Documentos de Académico
Documentos de Profesional
Documentos de Cultura
SERIE O R I EN T AL I i RONIA
ED E S T R E I\T O OR IE N TE
VI
SE R I E ORI B NT A LE IT O MA
SOTTO I,A DIIIIiZI0NIi
DI I'DVARD CONZII
GIU S E l 'I'B TUCCI
INTITOI)UCTIONAND TRANSI'ATION
FTTOIIORIGINA TEXT
WITII SANSKNIT.TII}ETANINI]I]X
oo
Kt{
ROMA
ROMA
Ia. It{. B. O.
Ie. M. B. 0. 7t -- 4,
1954
I 9 l'r
TAI]LU OF CONTENTS
Ivrr]
.IABLE
OF CONTENTS TA B LE OF C ON TE N TS
5. Wulr rHE p ATH oF DEv ELopt r ENT DoE s . v. lZ. 37 I. The marhs of cogrritiotr'
6. Rrsor,u'rE FArrH. 1B-19 37 la. As regarils all'knoPlctlSe . JI
6. Arunorps. 4-7 44 70
path of ileuelopment,
7. E x only ouns . B -1 0 b . 45 70
A. The depth of the poth of deoelopment '
at. T Hr s , t unx Es s o F T rIE EN D E Av o u R S . l 0cd, 46 deuelop'
B. The ilistinctiae features of tlw path of
9. ' I ur p, c . r r roF v rs to N . l l -l 5 . 47 ?0
tnettt .
L -III. A nnr lp RE S U rl rE. v . 1 6 4B C. Nine ilegrees of the path of de'uelopment' 7l
IV. THB FULL UNDERSTANDINGOF ALL MODES D. The mark of enlightenrnent. 7L
E, The eightfolil tlepth of the path o! deaelopment 7L
l . A s pnc r s . v v . l -5
9. Tnn sauENEss oF BEcoM I Nc aND Q UI ETUDE' v' 60 74
l. 27 aspects relating to hinayanistic all-knowlarlge 49
2. 36 aspccts relating to thc lutowleilge of the paths, 10. Trrr uriltosr PUnlrY oF 'rrIE Bunnttl'rlnr'o' 61 ' JJ
49
3, 110 aspects reloting to the knowledge of aII modes. 49 l l . Trru sKI LL I N M EANs. 62'63 , JJ
I vrrr ] It*]
T ABI,E OF CONT ENT S TABLE OF CONTENTS
l xl l xr l
PREFACE
lll
I. (oNtr,
- li. Al'hi:nnoti,ln,thnra.
ED\I'ARD CONZE Abhisamayilaikira
have relied on the Cambridge manuscript Add L628. In sometimes rentlered this as 'etc.'o but in othef cases I
addition I have generally rvorked out the correspondence have given in brackets the factors referred to, and r[pa-
of P with the chapters and pages of the Ashtasd.hasri.kd. edi I have translated as 'the skanrlhas '. (2) Sometimes
(: A) t), and with the chapters of the Sonsdhasrilcd (: S)') the exigencies of the rnetre have led to thc choice of unu-
and of the Asluddaflasd,lnsrikd (: Afl)q. sual terms, like khadga regularly for pratyekabuddha,
2. The commentary of llaribhadra, thc Abldsu- dpin*rnirrga or dyik-patha for dar6ana*mflrga, ctc. I have
moydlniftd,ra-d.loka a), which, among other things, para- not regarded it as my task to reproduce these peculiari-
phrases the entire text of the Abhisamayd.Ioitkdra. The ties, and I have, for instance, translated khadga as 'Pra-
interpretation of this commentary is, again, greatly assi- tyekabuddha ', and not as 'rhinoceros o.
sted by the analysis which E. Obermiller 5) has given of The headings which I have given in front of each sec-
it, and which owes a great deal to the Tibetan commen- tion do not form part of the text of the Abhisarnaydlnfi-
tators. kdra, They are supplied from the revised version of the
Vimuktisena's Abldsamaydlaiftdrouyahhyd is a source Paitcuuirl&atisdlmsrikd,, antl in a few cases from Haribha-
of some importance which I have not bcen able to eon- dra's commentary.
sult. The sanskrit mamrscript is in the possession of
Prof. Tucci, and an edition is expected in the near future.
This ryikhyd or vgti is a commentary on both P and
AA, sid,eby side, and it is chiefly concerned with showingo
point by point, the correspondence which exists between
AssnrvrarroNs.
the divisions and verses of AA and the text of P. The
verses of AA are usually explained, and so are difEcult
A : Atlasd.hasrikd
words occurring in the quotations from P.
AA : Abhisamaydloitkdra
Except for the additions in brackets, my translation
AAA : Abhisamay dlairk ar alok a
is in general quite literal. Only in two cases have I depar-
Ad : Arl,iila*asdhasrihd
ted from strict literalness. (1) The verses very often
H : Wocrrr.lne's edition of Hlnrerrann{s AAA
indicate a whole sequence of of items by -edi. I have
P : Paiicaaiqr{atisd,hasrikd prajir.d.pdrarnitdobhisamaydlaikd-
1) Ed. R. Mrrne, Calcutta IBBB. Bibliotheca Indica. rdnusarena sam{oilhitd
2) Ed. P, Gnosnr, Calcutra 1902-13.BibliothecgIndica. And the Cam- S : iatasdha'srikd
bridge manuscipte Ailil L630, 1627, 1632,
3) Tibetan only, 3 volumes. T : Tuccr's edition of AA
a) For editiour see notes 2) and 3).
5) Analyeie of the lbhisama.yd,laikdrd,.I, 1933,II;1936, III, 1943, up
to ll IV, 5, 3.
[2] t3 l
ED\YARD CONZ E
A b h i 6 a m a yd l a i ki r a
l4l tsl
EDIYARD CONZ E AbhisaDrayilariklra
(5.-6.) Of the fourfold discrimination the fourfold 9 26ib l6r xxiv .t.)
ti 1
t't
t6l
EDWARD CONZ E AbhiEar naynlankir a
AA P A Ad
IV 3 3l0 c 22L xxx 39
4 3I 5 a XI 232 xxxi 353a 40-41
D 32Ba xI 2s3 xxxii 42-48
6 3694 xvl 3 1 2 ,I xxxviii 48
7 3 ?3 c 3 2 1 ,6 xxxviii 4B I. TIIE KNOWLEDGE OF ALL MODES
o 377a xvii 323 xxxi x (r0b 49-51
9 3986 xr x 356 xlii 96b J'
[10]
I ll ]
EDWARD CONZ E Abhisamaydlaikira
l t2 l I 13]
EDWARD CONZ E Abhisam aydlaikir a
[14] l t5l
EDIY,\RD CONZ E Alrhisamaynlarikdra
the Bodhisattva and perfect wisdom). (The asPect is) the 6. the path of vision, Z. the path of developmento B. the
non-discrirnination of the meditative trancc (since all rlistinctivc Path, 9. the path of the adepts).
dharmas have ceased to exist for him). (D. Assistance) (v. 36).
(E. The four kinds of false discrimination) (vv. 34-35). (Three things) at all times give assistance:
There are two kinds of imputation of an object, the one l. (I 3ro) the abseneeof despondency, etc., in thought,
(I, 3s, corresponding to Heat) concerns (all) objcctive enti' 2. (I 3") (the good friend) lvho rlemonstrates the
tieso the other (I 3r, corresponding to Summits) the arrti- st:rte of al-rsenceof own-being, etc.;
dotes (to unwholesome states). Each one is ninefold. 3. (I 3r) the renunciation of states hostile to that.
The first (I 3s) is divided under the headings of l. delu'
sion (2. the skandhas, form, etc; 3. settling down in name I 3o.Weak fleat with regartl to the Truth of Ill.
P ll9,1l. s iii 486.?.
and form; 4. attachment to the two extremes; 5- the non'
I 3b. Weak Heat. . . Truth of Origination. p llg,l9.
cognition of defilement and purification; 6. the non'esta-
s 488.7.
blishment in the holy path; 7. the basis; B. thc self, ctc.; I 3c. Veak lleat. . . 'l'rutlr of Stopping. I, 120,4.
9. purity in relation to production, etc.). The second s 488.13.
(I 34 (is divided) under the headings of l. heap, (2. sense' I 3d. V eak Heat . . . Tr ut h of t he pat h. P 72t,5. S 490.4.
fields, 3. the elements, 4. co-production, 5. emptiness, I 3e. The distinctive causality for all degrees P 123,6.
l16l I l7 ]
- li. C o r r n .,l l ,h i "4 .td \,i ti ,,t,,j ,.l
ED' WARD CONZ E
AlrLisarnayElaik6ra
l, 4. The Lineage. vv. 37'39. l. those belonging to the worltlly
path, 2. the supra-
The lincage (or the subjective source, or substraturn, r'.'rlane. (The first are) dharm", with, (the
of the activities of a Bodhisattva and of the propertics secon,l ,.e)
dharlnas rvithout outflorvs.
of a Buddha) is so called as the source (of 13 factors, i.e.) of (The dharmas withou[ rutflorvs
are again subdivided
1.-6. the six dharmas conducive to spiritual achieve- into) (2o) conditioned and (20)
unconditionetr (dharrnas),
ment, (i.e. the four Aids to Penetration, the path of vision, a'd (into 2c) dharrnas eharcd arso
with trre Discipl"*, uo,l
the path of development), (2d) (dharmas) nhich are special
to the Sage.
7. (the production of) the antidotes,
B. the forsaking (of detrimental states), I 5. P t(t4,IJ-169. S l2S?,tS_126J.
9. the state of being able to overlook the difference a) The objecr in gcneral. 6)
Worltily wholesomedharmas.
c) Vorltlly rrnwLolesometlharmas.
between those two (i.e. betrveen antidotes and harrnful
r/) Indeterminatctlharmas. e) Vorltlly
states)r wholesomedharmas.
./) Supramundanedharmas. g; Dlrur-^, with outflowe.
10. wisdom, together with pity, i) Dharmas without or,tflo*r. r.)
Conditionetltlharmas.
It. (the virtues of a Bodhisattva) which are not shared /r) Unconditionedtlharmas. /)
Cornmondharmas.
with the Disciples, nl) Urrcommondharrnas. n) The objective
supports of pro-
12. the successive actions for the x'elfare of others, gress.
13. the action of the cognition which rvorks without
I, 6. The program. v. 42.
any effort (for the rveal of beings).
The program of the Self-Existent
A distinction between the various lineages is rrot tena- should be known by
three kinds of greatnesso i.e.
bleo because the Dharma-element (o" the Absolute) ig
l. the aspiration to raise all beings
undifferentiated. But it is because of the difference bet- to the highest.pos-
sible state.
ween the dharmas that are founded on it that their distin-
.1" forsaking (of all false views),
tion is proclaimed. ?.
3. the achievement (of the thought
of all_knowledge
which is quite pure ancl transcendant).
P 160,15-164,19, S vii 1209-1257,14.
I6,I. P 169,4. S vii 1263,9. I i l8,l0.
I 6,2. P t72,6. S1270,3. Aill,l4.
I6,3. P t72,22. S t2?8,16.
I, 5. The objectiue supports. vv. 40-41. A i tg,6.
The objective supports (of a Bodhisartva?s activity) are (I, 7-10. The Progress).
all-dharmas. They again are reckoned as l, 7. Putting on the armour, v, 43.
l) wholesome, (B. unwholesome, C. indeterrninate); The progreas(which consietsin putting
(tle wholesome are subdivided into): on the) armour
is experiencedin six times six \ryays,
when the six (per-
I rB]
l l el
EDWARD CONZ E Alrhisamaynlaikera
fections), giving, etc. are combined with each other one 6. the threcfold purity (by which one does rot
by one. apprehend the object of each perfection, nor its subject,
nor the perfection itself),
i. e. The perfection of giving of a Bodhisattva who practises 7. the program,
the perfection of giving; the perfection of morality of a Bodhi'
B. the six superknowledges,
sattva who practices the perfection of giving; etc. fot 36 possible
9. the principle of the knowledge of all modes.
combinations.
I ?o) The first sextad connected with the perfection of giving
6) The sccond sextad connected with the perfection of morality' I B,l. P l80,l. s vii l3l3,l9
c) Thc third sextad connected with the perfection of patience. I ,2 ,IB 1324,1 I
d) The fourth sextad connected witlr the perfection of vigour' ,3 l8l.r3 1325,20
e) The fifth sextad connected with the perfection of meditation. ,4 ,lB 132(t,I7
of lr'isdom' ,5 183,1 1328,I
/) The sixth sextad connected with the perfection
g) The perfection of wisdom developing into skill in meaus ,6 ,lB 1329,16
h) The armour of the skill in means of a Bodhisattva who ,7 184,5 I 331,1
courses in the perfection of wisdom. ,B ,20 1340,1
i) The r6sum6 of the sextad of the armour. ,9 I85,t0 ,ll
I 7a. P 176,7. S vii 1302,20.- I 7b- P 177.6. s 1304,6.
T7c. Pl77,LB. S1305,1d. -I7d. Pl7B,7 s 1306,18.
I, 9, The equipment. vv. 46-47.
l'le. P178,14. S1308,3. -I7f. PL7B,22' s 1309,12.
P179,12. s 1311,8. One should know that the progressive steps in the pro-
I7S. P1?9,8. S1311,3. -I7h.
S 1311,13. gress in equipment are as follows:
I 3;. P 179,15.
l. (cornpassionate) syrnpathy,
I, B. Setting out. vv. 44'45. 2.-7, the sextad of giving (and the other five per-
The progress in setting out, which consists in ascend- fections),
ing on the great vefuicle should l)e klown with reference to B. tyrrietutle,
1. the (entering on and emerging from the four) trances 9. togcther rvith insight,
and the (four) formless (attainments), 10. the path which couples the two (i.e. insight and
2. (the six perfections of) giving, (morality, Patience' quietude),
vigour, meditation and wisdom), ll. the skill in means,
3. the path (as defi.ned by the wholesome practices), 12. cogrrition (of the 20 kinds of emptiness),
4. (the four Unlimited, i.e.) friendliness, (compassion, 13. merit (rvhich results in ll2 kinds of meditative
sympathetic joy, and evenmindedness), trance),
5. the absence of devotion to a basis (rvhich marks his 14. the path (which consists of 2l practices),
cognitions), 13. the (43) dharanis,
[20] [21 ]
EDWA.RD CONZ E Abhisar nayElaikdr a
1 6 . the ten stages (see vv. 4B-70), 7. alrvays (in all his births) his mind is benr on leav-
L 7 . the antidotes (see v. 7l). ilrg horne;
B. he longs for the body of a Buddha;
9,1 c om pas s io n P 1 8 5 ,2 0 . S v i i 1 3 4 2 ,1 6 9. he demonstrates the Dharma (to beings);
I perfection of giving P lB?,1. S 1353,4 10. he is truthful in his speech. That is the tenth.
3 perfection of morality P LB7,2l. S 1355,13 One should know that these are effective as prepara-
4 perfection of patience P IBB,B. S 1357,11
tions when one does not assume a basis with refereuce
5 perfection of vigour P 189,1. S 1358,7
6 perfection of meditation P 189,10. S 1359,5
to the own-being (of these activities or their objects).
n perfection of wisdom. P 189,23. S 1360,3
9,8. P 190, 5. S 1 3 6 1 ,1
2. The second sroge is marked by eight preparatiorrs):
9 lgl, I 1 3 7 4 ,t9
10 192,12 1390,14 (Form, etc. is neither bound nor l. (the perfect purity of) morality,
11 194,3 1405,? freed). 2. gratitude (and thankfulness for all the kindlv
L2 t 95, 10 1407 actions he has ever experienced),
t3 198, 11. S 1 4 1 2 . v i i i 1 4 1 4 3. (the fi.rm grounding in the power of) patience,
t4 203.22 ix 1427 4. (the cultivation of) rejoicing,
t5 2L2,8 1450,16
5. (the manifestation of the) great compassion,
t6 2r4,6 x L454
17 225,20 1473,19 6. (an attitude of) respect (for one's instructors),
7. reverence for the instructors,
B. the vigorous pursuit of (the perfections), giving, etc.
I, 9,L6. The ten st&ges.r'v. 48-70.
I. (The Bodhisattva) seizes the fi,rst stageby means of
ten preparations: 3. On the third sfage one stands in {ive dh.armas, and
f . fte forms the) resolute intention (to win the know- the absence of coneeit is the essential factor in each case.
ledge of all modes); (The livc dharmas arc):
2. he supplies (all beings) with beneficial things; 1. an insatiable desire to leam,
3. (he forms) an even attitude of mind towards (all) 2. the disintercsted gift of dharma (without expect-
beings; ing any reward),
4. (he practises) renunciation (by giving to all beings 3. the thorough purification of the Buddha-field (to
without discrimination); which one dedicates all the merit one has acquired),
5. he tends the (good) friends (or preceptors); 4. the indefatigability (with which one keeps on
6. he searchesfor objective support from the true doing good to others) in the samsaric world,
Dharma: 5. a sense of shame and a dread of bln-e.
r oo 1
LAL ] [23 ]
Abhisanl: r Ydlaikdr a
EDWARD CONZ E
2. morality,
should stand in ten dhar-
4. (On tne {ourrlt' s'og€ one 3. paticnce,
They arc):
maso and not abanrlon thern' 4. vigour,
1. living in a forest' 5. meditation,
2. fewness of wishes' wisdom;
6.
3. contentmentt
ascetic
4. the cultivation of the austere penancc of the
i.e.):
practices, 6,8. and rvhen he gives uP (another six dharmas,
outlook of)
'
5. the non-abanclonment of
moral training' ?. (he avoids all) longing for (the mental
qualities' the Disciples.l
6. the loathing of sensuous
outlook of)
7. disgust (for"the rvhole
of the phenomenal.world)' B. (he avoitls all) longing for (the mental
of all thnt is his' the Pratyekabuddhas;
B. the" complete renunciation
9. (an) uncowed (attitude
of mind)' 9. (he avoids all) inclination to worry;
a beggaro
10. a disrcgard (for all things)' 10. he remains uncowed rvhen he rneets with
eve-
I1. tloes not becorne sad when he has renounced
the ten (requisites) rything (he hail),
5. On tlnefiJtlt' stagehe accornplishes
by avoiding: 12. does not reject those rvho ask him for something,
atrtl rvith rnonks antl although he (hirnself) i" ')00r.
I. intimacY (with houscholtlcrs,
nuns):
(of the faithful)''
2. jcalousy about thc families 7A. He has arrivetl at the seuentlrstcge
when he has
society'
l. idfl places where one meets removed twenty blenrishes' They are:
of others'
4. exaltation of self and deprecation l. the seizing on a self,
action'
5. the ten paths of unrvholesome 2. (the seizing on) a fc'ingr
6. conceit, 3. (the seizing on) a soul,
7. arrogance' .1. (rhc seizing on) a Person'
B. Perverted viervs' 5. (the seizing on) annihilationist viewso
9. doubt, 6. (the seizing on) eternalist views'
10. consent to the defilements' ?. (the production of the notion of) a sign'
B. (the formation of the vierv of) a cause'
when
6. He gains the sixth sftrge 9. (settling down in) the (five) skandhas'
10. (settling down in) the (lB) elements'
i'e' the perfections of)
6A. he fulfills (6 tlharmas' It. (settling dou'n in) the (12) sense-lielde'
I. giving,
[2 s]
[24]
EDWARD CONZ E Alrhisarnaydlaikera
5. the accomplishment of (being born in a good) I 9,17b. A nti dot es t ot he second. . . object . . . P227, 4. S 1480, 12.
I 9,L7c. A nti dot e t ot he f ir st . . . subjecr . . . P227, 21. Sl4B?, 21.
family,
I 9,17d. A nti dot e t o t ho eecond.. . subject . . . P 228, 8,
6. (the accomplishment of) birth (in a Kshatriya or s t48g,l8.
Brahmin family), I 9,17e. Antidote to the first discrimination of the object on
7. (the accomplishlnent of bcing born in) the clan the path devcloprnenr. P 228,19. S 1491,3.
(from which all the Buddhas of the past have corne)' I 9,17f. A nti dot e t o t he second. . . object . , . P229, 13. S 1508, 16.
B. (the accomplishment of) a retinue (of Bodhisatt- I 9,17g. A nti dot e t o t he f ir st . . . subject , , . P 230, 14. S l5l?, 10.
I 9,I7h. A nti do t e t o t he second. . . subject . . . P 2J0, 19.
vas),
s 1 5l B . l .
9. (the accomplishrnent of) the rnanner of lrirth (so
that, even when just born, the Bodhisattva irradiates all
world systems with his splendour, and shakes them all I, 10. Going-Jortlr. vv. 72-73.
in six ways), The progress (which corrsists) in going-forth is eight-
10. (the accomplishment of) leaving home (together fold, and should be krrown with reference to:
with many other beings), l. the program (or ultimate goal),
Il. the accomplishment of (the miraeulous hannony) 2. the sameness (of all the elements involved in tLre
of the Bodhitree, process of going-forth to ernancipation),
12. the fulfilhnent of (all) the tlunlities. 3. (the activity for) the weal of h-ings (which pro-
duces the merit withoutl which the intuition of the ulti-
10. (The tentlt' stage) mate transcendent identity of evcrything is impossible),
Vhen he has passed beyond the nine stages' that cogni- 4. the absence of (the necessity for) exertion (in
tion by which he is established on the Butldha-stage, one's activity),
should be known as the tenth stage of a Bodhisattva' 5. the going-forth l'hich is free from (any attach-
ment to) the extremes (of eternalism and anrrihilation, of
Nirvarra and tlre samsaric world),
I, 9,L7. The eyr'ipment uiilt' an'titlotes. v. 71.
6. the going-forth which has the mark of (leading to)
The antidotes should be known as eightfold, with refe-
the attainrne't (of the achievements open to all the three
rence to the path of vision and to the path of repeated
vehicles),
meditational practice, and (they serve) the purpose of
7. the going-forth (rvhich leads to) the knowledge of
appeasing the eight discriminations of object and subject'
all modes (peculiar to a Buddha),
B. The (going-forth which lies within the) sphere of
I 9,I7. The equipment with antidotes.
I 9,17a. Antitlotc to the lirst discrimination of the object on the (highest degrees of the) path.
the path of vision. P 225,20. S x 1473,19'
[28 ] [2e]
ED1 YARD CONZ E Abhisam aydlaikdr a
[30] [31 ]
EDIVARD CONZ E Abhisam aynlaikdr a
but without taking them as a basis, should be known as rr' 3. The knowledge of the paths which consisrs i,. the cogni-
the path of the Disciples. tion of the path of the Pratyekabuddlns.
(w. 6.-7.) (The text next) indicates the deptlr. of
P 20Ib L-202b ? has a discussion, not found in l, of the well- the cogrrition of the Pratyekabuddhas, who do not need
known 16 aspects of the four holy truths, i.e. imperrnauent' to be instructed by others (in their present lives,
since
ill, etc., w[ic[ are sometimes tlircctly uteltiole{, sornetirles thcy havc in prcvioue livce learnetl wrrat is neces.ary
only alluded to.
for) the self-enlightenrnenr of the Self-existent. (When a
Pratyekabuddhao after his enlightenrnent, desires) to make
IL, 2,2. Tlrc aiils to penetr&liorr,. vv. 3'5.
some one hear something with regard to such antl such
1. The degree of. Heat (comes from seeing) the ern[)ti-
an object in such and such a form, the said object appears
ness of the skandhas, i.e. fornr, etc. arrd from making no
even without words (in the mind) of that person just in
difference between the emptiness (of different objects);
the form which is necessary.
2. the Summits from not taking theur (i.e. the skandhas)
as a basis; Nothing correspondsto thie in p.
3. stenilfast Paticnce from (seeing) that it is itradrr is-
sible to take one's stand on them as being permanent' etc'; fI, 3,1. Its threefold distinctiueness. v. B.
4. tlre highest nnondant.edharmas on' the road of the (The distinctive features of) the path of the pratyeka-
saintly Disciples have been laid down through the demorr- buddhas are summed up in the fact that
stration in detail that one should not take one's stand l. it forsakes the construction, i' thought, of objective
(anywhere) when one has undertaken the ten stages. And ,errtities,
why? The Buddha, when he has ktrown enlighterunenb' 2. rlocs not forsake the (bclicf in a) subject,
has not looked out for (t"y) dharma. 3. has a (special) foundation (or source, of its olvn).
[32] [33]
3. - li. Crrnzr, ll,hinnnynlaitr;rrt
EDWARD CONZ E Abhisamaydlaikira
w' 9-10' it (the Buddha) are not (ultimately distinct), and because
II, g,2. The aiils tu per,etrotion'
1. The degree of il*t consists in the absence of con- the Suchness of the skandhas) and the Buddha are in
existence (of form' etc') turn itlentical;
flict between the merely nominal
dharmas;
and the asPect which indicates the true nature of 2. (Cognition of dharma in su{Iering): the greatnesE
-Su**its
2. the (arise) when one discerns that formn (of perfect wisdorn and of all dharmas),
etc., cannot diminish (or increase)' 3. (Acceptance of subsequent cognition of dharma in
is no appropriation of
3. steadfosl Patience, when there suffering): their measurelessness,
of the internal ele' 4. (Subsequent cognition of sufiering): the absence of
form, etc., because of the emptiness
ment8, etc. limitations (in them),
through the aspects of 5. (Acceptance of cognition of dharrna in origination:)
4. the highest munilane dhnrmas
etc' the absence of extremes (in them);
the non-production, etc', of form'
6. (Cognition of dharma in origination:) The accu-
thitrgs are allowetl a con-
II 3,2,1. P 2L2' A ii 42' Separate rate deterrnination of ftrrm, etc. (reduces cverything to
ventionalexistencefromthestaudpointofempiricalreality. the purity of its dharrnic nature);
Tl 3,2,2. P 2L4a 5' A 1i 42' 7. (Acceptance of subsetluent cognition of dharmas
trains oneself neither to
if s,z,e. P 2l4b 4' A ii43' One in origination): one rvho stands in Buddhahood does not
let them go' ' A list of 20
approPriate the skaotlhas' nor to
the emptinessof the inter- take or give up anything;
kinds of emptin'ess'beginniug with
B. (Subsequent cognition in origination:) (a Bodhi-
nal elements,is giv"n at P 195-198'
ql' One does not ttain to get hold
II 3,2,4, P zLso li a ii sattva develops) friendliness (and the other Unlimited),
one' or rnake it disappear'
of any tlharrna, nor to prodluce 9. (Acceptance of cognition of dharma in stopp-
ing:) (and) emptiness (as the true essence of the skan-
dhas);
II, C. The potlt' oJ the Bodh'isattuas'
10. (Cognition of dharrna in stopping:) (his way of
II, C a. The Potlt oJ uision'
greut atluorltage' w' ll-16' lifc leads to) the attainrnent of Buddhahood,
II, 4. Thepath oJ uislio't",an'ilthe
pathso one speaks. of the 11. (Acceptance of subsecluent cognition in stopping:)
Next, in thc knowledge of the
its advantages' It is four- the acquiring of every kind of purity,
Path of Yision, togethei with
of the Truths' and has the 12. (Subsequent cognition in stopping:) the removal
fold, with regard io "u"h
and of Cognition' Thcse of all misfortunes and diseasesl
moments of patient Acceptance
of the paths: 13. (Acceptance of cognition of dharma in the Path:)
are the moments of the knowledge
of dharma in suffering): the desire to seize on Nirvana is brought to an end,
1. (Acceptance of cognition
existence of dharmas)o because 14. (Cognition of dharma in the path:) the protec-
No consent (to the separate
and that which is founded on tion, etc., Lry the Buddhas (and Devas);
the foundation lsuchness)
[34] [3 s]
EDWARD CONZ E
Alr hisar lr ay6laikdr a
15. (Acceptance of subsequent cognition of dharma II, WImt ilre parh oJ ileueloprnent
.5: tl,oes. v. 17.
in the Path:) following on (the observance of the precepts (Thcse are sorne of the rcsults
of the rnahayanistic
by which) one refrains from killing living beings, (it leads) path of tleveloprnent:)
to the establishment of beings in the principle of the know- l' self-disciprine at ail times, 2.
humility at ail rimes,
Iedge of all modes, in which he himself is (already) esta- 3. victory over the defilements,
4. no occasion for attacks
blished, (from others), 5. enlightenment,
6. (the place where the)
16. (Subsequent cognition of the path:) (and finally foundationi (of Buddhahood, i.e.
the perfection of wisdom,
to) the turning over of (the merit from) giving, etc. to is kept) is rvorthy of being
worshippetl.
the (cause of the) full enlightenment (of all beings).
L. p 229. A iii 54. 2. A iii 54.
3. A ;ii 54. 4. A iii 54-5.
l, P zLSb 2. A ii 43-4. The Sutra considersthe relation bet- 5. I iii 55-6. 6. p 2JIa 9. A iii SJ_57.
ween Suchnessand the Tathagata, Iretlveenperfect wisdorn
and the skandhas.
II, 6. Re,solutelraith. w. lB_19.
2. P 2L7a 7. A ii 45. 3. P 217b 9. A li 45. 4. P 2l9a B.
Resolute faith should be knou,n
A ii 45. as threefold: l, f-;
5. P 2IB b 2. A ii 45. The extremesare eternity and annihi- one's olvn welfarel 2. for one's
own welfare and that of
lation. others; 3. just for the welfare
of others. Each one of
6. P 2L9 b 3. A ii 46-8. The Sutra discussesthe infinitude of these again is regarded as threefoltl:
weak, medium, strong.
beings,and of perfect rvisdorn,and the Bodhisattvawlro under- That, by the division into very weak,
stands perfect wisdom is a potential Tatlr.agata. etc., is again three-
fold. In this way it has been
7. A ii 48. ft was becausehe possessed the fulnessof perfoct regardetl as 27_fold.
wisdom that the Buddha received his prediction from Di-
II 6,1. One aims at onersowrl rvelfare.
pankara.
II 6,1,1. Very weak. p 2l2a 2.
B. P 221 a 4. A iii 49. 9. P 221a 9. I iii 49-50. A iii S1,S_SL. The worahip
10. P 223 a 3. /4 iii 50-1. The Bodhisattvais protcctedby the of the perfection of wistlom brings
greatcr merit than the
Gods,etc., becauseit is thanks to hilr that all spiritual attairr- worahip of the relics of the Tathalata.
II 6,1,2. Moderatelyweak. p
ments, including Buddhahood,take place. fia ai. A iii 59-6I. The cult
11. P 223 b 2. I iii 5L. 12. P 224b 6. A ii. 5l-2. 13. A of the perfection of wisdonr is greatly
prnfitable, and bringe
iii 52-3. much reward. But rare are thise
who have perfect faith,
and rarer those who becomeirreversible.
L4. P 225 b 2. A iii 53. The Gods, and all the Buddhas and
II 6,1,3.- Fairly weak. p 2J6a
Bodhisattvas 'rvill protect, shelter and defenrl this follower 7. A iii 61. One shouldinde-
fatigably praetise perfect wisdom
of perfect wisdom. as the Tathagatas of the
15. P 226 a l. A iii 53. 76. P 228 b 6. A iii 54. past have done.
II 6,1,4. Weakly medium. p ZJ6b
B. A iii 6I-J. Devotionto
the perfection of wisdom brings nrore
II, C b. The path. of deaelopment. merit than the cult
of Stupas;
[36] [37]
EDWARD CONZ E Abhisam ay6laikdr a
II 6,1,5. Moderately medium. P 237 o 5. A iii 63. evert II, 7. Prai.se, eulogy and glorification. v. 20.
though one filled Jambudvipa with 6tupa3;
l. Praise, 2. Eulogy, 3. Glorification: with respecr to
II 6,1,6. Strongly medium. P 237 b L. A iii 64-5. and so
the perfection of wisdom one considers the clegieesof
for a Four-Continent'world system.
II 6,ln?. Weakly strong. P 237 b S- A iii 65-6. aud so for resolute faith, in nine triads (as before).
a emall cbuliocosm;
II 6,1,8. Medium Etrong. P 237 b 9. A iii 66'67. aud so for II 7,1. Praise.
a medium di-chiliocosm. l.P24BaB. Av t02 6. P 250a 3. I v 105
III 6,1,9. Snongly strong. P 238 a 4. A iii 67-8. and eo for 2. 104 7. 250a4 f06
a great tri-chiliocosm. 3. 249b 9 104 B. 5 106
II 6,2. One airns at the n'elfare of oneself and of others' 4. 250a 2 r05 9. 7 t07
II 6,2,L. Very weak. P 23Bo 9. A iii 68'70. And so for all 5. 250a2 105
beings in all the great tri-chiliocosms. II 7,2. Eulogy.
71 6,2,2. Moderately rveak. P 240 a 6. A 72-80. The power 1. P 250a B. Avl09 6. P 253a 6. A v lll
and advantages of perfect wisdoru are described' 2.8 110 7. 9 tL2
II 6,2,3. Fairly weak. P 242 b 2. ,4 80-83. Further advan- 3.9 lr0 B. b4 7t2
tages of perfect wisdorn. 4. ll0 9. lll
II 6,2,4. Weakly rnedium. A 82'83. 5. 110
II 6,2,5. Moderately medium. / 83-84- II 7,3. Glorification.
lI 6,2,6. Strongly rnedium. P 243 a 7. A 84. l. Av l r 6 5.P255b6. AvI2B
II 6,2,7. Weakly strong. A 84. , 120 6. 129
II 6,2,8. Medium strong. A B5'BB- 3. r23 7. I29
II 6,2,9. Strongly 6trong. A BB'92. 4. 126 B. r29
II 6,3. One aims at the welfare of others. 9. 256a6
in shar-
130
II 6,3,1. Yery 'w'eak. A iii 92-3. There is more merit
ing perfect wisdom with others, than in keeping it to oneself'
II 6,3,2. Moderately weak. A iv 94. Perfect wisdom is nore Ir, B. Th.e attention to rurning oaer (all merit to the cause
valuable than the relics of the Tathagata. of supreme enliglrtcruncnt). vv. 2l-23.
II 6,3,3. Fairly weak. A 94. 1. (The sutra {irsr describes) trre distinctive (merit
fI 6,3,4. Weakly medium. A 94-95. derived from) turning over (as compared with other meri-
II 6,3,5. Moderatcly uredium. A iv 96'8. Simile of wishing
torious actionso which results from) its supreme function
jewel.
(which is to turn over to supreme enlightenment the meri-
rr 6,3,6. Strongly medium. A 9B'9.
II 6,3,7. Weakly etrong. P 245 b 2. A iv 99. torious deeds of all beings after one has rejoiced over
rI 6,3,8. Iltedium strong. P 246 b 6. A 99'100. them);
II 6,3,9. Strongly strong. P 247a 5. I 100-10f. 2. (it then considers it under) the aspect of non-ap-
preherrsion (of all meritorious dharmas);
[38] [3 e ]
EDWARD CONZ E Abhi6anraynlarikira
3. (the mental activity by which the turning-over' or (of himself and of others) and rejoices at them, but (in
ultirnate trrrth) he tloes not apprehend them, - (in this
tledication, is e{fected) is marked by the absence of
way) is the development of the mental work on Ilejoicing
perverted views;
4. the isolatedness (of this accumulation of merit results prescribed here.
from the lack of any connection of it with a self, or such- II 9. P 267b 2. A vi 16I.
like);
5. (one takes as one's) range the recollection that in II, I0. The ntark oJ con,sutnnta,tiott.
(on the path of develop-
their own-being the multitude of the merits of the Bud- ment rchich is withouth outflows). v. 25.
dhas (is like an illusion); (It is considered from five points of view:)
6. (the turning over is characterised by being associat' l. its orvn-being (is omniscience, or the unpervertetl
ed with) skill in means' perception of the skandhas, which are seen to be devoitl
7. signless, of plurality);
B. enjoined by the Buddhas; 2. its excellcncc (it that of the perfection of wisdom,
9. (the merit) is unincluded in what belongs to the without which the other perfections cannot bring at'- -:
tripleworld; the attainment of Buddhahood);
10.-12. the turning over itself gives rise to great merit, 3. one does not get irrvolved in anything;
which is 10. weak, Il. mediumo 12' strong' 4,. the procuring of (the virtuous) dharmas, but not
after the rnanner of a basis;
II B,I. P 25Ba 6. I vi I35 5. (it is) that which brings about the great aim (i.e.
, B. 135,II
l40,IB Buddhahood).
3. 261 a 9.
4. 262. 149,19
II 10,1. 270a 5. A i; 170
5. 262 b B. 150,3
2. b2. t71
6. 263 a 4. oI 6 3. 27Lt B. 173
1 263 b , I vi 151,6
4. b6. 173
B. 265 a J. 153,7
5. 272b 7. r 75
9. b J, ,IB
10. 266 a 5 . l54,lB
II, ll, Absolute Pu,rity. r'v. 26-31.
1I. b l. 156,3
266 b 7 . l5 7,1 II, ll,l. T'lte cuu.sesof filrn belie,J(in the Dharma, which
L2.
are the factors favourable to purilication) are:
II, 9. Attention'to rejoicing. v. 24. l. tending (and honouriug) the Buddhas,
Owing to his skill in means (he appreciates)from thc 2. (fullillment of the six perfections, i.".) giving, etc.,
standpoint of (conventional truth) the wholesome roots 3. skill in means.
[40] [41 ]
EDWARD CONZ E AbhiEamay6latkira
II, IL,z. The causes of falling au)ay from Dlnrma (which rately weako etc. up to: very strong), and which
counter-
are the factors unfavourable to puriflcation) are: acts the taints, whiclr. are (correspondingly
divided in
I. being under the influence of Mara, nine ways into) very strong (,moderately ,trorr!,
etc. to, very
2. lack of fi.rm belief iu the deep (rnonistic) nature weak).
of dharma, b) Wirh regard to the process of counteracting
- - (the
3. settling down in (a belief in the reality of) the defilements of) the triple worrd (the sutra
then) .""f,.,.,
skandhas, etc., an objection (about the order of the antidotes
witi regar,l
4. being taken hold of by a bad friend. to the strength of the delilements), by
considering the
II, 11,3. (The generol clwracter of obsolute purity\. sameness of (the cognition) which measures
(the strengtlr
The purity of the fruit is (identical with) the purity of path and defiIements), (the object) which
is measured,
of the skandhas. The purity has here been proclaimed and_of the path (itself) (in view of the fact
trrat the tripre
in the sense that those two are not broken apart, not cut world ollers no basis for valid discriminations,
and all
apart. dharmas are equally illusory).
II, 11,4. (The different forms oJ absolute purity).
The purity of the (cognition of the) II lf. P 273b 6-283a 6. S xxvi l-xxviii 253. A vii 176-
lBg,1B.
o) Disciples, 6) Pratyekabuddhas, c) the legitimate
sons of the Jina (i.e. thc Bodhisattvas)
(results respectively from)
c) the forsaking of the (covering of the) defilements,
6) (the forsaking of the covering of the defilemerrts
and of that part of the covering of) the cognizable (which
consists in the imputation of the reality of an object),
c) (the forsaking of the covering on) the triple path
(of all the three vehicles);
d) but the absolute (purity) of a Buddha is (the
forsaking) of all (coverings, frorn defilement or from igno-
rance, together rvith their residues).
[42] [43]
ED- WARD CONZ E Alrhisarnaydlarikira
activity which has for its object) the Jinas, etc. (is a source
of *ruch merit, but it is not a complete antidote because
it has the character of) a subtle attachrnent. (The ap-
prehension of any formo or entityo whatsoever consti-
III. ALL-KNOVLEDGE
tutes a subtle attachment), because that (i.e. emptiness)
is (the original essential uature) of (all) dharmas in their
III, I-2. Unestablished in either beconti.ngor quietude. v. l. depth, owing to the fact that by their essential original
Not on the further shore (of Nirvana), nor on this nature they are isolated. When dharmas are cognized
(shore, of the samsaric world), nor established midway as having (all ultimately) one single essential and original
between them, the perfection of wisdom is understood nature (which is just the absence of a differentiated
through the cognition of the sameness of (the dharmas nature), - that is the removal of (all) attachrnent. (The
in the three) periods of time. depth of dharma) is spoken of as hard to understand,
III, 3-4. Farness ond nearrtess of perJect wisdom. v. 2. because (its intuition is reached by) the annulment .rf
She remains distarrt through lack of skill in means, sight'objects (and of all other objects of empirical consciour-
and (also) where a sign is taken as a basis. IIer nearness, ness); it is considered as unthinkable, because (in respect
in the right u'ay, has been said (to be due to) skill in means. of it there can be) no consciousness of the skandhas.
III, 5. Points to be shunneil. v. 3. That bei.g so, this whole distinction between the
Points
The points to be shunned consist in false notions about to be shurrned a'd the antidotes, as it has been expiained
the practice rvith regard to: (here), should be known (to fall) witrrin the compass of thc
l. the emptiness of the skandhas, (i.e.) form, etc. (hinayanistic) all-knowledge (and therefore it co'ccrns the
2. (the own-being of) the dharmas which belong to realistic misconceptions of the Hinayarrists).
the three periods of time, III, 7. Endeo,aou,rs. l'v. 8-106.
3. (the achievement of) the rvings to enlightenment, (The training of a Bodhisattva, u'hich confo''s to the
giving, etc.; (in each case the false notions interpret these hinayanistic capacity for undcrstanding, comprises ten)
items as real separate entities). endeavours. They are:
III, 6. Antiilotes. w. 4-7. I. (the training in the negation of the realistic impu-
(The antidotes are:) tations) with regard to the skandhaso
l. to have no sense of ownership in connection with 2. with regard to their impermanence, etc., (and to)
(the practice of the six perfections), giving, etc.; 3. their being neither complete nor incomplete;
2. to enjoin othcrs to the sarne (selflessness); 4. the rcrnoval of (attacluncnt to) his course (anrl
3. the rcpudiation of (all) thc points of attachment, Practiccs) (as separatc errtities), because of his non-attach-
(and in this conlection it is pointed out that the mental ment to them (i.e. the skandhas);
[44 ] [4 s]
EDWAND CONZ E
Abhi6amayilaikira
[46] [47 ]
Abhisam aydlar ikdr a
EDWARD CONZ E
[4e]
[48]
'1, - f'1. CoNtP, ,4l,hisomnril,th\nrn
ED1YAND CONZE
AbhisamayElaik6ra
IY,2. The endeo,Dours.w. 6'11. 6. (A beginner) reaches understanding painfully
IV,Z, A,. The persons who are suitable to make ,lw endea' and slowly, (and he is still full of fears about emptiness);
t)ours, w. 6-?. 7. (on the degree of Heat) he obtains (from the
(People are) worthy of hearing this (perfection of wis- Buddha) his prediction (to Buddhahood),
dom) because B. (on the degree of Summits) he (obtains) irrever_
l. they have done their duties under the Buddhas (of sibility (from full enlightenment),
the past),
9. (on the degree of Patience) he (defrnitely) goes
2. they have sown wholesome roots among them' forth (to emancipation),
3. they have good friends to help them. 10. (on the degree of Highest mundane dharmas)
The good are worthy of studying it, bearing it in mindo he (reaches) a state free from impetliments (in the unim-
(and meditating on it) because peded concentration, see V ?),
1. they have honoured the Buddhas, ll. (on the path of vision, or the first stagul (hi.
2. have questioned them, co'dition is characterised by his) to enJightenment,
3. have coursed in (the perfections of) giving, mora' 'earness
12. (on the 2nd to ?th stage by the) speedy (p.o_
lityoetc. gress to enlighten"'ent),
IV, 2o B. The methoils of traht'ittg. vv. B-Il. 13. (on the Bth stage) (by earrying on his activi-
(The endeavours which are needed firr the intuition of ties in pursuit of) the *'elfare of others.
the aspects of the three kinds of omniscience are 20 in c) (14-77,, concern the means by which the training
number. They arc): is perfected):
o) (1-5., concern the essence of the training): (In order to bring his practice of pcrfcct rvisdorn
I. One does not insist on the reality of the to fulfillmenr, the Bodhisattva should)
skandhas. 14. (sec that merits and defects from the stand-
2. (The insight into the fact) that (in true reality point of absolute reality) do neither gro\v nor diminish;
this endeavour) about them is no endeavour. 15. he should not form the vicw that there is a
3. (The insight into) the depth of the Suchness tlharma (or virtue), or a non,dharma (sin);
(of the skandhic elements which constitute the process of 16. he should not perceive (the fact even) that
training)o the skandhas are unthinkable etc.:
4. (the insight that these elements) are hard to 17. he should not discriminate the sign or exi-
fathom, (and really inaccessible to discursive thought), stence of the skandhas.
5. (the insight into) their immeasurableness; (they r/) (lB-19, concern the result of the training):
are infinite and without any limits). fB. (On the gth stage) he bestows (on others) the
b) (6-f3, concern the individual rvho trains): precious jervel of the fmits (of a holy life),
[50]
I st ]
Alr hiBam aydlaik6r a
EDWARD CONZ E
IV 3,1. The annihilation of Mara's power. P3I0a3. A x 221
19. (on the 10th stage he is perfectly) Pure' 2. One is brought to mind by the
e) (20, concerns time): Buddhasoaud is aware of this fact 3IOD I 223
20. (The last endeavour is) connected with the deli' 3. One is placed into the sight of
mitation of time (i.e. the Bodhisattva fixes a certain time, the Buddhas b 7 224
4. One is quite near full enlighten-
such as a month, or a year' which he will devote to the
lnent Sllo 3 224
study of the Praiftdpdramitdl.
One realises the gteat aim (i.e.
tLat one is not separatetl from the
lY 2,4. P30fb3. Ax 208. Buddhas; the great advantage,
rv 2,8,1. 2tL i.e. a happy destiny; the great
q
302 o 7. 211 fmit, i.e. supreme enlightenment;
3. 302 b 4. 2t2 the great karrnaresult, i.e. action
4. 302 b 7. 2L2 for othets after one has won
P
J. 303o l. 2L2 enlighterunent) 3ll a 4 ,., A
[53]
Is 2]
ED1 YARD CONZ E Abhisam ayilar ikdr a
29. The one has the higher know' 42. The teacher goes to a place
ledge of the dharma (as ex' haunted by robbers, and the
pounded i") the sutras, etc. student refuses to go there 324o 2 247
and the other has not 32l a 9 24314 43. The teacher likes to see the fa-
The one is endowed with the milies (which feed him, and so
six perfections, the other is uot 32rb 3 has rro time for his students) 324a B 248
IV 4,C. External unfavourable condi-
31 . The one has skill in means,
32Lb 7 tions
the other has rrot
44. lllara makes an effort to dissuade
32. The one has a powerful me'
322a 2 (from the perfection of wisdom) JZA b z 248
rnorlr the other has not
45. (Mara) arranges a fictitioua, or
The one lovee to (studY)'
(etc. the PraiftdPdra' counterfeit (appearance of the
write
322o 4 B uddh a) 325a I 249
mitd), the other does not
46. (Mara) produces a longing for
The one is covered over with
undesirable things 325a 7
sense-dcsires (and other evil
states)r the other is without
them 322o B 245 IY, 5. Morks, vv. 13-31.
JJ. The aversion to being reborn (The Sutra now considers the marks, or characteristic
in the states of woe (for the features, of the training). That by which something is
sake of other beings) 322b 4 246
rnarked, that should be known as its mark. And that
Delight at (the thought of)
is threefold, (i.e. 1. the marks of the) cognition (rvhich leads
going to a blissful existence
322b 7 to linal enlightenment)? 2. the distinctive marks (of the
(in the heavens)
37. The one is foud of solitude, mahayanistic path), 3. (the marks) of the activity (which
the other of companY 323aL 246 accompanies the cognition). But 4., that.rvhich is marhed
(The student) wishes to asso- is the own-being (of the training).
ciatc (with the teacher), but IV, 5,1. The marks of cognitiort.
(tl-re teaclrer) gives him no
246 fV, 5,1a. The marks of tlrc cogrtitiort.as regarils oll-knou-
opportunity 323a 4
ledge.
39. The one needs some material
hclp, the other is unwilling These are the rnarks of the cognition comprised under
to give it 323a 9 the hcading of (the hinayanistic) all-knowledge. (It is a
40. The one goesto a a Place of ilan- cognirion) rvith regard to:
ger' the other to a safe Place 323b 2 247
l. the appearance of the Tathagata (in the world,
41. The teaclrer goes to a Place as a result of perfect wisdom),
which is short of food, and the
323b 6 247 (2.-75. concern aspects of the Buddhaos cognitiq4)
other refuses to come with him
Is 6] Is7 ]
EDIYARD CONZ E
Abhisarnaydlaikira
Is B ] Ise]
EDWARD CONZ E
Abhisamaydlarikdra
6. (that the Buddha has a cognition of) the fact that 6. the knorvledge (of the Absolute) is accessi-bleto the
(all dharmas) have not been made by an agento experience of the wiseo
?. that (the Buddha has) a cognition which reaches 7. (but) it is not shared (by the Disciples);
everywhere, B. it brings quick(er) understanding (than that of thc
B. that (the Buddha) has the ability to show that which Disciples),
is imperceptiblc, 9. urrdergocs neither loss nor increase,
9. that he (cognizes)the world from the point of view 10. is an (intense) progress (in the six perfections),
of its emptiness, 11. (and leads to the accomplislrmenr) of full attain-
10. that he (can) indicate (this emptiness)o ment.
11. make it knowno 12. (This knorvledge of perfect wisdom is further con-
12. show it up, sidered rvith regard to) its objective supporr,
13. that he can demonstrate the unthinkability (of the
13. its (subjective) fou*dation (which is the Absolute
skandhas in their true nature), in the Bodhisattva),
14. their (basic) quiescence 14. the full complement (of the factors necessary for
'
15. the cessation of the world, realising perfect wisdom),
16. (and the cessation) of the perception (of the world)' 15. the assistance (provided by the power of perfect
IY, 5,2. The ilistirtctiue marhs. wisdorn and of skill in means),
The distinctive marks (which indicate the points of 16. the absence (in it) of a relishing (for any notiorm
superiority of the rnahayanistic path) are taught by way of I arrd mine, and for any separate dharmas).
of 16 moments' which have the (four holy) Truths for IY, 5,3. I'he ntarks oJ actiaity,
their range, (which conespond to the 16 moments of the The marks of the activity (of a Bodhisattva, who tluring
path of vision, as given at II4), and which are distinguish- his training helps others, are as follows):
ed by the special distinctive marks of unthinkableo etc' l. He brings benefits to people,
The 16 points by which the distinctive path (of a Bodhi- 2. ease,
sattva) is distinguished from the other paths are as fol- 3. shelter,
lows: (The Absolute is cognized as) 4. a refuge,
1. unthinkable, 5. a place of rest,
2. incomparableo 6. the final relief:
3. transcending all measure, 7. he becomes an island (to the *.orld), (and)
4. (transcending all) calculation; B. acts as a leader (to it);
5. as comprising (the virtuous qualities) of all the
9. he does not (in his mind) turn towards (an, beinge
saints; as to real persons whom he might really benefit),
[60]
[61 ]
CONZ E
Abhi6amaydlarik6ra
EDWARD
162) [63]
Abhisarnaydlaikdra
ED1 VARD CONZ E
IY 5,3,1. P 349b 3. A xv 293 7. P Ssrb 2. A xv 296 4. The meditative trance, lvhich is without discrimina-
b 9. 293 B. 352b L. 296 tion (between doer, deed and doing); (and)
2.
293 9. 353o 3. 297 5. Wisdom, which is the cognition of dharmas in all
3. 350 o 2.
a 4. 294 r0. b 9. 297
4. their modes.
a 7. 294 11. 359a 7. 298
5. IY, 6 c) Three degressof strength oJ the Aids to emancipation.
6. b 6. 29s
Full enlightenment is regarded as easy to know by the
9.P 359 a 5. ,4 xv 301
IV 5,4,1. P 356a 7. A xv 299 keen (i.e. by those who are strong irr faith, etc.), as hard
10. 360 o l . 302
(S ch. 37, Ail ch' 47)
299 (s 38' Ad 48\ to knorv by the dull (or those, who are weak in faith, etc.o
2. 356 o 9.
b L. 299 11. 362 b 7. 304 and also those who are only rnoderately strong ir. r'aitho
3.
299 t2. 364o 3. xvi 306 ctc.).
4. b 2.
300 13. b6. 306
5. b 7.
300 14. b9. 306 IV
6. 357a 7. 6a.P 369o5. lxvi3ll
301 15. 366b 9. 309
7. b 1. b. 3696 r. 312
30r 16. 367 a 6. 309 c. I.
B. b 5. The sttong Aids to emancipation. ,4 xvi 313,6
2. 'i'he .rveak Aids to crnancipation. P B7La J
3. Thc rnrrdiunrAids to emaucipation. o B
IV, 6. The Aiils to Emancipation' I'v' 32-34'
IV, 7. The Aids to Penetration. I'v. 35-36.
IV, 6a. The Aiits to enranciPation in general'
perfect wis- a) (In its next section the Sutra) recommends the
The skill (which is in possession of both
towards) full ways in which those who are on the stage of lIeat nake
dom and ekill in means) (and u'hich moves
takes) the all beings into an object (of their thoughts): their thoughts
attainment (by means of a cognition which
nanifestation are described (first of all) as even (friendly, well-disposed,
signless (for its object, and through the
of) gene' frce from avcrsion, free frorn harrnl and therr) as tenfold
within the personal continuity of a Bodhisattva'
of a Buddha)' (insofar as one regards all beings as if they were or,.,'s
rosity (ani of all the other constituents
is regarded mother, father, brother, sister, son, daughter, fricnd, rela-
that, in this Full understanding of All Modes,
tive, kinsman or maternal relative).
as the Aids to EmanciPation'
to emu'n'cipatiort" b) (The Bodhisattva) has come to the Summits when
IV, 6 lr. A f'uefoltl iliaisiort' oJ the Aitls
he himself desists from (all) evil, stands (himself in the
They are frvcfold, ff
and Samgha) progressive path rvhich consists in) giving, ctc.o and also
1. Faith, which has the Buddha (Dharrna
enjoins those (practices) on others, proclaims their praises
for its object;
(to them), and makes them conform (to them).
2. Yigour, which ranges over giving etc';
[64] [6 s]
5 - Ii. Corzr, .4hhisnmntilahk;n
EDWARD CONZ E AbhisamayElaikira
c) And so (he comes to the stage of steadfast) Ptl- 5. (the praetice of the perfections),
_ givingo ete., is
tience when he establishes both himself and others in the on (the ide'rificatioo ur oneserf
withl) otire.e;
cognition of the (four holy) Truths, 'ased
6. (he fccls) no
_- ab''r thc _ruoiog
r/) and likewise one should understand the Highest dharma) even where 'esitation 1uf tl"
it is dcep;
(mundane) ilharmas (as reached) when (he himself) matures 7. he is friendly (whencvei
he acts rvith) his body,
all beingso (and incites others to do the same). (voice or mind);
B. he tloes not-rneet rvith any
IV 7. P 373 a 4-377a l. A xvi 321-322. of the five hinrlrances;
9. he loses all latent bias (towards
igrrorance and other
evil states),
IV, B. The host of irreaersible Bodhisattaos. wv. 38-59.
f 0. (he acquires constant)rninrlfulness
The host of irreversible Bodhisattvas (consists of Bodhi- anJ _,lf-possession,
lf. (he has clean habits), (rvears
sattvas who) proceed successively I. on the Aids to Pene- a) clean rlbe, etc.
6) Summits.
tration, 2. on the path of vision, 3. on the path of repeaterl
12. The (S0.000 farnilics of) rvornrs
meditational developrnerrt. cannot spring u1r
in his body;
B. P 3?7 o 1. The marks of irrcversibility in gcneral. : 13. (there is) no crookedncss
in his heart,
A xvii 323. 14. he has taken upon hirnself
the (12) ascetic praetices,
15. (his mind k'ows) not (rhe
srarcs which arc hostire
fV, B,l. Tlrc marks of irreuersibility on, the leuel of the Aids to the perfections), Iike nlearuless.
etc.:
to Penetratiotr.. (vv. 39-45). 16. he moves tow_ardsa junction
(ruith perfect wisdom,
The marks of the irreversibility of him who stands on which is not in conflict) with
the true nature of Dharma;
the Aids to Penetration are said to be twenty? by way 17. he desires to go intn the
hells for the rveal of the
of the tokens which begin with the turning away frorn world.
the skandhas. (These tokens are as follows): c) Patience.
c) Heat. lB. He cannot be lcd astray
by others.
1. The turning away from the skandhas (to the Such- 19. 'When Mara recommends
a wrong (or counterfeit)
ness which is their true reality)o path, recognizes that . this is Mu.u jruiro
-he .p"utrf ;,
2. the extinction of doubt (which is shorvn by the d) Ilighest mundane dharrnas.
emergence of unwavering faith), 20..Td: finally, he takes rrp
. the (progressive) practices
3. the extinction of the (eight kinds of) inauspicious in (everywhere) the Butlclhas
_which h"rr"" ."joi".d.
rcbirth; It is by these trventy tokens
that (one can know that
4. he himself stands firm in what is wholesome, and a Bodhisattva) who cngagetl in tire practice of (the
he enjoins it also on others; -is
degreesof) a) Ilcat, 6) S""r-its, c) patiei"",
lli.
"rr.l I
[66] 167l
EDWARD CONZ E
Abhisamaydlafrkira
ghest (mundane) dharmas, does not turn back on full
that he cau enter into those states of meditative tra'cc,
enlightenrnent. b't does not allorv his future rebirth to be tlcternrincrl by
M,1,1. P37ia7. ,4 xvii 323 1r. P 379b 3. A 326 thern, with the result that he is reborn in thc world of
2. 323 12. 379b 5. 326 sense'desire, and not in the lvorld of form or of formless-
3' 378a 2. 324 13. b 9. 326 ness).
4. a5. 324 14. 380a 4' 327
5. He is light in body and rnintl,
5. bl. 325 15. a 6. 327
16. o B. 327 6. circumspect in the use of pleasant things (wtrich
6. b6. 326
326 r7 . b 2. 328 he possessesand enjoys rvithout caring for them, without
7. 379a 2.
B. o6. 326 lB. b 6. 328 eagerness or attachment).
9. o 7. 326 19. 381b 6. 329 7. at all times (in all his lives) he leads a chaste
10. o B. 326 20. 383 o 3. 330 life,
B. he is pure in the rnanner of earni-_ his livelihootl,
IY, 8,2. Tlrc marlrs oJ irreuersibilily oJ one wlrc slon'ds on' (and provides for it in the right way).
the path oJ uision. (vv. 46-5f). 9. He avoids to dwcll on, or to be occupied or pre-
o" tt path of vision one should discern the marks of occuPied with the (5) skandhas, (lB elements, 12 sc'se-
"
a Bodhisattva's irreversibility in accortlance wittr the (16) fields, which he regards as all equally empty).
moments, (defined by) the (patient) accePtance of the 10. with the (possible) obstacles (to his arrainment
of
cognition (of dharma) (etc. as at II 4)' The tokens of ema.cipation' which have all lost their power to harm
irreversibility of the wise who stand on the path of vision him),
are (in accordance with) the 16 moments, as follows: ll. with (the varied mrrltiplicity of) his ctluipment
l. revulsion from (the habit of forming) a notion of (for e^liglrtenment, in view of the fact that he has under-
the skandhas (u. separate entities which have actually stood the faults of discrimination),
been produced); 12. with battles (killers and their victimso hostile
2. firmness of the thought (by which he aspires for states and antidotes, because he has abandoned the dilfe-
as
supreme enlightenment, which he contirlues to regard rence between subject and object; and in consequence he
has
worth winning, although it is like sPace' and his self reaches a fourfold cessation of his karma-result, i.e. the
no place in it); cessation) l) of his faculties, (2) of the subjective basis of
3. the turning away from (thoughts which aspire the faculties, 3) of the objcctive range of the faculties,
Pra'
for) the two inferior vehicles (of the Disciples and and 4) of the settling down in the notion of self);
tyekabuddhas), 13. with meanness (immoralit/, and the other etates
4. the mastery over the limbs of the (four) trances hostile to the six perfections).
in
(and the four formless allsinments) (rvhich consists 14. He does not grasp at even the least dharma,
[68]
[6e]
EDWARD CONZ E Abhisam aynlat kdr a
15. (he reaches) certainty about his own stage, and IV, 8,3 C. Nine degress of the path oJ deuelopment.
By way of rnaking a continuoue series (the Sutra) con-
stands frrmly on the triad of the levcls (which is essen'
siders (thc path of development) as ninefold in kiml, (by
tially the same as the triple omniscicnce);
16. he renounces even his life for the sake of the distinguishing three degrees each of) weak, medium and
Dhanna (which consists in the knowledge of all modes, strong' and in addition it disti.guishes (another eeries of
etc.). with regard to the hostile states arising from false
'i^e,
discrimination, which are considered as very) weak, etc.
rv 8,2,1. P 3BI6 1. A xvii 33L,6 9. P 3866 l. A 334 (and in each case the strength of the path is inversely
, 3836 9. 331,25 10. b 6. 334
proportionate to that of the hostile state).
(S ch. 40, Ail ch. 50) il. b7. 334
1.4 332 t2. b B. 334 IY, 8,3 D. The mark oJ enlightenment.
3. P3846
4. b 7. 332 13. 387a 4. 335 Thc descriptions (of lthe merir accumulated by a Bodhi-
5. 385o +. 332 t4. b 4. 336 sattva rvho praetises this ninefold path of development)
6. b 2. 332 15. a
3BB 9. 337 as i'calculable (immeasurable and measureless) u." frorrt
,7
b 7. 333 16. 6 B. 338 the standpoint of ultimate reality not adequatc. In a
B. 386a J. 333
conventio'al sense, (horvever), they are admittetl as prol)er
outpourings of the sagesospity (which bring great fruits
fV,B, 3. The marks oJ irreuersibility oJ one uho stantls on'
in the mi.ds of ordinary peoplc). (The accumulatio.
the path oJ deueloptn,ent. vv. 52-59.
nrerit produced by the path of devclopment) is an entity 'f
IV, 8,3 A. The tlepth oJ the path. oJ deuelopmen't.
rvhich cannot (in its ultir'ate reality) be expressed in
1) Decp is the patlt of developnrcnt. 2) Its depth is
rvords, and (the attribution of) grorvth (to trrc anrid'tcs)
(due to its being) emptiness' (the signless, the wishlessothe
and of dimi''tion (to the hostile states) is not tcrrablc
uneffected, non-production, no-birth, uon-existence, dispas-
(in respect of such an cntity). One speaks of (a path of)
sion, cessation, Nirvarra, departure). 3) This depth (which
meditational developrnent, - but there is nothing (by rvay
consists in emptinesso etc.) is free frorn the two extrernes
and negation, (because the skandhas are of the nine kinds of thi'gs bor. from farse discrimination)
of attribution
rvhich is left behind, ai { there is nothing (by way of the
not in emptiness, etc., and yet ernptiness' etc. is not other
nine kinds of states born of the path) which is built up.
than they).
But it is like enlighrenme't that this (path of develop-
IV, 8,3 B. The tlistirlctiue Jeatu,res oJ the path oJ deuelop'
mcnt) accomplishes the desired aim (and all the merit
ment.
gained should be dedicated to enlightenmcnt). And enlight-
The path of development (consists of) repcated reflec'
ertment has suchness for its mark, arrcl so should also the
tionso assessments a1d meditations (about the perfection
mark of this (path of dcvelopmcnt) be understood.
of wisdom) (successively) on thc Aids to Petrctration, on
lV, B,3li. The eightfold depth o! the path of deuelopment,
the path of vision, on the path of development itself.
[70] [ 71 ]
$
Tt
(The attainment of full) enlightenrncnt is not joincd 2. The rlepth of the path of tle_
to the mind which (produced) thc first (thought of enlight- veloprnent 61. 342
enment), nor to (the one which produces) the last one. 3. Thc path of development is
frecrl frorn the trvo e_ytremes
The true nature of dharma (shoultl be understood) in
of attrilnrtiorr aud ncgation 391a 6.
accordance with the simile of a lamp (the wick has not 342
[V 8,3 B
been burned by the {irst incidence of the Ilarne, or by l. 'I'he roatl to devclopmerrt 39r b 6. 342
the last one, and it is also not burned without them, and 2. The roatl to development,
yet the wick has been burned up). (It then reveals itself rvhich consists of the Aids to
as) deep in eight ways. The depth lies in: penetration, etc. 39rb B. 342
'Ihe tlrreefirkl
f. its (rnode of) production, (in that it is produced
J
.vanraAe 3916 o 343
IV 8,3 C
C. The distinction of (9, or lB)
not as a result of the consecutivc moments of its deve-
kinds ou the path of rlevelop-
loprnent, and not independent of them, either);
ment.
2. its stopping, (in that, although they are in their I xviii 343
l. The discrirnination is very
own nature unproduced, entities are stopped in the con- -346
strong 392 b
ventional sense); 2. The path (antidote) is very
3. its Suchness, (rvhich is hard to understand because w eak 392b 3.
3. 'Ihc diecrimination is mc_
although not distinct from the skandhas, it rnust be rea-
dium strong
lized as a result of their removal); 4.
4. The path is moderately weak
4. the cognizable, (which is mere thoughto neither 7.
5. The discrirnination is weakly
dillerent nor not difierent
from Suchness); Ftrong
9.
5. the cognition, (which is non-cognition, since Such- 6. The path is fairly weak 393 a ,
ness can be seen only when it is not seen); 7. The discrimination is stron-
6. the practice (which is the absence of all practising)o gly mediurn 5.
B. The path is wea':ly rnediurn 1
7. its non-duality (rvhich results from the absence of
9. The discrimination is mode-
ideas of sign and signless), and rately medium 3 9 3b r .
B. the skill in means (by which he forsakes in a con- 10. The path is moderatelv me_
ventional sense that which in ultimate reality cannot be di um b4.
forsaken). Il. The discrimination is weakly
medium b q
12. The path is strongly medium 394a ,
IY 8,3 I 13. The discrirnination is fairly
l. Deep i s th e p a th o f d e v e l o p - rveak 6.
ment P 390 a 5. I xviii 341 14. The path is weakly strong
B.
1 7 2) li3 l
EDIry'ARD CONZE
Abhisarnaydlaikari
[74] [? s]
Abhisam aydlaf r kir a
ED' WAND CONZ E
[771
[76]
EDYT ARD CONZ E A b hisam ayilaikir a
(At this point Haribhatlra inserte P 413 b 5-4L6 b 4: tlrerein no one grows and notlring increases). p 4lg b g.
o. A 405.
A xxi 385-395, as a section dealiug with ' Mara's deeds
These are dividcd into o) (deeils) arising frorn the assi- The growth is considcred from the point of vjew that
gnation of a name (by which the irrevcrsible Bodhisattva it o{Iers no baeis for the apprehension of the real
exi_
shall be known as a Buddh.), - weak, medium, strong; Btence of the person who wins enlightenrnent. or of
D) (deeda) arising from (an irrcversible Bodhisattva's mis- the dharrna u-hich is known to tlre enliehtened.
conceptions about the) quality of detacltnrenl, - weak, P 420b 6. A 408.
medium, strong). 5. The growth (in perfect wistlorn) consiete essentially in
9. He advances courageously on his owu initiative to the the (increasing' endowment with wholesome roots (which
higher knowledge, and tends thc good friends. P 416b 4. render the Bo lhisattva) euperior (to att other beings).
A xi 395. xxii 396. P 421a 2. I xxiii 410. S ch. 46. Ail ch. 56.
10. He trains in perfect wisdorn in all manners and ways. 6. This growth (in merit) by its own natule (induces) all
P 4L7 b 4. I xxii 398. the Gotls to (reverently) approach (the Bodhisattva).
11. He does not settle do\,vn in anything. P 4L7 b 6- 4398. P 422 a 2. ,4 xxiii 414.
12. IIe comes near the enlightenment of a Buddha. 7. The growth (iu perfect wisdom also enables the Bodhi-
P 4lB o 6. A 400. sattva) to overcome all the Maras. p 422 b 2. I xxiv 416.
B. The growth (in perfect wisdom) manifests itself by the
fact that a Bodhisattva treats (all other Bodhisattvas)
Y,, 2. Their growth. v. 2. alike, revering them as if they were the Teacher himself.
The growth (corresponding to the degrec of Summits), P 424b 3. A xxiv 422.
consists of 16 points' rvhich begin with the (description of 9. By its verv nature the growth (in perfect wisdom) con-
the) merit (which) all the People of Jambudvipa (and of sists iu tl-re perfectly pure training in skill in lneans.
P 425 a 4, A xxv 424, S ch. 42. Atl cb. 57.
rvorld-systems up to a great trichilicosm) (can gain) from
10. This grorvth is rnark.tl by the fnct that .^e hag bec.rnc
worshipping the Buddhaso and with lvhich (the rnerit
one who belongs to the clan of the lluddhas. p 427 o I.
tlcrived from the perfection of wisdorn) is compared in A 428.
many ways. ll. It has for its sig' (the aspiration for) the attainrnent of
tlrc fruit of Buddlrrrhoorl. p 427 a 2. A 42g.
V 2,I. The growth of tb'e rnerit (derived frorn the practice of 12. Its nature consists in that the etates hostile to the per_
perfect wisdom) is superior to that which the beings fections (i.". meanness, immorality, ill-will, Iaziiess,
of Jambudvipa, etc., gain from honouring the Tatha- distraction and stupidity) do not arise in the thought
gatas,etc. P 4IB o 10. I xxii 401' (of a Bodhisattva). P 427 a 6. A 4J0.
2. In its distinctive own-beingthe growth consistsof atten- 13. (This item is omitted by l{aribhadra. p 427 a B has:
tions to the perfection of wisdom- P 4I9 a 5' A 404' There ariscs no thought associatetl *ith trre skandhas,
3. When one has gained the patient acceptanceof what et c.).
fails to lre producecl, (one appreciates) the fnct that 14. The growth (i" perfect wisdom) comprehends (the
the growth (in perfect v'isdom) is pre-eminent (because growth) of all the perfections, and (the growth in) the
[78] uel
EDT YARD CONZ E Abhisarnay6lariklra
cognition (of perfect wisdom) (puts a stop to the non- Yo 5a. The two discriminations of the object. v. 5.
cognition, which is the source of all unwholesome dhar- The trvo (false) discriminations of the object cause
mas). P 427 b 2. I xxv 431' objects within their range to appear dillerent from what
15. The growth (in perfect wisdom) implies tb'e acquisi- they are in reality. The one refers to worldly activity,
tion of all the accomplishments' (those of a Disciple as
the other to withdrawal from activity, and each should
well as those of a Buildha)' P 427 b 6' A 43I'
it consists in lreing near to full be known as consisting of nine (itcms).
16. By its very nature
enlightenment. P 428 a 9. A 433' V, 51,. The tuo discriminations oJ the subject w. 6-?.
(The Sutra I nen) considers the two (false)discriminations
Y, 3. Firm position. v. 3. ofthe subjcct. The one regards beings (or persons) as (real)
The firm position (corresponding to the degree of Pa- substantial entities, the seconrlas (merely) nominal entities.
tience) is so called (because one has gained l' a firm posi- The Iirst refers to the common people, the second to the
tion in) the supreme fulfillement of the dharmas (charac- saints. Each one consists of rrine iterns. If the objective
teristic) of the three kinds of ornniscience, (and 2' a {irrn reality (of objects) is rrot so (as it appears to the discrirni-
position with regard to) the non-abandonment of the nating mind), then the tu'o (discrirninations) of thc subject
welfare of beings. cannot be considered as related to anything. Therefore
emptiness is their (true) mark, as far as the existence of
V 3. P 429a L. I xxvi 434' S ch' 48' Ad c\' 58'
the subjcct is concemed.
V, 4. Complete stabilisation. oJ throught' v' 4' V, 5c. The first false discritnination oJ the object. vv. B-9.
(The Sutra then says that it is perhaps possible) to The (first) false tliscrirnination of the objecto rvhich
measure a Four-Continent world systern' or a chiliocosul' refers to (the rvhole of) worldly activity, has been corxid-
or a di-chiliocosm, or a tri-chiliocosm (by comparison rvith ered in nine ways, with regard to
a tip of straw); (but not the abundance of merit derived l. its orvn-L 'ing (as rhe irnpossibility of understand-
the
from the thouglrt of a Bodhisattva rvho rejoices at irrg an absolutely isolated object by an absolutcly iso-
Ily
progressive spiritual achievements of a llodhisattva). Iated subject),
this abundance of its merits has been proclaimed (this 2. the lineage (insofar as it is not possible to discri-
to
complete stabilisation of thouglrt, which corresponds minate between the level of a Disciple, that of a Pratye-
is
the degree of Highest mundane dharmas, and which kabuddha, and that of a Bodhisattva who wishes to win
essentially) a state of meditative trance' full enlightenment),
3. the progress (which leads to) full attainment (in-
V 4. P 429o 'i- -4 xxvi 435' sofar as one cannot discriminate the di{Ierent stages of a
path which is just an illusory process);
V, 5. TIrc path oJ o-isiott (at its surnrnit)'
l B 0l
6. - If. CoNtr, j{ihinmnvnlotikir
EDWARD CONZ E
Ab h i Ea r n a y6 l a fi ki r a
4. the fact that one is not deceived about the object 4. the fact that one goes for help (and instruction)
of cognition (which one sees as a mere illusory apPearance' to outsiders (and not to the Tathagata),
like that of a reflected image). 5. the fact that one goes back on the program
(as
5. the points to be shunned and antidotes (in that outlined in f, 6),
one does not distinguish between rvhat is dear and undear, 6. (that one is content) rvith a liurited activity,
(in-
virtuous and faulty, to be given up or to be taken up)' sofar as one limits oneserf to the removar
of the eovering
6. one's own (spiritual) achievements? (which are not of the defile.nents);
apprehended), 7. the -rilfcrentiati'n (of one's spiritual achievement',
?.the(existenceofa)doer(inview ofthefactthat by falsely distingrrishing between the
first fruit, etc.),
the Bodhisattva is no more an agent than a magical creation B. the delusions about stantling anrl
setting out
of the Tathagata is), (which result from one's inability to forsake
alr the latent
B. thc activity (of the agent? which has no separate tendencies to ignorance),
reality), 9. the fact that one should pursue (the knowledge
9. the actions (of establishing all beings in Nirvana' -
of all modes only) afterwarcls (should not be tliscrimi-
through skill in means together with) their fruits, (insofar nated).
as the actions are performetl as if by a rnachine, rvhich V, 5 e. The f.rst Jalse tliscriminati,on ,I rhe
subject,
makes no discriminations). \rv. l3-14.
V, 5d. The second' discrimination' oJ the obiect' r-v' 10'12' The first (false discrimination of) the
subject (refers
The (second) false discrimination (of the object) refers to- the common people) (and assumes
that the s"lf, as a
to the alternative of withdrawal from activity, and arises subject, is a real srrbstantial e'tity.
'rhis ass'rnption is
in the minds of the Disciples, etc. It is nine-fold, with both stated and refuted f.om nine points
of view). It
regard to: should be known with regard to
l. the defi"ciency in (spiritual) achievement which
l. taking r.old of and rejection (which
fall are consid-
results when one allows becoming and quietude to ered both as they actually nre antl
ag they conventionally
apart, (whereas the combination of wisdom and compassion appear),
should lead to a unification of N'rvana and the samsaric 2. the (act of) attention (to perfect wisclom,
which
world); is in reality a non-attention),
i. th" absence of the assistance (given by the good 3. the adherenr.e to (tlifferent things which)
such belong
friend and by skill in means, to him who makes to the triple world, (in view of the fact
that in the true
discriminations); nature of dharma such differences do
not exist)o
3. the incompleteness of the progress (which fails to 4. the standing place (in view of the
fact that emp-
produce antidotes to all the coverings of the cognizable)' tiness oflers no standing place),
l82l
l 83l
EDWARD CONZ E Abhisamaydlatkera
5. (all inclinations towards) settling down (in existents 7. the absence of striving (for enlightenment
which
and in non-existents) (which are replaced by the refusal does not at all diller f.om nnlthing
else)o
to settle down anywhere), B. the absence of a cause (for enlightenment,
in ulti-
6. the concept of dharmas as (real) entities (which rnate reality),
should be given up), 9. the absence of the apprehension
of hostile forces
?. attachment (which is unsuitable with regard to (since no dharrna offers lr*i, for apprehension).
V, 5g. Tlnee reasons "
the cognition of true reality)r lor tlre attainmerrt of full enlighten-
B. (the di{ferences between) the antidotes (which are ment. v. 77.
not in keeping with the identity of their development (The path of visio' is connected
with trrree reasons for
everywhere), the attainrnent of full enlightenment
(by others), i.e.)
9. the impairment of bis ability to go wherever he t. (the establishment) of others in
enlightenment (as
wishes to go (as the result of his having rightly under' a_resu* of) the intlicario' (of
the path of i,i.iorr, etc. to
stood the true character of perfect wisdom). them);
Y, 5J. The second tJisuimination of the subject w. 15'16' 2. with that_ (i.e. enlightenment)
as cause (thcre is)
The second false discrimination of the subject (refers the errtrusting (of the perfectiorr
of wisdom to others,;,
to the holy persons' and assumes that the self, as 3. and, rvhen that (i.e. enlightenmerrt)
is rrninternrp-
a subject, is a conceptual entity. This assumption is tedly attained, (it acts as) the
cause (of abuntlant tleve-
both stated and refuted from nine points of view, i'"') lopment of perfect wisdom), rvrricrr
is markecr arr abuu-
with regard to dance of merit.
'y
l. thc not going'forth according to the Program V, 5[. The great enliglilernn,ettt.
v. l{1.
(which the Bodhisattva avoids), O1" calls enlightenment the tno
. cogrritions of the ex-
2. the accurate determination of what is the path tinction of the taints (i.c. of the
coverings of the rrefirernerrts
and what is rrot the path (which is impossible, as irnplying and of the cognizarrre)anrr of trreir
norr-pr'rr'ctio' (in trre
a diflercnce in attainments), futurc).
3. production and stoPPing' (which are non-existent), v' 5i' The cogrtition's oJ extircriort.
ort' oJ trcr-ltroductiorr,.
4. the conjunction and disjunction of (all) entities vv. 19-2I.
(which is untenablc), But these two shoul<l be cognizetl
in due order through
5. the standing (on the skandhas, which is devoid the a'sence of extinction autl
iir" ,rorr-"*istence of protluc-
of a real support' as with a bird flying in the air); tion (in all dharmas). since
t'e essential originar nature
6. the destruction of the lineage (of the Hinayana, (of dharmas) is not (in reality
ever) stopped, how could
which takes place by the productiorr of the thought of (the force of) the path of vision
extinguish trrat which has
enlightenment), been born by rvay of false
discrimination, or how courtr
l84 I l Bsl
EDIYARD CONZ E Abhisamay6latlcira
That (some) others in means). From the transeending of one, two, tlrree,
it reach (a state of) non-genesis?
of dharmas'
should teach on the one hand the existence four, Iive, six, seven, eiglrt (stations)r the attainment of
extinction of the the crownirrg (and victorious) assault (takes place), rvhich
and on the other hand th'e (completc)
of the Teacher
covering from the cognizable on the part moves incornparably until cessation.
(because the-two
(i.". tnl guaah*), th"t surprises me Y, 6b. The first tliscrimination. oJ thc object. vv,26, 27a,b.
be
t"u"hiog, contradict each oth'er)' Nothing should The first false tliscrirnination of the object has the
nothrng should aspects of errdeavour for its range, and (it is considered)
taken away from it (i.e. from emancipation)'
true reality' One
be atlded to it. It shoultl be seen in its with regard to:
he is liberated'
who sees the truly real as it truly is' l. the corrdcnscd (explanation of dharma),
of the six
V, str. The accomplishnten't o! the deuelopment 2. the detailed (explanation of dharma),
pertections. v.22. 3. the fact that he is not upheld by the Buddha's aid,
' jWUua i'e') giving'
is further saicl about the perfections' 4.-6. the non-existence of the virtuorrs qualities (which
mutual combina'
etc., each one singly, ancl in thcir (36) miglrt arise on the three levels of the path, i.e. the path
16) moments (of
tions, that belongl it one single (of the of training, the path of vision and the path of deveiop-
under (the moment ment) (because they cannot take place) irr any of the three
the path of vision), and it is comprised
of the dharma pcriods of time, (for the past has ceased to be, the pre-
of th" Patient) acceptance (of the cognition
it is understood in
of suffJring) on this path of vision (as sent never really arises, the future is not yet);
at its summit)' 7.-9. (and with regard to the cognition) of the three-
connection with the }ull understanding
y, il. Conilition'ed co-production' v' 23' fold good path,
trance (which is (7. the path of training, rvhich is practised with an
Having entered ot th* meditative
o'-The Lion's Sport o" (since he is now free from understanding of the calm quietude of the skandhas, of
called)
coverings)' he then
any fear about any of ih* tt"o kinds of their voidrress, insignificance and lack of solidity),
in direct and in
surveys conditioned co'production' both (8. the path of visiorr, ryherc onc aspircs frrr cmpti-
reverse order. ness),
V, 6. The Path oJ deueloPn'ent' (9. the path of developmenr, where one develops
Y, 6a. The ctowning assauh' w' 24'25' emptiness without attacltmentto scllarate entitics).
(beginning with Y, 6c, T'he second discriminution of the object. vv. Z,l c,
He has gone up the nine attainments
of the cessa- d-29.
the fi.rst trance), lncluding the attainment
he has come (down The second (false) discrimination (of the object) on the
tion (of feeling and perception), and
consciousness' path of development lr.as the proceeding of thought and
the same way), with the unconcentrated
his terminus (which its constituents for its range, and it is considered with
which belongs to the sensuous world' for
power of his skill regard to:
he includes in his trance tlrrough the
[86] l BT l
EDWARD CONZ E Allhisamaynlaikira
l. the non-production of the thought (of enlighten- 7. the (going-forth) on the triad of the vehicles (which
ment) (which is due to defi.ciencies with regard to the results from taking the skandhas as a basie),
good friend, etc.), B. the non-purity of his acceptance of the o{ferings
2. the non-attention to the terrace of enlighterurent' (of others, which results from not progressing co*ectly),
3.-4. the attention to the (two) inferior vehicles (be- 9. and the disturbance of his practices (which results
cause he clings to the methods of Disciples and Pratye- from taking the progress in giving, etc.? as a basis).
kabuddhas), Yo 6e. The second iliscriminatiort. oJ the subject w. JZ-J4.
5. the non-attention to full enlightenment (because The second (discrimination of the subject), connected
one is deficient in the practice of perfect wisdom)o with the path of development is (considered) as a poinr
6. the development (of perfect wisdom)o to be shunned arrd should be opposed by that (path of
?. the non-development (of perfect wisdom), development). It has for its cause and objectivc range
B. the reverse of both (i.e. neither development nor the fact that bei'gs are considered as conceptual (or nomi-
non-developmcnt), nal) entities. It is considered irr ninc way6, with regard
9. the fact that (its) objective reality is not consider- to the bewildermerrt about
ed as it really is (because one is inclined to perverted 1.-3. the threefold covering which covers the three
thinking). kinds of om'iscience, taken in due order (i.e. r. the krrorv-
Y, 6d. The f'rst iliscrimin'q,tiott' ol the nr,bject \rv. 30'31' ledge of all modes, 2. the knowledge of the paths, an<l 3.
The first (discrimination of the) subject should be all-knowledge, and rvhich results from non-comprehen-
known sion, respectively, of all modes, of all the paths, of all
l. as having for its range the conceptual existence entities);
of beings (because no real entity can possibly arise); 4. the (conditions governing thc) path of guietude,
2. with regard to the conceptual existence of dhar- 5. the conjunction with and the disjunction frorn,
mas (which are merely reflected images), and suchness, (the reality-limit, thc Dharma-clemento tlrrarr'as
3. the non'emPtiness of the dhannas (which consti- and skandhaso which are both inapplicable),
tute the knowledge of all modes, etc.); 6. the absence of a state of sarneness (when one can
4. as consisting essentially of attachment (to dhar- be interrupted by Mara, owi'g to not understanding his
mas) (which is counteracted by giving up the attempt to works)o
settle down anywhere), 7. the truths of Ill (origination, stopping antl path),
5. and of the investigation (into dharmas) (which B. the essential nature of the defilementso
leads to an understanding of their non-substantiality); 9. and, last of all, the (conditions rvhich govern the
6. it has further been proclaimed 'rvith regard to the existence of) non-dualityo (because one has not understood
effecting of (the exposition of) entities, that it consists in the absence of both object and subject).
IB B ] l Be l
EDW' ARD CONZ E Abhisar naydlar ikdr a
Ie0] Ie l ]
Abhisam aydlaikir a
EDWARD CONZ E
v ?. P 47gb 2-452b 5.
lezl Ie 3 ]
EDWARD CONZ E Abhisamaydlaik6ra
Ie4] Ies]
EDWARD CONZ E Abhisar nay6laikir a
YIII, 2. The Dlnrm,a'boilY. (vv. 2-11). (VIII, 2,7. The coneentrationwhich appeases. ,.
T).
(The 21 features of thc Dharma-body. vv. 2'6). (The meditative tra'ce) which appeases(the arising
of
The Dharma-bodY has been described as (associated the delilements in- others consists) with the Disciples
(in
with): that) they avoid the (generation of) defilements
in people
I. The (37) wings to enlightenment (beginrring with (on the occasion of their) being seen by them.
Oo th"
the pillars of mindfulness, and ending rvith the eightfold ,other hand the Jina's (meditative
trance) which appeases
path), (the defilements of others) (is distinguished)by
the l"oor-
2. the (four) Unlimited, plete) annihilation of the srream of (alr) those
defirements,
3. the (eight) emanciPations, on the occasion of their (entering) into a
village, etc.
4. the nine successive attairrments,
ten Deviceso
5. the (YIII, 2,8. The cognition *.hich results
from resolve).
bases of overcoming, divided into eight kinds'
6. the (". B).
7. (the rneditative trance) rvhich aPPeascs (the ari- The following are regarded as (the special features,
- not
sing of the defi.lements in others), found among the Disciples, of) the Buddhaos
cognition
B. the cognition wlr.ich results from resolve, which results from resolve: it does not turn
towards an
9. the (six) superknowledges, (external) object, it ie frce from altachmerrt,
u'orretruct-
10. the (four) analytical knowledges, ed,' alrides for ever, and is able to solve all
questioqs.
Ie6] l e 7I
? - li. CoNrF, ,lh|inmolnldnkn,t
EDWARD CONZ E
6.his,"",
::"1 "'
(The work of the Dharma-body' vv' 9'11)'
As thc cause (of thc factors of pcrfection
in the con-
ffi :":';il'
7. he has broad hcels;
verts) come to maturityo He manifests himself (in his B. his body is tall antl straight;
and whenever
great compassion) at that placeo wherever 9. his an-kle-joints are inco*-pi",.or.;
is absent' there
ili. n.tp is needetl. (But where the cause 10. the hairs on his botly point
upwardsl
thc Raingod
the fruit cannot aPPeax)' For aso even though ll. his shanks resemble those
of the antelope;
up (into rice'
may (send) rain, a rotten seed cannot grow 12. his arrns are long and powerful;
sPrung up'
etc.); so also, even though the Buddhas have 13. his sexual organ is covlere.l
by a sheath;
benefi'ts from
the unworthy are unable to gain (spiritual) 14. his skin Jras a golden hue,
(and)
the Buddha
them. From the abuntlance of his activity 15. is very delicate;
o all'pervading', and' because he never 16. the hairs on his body are
is thus described as well_gro.wn,each one
be ' eternal
becomes extinguishedo he is also declared to singly by itself, an<l they curl
to the right;
"
17. his face is adonred .rvith
u h"i._a.,ft (between
YIII 2. P 523b. S ch' 63' Ail c]n' 73' the eye-brows);
18. his trunk is like that of
a lion:
VIII, 3. The EnjoYmen't'BoilY' 19. his shouldersare gently
(Definition. v. 12) 20. the flesh in between his "r.r.r"dj
shoulder-blatlesis com.
the 32 marke
The (body of) the Sage which possesses pact;
andtheB0minorcharacteristicsisconsideredashisEn- 21. (even things which) raste
disagreeablyappear ro
joyment-Body, because it enjoys the happiness of the hirn as having a very fine taste;
(dharma of the) great vehicle' I his figure has a circumference
like that of the
, ?2.
(stately) fig tree;
(The 32 marks of the superman)' (w' 13-17)' 23. on his head there is a
cowl;
as follows:
The 32 marks (of the Lord Buddha) are tongue is long and slender;
depict' 11. ltr
l. He has, stamped on his hands and feet' lines 25. he has a divine voice,
and
ing a wheel; 26. jaws like a lion:
like those of) a tor- 27. his teeth are very rvhite.
2. his feet (are well'Planted
toise; 28. equal in size,
hands and
3. webs join the fingers and toes on his 29. rvithout any gaps (betrveen
them),
feet; 30. no less than 40 in number:
4. his hands antl feet are tender and soft; 3J. his cyes arc tlark_blrre.
and
5. his body has seven protuberancesl 32. his eye-lashesare like those
of a magnificentcow.
IeB ] Iee]
ED1 YARD CONZ E Ab h i 6 a m a yd l a i kd r a
l r00l l l 0l l
EDWARD CONZ E Abhisamaydlaikira
63. his eyes are (white and dark-blue) like the petals world of animals, c) the world of yama,
cJ) the world of
of the (blue) lotus; the Devas, e) the workl of men);
64. his eye-brorvs are extensive, 65' smootho 66' IIe enters orr
quite glossy, 67. with hairs of equal length; 2. the fourfold means of conversion:
68. his arms are long and muscularl 3. the understanding of defilement
and purification,
69. the tlvo ears are equal (in size), and 70' (his atri' (and uf)
lity to hear) is not impaired in any \'Yay; 4 . the true character of (his work
for) the weal of
71' his forehead is unwrinkled' (and) ?2' broad; beings, (which is carried out in the absenee
of truly real
73. his head is large; beings);
?4. the hair of his head is (as dark) as a black bee' 5. (the practice of) the six perfections;
?5. thick, ?6. smootb,77- not shaggy, ?B' not rough, 79' 6. the Buddha-path (which consists
of the l0 paths
with a fragrant smell r-hich captivates the hearts of men; of wholesome action);
80. (he has) the Srivatsa sign and the Svastika (on 7. (the practice of the insight into)
the emptiness
the palms of his hands and the soles of his feet)' of the essential nature (of all dliarmas),
B. (arrd of their) non-duality;
VIII 3. P 531c 1. 9. (the cognition of all dharmas) as
(being merely)
conventional symbols;
VIII, 4. The TransJormation'Body. (v' 33)' 10. (the iruight into) the absence
of the Sage is that (body) by of a basis in all
The Transformation-body dharmas;
which (in the shape of Sakyamuni, etc') he effects without ll.
the maturing of living beings (through
interruption his various benefits to the world (of living in means);
his skill
beings) until the end of (samsaric) becoming' 12' the pat' of a Bodhisatrva (as distinct
- from thar
of the Disciples);
VIII 4. P 536b 4.
13' (the systematic e{fort to) brock
. (all) incrination
VIII, 5. The Junctiorls of the Dhanna-body' (r'v' 3a-40)' (to make realistic assumptions);
Thereupon (the Sutra) considers his activity (i'"' that 14. the attainment of enlightenment;
of the Dharma-body which acts by means of the Transfor- 15. (a reside.nce in various) pure
Buddha-fields;
mation-body, and) which (goes on) without irrterruption 16. (the condition where, as tied to
one more birth
as long as the samsaric world lasts. This work of the only, he is) bound to (win enJightenment
soon);
Dharma-body has been considered in 27 ways: 17. (working) the weal of countless
beings;
f. (He performs) the activity which appeases the IB. the virtuous acts which consist
in ten-rling, etc.,
(five difierent) places of rebirth (i'e. c) the hellso b) the the Buddhas;
ll02l l l o3l
EDWARD CONZ E . Abhisam ayilaikI r a
l r04l l l Os l
EDIVARD CONZ E Abhisar nayI lar ikir a
[106] ll07l