Documentos de Académico
Documentos de Profesional
Documentos de Cultura
Research
Hatesh Kumar, S. Faiza Hassan, Samreen Riaz
MSAL, NED UET
What is
Educational
Research
Research
Procedures
Presenting
Data
Methodology,
Procedures And
Ethical Concerns
Research
Approaches
Using
NUD.IST
Writing
Research
Reliability,
Validity And
Credibility
Using
Atlas.t
i
Chapters covered
What is
Educational
Research
Methodology,
Procedures
And Ethical
Concerns
Writing
Research
What is Educational
Research?
Hatesh Kumar
Chapter :1
What is Educational Research?
Clive Opie
What is Educational Research?
Research is.
Seeking through methodological processes to add ones body of
knowledge and, hopefully, to that of others, by the discovery of
non-trivial facts and insights. (Howard & Sharpes, 1983)
Educational Research
The collection and analysis of information on the world of education so
as to understand and explain it better, with a significant practicing
teachers in that it should be
viewed as critical, reflexive, and professionally oriented activity
regarded as crucial ingredient in the teachers professional
role.generating self knowledge and personal development in such a
way that practice can be improved.(Hitchcock and Hughes, 1989)
Hard work
Time consuming
Problematic
Difficult
Requires expertise
Educational Research
Educational Research is doable, albeit at
different levels of depth and
sophistication, by all interested in making
a systematic, critical and self-critical
enquiry which aims to contribute to the
advancement of knowledge (Bassey,
1990) of the world around them.
Methodology,
Procedures and
Ethical Concerns
Chapter :2
Pat Sikes
Working Definitions
Selecting Methodologies and Procedures
Researcher Positionality
Ethical issues and questions
Methodologies
Methodology refers to the theory of getting knowledge, to the considerations
of the best ways, methods, or procedures, by which data that will provide the
evidence basis for the construction of knowledge about whatever it is that is
being researched, is obtained.
Methodology is concerned with the description and analysis of research
methods rather than with the actual, practical use of those methods.
Methodological work is philosophical , thinking, work.
Methodology is the overall approach to a particular research project, to the
overarching strategy that is adopted.
Procedures/ Methods
Specific research techniques that are used to collect and analyze data.
Methodology
Procedures/ Methods
A Case Study
Interviews, questionnaire,
observation and
documentary analysis
The scale of the research and the financial, personnel and other
resources available to conduct it.
Continue
The nature of the research population and the ability of
informants to provide particular types of response.
Ethical and moral issues relevant at various stages of the
research process.
Researcher Positionality
The most significant factor that influences choice and use of
methodology and procedures is where the researcher is coming
from in terms of their philosophical position and their
fundamental assumptions concerning:
Social reality: their ontological assumptions;
The nature of knowledge: their epistemological assumptions;
Human nature and agency: specifically their assumptions about
the way in which human beings relate to and interact with their
environment.
Assumptions
Assumptions are colored by values and beliefs that are
based in political allegiance, religious faith, and
experiences that are consequent upon social class,
ethnicity, gender, sexuality, historical and geographical
location and so on.
Paradigm: A basic set of beliefs that guides action.
Education Research: Two main paradigms
Qualitative and Quantitative
Research Paradigms
Do you view the nature of knowledge as
Issue of how words can actually reflect reality and experience is complex and
problematic.
Researchers state their position explicitly tentative and cautious in presenting
conclusion.
Writing up
Data dissemination
Avoiding harm/Doing wrong
Research Design
What exactly do you want to know and why do you want to know it?
Can you justify your interest?
If you are intending to do anything that is in any way experimental
what are the implication for the people who will be involved? If you are
using a control group will people assigned to it miss out any thing that
you suspect will be beneficial? Can it be justified?
Research Design
Insofar as you are able, have you thought about potential unintended or
unexpected consequences either to the people directly involved in the
research or as a result what you might find out?
If you are intended to do covert research of some kind, can you justify it?
How do you regard the people you are going to be researching?
Access
Research relationships
You have a basic moral responsibility towards the people you
are working with. Are you sure that you are doing as you would
be done by?
Could you be accused by rape research?
Writing up
Do you own your research in your writing up.
Data dissemination
Are my informants sufficiently
protected when it comes to data
dissemination?
Writing Research
Chapter : 3
Writing Research
David Hyatt
Expected requirements for student academic writing
Feedback
Structuring your research-based assignment
Other problems
Avoid overgeneralizations
Avoid unsubstantiated claims
Be careful with rhetorical questions
Be specific
Use subject specific lexis
FeedbackTutors comment
Phatic
Comment , encouragement
Developmental
Structural
Content
Methodological
Introduction
Literature Review
Methodology
Space management
Referencing as you go
Proofreading
The value of critical friend
Conclusion
Good academic writing is clear, concise, critical, credible,
evidenced, well structured and well presented.
Remember to enjoy your writing.
Goethe claimed that The most original authors are not so
because they advance what is new, but because they put
what they have to say as if it had never been said before.
Samreen Riaz
Chapters covered
Reliability,
Validity And
Credibility
Research
Approaches
Research
Procedures
WHAT IS RESEARCH?
It has been argued that the results of educational research will lead to
the improvement of educational practice; therefore, professional
practitioners should maintain a continued interest in research.
Scientific Method:
1) Identifying a problem
The nature of the problem is to be defined; related knowledge is
identified and a framework to conduct the research is established. In
addition, necessary assumptions and conditions are also identified.
2) Review information
The researcher reviews how others approached a similar problem; i.e.
Literature review.
3) Data collection:
Collecting data requires a proper organization and control to validate the data to
make decisions upon them
4) Data analysis:
Data analysis must be done in a manner appropriate to the problem.
5) Drawing conclusions
Following data analysis, researchers draw conclusions and make generalizations
based on the data they had collected.
1. Internal reliability refers to the extent that data collection, analysis, and
interpretation are consistent under the same conditions.
- If internal reliability is lacking, the data becomes a function of who collected them
rather than what actually happened.
2. External reliability deals with the issue of whether or not independent researchers
can replicate studies in the same or similar settings with consistent results.
Research
Approaches
TYPES
QUANTITATIVE
RESEARCH
DESIGN
QUALITATIVE
RESEARCH
DESIGN
Applied Research
Basic Research
Basic and applied research are important; they should not be differentiated by
hierarchy of value judgments; instead, the purpose of research is the criterion.
Action
Research
Action
research is one type of applied research. It is conducted by a professional
educator to aid in making decisions in local schools.
Since it is local, there is concern upon generalizing its results to other educational
settings. Teachers are curious about their own practices rather than generalizing
the outcomes.
Action research is less rigorous in terms of methodology and design than other
educational research.
Action research + research literature = viable approach to making educational
decisions at local level.
Research
Procedures
Research Procedures
Quantitative
With
/without
conceptua
l
framewor
k
Both
METHOD OF ANALYSIS
ELEMENTS
motivation.
Chapters covered
Presenting
Data
Using
NUD.IST
Using
Atlas.ti
Presenting Data
Clive Opie
Presenting Data
Data
Quantitative
Qualitative
Themes
Descriptive
statistics
Parametric tests
Inferential
statistics
Non-Parametric
tests
Issues
Quantitative
Nominal
Ordinal
Interval
Ratio
Mode frequencies
Spearman rank
Order
ANOVA
Statistic analysis
Kruskal-Wallis
test
T-test
Nominal Data
Puts data into categories
Ethnic Groups
Ordinal Data
Indicates Order of Numbers is Meaningful
Scores
No arithmetic significance
Intervals between sets of scores
Difference between 60 & 70 Vs 45 and 55
Can be extrapolated
Generalized to other schools in the locality
Example:
# of Minority Community students in schools of a selected locality
Descriptive Statistics
Describes group
Age Range
Group Total
Cumulative
Percentage
19-21
22-24
25-27
178
42
7
78.4
96.9
100
Inferential Statistics
Tests
Non-Parametric Tests
Parametric Test
Non-Parametric Data
Data
Nominal
Ordinal Data
Parametric Data
Data
Interval-Ratio
Can be Extrapolated
Requires careful attention to characteristics
ANOVA-mean of more than two samples
Pearsons product Moment correlation-strength of
relationship between two interval scales variables
t-test: -testing the level of significance between the mean of two
samples
Presenting Data
Table
Bar Charts
Graphs
Guidelines
Colors
Simplicity
Labels
Total
Necessity
Age profile
80
70
60
50
40
Age profile
30
20
10
0
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
Age profile
200
150
100
Age profile
50
0
19-21
22-24
25-27
QUALITATIVE Data
Data
Open Questions
Interviews
Descriptions
Observation Notes
Challenges
Volume
Creating meaning (themes and issues)
Analysis is not straight forward or quick
Open to subjectivity of researcher
QUALITATIVE Data
Validity & reliability
Table or charts can be added
Positive aspects
Connects to social reality
Answer more reliably why findings are the way they are
Stumble upon new themes
Using NUD.IST
Ann-Marie Bathmaker
Using NUD.IST
Non-Numerical, Unstructured Data Indexing, Searching and Theorizing
Software Package for analyzing Qualitative
Data
In this Chapter
Practicalities of Using NUD.IST
Highlights of Pros & Cons (Criticism)
Recommendations for new Users
Context matters
Tone is important & holds meaning
Difficult to get a grip on and make connections
Difficult to Predict what will be important
Researchers
Feel the need
To organize data
Build connections
Cluster parts of texts together
Save time
NUD.IST
Works as a code and retrieve system
Import Text
Doc
Code Parts
of text
Retrieve
Coded Doc
Analyze the
text
Other features
Nodes can be further connected to get subcode
Memos can be attached to the nodes
Criticism
Might distance the researcher from actual data
Categories emerge from data
Criticism
Unnecessary or forced linking:
It is important to avoid the misapprehension that the
coding and computing lend a scientific gloss to qualitative
research. (Coffey et al, 1996)
Manual analysis may lead to more unclear stringing which
is difficult to get back to.
Computer encourages users to be clear about what they
are doing. (Fielding and Lee, 1998)
Criticism
Facilitates the development of theory in highly
organized and systematic way
Systematic Indexing
Researchers develop their own interpretations which
they have to make explicit and justify
Criticism
Tends to distance you from actual data to concentrate
on conceptual notions and, ponder and visualize these
concepts
Criticism
Increase reliability, validity and generalizability
Ease of access and, back and forth movement
Recommendations
Not to be influenced by what the software can do
Be clear at all times why an action has been taken
Using Atlas.ti
Michael Pomerantz
Using Atlas.ti
Software; used to study, analyze and compare
data for Qualitative analysis
Gives good qualitative descriptions
Preferred by researchers working with grounded
theory approach
(engage in interview/real life dialogue)
Atlas.ti
Works as a code and retrieve system
Import Text
Doc
Code Parts
of text
Retrieve
Coded Doc
Analyze the
text
Other features
Nodes can be further connected to get subcode
Memos can be attached to the nodes
Additional features
Has left & right side panes for codes & texts
One word codes
Can auto code a word across texts
Users Views
Allows to build networks of Codes (tree & Higher
hierarchy)
Allows time and space to go back and start all over
again
Allows categorization of codes; (important,
superordinate, Sub ordinate)
Allows later division and merger of codes
Thank you