Documentos de Académico
Documentos de Profesional
Documentos de Cultura
IE
Volume29 Number3
March 1990
Pages 223-328
An overview of the importance of and methods available for heat storage in the form of
sensible and latent heat is followed by a discussion of the advantages and disadvantages of
reversible thermochemical energy storage compared to conventional energy sources such as
fuels, i.e. irreversible chemical energy carriers. Of the reversible metal-hydride-metal systems,
the MgH,-Mg system is particularly attractive as a hydrogen and a high-temperature heat
storage material because of its high hydrogen content and the high energy content of the
Mg-H bond. The advances made in this area over the past few years, namely in catalytic
hydrogenation and the doping of magnesium powders, have led to the development of “active
MgH,-Mg systems” for energy storage. The first experimental results on high-temperature
heat storage (also with cooling) by coupling a MgH,-Mg storage system with a low-temper-
ature metal hydride storage system are presented.
1. Introduction the use of fossil fuels in favor of other energy sources, such
as nuclear power, water power and wind power; 2) intelli-
For thousands of years--ever since the discovery of fire- gent, more economical energy consumption;“] 3) the search
mankind has conveniently satisfied its energy needs by burn- for, and use of energy storage systems which obtain their
ing wood or fossil fuels, thus liberating, in the form of high energy from a primary energy source, e.g. from the sun, and
grade heat, solar energy which had been stored chemically whose energy transformations occur in a closed cycle and
for years (or millions of years) by photosynthesis. The energy hence are environmentally unobjectionable.[’’ The following
problem currently facing us primarily arises from an incorri- review article describes, inter alia, an experimental chemical
gible disparity between the storage of solar energy in nature contribution to the last of these three possibilities.
and our energy consumption, which will lead, on the one
hand, to a serious shortage of fossil fuels and, on the other,
most probably to a climatic change through a build-up of 2. The Importance of Energy and Heat Storage,
carbon dioxide in the atmosphere (“greenhouse-effect”). especially of High-Temperature Heat Storage r31
This problem may be resolved, however, by: 1) reduction of
The necessity of energy storage in general, and of heat
[*I Prof. Dr. B. Bogdanovii, DipLIng. B. Spliethoff storage in particular, arises from the fact that there is a
Max-Planck-Institut fur Kohlenforschung temporal and intensity mismatch and also a spatial separa-
Kaiser-Wilhelm-Platz 1, D-4330 Mulheim an der Ruhr 1 (FRG)
tion between the energy supply from an available energy
Dr. A. Ritter
Max-Planck-Institut fur Strahlenchemie source and our need or consumption of energy. Energy stor-
Stiftstrasse 34-36, D-4330 Mulheim an der Ruhr 1 (FRG) age can offset this incongruity, improve the efficiency of an
Angew Chem. / n l . Ed. Engl. 29 (1990) 223-234 8 VCH Verlugsgesellschaj’i mbH. 0.6940 Weinheim, 1990 0570-0833/90j0303-0223 $02.50/0 223
energy supply system and hence reduce the energy costs. energy is sufficient to produce an amount of warm water
Consequently, energy storage is a major factor in energy equivalent to that requiring approximately 10 000 L of heat-
saving and conservation. The storage of energy from a peri- ing oil, i.e., an amount which is more than adequate for
odic or intermittent energy source, such as the sun, is of heating a household during the winter. If one could make use
prime importance. of this energy in all of the households in the FRG, then up
The type and magnitude of the mismatch between energy to ca. 40% of the currently consumed primary energy could
supply and need are exemplified in Figure 1.[41 Figure 1 (a) be saved.
shows the case of constant energy supply with, however, a The amount of warm water whose energy content on
brief peak load which must be covered by energy storage. In cooling from, e.g., 90” to 40°C corresponds to that of
case (b), the energy supply is periodic (solar energy), while 10000 L of heating oil has however, in the ideal case, i.e.
the energy requirement remains constant; a significant part without heat storage loss, a volume of 1724 m3. This is far
of the energy must, therefore, be stored during daytime in larger than the volume of an average one-family house. Be-
order to cover the needs at any time. Finally, when energy cause of the unavoidable heat losses which constantly occur
supply and demand are out of phase, as in (c), the total due to insulation problems, the volume of the warm-water
energy requirement must be stored (e.g., nocturnal indoor storage tank would have to be substantially larger. Thus, it
heating via solar heat). is immediately apparent that the, as yet, unsolved problem of
The potential significance of heat storage, is impressively seasonal heat storage is the main reason why solar radiation
demonstrated by the fact that sufficient solar energy could be can presently play only an insignificant role as a source
collected on the roof of a building during the summer for of energy, particularly in more northerly latitude^.[^.^]
covering the heating requirements of the building during the An important aspect in connection with the amount of
winter (Fig. 2). In the case of a typical one-family house in stored heat, namely the quality of the energy, or the so-called
Germany with a roof surface of 100 m2-either facing south “exergy”, should not be overlooked. Heat energy can be
or oriented horizontally (flat roof)-an average incident so- converted into other forms of energy with good Carnot effi-
lar radiation of lo5 kWhC5]could be collected per year. This ciency, e.g. mechanical or electrical energy, but only above
Borislav BogdanoviC was born in 1934 in Navi Sad, Yugoslavia and studied chemistry at the
University of Belgrade. He gained his doctorate in 1962 under the supervision of G. Wilke at the
Technische Hochschule Aachen. Since 1960 he has been working at the Max-Planck-lnstitut fur
Kohlenforschung in Miilheim an der Ruhr, where he is now head of a catalysis department.
BogdanoviC habilitated in 1974 at the Universitat Bochum where he was awarded a professorship
in 1976. His research interests center on organometallic chemistry and catalysis and its applica-
tions in organic and inorganic synthesis; in 1986 he was awarded the Ruhrpreis fur Kunst und
Wissenschaft der Stadt Miilheim an der Ruhr for his more recent works on the storage of energy
with the MgH,-Mg system.
Alfred Ritter was born in 1928 in Rottweil am Neckar and studied chemistry at the Technische
Hochschule Stuttgart (where he gained his doctorate under L. Birkofer). Thereafter he worked
as a scientific assistant at the Universitat Koln and was engaged in research on organosilicon
reactions in organic synthesis. In 1963 he was awarded a fellowship grant by the Dow Corning
Corporation (Midland, Michigan) for research with L. H. Sommer at the Pennsylvania State
University. Since 1964 he has been in charge of a research group at the Max-Planck-lnstitut fGr
Strahlenchemie in Miilheim an der Ruhr. His current interests center on the radiation chemistry
of organosilicon compounds and reversible chemical reactions for the storage of solar energy.
Bernd Spliethoff was born in 1953 in Oberhausen and completed his training as a laboratory
technician at the Max-Planck-lnstitut fur Kohlenforschung in Miilheim an der Ruhr. In 1971 he
won the Bundeskanzler’s Prize f o r young scientists in the open competition “Jugend forscht ”.
Since completing his studies in engineering science at the Gesamthochschule Essen in 1975 he has
been working at the Max-Planck-lnstitut fur Kohlenforschung. He has participated right from
the beginning in the development ofactive MgH,-Mg systems as energy storers; he has developed
measuring instruments and measuring techniquesfor the characterization oftheir storage proper-
ties.
Table 1. Frequently used liquid and solid materials for the storage of sensible
heat [3 a, b] .
[a] Average density in the temperature range Dven. [b] Some thermo-oils can be
used up to 390°C. [c] Wt.%. [dl At room temperature.
6- 18W 6-
t-
Fig. 1. Energy available from store a,which balances out the mismatch be- A further basic method for reversible heat storage consists
tween energy supply (. - .) and need (-): a) constant energy supply, short peak in storing the heat evolved in a solid-liquid phase transition
period: b) constant energy requirement, variable (periodic) energy supply dur-
ing a half-day cycle; c) phase shift between energy supply and need; the entire
process in the form of latent heat. The advantage over the
energy need is covered by stored energy [3a] (reproduced by kind permission of storage of sensible heat is the higher energy density and that
Kluwer Academic Publishers). the temperature remains constant during the heat storage
and heat recovery processes. In contrast to the systems for
the storage of sensible heat, those for the storage of latent
300-400 “C. Consequently, energy storage systems must be heat are still at an early stage of development. A list of
developed, not only for low-temperature heat (LT) but also possible materials for this purpose is given in Table 2.
for high-temperature heat (HT).
An example of the spatial separation between energy
supply and need, is provided by electrical power plants, Table 2. Data for several potential latent heat stores [3a, b].
which produce large amounts of low-grade waste heat, but
M.p. Heat of fusion
owing to the distances between supply and consumer, often [“CI [kJ kg-’1
only part of this heat can be economically used for domestic
Salt hydrates 0- 150 100-300
heating (“power-heat-coupling”). Parafins 20-65 150- 200
LiOH 471 1080
LiF 848 1050
48 NaCI/52 MgCI, [a] 450 43 1
67LiF/33MgF2 [a] 741 900
67NaF/33MgF2 [a] 832 618
1 24.5NaC1/20.5 KClj55 MgCl, [a] 385-393 410
/
,
/ [a] Wt.%.
/
The demand for high energy content per unit weight and
volume especially in the case of mobile energy carriers,I71as
well as high exergetic quality and constant temperature, to-
gether with an unlimited storability of the stored energy,
usually can only be satisfied by chemically stored energy, i.e.,
J F M A M J J A S O N D by fuels and not by sensible heat. An advantage of chemical-
t- ly stored energy is its direct transformability not only into
Fig. 2. Utilizable solar energy and heating energy needs in summer and winter. heat, but also into other forms of energy with high efficiency
-rooftop solar energy, - - - heating energy need. (e.g., into electrical energy via fuel cells). The basic proce-
AS
ods" 'I are still a t an early stage of development.
In the following, we will concentrate on the problems of
heat storage. Its importance becomes immediately apparent It therefore follows that the turning temperature T* does not
through the fact that, apart from the fossil energy sources, exceed a certain value, and high energy densities (cf. A m can
the major remaining primary energy sources-nuclear ener- only be achieved if the reaction proceeds with large entropy
gy and solar energy-Aeliver their energy in the form of changes (As).[*,16] The highest entropy changes occur in
high-quality heat o r in the form of electromagnetic radiation dissociation reactions with gaseous reaction products and
which can immediately be converted into high-quality heat. with large differences in the number of moles of starting
Independent of the fact, whether nuclear or solar energy is materials and reaction products [see, e.g., Eq. (d)].[161
the primary energy source, it is necessary to search for new,
reversible (i.e., closed), ecologically compatible cycles for
In these reactions the turning temperature T* is relatively In view of the many criteria, it is obvious that the choice
low and in addition the different aggregation states allow of the reactions must involve compromises.
simple separation of A from B. The thermodynamical and Some examples of the best-known types of reactions which
technical advantages of heterogeneous vaporization are have been suggested for reversible thermochemical heat stor-
counterbalanced by the disadvantage of the considerable in- age or which are presently being investigated are given in
crease in volume, which lowers the volumetric energy density Table 4. Of the catalytic gas dissociation reactions, the disso-
of the total system (for a solution of this problem in the case ciation of SO, to SO, and 0, (Solchem process) and the
of the MgH,-Mg system, see Section 6). dissociation of NH, to give N, and H, have been particular-
The energetic and thermodynamic factors are not the sole ly well investigated or considered as reversible reactions for
factors which are important for the choice of reactions for the storage of solar energy. The technically mature NH,
reversible heat(energy)storage. Other criteria such as the fol- dissociation (catalysis of forward and reverse reaction, sepa-
lowing may also be important or even decisive: ration of the reactants, corrosiveness and toxicity) is consid-
ered to be less problematic than that of SO,
- complete reversibility of the reaction over a large number The thermal dissociation of NH,HSO, is a potential candi-
of cycles, i.e., no side reactions and hence no loss of stor- date for energy storage because of the high energy density
age capacity; and relatively low reaction temperature. The Eva-Adam
- excellent kinetics of the heat storage and recovery process- process now being operated on a pilot-plant scale at the
es; long stability and activity of the catalyst in the case of nuclear research center Jiilich (West Germany) is based on
catalytic reactions; the known steam reforming of methane to CO and H, . This
- possibility of stopping or controlling the heat producing process was developed for the transportation of nuclear reac-
process by separation of the components from each other tor heat to distant users according to the principle of the
or from the catalyst; chemical heat pipe.[' 91
- minimal heat loss by thermal radiation; Because of the necessity of complete reversibility, i.e., ab-
- heat storage and recovery in desired temperature ranges; sence of side reactions, the organic chemical reactions that
- as constant and controllable as possible a temperature were considered, apart from the methane reforming reaction,
during the heat recovery process; included only the reversible catalytic dehydrogenations of
- simple realization and low processing costs; cyclohexane, methyl cyclohexane, and ethane to benzene,
- no (or only minor) hysteresis effects; low temperature dif- toluene, and ethene, respectively.[201
ferences between storage and recovery, i.e., minimal exer- All of the remaining reactions in Table4 belong to the
gy loss; category of heterogeneous vaporization reactions. Of the
Table 4. Several potential reversible reactions for the thermochemical energy storage [3a, b].
Table 5 . Data for several energy stores used as reversible metal hydride-metal systems.
FeTiH, ,,-FeTi
LaNi,H6-LaNi,
1.8
14
0.1
0.09
3.5 bar/20"C
2 bar/20 "C
28 Ibl
32
- 300
200
2200
1700
Mg,NiH4-MgzNi 3.8 0.08 1 bar1245 "C 65 1260 4600
MgHz-Mg 76 0.1 1 bar1284"C 75 3079 9000
[a] Density of the hydride calculated from X-ray structure analyses. [b] Valid for the reaction FeTiH, ,-FeTiH,
The work began with the so-called homogeneous cataly- The Mg powder (270 mesh) doped with 2 wt.-% of nickel
synthesis of magnesium hydride.f391The superior ki- and obtained in this way proved to be suitable as a hydrogen
netics of the dehydrogenation of magnesium hydride which and heat storage material in numerous tests and it is used at
had been prepared by homogeneous catalysis (referred to as the present time as a standard material in our experiments
MgHT from here on), and the hydrogenation of the active described below. The standard material has the following
magnesium (Mg*)[33.401obtained from it, prompted our in- properties:
vestigations on their use as energy stores. Furthermore,
- reversible hydrogen contents of 6-6.5 wt.-%,
MgHT and Mg* found useage as reagents in organic and
- satisfactory and complete display of the kinetics after the
inorganic syntheses because of their high rea~tivity!~']They
first hydrogenation,
have also been employed for the preparation of intermetallic
- stability over a long period, demonstrated by extended
compounds and their hydrides and carbides via non-metal-
testing in a closed system through 1800 cycles,
lurgic routes.[42]In the following, we shall review more re- - very little absorption-desorption and an al-
cent developments in the area of energy storage (for earlier
most horizontal plateau in the concentration-pressure
work, see Ref. [33]). isotherm (cf. Fig. 4),
The high chemical reactivity of MgHT is considered to be
- relatively good heat conductivity of the solid MgH,-Mg
due to its generation in an inert atmosphere in the form of
storage bed during the hydrogenation and dehydrogena-
microcrystals (0.05 pm) with an oxide-free and high specific tion (Fig. 5).14']
surface area (70-180 m2 g- 1).[4'1 Other possible reasons for
the superior dehydrogenation-rehydrogenation kinetics of A further improvement of the H,-storage capacity and of
MgHT include the defects in the crystal lattice caused by the long term stability as well as the economic optimization
impurities such as MgO and MgCI, and the catalytic effect of the storage material production are currently being at-
of the transition metals (Ti, Cr)r431resulting from the te- tempted.[481
trahydrofuran-soluble hydrogenation catalysts which re- Our present research in the area of energy storage is fo-
main in the solid. In order to test this effect, the influence of cused on the use of active MgH,-Mg systems as high temper-
doping MgH? with small amounts of transition metals was ature heat stores.@,291 A heat store based on MgH,, operat-
studied using the transition metals in the form of soluble ing on the principle shown in Equation(g), consists
organometallic complexes or compounds and assessing the essentially of a pressure-proof container interconnected with
effect on the dehydrogenation-rehydrogenation. It was a second container for the intermediate storage of the de-
fl
Fig. 5. Top: opened cylindrical MgH,-Mg experimental heat store with an
internal diameter of 70 mm which can be heated or cooled externally. During
the dehydrogenation, which proceeds from the outside to the inside, as does the
heat flow. the reaction was stopped, so that two cylindrical zones were present
in the store. The slightly abraded material clearly shows an outside metallic
Circulation
shining ring made of magnesium, and an inner ring consisting of MgH,. The
middle of the store has a sinter metal pipe for delivering and withdrawing
hydrogen. The irregularities within the outer ring are due to the difficulties
, I
Thermostat
MgH,-Mg system during the chemicai reaction can be determined when using
an empirical formula. This is characterized by the various single conductivities
of the MgH,-Mg material combinations which are formed from the initially
pure educts MgH, or Mg, respectively, and which are separated by the reaction
zone which always moves from the outside to the inside. Bottom: From the
narrow width of the reaction zone and the temperature jump which occurs
there, it can be concluded that the chemical reaction rate must be greater than
the rate of the heat transportation. In the inverse case, the reaction zone should
be spread over the entire width of the tube filling [47].