Test Driven Development Large Scale

Test-Driven Development on a Large Scale Project
Speaker
Jan Van Reusel
1997
Speaker
Jan Van Reusel
1997
1999
Speaker
Jan Van Reusel
1997
1999
2002
Speaker
Jan Van Reusel
1997
1999
2002
2003
2003
Speaker
Jan Van Reusel
Speaker
Development Manager
Speaker
What keeps me awake at night?
...sometimes...
...more often...
...summer 2005...
...summer 2006...
12
Load factor
10
0 05/05 07/05 09/05 11/05 01/06 03/06 05/06 07/06 09/06
This Session
What did we do about it?
Context
Ventouris Renewal Program
Accountancy Bank Self-employed activity Look up and process income data Career data Continued insurance Payments receive reassign reimburse
Bailiff
Request remission / exemption
Modifications
FCP
Debt administration Reminder Summons Subpoena
Calculation
File
Family allowance
Discharge Pension Decease Failure (insurance) Normal suspension: request equalization continued insurance
NISSE
Self-employed Affiliation Suspension
customers
team size
60
100 my 3 year
Application clients
HTML Browser Web Service Client NISSE Batch Client
Presentation Layer
<<JSF>> Web User Interface
Service Layer
<<Session Bean>> Application Services <<JCAPS>> BPEL Engine <<POJO / MDB>> NISSE Gateway <<POJO / MDB>> Batch Dispatcher
Domain Layer
<<POJO>> Business Object <<JESS>> Rule Engine
Data Source Layer

<<JDO>> Domain Store <<POJO / MDB>> File Gateway <<POJO>> Document Gateway
Application Infrastructure
<<Oracle>> Database File System <<Scriptura>> Document Generator
Design Documentation Scope Trust
Why TDD?
Business Facing Support Programming Exploratory (proxy) Integration (XML) Exploratory (customer) System Alfa Beta Unit Integration (Java) Data conversion Performance Fail over Critique Product
Technology Facing
Brian Marick
Test Strategy
Developer 1 Machine Build/Test Process Developer 2 Machine Build/Test Process Developer 3 Machine Build/Test Process Application Server Application Server Application Server
Database Server
Database Schema 1 Schema 2 Schema 3
Client
Browser
Presentation
Faces Servlet
Service
Session Facade
Domain
Data Source
Infrastructure
JSF Component
Facade Impl
Business Object Business Object
Gateway
Managed Bean
Persistence Manager
JDO
RDBMS
Client
Browser
Presentation
Faces Servlet
Service
Session Facade
Domain
Data Source
Infrastructure
JSF Component
Facade Impl
Gateway
Managed Bean
Persistence Manager
JDO
RDBMS
http://xunitpatterns.com
Replace code on which SUT depends
Control indirect input
Verify indirect output
Client
Browser
Presentation
Faces Servlet
Service
Session Facade
Domain
Data Source
Infrastructure
Mock Object or Test Stub

Business Object Business Object Gateway
JSF Component
Facade Impl
Managed Bean
Persistence Manager
JDO
RDBMS
Client
Browser
Presentation
Faces Servlet
Service
Session Facade
Domain
Data Source
Infrastructure
JSF Component
Facade Impl
Gateway
Managed Bean
Persistence Manager
JDO
RDBMS
Test Helper
Client
Browser
Presentation
Faces Servlet
Service
Session Facade
Domain
Data Source
Infrastructure
JSF Component
Facade Impl
Gateway
Managed Bean
Persistence Manager
JDO
RDBMS
http://www.thoughtworks.com/object-mother-easing-test-object-creation.pdf
Object Mother
Object Mother
Test Helper
Client
Browser
Presentation
Faces Servlet
Service
Session Facade
Domain
Data Source
Infrastructure
Humble Object
JSF Component Facade Impl
Gateway
Managed Bean
Persistence Manager
JDO
RDBMS
Mock Object
Mock Object or Test Stub
Client
Browser
Presentation
Faces Servlet
Service
Session Facade
Domain
Data Source
Infrastructure
JSF Component
Facade Impl
Gateway
Managed Bean
Persistence Manager
JDO
RDBMS
Client
Browser
Presentation
Faces Servlet
Service
Session Facade
Domain
Data Source
Infrastructure
JSF Component
Facade Impl
Gateway
Managed Bean
Persistence Manager
JDO
RDBMS
Client
Browser
Presentation
Faces Servlet
Service
Session Facade
Domain
Data Source
Infrastructure
JSF Component
Facade Impl
Gateway
Managed Bean
Persistence Manager
JDO
RDBMS
http://www.openqa.org/selenium
JUnit Test Process Selenium Driver
Browser Process Selenium Browser Bot
AUT
Selenium Server Selenese Proxy WebApp
Web Server AUT WebApp

1. Launches
AUT

1. Launches
AUT
2. Requests command

1. Launches
AUT
2. Requests command
Selenium Server
3. Waits
Selenese Proxy WebApp

4. Go to AUT & request result 1. Launches
AUT
2. Requests command
Selenium Server
3. Waits

AUT
2. Requests command
Selenium Server
3. Waits

AUT
2. Requests command 5. Go to AUT
Selenium Server
3. Waits


6. Go to AUT
AUT
2. Requests command 5. Go to AUT
Selenium Server
3. Waits


6. Go to AUT
AUT
2. Requests command 5. Go to AUT 7. HTTP Request
Selenium Server
3. Waits


6. Go to AUT
AUT
2. Requests command 5. Go to AUT 7. HTTP Request 8. HTTP Response
Selenium Server
3. Waits


6. Go to AUT 9. Gets result
AUT
2. Requests command 5. Go to AUT 7. HTTP Request 8. HTTP Response
Selenium Server
3. Waits


10. Returns result & requests command
AUT
7. HTTP Request 8. HTTP Response
2. Requests command
5. Go to AUT
Selenium Server
3. Waits


AUT
2. Requests command
5. Go to AUT
Selenium Server
3. Waits

11. Waits

4. Go to AUT & request result 12. Result 1. Launches

AUT
2. Requests command
5. Go to AUT
Selenium Server
3. Waits

11. Waits
JUnit Test Process
13. Asserts on result 1. Launches

Selenium Driver
4. Go to AUT & request result 12. Result
AUT
2. Requests command
5. Go to AUT
Selenium Server
3. Waits

11. Waits
import com.thoughtworks.selenium.*; import junit.framework.*; public class GoogleTest extends TestCase { private Selenium sel; public void setUp() { sel = new DefaultSelenium("localhost", 4444, "*firefox", "http://www.google.com"); sel.start(); } public void testGoogle() { sel.open("http://www.google.com/webhp"); sel.type("q", "hello world"); sel.click("btnG"); sel.waitForPageToLoad("5000"); assertEquals("hello world - Google Search", sel.getTitle()); } public void tearDown() { sel.stop(); } }
Test Smells
12
Load factor
10
0 05/05 07/05 09/05 11/05 01/06 03/06 05/06 07/06 09/06
Buggy Tests
Buggy Tests
12
Load factor
10
0 05/05 07/05 09/05 11/05 01/06 03/06 05/06 07/06 09/06
High Test Maintenance Cost
Client
Browser
Presentation
Faces Servlet
Service
Session Facade
Domain Mock Object

Data Source
Infrastructure
Gateway
JSF Component
Facade Impl
Managed Bean
Persistence Manager
JDO
RDBMS
Mock Object
12
Load factor
10
0 05/05 07/05 09/05 11/05 01/06 03/06 05/06 07/06 09/06
Slow Tests
Slow Tests
Slow Tests
Slow Tests
Mock Object Client

Browser
Presentation
Faces Servlet
Service
Session Facade
Domain
Data Source
Infrastructure
JSF Component
Facade Impl
Gateway
Managed Bean
Persistence Manager
JDO
RDBMS
Slow Tests
Slow Tests
Slow Tests
Not Enough
HRS build time
test maintenance
Not Enough Lost ability to

respond to change
Not many tests Enough Too

too much overlap
Not Enough Slow component usage
Client
Browser
Presentation
Faces Servlet
Service
Session Facade
Domain
Data Source
Infrastructure
JSF Component
Facade Impl
Gateway
Managed Bean
Persistence Manager
JDO
RDBMS
Not Enough
Test type predeploy postdeploy number 5020 2606 % 66 34 time 170 5072 % 3 97
Not Enough
Test type predeploy postdeploy number 5020 2606 % 66 34 time 170 5072 % 3 97
Reduce to smoke tests
Result!
10 minute build
Client
Browser
Presentation
Faces Servlet
Service
Session Facade
Domain
Data Source
Infrastructure
JSF Component
Facade Impl
Gateway
Managed Bean
Persistence Manager
JDO
RDBMS
Continuous design well! sts as Te Educate your team Be agile with test strategy
Conclusion
More? Agile Applied on The Largest J2EE Project in The Benelux by Johan Lybaert Agile Development Workshop by Kathleen Cornelis www.ardatissoftwarefactory.com

Test Driven Development Large Scale

Cargado por

Información del documento

Descripción original:

Derechos de autor

Formatos disponibles

Compartir este documento

Compartir o incrustar documentos

Opciones para compartir

¿Le pareció útil este documento?

¿Este contenido es inapropiado?

Copyright:

Formatos disponibles

Test Driven Development Large Scale

Cargado por

Copyright:

Formatos disponibles

Test-Driven Development on a Large Scale Project

0 05/05 07/05 09/05 11/05 01/06 03/06 05/06 07/06 09/06

Request remission / exemption

Debt administration Reminder Summons Subpoena

Data Source Layer

Design Documentation Scope Trust

Database Schema 1 Schema 2 Schema 3

Business Object Business Object

Business Object Business Object

Replace code on which SUT depends

Control indirect input

Verify indirect output

Mock Object or Test Stub

Business Object Business Object

Business Object Business Object

Business Object Business Object

Mock Object or Test Stub

Business Object Business Object

Business Object Business Object

Business Object Business Object

JUnit Test Process Selenium Driver

Browser Process Selenium Browser Bot

Selenium Server Selenese Proxy WebApp

Web Server AUT WebApp

JUnit Test Process Selenium Driver

Browser Process Selenium Browser Bot

Selenium Server Selenese Proxy WebApp

Web Server AUT WebApp

JUnit Test Process Selenium Driver

Browser Process Selenium Browser Bot

Selenium Server Selenese Proxy WebApp

Web Server AUT WebApp

JUnit Test Process Selenium Driver

Browser Process Selenium Browser Bot

Web Server AUT WebApp

Selenese Proxy WebApp

JUnit Test Process Selenium Driver

Browser Process Selenium Browser Bot

Web Server AUT WebApp

Selenese Proxy WebApp

JUnit Test Process Selenium Driver

Browser Process Selenium Browser Bot

Web Server AUT WebApp

Selenese Proxy WebApp

JUnit Test Process Selenium Driver

Browser Process Selenium Browser Bot

Web Server AUT WebApp

Selenese Proxy WebApp

JUnit Test Process Selenium Driver

Browser Process Selenium Browser Bot

Web Server AUT WebApp

Selenese Proxy WebApp

JUnit Test Process Selenium Driver

Browser Process Selenium Browser Bot

Web Server AUT WebApp

Selenese Proxy WebApp

JUnit Test Process Selenium Driver

Browser Process Selenium Browser Bot

Web Server AUT WebApp

Selenese Proxy WebApp

JUnit Test Process Selenium Driver

Browser Process Selenium Browser Bot

Web Server AUT WebApp