Documentos de Académico
Documentos de Profesional
Documentos de Cultura
IN INVESTING
Submitted By
DIVYASINDHU.K
2006-2008
BANGALORE-560001
CERTIFICATE FROM THE PRINCIPAL
DATE: (Principal)
CERTIFICATE FROM THE GUIDE
I hereby certify that the research work embodied in the dissertation titled,
requirements for the award of MBA degree by Bangalore University. To the best
of my knowledge this report has not formed the basis for the award of any other
degree or diploma.
PLACE: Bangalore Dr. Nagesh S
Malavalli
DATE: (Principal)
DECLARATION
I hereby declare that the research work embodied in the dissertation titled,
Management. The report has not been submitted in part or full towards any
Place: Bangalore
Date:
DivyaSindhu K
The immense gratification of this project work does not lead to a sense of
fulfillment unless I express my boundless gratitude to all those who made this work
indebtedness for all the timely help, support and guidance I received.
guide for this project to whom I am deeply grateful for his constant support and
1 RESEARCH EXTRACT 2
2 INTRODUCTION 4
INTRODUCTION TO TECHNICAL
3 10
ANALYSIS
4 REVIEW OF LITERATURE 22
5 PROBLEM STATEMENT 23
7 RESEARCH METHODOLOGY 36
CONCLUSION &
10 69
RECOMMENDATIONS
11 BIBLIOGRAPHGY 73
12 ANNEXURES 74
Relevance Of Technical Analysis
4 PRICE MOMENTUM 56
M.P.Birla Institute of Management Page 10
Relevance Of Technical Analysis
RESEARCH EXTRACT
M.P.Birla Institute of Management Page 11
Relevance Of Technical Analysis
RESEARCH EXTRACT
The following research has been carried out in order to check the relevance of the use
of Technical analysis in investing i.e. does the use of technical analysis while
investing really gets the investors maximum returns possible.
In this research the sensex closing price for three years from 2005 to 2007 is
considered. Here sensex itself is assumed as a stock.
Days Moving Averages method, Relative Strength Index method, Rate of Change
method, Price Momentum method are the tools employed. These tools are analyzed
and the charts were plotted based on the analysis.
From the charts the stock was bought and sold as and when the signals were given
respectively for each year separately.
The profits or loss hence made from these predictions has been used to analyze the
percentage of returns each tool generates.
The returns thus obtained are compared with one another and also with the returns
obtained through buy and hold strategy where the sensex is bought at that year’s
closing price of first working day’ price and held till year end and sold at the closing
price of the last working day of the sensex.
It has been found from the analysis that Relative Strength Index method ranks FIRST
in terms of returns and it also shows that investors will be able to make maximum
benefit by employing tools of Technical Analysis than by simple Buy and Hold
strategy. Thus this research shows that Technical Analysis does have relevance in
generating profits or returns to its investors.
M.P.Birla Institute of Management Page 12
Relevance Of Technical Analysis
INTRODUCTION
M.P.Birla Institute of Management Page 13
Relevance Of Technical Analysis
Indian Stock Markets are one of the oldest in Asia. Its history dates back to nearly 200
years ago. The earliest records of security dealings in India are meager and obscure.
The East India Company was the dominant institution in those days and business in its
loan securities used to be transacted towards the close of the eighteenth century.
By 1830's business on corporate stocks and shares in Bank and Cotton presses took
place in Bombay. Though the trading list was broader in 1839, there were only half a
dozen brokers recognized by banks and merchants during 1840 and 1850.
At the end of the American Civil War, the brokers who thrived out of Civil War in
1874, found a place in a street (now appropriately called as Dallal Street) where they
would conveniently assemble and transact business. In 1887, they formally established
in Bombay, the "Native Share and Stock Brokers' Association" (which is alternatively
known as “The Stock Exchange "). In 1895, the Stock Exchange acquired a premise in
the same street and it was inaugurated in 1899. Thus, the Stock Exchange at Bombay
was consolidated.
M.P.Birla Institute of Management Page 14
Relevance Of Technical Analysis
Two types of transactions can be carried out on the Indian stock exchanges:
1. Spot delivery transactions "for delivery and payment within the time or on the
date stipulated when entering into the contract which shall not be more than 14
days following the date of the contract”
2. Forward transactions "delivery and payment can be extended by further period
of 14 days each so that the overall period does not exceed 90 days from the
date of the contract". The latter is permitted only in the case of specified
shares. The brokers who carry over the outstanding pay carry over charges (can
tango or backwardation) which are usually determined by the rates of interest
prevailing.
A member broker in an Indian stock exchange can act as an agent, buy and sell
securities for his clients on a commission basis and also can act as a trader or dealer as
a principal, buy and sell securities on his own account and risk, in contrast with the
practice prevailing on New York and London Stock Exchanges, where a member can
act as a jobber or a broker only.
The nature of trading on Indian Stock Exchanges are that of age old conventional style
of face-to-face trading with bids and offers being made by open outcry. However,
M.P.Birla Institute of Management Page 15
Relevance Of Technical Analysis
there is a great amount of effort to modernize the Indian stock exchanges in the very
recent times.
With the liberalization of the Indian economy, it was found inevitable to lift the Indian
stock market trading system on par with the international standards. On the basis of
the recommendations of high powered Pherwani Committee, the National Stock
Exchange was incorporated in 1992 by Industrial Development Bank of India,
Industrial Credit and Investment Corporation of India, Industrial Finance Corporation
of India, all Insurance Corporations, selected commercial banks and others.
¾ Trading members
¾ Participants.
Recognized members of NSE are called trading members who trade on behalf of
themselves and their clients. Participants include trading members and large players
like banks who take direct settlement responsibility.
M.P.Birla Institute of Management Page 16
Relevance Of Technical Analysis
NSE has several advantages over the traditional trading exchanges. They are as
follows:
¾ NSE brings an integrated stock market trading network across the nation.
¾ Investors can trade at the same price from anywhere in the country since inter-
market operations are streamlined coupled with the countrywide access to the
securities.
Unless stock markets provide professionalized service, small investors and foreign
investors will not be interested in capital market operations. And capital market being
one of the major sources of long-term finance for industrial projects, India cannot
afford to damage the capital market path. In this regard NSE gains vital importance in
the Indian capital market system.
M.P.Birla Institute of Management Page 17
Relevance Of Technical Analysis
The Stock Exchange, Mumbai, popularly known as "BSE" was established in 1875 as
"The Native Share and Stock Brokers Association". It is the oldest one in Asia, even
older than the Tokyo Stock Exchange, which was established in 1878. It is a voluntary
non-profit making Association of Persons (AOP) and is currently engaged in the
process of converting itself into demutualised and corporate entity.
It has evolved over the years into its present status as the premier Stock Exchange in
the country. It is the first Stock Exchange in the Country to have obtained permanent
recognition in 1956 from the Govt. of India under the Securities Contracts
(Regulation) Act, 1956.
The Exchange, while providing an efficient and transparent market for trading in
securities, debt and derivatives upholds the interests of the investors and ensures
reprisal of their grievances whether against the companies or its own member-
brokers. It also strives to educate and enlighten the investors by conducting investor
education programmers and making available to them necessary informative inputs.
A Governing Board having 20 directors is the apex body, which decides the policies
and regulates the affairs of the Exchange. The Governing Board consists of 9
elected directors, who are from the broking community (one third of them
retire ever year by rotation), three SEBI nominees, six public representatives and an
Executive Director & Chief Executive Officer and a Chief Operating Officer.
The Executive Director as the Chief Executive Officer is responsible for the day-to-
day administration of the Exchange and he is assisted by the Chief Operating Officer
and other Heads of Departments.
M.P.Birla Institute of Management Page 18
Relevance Of Technical Analysis
The Exchange has inserted new Rule No.126 A in its Rules, Bye-laws & Regulations
pertaining to constitution of the Executive Committee of the Exchange.
The Committee considers judicial & quasi matters in which the Governing Board has
powers as an Appellate Authority, matters regarding annulment of transactions,
admission, continuance and suspension of member-brokers, declaration of a member-
broker as defaulter, norms, procedures and other matters relating to arbitration, fees,
deposits, margins and other monies payable by the member-brokers to the Exchange,
etc.
M.P.Birla Institute of Management Page 19
Relevance Of Technical Analysis
It is important to form a view on the likely trend of the overall market, and it is helpful
to have some idea of how to go about selecting individual stocks. Naturally, all
investors would like their investments to appreciate rapidly in price, but stocks, which
may satisfy this wish, tend to be accompanied by a substantially greater amount of risk
than many investors are normally willing to accept. However, it is important to
understand that investors can be very conscious when it comes to stock ownership.
Technical analysis is the use of numerical series generated by market activity, such as
price and volume, to predict future price trends. The techniques applied to any market
with a comprehensive price history.
Some speculators combine elements from both technical and fundamental analysis.
Technical analysis is viewed by many of its practitioners as more of art than science.
Many academic studies conclude that technical analysis has little, if any, predictive
power. However, the practice has a dedicated following especially among active
traders and does have support amongst the academic community.
M.P.Birla Institute of Management Page 20
Relevance Of Technical Analysis
As an example of the debate regarding the efficacy of technical analysis, Peter Lynch,
a very well-known and successful fundamental analyst, once commented, "Charts are
great for predicting the past." On the other hand, the U.S. Federal Reserve once
published a study saying that certain element of technical analysis was effective in
price forecasting.
Dow Theory, a theory based on the collected writings of Dow Jones co-founder and
editor Charles Dow, inspired the increasingly widespread use and development of
technical analysis from the end of the 19th century. Modern technical analysis
considers Dow Theory its cornerstone.
New tools and theories have been produced and existing tools have been enhanced at a
rapid rate in recent decades, with an increasing emphasis on computer-assisted
techniques.
Technical analysis is not concerned with why a price is moving but rather whether it is
moving in a particular direction or in a particular chart pattern. Technical analysts
believe that profits can be made by "trend following." In other words if a particular
stock price is steadily rising (trending upward) then a technical analyst will look for
opportunities to buy this stock. Until the technical analyst is convinced this uptrend
has reversed or ended, all else equal, he will continue to own this security.
Additionally, technical analysts look for various price patterns to form on a price chart
and will take positions in anticipation of the expected move following that pattern.
M.P.Birla Institute of Management Page 21
Relevance Of Technical Analysis
The various tools of technical analysis assist the technician in determining when
trends have formed, ended, etc. and when particular patterns are unfolding.
The beauty of technical analysis lies in its versatility. Because the principles of
technical analysis are universally applicable, each of the analysis steps above can be
performed using the same theoretical background. One does not need an economics
degree to analyze a market index chart. One doesn’t need to be a specialist to analyze
a stock chart. It does not matter if the time frame is 2 days or 2 years. It does not
matter if it is a stock, market index or commodity.
The technical principles of support, resistance, trend, trading range and other aspects
can be applied to any chart. While this may sound easy, technical analysis is by no
means easy. Success requires serious study, dedication and an open mind.
One of the forecasting tools very popular among practitioners is technical analysis.
Technical analysis is the examination of past price movements in order to forecast
future price movements. Technical analysis is open to interpretation. Many times two
technicians will look at the same chart and paint two different scenarios or see
different patterns. Both would be able to come up with logical support to justify their
position.
M.P.Birla Institute of Management Page 22
Relevance Of Technical Analysis
In addition, even if stock prices completely followed a random walk, people would be
able to convince themselves that there are patterns having a predictive value. It has
become more and more popular, as it offered an unlimited set of tools and signals and
seemed to be an interesting method of market analysis. It has been proven that stock
prices most of the time approximately follow a random walk pattern.
In addition, some technical analysts include volume or open interest figures with their
study of price action.
Technical analysts believe that their methods will permit them to beat the market.
Economists have traditionally been skeptical of the value of technical analysis,
affirming the theory of efficient markets that holds no strategy should allow investors
and traders to make unusual returns except by taking excessive risk.
M.P.Birla Institute of Management Page 23
Relevance Of Technical Analysis
Technical analysis holds that because every possible bit of information is immediately
included in the price of a security, it is not necessary to explicitly analyze the
fundamental, economic, political, etc. factors that might influence that price. Because
all possible information is reflected in the price, only a study of the price movement is
required.
This theorem is similar to the strong and semi-strong forms of market efficiency.
Technical analysts believe that the current price fully reflects all information. Because
all information is already reflected in the price, it represents the fair value, and should
form the basis for analysis. After all, the market price reflects the sum knowledge of
all participants, including traders, investors, portfolio managers, buy-side analysts,
sell-side analysts, market strategist, technical analysts, fundamental analysts and many
others.
It would be folly to disagree with the price set by such an impressive array of people
with impeccable credentials. Technical analysis utilizes the information captured by
the price to interpret what the market is saying with the purpose of forming a view on
the future.
M.P.Birla Institute of Management Page 24
Relevance Of Technical Analysis
Most technicians agree that prices trend. However, most technicians also acknowledge
that there are periods when prices do not trend. If prices were always random, it would
be extremely difficult to make money using technical analysis. A technician believes
that it is possible to identify a trend, invest or trade based on the trend and make
money as the trend unfolds. Because technical analysis can be applied to many
different time frames, it is possible to spot both short-term and long-term trends.
While it cannot be shown that prices must trend, technical analysis relies on While it
cannot be shown that prices must trend, technical analysis relies on empirical evidence
and common sense to assert that prices do trend. To a technician, markets are trending
up, trending down, or trending sideways (flat). This definition of a price trend is
essentially the one put forward by Dow Theory. A person who does not believe that
prices move in trends will find little use for technical analysis. The assumption that
prices must trend is probably the most important concept in technical analysis.
To a technical analyst, the human characteristics of the market might be irrational, but
they exist. Because investors' attitudes often repeat, investors' actions in the
marketplace often repeat as well i.e., patterns of price movement will develop on a
chart that a technical analyst believes have predictive qualities.
M.P.Birla Institute of Management Page 25
Relevance Of Technical Analysis
The logic being that is if most investors are bullish, then they would have already
bought the market (anticipating that the market will move higher). But because most
investors are bullish and have invested, it is safe to assume that there are few buyers
remaining in the market. With most investors long, there are more potential sellers in
the market than buyers despite the fact that the overall attitude of investors is bullish.
Analyst Bias
Just as with fundamental analysis, technical analysis is subjective and our personal
biases can be reflected in the analysis. It is important to be aware of these biases when
analyzing a chart. If the analyst is a perpetual bull, then a bullish bias will overshadow
the analysis. On the other hand, if the analyst is a disgruntled eternal bear, then the
analysis will probably have a bearish tilt.
M.P.Birla Institute of Management Page 26
Relevance Of Technical Analysis
Open to Interpretation
Furthering the bias argument is the fact that technical analysis is open to
interpretation. Even though there are standards, many times two technicians will look
at the same chart and paint two different scenarios or see different patterns. Both will
be able to come up with logical support and resistance levels as well as key breaks to
justify their position. While this can be frustrating, it should be pointed out that
technical analysis is more like an art than a science, somewhat like economics. Is the
cup half-empty or half-full? It is in the eye of the beholder.
Too Late
Technical analysis has been criticized for being too late. By the time the trend is
identified, a substantial portion of the move has already taken place. After such a large
move, the reward to risk ratio is not great. Lateness is a particular criticism of Dow
Theory.
Even after a new trend has been identified, there is always another "important" level
close at hand. Technicians have been accused of sitting on the fence and never taking
an unqualified stance. Even if they are bullish, there is always some indicator or some
level that will qualify their opinion.
M.P.Birla Institute of Management Page 27
Relevance Of Technical Analysis
Trader's Remorse
Not all technical signals and patterns work. When one begins to study technical
analysis, one will come across an array of patterns and indicators with rules to match.
For instance: A sell signal is given when the neckline of a head and shoulders pattern
is broken. Even though this is a rule, it is not steadfast and can be subject to other
factors such as volume and momentum. In that same vein, what works for one
particular stock may not work for another. A 50-day moving average may work great
to identify support and resistance for SBI, but a 70-day moving average may work
better for Infosys. Even though many principles of technical analysis are universal,
each security will have its own idiosyncrasies.
Lack of evidence
Although chartists assert that their techniques provide excess returns over time, this
assertion is controversial. Many academics believe that technical analysis has no
predictive power. Burton Malkiel in his book "A Random Walk Down Wall Street"
(8th edition, 2003) and Eugene Fama in "Efficient Capital Markets: A Review of
Theory and Empirical Work," May 1970 Journal of Finance summarize many early
studies, conducted from the 1950s-70s, that show that after trading costs are
considered, the returns generated by many technical strategies under perform a simple
buy and hold strategy.
Critics of technical analysis include well known fundamental analysts. Warren Buffett
has exclaimed, "I realized technical analysis didn't work when I turned the charts
upside down and didn't get a different answer" and "If past history was all there was to
the game, the richest people would be librarians."
M.P.Birla Institute of Management Page 28
Relevance Of Technical Analysis
The efficient market hypothesis concludes that technical analysis cannot be effective.
According to this hypothesis, all relevant information is quickly reflected in a
security's price through the actions of traders who have that information. Thus, it is
impossible to "beat the market," and technical analysis cannot work. News events and
new fundamental developments which influence prices occur randomly and are
unknowable in advance. Advocates of EMH have produced many studies that reject
the efficacy of technical analysis.
Proponents of technical analysis counter that technical analysis does not completely
contradict the efficient market hypothesis. Technicians agree with EMH and that they
believe that all available information is reflected within a security's price; that is why
technicians say a study of the price movement is necessary. Technicians argue that
EMH ignores the realities of the market place, namely that many investors base their
future expectations on past earnings, track records, etc. Because future stock prices
can be strongly influenced by investor expectations, technicians claim it only follows
that past prices can influence future prices.
M.P.Birla Institute of Management Page 29
Relevance Of Technical Analysis
The random walk hypothesis is also at odds with technical analysis and charting.
Essentially, the hypothesis claims that stock price moments either independent or
uncorrelated increments. In this model, future stock prices are not dependent on past
stock prices, so trends cannot exist and technical analysis has no basis. Again,
proponents of this theory have generated substantial research in support of the
hypothesis.
Technical analysts maintain that trends are identifiable in the market and that it is
impractical to believe that market prices move in a random fashion. To a technician,
over time prices will trend in a direction until supply equals demand. Therefore, there
cannot be any pure random price movement.
As stated earlier, one of the cornerstones of technical analysis is that prices trend. If
one does not believe this concept, one will not agree with technical analysis.
Also, with regards to EMH and Random Walk Theory, technicians claim that both
theories ignore the realities of the marketplace. To a technician, the market is neither
composed of completely rational participants as EMH assumes (participants can be
greedy, overly risky, etc. at any given time) nor is its stock price movement
completely independent of its prior movement.
M.P.Birla Institute of Management Page 30
Relevance Of Technical Analysis
M.P.Birla Institute of Management Page 31
Relevance Of Technical Analysis
REVIEW OF LITERATURE
M.P.Birla Institute of Management Page 32
Relevance Of Technical Analysis
PROBLEM STATEMENT
Although the interest of both the type of investors is to make profits the
method followed varies a lot.
The study also tries to capture the contradicting views of different tools used in
technical analysis.
This creates a need to check who makes more profits i.e. is it the active trader
who enters and exits the market to make profits or is it the passive trader who
buys and holds a scrip for a particular period and then sells it to make profit.
M.P.Birla Institute of Management Page 33
Relevance Of Technical Analysis
Technical analysis of market data has long been a pervasive activity in both
security and future markets.
Technical analysts believe that price and volume data provide indicators of
future price movements, and that by examining these data, information may be
extracted on the fundamentals driving returns.
If markets are efficient in the sense that the current price impounds all
information then such activity is clearly pointless. But if the process by which
prices adjust to information is not immediate, then the market statistics may
impound information that is not yet incorporated in to the current market price.
Technical analysis is very useful because it provides tools that allow investors
to identify the signs that new information is being priced into a stock before
news is released.
M.P.Birla Institute of Management Page 34
Relevance Of Technical Analysis
To find out the relevance of technical analysis in market analysis that helps in
profit making in terms of returns.
To find out the relevance of the tools used in technical analysis in the
assessment of the market.
The study tries to capture the contradicting views of different tools used in
technical analysis.
To find the returns provided by each method for a period of three years
M.P.Birla Institute of Management Page 35
Relevance Of Technical Analysis
LITERATURE REVIEW
Literature review has been under taken to analyze various literature and research
papers available in the related field. Further research can be undertaken where
sufficient study is not done in particular field. Various sources of information have
been used in this review include technical analysis books, financial journals, articles
and research papers.
Research papers
1. TECHNICAL ANALYSIS AND TYPICAL COGNITIVE
BIASES
Piotr Zielonka, Warsaw University SGGW and Leon Kozminski Academy of
Entrepreneurship and Management, Poland
ABSTRACT
The paper describes a study carried out on a group of 24 Polish financial analysts. The
analysts responded to a questionnaire with 24 items (signals). They were asked to rate
the predictive value of different signals for the movements of stock prices. The signals
were of three types:
(b) technical-like signals created by the author of the research that imitated technical
signals and represented the same types of biases as real technical signals,
(c) other technical-like signals that did not represent any biases.
M.P.Birla Institute of Management Page 36
Relevance Of Technical Analysis
It turned out that the analysts tended to ascribe high predictive value to the
questionnaire items associated with psychological biases (either technical or technical-
like signals). At the same time, these items were rated very similarly by different
analysts. On the other hand, the technical-like signals not related to any biases were
given very low predictive values by the analysts. These results suggest that popularity
of technical analysis is associated with its relation to the typical cognitive biases of
humans.
METHODOLOGY
The study was carried out in Warsaw in January-February 2002. The participants were
24 financial analysts or dealers employed by banks and Polish capital market
institutions. The sample was not random. Each participant was administered a 24–item
questionnaire. There were three groups of items within the questionnaire. Each group
consisted of 8 items. The first group consisted of regular technical analysis signals
representing four common psychological inclinations. Each inclination was
represented by two signals. Usually one from a pair of signals was a predictor of a
stock fall (-), whereas the other signal was a predictor of a stock rise (+). The group
consisted of technical-like signals, created by the author of the questionnaire that did
not represent any psychological inclinations.
M.P.Birla Institute of Management Page 37
Relevance Of Technical Analysis
The cover page of the questionnaire stated that the survey was designed to better
understand the opinions of experts on implementation of technical analysis. This
remark allowed the participants to feel more like experts whose opinion is needed for
some further research rather than merely the persons to be examined. Respondents
were assured of confidentiality.
CONCLUSION
The present research shows that many technical analysis signals represent common
psychological biases such as the gambler’s fallacy, anchoring effect or herd behavior.
All real technical analysis signals were assigned a high predictive value by the
financial analysts who responded to the questionnaire.
The “technical” signals created by the author of the research either represented
psychological biases or not. If they did, they received high scores from respondents as
good predictors the of stock market behavior. If they did not, the respondents
estimated them as bad predictors. In addition, the respondents were in general
agreement about their judgments. These results confirm both hypotheses of this
research: technical analysis signals represent some common psychological biases and
financial analysts are subject to these biases.
M.P.Birla Institute of Management Page 38
Relevance Of Technical Analysis
Most technical analysis studies are concerned with the profitability of technical trading
rules and almost all of them focus exclusively on trend following patterns. In this
paper they examine a different kind of technical indicator which suggests a structural
relationship between High, Low, and Close prices of daily exchange rates. Since, for a
given exchange rate, it can be shown that these prices have different time series
properties, it is possible to explore the structural relationships between them using
multivariate co-integration methods. This methodology facilitates the construction of
dynamic structural econometric models, which are used to derive dynamic out of-
sample forecasts over different time horizons. Compared to standard benchmarks, it
turns out that these models have extremely good forecasting properties, even when
allowance has been made for transactions costs and risk premium.
M.P.Birla Institute of Management Page 39
Relevance Of Technical Analysis
vector autoregressive model (VAR) in levels into a set of linear structural equations
that incorporate both long and short-run dynamics. Starting from an unrestricted VAR,
the hypothesis of co integration is formulated as a hypothesis of reduced rank of the
long-run impact matrix. The VAR is generated by the vector, which defines the
potential endogenous variables of the model.
The Stochastic establish a structural relationship between the Close of today and the
Maximum and Minimum price of a moving period, measured as the highest High and
the lowest Low. Specifying a VAR with the data vector testing for co-integration
between the three variables should reveal if, when using the Stochastic, an investor is
intuitively exploiting Granger causality among the three series. Each VAR included a
constant in the co integration space and 15 lags of each of the variables, which was
sufficient to produce random errors
CONCLUSION
The forecasting models were estimated over the first 2500 data observations, thus
sparing roughly 10% of the total sample for forecasting. Since the classic paper of
Meese and Rogoff (1983), the crucial factor in determining the worth of an exchange
rate model is how well it forecasts in an out-of-sample context relative to a random
walk, using the metric of the root mean square error (RMSE) criterion. In table 5, their
statistics are calculated as the ratio of the RMSE of the forecasting model over the
RMSE of a drift less random walk; a value.
M.P.Birla Institute of Management Page 40
Relevance Of Technical Analysis
METHODOLOGY
Brock et. al. emphasize the danger of obtaining spurious empirical results if
trading rules are both discovered and tested in the same data set. They note that
there is no complete remedy for “data snooping” biases, but attempt to mitigate
the problem by using a long data series and by reporting results for all rules
evaluated. To avoid compounding the dangers of data snooping biases, they
M.P.Birla Institute of Management Page 41
Relevance Of Technical Analysis
evaluate precisely the same set of twenty six technical rules as Brock et. al.
These include ten Variable Length Moving Average (VMA) rules, ten Fixed
Length Moving Average (FMA) rules, and six Trading Range Break (TRB)
rules.
B. Measuring Returns
The results reported by Brock et al. are based on percentage changes in the
DJIA, data on which was available for a long time horizon. However, some
limitations of the Dow Jones data potentially affect the interpretation of their
evidence. First, changes in the [stock index] understate actual returns due to
the omission of dividends.
CONCLUSION
Brock, et. al. (1992) demonstrate that a set of relatively simple technical trading rules
possess statistically significant forecast power for changes in the Dow Jones Industrial
Average over a long sample period. They extend their analysis to ascertain whether
this evidence can be reconciled with market efficiency.
M.P.Birla Institute of Management Page 42
Relevance Of Technical Analysis
ABSTRACT
This article reports the results of a questionnaire survey conducted in February 1995
on the use by foreign exchange dealers in Hong Kong of fundamental and technical
analyses to form the forecasts of exchange rate movements. Findings of this study
reveal that > 85% of respondents rely on both fundamental and technical analysis for
predicting future price at different time horizons. At shorter horizons, there exists a
skew towards reliance on technical analysis as opposed to fundamental analysis, but
the skew becomes steadily reversed as the length of horizon considered is extended.
METHODOLOGY
To prepare the survey, they concluded dealers at the Hong Kong monetary Authority
and most of the major banks. After consultation, they designed a questionnaire
investigating the following.
M.P.Birla Institute of Management Page 43
Relevance Of Technical Analysis
The Hong Kong Forex Association with its membership list as of September 1994
provided them. A total of 153 fully completed questionnaires were returned. A
response rate of 19%. Most respondents firms are active participants in the market,
with over 60% in number having a daily average turnover greater than US $ 100
million.
CONCLUSION:
At all the time horizons, a very high proportion of respondents place some weight on
both fundamental and technical analysis when forming views. Dealers perceive value
in using both fundamental and technical analysis to predict both trends. Technical
analysis is considered only slightly more useful than fundamental analysis.
M.P.Birla Institute of Management Page 44
Relevance Of Technical Analysis
RESEARCH
METHODOLOGY
M.P.Birla Institute of Management Page 45
Relevance Of Technical Analysis
Capital market comprising the new issues market and secondary markets or stock
exchanges, is one of the most sensitive markets in the whole economy. The secondary
market enables investors to continuously rearrange their assets if they so desire by
divesting themselves of such assets while others can use their surplus funds to acquire
them. This rearrangement is not a product of instant decisions but a thorough research.
The major tools used for this are Fundamental analysis and technical analysis. Of
which fundamental analysis requires a large amount of inside data regarding the
companies concerned and also requires lot of calculations and deep knowledge.
Whereas technical analysis is comparatively a simpler tool for an investor to decide
his short/medium term investment decisions. By closely watching the price changes,
its trend can be analyzed and the timings of entry and exit can be decided.
And this method is used in this research where different tools of technical analysis are
selected and based on the signals given by the charts plotted with the calculation
obtained the sensex which has been considered as a stock is bought on that day’s
closing price and is sold at the next signal as plotted by the graph. The profits or loss
so obtained is checked for the percentage of returns and the tools are ranked based on
the returns, higher the return higher the rank.
For the sake of convenience the stock gas been bought and sold for that particular year
based on the predications made by only one indicator and its return is calculated. But
in reality predications made by all the indicators are considered and decisions are
made
M.P.Birla Institute of Management Page 46
Relevance Of Technical Analysis
DATA:
The data collected for the research purpose are secondary data. Index prices
were collected through Bombay Stock Exchange website and through
Capitaline website. The data employed in this study comprises of three year
observations on the SENSEX stock index Closing price.
Daily data are preferred in this study as daily closing price is realistic and is
helpful to calculate and in testing the results in technical analysis.
DATABASE:
The data relating to the study is taken from CAPITALINE PLUS database.
The data regarding index share price was also taken from website:
www.bseindia.com.
th
Technical analysis of stock trends, 8 Edition, Robert D. Edwards, and John
Magee.
Financial journals, dailies like capital market, dalal street, and Economic times
are also used.
M.P.Birla Institute of Management Page 47
Relevance Of Technical Analysis
SAMPLE SIZE:
Three year closing price of SENSEX INDEX from1st January 2005 to 31st
December 2007 has been taken for testing the relevance of technical analysis.
The Momentum.
M.P.Birla Institute of Management Page 48
Relevance Of Technical Analysis
Day Moving averages are one of the most popular and easy to use tools available to
the technical analyst. They smooth a data series and make it easier to spot trends,
something that is especially helpful in volatile markets. They also form the building
blocks for many other technical indicators and overlays.
The two most popular types of moving averages are the daily Moving Average (SMA)
and the Exponential moving Average (EMA). In this study day moving average has
taken.
For example: a 5-day simple moving average is calculated by adding the closing prices
for the last 5 days and dividing the total by 5.
10 + 11 + 12 + 13 + 14 = 60
60 ÷ 5 = 12
The calculation is repeated for each price bar on the chart. The averages are then
joined to form a smooth curving line - the moving average line. Continuing the
example, if the next closing price in the average is 15, then this new period would be
added and the oldest day, which is 10, would be dropped. The new 5-day simple
moving average would be calculated as follows:
11 + 12 + 13 + 14 + 15 = 65
65 ÷ 5 = 13
The averaging process then moves on to the next day where the 10-day SMA for day
12 is calculated by adding the prices of day 3 through day 12 and dividing by 10.
M.P.Birla Institute of Management Page 49
Relevance Of Technical Analysis
The primary purpose of moving averages is to "smooth" data so that trends are more
discernable. They are used to construct market indicators and to assist in interpretation
of price charts.
Moving average crossovers can also be used as signals to buy and sell. This is
normally done in two ways:
(1) by watching for price to cross whatever moving average one may be using, or
(2) running two moving averages of the same price or index, one faster than the other,
and buying or selling when the faster average crosses the slower.
The weakness of moving average buy and sell systems is that they will most likely
become unprofitable when the stock or index begins moving sideways in a narrow
trading range. Under these circumstances price never moves above or below the
average far enough to become profitable.
Usage of pure moving average systems for timing purposes may not be recommended,
but, in spite of their weaknesses, if one is trying to develop their own system of
timing, the use of moving averages is a good place to start with.
M.P.Birla Institute of Management Page 50
Relevance Of Technical Analysis
The Rate of Change (ROC) indicator is a very simple yet effective oscillator that
measures the percent change in price from one period to the next. The ROC
calculation compares the current price with the price n periods ago.
The plot forms an oscillator that fluctuates above and below the zero line as the Rate
of Change moves from positive to negative. The oscillator can be used as any other
momentum oscillator by looking for higher lows, lower highs, positive and negative
divergences, and crosses above and below zero for signals.
ROC can be plotted using different periods such as 10 days or 30 days by changing the
value. The longer the time span used, the greater the fluctuation in the indicator (in
terms of both magnitude and duration).
There is another popular indicator called "Momentum" that is almost identical to the
Rate of Change indicator. The only difference is that the Rate of Change indicator
adds 100 to the ROC's value. Momentum also uses 100 as its center line instead of
zero like the ROC. Because both indicators give identical signals, StockCharts.com
has chosen to only implement the Rate of Change version. People who are used to
using the Momentum indicator can simply replace that with the ROC indicator on their
charts.
M.P.Birla Institute of Management Page 51
Relevance Of Technical Analysis
The Relative Strength Index (RSI) is an extremely useful and popular momentum
oscillator. The RSI compares the magnitude of a stock's recent gains to the magnitude
of its recent losses and turns that information into a number that ranges from 0 to 100.
It takes a single parameter, the number of time periods to use in the calculation.
Calculation:
To simplify the formula, the RSI has been broken down into its basic components
which are the Average Gain, the Average Loss, the First RS, and the subsequent
Smoothed RS's.
For a 20 -period RSI, the Average Gain equals the sum total all gains divided by 20.
Even if there are only 5 gains (losses), the total of those 5 gains (losses) is divided by
the total number of RSI periods in the calculation (20 in this case). The Average Loss
is computed in a similar manner.
Calculation of the First RS value is straightforward: divide the Average Gain by the
Average Loss. All subsequent RS calculations use the previous period's Average Gain
and Average Loss for smoothing purposes.
M.P.Birla Institute of Management Page 52
Relevance Of Technical Analysis
THE MOMENTUM
The momentum is certainly the easiest one to compute. The momentum is the
difference between today's price and the one of n days before.
MO = P - P
t t t-n
The most often used are 5, 10, 20, 25 and 28 days. Here 20 days momentum is used to
find out the short term appliance of the momentum.
Buy and Hold Strategy is in fact the easiest method that can be followed without much
hassle and it is tension free as it does not look for right time to entry and exit the
market now and then.
It actually follows a scheme of buying the stock and holding it for a period of time and
selling the same at the end of the tome period..
M.P.Birla Institute of Management Page 53
Relevance Of Technical Analysis
Transaction cost involved in the trading of stock has been considered nil.
The research has been conducted for a period of three years only.
Only a selected few tools of technical analysis like Days Moving Average,
Relative Strength Index, Rate of change method and Price Momentum has
been used from numerous tools available.
M.P.Birla Institute of Management Page 54
Relevance Of Technical Analysis
DATA ANALYSIS
&
INTERPRETATION
M.P.Birla Institute of Management Page 55
Relevance Of Technical Analysis
PROFIT/ RETURNS IN
DATE BUY SELL LOSS TERMS OF %
17.02.2005 6460
28.02.2005 6595 135
17.03.2005 6727
04.05.2005 6326 -401
23.08.2005 7707
01.09.2005 7727 20
06.10.2005 8438
07.11.2005 8121 -317 -2.95
-563
17.02.2006 9981
21.02.2006 10168 187
15.05.2006 11822
19.06.2006 9998 -1824
17.07.2006 10293
26.07.2006 10617 324
11.09.2006 11551
12.09.2006 11661 110
08.12.2006 13799
15.12.2006 13615 -184
19.12.2006 13382
26.12.2006 13708 326 -3.51
-1061
05.01.2007 13861
02.02.2007 14404 543
02.03.2007 12886
30.05.2007 14411 1525
06.06.2007 14256
19.07.2007 15550 1294
14.08.2007 15001
29.10.2007 19978 4977
08.11.2007 19059
13.11.2007 19035 -24
19.11.2007 19633
11.12.2007 20291 658 0.72
8973
TOTAL
PROFIT 7349 RETURNS -5.75
M.P.Birla Institute of Management Page 56
Relevance Of Technical Analysis
A Daily Moving Average is an indicator that shows the average value of a security's
price over a period of time. When calculating a daily moving average, a mathematical
analysis of the security's average value over a predetermined time period is made. As
the security's price changes, its average price moves up or down.
It is evident from the plotted graphs that trends in stock prices can be very volatile.
One technique for dealing with volatile stock price is day moving average. It is
constructed by totaling a set of data and dividing the sum by the number of
observation. Here in this study 20 day moving average is constructed for the Sensex
index price of 2007. The actual closing price and the calculated DMA are plotted in
the same graph monthly vice basis. A rising DMA indicates market strength and a
declining one denotes weakness. Changes in the price trend are identified by the price
itself crossing its day moving average.
The most popular method of interpreting a daily moving average is to compare the
relationship between a daily moving average of the security's closing price and the
security's closing price itself. A sell signal is generated when the security's price falls
below its daily moving average and a buy signal is generated when the security's price
rises above its moving average. This type of daily moving average trading system is
not intended to get in at the exact bottom and out at the exact top. Rather, it is
designed to keep in line with the security's price trend by buying shortly after the
security's price bottoms and selling shortly after it tops.
M.P.Birla Institute of Management Page 57
Relevance Of Technical Analysis
The critical element in a daily moving average is the number of time periods used in
calculating the average. When using hindsight, one can always find a moving average
that would have been profitable. The key is to find a moving average that will be
consistently profitable. Here 20-day moving average has been used to find out the
significance of moving average in short term trading.
A change from a rising trend to declining price is signaled when the price moves
below its day moving average. A bullish signal is given when the price goes above the
DMA. The technicians gets the sell signal at the point where declining DMA
crossover the price line. Traders will buy the share at the point where rising trend
crosses the actual price line.
The calculations were done as mentioned above for 20 days DMA and the
corresponding chart was made in order to find out the various timings to enter and exit
the market.
As indicated by the chart the stock was bought and sold every year for a period of
three years.
It was bought and sold 4 times during 2005, 6 times in the year 2006 and around 6
times in 2007.
On 17.02.2005 DMA technique gave a buy signal and the stock (sensex closing price)
was bought for a price of 6460 and similarly a sell signal was given by the same
method around 20.02.2005 where it was sold at 6595 by making a profit of about 135.
Similarly the process was followed for that whole year and was able to make a profit
of -563.
The technique was employed during 2006 and 2007. During 2006 DMA was able to
generate a profit of -1061 and 8973 respectively.
M.P.Birla Institute of Management Page 58
Relevance Of Technical Analysis
Once this has been done the returns DMA made for every year was calculated as
follows
(The price stock was sold at the year end – The price brought at the beginning)
_______________________________________________________________
For 2005,
-563 - 563
Similarly it was found that year 2006 gave a return of about -3.513 and during 2007
about 0.717
And Using DMA as a tool to aid in investing one was able to make returns of -5.75
for three years .
M.P.Birla Institute of Management Page 59
Relevance Of Technical Analysis
01.02.2005 6552
10.02.2005 6578 26
28.02.2005 6714
04.03.2005 6849 135
18.04.2005 6157
13.05.2005 6452 295
19.07.2005 7347
16.09.2005 8381 1034
28.10.2005 7686
23.11.2005 8638 952
2442 0.85
02.02.2006 9844
10.02.2006 10111 267
07.03.2006 10726
13.03.2006 10804 78
12.04.2006 11356
07.07.2006 10510 -846
20.07.2006 10353
11.08.2006 11192 839
11.09.2006 11551
20.09.2006 12010 459
03.10.2006 12366
09.10.2006 12366 0
11.12.2006 13399
14.12.2006 20031 6632
7429 1.37
28.02.2007 12938
17.04.2007 13607 669
18.06.2007 14080
05.07.2007 14862 782
21.08.2007 13988
13.09.2007 15614 1626
12.11.2007 18737
16.11.2007 19698 961
28.11.2007 18938
11.12.2007 20291 1353
M.P.Birla Institute of Management Page 60
Relevance Of Technical Analysis
5391 1.36
TOTAL
PROFIT 15262 RETURNS 3.59
A popular method of analyzing the RSI is to look for a divergence in which the market
index is making a new high, but the RSI is failing to surpass its previous high. This
divergence would be an indication of an impending reversal. When the RSI then turns
down and falls below its most recent trough, it is said to have completed a failure
swing. The failure swing would be considered a confirmation of an impending
reversal.
If the RSI goes above 70 the shares are overbought, and one should consider selling at
that price level. If the RSI goes below 30 the shares are oversold, and one should be
looking for buying opportunities. The neutral position of this oscillator is at 50; if it
rises above 50, the instrument is becoming overbought, if it falls below it is becoming
oversold. Critical levels exist at 75 and 25. An RSI above or below these levels
indicates the instrument is overbought or oversold.
The calculations were done as mentioned above for 20 days RSI and the
corresponding chart was made in order to find out the various timings to enter and exit
the market.
As indicated by the chart the stock was bought and sold every year for a period of
three years.
It was bought and sold 5 times during 2005, 7 times during 2006 and 5 times in 2007.
M.P.Birla Institute of Management Page 61
Relevance Of Technical Analysis
On 01.02.2005 RSI technique gave a buy signal and the stock (sensex closing price)
was bought for a price of 6552 and similarly a sell signal was given by the same
method around 10.02.2005 where it was sold at 6578 by making a profit of about 26.
Similarly the process was followed for that whole year and was able to make a profit
of 2518.
The same technique was employed during 2006 and 2007. During 2006 RSI was able
to generate a profit of 7429 and 5391 respectively.
Once this has been done the returns RSI made for every year was calculated as follows
(The price stock was sold at the year end – The price brought at the beginning)
_______________________________________________________________
For 2005,
2442 2442
Similarly it was found that year 2006 gave a return of about 1.37 and during 2007
about 1.36.
And Using RSI as a tool to aid in investing one was able to make returns of 3.59 for
three years .
M.P.Birla Institute of Management Page 62
Relevance Of Technical Analysis
01.02.2005 6552
14.02.2005 6679 127
18.04.2005 6157
26.05.2005 6671 514
29.08.2005 7634
21.09.2005 8487 853
19.10.2005 7971
28.11.2005 8995 1024
2518 0.97
03.02.2006 9920
16.02.2006 10124 204
24.02.2006 10201
05.04.2006 11747 1546
13.04.2006 11237
10.05.2006 12612 1375
15.05.2006 11822
17.05.2006 12218 396
08.06.2006 9296
09.06.2006 9810 514
13.06.2006 9063
10.07.2006 10684 1621
19.07.2006 10007
16.08.2006 11448 1441
12.09.2006 11661
21.11.2006 13617 1956
12.12.2006 12995
29.12.2006 13787 792
9845 0.39
04.04.2007 12787
25.07.2007 15699 2912
18.09.2007 15669
31.10.2007 19784 4115
7027 1.00
TOTAL
PROFIT 19390 RETURNS 2.359
M.P.Birla Institute of Management Page 63
Relevance Of Technical Analysis
The Rate of Change indicator (ROC) is a way of showing how rapidly the price of a
particular share (or other financial instrument) is moving. The theory is that if a price
is rising (or falling) very quickly there will soon come a time when it is thought to be
overbought (or oversold). When this occurs the price may still continue to rise (or
fall), but not as rapidly as it was before.
This oscillator always has a value between 0 and 10 and is calculated from the average
of all price rises in a given period divided by the average of all price falls in the same
period. Again the choice of period is arbitrary and dependent on one’s position in the
markets.
The major use of this oscillator is to identify the overbought and oversold zones. To
identify the overbought zone, look at the historic high values on the ROC chart for the
scrip that is been studied. If one finds that the current value is in the peak of the
historic high values, the scrip can be said to have entered the overbought zone. On the
same count, if the ROC touches the historic low values, the scrip can be said to have
entered the oversold zone.
The Rate of change indicator is not necessarily same with the other indicators.
It was bought and sold 4 times during 2005, 9 times during 2006 and twice in 2007.
On 01.02.2005 ROC technique gave a buy signal and the stock (sensex closing price)
was bought for a price of 6552 and similarly a sell signal was given by the same
method around 14.02.2005 where it was sold at 6679 by making a profit of about 127.
M.P.Birla Institute of Management Page 64
Relevance Of Technical Analysis
Similarly the process was followed for that whole year and was able to make a profit
of 2518.
The same technique was employed during 2006 and 2007. During 2006 DMA was
able to generate a profit of 9845 and 7027 respectively.
Once this has been done the returns ROC made for every year was calculated as
follows
(The price stock was sold at the year end – The price brought at the beginning)
_______________________________________________________________
For 2005,
2518 2518
Similarly it was found that year 2006 gave a return of about 0.39 and during 2007
about 1.00.
And Using RSI as a tool to aid in investing one was able to make returns of 2.359 for
three years .
M.P.Birla Institute of Management Page 65
Relevance Of Technical Analysis
THE MOMENTUM
PROFIT RETURNS IN
DATE BUY SELL /LOSS TERMS OF %
03.01.2005 6679
12.01.2005 6103 -576
31.01.2005 6221
08.02.2005 6545 324
21.03.2005 6657
19.04.2004 6135 -522
25.04.2005 6378
02.05.2005 6195 -183
24.06.2005 7149
07.07.2005 7145 -4
12.07.2005 7304
14.07.2005 7188 -116
01.08.2005 7669
23.08.2005 7616 -53
21.09.2005 8487
28.09.2005 8606 119
29.11.2005 8931
30.12.2005 9398 467
-544 -5.00
16.02.2006 10124
24.02.2006 10201 77
03.03.2006 10595
08.03.2006 10509 -86
05.04.2006 11747
13.04.2006 11237 -510
21.04.2006 12030
05.05.2006 12360 330
10.05.2006 12612
16.05.2006 11874 -738
10.07.2006 10684
19.07.2006 10007 -677
26.07.2006 10617
01.08.2006 10752 135
M.P.Birla Institute of Management Page 66
Relevance Of Technical Analysis
03.08.2006 10623
18.09.2006 12071 1448
23.10.2006 12623
22.11.2006 13707 1084
12.12.2006 12995
29.01.2006 13787 792
1855 1.97
05.03.2007 12415
16.04.2007 13696 1281
15.06.2007 14163
23.07.2007 15732 1569
21.08.2007 13989
19.09.2007 16232 2243
08.10.2007 17491
15.10.2007 19059 1568
22.10.2007 17614
29.10.2007 19978 2364
09.11.2007 18908
15.11.2007 19785 877
22.11.2007 18526
07.12.2007 19966 1440
17.12.2007 19261
27.12.2007 20287 1026 12368 0.64
TOTAL
PROFIT 13679 RETURNS -2.39
The Momentum indicator measures the amount that a security's price has changed
over a given time span.
M.P.Birla Institute of Management Page 67
Relevance Of Technical Analysis
INTERPRETATION:
There are basically two ways to use the Momentum indicator: You can use the
Momentum indicator as a trend-following oscillator similar to the MACD. Buy when
the indicator bottoms and turns up and sell when the indicator peaks and turns down
(this is the method preferred in this study).
If the Momentum indicator reaches extremely high or low values (relative to its
historical values), one should assume a continuation of the current trend. For example,
if the Momentum indicator reaches extremely high values and then turns down, one
should assume prices will probably go still higher. In either case, only trade after
prices confirm the signal generated by the indicator (e.g., if prices peak and turn down,
wait for prices to begin to fall before selling).
One can also use the Momentum indicator as a leading indicator. This method
assumes that market tops are typically identified by a rapid price increase (when
everyone expects prices to go higher) and that market bottoms typically end with rapid
price declines (when everyone wants to get out).
As a market peaks, the Momentum indicator will climb sharply and then fall off-
diverging from the continued upward or sideways movement of the price.
Similarly, at a market bottom, Momentum will drop sharply and then begin to climb
well ahead of prices.
M.P.Birla Institute of Management Page 68
Relevance Of Technical Analysis
Both of these situations result in divergences between the indicator and prices.
It was bought and sold 9 times during 2005, 10 times during the year 2006 and about 8
times in 2007.
On 03.01.2005 MOMENTUM technique gave a buy signal and the stock (sensex
closing price) was bought for a price of 6679 and similarly a sell signal was given by
the same method around 12.01.2005 where it was sold at 6103 by making a loss of
about 576.
Similarly the process was followed for that whole year and was able to make a loss of
544.
The same technique was employed during 2006 and 2007. During 2006
MOMENTUM was able to generate a profit of 1855 and 12368 respectively.
Once this has been done, the returns MOMENTUM made for every year was
calculated as follows
(The price stock was sold at the year end – The price brought at the beginning)
_______________________________________________________________
For 2005,
-544 -544
Similarly it was found that year 2006 gave a return of about 1.97 and during 2007
about 0.64.
M.P.Birla Institute of Management Page 69
Relevance Of Technical Analysis
And Using RSI as a tool to aid in investing one was able to make returns of - 2.39 for
three years .
03.01.2005 6679
30.12.3005 9398 2719 0.41
02.01.2006 9390
29.12.2006 13789 4399 0.47
02.01.2007 13942
31.12.2007 20287 6345 0.46
In this method the stock is bought at the beginning of the year i.e. on 03.01.2005 for
6679 and sold at the yearend for 9398 on 30.12.2005 and a profit of about 2719 has
been made.
And during 2006 , the stock was bought on 02.01.2006 for 9390 and sold at
29.12.2006 for 13789 with a profit of 4399
And during 2007, it was bought at 13942 on 02.01.2007 and sold for 20287 on
31.12.2007 with a profit of 6345.
M.P.Birla Institute of Management Page 70
Relevance Of Technical Analysis
In terms of returns,
(The price stock was sold at the year end – The price brought at the beginning)
_______________________________________________________________
For 2005,
6679 6679
Similarly returns for 2006 and 2007 are 0.47 and 0.46 respectively with a total of 1.33
for three years.
M.P.Birla Institute of Management Page 71
Relevance Of Technical Analysis
M.P.Birla Institute of Management Page 72
Relevance Of Technical Analysis
M.P.Birla Institute of Management Page 73
Relevance Of Technical Analysis
2007
METHOD 2005 RANK 2006 RANK
RANK
DMA 5 5 3
RSI 2 2 1
MOMENTUM 4 1 4
ROC 1 4 2
BUY/HOLD 3 3 5
M.P.Birla Institute of Management Page 74
Relevance Of Technical Analysis
M.P.Birla Institute of Management Page 75
Relevance Of Technical Analysis
SUMMARY
&
CONCLUSION
M.P.Birla Institute of Management Page 76
Relevance Of Technical Analysis
SUMMARY
With the use of various tools of technical analysis like DMA, RSI, ROC and
MOMENTUM the profits and the returns are calculated and it is found that
In 2005 by using DMA alone as an indicator one will be able to make a loss of
563 with about -2.95 returns and in the year 2006 loss of 1061 with -3.51 as
returns but in the year 2007 a profit of 8973 with 0.72 as returns could be
made totaling to about 7349 as profit with a total of about -5.75 returns at the
end of three years. Although DMA has a negative returns of 5.75 was able to
make profit of 7349 as a whole.
In 2005 when Relative Strength Index alone used as indicator was able to
make a profit of 2422 with 0.85 as returns and in 2006 about 7429 as profit
with 1.29 as returns and in the year 2007 was able to make a profit of 5391
with 1.36 as returns totaling to a profit of about 15262 with 3.59 as returns.
Instead of using any of the tools of technical analysis if one simply buys and
holds will be able to make a profit of 2719 with 0.41 returns in 2005 and a
profit of 4399 with 0.47 returns in 2006 and a profit of about 6345 with 0.46
returns in 2007 totaling to about 13463 of profits with 1.33 returns for three
Years.
M.P.Birla Institute of Management Page 77
Relevance Of Technical Analysis
When ranks were graded to these tools based on the returns they made it could be seen
that
Rate of Change Method ranked first for two years in 2005 and 2006 and
ranked second in 2007 and ranks second as whole in three years.
Relative Strength Index ranked first in 2007 and second in the years 2005 and
2006 and ranks first as a whole for three years.
Buy and Hold Strategy ranks third for 2005 and 2006 and the last rank i.e. fifth
rank in 2007 and ranks three as a whole for three years.
Although Momentum ranks first in 2006 it takes the fourth place in 2005 and
2007 and ranks fourth as a whole for three years
Days Moving Average ranks fifth in 2005 and 2006 but ranks third in 2007.
But it takes the last rank i.e. fifth rank as a whole for three years.
FINDINGS
Tools of Technical analysis were able to make more profits when compared to
buy and hold strategy in this study.
Not all the tools used here gave the same result for the same period.
Relative Strength Index is the most appropriate tool to predict the stock price
movement to make profits in terms of returns for three year period.
Rate of Change Method is the second best method in terms of returns though it
was able to generate more profits than Relative Strength Index.
M.P.Birla Institute of Management Page 78
Relevance Of Technical Analysis
CONCLUSION
Technical analysis can offer great insight, but if used improperly, they can also
produce false signals. While trend lines have become a very popular aspect of
technical analysis, they are merely one tool for establishing, analyzing, and confirming
a trend. Trend lines should not be the final arbiter, but should serve merely as a
warning that a change in trend may be very useful.
The price set by the market reflects the sum knowledge of all participants, and one is
not dealing with lightweights here. These participants have considered (discounted)
everything under the sun and settled on a price to buy or sell. These are the forces of
supply and demand at work.
Even though there are some universal principles and rules that can be applied, it must
be remembered that technical analysis is more an art form than a science. As an art
form, it is subject to interpretation. However, it is also flexible in its approach and
each investor should use only that which suits his or her style. Developing a style
takes time, effort and dedication, but the rewards can be significant.
The result of this study shows that Relative Strength Index is the most reliable tool of
technical analysis in terms of returns and next comes Rate of Change Method.
It may not be 100% true, because the tools and the software used in the chart here are
not very advanced one as traders use in their analysis.
M.P.Birla Institute of Management Page 79
Relevance Of Technical Analysis
Which technical analysis tool one uses will depend on one’s trading and investing
style and preferences. Some traders prefer to use Relative Strength Index for shorter
time periods to capture changes quicker. Some investors prefer simple moving
averages over long time periods to identify long-term trend changes. The day moving
average also has a lag, but the other tools which are used here also are prone to
quicker breaks.
In addition, much will depend on the individual security in question. The technical
chart type and length of time will depend greatly on the individual security and how it
has reacted in the past.
The initial thought for some is that greater sensitivity and quicker signals are bound to
be beneficial. This is not always true and brings up a great dilemma for the technical
analyst: the tradeoff between sensitivity and reliability. The more sensitive an
indicator is the more signals that will be given. These signals may prove timely, but
with increased sensitivity comes an increase in false signals.
The less sensitive an indicator is the fewer signals that will be given. However, less
sensitivity leads to fewer and more reliable signals. Sometimes these signals can be
late as well.
Technical analysis can offer great insight, but if used improperly, they can also
produce false signals. While trend lines have become a very popular aspect of
technical analysis, they are merely one tool for establishing, analyzing, and confirming
a trend. Trend lines should not be the final arbiter, but should serve merely as a
warning that a change in trend may be very useful.
The price set by the market reflects the sum knowledge of all participants, and one is
not dealing with lightweights here.
M.P.Birla Institute of Management Page 80
Relevance Of Technical Analysis
These participants have considered (discounted) everything under the sun and settled
on a price to buy or sell. These are the forces of supply and demand at work.
Even though there are some universal principles and rules that can be applied, it must
be remembered that technical analysis is more an art form than a science. As an art
form, it is subject to interpretation. However, it is also flexible in its approach and
each investor should use only that which suits his or her style. Developing a style
takes time, effort and dedication, but the rewards can be significant.
And it can be said that based on this study Technical Analysis does has relevance in
aiding investors to make maximum profits rather than the simple buy and hold
strategy and it can be said that the profits are worth the effort one puts in to make
profits than Buy and Hold Strategy .
As the research has been done by taking only the closing price of the Sensex index for
a period of three years, further research could be done by considering sector wise
closing price of the stocks and/or by selecting few stocks from Large Cap, Mid Cap
and Small Cap stocks for a long periods of time and can be back tested by applying
various tools of Technical Analysis and its relevance could be found for the same.
M.P.Birla Institute of Management Page 81
Relevance Of Technical Analysis
BIBLIOGRAPHY
M.P.Birla Institute of Management Page 82
Relevance Of Technical Analysis
TEXT BOOKS:
th
1. Technical analysis of stock trends, 8 Edition, Robert D. Edwards, John Magee.
2. Technical analysis of stock trends by Martin Pring.
ARTICLES:
1. MARKET EFFICIENCY AND THE RETURNS TO TECHNICAL
ANALYSIS (Article published in December 1997)
Hendrik Bessembinder and Kalok Chan, Department of Finance, College of Business,
Arizona State University.
2. THE USE OF FUNDAMENTAL AND TECHNICAL ANALYSES BY
FOREIGN EXCHANGE DEALERS: hong kong evidence.
Journal of international money and finance, 1998.
David Mole, Department of economics and finance, City university of Hong Kong.
3. TECHNICAL ANALYSIS IN THE FOREIGN EXCHANGE MARKET: A
Co-integration-Based Approach (Article in Multinational finance journal, 1999).
Nobert Fiess, University of Strathclyde and U. K. Ronald MacDonald, University of
strathclyde,
4. TECHNICAL ANALYSIS AND TYPICAL COGNITIVE BIASES
(Article in journal of finance 2001)
Piotr Zielonka, Warsaw University SGGW and Leon Kozminski Academy of
Entrepreneurship and Management, Poland.
WEBSITES:
www.capitaline.com
www.google.com
www.investopedia.com
www.bseindia.com
www.valuenotes.com
www.yahoofinance.com
www.rediffmail.com.
M.P.Birla Institute of Management Page 83
Relevance Of Technical Analysis
ANNEXURES
TABLE FOR DAY MOVING AVERAGES CALCULATION FOR 2007
02.01.2007 13942.24 0
03.01.2007 14014.92 0
04.01.2007 13871.71 0
05.01.2007 13860.52 0
08.01.2007 13652.15 0
09.01.2007 13566.33 0
10.01.2007 13362.16 0
11.01.2007 13630.71 0
12.01.2007 14056.53 0
15.01.2007 14129.64 0
16.01.2007 14114.73 0
17.01.2007 14131.34 0
18.01.2007 14217.75 0
19.01.2007 14182.71 0
22.01.2007 14209.24 0
23.01.2007 14041.24 0
24.01.2007 14110.46 0
25.01.2007 14282.72 0
29.01.2007 14211.96 0
31.01.2007 14090.92 13984
01.02.2007 14267.18 14000
02.02.2007 14403.77 14020
05.02.2007 14515.90 14052
06.02.2007 14478.19 14083
07.02.2007 14643.13 14132
08.02.2007 14652.09 14187
09.02.2007 14538.90 14245
12.02.2007 14190.70 14273
13.02.2007 14090.98 14275
14.02.2007 14009.90 14269
15.02.2007 14355.55 14281
19.02.2007 14402.90 14295
20.02.2007 14253.38 14297
21.02.2007 14188.49 14297
22.02.2007 14021.31 14287
23.02.2007 13632.53 14267
26.02.2007 13649.52 14244
27.02.2007 13478.83 14204
28.02.2007 12938.09 14140
M.P.Birla Institute of Management Page 84
Relevance Of Technical Analysis
M.P.Birla Institute of Management Page 85
Relevance Of Technical Analysis
M.P.Birla Institute of Management Page 86
Relevance Of Technical Analysis
M.P.Birla Institute of Management Page 87
Relevance Of Technical Analysis
M.P.Birla Institute of Management Page 88
Relevance Of Technical Analysis
M.P.Birla Institute of Management Page 89
Relevance Of Technical Analysis
M.P.Birla Institute of Management Page 90
Relevance Of Technical Analysis
M.P.Birla Institute of Management Page 91
Relevance Of Technical Analysis
M.P.Birla Institute of Management Page 92
Relevance Of Technical Analysis
M.P.Birla Institute of Management Page 93
Relevance Of Technical Analysis
M.P.Birla Institute of Management Page 94
Relevance Of Technical Analysis
M.P.Birla Institute of Management Page 95
Relevance Of Technical Analysis
02.01.2007 13942
03.01.2007 14015
04.01.2007 13872
05.01.2007 13861
08.01.2007 13652
09.01.2007 13566
10.01.2007 13362
11.01.2007 13631
12.01.2007 14057
15.01.2007 14130
16.01.2007 14115
17.01.2007 14131
18.01.2007 14218
19.01.2007 14183
22.01.2007 14209
23.01.2007 14041
24.01.2007 14110
25.01.2007 14283
29.01.2007 14212
31.01.2007 14091 1.1
01.02.2007 14267 1.8
02.02.2007 14404 3.8
05.02.2007 14516 4.7
06.02.2007 14478 6.1
07.02.2007 14643 7.9
08.02.2007 14652 9.7
09.02.2007 14539 6.7
12.02.2007 14191 1.0
13.02.2007 14091 -0.3
14.02.2007 14010 -0.7
15.02.2007 14356 1.6
19.02.2007 14403 1.3
20.02.2007 14253 0.5
21.02.2007 14188 -0.1
22.02.2007 14021 -0.1
23.02.2007 13633 -3.4
26.02.2007 13650 -4.4
27.02.2007 13479 -5.2
28.02.2007 12938 -8.2
01.03.2007 13160 -7.8
02.03.2007 12886 -10.5
05.03.2007 12415 -14.5
06.03.2007 12697 -12.3
07.03.2007 12580 -14.1
M.P.Birla Institute of Management Page 96
Relevance Of Technical Analysis
M.P.Birla Institute of Management Page 97
Relevance Of Technical Analysis
M.P.Birla Institute of Management Page 98
Relevance Of Technical Analysis
M.P.Birla Institute of Management Page 99
Relevance Of Technical Analysis
M.P.Birla Institute of Management Page 100
Relevance Of Technical Analysis
M.P.Birla Institute of Management Page 101
Relevance Of Technical Analysis
02.01.2007 13942
03.01.2007 14015
04.01.2007 13872
05.01.2007 13861
08.01.2007 13652
09.01.2007 13566
10.01.2007 13362
11.01.2007 13631
12.01.2007 14057
15.01.2007 14130
16.01.2007 14115
17.01.2007 14131
18.01.2007 14218
19.01.2007 14183
22.01.2007 14209
23.01.2007 14041
24.01.2007 14110
25.01.2007 14283
29.01.2007 14212
31.01.2007 14091 149
01.02.2007 14267 252
02.02.2007 14404 532
05.02.2007 14516 655
06.02.2007 14478 826
07.02.2007 14643 1077
08.02.2007 14652 1290
09.02.2007 14539 908
12.02.2007 14191 134
13.02.2007 14091 -39
14.02.2007 14010 -105
15.02.2007 14356 224
19.02.2007 14403 185
20.02.2007 14253 71
21.02.2007 14188 -21
22.02.2007 14021 -20
23.02.2007 13633 -478
26.02.2007 13650 -633
27.02.2007 13479 -733
28.02.2007 12938 -1153
01.03.2007 13160 -1108
02.03.2007 12886 -1518
05.03.2007 12415 -2101
06.03.2007 12697 -1781
07.03.2007 12580 -2063
M.P.Birla Institute of Management Page 102
Relevance Of Technical Analysis
M.P.Birla Institute of Management Page 103
Relevance Of Technical Analysis
M.P.Birla Institute of Management Page 104
Relevance Of Technical Analysis
M.P.Birla Institute of Management Page 105
Relevance Of Technical Analysis
M.P.Birla Institute of Management Page 106
Relevance Of Technical Analysis
M.P.Birla Institute of Management Page 107