Documentos de Académico
Documentos de Profesional
Documentos de Cultura
to diet, can be caused by excessive use of antacids or diuret- attempts to calculate the impact of the whole food—a daunting
ics, chronic vomiting or diarrhea, overactivity of the adrenal task given the complexity of metabolism.3
glands, and living at high altitudes.3 A further step in the evolution of quantifying foods’ impact
on pH involved estimating the potential kidney-acid load of
foods (i.e., the extent to which foods affect urine pH and
Consequences of Disturbed Acid–Base urine acid excretion). This model enabled the development of
Homeostasis food tables showing estimates of the acid- or alkaline-form-
ing potential of many common foods. A simplified related
Acidosis and alkalosis are not diseases in themselves, but strategy analyzed a food’s ratio of protein (the major dietary
rather are imbalances indicative of underlying conditions. A acidifying force) to potassium (the major dietary alkalizing
typical acidogenic Western diet low in K-base–rich plant foods force) to predict the amount of acid excreted by the kidneys
and high in acid-forming nutrients from animal protein in-
creases the body’s net systematic acid load and may result in
chronic, low-grade acidosis. Superphysiologic acid loads can
result in kidney-stone formation, decreased muscle and boss Acidosis and alkalosis are not
mass in adults, and mental retardation in children. Death can
even result in severe cases.1
diseases in themselves, but rather
Christopher Vasey, N.D., a naturopathic doctor, based near are imbalances indicative of
Montreux, Switzerland, has stated that chronic imbalance
results in health problems, including fatigue, slowed down
underlying conditions.
endocrine functioning (except in the thyroid), and suscep-
tibility to respiratory and urinary-tract infection (UTI), by
causing enzyme disturbances, aggressive activity by acids, and thus, the amount of acid created by the metabolized food.
and demineralization of bones.6 Chronic demineralization Other formulas exist for quantifying the impact of foods on
of bones can lead to osteoporosis, osteoarthritis (OA), and acid excretion.3
other bone-related conditions, which have been associated
with animal protein–dominant, acid–base unbalanced diets,
and lifestyles not conducive to bone health.3 A Model of Acid–Base Chemistry
Chronic low-grade acidosis can also contribute to prema-
ture aging by impairing cellular-repair processes, accelerating A quantitative model was developed by Canadian physi-
muscle loss (by breaking down cells to derive the amino acid ologist Peter A. Stewart, Ph.D. (1921–1993), to provide in-
glutamine used in the manufacture of the base ammonia for sights into the complex chemistry of acid–base equilibrium,7
deacidification), and cognitive decline.3 which is beyond the scope of this paper.* The Stewart model
has been influential in the understanding of the mechanisms
of this metabolic balance and its imbalances,8 and in main-
Methods of Food pH Analysis stream clinical practice,9 particularly in critical-care set-
tings.10 Even practitioners who only perform surgery under
Estimates of acid–base food impact were originally based on local anesthesia need to be familiar with principles of the
the concept of acid and alkaline ash. Foods were considered acid–base balance.11
acidic if, when burned, their remaining ashes contained such
acid-forming minerals as phosphorus, sulfur, and iodine. Foods
were deemed alkaline if their ashes contained such minerals Assessing pH Level
as calcium, magnesium, and potassium. A newer approach
examines foods’ metabolic effects (i.e., the types of minerals, Measuring a patient’s pH level as an index of acid–base bal-
amino acids, and other compounds that the food contributed ance can be conducted through blood, urine, and saliva tests.
to the body after being metabolized). Formulas were created in Each bodily fluid has a slightly different pH level; arterial
blood has an average pH of 7.41, whereas urine pH can vary
*The Stewart model is based on the same principles as more-traditional from 5 to 8 over the course of a day, depending on the nu-
treatments of acid–base balance, but this mathematical approach treats trients consumed.3 In critical care, metabolic acidosis can be
pH in terms of independent and dependent variables. Bicarbonate and diagnosed through one of several blood tests: an arterial blood
hydrogen ions are the dependent variables. They represent the effects test to assess severity; a complete blood count (CBC) to assess
rather than the cause of acid–base imbalances and are regulated by the possible cause(s); and a metabolic panel to reveal the severity
independent variables in blood plasma of the partial pressure of CO2
and cause of the condition.4
(PCO2, the amount of CO2 gas dissolved in the blood), weak acids,
and the strong ion difference. As PCO2 levels rise, blood pH levels For assessing chronic low-grade metabolic acidosis in her
decrease, making it more acidic; as PCO2 decreases, blood pH levels patients, Dr. Brown utilizes a time-specific urine sample (i.e.,
will rise, making it more alkaline. a test that uses pH litmus paper with a first-in-the-morning
urine sample provided by patients at home) for initial assess- Nutritional Therapy
ment and subsequent monitoring. Dr. Brown suggests using
test paper that measures pH with sufficiently small gradi- Foods
ents to detect the 6.5–7.5 pH range. For patients who can- Ideally, every meal should contain a balance of alkalizing
not sleep for more than 6 hours without waking to urinate, a and acidifying nutrients. However, it is not always appar-
saliva test is an acceptable alternative. The normal range for a ent which foods are acidifying or alkalizing. For example,
saliva sample taken the first thing in the morning, which may although citrus fruits are chemically acidic, they have an
be higher than urine pH, is 6.5–7.5.3 alkalizing effect once they are metabolized, because a sig-
Certain drugs can interfere with the accuracy of pH read- nificant percentage of the citric and malic acids in these
ings. For example, ammonium chloride, which is found in foods is converted into bicarbonate in the liver. However,
some cold and cough medications, may produce high acidic
urine. Acetazolamide, which is used for treating glaucoma
and other conditions, may produce a falsely high alkaline
reading because this chemical forces the kidneys to excrete
It is not always apparent which
bicarbonate, which results in a lower blood pH. Conversely, foods are acidifying or alkalizing.
imbalanced acid–alkaline levels can interfere with the effec-
tiveness of some medications.3
because orange juice also contains high amounts of alka-
linizing potassium, this juice’s effect on raising urinary pH
Clinical Approaches to Achieving Acid–Base is much greater than that of lemonade, which is low in po-
Balance tassium.16 To complicate matters further, different forms of
the same food can be categorized differently. For example,
To achieve a consistently acidic pH level, Dr. Brown ad- while miso (soybean paste) is highly alkaline-forming, other
vises her patients to make dietary modifications aimed at al- soy products, including soybeans and tofu (soybean curd),
kalizing their diet. She recommends that 80% of each meal are considered highly acid-forming.3
consist of alkalizing foods. When a patient’s pH level reaches It is important to note that different practitioners may classify
the healthful range, a 60% alkaline to 40% acid ratio food foods somewhat differently in terms of their degree of acidity or
diet is then recommended.3 Adjustment of tissue alkalinity alkalinity. Dr. Vasey has noted that the ripeness and processing
through an alkalizing food-rich diet and appropriate supple- of foods affect their acid and alkaline levels. For instance, unripe
mentation can result in more-efficient metabolic detoxifica- fruit is more acidic than ripe fruit. Although dairy products are
tion and chronic-disease prevention.12 generally classified as acidifying, raw whole milk, fresh unheated
Robert O. Young, Ph.D., a microbiologist and nutritionist butter, and fresh soft unripened cheeses, such as well-drained
in Valley Center, California, applies principles of acid–base cottage cheese, are considered alkalizing.6
pH balance to treating types 1 and 2 diabetes. Chi C. Mao, Dr. Vasey has added a third category of foods to the al-
M.D., Ph.D. (chief medical officer, Select Specialty Hospi- kalizing and acidifying groups usually considered useful for
tals, Houston, Texas, at the time of publication), has likened maintaining a proper acid–alkaline balance: weak-acid foods,
this balance to the Traditional Chinese Medicine (TCM) (i.e., foods that can increase the alkalinity of the blood by
concept of the balance of opposite life forces necessary the abovementioned mechanism). Strong or stable acids, in
for health.13 contrast, come primarily from animal proteins and must be
Herman Aihara (who died in 1998), a noted advocate for eliminated by the kidneys. Weak acids, also called volatile ac-
the macrobiotic diet, explicitly linked acid–base balance with ids, come primarily from plant foods containing unacetylated
the concepts of yin and yang and imbalances in both to health salicylic, citric, oxalic, or pyruvic acid. However, yogurt and
problems, including cancer.14 TCM recommends a diet rich whey are protein-based sources of weak acids. Plant-based
in fresh vegetables and fruits, which are rich in bicarbonate sources listed by Dr. Vasey include unripe fruits, acid fruits
precursors, to promote health and longevity.15 (e.g., berries, citrus fruit), fruit juices, acidic vegetables (e.g.,
In two controlled studies (combined N = 30) conducted in tomatoes, rhubarb, watercress), sauerkraut, lactofermented
2002–2003, Dr. Young found that 20 patients (ages 10–61) vegetables, lemon juice, vinegar, and honey.
who remained in either of the studies were able to control Dr. Vasey considers weak acid foods particularly important for
their diabetes through a strict alkaline diet, nutritional sup- treating patients who, because of metabolic problems, cannot elim-
plements, and aerobic exercise in 12 weeks following an ini- inate weak acids through the usual route of respiration. Because
tial 1-week liquid fast. The regimen also resulted in weight “[t]he same food can have an entirely different effect depending
loss, maintenance of normal blood sugar, lower blood pres- on the body of the person who ingests it,” according to Dr. Vasey,
sure (BP), reduced total cholesterol, and significant reduc- diets for promoting a pH balance must be individualized.6
tion in need for insulin or other diabetic medication (an 81% Russell M. Jaffe, M.D., Ph.D., C.C.N., of ELISA/ACT
reduction for type 1 diabetes and 96% reduction for type Biotechnologies LLC, in Sterling, Virginia, lists antibiotics as
2 diabetes).13 highly acidic.17 Other drugs that may have an acidifying effect
8. Rehm M, Conzen PF, Peter K, Finesterer U. The Stewart model. “Mod- 18. Cook MS. The Ultimate pH Solution: Balance Your Body Chem-
ern” approach to the interpretation of the acid-base metabolism [in German]. istry to Prevent Disease and Lose Weight. New York: HarperCollins,
Anesthetist 2004;53:347-357. 2008.
9. Doberer D, Funk GC, Kirchner K, Schneeweiss B. A critique of Stewart’s 19. Ceglia L, Harris SS, Abrams SA, et al. Potassium carbonate attenu-
approach: Th
e chemical mechanism of dilutional acidosis. Intensive Care Med ates the urinary nitrogen excretion that accompanies an increase in dietary
2009;June 17:e-pub ahead of print. protein and may promote calcium absorption. J Clin Endocrinol Metab
10. Wooten EW. Science review: Quantitative acid-base physiology using the 2009;94:645–653.
Stewart model. Critical Care 2004;8:448–452. 20. Dawson-Hughes B, Harris SS, Palermo NJ, et al. Treatment with potas-
11. Shiffman MA. Acid–base balance: Biochemistry for all surgeons [review]. sium carbonate lowers calcium excretion and bone resorption in older men
Int J Cosmetic Aesthetic Dermatol 2001;3:17–18. and women. J Clin Endocrinol Metab 2009;94:96–102.
12. Minich DM, Bland JS. Acid–alkaline balance: Role in chronic disease and 21. Wynn E, Krieg MA, Aeschlimann JM, et al. Alkaline mineral water lowers
detoxification. Altern Ther Health Med 2007;13:62–65. bone resorption even in calcium sufficiency: Alkaline mineral water and bone
13. Young RO; Mao CC, Foreword. The pH Miracle for Diabetes: The Revolution- metabolism. Bone 2009;44:120–124.
ary Diet Plan for Type 1 and Type 2 Diabetes. New York: Warner Books, 2004. 22. Roux S, Baudoin C, Boute D, et al. Biological effects of drinking-water
14. Aihara H. Acid and Alkaline, 5th ed. Oroville, CA: George Ohsawa Mac- mineral composition on calcium balance and bone remodeling markers. J Nutr
robiotic Foundation, 1986. Health Aging 2004;8:380–384.
15. Matesz D. Achieving Acid–Base Balance. Acupuncture Today. Online 23. Shirahata S, Kabayama S, Nakano M, et al. Electrolyzed-reduced water
document at: www.acupuncturetoday.cm/archives2003/jul/07matesz.html scavenges active oxygen species and protects DNA from oxidative damage.
Accessed June 23, 2009. Biochem Biophys Res Comm 1997;234:269–274.
16. Odvina CV. Comparative value of orange juice versus lemonade in reduc-
ing stone-forming risk. Clin J Am Soc Nephrol 2006;1:1269–1274.
17. Jaffe RM. Food & Chemical Effects of Acid/Alkaline Body Chemical Bal-
ance. Online document at: www.elisaact.com/pdfs/EABAcidAlka_neChart_ To order reprints of this article, e-mail Karen Ballen at: Kballen@liebertpub.
FINAL.pdf Accessed July 1, 2009. com or call (914) 740-2100.