Documentos de Académico
Documentos de Profesional
Documentos de Cultura
SLIDE #/124
Many students share a common idea about the task of writing a research paper: Choose a topic Do research on the topic Write an essay based on your research
SLIDE #/124 2
Topic Selection
Most topics you start with are too broad to be useful research papers.
SLIDE #/124 4
Topic Selection
If you leave a topic broad, it will be superficial.
SLIDE #/124 5
If your topic is narrow, you can deal with it in depth. If your topic is broad, you will deal with it only in a shallow way.
SLIDE #/124 6
Thus you want to avoid a broad survey in a research paper. Instead, focus on a narrow topic so you can deal with it in depth.
SLIDE #/124 7
SLIDE #/124
Every research essay should have only one research question. You do not want to have an essay that states, "The following paper will examine __________ and will also _____________ and will also ____________."
SLIDE #/124 10
You are allowed to quote from the things you have read, but there are definite rules for doing this:
SLIDE #/124
11
The quotations should be short (usually 5 lines or less) and few. It is best to have no more than one short quotation per page of your essay. Quotations must have quotation marks (" ") around them or be put in an indented block (for longer quotations) to make it clear that they are quotations.
SLIDE #/124
12
All quotations must have a note (footnote, endnote, or short note) attached to them so that its very clear what source you are quoting. Every item quoted must also be in your bibliography. You cannot just quote long paragraphs without using quotation marks and then adding a citation, footnote or endnote indicating what source you used.
SLIDE #/124
13
SLIDE #/124
14
SLIDE #/124
15
The readers are mainly interested in seeing how well YOU have understood and digested the material. They do not want you simply to repeat what youve read but to interpret what youve read, expressing your own understanding in your own words.
SLIDE #/124
16
What is Plagiarism?
Plagiarism is using another writers words or unique ideas as if they were your own. The professor believes those are your own words or ideas, because you have not shown that they came from someone else.
SLIDE #/124
17
SLIDE #/124
18
What, then, is the best way to use research from other authors?
Quote only when something an author has said really explains well what you are trying to say. Quotations should be short, and there should be few of them.
SLIDE #/124
19
General
The goal of the research paper is not to gather information and report on it. Research papers are to study certain topic, develop a research question, and answer it using the materials you have studied plus your own results and analysis.
SLIDE #/124
20
The information you discover in your research is thus only the foundation, the first part, of the task. What is more important is your ability to use that information and your own results to advance the worlds knowledge.
SLIDE #/124
21
The components
Title Abstract Introduction Experimental Results & Discussion Conclusions (or Summary) Acknowledgments & References
SLIDE #/124 22
What do I do first?
Certainly NOT write in the order the sections appear. Perhaps as follows.
Results & Discussion Conclusions Experimental Introduction Abstract Title Organize References Acknowledgments
SLIDE #/124 23
Results
A paper is centered around the Results
First get them organized. What to include? Any photographs? How will I present them - figures and/or tables? Do I need to combine results with discussion? Some results be presented as Supplementary Material? [website allows this]
SLIDE #/124 24
Results - organization
Tables Graphs
Photographs
Supplementary Material
SLIDE #/124 25
Figures
Make sure each one is important. There is no need to have a photograph that does not convey relevant information! Do not duplicate data in both figures and tables. Which shows the data more clearly? Often a figure is better in the main body with tables in Supplementary Material.
SLIDE #/124 26
Discussion
If possible, separate from the Results BUT Sometimes a result, or set of results, must be discussed in order to logically point to the next stage in the experiment. In this case combine Results and Discussion.
SLIDE #/124
27
Discussion
Keep it logical. Do not ramble. Compare your results with those of others. References are really important here. Be careful to show where your work has advanced the subject. Try to lead naturally to the Conclusions.
SLIDE #/124 28
Conclusions
This is NOT the same as a summary. The Abstract is usually a summary. A reader who has the paper will certainly have the Abstract. Preference is to have the Conclusions as a list, at least to begin with. If it is a summary -give it that heading and make it more than the Abstract. NEVER make conclusions that cannot be justified or are not mentioned in the main text. The conclusions ought to be logical extension of the results
SLIDE #/124 29
Titles
Be straightforward and precise:
Improved mechanical properties
Which ones? Strength? Stiffness? For what applications? Better for one application may be the opposite for another.
SLIDE #/124
33
Abstract KISS
In this paper we report new results on the successful preparation of
1. We know it is not a different paper, but this one. 2. We know it is you. 3. We know the results are new - we would not publish if they were old. 4. We assume the experiment was successful you do not usually report failures!
SLIDE #/124 34
Abstract
Simply tell the reader two things:
1. What was done. 2. Important results obtained.
Do not:
1. Provide history or narrative. 2. Speculate - possible uses, etc. 3. Include data that is not in the manuscript.
SLIDE #/124 35
A recent example.
SLIDE #/124
36
SUBMITTED
This paper presents the development of activated carbons (ACs) for a 4.5 K sorption cooler for ESAs Darwin mission. A sorption cooler has two parts: (i) cold stage; (ii) sorption compressor. ACs are very interesting candidates for sorption compressors because large amounts of gas can be adsorbed reversibly. In the present paper, ACs with different surface area, micropore size distribution and packing density were prepared from an anthracite and bituminous coals. The development of porosity was carried out by different activation methods using KOH, NaOH and CO2 as activating agents. Some ACs were agglomerated using different binders to prepare activated carbon monoliths (ACMs). In order to predict the performance of these materials in Helium sorption compressors, Helium adsorption isotherms were measured up to 35 bar in a cryogenic volumetric characterization set-up, at different temperatures (from 20 K up to 150 K). Moreover, other measurements were carried out, including packing density, mechanical properties (compression strength, vibration tests), thermal expansion and also pressure-drop measurements. From the results obtained in this study, an ACM with a high helium adsorption/desorption capacity, high density, low pressure drop, low thermal expansion and good mechanical properties was prepared and
Edited Abstract
For use in a 4.5 K sorption cooler, activated carbons (ACs) with different surface areas, micropore size distributions and packing densities were prepared from anthracite and bituminous coals. The development of porosity was carried out using KOH, NaOH and CO2 as activating agents. Some ACs were combined with different binders to prepare activated carbon monoliths. In order to predict the performance of thesematerials in helium sorption compressors, helium adsorption isotherms were measured up to 35 bar in a cryogenic volumetric characterization apparatus, at different temperatures (20 to 150 K). Packing density, mechanical properties (compression strength, vibration tests), thermal expansion and pressure-drop measurements were also investigated. From the results, a monolith with a high helium adsorption/desorption capacity, high density, low pressure drop, low thermal expansion and good mechanical properties was prepared and used successfully.(134 words, >30% less)
What were the binders? What was the successful monolith? Were commercial materials compared?
SLIDE #/124
38
SLIDE #/124
39
Better?
Entangled and bundled MWCNTs produced by CVD at different temperatures and using different catalysts were used to fabricate MWCNT/PA6 composites. Better mechanical properties were achieved for bundled MWCNTs than for entangled MWCNTs. With the addition of only 1.0wt% MWCNTs to the PA6 matrix, the tensile strength and modulus were increased by 15.6% and 16.5% respectively. The storage moduli of the two MWCNT/PA6 composites at 40C increased about 30%, and the Tg increased from 57.7C for neat PA6 to 61.3 and 63.3C for the bundled and entangled MWCNTs, respectively.
SLIDE #/124
40
You MUST submit using the website. Make sure you include suggestions for international reviewers. If a revision, include responses to reviewers.
SLIDE #/124 41
Submission
If the Editor-in-Chief has told you to resubmit - true for most papers from Poland. Make sure you do as requested and carefully follow each point in the Resubmit letter. If you do not agree with some of my suggestions, please include a cover letter to explain why this is so. Be sensible! If I correct something in the Abstract, ask yourself whether it needs to be corrected elsewhere?
SLIDE #/124
42
Some nationalities tend to use the where not necessary and omit a where it is necessary
The FTIR is one of the typical methods used to characterise the chemically modified nanotubes.
FTIR is a typical method used to characterise chemically...
This is the reason why some samples gave different results. is correct. NOT It is the reason why
SLIDE #/124
45
Respectively
The word is used to link items in two or more lists in the order in which they appear in those lists. To say that samples were heat treated at 450C and 700C respectively is incorrect unless there is a list of two samples.
SLIDE #/124 46
Latin phrases
In situ - means in the place. All things happen in a place! Use it ONLY to indicate that something is taking place where it will later be used. Via - by is usually enough & simpler e.g. (for example) and i.e. (that is, or that is to say)
SLIDE #/124
47
Conclusions
Read the Guide for Authors. Take time! Organize. Be honest. Remember to make Title, Abstract & Paper independently understandable. Pay careful attention to the comments of the Editor and the Reviewers. Do not waste their time!
SLIDE #/124 48
SLIDE #/124
49
SLIDE #/124
50
What Is a Thesis?
An argument to support a hypothesis An original piece of research The product of an apprenticeship Something that could be published
Thesis is nothing but a transference of bones from one graveyard to another . Frank Dobie SLIDE #/124
51
Definition
A thesis for the Ph.D. (dissertation) must be a distinctive contribution to the knowledge of the subject and afford evidence of originality shown by the discovery of new facts and/or by the exercise of independent critical power.
SLIDE #/124 52
LAY-OUT
First Chapter: Introduction Last Chapter: Conclusion and Suggestions Three Parts: 1. Preliminary pages 2. Main body 3. Reference section
SLIDE #/124 53
Getting Started
Decide your title Write your title page Start your document Look at other theses in your area Plan your argument You can always change things later But you cant change anything unless you have something to change
SLIDE #/124 54
SLIDE #/124
55
Contents
Title conveys a message Abstract for the librarian and announcement, bait Contents listing shows that everything is there Acknowledgements Introduction I am doing the following Review of Previous work show you know the subject -> why you do your work Philosophy of the approach show you can pick out an important problem Plan of Attack show you approached the problem in a systematic manner
SLIDE #/124 56
Contents
Cont.
Description of the work details, so that others can follow what you did Critical analysis of the results show you understand the limitations Future work show you know whats missing Conclusions repetition of the intro, but with reference to detail References cover the field; examiners will look for key dereferences Appendix the gruesome details that would clutter the description
SLIDE #/124 57
Title
Concise Descriptive
SLIDE #/124
58
Abstract
A brief summary of 150-300 words Research Question A rationale for the study The hypothesis The methodology The main findings
SLIDE #/124
59
Introduction
Provides a necessary background for research problem Begin with a general statement of the problem area Focus on specific research problem Justification of the proposed study
SLIDE #/124
60
Literature review
Functions: Ensures that you are not reinventing the wheel Give credit to those laying the ground work Demonstrate your knowledge about of the problem
Convince readers that you proposed research will make a significant contribution
SLIDE #/124 61
SLIDE #/124
62
Methods
Plan to tackle the problem Shows that your approach is most appropriate
SLIDE #/124
63
Discussion
SLIDE #/124
64
Bibliography
Keep a database of complete references Use a consistent citation style Use a tool (Endnote, Bibtex, etc.) Attention to detail is important (correct spellings!) Keep complete references (page numbers, volume,location and dates for proceedings, etc.)
SLIDE #/124 65
Bibliography
Cont..
Find out what the local rules are for citation style If there are no rules use [Author Year] or [Author1,Author2, Author3, Year] so your name shows up! Assume the reader is familiar with the main references (but dont skip any)
SLIDE #/124
66
Reviewing
Get other people to read your drafts Peers will give friendly comments and typically have time on their hands Advisor will steer you Above all: Get the bugs out before the committee sees it
SLIDE #/124
67
In Summary
Start writing today (never tomorrow) Make up a title page for inspiration Write down your argument succinctly Turn the argument into a chapter plan Maintain a file of all the stuff to use Dont be afraid to change the plan
SLIDE #/124
68
In Summary Cont..
Know your audience Help them understand Keep it short Use signposts Get the contents right Make sure youve covered the bases
SLIDE #/124
69
PLAGIARISM
Plagiarism means using other writers ideas, words or frameworks without acknowledgement. You are falsely claiming that the work is your own. This can range from deliberate plagiarism to splicing phrases.
SLIDE #/124
70
Limits of Plagiarism
SLIDE #/124
71
Review of literature
Is the literature relevant? Is the review critical or just descriptive? Is it comprehensive? Does it link to the methodology in the thesis? Does it summarize the essential aspects?
SLIDE #/124
72
Methodology
Is there a clear hypothesis? Are precautions taken against bias? Are the limitations identified? Is the data collected appropriately? Is the methodology justified?
SLIDE #/124
73
Presentation of results
Have the hypotheses in fact been tested? Are the results shown to support the hypothesis? Is the data properly analyzed? Are the results presented clearly? Are patterns identified and summarized?
SLIDE #/124 74
Discussion and Conclusions Are the limits of the research identified? Are the main points to emerge identified? Are links made to the literature? Is there theoretical development? Are the speculations well grounded?
SLIDE #/124
75
SLIDE #/124
77
78
79
This needs to standalone i.e. complete in itself A complete summary of the entire report from aims to conclusions Allows the reader to gain a very brief but complete overview of your project Typically 100-200 words in length One paragraph Highly succinct Is not an introduction Is the final piece you write
SLIDE #/124 80
Report Structure: The introduction This gives sets the scene for the report some background to the study explains connections with previous work
SLIDE #/124
81
Report Structure: The introduction At the end of the introduction explain your aims clearly introduce how you will address these
In longer reports it is helpful [reader- friendly] to explain briefly how the report is structured
[signposting]
SLIDE #/124 82
Presents the results from the experiment or model Do not just include figures and tables, ensure that the text provides: a commentary guiding the reader through the figures & tables references all of these: Figure 3.2 shows how Remember the reader will look at the figures & tables only if directed to do so in the text. The results should include any assessment of uncertainty in your data/model.
SLIDE #/124 84
This section is reasonably short & succinct State what you major conclusions are, referring back to your original aims
SLIDE #/124
85
Part
Checklist
Does it explain what the report is about succinctly ? Does it explain why the work was done ? Does it outline the entire report, including the findings ? Have you managed to keep the abstract to one paragraph ? Are all the sections covered ? Are the page numbers correct ? Does it contain enough background material and cite the relevant references ? Have you defined all the technical terms used ? Is it clear why you have investigated the problem ? Have you explained why you have chosen the experimental or mathematical approach adopted for your work ? Is there sufficient detail to allow repetition of the work ? Are correct names used for all chemicals used ? Is the sequence of experimental results presented logically ? Are the data presented in the clearest possible way ? Have SI units been used throughout ? Have adequate statistical techniques been used ? Are all figures and tables numbered in the order they appear ? Tables Are all your tables clear ? Do the tables have a caption placed above the table ? Does the caption provide all the necessary information without reference to the main text ? Have you referred, in the main text, to all tables ? Figures Are all your figures clear ? Are all the symbols used explained in a key or in the caption ? Do all maps have a scale bar and north arrows ? Do all figures have a caption placed beneath the figure ? Does the caption provide all the necessary information without reference to the main text ? Have you referred, in the main text, to all figures ? Have you explained the significance of the results ? Have you compared your results with published work ? Are your conclusions justified by the data and statistical techniques used ? Have you managed to suggest what further work is useful ? Have you listed all people who have contributed to the work you have reported ? Do all the references in the main text (and appendices) appear in the list ? Is the list in alphabetical order ? Have you used a consistent format for all references in the list ?
A final check
Go through this check list before submitting your reports!
Methodology Results
Discussion/ Conclusions
Acknowledgements References
SLIDE #/124
86 86
Hard work without talent is a shame, but talent without hard work is a tragedy.
Robert Half
SLIDE #/124
87
Pick battles big enough to matter, small enough to win. Jonathan Kozol
SLIDE #/124
88
Issues of papers
Paper Title The Abstract The Introduction Related Work The Body Performance Experiments The Conclusions Future Work The Acknowledgements Citations Appendices
SLIDE #/124 89
Sections of paper
Experimental process What did I do in a nutshell? What is the problem? How did I solve the problem? What did I find out? Section of Paper Abstract Introduction Materials and Methods Results
Discussion
Acknowledgments (optional)
SLIDE #/124
Literature Cited
90
Abstract
First, write your paper. While the abstract will be at the beginning of your paper, it should be the last section that you write. Once you have completed the final draft, use it as a guide for writing your abstract. Function: An abstract summarizes, in one paragraph (usually), the major aspects of the entire paper in sequence
SLIDE #/124 91
Abstract (Sequence)
the question(s) you investigated (or purpose), (from Introduction)
state the purpose very clearly in the first or second sentence.
the major findings including key quantitative results, or trends (from Results)
report those results which answer the questions you were asking identify trends, relative change or differences, etc.
Introduction
Should be short, but does not have a word limit; Main purpose is to introduce the research by presenting its context or background. Introductions usually go from general to specific, introducing the research problem and how it will be investigated
Abstract
Has a maximum word limit; Is a summary of the whole research; Main purpose is to summarize the research (particularly the objective and the main finding/conclusion), NOT to introduce the research area.
SLIDE #/124 93
Writing style
Passive voice has no place in technical writing. It obscures who the actor was, what caused it, and when it happened. Use active voice and simple, clear, direct phrasing. Do not use words like obviously or clearly, as in Obviously, this Taylor series sums to pi. If the point is really obvious, then you are just wasting words by pointing it out. And if the point is not obvious (readers won't be intimately familiar with the subject matter the way the author is), then you are offending readers by insulting their intelligence, and demonstrating your own inability to communicate the intuition.
SLIDE #/124 95
Writing style
Prefer singular to plural number. In sequences induce graphs, it is not clear whether the two collections are in one-to-one correspondence, or the set of sequences collectively induces a set of graphs; each sequence induces a graph avoids this confusion. Likewise, in graphs might contain paths, it is unclear whether a given graph might contain multiple paths, or might contain at most one path.
SLIDE #/124
96
Figures
A figure should stand on its own, containing all the information that is necessary to understand it. Good captions contain multiple sentences; the caption provides context and explanation. For examples, see magazines such as Scientific American and American Scientist. Never write a caption like The Foobar technique; the caption should also say how the Foobar technique works or what it is good for.
SLIDE #/124 97
use words that say precisely what you mean use simple and familiar words
conceal - hide conflagration - fire increment - increase laceration wound repudiate refuse
SLIDE #/124 98
slang Lims (1980) statement is merely a cop out because he refuses to acknowledge that there are major morphological differences between the two groups.
standard Lims (1980) statement fails to address this issue because he refuses to acknowledge that there are major morphological differences between the two groups.
SLIDE #/124
99
SLIDE #/124
100
Be concise
some words that are often used incorrectly adopt to make suitable, to adjust adapt to take as ones own affect to influence effect to cause imply to imply or suggest indirectly infer to draw conclusions from the evidence
SLIDE #/124
101
Be concise
WORDY
CONCISE
SLIDE #/124
102
Be concise
WORDY
In spite of that fact that our knowledge at this point is far from complete At the present time
CONCISE
Although our knowledge is incomplete Now
Owing to that fact that, in light of the fact that, because of the fact that
SLIDE #/124
Because
103
avoid putting too many ideas in a sentence have a topic sentence for a paragraph four to six sentences per paragraph
SLIDE #/124
104
Passive
Nearly half the seedlings were eaten by snails. Active Snails ate nearly half the seedlings. Passive Oxygen was consumed by the mouse at a higher rate than Active The mouse consumed oxygen at a higher rate than
SLIDE #/124 106
Punctuation A comma is placed before the conjunctions and and or in a series Ex: The infested tomato plants were sprayed, burned, or buried. Place periods and commas inside the quotation marks;
Ex: Jones (1997) calls Davidsons explanation the most exciting model of this century.
Apostrophe and s (s) or s and apostrophe (s) fpr expression of time and value. Ex: ten pesos worth of vegetables five years cultivation of Bt corn late 1970s but not late 1970s
SLIDE #/124 107
Handling of numbers
Spell out all numbers below 11 and use figures for 11 and upward. When the numbers are used with measures (which should be abbreviated), these are all in figures Ex: Ten students, nine days 1 km, 96 t/ha Two numbers coming together Ex: ninety 10-m bamboo poles or ninety 10meter bamboo poles
SLIDE #/124 108
Spelling
AMERICAN
traveler hemoglobin rationalize center program honor color
BRITISH
traveller haemoglobin rationalise centre programme honour colour
-With
words having two acceptable spellings, choose one and use it throughout
SLIDE #/124
109
Compound words
Some compound words airborne, cutworm, blackberry, childlike, freshwater, glasshouse, hedgerows, homemade, offtype, schoolchildren, threefold Hyphenated words Fraction: three-fourths Technical compound unit: kilowatt-hour Adjective forms: fine-grained wood
SLIDE #/124
110
SLIDE #/124
111
Comparisons
Add words if necessary to make comparisons Comparisons should be between two or more logical words or concepts. Example: Ambiguous - Average body length in Libellula pulchella is longer than Plathemis lydia. Unambiguous - Average body length in Libellula pulchella is longer than that Plathemis lydia.
SLIDE #/124
in
112
Misplaced modifiers
Faulty - After mating, the sperm are stored in a sac within the damselflys body. Revised - After mating, the female damselfly stores sperm in a sac within her body. Who is actually mating, the sperm or the dragonfly?
SLIDE #/124
113
SLIDE #/124
115
Avoid repetition
Poor - In Kims study in 1997, she failed to account for temperature fluctuations (Kim, 1997).
SLIDE #/124
116
Verb tense
Past tense is used when reporting your present findings. Present tense is used when discussing the published work of others ( as part of existing theoretical framework) - Example: D. minutus was dominant in the zooplankton of Lake Mibaha uring both years of study. This species is common in the region (Minal and Sy, 1998). Exceptions: Ladera (1990) found that. . . . Table 3 shows that . . . .
SLIDE #/124 117
Parallelism
When linking two or more word, phrases or clauses in a sentence, put them in the same grammatical form. Faulty - These two species differ in color, wingspan, and where they typically occur. Parallel - These two species differ in color, wingspan, and habitat.
SLIDE #/124 118
Parallelism
Faulty - They introduced new ways of planting corn and control of pests. Parallel - They introduced new ways of planting corn and controlling pests.
SLIDE #/124
119
Use of jargon
Jargon - technical language of a specialized group - often long-winded, confusing
Writers of jargon rely on long sentences, big words, and sentences in the passive voice
SLIDE #/124
120
Subject-verb agreement
Examples: The size of all territories was (not were) reduced at high population densities. The zygote of the Ascomycetes develops (not develop) into ascospores. The color and shape of the beak are (not is) important taxonomic features (not feature)
SLIDE #/124 121
Singular
It is worthwhile to. .
Use a dictionary Consult a form and style guide Discuss your paper with your classmates or your professors
Also do not assume that to really sound like a scientist you must write dry, stilted prose or that complex ideas must be couched in equally complex sentences
SLIDE #/124 123
SLIDE #/124
124