/!&V">/."9&WA&".$0/!&/%&$!8$/.#"I&?/."&?E./8/&/%#E.&J$!8A@EB"&8"!&@E&
!"8$P!&B/&?.$JE8$P!&,(X*+-&J$ABE19&Y)*+&%/&8"!%#E#E&8"!&V/.PB"#"&C&./%A@#E&B/&A%"&'./8A/!#/&E&
?E.#$.&B/&Z@9&[3456&#$/!/&%A&?.$>/.E&./8A../!8$E&/!&\%NA$@"9&W$!&/#$>"@"0]E&8@E.EI&?E./8/&".$0$!E@B
'#1*#$4#+&21%,$:1$.:2%,$%.#E%4(?$0#,($,L0&4%'#1*#$0:#4#$,#)#,&,$%$-:%.A:&#,$.:2%,>$;9$9&RA@$E!&B/&
S"A8;/#I&^\F?Z.$/!8/&/#&./?.Z%/!#E#$"!%&B/&@_/%?E8/&/!&0./8&E!8$/!`I&/!&a;$@$??/&7A$%E.B&C&b;.$%B
*#..#$M%&9K$N-((,4>8?$<='>$,-:7-)2-&2$-'$>)-:&%&,(:)24-2+?-)'%7-?$D..&0+#+?$O%,&+?$PQGP?$00>$RBGR>

EN-CLAVES DEL PENSAMIENTO, ao VIII, nm. 16, julio-diciembre 2014, pp. 177-201.

Si Helena hubiera estado en Ilin. Khra y tpos en de la Historia griega antigua

179

!"# $"# %&# '()'&"%!*# "'+%!",)-./+0*12# 3"# "%!*# 4)(,*5# -*# 6+%!)(+*# ("4+"("5# 0),)#
"-","7!)#'(+,"()#$"#%&#0)7%!(&00+.7#"'+%!",)-./+0*5#*-#,*(0)#$"7!()#$"-#0&*-#
-)%#*0)7!"0+,+"7!)%#!+"7"7#-&/*(5#"7#'*(!+0&-*(5#,"$+*7!"#"-#",'-")#$"#-*%#7)8
0+)7"%#"%'*0+*-"%#$"#!"#$%#9#&'()*1#:"#);%"(<*#"7#"4"0!)#"7#-)%#!"=!)%#6+%!.(+8
0)%#/(+"/)%#*7!+/&)%#"-#",'-")#,>%#("0&(("7!"#$"#"%!*%#<)0"%5#$+4"("70+>7$)%"#
0)7#"--)#-?=+0*#9#0)70"'!&*-,"7!"#$"#-)%#("-*!)%#,@!+0)8')?!+0)%#9#!(>/+0)%1#:+7#
",;*(/)5#"7#"%!"#'()0"%)#"='-+0*!+<)#7)%#6",)%#6*%!*#*6)(*#-+,+!*$)#*#);%"(8
<*(#"-#*&,"7!)#0&*7!+!*!+<)#$"-#",'-")#$"#"%!)%#!?(,+7)%#%+/7+4+0*!+<)%#$"-#,*(8
0)# $"# ("4"("70+*# $"# -)%# *%&7!)%# 6&,*7)%# 0),)# 4&7$*,"7!)# '*(*# A')(# &7#
!"#$%& '()"!"*& !"& $*+(,-".+/,& ('0".+"!& #(& !"& +,#"1".+/,& '$2*(& !$& 345",$& 678&
9:;<=>?@A:B&&+,%-&"$#(./)-B#"7#"-#'"7%*,+"7!)#/(+"/)#*7!+/&)5#*%@#0),)#A')(#
$-*$&!"#$%&"C",D"*&(,&!"&.$50*(,'+/,&#(!&.4('-+$,"*&".(*."&#(!&(,-(&(,&E..+8
$"7!"1C# D*# !*("*# E&"# 7)%# *%+/7*,)%# "7# "-# '("%"7!"# !"=!)# "%# *<*7F*(# "7# -*#
'()4&7$+F*0+.7#9#0)7%)-+$*0+.7#$"#"%!*#'"(%'"0!+<*#"='-+0*7$)#$"#E&?#,*7"(*#
9#0)74)(,"#*#E&?#0)74+/&(*0+)7"%5#-)%#<)0*;-)%#!"#$%#9,&'()*#0)7%!+!&9"7#"-#
,"$+)#-?=+0)#E&"#6*0"#')%+;-"#'*(*#-*#6+%!)(+*#)4("0"(#&7*#*-!"(7*!+<*#"'+%!",)8
-./+0*#4("7!"#*#-)%#$+%0&(%)%#,@!+0)8')?!+0)#9#!(>/+0)1#:"#!(*!*#'&"%#$"#(";*%*(#
"-#,*(0)#0)7%!*!*!+<)#$"#-*#+,')(!*70+*#0&*7!+!*!+<*#$"#-*#'("%"70+*#$"#-)%#("4"8
(+$)%#!?(,+7)%#"7#-)%#!"=!)%#6+%!.(+0)%#/(+"/)%#"7#-*#'"(%'"0!+<*#A*6)(*A#$"#
+7$+0*(#"-#"-","7!)#"'+%!?,+0)#%);("#"-#0&*-#%"#--"<*#*#0*;)#-*#')%!&-*0+.7#$"-#
,*(0)#$"#("4"("70+*#0),)#'(+70+'+)#"'+%!",)-./+0)#$"#0)7%!*!*0+.7#$"#-)%#6"8
06)%1#G)%#'()')7",)%#"7#"%!"#!(*;*H)#$"%!*0*(#0.,)#"-#'()0"%)#("4"(+$)#"%#"-#
("%&-!*$)#$"-#0&"%!+)7*,+"7!)#*(/&,"7!*!+<)#0*(*0!"(@%!+0)#$"#-*#()01*#/(+"/*5#
$"-#0&*-#-*#6+%!)(+*#4)(,*#'*(!"5#$)7$"#-*#$"-+,+!*0+.7#$"#-)%#6"06)%#"7#&7#,*(8
0)#"%'*0+*-#$"#("4"("70+*#,"$+*7!"#-*%#7)0+)7"%#$"#!"#$%#9#&'()*#)4("0"#&7*#
*-!"(7*!+<*#"'+%!",)-./+0*#*-#'();-",*#$"#-*#("4"("70+*-+$*$#9#-*#$"4+7+0+.7#$"#
-)%#0)70"'!)%#0*(*0!"(@%!+0)#$"-#$+%0&(%)#'("')-@!+0)5#H&(@$+0)8')-@!+0)#9#!(>/+0)1
2# I)7#J6"06)%K5#J*0)7!"0+,+"7!)%K#9#J*%&7!)%#6&,*7)%K#%"L*-*,)%#-*#,*!"(+*#$"#-*#6+%!)(+*#

1*+(1"&",-+14"&F4(&'(&*('45(&(,&!"&G$*54!".+/,&H7I&J?:KL?:M&NO&9:;<P>=:Q&#(&R(*/#$-$&6SB&H0*(8
4*0+)KBM#23$1#7)!*#NO1
C# P%!*# !"%+%# -*# 6",)%# $"%*(()--*$)# '(+70+'*-,"7!"# "7# $)%# !"=!)%Q# JR+%!)(+*# 9# /")/(*4@*1# P-#
4&7$*,"7!)#"'+%!?,+0)#$"#%&#0),'-","7!*(+"$*$#"'+%!",)-./+0*K5,(,&T$*+'&T(*(,D$,&U$*,&V&U($*8
/+7*#I*-$"(.7#S(*/.7#T"$%1B5#4))$5.-%5%*,*)21%0.*6,78*,%008,5.0,&1.7(),9,5.0,.*(%21)5#U7+<"(%+$*$#
$"#-*#I+&$*$#$"#V?=+0)8W7%!+!&!)#X*7*,"(+0*7)#$"#Y")/(*4@*#"#R+%!)(+*5#V?=+0)5#2OOZ5#''1#22C82N[#
9#J:"#$%,"7,"-#'"7%*,+"7!)#*7!+/&)K5,"7,T$*+'&T(*(,D$,&V&U($*1+,"&W"!#(*/,&6(#'XYB&;1221)-%$1),
<1.7()=*(%21)5#!1#W5#U7+<"(%+$*$#G*0+)7*-#S&!.7),*#$"#V?=+0)5#V?=+0)5#2OO[5#''1#2\\82]\1#43$1#
Z"52+[,&(!&."0\-4!$&S]B&0"*^1*"G$&__B&+,.+'$&H`P<MB&7a>Ab&V&>c<Mb!T"%'*0+)5#-&/*(#9#-@,+!"B1#:"7!+$)#
/")/(>4+0)#$"#-*%#;*%"%#0)70"'!&*-"%#$"-#'()0"%)#6+%!.(+0)#$"#-*#$"%0(+'0+.7#9#*'()'+*0+.7#$"-+,+8
!*!+<*#$"-#,&7$)K5#$"#7&"%!()#-+;()#=*(%21)6,0>?%$,9,7>-5)@,=0,3>-5%7.-&),&)()0'?12),5.,0%,A)5.$B
-15%5,9,0)*,)$/?.-.*,5.,0%,7>-51%01C%21'-5#U7+<"(%+$*$#G*0+)7*-#S&!.7),*#$"#V?=+0)5#V?=+0)5#2O^^5#
''1#C\[8NOO1
EN-CLAVES DEL PENSAMIENTO, ao VIII, nm. 16, julio-diciembre 2014, pp. 177-201.

180

Ren Cecea

!"#"$%&&'$(#')%*%#%+',$(#-+%#'$"$*"#$).%/0"$*%$&"$1'#+"$%/$2.%$,%$-/,)#-3
4%/$"&$-/0%#-'#$*%&$*-,).#,'$+50-)'3('60-)'$&",$1'#+",$*%$0%+"0-7")-8/$*%&$%,("3
)-'$ 2.%$ %/$ 6&$ '4,%#9"+',:$ %,0'$ %,:$ &"$ 1'#+"$ %/$ 2.%$ %/$ %,0%$ *-,).#,'$ ,%$
!"#$%&'()*+,*&)+,!-.#*)#%&)*)$/,!-"*(*01234*5!"#$%&;:$",5$)'+'$%&$("(%&$2.%$
%,0"$#%&")-8/$<.%="$%/$,.,$+%)"/-,+',$*%$)'/,0#.))-8/$*%$)'/')-+-%/0'>$?#",$
%&&'$#%9-,"#%+',$&",$)'/1-=.#")-'/%,$2.%:$,'4#%$&"$4",%$*%$&',$"&)"/)%,$%(-,0%3
+'&8=-)',$*%$&"$)#50-)"$('&50-)"$@A$",5$"#=.+%/0"0-9"@$2.%$&"$0#"=%*-"$,-=/-1-)":$
&"$%,(")-"&-*"*$"*2.-%#%$%/$%,0%$*-,).#,'>$B,$1-/"&+%/0%$,'4#%$%,0"$4",%$2.%$
('*#%+',$C")%#$./"$)'/1#'/0")-8/$)'/$&",$)'##%,('/*-%/0%,$)'/1-=.#")-'/%,$
*-,).#,-9",$*%$&"$C-,0'#-"$("#"$%&$)",'$*%&$%+(&%'$*%$'$()*$A$#+,%&:$*%$+"/%#"$
"$-/*-)"#$%&$("(%&$%(-,0%+'&8=-)'$2.%$%,0",$/')-'/%,$*%,%+(%D"/>
E'+%/)%+',$)'/$0"&$1-/$('#$%F(&-)"#$2.6$%/0%/*%+',$('#$*-,).#,'$+50-)'3
('60-)'$A$)8+'$,%$#%&")-'/"$6,0%$)'/$&"$0%+"0-7")-8/$*%&$%,(")-'>$G-$%,0"+',$
)"#")0%#-7"/*'$)'+'$+50-)'3('60-)'$"$%,0%$*-,).#,'$2.%$.4-)"+',$%/$%&$(%#5'*'$
2.%$ 9"$ *%$ 1-/%,$ *%$ &"$ &&"+"*"$ B*"*$ H%*-"$ =#-%="$ I,-=&',$ JKK3KJ;$ "&$ -/-)-'$ *%$
)'/,0#.))-8/$ *%$ &"$ ,')-%*"*$ ('&50-)"$ I,-=&',$ LKKK3LKK;:$ %,$ ('#$ 2.%$ 9%+',$ %/$ %&$
!"#$%&$ @%/0%/*-*':$ ,%=M/$ "#=.+%/0"#%+',:$ )'+'$ ("&"4#"$ %F(&-)"0-9"@$ &"$
!"#6-!-.#*6)*/"$-7-+-6,6*6)+*%&,7,8"*6)*9,7&-!,!-.#*:')*+,*;3<=>?4*5,%-.&/&;$,-=3
/-1-)">N$E'/,0"0"+',$%/$%1%)0'$2.%$%&$#%&"0'$*%&$"%*'$%,$%/0%/*-*'$)'+'$O("&"3
4#"P$"$&"$2.%$,%$&%$*%/'+-/"$!"#$%&>$B/$&"$01-*2*:$KJ:$NNQ$I("#"$)-0"#$./$%<%+(&'$
*%$0"/0',$(',-4&%,;:R*@"A)&"*)B/&)$,C*DE/,&,*:')*%)*)#$)F,&,G*,*$)&*6)!-6"&*6)*

N* DHI)* J&))K* L"&6* 9"&* /")%&(M* ,%/.&/&M* A),#$* $-A/+(* NA,K-#OPM* ,#6* %I)* /")%* 5,%/.#.&;$ -,$ "$

NA,K)&PQM*R"I#*S,&-#!"+"M*D@)&"6"%'$*,#6*%I)*/")%&(*"9*%I)*/,$%QM*)#*T,&"+(#*U)L,+6*(*R"I#*S,&-#3
)'&'$I%*,>;:$3$456*!7)/28456%!,*9/%95#%5:4)%2%#;&:$E"+4#-*=%$S/-9%#,-0A$!#%,,:$?C-#*$(#-/0-/=$
L-%I*!"&&)!%-"#$M*T,A7&-6O)M*VWWXM*/Y*Z[\*DE]G*+)$*%^A"-O#,O)$*-#6-!-)+$*6'*/,$$^*"99)&%$*/,&*'#*
T'+U#%$,'/0$-,,.,$*.$0#"9"-&$*%$1"4#-)"0-'/$I,%-4&/&;$(#'(#%$".$('U0%$2.-$#6)-0%V$W$)%$0-0#%:$&%,$")0-'/,$
/"##6%,$,'/0$&X'4<%0$*"/,$&%.#$'#="/-,"0-'/$*X./$%+4%&&-,,%+%/0$)%#0"-/$I'%&!.&*/;P:$E&".*%$E"&"+%:$
<)*#/=;4&5,%>#/=;4&52451*5!>!%/)4?5@4,)>&49#*#/%952451A4&,*B4C#4!,&5495D)EB45*9B/4994:$Y*-0-'/,$
*%$&"$*6)'.9%#0%:$!"#5,:$Z[[\:$((>$R]$A$RZ>
R$ T'+%#'$%,$%&$(./0'$*%$("#0-*"$'4&-="*'$("#"$%&$%,0.*-'$*%&$(%/,"+-%/0'$=#-%='^$(#-+%#$#%3
1%#%/0%$)'/$%&$2.%$)'/0"+',$*%&$+./*'$=#-%='$"#)"-)':$%,$"*%+_,$%&$#%1%#%/0%$("#"$&"$(#'(-"$).&3
0.#"$ )&_,-)"$ =#-%=">$ `$ *%)-#$ *%$ a#"/b'-,$ T"#0'=^$ OB/$ c#U)%:$ 0'.0$ )'++%/)%$ "9%)$ &X6('(6%:$ 0'.0$
,X-/".=.#%$"9%)$%&&%$%0$*%+%.#"$*%,$,-U)&%,$*.#"/0$,'.,$&%$,-=/%$*XT'+U#%>$EX%,0$&W$2.X-&,$/'.,$1".0$
)C%#)C%#$&"$+-,%$%/$(&")%$%0$%/$")0%$*%,$(#-/)-("&%,$)"06='#-%,$*%$&X"/0C#'('&'=-%$=#%)2.%P:$F>C
!%/)452AG1H&&4:$c"&&-+"#*:$!"#5,:$]dd\:$(>$ZQ>$6I)>$-=."&+%/0%$a>$T"#0'=:$O?C%$K/9%/0-'/$'1$T-,0'#A^$
?C%$!#%3T-,0'#A$'1$"$E'/)%(0$1#'+$T'+%#$0'$T%#'*'0.,P:$%/$:/&#%)H5*9253$4%)H:$9'&>$Qd:$/M+>$Q:$
')0.4#%:$Z[[[:$((>$Qee$A$Qed^$OK/$c#%%)%$"&&$4%=-/,$f-0C$0C%$%(-)>$g-0C$-0:$0C#'.=C$-0:$0C%$?#'<"/$g"#:$
fC-)C$1'#$0%/$A%"#,$(-00%*$0C%$`)C%"/,$"="-/,0$0C%$?#'<"/,:$4%)"+%$0C%$h"F-"&X$%9%/0$,-0."0%*$"0$0C%$
%*=%$'1$C-,0'#AP>$i"$01-*2*$A$&"$J2/&4*$).%/0"/$)"*"$./"$)'/$"&#%*%*'#$*%$Z[[$#%).##%/)-",$*%&$
9')"4&'$!"#$%&>$B/$%&&",$,%$'4,%#9"$%&$,%/0-*'$"2.5$%F(#%,"*'$*%$!"#$%&$)'+'$*%)-#$,-=/-1-)"0-9'$
@h("&"4#"X@$)'/$%&$2.%$%&$"%*'$%,0#.)0.#"$%&$*-,).#,'>$i"$&-,0"$*%$#%).##%/)-",$*%$!"#$%&$(.%*%$
EN-CLAVES DEL PENSAMIENTO, ao VIII, nm. 16, julio-diciembre 2014, pp. 177-201.

Si Helena hubiera estado en Ilin. Khra y tpos en de la Historia griega antigua

181

!"#$%&!"!#$%&'!()!*#+#,#-./0!'"#$%&!)-1!-)234!-)!()-5')4()!()!)-%)!"!&%'&-!
6&4%)7%&-!()!$-&1!85#9#:'#.1!$4;(#(!-;24;<;6#%;=#!)4!:$-6#!()!(#'!6$)4%#!()!9#-!
*#+#,#-!>$)!)75')-#!=&6#9?)4%)/!@#!5')2$4%#!>$)!():)!6&4-)6$)4%)?)4%)!
')-5&4()'-)!5#'#!6&?5')4()'!)9!()6;'!()9!!"#$%&!)-A!B>$C!-)!:$-6#!)75')-#'!
!"#$%&$'&%&()&$*+,$,%$-./"$0.1#.2.!&3$4-'%.&-,#/,$!"#"!.5"$,0$,%$').-,)$6,)0"$
()!9#!()*+,+A!8@#!6D9)'#1!6#4%#1!(;&-#1!()9!E)9;(#!F>$;9)&./G!F9!<&'?$9#'!9#!6D9)'#!()!
F>$;9)-!()-()!)9!;4;6;&!>$)!4&-!;4%'&($6)!#9!6#4%&1!-)!4&-!;4(;6#!)9!;4%)'C-!"!9#!
;?5&'%#46;#!>$)!)9!5&)%#!6&4<;)')!#!9#!6&?5')4-;D4!()!9#!')#9;(#(!*$?#4#!)4H
%)4(;(#!6&?&!)-%#(&!#4I?;6&!>$)!')-5&4()!#!9#-!-;%$#6;&4)-!>$)!6&4<'&4%#1!
/"-&#5"$&*+7$!"-"$8.%"$/,-9/.!"$&$%&$:;<=>$?!-./&A!6D9)'#J/K!L#9!)-%#(&!#4I?;H
!"$,0$%"$*+,$@"-,)"$5,#"-.#&$AB:C>$?#$0!1&J1!)9!;?5$9-&!()!=;(#1!)9!6$#9!)-1!
5&'!9#!%)?#%;+#6;D4!>$)!6&499)=#!"!9#!<')6$)46;#!()!-$!)?59)&1!$4&!()!9&-!5';4H
6;5#9)-!6&46)5%&-!()!9#!()*+,+!"!()!9#!2,/&3+M!()!*)6*&1!#!4$)-%'&!)4%)4()'1!)9!
6&46)5%&!6)4%'#9A!-;!:;)4!)9!%)?#!()!9#!()*+,+!)-!9#!!-./&!()!F>$;9)-!N456/!4&%#!
GJ1!-$!6#?5&!()!;4(#2#6;D4!"1!#-I1!()!)759;6#6;D4!)-!)9!#$0!1&!)4!%#4%&!>$)!
%)?#%;+#6;D4!()9!)-%#(&!#4I?;6&!6&?&!(;-5&-;6;D4!<')4%)!#!9#!')#9;(#(!>$)!-)!
6&4<'&4%#/O!@#!%'#($66;D4!%'#(;6;&4#9!()!#$0!1&!)-!(;=)'-#A!#9;)4%&1!=;(#1!#9?#1!
)-5I';%$1!?)4%)1!%)?5)'#?)4%&1!6&'#P)1!6&'#+D41!;469;4#6;D41!()-)&/QR!@#!#?59;H
6&4-$9%#'-)!)4!9#!5S2;4#!()!9#!E)'-)$-!T;2;%#9!@;:'#'"1!*%%5AUUVVV/5)'-)$-/%$<%-/)($U*&55)'UV&'(<')
*3%&#1D1),,EF%""E+'D-+GHI*"0
0$ :JAK<$ LM$ NOL;P$ Q:M<R=$ SPOTL;PR$ LM$ QPUK<V$ W,)0.X#$ !&0/,%%&#&$ 5,$ Y+(Z#$ ["#.2&\$ ]+^"_$
WXFY_$[.(%."/8,!&$`!).'/")+-$a)&,!")+-$,/$Y"-&#")+-$b,c.!&#&_$bZc.!"_$deefV$g&$6,)0.X#$),H
2,).5&$8&$0.5"$,#$,0/,$!&0"$%,6,-,#/,$-"5.2.!&5&$'&)&$.#!%+.)$:JAh>$,#$0+$1)&27&$1).,1&$i$,6.5,#!.&)$
&07$0+$,-'%,"V$g&$/)&5+!!.X#$5,$["#.2&\$]+^"$5.!,$&$%&$%,/)&j$k'&)&$*+,$/,$,#0,^&)&l$m&$0,)$5,!.5")$
()!5#9#:'#-!"!#$%&'!()!*#+#,#-./!
G$ n;<=<$oM=pM$AMq$rOsOtqpMK$uv=s;h>V
K! 8Z*)4![&?)'!5'#"-!%&!*;-!&V4!Y$-)!%&!-;42!%*)!!-./&!&<!F6*;99)-!-&4!&<!E)9)$-1!*)!-)%-!;4!
-"/."#$/8,$,#/.),$0/")i_$.#6"E.#1$/8,$5).6.#1$/8,-,$&#5$8,&5.#1$),%,#/%,00%i$/"w&)5$/8,$.#,6./&(%,$
6&469$-;&4!#4(!-)9<H')#9;+#%;&4!&<!%*)!-%&'"./!\')2&'"!X#2"1!8]&')V&'(.1!;4!@)&4#'(!Y$)994)'1!7$38
9.:368%5894$/))3&;8'-./&8/.8<633=8>?/41!^&'4)99!W4;=)'-;%"1!_%*#6#1!QOO01!5/!`__/
O! X&-!(;-%;42$;?&-!6&4!)99&-!()!9#!;4%)'5')%#6;D4!()!\')2&'"!X#2"!"!()!@)&4#'(!Y$)994)'!N7$38
9.:368%5894$/))3&@1!%?;84/#/J1!>$;)4)-!-)!9;?;%#4!#!;4(;6#'!9#!!-./&!a-;4!($(#!#92$4#!6)4%'#9!)4!)9!
-)4%;(&!>$)!)99&-!;4(;6#4!()!%)?#!()!9#!()*+,+a!5#'#!-),#9#'!a4&-&%'&-a!)9!<&4(&!6&46)5%$#9!
-&:')!)9!6$#9!)9!%)?#!-)!()-#''&99#!"!#!5#'%;'!()9!6$#9!#(>$;)')!-$-!6&4<;2$'#6;&4)-A!#$0!1&/
QR$ x%$5.!!."#&)."$g.55,%%y`!"//yz"#,0$?@,#)i$a,")1,$g.55,%%_$Y"(,)/$`!"//_$ 98<633=A>.:)/&$8
B3C/4%._$),6.0,5$&#5$&+1-,#/,5$/8)"+18"+/$(i$`.)$@,#)i$`/+&)/$z"#,0_$w./8$/8,$&00.0/&#!,$"2$Y"H
5,).!E$b!{,#\.,_$|%&),#5"#$}),00_$~c2")5_$e$5,$&8")&$,#$&5,%&#/,$&(),6.&5"j$g`z1!5'&5&4)!
9#-!-;2$;)4%)-!#9%)'4#%;=#-A!F/!&%0)D8&?/6/#1!#-!#$38?6/.4/?)38%58)/53D8533)/.:8+.,8#$%0:$#1!)-5/!%58&#6%.:8
533)/.:8+.,8?+&&/%.$ ?).18/%i$ 5,).6,5$ 2)"-$ AJK$ kl$ V$ .#$ '8i0.!&%$ 0,#0,_$ E63+#$D8 )/53$ kl$ dV$ &?/6/#D8
&#63.:#$$kl$HV$kl$$3+6#$kl$V$&%0)_$&0$08"w#$(i$/8,$2,,%.#10$&#5$'&00."#0$&#5$0"$kl$V$,3&/63!
&'!/.4)/.+#/%._$,0'V$5,0.),$2")$-,&/$&#5$5).#E_$+??3#/#3_$kl$dV$!/.,D8#3!?36D8F/))$kl$HV$&?/6/#D84%06+:3!
kl$V$#$38&3+#8%58+.:36$kl$fV$#$38$3+6#_$&0$/8,$0,&/$"2$/8,$,-"/."#0_$,0'V$"i$")$1).,2_$kl$V$!/.,D8
&%0)D8+&8#$38&3+#8%58#$%0:$#$klV$WZ&0,$&%$),0',!/"$%&$!%&0.2.!&!.X#$')"'+,0/&$'")$|&)"%.#,$}V$|&0w,%%j$
EN-CLAVES DEL PENSAMIENTO, ao VIII, nm. 16, julio-diciembre 2014, pp. 177-201.

182

Ren Cecea

!"#$#%$%&!%$'()*+$&%),-!.'+$/%&*+-#%$(0$1%'1+$2"%$!"#$%&$%&$%0$(&.%-!+$#%$
0(&$%)+'.+-%&$%3$.-'0"&+3$#%0$*%-&().%-!+3$0+$2"%$1('%$#%0$!"#$%&$1+)4/.'+$%0$
0"5(/$*/.6.0%5.(#+$#%$0($.-#(5('.7-$&+8/%$0+$1")(-+9::$;&$%-$<"-'.7-$#%0$$'!"(&$
2"%$%0$*+%!($=$0($&+'.%#(#$2"%$0+$%&'"'1($+/#%-(-$&"$/%(0.#(#3$#.&*+-.%-#+$%0$
!"#$%#&"'()'!"#!)*&"+',%)'-%#(.#'/.'!"#+&0%!!12#'()'+%'3%#("4'.+5'!"#'6789'
>)%(&4' 1#&)/)!&":;' <=>?9' @$*!+&4' A.B1/1(.(' *0C!&1!.:;' DEFG' @,&-."*?$ @(0)(AB3$
HI86JK?9'@,"/()01+&?$/%<0%C.7-$*/,'!.'(B9$D%$(1E$&"$.)*+/!(-'.($%-$0+&$*+%)(&$
1+)4/.'+&?$0($234565$%&$"-($.-#(5('.7-$=$"-($*/+*"%&!($#%$'+)*/%-&.7-$#%0$
!"#$%&$&%5F-$&%$%C*/%&($%-$G2".0%&$=$H4'!+/$'+)+$&"&$*%/&+-(I%&$*/.-'.*(0%&9$
7'!"(&$%&$#%$%&!($<+/)($0($6E($#%$%C*0+/('.7-$#%08!"#$%&3$=$'+-$%00+3$%0$)+#+$
#%$(''%&+$($0(&$%&!/"'!"/(&$<"-#()%-!(0%&$#%$0+$1")(-+$%-$"-$'+-!%C!+$#%$
'+-&!/"''.7-$#%$'+-+'.).%-!+&$2"%$/%&*+-#%$($0+&$)%'(-.&)+&$#%$%-"-'.('.7-$
#%$0($*(0(8/($(/'(.'($(0$.-!%/.+/$#%$"-$*/+'%&+$#%$!/(-&<+/)('.7-$=$#%$'+-&!.!"J
'.7-$#%$"-($&+'.%#(#$*+0E!.'(3$%&!+$%&3$#%$"-($&+'.%#(#$2"%$'+).%-K($($*%-J
&(/&%$%-$!4/).-+&$#%$("!+.-&!.!"'.7-$=3$*+/$!(-!+3$#%$0($'+-&%'"%-!%3$=$($&"$6%/$
-%'%&(/.(3$8F&2"%#($=$'+-&!/"''.7-$#%$"-$<"-#()%-!+$&+8/%$%0$'"(0$0($&+'.%#(#$
#%8%$=$*"%#%$.-&!.!"./&%9:L$7'!"(&$%&3$*+#%)+&$'+-'0"./3$0($*(0(8/($2"%$8"&'($
LMA)'#))('-"0'&A"0"%NA#)++'.#('!"#+1+&)#!O'+%NN)+&)('.#'.(.*&.&1"#'"-'PQA3)R+'+O+&)3'-"0'&A)'
!.&)N"01S.&1"#'"-'*.++.N)+'.!!"0(1#N'&"'&A)'&O*)'"-'!"#&)T&'1#'UA1!A'VE<79'"!!%0+W'B%&'+1#!)'X'U1+J
1%#$!+$(#1%/%$(&$'0+&%0=$(&$*+&&.80%$!+$!1%$('!"(0$'(!%5+/.%&$+<$<"-'!.+-3$.!$&%%)%#$-%'%&&(/=$!+$(#$
!M+$(##.!.+-(0$+-%&9$N1%$'(!%5+/.%&$(/%$(&$<+00+M&?$:B$0+&&$+<$'+-&'.+"&-%&&O#%(!1$LB$!1%$'+5-.!.6%$
+/$.-!%00%'!"(0$<"-'!.+-$PB$!1%$%)+!.+-(0$<"-'!.+-$QB$!1%$#%0.8%/(!.6%$<"-'!.+-3$(-#$RB$!1%$<"-'!.+-$+<$
3"&1Y.&1"#'Z[\'X&'U1//'B)!"3)'!/).0'&A.&'.&'&A)'*)01"('(%01#N'UA1!A'&A)']"3)01!')*1!+'U)0)'B)1#N'
-"03)(;' VE<79' U.+' .&' &A)' -"%#(.&1"#' "-' )Y)0O' 1#&)0#./' )T*)01)#!)' "0' 3.#1-)+&.&1"#^;' 98 :!#6-8 (;$
N1")+&$+)8<5/3-8=/11.8<,+>;'_`'a`'P01/;'MA)'b)&A)0/.#(+;'cdde:;'**`'fghW'>;/9$*$::9
::$ @?"#$(&$.&$!1%$&%(!$+<$!1%$M1+0%$*/('!.'(0$'+-&'.+"&-%&&3$</+)$.-&!(-!$/(5%$(-#$*(.-$!+$
*0(--.-5$(-#$#%0.8%/(!.+-$+-$!1%$8(&.&$+<$0%&&+-&$0(8+/.+"&0=$0%(/-%#9$N1.&$*/('!.'(0$.-!%00.5%-'%3$.-$
H+)%/3$.&$*/%&%-!%#$(&$($&.-50%$*1%-+)%-+-$(-#$(!$!1%$&()%$!.)%$M.!1$%C!/(+/#.-(/.0=$&"8!0%$.-!%/J
-(0$#.<<%/%-!.(!.+-S$($'(/%<"0$!(C+-+)=$+<$!1%$M1+0%$/(-5%$+<$6%/8(0$.#%(&$(&&+'.(!%#$M.!1$!"#$%&$
M+"0#$ /%6%(0$ !1%$ '+)*0%C.!=$ +<$ !1%$ .)*0.'.!$ %)*./.'(0$ (-(0=&.&$ (-#$ M+"0#$ .00").-(!%$ )"'1$ .-$ !1%$
*")3+^;'a.3)+'i`'j)(-1)/(;'@5!#/185)68A#3!#/18+)8!"1823+56B8!"18?/5C16-8(;8D1>!(/3$N1%$T-.6%/&.!=$
+<$U1.'(5+$V/%&&3$U1.'(5+3$:WXR3$*9$:XQ9
:L$ Y%!+)()+&$%&!($'+)*/%-&.7-$#%0$*/+'%&+$#%$'+-&!/"''.7-$#%$0($,(3+&$5/.%5($'+)+$@("!+J
1#+&1&%!12#'.0N%3)#&.(.^' @)/' .*)/.&1Y"' )+' #%)+&0":' ()' a`' k`' l)0.#&' O' ()' m`' m.+&"01.(1+4' Ln1' #"%+'
6+"0+-&$#/%&&%/$0Z('!%$#%$-(.&&(-'%$#%$'%!!%$Y(.&+-$5/%'2"%3$&".6/%$0($6+.%$*(/$+[$%00%$($*"$&%$
#45(5%/$#Z"-%$)%-!(0.!4$/%0.5.%"&%3$.-#.2"%/$'%$2"Z%00%$#+.!$("$)=!1%$%!$'+))%-!$%00%$0Z($#4*(&&43$
.0$-+"&$<("!$'+)*(/%/3$'+-</+-!%/$(6%'$0Z(//.\/%J*0(-$)='4-.%-$'%$!+"/-(-!$#"$!"""%$("$!""%$&.\'0%$+[$
0($]/\'%$*/%-#$"-$-+"6%("$#4*(/!$%!$%C*0+/%$0%&$6+.%&$2".$0".$&+-!$*/+*/%&?$4*+2"%$#%$)"!(!.+-$
#4'.&.6%$2"%3$#(-&$0%$)+)%-!$)^)%$+[$!/.+)*1%$0%$&!=0%$+/.%-!(0.&(-!3$I%!!%$0%&$<+-#%)%-!&$#"$/4J
5.)%$#%$0($V+0.&$%!$(&&"/%$*(/$'%!!%$0(_'.&(!.+-$#%$0($*%-&4%$*+0.!.2"%$0Z(6\-%)%-!$#%$0($*1.0+&+*1.%A9$
a).#gk1)00)'l)0#.#&;'E1&8(/+C+)1&8618358,1)&018C/1>F#13$V/%&&%&$T-.6%/&.!(./%&$#%$`/(-'%3$V(/E&3$
cdof;'**`'p'O'qW'LZ[\'!%.#("'A.B/)3"+'()'()3"!0.!1.;'#"'*)#+)3"+'+13*/)3)#&)')#'/.')T1+&)#!1.'
#%$"-($(&()80%($2"%$#%0.8%/($=$#%'.#%$#%$)(-%/($'+-&%-&"(#(3$-.$%-$0($("&%-'.($#%$"-($#+).J
EN-CLAVES DEL PENSAMIENTO, ao VIII, nm. 16, julio-diciembre 2014, pp. 177-201.

Si Helena hubiera estado en Ilin. Khra y tpos en de la Historia griega antigua

183

!"#$!%&$'!('!"#$%&'!)'*&)*+',-!'*!.&*/0&1/2)'3!'(&'$!&(/3&3'4-.&)&5'!%*$-1*-6
$&1/2)'!)'3/%1-$%+'3!('1-!%*/+)&$'4-.&)+'!)'%-'!"#!$/!)1/&'7$/!7&'&$1&/1&8
9%:5'%/!)3+'!('!"#$%&'!(';-)3&.!)*+'3!('1-!%*/+)&./!)*+'3!('3/%1-$%+'.:6
*/1+6#+<*/1+'=#-!%'!%'!)*!)3/3+'1+.+'1(&>!'3!'(&'$!&(/3&3'4-.&)&',-!'/)3&6
7&=5'!('1+)?-)*+'3!'$!;!$!)*!%'!%#&1/&(!%'3!)*$+'3!('1-&('%!'((!>&)'&'1&@+'(&%'
&11/+)!%'3!'(+%'4+.@$!%'#-!3!'1+)%*/*-/$'-)'!(!.!)*+'$!(!>&)*!'3!'%-'/)3&7&6
1/2)'!)'(&'.!3/3&'!)',-!'1+)'<('%!'3!'1-!)*&'3!'&%#!1*+%'$!(&*/>+%'&'(&'3/%#+6
%/1/2)'&):./1&'3!('%!$'4-.&)+8'A/14+'3!'+*$&'.&)!$&5'(+%'$!;!$!)*!%'!%#&1/&(!%'
3!('3/%1-$%+'%!'+$3!)&)'B'&3,-/!$!)'%-'%/7)/;/1&1/2)'!)';-)1/2)'3!'(+%'>:)1-(+%'
,-!'#-!3&)'!%*&@(!1!$'1+)'(&'/)3&7&1/2)'%+@$!'(+'4-.&)+'&$*/1-(&3&5'<%*&5'&(6
$!3!3+$'3!'(&'#$+@(!.&*/0&1/2)'3!('!"#$%&8
C&''()&*+'!%'!('.!?+$'$!1-$%+'1+)'!(',-!'1+)*&.+%'#&$&'1+.#$!)3!$'(&'
#!$%#!1*/>&',-!'&4+$&'/)3/1&.+%8'D%*&'+@$&'+$7&)/0&'#&$*!'/.#+$*&)*!'E1-&)*/6
*&*/>&'B'1+)1!#*-&(.!)*!'4&@(&)3+F'3!'%-'*$&.&'*+.&)3+'#+$'@&%!'!('>:)1-(+'
!)*$!'!('1-!%*/+)&./!)*+'%+@$!'(&'$!&(/3&3'4-.&)&'1+.+'!"#$%&'B'(&'*!.&*/0&6
1/2)'3!('!%#&1/+8'G+.+'!%'%&@/3+5'!%*!'*!"*+'4+.<$/1+'3&'1-!)*&'3!('$!7$!%+'
3!'%-'#$+*&7+)/%*&'&'H*&1&'*$&%'!('%/*/+'3!'I$+B&5'3+)3!'1+)%!1-!)*!.!)*!'(&'
!"#$%&'()"(*!")+&,-.,&%&'()$(/0&%$)1)",-$%&.)!",2#*$)!"#"3$(*"4)5+&,".)",6)-.6
3!.+%'3!1/$5'!('9,-/(!%'B'!('J<1*+$'3!('3!%#(&0&./!)*+'B'3!'(+%'1+);/)!%5'&,-!('
!)',-!'$,!"-&'E#&(&@$&F5'!"#$%&'E*!.&*/0&1/2)'7$/!7&'&$1&/1&'3!'(&'$!&(/3&3'
4-.&)&F'B'.%&!-&'E(&'*$&>!%:&'3!'$!7$!%+'&'1&%&F'1+);(-B!)8'K-'/)/1/+'!%'B&'
%/7)/;/1&*/>+'!)'!%*!'%!)*/3+'=B'1+.+'4!.+%'/)3/1&3+='!('/)/1/+'!%'!)'!('*!"*+'
4+.<$/1+'!('.+.!)*+'/)3/1&*/>+'3!('*!.&'1!)*$&('E/018')+*&'LFM
728(*$0"6)92,$6)#$):&,*.!&$)+"#):.0;!")+")02%:.,),"(+"!.,)<=>?@AB>=>CD6
E2")$(+23.)"!!$(*")<=?FGHIJD)021)02%:.)+",-28,)+")K!.1$),$L!$+$)$,.#$!M
3&.)<NOPCD)02%:$,)%&2+$+",)+"):.0;!",)1)%.(.%&'),2)*$#$(*")<CQ>C)RGCSD6
1)+.#.!",),2T!&')<UVAW)IXYZCD),&()%2"(*.)"()"#)0$!)*!$*$(+.
+")$,"L2!$!)#$)3&+$)1)"#)!"*.!(.)<CZ[A>CD)+"),2,)%.0-$\"!.,4NO

)&1/2)'!)'!('%!)*/3+';&1*-&('3!('*<$./)+'#+$'#&$*!'3!'-)'7$-#+'!%#!1/&(M'(&'1$!&1/2)'7$/!7&'3!'(&'
3!.+1$&1/&5'3!'(&'#+(:*/1&5'!%'1$!&1/2)'3!'-)&'&1*/>/3&3'!"#(:1/*&.!)*!'&-*+/)%*/*-B!)*!'3!'(&'1+(!16
*/>/3&3P5'G+$)!(/-%'G&%*+$/&3/%5'2-34#*3"+/*3+351*/)+36738*39-$*1-3+39*1:/;)!-5'*$&38'K&)3$&'Q&$6
].(&.6)^.(+.)+")72#*2!$)_%.('0&%$6)`2"(.,)a&!",6)bccd6)--4)efgeb4
NO) hCOBV) Y>i) RCCP=P6) Y>j[V6) =>?kAB>=>C6) lm) YF?V) =>??W) n) =?FGHIJ6) o=Pp) qB>rJm) sPBtC)
=A>?rPIB>C)R=PB[PCu)n)=>??vC)Ow)xCIBy=SC)NOPC)h[APV)UVp)CQ>C)RGCS6)n)=>??W)Ow)z)Gw)oC)=QCA{)
=FIPC)h?GPV)lC)UVAW)IXYQC6)n)|BC@YPC>m)}C)AP)~XHC)UVp)CZ[A>C)AVBSC6)'(88' !5'N6R5''<*1+5'S!6
%.L(.3"!2(*) ;!"3&E2") $+(.*$*&.(") %!&*&%$) &(,*!2"!2(*) $3&+) `4) 9.(!.) "*) K:.0$,) 4) a##"(6)
=)>"!**.!"3)$<1*&&)-.6)5T.!+)7#$,,&%$#)K"*,6)_)K1-.L!$-:".)7#$!"(+.(&$(.6)5.(&&6)ff4)"!,&'()
+").,8)2&,)7$#3.6)98&%.6)SDT5'NUUV8
EN-CLAVES DEL PENSAMIENTO, ao VIII, nm. 16, julio-diciembre 2014, pp. 177-201.

184

Ren Cecea

!"#!"#$%&$#%&'()*"+%'#(,#'-#.%)+-/"012,#1,101"/$#('#-,#)(/"3%#4(#315%#'1,6
!"#$%&'"(')*+,-./'0#'%0#$12'30#'45$60'70('8$%159"#$%/'8$%$':2;0%2/'30#'45$60'30'
)(7)('%#"#0"'"89:;'<35=02'0='0('>#'5(595$#;0(10'9$%$910%5?$32'92;2'@-AB,C-@-)'
<'()*+,('(-=$#>%+&)(#4(#+-0>%'#'(,4()%'?#0%,41012,#@-(#('#"4(+A'#)(.%)B"4"#
;035$(10'0#'@ADEF'G')./0=$#'-#())")9#C%+&)(#@-(#())"#D#@-(#'(#>"#>(0>%#4(#
;H#158#0='9$;5(2=/'<35=02'0='"('I2;J%0'K"0'I$'45=12'GLMN)/'O30(P'NQM-)/'%1"(-=E#
I$' 0R80%5;0(1$32' S' 92(29532' 3540%=2=' $=0(1$;50(12=' I";$(2=' G@-AAT)' MU'
V)WCX@F)'Y+,NZ[/'$=O'92;2'0#';$%'G\)'@*),]/'0#'0=8$952'4$9O2'30'I";$(2=[/:F#
0%,.)%,3"4%#(,#('3(#5)%0('%#8D#('3%#('#/%#.-,4"+(,3"/#(,#(/#'(,314%#4(#,-('6
1%$'5(10%8%01$95^(7'="'35=82=595^('$(O;59$&'_Z,`'Wab*)/'5(359$'S$'0('="'9"$%12'
*()'G0-/%9#H'#5%)#3",3%#0%,%0(4%)#@-(#5%'((#(/#0%,%01+1(,3%#+A'#1+5%)3",3(#
4(#(,3)(#3%4%'$#(/#0%,%01+1(,3%#4(#'G#+1'+%#(,#(/#0%,3(I3%#4(#'13-"01%,('#416
40%=$='G)*-)'cd)F[/'#2'K"0'#0'80%;510'92(e%2(1$%#$=f:J#!"#"'%01"012,#(,3)(#41'6
5%'1012,# ",G+10"# D# ('5"01%# ('# (,3%,0('# )(/(*",3(# (,# /"# 1,4"7"012,#
",3)%5%/2710"#@-(#'(#%5()"#(,#('3"#(5%5(D"$#5-('#'(#0%,'3)-D(#'%&)(#/"#41*()6
'14"4#4(#(I5()1(,01"'#@-(#(/#*1"K(#'17,1.10"#>"01(,4%#5%'1&/(#(/#0%,%01+1(,3%#4(#
/"#)("/14"4#>-+","$#4(/#+2345$9#H'#"'G#@-(#/"#)(.()(,01"#"#/-7")('#(#131,()")1%'#
('3A#5)('(,3(#0%+%#-,%#4(#'-'#(/(+(,3%'#4(#0%,'3)-0012,#4(#-,#41'0-)'%#'%&)(#
/%#>-+",%#D$#0%,#(//%$#4(#'-#0%+5)(,'12,9
L%#3%4"#)(.()(,01"#('5"01"/#31(,($#'1,#(+&")7%$#('3"#1+5%)3",01"9#M/7-,"'#
)(.()(,01"'#('5"01"/('#4(#/"#!"#$%&#0%,'313-D(,#-,#5/",%#4(#"0%+5"N"+1(,3%#
'(0-,4")1%#4(#/"#3(+A310"#0(,3)"/#@-(#"3"N(#"/#41'0-)'%#+G310%65%O310%9#H,#(.(06
3%$#3)('#0/"'('#4(#)(.()(,01"'#('5"01"/('#'%,#%&'()*"&/('#(,#/%'#5%(+"'#>%+O6
)10%'E#)(.()(,01"'#4(G0310"'$#)(.()(,01"'#8@-($#"#5")31)#4(#/%#@-(#"/#)('5(03%#
>(+%'#1,410"4%$#//"+")(+%'8#,2'310"'#D#)(.()(,01"'#3%5%,G+10"'9#!"'#5)1+()"'#
4",#0-(,3"#4(#/"'#)(/"01%,('#4(#5)%I1+14"4$#41'3",01"$#%)1(,3"012,#D#+%*1+1(,6
3%$#/"'#'(7-,4"'#4(#)(/"01%,('#",G+10"'#)('-/3"4%#4(#/"#5)%I1+14"4#%#41'3",01"#
)('5(03%#"#)(.()(,3('#0%,#/%'#@-(#+",31(,(#-,#'.+2($$#+1(,3)"'#@-(#/"'#3()0()"'#
)(.1()(,#"#)(/"01%,('#7(%7)A.10"'$#('3%#('$#"#)(/"01%,('#4(#5")3('#0%,#)('5(03%#
"/#3%4%#0%,'313-14%#5%)#/"#(0-+(,(9#P(/#5)1+()#315%#('$#(,#/"#!"#$%&#5%)#(K(+5/%$#
gh"0!2' 30=90(35^' #$(?i(32=0' 30' #$=' 9";J%0=' 30#' <#5;82' S' =0' 301"42' 0(' 0#'
:;# hjk'3$'9"0(1$'30'#2='=5!"50(10='=5!(5e59$32=&'lf'gG)m-bZn[o,%+3,-62(4%7#8(49$#('59#1,#!"9$#
pqrG#S%f['&'!0(0%$##S/',%+3,-'pqr'sf'!0(0%$##S/'+,&:%)76;(3,-%<7'pqr'+('1I0'#$(3'2e'1I0'tf/'pqr';(3,-%<#
$e10%'G5f'0f'5('=0$%9I'2e['e223'pqr'uf!$='8%f'(f'v*+,-n'+2%62(4%=&,"6;(3,-%<$'2e'1I0'w%00x'I0%20='
$e10%'1I0'1$x5(!'2e'y%2S/'151#0'2e'zS9#59'{859/'pqrP'2e'$'|2%x'JS'l(159#530=f
:F' g}A~.'V+,Cadm,-n-&'0#'=$#$32';$%''0#'0=1>%5#';$%o'G!"9$#Q$#RS=#0%+%#3)"4-0($#"#,-('3)%#5"6
%090%'$90%1$3$;0(10/'k2=>'h"5='z$#42f
:J# T%&)(#/"#)(/"012,#(,3)(#0%,%01+1(,3%#D#*1"K(#*O"'(#(/#/1&)%#D"#)(.()14%#4(#U9#C")3%7#<>?4(#@
,%6"AB)<$$%=#D#(/#/1&)%#4(#V")%/#P%-7>()3D$#C2%6D&E+6(E6!"<$$%3$F6+2%6G+2-(H,&'2#I6J4&H#-&+#(-6(E6
8(4%,A$6!"<$$%</'<Re2%3'(540%=51S't%0==/'"04$'2%x/'sf

EN-CLAVES DEL PENSAMIENTO, ao VIII, nm. 16, julio-diciembre 2014, pp. 177-201.

Si Helena hubiera estado en Ilin. Khra y tpos en de la Historia griega antigua

185

!"#$%&'(#')*+,+-'.&$/#'#%'!0/*1,&'(#'2(1.#&-'#3'#%'"4$/+%'(#%'!+*1&56!"#$%#&'()*+,#
-./,#0,11'&/,*+'#2'%%,#'&#3)'#-,+,&#%,&#+'45&6#0)7*-,&#879:7*#'&07/7+,#7#%7#
+4+/7+'4"#/*#-'#.*+$+3'#3',+.+-'(#8+3(&'+*/9.'%+'7"#//+':'#%'4+/6';0%&'<%'=2(1;
.#&>-'#.*+$+'!/1?+(&'(#'/#7/#.&':'#.!&.+56!<#=717%'%74'*-'6#-'*'4,&#+'*-1,#+'%#
&'()*+,#-./,6#27*+71#'117*-'#%'>,&#+'#%7#/7-1.7?@!A#B7&#1'C'1'*0.7&#-,/,*:4.07&#
+7*#0)'*-7#/,1#&)#/71-'#+'#1'C'1'*-'&#3)'#/'14.-'*#&.-)71#%,#1'C'1.+,#'*#'%#0,*;
>)*-,#+'#%7#.47('*#+'#%7#D.'117E#7&:#/,1#'>'4/%,F#2='1,#879:7#70)+.+,#'*-,*0'&#
>)*-,#7#%,&#'-:,/'&#3)'#879.-7*#%'>,&#G%,&#'-:,/'&#3)'#'&-5*#+.H.+.+,&#'*#+,&#
(1)/,&6#)*,&#+,*+'#&'#8)*+'#I./'1.J*#K#,-1,&#+,*+'#&'#%'H7*-7L?@MN#O*#'%#'&;
3)'47#+'%#+.&0)1&,#4:-.0,;/,P-.0,6#'*#%7#9Q&3)'+7#+'#'%'4'*-,&#'R/%.07-.H,&#
+'%#!"#$%&6#'%#1'C'1'*-'#'&/70.7%#*J&-.0,6#73)'%#'*#3)'#'%#'&/70.,#&'#0,*&-1)K'#
0,*#1'&/'0-,#7%#!"#$%&#K6#/,1#-7*-,6#+'H'%7#'%'4'*-,&#+'#P&-'6#'&#'%#45&#&.(;
*.C.07-.H,@#B,&#,-1,&#+,&#-./,&#%,#&,*#'*#%7#4'+.+7#'*#3)'#%7&#1'%70.,*'&#3)'#
'&-79%'0'*#&'7*#0,4/1'*+.+7&#0,4,#1'%7-.H7&#7#&)#.*+7(70.J*#7*-1,/,%J(.07#K6#
'*#/71-.0)%71#/717#%7#-'10'17#C,1476#7#%7#'0)4'*'#0,4,#%)(71#+'#%,#8)47*,@
S.&0)1&,#3)'#'R-17'#&)#47-'1.7#+'%#4.-,6M!#%7#-17('+.7#-.'*'#-749.P*#0,4,#
97&'#+'#&)#/1,9%'45-.07#7#%,#8)47*,E#'&#/,1#'%%,6#+'#8'08,6#3)'#/)'+'#1'0)11.1#
7%#+.&0)1&,#4:-.0,;/,P-.0,#0,4,#/)*-,#+'#/71-.+7F#%7#.*+7(70.J*#+'#%,#8)47*,#
'&#&)#074/,#0,4Q*@#='1,#*,#&'#-17-7#K76#/717#%7#-17('+.76#+'#70-,&#3)'#)9.07;
+,&#'*#)*#-.'4/,#1'4,-,#K#8'1,.0,#'*(%,971:7#7#%,&#*)'H,&#-.'4/,&#+7*+,#/,1#
'%%,#0)'*-7#+'#%,#8)47*,6#&.*,#+'#/'1&,*7>'&#'*#'%#0,*-'R-,#+'#%7#'()*&6#+'%#
,1"(+(+3&'!+/+'@"1#3'#%'!/&$%#4+'A@"<'#.'#%'B&4$/#C'.#'!1#3.+'#3'%&.'*</41;
3&.'A@"<'#.'%+'.&,1#(+(C-'#.*&'#.-'A@"<'#.'%+''()*&C-'(#'%&'B"4+3&'#3*#3(1(&'
K#0)'&-.,*7+,#7#/71-.1#+'#%,#&,0.7%#0,4,#&)#8'08,#0,*&-.-)K'*-'@MM#O*#'&-'#&'*;

!"' DE'FG'HIJK'LMNOPQRSR'HITUVWV'XYZI[I'\'[JE'FK']^_H`a'bVY'FUPc'bQd'QTR^OTRSa'eFf[ERa-'
\'RMFRg'bQK'IMNhYRf-!T6#//@#!NU#K#!NV
!<' iV^j'kNNRS'PGV'QlVJha-'m[RS'nopRV'IqQrV'sNh^TRV-'\'RtHRS'i[IV-'QuNhPuV'Jh'QhnhfpuJha'vFG'
^lNI[[IVw'\'JxV'Fj'RyRV'Vu[JRf'HhzT`P{VRV'vFG'pfVISHxa-'"6#!!;!U@
!A' QN_|hS'FK'XQx'QIJTYFRa'It`a-'"6#"W@
MN' XNNj' }' PGV' ~q^RQIa' PhJhHI^h' J`Nu^j' buVJIa-' \' ~q^RQIa' JRd' FSz^' FhFIIJIS-' i[zIJRS'
XVFTV-'\'R'PGV'Ff[RP{VRf'QhTRVRa'R'Fj'XVSuVJRa-! T6#//@#MM;MV@
M!# 2B7#-17(P+.'#/1'*+#/,)1#47-.X1'#%7#%P('*+'#8P1,Y3)'@#O%%'#*Z.*H'*-'#*.#%'&#/'1&,**7('&#*.#
%Z.*-1.()'#+'#&'&#/.X0'&@#O%%'#%'&#-1,)H'#+7*&#%'#&7H,.1#0,44)*#+'&#[1'0&#0,*0'1*7*-#0'#3)Z.%&#01,.'*-#
*/#'%#"/'!+..<-'%KB&/1&3'%&13*+13'(#.'B&44#.'(K+"*/#&1.5-'#+31#//#'#/3+3*':'1#//#'1(+%'+;
3)'-6#2B'#&)>'-#-17(.3)'F#I.&-,1.0.-P#'-#-17*&8.&-,1.0.-P?6#'*#+,!"-.-!.!/0123*-.-4.5/67-.047*-44-6# TT6#
B7#SP0,)H'1-'6#=71.&6#MNN!6#/@#<V@
MM' #.'*/+7<(1#.-'$1#3'#3*#3("-'3#'.&3*'!+.'(#.'4:*B#.6'23'!#"*'.&"*#31/'+"',&3*/+1/#'@"#'
%'#('*1'#-17(.3)'#C7.-#&,*#7//71.-.,*#\#%7#C.*#+)##"'#&.X0%'#%,1&3)'#%'#%7*(7('#+)#4K-8'#0'&&'#+Z]-1'#
#3'!/1.#'."/'%#'/<#%'!&%1*1@"#'(#'%+',1*<5-'#+31#//#'#/3+3*':'1#//#'1(+%'+@"#*-'('8.7*!86#T6#=1'C7;
0.,6#/@#"E#2BZ.*H'*-.,*#+'#%7#-17(P+.'#(1'03)'6#+7*&#%Z$-8X*'&#+)##'#&.X0%'6#0'#*Z'&-#/7&#&')%'4'*-#
%7#/1,+)0-.,*#+Z^)H1'&# %.--P17.1'&6# +Z,9>'-&# +'# 0,*&,447-.,*# &/.1.-)'%%'#+'&-.*P&#7)R# 0.-,K'*&#'-#

EN-CLAVES DEL PENSAMIENTO, ao VIII, nm. 16, julio-diciembre 2014, pp. 177-201.

186

Ren Cecea

!"#$%&'%!(')*#"'%+($+$,*%+($-&*.'/%,0*1$/%20*%,$%+0*#*,%/*(%'-$(#'#$/%*,%
&$/%!3(.",$/%!('#"4"$,'&*/%+&',!*'#$/%+$(%*&%."!$5%6'%!(')*#"'7%*,%*8*4!$7%8$(.'%
+'(!*%#*%0,% 4'.-"$%*+"/!3."4$7%0,%4'.-"$%#*%+(".*(%$(#*,%20*%".+&"4'%0,'%
.0!'4"9,%*,%&'%4$.+(*,/"9,%:%*;+&"4'4"9,%#*%&$%<0.',$=%&'%4$,/!"!04"9,%#*%0,%
#"/40(/$%>0(?#"4$@+$&?!"4$%20*%/*%$-/*(1'%*,%*&%#*/+&'A'."*,!$%#*%&'%+'&'-('%
+($83!"4$@#*/4("+!"1'7%40:$%+(",4"+"$%#*%4$,/!(044"9,%*/%&'%",/+"('4"9,%B#*%",1$@
4'4"9,%#*%&$%/0+('<0.',$7%&'/%.0/'/B7%'%0,%#"/40(/$%(*!($/+*4!"1$@!*/!".$,"'&%
*,% *&% 40'&% 4$,$4*(% */% (*4$,$4*(% +(0*-'/7% .'(4'/% 20*% '&% +*(.',*4*(% 4$.$%
1*/!")"$/%+0*#*,%/*(%(*4$,$4"#'/%4$.$%!*/!".$,"$%#*%&$%'4$,!*4"#$%B+*(!*,*@
4"*,#$%'/?%'&%$(#*,%#*%&$/%<$.-(*/5CD%
E;+&"20*.$/%*/!'/%4'('4!*(?/!"4'/%+'('%(*/'&!'(%/0%#"8*(*,4"'4"9,%*+"/!*@
!"#$%&'()*+,(-.!&/&0"*1",*#(.*!2.(.*(#*1"3/(*4567897*:7;<=>*3#*1,&-'&1&"*31&./3!"@
&9)"4$%#*%4$,/!(044"9,%#*&%#"/40(/$%.?!"4$@+$3!"4$%*/%&'%",/+"('4"9,7%*,%*&%40'&%
,$%",!*(1"*,*%,",)F,%+($4*#"."*,!$%#*%+(0*-'%'()0.*,!'!"1'%$%#*%1*("8"4'4"9,%
!*/!".$,"'#'5%E&%4$,$4"."*,!$%',!($+$&9)"4$%'/?%)*,*('#$%,$%*/%*,!*,#"#$%4$.$%
0,%*>*(4"4"$%<0.',$7%*/%0,%*>*(4"4"$%20*%&$%!('/4"*,#*%:%20*%+0*#*%4$,/*40*,@
!*.*,!*%$8(*4*(%*&*.*,!$/%+'('%/0%*;+&"4'4"9,5%G*%!('!'%#*%0,%#"/40(/$%20*7%'&%
*,!*,#*(/*%!('/4*,#*,!*7%/*%4$,4"-*%",*20?1$4$7%+*($%20*7%*,%!',!$%20*%<0.'@
,'.*,!*%.*#"'#$%B/"*,#$%*&%+$*!'%20"*,%40.+&*%*/!*%+'+*&B7%+0*#*%'%&'%1*A%
+(*/*,!'(%+($-&*.'/%#*%",!*(+(*!'4"9,7%#*%'.-")H*#'#5%6'%8('/*%#*%I*/?$#$%*,%
!"#$%&'&()"%B/"*,#$%&'/%.0/'/%20"*,*/%<'-&',B%*/%'&%(*/+*4!$%/"),"8"4'!"1'=%
5?@A*/(-*.$#"*.(B3!".*03'&,*!2'C(.*!3-/&,(.*(*D3,0(0*1(,3'&0(.>*!(.*1"03@
.$/%!'.-"3,7%/"%20*(*.$/7%4',!'(%&'%1*(#'#J%KCL@CMN5CO%G*%!('!'7%+0*/7%#*%0,'%
+'&'-('%+*(/0'/"1'7%'/*(!9("4'%:%'.-")0'7%20*%/*%*,!"*,#*%4$.$%!('/4*,#*,!*%
#*%&$%<0.',$7%+*($%20*%-0/4'%:%+0*#*%B+$(%*&&$7%+(*!*,#"#'.*,!*B%*;+&"4'(@
&$5CP%Q$(%/0%+'(!*7%*&%#"/40(/$%!(R)"4$7%",/*(!$%*,%0,%4$,!*;!$%+$&?!"4$%#*%*&'-$@
'#'+!3/%S%*0;7%.'"/%S%!('1*(/%&*%/+*4!'4&*7%&'%&*4!0(*7%&T"."!'!"$,%*!%&T3!'-&"//*.*,!%#T0,*%!('#"!"$,%
&"!!3('"(*7%&'%4(3'!"$,%#T0,%/0>*!7%#T0,*%4$,/4"*,4*%!(')"20*7%&T'1U,*.*,!%#T0,%<$..*%!(')"20*J7%*+,.%/7%VV7%+5%LD5
CD% G*)0".$/%*,%*/!*%/*,!"#$%K*&%#*/+&'A'."*,!$%#*%&'%+'&'-('%+($83!"4$@#*/4("+!"1'%'%0,%#"/@
40(/$%(*!($/+*4!"1$@!*/!".$,"'&N%&'%&*4!0('%20*%W"4<*&%X$04'0&!%<'4*%#*%E#"+$%(*:%*,%&'/%4$,8*(*,4"'/%
E23*0&'/"*3-*FG"*03*H(-3&,"*3-*IJKL*M*E23*N23,"-*12B#&'(0(.*B(O"*3#*/G/2#"*!"#012,31#%3#4%5#6&2/%5#
782,.,98%55%:625%W"4<*&%X$04'0&!7%;<,4&5&=<,%>#?(3<&4&',%7%Y,!<$&$)"*%3!'-&"*%*!%+(3/*,!3*%+'(%Y(,$&#%
V5%Z'1"#/$,%*!%X(3#3("4%[($/7%['&&".'(#7%Q'("/7%C\\O7%++5%ODO@OD]5
CO* P9Q7R*S7T9U*VWXXY*XZ[78R*Z\TQW8]8R*^QW_U>*P9Q7R*9`>*7a\*Z:bXcQ7R>*dXe:bU*[efT]U]:U8>*
1*(/"9,%4'/!*&&','%#*%Q'$&'%^"',*&&$%#*%_9(#$-'`%I*/?$#$7%$%&'&()"7%E/!0#"$%)*,*('&7%",!($#044"9,7%
1*(/"9,%(?!."4'%:%,$!'/%#*%Q'$&'%^"',*&&$%#*%_9(#$-'7%abYW>*g&B#&"/C3'(*h',&1/",2!*i,(3'",2!*3/*
c$.',$(0.%W*;"4','7%W3;"4$7%dML]5
CP% eZ$!3%#*%4*%/'1$"(%",/+"(37%&*%+$U!*%43&U-(*%+'(%/'%+'($&*%4<',!3*%&*/%*;+&$"!/%*!%&*/%'4!"$,/%
<0.'",*/%20"%*,!(*,!%'",/"%#',/%&T34&'!%*!%&'%&0."U(*%*!%20"%(*f$"1*,!%8$(4*%1"!'&*%*!%+&3,"!0#*%#Tg!(*%
?@A*j2*!&#&32*03*'3//3*'"-N&%2,(/&"-*0`",0,3*!M/C&'"k,3#&%&32l>*?413<%,"%3,$,4*%0,*%13("!3%'//*(!$@
EN-CLAVES DEL PENSAMIENTO, ao VIII, nm. 16, julio-diciembre 2014, pp. 177-201.

Si Helena hubiera estado en Ilin. Khra y tpos en de la Historia griega antigua

187

!"#$%&'()'*)+),'-./"&",'0()'".12$&,1$1.#$%&3'4+'/5,'"6&7')&'.&'#2&1)812'()'
#!$,$,'9.)'),1)':!2+)#12':2*;1$#2'#2&<!2&1"47'<2!/"':"!1)'()*':!2#),2'()'"="&>
(2&2'()'*"':"*"=!"'!$1."*'#.+"'#2&1!":"!1)'$/:*$#"')*'(),"!!2**2'()'1?#&$#",'()'
"!@./)&1"#$%&'9.)'"1$)&()&'"'.&"'*%@$#"'()'*2'A)!("()!2')&1)&($("'?,1"'6*1$/"'
#2/2')&.&#$"#$%&'()'*"':"*"=!"':!)#$,"7'*"':"*"=!"'9.)7'"*',.:)!"!'*"'"/=$@B)>
("('-"#)':2,$=*)'*"'"##$%&':2*;1$#"')<$#"CD'E,9.$*2')8:!),"'),1"'=6,9.)("')&'
A2C'()*'/)&,"F)!2'()'!"#$#%&'()"*+,#G'HI2'2=,1"&1)'#2&')*'<$&'()'9.)')&1)!"(2'
:.)("'-"=*"!'#2&'/5,'#*"!$("('4:.),'1"/=$?&'#2&A$)&)'9.)'.&'-)!"*(2'"&.&>
!"#$!%&%$!'(%$!')$*+#!"(",)-$.!,/'$&#0'$&#!"+1$23456JK'L&'#",2':"!"($@/5>
1$#2'"'),1)'!),:)#12'),')*':!2=*)/"'()'*",'"#):#$2&),'($A)!@)&1),'()'*"'&2#$%&'
&#$789:;<$=-./+0#37'*"'<.)!C"7'9.)':.)()',)!')&1)&($("'#2/2'!)<)!$("'"'9.$)&'
:2,))'*"'".12!$("('*)@;1$/"'()'*"'&0'(#7'$&,1$1.$("')&'","/=*)"7'2'"'*"'<.)!C"'<;>
,$#"'9.)')&',.')F)!#$#$2',)'2:2&)'"'?,1"'+'#.+"'!),2*.#$%&'),'!)9.)!$("':"!"'
("!',)&1$(2'"'*"'"##$%&':2*;1$#"7':"!"'@"!"&1$C"!',.')<$#"#$"DJM'N)/2,')&12&#),'

!$9.)O')**)'),1':.$,,"&#)'(P)<<$#"#$1?7')**)'),1'#!?"1!$#)'(PQ1!)R7'S"!#)*'T)1$)&&)7'!,#$1"2+.,#$3,$456
.(+5$3"*#$'"$7.8),$".)9":;%,>$?'!@#A>$?%+B(>$CDDE>$*6$F6
JK$ GHHI$ J<$ KL$ MNOP<$ GLLQRS$ TUVQT:M8;L>$ W$ X$ 7UY$ Z[8$ R8QRM\$ 7]8^7I$ GRUZZQHHM\L$ :;8_<$ X$
`7UT:U>W$R_<$V_$234>$<=(3D7'::D'UVW>UVJD
JM' EF)/:*2,'($A)!@)&1),'()*')/:*)2'()'-./+0#',2&7')&'!"#$#%&'()"*+,#a$bc#$)'$dd#ec#$f%/g($
%$#(A%+$('/#A"&%$%d$*'&#+$&#$d'($h%+')#($=i]$:j$R;:I$;kL$ZML;jiU\$lR;mMj8;<$X$789:MTM\L$G8TQLSLno$
X"*),',2&'*2,'()#!)12,'9.)'-"&',$(2':!2/.*@"(2,':2!':"!1)'()'*"'#$.("('#2&')*'A212'.&5&$/)'"'
!%+e'$&#d$*c#0d'a$)'$#)A+#e%+$*'+$d%$pc#+q%$%d$e+c*'$&#$/cf#+#($=:;jU$Or$OsitR8U7:;<$u7$RtHMS<$
ijU$X$vwV;<$7Q78UL:U\>$i]R;:I$u7O;xLU\$yjz$X$T:tH;L$Z^LU\7_Ln>$!"#$#%&'()"*+,#7'::D'VUJ7'VUV'+'
D{|}D{{6$~#%)}?"#++#$#+)%)A$$?"#++#$"&%d$%c#A>$%)$'0(#+h%&'$#(A#$#!'$!'/'$A%/0")$#d$
#",2'()'*>10#')&'?*+@A0*"G'HY)'/2/)&1'-$,12!$9.)'()'*"'1!"@?($)')&'Z![#)G'9.)*9.),'#2&($1$2&,'
,2#$"*),')1':,+#-2*2@$9.),R7'H\P),1'9.)'*)'(!2$1'&P),1':",'.&)'#2&,1!.#1$2&'*2@$9.)O'$*',P),1'#2&,1$1.?'
-$,12!$9.)/)&1']':"!1$!'()':!2#?(.!),'^:!?F.!$($9.),P'(2&1'$*',P),1'(?@"@?7'".89.)**),'$*',P2::2,)'
/%"($&')A$"d$+#(A#$#)$*%+A"#$('d"&%"+#$234$#$!#$*'")A$&#$hc#>$d%$B@-C'($A$&)')**)>/Q/)':).1'"::">
!"_1!)' 2:"9.)' )1' $&#2/:!?-)&,$=*)G' )**)' #2/:2!1)7' :2.!' *),' -./"$&,7' .&' ?*?/)&1' $!!"1$2&&)*' ()'
:.$,,"&#)'=!.1)D'`.,,$'A2$1>2&'("&,'*),'D%&&'("*+,#'*"'&21$2&'()'-./+0#'2,#$**)!')&1!)'().8'"##):1$2&,'
#2&1!"$!),G'1"&1a1')**)'(?,$@&)'*P".12!$1?'*?@$1$/)7'.&)'/"$&/$,)'F.!$($9.)/)&1'<2&(?)7'1"&1a1'*"'<2!#)'
=!.1"*)'("&,',2&'",:)#1'()'A$2*)&#)'*)':*.,'2::2,?'".'(!2$1')1']'*"'F.,1$#)D'T)'/Q/)7'("&,'?*+(A06
*,7'*)'/21'*>10#':).1'Q1!)'$&A29.?'"A)#'(),'A"*).!,')8"#1)/)&1'$&A)!,),':"!'*),'($<<?!)&1,':!21">
@2&$,1),D'\)'9.$'/2&1!)'*"'1!"@?($)7'#P),1'.&)'3@-C')&'*.11)'#2&1!)'".1!)'3@-C7'.&'(!2$1'9.$'&P),1':",'
<$8?7'9.$',)'(?:*"#)')&',)'1!"&,<2!/"&1')&',2&'#2&1!"$!)R7'0&E$)(+D7'b7':D'cdD'\2&,6*1),)'1"/=$?&7'
!),:)#12'"'*"':!2=*)/51$#"')&'*"'1!"@)($"'()'*"'()<$&$#$%&'()'*",':"*"=!",'+',.':2()!7')*'1)812'He)>
!2(21.,7'f2:-2#*),'"&('1-)'g2/"&'g-2'g"&1)('-)!'=!21-)!',"A)(R'()'\"!2*+&'T)g"*('+'h"#-)*'
"Aq")e#+>$#)$%+'d)$#%d&$$~')$%+")!'d'$=#&(6n>$0&E$)(+E7'::D'cJJ>cJUG'Hb&'f2:-2#*),'A$,$2&'1-)'
:2g)!'2<'*"&@."@)'12')8:!),,'g-"1'g)'(2'*0+$@)'>$%A$#$%h#$)'A$#*#+"#)!#&>$%A$#$&'$)'A$
p##d>$"($A#++"0d#$%)&$*%")pcd$234$'*'!d#($%($%)$%!cA#$c)&#+(A%)&")e$'p$A#$'p$A#$%$#$!%)$")>
&"h"&c%dd$#/0'&$%)&$#*+#(($%A$#$@)'$%)&$#A$p%"d$A'$!'//c)"!%A#$A%A$A+cA$A'$'A#+(6$cA$
#$%d('$(##($A%A$A#$)%Ac+#$'p$d%)ec%e#$"A(#dp$%dd'($c(>$c)d"@#d>$A'$d%$!d%"/$A'$%A$#$&'$)'A$
@)'$")$'+&#+$A'$!')h")!#>$A'$*#+(c%&#$W")$'+&#+$A'$")$'h#+$'A#+($A'$'c+$*#+(*#!A"h#5$=*6$C|n6
EN-CLAVES DEL PENSAMIENTO, ao VIII, nm. 16, julio-diciembre 2014, pp. 177-201.

188

Ren Cecea

!"#$%&$'()'"#*+&$!"#$&%$(#*'#,+)$#%&-)(&$%&$+(&.#/0&$#*$%&$,(1+0,&$2#3+#3/0/&$
,)4)$%&$'"#*+&$#3$#50/#3,0&26$/#$%&$&4-0.7#/&/$/#%$(#8#(0($41+0,)9'):+0,)$)6$
'&(&$/#,0(%)$#3$#%$%#3."&;#$/#$!"#$%&'()6$#%$,"#*+0)3&40#3+)$/#$0/#&*$#%&-)(&/&*$
&$'&(+0($/#$<'&%&-(&*$4&%$,)4'(#3/0/&*=>?@$A)$!"#$-"*,&$&%,&3B&(*#$#*6$,)4)$
!"#$%&'()"*+,%-./*.#%0+1%23.*./#.'%45')#.!.'%6789:;<=%>?<@AB,?C$'&%&-(&*$,"D)$
(#8#(#3+#$#*$)-;#+)$/#$'(#,0*0E3$24#*"(&-%#2$#3$*"$/#,0(>$F0$#%$,)3),#($3"#9
5)6$#%$,)3),#($/#$%&$$%*#+6$*#$#3+0#3/#$*)-(#$%&$04')*0-0%0/&/$/#$%&$'(#+#3*0E3$
'()8:+0,&$/#%$/0*,"(*)$41+0,)9'):+0,)$G<,)4'(#3/#(H*$!"#$3)$I&D$4)(+&%$#3$&-9
*)%"+)$!"#$')*#&$#%$&(+#$/#$'(#/#,0(=JKL$#*$')(!"#$#*+#$M%+04)$04'%0,&$"3&$,)49
3#51'"C1%!5*%!50"#%()5%5'0.3.%.%*+%-)4.1+%67D=9;EF@%98G=H@A,%'"51!+%51I+105'%
/0,I)$/#,0($&4-0.")$D$)-;#+)$/#$03+#('(#+&,0E3$/#$/05#(*&*$8)(4&*N$%&$03+#('(#9
+&,0E3$/#$%&$'&%&-(&$8"3/&/&$#3$%&$03*'0(&,0E3$(#*"%+&$03)'#(&3+#$#3$"3$,)3+#O9
+)$')%1+0,)$/&/)$#%$,&(H,+#($&4-0.")6$')%0*:40,)$/#$:*+&>$P)+#4)*$&%$(#*'#,+)$
%&*$*0."0#3+#*$8(&*#*$/#$!"#$%&'()N
J.%I5154+'%.*%()5%1+'%*5%-.%!5%!5'0)/#"#%K.*%.'5'"1+L
QI1$3)*$+(&#3$&%$/0503)$'()8#+&
Q%$M30,)$4)(+&%$!"#$%%#5&$%&$5#(/&/$033&+&$#3$#%$&%4&KR
P)$'&()$I&*+&$3)$/&($,)3$%&$#50/#3,0&$D$#%$*&-#(K?
Q"3!"#$#(#*$(#D6$I#4)*$/#$*#($0."&%#*6
')($%)$4#3)*$#3$#%$/#(#,I)$&$,)3+#*+&(SKK

M/'5#N.4+'%51%5**.'%*.%0+1O#+1I.0"C1%!5%)1%'./5#%4$1I"0+,%5*%0+1+0"4"519
+)$/#%$'()8#+&$(#*"%+&/)$/#$%&$03*'0(&,0E3$,)3*+0+"+05&$/#$*"$'(03,0'0)$#'0*+#4)9
*CP"0+%3+#%*+%()5%5*%0+1+0"4"51I+%!5%*.%N5#!.!%*5%5'%Q7?8RSET=%U"1I#V1'50+%.%
*"$$+),-.2$G'(04#(&$8(&*#$&!"1$,0+&/&J6$,)3$#%$,)3),040#3+)$!"#$#*$,)3*+("0/)$
')($#%$*#($I"4&3)$G*#."3/&$8(&*#J6$#%$,)3),040#3+)$')%1+0,)$!"#$#*$#%$(#*"%+&/)$
/#$%&$')*0-0%0/&/$/#$28(#3+#$&%$*&-#(2$"-0,&($#3$"3$40*4)$'%&3)$&%$(#D$D$&%$
,0"/&/&3)N$#%$,)3),040#3+)$#*$#%$,)3),040#3+)$/#$%&$$%*#+6$#%$,)3),040#3+)$!"#$

?@$ /0'>$!"#$%&'(),%WXYZ%[\EH];@%^_=`@%a\_b=%cadT,%e+3-+0*"'%123*46$T#,).3)50+$-(#50!"#$
.!1+I.I"+15%0#"I"0.%"1'I)"fI%gh%ih%j5.#'+1,%kl3+P#.3-5+%i*.#51!+1".1+,%Mf+1"",%Ymnop%N5#'"C1%0.'9
I5**.1.%!5%q+'r%s.#.%t+1.!+Z%eCO+0*5',%5'26("#2+&7%8$*(92+,%5!h%l%I#.!h%!5%q+'r%s.#.%t+1.!+,%
UH+#/(&6$V&/(0/6$RCCL>
?C$ :2+&+3$*#72;9(+,%Yonmp%N5#'"C1%0.'I5**.1.%!5%&1#"()5%u1P5*%v+4+%q)#.!+Z%&'()"*+,%5'26(<
"#2+,%w1I#+!)00"C1,%I#.!h%l%1+I.'%!5%&1#"()5%u1P5*%v+4+%q)#.!+,%g*".1x.%&!"I+#".*,%y.!#"!,%zooYh
KL% 7Dd{%<|=TE{%8]9}%]<;%~:\9T;<=%<=%7D=9;EF@%>G<=%98G=H@,%3h%omh
KR% ^aa{% <Ta8_b=% D9=% >]9;=% <T% _D:% % 9=% dT<=% H% 7=9;=% {% _<S];=,% % % 9^aHd@%
Q7?8RSET=%^=d:?b=%7\=,%33h%zmzmmh
K?% <E%=%?;d<}7H=%7%<%9{%QE7DdT=%]DR@,%3h%YoWnh
KK% T%ED%9S:D==T@,%Q;]b98<=%9%_<=%%]{%^=9;a8D;%9<T%_:%E^_`%E:D9,%33h%oXomh

EN-CLAVES DEL PENSAMIENTO, ao VIII, nm. 16, julio-diciembre 2014, pp. 177-201.

Si Helena hubiera estado en Ilin. Khra y tpos en de la Historia griega antigua

189

!"#!"#$%#$%&%'"#()%'*%'"#+'",%-.#/!#*0&0*121%&)0#%,#%&#%,)%#,%&)130#%&)%&3130#
*020#*0&,)'4**15&#642"&"#7"'"#!0#84%#,%#%,)"9!%*%#4&#7'0*%3121%&)0#&0'2":
)1;0# %&# %!# 84%# ,%# '%*4''%# "# !"# %<7%'1%&*1"# *020# 7'1&*1710# 3%# 3%+1&1*15&# 3%# !"#
7"!"9'"#70!=)1*".#/!!0#!0#*0&,)")"20,#%&#!"#7'%0*47"*15&#2"&1+1%,)"#70'#!"#'%*0:
!"#$%"&'()*(!"+,$+-(./%&01(2$##$3(*#(3$+,314(51331+1(6$4()*(,$'($',"781(%3"0*'9:4(
7"'"#'%)02"'#"#/3170>?@#71,)",#84%#%&#!"#*0&,)")"*15&#3%#!0,#6%*60,#7%'21)"&#
4&#3%*1'#7'%*1,0A#,1&#"291$B%3"3%,.#C%#7","#",=#3%!!%$',$3;"'+!"3$3(<)*#(=>?@>AB4(
&'()'$*C(D!31!"1()*#()"+%83+1(0E,"%1;!1F,"%1D($#(0"3$3;%1'1%*3(<GH@=4("+)&->#,4#
7'%0*47"*15&#%,#!"#*0&,)")"*15&#3%#6%*60,#(21'"':*0&0*%'#3%!#"+)&-#84%A#*0&#
!"#7"!"9'"#7'%*1,"#6"*%#70,19!%#'%9","'#%!#09,)D*4!0#3%#!"#7"!"9'"#2"!#*027'%&:
)")$(<IJBKL(MNJOBC(6(!*30",*(D$#(0*'1+(!3*,*')*D()$3(%8*',$()*(#1(280$'14(
3%#!"#!"#$%#%&#,4#*",0.
E60'"#91%&A#"F&#%&#,4#31+%'%&*1"#'%+%'%&*1"!A#%&*0&)'"20,#%&#!"#)'"$%31"#
)%,)120&10,#3%#3%,*'17*15&#3%!#2"'*0#3%#!0,#6%*60,#*0&,)")"30,#84%#%&#7'12%:
'"#1&,)"&*1"#09%3%*%&#"#!0,#21,20,#7'1&*1710,#3%#*0&,)'4**15&#84%#%&#%!#31,*4':
,0#2=)1*0:70G)1*0A#74%,#!,'-&#'.'#%&#%!!"#4&"#*027'%&,15&#3%#!0#%,7"*1"!#%&#,4#
*"'D*)%'#3%#'%+%'%&)%#&5,)1*0.#H02%20,#%!#*",0#3%#/"%01',%&%#3%#/,841!0A#%&#
)1')*(#$($P*',83$($(,"*33$+(73"*7$+(!13(!$3,*()*#(*QF3%",1(%10$')$)1(!13(R*3Q*+(
,1$&1+1*"'D#,4#3%,$'"*1"A#20,)'"&30#",=#%!#*"'D*)%'#2=,%'0#3%#!0#642"&0.#I"#
71%J"#*021%&J"#*0&#!0,#,1$41%&)%,#;%',0,K
/,)0,#,0&#!0,#+1%!%,#LM#",=#,%#&0,#!!"2"L
)*(#$(28*+,*(!*3+$(S8*($(#$(,"*33$(2*#*'$(<TMMU@V(WLC
!$3,"&(<GXYGZ[BOBC(*'(+1'()*(78*33$\(]1+('1053&(78$3)"$'*+
3%!#7"!"*10A#%&#0'0#M#%&#)%,0'0,#'1*0A
*#(^*6()*(*+,$(,"*33$4(R*3Q*+4('8*+,31(!3E'%"!*4
61N0#3%#O"'=0
_*'+$')1(*'(#$(P8*#,$(<IZ`a(@b(BNcdeC()*#(3*6(6()*#(3"%1(
%NG'*1)0#&4%,)'0A#7'0+%)"#3%#2"!%,
+*(*3"f$(*'(0"(!*%21(0"(*+!E3",8(<ghZiLC(,1)1
DS8*(#$(j8*3f$(*',*3$4(*'(k+"$('$%")$(<lcA=dGJ>BmLC4
*+,n($213$(086(#*Q1+(<oYOp>C4(6($(+8()8*q1(##$0$4
,1&#84%#&4&*"#!!%$4%#*0''%0#0#N1&%)%
"#!"#)1%''"#7")'1"?P

?@( rGs(dN@V(>tu>gvc>d=A(w(xYBGL(r=M=AyL(@hcd[pZ=udGB(=?dX=Lz4(!A#77.#QRS#M#QRT.
?P( {U@>(ZbB(|>uc}B(d}B(G?YGZ[BOB(w(TMMU@V(WL(=H=B(rAcd~(p=M>d=A4(w(p=a(d}B(I`B>}B(p=a(

rGMhYucOB(w(@uUBOB(`M=p>L4(p=d~(ru>c>X=B(w(GL(=diL(B=([uL(=cAM>L(w(=u>AGJ>BmL(
w(>M>dG(Yu=L(W`Gu>>AB\(w(IZ`a(@b(BNcde(d(=cAM>Xe(w(p=a(rGMhYucGh(cdu=dAyL(@(w(p=pNZ=BdAL(
J=B(ucGMGr>d=A(w(ghZiL(cOg>B\(w(ryc=(J~u(?cYL(lcA=dGJ>BmL(w(YOp>4(B[GB(@V(B@u=(=>A4(
w(pGd>(dAL(JJ>MGL(Gd>(dAL(rr>L(w(cdh(di(|>uc}B(I`ApB>d=A4(;\(2,*6M!1A#3'!4'506780%7!',9
%7*40:,&;"')$84(^*%*'+8",("#5*3,8+(833$64(6!173$!2*1(#$3*')1'"$'14(1'""4( (<Cz(
EN-CLAVES DEL PENSAMIENTO, ao VIII, nm. 16, julio-diciembre 2014, pp. 177-201.

190

Ren Cecea

!"#$%&'()*$$+,&#-./#.'0"$+%1#%2'.)3"4%'#"5*61#.'#*&#.7.$(%#-./#$*.'(+%&"8
4+.&(%#0%)#/"#)."/+-"-#9*4"&"1#4.-+"-"#.&#'*#$%40).&'+,&#0%)#./#!"#$%&1#:1#
.&#.'(.#'.&(+-%1#0")(.#-.#'*#+&-";"$+,&#.&#/"#4.-+-"#.&#5*.1#$%4%#.&#./#-+'8
$*)'%#46(+$%80%<(+$%1#'.#-.#$*.&("#-.#"'0.$(%'#)./"(+3%'#"#/"#-+'0%'+$+,&#"&64+8
$"#-./#'.)#9*4"&%#.&(.&-+-"#$%4%#./.4.&(%#.'()*$(*)"&(.#-.#'*#)."/+-"-=#>.#
.&(+.&-.#.&(%&$.'#("42+<&#.&#.'(.#$"'%#/"#)./"$+,&#$%&#./#.'0"$+%#.&#(<)4+&%'#
-.#)./"$+,&#$%&#/"#(+.))"#.&#/"#5*.#'.#3+3.1#$%&#/"#5*.#'.#4"&(+.&.&#)./"$+%&.'#-.#
0)%?+4+-"-#:#-+'("&$+"#.&#7*&$+,&#-.#/"@%'#&,'(+$%'#0")"#/%'#$*"/.'#./#!"#$%&#
$%&'(+(*:.#'*#./.4.&(%#%);"&+@"-%)=
A'#.&#.'(.#$%&(.?(%#5*.#/"#9+'(%)+"1#/"#+&-";"$+,&#-./#"'&!()#$%4%#$%4+.&@"&#
"#$%&7+;*)")/"#B.$"(.%#:1#'%2).#(%-%1#B.),-%(%#:#C*$6-+-.'1#3"#"#$%&'(+(*+)#*&"#
"/(.)&"(+3"#"/#./"2%)")#*&#-+'$*)'%#-.&()%#-./#$*"/1#0")"#./#$*"/1#./#4")$%#-.#/%'#
"$%&(.$+4+.&(%'# $%&'(+(*:.# *&# ./.4.&(%# .0+'(.4%/,;+$%# 5*.# /.# 0.)4+(.# -")#
$*.&("#-./#"$%&(.$+4+.&(%#"/#5*.#2*'$"#).7.)+)1#.&(.&-+-%#D-+$9%#4")$%E#$%4%#
0)+&$+0+%#-.#).7.).&$+"#5*.#$%4%#("/#%7).$.#./.4.&(%'#0")"#/"#'*0.)"$+,&#-./#
0)%2/.4"#-.#/"#"42+;F.-"-#-+'$*)'+3"#-./#)./"(%#46(+$%80%<(+$%=#!"#()";.-+"1#
5*.# '.# 2*'$,# +&+$+"/4.&(.# $%4%# %0$+,&# $)6(+$"# 7).&(.# "/# $*!"+&1# &%# %0.)"1#
.40.)%1#.'(.#$"42+%1#"/#&%#0)%0%&.)#./.4.&(%'#.0+'(.4%/,;+$%'#"/(.)&"(+3%'#
-.#0).$+'+,&#-./#-+'$*)'%=GH#A&#.7.$(%1#.'#.&#/"#2I'5*.-"#-.#*&#-+'$*)'%#5*.1#
4.-+"&(.# /"# '*0.)"$+,&# -.# /"# "42+;F.-"-# -./# -.$+)# 46(+$%80%<(+$%1# ./"2%)"#
");*4.&(%'#$"0"$.'#-.#'*0.)")#./#.J.)$+$+%#-.#/"#0)*.2"1#5*.#/"#9+'(%)+"#'.#
!"#$%&'()*+,-)!.%)"+/)+012)%"+&)2.%.+.$3+456789:;<=*+2"+>')+)$!&1?"+.>'3@+)$+2"+
A)&$1B#+!.$%)22.#.+/)+C"$D+E2$1#.+F2"%.+4G$>'12"@+,)-./0'-&12+$34/!-&@+HI+)/J@+)/J+(+%&./J+/)+C"$D+
K/'+&"#L/%("1#LM(.-)"1#N"-)+-1#OPPQE=
GH# A'(.#0*&(%#-.#0")(+-"#$%4I&#0")"#/"#()";.-+"#:#/"#B+'(%)+"#9"#'+-%#+&-+$"-%#0%)#L")%/:&#
K)L.2/+ (+ M.!N)2+ O1%P1#Q)&*+ ,-)&"/"%'$+ .#/+ R"SN"!2)$+ L"&T+ 1#+ /1UU)&)#%+ Q)#&)$@+ .#/+ )VS2"1%+ %N)+
0%''+2+/+(+.'#%7#(9.#"&.$-%(.#5*+(.#-+77.).&(/:1#2*(#+&#(9.+)#-+77.).&(#*'.'1#%7#(9.#'(%):1#."$9#%7#(9.4#
).7/.$('#+)%&+$"//:#%&#'%4.#%7#(9.#"42+;*+(+.'#+&9.).&(#+&#(9.#+&(.//.$(*"/#(*)4%+/#0).3"/.&(#+&#4+-87+7(98
$.&(*):#R)..$.#"2%*(#(9.#&"(*).#"&-#0%S.)#%7#/"&;*";.T1#UC9.+)#$9%'.&#;.&).'1#(9%*;9#3.):#-+77.8
).&(1#2%(9#$%&7)%&(#"&-#;)"00/.#S+(9#(9.#7/*+-+(:#"&-#.09.4.)"/+(:#%7#S%)-'#V(9.#4"//."2+/+(:#%7#%)"/#
$%"&1)$+.#/+%N)+1WS)&W.#)#!)+"U+L"&/$+$S"T)#+"#!)+"#+%N)+$%.Q)X+4+3512'!51#00=#QOO#:#QOWE=#L%+&8
$+-+.&-%# .&# /%# ;.&.)"/# $%&# .'("# /.$(*)"1# /"# &*.'()"# '+&# .42");%# &%# '.# -.(+.&.# "# .&*&$+")'.# .&#
%D&W1#"$+/)+&)2.!1"#)$+$"!1.2)$J+K)L.2/+(+O1%P1#Q)&+.U1&W.#+)#+)U)!%"*+,E#/+1#+%N)1&+L"&T+).!N+)V8
0/%).#(9.#+&(.)'.$(+%&#%7#/"&;*";.#"&-#0%S.)X#>%09%$/.'1#"00)%0)+"(./:#(%#(9.#4.-+*4#%7#(9.#-)"4"1#
+&#(9.#*&."':#"&-#$%40/.?#)./"(+%&'9+0#2.(S..&#S%)-'#"&-#"$(+%&'Y#B.)%-%(*'1#"'#"#0)%'.#9+'(%)+"&1#
+&#"#4%).#/.+'*).-#"&-#/%&;8(.)4#.?0/%)"(+%&#%7#(9.#S":'#4+.+&#$%))*0('#(9.#.?.)$+'.#%7#0%S.)#2%(9#
"'#+(#+'#*'.-#2:#(9%'.#+&#0%S.)#"&-#(9%'.#'.)3+&;#*&-.)#(9.4T=#L%&()")+"4.&(.#"#*&"#0%'+2/.#+&(.)8
0).("$+,&#-.#.'("#"7+)4"$+,&#.&#./#'.&(+-%#-.#*&"#"*'.&$+"#-.#$*.'(+%&"4+.&(%#-.#/"#)./"$+,&#.&().#
0"/"2)"'#:#9.$9%'#D"$(%'#9*4"&%'E1#&*.'()"#0)%0*.'("#"#.'(.#).'0.$(%#$%&'+'(.#.&#.?0/+$+(")#./#
"/$"&$.#.0+'(.4%/,;+$%#-./#$*.'(+%&"4+.&(%#5*.#'%2).#./#/.&;*"J.#'.#%0.)"#.&#.'(.#$%&(.?(%#'%$+"/1#
.'(%#.'1#("&(%#0")"#/"#()";.-+"#$%4%#0")"#/"#B+'(%)+"1#-./#$*.'(+%&"4+.&(%#"$.)$"#-.#/"#)./"$+,&#
.&().#0"/"2)"'#:#"$$+%&.'=
EN-CLAVES DEL PENSAMIENTO, ao VIII, nm. 16, julio-diciembre 2014, pp. 177-201.

Si Helena hubiera estado en Ilin. Khra y tpos en de la Historia griega antigua

191

!"#$%#$&'(#)#$*#(+'+#(,$-./$012$31456$789:;<$5=><2?@$&"#A$B,A$+CA)"(A,A$+#$B,A$
D(C#D,A$-1E$F88G>H>$8IJ12?$A,KL$%#$&'(#)#$%MBNC&B#A$O$(C+P)"B,A$-Q1881R$S5$4<T$
J581612?UV!"
#$%$&$'()*+,%$(&)-&)(.)&/*,0%)-.$1&2)3,.)$&)%4*)-5)&6,&6,'$*&5)&$/*)7
)#($"K$+CA)"(A,$'BN#(K'NC*,$-./$012$31456$789:;<$5=><2?$'B$+#$B,A$D(C#D,AL$&"#A$B'$
&'B'W('$),K$B'$!"#$XAN,A$Y'K$(#Z#(C+,$B'A$),A'A$-1E$F88G>H>$8IJ12?$#AL$*'(C'+'L$
'%WCD"'$ -Q1881R$ S5$ 4<T$ J581612?V$ ['$ &(,&"#AN'$ #&CAN#%,B\DC)'$ +#$ B'$ YCAN,(C'$
3$-(8(.)&)-&)(.)&()-.85$&9:&,&-;)(.*$&4,*)3)*&)-&(;&',()91&)-&)(.,'6)3)*&;-,&
*)6,38<-&4*$',5,&)-.*)&6,(&4,6,'*,(&:&6,(&3$(,(&,&6,(&=;)&3$-&)66,(&()&*)/8)*)&
4,*,&5,*&3;)-.,&5)&6,&*),685,5&>;%,-,1&5)&%,-)*,&,&4$5)*&,/8*%,*&$&*)/;.,*&6$&
=;)&3$-&6,(&4,6,'*,(&()&583)?&@(A1&)6&.84$&5)&58(3;*($&=;)&2)3,.)$&4*$4$-)&()&
),KAN("O#$),%,$'(D"%#KN')C\K$(#Z"N'NC*'$-7QI3;]2/L$7Q13;^10<2L$_85>^1/?L!B&
4,*,&6,&3;,6&)6&58(3;*($&>8(.<*83$&5)&2)*<5$.$&46,-.),&)C46A38.,%)-.)&3<%$&4*8-7
3848$&)48(.D%83$&6,&3$-(.,.,38<-&5)&>)3>$(1&)6&.)(.8%$-8$&=;)&5,&3;)-.,&5)&6$&
,3$-.)385$& %)58,-.)& )6& *)6,.$& 5)& 6$& +8(.$& 58*)3.,%)-.)& $& 5)& 6$& *)6,.,5$& 4$*&
=;8)-)(&6$&4*)()-38,*$-?&E(&4$*&)66$&;-,&8-5,0,38<-&,4$5A3.83,F&()G,6,&,=;)66$&
!"#$&,($AP$A#$%"#AN('$-7QI`3;]2/?$),%,$%#+C,$+#$&("#W'a
bAN'$#A$"K'$#c&,AC)C\K$+#$B'$CK*#ANCD')C\K$-EdS1eR9/$7QI3;]2/?$+#$f#(\+,N,$+#$f'7
BC)'(K'A,L$'$ZCK$+#$!"#$KC$B,$(#'BCg'+,$&,($B,A$Y,%W(#A$-Sh$J5>I05><$i]$7>:ejQH>?$
()&5)(+,-)H3,&3$-&)6&.8)%4$1&-8&=;)5)-&(8-&06$*8,&6,(&$'*,(&0*,-58$(,(&:&,5%8*,7
WB#A$-_eJ<$05Jk8<$S5$4<T$:H0kdS<?L$(#),DC+'A$-7Q135^:;>S<?$"K'A$&,($B,A$D(C#D,A$
O$,N('A$&,($B,A$Wl(W'(,A$mno!I

!"$ p4<S<61/$q$r28Gd21/$s35$0t:56S<2u$Sh$3v$JekwHL$./$012$31456$x89:;<$5=><2u$1E$Jhe$p88G>H>$
8IJ12$Q1881R$S5$4<T$J581612L$y/$i01T$w<R>1>S<2L$5zdR>L${|(fCAN$}${$}@$!"#$%&'()#*+#$,#&$-&"#./"0./#*$
1"0+2&"3#&$*,K${#BCc$~'),WO$-[#C+#Ka$bV$~V$(CBBL$}?V$b(AN#($#CBL$|#K#'B,DC#$"K+$ONY,D('&YC#V$$
*,((#+#V$N#cNV$'++#K+'V$,K,(+'KgV$Y,N,%#)Y'KCA)Y#($K')Y+(")$+#A$*#(%#Y(N#K$K#"+(")#A$
+$-&JIK"?
!B& E-&(;&68'*$&($'*)&)6&-,38%8)-.$&5)6&58(3;*($&>8(.<*83$&)-&L*)38,1&#,.>)*8-)&M,*'$7N)(3>,-(7
C$+'$)"#KN'$+#$B'$YCAN,(C'$),%,$"C)C,$+#$+CA)"(A,AL$),%,$'KlBCACA$)(PNC),$+#$B,A$N#ANC%,KC,A$(#),&C7
6,5$(F&O#$-.*,8*)%)-.&P&3)&=;8&()&4*$5;8.&4$;*&6Q/"0+4&1&=;)&5);C&4,*.8)(&+8)--)-.&($66838.)*&).&,;=;)6&
)66)(&($;%)..)-.&3>,3;-)&(,&+)*(8$-&5)(&/,8.(1&6)&4*,.838)-&5)&6Q/"0+2&"'1&6;81&($66838.)&5)(&*D38.(&).1&=;Q86&
6)&58()&$;&-$-1&6)(&3>$8(8.?&RP&()&(8.;)&;-)&4*)%8S*)&(.*,.)&5)&T;0)%)-.(1&=;8&($;(7.)-5&(,-(&)C3)47
.8$-& 4$((8'6)& .$;.)& 6)(& 1"0+2&"#01& %U%)& =;,-5& 6);*& %,V.*)& 5QW;+*)& *)(.)& (86)-38);C& (;*& 3)& =;Q86&
*,44$*.)&XY1&JZ& !1&!Z& YY1&![F&6)(&*D38.(&($-.&;-)&4*)%8S*)&/$8(&(D6)3.8$--D(&).1&4,*&6P1&T;0D(&5)&=;)6=;)&
&#(NCK#K)#$&,"($B#$&(,&,AUL$'NY#(CK#$'(W,`#A)Y'KACL$561"0+2&"'7$82))#*.#)#*+0$(&#.01&L,6687
%,*51&N,*8(1&\]]"1&4?&"!?&E66$1&-$(&4,*)3)1&+,&)-&3$**)(4$-5)-38,&3$-&-;)(.*,&8-.)*4*).,38<-&5)&
28(.$*8,&0*8)0,&,-.80;,&3$%$&,*0;%)-.,38<-1&4,*,&6$&=;)&-$($.*$(&5)(.,3,%$(&(;&3,*^3.)*&,4$5A37
NC),$-7QI3;]2/7Q13;^10<2?L$B,$!"#$B'$D"P'$&'(NC)"B'($+#$K"#AN('$B#)N"('V
!I$ e13IS1t$824<e>9dd;1/$EdS1eR9/$7QI35]2/$35L$y/$0GS5$Sh$J5>I05><$i]$7>:ejQH>$S$
^eI>$ i]RS98<$ J;>9S<2L$ 0GS5$ _eJ<$ 05Jk8<$ S5$ 4<T$ :H0<dSkL$ Sh$ 0v>$ 889d2L$ Sh$ 3v$ <eke12d2$
7Q135^:;>S<L$485$J;>9S<2L$mnoL$!1&O4*)/,38$_Z&+)*(8<-&3,(.)66,-,&5)&@*.;*$&`,%A*)H&a*)T$F&2)*<5$.$1&

EN-CLAVES DEL PENSAMIENTO, ao VIII, nm. 16, julio-diciembre 2014, pp. 177-201.

192

Ren Cecea

!"#$%&'()"$*'$+,$"%,()'%-*,$.-/(-0-%"$'($'.)'$%,()'1),$"2"(*,("#$'+$*-.%&#3
.,$45)-%,36,7)-%,$8$'+$6#,%'*'#$6'#.&".-9,$:&'$"$7.)'$+'$%,##'.6,(*';$#'%&##-'(3
!"#$#%&$#'&!'($(')&#*%+#,-%+.+#/01234567#89:;<=>7?#@+!'$&A+#B$#-+(",'B$(')&#!+#
A+CA'@"&'"C#/893;DEF<G2H?I#A$&A"#!+#J-'+J"C#("@"#!+#&"KJ-'+J"CL#MCNI#$*%+BB"#
*%+#'&!'($#B$#01234567#89:;<=>7#OB$#P,%.B'($(')&Q#"#P+R,"C'(')&Q#!+#B"C#-+C%BA$3
*,.$*'$+"$-(9'.)-/"%-<($.'/=($.'$'()-'(*'$8$)#"*&%'$+"$0<#4&+"$*'$>'#<*,),?$'.$
.&$%"#@%)'#$*'$*-.%&#.,$.,4')-*,$"$6#&'2".A$!'$'.)"$0,#4";$.'B"+"$":&'++,$:&'$
.'$4&'.)#"$%,4,$#'.&+)"*,$*'$+"$#'%,6-+"%-<($*'$)'.)-4,(-,.;$6"."(*,$%,($'++,$
!+B#@"CA-$-#$B#!+@"CA-$-L#S$#01234567#89:;<=>7#T$(+#+&#+U+(A"#,"C'.B+#B$#!+@"C3
)#"%-<($ "+$ -(*-%"#$ )"(),$ '+$ %"#@%)'#$ *'5%)-%,$ *'$ +"$ 6'#%'6%-<($ :&'$ '($ 6#-4'#"$
-(.)"(%-"$%,(.)")"$'+$C'%C,$?:&'$.'$%,(.)#&8'$.,2#'$+"$2".'$*'$+"$#'+"%-<($
'()#'$9'#$8$."2'#$'($'+$6'(."4-'(),$/#-'/,?;$%,4,$+"$2".'$*'5%)-%"$*'+$"#/&3
4'(),$?:&'$'.$&($4,.)#"#$.,2#'$+"$2".'$*'$+,$9'#,.54-+$'($0&(%-<($*'+$)'.)-3
4,(-,$*'5%)-%,?ADE$F.$'.)'$6#,%'*'#$'+$:&'$6'#4-)'$*"#$%&'()"$'($.&$/#"(*'G"$
/V4WH#XDWYZH#2D#[H\#F]XY12H?#!+#B$#-+$B'!$!#T%@$&$I#!+#B"C#T+(T"C#T%@$&"C#
/2^#WDG:XDGH#_=#8GF4`9]G?LDH$I$'.$'($'.)'$4-.4,$.'()-*,$:&'$J&%5*-*'.$%,(.3
)#&8'$.&$!"#$%&"'()*(+'(,-*&&'()*+(.*+%/%0*#%A
a'&#+@.$-J"I#&"#C+#+*%'b"($-c#*%'+&I#!+#$(%+-!"#("&#B"C#'&!'('"C#/2dG#2D[X645]G?#
'16&'.),.;$%#'"$:&'$+,.$C'%C,.$"$+,.$:&'$4'$C'$#'0'#-*,$0&'#,($6,%,$4@.$,$4'3
(,.$%,4,$C'$*-%C,$8$(,$*'$4@.$0'$"$+,$:&'$.,2#'$'.),.$C'%C,.;$'42'++'%-7(*,+,.$
/[31X3eG2D7?# ,$-$# +&J-$&!+(+-B"CI# T$&# ($&A$!"# B"C# ,"+A$CI# &'# $# B"# *%+# B"C# B"J)3

!"#$%&"'#I#f&A-"!%((')&I#b+-C')&I#&"A$C#g#("@+&A$-'"C#!+#M-A%-"#h$@N-+i#j-+k"I#l'.B"AT+($#a(-',A"-%@#
K#L%,#&4$')$M,4"(,#&4$N'1-%"(";$OPQN;$N71-%,;$HRSD;$A
DE$ N"#-'3T"&#'(%'$!'.%+,.$C"$++"4"*,$+"$")'(%-<($.,2#'$'+$%"#@%)'#$6#'0,#4")-9,$*'$+"$0,#4&3
B$(')&#!+#m+-)!"A"n#Popq#B+#(T"'R#B+R'($B#!+#Br'/%)*1"#$:&-$*-)$),&)$U$+"$0,-.$+"$6&2+-%")-,($*'$+V'(:&W)'$
+A#B$#!s@"&CA-$A'"&#!+#C$#b$B'!'AsL#t"%-#B+#!'-+#(B$'-+@+&AI#&"%C#C"@@+C#+&#,-sC+&(+#!+#(+#*%+#uL#
TA$Q&.)-($')$*V"&)#'.$"6#X.$+&-$"66'++'#,()$&($7(,(%7$6'#0,#4")-0;$+V7(,(%-")-,($*'$+"$*74,(.)#")-,($
#'9'("()$U$+V"%%,46+-#Y;$2-1(3'&,*#()*#()"'+%,-*#()*(.+'$%04(5##'"()67"#$%"&*('0$7&%/%+%,"8-*()*(
+'(/7"+%#%/7"*('09"*00*I#us-v@+#w'BB"&I#t$-'CI#xyyzI#,L#x{L#|&#$(%+-!"#("&#+CA"I#&%+CA-$#B+(A%-$#
2&.%"$*"#$%&'()"$*'+$6'.,$'6-.)74-%,$:&'$'.)'$C'%C,$%,(.)-)&8'()';$:&'$'.$"$+"$9'G;$%,4,$":&5$
'16+-%"4,.;$":&'++,$:&'$+,$C"%'$6,.-2+'Z$+"$#'+"%-<($*'$+"$*'-1-.$*'$+"$6'#%'6%-<($%,($+"$*'-1-.$"#3
/&4'()")-9";$8$".5;$'+$6".,$*'+$4,.)#"#$"+$*'4,.)#"#A
DH$ [>'%C,Y;$["%,()'%-4-'(),Y;$[.&%'.,Y;$*'2'($":&5$.'#$%,46#'(*-*,.$"()#,6,+</-%"4'()'$8;$
4@.$"=(;$'($.'()-*,$6,+5)-%,;$'.),$'.;$*'.-/("*,$"+$:&'C"%'#$*'+$)-6,$*'$.,%-'*"*$:&'$+"$/%+"#$#'3
,-+C+&A$L#}"@"#'&!'($#}$AT+-'&+#~$-."Kt+C(T$&C'I#g#+&#("&("-!$&('$#("&#B$#$-J%@+&A$(')&#*%+#
":&5$*'."##,++"4,.;$+,.$[C'%C,.Y$*'$+,.$:&'$+"$C-.),#-"$2&.%"$*"#$%&'()";$.,($C'%C,.$*'$\&.)-%-"$8;$
'($'+$%,()'1),$*'$(&'.)#"$6'#.6'%)-9";$C'%C,.$#'+")-9,.$"$+"$6#,2+'4@)-%"$*'$+"$/%+"#n#Popq#B+C#sbs3
('4'().$:&'$#"66,#)'()$%'.$+%,%"$')$.'+,($+'.:&'+.$.,()$"#)-%&+7.$+'.$!"#$%"&*#$.,()$*,((7.;$'&1$
"&..-;$%,44'$+'.$4,4'().$-(-)-"&1$*V7%C"(/'.$'()#'$*'.$,00'(.'.$%,()#'$+"$\&.)-%'$')$*'.$#76"#"3
)-,(.]6&(-)-,(.$ :&-$ 9-'(('()$ #7)"2+-#$ .,($ 7:&-+-2#'$ "-(.-$ 4-.$ U$ 4"+A$ T'$ 0"-)$ '.)$ &($ 0"-)$ *'$ \&.)-%'Y;$
}$AT+-'&+#~$-."Kt+C(T$&C'I#%/4(9"$A;$6A$HE^A
EN-CLAVES DEL PENSAMIENTO, ao VIII, nm. 16, julio-diciembre 2014, pp. 177-201.

Si Helena hubiera estado en Ilin. Khra y tpos en de la Historia griega antigua

193

!"#$%&' (#)' *%+,-.&/%0' +1&' #/.)/%&' #' *#-/23#"' &-' #-42/%"2%' 5-.' #' 6#' 3."4#4' 789'
:;<=>?@?A8B;<C' 8D' EF;<G=BH' I' EJKLM=8B;<CN0' ,-.&' &%)' (.*(%&' &2)' ,"-.O#&'
7PC8>' ECBQMJB?F8>N' R0' .)' &-' +#R%"' ,#"/.0' 4.O24%' #6' ,#&%' 4.6' /2.+,%0' 2)*".SO6.&' .'
2)+."&%&'.)'.6'+2/%'7T:U'89'VWLXYBZ'TFCBCHFKFA8>N['\-.',2.)&.'5-.'6%&'".&-6/#4%&'
4.' +2' 2)3.&/2!#*2])' %O.4.*.)' #' 6%&' 2)42*2%&' +1&' .324.)/.&' 78XC' T:H^>CB=8G8@C'
=KVB_@CN'R'".&-6/#)'O#&/#)/.'&#/2&$#*/%"2%&',#"#'/"#/#"&.'4.'(.*(%&'#)/2!-%&[!"

#$%&'()$*+,-.$/-*$0-&12*$3-$42'&3$*(3-$250/(6('2)$/-*$4&'4-*$'-3$&/$6(3$%&$
#"".!6#"6%&'7F<=V<`C8BZN'R'(#*."6%&'#&S'+1&',."&-#&23%&'789':;<=>?@?A8B;<C'
8D'EF;<G=BH'I'EJKLM=8B;<CN'4.'+#)."#'5-.'6%&'(.*(%&'".6#/#4%&'&.'*%)32."/.)'
.)'+2/%&'7T:U'89'VWLXYBZ'TFCBCHFKFA8>N'R'4.32.).)'2)*%)/"%6#O6.&0',#6#O"#&'5-.'
*%)' ".&,.*/%' #' 6#&' *%&#&' #' 6#&' 5-.' ".$2.".)' )%' #,%"/#)' ,"-.O#&' 7PC8>'
ECBQMJB?F8>N['a&',%"'.6'*%)/"#"2%0'*%+%'&-*.4.'*%)'6#'(2&/%"2#0'6#'.b,%&2*2])'4.'
/-*$(3%('(-*$/-$7+&$42'&$0-*(8/&$*+$20)-82'(93$,$/&$0+&%&$-1-):2)$*+$'2);'1&)$
%&$<&)%2%$0)-82%2=
>2$4(*1-)(2$&*$2*?$'-3'&8(%2$'-5-$+3$%(*'+)*-$2/1&)321(<-$2/$%(*'+)*-$5?1('-@
0-A1('-.$&*1-$&*.$'-31)2)(-$2$+3$%(*'+)*-$'+,-$0)(3'(0(-$%&$'-3*1(1+'(93$&*$/2$*&@
4-**2])'7Bc:B;:dZN'+1&'5-.'-)'*"2/."2%'4.'3."4#4'#"!-+.)/#4#['e%4#'6#'!"#$%$.$
1&B1-$7+&$'-5-$4&5-*$(3%('2%-$'-3*1(1+,&$&/$)&6&)&31&$0)(5&)-$%&$)&0)&*&312@
'(93$&B0/('21(<2$%&$/2$*-'(&%2%$:)(&:2$231(:+2$C&'(=$3-12$DE.$&*$%&$&*12$523&)2$
-8F&1-$%&$')?1('2$,$)&'1(6('2'(93$%&$/2$02)1&$%&/$4(*1-)(2%-)G$/2$:+&))2$%&$H)-,2.$
*+*$-)?:&3&*$&3$*+$<&)*(93$4-5A)('2.$*-3$0+&*1-*$&3$%+%2$,$)&'1(6('2%-*$0-)$
I&)9%-1-=$J&$&//-$%2$'+&312$&/$/(8)-$KK$%&$/2*$)*+,-(*$+.$&3$%-3%&$I&)9%-1-$&B0/('2$
7+&$ *($ 8(&3$ I-5&)-$ '-3-'?2$ &/$ )&/21-$ 7+&$ %282$ '+&312$ %&$ /2$ 0)&*&3'(2$ %&$
I&/&32$&3$L:(01-$1)2*$*+$)201-.$0)&6()(9$*(1+2)/2$&3$H)-,2$02)2$8&3&6('(-$%&$/2$
&0-0&,2G$MN$5&$02)&'&$7+&$1258(A3$I-5&)-$'-3-'(9$&*12$32))2'(93O$0&)-$'(&)@
125&31&$02)2$/2$&0-0&,2$3-$&)2$(:+2/5&31&$2012$7+&$/2$-1)2$%&$/2$'+2/$*&$*()<(9$
f#6'!"#4%'4.'5-.g'6#'".6.!]'(#O2.)4%'+%&/"#4%'5-.'/#+O2h)'.&/#')#""#*2])'6#'
'-3-'?2P=!D
L/$)2*:-$'2)2'1&)?*1('-$%&$/2$4(*1-)(2$2*?$&31&3%(%2$&*.$&31-3'&*.$/2$'-3*@
1)+''(93$%&$+3$%(*'+)*-$%-3%&$/2*$02/28)2*$%&3$'+&312$%&$/2$)&2/(%2%$4+5232$
5&%(231&$+3$%-8/&$0)(3'(0(-$%&$2'-125(&31-G$+32$%&/(5(12'(93$6;'1('2$C/2$)&6&@

!"' TF' Yi' 8XC' Bj;KVMC@C' 8BFVK;_@C' kV@Z' 8<H>`8>' lC' 8HZ' C<V_m@C' VGJH=8>' n' YHDJL<C' <co'

>V>;8GC<H0'F>U'<p8B'qZ':<HK8>U'rVCsF>=H':B;U'>c8XC'T:U'89'VBtm<C'F<=V<`C8BZ'VuJJ<C':H=8Bv@C0'
<p8B' qZ' J<?<?;G^<H' QWCMLB=>C' T:U' 89' :;<=>?@?A8B;<C' 8w' EF;<G=BH' I' EJKLM=8B;<C0' PC8>'
ECBQMJB?F8>'F>U'8x':<JJx'r:9'o;AC<W'>c8XC'E:_=8@Z'T:U'89'VWLXYBZ'TFCBCHFKFA8>0'Kr;D=L>H'Yi'
y?K=GVBC<Z'TF'8XC'T:H^>CB=8G8@C'=KVB_@C'qZ':>J>Hx'BzC>H'E:<o;{C8@C0'|0',['}~0'~[
!D' Y<FMBH'YM'V<H'F>U'VK;<Z'89C'JA?<C'8<`8<C':WLM=L>H'EJJ'<c'?x;'<V<_@Z'TZ'8dC'T:<:<H_KC'
Bc:B;:dZ'!C'8'8M;'8':B;'To;s=>8<'fTZ'kg'VB8DFB'>c8AC0'YKJ{=>Z'qZ'F>U'8<`8<C'T:_=8>H8<'89C'
JA?<C0'||0',['~~0'~[
EN-CLAVES DEL PENSAMIENTO, ao VIII, nm. 16, julio-diciembre 2014, pp. 177-201.

194

Ren Cecea

!"#$%&'%(&()(")'&*)+&'&,!&*)$-#)'-*)."$.-*/)0)12*)+!"$%*&1"#3"/)'&)("3"!1%#&4
$%5#)("')$-#$"+3-)0)'&*)$-*&*)1"(%&#3")*6)!"*+"$3%7&)!"8"!"#$%&'%(&(9)0/)*-,!")
"''&/)6#&)("'%1%3&$%5#)%#3"!$-#$"+36&'):'&)("'%1%3&$%5#)(")'-*)$-#$"+3-*)"#)0)+-!)
*6*)';1%3"*)!"*+"$3%7-*9/)'-<!2#(-*")&*;)6#)&$-3&1%"#3-)=6")"#)'&)+"!*+"$3%7&)
("').%*3-!%&(-!/)+"!1%3")!"8"!%!)>#%$&)0)"?$'6*%7&1"#3")&)'-*)&$-#3"$%1%"#3-*)=6")
,6*$&#)("*$!%,%!@)A*3&)+!"-$6+&$%5#).%*35!%$&)*")"?+!"*&)"#)'&)85!16'&)(")B"4
!"#$%$&'()*'+,*(-'./012*'.,03*4CC)!"8"!%!)"')!"'&3-)7"!(&("!-/)"*3-)"*/)(&!)$6"#3&)
("')"#3")$-#)"')!"#$%)=6")'")$-!!"*+-#("/CD)0)'&)!"'&$%5#)"#)E6$;(%("*)"#3!")'&)
#56$7%!89:";' 5<:#5;%5' =' >$7' ?59?$7' 6:76$74' 5;' @8>8A!87' #5' BC9D#:#574' EF!'
-G(H*'(H*'IJ0K*'LM3F3NL2'OP.QL124'5>'?895!'5<:#5;%5'8'RC:5;'5S86:;5'>$7'
."$.-*)1%*1-*@CF
G*;/).&,'&!)(")B"'"#&)"#)E!-0&)"*)+-*%,'")"#)"')1&!$-)(")'&)$!"&$%5#)(%*4
$6!*%7&)$"#3!&(&)"#)'&)+"!*6&*%5#)("')&6(%3-!%-/)'&)+-"*;&/)#-)&*;)+&!&)"').%*3-4
!%&(-!)$60-)!"#$%)$-#*3%360")6#)H6%$%-)*-,!")'-*)!"'&3-*)("!%7&(-*)(")3"*3%1-#%-*)
(%!"$3-*/)*-,!")'-*)(%*$6!*-*)=6")(&#)$6"#3&)(")&$-#3"$%1%"#3-*)0)=6"),6*$&#)
&$-3&!)$-#$"+36&')0)82$3%$&1"#3")'&*)+&'&,!&*@)A#)"*3")>'3%1-)$&*-/)'-)"+%*3"4
1-'5<%$&1"#3")&$"!3&(-/)&=6"''-)(")'-)=6")*")+6"(").&,'&!/)"*)(")B"'"#&)"#)
A<%+3-@
T5' :;<57%:U8#$' VWL(3JX3*(2Y' 65' #59D8;' >$7' 7895!#$%57' RC5' >$' !5Z5!5;%5' 8' T5>5;8'
V([' F1J\' ].X*P*Y' 7C95#:"' 87D' V01*XL^-2' _O1Y&' `C5' a>5b8;#!$' cd' e8!:7f4' ?8A:5;#$'
!&+3&(-)&)B"'"#&/)I&!+5)(")A*+&!3&).&$%&)*6)+!-+%-)+&;*J)0)=6")$6&#(-)*")"#$-#4
3!5)"#)"')A<"-/)7%"#3-*)$-#3!&!%-*)'-)&!!-H&!-#)&')1&!)"<%+$%-)0)=6")(")&.;):+6"*)'-*)
7%"#3-*) #-) $"*&,&#9) ''"<5) .&*3&) A<%+3-) 0) "#) A<%+3-) .&*3&) '&) ("*"1,-$&(6!&) ("')
K%'-)&$36&'1"#3")''&1&(&)L&#5,%$&)0).&*3&)E&!%H"&*@CM

CC) N/)+@)OD/)P@
CD' g$7'#:Z5!5;9:86$7'8RCD'#5'>8'>59%C!8'#5'h8%?5!:;5'i8!A$je579?8;7k:'V$&'()*+'/)++@)QR4OP9/)
=6%"#)"#)"*3")$-#3"?3-).&$")("')!"#$%)."!&$'%3%&#-)6#)"#3")12*)("#3!-)("')$-#H6#3-)(")'-*)"#3"*@)
A*3&)+!-+6"*3&)#-*)+&!"$")$-!!"$3&)&6#=6")%#*68%$%"#3")&')%#3"!%-!)(")'&*)$-#*%("!&$%-#"*)=6")&=6;)
''"7&1-*)&)$&,-@)A*)+&!&)#-*-3!-*)$"#3!&')*6,!&0&!)"')$&!2$3"!)-#3-4'5<%$-)(")(%$.-)!"#$%/)"*3-)"*/)
(")*6)$-1+!"#*%5#)$-1-)"'"1"#3-)!"8"!"#$%&')(")'-*)"#3"*)$-#*3%363%7-*)(")'&)!"&'%(&().61&#&)
:S."$.-*T/)S!"&'%(&(T/)S&$-#3"$%1%"#3-*T/)),-@)#-3&)CR9@
CF) N/)UP/)U/).*%+$-*//)N3"!71)!"$-<#-7%3),!"7%=7")&(#-3&3%-#")$!%3%$&)%#*3!7?%3)B"#!%$6*)V36&!3)
l$;57m'0&&1-1+23()-*+*)243()$--56*+(5+(126*+(7$81995%(:9$)8(;$<5!!4'nSZ$!#'h>877:98>'B5S%74'B=@$4
U!8@?5$'h>8!5;#$;:8;$4'nS$;::4'opqq'Voprr"Ys'<5!7:";'987%5>>8;8'#5'lC8;'l$7t'B$!!57'u7A8!!8;9?&'
E6$;(%("*/).*%+$-*1(=5(!1(>45--1(=5!(;5!$&$95%$4'v;%!$#C99:";'U5;5!8>4'%!8#m'=';$%87'#5'lC8;'l$7t'
E-!!"*)A*,&!!&#$./)W!"(-*/)X&(!%(/)URRF@
CM' I.103*'OX'w32'3W'WJX1x'WL(3JX3*(2'(['F1J\'].X*P*'01*XL^-2'_O1m'y.Xz-*OJ3*'{JF|L-*(-'
].X*P*'+M'#F|J(Px'EF3F.X12*'+x'(}*'~K(3N'M-'w2*4'x'+0X*1(3'+*'('0-4'+zHL(-2'*1w32'
+M|..3L2'+x'()'0F(23*'FX.-03x4'+*^1N(1*'OX4'3G'0[J'E*21'(['F*1w-(-4'EF2M*X1(-2'+x'0F(3*'
M-\'0F(3'+x'()'*N*'$-*K2M)*'M-.1w1*3*'L(w-'(3N'1.3'M-\'+x'-J21-x4'NN/)+@)PPY/)P@

EN-CLAVES DEL PENSAMIENTO, ao VIII, nm. 16, julio-diciembre 2014, pp. 177-201.

Si Helena hubiera estado en Ilin. Khra y tpos en de la Historia griega antigua

195

!"#$%&'()$*"+$,%#-.'#/'"0$1"#2'/,34)4#56789:;9<8=>#?0"#/'+4@$0"+$,%#'%#'()'#
!"#$%&'%('#()*$+)$#%$,"-'#./%01'%21#!"%'34-5!)("*'+('%&",%!1'+("%&'%-$%"!$+6
('!)&$%"%7'-'+"%!$+#()(189+&$-$%'+%#1%:'!:$%,';','+('/%'+%#1%"!$("*)'+($%;<!6
)$+4#58A#BC:D#EF;<G<H#IC<;7JK=#LMC>H#%4(#$%3$+"%#-.'#N"/$(#O#2'0'%"#%4#00'*"/4%#
"%=,$8"/%#)+$%01'%-$%:)!)',$+%"%>?)4($@%A"%!$+#("("!)B+%;<!()!"%$4',"&"%4$,%'-%
('#()*$+)$%"4$,("%1+"%4,)*',"%)+&)!"!)B+%,'-"()C"%"%-$%"!$+('!)&$/%'-%:'!:$%!$*$%
#'%*$#(,B%"%01)'+%&'%9-%&"%!1'+("@%D$2,'%'--$%7',B&$($%"C"+E"%4","%*$#(,",/%
4","%",?1*'+(",%#$2,'%-"%2"#'%&'%-$%C',$#5*)-/%8%"#5%&'*$#(,",/%),%*<#%"--<%&'%
-"%C)#("%8%'-%('#()*$+)$F
G$% *)#*$% ("*2)9+% *'% "&:)',$% "% -"% $4)+)B+% &)!:"% "!',!"% &'% 7'-'+"/% "-'?"+&$%
'()4P#Q.'#($#2'0'%"#R.S$'/"#'()"34#'%#T0$,%#5CU#!<#EF;<G#V<#WFXY>H#R"S/Z"#($34#'%6
(,'?"&"% "% -$#% ?,)'?$#/% 01',)'+&$% H-'I"+&,$@% J1'#% !)',("*'+('% J,5"*$% +$% ',"% ("+%
*'+('!"($/% +)% -$#% &'*<#% '*4",'+("&$#% !$+% 9-/% &'% *$&$% 01'% 01)#)',"+% !"',% '+%
@'0$*/4# @"/"# (.(# @/4@$"(# @'/(4%"(# O# (.(# R$[4(# O# 0"# +$.3"3H# @"/"# -.'# \0'["%3/4# ]^#
N"/$(_#+4R"S$)"/"#+4%#2'0'%"`KL

aS('/&"b4(#'%#'()"#/'c.)"+$,%#3'0#@4'b"#3'#2'0'%"#'%#d/4O"H#-.'#4@'/"#
"%-"%C'E%'+%-"%!$+#(,1!!)B+%&'%-"%";),*"!)B+%!$+!-1#)C"%&'%-"%:)#($,)"%&'%7'-'+"%
'+%>?)4($/%"%-"%:)#($,)"%?,)'?"%"+()?1"%!$*$%1+%&)#!1,#$%'+%$4$#)!)B+%"%-"%4$-)6
('b$"#$%)'/@/')")$&"#3'0#3$(+./(4#bZ)$+4e@4f)$+4#5ghJCi8K=H#B9FF9j#8C#kKD#ICF9i9=>H#
-.'#('#c.%3"#(4S/'#0"#/'c'/'%+$"0$3"3#@"0"S/"eR'+R4#58A#BC:D#EF;<G<H#IC<;7JK=#
LMCH#Kl8A#8A#m:IK>#0"#$%&'()$*"+$,%#3'#)'()$b4%$4(#56789:jGn>#O#0"#"/*.b'%)"+$,%#
+4%#S"('#'%#04#&'/4(Zb$0#5oBpMqr=nH#oB9Mqs9gK=H#mFC<s9n>`#N43'b4(#+4%()")"/#
"&'*<#%$(,$%'-'*'+($/%;1+&"*'+("-%4","%-"%-'!(1,"%01'%4,$4$+'*$#F%,';1("!)B+%
8% !$+!-1#)B+% #'% !$+#(,18'+% #$2,'% -"% 4$#)2)-)&"&% 01'% '-% *",!$% &'% ,';','+!)"%
'#4"!)"-%-'#%$;,'!'%MN!"%O-)B+P/%N!"%>?)4($PQ/%41'#%'#%'-%*",!$%'#4"!)"-%&'%,';'6
,'+!)"%-$%01'%!$+#()(18'%4","%-"%:)#($,)"%'-%4,)+!)4)$%'4)#('*$-B?)!$%&'%!$+#("("6
!)B+% &'% -$#% :'!:$#@% >+% ';'!($/% -"% &'-)*)("!)B+% ;<!()!"% 01'% 4","% -"% :)#($,)"% #'%
!$+#()(18'%'+%2"#'%&'%-"%&'-)*)("!)B+%!$+!'4(1"-%($*"%-"%;$,*"%!$+!,'("/%'+%#1%
;$,*1-"!)B+/%&'%,';','+!)"-)&"&%'#4"!)"-%'+('+&)&"%!$*$%&'-)*)("!)B+%4,)*',"%
&'-%:'!:$%,';',)&$F%"!$+('!',%'#%('+',%-1?",/%#)'+&$%#1%4,1'2"%'-%('#()*$+)$%01'%
41'&'%&'-)*)(",-$%.!$+#()(189+&$#'%'+%'-%4,)+!)4)$%&'%#1%&'-)*)("!)B+.%'+%'-%
-1?",%01'%-'%!$,,'#4$+&'%M7'-'+"%!"%>?)4($/%8%+$%7'-'+"%!"%O-)B+Q@

KL# VIt#Mu#8v#FwIY#8v#BC:D#EF;<Gn#FCsJ;<8=#kKD#Kl8xn#B:978XJCgK=H#8yMC#VB=FCIwgC<9nH#CU#!<#
EF;<G#V<#WFXYH#oB9M9Jz<K=#{<#Kl8|<#89i7=#}FFG7=#~89=#kw<89n#IC##o;k9<89n#FCry<M:9h`#]_#9l#
IA:# M|# 98# IC# :C<9FK|n# !<# # :XKg9n# 9lMu# 96# FF9=# 96# B:97"k9<8Cn# Kl8vH# 78C# 89i7=#
7C8;:9=7=#7gK7=#kKD#89i7=#8;k<9=7=#kKD#8#BwF=#k=<Mh<CC=<#V9F9<89H#kn#F;rK<M:9n#EF;<##
7h<9=k;#H#TTH#@`#H#e`

EN-CLAVES DEL PENSAMIENTO, ao VIII, nm. 16, julio-diciembre 2014, pp. 177-201.

196

Ren Cecea

!"#$%&$'(()*+%,")-.'%")%$/")0*+%1%&$2$%3)2$"%+4)(+'#+4$,%+(%)25()$%
"6-'676&+#6*+2)'#)%2+1$0%4)%(+"%'$&6$')"%4)%!"#$%%1%4)%&'()*%&$'%0)"5)&#$%+%($"%
46"&80"$"%29#6&$:5$;#6&$%)<%6'&(8"$<%#0=-6&$<%)'#)'46)'4$%5$0%"6%"6-'676&+#6*+2)'#)%
2+1$0%'$%">($%)(%+82)'#$%&8+'#6#+#6*$%4)%"8%0)&80"$<%"6'$%"8%0)*+($0+&6>'%78':
&6$'+(%+(%6'#)06$0%4)(%46"&80"$<%)"#$%)"<%&$2$%506'&656$%&$'"#6#8#6*$%4)(%&$'$&6:
26)'#$%?8)%-)')0+'@%!'%)7)&#$<%1+%)'%(+%#0+-)46+%$/")0*+2$"%8'%+82)'#$%)'%
)(%)25()$%4)%($"%*$&+/($"%!"#$%%1%&'()*<%'$&6$')"%?8)%/8"&+'%4)(626#+0<%50)&6"+0<%
+?8)(($%4)%($%?8)%3+/(+'A%$70)&)'%8'%(926#)%?8)%5)026#)%+50)3)'4)0%($%0)(+#+4$<%
!"#$%!&!'"()*)+,"+-"+./%$)+(,+(,*!.!0/$!1"2+345-'+%,6!)",#+#)"+'#0/#+7-,+8,.)#+
/*$/"9/():;<+34(1"(,+,#0/.)#:;<+34(1"(,+")#+8,.)#+,#0/&*,$!():;<+347-'+%,6!1"+
,#:;<+347-'+%,6!1"+,#+=-,#+'#0/+,"+*/+7-,+8,.)#+,"0%/():;<BC%#+(%)"%(+%50$/()2=:
#6&+%6'6&6+(%?8)%")%5(+'#)+%)'%+,-()./0.1)2)0)@%!(%50$/()2+%4)%!465$%)"%)'&$'#0+0%
)(%)"5+&6$%50)&6"$%?8)%($%4)(626#+%1%?8)%5)026#)%+50)3)'4)0($%)'%"8%&$'46&6>'%
=%)=!/.,"0,+8-./"/<+$).)+,"0,+,"+-"+*-6/%+=%,$!#)+>(,+/8?+#-+0?0-*)@+ABCDEFGH+
IEJ+!FKLMN<++,-()./0.1)2)0)D<%?8)%0)76)0)%+%"8%&$'46&6>'%(626#+4+%1<%5$0%#+'#$%
50)&6"+/()%5$0%,)'#0)%$#0$"%5$"6/()"%+"5)&#$",%)(%(8-+0%?8)%($%&$'#6)')<%)(%2+0:
$)+(,+%,O,%,"$!/+,#=/$!/*+7-,+*)+(,*!.!0/+>IED+.P#+,*+(/0!Q)R<+S+S/+")+$).)+&3$%04
0'*+>$).)+,"+,*+0?0-*)+(,+*/+)&%/+7-,+$)"#0!0-S,+#-+O)"()+S+/"0,$,(,"0,@+ABCDEFGH+
TGUVMMWH<++,-().5/3%)'%'$26'+#6*$D<%)"#$%)"<%)(%3$2/0)%4)%5$4)0%?8)%)'%8'%
5)'"+26)'#$%+0&+6&$%'$%")%(626#+%&$2$%($%382+'$@EF%G+(%)"%)'%)7)&#$%($%?8)%'$"%
28)"#0+'%)(%&6&($%)4956&$A%&$2$%3$2/0)%4)%5$4)0<%!465$%#0+"5+">%($"%(626#)"%4)%
*)+8-./")+>3EXU"H<+YVU+EXU"H;<+,#+Z(!=)+%,SREH%?8)%4)/)%+3$0+<%)'%"8%&$'46&6>'%
(,+$!-(/(/")+>(,+8).&%,+(,+*/+=)*!#<+,#+Z(!=)+,"+[)*)")R+%,,#0/&*,$,%@+3\]^+.,+
#,_/*1+\`+a,&)<+!"(!$/+Z(!=)^+7-,+,*+8,$8)+(,+**,6/%+S)<+0%/"#$-%%!()+*/%6)+0!,.=)<+
/+-"+=/?#+>bLUVMR+Q,",%/&*,<+#!6"!O!$/&/+.!+(,#$/"#)+(,O!"!0!Q);2EI%6"#$%%$70)&)<%
BC+ 3cDMVH+bLUFGH+deDYfXgh+i+TDMjM+dMCUkM+EWKlMm;+3nEFG+EFTh+IofXM;<+3nEFl+pVgqoTVfXM;<+3TlH+
Ch+rogh+s+bkUFH;<+3TlH+Ch+rogh+s+bkUFH+CtTh+IM+u+vXvwpVfXM;<+1)2)0)<%H:EI@%J7@%'8)"#0$%+'=(6"6"%+(%
0)"5)&#$%)'%'8)"#0$%(6/0$%+*(%7-)8.29:%$.3.;90,)<<%2)7=.7-&@
EF+ x,#=,$0)+/+*/+!"0,%=%,0/$!1"+(,+*/+")$!1"+(,+TGUVMMWH+S+(,+#-+%,*/$!1"+$)"+*/+=!,9/+(,+
K>7$&()"%&$2$%&09#6&+%4)(%5$4)0<%*;+")%)(%#)L#$%1+%0)7)064$%4)%(+"%&$'7)0)'&6+"%4)%M6&3)(%N$8&+8(#%
58/(6&+4+"%/+O$%)(%#9#8($%>%.?@$-&@./&.2/*.A)$;/*.B9$-,-C9/*A%PQ)%#6#0)%2R2)%4)%(+%#0+-;46)%4)%K$53$:
$*,+,#0+!"0'%,##/"0@+#(!=,<+$h,#0+#(!=,+%)!<+ADClEFgH+TyUVMMFH2+z*+,#0+(!OO!$!*,+(,+0%/(-!%,+*,+.)0+
TyUVMMFH2+{/+0%/(-$0!)"+",+%,"(+=/#+$).=0,+(-+#!6"!O!'+,|/$0+(-+.)02+#(!=,+,#0+*h8)..,+(-+=)-Q)!%<+
(S3$22)%?86%)L)0&)%8'%&)0#+6'%5$8*$60@%!#%6(%)"#%&+0+&#;06"#6?8)%?8)%()%#6#0)%4)%(+%56T&)%4)%K$53$&()%
",+#)!0+=/#+#(!=,<+*h!"$,#0-,-|<+"!+#(!=,<+*,+.,-%0%!,%+(,+#)"+=$%,<+./#+#(!=,+%)!<+5-!+#!6"!O!,+*/+
%)S/-0'+(h#(!=,:+})-#+=)-Q)"#+%,./%7-,%+*h!.=)%0/"$,+(,+*/+08'./0!7-,+(-+=)-Q)!%+0)-0+/-+*)"6+
4)%(+%56T&)@%U)'4+'#%#$8#)%&)(():&6<%&)%?86%)"#%)'%?8)"#6$'%)"#%)"")'#6)(()2)'#%()%5$8*$60%4SV465)<%
,0+$h,#0+$,*/+7-!+O/!0+7-h!*+#,+#,"0+.,"/$';<+~!$8,*+a)-$/-*0]<+)(=.7-&=<%55@%BWX%1%BWY@
EH% J70@%+,-()./0.1)2)0)]<+)(=.7-&=<%55@%HEE%1%HEX@
EI+ 3%FDvN+TX+pdfFJ+f+YqMogh+dYMLfFMXH<++nH+fFl<+T+EWKKh+IpXMh+nTh+IqbU+pVp<++TVyTM+
rKXX+EVKVM+IM+bUWMN+fVpUN<++IKgWMTl+bLUVM+TXUfDVM<+nEFG+gXkM++oXfMkM+CUVM+KvFlfl+pVJ+
XMWoTVolM;<+==2+2

EN-CLAVES DEL PENSAMIENTO, ao VIII, nm. 16, julio-diciembre 2014, pp. 177-201.

Si Helena hubiera estado en Ilin. Khra y tpos en de la Historia griega antigua

197

!"#$%& #'& ()& *+),#-.)%& "'& !+.'/.!.0& -#& -#*#+1.')/.2'%& -#& (31.*#& 456789:& !"#$%!"
;7<9:&&'#'%#$"%&"'()*+,+-."/)"%0,"%12+3),"/)%"%45&($"6")."'(+2)(&"+.,3&.*+&"/)%"
(",)+&-#&()&)//.2'&!0(3*./)%&#(&-01.'.0&-#&(0&!0(3*./0=&>?$#+@#10$&#'&($%)%*!+,.$/01%"/)"7,84+%09"
:0" ,06" ;)%&,50$" ()30<0" /)" ;&%)*30.$" .&*+/0" /)" %&" 3+)((&=" >)" 21$" ,4" ()6$" 302&" ,4"
.02?()$")%"'4)?%0"/)"%0,"')%&,50,"84)"*0,)*@&"%0,"A(430,"/)"),3&"3+)((&=":"30/&"%&"
*.#++)&A"#&+#/0++#&#(&B$*+.12'&$),+)-0&#'&-.+#//.2'&)(&$0(&!0'.#'*#&-01.'0&4C78DEF=&
G#',0&/010&(.'-#$&4H7IJ<K8LF&()&*.#++)&-#&(0$&!#++#+0$&M&()$&-#&1N$&)((N&-#(&O.'-0%&
*)(*&"/)"%0,"')0.),"6"%&,"20.3&<&,"/)">0/0.&!")%"@B2)/0"2&("2)",+(C)"/)"A(0.D
*#+)&4;7<9F=&P0?+#&()$&*.#++)$&-#&#$*#&()-0&#Q#+R0&1.&!0-#+&4C78DEF=EF

G,1$" /)" &*4)(/0" *0." ,4" '(+.*+'+0" )'+,3H2+*0" /)" )I+5).*+&" /)A+.+30(+&" 84)"
'()*+,)" )%" /)*+($" %&" 3)2&3+J&*+-." '0%13+*&" /)%" ),'&*+0" 84)" ,)" 2&.+A+),3&" )." %&"
3(&5)/+&"*02+).J&"&"A0(24%&(,)")."3H(2+.0,"/)"/)%+2+3&*+-."')(0"84)",0?()"
%&"?&,)"/)",4"2&3)(+&"84)"),")%"2+30"84)/&"&3(&'&/&")."H,3)$"*0.,3(46)./0")%"
),'&*+0" ,)5B." ()A)().3)" .-,3+*0,=" K&" @+,30(+&" ,)" *0.A(0.3&" &" ),3)" 0?,3L*4%0"
)'+,3)20%-5+*0="7%"*&2?+0"84)"%&"@+,30(+&"0')(&"()A+)()"&"%&"*0.,3(4**+-."&"%&"
84)"*0."%0,"3H(2+.0,"/)"2&3#$"6"04!'%",)"&**)/)"'0(",4")2'%)0")."),3)"/+,*4(D
,0"&%3)(.&3+C0$"6"84)$"'0(",4"+2'0(3&.*+&$"),30"),$"'0("%&"()%&*+-."84)"2&.3+).)"
*0.",4"A0(2&"/)").3)./)(")%"*0.0*+2+).30$",)"()A%)M&").")%"()*4(,0"&"3H(2+.0,"
&"%0,"84)",)"/&"'(+0(+/&/"A().3)"&"%0,"3(&/+*+0.&%2).3)")2'%)&/0,9"%&"/+,3+.*+-."
)."%&,"(),')*3+C&,"3)2&3+J&*+0.),"/)%"),'&*+0"N213+*0D'0H3+*&$"3(L5+*&")"@+,3-(+D
*&#".0"),"%&"/)"4.&"&4,).*+&"/)"+2'0(3&.*+&"/)"%0,"()*4(,0,"%HI+*0,"),'&*+&%),"
)."%0,"/+,*4(,0,"213+*0D'0H3+*0"6"3(L5+*0"A().3)"&",4"()*0.0*+2+).30").")%"/+,D
*4(,0"@+,3-(+*0$")%"*4&%",)",+5.+A+*&(1&"'0(")%")2'%)0"'&(&/+52L3+*0"/)"2&3#$"6"
04!'%")."),3)"B%3+20"O%0"*4&%"'0/(1&20,")C).34&%2).3)"),3&("+.*%+.&/0,"&"').,&($"
'0(")M)2'%0$"%&"*&,+"&4,).*+&"/)"2&3#$")."%0,"3)I30,"@02H(+*0,O=">)"@)*@0$".0"
,-%0"0?,)(C&20,")%")2'%)0"/)"2&3#$"6"04!'%"3&.30").")%"/+,*4(,0"213+*0D'0H3+*0$"
*020").")%"3(L5+*0"0")%"@+,3-(+*0"N&4."*4&./0"*4&.3+3&3+C&2).3)"/+A)().3)$"%0"*4&%"
),$"*020")."03(&,"0*&,+0.),"@)20,"+./+*&/0$")'+,3)20%-5+*&2).3)",+5.+A+*&3+D
C0#$",+.0"84)"3&2?+H.",)"&3+)./)$",)5B."@)20,"3(&3&/0"/)"20,3(&("&%",)("%0"84)"
&@0(&".0,"0*4'&$"&"%0,"()A)().3),"),'&*+&%),")."%&"*0.,3(4**+-."/)"%0,"/+,*4(,0,"
213+*0D'0H3+*0"6"3(L5+*0"*020")%)2).30,"84)"&'0(3&.")%)2).30,"/)"()%)C&.*+&"
*0."(),')*30"&",4"'(0?%)2L3+*&"*).3(&%$"*0."(),')*30"&%"0&*54%=EP"K&"*&(&*3)D
(1,3+*&")'+,3)20%-5+*&".4)C&"/)%"/+,*4(,0"@+,3-(+*0$"6"84)")I'%+*&",4"2&60("()D
EF" ($%)%*!+,.$/01%6$"'!7).,07$"''="QEQDQRS=
EP" 7." &2?0," *&,0," 0?,)(C&20," 4." A4./&2).30" /)1*3+*0" 84)" /&" %45&(" &" 4.&" 3)2&3+J&*+-."
),'&*+&%"/)%"'(0?%)2&"&?0(/&/0="7,3&"3)2L3+*&"%&"&?0(/&20,")."03(0"3)I30"84)"'()'&(&20,"'&(&D
%)%&2).3)"&%"84)"&841"'(),).3&20,"6"&%"*4&%"()2+3+20,"&%"%)*30("+.3)(),&/0="

EN-CLAVES DEL PENSAMIENTO, ao VIII, nm. 16, julio-diciembre 2014, pp. 177-201.

198

Ren Cecea

!"##$%!&'()$*)+"$)$%),')-&*./#&')!"#$%)0)&'()*)*/%)$,),"1'#)2$)&%.$#*$!!&3%)$%.#$)
2$,&4&.'!&3%)56!.&!')0)7#&%!&7&/)2$)'#1"4$%.'!&3%8)'7/2$&9&*:
;')2$,&4&.'!&3%)56!.&!')+"$)/7$#'%)!"#$%)0)&'()*)$%)$,)7$%*'4&$%./)-&*.3<
#&!/() 0) +"$) *$1=%) '5&#4'4/*) $*.6) '"*$%.$) 2$) ,/*) 4$!'%&*4/*) $%"%!&'.&>/*)
4?.&!/<7/@.&!/*)0).#61&!/*()7"$2$)!/%*.'.'#*$)$%),')1$%$',/1?')2$),')',.$#%'.&>')
,@9&!/<!/%!$7."',)+"$)$*.'*)%/!&/%$*)*&1%&5&!'%()7/#)$,)!'47/),@9&!/)2$,)+"$)*$)
'7#/7&'%)7'#')#$5/#4",'#,/:)A%)$5$!./()!"#$%)0)&'()*)!/4/)7#&%!&7&/*)$7&*.$4/<
,31&!/*)2$)7#$!&*&3%)2$,)2&*!"#*/()*/%),/*)!/%!$7./*)',.$#%'.&>/*)2$),')-&*./#&')
!"#$%&'(#)+,$-*B)4?.&!/<7/@.&!/()')'+"$,,/)!"0')4$2&2')#$C'*'),')$*!',')-"4'<
%'8)+,$-*)$*)$,).@#4&%/)+"$)$97#$*')$,)!'47/)!/%!$7."',)2$),/)>'*./()2$),/)
'47,&/()$,)!/%!$7./)+"$()$%)!/##$*7/%2$%!&')!/%)$,)4'#!/)2$)4'1%&5&!$%!&')2$,)
2&*!"#*/)4?.&!/<7/@.&!/)+"$),/)$%"%!&'()*$D',')'),')4'1%&5&!$%!&')2$)'+"$,,/)')
"*#+,-#.-/0-.-1#23#!34#+,-#"!#503067#8#-"#9-:0.#9-#;-,3#3*7#$%&'(<#$%&'=>?@#30-7<
9*#3,#-A4B-B*#C$%&'=>?#!$'(DE#"*#!FA"0*#+,-#B*9*#"*#:0-.7-#FG3#!""G#9-#"!#F-<
2&2')-"4'%':EE
F/%)!$#!')2$)!&$%)#$!"##$%!&'*).'%./)$%),')./0%1%)!/4/)$%),')213*+%()+,$-*)
.&$%$)$%)$*.'*)2/*)/C#'*)*")4'0/#)7#$*$%!&')$%),'),&.$#'."#')1#&$1')'%.&1"'()
*$1"&2')2$),'*)43*&)$3%*)2$)G$#32/./)HIJ)#$!"##$%!&'*B(),')5+)6)70%)2$)G$*?/2/)
HKL)/!"##$%!&'*B),/*)4387)*9")8:$3;)*)HKJ)#$!"##$%!&'*B:EM)N2$46*)2$,)>$#)0)
2$!&#)2$)O$"*()+,$-*)!'#'!.$#&P')$%)*")$47,$/)$%),/*).$9./*)4?.&!/<7/@.&!/*)
0).#61&!/*()'),'*).&$##'*(),/*)!&$,/*)0),/*)4'#$*8)',)$*7'!&/)'C&$#./)2$)7#/7/#!&/<
%$*)@7&!'*:)AQ$47,/*)2$)+,$-*)$%)$*.$)*$%.&2/)$%),/*)2&*!"#*/*)4?.&!/<7/@.&!/)
0).#61&!/()*/%8
8#3-#+,-.-""6E#5070-79*#H!:0!#-"#!7:H*#:0-"*#)$I(#=%&?JKJ#$%&'JLE#-"#MB.09!
./:) !!!()RMS
N23#+,-#7*#B-#-.!#O.!B*E#P903-*E
!"'%2/).$)*'!#&5&!'C'%)>?!.&4'*)Q"%./)'),'*)%'>$*)'+"$'*
-7#"!#5!3B!#Q.*8!#)R&=I"#SJ#$%&$T"LU#
21:) !()MT<MI
U$#/)46*).'#2$)'7#$%2&$#/%
9-"#!7:H*#F!.#)$%&V>W&=X#Y#Z?[\]]?(LE#<)*9=+$*%*()KTT<KTK

EE) ^_`"0790:!<#M1#abc#>31+?9@$)%1E#d1#abc#A%$B$+%;"376?9A%$B*($+%1#abc
EM) N2$46*)2$),/*).$9./*)!&.'2/*(),/*)46*)*&1%&5&!'.&>/*)',)#$*7$!./)*/%)C$6)7%-&3;%)2$)N7/<
,/%&/)2$)V/2'*)HKJ)#$!"##$%!&'*B()D+*;$3(;3'791+9/%9E$+;3%)2$)U'"*'%?'*)HKK)#$!"##$%!&'*B)0)E+)B
6$%A0%)2$)A*.#'C3%)HW)#$!"##$%!&'*B:)FA$1#e*.9#/.-+,-7:8#07/*.F!B0*7#/*.#$%&'(E#5"+9D363&%/9<3@$%$G()
HBBA<ffggg1A-.3-,31B,/B31-9,fH*AA-.fg*.9/.-+U"!7OhO.--ij"**i,Ah-,L.,kdl3# :*73,"B!9*# -"#
TR:TM:ITKK:

EN-CLAVES DEL PENSAMIENTO, ao VIII, nm. 16, julio-diciembre 2014, pp. 177-201.

Si Helena hubiera estado en Ilin. Khra y tpos en de la Historia griega antigua

199

!"#$%!"#$%#"#!#&!#'()'!*+')'!+,!#'-+*%)!#&!#,!./#!'#!%&'*"%0#&!,)'!+*)&(#1
*%2%#&()'!3-%*)'!4#!,)'!./#!("+(+!#,!4%'*/"')!25(%*)1-)3(%*)!)!6-+"+!4+"!*/#&1
(+!4#!'/!+-)"(#!#-%'(#2),78%*)!8#&#"+,!4#!2+&#"+!+!%&*,/%"!+,!4%'*/"')!("98%*)6:!
,+!*)&'("/**%7&!#'-+*%+,!./#!*)""#'-)&4#!+,!"#,+()!./#!4+!*/#&(+!4#!;#*;)'!
2+8&5$%*)'!<#,!2%()!*)2)!2+(#"%+!4#!,)'!4%'*/"')'!+"*+%*)!=!("98%*)>!=!./#:!-)"!
(+&():!(%#&#!,/8+"!#&!/&!2+"*)!%8/+,2#&(#!#?*#,')@!A#,+()!./#!*)&'#*/#&(#1
2#&(#!'#!0/'*+!#&!,+!-#"'/+'%7&!2#4%+&(#!#,!#20#,,#*%2%#&()!=!2+8&%$%*+*%7&!
4#,!4%'*/"'):!=!./#!*)&'("/=#!/&!#'-+*%)!*)2)!2+"*)!/&%B#"'+,C!&"#$%:!#'!#,!
!"#$%&'()!*(+,-./(0'()*%>:!4#!,+!8,)"%+!4#,!;3")#!3-%*):!-/#'!+!+**%)&#'!;#")%*+'!
=!3-%*+'!*)""#'-)&4#!/&!#'-+*%)!*/=+!2+8&%$%*#&*%+!"#'+,(#!,)'!;#*;)'!./#!#&!
3,!'#!%&'*"%0#&!=!./#!'#!#?-"#'+!*)2)!B+'(#4+4@!D)&!#,,)!&"#$%!'#!*)&'(%(/=#!
#&!,+!(#2+(%E+*%7&!$/&4+2#&(+,!4#,!#'-+*%)!#&!/&!"#,+()!./#!(%#&#!#&!#,!+,"-.%!
,+!0+'#!4#!'/!*/#'(%)&+"C!#&!#,!4%'*/"')!25(%*)1-)3(%*)!*)2)!*#&(")!2%'2)!4#!
'/!*/#'(%)&+":!#&!,+!("+8#4%+!*)2)!"#'/,(+4)!4#!'/!"#,+*%7&!*)&!#,!2%()!#&!(+&1
()!./#!$/#&(#!4#!'/!2+(#"%+!4#!("+0+F)@!!"#$%!#':!-/#':!/&!#'-+*%)!-"#1-),5(%*):!
/&!#'-+*%)!-)3(%*)!-"#1+"8/2#&(+(%B)!./#!#':!-)"!#,,)!/&!#'-+*%)!4#!,)!-)'%0,#:!
'%&!,+!,%2%(+*%7&!4#!,)!+*)&(#*%4)@
/,0#1!=!+.2*%!')&!-)"!'/!-+"(#!#,!4)2%&%)!4#!,)!-),5(%*):!#,!2+"*)!#'-+*%+,!
./#! #,! 4%'*/"')! 4#! ,+! 2*(3%! "#*/-#"+! =! "#4#$%&#! *)2)! #,#2#&()! 4#! '/! *"5(%*+!
#-%'(#2),78%*+!+!,+!-"#*%'%7&:!#'()!#':!,+!4#,%2%(+*%7&!4#!,)!4%*;)@!G)"!#,,)!2%'1
2):!,+!'/0'(%(/*%7&!4#!&"#$%!'#!,,#B+!+!*+0)!2#4%+&(#!4)'!&)*%)&#'C!*)&!+20+'!
&)*%)&#'!'#!)$"#*#:!&)!'7,)!,+!4#,%2%(+*%7&!4#,!;#*;)!"#,+(+4):!'%&)!+4#29':!
/&+! 8"+4/+*%7&! #&! ,+! +-")-%+*%7&! 4#! ,)! "#,+(+4)! +,! *)&'%4#"+"! 4)'! #'*+,+'@!
/,0#1!"#$%#"#!=!#'(+0,#*#!/&!-"%&*%-%)!4#!4#$%&%*%7&!-+"+!,)'!#'-+*%)'!29'!+21
-,%)':!4#,%2%(+0,#'!*)&*#-(/+,2#&(#!<'%#&4)!#&()&*#'!-"%&*%-%)!4#!4#,%2%(+*%7&!
*)&*#-(/+,>:!2%#&("+'!+.2*%!"#$%#"#!+!,)'!;#*;)'!*/=+!4#,%2%(+*%7&!#'!'/'*#-(%1
0,#!4#!'#"!-"#*%'+4+!-)"!,)'!'#&(%4)':!+0+"*+0,#'!#&!'/!#?(#&'%7&!-)"!2#4%)!4#!
,+!-#"*#-*%7&!'#&'%0,#!<'%#&4)!*)&'#*/#&(#2#&(#!-"%&*%-%)!4#!4#,%2%(+*%7&!$9*1
(%*+>@4/,0#1!=!+.2*%!4#2+"*+&!+./#,,)!4#!,)!./#!("+(+&:!./#!#'!*)&'#*/#&(#!
6+'5!*)2)!#,!4%'*/"')!25(%*)1-)3(%*)!,)!#'!-)"!2#4%)!&"#$%!*)&!#,!'/=)6!*)&!
'/!-"%&*%-%)!#-%'(32%*)!4#!*)&'("/**%7&!4#!*)&)*%2%#&():!#'()!#':!*)&!,+!"#,+*%7&!
4#!+*)&(#*%2%#&()'!;/2+&)'!*)&!,+!-"#(#&'%7&!4#!/&+!*)2-"#&'%7&!4#!'/!*)&1
4%*%7&!=:!-)"!(+&():!4#!'/!4#,%2%(+*%7&@!H'!+'5!#&()&*#'!./#!'#!*)&'(%(/=#&!#&!
-"%&*%-%)!4#!+"8/2#&(+*%7&@!H&!#$#*():!+,!-"#8/&(+"'#!-)"!,+!-+,+0"+!./#!"#$%#"#!
+,!;#*;):!,+!;%'()"%+!-+"(#!4#!/&+!*)&*#-*%7&!4#,!;#*;)!*)2)!+./#,,)!./#!-)"!'5!
'#!2/#'("+!+!,+!B%'(+!#&!/&!,52%(#!./#!#'!'/!-"%2#"!#,#2#&()!4#!4#$%&%*%7&:!4#!
+*)(+2%#&():!'%#&4)!#&()&*#'!-"%&*%-%)!#-%'(#2),78%*)!#&!,+!*)2-"#&'%7&!4#!,)'!
1!%1'"(023456(4789:7856(;8<5=(%'>(*'"(?@!(*$(1&"A'B&$(C@"%$()$B(%@!>A$()!(*$(
"#+,%4+4!;/2+&+@!H,!2+"*)!#'-+*%+,!'#!*)&B%#"(#!4#!#'+!2+&#"+!#&!#,!-"%&*%-%)!
"'CB!(!*(%@$*()!"%$>"$(!*()&"%@B"'("@D!A'($(#B@!C$6(*$(EF<.3GH/(IJKL-MN/6("&!>)'(
EN-CLAVES DEL PENSAMIENTO, ao VIII, nm. 16, julio-diciembre 2014, pp. 177-201.

200

Ren Cecea

!"#$%!"#$%$&$&'()*%$"'"$()*+!$,*-.-/01-!2!"$%03$4)2)$5!")$/!"$+6"$*05'**037
40"%$20$40+!4-8!5-93$20/$0",!5-):$;-$<0/03!$='>-0*!$0"4!2)$03$?/-93@$"0$='>-07
*!3$ 20*-.!2)$ '3!$ "0*-0$ 20$ 5)3"05'035-!"$ A'0$ 3)$ "0$ 5)3"4!4!3$ ,)*$ 3-31B3$
40"4-+)3-):$C/$+!*5)$0",!5-!/$20/$!5)3405-+-034)$3)$,'020$034)350"$"0*$0/$-37
2-5!2)$,)*$0/$,)04!D$+6"$!B3@$0/$+!*5)$0",!5-!/$20/$03'35-!2)$,)E4-5)@$+'0"4*!$
/!$-35)31*'035-!$20$/!$,*),-!$()*+'/!5-93$,)E4-5!$03$/!$A'0$"0$/0$*0(-0*0:$C/$*07
/!4)$20$<0/03!$*0A'-0*0$)4*)$+!*5)$20$*0(0*035-!D$+6"$!B3@$0/$+!*5)$20$*0(07
*035-!$A'0$2!$/'1!*$!/$40"4-+)3-)$-32-5!$/!$3050"-2!2$20$'3$4-,)$20$2-"5'*")$
!/40*3!4-.)$!/$2-"5'*")$+#4-5)7,)E4-5)F$<0/03!$"0$035)34*!>!$03$C1-,4)@$/!$=-"4)7
*-!$,'020$5)+038!*:
G/01!+)"$ !"#$ !/$ ,'34)$ A'0$ 3)"$ =!>#!+)"$ ,*),'0"4)$ -3-5-!/+0340$ 5)+)$
3'0"4*)$)>H04-.)F$5)+,*0320*$0/$"034-2)$0,-"40+)/91-5)$20$!"#$%$&$&'()*$03$/!$
5)3"4*'55-93$20$/!$=-"4)*-!$1*-01!$!34-1'!:$+"#$%$&$&'()*$")3$3)5-)30"$")>*0$/!"$
5'!/0"$"0$0"4*'54'*!@$03$0/$2-"5'*")$=-"49*-5)$!34-1')$&$5)+)$,*),'0"4!$20$0"40$
2-"5'*")@$/!$*0(0*035-!/-2!2$0",!5-!/$A'0$,0*+-40$,)30*$03$*0/!5-93$0/$*0/!4)$I/!$
,!/!>*!J$5)3$/)"$!5)3405-+-034)"$*0/!4!2)"$I0/$=05=)J:$C/$5!*6540*$A'0$!"#$!27
A'-0*03$0"4!"$3)5-)30"$0"46$03$5)3")3!35-!$5)3$0/$,*)&054)$20$5)3"4-4'5-93$
")5-!/$A'0$/!$(),-*$"-13-(-5!@$0"4)$0"@$20$5)3"5-035-!$!'4)-3"4-4'&0340$IK!"4)*-!2-"J$
&$20$/!$5)3"05'0340$3050"-2!2$20$5)3"4*'55-93$20$'3$,03"!+-034)$!*1'+037
4!4-.)$!'4)('32!2)@$5-+034!2)$03$/)$='+!3)$"-3$,*0403"-93$20$4*!"5032035-!:$
G!$=-"4)*-!$"0$5)3"4*'&0$!"#$5)+)$'3!$,*),'0"4!$20$0/!>)*!5-93$20$'3$2-"5'*")$
A'0@$*0",)32-032)$!$/!$0L-1035-!$H'*#2-5)7,)/#4-5!$20$5)3"4*'55-93$!*1'+034!4-7
.!$&$!$,!*4-*$20$/!"$=0**!+-034!"$A'0$!$"'$.08$/0$)(*0503$0/$,*),-)$20>!40$H'*#7
2-5)7,)/#4-5)$ IH'-5-)J$ &$ /!$ 5*#4-5!$ 4*61-5!$ I40"4-+)3-)$ 5)+)$ ,*'0>!J@$ =!50$ 20$ /!$
*0/!5-93$034*0$!5)3405-+-034)$I&./012'312%J$&$+!*5)$20$/)"$!5)3405-+-034)"$
I5!+,)$20$/!$!"#$%$&$20/$&'()*J$0/$,*)502-+-034)$0,-"40+)/91-5)$A'0$!,'34!/!$
0/$,*)&054)$,)/#4-5):$K)3$0"40$,*)5020*$A'0$03'35-!$0/$5!+,)$20$/!$!"#$%$&$20/$
&'()*$5)+)$5)32-5-93$20$*0!/-8!5-93$20$/)"$!5)3405-+-034)"$*0/!4!2)"$&$!"#$20$
"'$03'35-!5-93@$/!$=-"4)*-!$,*-.-/01-!$/!$,*05-"-93$20/$!5)3405-+-034)$5)+)$0/07
+034)$20$,*'0>!$!*1'+034!4-.!@$03$),)"-5-93$!/$+-4)$A'0$'>-5!$/)$*0/!4!2)$03$
0/$5!+,)$20$/!$14$-*@$0/$+!*5)$0",!5-!/$20$/!$0L!/4!5-93$E,-5!$A'0$*0",)320$!$
'3$,*-35-,-)$20$5)3"4*'55-93$,!4E4-5)$I(%&")*J@$5'&)$"034-2)$0,-"40+)/91-5)$0"$
0/$-3.)/'5*!+-034)$0"4E4-5)$20/$!'2-4)*-)$03$0/$*0/!4)@$03$5)3")3!35-!$5)3$'3$
5'0"4-)3!+-034)$!34*),)/91-5)$!*5!-5)@$,*0,)/#4-5):$G!$()*+'/!5-93$M"-$<0/03!$
='>-0*!$0"4!2)$03$?/-93N@$*0"'+0$0"40$+).-+-034):$K)3$0//!$<0*92)4)$()*+'/!$
"'$5*#4-5!$!/$2-"5'*")$=)+E*-5)@$5'0"4-)3632)/)$20"20$"'$('32!+034)$03'35-!7
4-.)F$0/$2-"5'*")$20/$&"53'*$20$/!$6,7%8%$0"$-35!,!8$20$*0",)320*$!/$,*-35-,-)$20$
5)3"4!4!5-93$20$/)"$=05=)"@$/!$0L-1035-!$20$*0/!5-93$034*0$0/$=05=)$&$/!$,!/!>*!$
A'0$/)$03'35-!:$G!$),5-93$=)+E*-5!$,)*$,*0(0*-*$/!$3!**!5-93$4*)&!3!$*0",054)$!$
O!*-"$&$<0/03!$4-030$5)+)$('32!+034)$0/$,*-35-,-)$0"4E4-5)$20$-3.)/'5*!+-034)$
EN-CLAVES DEL PENSAMIENTO, ao VIII, nm. 16, julio-diciembre 2014, pp. 177-201.

Si Helena hubiera estado en Ilin. Khra y tpos en de la Historia griega antigua

201

!"#$#%&'( )*+( ",)%#'-%'( *.( *+( -*+"#'/( *+( 0*-( 120( "!#"( !"-"( +"( *!'!*3"( &'1'( +'(
1*.&%'."( 4*-5)'#'6( *+( #*.*-( &'1'( 7"0*( ,."( &'1!-*.0%5.( #-"0&*.)*.#*( )*+(
&'.'&%1%*.#'(0*89.(+"(&,"+(*+(&'.'&%1%*.#'(*0(%.0!%-")'/("8-*8"1'0(.'0'#-'0:(
;<%-1"-(=,*(+"0(!-,*7"0(%.)%&".(+"(!*-#%.*.&%"()*+()%0&,-0'(*8%!&%'/(1,*0#-"(=,*(
*+(!-%.&%!%'()*(&'.0#-,&&%5.()*+(&'.'&%1%*.#'(*0(*+(>,%&%'(?,1".'(=,*(0*("!+%&"(
"+(#*0#%1'.%':(@*(#-"#"(!,*0()*(+"(&'.0'+%)"&%5.()*+(!-'3*&#'(!'+A#%&':(B++'(!"0"/(
.'0(!-'!'.*(+"(?%0#'-%"(8-%*8"(".#%8,"/(!'-(!'.*-(*.(-*+"&%5.(+'("&'.#*&%)'(&'.(
0,(+,8"-()*("&'.#*&%1%*.#'/(*0#'(*0/(!'-(!-*&%0"-(*+(1"-&'()*(-*<*-*.&%"(*0!"&%"+(
)*("&"*&%1%*.#'()*(+'0(?*&?'0/(*.,.&%"-(!"#$%(3(&'()*:
Fecha de recepcin: 28/11/2012
Fecha de aceptacin: 07/05/2013

EN-CLAVES DEL PENSAMIENTO, ao VIII, nm. 16, julio-diciembre 2014, pp. 177-201.