Documentos de Académico
Documentos de Profesional
Documentos de Cultura
Industry Definition This industry provides advice and human resource policies. This industry
assistance to businesses and other does not contain information technology
organisations on management issues, or computer consultancy and accounting
such as strategic and organisational firms, which significantly lowers
planning, financial planning and revenue and establishment estimates
budgeting, marketing objectives and from other sources.
Industry at a Glance
Management Consultants in 2010
% change
Holdings (Australia) 4 9.0
p. 4 28.2%
VIC SOURCE: WWW.IBISWORLD.COM.AU
SOURCE: WWW.IBISWORLD.COM.AU
For additional statistics and time series see the appendix on page 36
www.ibisworld.com.au Management Consultants in Australia September 2010 4
Industry Performance
Executive Summary | Key External Drivers | Current Performance
Industry Outlook | Life Cycle Stage
Key External Drivers Capital expenditure by private sector Pervasive outsourcing for
When capital expenditure by the private financial functions
sector is considered a proxy for the Attempts by governments and businesses
general level of confidence among to concentrate on their core strengths
businesses, it serves as a key indicator and functions, and lower staff and
of the performance of management associated overheads, has had them move
consultants. As business confidence and towards outsourcing (or buying in)
profits rise, the capacity and desire to expertise from specialist firms. This can
bring in external experts to advise on either replace or supplement some of the
expansion or restructuring plans in-house resources and functions.
become greater.
www.ibisworld.com.au Management Consultants in Australia September 2010 5
Industry Performance
Key External Drivers Business outsourcing in the public sector at ensuring greater efficiency
continued Government is an increasingly common
user of outsourced services – any Globalisation of business
sporadic work conducted by government management services
offices can be limited by bringing in Global operation of major corporations
contracted staff. In the case of has led to a demand for globally linked
management consultants, government companies in this industry.
policy- and decision-making is made
easier if relevant research has been Number of businesses
conducted by an impartial third party. The number of businesses, and particularly
Also, internal reviews of operations and new medium and large ones, increases the
procedures are regularly outsourced to demand for consultancy services, much of
consultants, as their impartiality is aimed which has now been outsourced.
18.0 6.75
5.75
13.5
4.75
% change
% change
9.0 3.75
2.75
4.5
1.75
0.0 0.75
Year 04 06 08 10 12 14 16 Year 03 05 07 09 11 13 15
SOURCE: WWW.IBISWORLD.COM.AU
Still standing The industry’s robust profit margins in offerings to more simplified services for
the past offered a substantial buffer struggling clients in 2009, after
against the slowdown experienced as spending many years providing more
clients tightened their budgets. The complicated business solutions to aid in
industry has routinely exhibited double- growth. The cost of retaining skilled
digit profit margins, and these were cut employees whose skills may not have
to around 8.0% of revenue in 2009. translated to a recession environment
Many consultancies adjusted their also ate into margins.
www.ibisworld.com.au Management Consultants in Australia September 2010 6
Industry Performance
Still standing Over the five years through 2010-11, strategy planning
continued real industry revenue is expected to However, while the big firms have
increase to $7.08 billion, at an average been strong over the past few years, the
real rate of 2.0% per year. While the number of small firms in the industry has
previous two years were weak due to a increased. Many consultancies have
decrease in business spending, this trimmed staff, or focused on employing
appears to be only a momentary blip as consultants with expertise in change
stronger growth is set to resume in the management, meaning many specialists
coming year. Business confidence, while found themselves unemployed. It appears
not surging, is set to grow steadily as that many of these consultants started
economic signs become more positive. their own small firms (using existing
Larger firms were able to weather the contacts) as a means to ride out the
downturn by tailoring their services to current downturn. Despite slow revenue
clients’ needs, however small growth the number of consultancies in
consultancies (due to their niche the industry is estimated to have
operating nature) were without the increased by 2.6% in 2008-09 and 2.4%
necessary skills to assist with downsizing in 2009-10.
Industry Performance
Consulting KPMG sold its consulting operations become more interested in providing
consolidation (which was renamed Bearing Point), Ernst start-to-finish assistance, the need to
& Young signed a non-compete agreement have IT skills has grown.
continued
with French firm Capgemini and Correspondingly, IT consultancies
PricewaterhouseCoopers’ consulting work have become interested in developing the
was absorbed into IBM’s global operations. strategies they once helped to implement.
Deloitte was the only firm to remain in the As such, IT consultants and management
industry and has established itself as a consultants are finding themselves more
market leader. The three other firms are often in competition with each other.
facing a highly competitive marketplace. Many of the major players in these
Arthur Anderson (now rebadged as industries have become so intertwined
Accenture) has developed a strong that they struggle to differentiate their
foothold in the industry, with its greater various consulting operations.
focus on IT solutions. This trend has emerged during the
This is the other great shift to occur in past five years and is likely to be
the industry in recent years. At one point, exacerbated by the current downturn.
IT consultancy and management Companies will look to increase
consultancy were distinctly different economies of scale by offering a full
business propositions. However, today it service for clients including assessment,
is increasingly apparent that IT skills are advising, implementation and post-
critical in implementing strategic or payment assistance. This will mean that a
change-management processes. As greater meshing of IT and management
management consulting firms have consulting activities will be required.
Fierce competition Increasing competition from other strategy and risk management. As the
industries providing consultancy services economy has turned down, the level of
has led to reductions in fees in recent differentiation has dropped markedly.
years, causing some minor reduction in Today, companies offer similar services
revenue. Also, during the earlier part of centred on aiding cost-cutting activities.
the past five years, consultancies focused As such, competition is based on
on developing proprietary methods of price comparisons, driven by cost-
evaluating and advising on change conscious clients.
Industry Performance
Redundant
Profit vs. wages Employees per establishment
consultants get
competitive 12.50 8.0
continued 7.7
6.25
7.4
% change
Ratio
0.00 7.1
6.8
−6.25
6.5
−12.50 6.2
Year 02 04 06 08 10 12 14 16 Year 02 04 06 08 10 12 14 16
Profit Wages
SOURCE: WWW.IBISWORLD.COM.AU
Industry Performance
Consulting becomes stronger economic growth over the next are likely to take an active role in the
more popular five years will increase industry activity, development and implementation of the
demand, revenue, and external national broadband network, which will
continued
competition. Furthermore, consultants place millions of dollars into the industry.
Hitting the bottom In terms of the management consultancy important and in many cases a key
line component, the major growth areas are reason behind a company’s choice of
currently in training and productivity management consultant firm. The
improvement; skills audits; enterprise balance of work in the consulting area
bargaining implementation; right-sizing has tended to shift more towards
of businesses and building on core technical consulting (and
activities and competitive strengths; total implementation) and away from
quality management; advising on and management and strategic consulting.
implementing world’s best practices; and This shift towards a more holistic
to a lesser extent on information service offering is indicative of an
technology strategies. industry that is beginning to run out of
Other important areas for management new markets. Without new potential
consultants are in providing information clients the competition is peaking in the
system; financial and administrative form of denying competitors as much
services; and strategic, corporate and market share as possible. This will be
business planning. As part of the most notable in the major players’
industrial structural adjustment occurring balance sheets. Offering wide-ranging
in Australia, many companies are seeking services across varying industries and
advice on investment opportunities in skill sets is a costly enterprise, and these
Australia and internationally, and in firms will be willing to eat into their own
implementing world’s best practice margins to hamper competitors’ growth.
techniques in their companies to ensure Profit margins have historically been as
long-term financial viability. high as 20% industry wide, and have
Increasingly, consultants are being hovered around 16% for much of the past
asked to assist in implementing their two decades. This trend appears to be at
recommendations and to monitor and an end due to the cost-cutting of the
evaluate the progress of that global downturn.
implementation. The emphasis therefore In 2010-11, profit is expected to be
is not only to offer solutions but also to only 10% of revenue and while this is
assist the client in their implementation. expected to pick up again as corporate
In some cases this has involved helping spending lifts, the high cost of doing
clients find finance for new or expansion business in the new market will ensure
ventures. Emphasis is on providing that the new average profit level will be
quality service and helping clients to lower. Figures closer to the low teens are
implement the recommendations. expected as increasing competition from
However, helping clients to implement IT Consultants and Managed Service
recommendations, which from the providers, whose computing expertise
perspective of the consulting firm may be threatens one of the industry’s growth
seen as work with low return and high sectors, couples with the existing
input, is increasingly being seen as competitive industry pressures.
www.ibisworld.com.au Management Consultants in Australia September 2010 10
Industry Performance
Industry Performance
Life Cycle Stage While the industry may be growing internationally,
the Australian industry is in its maturity
Increasing globalisation has led to a broader
geographic spread internationally, but is
leading to moderate growth in Australia
External competition is increasing, and is expected
to continue to become more prominent
Competition is increasingly based on price, particularly
among smaller players, leading to lower revenue growth
Mining
20
15
Engineering
Quantity Growth
Consultancy Many new companies;
Services minor growth in economic
importance; substantial
10 technology change
5 Consumer
Goods
retail
Computer Consultancy Services
0
Management
Computer Consultants
Shakeout
and related
Equipment Mfg
Shakeout
–5
Industry Performance
Products & Services Over the last five years, there has been (like Accenture), will likely increase the
continued minimal change in the product presence of IT consulting services,
segmentation in the industry, and possibly resulting in a minor increase in
IBISWorld expects no significant changes the revenue share of the general business
over the next five years. Growing management consulting services
competition from external sources, such segment, which is already the industry’s
as information technology consultants primary product.
8.7%
Marketing management
consulting services
43.7%
General business management
consulting services
15.7%
Human resource management
consulting services
19%
Other management
Total $7.1bn consulting services
SOURCE: WWW.IBISWORLD.COM.AU
Demand potential future losses, the employment of sector is the industry’s largest client base.
Determinants consultants is predominantly viewed as a As such, the strong growth that that sector
cost incurred when a company is has experienced has been instrumental in
continued
performing well, and looking to expand driving growth among management
service offerings, or is looking to deal with consultancies. Other sectors that drive
the difficulties inherent in expansion. As industry growth include Federal and State
such, growing business profits routinely Governments and the Retail sector, which
influence growth in the industry. increasingly looks to consultants to aid in
The Banking, Finance and Insurance supply chain management.
Major Markets The industry mainly obtains its revenue best practice.
from the business and government This sector segment of the industry’s
sectors as part of their consulting market is falling as governments and
budgets. IBISWorld estimates that other industries become more inclined to
around 77.4% of the revenue is derived outsource assistance in management
from the business sector, 60% of which is decision making and implementation. It
derived from the banking, finance and is still the largest segment in the
insurance industry (which equates to industry, at 46.4% of revenue, and is
46.4% of total industry revenue), and the almost certain to remain so for the
remainder from government at all levels, foreseeable future. However, as the
primarily state and federal. acceptance of management consulting
Demand from the business sector has economy-wide grows, it is likely to
fluctuated in line with economic assume a slightly diminished role as the
conditions and business confidence. dominant market segment.
However, demand has been increasing in Historically, the management
areas associated with business re- consulting industry has relied heavily on
engineering, increasing labour firms in the finance and insurance sector
productivity and skills. Globalisation has for income, but companies across all
also spurred demand – in terms of sectors are increasingly becoming
import competition, export development inclined to invest more heavily in
and investment, mergers and consulting services such as supply chain
acquisitions, technology use, access and management, customer relationship
transfer and achieving overall world’s management, human performance
6.8%
State Governments
15.8%
46.4%
Federal Government
Finance, Banking
and Insurance Sector
31%
All other
private businesses
Major Markets management, strategy, and finance and decisions and management of the public
continued performance management. This segment service. IBISWorld expects this to continue
has thus increased in prevalence in its over the five years through 2015-16,
share of industry spending, up to 31.0%, moderately increasing its share of industry
from 25.2% five years ago. revenue generation, most likely at the
Over recent years, state governments expense of the banking, finance and
have increased their expenditure on insurance sector, which may reduce
consultancy outsourcing, both on policy consulting costs as the economy slows.
NT
0.5
QLd
8.9
wA
10.1
SA
2.8
NSw
40.3
ACT
5.7
VIC
31.0
revenue (%)
Cold Zone (<10) TAS
0.7
<25
<50
Hot Zone (<100)
Not applicable
SOURCE: WWW.IBISWORLD.COM.AU
www.ibisworld.com.au Management Consultants in Australia September 2010 18
50 50
40 40
Percentage
Percentage
30 30
20 20
10 10
0 0
ACT
NSW
NT
QLD
SA
TAS
VIC
WA
ACT
NSW
NT
QLD
SA
TAS
VIC
WA
Revenue Revenue
Population Establishments
SOURCE: WWW.IBISWORLD.COM.AU
www.ibisworld.com.au Management Consultants in Australia September 2010 20
Competitive Landscape
Market Share Concentration | Key Success Factors | Cost Structure Benchmarks
Basis of Competition | Barriers to Entry | Industry Globalisation
Market Share While there are numerous widely-known the lower end of the industry for local
Concentration and reputable management consultancies government and small- to medium-sized
operating in Australia, the industry is business contracts. The ease with which
highly fragmented due to the sheer volume small players can enter the market, and the
Level
of small firms operating on a highly high capacity for providing niche services
Concentration in specific skill or regional basis. The ease are prime drivers of such a fragmented
this industry is Low with which a consultancy can be started industry. Another 1,408 establishments
means that any individual with the have 20 or more employees, including 83
requisite skills can enter the industry at a with more than 200 staff, which highlights
moment’s notice. As the industry has the divide between large and small firms.
broadened its services – specialising in In 2008-09 and 2009-10, it is likely
individual industries as opposed to broad that the industry will see brief spike in
strategic skills – individuals with skills in the number of sole proprietors and
certain industries may enter as well. For partnerships, as consultants made
example, a former telecommunications redundant during restructuring look to
executive may act as a subcontractor to establish their own firms. This will cause
many telecommunications companies. The a small increase in industry
recession in 2009 saw many skilled fragmentation, however, it is likely to be
workers losing their jobs, and for many, short lived, as other small firms may be
consulting acts as an effective interim step. acquired by larger consultancies during
As a result, the industry’s major their restructuring.
players account for less than 15% of Over the five years through 2015-16,
industry revenue. Competition between the level of concentration in the
these players is fierce, but the divide Management Consultants industry will
between major players and smaller firms continue to increase, as major
is stark. The largest firms, while corporations increase their emphasis on
controlling 15% of revenue, only mergers and acquisitions. The sale of the
represent 8.0% of establishments, major accounting firms’ consulting arms
indicating that the average size of offices to existing consulting firms is a prime
for the large firms is markedly greater. example of this tendency to increase
concentration. Despite low barriers to
Recession boosts small firms entry, the rate at which small players
The industry has two extremes, one being enter the industry is expected to slow as
that 98.4% of establishments expect to the market becomes saturated to the
have 19 or fewer employees. These small point that there is insufficient clientele
groups engage in intense competition at for prospective consultants.
Competitive Landscape
Key Success Factors Access to the latest available and most Ability to effectively
continued efficient technology and techniques communicate and negotiate
Access to the latest and appropriate To have strong presentation skills in
computer software and hardware, relation to client report presentations
maximum labour productivity and to and for tenders is a key success factor for
have support as a key success factor is companies in this industry.
needed to be successful in this industry.
Cost Structure After furious cost-cutting in 2009, revenue, demonstrating the industry’s
Benchmarks margins in the industry will benefit in labour intensive nature. Work performed
2010-11, expanding to 10% of revenue. by the industry, while beginning to focus
Low levels of capital input and operating more on the implementation of
expenses mean that once project fees recommendations, still primarily revolves
cover the wages of consultants being around the provision of advice, for which
employed, much of the remainder is the cost of expert labour remains pre-
considered profit. Depreciation, quite low eminent. Among the industry’s major
at 3.0% of revenue, reflects the low firms, wage pressures are often not as
capital expenditure the industry incurs. high, as effective management of staff
Beyond standard office equipment and and project assignments, coupled with
computers there are no compulsory greater economies of scale, can improve
capital costs. staff efficiency.
In general, labour costs are the Beyond ordinary wages, the industry is
industry’s predominant cost, at 55% of beginning to invest more in outside
−
L7713 Office Property Operators
Costs for operators in the Management Consultants industry are affected by the price of goods and
services from supplier industries. IBISWorld has estimated the trends of key input prices over the
previous five years and for the coming five years. is good news for this industry as IBISWorld
•
expects the price of key inputs to fall; shows where this industry is negatively affected as IBISWorld
-
expects the price of key inputs to rise; means price changes will not be a key issue for the industry.
SOURCE: WWW.IBISWORLD.COM.AU
www.ibisworld.com.au Management Consultants in Australia September 2010 22
Competitive Landscape
Cost Structure labour. As the skills required of a is reflected in the wage they command.
Benchmarks consultancy broaden, it becomes more Purchase costs, at a low 11% of
economical to share skilled staff on revenue, centre on the purchase of
continued
secondment. Mid-size firms, which specific equipment required to assist in a
cannot afford to keep a broad variety of certain consultancy project. The greatest
skilled staff on its payroll, tend to rent its purchase cost is the cost of accessing
staff to other firms, which return the information to aid decision making.
favour with its own talent. This pushes Access to market research reports can be
total industry spending up toward 60% of quite expensive, and as the industry’s
revenue. However, this increase in success is predicated on the performance
outsourced labour does not represent an of analysts and consultants, high quality
increase in wage costs over time. In the information is considered crucial as a
late 1990s, total wages – including a decision-making tool.
much smaller subcontracting cost – Other costs, at 10% of total industry
absorbed more than 60% of revenue. revenue, represents expenses such as
The average wage in the industry is marketing costs (including advertising
expected to be quite high at an estimated and establishing a presence at
$114,200, due to the high quality of many conferences and seminars), insurance
consultants. Consultants often possess costs, employee benefits and other
substantial tertiary education, along with retention programs (such as bonuses or
experience in the industry or sector in company cars) and recruiting, along with
which they perform their consultancies. the transportation and accommodation
Consultancies often charge high fees for of consultants when conducting projects
the services of their consultants, and this for clients in interstate or remote areas.
Basis of Competition This industry is very competitive, with a becoming more demanding and seeking
high number of firms ranging from large, further work from business management
internationalised entities to small, services companies for the same budget
Level & Trend non-employing, area-specific companies. (or even a reduced budget).
ompetition
C in Over the past decade, the industry has More importantly, clients are
this industry is become increasingly competitive between becoming more results oriented, are
High and the trend existing consultancies and external seeking quantifiable targets and more
companies looking to eat into their direct results for their money. They are
is Increasing
market share. During periods of also demanding consultants be more
economic difficulty, this competition involved in actually implementing their
tends to focus increasingly on price and recommendations, particularly in the IT
service offerings become more area, and also in access and delivery of
homogenised – that is, assisting with cost financial resources to implement any
cutting and redundancies rather than agreed strategy.
growth strategies. Strategic alliances between companies
Reputation is essential for a in this industry and those in the IT and
consultancy to operate effectively. This is finance areas are continuing to be
most often built on quality performance important in terms of implementing and
and the word-of-mouth promotion it delivering recommended strategic
generates. The high fees charged by directions. During periods of low profit
players in the industry serve to demand a growth competition can become
high quality of performance, which a increasingly price-based, particularly
good reputation infers. among smaller firms that do not have the
The industry has a significant number luxury of pre-existing branding or
of operators and the barriers to entry are reputation to attract clients.
low. Clients are also increasingly Also, larger players tend to promote
www.ibisworld.com.au Management Consultants in Australia September 2010 23
Competitive Landscape
Barriers to Entry The prominence of small one- or two- for larger management consultancies) of
person operations (particularly in the US) a particular industry, skill or geographic
Level & Trend is evidence of the ability of new industry region (intimate knowledge of Chinese
entrants to access the requisite capital to culture and the Chinese economy is
arriers to Entry
B establish a new company. Capital costs particularly valuable in the current
in this industry are are minimal, as basic computing economic climate), while targeting clients
Low and Steady equipment is all that is required, and with interests in these industries, skills or
business may still be conducted without regions. However, new entrants to the
this, while regulations governing the industry often possess skills and
industry are minimal. Some industries expertise relevant to their service
require licensing, or membership of a offering, which is often the primary
particular industry group. Without this motivation for starting a firm, and as
type of official ratification, business can such, absence of specialty skills is mostly
be difficult to obtain. limited to new players looking to offer
broad advice on non-specific issues.
Service Specialisation Major players in the industry have
New companies can exploit specialist sufficient staff with varied skills to allow
knowledge (often acquired while working conducting multiple projects at lower cost
www.ibisworld.com.au Management Consultants in Australia September 2010 24
Competitive Landscape
Competitive Landscape
Industry of the bulk of the major players’ head Specialisation and connectivity
Globalisation offices. With the exception of Capgemini, Increasing connectivity between
which itself purchased the consulting arm developed economies is allowing large
continued
of accounting firm Ernst & Young in 2000, industry players to broaden their
all major players are based in the US. international approach by conducting
While these firms all conduct international consulting projects across international
operations, their origins in the United borders, increasing industry globalisation.
States have necessitated a recent move Clients of firms in this industry
into international markets and are demand a high level of customisation of
subsequently increasing the industry’s services and personal attention, which
level of globalisation. minimises the ability of firms to offer
IBISWorld expects the industry to internationally homogeneous services
remain at a low level of globalisation over that many service-based industries can
the five years through 2015-16, as smaller afford to do. Client firms often require
players in specific geographic regions, advice tailored to the business culture of
particularly Europe and North Asia gain the geographic region in which they
a foothold. Also, large clients will operate, ensuring that while the level of
increasingly utilise the services of globalisation in the industry is increasing,
multiple consultancies as a risk the predominance of large multinationals
management strategy that is most likely will be mitigated by the specialist
against the recommendations of their requirements that can be offered by local
current consultants. niche competitors.
www.ibisworld.com.au Management Consultants in Australia September 2010 26
Major Companies
Accenture Australia Holdings Pty Ltd | Marsh Mercer Holdings (Australia) Pty Ltd
Deloitte Touche Tohmatsu | Boston Consulting Group Pty Ltd | Other
86.7%
Other
Deloitte Touche Tohmatsu 3.1%
Accenture Australia Holdings Pty Ltd 4.9%
SOURCE: WWW.IBISWORLD.COM.AU
Player Performance Accenture is one of the world’s leading Arthur Andersen. Andersen Consulting
management consulting, technology was upset that it was paying Arthur
services and outsourcing organisations, Andersen up to 15% of its profits each year
Accenture Australia with approximately 140,000 employees; (a condition of the 1989 split was that the
Holdings Pty Ltd offices and operations in more than 150 more profitable unit – AA or AC – paid the
Market share: 4.9% cities in 49 countries; and revenues other this sum), while at the same time
before reimbursements of US$23.39 Arthur Andersen was competing with
billion for fiscal 2008. Andersen Consulting through its own
Accenture grew from the collapse of newly established business consulting
Arthur Anderson Consulting in the wake service line.
of the Enron collapse and associated This dispute came to a head in 1998
concerns regarding auditors and when Andersen Consulting claimed
consultants involved in the process. breach of contract against AWSC and
Increasingly, Accenture’s focus is on Arthur Andersen. In August 2000,
providing IT assistance, and as a result, Andersen Consulting broke all
the company’s IT consulting revenue is of contractual ties with AWSC and Arthur
growing importance to the company’s Andersen. As part of the arbitration
total revenue. IBISWorld estimates that settlement, Andersen Consulting was
around 48% of Accenture’s revenue falls required to change its name, resulting in
under the purview of the IBISWorld the entity being renamed Accenture.
definition of management consulting, Its organisational structure includes
hence for 2008, global revenue was divisions based on client industry types
estimated to be around US$11.1 billion. and employee workforces. Industry
divisions, referred to as operating groups,
History include Products (e.g. consumer packaged
Accenture originated as the consulting goods or industrial equipment),
division of Arthur Andersen which was Communications High Technology and
founded in 1913 by Arthur Andersen and Media (CHT), Financial Services (e.g.
Clarence DeLany and was named banking and insurance), Resources (e.g.
Andersen, DeLany & Co. utilities, chemicals and energy), and
In 1989, the consulting division split Government. The employee workforce
from Arthur Andersen (AA) and began divisions are respectively titled Consulting,
using the name Andersen Consulting Services, Enterprise and Solutions.
(AC). Both Arthur Andersen and Accenture’s business is structured
Andersen Consulting consisted of groups around these five operating groups,
of locally-owned independent which together comprise 17 industry
partnerships and other entities around groups serving clients in major industries
the world, each in a contractual around the world.
agreement with Andersen Worldwide
SocieteCooperative (AWSC), a Swiss Performance
administrative entity. Accenture has exhibited strong growth
Through the 1990s there was increasing across all sectors over the five years
tension between Andersen Consulting and through 2010-11 (see revenue tables) and
www.ibisworld.com.au Management Consultants in Australia September 2010 27
Major Companies
Player Performance overall company revenues have grown at In 2007, collaboration with Macquarie
continued an annualised rate of 16% over the last Bank to consolidate their global human
ten years. In recent years, growth in the resources functions led to a marked
Asia Pacific region has encouraged increase in revenue beyond the normal
further incursions into that region, organic growth the company has been
particularly growth in the EMEA experiencing. Also, organic growth in IT
(Europe, Middle East and Asia) region consulting as well as the acquisition of
has been well below the US and Asia over numerous small IT systems design firms
the same period. contributed to the 78.1% increase in
Accenture maintained its place as revenue. However, little of this revenue
Australia’s largest consulting firm over falls under the banner of management
2009-10, with a market share of around consulting and thus Accenture’s market
5% of revenue, or $340 million. The share remained more stagnant.
increasing collaboration between For Accenture’s Australian operations,
management consulting and IT consulting revenue fell in 2003 as the result of a
arms of major firms has left Accenture shift to new, international accounting
ideally placed, as they were among the first standards. Since then, revenue growth
to adopt an IT consulting strategy in the has been strong, increasing by 19.6% in
wake of the Arthur Anderson collapse. In 2005 and 16.5% in 2006. IBISWorld
2008, the company actually saw a drop in estimates that around 48% of total
revenue, which bucked not only the revenue is generated by activities in
long-term trend but also the company’s management consulting, rather than IT
international performance. The reduction consulting services, and as such, revenue
in revenue is likely to be only a momentary in 2009-10 was expected to be around
hiccup as demand for consulting services $340 million, which equates to
was very strong going into 2010. approximately 5.0% of total revenue.
Major Companies
Player Performance Marsh Mercer Holdings (Australia) Pty and reduction, actuarial services and
Ltd, incorporated in 2001, is the more. In 2009, the company reported
Australian proprietary company owned revenue of $568 million and employed
Marsh Mercer by foreign entity Marsh & McLennan 2,365 people.
Holdings (Australia) Companies Inc. Like Marsh Mercer Despite the industry’s poor performance
Pty Ltd Holdings, there are other subsidiaries of globally in 2008 and 2009, Mercer’s global
Marsh & McLennan worldwide, operations, via Marsh & McLennan,
Market share: 3.6%
providing personnel, organisational, managed 3.6% growth in 2009. However,
risk-management and many more types despite this comparatively buoyant
of consultancy services. growth, the company posted a loss of
Marsh Mercer Holdings provides US$75 million, down from a profit of more
services for risk management and than US$2.0 billion a year earlier. The
insurance, and the company segments its company’s Australian operations are likely
operations. The company’s risk to have suffered a poorer fate – much of
management segment includes insurance the growth came from branches of the
and reinsurance broking. The consulting business operating in developing
services segment conducts risk evaluation economies like China and India.
Major Companies
Player Performance as one of the world’s two largest six consecutive years of double-digit
continued consultancies (along with Accenture), revenue growth from continuing
with operations in 140 countries, and operations. Revenue growth was 13%
total DTT revenue reaching US$27.4 when measured in local currencies.
billion in 2008. Global consulting Deloitte faces increasing competition in
revenue was $6.3 billion in 2008, or 22% the form of the return of the other Big
of total global revenue. Asia Pacific Four firms – Ernst &Young,
growth in 2008 was the fastest of any PricewaterhouseCoopers and KPMG.
region, increasing at 30.3%, although However, these companies re-enter the
much of this growth took place in China, market at a distinct disadvantage, having
India and Vietnam. Aggregate revenue of lost significant market share to Deloitte
Deloitte member firms for the year and Accenture over the seven years since
ending 31 May 2008 was US$27.4 billion, they exited the industry, while also
an increase of 18.6% in U.S. dollars over surrendering older clients to the firms that
the previous year. It was the highest in were established in the wake of their exits.
Player Performance The Boston Consulting Group (formerly that 80% of its largest 50 clients that
Pappas Carter Evans and Koop), was engaged BCG over the last five years are
established in 1979 and has always placed continuing to use their services.
Boston Consulting an emphasis on the necessity of Its activities include the areas of
Group Pty Ltd companies to watch their overhead business strategy, marketing and sales
Market share: 1.7% structure and associated costs. Most of its strategy, strategy audit, industrial policy,
senior consultants have worked with organisation structure, time-based
leading consultancies in the US or UK competition, new product development,
and competitor analysis has been an portfolio strategy, international
important aspect of their work. development, optimising equity value,
The Boston Consulting Group (BCG) is diversification, financial policy, product
an international company and has offices positioning and information technology.
in 18 cities across the globe such as Its clients have included Pacific Dunlop,
London, Milan New York and Paris. Rheem, Castlemaine Tooheys, Macquarie
BCG seeks to establish an on-going Bank and more.
and long-term relationship with its It has recently assisted an airline to
clients and, like most others, guarantees respond to changes in its competitive
to maintain an uncompromising policy of environment, assessing the performance
client confidentiality. The company of various business units for a bank,
indicates that its success can be shown in undertaking a strategic review for an
Major Companies
Other Companies Beyond the industry’s largest players, the benefits of less travel time and cost as
industry includes many smaller well as giving access by clients to their
operations specialising in niche services. world wide group of consultants. About
This is best evidenced by the 81.6% of 40 of McKinsey’s consultants are
firms that are sole traders or partnerships. involved in consulting in the
telecommunications, electronics and
McKinsey Australia New Zealand media industries in the Asia-Pacific
Estimated market share: 1.8% region. A specialty has involved advising
McKinsey’s local operation is a subsidiary on the process and implementation of
of the McKinsey in the US located in skill building, monitoring progress
Seattle with the local agent for the against world’s best practices and on
company is Dabserv Corporate Services defining a company’s theoretical limits.
Pty Ltd, which is located in Sydney. It is McKinsey’s consulting tasks usually
estimated that McKinsey generated average between $1 million and $2
around $110 million in Australian million each. It became involved in the
revenue in 2007-08, representing around (then) fast growing IT consulting area.
1.8% of market share. Like many other high-profile consulting
McKinsey usually commands fees in firms to early 2000, it was experiencing
excess of $5,000 per day, although its problems holding onto staff, with
philosophy is that it is not selling time competition coming from start-up IT and
but techniques. It has 100 consultants in dot com businesses. It has a deliberate
Australia (and 120 overall, including corporate policy of not being involved in
support staff) and has expanded rapidly assisting its clients to implement its
in Asia, with offices in Seoul, Taipei, report recommendations. This goes
Hong Kong, Tokyo and Osaka. These against the industry-wide trend of
were initially supplied with some staff increasing integration between
from Sydney and Melbourne. consulting, advising, overseeing
McKinsey’s Australian operations implementation and execution, then
received a significant boost when it was assessing the success or failure of
announced that they, in conjunction with a contract. This company policy is
KPMG, would advise on the development intended to give a greater perceived
and implementation of the national level of independence for McKinsey from
broadband network, first announced in its clients.
2007. The contract was originally worth McKinsey indicates that some of the
$25 million and is likely to be extended current major issues facing Australian
as the broadband operation continues. companies are innovation, balancing
The company has invested in video increasing shareholder value with wider
conferencing facilities and both social responsibilities, performance
Australian offices are linked as part of management while recognising the value
their world network. This offers the of cultural capital (including skills and
www.ibisworld.com.au Management Consultants in Australia September 2010 31
Major Companies
Other Companies knowledge) and possibly re-engaging with billion in 2002 to $4.1 billion in 2007, as
continued the Asia-Pacific region for expansion. continuing major contracts have arrived
as the business community and
Booz & Co. government have become increasingly
Booz Allen Hamilton (BAH) has long willing to outsource management advice
been a presence in the Australian and decision-making assistance.
management consulting scene. In early Employment growth has mirrored
2009, however, the company decided to increases in revenue, going from 11,300
split in two, with Booz & Co., the original staff in 2002 to around 21,000 in 2007.
consulting firm formed in 1914, re-
emerging as the global consulting player, IBM and Bearing Point
while BAH retained its focus exclusively Estimated market share: 0.5%
on US Government Consulting jobs. IBM, after purchasing the consulting arm
While the parent company was of PWC in 2001, has increasingly taken its
established in 1914, Booz Allen has been focus away from management consulting
operating throughout Australia, New services in favour of IT consultancy and
Zealand and South East Asia (ANZSEA) systems design, which is more in line with
since 1987. With over two hundred the company’s core business.
employees across seven offices in three Meanwhile, Bearing Point, which
countries, Booz Allen ANZSEA has been KPMG’s consulting services segment
experiencing strong year on year growth, became in 1997 and spun off as an
while maintaining its regional independent entity in 2001, has also
headquarters in Sydney, through which it increased its focus on technology
manages all operations across ANZSEA, consulting. With international revenue of
under one management structure for the $3.46 billion, IBISWorld estimates
entire region. Australian Management Consulting
Global revenue growth has been strong revenue is around $85 million, or 0.8%
over recent years, increasing from $2.2 of total industry revenue.
Operating Conditions
Structural Risk Index | Investment Requirements | Technology & Systems
Industry Volatility | Regulation & Policy | Industry Assistance | Taxation Issues
ola
om
om
eV
eV
Imports
pe
pe
nu
nu
titi
titi
Revenue Volatility
Reve
Reve
on
on
Industry Pressure Points
Barriers to Entry 54.0 47.6
Life Cycle
Life Cycle
Competition Score Score
Levels of Assistance
Expor
Expor
ts
ts
Sta
Sta
ge
ge
Le Le
ve ve
ls o s ls o s
f As ort f As ort
sistance Imp sistance Imp
IBISWorld has scored key elements of Property and Business Services division.
industry structure on a scale of 1 to 9 – The industry structural risk index totals
the higher the figure, the greater the risks 54.0 points compared to 47.6 points for
to businesses operating in the industry. the Property and Business Services
Operating conditions in the division as a whole (100 points equates to
Management Consultants industry are extremely poor operating conditions).
more risky than in other industries in the
SOURCE: WWW.IBISWORLD.COM.AU
somewhat constant.
Some assistance in increasing labour operators in this industry have to offer
productivity is available in areas such as IT high levels of customer service, often on a
(hardware and software) communications, face-to-face basis.
(mobile and video-conferencing and by Therefor the industry is labour
e-mail) and in the delivery of reports using intensive, particularly in the knowledge
digital means. Like most service industries, and skills areas. Overtime most
www.ibisworld.com.au Management Consultants in Australia September 2010 33
Operating Conditions
Mining
Operating Conditions
Revenue Volatility The industry has a high reliance on The industry’s counter-cyclical
government and business consultancy tendencies protect it somewhat from
budgets. Many strategic and other major downturns, as clients often retain
Level
consultancy functions have been advisory services to assist with cost
The level of outsourced. Some companies consider cutting and redundancy packages. Also,
Volatility is Low outsourced consultancy to be a the industry has a great deal of flexibility
discretionary expense, and as a result it is to adjust to difficult periods due to its
often the first expense cut when revenue high profits, wide variety of clients, skill
falls. This tends to affect smaller firms offerings and staff. Profit can be more
more so than major players. Volatility is volatile however, as shifting skill focuses
moderately reduced as firms use often involves changing staff levels and
consultants to improve during downturns this can be an expensive proposition that
and increase profits during boom periods. eats into bottom lines.
www.ibisworld.com.au Management Consultants in Australia September 2010 35
Operating Conditions
Revenue Volatility
A higher level of revenue Volatility vs Growth
continued volatility implies greater
industry risk. Volatility can 1000 Hazardous rollercoaster
negatively affect long-term
Regulation & Policy The industry is largely self-regulated. In experience. Members are required to
terms of the management consultancy observe a code of professional conduct.
component, the Institute of Management The main objective of the institute is to
Level & Trend Consultants in Australia is the main enhance the image of the profession in
he level of
T professional body. The institute, which the community. It is designed for
Regulation is was founded in the late 1960s, is individual consultants and within it the
Light and the restricted to practicing consultants, College of Principals exists for the
where there are strict entry conditions principals of the larger management
trend is Steady
regarding qualifications and work consulting firms.
Taxation Issues The industry is not subject to any special services performed outside of Australia
taxes. The Federal Government for a non-resident. Credits for GST paid
introduced a GST at a rate of 10%, with on inputs can now be deducted against
Level
only a few basic food exemptions, since 1 the GST payable by businesses on goods
The levelof Tax July 2000. GST, however, does not apply and services sold or invoiced in each
Burden is Low to goods exported from Australia or monthly or quarterly period.
www.ibisworld.com.au Management Consultants in Australia September 2010 36
Key Statistics
Industry Data Industry
Revenue Value Added Employment Wages Domestic
($m) ($m) Establishments Enterprises (People) Exports Imports ($m) Demand
2001-02 4,903.9 3,255.6 3,965 3,363 25,260 -- -- 2,751.9 N/A
2002-03 5,064.5 3,355.9 3,984 3,409 25,799 -- -- 2,836.6 N/A
2003-04 5,520.7 3,595.3 4,046 3,429 27,433 -- -- 3,124 N/A
2004-05 5,970 3,692.4 4,062 3,384 28,687 -- -- 3,300.9 N/A
2005-06 6,428.6 3,760.2 4,154 3,433 30,080 -- -- 3,571.7 N/A
2006-07 6,686 3,664.8 4,224 3,458 31,456 -- -- 3,673.1 N/A
2007-08 6,813.3 3,371.3 4,372 3,582 32,126 -- -- 3,802.6 N/A
2008-09 6,802.5 3,072.5 4,484 3,673 32,804 -- -- 3,766.1 N/A
2009-10 6,883 3,148.8 4,592 3,732 33,427 -- -- 3,818.2 N/A
2010-11 7,080.8 3,261.3 4,702 3,808 34,062 -- -- 3,889.9 N/A
2011-12 7,427.8 3,558.1 4,857 3,958 35,595 -- -- 4,061 N/A
2012-13 7,925.5 3,860.6 4,920 3,951 36,521 -- -- 4,268.1 N/A
2013-14 8,250.4 4,188.7 4,994 3,940 37,908 -- -- 4,528.5 N/A
2014-15 8,539.2 4,389.8 5,154 4,159 39,311 -- -- 4,850 N/A
2015-16 8,957.6 4,670.7 5,324 4,232 41,080 -- -- 5,097.3 N/A
Sector Rank 12/33 13/33 17/33 17/33 14/33 N/A N/A 8/33 N/A
Economy Rank 137/501 95/501 116/501 105/489 96/501 N/A N/A 48/496 N/A
Figures are inflation-adjusted 2011 dollars. Rank refers to 2011 data. SOURCE: WWW.IBISWORLD.COM.AU
www.ibisworld.com.au Management Consultants in Australia September 2010 37
Key Statistics
Historical The Management Consultancy industry legislative changes (including tax law
Performance had its beginnings in Australia in the late changes), IT consulting (including
1930s, with the formation of W.D. Scott & e-commerce) and from general review of
Co by Sir Walter Scott, a cost accountant. management practices (in areas such as
The industry developed slowly until the staff downsizing, export growth, takeovers
1960s when it became more acceptable to and mergers).
Australian business to make use of In the early 2000s, the slower
management consultants. Since then economic growth and its resultant effect
numerous consultants and consultancy on business confidence was estimated to
firms have entered the market. have led to a real decline in industry
The consolidation of Australian revenue, as budgets were reduced for
industry that occurred throughout the consulting and related consulting
early to mid-1990s, due to mergers, activities. The uncertainty and
takeovers and general restructuring, complexity initially associated with the
resulted in many retrenched executives GST also led to many firms largely
establishing themselves as consultants. concentrating on its implementation and
However, it was estimated that the ensuring that the systems were in place
average life in consulting for many was and operating effectively. Business also
just over 12 months. slowed around the period of the Sydney
During the early 1990s recession, the Olympics in September 2000, as
industry was affected by the numerous domestic and international attention was
corporate collapses which occurred, focused on this world event.
coupled with the significant number of One of the other major effects on
companies that were placed in industry operators resulted from the
receivership and the associated decline in effect of the high-technology stocks
consumer confidence (particularly with correction that flowed into 2000-01 and
the collapse of companies in the financial created both uncertainty and a re-
services sector). According to industry evaluation of expenditure. This led to
sources, this led to an increased level of reduced expenditure on many internet-
funds being allocated to consultancies by and web-based plans and strategies by
many major clients as companies slashed business and governments. This was
all of their general and discretionary confirmed by an Australian Financial
consultancy expenditures. This resulted Review survey of firms on their use of
in reduced consulting work and increased consultants in this year, which found that
fee-based competition, as firms sought more than 20% had reduced their
to at least cover their short term spending on consulting.
cashflow requirements. In 2001-02 many clients reduced their
Due to the slow economic growth there consultancy budgets across most areas,
was also a tendency for clients to turn to which included strategic advice, IT and
consultancies that were highly regarded web page design. A survey by the
and specialists in their area of need, Australian Financial Review on the
although price was still an important intended use of consultants in this year
factor. Competition also increased, found that 32% of firms intended to
especially for government sector reduce expenditure on consultants. Also,
consultancies, which was estimated by while 82% of firms had used a consultant
industry sources to have accounted for in 2000-01, only 77% intended to do so
around one-third of industry revenue. in 2001-02. The main areas consultants
However, past the recession, industry were to be used were in the IT, human
surveys indicated that major management resources, mergers and acquisitions,
consultancy firms had experienced e-commerce, strategic planning and
significant revenue growth from areas business process and best practice areas.
such as assisting clients to achieve world’s IBISWorld estimated that real industry
best practice. Growth also resulted from revenue decreased by about 0.9%.
www.ibisworld.com.au Management Consultants in Australia September 2010 38
Industry Jargon CHANGE MANAGEMENT Consultants are brought in to STRATEGIC CONSULTING Consultants can be
oversee structural changes to a company’s operation. contracted to advise on long-term planning, with an eye
HUMAN RESOURCES CONSULTING The development to minimise costs growth and maintain profits. Often
of policies designed to ensure staff are adequately this involves the development of new products and
provided for and their productivity is maximised. services.
IBISWorld Glossary BARRIERS TO ENTRY Barriers to entry can be High, tax) of goods and services; plus transfers to other firms
Medium or Low. High means new companies struggle to of the same business; plus subsidies on production; plus
enter an industry, while Low means it is easy for a firm all other operating income from outside the firm (such
to enter an industry. as commission income, repair and service income, and
CAPITAL/LABOUR INTENSITY An indicator of how rent, leasing and hiring income); plus capital work done
much capital is used in production as opposed to labour. by rental or lease. Receipts from interest royalties,
Level is stated as High, Medium or Low. High is a ratio of dividends and the sale of fixed tangible assets are
less than $3 of wage costs for every $1 of depreciation; excluded.
Medium is $3-$8 of wage costs to $1 of depreciation; INDUSTRY VALUE ADDED The market value of goods
Low is greater than $8 of wage costs for every $1 of and services produced by an industry minus the cost of
depreciation. goods and services used in the production process,
DOMESTIC DEMAND The use of goods and services which leaves the gross product of the industry (also
within Australia; the sum of imports and domestic called its Value Added).
production minus exports. INTERNATIONAL TRADE The level is determined by:
EMPLOYMENT The number of working proprietors, Exports/Revenue: Low is 0-5%; Medium is 5-20%; High
partners, permanent, part-time, temporary and casual is over 20%. Imports/Domestic Demand: Low is 0-5%;
employees, and managerial and executive employees. Medium is 5-35%; and High is over 35%.
ENTERPRISE A division that is separately managed and LIFE CYCLE All industries go through periods of Growth,
keeps management accounts. The most relevant Maturity and Decline. An average life cycle lasts 70
measure of the number of firms in an industry. years. Maturity is the longest stage at 40 years with
Growth and Decline at 15 years each.
ESTABLISHMENT The smallest type of accounting unit
within an Enterprise; usually consists of one or more NON-EMPLOYING ESTABLISHMENT Businesses with
locations in a state or territory of the country in which it no paid employment and payroll are known as
operates. non-employing establishments. These are mostly set-up
by self employed individuals.
EXPORTS The total sales and transfers of goods
produced by an industry that are exported. VOLATILITY The level of volatility is determined by the
percentage change in revenue over the past five years.
IMPORTS The value of goods and services imported
Volatility levels: Very High is greater than ±20%; High
with the amount payable to non-residents.
Volatility is between ±10% and ±20%; Moderate
INDUSTRY CONCENTRATION IBISWorld bases Volatility is between ±3% and ±10%; and Low Volatility
concentration on the top four firms. Concentration is is less than ±3%.
identified as High, Medium or Low. High means the top
WAGES The gross total wages and salaries of all
four players account for over 70% of revenue; Medium
employees of the establishment.
is 40 –70% of revenue; Low is less than 40%.
INDUSTRY REVENUE The total sales revenue of the
industry, including sales (exclusive of excise and sales
www.ibisworld.com.au | (03) 9655 3881 | info@ibisworld.com
Who is IBISWorld?
We are strategists, analysts, researchers, and marketers. We provide
answers to information-hungry, time-poor businesses. Our goal is to
provide real world answers that matter to your business in our 500
Australian industry reports. When tough strategic, budget, sales and
marketing decisions need to be made, our suite of Industry and Risk
intelligence products give you deeply-researched answers quickly.
IBISWorld Membership
IBISWorld offers tailored membership packages to meet your needs.
Disclaimer
This product has been supplied by IBISWorld Pty Ltd. (‘IBISWorld’) solely for the use of, or reliance upon, the data or information contained herein.
use by its authorised licenses strictly in accordance with their license Copyright in this publication is owned by IBISWorld Pty Ltd. The publication
agreements with IBISWorld. IBISWorld makes no representation to any is sold on the basis that the purchaser agrees not to copy the material
other person with regard to the completeness or accuracy of the data or contained within it for other than the purchasers own purposes. In the event
information contained herein, and it accepts no responsibility and disclaims that the purchaser uses or quotes from the material in this publication – in
all liability (save for liability which cannot be lawfully disclaimed) for loss or papers, reports, or opinions prepared for any other person – it is agreed that
damage whatsoever suffered or incurred by any other person resulting from it will be sourced to: IBISWorld Pty Ltd