Redalyc

Sistema de Informacin Cientfica

Red de Revistas Cientficas de Amrica Latina, el Caribe, Espaa y Portugal

CASTELLS, ERNESTINA; OJEDA, MARIO M.; MONTERO, MINERVA

Procedimiento y algoritmo de estimacin en modelos multinivel para proporciones
Revista Colombiana de Estadstica, vol. 33, nm. 2, diciembre, 2010, pp. 233-250
Universidad Nacional de Colombia
Bogot, Colombia
Disponible en: http://www.redalyc.org/src/inicio/ArtPdfRed.jsp?iCve=89919847009

Revista Colombiana de Estadstica

ISSN (Versin impresa): 0120-1751
bpurdinolac@bt.unal.edu.co
Universidad Nacional de Colombia
Colombia

Cmo citar?

Nmero completo

Ms informacin del artculo

Pgina de la revista

www.redalyc.org
Proyecto acadmico sin fines de lucro, desarrollado bajo la iniciativa de acceso abierto


  

 
   !! "  ## " !! $ %
&'()*+,-,*./( 0 123(',/-( +* *4/,-1),5. *.
-(+*2(4 -62/,.,7*2 81'1 8'(8('),(.*4
9:;<=>?:= @A> BCDEF@DE;A GHI;:EDJF EA K?HDEH=L=H K;>=HC M;:
9:;N;:DE;AC
OPQRSTUQV WVSTRXXS1, YZ [VPU\ [] ^_R`V2, aZ [UQRPbV [\QTRP\3, c
defghiej jk leikmniofep qrosktuojej vgiwrxme jk ygkttktxp vfezghfxp l{|ofx
defghiej jk }uiej~uiofe k rxtmniofep qrosktuojej kteftgerep ehezep l{|ofx
oktr{iofep leikmniofe d~uofep e
kzetiemkrix jk leikmniofep ruioigix
eerepjkge

1
2




 $    #  #$$ $ $  #$
  $$     #$$ ##  "  #
   $  $$        $$
 $$ " $    $     $   #
 $#$ $ $ $ $  $   $    $
 $"  $$  $  # $$  $ #
# " $ $#$  $   #  $$  "   
  #  # $ #   $ $$ $$   
$  $#$$ "
  $$  $$ $  
   $$     $"

 #$#  $ #   $   $ $ 
#$$     ## "  $ #
 #  $  $ $ $ "    
$   $ $   #  $##  $# 
$    $    $  $ " $
 $$  ## $  $$"  $  $##
$  $ $#  $$ $ "    $  ##
# $  $$ $   $## $ "
    $ $  $ $ $ 
  "

  $ $ $ " $  $  

./'(+6)),5.

 

 


    

 
 

 


  
 
 
 
 









 

 

   
 
  
 (/,71),5.

81'1 *2 1.2,4,4 -62/,.,7*2 +*

8'(8('),(.*4


  
    

    

    
  !! "#$%$& #''( #)$

*+,-./010 .23, 4 567,+031, /. .83015-092 .2 1,/.6,8 1:63020; .6 < 5+5 <+,< ,+-0,2.8

=>? @   ?  ? A 

B C 
 

 D
=  

 



E

 
 
  C 






 E
 
 F  G 

 





 
 
 
 =  

 
 
  




H I2

-(+*2( 2,.*12 -62/,.,7*2 81'1 8'(8('),(.*4

  



=  =

R
X1 , X2 , . . . , Xt

 Y  =

 = A  G J
  !! "#$%$& #''( #)$

  $ $ $ " $  $  

X1, X2, . . . Xt  = I  A J = {1, 2, I} .

F K
 L A


C

(x1 , x2 , . . . xt )
 M
G
 =

i
B
nji
njir

, r (i = 1, 2, . . . , I;
j


j = 1, 2, . . . , J; r = 1, 2, . . . R)
=
K
 =
i
r|ji = P (Y = r | = i, N = j)
(nji1 , nji2 , . . . , njir )


1|ji , 2|ji , . . . , R|ji

j

O

J I R 
PQRSQ TU $$     $ #$$   #"
j

=
L
1
2

R




D

nj11
nj21


nj12
nj22


nj1R
nj2R


nj1
nj2


njI1

njI2

njIR

njI











j
R
= 0 , 0 , . . . , 0
0 = , , . . . ,
0 P
r|ji =
j
ji
1|ji
2|ji
R|ji
j1
j2
jI
r=1

  

1
(i, j)
R1
 J

= (0 , 0 , . . . , 0 )0 
=
 1 2 J M F ( ) =
F m ( j ) , m = 1, 2, . . . , a j .
j = 1, 2, . .j. , J
[F 1 ( j ) , F 2 (j ) , . . . ,F a ( j )]0
a I (R 1)   j VWXY
Z[\  WXZ[W

F () = [F (1)0 , F (2 )0 , . . . , F (J )0]0
(aJ 1). ] VWXZ[\

M
     

   


  

 
J
j

F ( j ) = X j j ,

j = 1, 2, . . . , J

  !! "#$%$& #''( #)$

*+,-./010 .23, 4 567,+031, /. .83015-092 .2 1,/.6,8 1:63020; .6 < 5+5 <+,< ,+-0,2.8

= ( , , . . . , )0
B
1j
j
Xj (at)
2j tj
(t 1) t;
kj
Xk j 
J ( , , . . . , ) k
k1 k2  kJ
(k = 1, . . . , t)

Z Z ,...,Z
1,

kj = Z 0kj k + ukj ,

k = 1, . . . , t,

j = 1, 2, . . . , J

(qk 1)
k Z
qk
kj

j ukj 



j = Z j + uj ,

j = 1, 2, . . . , J

Z j = diag Z 01j , Z 02j , . . . , Z 0tj

(t Q)
+ . . . + qt
 (Q
Q=q1 + q2
(t 1)  = E (u ) =
1) uj

  j
0
Cov (uj )
u u 

(k,
k
=
1,
2,
.
.
.
,
t)
u
F
(j, j = 1, 2, . . . , J) 
Cov (uj , uj ) = 0
E


F () = A + Xu
A = Z 01 X 01, Z 02X 02, . . . , Z 0J X 0J
0 , X j = X j j 6= j ,
(aJ Q) X = diag(X 1 , X 2, . . . , X J )
(aJ tJ) .  Q  u =
j

kk

(u1 , u2 , . . . , uJ ) .

E(u) = 0 Cov (u) = , = I 

u
J
  M u E [F ()]
u

= A V ar [F ()] = V F ()


V F () = Xu X 0 ^









E
 

j

  !! "#$%$& #''( #)$

  $ $ $ " $  $  

_ I4/,-1),5.
 



=

 FJ i
j p =

 =
ji
0
(pji1 , pji2 , . . . , pjiR ) , pjir = njir /nji
pj = [p0j1 , p0j2 , . . . , p0jI ]0

j. p V I
j

(IR IR)
ji ji ]
i = 1, 2, . . . , I j = 1, 2, . . . , J, V =1/n

ji [D
D
(I I) ji


J
p = [p0 , p0 , . . . , p0 ]0
12 J p  
V

j
p
V 
= C  


  F  



  

W Zgh Kgi hjWfZ[d VW
W j W ljW ZgWXW
`=;:=F@ ab c Wd
F (p) ed f d X
e F () ^ c f k\X
F
j

ji

ji

ji

VW[gmdVdf kd[Kgd Wf K\XZgXjdf VW f W jXV\ \[VWX WX jXd [W giX dngW[Zd ljW K\XZgWXW
e
N
N
d ^ c Wd H ed hdZ[go p dK\ngdXd VW ed q jXKgiX F () r WmdejdVd K\[[Wfk\XVgWXZWY
hWXZW d Kjd f W fjk\XW X\ Xj d^
re
e
e
sXZ\XKWft


d
i)F (p) | u N A + Xu, HV H 0


0
d
ii)F (p) N A, Xu X + HV H 0




F (p) = A + Xu + e
e  A X


u
  !! "#$%$& #''( #)$

*+,-./010 .23, 4 567,+031, /. .83015-092 .2 1,/.6,8 1:63020; .6 < 5+5 <+,< ,+-0,2.8

  =
u N (0, ) e N (0, HV H 0)


u
=
  

u

 n . =
ji
I
  N (0, )
e
2 /n e
e.
ji
e
 B

 
 



 F
   
 

uvwv xyz{|}~  }~




F (p) = A + e e = Xu + e
M
C   

 


b = A0 V 1 A 1 A0 V 1 F (p)

V = Xu X 0 + e.

 = b b C   


=

 


b = A0 V 1 A 1
V ar

C C    V

b
=

e
 =
 E
  !! "#$%$& #''( #)$

  $ $ $ " $  $  

b


1
1
b
b = A0 Vb 1

A0 Vb F (p)
A

Vb V .

uvv } }z|z~ z
E 
e  e = $ + $ , 
2 2

 E ( ) = 0 i = 11, 21 Cov(

$ 1 = X, $ 2 = I aJ , 1 = u 2 = e
) = u
i
1


V ar (e ) = $1u$0 +
Cov ( ) = e Cov ( , ) = Cov ( , ) = 0
e

1
 2

=


A [L (A)]
L (A)
L (A) R = hI A A0A
1 A0 i
[L (A)] r (C) C   r (R) =
=
naJ r (M ) = n M A = 0 
aJ r (A) = n.
M
M e

F = M F (p)
 
e = E (M F (p)) = M A = 0
E F

 
e = Cov (M F (p)) = M V M 0
Cov F


d
F (p) N (AF , V )
= 

Fe (p) d N



0

0
e
e
E F F = M V M = M $ 1 $01 M 0

z =




00 0
M $1$1M M M

0, M V M 0



 0
MM

!
u
= Z

=  0
u




 FeFf

f
e
= Z +
= FF Z ,


E () = 0 Cov () = V ,
V

V F

"
# " 
#
 0
 0
0
0
0
0
f
f
f E F
f
eF
eF
eF
eF
=E
F
F
E F

  !! "#$%$& #''( #)$

*+,-./010 .23, 4 567,+031, /. .83015-092 .2 1,/.6,8 1:63020; .6 < 5+5 <+,< ,+-0,2.8

ff
f e f0
f
1 1F F

"
#
 0
f
f f e f0
2 f 1F F
f0
f0
eF
eF

F
F
=

fF
e f0
ffn f
1 F

f ff F
e f0
f
1 n F

f0
f ff F
eF
... f
2
n





f0
eF
. . . ffn ffn F

f ff F
e f0
f
1 2 F
f0
f ff F
eF
f
2

...

2



f0
eF
ffn ff2 F

i Fe 
f
fi
 f f e f0 
E f if j F F ,
F 



fF
e f0 = ij R + [i1 R (j) , i2 R (j) , . . . , in R (j)]
E f
f if
j F
+ [j1 R (i) , j2 R (i) , . . . , jn R (i)]

= ij R + R0 (i) R (j) + R0 (j) R (i)

 
 M V M 0 = R R (i) R 

= 
"
#
 0
0
0
f
f
e
e
E
FF
FF
= R R + [R R(1), R R(2), . . . , R R(n)]
h

i
+ R0 (1) R,R0 (2) R, . . . , R0 (n) R

= R R + [R R (1) , R R(2), . . . , R R(n)] + R0 R

 

 

" 
#
 0


 
0

0
0
f
f
eF E F
eF
E F
= R R = R0 R


f0 = [R R] + [R R (1) , R R (2) , . . . , R R (n)]
eF
Cov F
= V 0


V

=
+

M V 0 M

M V 0 M

FeFf
0

Z

M V 0 M



V
0


M V 0 M 0 (1) . . . M V 0 M 0 M V 0 M 0 (n)

  !! "#$%$& #''( #)$

  $ $ $ " $  $  

b 
0
Cov ( ) = 0
1

 

 0
 0

f0
b
e F
= Z V 0 Z Z V 0 F

B

 b
B


uvv }zz~ z }~ z~|}z~

 b

DGE
 


`=;:=F@ b s WfZghdV\[ b Wf jX WfZghdV\[ VW Zgk\ Ys ^

0
e
e
0
b =
 
b 

SZ (0 ) = U (0 , F (p))

U i = F (p) M 0 M V 0 M 0

SM (0 )ij = tr M V 0 M 0
e 1 = I aJ ,
F

1

1

e i M 0 M V 0 M 0
MF

e iM 0 M V M 0
MF
0

e 2 = 1 0
F
1

A0V
e f0
0 F F

1

1

e jM0
MF

e j M 0,
MF

j = 1, 2


 0

0 e f0
f0
e i M 0 V F
eF
A V 0 F F = M i F
0
=

0

f0
e i M 0 1 F
eF
MF

i

1


1 h
f0
e i M 0 M V 0 M 0 1 F
eF
tr M V 0 M 0
MF
2

1


1 e0
e i M 0 M V M 0 1 F
e
= F
M V 0 M 0
MF
0
2
=

  !! "#$%$& #''( #)$

*+,-./010 .23, 4 567,+031, /. .83015-092 .2 1,/.6,8 1:63020; .6 < 5+5 <+,< ,+-0,2.8

0

ij

AV

0 A ij

A0 V
0 A

0

0

f
fj M 0
= M F iM
V 0 M F



1 

i
1 h f 0 
fj M 0 M V M 0 1
tr M F i M
M V 0 M 0
MF
0
2 
1





1

0
0

0 1
0
f
e
= tr M V 0 M
M F iM
M V 0 M
M Fj M
2
=

b 0 DGE
0

12,+1),5.

+*2 123(',/-( +* *4/,-1),5.



B

B
 

e\N \VVf [dZg\f

 
 
    

B
 = B


    
B       

B 

B B


 

> 



B  

  


 

  
  

 B
B
  !! "#$%$& #''( #)$

  $ $ $ " $  $  

 =


 =


 B 
I *-82(

L  ]  L 


 =


 


e\N \VVf [dZg\f




M
 
 


e\N \VVf [dZg\f

J L  

logit (ij ) = 0j xij +

J
X

k Dkij

k=1

0j
uj

+ uj


N 0, u2

jij x = 0/1 Oi
 D , . . . , D ij = 0/1 
1ij
Jij
=   
logit (ij ) = ( + uj ) xij +

J
X

k Dkij

k=1

e\N \VVf [dZg\


  !! "#$%$& #''( #)$

*+,-./010 .23, 4 567,+031, /. .83015-092 .2 1,/.6,8 1:63020; .6 < 5+5 <+,< ,+-0,2.8

=

L  

?G  C ? M
? ] C 




  C   


 2
 G u=
   u2 ,
= 2 
u

PQRSQ U $

  $$    $     $ #$"

 % $$ $    $ %
  

 !  


 

  



$#

  %
 !




!
  

  






2
u

 =

     

= = L 

F = 

 
E=  L = 

= 



2
u

  




 

 M

 

  !! "#$%$& #''( #)$

  $ $ $ " $  $  

(.)264,(.*4



E 

  

 


 
 

**'*.),14

F  =  
F  D
 cZdZgfZgKf gX WVgKgXW a  

F F 
JdZW \[gKd dZd Xd fgf G? 
N
e
e
]
F L  
X XZ[\VjKZg\X Z\ j Zgmd[gdZW cZdZgfZgKd Xd fgf
e
e
e
G? ]
? G  A   
C = 
 = g\hWZ[gKf  
 F = C =  
gW[d[KgKd gXWd[ \VW ft kk gKdZg\Xf
e
e
e
dXV dZd Xdefgf WZ \Vf =   
  
 L
  E   

  
     \j[Xd
e
\q ZW hW[gKdX cZdZgfZgKde ff\KgdZg\X
  
 L C ?   
C  C
  M  =  g\hWZ[gKf
 
 C G C  
jn gK [\ [dh Xd fgft W JdZWY
e
N
e
[gK
Z
[ K    
N \ de d d kk \d
 C G    
F F  
 M g\hWZ[gKf  
  !! "#$%$& #''( #)$

*+,-./010 .23, 4 567,+031, /. .83015-092 .2 1,/.6,8 1:63020; .6 < 5+5 <+,< ,+-0,2.8

 F C 
   G 
 \j[Xde \q cZdZgfZgKde c\q Zd[W 

  C L F = M  
F 
   cZdZgfZgKgdX  

  @ 
 = F C sVjKdY
Zg\Xd Wf Wd[KW[ 
e
  
j Zg WmW \VW f gX sVjKdZg\Xd dXV c\Kgd Wf Wd[K 
e
e
e
  e e e

  
j Zg WmW cZdZgfZgKd \VW f   G? 
e e e
e
e
]
  C  
D F  
?  C \j[Xde \q ZW \de cZdZgfZgKde c\KgWZ^ cW[gWf


  C  ? D M M ?  
 C  
jfW[f NjgVW Z\ g D]  
   =      
F  M
 g\hWZ[gKf   

 F   
 gX
 F      = F  =
 =  =  G?   
]

  D F F 
M  
=   L ? F  
J\hk jZdZg\Xde cZdZgfZgKf dXV dZd Xdefgf 

  @  D 
cZdZgfZgKd WZ \Vf q \[ WZdYdXd fgf F
e
e
 G? 
]

  
Xd fgf \q dXW dZd  E  G? 
e
e
]
  
F G DGE G  dZWhdZgf KW k WY
[dZg\Xfq \[f KjX jXV cZdZgfZg
  
N
 F   
F E  
 ] ? C  \j[Xd \q ZW \ d cZdZgfZgKd c\KgZ 
e
e
e



]  G  F 
F E E  
 cZdZgfZgKf gX WVgKgXW a  
G 
dXV\h K\W KgWXZ h\VWeft dXVn\\
\q cZdZgfZgfKde \VWegXN
q \[ ZW c\Kgde dXV W dmg\[de c KgWXKWf   G? ]
  !! "#$%$& #''( #)$

  $ $ $ " $  $  

        C   C  
=>? M @  
  C F
L  = XZW[XdZg\Xde \j[Xde \q JdXKW[  
  
F 
L   E 
 
       
  
=  L = F WmgfZd XmWfZg dY

N
KgiX k W[dKg\Xd
  
e
       
F  L
 F = = WmgfZd JgWXKgdf dZWhZgKdf 
   @ 
   
M  = WmgfZd J\e\hngdXd VW sfZdVfZgKd^
a 
 
C  C 
gXWd[ cZdZgfZgKd Xq W[WXKW dXV Zf kk gKdZg\Xf
e
= D  G? e 
]
C L 
F    = = 
  C C = \j[Xde
\q cZdZgfZgKde J\hk jZdZg\X dXV cghjedZg\X
 
= L  = M  L F 
 F
C   F  = cZdZgfZgKf gX WVgKgXW
a  
= L F   C 
XZ[\VjKZg\X Z\ dfgK dXV VmdXKWV j Y
e
Zg WmW \VW gX = 
e e
ee N
L C   C A    L =  

]

?
K
WV
K
W

g gX a  
cZdZgfZg f gX
8 .+,)* 
`=;:=F@ b c WdX df hdZ[gKWft
e
V = R R+ [R R (1) , R R (2) , . . . , R R (n)] y
= 2 (R R) ,

V h Z[gKWf fghZ[gKdf Kjd Wf ljgW[d VW \[VWX

W Z KW W Kjhk Wt
A B \f d
e
n n r X \X f f
e

i) V B = B

ii) A 0 V  B = A 0 1 B

  !! "#$%$& #''( #)$

*+,-./010 .23, 4 567,+031, /. .83015-092 .2 1,/.6,8 1:63020; .6 < 5+5 <+,< ,+-0,2.8

23(',/-( +* - .,-(4 )61+'1+(4 3*.*'12,

1+(4
,/*'1/,7(4

   $ #$   # $$     

 $ #$$ $  $ $ $  $ "
D OL
VVf [dZg\ C @ C

L 
 
O 
O
 


O


 
O 
 

O
O

 
 


O
O

 

O

O

 

O
O
 

 

O

O
 
 

O

O
 

O

O
 



O
O
 



O
O
 

 

O
O
 
 
 

O 
O
 
 
 

O
O
 
 
 

O
O
 




O 
O
 
 
 

O

O
 
 

O
O
 

 


O
O
 


O

O
 


 O


O
 

O
O
 
 
 

PQRSQ  U





















 

 


 F
e (p) = F (p) A
b
F

   F (p) = Fe (p) Fe (p)0 

   F (p) = F(p)
.

  =
V

  !! "#$%$& #''( #)$

  $ $ $ " $  $  


 E F (p)
= Z , z
B u e ) 
 F (p) = Z + R 
  




1 0

b = Z 0 V Z

Z V

F (p)

V = Vb Vb 


u e
V = Xu X 0 + e

 =





 C


1
1
b
b = A0 Vb 1

A
A0 Vb F (p)

bb b 

 

 

  !! "#$%$& #''( #)$