Documentos de Académico
Documentos de Profesional
Documentos de Cultura
duras was unknown and full of danger; the emperor would punish Olid. Such
were the arguments used. Cortes replied that unless prompt chastisement
was inflicted others would follow the example, and disorder must follow,
with loss to himself of respect and territory. The crown officials demanded
inthe emperor s name that he should remain. Oomara, Hist. Mex. 245. Corte"s
,
yielded, and wrote to the emperor that he had intended to march through,
Guatemala but would remain, especially since he expected news from Hon
duras within two months. Carta, Oct. 15, 1524 Afew days later he began his
march.
PERSONNEL OF THE ARMY. 539
3
something in the service of his Majesty. Prepara
tions were accordingly resumed under pretence that a
disaffection in the Goazacoalco region required his
personal attention.
7
Bernal Diaz names a number of the officers and staff servants, as Carranza,
mayordomo; lasso, maestresala, or chief butler; Salazar, chamberlain; Licen-
ciado Pero Lopeza, doctor, a vintner, a pantler, a butler, etc. ; 2 pages with
lances, 8 grooms, and 2 falconers ; 5 musicians, etc.
8
Bernal Diaz relieves his feelings in a loud grumble, which softens as he
recalls the consolation to his pride in being given for a time a petty command^,
Hist. Ve.rdud., 197.
y
Y aim hasta Nicaragua .... y hasta dode residia Pedrarias. Gomara,
Hint. Max., 250.
A GAY COMPANY. 541
10
See Cortes, Cartas, 337, 397.
11
The pueblos at the crossing-places are called respectively Tonalan and
Agualulco, written in different forms even by the same authority.
12
Cortes calls the province Qupilcon, 35 leagues from Espiritu Santo, a
figure which may be correct by the line of march. It was 20 leagues in length,
and its extreme eastern pueblo was Anaxuxuca.
542 MARCH OF CORTES TO HONDURAS.
13
Giiezalapa, or Quetzatlapan.
14
Zagoatau, Zagutan, etc.
15
Ocuniba was one of the pueblos discovered up the river.
CONQUERING AND TO CONQUER. 543
16
Spaniards were lost, beside a number of Indians.
After a week s rest at the ruined yet well-stocked
Tamacaztepec, they made another marshy journey
of three days before reaching Iztapan, a fine large
pueblo on the banks of the Usumacinta, burned and
deserted like the preceding. The Cihuatlatecs had,
it seems, in their wild scamper spread the most
19
The fate of the crew and vessels appears to have been mixed up with the
invented narrative of the general disaster, and it was not till after Cortes
return to Mexico, two years later, that inquiries were made which revealed
their fate. Bernal Diaz, Hist. Verdad., 196, 210. Albornoz, one of the rulers
appointed by Cortes over Mexico, relates in a letter to the emperor, dated
15 December, 1525, that according to reports from Xicalanco traders to Ordaz,
the party of Cortes had been killed seven to eight moons before, in an island
city, seven suns distant from Xicalanco, called Cuzamelco. They had been
surprised by night and slaughtered with sword and fire. A number of captives
had been reserved for the table, but the flesh being found bitter of taste it had
been cast into the lake. Icazbalceta, Col. Doc. i. 4S5-G.
,
DARK FORESTS AND MORASSES. 545
with three other pueblos beyond. Cartas, 412. Cortes gave presents in return,
and made so forcible an appeal in behalf of his creed, that many returned to
bum their idols. Gomara, Hist. Mex., 254. Bernal Diaz states that four foi>
He was one of three Flemish monks who formed the first special mission
of friars to New Spain, arriving a year before the famous twelve. Torquemada, -
31
The plan is said to have been imparted to sympathizers in Mexico, with
the recommendation to rise on a certain day against the colonists. Y dc
aqui creyeroii muchos que naci6 la fama do la muerte de Cortes. llcrrera, dec.
iii. lib. vii. cap. ix. For this uprising there was opportunity enough, says
Comara, during the anarchy prevalent during Cortes absence but the Indians
;
says Cort6s, had promised a province for his share of the spoil. Cartas, 420-1.
Bernal Diaz states that the revelation was made by two prominent caciques,.
THE KILLING OF THE KINGS. 553
were imitating the Spaniards in the festivities which precede Lent, but in such
a manner as to arouse the suspicion of Corte"s. One cause for the enjoyment
was a statement by Corte"s that here they would turn back to Mexico. The
general called his spy Costemexi, of Ixtapalapan or Mexicaltzinco, and bade
him ascertain what was going on. He soon returned to report that the three
kings and six courtiers had been engaged in a humorous dispute as to which
of the trio the now conquered provinces should belong to. Tlacatecatl, one
of the chief lords, thereupon observed that if discord had brought about the
fall of the native empire, they had gained instead the supreme happiness of
instruction in the true faith. After this came tales and songs. When tort
ured some years after by Prince Ixtlilxochitl, the spy insisted that he had
represented the case only as above stated, but that Cortes chose to interpret
it as a malicious plot. Horribles Crucldades, 90-3. This version is doubtful in
its details, and for the reason that the author s chief effort is to vindicate the
natives. The cause for the rejoicing at a return to Mexico from Acalan savors
rather of a. promise from the conspirators than from Corte"s.
33
The kings had formed it, and although they had not been parties to it,
yet as subjects they naturally desired the liberty and w eal of their lords.
r
Gomara, Jlerrera, Cortes, Bernal Diaz. The two former implicate the three
allied kings, the latter only the two of Mexico and Tlacopan.
31
The rest being spared, since they had been guilty chiefly of listening to
the plot, says pero quedaron procesos abiertos para que. .puedan ser
Corte"s ; .
castigados, if required. The execution took place within a few days of the r
disclosure. Cartas, 421. Bernal Diaz, Herrcra, and Gomara agree. ihc latter
adds that king Cohuanacoch, of Tezcuco, who had also plotted, cicd sometime
before of bad food and water. Hist. Mex. 274. Torquemada adds five caciques
,
February 2G, 1525, specifies Vetancurt on a Tuesday, three hours before dawn,
;
adds Ixtlilxochitl, who also declares that the native songs and versions place
it at Teotilac, and it certainly appears to have been carried out before the cap
ital was reached. The Mexicans were so oppressed by hardships, says Bernal
Diaz, that they seemed to be quite indifferent still, the Spaniards hastened
;
ci6 mal a todos los que ibamos aquella Jornada. Bernal Diaz, Hist. Verdad.^
200. But his account of all this expedition is questionable, and his testimony
loses force through the evident fact that he is carried away by sympathy for
the kings, who had often favored him, and for the natives to whom his later con-
EXCUSES FOR THE ATROCITY. 555
dition in life bound him rather closely. He certainly admits the strong accusa
tion and the confirmatory admission of the victims, the king of Tlacopan stating,
for instance, that he and Quauhtemotzin. had declared one death pi-eferable
to the daily deaths suffered. Torquemada adopts the version of a Tezcucaii
manuscript, which relates that Cohuanacoch on one occasion remarked to his
royal confreres that, if they chose to be disloyal, the Spaniards might have to
regret past injuries. Quauhtemotzin hastened to silence him by observing
that walls had ears, which might misunderstand such expressions. A ple
beian native reported them, and that very night those who had been present
at the conversation, three kings and five caciques, were found hanging from a
ceiba-tree. Torquemada will not believe that the Indians intended to revolt,
especially since their country was now divided, but that Cortes regarded the
kings as a burden, i. 575-6. Cavo, Tres Stylos, i. 46-8, agrees, and Gomara
even intimates something to this effect in saying that Cortes ought to have
preserved so prominent and brave a captive to point the triumph of his vic
tories, but that the dangerous circumstances must have prevented him. Hist.
Alex., 259. Es notorio, que Quauhtemoc y los demas seuores murieroii sin
culpa, y que les levantaron falso testimonio. Indeed, continues Ixtlilxochitl,
when the Indians complained to the kings of maltreatment, they counselled
submission. But his story is so full of glaring misstatements and absurdities,
and so evident is the desire to relieve his kinsmen from the traitor s brand,
that he cannot be relied on. Horribles Cruddades, 82, etc.; Id., llelaciones,
Kingsborough s Mex. Antiq., ix. 440, etc. Brasseur de Bourbourg follows him
implicitly of course, as he does almost any record from native source. There
was no witness except the spy, and the princes were not allowed to defend
themselves. Hist. Nat. Civ., iv. 608. He evidently pays no attention what
ever to the Spanish versions. Bustamante accepts even more implicitly
the records of those whom he prefers to regard as his ancestors. See his
edition of Gomara, Chimalpain, Hist. Conq., ii. 135-6. Cano, who married the
cousin and widow of Quauhtemotzin, calls the execution of the three kings a
murder, as may be expected from his dislike of Corttis. Oviedo, iii. 549.
Carried away by hyperbolic flights of fancy, wherein he surpasses even Solis
himself, Salazar condemns the deed as based on false testimony, and blames
Cortes for irritating the natives by resorting to so rash a measure. Conq. Mex. ,
240-3. Father Duran emphasizes this with well-known sympathy for the
native cause. Y levantandose contra el algunos testigos falsos lo mand6 a
horcar. Hist. Ind., MS., ii. 522. On imperfect evidence and without a trial,
says Robertson, Hist. Am., ii. 138. Prescott sympathizes with Quauhtemotzin
and regards the testimony as insufficient, while Helps, Cortes, 208-9, doubts
the statements of Bernal Diaz, and refers to the act as cruel practical wisdom.
The chief ground for this view is that Cortes, as an hidalgo, would not lie, and
can therefore be relied upon. It has not been my fortune to acquire such
faith, and I fancy that a closer study of his hero might have changed Sir
Arthur Helps views. Alaman, a Mexican with Spanish sympathies, believes
in the conspiracy, but regards the execution as a blot on Cortes. Quauhte
motzin, afc least, should have been sent to Spain after the fall of Mexico.
Disert., i. 214. This certainly would have been the best way to secure and
make use of him. Pizarro y Orellana, Varones Ilvstres, 114-16. regards the
evidence as clear and the execution as just; so does Revilla, although his
reasons are not the best. Solis, Conq. Mex. (ed. 1843), 508.
38
It is not improbable that suspicions as to the thoughts and acts of the
kings may have created a prejudice against them, but the sitspicions existed
already before they left Mexico, as proved by their being taken not only as
556 MARCH OF CORTES TO HONDURAS.
of the natives, particularly those now en
Many
countering the Spaniards for the first time, regarded
the discovery of the conspiracy with superstitious
awe. The idea of treachery by an accomplice did
not seem to so occur to them, but with mysterious
shaking of the head they pointed to the compass and
chart. Instruments which had so unaccountably, and
bettor than any guide, pointed out the road and saved
the army from destruction, could of course reveal a
simple conspiracy. Nothing could be hidden from the
o\vner of that needle. Conscious, perhaps, of some
stray unfriendly thought, many hastened to Cortes to
protest their devotion. Look into the mirror, and
"
hostages for the loyalty of their subjects, but as a precaution against their
own. possible disloyalty. Quauhtemotzin was evidently not the most submis
sive of men, for he had always been regarded as requiring a close watch, and
Cortes brought him chiefly because of his bullicioso character, as he ex
presses it. It may not be considered unpardonable for the Indian auxiliaries
to relieve their feelings in mutinous expressions against the taskmasters and
despoilers who were taking them away from home to meet an unknown fate,
to endure toil, hunger, and danger. But such sentiments could not be over
looked in the kings. They, as captured leaders, existed only by sufferance,
the condition being good behavior. For them even to listen was to en
courage, and they were consequently guilty. Not that I blame them. Nay,
I would rather blame them for not being mere prompt and determined in the
patriotic effort. But in resolving to listen, and to act, no doubt, they accepted
a risk with a penalty well denned among all peoples. Cortes was not the man
to hesitate at almost any deed when private or public interests demanded it;
and it needed but little to rouse to blind fury the slumbering suspicions of the
soldiers regarding Mexican loyalty. But here we have evidence not ground
less even from a native point of view to justify the Spaniards in assuming
that a conspiracy, or, at least, mutinous talk, was wide-spread, and this among
a horde tenfold superior in number; a horde known ever to have cherished un
friendly feelings, and now doubly embittered by suffering. Under the circiim-
stances even saints would not have disregarded testimony however doubtful;
and the Castilians were but human. Self-preservation, ay, duty to king, and
country, and God, whose several interests they were defending, demanded the
prompt suppression of so ominous a danger. What were the best measures?
A long campaign in Mexico had impressed Cortes with the belief that a peo
ple so trained to abject subservience as the Aztecs, and so bloody in their
worship, could be controlled by severity alone, and that the lesson must fall
on the leaders. Situated as they were the soldiers could not be expected to
guard a large number of captives. Hence no course remained, except capital
punishment. According to Bernal Diaz, Hist.Verdad., 201, Cortes distress
of mind at the sufferings of the expedition was so increased by this deed that
he became sleepless, and, in wandering around one night in a temple forming
the camp, he fell from a platform a distance of ten feet, hurting his head
severely.
THE ARMY AT IZANCANAC. 557
39
The army now proceeded to Izancanac, the popu
lous capital of Acalan, conducted by Apochpalon in
person. He was mounted on a horse, and the first
apprehensions over, he strode his steed with childish
delight. The soldiers were treated with sumptuous
hospitality, and Cortes was gratified with presents of
gold and women. Meanwhile, to facilitate the further
march, the road was improved, a bridge built, and
guides were provided, besides an advance corps laden
with provisions. In return for all this Apochpalon
asked merely for a letter to prove to other white
comers that he had been faithful.
There was every inducement to prolong the stay
at Izancanac, served and feasted as they were, but
the nearness of the Spanish settlements, as allur-
mgly depicted by the calculating Apochpalon, was
an incentive for all to proceed. Laden with rations
for a week, they departed on the first Sunday in Lent
from the fair province of Acalan, over which, the
protective letter notwithstanding the withering in >
adds Gomara ; but this Villagutierre will not allow. Idolatry rather increased,
he goes on to show. Hist. Cong. Ifza, 50. Here three Spaniards, two Indians,
and one negro deserted, tired of the constant hardship. Bernal Diaz, Hist.
Vcrdad., 202.
46
When the conquerors entered a century later to occupy the district, they
found more than a score of stone temples on the island alone, and in one of the
principal ones this idol. Villayutierre, Hist. Conq. Itza, 100-2; Cogolludo, Hist.
Yucathan, 55 ; Native Races, iii. 483.
47
Nuestra Seilora de Marco. Herrcra, dec. iii. lib. viii. cap. i.
HIST. CEN. AM., VOL. I. 3G
562 MARCH OF CORTES TO HONDURAS.
48
This was Medrano ; Chirimia de la yglesia de Toledo. The victims are
named. Herrera, dec. iii. lib. viii. cap. i. Cortds also admits that great hunger
was suffered, yet the swine were only sparingly used.
49
Murieron sescnta y ochocaballos despefiados y dejarretados, etc. Cortes,
Carfax, 433. Bernal Diaz is less clear on this incident. Gomara follows
Cort6s, although he says that the passage took only eight days, Jlixt. Mex-:,
263, and Herrera is the only one who enters into the losses sustained in men,
a number dying also of diarrhoea from palm-cabbage. Ubi sup.
A FORMIDABLE FORD. 563
50
Cortds describes even these crossings as quite dangerous. The horses
swam below the fall in the still water. Three days were passed ere all the
horses could crawl into the camp, a league further. Carlo,*, 434.
51
A 15 dias del aiio de 1523. Id.; that is, April 15.
52
Habia diez dias quo no comiamos sino cuescos de palmas y palmitos.
Aun dc aquellos palmitos sin sal no teniamos abas to, porque sc cortaban con
mucha dificultad de unas palmas muy gordas y altas, que en todo un dia dos
hornbres tertian que hacer cortar uno, y cortado, le comian en media hora.
Corlcx, Carter, 434, 439.
APPROACH TO NITO. 565
confound Nito and San Gil, and Prescott actually does so with Naco.