Está en la página 1de 35

Iellered E s,4olloJ sessetrordSurlcolas;o; dSolerrs rqf 'orroqt leug eqr aprn8

ot uortplueurncop Sunlaas d11eug'qloq leau rsag r€ql slerrareruJo rsrl-uoqs


por.raye.rde Surrea.rlap'1uer ol sa,l,rtcafqoeqr pue uaerf,s01 pesn aJ€ stur€rtsuoJ
og1 'sa,l.rnafqopue sturerlsuof,Jo tas e otur sluaurerrnbaruSrsapaqt al€lsuerl
ol sE,&\'auo Surlsrxa ue Surugar ro u8rsep leur8rro qrr-LrSurleap reqleg.r,r'a.rnp
-acord aql'€ rerdeq3 ur peurTlno se^. uorlf,alasslerroteur -ro;.t8ererrs aq1
'L'T pue 9'7 sa.rn8rgur 'l.red ur 'pats4
salnqrlle Io les e trqpez:uatteJeqf, sr r{leg '(S'Z pue V'T sarn8rg)Sutqstu! pue
Sututol'Swdpqs:sorlrrue peorg eerqr orur il€t sesseco.rd
reqr por{srlqelsase,r\rr
'araq1 '7 :eldvqS ur patuasard se^\ sassef,ord SurrnlceJnueru Jo druouoxel aq1
K8apus uou?aps aql

i-lnl"i'*L]
i,jiij';ii,-"1rji*S
$S*l*id
m.m fu

'o8els uortelueurnf,op ar{r roJ papeeu


(saulloprn8
uorleruroJur aql Surpr,tord arerru;os pue saprn8 of,rtf,EJdlseq u8rsap
se parnldeo arou tn9 saadoldruapaqsrlqersa-BuolJo speeq aql ur 6lsed or{1ur
'luaprse.r'esrlradxa pue ,reoq-.{\oDl perelnunf,f,p uo serleJuoryo Surrn}ceJnueruur
ssef,f,nsleql ezruSocar01 luarf,UJnssr lr '.trou roC '6I rardeq3 uI ral{lrnJ peroldxe
ale 'sessaoo.rd yo lorluor pue af,ror{l aql ol IEJluoJ'suorlcerelul aseql (e.r,rIelueu
-rJlop E ur eJntf,nJtsoJf,rrueqt Sur8uegc dq .ro srra;ap pue $lJpJJ 'drlsorod Surcnp
-orlur dq saruadord a8eurep osle uuf, Surssaco.rdJo pe eql tng 'ql8uar1s sE r{f,ns
sar].rado.rdef,uer{ueol pasn sr Surssarord pue paqsrug ro pauro[ 'pedegs ere .{aql
aroJaqsaruodord a,neq'asrnoc 1o 'syerreleyAJ 'se^lesueql slrrraletu eql yo saruodo.rd
oql uo Surssaro.rdJo aJuangur agt ot selelor tI 'srqr ol tJedse rar{loue sr arar{I
'uSrsepoql sluaua.rrnbaraql leatu lerll sesserord;o rsrl lroqs e
Sur.tr8'Suruae;ls:oy slndur 'oaql aprlord eseql uo slurertsuoJ 'el€ru uer 1rsadeqs
ar{r puu elpuer{ uEtr }r sessBlrro serlrrueJlerretetu oql Xlerrlrrc 'pue alqedeo sr 1r
(eJnpoJd
qJrr{,lltJo rlsrug eJEJrnseqt ueo lr ged 1o ezrseg} :elep Jrrorunu-uou pue
rrraurnu dg peqrrcsap eq uer sseco.rdE Jo sf,rtsrra]f,€reqJIelrurlJet duelaq 'salep
-rpuer palue.r-dol aqt p aBpa1mou4paruaLurcop eqt eroldxa pue (rsoc tse.aol
agt qlr-4\esoql Sur4easdlensn) ueo leqt ?soqt 4uol'qof agt op touuef, leql esoqr
ino uaat)s :slrrreleru roJ leql slalered ssaco.rde Sursooqc .royd8a1e4s
r""Tr"
pep.re8a.leg ol pesn teqzvrruo{ IErJetEruelgrsn lJrrlxo ol Sur8raruaere sassaro.rd
eN 'aJII rnpo.rd Jo pue eql te palcdcar are slprret€ru leql arrnber uorurdo
^
rqqnd pue uon€lsr8a1{18urseeJf,ul'esn o} glq^a Sursooqc roJ spoqtau pue
sartrlgedec Iprrugrel rraql aroldxe a,u reldegr srql ur lsessecordesaqr ro; dqc
-rerorr{B peugap g .rardeg3 'slcnpord e>leruol pauloI puu peqsruy'sluouodruoc
olur padeqs eJEeseql 'ruro; elgesn 'ueeycur SurraaurSuaJo unrs eqt elEOrJol
passecordeJp Iro pue sl€reurtu'sarg 'alqeredasurare Sursserordpup slerralery

frLrpi"i*it,}r'ril*"ji!-ji
5r5*ou,{5
$_.ffifu

s#ss*Joid S*;:$3.:r;nu*u: :iys,ryr:d/f,r"rf ';, ,r: 1. ii!t,i::r


-ft,-r';
-Y:],,;5 #&tr

Please purchase PDF Split-Merge on www.verypdf.com to remove this watermark.


18.2 Process in desiqn 411
selection

Translate design requirements


idenw function,technical& quality
@nstraints,objectivesand frce variables

Screen using constraints


eliminateprccessesthat
cannotdo theiob

Rank using obiective


find thescreenedprocesss
thatdo thejob mostffinomically

Seek documentation
researchthe effectof processing
on detecEandDrcperties

Final process choice

Figure18.1 The selectionstrategyappli*d to processes.


As for materials,the four stepsare
tra n s l a ti o ns, c re e ni ng,ranki ngand supporti ngdocumentati on.A l l can be
imnlementedin software.

path, shown in Figure 18.1. It usesconstraints on process attributes to screen,


together with an appropriate objective to rank, culminating as before with a
search for information documenting the details of the top-ranked candidates.
Translation
As we saw in earlier chapters, the fwnction of a component dictates the initial
choice of material and shape. This choice exerts constraints on the choice of
processes. It is helpful to think of rwo types of constraint: technical-can the
process do the job at all? And quality-can it do so sufficiently well? One tech-
nical constraint applies across all process families: it is the compatibility of
material and process.Shape,too, is a general constraint, although its influence
on the choice of shaping, joining and finishing processes differs. Quality
includes precision and surface finish, together with avoidance of defects and
achieving the target for material properties. The usual obiectiue in processingis
to minimize cost. The free uariables are largely limited to choosing the process
itself and its operating parameters (such as temperatures,flow rates and so on).
Table 18.1 summarizes the outcome of the translation stage. The case studies
of Section 18.9 illustrate its use for each processfamily.

Please purchase PDF Split-Merge on www.verypdf.com to remove this watermark.


'ssef,ord rq8rr eqr Sutpug
ur sn e>{eluec Sulluer pue Surueans letll reJ os dpo sI areql'u8rsap uI IBf,IIIJl
sr (qro,r. l uop ro) {ro1\4.sessaf,ordrnoq to eBPalA{ou>IPUEuoll€luarunf,op 'oS
'seluadoJd eunl-aug of fnq sedeqs aTpru ol lsnl lou uesoqc
Glualxe
aJEsessef,ord'eJntf,nrlsoJf,Ilu uo eJuengq sfl q8norqf drotsrq ssarord uo
ressel ro JalEeJBr ol'puadap selgedoJd lelreletu elull oIUES eq] fY 'eJnllet arnl
i -?rueJd asn€J deru tesn eql ol uo passed I 'Pu€ lfit,rrpnpord lsol PUE derrs ol
!i,
spBelurru ul sHI'Ssarls lEnprsalJo 8ur>lf,eJl'llrsorod aAISSeJXe sE I{)ns 'sna;ep
Surrntrelnueu or PEal uEJ r oPut-l\^sql uqlll\{ eleredo ol arnlle{ ,bqenb pasnu
-oJdtuof,un qtr^{ stJnpoJd arnpord: pue lsaq ryo,tr deqf I{JIIIrlaJOPUnsuolllPuoJ
Surterado Jo seSuer runulldo e^eq il€ seulqf,el/'{ 'dtrTenb PUE dll^Ipnpord or
salPl3r esluadxe IEf,IuqJal lueilodlul lsou aql 'sas^{1eue arnlIEJ puE salPnls aseJ
.saprn8arplerd Neg (seuqePln8u8rsap suollellduo) ur dlqrsseoceeJoIII PeJolssI
1o
,errorusuedxa ldepor etet ?te eJrTJoJ sqot
asriledxg .uagr qly\{ spearlJrar{l3ur1e1
lnfl 'uorleueldxa cgnueros el€IPeurul {ep teql surelgord trataP ol drqrqe pcu
-sdur tsourle ue dole^ep uEf, PuB sPeaqrleql uI uolletuJolul sql dr.recsepecepro;
.sessef,oJd
roJ enrl sBlsnl sl sHI'qf,JBes
ssesoJd€ pa8€uErue^eq oq^. spuEqplo
uoqetuaurnJop e q8norqr paroldxe lsaq aJE daqf !(ror,reqaq uoISoJJof,se qcns)
senssr alqEp€rl ssJI eqr qrIA\ dlarenbape edot lou op Sur4uer pu€ Suruearf,s
uogpTualan?ocI

.lq8nos sr lBql o^,u eql uea^$ag (lsof, ssol


JJo-epErru sr 1r,(1pnsn erour qSnoql Jo
-pre8ar drrlenb Sutztrurxetu Jo a^Ipalqo eqf dg parelder 3q deru ll suoneclTdde
Sulpueurep ulegef, uI 'lsol Sutzlulrurul Jo fEI{f sI ssef,oJdE Sulpeles uI elllf,elqo
snor^qo lsouJ erll 'san4)alqo uo Pes€q sr 'pareqruaruar eq III^{ lr '3ut1ue1
3u14uoy

'31 g se a8rrl se lueuod{uof, E alPuuq louuef, ro runtseu8eureduqs louuel


teqt esoqt eleurullle ol salnglJlle sssf,oJdaqr qlIA\ PeJedIuoJdllsee are .31 g rnoqe
Surq8rarlrpue urnrseuSeluJo aP€Iu, sB qJns sluelueJlnbaU 'eldurexa ro; 'peqdde
eq uef, ssarord eqt qJIII.&\ol slEIJelEIuJo slslT-JlJalunu-uou eIe sraqlo 'aAaIIIf,e
(elPuEIIuel ssarord aql
ueJ I sseuglooruseJBlJnsaql Jo uotstrerd 3g1 lueuodluof,
sseru Jo ozIS aql-se8uer JlJetunu eldIuIS eJE salnqlJlle ssarord eluos 'slul€rls
Jo
-uoo aql lJaru touueJ leql sessef,ordSutleurruqe 'asaql seqdde dals Sutuoarcs
eql 'salnqrJDP sseJoJdroJ slulErlsuoJ ol sPeal 'slurraleur qI^\ sB 'uottelsuerl
Sutuaa,og

eerl
salqerien
e ipofqo
""J:fi"";
solqerje^eaJ+puP o^ll)afqo 'slul?rlsuo)'uolDunl l'8 ! alqel

sossafoJdSuunpelnueu :qepd pue 4)4s']eaq 'leaH 8L j01d8qf z\n

Please purchase PDF Split-Merge on www.verypdf.com to remove this watermark.


*
4

tlfh
mel * ri ai i nrnpatrL:l l l ty 4S 3
::.i i r1:Lrteg.

dt r $ ro
r rt]{.e55e i{r'lb u ir: :-;: :'
1:'-:'3':; t li i ij i i it}'
$m # ":'
- "-r'::-l
T h e m a i n g o a l i n d e fi ni ngprocessattri butesi stoi denti fythecharacteri sti cs
their selection by screening'
that discriminate between processes,to enable
and surface treatment-
Each of ;h; ;h;.. process families-shaping, ioining.
h a s i to w n s e to fc h a r acteri zi ngattri butes,descri bedhereandi nthenextthree
physical limits to these for a given
sections.It is also of interest to explore the
p ro c e s s ' a n d to e x a m i nehow theproperti esofthemateri al bei ngprocessed
iimit the rate of the processitself'
with
orr. p*.rs art;bute applies to all three families-compatibility
material'-so we examine this first'

Materi al-P ro cess comPatib ilitY


matrix. Shaping processes
Figure 1g) shows a material-process compatibility
with compatible combinations marked by dots the color of
are atrh.1;,
screeningis straightforward-
which identifies the material family. Its use for
immediately eliminated (or the
specify the material and some processes-are
re v e rs e ' a s a s c re e n i ngstepi nmateri al sel ecti on).Thedi agonal spreadofthe
class-metals, polymers, etc'-has
dots in the matrix revealsthat each material
largely reflects the underlying process
its own set of process routes. This
softening the material, and the
physics. Shaping is usually easedby meltiirg-o,
of ih. classes are quite distinct (Figure 13'6)'
melting;;;;;r.,
-"t"ii"l
T h e re a re s o me o v e rl aps-pow dermethodsarecompati bl e-w i thbothmetal s
(when used
*irt uotr, polymers.and glasses.Machining
""d.J;;;;;-otai,rg all families. processes using
fo, ,h"pfii is comp"atible with ul-or, Joining
a d h e s i v e s a n d fa stener,u..u.,yversati l eandcanbeusedw i thmostmateri al s'
* h ...u ,* .l d i n g me thodsaremateri al speci fi c.Fi ni shi ngprocessesarepri ma-
are__molded to
rily used for thJarder materials, partic;larlymetals-polymers 'We see
for decorative purposes. will
,t up. ulra ,"r.ry ,r."r.a further ."..p,
whY later.

Coupling of material selection and process sglytlon


linked. The compatibility matrix
Th..t oi?. of material and of processare clearly
shows that the choice of isolatesa sub-domain of processes'The process
-ut.riul aluminwm alloys were chosen in
choice feeds back to material selection. If, say,
initial processselection stage'
the initial material selection stage and casting the
in
are castable can be used' If the com-
th.r, orrty,t. ,oUr., of aluminrim alloys thai
proc€ss), matefl^;hoice is
por.rrii, ih.r, ,o be age hard.ened(a heat-treatment,
alloys' So we must continuallY
further fi-ir.J to heatlteatable aluminum cdsting
and material, checking that inconsistent combinations
it"rut. ;;;;;..cess
nor process choice can be car-
are avoided. The key point is that neitler material
Once past initial screening' it is
,l.a ,."rl"t'*irno"i giuing thought to the other.
essentiallya co-selectionprocedure'

Please purchase PDF Split-Merge on www.verypdf.com to remove this watermark.


'! \EaI{ers s8urql 3rq-asn
a,lnqJrr{,{ aJuaJe;JrpqJnr.ua{e{u l(usaop .0I
lo rolf,EJ e ueds.,(1uosarllsuap oll.{oo,,.p.rrr,rA"* fr fnoqp
yo ,irpro d,rerl, sranoc auo
ilqrra Jo aSueraql aJurslnq
'sseru'dqro r*nion xq parnse"r,,eq uEf,ezr5 dpure;
erJeleruauo u'r{' l'eJl uec sseco.rdeqr ueq^\ JOI.J auo ueqt e.rour
'Joru
'DrurElal ueag sBgdrrlrgrredruof, Sursn
lprJele.uro;Surpoc rolor egr .slrurl eql s^^or{s
;'31 e;n8rg 'e>lBruuBJ ssaco.rdE lBr{l ruouod*or;o azrsaql 01 s}rull
erE oror{J
ssau4?xq|uotx)as puo ssow

si-ri St..t il il 5il1nrq Ij * u "sos!;:i},J;d fi i: Iij r.:i..1,., "


{"rtr_}
Sp ffi #

.fii"rj*.)
fJ] 5*ii]!.ti5 *it)$i
r, - ! i L a i j } : S * l p * r ; ; liJ,l ij* $ r t,v,clq*ijl '!r1J$j.*!..{.}
":;r;u$! Iq p*p+: ;r;g*-rl*ssu:*-l*
r.,Ii I I,j$I ii I f , u l-r $ r: I * l,'fi
I 1* u,i d eq s : r:3 x l.rtrr l-* r Il,;I1a rJLu* : st ;1.:
1 "1,1 n: r{*.
Ir r"t* i r ru i} {.,i
-L 4'g; ;*;nf:11

pol
-uoc
weoJ Q atsodw@ a Jaul{lod @ Jweral a ptew a

._w e

ti
-..p_. -p. ....v-_... ..? 6ur qs r 1o3 TIT
4.. .._o_.
o.. ..9 ..."4. 6urdde"l ti'

r& 6
- 6- ..o_ o .."?. 6ur puuO l6
a 6ururqceu uorstcald I6

...9.....o. .-@ -@_ @ ...o....s)..."4 ...o_.sauelsel


-s *-66
-q -@* @_ srau^lod ,6utplaM
T.
to
-8-
& -66- -a- ."4
a
" 5.
a
s l Pl au'6utpl aM
se^lsaqpv
l ='
l ='
l@
!

6eq unncen
spoLllau dn-^e-l
6urputMluoueltl
6urplou talsuerl-ursaH
6urlsec Joullod
6urutol-ouloqf
6urplou leuorlelog
6urplou uotssajduoC
6urplou Molg a
6urplou uorlcalul D
6ururqceuleuolluaAuoC =
6ulutqcEu-ollcalf
spoqlau rapmod
6ururol laaqS
uorsnllx=
6urOloJ
6urlsecarnssatd-mo1
6urlspcluaulse^uJ
6urlsecarq
6urlsecpueg

9= q d ' e f# Q<
;-==ya
E6
t d 3 :3 ff d-_
oo666
-*xgo J
6f)
I
c

jsss.sls.J#.
#,;::*1.:sjr:ru#il./:tisJl*sfftrs.y-lJ;S
!r*ry ltr*E El ..r*jCsr,l
I trhtr

Please purchase PDF Split-Merge on www.verypdf.com to remove this watermark.


t
" 1t,

::'.::,:i+li.
t;tiil'Jr.rie::t{i triCiil:, 4T S \

Sand
^ .ci i n ^

o Die casting
c
-o Investment Casting
6 Low-pressure casting
c
Forging
E
b Extrusion
Sheet forming
Powder methods
--=
60
o> i
Electro-machining
Conventional machining
OA :,
z Injection molding
i Blow molding
.9
o Y,i Compression molding
>=: Rotatlonal molding
^e< !
L@i ThermoJorming
i Polymer casting
o- i Resin-transfer moldin g
'6 P l*.
Filament winding
ooI
c6l Lay-up methods
d'1 Vacuum bag

10-3 10 2 0.1 1 10 102 103 104


Mass (kg)
. metal a ceramic @polymer. composite

Fiq*l* 'nff.3 J"n* pr*ress--r'fla,q$ r{inq* ner ci";*ri"f*i' l;i:;*n!r:g$Jr${q!$*5.ignnr*" *r fir:;i


r,;,1$inrl.ih* hr:xe:; th*y rtf*r i* r;l,re sfu{lies t* et:ry:r.The icicrr r*f*r t* th*
rriule!'ifii,ar in f igr.trt 18.7. t'rit:llip!t e.r:l*rsindlcete r*r*6;*tlhiliiy l,irith m*i.* l..i;an
*r":* i*rr:ilir,,

whatever they are made of. Most processesspan a mass range of about a factor
of 1000 or so. Note that this attribute is most discriminating at the exrremes;
the vast majority of components are in the 0.1-10 kg range, for which virtually
any processwill work.
It is worth noting what the ranges represent.Each bar spansthe size range of
which the process is capable without undue technical difficulry. All can be
stretched to smaller or larger extremes but at the penalty of extra cost because
the equipment is no longer standard. During screening,therefore,it is important
to recognize'near misses'-processeswhich narrowly failed, but which could, if
needed, be reconsideredand used.
Figure 18.4 shows a secondbar chart: that for the ranges of section thickness
of which each shaping processis capable. It is the lower end of the ranges-the
minimum section thickness-where the physics of the process imposes limits.
Their origins are the subject of the next sub-section.

Physical limits to size and section thickness


Castingand molding both rely on material flow in the liquid or semi-liauid
state.Lower limits on secrionthicknessare imposedby the physicsof flow.

Please purchase PDF Split-Merge on www.verypdf.com to remove this watermark.


F{|]!,j'Wl!h&,qioP'ouJ!l

l.

si

Please purchase PDF Split-Merge on www.verypdf.com to remove this watermark.


altrbutesandorigns 417
I8.4 Shapng processes

Fiqure 18.6 (a)Difierentialshrinkage.ausesinternalstress, andcavitation


distortion in thi(k
as
sectionsor at chanqesof section.(b) Gooddesignkeepssectlonthickne'ss
uniformas possible.
avoiding the problem

temperature, with a step increasein viscosity, but for allovs this happensover a
ranie of ternperature,known as the 'mushy zone', in which the allov is part liq-
uid. oart solid. The width of this zone can vary from a {ew degreescentigrade
to several hundred-so metal flow in castings dependson alloy composition'
In general,higler pressuredie-castingand molding methodsenablethinner
seciionsto be made, but the equipment costs nore and the {aster,more nrbu-
Ient flow can entrapmore porosit'1and causedamageto the molds.
UDDerlimits to sizeand sectionin castingand molding are set bv problems
of shrinkaee. The outer layer of a casting or molding cools and solidifies first'
eninq it a rieid 'kin. Whenthe inler;orsubsequenrl) rhechrngern
'olidifie.'
iolume candi.ron the produ.tor crackrhe"kin. or cdu\einrernalcavitarion'
Problemso{ this sort are most severewherethereare changesof section,since
the constaint introduces tensile stressesthat calse hot tearinS -.lacki'ng
causedby constrained thermal contraction. Different compositions have differ-
ent susceptibilities to hot tearing-another ex.mple of coupling betweenmate-
rial, processand designdetail.
Much of the documentation for casting and molding processesconcerns
guidance on designing both the component shape and the mold geometry to
achievethe desired cross-sectionswhile avoiding defects Even when the com
oonent sh:pei' 6xed,thereis freedomlo choo.ewhererhemarerialrnletqare
't'"it.,"to,L.
{rhe runner.)and wherethe arr and exce" marenalwill
escape (the 'risers').Figure18.5 showsan exampleof good practicein design-
-old
ing the cross sectional shapeof a polymer molding.
Powder methods for metals and ceramicstoo dependon flow. FillirE a mold
-,- with powder uses free flow under gravity plus vibration to bed the powder
downand achieveuniform 6lling. This may be followed bv compression ('cold
compaction').Oncetullofpowder, the mold is heatedto allow densificationby
Ls sintering or, if the pressureis maintained, by hot isostatic pressing (HIPing) -
Metal shapingby de{ormation-hot or cold rolling, {orging or extrusion-also
ibs involves flow. Solid metals flow by plasdc deformation or bv creep--{hapter 13
H describedhow the flow rate dependson stressand temperature Much forming

Please purchase PDF Split-Merge on www.verypdf.com to remove this watermark.


In u^\oqs-,3urrtrlJeq,-'--.dErls 1rIuoiuorsrpsarnpordostErr'p.uuoj 3q u"tr rql
oDErnedsE rl]l srurrTpuE peol iqr s.se.J]Lr {Fro rou uoD:)uC\Jlrlssrrd a8rEl
,(Jr^ qrr^\ u:^r 'fl.rl rcu IIia puB sloor :qr or )I]Ds ildu$ suoDr.s urqr fiaa sseu
-IrrLIl uorlrrs uo uorrrr.rJJo rru{ Fru.rr?unr .rP sileirsn srrlJ (r) uI su !3ur
-pt.r{.sn!. (,1p.p.ru rlnssird lununxEulaqrleq8rqiqr r(ssroprqrAlpr^!)uoDrrs
.q] Jo oqE.rF.dsE .qr rarErl8 .qf Tlol .qr srsD.r.ul uoDrrrl os (PPolBururol Iorol
.qr $ uoDnqrrsrPansserdrqr r.Pun crJE3ql ,llrrluoqrr{j e 5ul^€ 'Surprards
IEr.lrl rqr s$nr uolrtrrryrqr ssnDr.qdn sdullrl rmss.rd rqr puP arE|alur arP
rqr rr srPrqsIP.r.urqr'(q) ur sD'uoDrr! qrrt( ", ssrlrsPlar^srl r? sr\ou laretru'
rqr Pu': IExerunrsourtug suPPot.$!(E) L]l sElP$e.nqnt Il..^\3r" d3rpuaqa
. to- irr .iPL,nPUfJ,PJq, uo uo,rnq,. r',P*n.\),d rqr!3urq1 oDr. | \uo.r
rrs urqrire^ jlurrlorro 8u€rot uI p.^to^ulsruatqord.qrsrrErsnllr/ 8 L arnBu
'alrol
:ur8ror Io.rnssrrd JIorpernber rqr r:]prr8 rqr 'uoutrrseql raunrqleql :llrsol
sr^Iq prr[urr $ SuDse]w ssruuqr :qt rrqr iE^\ 3ues eqr qrn ur .{\oUrrls"id
lq partrJrtsr prpn]rx: .ropaErot'prllor !q uetrroqr ss.uurqraql !tresqr sr r()u
luuol.p PIor surrnPdn qr;urrs PI.rl eqr s3^uPqrq.\ 'i8uruapr"rt)Po^\ Pu!
.rnni.du uroor lE rrqr u.qr r.^\ol sr ss:rIrsPI.iI roq .qr :sn€rrq roq suop sr

' !.rL trj .tj p rri tn p!! .rt.j rrft!::) o nLrt:.rfi :r I ;r11 .j ti n
r r ;.1 . r ? r1 1;rl r ; rI a r) e ! rr:j.r!:,1 i Lr!5n.:.j L,rrc;r1,r.i , i , r;r:,r;,n!e:r' a
r?t r- ilr ir!.i1r!r+irl rp 1! rtr rn (.1) ir: 1r r: .r. n .r.1r;irr,rr')rtsir.J! r-,
t . l )1 € i !r;rrr i ,r j o i rrp rr;L l ,r!o !,r!j rri i ti (e .ru !crtrr] 1r r)r!ri tu' .)l l ai ::j i ti t)

lool l= 2 : 1= t
loof Y =r t|-I

[€

lool 0 =1 t r =1

:t)\.f..;:.i it t : ) . t l i 2 1 ! l L t r t r ttr;i j:rH


,3t:ti.) P:je l]i):: fli..rri : lj ttt

Please purchase PDF Split-Merge on www.verypdf.com to remove this watermark.


processes:
18.4 Shaplng and origins 419
attributes

both (b) and (c). A positive aspectof the high contact pressuresin {orgins is the
reoeatabiliw wi*r which the metal can be forced to take up small features
machiaedon the face o{ the tootins, exploit€d h making coins.

Yery small or uery tbin obiects-p sbing the limits


Sohow do you makevery smallthings?The obviousway to do it is to ctlt them
out of bigger ones.That meansmachining turning, shaping,drillins and millins.
The upper limit on sizeis set by the budget available to buy the machineand the
electricity bill for its use Lol.rer limits-now we 3r€ thinking of nilligams and
fractions of a millimeter-are set by the stiffnessof the machineand the material
itself.
One continuousshapingprocess'rolling, is able to producesectionsas thin
as 10 um-the thicknessof aluminum knchen foil. The foil onlv vields and
thins just as it entersand leavesthe roll bit+in between,the hugeaspectratio
and frictional constraintmeanthat the high pressureactuallyflaftensthe steel
rolls elastically.The processis helpedby'pack rolling'-feeding two sheets
through together,with lubricant in between so that they can be peeledapart as
they exit the rolls. This is why kitchen foil is shiny on one side(wherecontact
was with the roll) and matt on the other.
Supposeyou want to go still smaller'Flow \ton't work, and the sectionsare
so thin that they simply bend if you try to machine them Now you needchem-
istry. Conventional chemistry---+tching, chemical milling, electro discharge
milling allow featureson the samescaleas that of precision machining. To get
really small, we needthe screening,printing and etching techniquesusedto fab
ricateelectronicdevices. Theseareusedto makeMEMS (micro-elecfto'mechan
ical systems)- tiny sensors,actuato$' gearsand evenengines.At presentthe
rangeof materialsis lirnitedby this siliconbasedtechnolognbut somecommer-
cial devices,such as the ineniai triggers lor airbags, are made in this wav.
-re
dtF Shape
trt5- A key attribute of a processis the families o{ shapesit can make. It is also one
* of the most difficult to characterize.A classificationschemeis illustratedin
Figure 18.8, wi$ threegenericclassesoI shape,eachsub divided in two. The
merit o{ this approachis that processes map onto specifrcshapes.Figure18.9
nlk showsthe matrix oI viablecombinations.
ade The prismatic shapesshown on the left of Figure 18.8, made by rolling'
.de extrusionor drawing, have a specialfeature:they can be made in continuous
lengths. The other shapes cannot-they are discrete, and the processesthat
ldE
-€I makethem are calledbatchprocesses. The distinctionbetweencontinuousand
{de discrete(or batch)processes is a usefulone,bearingon the costofmanufaciure.
Fr4 Batch processesrequire repeatedcycles of setting-up,which can be time-
Er- consumingand costlp Onthe otherhand,they areoften net-shapeor nearlyso,
m€aning that little further machining is needed to finish the component.
lso Castingand molding,processes are nearnet-shape. Forging,on the otherhand'
hir is limited by the strains and shapechangesby solid-stateplasticitv,starting

Please purchase PDF Split-Merge on www.verypdf.com to remove this watermark.


I"rrpurrI) 'Faqs pue lrEld's.qnr sErlJnslelJor"tuIrors prepu?lsro )p?Jrle,{
Ir€r s€qtrnssrrnpord lreusrrd '8uol or Palms .^r .r? sass.rord s onu4uoJ
'salplo ,Ju.nbas? SulrFbor
seBsrspJJ !s ur .dEqs C-t r .reaD or (roaqsro por <req)lrols pr?puels luolj

-arojsqsep3po)rotor uolleu!qLUo)slqer^
e sujro+red oq] lPLllsalerpur]op v xulPu ilrlrqrlEdurorssa)ord+deqs3qj 6 81 arn6rl

atsoduoc. rcu4od . swaac @tqew .

ta

'lEl
I
t5P
te <=
la d
:
I I

i
r?u
le
l'
9I<a.
t6u I
e

'L,oneu,L'rrx'p,aqunJ
tnJdsnd^tbrousaoppue
'ln)t]+tp xrsueql
stsesset) qnS adeqsjo rrolFrt+tsset)
olur uorsr^rp aq1 8 81or n6r l

|l
Please purchase PDF Split-Merge on www.verypdf.com to remove this watermark.
<esse)otd
dutJnl'telnuea:q9tad pup >!)\\ ledq leaH 8l rdrdeqJ
I8 a Sfapirg prcce55es:
attrrbLrtes
andorigrns 421

Iable 18.2 Typi.allevels andsuiiableprocesses


offinirhrequiredn diffefentapplication5,

RoughneeS('m)Typicalapp'ication

L
-l

E
;

Figure 18.10 Asectlonthrougha surface,showingits irregularsurface(anisti(allyexaggerat€d


in the vertiraldirection).Theirregularityis measuredby the RMSroughness,
R.

rclls produce sheets.Shapedrolls make more complex prodles-rail track is


one of these.Extrusion is a partrcularlyversatilecontinuousprocess,since
complex prismatic proliles that include internal channelsand longitudinal tea-
turessrch as ribs and stiffenerscan be manufacturedin one step.
Tolennce and ro4hnzss
we think of the precision and sur{ace6nish o{ a component as aspectsof its
qualitl. They are measlred by the tolerance, T, all'd the surfare roughness,R.
\0hen the dimensions of a component are specifed the surface quality is specr
f,ed aswell, though not necessarilyover the entire surface.Surfrce quality is crit-
ical in contacting surfacessuch as the faceso{ flangesthat must mate to form a
seal or sliders running in grooves. It is also important for resistanceto fatigue
crack initiation and for aestheticreasons.The tolerance T on a dimension v is
specifredas y: 1O0l0.1nrm, or as y = 501$$l1mm,indicatingthat there is
more {reedomto oversizethan to undersize.Sur{aceroughness,R, is speci6edas
an upper limit, e.g.R < 100pm. The typical su acefinish requiredin various
products is shown in Table 18.2. The table also indicates typical processesthat
can achievetheselevels of finish.
Surfaceroughnessis a measureof the iregularities of the surface(Figure18.10).
It is definedasthe root'mean-square(RMS) amplitude of dre surfacepro6le:
4!"s
,L
.';:- pz : 1 f u:1r16" (18.1)
Please
*-J purchase PDF Split-Merge on www.verypdf.com to remove this watermark.
pse uorsbard q8q 01 p.ddq Pu" punojS-ar"Jrnseq ue. srlttr?r3r Pu?
"
slvratvupq ssa.o.tdE SulrEorrla,{al peIIsePaql or dn qslugro oruPralolrql
r Sulrq or Burss.roJd uolr€urroJaP ro Buus€r rau€ Pesn ,{Iuofiuor sI 'qsrug
a.qins puE ,trernrr? FuolsuelllP qBIq Jo elq"d"tr '8uluq."W fflso = I
rsPlaIII roj slsssrord Suld€qs oN
pu? ui I 0 = J u?q1 I3Dlq oP :Ia^3 \oq
'.uo raqroorus e sa,\13selp lEFtu olul gBrssJ :satr€]ns qfnor se^€ 8uqs"tr PueS
'sosse.ordSurd€qsaqr r{olaq PPpe aIP sassaoo.rd Suluslug rol el?q IIIurcJ ISIJ
-4sur roj Surpor rolor aqr 8uM"l.r 'alq"dtr ale soss"rord q I,t Jo ssauqanor
pue .)uerrlor ro \i3uPr rusuJr)erPqreqr $otls ZT 8l PUPll Sl crrn€r{
'u000I 01uol uro{ abuerreql saruenlol
!^€ sassarordPei US e{rt arotu sI brueralol ro, rllu{ r.^4ol .lnlosq9 rruaq
puE 'ssauqgnor{ead aqr 'sssuqSnorar?nbs-u€.1u-roor srll $ U a.uls 'Paeplll
iy7 ueqr :area:8 ,(lsnor,qo sI J aru"ralor 3qI ,{lu"F3arrl 3r"Jlns d€tu or lrr
aluolalrolq Sulsnlr?Jlns aqr r3 o rtsq € su?rsrI Poqrau snl^rsoq1Patr€lo.r
seq'ar?rntr]E trJorIIpu€ €rs€J $ .qa\*\'K4auogord P2fdO Prcxer
^\ou
euoqdouers 8tn,{!ld a{r '(r),( llyord I"]Iu3^ .qr SuPjorer aFl^a uo4tanP ,
eqr uI .telms "etl1rr^o snllrs drEqs.1qgq€ 3u€3€ry Iq Pans€rur .q 01 Pasn{
I
I
I 'sarpn15 3se)sql roj sanle la6re] aql qlur^palelou'repue leualpLu
t 1il ,{q papo)roto) el yeqr sqt pspalasaq o} suleqrssa)ord6ullqeu3$sserord
I 6urdeqsro, veqr req o)ueralol-sssrordaq] l L 8L oln6ll
6urqsru|lEuospue sEsse)o]d
trlt
: elsodwo..)au\od . cluerac a Pteu .

ffi
-

sassaold6uqnt)e4nueu:qsllodpue 1)!1sleaq ?eaH 8l raioPq) zzn


Please purchase PDF Split-Merge on www.verypdf.com to remove this watermark.
i
l8 5 loiningprocesses: andorigins 423
attributes

T sanddsrinsI
D ecdnql --f!Fl
ltr -l ms,m.nrcdns
EI
FI Low_P€$urodnaI f:"-J
: I FoqinqI
:
;l
> I sh€€Uorminq
I
e -i I
E:[ | E odrc-m,chi nms
I
EFlTlc"-*rc*.*n..s I
Ini.ctonmodinQ
I Bl@mordi'aI
Eg I compr#ionmordinq
l
'- 41

:u n
E i; I rhermo I
I 'omns
casrins
Polymar -- ---1td
.c rl mord
Resfrkansrs nq L €,i)
E nl- Famotw mdns I
E FI
36t v&wm bas L
001

e,T P,sisonm&hinins
: I Grndhs
E I Lapp'ns
Polish'nC
. metal 6 @tanic . polymet. @nposne

andsomeflnishing
ba' chartfof shapingprocesses
Fioure '18.12 Theprocess roughness
- oro."rt"t, enablinqprocesschainsto be selected
It
,

5 and a
smoothness:a large telescopereflector has a tolerance approaching irm
nde f/fO0 of this overa dimension ofa meteror more--Butpre-
.o"gh"."" of
raorF "bo,it costs increaseexponentiallvas the
cisiin and finish carry a cost: processing
{or both aremademore severe lt is an mrstaKe
expensrv€ to over-
reouirements
soicifv Precision and linish
r fR: 'Uoid.d polv-e." inhedt the 6nish of the molds and thus can be verv
smooth (Fiiure 18.12); machiningto irnprow the 6nirh is rarelv-necess:rv'
Ege -better
Tolerances than a02nrm are teldom pos$ble (Figure 18 Il) because
Jternal stresses le{t bv molding causedistortion and becausepolvmerscreep
ir service

h"".- andorigjns
attributes
18,5 loiningprocesses:
i aad
j2;r drfferfrom $ose
to be mer in choosinga-ioiningprocess
The designrequirements
r tri€ purchase PDF Split-Merge on www.verypdf.com
Please process
to remove
for choosinga shapng Even
this materialcomparibilLqis more invoJved
watermark.
materiar*'
5!riL
ir''* i.. i",t'.. i''ints are often to be madebetweendissimilar
."a 'r'"lpi"*
iaqttl€qr Innn € rrrqr \ rg {qru:sse aqr reqr sa:mbr ,qlEnsn'erulrsur roJ '8In
"
-pla r itlerq uorrtrela!4quass€ aW to rzls arlr uo srurr rsodrur sasslrord Sururof
urErel ufisep rurol uo sluwrsuor.sodrm oq? suolrlpuor SulJnl,e]nuew
'spnbt jo $s?3 .pnlrx. ot parrnb.r .q pu?
lEas € sEa res osl" lEru turol y oJnrlredtu,l Suqe€do par?^!l! u! r? lrlJ3do
01 pannbar eq I"III ,{aqr ro .lrnlJlrll! ro 1e.q to uoq.npuor lqr rsurcg" 31el
-nsul io Fnpuotr or P3auI€ttI srurol'IF rou sr reqr rnq 'p"ol lrr€r srsrolrsow
qunr4suo. 8uurryr'Jnutur pup safa\euofpunJ t,opuo"as
dra1uoa8or paldnotrsr 'oo1sseDlrqr aqr arl]r".Td
uI lenbe ,{FEauare l?ql suo!.as ro, rsaq Iro \ 8uI \as pu€ Suqa^u alq,{ 'auo
lrrqr lI!^ e ot r.lq urql &o ? puoq u?r se,{rsaqp" :suonrasl"nbaun dll"aI5
€ururol o! s€qto uEql paldepe rauaq aj? sassatro.rd aluos suoperaplsuor .raj
su€rr r€aq,(q 's!3€!p Surire^ or 'porru$ar si paplaa aq u?r r?rF ssau)l.rql orIJ
l"qr qrl^{ rou rnq suorrmsuqr qr \ p.sn aq u€.8w$as pu€ 3uo.^u'8lnld
-crs aI{ sassarordBururol !ns$ us $ ss.Dltrrqr raeqs 'srurol SuDIEruurqlN
'.8?rs uo4?rueumrop eqr l? p.rlcreas.r ,q lsnur Sundnor aql
Jo slrEr.p eqr ]nq 'u.do suoDdo sdool ,{lrrallor uolrelosr uI qtr?euo SwueartrS
'ruerrodur $ 8lnplol pue lrauoe8 01 ssarord Jo auoq. 8uqtl?ru 'oo1 'eiaq
n6ll lnq 'llq€rd€p€ rrour are sr.u.lseJ pap?orqr pu? spl.l( uo$uar uI pooS ssel
ar€ rnq srurol del lo 8tnp"ol relrls ro] pad"p? Il.,{ ar? 'oor 's.lders pue st.^ru
rou ar" srurol$nq'aug elE slurol dq-€.r? SuDIro^rpoo8 p p!3u se^$!qpy
! 'ad"r d)ltrIrsIJo guqaedJo lrltll-8u{led ur rood !r" rnq l€.qs uoddns slurol
a rseqpy'Inalqordpeldnor? srrr-Supeol Jo opou .qr pu" 'pouroleq or susd
aqr ro s3ssau-irl(Ilpu? s.deqs ltll uo spuedapl!aluo.8 lo erorltr lqf SInpEol
,o slporu pu€ sourotuoeS lurol pr?puels ar?llsnlll tI SI pue €I 8] sorn8rC
'pep"ol .q llr \ rurol eqr l"^,| arlr pue apueq uer ,{eqr l?uerslu to sslll)lrql
aqr lmol eqr lo &r31uoa3 lqr .re suoneraprsuor rgD.ds-3ururol ru"uodrul
Sutppot Jo apout pup taa'aoaB y'o[
.dets Lloll€lua1unaopaqr ued $ sl?ual€lu
Jo
r?lrunssp SInInol In a .eJd poo8 3u/jrruepl e8eu"p Jo Isu W { 's.3u?qc arnl
-rr.dlu.r aqr I rurot eIIr n s3ssa4sl"ureru sa^€ qtrr€ursruluolsu"dxafuueql
16l l 'saceJlns.qr uea leq re&lrarul 3uq€lnsur uE Sr4rasm Iq papro^e aq u€r sql
'uoqnlos SurDnpuor e ro rote,[ o] osoltrJI srEadd€oldnoa uorsoror e 'lf,eluol
IErlxrll! ur !r" laqr r"qr le,{ e q]ns ur paulo( ol? sleuor?ur odrl JI .nssr rua
reJJrpe sr r]I^I!s trllrrlE:rrr?rd tou op sassorordSurpla^ ,(u"ru :sl"u;rslu rur
regrp uee \raq sNrol^\oIE,!lE€u!8 s€rlo$ej puEs!^rslqpy st?rr4€ruWoq qrLll
elqrrEduor .q llsnol^qo rsnu ssatrord.rIJ a.t^Fs ur puE lrnrrE nuelu uI qroq
'esrr" suoaerlprsuor JJqunJ 'slelrol?ru r€llunssp u.aaDq sr $ro[ lqr ueqlN

srsse'mo, $pn'ur (Z 8I em'rC)xurerussaro".-r","rr"*;;$r:::'J:!1:


trgneds rnnbar u3{o slEl3urrgl]lds pue :sFFru Supta \ roJ rsoq! tuo{ raJJrp
sJ3lnqod Supte^{ rot spoqr.u :srrqro or lou rnq sl"uer€In euos or puoq r {
sa rsaqpv :atp sess€Fpu€ strruErer 's€rultod 'sFraln culmot rot sessa3ord
4L9p4wot loy4pw

sassatddoulrn])elnueur:tlsllodpue 4)!ts Teaq'teaH Bl )aldeq) VZI

Please purchase PDF Split-Merge on www.verypdf.com to remove this watermark.


l8 5 .loinrng andorigins
attributes 425
Plocesses:

,-, -::rv
U'
Buli
:cfic
bsses

Fible
'[!tur-
&fkr

&cts. F i g u re1 8 .1 3
!Fa
iDilar
@ (compressron,
Tension
+v
,+

sded- @
les oi
rof the
lesise
@W Bending
T IaPE.

lm ar€ {or
Figure 18.14 standardmodesof loading ioints
lE, but
requte ponable equrpment'
On-site joining operations conrlucted out of doors weldingof
rrils of *i r' p"it"ur" p"*"' *fpri'"' * '**pte iithr hot-plate ihdets
".""iiiri ne r;'pait* i'ortabilirv' means
on theotherhand'.effectivetv
ksa- iv"6lia
t dick- nolimitonthesizeofthe"""Jiv-S;ag"''l'ipOurLdbgandaircrahmakethis
sel{-evident.
fEans_ tequirement for econornicdis-
An inqeasingly imponant consideration is the fas'
lotoins p'od""tiu" to t""ilit't" ""v'ling andreuserhreaded
i dlck ^"";ild;;?t'i
t"."., ft" aisa"*tifed and adhesives can be loosenedwith solventsor heat'
tsI In "i"
PhYsical li'nits i" ioi'|i'tg
for exarnpre -oper-
Therrnal ioining processes-arc, hser and {riction welding'
to the joint area to produce a bond in the
U i f.l*f thermaicvcle
F ins"- ',"p*i"i physicallimit to fhe slze
",e
]i.j Joria.i".". rr""t transferandconductionsetthe
ttd to ing heatsorr'cetol
oiioint- Hererhernren(rryof hearingis LnponanLFor ran\lat
F.*r ;:;:;'6;;;;; :i ';;;;l urone;' rointri* 'heherrinputperunrtrennr"
b.la(y-), ls'o'o'o"tv ""edasa characteristrc
weldins erramerrir:il-teTryl-
pEtar., Hear inpur is rhus importanrtrleteffntntna
.ooling t"tt" wirh Q/'
p reld- ":t".." ""i rigion the weld affectedbv the
ir'. i**-"n'ct'dlon'-the 'ound
tEnber "o."i "r,f"
Please purchase PDF Split-Merge on www.verypdf.com to remove this watermark.
slusule€rl a)e:|rns
pepr^ord
suotpunju6rs6p aqt € It alqel
^q

r?qr suoqtrunJJo,{llsr.rp aq1sal"lsnllr € 8I 3lq"I ruaurmrr eqr 6u ldd€


Jo lsodrnd lqr aq or sa,\ordalnquD€ trgnads-Suqsrug8uq€urujurslp rsoul eql
u.Qupa4 aql Jo asodr','da'!I
'srarullod roj ueqt sl"131uIoJ rueuodrur
.roru sr Surqsruger€Jrns'IFnor^ard parou sV Z8I smgrCur x r"ru rqr Jo
.!o||oq rqr rP usorl\ \r lrururErn r)Ptrn\ rol ftrlrqDed_uoa sJ]ordlEurrew
qllqgo4tuo) loualpw

puesalnqrrltre
surOuo (6urqsrur])
:sassolord a)e,]ns9'8 !
luauJtreorl

'8urplr,1\ru!3q uo rala pue I.s?l olr sess..ord.,\IsurluFler


-rd€r Jo atru€u.rrotredrtuouotr. rqr .lq?ua o1 p.sn lSar?Is ? 'rurqreu 8ururol
paadsqgq € qrr \ Iall€rpdurImr s?el" SuiroorlrnPord pu! dn-ras.ldDFurr?qr
Surgu"lJE ,{q srruouotr! .qr a,,lordur 01 dlaq u€r uSlsapuoD?ls]ro^{ e^!ua^ul
'uortur ruro{ lqr uI ssau{u?.I, Jo >ltrelio luaruu8lleslttlPron" or PaeuJleslt
rurol aqr .)ptu or urqr dn l.s or roSuol qtrnru al?r sosserordiu?Lu pliv 1nd
-qgnorqr aqr Bur {ols tne8€ 'pEol !{€r uer laqr .rol3q s.unr 3uuntr p.Suolord
annbarsa rsaqp€auos p!^oru puEp3tpueqaq ulr 1reloleqruluoduor .qr lo
8uqootrur pu" rurot aqr SrrDI"ruuI qroq l.,!{od lo l!^.1sa^rB E qr^{ prads 8ulr€
'iado aqr sura^og r"eq Jo uolrrnpuor 's.ssarord leurr.qr roC rurot .qr 8ln)i€tu
ror elnsr€np€rqr puElruu dn-ras.qr.(qpar€f:ffiHff;:i:.":Jl:"$,"
-ord Felqns aqr uo qooqpueq jpoorsrapunIIa,!{,.!\ourrE pu" qrdrp ur pnlrrE.s.I
uaeq e^"q €tnple r Sulmp s3BuEqrl?rnr-rnlrso.Ijrlu '.ruEuodun n!$ lo lsnlrrg
'sasse$ Fnprsarl?uraru rnPur qrltr Pru€qr Prot puv 8tnpt..\,{q Psurol
,tFoluriror ei" qrrq \ 'qaars ur l[I€r]3ds3----ersrStrrloo" aqr pu" arnrpraduer
lerd aq1uo puadappatrnpmsasupqtrlErnrrnlsolr[u 3qI Fsodrnr al]jtr i€urraqr

sass,otd ouunDelnuew:qsllodpue )tlts'leaq']eaH BL)atdetlJ gzl

Please purchase PDF Split-Merge on www.verypdf.com to remove this watermark.


i 8 7 Estrr.;iinqcost{or shaprnoprocesses 427

hiE* surface treatments can p.ovide. Someprorect, some enhanceper{ormance, still


Lrd. others are primarily aesthetic.All surfacetreatmentsadd cost but the addedvalue
ks. can be large. Protecting a component sur{aceextendsproduct life and hcreases
FE-5 the interval betweenmaintenancerycles. Coatings on curing tools enablefaster
cutting speedsand greater produaivity. And surface hardening processesma]
tsFr.' €nablethe srbstate alloy to be replacedwith a cheapermaterial-for example,
bE. tsing a piain carbon steel with a hard carburized sudace or a coatins of hard
fqa- titaniumnitride (TiN), insteadof usinga moreexpensive alloy steel.
F-s Secondaryconqatibilities
5F Material comparibilir./and designfunctionarethe 6rst considerations in select
boen ing a finishingprocess.But thereafe othe$. Somesurfacetreatmentsleavethe
L r.-, dimensions,precisionand roughnessof the surfaceuchanged. Depositedcoatings
Hd-- obviouslychangethe dimensionsa linle, but may still leavea perlectlysmooth
li-u surface.Othersbuild up a relativelythick layerwith a rough surface,requiring
lryEi rennishing. Component geometry also inJluencesthe choice. 'Line-o{-sig}rC
fcae. depositionprocesses coat only the sur{aceat which they are directed,leaving
inaccessible areasuncoated;others,with what is calledthrowing power', coat
a flat, curvedand re-entrantsurfacesequallywell. Many surface-treatmentprocesses
a requireheat.Thesecan only be usedon materialsthat can toleratethe rise in
ft,: temperature.Somepaints are appliedcold, but many requirea bake at up ro
150'C. Heat treatrnentslike carburizingor nitriding to give a hard suriace
i layer require prolongedheating at temperaturesup to 800"C. This thermrl
exposure o{ the substratecan changethe underlying microstructure, not neces-
id',.c
sarily Ior the better.Thereare someinnovativedevelopmentsto matchthe thermal
treatmentsrequiredin both substrateand surface,achieving*vo treatmentsrn
I one go. An exampleis the paint-bakecyclefor heat-treatable aluninum alloy
automotivepanels,whichcuresand hardensthe paint while simultaneously ase
Fe oi hardeningthe sheetitself.
Physicdl hrnits to surface treatneflk
t For thermalprocesses, the surfaceheatingintensityand absorptivity,and the
thermalpropertiesof the substrate,dictatethe rise time in temperature.For .
stationaryheat sourceof given power density,the temperaturerises$ith the
square root of time Jt. This in turn determinesthe depth of surfacelayer thar
reachesthe temperatureat which the desiredmicrostructural changetakes place.
Sincediflusionof matter and heat{ollow the samemathematicalequations,the
depth of treatmentin diffusion processessuch as carburizinghas the same
dependence on time. For a spmy-coatingprocessdeliveringa givenvolumeftic
flow rate, the coating thickness incrases linearly with time.

co)t Iorshap;rgprocesses
| t'. / L5t,mating
Estimating process costs accurately-at the precision needed for competitive
contract bidding, for example-is a specializedjob. It is commonly based on

Please purchase PDF Split-Merge on www.verypdf.com to remove this watermark.


t:i:a:,:,ii

tapou.rLso)€ql ur s.!unouPluorlrrrljspSroqLUIs t 8t alqPl

pedrunl pu? peeqra^o eqr Jo u?d s? parslJ] sL{ ?nsn aroul rnq '! $ullul lSraua
lJ" sr 1rJr dars ssetrorde Nupg? pe3retltrsa1lrlFurossr qcq \ t{Br.u. sannbar
rI srsotrru€ld l"raueSPul uorl?rrslurupe'roqq rsot aqr ePnltrurra qrq {
ur '(Wg Jo srrun qrr { snqr) 'lo, arPl peltlr.^o u" re
'o alq€a8l€qr 'at&r?sarrnbai rI
'p!snaq L,!\suroor.q1WIql L 'l 'J 'sa'udlrra PId"r lqr Io l€q1Pu€'($)
rO
'SrrooJ par"rlPlp Jo 1sotraqr se^lo^ul 1I ep"tu sI r qrlqA{ tuo4 $po1s-Paej
elqErunsuotrpu" slerroreu oql Jo ($v$) uj| rsotr aqr ql?rtle t ss?lu Jo luouod
-tuor r SuDnPordJo rsor aql '{snql 8I elqel m PaugaPar€ daql s.unsuotr 1I
sarrno$r eIIr lo asoqrJo Lunsaql si rsor
' Fus aql rsotrParEl3osse uE sEtIquqa
to qrE! '(sI 8I ernSrc)slrrnosar saunsuof, luruodwor € to ernpElnu"ur .q.L
IaPoat $ox o.ll
'ssaxotdq.ee lo saltql4{J
papp*tsc, tol sonF^ s" II3^{ se 's$otr roqEl le.ol se qrns \ladu Paleads
-las, ur?u.r ssrnb.r r[ ssatord Suld?qsqtrr"q E Jo rE(p :s.roq. uoruttlo] lsoln
lqr to auo roJ IsPou lsor $r t Poqrllu oqr ar"rlsnlll 3a .slr.rdlut uaq { ua^a
"
p'.sn aq uEr sql s.lnol sserord e l]?urelle jo slsor lrPtgrxordde aredulotr or
rr :rcodrnd.rqrroj lsorSuuEurusr ur rou\r rrJl r\rrrrurino prler! {lrtEud
-orddp\qol 'nor\ d :Plun\ roJsFor usoul lo uonPlodPiarro uorlElodrrlot

'sss)o]d
6ur.rnpelnuelu ar"tl sl Sl arn6!l
e ol srndut

sessa)dd5uunDelnuea :qelod pue >pl)t'leag leeH 8t roldPqf 8zt

Please purchase PDF Split-Merge on www.verypdf.com to remove this watermark.


- 3 , Esi,iiatingcos1for shapng processes 429

into C.u,as we shatldo here.Finally,rheleis the cost of information,meaning


that o{ researchand development,royalty or license{ees;this, too' we view as
a costper unit time and lump it into the overhead
Considernow rhe rnanufaaureof a component(the 'unit of output') weigh'
ing fl kg, and madeof a materialcostingC- $/kg The tust contributionto the
unit cost is that of the material zrC-. Processesrarely use exactlv the right
amount of materialbut generatea scrap{raction/, which endsup in runners,
risers,machiningswarf and reiects.Someis recycled,but the materialcost per
unit needsto be magniied by the factor 1/(1 - /) to accountfor the iraction
that is lost. Hencethe materialcontributionper untt ls:
(_r8.2)
,
"1 (1 J )

The cost C. of a setof tooling-dies, molds,ixtures and jigs-is what is called


a dedicated cosr one that must be wholty assignedto the production run of this
single€omponent.It is written off againsithe numericalsizet of the produc-
- Ir r s
Rd de tion run. However,toolingwearsout at a ratewhich dependsonthe numberof
itemsprocessed. We definerhe tool li{e 4 as the numberof units that a set of
JneJ roolingcan male belorerr I'.r' ro be replr.ed We hr\e ro u.e one rooling'et
eveni{ the productionrun is only oneuait. But eachtirnethe toolingis replaced
thereis a stepup ir the totalcostto be spreadoverthe whole batch.To capture
this with a smooth function, we multiply the cost of a tooling set q bv
a& of (1 + z/2.). Thus, the tooling costper unit takesthe form:

rable c, :9[r*ll (18.3)


E.q
rxed
5:.'' The .apnal cost of equipment, Ce, by cor'.trast, is rarely dedicated. A given
E-IT pieceof equipment-a powderpress,for example---<an be usedto makemanv
ig by installing different die-sets or tooling. It is usual to
-ct different components
FFec convert the capital cost ot non'detlicated eqtipment and the cost of bolrowing
the capital itself into an overhead by dividing it by a caqital urite'off tine, t.,,'
(5 years,say)overwhich itis to be recovered. The quantity CJtwois then a cost
per hour-provided the equipmentis usedcontinuouslnThat is rarelythe case,
so the term is modified by diid\ryitby a load fa.tol, I-the ftaction of time
for which the equipment is productive. This gives an efI€ctive hourly cost of
the equipment, like a rcntal charge, even though it is your own pieceof kit. The
capitalcontribution to the cost per unit is then this hourly cost dividedby the
production ratdhour ti at which units are produced:

(18.4)
'=;l#l
Please purchase PDF Split-Merge on www.verypdf.com to remove this watermark.
rot $qrrEq Jo !8u"r E-rzrs fpq tt'uouota uElo eaPreqr srsa88nssql azrs
rlrr€q rqr uo spuldaplsad?aqrsl 1?rl1ssatroidaqr r€qr su€ettlra^ossortraqJ
'9I 8I arnarJur s \oqs
sE (ssorr or s.^rnr Frl oq1sesn€rssarordr{3€aroj sror."l asaql11)Jo uolr
-€urqrqor!r[ I]DsraqSnl.r? 3D4sereP einsserdqCq rot asoqrl5uqs"trPu"s
roJ uEqr rasrrB 3re SuDs?ratP ornssard-^{olroJ srsor Plow lars"J qrnu osF
sr rnq rrou rlrmu srsor ruaud ba Suirs?tr-ero ]'!\ols rnq deaqr sr ruarlldmba
SurrsEr'pu?S?l.rrr uoDrpord pu? r, lsor ruaudrnb 'rl rsor Surtootul rejjlp
sass.rordSrnFdruo:) sP?.qDnor.q1o Pu€ roqq l€Iral"In jo srsotr,alq"rl"^,
rqr ,{q p.r?uruiop sr t€ql .nF^ ? r? rno suarr?Urr lrun (?lu"qr rerEerg$ r"qr e,]l
E ssq Surrool,ql reqr rosjnotrto {PaPrord) s €, rsor rrun aqr or sqr Jo uoDnq
rluor lqr 's.searJqr ezlsqr1"q aq1sv ((9 8I) uoq"nba to rqftr eqr uo turar
puoroseqr)Suqoorlo slsoi,Paxulrql lq Par"unnoPsrrsotrrrun aqr sezsqrr"q
ll€urslY Sullser.rnss.rd-aol Pue 3uos"r aP '8uDs?trpu€s :sasseroida^n?u
rerl" lrrqr dq ruouodruoJ lunululnle lFl:rs € BassEtrJo rsor aqr Sulj"dtuor ',
razrsqrr"q rslnE8"
's, 'rsor to lotd € sr lI (9 8I) uos€nbasasn9t 8I a.ln8tJ
:asn aql lq PeugaPaq rsnu o\ alnq JJoaru. r l"rrd"tr
rqr pu? 7 rolf,q Peol aqr 'Ilb el"r PEaqre^oaqr r, 3zlsqrr€q F€rEr :ssacordqr€e
ro] .3u€r o^t1?luasorda.r ? Iq paugapaq 1)u€r srEr uorpnpord aql pu" Uo errr {
I?rrdErJo .rer dlrnoq a,tlr.ejJooq1'1sotrper"rrpep aql (ryI) al"r noqrnpord alp
Jo l?rordl].r .qr se s.rre,\reql uoornPord Jo rrunrad P"aqra o ssot€E Pu"r(r/I)
rumlo^ uoDrnpord .rlr Jo Ierordlror .q1 s€ sau?^r€qr uogtrnPo.rdJo rrun jed rsotr
pors p.p ? '.r"r Pu? a4s q)leq Jo luePuedaPusI r€qr uoqtrnPordJo rlun rad rsotr
Ilu.rElu e-suopnqtrluor F4uasseaaiqr s"q rsor 3qr r?qr s^{oqsuos"nba srql

lL'Br) * * F**c : ")


--$5
:uarrrr \ eq u?tr rr 'uolrpnba srqr lo uuoJ 3ldrursrqr rzrseqdur. oJ

(98 r) ') )r u,| \


['"t
:urro, aqr cuDl€l
!t)-r, rsuuer noj asaqt uins aqr sr rod Surd"qs
Jo '"J 'ued rsor l€ror eql

( 98 r) 5-
:rnoqreoslrun4 a1?ruoDcnporo
lqr lq 8uryr^p dq rrun r.d $or e or para uotrurc8?sr srql uo os pue lSraua
.rb apt praqhno lqnoq punorSp"q
'roqel rot lprauogaq1sr ar.ql 'lfleurC

sass d oultnpelnueur:qstpdpue 4)!]s Teag ?paH B! raldeq) 0€t

Please purchase PDF Split-Merge on www.verypdf.com to remove this watermark.


431
:: ; ::: n;ILngcostforshapng processes

hbot 104
ts.
P 10'
E
3 ro,
F8-i r
614

i.c.. ,:
6
0 .f.i
Numberol componenG
F8-6
processes
bv th reecompeting
component
a smallalumlnum
Figure 18.16 Thecostofcasting

T s4d ms'ha I
I D 'e.6srnq
FE.: FI l*sLient cas,hoI
E' I LowP€$u€.5ensl
!g I Fo'sinql
Erlruson!
3l
I
she6r tormhq rffi\
-da-t "-r'l Eredm_machnrns
\isJ sparkI
EEll
; q lTl co"6nri.narmachni"q
Inr{nonmod'ng
-n
I Bl@moldi^a
b q I comp'ssionmodins
qil Fobron€ mordina
Hl
F+ | rh€mo-io,mns
I Polymercaims
o rl ns
B€s'niransbrmold
; st' m€ihods
Etrl Lav-up
55 | vacuumbao
--fcr rot ro+ rot
[
Economicbalchsrza(unrts)
. netat @ceartlc . patnet t camposite

colorcodedbv
processe!
batchsizebarchadfor shapinq
Fiqure 18.17 Thepfocels-economic
material.

islikelvto bethemostcompeli'n"tff"['Jr[n::*:;
whicheachprocess
:li;::.:'j:?::*:,',',",'$:?
d!,,**j:t#i#Xid::J,t
".,,
an alternativeway of ranking Figure18 17
;#"'J;;;,i"';J color coding as the earrier charts'
""iig '[' ",''

Please purchase PDF Split-Merge on www.verypdf.com to remove this watermark.


'ratua)aqr ur u^\oqs3axoq6ote:pq6norql paraluaaq osteue) slueurarrnb3r
u6rsapta6rer'arpMrlos53) aql ut slreqtrr€q
serq6uaq}o1,{tterrqdpr6pEDotd
's3lnqDup)uallrnuuo uoaDsuaq} jadeqspue Leualeur sPq)nssassPP
lu'' leH l6utdeqsroj araq)s$rord6utrratas ursdalt6utuaar)s ^lt)ads 8t 8L sin6rl
oql,o )tleLlraq)S

H'

eqr srtlutlrlqr e8els€ st ryalaql uO 81 8I ernBIClq pers!38nslsoqr 3TI s!3e1s


pasodruuadns Suraolle 'uootralaslErrar"urrol pasn$ rpqr eurBu!qrr€rs alues
rqr ,{q p4sSorJar ore aql ssacord3qr rnoqE uolrpurro}ulJo s.rrnos
or seru.r.ler puE sa8euli"1"p
'rxar Io Inrot lqr uI uoq€ruruntrop prrut suleluol
osF q ssa.o.rdr?r 1rsFrrat€tuaqrroJ spror.r aqr or polurt sr pu€ 's.nF^ I?nsn
srr Suruuedsa8u€r ? s? parors atnqrrrle qr". qrl^'| 'sslrord Iol er"p rFqull€
surEruor pro..r qrEI Z rald€q) Jo Z Z S Z sarnSICut u^{oqs " srrqlu3ru pue
sess€p .s3qrue' .ql orul pazlu€8jo 'sassarordroJ sprotrarsul€ruotr.sEq€r€psrl
'poqFtu eqr Jo uoq€rueualdufl Sg:)
eqr trrarsore^o ere suralqordas"ql V sraFuer€d paugeprasnrol pa.u.qtIo
rsn"r.q,(e,u lnlasn ur paruasard eq rouuErI.poursor lqr pus'rluosrlquntr sr
uraqt sreru " ra^€ €
ssatrojd 3uq]rqr----orE dllEnsn .r.rlr s?-duelll ,r?
[! r€qr
3rrrl ueq^\ lnq 's1ur€4suotrr{aj arp ar.qr ueq,t{ lerrpEld sr Lulqr Sursnuoorol.s
'p!rru{ $ LuaqrJo auo tru€uo u toqs aq u€r r"qr $sserordlo rrqunu eqr rnq
a\ar^rr^o u? .^rB redeqr sqr Jo sr€rp ss"rord aqr 'suEqtr l€uar"ru eqr qrl^\ sy
uoarap s p r ar' 4ruoJ
"?'p
uorpalas paprP-relnou.ro)
ssaloro 8'8 L
'e^nurdxasl 3uloo1 aq1]nq 1s€Jare ,taq1:sroru
-,{lod Io Sulplottl uosralul aqr puE sllrrur Jo Sunse rp 3ql Jo .fir sl asranar
eqt auo a8.wl ? tu?^\ nod uaq.u rou rnq sruauodruor Jo llqlunu IIErusE !{Eur
or lu?a nol uoq^\ trurouora ar€ leqr :^1ols.rE rnq srsor Suqoor .1,!ol!^er{ s.rr
-soduor rol spoqlallldn-l€l puEsl€retutoBuqslr rur(ulsa^ulspqrns sass.3ord

sassa)dd5uunDelnueu :qstlodpue ]l.')es']eeq?eeB 8l raldpqf Z€t


i
I PDF Split-Merge on www.verypdf.com to remove this watermark.
Please purchase
i 8 8 LomputeFaldedprocessseiectlon 433

cld* or mem-
orocess choi.ero rhoseablero handlea .h'*en mrterialfamil)'
F i.. ,i... ir,.,..tt,.*'r. ln the cenreri' J 'rmple querl inleriacetor reen-
q'
FE or rower lrmrrs ror
,F ins on one or.or. pro..* adribure':the detireduPpef
.,re enteredand rhe 'earch ensineretecr' a{r proce+e'
:;il;:i;;;;";til;.:
F
! $irh arrriburevalues rhat do nor lie tithrn rhe limi'' On the nqhr r\ a Dar
I .[.i- bv rhe'okware.tor anl numericadriburelhere'e'onomrc
;:i;,;;;.-^,-*.a i;;..;;;;g., .erecrionbo:. i"upenmpo*d on.rhebar 'han
i' !ilue\ ol the rnrrDure'
riLh upoerand loweredge'rharlie iL rhecon'lt'ined
I wirh rharpenerraLe rhe bo:" retecrine tho*
ir.l' t,...G "aluet
'iii"-,i.
outsideit.
"'ir.'" lie
that A
the batch-processcost model describedin the text
l!
..i*r*"i.4'a*
pa'meter' L'
tsd_ d.i;;;;;,il";; ,'.r ro edirdeiaurrvarue'or rheu'er detued
l-- ;."."4:. .;:. i h;
'i. rhen rer.e'e' approximarevaruesror rhe economit
';;*,re ba'i whererherare'rored a' "anee'rt
Fsr J.1,.*-llirt,,i' i, c, t rromrhedara
u. in I nurnber of tal' tuoofwhichare'hotntn
G Iir.*',i.d,"
tieurerl8.lq and l8.20
'.
nro.essrhere.inie.rionmoldingr.
The
";.enred 6rsr i' a plot of co*t.agaLn+ b"(:I *'':i
i.tTql:
in rhemdnneror ffe errrrerrrgurerd ro r rrr
h*
F^
[.;;;fi";;;,;;;.,''
;{,h.;:;k. amrbure":
,re li'id on ir. r]e bandwidrhderive' rrom rhe range'
a 'rmple'hape'requrring onlv 'impledre('lie' neir
liet nerr rneupper
rheloweredeera more"omplu one.requinngmuli-Pafl dre<-'
r't;tgeor co*r rcr
feI*' edee.!rsure-|8.20 shou' an alrernrrirepre'enrationHerethe
a componenr bl a number or alrer-
F: #ii";'"*.;.;;*"h 'te rhere.r0ooiiror u'er-defled p:rarnerenare agatn
tq ot.".d a' I bar chan The
",i'"-'-..t*' rhj' one ral in,Iisure
FF3 i'.,.a. 6*.' ..r..,11,' 'rage' can be appliedin parrllellvirh
"
marenal.'hape'etc'cau'ing'omeol LneDafiro
Flhe l8.l8r appl)ingcon.urinrson
drop ori. Tie iffe.' i' rank the 'urvit ing processe'bv cosr'
! 'o
I
.1.
+-
tl
106

b 1oo
i. I
6
E 8
.9 10'

br
t
6

10
I
t
l-
ls show'nq
Fioure 18.19 Theoutput of the costmodelasimplementedin the CEssoftware'
F lo* , nit .ost .tt"nqet *ith batchsize The range the rangesin th€
15'9' 'eflects
inout oarameters to the mooel
F

Please purchase PDF Split-Merge on www.verypdf.com to remove this watermark.


$ azls q'r€q Pelalord aTt-srequrnu a3r"l ur .Peu .rE sSnld {reds rlsrtrg
erelms Pu" uorsberd uo slnIIIr 8u4tas !3urs?trslr uqlra l"as rsnu rorslnsur eql
I 'pag:rlttaPrssaqsrqr uoqtrasumururu aqr Pu€ patelllosa .q u?r ss€tupaF.dx.
I a$ 'suo$uelnp prj€ l€rrar"Ill eqr ua^rC suorsuaurp srr Sulrg r,qqilrasseu€ Jo
u€d sr rol€lnsu aql ad€qs C-€ trrrauru slxe u" ui .elntunl? .rrtu?rll
I ^\olorl
I aPEureq ot sr sql ror"Fsn aqr sr qrq r to auo ,sluouodluor Jo llqusssp
"u"JosI 'IZ
l rI 8l arnAICul(n?tpeueqrs u,roqs sl Snld Ireds e Jo ,(1uo19uE aql
t .tolnpsut Sttlil Voils ?!Luen) D Sutdptls
s 'uoq€rulumroP suDJeesIq Pessa.:PP" aq u€r qtrqr{
l rl[ouo]a
Jo fle----€uoDelrulrl ro 'serrredord FuarEu ro 'sltrajaP ar€Jarasaql
ol
'p.lou .re 8ulu.or:)s oldurs Jo odors eqr Plrolrq Surssaoordto srtrads€'asel
qr". uI I3rElrB qrmu sr lrs \Tos rqt ur FraP to la^al eqr s€ereqr{tsassarojd3ur
I -qsltrgpuESururolJosrssElrpeorq aqr,(Iuo
esn3 { r$qr rog 'sasserordrueuq"er ar€lrns pu€^{oqs
suEqr aql lor?^\gosSgC .q1
Slnmot8u!r{as Jo sal&uex. lq
i P3^{olloJ3re ssaql $rqr aqrjo rsq aqr or Psrrdd?lePoru lsor aql qt {'r.td€ql

t sqr lo susqr rqr Sursn plqr?oJdd? 3r" srmtqold Surd€qs aaiql SuIuo.J]s
ro' s.$quDs ssrtrordJo rsrl r!8rer ? or sP?.I srueuennbar ucrsapaw Jo uooel

I
I
-su?Jl 'os€r qrs. uI .sn uI lSolopoqFru uoBr.lls lqr ,o saldur"xa a^"q e { eraH

sarpn$
osef 6.9 L

I
I

t,
-lspouaqtlo srsl3r!predlndursql urs6uer
aql sDotlerreq q)eo,o ezls€q]-eztsq)]eq us^|6€ ls lusuodluor parlPedse roJ
sassa)ord]o los e 4olsor uun 6utMoqssrpMuos5l) Eq+qlt,l tspeLUueq) req v 0z g! aln6tl
r
I
tD!l
90=roF€tpEo.l
$^ I = autr jo-olim Pudec
rr,09,l =.la pBa+3 o
6tL=*uuE d
000 01 = 4F qclE€

rl sEo@rsd p€uu€pjoBn

:.

setse)old6uln7)elnuew :qslpd pue 4)tts'teaq lpaH 8l loldpql tE


i
Please
I
purchase PDF Split-Merge on www.verypdf.com to remove this watermark.
18.9casestudies435

Figure 18.21 A sectionthrough a sparkplug.The insulatork cylindri.albut not prismatic,


makingil3-D hollowin the shapeclassification.

Table 18.5 Tranrlation a sparkpluginsulator


{orshaping andpotentialprocess'sensitive
defects

100000. Table 18.5 lists the constraints.The lower part of the table flagsup
key process-sensitiveoutcomes which cannot be checked by screening, but
should be investigated by a documentation search for the processesthat suc
cessfully passthe screeningsteps.
Part The constraints are plofted on the compatibllity matrices and bar charts of
dte Figures18.2-18.4, 18.11 and 18.12. The material compatibilitychan shows
only three processgroups for ceramics, and all three can handle the required
shape.A1l ttuee can cope with the massand the section thickness.All three can
also meet the quality constraints on roughnessand tolerance, althougl powder

Please purchase PDF Split-Merge on www.verypdf.com to remove this watermark.


'0000! Io ezlsqrrq r.bl"r E .Lunss?atN
(cu!]EdsuEr !^J's!rd ot pep.ru sr ssauqSnoror?Ins ao'I e.urr.lor poo8 ?
errnbrroslesslnrrg ,s.qf areld ur a^ealsaqr ploq ol sqetPuesaSuIIeql oFlu
or s.8p. rqr r? s3nr?e] ser{1nqlau?d1"u rou sr 1rse .c-€ rPlos, se Pagoods
sr sdEqslqJ scl Jo lzls prsPrePu?ls.qr "trq Fs er€ sseruPu?suorsurlurpaql
'as€rm lrlr roj uorrElsurn.qr saorls / 8I alq{ l!oruo.3 srql uI strEseldou
reqr ro' suoEdo Ssrss3rordrno Itr.qtr or qstr{ rqSnu .^'r lErrll"ur Jo .8u!qr e
Cuu.prsuotr.roJ.q rnq 'eulrhsllod $ .toq. Fljol?lu ru3rnr rrlf 8 € emSrCpue
€rerdeq:r
tlrparou
arr.lt\ aq1r.;;r:):*itrilT;:iili
sm rosrs"tr,raaot.

'3rEIuorFnpord pu€ qsrug{rrsorod


Surrloruor roj luExodruramleiedurarpup arnssardJoaltrdreql pu€'cuqlg arp
'hll€nb rop,rod 'u3rsrpep ur ar4reid poo8 sFrep qtrnasuorl€ruetllnropV
'srol?FsurSnldlftds el€ff 01Pasnssarordeq1PaePflsr SurPloruuorl
(slur"llsuor eqr
-r.lur r.paod 9 8I alqel ur Polsrr laattlleqr sPorporlrGP^\od
Jo s1u?1r?,\rgtrads o,\\t segquaPr(8 8Ia asrtrraxg)arerrrjos sgc aql Suisn sdars
rures:ql Surttddv erroqr paxalard aqr s" spoqreu rap^\od sagDuap'(/I 8I
omftC) azrsqrr€q Jlrlouotre uo ruplsuor aql rrurt r. \ot naql r"au er€ spoqFrn

I n6rj

)rurouo)!
lurerlsuo)
o' A' r Dn ^
"o n ( ' ' ^ r

slu!e4suo)le)!ulpej

rluler$uo)
€^!Palqo
uolpunl
slr3]EpE^rllsuoessErord pueose)o) € 6urdsqs
tPllualod ro] uorlPtsuPrr13!alqel

6utPlouruolralur rapMod
6ulralutspus 6utssadrapMod

roletnsur
6ntdtredsP 6urdeqs
Fl ro+sassarord
rtolstfuo'ls 9 Bt alqPl

sats,ard dulnDe|nuew :Llstpd pue 4rts']eaq ?paH 8, r3]deql g€t

Please purchase PDF Split-Merge on www.verypdf.com to remove this watermark.


189 casestudes 437

I
I Table 18.8 Shortl;stof processes
{or
a polymercD case
I shaping

I
II
2gxo.25

-w 410,25

a18.0+ 0-O2

rod.Theprecision
Figure 18.22 A steelconnecting requiredfor the boresandborefacingis
muchhigherthan{orthe restofthe bodv,requifingsubsequentmachining

Refer again to the compatibility matrices and bar charts. Screeningon the
materiallthermoplastic),shape,massand minimum sectionleadsto threepos-
FI€ sible processes: machining, injection molding and compression molding.
Compression molding is itlst beyondits normal massmnge.All threeProcesses
cof meet the targets for tolerance and roughness.The final bar chart shows that
lF- rnachining is not economic for tle given batch size, but the other two are
acceptable. Table18.8 summarizes the survivingprocesses.
{ltr. Good die design to include the protruding ridges and tabs on a CD case
hs requiresexpert input. Thesere-entrantfeaturesexcludecompressionmolding
using uniaxial loading and open dies. Following up the avoidance o{ defects,a
i documentation search is principally a matter of good die design with correct
location of the runners and risers.
l.r.i
iriog Shapi.ngd steel connzcting rod
F-- Figue 18.22 shows a schematic connecamgmd ('con-rod') to be made of a
E-€- medium carbon steel.The minimum sectionis around 8 mm, and an estimateo{
F Is the volume glvesa massaround 0.35kg. Dimensional precision is important to
ensureclearancesat both the tittle and the big end. The con-rod carries cvclic
l-. loadswith the consequentrisk of fatigue crack initiation, so a low suJ{acerough-
h'-"- nessoverall is necessary(the bores will be fnished by a subsequentmachidttg
I operation). A modest barch size of 10000 is required. Control of properties

Please purchase PDF Split-Merge on www.verypdf.com to remove this watermark.


Iq Suqs g 1nq suolqord euos tueserd lr?nrr? puE rlslug lrElms por 8tn
-Fauuor lo adPqsPu€ az$ eSuer-PruprePuels aqt q slueuoduotr I331suoqr?l
"
Jo ajn1]"lnu"Ill aq1roj uorlDadruor asolr sr a-Iaql1eq1slee^r,{pnrs esErsrql
'sezu"urums 0I8I alqel 0000I Jo azlsqtr1eqe ro].Iurouor. rou
or? Suqs€r eurrsanulpu? (pllos 1uo{) 3uruqr?ur--nlq4ms .Ie sporplru rlp rod
pu? SurAjoJ]?{r s$a83nsrreqr azrsrp?q rllaouotra aqr <llleurC tulqr SulPunor
-rns s.rq .qr pue s.roq .qr SurlsJrrgrol ,wudordd? rsou sr Btnurq3eluuolsl]ard
-Pagr.ods .€ql sseuq&torPu? ,rueDlor resaq o € II SI rjn8rC Jo uiolroq elp
r? sassatrordSrnqslrg aqrJo IV Paqr€.r aq uer ru.luonnbr lru"ralor aqt 'sssrord
Surqsug qlrrr ssetrordSurd"qsaql Suraollol ,tq 'ra^a-/t\oHseroqltlr roJ p.nnbar
"
r€qr 1ou q8noql reruaalol3r"Jms Pue 'ssauq8nojtaft?r .qr a4erqrEIIv wEluar
sPoqlolll$P^rod PueSurSroJ'SBurqreur FuoDu. uor 'BlnrsEtrru!u4s3^ul rurclls
-uor sruer.lor .q1 dq pogrtenbsrpsr SurrsErpuPS .^I,lns suoqdoto ltuald rnq €ur
-urroJr.rqs Pue uorsnnxr 'SurrsEr.rp €urrsEr .Dssard-^\ol set€ultlqa adeqsPu€
,!l IErJrrru uo SurureDs surqr Pu" srrrl?ru IIr uo Pal]qd rr" stq€rmtrrryns

6 8I .lqel ernlreJ rnSrrEJPro or P..u aqr Iq p.r"uluroP sr sr$leP lo pu€


"

por buritrauuortaalse 6urdeqsrot sassarord


jo 15rt,uor.lsOt SL alqef

PuPssts)ord 6urdeqslo tsroq) . etqetre^aerj


r|rliouo)],.
]urP.rlsuor 00001:azrsr.l)le8 .
I udc-:sseuu6nox.
slulejNud)/qlenb .{ (sercq)ururz0'0> :a)uPr€lol .
I (a)e$st LUr1.1(7:6>:e)Uer€ror.

|eI a^lrrsuas
ssa)ord pu! porou,pauuorlaaF b"'d"q,,.j
re,1ua1od etq€l
" ".D?;",]"",i 6.gt

sassaud Eu'.tnflelnueur :tlstlodpue \tts leag leaH 8i jaldpql g€l'

Please purchase PDF Split-Merge on www.verypdf.com to remove this watermark.


es 439
189 CasestLrd

modelinputdsiai.' :'..e shapins


Table18.1'l Processcost con-rod
makethe
methodsto
D i e casti ng

I
lo0
5
0.5
17500
50 000
50
* Costsnormali2edto mC,,/(1 f).

E 103 . Die
\.zcasling ' Powder

E ro,

810

E -
;;;;";
l] = 10000
102 103 104
$le 18.9 Numberoi @mponenis

Figure1B-23 Thecostmodel{orthree possibleoro.essesto manufaciLrre


the steelcon-rod
(onstantvaluesfor the modelparan]eters.
usingrepfesentative Forthe targ€t
batchsizeoJ 10000,the (heap€st
option indi(ai€di5{orging.
tu€rhods

machining is not difficult for carbon steel.The final choic€will be deternined by


'fnishing detailed cost considerations and achieving the requir€d fatigue strengd. The
tci6€d- properties wiI be sensitive to the composition of the steel and its heat treat
hcB sur ment-something illustrated further in the next chapter.
li€ and Cost is consideredturther by applying the model of Section18.7 Table
lfng are 18.11 lists valuesfor the parametersin the cost model {or threeprocesses: die
casting, forging and powder methods. Assuming the same amount of material
is used in each process,the costs are all normalized to the material cost Figure
18.23showsthe computedrclativecostpet part againstbatchsizefor the three
&ing b"

Please purchase PDF Split-Merge on www.verypdf.com to remove this watermark.


lou op .rnrEr.dur$ SrnrBrr.loPrr" mu€tsrser rar€l( ssld eor s.ss.rord0I ,iluo
-SuEEururursrprsou rqr uaql srr?rq pnpuor or ruauarrnbrrrqf srssrrord0Z
or rq rq1 srrnPr ssJtDltrrql uootr:sPur SupEolJo aPo( {rreuoa8 1uioluo 8ur
-rrrrr.sr.qrnc sossoordrgljads-JauIlodI ar€Pa1"urrurle asoql-laaN
uoqr€r-aol SururolroJ rlqellns oq ()1PUno,"dltrur]d
are srssr)ordzt '!$ru l.rq. ,orrrqr
r"duor lErr.r"ru rqr 8ur.{lddv s.ssr.ord SururolZSrol s.rnqlIuE pu€ sprotr.r
s.rors rI :orDPs SurrreurBug.8Prrqur":) .ql esn .a uorFelas srqr .Hrer ol
'uo rP,\uP-r Jl' \)ir. errtun\zt 8t rt!Pl uo.,flJ.'un.1uP3u'tJJ. {q PJtrrLt'Jq
uPtrsqr rnq-slurlqold ruaurPrrrque ro 8rqr"]i) SunnErss$ord BuPIr,\\duE
lo Isu ! $ .rerP rsqr dt.lrrun sr rr os '!;tq€Pla\ llrP€or rr" str.ls uoqr"r-ao-I
rlnrgJP srurotru.."tp€ lo cln-iu JIeu l|r\ ss3r1slenP$arPu" uoDlorsP rncl
'ara^asrou arEsrurelsuor irtFnb l.rrs sr Bmql olorlA rqr J]un 'qrr Jo pur rqr
lE 3urp,{rarro} palqur.ssEsrp eq or srurolrqr.roj prru ou sr areqf lo00l or dn
sarnl€r3dur.rar?r3loror 3lq" PuerqSDr4EA3q 'rEaqrrnPuor rsmu,{eqI rEaqs
pu" uorsuarasodu.rr,{Eru uoD€tl€rsulSu nP SuqPu"qrnq etrr^ras ui spPot.\ol
lJUolrEr sruioldpt rql (tmut I ss.u)pqr Jo r.rrts IaarsuoqrEr '..r3q)IErr
erEru.qr qr.^\ elqrledruoraq rsnlu ss$ord iqr '!slEAI€sY sraeqs ^rot
lqr uaa^lraq
suEeslql roJ ss..ord SumrolE rsooq. or $ lser erll la.ls r.rqs Plssrrd Per€8
nrror ruoq rPErurorlrpEr rlrs.luoP e qSrlollr uoir.rs s^\oqs 8I rrnSrc
"
.tolowpt 'z D Suttltol
Pa$
'sorurdord.lqE^rrqr! rqr lo
uoDESEs.^ur IoJ rsrTrql uo urEnrrrqroq-ruergruSrsrou sr SuDsErrrp put 8ur
-BroJurrar.q e:)ur.rrDrp rsor rqt '!Suurqreu{q praolloj .q or dlrlrr $ SurBroJ
puB '.(endmoqr m ll!ftllarun or enp)lsor pareuDssJo p"rrds E sr rr.qr rrrrrs
'1l€d rad uoonquluor praqra^oe8rel ar€ rsor l€rdrr q8rqpue o1€ruorrnp
"
-ord.rr.'!\olsaqr ,snerrq llledbuud 'e^rsuad).a arou sr .r.paod SuBserrrp lq
IFsop p.ao ol lsrdErqtr.q no sauo. srrrtuoj000 0I Jo ,zls qtrrEqaqrroC

sr'rof dE nq psuroi
.re 5folFaslsstspossr.].i r isaurop€ q6norqruo|]):sv ta 3, 4ttbtJ
aarLtlolt! rolPrper

i:

.i j ..e rc d er,uni )e| ttueLu:tt< !todp.to \\).. tpc,.i toaH *w


Please purchase PDF Split-Merge on www.verypdf.com to remove this watermark.
18 9 Casestld es 441

{orjoin ng a steelradlatorandoutcome(potential
Table 18.12 Translation process
sensitive
defectsand properties
. Domesticradiator

d closely

Fr pari

€en forg- Table18.13 Shortlistof processes


forjoining a steelradiator

rry only
6lon and

tctiq at

diEicult.
changethe shortJist furthel The processespassingthe screeningstag€are listed
tthis can in Table18.13.
[slation. Quality and economic cdteria are difficult to apply as screening steps in
'It stores selectingjoining processes.At this point we seek documentation{or the
processes. This revealsthat explosiveweldingrequiresspecialfacilitiesand per-
mits (hardly a surprise).Electron beam and laserwelding require expensive
equipment, so use of a shared facility would be necessaryto make them eco
b lisr to nomic. Resistancespot welding is screenedout becauseit failed the require
rating- ment to be watertight. This is ody n€cessaryfor the edge seams,so internal
joint lines could be spot welded. This highlightsthe need for judgementin

Please purchase PDF Split-Merge on www.verypdf.com to remove this watermark.


'.lqrr^ $ 'r^Isuadx.,{ra^I ur a
'ru.rudmbo p4?.rprp areq \ sr srqJ rou s.op ,.hrauo.8 rl3ql'&e,\ soasraql alq r
pue <Jqreq <nouJrouru' rPPrurrP Q)PJlle€ <irui')srno) Jo lrltuouo1: Puv
'I$rs .rlr Jo uoDrsodulo3 eqr pu! ruou4?.r1 aql Jo .rnleredrual pu€ aunr aqr
:salqEue^ssrrord uo puadapralEJpaurpr"q aq1 qrdop oqr pue arqns aqr
Jo ssauprrq .qf sasso.ordasaqrrot uoDEru.Luniop 'o or ur.D a.{,\raqrrn] 1eBoI
'Suprrru pu" 'BulPuruoqr"3pus Surzrmqre.:o,\\rNrg
eqr rsnl sr^?alpoo8,Oa, aq rsnlll ac"ra^or rrqrns p.^rnr .r{r l€q1 rulerlsuor
requnt aqr Buppy 9I 8I alq"I m ue € $ 8uru.eDseqr ,^r^ns reqr sass.rord
Jo rst-rroqs aql qsruUaql esuorduor.slrll .sne.aq otreJJns,q1 urrojap ro
l?or reql .soq1 1nos)roq etr€trnsqroorus lr.^ e ro] luau.{nbor arll Sulsodurl
rq8rc or rsrl eqr Surrnpar--nru€rsrsar rEr^\ pue .n8!€t rr?drur ol-luouil?ar
aql lo asodmd .ql sr 3ull?urururslp arow sle.rs ,{olle rlll^\ ,lqlrdluoJ .r€
lupl l $ssarord rmrurean atrelrns tt rol spror.I sul?ruor tur$ls Sgl aql
'uorlEFu?Jl 3ql sozlr?lu
-IIJns,I 8I rlq€J ssauqroousatrErns aqr ro suorsmurplqr.srurordruor rou
rsnru ss.rord .rp os 'learrrrr sr ao"r pu€ sllpq qroq Jo uorsDard .rIJ .ruelslsor
en8q?Jpu" reo^{ roj sJralsdolJpuapr"q 33p}rns01 sossoJordI..s aro}eraql al(
'srlgEru 1r araq,\{ ssa preq aqr asEer]uror xuawlear aJ€Jmsae.r?das? {dd?
o] pu€ 's3ruadord lFq luallarxa s€qqrq$ Ilors ,{oI? u? .sn or sr uoonlos .rIJ
'ernl'E{ or rr?r aql .sn€r rq8ItII Suqpu"qsru ro SurpEol{ror{s rpqr {sIJ .qr Surr
-rntrul 'q3nor rou are 'r.^a^{oq 'sleuat"In prpH slerar"u prerl StnsnIq porrutl
eI" qrog !n8De',(q pu? r?e { dq pa{uq sr erpr II"q Elo eII eqr'II r3rd"qC ur
Fssnrsrp sy 1SZ 8I am8rC) $Itr€rr pe^oor8 ur unr s.r!r SuuEeqIIeq Jo slt€q .qI
are.t 8ul,araq1pq b Sunapnq nblrxs
Fl"
'rp.dd? 1€q1suopdo eqr Smroldxe 'SrIIIIII l"ruaunu
lsntp? pue 9o pu" uo stut?rrsuor timl ol st p*^uoj dea rstq aql idrualrgap
? tJorro. '.11s?t1l? qll,lr rurol papla \-tods aql Suleas .Il 'd.ls ssarojd puoras
E plnol au3$apej $apour qrla p4€poluuortrB oq pFor uoldo lsor-,t,!ol ? rEtll
os 'palrq Il {o.I.IeuSuqrauos s€H asrqr se,r lql( lpaleulunle u.oq uoDnlos
(Suosrxaro) snor^qo u" seq :{sE s,{e.'r[V 'sdars Suuaaitrs pal"uorn" Surdldd"

'uotrettlut on6trelpuerpoMtslsBr
)i)p.r) o1
pauapreq aql drpr6urJe.q eq ? q6norqluorl)osV EZ St
rq or r, a)prBqt a1p+rns arn6r l
'o

["t

6ulrnDelnueu :qstladpue \)!trs'teeq',eaH Bl )a$eV) ZW


sassa)o.,d

Please purchase PDF Split-Merge on www.verypdf.com to remove this watermark.


' :i j ! 5!ir r;r,,/anci.crr.lusron5443

for turfaceha
Table'18.14 Translaticn !!ar ng ra.eandpotentlalpro.est
sensrtive
ciefect5

Function . Ball'bearingrac€
Objective
Constraints . Material:alloysteel
. Functiono{ treatmentihardening
for {atigueand wear resistance
. Curv€dsurfacecov€rage:good Technicalconstraints
. Pr€cision and surfacefinishnol

. Choiceofsurfacetreatmentprocess
and proc€ss
op€ratingconditions

Defects . Cracks Influencingsurface


failed, so . Residualstress toughnessand {atigue
t Could a

of pro(esses
Table'18.15 sho!-1-llrt for hardenng
discussed an alloysteelbalira(e
. Both are Carburizingand carbonitriding
gn, tncur Nitriding
Inductionandflamehardening
Lasersurfacehardeningand melting
vapor metallizing
d tatigue

i.14 sum-

es.Many 18"'!05 r m m a ray n dco n clu slo fs


to erght. Selecting a processfollowsa strategymuchlike that lor materials:*ansktion oI
requirements,soeeningof the options, /drAi"g o{ the processes that survive
r.r-list of screening,ending with a seatchol documentation for the most promisnrg ca[di
dates.For processes, translationis straightforward the requirements convert
direcrlyinto the attributesofthe processto be usedin the screeningstep.Process
attributescapnre their technicalcapabilitiesand aspectsofproduct quality.All
processfamiliesrequirescreeningfor compatibilitywith materialto which they
are to be applied,but a{terthis the attdbrtes and constraintsare specificto the
family.For shaping,componentgeometry,precisionandfinisharemost discrim-
inating.For joininstoit is joint shapeand modeofloading. For surfacetreatments
Please purchase PDF Split-Merge on www.verypdf.com remove this watermark.
ir is the purposefor which the treatmentis applied(weaqcortosion,aesthelics,
ctc.). Rankins is basedon cost if this can be modeled,as it can for barch
("o47atasste.a4t aptr8 oj patu)tujs.jtu)o]
pttPrbls p Lt tafe)or4 8, lo slttlaQ) 6 6t769 c|rt-O Nf,sI )n ruopuol .plolrv
'aru)rln,pw aj u8tsae tu J .uoq.alas*..o1d lL65r) .a.I la]oog pua .O ) qbls

,oll,itqp!hl D),arara),lary/.s-20€-0l.L.s
0N8u.orn."o
sPr.w rlPloD€ur.rq rr'{sy b$a,o|.I "*-ljjl'#l
}o |ootp,,H (835t)
.C.O leorsst
( 8rse)a,|pbjb t uo $al p.sn"atp)uq,J
q.pid pu" a s'aqrtdtuo .6
rLsot).rl
0 NSSI YSn lbsr.f a.N rlollFJnpn uosr&d lteH.ruu.rd '!uoupJ q+ ,st,r/a7,lv
sLuaau6ur ta] sassDarJ 3run12r|,utrt\{ (€002) x.S ,pl-q.S puD ,ulrrlEdp]{
T
( slurular4ba1tuj,rapaql ojssa2 d
ary 8nq2lrtu'pao8 st jt araqng ,pas Ja 8uryt.h aqt :'sa.otl Bu,tuat p,q", a
]o
qra tpa slaapil-sutpratsitu si 4aoqt"]asfl s14jJoat?r at, .L 800 I NsSr
'in bjjpuqur:) 'lor?urqy 'sunJsqqndlorsurqy ,i ss,,orJ ./r,./t[ (066'ZSSS
r ) A ltor.ptnoH
l s,e)atJ suarb lo LJoloufal pup aruaDsttl'2tu'p"nl aII) .T 9t;9r
-909t 0 Nrr$ )n rtIoIO ,urEr!:ur.H quoarrnnq r,as,J (r6dr) .l lt.qduEtr
(sassDard 8Lt!a,"J"u'tu jfl.,qo uoljru)aJu1
,8tuprat pl8rnD
]o atlu tp't r 1nq x 6€L.0010-0 Nssr ysn .for aaN , rH
Aprtrl|uoupa puz ,looqpuoH r44tqprnpplflu'w hJ u8saA lg6!;r) .r.l ,ct!{€
( 4,t xapuu4q qF r\"uaqbrr.ju1tustma
1r auquo atqtt1r4, aar puti ,tatrp4, {. pLolsn)a .Bua'Dotd s4oaqpwq
.ysn ,HO 'a
Jo ps an$".qr/.luo yl :rR.I slsr.y,r lruoqe@rul \\Sy tstua;q.qtt
'9 t .unlo^ p u€ lta4srJ ,S| .unla^:.3u13toCput Suturot. Vt.u lo ts.ljJopufaL
t ay{ rapdad 'r .ul:]o|:Ruurnos p,o 8,!zp!s ,3a! all',9 .utto tB,uaatuB,t
Drlrt<'s aun'o\ r,aw,,{ ?,aH.n.urnto (n0oz-IL6,i salr,S4aoqp",H WSv
(ssbu q)@ uj ra4 aq Jo uoltdu.sapr!,utuk
b 8ut 3 raryus asp. DqtrkJ t|11tu1,pow '.s,..ot4
$a. pup IsotapaEatu uaq.ap' *..otd
atq lo 2rtnos aqJJ Z.B9r9 90sL-A Nf,Sr 'r rardPqt tn .proJxo .lneueuriH
-rFroAr.nns 'uourp. prg ,u36ae F.1Lt'eaw uj uo11.,t,sq,1-?rw (s002)r.r{ .rqqsy

fiujpFaJ.t;'-t].rftj
aa"'frL.
rPdaparou ur
ssoqtrEraFrdu.dord ss:.ord lo stradsesrroldxeraldrqr rxau rql .l.lJ"red ur
suolrEtrgrrads
ssrtrordpuelEu.rmr rrl ru5.r or paeulrp pu".s.sserord eror{l
Jo
IEuq:qrBuqrul ur a8ErsuoD"lurunrop 3qr jo etru"rrodrneqr stqgrl{l8qsql
Il"llp u&s.p pu€ uooNodurorl?u$Eru iqr .suourpuotrguDu3do ssoord .qr
uee-'vurq
Bu{dnor,^to^u JP.(sruouor. snqrpu") pradsssr.ordaqrsurururarap
pue'sJrrrrdordl"u,reluto uouergrpoluparnbr.qr 5ur^rqrE ttrejap
Jo a.u"
pro^Erql .ss3rord3uruaartrs etdu$ puotaq et rpqr Bu$slrord Jo sI.ds"
"
ru!]rodur ot srurod lpuanba{ sru.lu3rrnba., u8$ap aqr Jo uouelsuE{
.rrurouore aq or punoJIluouruotr si ssrrord aq] qrq^\ roJ
azrsqrreq,.qr jo uorrErrpurhEururrard p-lapotu rsor aqr or a tl€urarlEapml
€ s.pr^ord ezrsq,rsq rruouorr eql .azrsq.r?q Frnber pu" sjr"r p"aqrrno
sEqrns sr3leueredpegrtrads-Dsn r{rr \.31"] uoDrnpord.qr pu" stso.l€rrd"trput
&rtoor st qrns s.rnqurle ssoord rlrsuaD?r?qrrurqL"orqapo- rso3 .sassa:ora

\atse)a.t(i 54i|irta.in'- l)a :qe ca pu" r)tls 'lesq 7ea tll ta)tdt,n.) t yV

Please purchase PDF Split-Merge on www.verypdf.com to remove this watermark.

También podría gustarte