PAREVOLUTION.

COM
Daniels, 'Kristin
From:
Sent: Thursday, December 03, 2009 9:26 AM
To: Powers, James; Perelman, Michael; 411• • • • • • • • •
Co: Hoffman, Steven; Daniels, Kristin
Subject: Re: News from Institute of Terrorism Research and Responsel

Jim,
Definitely doable, What we would do is put together an ITRR team in conjunction with our counterparts in the
police and campus security for snch a seminar, If you want to include all emergency selvices, we would invite
the other Israeli emergency selvices as well. We would include case studies dealing with acl'vel'sarial planning,
using keysources, emergency response, command and control, perimeter and layered security, all dealing with
educational institutions, We would end the day with a tabletop, When we do tabletops ofthis nature, we break
the Israeli SMEs up into the breakout groups, so there is an exchange of information even at the "playing stage",

In short, yes, Would love to work with the Commonwealth on another project.

Let me know how we can help,

Aaroll

Sent ii'om my BlackBell'y® smartphone

From: "Powers, James" <japowers@state,pa,us>

Date: Thu, 3 Dec 2009 08:59: 11 -0500
To: Michael Perelman' 2 _ , '; Aaron ~:}:~~~~!=!,~~~
Cc: Hoffinan, Steven<sthoffinan@state,pa,us>; Daniels, ~
Subject: FW: News from Institute of Tell'olislll Research and Response!

Mike/Aaron,

From all Indications, this appears to be superb tralnlng- but probably not affordable by our
campus/university security directors, What's the chance of bring this trilinlng to the Commonwealth? I'll
bet we could get a ton of folks to attend, Perhaps run one session In Phil/y, one at HACC, and one In
Pittsburgh, '

Thoughts?

Jim

James F, Powers, Jr. I Director

Pennsylvania Office of Homeland Security
2605 Interstate Drive 1 Suite 380
Harrisburg, PA 17110-9382
Office: 717,651.27151 Fax: 717,651.2040
.W\N\'Y.JJ.Q rn e la nd secu J-j ty. state. ~~

This e-mail,lncludlngattachments, Is Intended for the sole use of the Indlvldual(s) and entlty(les) to whom addressed
and may contain Information that Is privileged, confidential and exempt from disclosure under applicable laws, If you
are neither the Intended addressee, nor authorized to receive emali on behalf of the Intended addressee, you
are hereby,notified that you may not use, copy, disclose or distribute any Information contained herein, If you have
received this message In error, Immediately notify the sender and delete the message,
1
 PAREVOLUTION.COM
From: Ety Richman On Behalf Of Ety Richman
Sent: Monday, November
To: Powers, James
Subject: News from Institute of Terrorism Research and Responsel

Sponsored by:

Institute of Terrorism Research and Response

&
BLUELINE Risk Mitigation Group, LLC

The Institute of Terrorism Research and Response (ITRR) In partnership with BLUELINE Risk
Mitigation Group Is making accessible to University Campus Security Professionals the opportunity to
study and view terrorism preparedness and response activities, capabilities and resources of Israel; and Is
providing direct access to the Israeli agency and response officials who combat the terrorist threat and
direct the response to terrorist actions. The lessons learned, response and preparedness systems and the
capabilities developed over time by Israel may be useful for adoption and adaptation by agencies In the
United States.

When: February 7,2010 to February 13, 2010

Syllabus: This high Impact training experience Is filled with seven days of exposure to all aspects of safety
and security to Include - physical security, Intelligence operations, policy and procedures, threat analysis and
more. Hear from those who are living proof of how crime and terrorism can Impact educational institutions
and how to minimize those effects while maintaining an open educational environment.

Because of the small group (maximum 10 people) approach, you will have direct access to the principals for
face-to-face Interviews and full access to sites normally closed to larger groups.

Total Fees: $5,250.00 US Currency - Includes, Round Trip Airfare from JFK,
Hotel Accommodations, 2 Meals pe(Day, Travel In Israel and Conference / Training fees.

2
 PAREVOLUTION.COM

• Air Travel
• JFK* To Israel - Arrive on November 8th

o ..---..-.----.-...

• Arrival to Israel - Welcome by representallve from the Israeli governmenl.

• Welcome dinner

Lectures

• Understanding the Threats and Origins of Fundamentalist Terrorism.

• Intelligence, the uses of live sources, Intelligence: Receiving the Information, passing it on the
execution level, commanding and controlling forces.

• TBD (Intelligence and Terrorism Information Center I INP Intel Center)

Tabletop
3
 PAREVOLUTION.COM
o Include delegation and Israeli subject matter experts to address a response and
management scenario Involving a crisis at an educational Institution

Lectures

• Lesson learned In terror attack sites at (TBD) University

• Communications with Media during Mass Casualty Incident
• Emergency Situation I MO, 3 stages of operations.

• Site visit to Hebrew university, Jerusalem

• Site visits to terror attack sites

~ •...__ ..-._---_.. - •

• Travel to Tel Aviv -Visit the Azrlell Towers, 350,000 square meters of modern businesses and
services, and 186 meters high, the Azrleillargest commercial center in the Middle East. Learn about
mall security and the Emergency Management of Large populated private Installations.

Visit to Port of Ashdod . On the border with Gaza. (Relate to security concerns with large population
facilities).

On site visit to Shderot· see the considerations and actions of a municipality and Its school system to
address public resiliency.

4
 PAREVOLUTION.COM

o ....--..-.-------.-

• Visit the Old City - Learn security concerns, visit areas that are
flashpolnts In the continuing tensions In the Middle East
• Visit to the HolV Sites (Church of the Holy Sepulcher, Wailing Wall, Via De La Rosa (9 Stations of
the Cross) and Dome of the Rock.
• Briefing - Mabat 2000, command and control center of the Old City of Jerusalem

• Lecture - General security and Introduction to public

transportation Issues.
• Site visit - Surface transportation, forms of defense and security consideration.
• Tour - Rabin Square (The analysis of Prime Minister Rabin's assassination In the actual location of
the event). Protecting dignitaries during site visits.

Because offices are closed on the Jewish Sabbath, special program will be
provided

' -_ _ _ _ _-1 Travel back to States

5
 PAREVOLUTION.COM
Further Info:
*JFK will ,serVe as the primary airport tq and from Israel. Additional locations can be arranged on a case by
cases bases but may Incur additlonili expense,
. '. ' . . . - " ,". .
**' Proposed program can be adjusted to fit participant's request - slt~ visits andsPI:;~~;~am~:a~y change
without notlce'and will be replacedwifh suitable and' af I or questions,
please contact patrick Chagnon at ' ' , or
"'0 _/, 1<1 ?12K
Final payment isdu~ Janu'ary 10, 2010
, '

~MP'O~TANT * IMPORTANT * ' IMPORTANT

. ,' , i'Time sen-~itiveil1fortn~tion must be completedr returned iNith,$l r200.0()
, ' qeposit by December ,30r 2009" '

Email Marketing by

This email wassenttojapowers@state.pa.usbYI!I!II!ll!lll.!IIII!I~

Update ProfilelEmail Address I Instant removal wIth SafeUnsubscrlbe™ I PrIvacy Policy.
@]
Institute of Terrorism Research and Response I p,O, Box 56555, Philadelphia, PA 19111 I Philadelphia I PA I 19111

6
 PAREVOLUTION.COM
Powers, James

From: Aaron R i c h m a n ' - - ' ]

Sent: Tuesday, Augus~
To: Mike Perelman; Powers, James; Aaron Richman; Erik Miller
Subject: Re: Intelligence Cycle & The Missing Piece - Input from the Field

To build upon Mike's concept, there is a NY model called, Operation Safeguard/Operation Nexus. This conc(
is very similar to other global programs. In short, the concept says, we should be able to outreach to the vario
sectors, bring them in for coffee and donuts and present them with a presentation that explains their role in th
intel cycle. We explain to them what the adversary may be doing to "use" the specific sector. Not just to targe
the CIKR, but how the adversary plans, trains, recruits .. .all in relationship to the specific sector.

This training can be 1 hour to save them time and can be done at their facility. We would give them a busines
card with a number to call, an email to send for anything that is not an emergency and meets the "shopping Ii:
of suspicious indicators and warning signs that we submitted to them.

I think the important thing, like you mentioned, is to make them a part of the process. How we do that, is by
explaining why, specifically, they need to. This may not answer all the issues, but if we pull them in as such,
may get them more involved and have a stake in the material being sent to them.

AR

Sent via BlackBerry by AT&T

From: "Mike Perelman"

Date: Tue, 10 Aug 2010 1
To: James F. Po'wel·s<;jap'Dwers@s,tat1e.p:a.u:s>, Aaron Ri(;hnlan . . . . , Erik

ReplyTo:
Subject: Re: Intelligence The Missing Piece - Input from the Field

Not surprisingly, you are ahead of the curve. Can you set aside time next week for a working meeting on hoy,
approach the problem?

I think the issue of what is needed and what can be done to improve the situation is helping people understan.
their role in the process. I can picture a person in your office arranging county by county (brief) training .
sessions that would educate people on intelligence, the cycle, their role, etc.

Everytime you and I have met people in the field, it has resulted in ground-up information sharing.

Something to think about. I'm on the road right now. I will call you as soon as I reach my destination If you
think a working meeting is appropriate we can schedule it then - about 1 hour from now.

Mike

1
 Mike Perelman
PAREVOLUTION.COM
Institute of Terrorism Research and Response

F"om: "Powers, James" .gapowers@STATE.PA.US>

Date: Tue, 10 Aug 201009:23:36 -0400
To: <Institute-of-Terrorism@LISTSERV.STATE.PA.US>
Subject: Intelligence Cycle & The Missing Piece - Input from the Field

ITRR Colleagues,

As I have repeated many times, we are extremely pleased with the product ITRR has developed/delivered thus far - a
superb job by all involved - whoever they are!

The piece that we still miss, however - and have no ability or authority to fix - is the Input from the ground level
stakeholders here in PA. This group comprises three major elements associated with our CIKR:
• local first responders
• owners/operators/security directors of our CIKR
• sector-specific associations/informal working groups associated with the 18 sectors of CIKR

Thus far, these three groups have received both raw and processed intelligence from ITRR; they understand that any
follow-up actions are totally up to them.

I have also informed each recipient of the PIB previously that their input is just as valuable in assisting your analysts al
researchers to validate their own thesis, predictions and trends/patterns (i.e., where they were right and where they
were incorrect).

My assessment thus far: UNSATISFACTORY

I am not pleased with what I have received from the field but I know it's neither a result of your efforts nor caused by
personality/Southern drawl. We'll continue to attempt to cultivate these relationships and trust in order to facilitate t
flow of information from these groups to the TAM-C via this office. Consider this another task for the person you wis~
add to the upcoming contract.

I've also been thinking about sources for the PIB that deal with areas that don't get top priority in intelligence or med
reporting. Some of the executive agencies responsible for infrastructure and key systems put out their own
announcements of developments or threats that don't necessarily go through the FBI or DHS so the latter two may nc
have to be relied upon to get the kind of reporting we want. For example, I rarely if ever receive anything relating to.
other than the usual product recall notices. But there may be some internal, security-related issues out there that we
don't see. I'll ask our Sector-Specific Working Group Chairpersons if they are receiving anything related to security bu'
am not optimistic about getting anything for a number of reasons.

There are some pretty good providers like ASIS, Ag Security. com (http://www.ag-security.coml). InfraGard
(http:/(www.infragard.net/) (FBI-sponsored), various energy organizations, etc. Hopefully I can use my CIP Advisory
Group to provide you some internal, security-related data that may be of interest.

I feel there is valuable, untapped information out there that may be of use to your analysts/researchers and want. I'll
keep you informed if and when we see progress. In the meantime, I'd like to hear your thoughts as well regarding the
associations and tapping into their lessons learned, etc.

Jim
2
 PAREVOLUTION.COM
JAMES F. POWERS, JR. I Director
Pennsylvania Office of Homeland Security
2605 Interstate Drive I Suite 380
Harrisburg, PA 17110-9382
Office: 717.651.2715 I .'~lh;lo·" Fax: 717.651.2040
www.homelandsecurity.state.pa.us

This e-mail,includingattachments, is intended for the sole use of the individual(s) and entity(ies) to whom addressed
and may contain information that is privileged, confidential and/or exempt from disclosure under applicable laws. If y
are neither the intended addressee, nor authorized to receive email on behalf of the intended addressee, you
are hereby notified that you may not use, copy, disclose and/or distribute any information contained herein. If you he
received this message in error,.immediately notify the sender and delete the message.

3
 PAREVOLUTION.COM
Powers, James

From: Mike Perelman

Sent: Tuesday, /'"\U,IU:>'
To: Powers, James; Aaron Richman; Erik Miller
Subject: Re: Intelligence Cycle & The Missing Piece - Input from the Field

Jim:

Not surprisingly, you are ahead of the curve. Can you set aside time next week for a working meeting on ho"
approach the problem?

I think the issue of what is needed and what can be done to improve the situation is helping people understan,
their role in the process. I can picture a person in your office arranging county by county (brief) training
sessions that would educate people on intelligence, the cycle, their role, etc.

Evelytime you and I have met people in the field, it has resulted in ground-up information sharing.

Something to think about. I'm on the road right now. I will call you as soon as I reach my destination If you
think a working meeting is appropriate we can schedule it then - about I hour from now.

Mike

Mike Perelman
Institute of TelTorism Research and Response

Fl'Om: "Powers, James" <japowers@STATE.PA.US>

Date: Tue, 10 Aug 201009:23:36 -0400
To: <Institute-of-Terrorism@LISTSERV.STATE.PA.US>
Subject: Intelligence Cycle & The Missing Piece - Input from the Field

ITRR Colleagues,

As I have repeated many times, we are extremely pleased with the product ITRR has developed/delivered thus far - a
superb job by all involved - whoever they arel

The piece that we still miss, however - and have no ability or authority to fix - is the Input from the ground .level
stakeholders here in PA. This group comprises three major elements associated with our CIKR:
• local first responders
• owners/operators/security directors of our CIKR
• sector-specific associations/informal working groups associated with the 18 sectors of CIKR

Thus far, these three groups have received both raw and processed intelligence from ITRR; they understand that any
follow-up actions are totally up to them.

I have also informed each recipient of the PIB previously that their input is just as valuable in assisting your analysts al
researchers to validate their own thesis, predictions and trends/patterns (i.e., where they were right and where they
were incorrect).

My assessment thus far: UNSATISFACTORY

1
 PAREVOLUTION.COM
I am not pleased with what I have received from the field but I know it's neither a result of your efforts nor caused by
personality/Southern drawl. We'll continue to attempt to cultivate these relationships and trust in order to facilitate t
flow of information from these groups to the TAM-C via this office. Consider this another task for the person you wis~
add to the upcoming contract.

I've also been 'thinking about sources for the PIB that deal with areas that don't get top priority in intelligence or med
reporting. Some of the executive 'agencies responsible for infrastructure and key systems put out their own
announcements of developments or threats that don't necessarily go through the FBI or DHS so the latter two may nc
have to be relied upon to get the kind of reporting we want. For example, I rarely if ever receive anything relating to .
other than the usual product recall notices. But there may be some internal, security-related issues out there that we
don't see. I' ll ask our Sector-Specific Working Group Chairpersons if they are receiving anything related to security bu'
am not optimistic about getting anything for a number of reasons.

There are some pretty good providers like ASIS, Ag Security.com (http:Uwww.ag-security.comJ). InfraGard
(http://www.infragard.netf) (FBI-sponsored). various energy organizations, etc. Hopefully I can use my CIP Advisory
Group to provide you some internal, security-related data that may be of interest.

I feel there is valuable, untapped information out there that may be of use to your analysts/researchers and want. I'll
keep you informed if and when we see progress. In the meantime, I'd like to hear your thoughts as well regarding the
associations and tapping into their lessons learned, 'etc.

Jim

JAMES F. POWERS, JR. I Director

Pennsylvania Office of Homeland Security
2605 Interstate Drive I Suite 380
Harrisburg, PA 17110-9382
Office: 717.651.2715 I Mobile : • • • •• I Fax: 717.651.2040
www.homelandsecurity .state.pa.us

This e-mall.includingattachments.islntended for the sole use of the individual(s) and entity(ies) to whom addressed
and may contain information that is privileged, confidential and/or exempt from disclosure under applicable laws. If y
are neither the intended addressee, nor authorized to receive email on behalf of the intended addressee, you
are hereby notified that you may not use, copy, disclose and/or distribute any information contained herein'. If you he
received this message in error, immediately notify the sender and delete the message.

2
 PAREVOLUTION.COM
Powers, James

From: Branaman, Joseph G. [Joseph.Branaman@ic.fbLgovj

Sent: Friday, July 30, 2010 11 :53 AM
To: Powers, James
Subject: RE: Michael (Mike) Perelman

Jim,

Thanks again for the info and the contact #'s for Mike. Please add me to your contacts and reach out if you need anything
in Florida.

Jody

Joseph G. Branaman, TFO

Assistant WMD Coordinator
Jacksonville Division I GVRA

From: Powers, James [mailto:japowers@state.pa.us]

Sent: Friday, July 30, 2010 11: 16 AM
To: Branaman, Joseph G.
Subject: FW: Michael (Mike) Perelman

Joe,

As requested.

Jim

JAMES F. POWERS, JR. I Director

Pennsylvania Office of Homeland Security
2505 Interstate Drive I Suite 380
Harrisburg, PA 17110-9382
Office : 717.551.2715 I Mobile:• • • • • I Fax: 717.551.2040
www.homelandsecurity.state.pa.us

This e-mail.includingattachments.isintended for the sole use of the individual(s) and entity(ies) to whom addressed
and may contain information that is privileged, confidential and/or exempt from disclosure under applicable laws. If you
are neither the intended addressee, nor authorized to receive email on behalf of the intended addressee, you
are hereby notified that you may not use, copy, disclose and/or distribute any information contained herein. If you have
received this message in error, immediately notify the sender and delete the message.

1
 PAREVOLUTION.COM
Powers, James
. From: Michael Scullin 1
Sent: Wednesday, September 08,20105:34 PM
To: Powers, James
Subject: RE: Pennsylvania Intelligence Bulletin No. 117, Item #2

Dear Jim,

Sorry that it has taken so long to get back to you on "French assets" in the region.

There are a number of French organizations in our region, including the French American Chamber of
Co=erce, the French International School, and the Alliance Francaise de Philadelphie.

This region is also considered to have the highest level of direct investment in the US, with
companies like Saint-Gobain (North American headquarters), Sanofi-Aventis, Arkema, Boiron (North
American headquarters), Sonepar, Air Liquide, Veolia, and more generally throughout Pa, Suez and Areva.

Regards.

Michael
Michael E. Scullin, Esq.
Han. Consul ofFrance in Philadelphia and Wilmington

McElroy, Deutsch, Mulvaney & Carpenter

r. . . .
•
_·,PA
1617 JFK Blvd., Suite 1500
19103
I -~IS'· 'f"~'Aq7j
,-u,.- ~7_Z.t140

http://www.consulfrance-washington.orgl

Ce message est sans accent afin de ne pas pertuber certains logiciels de message";e anglopizones .

--- On Thu, 8/S/10, Powers, James <japolVers@,state.pa.lIs> wrote:

From: Powers, James <japowers@state.pa.us>

Subject: RE: Pennsylvania Intelligence Bulletin No. 117, Item #2
To: '''Michael Scullin'"
Date: Thursday, August 5, 2010, 9:04

Thanks, Mike. I understand completely. Welcome back to the heat.

I am originally from Birmingham, AL but haven't lived there since graduating from the University of Alabama in
1969. I have no idea how I acclimated to that temperature! Now when I return, it's like walking into a steam
bath.

1
 PAREVOLUTION.COM
Let me know when you plan to come to Harrisburg.

Jim

JAMES F. POWERS, JR. 1Director

Pennsylvania Office of Homeland Security

2605 Interstate Drive 1Suite 380

Harrisburg, PA 17110-9382

Office: 717.651.27151 Mot)ile:l Fax: 717.651 .2040

www.homelandsecuritl..state.pa.us

This e-mail.includingattachments.isintended for the sole use of the individual(s) and entity(ies) to whom
addressed and may contain information that is privileged; confidential and/or exempt from disclosure under
applicable laws. If you are neither the intended addressee, nor authorized to receive email on behalf of the
intended addressee, you are hereby notified that you may not use, copy, disclose and/or distribute any
information contained herein. If you have received this message in error, immediately notify the sender and
delete the message.

From: Michael Scullin [m,lilto>!IiI

Sent: Thursday, August 05,
To: Powers, James
Subject: RE: Pennsylvania Intelligence Bulletin No. 117, Item #2

Jim,

I've been out of town all week on a grueling business trip in the South. I'll get the info to you as soon as I
surface for air!

Michael E. Scullin, Esq.

Hon. Consul ofFrance in Philadelphia and Wilmington

2
 PAREVOLUTION.COM
McElroy, Deutsch, Mulvaney & Carpenter

1617 JFK Blvd., Suite 1500

1----
Philadelphia, PA 19103

F: _ __

http://www.consulfrance-washington.org/

Ce message est sans accent afin de ne pas pertuber certains logiciels de messagerie anglophones .

--- On Tue, 8/3/10, Powers, James <japolVel's@fitate.pa.lIs> wrote:

From: Powers, James <japowers@state.pa.us>

Subject: RE: Pennsylvimia Bulletin No. 117, Item #2
To: '''Michael Scullin'"
Date: Tuesday, August 3, 2010, 9:36 AM

Mike,

Just following-up on our discussion regarding other French high-value assets in Pennsylvania. You know better
than me as to their importance.

I would like to insure I have them covered (i.e., security director contact data, associated first responders, etc.)

Thanks,

Jim

",
JAMES F: POWERS, JR. I Director
3
 PAREVOLUTION.COM
Pennsylvania Office of Homeland Security

2605 Interstate Drive I Suite 380

Harrisburg, PA 17110-9382

Office: 717.651.2715 I Mobile: I Fax: 717.651.2040

WW\"I.homelandsecurit)l.state.pa.us

This e-mail.includingattachments.isintended for the sole use of the individual(s) and entity(ies) to whom
addressed and may contain information that is privileged, confidential and/or exempt from disclosure under
applicable laws. If you are neither the intended addressee, nor authorized to receive email on behalf of the
intended addressee, you are hereby notified that you may not use, copy, disclose and/or distribute any
information contained herein. If you have received this message in error, imm'ediately notify the sender and
delete the message.

From: Michael scuIiOrin*;;;m~iiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiil---------------------­

Sent: Friday, July 30,
To: Powers, James
Cc: 'Mike Perelman'
Subject: Re: Pennsylvania Intelligence Bulletin No. 117, Item #2

Dear Jim,

Good to make contact with you, and thanks very much for the info.

Mr. Perelman, we very much appreciate the work you are doing.

Michael

Michael E. Scullin, Esq.

Hon. Consul ofFrance in Philadelphia and Wilmington

McElroy, Deutsch, Mulvaney & Carpenter

1617 JFKBlvd., Suite 1500

4
 Philadelphia, PA 19103
PAREVOLUTION.COM
1-7..I:{'-557- 2.Q7:;t

/-'2J:T- 5"57- ~ ~<t V

http://www .consulfrance-washington.org/

Ce message est sans accent afin de ne pas pertuber certains /ogicieis de me.rsagerie angiopilone.r.

--- On Fri, 7/30/10, Powers, James <japolVer~tate.pa.us> wrote:

From: Powers, James <japowers@state.pa.us>

Subject: Pennsylvania Intelligence Bulletin No. 117, Item #2
To: "Michael Scullin ~.IIIiI• •",..
Cc: '''Mike Perelman'"
Date: Friday, July 30, 20

Michael,

Thanks for your call re: Item #2, provided to you by the CBP-Philadelphia Airport. Glad to see the information
is flowing as we recommended.

I have also attached copies ofPIB No. 114 (Item #11) and 115 (Item #5), the first entries regarding the events
related to the hijab ban.

I have also copied Mike Perelman, Co-President of ITRR, in case you would like a more detailed explanation of
how this information is derived. I'm sure Mike will be glad to establish contact with you

Jim

5
 PAREVOLUTION.COM
JAMES F. POWERS, JR. 1 Director

PelUlsylvania Office of Homeland Security

2605 Interstate Drive 1Suite 380

Harrisburg, PAl 7 I 10-9382

Office: 717.651.27151 Mobile: • • • • 1Fax: 717.651.2040

I I'WI \'.11 a meta ndsec u l'itv. sta teo p a. us

This e-mail,includingattaclunents, is intended for the sole use of the individual(s) and entity(ies) to whom
addressed and may contain information that is privileged, confidential and/or exempt from disclosure under
applicable laws. If you are neither the intended addressee, nor authorized to receive email on behalf of the
intended addressee, you are hereby notified that you may not use, copy, disclose and/or distribute any
infonnation contained herein. If you have received this message in error, immediately notify the sender and
delete the message.

6
 PAREVOLUTION.COM
Powers, James
From: ••••
Michael Scullin ~II!I!II!I!I!I!II
Sent: Friday, July 30, 2010 9:16 AM
To: Powers, James
Cc: 'Mike Perelman'
Subject: Determine French Assets wfl Commonwealth

Follow Up Flag: Follow up

Flag Status: Flagged

Dear Jim,

Good to make contact with you, and thanks very much for the info.

Mr. Perelman, we very much appreciate the work you are doing.

Michael
Michael E. Scullin, Esq.
Han. Consul ofFrance in Philadelphia and Wilmington

McElroy, Deutsch, Mulvaney & Carpenter

1617 JFK Blvd., Suite 1500
Philadelphia, PA 19 i 03 ,., 0 .... ..-
1_-u:f-5"lf1-.... I .
F: 1-"lJ:5"-!>"S1- ZQQ{)

http':!/www.consulfrance-washington.org!

Ce message est sans accent afin de ne pas pertuber certains logiciels de messagerie anglophones .

. --- On Fri, 7/30/10, Powers, James <japowerS@state.pa.us>wrote:

From: Powers, James <japowers@state.pa.us>

Subject: Pennsylvania Intelligence Bulletin No. 117, Item #2
To: "Michael Scullin '< >
Cc: "'Mike Perelman'"
Date: Friday, July 30, 20 I 0, 9: lOAM

Michael,

Thanks for your 'call re: Item #2, provided to you by the CBP-Philadelphia Airport. Glad to see the information
is flowing as we reco=ended.

I have also attached copies ofPIB No. 114 (Item #11) and 115 (Item #5), the first entrieS'regarding the events

1
 PAREVOLUTION.COM
related to the hijab ban.

I have also copied Mike Perelman, Co-President of ITRR, in case you would like a more detailed explanation of
how this information is derived . I'm sure Mike will be glad to establish contact with you

Jim

JAMES F. POWERS, JR. / Director

Pennsylvania Office of Homeland Security

2605 Interstate Drive / Suite 380 .

Harrisburg, PA 17110-9382

Office: 717.651.2715 / Mobile: •••• / Fax: 717.651.2040

\lww.homelandsecuritv.state.pa.us

This e-mail,includingattachments, is intended for the sole use of the individuaI(s) and entity(ies) to whom
addressed and may contain information that is privileged, confidential and/or exempt from disclosure under
applicable laws. Jfyou are neither the intended addressee, nor authorized to receive email on behalf of the .
intended addressee, you are hereby notified that you may not use, copy, disclose and/or distribute any
information contained herein. If you have received this message in error, immediately notify the sender and
delete the message.

2
 PAREVOLUTION.COM
Powers, James

From: Miller ./111• •~~!1!1!!~

Sent: Tuesday, June 01,201010:16 PM
To: Powers, James
Subject: Re: Additional Verbiage to the ITRR Updates

Follow Up Flag: Follow up

Flag Status: Flagged

Jim,

I'll share this with TAM-C for their thoughts but speaking personally for a moment, I am in total agreement.
The more feedback the better, I say. The intelligence cycle as you said is two-way, that is, it's interactive (or
should be.) Some sort of feedback structure is crucial for focusing the monitoring and adjusting it to be more
effective when necessary.

By the way, I got a call today from a Detective Carey of Pittsburgh PD. He asked for any followup info
regarding the pro-Palestinian protest tomorrow. We appreciate how widely you distribute the material. I think
it's truly making PA a safer place.

Erik

Sent from my iPhone

On Jun 1,2010, at 10:05 PM, "Powers, James" <japowers@state.pa.us> wrote:

Erik,

Mike and I have been discussing the next step to your analysis and our dissemination of the PAIS . The
Intelligence Cycle as you know incorporates two-way communication (feedback). Thus far, we've pushed
information to the customer and haven't actually requested feedback regarding the sites/cities mentioned
in the PAIS.

Sob Anspach and I discussed adding a sentence or two after the header and before the main body of the
PAIS. This is a suggestion only.

We're not looking for them to dump everything on us that occurs In their jurisdiction - only that which
relates to the critical infrastructure. In turn, we'll provide it to you for the analysts to review and make
further findings.

Please review/discuss and let me know.

Thanks

Jim

James F. Powers, Jr. I Director

Office of Homeland Security
2605 Interstate Drive I Suite 380
Harrisburg, PA 17110 ..-.93.82.
717-651-2715 I Cell:_

This e-mail message.includinganyattachments.isintended solely for use by the individual(s) and

entity(ies) to whom addressed. It may contain information that is privileged, confidential and exempt from
1
 PAREVOLUTION.COM
disclosure under applicable laws. If you are neither the intended addressee, nor authorized to receive
correspondence on behalf of the intended addressee, you are hereby notified that you may not use, copy,
disclose or distribute any information contained in this e-mail message. If you have received this message
in error, immediately notify the sender and delete the message.

From: Anspach, Robert (PEMA)

To: Powers, James
Sent: Tue Jun 0111:40:15 2010
Subject: Additional Verbiage to the ITRR Updates

The quality of the information provided relies on two-way communications. We invite you to
advise us when the infonnation in the Pennsylvania Actionable Intelligence Bulletin is helpful
and, more impoliantly, when incidents happen in your area that draw a parallel with the
intelligence we have reported.

Bob Anspach I Executive Assistant to the Director

Pennsylvania Emergency Management Agency

2605 Interstate Drive I Harrisburg, PA 17110

Phone: 717.651.2739 I Fax: 717.651.2040

www.PE~1A.state.pa.us

"This e-mail message, including any attachments, is intended for the sole use of the individual(s)
and entity(ies) to whom it is addressed and may contain information that is privileged,
confidential and exempt fi'om disclosure under applicable law. If you are not the intended
addressee, nor authorized to receive for the intended addressee, you are notified that you may not
lise, copy, disclose or distribute any information contained in this e-mail message. If you have
received this message in error, immediately notify the sender and delete th e message."

2
 PAREVOLUTION.COM
Powers, James
From: Michael Perelman
Sent: Friday, September
To: Powers, James
Subject: Re: Received call from Kay in DGS

~ ..
I know it's unlikely to happen t~at fast, but we could have your first document on your desk by Friday the 2nd.

Mike Perelman, Co-Director

Michael Perelman, MS, CPP

Institute of Terrorism Research and Response
P.O. Box 56555
Philadelphia, PA 19111

www.terrorrespollse.org
l1RR provides urgent and actionable intelligence to. subscribers around the world.
----- Original Message -----
'_~·~2m.;~ pbwe·fs;:~mm·e!s~;~~~¥~y:·:~~j~~~:::~.:·iT'~::~:{:;F,~;~?"~.::·:·~\J,:>~;:.;~··~::.:V:U~'>\.:::(."::: .;,-J~~-:,. ~~~ , ':~ii ~.; ~.,- :.'--~ :,', ',-,' :- ,~::( :,~'T .1:. ~~;:-.~(:!.~'~:':-~~
To::iII_ _• •i
Sent: Friday, September 25, 2009 12:16 PM
Subject: Re: Received call from Kay In DGS

Great! Thanks

Jim

James F. Powers, Jr. I Director

Office of Homeland Security
Commonwealth of Pennsylvania
0: 717.651.2715 1M: . . . . . .
www.homelandsecurity.state.pa.us

From: Michael Perelman ~

To: Powers, James
Cc: Aaron Richman < . . . . . . . ...
Sent: Fri Sep 25 11:20:122009
Subject: Received call from Kay in DGS

Jim:

Expect a call from Kay. Her statement to me was, "You REALLY are the only people who do this, aren't you?"

Mike Perelman, Co-Director

Michael Perelman, MS, CPP

Institute of Terrorism Research and Response
P.O. Box 56555
Philadelphia, PA 19111

www.terrorresponse.org .
ITRR provides urgent and actionable intelligence to subscribers around the world.

1
 PAREVOLUTION.COM
Powers, James

From: Mike Perelman ~11!11"~!111)1 •••

Sent: Friday, May 28, 2010 1:41 PM
To: Stephen McCauley
Cc: Powers, James
Subject: Field Interrogation Report information
Attachments: Notes on Field Interrogation conducted by Pittsburgh Port Autority PO, 22 May 201 O.pdf

Chief McCauley:

I hope all is well with you.

Attached is information gleaned from the vehicle stop conducted by Officer Tima. As you will see, the owner of the vehicle
had recently shipped a similar vehicle to Corvallis, OR. It would appear that Bly, Oregon, the location of a jihadist training
camp, is about a 5 hour drive from Corvallis. But pending further investigation, we have no idea what his link is to Oregon
is.

Have a good weekend.

Mike

Mike Perelman

Michael Perelman, MS, CPP

Co-Director
Institute of Terrorism Research and Response
PO Box 56555
Philadelphia, PA 19111

www.terrorresponse.orq
ITRR provides urgent and actionable intelligence to subscribers around the world.