Está en la página 1de 50

PROYECTO FINAL

ANLISIS MODAL ESPECTRAL Y CRONOLGICO DEL EDIFICIO


350

DISEO SISMO RESISTENTE

JUAN JOS CARVAJAL


MARCOS OMAR QUIMBAYO

UNIVERSIDAD DEL VALLE


ESCUELA DE INGENIERA CIVIL Y GEOMNTICA
ESPECIALIZACIN EN ESTRUCTURAL
2014

TABLA DE CONTENIDO
1.

INTRODUCCIN ................................................................................................................ 3

2.

PROCEDIMIENTO Y DESCRIPCIN ESTRUCTURAL .......................................................... 4

3.

2.1.

Pre-Dimensionamiento ............................................................................................ 4

2.2.

Evaluacin De Cargas ............................................................................................... 4

2.2.1.

Cargas muertas ................................................................................................. 4

2.2.2.

Carga viva.......................................................................................................... 4

ESPECTRO NEWMARK HALL ............................................................................................. 6


3.1.

Caractersticas Geotcnicas Consideradas .............................................................. 6

3.2.

Seales Ssmicas Consideradas ................................................................................ 6

3.3.

Procedimiento .......................................................................................................... 7

3.4.

Resultados Obtenidos .............................................................................................. 7

3.5.

Mtodo De Newmark-Hall ....................................................................................... 8

4.

ANLISIS CRONOLGICO ............................................................................................... 12

5.

RESULTADOS................................................................................................................... 16
5.1.

5.1.1.

Ajuste de los resultados ................................................................................. 19

5.1.2.

Chequeo de la deriva con las fuerzas ajustadas ............................................ 21

5.1.3.

Calculo de las irregularidades ........................................................................ 22

5.2.

6.

7.

Mtodo De NewMark-Hall ..................................................................................... 18

Mtodo De Anlisis Cronolgico............................................................................ 27

5.2.1.

Ajuste de los resultados ................................................................................. 28

5.2.2.

Chequeo de la deriva con las forzar ajustadas .............................................. 30

5.2.3.

Calculo de las irregularidades ........................................................................ 32

DISEO DE LOS ELEMENTOS .......................................................................................... 34


6.1.

Mtodo De Newmark-Hall ..................................................................................... 34

6.2.

Mtodo De Anlisis Cronolgico............................................................................ 41

CONCLUCIONES .............................................................................................................. 49

1. INTRODUCCIN
De acuerdo a lo propuesto para el proyecto final de diseo sismo resistente se
obtuvo la arquitectura del bloque 350 y se realizaron los pasos propuestos por
medio de anlisis modal espectral usando el espectro de NewMark Hall y el anlisis
cronolgico utilizando los registros de los acelero-gramas de la microzonificacin
ssmica de Cali con el objetivo de llevar la estructura propuesta a cumplir las derivas
mximas permitidas por la Norma Sismo Resistente Colombiana (NSR-10).

2. PROCEDIMIENTO Y DESCRIPCIN ESTRUCTURAL


La estructura se cheque para tener la resistencia y rigidez adecuada ante las
solicitaciones mnimas exigidas en las NSR-10; adems se verific que se dispone de
la rigidez necesaria para limitar la deformabilidad ante cargas de servicio, de tal
manera que no se vea afectado el funcionamiento de la estructura. A continuacin
se especifican las etapas que se llevaron a cabo para la realizacin del anlisis y
diseo estructural.
2.1. Pre-Dimensionamiento
Para evaluar las solicitaciones que puedan afectar la estructura, tales como el peso
propio de la estructura (PP), las cargas muertas de cubierta y de entrepiso (DL),
carga viva cubierta (Lr), carga viva de entrepiso (L), cargas de viento en la cubierta y
fachadas (W) y cargas ssmicas (E). De esta manera se pre-dimensiona la estructura
de acuerdo a las cargas estticas a las que se ver sometida.
El sistema estructural empleado para resistir cargas verticales y horizontales
(ssmicas) es de tipo Prticos Arriostrados Excntricamente, tal como se describe
en el Captulo A.3 de Reglamento Colombiano de Construccin Sismo Resistente
(NSR10).
2.2. Evaluacin De Cargas
2.2.1. Cargas muertas
La carga muerta cubre todas las cargas de elementos permanentes de construccin
incluyendo el peso propio, muros, pisos, cubiertas, cielos rasos, acabados y todas
aquellas cargas que son causadas por la ocupacin y su uso (NSR-10 Cap. B.3).
2.2.2. Carga viva
Las cargas vivas son aquellas cargas producidas por el uso y ocupacin de la
edificacin y no deben incluir cargas ambientales tales como viento y sismo. Las
cargas vivas en la cubierta son aquellas causadas por materiales, equipos y
trabajadores utilizados en el mantenimiento de la cubierta y durante la vida de la
estructura causada por objetos mviles y por las personas que tengan acceso a ellas.
A continuacin se presenta una relacin se las cargas vivas y muertas empleadas en
el diseo segn NSR-10.

CARGAS DE PISO
Carga Viva:
Carga Viva:

2.00 kN/m2
5.00 kN/m2

Tabla B.4.2.1-1 Salones de clase

Carga Muerta
Muros Y particiones:
Acabados De piso:
Total Carga Muerta:

2.00 kN/m2
1.50 kN/m2
3.50 kN/m2

Tabla B.34.3-1

Carga Viva:

0.50 kN/m2

Tabla B.4.2.1-2

Teja:
Cielo Raso:
Total Carga Muerta:

0.40 kN/m2
0.10 kN/m2
0.50 kN/m2

Tabla B.4.2.1-1 Corredores y escaleras

Tabla B.34.3-1

CARGAS DE CUBIERTA

Carga Muerta

3. ESPECTRO NEWMARK HALL


A continuacin se presenta un resumen de los resultados obtenidos al desarrollar un
espectro de diseo elstico mediante el uso del mtodo de Newmark-Hall y el
programa EFE-SIO desarrollado en la Universidad del Valle.
El espectro contempla los efectos de amplificacin generados por las caractersticas
dinmicas del suelo subyacente al Edificio 350 de la Universidad del Valle, por lo que
puede considerarse un espectro de diseo vlido nicamente en este sitio
especfico. Adicionalmente, el modelo considera la respuesta del suelo ante seales
ssmicas en escenarios Corticales, de Subduccin Superficial y de Subduccin
Profunda.
3.1. Caractersticas Geotcnicas Consideradas
La siguiente tabla relaciona las caractersticas geotcnicas consideradas durante el
anlisis de efectos de sitio.

H
[m]
3.50
2.70
4.30
7.50
12.0

Vs
[m/s]
176.8
172.4
187.6
138.0
174.4

[kN/m3]
17.95
21.58
15.94
17.17
21.09

[%]
6.0
10.0
6.0
6.0
10.0

Datos en roca:
Vs= 1500 m/s
=
26 kN/m3
=
5 %

3.2. Seales Ssmicas Consideradas


Con el objetivo de considerar un amplio rango de comportamientos ssmicos, se
utilizaron los acelero gramas correspondientes a 10 sismos histricos, con diferentes
caractersticas
y
diferentes
fuentes.
A continuacin se presenta una tabla donde se presentan los sismos considerados.

Escenario

Cortical

Subduccin
Profunda
Subduccin
Superficial

Pas
Irn
Japn
N.
Zelanda
Italia
Japn
Per
Chile
Mxico
Mxico
N.
Zelanda

Ao
2002
2005
1991

Mes
Junio
Marzo
Enero

Da
22
20
28

Hora
2
1
18

Minuto
58
53
0

Segundo
20
48
57

1997
2003
1974
2005
1985
1985
2003

Septiembre
Mayo
Enero
Junio
Septiembre
Septiembre
Agosto

26
26
5
13
19
21
21

9
9
8
22
13
1
12

40
24
33
44
17
37
12

30
39
51
33
43
19
59

3.3. Procedimiento
El proceso de construccin del siguiente espectro comienza con la adquisicin de los
acelero gramas antes mencionados, dada su variedad de orgenes, es necesario
estandarizar el sistema de unidades que manejan los datos para poder compararlos;
para esta tarea se escogi de la unidad [g].
Eventualmente, se procede a determinar la mxima aceleracin de todos los
registros y a normalizar los datos de todos los acelero gramas con respecto a dicho
valor.
Por ltimo, se ingresan los registros normalizados al programa EFE-SIO y se registran
las respuestas mximas en superficie en trminos de Aceleracin, Velocidad y
Desplazamiento.
3.4. Resultados Obtenidos
Respuestas mximas de los sismos del decreto de microzonificacin

Sismo
Chile
Irn

Acel.
g
0.028
0.140

Vel.
m/s
0.007
0.055

Desp.
m
0.008
0.571

para = 5%
A= 2.71

Italia
Japn Fukuoka
Japn Honshu
N. Zelanda
Inangahua
N. Zelanda Jackson
Bay
Per
Mxico PAPD
Mxico Union
Valores Mximos
Valores Amplificados

0.001
0.830
0.459

0.001
0.444
3.180

0.005
105.400
2293.900

0.389

0.532

96.740

0.138

0.142

16.930

0.517
0.001
1.215
1.215
3.293

0.296
0.001
1.470
3.180
7.314

12.900
0.059
16.330
2293.900
4610.739

V= 2.3
D= 2.01

Respuestas mximas de los sismos retirando valores no


representativos
Acel.
Vel.
Desp.
Sismo
g
m/s
m
Chile
0.028
0.007
0.008
Irn
0.140
0.055
Italia
0.001
0.001
0.005
Japn Fukuoka
Japn Honshu
N. Zelanda
0.389
Inangahua
N. Zelanda Jackson
0.138
0.142
Bay
Per
0.517
0.296
Mxico PAPD
0.001
0.001
0.059
Mxico Union
Valores Mximos
0.517
0.296
0.059
Valores Amplificados
1.401
0.680
0.118

3.5. Mtodo De Newmark-Hall


El mtodo de Newmark-Hall es uno de distintos mtodos utilizados para la
generacin de espectros de diseo con base en seales ssmicas existentes.
Dicho mtodo consiste en graficar en un diagrama tripartita (Aceleracin, Velocidad
y Desplazamiento) las respuestas mximas obtenidas del anlisis de efectos de sitio

y generar unas lneas envolventes siguiendo criterios geomtricos. Adicionalmente,


se escalan los valores obtenidos por los factores A,V,D
A partir del espectro generado en el diagrama tripartita en escala logartmica, se
procede a leer distintos valores sobre el diagrama para generar un espectro en
escala lineal ms fcil de interpretar y utilizar.
Una vez se obtiene el espectro de pseudo-velocidad, se pueden calcular los
espectros de pseudo-aceleracin y desplazamientos simplemente modulando por el
valor .

T
[s]
0.00
0.01
0.03
0.05
0.10
0.13
0.20
0.30
0.33
0.50
0.75
1.00
1.50
2.00
2.70
3.00
4.00
5.00

Acel.
[g]
0.000
0.544
0.528
0.769
1.089
1.332
1.329
1.324
1.320
0.871
0.581
0.436
0.290
0.218
0.161
0.128
0.074
0.049

Vel.
[m/s]
0.008
0.009
0.025
0.060
0.170
0.260
0.415
0.620
0.680
0.680
0.680
0.680
0.680
0.680
0.680
0.600
0.460
0.380

Desp.
[m]
0.000
0.000
0.000
0.000
0.003
0.005
0.013
0.030
0.036
0.054
0.081
0.108
0.162
0.216
0.292
0.286
0.293
0.302

Espectro de diseo elstico (Aceleracin)


1.40

Aceleracin [g]

1.20
1.00
0.80
0.60
0.40
0.20
0.00
0.00

0.50

1.00

1.50

2.00

2.50

3.00

3.50

4.00

4.50

5.00

5.50

Perodo T [s]

0.80

Espectro de diseo elstico (Velocidad)

Velocidad [m/s]

0.70
0.60
0.50
0.40
0.30
0.20
0.10
0.00
0.00

1.00

2.00

3.00
Perodo T [s]

4.00

5.00

6.00

Espectro de diseo elstico


(Desplazamiento)

0.35
Desplazameinto [m]

0.30
0.25
0.20
0.15
0.10
0.05
0.00
0.00

1.00

2.00

3.00

4.00

5.00

6.00

Perodo T [s]

Espectro de diseo elstico (Aceleracin)


1.40

Aceleracin [g]

1.20
1.00
Newmark-Hall
0.80
NSR-10
0.60
0.40
0.20
0.00
0.00

0.50

1.00

1.50

2.00

2.50

3.00

Perodo T [s]

3.50

4.00

4.50

5.00

5.50

4. ANLISIS CRONOLGICO
Para realizacin del anlisis cronolgico utilizaron 7 registros de acelero gramas, los
cuales se procesaron por el programa EFE-SIO para obtener la respuesta del suelo
frente a cada uno de dichos sismos en unidades de gravedad, los sismos utilizados
para el anlisis cronolgico son los siguientes:

Iran
Japon F.
Fapon H.
Mexico U.
Nueva Zelanda I.
Nueva Zelanda JB.
Peru

A continuacin se muestran las grficas que representan las respuestas del suelo
frente a los registros sismogrficos estudiados, todos estn en unidades de
gravedad:

Registro Sismo de Irn

Registro Sismo de Japn F.

Registro Sismo de Japn H.

Registro Sismo de Mxico U.

Nueva Zelanda I.

Nueva Zelanda JB.

Per

5. RESULTADOS
Se realiz la modelacin del edificio 350 por medio del software Etabs y se
realizaron los chequeos de las derivas mximas permitidas por la NSR-10 realizando
un anlisis modal utilizando el espectro de NewMark Hall y el anlisis cronolgico.

Modelo Utilizado para el anlisis estructural


Una vez definido el sistema estructural a utilizar (Prticos de acero arriostrados
excntricamente) se procedi a hacer el anlisis modal para obtener las propiedades
dinmicas de la estructura.

Periodos Modales de la estructura


Case
Modal
Modal
Modal

Mode
1.0
2.0
3.0

Period
sec
0.292
0.188
0.166

UX

UY

Sum UX

Sum UY

0.964
0.000
0.000

0.000
0.953
0.045

0.964
0.964
0.964

0.000
0.953
0.998

Como se observa en la tabla anterior la participacin de la masa supera el 90% lo


cual es satisfactorio, adems se observa que el modo fundamental es 0.292 seg.

Modo 1

Modo 2

Modo 3
5.1. Mtodo De NewMark-Hall
Tomando el espectro obtenido por el mtodo de NewMark Hall para el perfil de
suelo analizado se realiz un anlisis modal espectral del edificio 350.

Espectro obtenido por el mtodo NewMark Hall

De acuerdo al periodo fundamental de la estructura se obtiene el Sa para realizar el


analisis por el metodo de Fuerza Horizontal Equivalente.

Con base en el espectro de NewMark Hall se obtiene el Sa =1.324 como se observa


en la tabla anterior.

5.1.1. Ajuste de los resultados


Load
Case/Combo
Dead
FHEX
FHEY
EX_NH Max
EY_NH Max

FX
FY
FZ
MX
MY
MZ
kN
kN
kN
kN-m
kN-m
kN-m
0.0
0.0
7317.3
84561.5 -177385.0
0.0
-9554.3
0.0
0.0
0.0
-31191.1 115499.8
0.0
-9554.3
0.0
31191.1
0.0
-242054.0
9207.3
129.4
0.0
409.6
29724.7 102538.1
129.4
9264.5
0.0
29414.3
418.1
209374.0
Tabla de reacciones en la base sin ajustar

De la tabla anterior se puede observar que la masa del edificio es de 7317 KN y el


cortante basal por medio del mtodo de FHE es de 9554 KN lo cual es coherente de
acuerdo al Sa utilizado.
Con este dato se puede realizar el ajuste del cortante en la base para el mtodo
modal espectral (EX y EY) para cada una de las direcciones, asumiendo que se
ajustara a un 90% de la FHE.
Realizando el caculo para el ajuste de los resultados se obtiene que el factor de
modificacin para EX=0.94 y EY=0.93.

Load
Case/Combo
Dead
FHEX
FHEY
EX_NH Max
EY_NH Max

FX

FY

FZ

MX

MY

MZ

kN
kN
kN
kN-m
kN-m
kN-m
0.0
0.0
7317.3
84723.0 -177737.0
0.0
-9554.3
0.0
0.0
0.0
-31255.0 115681.5
0.0
-9554.3
0.0
31255.0
0.0
-242450.0
8666.9
13.8
0.0
43.2
28020.5
99691.4
13.7
8670.9
0.0
27051.7
44.4
194669.8
Tabla de reacciones en la base ajustados

Realizado el ajuste se verifica que el 90% de FHE es 8598 KN y como se observa en la


tabla anterior los valores de EX y EY estn muy prximos a dicho valor, lo cual es
satisfactorio en cuanto al ajuste de los resultados.

5.1.2. Chequeo de la deriva con las fuerzas ajustadas

Deriva Mxima En la Direccin X=0.83%

Deriva Mxima En la Direccin Y=0.43%

5.1.3. Calculo de las irregularidades


Con base a los resultados obtenidos se calcularon las deformaciones en la esquinas
debidos a las fuerzas ssmicas corregidas para el clculo de las deformaciones,
adems la geometra de la estructura para el clculo de las irregularidades

Desplazamiento Debido al sismo EY

Desplazamiento Debido al sismo EY

Clculo de coeficiente de reduccin por irregularidades en planta ( p)


Descripcin grfica de irregularidades:

Evaluacin en el par de nudos ms criticos


1 =
2 =

15.00 mm
9.60 mm

IRREGULARIDAD TORSIONAL

p=

0.9

Hay retrocesos en las esquinas?


A=
B=
C=
D=
p=

43.20
54.60
17.00
26.70

m
m
m
m

0.9

Hay Irregularidad interna del diafragma?


A=
B=
C=
D=
p=

43.20
28.80
26.70
7.02

p=

SI

m
m
m
m

1.0

Hay Irregularidad de borde del diafragma?


A=
B=
C=
D=
E=

SI

0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
1.0

m
m
m
m
m

NO

Hay Desplazamiento de los planos de accin?


p=

1.0

Hay Sistemas no paralelos?


p=

NO

NO

1.0

Clculo de coeficiente de reduccin por irregularidades en altura ( a)


Descripcin grfica de irregularidades:

Hay cambios de flexibilidad de piso?


KC=
KD=
KE=
KF=
a=

0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
1.0

kPa
kPa
kPa
kPa

1
1

NO

Hay cambios de distribucin de masa?


mC=
mD=
mE=
a=

0.00 kN
0.00 kN
0.00 kN
1.0

Hay cambios de geometra en altura?


a=
b=
a=

a=

NO

0.00 m
0.00 m
1.0

Hay desplazamiento dentro del plano de accin?


a=
b=

NO

0.00 m
0.00 m
1.0

NO

Hay cambios de resistencia por piso?


Resist. B=
Resist. C=
a=

NO

0.00 kN
0.00 kN
1.0

Clculo de coeficiente de reduccin por ausencia de redundancia ssmica ( r)


r= Consultar NSR-10 A.3.3.8.2
r=
1.0

5.2. Mtodo De Anlisis Cronolgico


Una vez cargados los sismos tomados para realizar el anlisis cronolgico se
definieron los casos de carga tomando como factor de carga la gravedad 9.81
m/seg2. Ademar se realizara el ajsute de los resultados tomando como base el
mismo resultado del mtodo de FHE utilizado en el mtodo anterior, es decir,
Sa=1.324.

5.2.1. Ajuste de los resultados


Del anlisis de la estructura se obtiene los cortantes en la base para cado uno de los
registros utilizados, como se observa en la siguiente tabla:
Load Case/Combo
Dead
FHEX
FHEY
EX_Iran Max
EX_Iran Min
EY_Iran Max
EY_Iran Min
EX_Japon_F Max
EX_Japon_F Min
EY_Japon_F Max
EY_Japon_F Min
EX_Japon_H Max
EX_Japon_H Min
EY_Japon_H Max
EY_Japon_H Min
EX_Mexico_U Max
EX_Mexico_U Min
EY_Mexico_U Max
EY_Mexico_U Min
EX_NZ_I Max
EX_NZ_I Min
EY_NZ_I Max
EY_NZ_I Min
EX_NZ_JB Max
EX_NZ_JB Min
EY_NZ_JB Max
EY_NZ_JB Min
EX_Peru Max
EX_Peru Min
EY_Peru Max
EY_Peru Min

FX
kN
0.0
-9554.3
0.0
3093.5
-2654.2
6.5
-7.5
13818.3
-11460.2
41.4
-44.8
7551.8
-9647.1
18.7
-20.1
32416.4
-32452.6
48.9
-50.6
6528.6
-6216.2
16.3
-17.5
3971.6
-3186.3
4.4
-4.4
18674.8
-19314.7
32.6
-28.6

FY
kN
0.0
0.0
-9554.3
6.5
-7.5
4233.3
-4116.4
41.4
-44.8
27838.4
-29991.3
18.7
-20.1
12262.9
-13164.7
48.9
-50.6
31556.0
-25145.0
16.3
-17.5
10198.2
-9251.4
4.4
-4.4
3649.9
-2920.0
32.6
-28.6
16707.0
-15387.2

FZ
kN
7317.3
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0

MX
kN-m
84723.0
0.0
31255.0
23.6
-20.2
12870.7
-13272.8
140.0
-129.5
93644.5
-87073.2
62.7
-58.4
40941.7
-38230.8
158.0
-152.9
78300.8
-98536.9
54.7
-50.8
28895.9
-31830.2
13.7
-13.7
9143.7
-11385.4
89.2
-101.9
48291.4
-52213.5

MY
kN-m
-177737.0
-31255.0
0.0
10047.9
-8582.6
21.0
-24.5
44826.3
-37037.4
134.5
-145.5
24221.8
-31127.8
60.7
-65.1
104666.7
-104721.0
158.8
-164.3
21115.5
-20227.2
52.8
-56.8
12852.1
-10297.2
14.2
-14.2
60413.6
-62544.5
105.8
-92.9

MZ
kN-m
0.0
115681.5
-242450.0
30053.5
-35329.8
101154.6
-95896.6
130190.5
-158500.0
675113.5
-713851.0
111393.8
-87109.8
258892.3
-291747.0
373761.2
-373846.0
721256.4
-568982.0
70757.6
-75215.5
248130.9
-218311.0
36725.0
-45642.9
81238.4
-68247.7
221328.0
-215846.0
398922.1
-380568.0

Tabla de reacciones en la base sin ajustar


Con este dato se puede realizar el ajuste del cortante en la base para el mtodo
modal espectral (EX y EY) para cada una de las direcciones y cada registro,
asumiendo que se ajustara a un 90% de la FHE.

FX
kN

FY
kN

FZ
kN

Dead

0.0

0.0

7317.3

FHEX

-9554.3

0.0

0.0

FHEY

0.0

-9554.3

0.0

EX_Iran Max

8878.4

18.5

0.0

EX_Iran Min

-7617.6

-21.6

0.0

EY_Iran Max

13.1

8593.6

0.0

EY_Iran Min

-15.3

-8356.3

0.0

EX_Japon_F Max
EX_Japon_F Min
EY_Japon_F Max

8705.5
-7219.9
11.9

26.1
-28.2
7989.7

0.0
0.0
0.0

EY_Japon_F Min

-12.9

-8607.6

0.0

EX_Japon_H Max
EX_Japon_H Min
EY_Japon_H Max

6721.1
-8585.9
12.1

16.6
-17.9
7970.9

0.0
0.0
0.0

EY_Japon_H Min

-13.0

-8557.0

0.0

8590.5

13.0

0.0

41.9

27737.2

99048.6

-8600.1

-13.4

0.0

-40.5

-27751.6

-99071.1

13.2

8520.1

0.0

21141.2

42.9

194739.2

-13.7

-6789.1

0.0

-26605.0

-44.4

8598.2

21.4

0.0

72.1

27809.2

Load
Case/Combo

EX_Mexico_U
Max
EX_Mexico_U
Min
EY_Mexico_U
Max
EY_Mexico_U
Min
EX_NZ_I Max

MX
kN-m

MY
MZ
kN-m
kN-m
84723.0
0.0
177737.0
0.0
-31255.0 115681.5
31255.0
0.0
242450.0
67.7
28837.4 86253.4
-58.0
-24632.2
101397.0
26127.5
42.6
205343.8
-26943.7
-49.7
194670.0
88.2
28240.6 82020.0
-81.6
-23333.6 -99854.9
26876.3
38.6
193759.6
-24990.3
-41.7
204877.0
55.8
21557.4 99140.5
-52.0
-27703.8 -77527.8
26612.1
39.4
168280.0
-24850.1
-42.3
189636.0

153625.0
93188.0

EX_NZ_I Min
EY_NZ_I Max

-8186.8
13.7

-23.1
8597.1

0.0
0.0

-66.9
24359.2

EY_NZ_I Min

-14.8

-7798.9

0.0

-26832.7

EX_NZ_JB Max
EX_NZ_JB Min
EY_NZ_JB Max

8598.6
-6898.3
10.3

9.5
-9.5
8599.1

0.0
0.0
0.0

29.6
-29.7
21542.6

EY_NZ_JB Min

-10.3

-6879.6

0.0

-26824.1

EX_Peru Max
EX_Peru Min
EY_Peru Max

8310.4
-8595.1
16.7

14.5
-12.7
8587.4

0.0
0.0
0.0

39.7
-45.3
24821.6

EY_Peru Min

-14.7

-7909.0

0.0

-26837.5

-26639.3 -99059.0
44.5
209173.6
-47.9
184036.0
27824.8 79509.7
-22293.6 -98817.1
33.6
191398.0
-33.4
160792.0
26884.3 98492.1
-27832.6 -96052.5
54.4
205044.3
-47.7
195611.0

Tabla de reacciones en la base Ajustada


Realizado el ajuste se verifica que el 90% de FHE es 8598 KN y como se observa en la
tabla anterior los valores de EX y EY estn muy prximos a dicho valor, lo cual es
satisfactorio en cuanto al ajuste de los resultados.
5.2.2. Chequeo de la deriva con las forzar ajustadas
Una vez realizado el ajuste de los resultados del cortante basal se realiz el chequeo
de las derivas utilizando la mxima una combinacin envolvente de los registros de
los sismos utilizados para obtener la mxima deriva del sistema estructural de
edificio 350.

Deriva Mxima En la Direccin X=0.86%

Deriva Mxima En la Direccin Y=0.43%

5.2.3. Calculo de las irregularidades


Se obtuvieron los desplazamiento en los columnas de esquina para calcular las
irregularidades debido a las fuerzas ssmicas de la envolvente de los registros de los
acelero gramas y se obtuvieron los siguientes resultados.

Desplazamiento Debido al sismo EY

Desplazamiento Debido al sismo EY

Por el mtodo de anlisis cronolgico la estructura no presenta irregularidad


torsional, a diferencia del mtodo con el espectro calculado con NewMark Hall que
si presenta esta irregularidad.
Clculo de coeficiente de reduccin por irregularidades en planta ( p)
Descripcin grfica de irregularidades:

Evaluacin en el par de nudos ms criticos


1 =
2 =

14.50 mm
11.10 mm

No se presenta irregularidad
torsional

p=

1.0

Hay retrocesos en las esquinas?


A=
B=
C=
D=
p=

43.20
54.60
17.00
26.70

m
m
m
m

0.9

Hay Irregularidad interna del diafragma?


A=
B=
C=
D=
p=

43.20
28.80
26.70
7.02

p=

SI

m
m
m
m

1.0

Hay Irregularidad de borde del diafragma?


A=
B=
C=
D=
E=

SI

0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
1.0

m
m
m
m
m

NO

6. DISEO DE LOS ELEMENTOS


Utilizando el mdulo de diseo del programa Etabs para estructuras de acero se
chequearon cada uno de los elementos del sistema, y se chuequeo que no
presentaran ningn tipo de falla por cada uno de los mtodos realizados.

6.1. Mtodo De Newmark-Hall


A continuacin se presentan los resultados del diseo de los elementos metlicos utilizando
las fuerzas obtenidas del espectro de diseo de NewMark Hall.

Table 6.3 - Steel Column Envelope

Label Story Section


C16

Story3 W12X96

C17

Story3 W12X96

C20

Story3 W12X96

C21

Story3 W12X96

C24

Story3 W12X96

C25

Story3 W12X96

C28

Story3 W12X96

C29

Story3 W12X96

C32

Story3 W12X96

C33

Story3 W12X96

C11

Story2 W12X96

C12

Story2 W12X96

C13

Story2 W12X96

C14

Story2 W12X96

C15

Story2 W12X96

C16

Story2 W12X96

C17

Story2 W12X96

Moment Interaction
Check
0.025 = 0.001 + 0.022 +
0.002
0.027 = 0.001 + 0.022 +
0.004
0.054 = 0.001 + 0.018 +
0.036
0.047 = 0.001 + 0.011 +
0.035
0.025 = 0.001 + 0.02 +
0.004
0.018 = 0.001 + 0.017 +
0.001
0.049 = 0.001 + 0.014 +
0.035
0.049 = 0.001 + 0.012 +
0.036
0.03 = 0.001 + 0.026 +
0.003
0.029 = 0.001 + 0.025 +
0.002
0.311 = 0.002 + 0.115 +
0.195
0.2 = 0.002 + 0.159 + 0.04
0.202 = 0.001 + 0.158 +
0.042
0.283 = 0.002 + 0.111 +
0.17
0.345 = 0.002 + 0.009 +
0.334
0.072 = 0.002 + 0.034 +
0.036
0.073 = 0.002 + 0.034 +
0.037

PMM Combo

V22 V33
Ratio Ratio

Class

Cont.
Plate
mm

Dbl.
Plate
mm

B/C
Ratio
Major

B/C
Ratio
Minor

1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY 0.009

0.002 Seismic HD 2299.5

1.4

1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY 0.009

0.002 Seismic HD 2299.5

1.4

1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY 0.009

0.004 Seismic HD 2299.5

22.6

1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY 0.005

0.004 Seismic HD 2299.5

22.6

1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY 0.011

0.001 Seismic HD 2299.5

22.6

1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY 0.006

0.001 Seismic HD 2299.5

22.6

1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY 0.007

0.004 Seismic HD 2299.5

22.6

1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY 0.006

0.004 Seismic HD 2299.5

22.6

1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY 0.013

0.001 Seismic HD 2299.5

1.4

1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY 0.012

0.001 Seismic HD 2299.5

1.4

1.2D+1L+0.3EX+1EY 0.035

0.01

Seismic HD 2299.5

1.4

1.2D+1L+0.3EX+1EY 0.051

0.002 Seismic HD 2299.5

1.4

1.2D+1L+0.3EX+1EY 0.051

0.002 Seismic HD 2299.5

1.4

1.2D+1L+0.3EX+1EY 0.035

0.009 Seismic HD 2299.5

1.4

1.2D+1L+0.3EX+1EY 0.008

0.017 Seismic HD 2299.5

22.6

1.2D+1L+0.3EX+1EY 0.021

0.002 Seismic HD

989.6

22.5

0.474

1.2D+1L+0.3EX+1EY 0.021

0.002 Seismic HD

989.6

22.5

0.474

Label Story Section


C18

Story2 W12X96

C19

Story2 W12X96

C20

Story2 W12X96

C21

Story2 W12X96

C22

Story2 W12X96

C23

Story2 W12X96

C24

Story2 W12X96

C25

Story2 W12X96

C26

Story2 W12X96

C27

Story2 W12X96

C28

Story2 W12X96

C29

Story2 W12X96

C30

Story2 W12X96

C31

Story2 W12X96

C32

Story2 W12X96

C33

Story2 W12X96

C34

Story2 W12X96

C35

Story2 W12X96

C36

Story2 W12X96

C37

Story2 W12X96

C38

Story2 W12X96

C41

Story2 W12X96

C42

Story2 W12X96

C45

Story2 W12X96

C46

Story2 W12X96

C11

Story1 W12X96

C12

Story1 W12X96

C13

Story1 W12X96

C14

Story1 W12X96

Moment Interaction
Check
0.3 = 0.002 + 0.008 + 0.29
0.355 = 0.002 + 0.013 +
0.34
0.168 = 0.002 + 0.029 +
0.137
0.142 = 0.002 + 0.002 +
0.138
0.304 = 0.002 + 0.006 +
0.296
0.36 = 0.002 + 0.022 +
0.336
0.09 = 0.002 + 0.052 +
0.036
0.04 = 0.002 + 0.003 +
0.035
0.295 = 0.002 + 0.006 +
0.287
0.346 = 0.002 + 0.001 +
0.343
0.143 = 0.002 + 0.007 +
0.134
0.14 = 0.002 + 0.005 +
0.133
0.301 = 0.002 + 0.006 +
0.293
0.34 = 0.002 + 0.002 +
0.336
0.092 = 0.002 + 0.058 +
0.032
0.088 = 0.002 + 0.056 +
0.03
0.292 = 0.002 + 0.006 +
0.284
0.297 = 0.002 + 0.115 +
0.181
0.219 = 0.001 + 0.21 +
0.008
0.153 = 0.001 + 0.149 +
0.002
0.311 = 0.002 + 0.043 +
0.266
0.041 = 0.001 + 0.04 +
0.001
0.235 = 0.002 + 0.005 +
0.228
0.084 = 0.001 + 0.053 +
0.029
0.206 = 0.001 + 0.071 +
0.134
0.331 = 0.021 + 0.142 +
0.168
0.263 = 0.023 + 0.215 +
0.025
0.261 = 0.024 + 0.216 +
0.022
0.316 = 0.02 + 0.195 +

PMM Combo

V22 V33
Ratio Ratio

Class

Cont.
Plate
mm

Dbl.
Plate
mm

B/C
Ratio
Major

B/C
Ratio
Minor

1.2D+1L+0.3EX+1EY 0.008

0.015 Seismic HD 2299.5

22.6

1.2D+1L+0.3EX+1EY

0.018 Seismic HD 2299.5

22.6

1.2D+1L+0.3EX+1EY 0.019

0.008 Seismic HD

989.6

22.6

0.474

1.2D+1L+0.3EX+1EY

0.008 Seismic HD

989.6

22.6

0.474

0.015 Seismic HD 2299.5

22.6

0.01

0.01

1.2D+1L+0.3EX+1EY 0.008
1.2D+1.6L

0.012

0.017 Seismic HD

1.2D+1L+0.3EX+1EY 0.026

0.002 Seismic HD

989.6

22.6

0.474

1.2D+1L+0.3EX+1EY

0.002 Seismic HD

989.6

22.6

0.474

0.015 Seismic HD 2299.5

22.6

0.01

1.2D+1L+0.3EX+1EY 0.007
1.2D+1.6L

0.008

0.018 Seismic HD

1.2D+1L+0.3EX+1EY 0.011

0.008 Seismic HD

989.6

22.6

0.474

1.2D+1L+0.3EX+1EY 0.011

0.008 Seismic HD

989.6

22.6

0.474

1.2D+1L+0.3EX+1EY 0.007

0.015 Seismic HD 2299.5

22.6

1.2D+1.6L

0.008

0.017 Seismic HD

1.2D+1L+0.3EX+1EY 0.031

0.002 Seismic HD

989.6

22.6

0.474

1.2D+1L+0.3EX+1EY

0.002 Seismic HD

989.6

22.6

0.474

1.2D+1L+0.3EX+1EY 0.007

0.015 Seismic HD 2299.5

22.6

1.2D+1L+0.3EX+1EY 0.036

0.009 Seismic HD 2299.5

1.4

0.03

1.2D+1.6L

0.063

0.002 Seismic HD

1.2D+1.6L

0.048

0.001 Seismic HD

1.2D+1.6L

0.021

0.014 Seismic HD

1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY 0.011

0.002 Seismic HD 2299.5

22.6

1.2D+1L+0.3EX+1EY 0.011

0.012 Seismic HD 2299.5

22.6

1.2D+1L+0.3EX+1EY 0.017

0.001 Seismic HD 2299.5

1.4

1.2D+1L+0.3EX+1EY 0.022

0.007 Seismic HD 2299.5

1.4

1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY 0.101

0.016 Seismic HD

989.6

1.2

0.241

0.564

1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY 0.123

0.005 Seismic HD

989.6

2.1

0.241

1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY 0.123

0.004 Seismic HD

989.6

2.1

0.242

1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY 0.102

0.015 Seismic HD

989.6

1.2

0.241

0.569

Label Story Section

Moment Interaction
Check

PMM Combo

V22 V33
Ratio Ratio

Class

Cont.
Plate
mm

Dbl.
Plate
mm

B/C
Ratio
Major

B/C
Ratio
Minor

0.101
C15

Story1 W12X96

C16

Story1 W12X96

C17

Story1 W12X96

C18

Story1 W12X96

C19

Story1 W12X96

C20

Story1 W12X96

C21

Story1 W12X96

C22

Story1 W12X96

C23

Story1 W12X96

C24

Story1 W12X96

C25

Story1 W12X96

C26

Story1 W12X96

C27

Story1 W12X96

C28

Story1 W12X96

C29

Story1 W12X96

C30

Story1 W12X96

C31

Story1 W12X96

C32

Story1 W12X96

C33

Story1 W12X96

C34

Story1 W12X96

C35

Story1 W12X96

C36

Story1 W12X96

C37

Story1 W12X96

C38

Story1 W12X96

C41

Story1 W12X96

C42

Story1 W12X96

C45

Story1 W12X96

C46

Story1 W12X96

0.415 = 0.041 + 0.053 +


0.321
0.235 = 0.046 + 0.166 +
0.023
0.23 = 0.046 + 0.164 + 0.02
0.366 = 0.04 + 0.051 +
0.276
0.42 = 0.038 + 0.056 +
0.326
0.269 = 0.032 + 0.164 +
0.074
0.255 = 0.034 + 0.149 +
0.072
0.365 = 0.037 + 0.048 +
0.281
0.425 = 0.038 + 0.067 +
0.32
0.224 = 0.037 + 0.168 +
0.019
0.213 = 0.044 + 0.15 +
0.019
0.362 = 0.039 + 0.048 +
0.275
0.414 = 0.038 + 0.05 +
0.326
0.257 = 0.034 + 0.154 +
0.069
0.257 = 0.034 + 0.151 +
0.072
0.364 = 0.037 + 0.048 +
0.279
0.412 = 0.041 + 0.051 +
0.321
0.239 = 0.05 + 0.174 +
0.016
0.243 = 0.05 + 0.173 + 0.02
0.362 = 0.04 + 0.049 +
0.273
0.332 = 0.021 + 0.202 +
0.109
0.279 = 0.028 + 0.236 +
0.015
0.265 = 0.034 + 0.212 +
0.02
0.37 = 0.034 + 0.086 + 0.25
0.186 = 0.019 + 0.152 +
0.014
0.314 = 0.032 + 0.155 +
0.127
0.197 = 0.01 + 0.169 +
0.018
0.262 = 0.018 + 0.176 +
0.069

1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY 0.064

0.028 Seismic HD

989.6

22.6

0.491

0.574

1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY 0.073

0.005 Seismic HD

989.6

22.6

0.493

1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY 0.072

0.004 Seismic HD

989.6

22.6

0.493

1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY 0.061

0.025 Seismic HD

989.6

22.6

0.49

0.578

1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY 0.066

0.028 Seismic HD

989.6

22.6

0.489

0.572

1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY 0.071

0.012 Seismic HD

989.6

22.6

0.487

0.623

1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY 0.059

0.011 Seismic HD

989.6

22.6

0.488

0.624

1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

0.06

0.025 Seismic HD

989.6

22.6

0.489

0.577

1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY 0.068

0.028 Seismic HD

989.6

22.6

0.489

0.572

1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY 0.079

0.004 Seismic HD

989.6

22.6

0.489

1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY 0.059

0.004 Seismic HD

989.6

22.6

0.492

1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

0.06

0.024 Seismic HD

989.6

22.6

0.49

0.578

1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY 0.063

0.028 Seismic HD

989.6

22.6

0.489

0.572

1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY 0.062

0.011 Seismic HD

989.6

22.6

0.488

0.624

1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

0.06

0.011 Seismic HD

989.6

22.6

0.488

0.624

1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

0.06

0.024 Seismic HD

989.6

22.6

0.489

0.577

1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY 0.061

0.028 Seismic HD

989.6

22.6

0.491

0.574

1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY 0.084

0.004 Seismic HD 2201.2

30.1

0.583

1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY 0.083

0.004 Seismic HD 2201.2

30.1

0.583

1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY 0.061

0.024 Seismic HD

989.6

22.6

0.49

0.578

1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY 0.105

0.016 Seismic HD

989.6

1.2

0.241

0.564

1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY 0.138

0.003 Seismic HD 2201.2

8.6

0.329

1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY 0.117

0.003 Seismic HD 2201.2

30.1

0.578

1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY 0.077

0.022 Seismic HD

989.6

22.6

0.491

0.576

1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY 0.064

0.003 Seismic HD

989.6

22.6

0.487

1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY 0.064

0.019 Seismic HD

989.6

22.6

0.493

0.574

1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY 0.077

0.003 Seismic HD

989.6

1.3

0.242

1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY 0.084

0.011 Seismic HD

989.6

1.3

0.243

0.567

Table 6.4 - Steel Beam Envelope

Label

Story

Section

Moment
Interaction Check

PMM Combo

V22 Ratio V33 Ratio

Class

Conn. V I- Conn. V JEnd


End
N
N

B5

Story3

W10X45

0.011 = 0 + 0.011 + 0

1.4D

0.007

Seismic HD 111672.02

111650.69

B17

Story3

W10X45

0.011 = 0 + 0.011 + 0

1.4D

0.007

Seismic HD 111633.18

111689.53

B29

Story3

W10X45

0.036 = 0 + 0.036 + 0 1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

0.01

Seismic HD 111765.57

111949.39

B30

Story3

W10X45

0.035 = 0 + 0.035 + 0 1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

0.01

Seismic HD 111866.59

111848.36

B31

Story3

W10X45

0.035 = 0 + 0.035 + 0 1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

0.01

Seismic HD 111802.73

111912.23

B32

Story3

W10X45

0.036 = 0 + 0.036 + 0 1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

0.01

Seismic HD 111942.76

111772.2

B35

Story3

W10X45

0.036 = 0 + 0.036 + 0 1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

0.01

Seismic HD 111772.32

111942.63

B36

Story3

W10X45

0.035 = 0 + 0.035 + 0 1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

0.01

Seismic HD 111918.42

111796.53

B37

Story3

W10X45

0.035 = 0 + 0.035 + 0 1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

0.01

Seismic HD 111808.05

111906.9

B38

Story3

W10X45

0.036 = 0 + 0.036 + 0 1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

0.01

Seismic HD 111961.66

111753.29

B1

Story2

W10X45

0.09 = 0 + 0.09 + 0

1.2D+1L+0.3EX+1EY

0.053

Seismic HD

-7007.9

8564.36

B2

Story2

W10X45

0.02 = 0 + 0.02 + 0

1.4D

0.007

Seismic HD

3185.53

3185.53

B3

Story2

W10X45

0.05

Seismic HD

-7158.26

8389.65

B4

Story2

W10X45

0.02 = 0 + 0.02 + 0

1.4D

0.007

Seismic HD

3185.53

3185.53

B5

Story2

W10X45

0.02 = 0 + 0.02 + 0

1.4D

0.007

Seismic HD

3185.53

3185.53

B6

Story2

W10X45

0.02 = 0 + 0.02 + 0

1.4D

0.007

Seismic HD

3185.53

3185.53

B7

Story2

W10X45

0.073 = 0 + 0.073 + 0 1.2D+1L+0.3EX+1EY

0.036

Seismic HD

-6614.32

6682.26

B9

Story2

W10X45

0.072 = 0 + 0.072 + 0 1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

0.037

Seismic HD

-6403.07

6927.38

B10

Story2

W10X45

0.02 = 0 + 0.02 + 0

1.4D

0.007

Seismic HD

3185.53

3185.53

B12

Story2

W10X45

0.02 = 0 + 0.02 + 0

1.4D

0.007

Seismic HD

3185.53

3185.53

B13

Story2

W10X45

0.065 = 0 + 0.065 + 0 1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

0.035

Seismic HD

-6250.18

5424.9

B15

Story2

W10X45

0.065 = 0 + 0.065 + 0 1.2D+1L+0.3EX+1EY

0.035

Seismic HD

-6117.02

5649.39

B16

Story2

W10X45

0.02 = 0 + 0.02 + 0

1.4D

0.007

Seismic HD

3185.53

3185.53

B17

Story2

W10X45

0.02 = 0 + 0.02 + 0

1.4D

0.007

Seismic HD

3185.53

3185.53

B18

Story2

W10X45

0.02 = 0 + 0.02 + 0

1.4D

0.007

Seismic HD

3185.53

3185.53

B19

Story2

W10X45

0.038

Seismic HD

-6221.05

4802.28

B20

Story2

W10X45

0.007

Seismic HD

3185.53

3185.53

B21

Story2

W10X45

0.066 = 0 + 0.066 + 0 1.2D+1L+0.3EX+1EY

0.042

Seismic HD

-6443.06

B22

Story2

W10X45

0.067 = 0 + 0.067 + 0 1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

0.015

Seismic HD 112547.49

111167.46

B23

Story2

W10X45

0.055 = 0 + 0.055 + 0 1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

0.013

Seismic HD 111520.04

112194.91

B24

Story2

W10X45

0.051 = 0 + 0.051 + 0 1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

0.013

Seismic HD 111781.59

111933.36

B25

Story2

W10X45

0.052 = 0 + 0.052 + 0 1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

0.013

Seismic HD

111812.7

111902.26

B26

Story2

W10X45

0.052 = 0 + 0.052 + 0 1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

0.013

Seismic HD 111749.86

111965.09

B27

Story2

W10X45

0.072 = 0 + 0.072 + 0 1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

0.015

Seismic HD 110774.96

112940

B28

Story2

W10X45

0.074 = 0 + 0.074 + 0 1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

0.015

Seismic HD 113025.89

110689.06

B29

Story2

W10X45

0.051 = 0 + 0.051 + 0 1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

0.013

Seismic HD 111486.61

112228.35

B30

Story2

W10X45

0.046 = 0 + 0.046 + 0 1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

0.012

Seismic HD 111898.33

111816.63

B31

Story2

W10X45

0.049 = 0 + 0.049 + 0 1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

0.012

Seismic HD 111916.66

111798.3

B32

Story2

W10X45

0.049 = 0 + 0.049 + 0 1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

0.012

Seismic HD

112079

111635.96

B33

Story2

W10X45

0.081 = 0 + 0.081 + 0 1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

0.016

Seismic HD

110414.9

113379.47

B34

Story2

W10X45

0.074 = 0 + 0.074 + 0 1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

0.015

Seismic HD 113060.81

110654.15

B35

Story2

W10X45

0.049 = 0 + 0.049 + 0 1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

0.012

Seismic HD 111619.88

112095.07

B36

Story2

W10X45

0.047 = 0 + 0.047 + 0 1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

0.012

Seismic HD 111873.83

111841.12

B37

Story2

W10X45

0.048 = 0 + 0.048 + 0 1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

0.012

Seismic HD 111744.67

111970.28

B38

Story2

W10X45

0.049 = 0 + 0.049 + 0 1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

0.013

Seismic HD 112099.53

111615.42

B39

Story2

W10X45

0.065 = 0 + 0.065 + 0 1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

0.014

Seismic HD 110994.74

112720.22

B40

Story2

W10X45

0.068 = 0 + 0.068 + 0 1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

0.015

Seismic HD 112673.47

111041.49

0.087 = 0 + 0.087 + 0 1.2D+1L+0.3EX+1EY

0.063 = 0 + 0.063 + 0 1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY


0.02 = 0 + 0.02 + 0

1.4D

4707.7

Conn. V I- Conn. V JEnd


End
N
N

Label

Story

Section

Moment
Interaction Check

B41

Story2

W10X45

0.052 = 0 + 0.052 + 0 1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

0.013

Seismic HD 111722.08

111992.88

B42

Story2

W10X45

0.051 = 0 + 0.051 + 0 1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

0.013

Seismic HD 111831.82

111883.13

B43

Story2

W10X45

0.052 = 0 + 0.052 + 0 1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

0.013

Seismic HD 111795.91

111919.05

B44

Story2

W10X45

0.051 = 0 + 0.051 + 0 1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

0.013

Seismic HD 111849.43

111865.53

B45

Story2

W10X45

0.055 = 0 + 0.055 + 0 1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

0.013

Seismic HD 111543.37

112171.58

B46

Story2

W10X45

0.007

Seismic HD

3185.53

3185.53

B47

Story2

W10X45

0.065 = 0 + 0.065 + 0 1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

0.044

Seismic HD

-6554.85

-4320.98

B48

Story2

W10X45

0.063 = 0 + 0.063 + 0 1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

0.018

Seismic HD 140484.42

143218.17

B49

Story2

W10X45

0.067 = 0 + 0.067 + 0 1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

0.017

Seismic HD 141108.81

142300.79

B50

Story2

W10X45

0.055 = 0 + 0.055 + 0 1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

0.016

Seismic HD 141345.26

142064.34

B51

Story2

W10X45

0.07 = 0 + 0.07 + 0

1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

0.017

Seismic HD 140834.25

142575.35

B52

Story2

W10X45

0.036 = 0 + 0.036 + 0

1.4D

0.012

Seismic HD 331699.43

B53

Story2

W10X45

0.063 = 0 + 0.063 + 0

1.4D

0.019

Seismic HD 334552.68

B54

Story2

W10X45

0.063 = 0 + 0.063 + 0

1.4D

0.019

Seismic HD 334552.68

B55

Story2

W10X45

0.063 = 0 + 0.063 + 0

1.4D

0.019

Seismic HD 334552.68

B56

Story2

W10X45

0.063 = 0 + 0.063 + 0

1.4D

0.019

Seismic HD 334552.68

B57

Story2

W10X45

0.063 = 0 + 0.063 + 0

1.4D

0.019

Seismic HD 334552.68

B58

Story2

W10X45

0.058 = 0 + 0.058 + 0

1.4D

0.017

Seismic HD 333958.25

B59

Story2

W10X45

0.052 = 0 + 0.052 + 0

1.4D

0.016

Seismic HD 333363.82

B60

Story2

W10X45

0.03 = 0 + 0.03 + 0

1.4D

0.01

Seismic HD

331105

B61

Story2

W10X45

0.021 = 0 + 0.021 + 0

1.4D

0.007

Seismic HD

B62

Story2

W10X45

0.021 = 0 + 0.021 + 0

1.4D

0.007

Seismic HD

B63

Story2

W10X45

0.021 = 0 + 0.021 + 0

1.4D

0.007

Seismic HD

B64

Story2

W10X45

0.021 = 0 + 0.021 + 0

1.4D

0.007

Seismic HD

B65

Story2

W10X45

0.021 = 0 + 0.021 + 0

1.4D

0.007

Seismic HD

B66

Story2

W10X45

0.021 = 0 + 0.021 + 0

1.4D

0.007

Seismic HD

B67

Story2

W10X45

0.013 = 0 + 0.013 + 0

1.4D

0.006

Seismic HD

B68

Story2

W10X45

0.013 = 0 + 0.013 + 0

1.4D

0.006

Seismic HD

B69

Story2

W10X45

0.04 = 0 + 0.04 + 0

1.4D

0.012

Seismic HD

305643.97

B70

Story2

W10X45

0.07 = 0 + 0.07 + 0

1.4D

0.019

Seismic HD

308497.22

B71

Story2

W10X45

0.07 = 0 + 0.07 + 0

1.4D

0.019

Seismic HD

308497.22

B72

Story2

W10X45

0.07 = 0 + 0.07 + 0

1.4D

0.019

Seismic HD

308497.22

B73

Story2

W10X45

0.07 = 0 + 0.07 + 0

1.4D

0.019

Seismic HD

308497.22

B74

Story2

W10X45

0.07 = 0 + 0.07 + 0

1.4D

0.019

Seismic HD

308497.22

B75

Story2

W10X45

0.04 = 0 + 0.04 + 0

1.4D

0.012

Seismic HD

305643.97

B76

Story2

W10X45

0.021 = 0 + 0.021 + 0

1.4D

0.007

Seismic HD

B77

Story2

W10X45

0.021 = 0 + 0.021 + 0

1.4D

0.007

Seismic HD

B78

Story2

W10X45

0.021 = 0 + 0.021 + 0

1.4D

0.007

Seismic HD

B79

Story2

W10X45

0.021 = 0 + 0.021 + 0

1.4D

0.007

Seismic HD

B80

Story2

W10X45

0.021 = 0 + 0.021 + 0

1.4D

0.007

Seismic HD

B81

Story2

W10X45

0.007

Seismic HD

B1

Story1

W10X45

0.233

0.001

B2

Story1

W10X45

0.056

B3

Story1

W10X45

0.237

0.001

B4

Story1

W10X45

0.021 = 0 + 0.021 + 0
1.4D
0.457 = 0.005 + 0.449
1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY
+ 0.003
0.204 = 0 + 0.204 + 0
1.2D+1.6L
0.46 = 0.005 + 0.452 +
1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY
0.003
0.387 = 0 + 0.387 + 0
1.2D+1.6L

0.107

B5

Story1

W10X45

0.47 = 0 + 0.47 + 0

1.2D+1.6L

0.136

B6

Story1

W10X45

0.372 = 0 + 0.372 + 0

1.2D+1.6L

0.107

0.02 = 0 + 0.02 + 0

PMM Combo

1.4D

V22 Ratio V33 Ratio

Class

Seismic HD -45306.97

46916.96

Seismic HD

26645.7

26645.7

Seismic HD -45020.22

47131.61

Seismic HD

50560.94

50560.94

Seismic HD

63959.62

63959.62

Seismic HD

50560.94

50560.94

Moment
Interaction Check

Label

Story

Section

PMM Combo

B7

Story1

W10X45

B9

Story1

W10X45

B10

Story1

W10X45

0.413 = 0.005 + 0.406


1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY
+ 0.002
0.417 = 0.004 + 0.41 +
1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY
0.003
0.407 = 0 + 0.407 + 0
1.2D+1.6L

B11

Story1

W10X45

0.569 = 0 + 0.569 + 0

B12

Story1

W10X45

B13

Story1

W10X45

B15

Story1

W10X45

B16

Story1

W10X45

0.387 = 0 + 0.387 + 0
1.2D+1.6L
0.373 = 0.004 + 0.366
1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY
+ 0.003
0.37 = 0.004 + 0.364 +
1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY
0.003
0.372 = 0 + 0.372 + 0
1.2D+1.6L

B17

Story1

W10X45

B18

Story1

W10X45

B19

Story1

W10X45

B20

Story1

W10X45

B21

Story1

W10X45

B22

Story1

W10X45

0.341 = 0 + 0.341 + 0 1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY


0.335 = 0.004 + 0.328
1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY
+ 0.003
0.295 = 0 + 0.295 + 0
1.2D+1.6L
0.345 = 0.004 + 0.338
1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY
+ 0.003
0.67 = 0 + 0.67 + 0
1.2D+1.6L

B23

Story1

W10X45

0.647 = 0 + 0.647 + 0

B24

Story1

W10X45

B25

Story1

B26

V22 Ratio V33 Ratio

Class

Conn. V I- Conn. V JEnd


End
N
N

0.206

0.001

Seismic HD -50918.53

51135.23

0.21

0.001

Seismic HD -50338.19

51108.54

0.122

Seismic HD

57616.39

45852.53

0.164

Seismic HD

77358.31

77358.31

0.107

Seismic HD

50560.94

50560.94

0.191

0.001

Seismic HD

-47537.3

46454.32

0.186

0.001

Seismic HD -47182.75

46666.73

0.107

Seismic HD

50560.94

50560.94

0.161

Seismic HD

75865.75

75865.75

0.107

Seismic HD

50560.94

50560.94

0.176

0.001

Seismic HD -36343.22

34074.02

0.082

Seismic HD

38551.82

38551.82

0.177

0.001

Seismic HD -44752.45

43061.08

0.306

Seismic HD 231036.41

236303.39

0.3

Seismic HD 233637.42

233702.39

0.602 = 0 + 0.602 + 0 1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

0.286

Seismic HD 228048.62

203809.98

W10X45

0.654 = 0 + 0.654 + 0

1.2D+1.6L

0.302

Seismic HD 232935.85

234403.95

Story1

W10X45

0.652 = 0 + 0.652 + 0

1.2D+1.6L

0.301

Seismic HD 233354.03

233985.78

B27

Story1

W10X45

0.663 = 0 + 0.663 + 0

1.2D+1.6L

0.305

Seismic HD 235745.04

231594.76

B28

Story1

W10X45

0.964 = 0 + 0.964 + 0

1.2D+1.6L

0.444

Seismic HD 286819.56

293057.61

B29

Story1

W10X45

0.81 = 0 + 0.81 + 0

1.2D+1.6L

0.408

Seismic HD 271139.58

230498.33

B30

Story1

W10X45

1.2D+1.6L

0.248

Seismic HD 209098.79

202483.78

B31

Story1

W10X45

0.774 = 0 + 0.774 + 0

1.2D+1.6L

0.402

Seismic HD

268893.6

232744.31

B32

Story1

W10X45

0.826 = 0 + 0.826 + 0

1.2D+1.6L

0.409

Seismic HD 230109.37

271528.54

B33

Story1

W10X60

0.872 = 0 + 0.872 + 0

1.2D+1.6L

0.456

Seismic MD 364777.36

357431.74

B34

Story1

W10X45

0.963 = 0 + 0.963 + 0

1.2D+1.6L

0.444

Seismic HD 286916.64

292960.54

B35

Story1

W10X45

0.806 = 0 + 0.806 + 0

1.2D+1.6L

0.406

Seismic HD 270667.28

230970.63

B36

Story1

W10X45

0.799 = 0 + 0.799 + 0

1.2D+1.6L

0.406

Seismic HD 231393.05

270244.86

B37

Story1

W10X45

0.796 = 0 + 0.796 + 0

1.2D+1.6L

0.405

Seismic HD 270031.64

231606.27

B38

Story1

W10X45

0.824 = 0 + 0.824 + 0

1.2D+1.6L

0.409

Seismic HD 230213.95

271423.95

B39

Story1

W10X60

0.862 = 0 + 0.862 + 0

1.2D+1.6L

0.453

Seismic MD 363129.56

359079.54

B40

Story1

W10X45

0.654 = 0 + 0.654 + 0

1.2D+1.6L

0.3

Seismic HD 228866.16

233526.95

B41

Story1

W10X45

0.635 = 0 + 0.635 + 0

1.2D+1.6L

0.294

Seismic HD 231236.66

231156.45

B42

Story1

W10X45

0.634 = 0 + 0.634 + 0

1.2D+1.6L

0.294

Seismic HD 231181.15

231211.95

B43

Story1

W10X45

0.634 = 0 + 0.634 + 0

1.2D+1.6L

0.294

Seismic HD 231158.95

231234.15

B44

Story1

W10X45

0.635 = 0 + 0.635 + 0

1.2D+1.6L

0.294

Seismic HD 231154.45

231238.66

B45

Story1

W10X45

0.64 = 0 + 0.64 + 0

1.2D+1.6L

0.296

Seismic HD 231997.36

230395.74

B46

Story1

W10X45

0.106

Seismic HD

B47

Story1

W10X45

0.17

0.001

Seismic HD -34993.28

B48

Story1

W10X45

0.383 = 0 + 0.383 + 0
1.2D+1.6L
0.318 = 0.004 + 0.312
1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY
+ 0.003
0.394 = 0 + 0.394 + 0 1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

0.175

Seismic HD 211861.41

203741.5

B49

Story1

W10X45

0.346 = 0 + 0.346 + 0 1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

0.168

Seismic HD 209051.05

206551.85

B50

Story1

W10X45

1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

0.221

Seismic HD 231484.25

229101.1

B51

Story1

W10X45

0.435 = 0 + 0.435 + 0 1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

0.223

Seismic HD 232306.77

228278.58

0.58 = 0 + 0.58 + 0

0.44 = 0 + 0.44 + 0

1.2D+1.6L

1.2D+1.6L

1.2D+1.6L

50062.7

50062.7
32157.72

Conn. V I- Conn. V JEnd


End
N
N

Moment
Interaction Check

PMM Combo

W10X45

0.38 = 0 + 0.38 + 0

1.2D+1.6L

0.117

Seismic HD 375947.08

W10X45

0.753 = 0 + 0.753 + 0

1.2D+1.6L

0.23

Seismic HD 423047.99

Story1

W10X45

0.753 = 0 + 0.753 + 0

1.2D+1.6L

0.23

Seismic HD 423047.99

B55

Story1

W10X45

0.753 = 0 + 0.753 + 0

1.2D+1.6L

0.23

Seismic HD 423047.99

B56

Story1

W10X45

0.753 = 0 + 0.753 + 0

1.2D+1.6L

0.23

Seismic HD 423047.99

B57

Story1

W10X45

0.753 = 0 + 0.753 + 0

1.2D+1.6L

0.23

Seismic HD 423047.99

B58

Story1

W10X45

0.675 = 0 + 0.675 + 0

1.2D+1.6L

0.209

Seismic HD 414500.96

B59

Story1

W10X45

0.596 = 0 + 0.596 + 0

1.2D+1.6L

0.189

Seismic HD 405953.93

B60

Story1

W10X45

0.302 = 0 + 0.302 + 0

1.2D+1.6L

0.096

Seismic HD 367400.05

B61

Story1

W10X45

0.286 = 0 + 0.286 + 0

1.2D+1.6L

0.079

Seismic HD

B62

Story1

W10X45

0.286 = 0 + 0.286 + 0

1.2D+1.6L

0.079

Seismic HD

B63

Story1

W10X45

0.286 = 0 + 0.286 + 0

1.2D+1.6L

0.079

Seismic HD

B64

Story1

W10X45

0.286 = 0 + 0.286 + 0

1.2D+1.6L

0.079

Seismic HD

B65

Story1

W10X45

0.286 = 0 + 0.286 + 0

1.2D+1.6L

0.079

Seismic HD

B66

Story1

W10X45

0.286 = 0 + 0.286 + 0

1.2D+1.6L

0.079

Seismic HD

B67

Story1

W10X45

0.186 = 0 + 0.186 + 0

1.2D+1.6L

0.059

Seismic HD

B68

Story1

W10X45

0.186 = 0 + 0.186 + 0

1.2D+1.6L

0.059

Seismic HD

B69

Story1

W10X45

0.446 = 0 + 0.446 + 0

1.2D+1.6L

0.126

Seismic HD

353580.55

B70

Story1

W10X45

0.882 = 0 + 0.882 + 0

1.2D+1.6L

0.248

Seismic HD

404370.39

B71

Story1

W10X45

0.882 = 0 + 0.882 + 0

1.2D+1.6L

0.248

Seismic HD

404370.39

B72

Story1

W10X45

0.882 = 0 + 0.882 + 0

1.2D+1.6L

0.248

Seismic HD

404370.39

B73

Story1

W10X45

0.882 = 0 + 0.882 + 0

1.2D+1.6L

0.248

Seismic HD

404370.39

B74

Story1

W10X45

0.882 = 0 + 0.882 + 0

1.2D+1.6L

0.248

Seismic HD

404370.39

B75

Story1

W10X45

0.446 = 0 + 0.446 + 0

1.2D+1.6L

0.126

Seismic HD

353580.55

B76

Story1

W10X45

0.307 = 0 + 0.307 + 0

1.2D+1.6L

0.085

Seismic HD

B77

Story1

W10X45

0.307 = 0 + 0.307 + 0

1.2D+1.6L

0.085

Seismic HD

B78

Story1

W10X45

0.307 = 0 + 0.307 + 0

1.2D+1.6L

0.085

Seismic HD

B79

Story1

W10X45

0.307 = 0 + 0.307 + 0

1.2D+1.6L

0.085

Seismic HD

B80

Story1

W10X45

0.307 = 0 + 0.307 + 0

1.2D+1.6L

0.085

Seismic HD

B81

Story1

W10X45

0.307 = 0 + 0.307 + 0

1.2D+1.6L

0.085

Seismic HD

B92

Story1

W10X45

0.3 = 0 + 0.3 + 0

1.2D+1.6L

0.162

Seismic HD 619181.08

B93

Story1

W10X45

0.3 = 0 + 0.3 + 0

1.2D+1.6L

0.162

Seismic HD 619181.08

B94

Story1

W10X45

0.3 = 0 + 0.3 + 0

1.2D+1.6L

0.162

Seismic HD 619181.08

B95

Story1

W10X45

1.2D+1.6L

0.162

Seismic HD 619181.08

B252

Story1

W10X45

1.2D+1.6L

0.128

Seismic HD

60215.79

47922.86

B254

Story1

W10X45

0.3 = 0 + 0.3 + 0
Lb/ry > 0.086*E/Fy
(AISC 341-PartI 9.8)
0.133 = 0 + 0.133 + 0

1.2D+1.6L

0.056

Seismic HD

26649.81

26649.81

Label

Story

Section

B52

Story1

B53

Story1

B54

V22 Ratio V33 Ratio

Class

Table 6.5 - Steel Brace Envelope

Label Story

Section

Moment Interaction Check

PMM Combo

V22
V33
Ratio Ratio

Class

Conn. P I- Conn. P JEnd


End
N
N

D1

Story2 PIPE6SCH40

0.047 = 0.033 + 0.014 + 0

1.2D+1L+0.3EX+1EY 0.003

Seismic HD -36778.31

-35879.66

D2

Story2 PIPE6SCH40

0.045 = 0.031 + 0.014 + 0

1.2D+1L+0.3EX+1EY 0.003

Seismic HD -34848.23

-33949.59

D3

Story2 PIPE6SCH40

0.038 = 0.024 + 0.014 + 0

1.2D+1L+0.3EX+1EY 0.003

Seismic HD -26584.54

-25685.89

D4

Story2 PIPE6SCH40

0.038 = 0.024 + 0.014 + 0

1.2D+1L+0.3EX+1EY 0.003

Seismic HD -27218.26

-26319.62

D5

Story2 PIPE6SCH40

0.03 = 0.017 + 0.014 + 0

1.2D+1L+0.3EX+1EY 0.003

Seismic HD -18530.26

18494.54

D6

Story2 PIPE6SCH40

0.031 = 0.017 + 0.014 + 0

1.2D+1L+0.3EX+1EY 0.003

Seismic HD

-18716.52

-19390.5

Label Story

Section

Moment Interaction Check

PMM Combo

V22
V33
Ratio Ratio

Class

Conn. P I- Conn. P JEnd


End
N
N

D7

Story2 PIPE6SCH40

0.027 = 0.014 + 0.014 + 0

1.2D+1L+0.3EX+1EY 0.003

Seismic HD

19392.97

20291.61

D8

Story2 PIPE6SCH40

0.029 = 0.015 + 0.014 + 0

1.2D+1L+0.3EX+1EY 0.003

Seismic HD

21887.03

22785.68

D9

Story2 PIPE6SCH40

0.03 = 0.016 + 0.014 + 0

1.2D+1L+0.3EX+1EY 0.003

Seismic HD

23397.33

24295.97

D10

Story2 PIPE6SCH40

0.034 = 0.02 + 0.014 + 0

1.2D+1L+0.3EX+1EY 0.003

Seismic HD

28625.61

29524.25

D11

Story2 PIPE6SCH40

0.033 = 0.019 + 0.014 + 0

1.2D+1L+0.3EX+1EY 0.003

Seismic HD

26735.97

27634.62

D12

Story2 PIPE6SCH40

0.035 = 0.021 + 0.014 + 0

1.2D+1L+0.3EX+1EY 0.003

Seismic HD -23677.83

-22879.8

D13

Story2 PIPE6SCH40

0.034 = 0.021 + 0.014 + 0

1.2D+1L+0.3EX+1EY 0.003

Seismic HD -22959.66

-22061.02

D14

Story2 PIPE6SCH40

0.037 = 0.023 + 0.014 + 0

1.2D+1L+0.3EX+1EY 0.003

Seismic HD -26098.98

-25200.34

D15

Story2 PIPE6SCH40

0.037 = 0.023 + 0.014 + 0

1.2D+1L+0.3EX+1EY 0.003

Seismic HD -25723.35

-24824.71

D16

Story2 PIPE6SCH40

0.039 = 0.025 + 0.014 + 0

1.2D+1L+0.3EX+1EY 0.003

Seismic HD -27557.97

-26659.32

D17

Story2 PIPE6SCH40

0.041 = 0.027 + 0.014 + 0

1.2D+1L+0.3EX+1EY 0.003

Seismic HD -30182.15

-29283.5

D18

Story2 PIPE6SCH40

0.042 = 0.028 + 0.014 + 0

1.2D+1L+0.3EX+1EY 0.003

Seismic HD -31456.04

-30557.39

D1

Story1 PIPE6SCH40

0.314 = 0.302 + 0.012 + 0

1.2D+1L+0.3EX+1EY 0.003

Seismic HD -165659.08 -164760.44

D2

Story1 PIPE6SCH40

0.319 = 0.306 + 0.012 + 0

1.2D+1L+0.3EX+1EY 0.003

Seismic HD -168228.19 -167329.55

D3

Story1 PIPE6SCH40

0.309 = 0.297 + 0.012 + 0

1.2D+1L+0.3EX+1EY 0.003

Seismic HD -162975.77 -162077.13

D4

Story1 PIPE6SCH40

0.314 = 0.301 + 0.012 + 0

1.2D+1L+0.3EX+1EY 0.003

Seismic HD -165521.76 -164623.12

D5

Story1 PIPE6SCH40

0.271 = 0.259 + 0.012 + 0

1.2D+1L+0.3EX+1EY 0.003

Seismic HD -142174.17 -141275.52

D6

Story1 PIPE6SCH40

0.277 = 0.264 + 0.012 + 0

1.2D+1L+0.3EX+1EY 0.003

Seismic HD -145218.32 -144319.68

D7

Story1 PIPE6SCH40

0.11 = 0.096 + 0.014 + 0

1.2D+1L+0.3EX+1EY 0.003

Seismic HD -105731.33 -104832.69

D8

Story1 PIPE6SCH40

0.246 = 0.234 + 0.012 + 0

1.2D+1L+0.3EX+1EY 0.003

Seismic HD -128346.79 -127448.14

D9

Story1 PIPE6SCH40

0.101 = 0.087 + 0.014 + 0

1.2D+1L+0.3EX+1EY 0.003

Seismic HD -95845.73

-94947.09

D10

Story1 PIPE6SCH40

0.286 = 0.274 + 0.012 + 0

1.2D+1L+0.3EX+1EY 0.003

Seismic HD

-149354.36

D11

Story1 PIPE6SCH40

0.281 = 0.269 + 0.012 + 0

1.2D+1L+0.3EX+1EY 0.003

Seismic HD -147779.21 -146880.56

D12

Story1 PIPE6SCH40

0.305 = 0.293 + 0.012 + 0

1.2D+1L+0.3EX+1EY 0.003

Seismic HD -160932.32 -160033.68

D13

Story1 PIPE6SCH40

0.299 = 0.287 + 0.012 + 0

1.2D+1L+0.3EX+1EY 0.003

Seismic HD -157679.46 -156780.82

D14

Story1 PIPE6SCH40

0.291 = 0.279 + 0.012 + 0

1.2D+1L+0.3EX+1EY 0.003

Seismic HD -153116.57 -152217.93

D15

Story1 PIPE6SCH40

0.286 = 0.274 + 0.012 + 0

1.2D+1L+0.3EX+1EY 0.003

Seismic HD -150258.47 -149359.83

D16

Story1 PIPE6SCH40

0.247 = 0.235 + 0.012 + 0

1.2D+1L+0.3EX+1EY 0.003

Seismic HD -129184.53 -128285.89

D17

Story1 PIPE6SCH40

0.276 = 0.264 + 0.012 + 0

1.2D+1L+0.3EX+1EY 0.003

Seismic HD -144951.12 -144052.47

D18

Story1 PIPE6SCH40

0.24 = 0.228 + 0.012 + 0

1.2D+1L+0.3EX+1EY 0.003

Seismic HD -125240.75 -124342.11

-150253

6.2. Mtodo De Anlisis Cronolgico


A continuacin se presentan los resultados del diseo de los elementos metlicos utilizando
las fuerzas obtenidas de los registros ssmicos del anlisis cronolgico.
Table 2.3 - Steel Column Envelope (Part 1 of 2)

Label

Story

Section Moment Interaction Check

PMM Combo

C16

Story3

W12X96

0.025 = 0.001 + 0.022 + 0.002

1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

0.009

C17

Story3

W12X96

0.027 = 0.001 + 0.022 + 0.004

1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

0.009

Class

Cont.
Plate
mm

0.002

Seismic HD

2299.5

0.002

Seismic HD

2299.5

V22 Ratio V33 Ratio

Class

Cont.
Plate
mm

0.004

Seismic HD

2299.5

0.004

Seismic HD

2299.5

0.011

0.001

Seismic HD

2299.5

1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

0.006

0.001

Seismic HD

2299.5

0.049 = 0.001 + 0.014 + 0.035

1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

0.007

0.004

Seismic HD

2299.5

W12X96

0.049 = 0.001 + 0.012 + 0.036

1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

0.007

0.004

Seismic HD

2299.5

Story3

W12X96

0.031 = 0.001 + 0.027 + 0.003

1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

0.013

0.002

Seismic HD

2299.5

C33

Story3

W12X96

0.029 = 0.001 + 0.026 + 0.002

1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

0.012

0.001

Seismic HD

2299.5

C11

Story2

W12X96

0.311 = 0.002 + 0.115 + 0.194

1.2D+1L+0.3EX+1EY

0.035

0.01

Seismic HD

2299.5

C12

Story2

W12X96

0.2 = 0.002 + 0.159 + 0.039

1.2D+1L+0.3EX+1EY

0.051

0.002

Seismic HD

2299.5

C13

Story2

W12X96

0.201 = 0.001 + 0.158 + 0.041

1.2D+1L+0.3EX+1EY

0.051

0.002

Seismic HD

2299.5

C14

Story2

W12X96

0.283 = 0.002 + 0.112 + 0.17

1.2D+1L+0.3EX+1EY

0.035

0.009

Seismic HD

2299.5

C15

Story2

W12X96

0.345 = 0.002 + 0.009 + 0.334

1.2D+1L+0.3EX+1EY

0.008

0.017

Seismic HD

2299.5

C16

Story2

W12X96

0.071 = 0.002 + 0.034 + 0.035

1.2D+1L+0.3EX+1EY

0.021

0.002

Seismic HD

989.6

C17

Story2

W12X96

0.073 = 0.002 + 0.034 + 0.037

1.2D+1L+0.3EX+1EY

0.021

0.002

Seismic HD

989.6

C18

Story2

W12X96

0.3 = 0.002 + 0.009 + 0.289

1.2D+1L+0.3EX+1EY

0.008

0.015

Seismic HD

2299.5

C19

Story2

W12X96

0.355 = 0.002 + 0.014 + 0.339

1.2D+1L+0.3EX+1EY

0.01

0.018

Seismic HD

2299.5

C20

Story2

W12X96

0.168 = 0.002 + 0.029 + 0.137

1.2D+1L+0.3EX+1EY

0.019

0.008

Seismic HD

989.6

C21

Story2

W12X96

0.142 = 0.002 + 0.003 + 0.137

1.2D+1L+0.3EX+1EY

0.01

0.008

Seismic HD

989.6

C22

Story2

W12X96

0.304 = 0.002 + 0.006 + 0.296

1.2D+1L+0.3EX+1EY

0.008

0.015

Seismic HD

2299.5

C23

Story2

W12X96

0.36 = 0.002 + 0.022 + 0.336

1.2D+1.6L

0.013

0.017

Seismic HD

C24

Story2

W12X96

0.089 = 0.002 + 0.052 + 0.035

1.2D+1L+0.3EX+1EY

0.026

0.002

Seismic HD

C25

Story2

W12X96

0.04 = 0.002 + 0.037 + 0.001

1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

0.01

0.002

Seismic HD

989.6

C26

Story2

W12X96

0.295 = 0.002 + 0.007 + 0.286

1.2D+1L+0.3EX+1EY

0.008

0.015

Seismic HD

2299.5

C27

Story2

W12X96

0.346 = 0.002 + 0.001 + 0.343

1.2D+1.6L

0.008

0.018

Seismic HD

C28

Story2

W12X96

0.143 = 0.002 + 0.007 + 0.134

1.2D+1L+0.3EX+1EY

0.011

0.008

Seismic HD

C29

Story2

W12X96

0.141 = 0.002 + 0.005 + 0.133

1.2D+1L+0.3EX+1EY

0.011

0.008

Seismic HD

989.6

C30

Story2

W12X96

0.302 = 0.002 + 0.007 + 0.294

1.2D+1L+0.3EX+1EY

0.008

0.015

Seismic HD

2299.5

C31

Story2

W12X96

0.34 = 0.002 + 0.002 + 0.336

1.2D+1.6L

0.008

0.017

Seismic HD

C32

Story2

W12X96

0.093 = 0.002 + 0.058 + 0.033

1.2D+1L+0.3EX+1EY

0.031

0.002

Seismic HD

C33

Story2

W12X96

0.09 = 0.002 + 0.056 + 0.032

1.2D+1L+0.3EX+1EY

0.03

0.002

Seismic HD

989.6

C34

Story2

W12X96

0.293 = 0.002 + 0.006 + 0.285

1.2D+1L+0.3EX+1EY

0.007

0.015

Seismic HD

2299.5

C35

Story2

W12X96

0.3 = 0.002 + 0.115 + 0.183

1.2D+1L+0.3EX+1EY

0.036

0.01

Seismic HD

2299.5

C36

Story2

W12X96

0.219 = 0.001 + 0.21 + 0.008

1.2D+1.6L

0.063

0.002

Seismic HD

C37

Story2

W12X96

0.155 = 0.002 + 0.122 + 0.031

1.2D+1L+0.3EX+1EY

0.048

0.001

Seismic HD

C38

Story2

W12X96

0.311 = 0.002 + 0.043 + 0.266

1.2D+1.6L

0.021

0.014

Seismic HD

C41

Story2

W12X96

0.044 = 0.001 + 0.005 + 0.038

1.2D+1L+0.3EX+1EY

0.011

0.002

Seismic HD

2299.5

C42

Story2

W12X96

0.239 = 0.002 + 0.006 + 0.231

1.2D+1L+0.3EX+1EY

0.011

0.012

Seismic HD

2299.5

C45

Story2

W12X96

0.089 = 0.001 + 0.054 + 0.034

1.2D+1L+0.3EX+1EY

0.017

0.002

Seismic HD

2299.5

C46

Story2

W12X96

0.212 = 0.001 + 0.072 + 0.139

1.2D+1L+0.3EX+1EY

0.022

0.007

Seismic HD

2299.5

C11

Story1

W12X96

0.332 = 0.021 + 0.143 + 0.168

1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

0.103

0.016

Seismic HD

989.6

C12

Story1

W12X96

0.267 = 0.023 + 0.219 + 0.025

1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

0.124

0.005

Seismic HD

989.6

C13

Story1

W12X96

0.265 = 0.024 + 0.22 + 0.022

1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

0.125

0.004

Seismic HD

989.6

C14

Story1

W12X96

0.32 = 0.02 + 0.199 + 0.101

1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

0.103

0.015

Seismic HD

989.6

C15

Story1

W12X96

0.416 = 0.041 + 0.053 + 0.321

1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

0.065

0.028

Seismic HD

989.6

C16

Story1

W12X96

0.236 = 0.046 + 0.167 + 0.023

1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

0.073

0.005

Seismic HD

989.6

C17

Story1

W12X96

0.231 = 0.046 + 0.165 + 0.02

1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

0.073

0.004

Seismic HD

989.6

C18

Story1

W12X96

0.367 = 0.04 + 0.051 + 0.276

1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

0.062

0.025

Seismic HD

989.6

Label

Story

Section Moment Interaction Check

PMM Combo

V22 Ratio V33 Ratio

C20

Story3

W12X96

0.054 = 0.001 + 0.018 + 0.036

1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

0.009

C21

Story3

W12X96

0.047 = 0.001 + 0.011 + 0.035

1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

0.006

C24

Story3

W12X96

0.025 = 0.001 + 0.021 + 0.004

1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

C25

Story3

W12X96

0.019 = 0.001 + 0.017 + 0.001

C28

Story3

W12X96

C29

Story3

C32

989.6

989.6

989.6

2299.5

Class

Cont.
Plate
mm

0.028

Seismic HD

989.6

0.011

Seismic HD

989.6

0.06

0.011

Seismic HD

989.6

1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

0.062

0.025

Seismic HD

989.6

0.426 = 0.038 + 0.068 + 0.319

1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

0.069

0.028

Seismic HD

989.6

W12X96

0.228 = 0.037 + 0.172 + 0.019

1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

0.081

0.004

Seismic HD

989.6

Story1

W12X96

0.214 = 0.044 + 0.151 + 0.019

1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

0.06

0.004

Seismic HD

989.6

C26

Story1

W12X96

0.363 = 0.039 + 0.049 + 0.275

1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

0.062

0.024

Seismic HD

989.6

C27

Story1

W12X96

0.415 = 0.038 + 0.051 + 0.326

1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

0.064

0.028

Seismic HD

989.6

C28

Story1

W12X96

0.259 = 0.034 + 0.155 + 0.069

1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

0.062

0.011

Seismic HD

989.6

C29

Story1

W12X96

0.258 = 0.034 + 0.152 + 0.072

1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

0.06

0.011

Seismic HD

989.6

C30

Story1

W12X96

0.366 = 0.037 + 0.049 + 0.28

1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

0.062

0.024

Seismic HD

989.6

C31

Story1

W12X96

0.414 = 0.041 + 0.052 + 0.321

1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

0.062

0.028

Seismic HD

989.6

C32

Story1

W12X96

0.244 = 0.05 + 0.178 + 0.016

1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

0.086

0.004

Seismic HD

2201.2

C33

Story1

W12X96

0.248 = 0.05 + 0.178 + 0.021

1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

0.085

0.004

Seismic HD

2201.2

C34

Story1

W12X96

0.364 = 0.04 + 0.05 + 0.274

1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

0.062

0.024

Seismic HD

989.6

C35

Story1

W12X96

0.334 = 0.021 + 0.204 + 0.11

1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

0.105

0.016

Seismic HD

989.6

C36

Story1

W12X96

0.281 = 0.028 + 0.237 + 0.017

1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

0.139

0.003

Seismic HD

2201.2

C37

Story1

W12X96

0.268 = 0.034 + 0.213 + 0.021

1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

0.117

0.004

Seismic HD

2201.2

C38

Story1

W12X96

0.371 = 0.034 + 0.086 + 0.25

1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

0.078

0.022

Seismic HD

989.6

C41

Story1

W12X96

0.192 = 0.019 + 0.157 + 0.016

1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

0.066

0.004

Seismic HD

989.6

C42

Story1

W12X96

0.321 = 0.032 + 0.159 + 0.129

1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

0.066

0.019

Seismic HD

989.6

C45

Story1

W12X96

0.201 = 0.01 + 0.17 + 0.022

1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

0.078

0.004

Seismic HD

989.6

C46

Story1

W12X96

0.266 = 0.018 + 0.177 + 0.071

1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

0.085

0.011

Seismic HD

989.6

Label

Story

Section Moment Interaction Check

PMM Combo

V22 Ratio V33 Ratio

C19

Story1

W12X96

0.421 = 0.038 + 0.057 + 0.326

1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

0.066

C20

Story1

W12X96

0.27 = 0.032 + 0.165 + 0.074

1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

0.071

C21

Story1

W12X96

0.257 = 0.034 + 0.151 + 0.072

1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

C22

Story1

W12X96

0.367 = 0.037 + 0.049 + 0.281

C23

Story1

W12X96

C24

Story1

C25

Table 2.4 - Steel Beam Envelope (Part 1 of 2)


Label

Story

Section

Moment Interaction Check

PMM Combo

V22 Ratio V33 Ratio

Class

B5

Story3

W10X45

0.011 = 0 + 0.011 + 0

1.4D

0.007

Seismic HD

B17

Story3

W10X45

0.011 = 0 + 0.011 + 0

1.4D

0.007

Seismic HD

B29

Story3

W10X45

0.036 = 0 + 0.036 + 0

1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

0.01

Seismic HD

B30

Story3

W10X45

0.035 = 0 + 0.035 + 0

1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

0.01

Seismic HD

B31

Story3

W10X45

0.035 = 0 + 0.035 + 0

1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

0.01

Seismic HD

B32

Story3

W10X45

0.037 = 0 + 0.037 + 0

1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

0.01

Seismic HD

B35

Story3

W10X45

0.036 = 0 + 0.036 + 0

1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

0.01

Seismic HD

B36

Story3

W10X45

0.036 = 0 + 0.036 + 0

1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

0.01

Seismic HD

B37

Story3

W10X45

0.035 = 0 + 0.035 + 0

1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

0.01

Seismic HD

B38

Story3

W10X45

0.037 = 0 + 0.037 + 0

1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

0.01

Seismic HD

B1

Story2

W10X45

0.088 = 0 + 0.088 + 0

1.2D+1L+0.3EX+1EY

0.051

Seismic HD

B2

Story2

W10X45

0.02 = 0 + 0.02 + 0

1.4D

0.007

Seismic HD

B3

Story2

W10X45

0.086 = 0 + 0.086 + 0

1.2D+1L+0.3EX+1EY

0.048

Seismic HD

B4

Story2

W10X45

0.02 = 0 + 0.02 + 0

1.4D

0.007

Seismic HD

B5

Story2

W10X45

0.02 = 0 + 0.02 + 0

1.4D

0.007

Seismic HD

B6

Story2

W10X45

0.02 = 0 + 0.02 + 0

1.4D

0.007

Seismic HD

B7

Story2

W10X45

0.072 = 0 + 0.072 + 0

1.2D+1L+0.3EX+1EY

0.036

Seismic HD

B9

Story2

W10X45

0.071 = 0 + 0.071 + 0

1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

0.037

Seismic HD

Label

Story

Section

Moment Interaction Check

PMM Combo

V22 Ratio V33 Ratio

Class

B10

Story2

W10X45

0.02 = 0 + 0.02 + 0

1.4D

0.007

Seismic HD

B12

Story2

W10X45

0.02 = 0 + 0.02 + 0

1.4D

0.007

Seismic HD

B13

Story2

W10X45

0.066 = 0 + 0.066 + 0

1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

0.036

Seismic HD

B15

Story2

W10X45

0.066 = 0 + 0.066 + 0

1.2D+1L+0.3EX+1EY

0.035

Seismic HD

B16

Story2

W10X45

0.02 = 0 + 0.02 + 0

1.4D

0.007

Seismic HD

B17

Story2

W10X45

0.02 = 0 + 0.02 + 0

1.4D

0.007

Seismic HD

B18

Story2

W10X45

0.02 = 0 + 0.02 + 0

1.4D

0.007

Seismic HD

B19

Story2

W10X45

0.068 = 0 + 0.068 + 0

1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

0.04

Seismic HD

B20

Story2

W10X45

0.02 = 0 + 0.02 + 0

1.4D

0.007

Seismic HD

B21

Story2

W10X45

0.071 = 0 + 0.071 + 0

1.2D+1L+0.3EX+1EY

0.045

Seismic HD

B22

Story2

W10X45

0.068 = 0 + 0.068 + 0

1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

0.015

Seismic HD

B23

Story2

W10X45

0.055 = 0 + 0.055 + 0

1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

0.013

Seismic HD

B24

Story2

W10X45

0.051 = 0 + 0.051 + 0

1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

0.013

Seismic HD

B25

Story2

W10X45

0.053 = 0 + 0.053 + 0

1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

0.013

Seismic HD

B26

Story2

W10X45

0.052 = 0 + 0.052 + 0

1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

0.013

Seismic HD

B27

Story2

W10X45

0.072 = 0 + 0.072 + 0

1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

0.015

Seismic HD

B28

Story2

W10X45

0.075 = 0 + 0.075 + 0

1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

0.015

Seismic HD

B29

Story2

W10X45

0.051 = 0 + 0.051 + 0

1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

0.013

Seismic HD

B30

Story2

W10X45

0.048 = 0 + 0.048 + 0

1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

0.012

Seismic HD

B31

Story2

W10X45

0.05 = 0 + 0.05 + 0

1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

0.012

Seismic HD

B32

Story2

W10X45

0.05 = 0 + 0.05 + 0

1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

0.013

Seismic HD

B33

Story2

W10X45

0.081 = 0 + 0.081 + 0

1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

0.016

Seismic HD

B34

Story2

W10X45

0.075 = 0 + 0.075 + 0

1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

0.016

Seismic HD

B35

Story2

W10X45

0.049 = 0 + 0.049 + 0

1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

0.013

Seismic HD

B36

Story2

W10X45

0.048 = 0 + 0.048 + 0

1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

0.012

Seismic HD

B37

Story2

W10X45

0.049 = 0 + 0.049 + 0

1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

0.012

Seismic HD

B38

Story2

W10X45

0.05 = 0 + 0.05 + 0

1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

0.013

Seismic HD

B39

Story2

W10X45

0.066 = 0 + 0.066 + 0

1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

0.014

Seismic HD

B40

Story2

W10X45

0.069 = 0 + 0.069 + 0

1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

0.015

Seismic HD

B41

Story2

W10X45

0.052 = 0 + 0.052 + 0

1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

0.013

Seismic HD

B42

Story2

W10X45

0.052 = 0 + 0.052 + 0

1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

0.013

Seismic HD

B43

Story2

W10X45

0.052 = 0 + 0.052 + 0

1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

0.013

Seismic HD

B44

Story2

W10X45

0.052 = 0 + 0.052 + 0

1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

0.013

Seismic HD

B45

Story2

W10X45

0.056 = 0 + 0.056 + 0

1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

0.013

Seismic HD

B46

Story2

W10X45

0.02 = 0 + 0.02 + 0

1.4D

0.007

Seismic HD

B47

Story2

W10X45

0.079 = 0 + 0.079 + 0

1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

0.051

Seismic HD

B48

Story2

W10X45

0.063 = 0 + 0.063 + 0

1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

0.018

Seismic HD

B49

Story2

W10X45

0.067 = 0 + 0.067 + 0

1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

0.017

Seismic HD

B50

Story2

W10X45

0.056 = 0 + 0.056 + 0

1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

0.016

Seismic HD

B51

Story2

W10X45

0.07 = 0 + 0.07 + 0

1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

0.018

Seismic HD

B52

Story2

W10X45

0.036 = 0 + 0.036 + 0

1.4D

0.012

Seismic HD

B53

Story2

W10X45

0.063 = 0 + 0.063 + 0

1.4D

0.019

Seismic HD

B54

Story2

W10X45

0.063 = 0 + 0.063 + 0

1.4D

0.019

Seismic HD

B55

Story2

W10X45

0.063 = 0 + 0.063 + 0

1.4D

0.019

Seismic HD

B56

Story2

W10X45

0.063 = 0 + 0.063 + 0

1.4D

0.019

Seismic HD

B57

Story2

W10X45

0.063 = 0 + 0.063 + 0

1.4D

0.019

Seismic HD

B58

Story2

W10X45

0.058 = 0 + 0.058 + 0

1.4D

0.017

Seismic HD

B59

Story2

W10X45

0.052 = 0 + 0.052 + 0

1.4D

0.016

Seismic HD

B60

Story2

W10X45

0.03 = 0 + 0.03 + 0

1.4D

0.01

Seismic HD

Label

Story

Section

Moment Interaction Check

PMM Combo

V22 Ratio V33 Ratio

Class

B61

Story2

W10X45

0.021 = 0 + 0.021 + 0

1.4D

0.007

Seismic HD

B62

Story2

W10X45

0.021 = 0 + 0.021 + 0

1.4D

0.007

Seismic HD

B63

Story2

W10X45

0.021 = 0 + 0.021 + 0

1.4D

0.007

Seismic HD

B64

Story2

W10X45

0.021 = 0 + 0.021 + 0

1.4D

0.007

Seismic HD

B65

Story2

W10X45

0.021 = 0 + 0.021 + 0

1.4D

0.007

Seismic HD

B66

Story2

W10X45

0.021 = 0 + 0.021 + 0

1.4D

0.007

Seismic HD

B67

Story2

W10X45

0.013 = 0 + 0.013 + 0

1.4D

0.006

Seismic HD

B68

Story2

W10X45

0.013 = 0 + 0.013 + 0

1.4D

0.006

Seismic HD

B69

Story2

W10X45

0.04 = 0 + 0.04 + 0

1.4D

0.012

Seismic HD

B70

Story2

W10X45

0.07 = 0 + 0.07 + 0

1.4D

0.019

Seismic HD

B71

Story2

W10X45

0.07 = 0 + 0.07 + 0

1.4D

0.019

Seismic HD

B72

Story2

W10X45

0.07 = 0 + 0.07 + 0

1.4D

0.019

Seismic HD

B73

Story2

W10X45

0.07 = 0 + 0.07 + 0

1.4D

0.019

Seismic HD

B74

Story2

W10X45

0.07 = 0 + 0.07 + 0

1.4D

0.019

Seismic HD

B75

Story2

W10X45

0.04 = 0 + 0.04 + 0

1.4D

0.012

Seismic HD

B76

Story2

W10X45

0.021 = 0 + 0.021 + 0

1.4D

0.007

Seismic HD

B77

Story2

W10X45

0.021 = 0 + 0.021 + 0

1.4D

0.007

Seismic HD

B78

Story2

W10X45

0.021 = 0 + 0.021 + 0

1.4D

0.007

Seismic HD

B79

Story2

W10X45

0.021 = 0 + 0.021 + 0

1.4D

0.007

Seismic HD

B80

Story2

W10X45

0.021 = 0 + 0.021 + 0

1.4D

0.007

Seismic HD

B81

Story2

W10X45

0.021 = 0 + 0.021 + 0

1.4D

0.007

Seismic HD

B1

Story1

W10X45

0.45 = 0.004 + 0.443 + 0.003

1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

0.227

0.001

Seismic HD

B2

Story1

W10X45

0.204 = 0 + 0.204 + 0

1.2D+1.6L

0.056

Seismic HD

B3

Story1

W10X45

0.453 = 0.004 + 0.446 + 0.003

1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

0.231

0.001

Seismic HD

B4

Story1

W10X45

0.387 = 0 + 0.387 + 0

1.2D+1.6L

0.107

Seismic HD

B5

Story1

W10X45

0.47 = 0 + 0.47 + 0

1.2D+1.6L

0.136

Seismic HD

B6

Story1

W10X45

0.387 = 0 + 0.387 + 0

1.2D+1.6L

0.107

Seismic HD

B7

Story1

W10X45

0.409 = 0.004 + 0.402 + 0.002

1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

0.203

0.001

Seismic HD

B9

Story1

W10X45

0.413 = 0.004 + 0.406 + 0.003

1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

0.208

0.001

Seismic HD

B10

Story1

W10X45

0.407 = 0 + 0.407 + 0

1.2D+1.6L

0.122

Seismic HD

B11

Story1

W10X45

0.569 = 0 + 0.569 + 0

1.2D+1.6L

0.164

Seismic HD

B12

Story1

W10X45

0.387 = 0 + 0.387 + 0

1.2D+1.6L

0.107

Seismic HD

B13

Story1

W10X45

0.378 = 0.004 + 0.371 + 0.003

1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

0.192

0.001

Seismic HD

B15

Story1

W10X45

0.375 = 0.004 + 0.368 + 0.003

1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

0.187

0.001

Seismic HD

B16

Story1

W10X45

0.387 = 0 + 0.387 + 0

1.2D+1.6L

0.107

Seismic HD

B17

Story1

W10X45

0.558 = 0 + 0.558 + 0

1.2D+1.6L

0.161

Seismic HD

B18

Story1

W10X45

0.372 = 0 + 0.372 + 0

1.2D+1.6L

0.107

Seismic HD

B19

Story1

W10X45

0.365 = 0.004 + 0.357 + 0.003

1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

0.187

0.001

Seismic HD

B20

Story1

W10X45

0.238 = 2.826E-04 + 0.238 + 0

1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

0.082

Seismic HD

B21

Story1

W10X45

0.375 = 0.004 + 0.368 + 0.003

1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

0.189

0.001

Seismic HD

B22

Story1

W10X45

0.67 = 0 + 0.67 + 0

1.2D+1.6L

0.306

Seismic HD

B23

Story1

W10X45

0.647 = 0 + 0.647 + 0

1.2D+1.6L

0.3

Seismic HD

B24

Story1

W10X45

0.604 = 0 + 0.604 + 0

1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

0.286

Seismic HD

B25

Story1

W10X45

0.654 = 0 + 0.654 + 0

1.2D+1.6L

0.302

Seismic HD

B26

Story1

W10X45

0.652 = 0 + 0.652 + 0

1.2D+1.6L

0.301

Seismic HD

B27

Story1

W10X45

0.663 = 0 + 0.663 + 0

1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

0.305

Seismic HD

B28

Story1

W10X45

0.964 = 0 + 0.964 + 0

1.2D+1.6L

0.444

Seismic HD

B29

Story1

W10X45

0.81 = 0 + 0.81 + 0

1.2D+1.6L

0.408

Seismic HD

B30

Story1

W10X45

0.511 = 0 + 0.511 + 0

1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

0.248

Seismic HD

Label

Story

Section

Moment Interaction Check

PMM Combo

V22 Ratio V33 Ratio

Class

B31

Story1

W10X45

0.774 = 0 + 0.774 + 0

1.2D+1.6L

0.402

B32

Story1

W10X45

0.826 = 0 + 0.826 + 0

1.2D+1.6L

0.409

Seismic HD

B33

Story1

W10X60

0.872 = 0 + 0.872 + 0

1.2D+1.6L

0.456

Seismic MD

B34

Story1

W10X45

0.963 = 0 + 0.963 + 0

1.2D+1.6L

0.444

Seismic HD

B35

Story1

W10X45

0.806 = 0 + 0.806 + 0

1.2D+1.6L

0.406

Seismic HD

B36

Story1

W10X45

0.799 = 0 + 0.799 + 0

1.2D+1.6L

0.406

Seismic HD

B37

Story1

W10X45

0.796 = 0 + 0.796 + 0

1.2D+1.6L

0.405

Seismic HD

B38

Story1

W10X45

0.824 = 0 + 0.824 + 0

1.2D+1.6L

0.409

Seismic HD

B39

Story1

W10X60

0.862 = 0 + 0.862 + 0

1.2D+1.6L

0.453

Seismic MD

B40

Story1

W10X45

0.654 = 0 + 0.654 + 0

1.2D+1.6L

0.3

Seismic HD

B41

Story1

W10X45

0.636 = 0 + 0.636 + 0

1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

0.294

Seismic HD

B42

Story1

W10X45

0.635 = 0 + 0.635 + 0

1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

0.294

Seismic HD

B43

Story1

W10X45

0.635 = 0 + 0.635 + 0

1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

0.294

Seismic HD

B44

Story1

W10X45

0.635 = 0 + 0.635 + 0

1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

0.294

Seismic HD

B45

Story1

W10X45

0.64 = 0 + 0.64 + 0

1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

0.296

Seismic HD

B46

Story1

W10X45

0.368 = 0 + 0.368 + 0

1.2D+1.6L

0.106

Seismic HD

B47

Story1

W10X45

0.384 = 0.004 + 0.377 + 0.003

1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

0.201

0.001

Seismic HD

B48

Story1

W10X45

0.396 = 0 + 0.396 + 0

1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

0.175

Seismic HD

B49

Story1

W10X45

0.349 = 0 + 0.349 + 0

1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

0.168

Seismic HD

B50

Story1

W10X45

0.442 = 0 + 0.442 + 0

1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

0.221

Seismic HD

B51

Story1

W10X45

0.438 = 0 + 0.438 + 0

1.2D+1L+1EX+0.3EY

0.223

Seismic HD

B52

Story1

W10X45

0.38 = 0 + 0.38 + 0

1.2D+1.6L

0.117

Seismic HD

B53

Story1

W10X45

0.753 = 0 + 0.753 + 0

1.2D+1.6L

0.23

Seismic HD

B54

Story1

W10X45

0.753 = 0 + 0.753 + 0

1.2D+1.6L

0.23

Seismic HD

B55

Story1

W10X45

0.753 = 0 + 0.753 + 0

1.2D+1.6L

0.23

Seismic HD

B56

Story1

W10X45

0.753 = 0 + 0.753 + 0

1.2D+1.6L

0.23

Seismic HD

B57

Story1

W10X45

0.753 = 0 + 0.753 + 0

1.2D+1.6L

0.23

Seismic HD

B58

Story1

W10X45

0.675 = 0 + 0.675 + 0

1.2D+1.6L

0.209

Seismic HD

B59

Story1

W10X45

0.596 = 0 + 0.596 + 0

1.2D+1.6L

0.189

Seismic HD

B60

Story1

W10X45

0.302 = 0 + 0.302 + 0

1.2D+1.6L

0.096

Seismic HD

B61

Story1

W10X45

0.286 = 0 + 0.286 + 0

1.2D+1.6L

0.079

Seismic HD

B62

Story1

W10X45

0.286 = 0 + 0.286 + 0

1.2D+1.6L

0.079

Seismic HD

B63

Story1

W10X45

0.286 = 0 + 0.286 + 0

1.2D+1.6L

0.079

Seismic HD

B64

Story1

W10X45

0.286 = 0 + 0.286 + 0

1.2D+1.6L

0.079

Seismic HD

B65

Story1

W10X45

0.286 = 0 + 0.286 + 0

1.2D+1.6L

0.079

Seismic HD

B66

Story1

W10X45

0.286 = 0 + 0.286 + 0

1.2D+1.6L

0.079

Seismic HD

B67

Story1

W10X45

0.186 = 0 + 0.186 + 0

1.2D+1.6L

0.059

Seismic HD

B68

Story1

W10X45

0.186 = 0 + 0.186 + 0

1.2D+1.6L

0.059

Seismic HD

B69

Story1

W10X45

0.446 = 0 + 0.446 + 0

1.2D+1.6L

0.126

Seismic HD

B70

Story1

W10X45

0.882 = 0 + 0.882 + 0

1.2D+1.6L

0.248

Seismic HD

B71

Story1

W10X45

0.882 = 0 + 0.882 + 0

1.2D+1.6L

0.248

Seismic HD

B72

Story1

W10X45

0.882 = 0 + 0.882 + 0

1.2D+1.6L

0.248

Seismic HD

B73

Story1

W10X45

0.882 = 0 + 0.882 + 0

1.2D+1.6L

0.248

Seismic HD

B74

Story1

W10X45

0.882 = 0 + 0.882 + 0

1.2D+1.6L

0.248

Seismic HD

B75

Story1

W10X45

0.446 = 0 + 0.446 + 0

1.2D+1.6L

0.126

Seismic HD

B76

Story1

W10X45

0.307 = 0 + 0.307 + 0

1.2D+1.6L

0.085

Seismic HD

B77

Story1

W10X45

0.307 = 0 + 0.307 + 0

1.2D+1.6L

0.085

Seismic HD

B78

Story1

W10X45

0.307 = 0 + 0.307 + 0

1.2D+1.6L

0.085

Seismic HD

B79

Story1

W10X45

0.307 = 0 + 0.307 + 0

1.2D+1.6L

0.085

Seismic HD

Seismic HD

Label

Story

Section

Moment Interaction Check

PMM Combo

V22 Ratio V33 Ratio

Class

B80

Story1

W10X45

0.307 = 0 + 0.307 + 0

1.2D+1.6L

0.085

Seismic HD

B81

Story1

W10X45

0.307 = 0 + 0.307 + 0

1.2D+1.6L

0.085

Seismic HD

B92

Story1

W10X45

0.3 = 0 + 0.3 + 0

1.2D+1.6L

0.162

Seismic HD

B93

Story1

W10X45

0.3 = 0 + 0.3 + 0

1.2D+1.6L

0.162

Seismic HD

B94

Story1

W10X45

0.3 = 0 + 0.3 + 0

1.2D+1.6L

0.162

Seismic HD

B95

Story1

W10X45

0.3 = 0 + 0.3 + 0

1.2D+1.6L

0.162

Seismic HD

B252

Story1

W10X45

Lb/ry > 0.086*E/Fy (AISC 341-PartI 9.8)

1.2D+1.6L

0.128

Seismic HD

B254

Story1

W10X45

0.133 = 0 + 0.133 + 0

1.2D+1.6L

0.056

Seismic HD

Table 2.5 - Steel Brace Envelope

Label

Story

Section

Moment Interaction
Check

PMM Combo

V22
Ratio

V33
Ratio

Class

Conn. P I- Conn. P JEnd


End
N
N

D1

Story2 PIPE6SCH40 0.046 = 0.032 + 0.014 + 0 1.2D+1L+0.3EX+1EY

0.003

Seismic HD

-35972.1

D2

Story2 PIPE6SCH40 0.045 = 0.031 + 0.014 + 0 1.2D+1L+0.3EX+1EY

0.003

Seismic HD

-34042.14

-35073.45
-33143.5

D3

Story2 PIPE6SCH40 0.037 = 0.024 + 0.014 + 0 1.2D+1L+0.3EX+1EY

0.003

Seismic HD

-26271.69

-25373.04

D4

Story2 PIPE6SCH40 0.038 = 0.024 + 0.014 + 0 1.2D+1L+0.3EX+1EY

0.003

Seismic HD

-26905.9

-26007.25

D5

Story2 PIPE6SCH40 0.031 = 0.017 + 0.014 + 0 1.2D+1L+0.3EX+1EY

0.003

Seismic HD

-18809.07

18700.94

D6

Story2 PIPE6SCH40 0.031 = 0.017 + 0.014 + 0 1.2D+1L+0.3EX+1EY

0.003

Seismic HD

-19668.89

-18994.91

D7

Story2 PIPE6SCH40 0.029 = 0.015 + 0.014 + 0 1.2D+1L+0.3EX+1EY

0.003

Seismic HD

20913.27

21811.91

D8

Story2 PIPE6SCH40 0.03 = 0.016 + 0.014 + 0 1.2D+1L+0.3EX+1EY

0.003

Seismic HD

23402.92

24301.56

D9

Story2 PIPE6SCH40 0.033 = 0.019 + 0.014 + 0 1.2D+1L+0.3EX+1EY

0.003

Seismic HD

27811.13

28709.77

D10

Story2 PIPE6SCH40 0.033 = 0.019 + 0.014 + 0 1.2D+1L+0.3EX+1EY

0.003

Seismic HD

27819.06

28717.7

D11

Story2 PIPE6SCH40 0.033 = 0.019 + 0.014 + 0 1.2D+1L+0.3EX+1EY

0.003

Seismic HD

25929.55

26828.19

D12

Story2 PIPE6SCH40 0.035 = 0.021 + 0.014 + 0 1.2D+1L+0.3EX+1EY

0.003

Seismic HD

-23328.34

-22530.32

D13

Story2 PIPE6SCH40 0.034 = 0.02 + 0.014 + 0 1.2D+1L+0.3EX+1EY

0.003

Seismic HD

-22609.81

-21711.16

D14

Story2 PIPE6SCH40 0.037 = 0.024 + 0.014 + 0 1.2D+1L+0.3EX+1EY

0.003

Seismic HD

-26305.06

-25406.42

D15

Story2 PIPE6SCH40 0.037 = 0.023 + 0.014 + 0 1.2D+1L+0.3EX+1EY

0.003

Seismic HD

-25929.76

-25031.11

D16

Story2 PIPE6SCH40 0.04 = 0.026 + 0.014 + 0 1.2D+1L+0.3EX+1EY

0.003

Seismic HD

-29077.93

-28179.29

D17

Story2 PIPE6SCH40 0.042 = 0.029 + 0.014 + 0 1.2D+1L+0.3EX+1EY

0.003

Seismic HD

-31698.21

-30799.57

D18

Story2 PIPE6SCH40 0.046 = 0.032 + 0.014 + 0 1.2D+1L+0.3EX+1EY

0.003

Seismic HD

-35869.34

-34970.69

D1

Story1 PIPE6SCH40 0.307 = 0.295 + 0.012 + 0 1.2D+1L+0.3EX+1EY

0.003

Seismic HD -161833.31 -160934.67

D2

Story1 PIPE6SCH40 0.312 = 0.299 + 0.012 + 0 1.2D+1L+0.3EX+1EY

0.003

Seismic HD -164402.31 -163503.67

D3

Story1 PIPE6SCH40 0.306 = 0.294 + 0.012 + 0 1.2D+1L+0.3EX+1EY

0.003

Seismic HD -161414.02 -160515.38

D4

Story1 PIPE6SCH40 0.311 = 0.299 + 0.012 + 0 1.2D+1L+0.3EX+1EY

0.003

Seismic HD -163959.89 -163061.25

D5

Story1 PIPE6SCH40 0.273 = 0.261 + 0.012 + 0 1.2D+1L+0.3EX+1EY

0.003

Seismic HD -143480.93 -142582.28

D6

Story1 PIPE6SCH40 0.279 = 0.267 + 0.012 + 0 1.2D+1L+0.3EX+1EY

0.003

Seismic HD -146525.19 -145626.54

D7

Story1 PIPE6SCH40 0.221 = 0.209 + 0.012 + 0 1.2D+1L+0.3EX+1EY

0.003

Seismic HD -114663.04

D8

Story1 PIPE6SCH40 0.262 = 0.25 + 0.012 + 0 1.2D+1L+0.3EX+1EY

0.003

Seismic HD -137278.18 -136379.54

-113764.4

D9

Story1 PIPE6SCH40 0.113 = 0.099 + 0.014 + 0 1.2D+1L+0.3EX+1EY

0.003

Seismic HD -108847.26 -107948.61

D10

Story1 PIPE6SCH40 0.281 = 0.268 + 0.012 + 0 1.2D+1L+0.3EX+1EY

0.003

Seismic HD -147468.02 -146569.38

D11

Story1 PIPE6SCH40 0.276 = 0.264 + 0.012 + 0 1.2D+1L+0.3EX+1EY

0.003

Seismic HD -144994.16 -144095.51

D12

Story1 PIPE6SCH40 0.302 = 0.29 + 0.012 + 0 1.2D+1L+0.3EX+1EY

0.003

Seismic HD -159054.36 -158155.72

D13

Story1 PIPE6SCH40 0.296 = 0.284 + 0.012 + 0 1.2D+1L+0.3EX+1EY

0.003

Seismic HD -155801.58 -154902.94

D14

Story1 PIPE6SCH40 0.293 = 0.28 + 0.012 + 0 1.2D+1L+0.3EX+1EY

0.003

Seismic HD

D15

Story1 PIPE6SCH40 0.288 = 0.275 + 0.012 + 0 1.2D+1L+0.3EX+1EY

0.003

Seismic HD -151210.22 -150311.58

D16

Story1 PIPE6SCH40 0.261 = 0.248 + 0.012 + 0 1.2D+1L+0.3EX+1EY

0.003

Seismic HD -136511.15 -135612.51

-154068.4

-153169.76

Label

Story

Section

Moment Interaction
Check

PMM Combo

V22
Ratio

V33
Ratio

Class

Conn. P I- Conn. P JEnd


End
N
N

D17

Story1 PIPE6SCH40 0.29 = 0.277 + 0.012 + 0 1.2D+1L+0.3EX+1EY

0.003

Seismic HD -152278.39 -151379.74

D18

Story1 PIPE6SCH40 0.277 = 0.264 + 0.012 + 0 1.2D+1L+0.3EX+1EY

0.003

Seismic HD -145229.34 -144330.69

7. CONCLUCIONES

Realizados los dos anlisis, espectral y cronolgico se puede decir que


la respuesta de la estructura frente a la derivas presento un
comportamiento similar ya que nicamente se observa una diferencia
de 3.5% entre las derivas mximas, que en este caso se dieron en la
direccin X del modelo.
Tipo de
Anlisis
Espectral
Cronolgico

Deriva Mxima
X
83%
86%

Y
43%
43%

3.5%

0.0%

Otro de los parmetros calculados fue las irregularidades, en el caso


del anlisis espectral se present una irregularidad torsional, por otro
lado, en el anlisis cronolgico este tipo de irregularidad no se
present, lo que se podra ver representado en el diseo ya que se
puede usar un factor de modificacin ssmico mayor permitiendo
reducir las fuerzas ssmicas un poco ms en comparacin con el
anlisis espectral, sin embargo para este caso no es un factor
determinante ya que la estructura presenta una irregularidad en
planta del tipo 2P.

En cuanto a los ajustes del cortante basal se observa una gran


diferencia en los factores de modificacin ya que en el caso del
anlisis espectral estos factores son muy prximos a 1.00. En el caso
del anlisis cronolgico estos factores varan entre 0.26 y 2.77 lo cual
se debe a las magnitudes de la gravedad de los registros de los
sismos.

El mtodo de NewMark Hall es uno de los muchos mtodos


disponibles para elaborar un espectro de diseo a partir de una
familia de acelero gramas conocidas. Vale la pena resaltar que para
que el mtodo sea confiable se debe escoger adecuadamente los

registros acelero grficos para que estos representen


movimientos ssmicos en el sitio analizado.

los

El mtodo de anlisis cronolgico teniendo en cuenta los resultados


no representan una diferencia significativa en el clculo de las derivas
de la estructura.

También podría gustarte