Documentos de Académico
Documentos de Profesional
Documentos de Cultura
Childhood and adolescence are critical periods of skeletal mineralization. Peak bone
mineral density achieved by the end of adolescence determines the risk for later patho-
logical fractures and osteoporosis. Chronic disease and medication often adversely affect
bone health. Epilepsy is one of the most common neurological conditions occurring in
persons under the age of 21. Epilepsy may affect bone in a number of ways. Restrictions
of physical activity imposed by seizures, cerebal palsy or other coexisting comorbidities
adversely affect bone health. It has been observed that treatment with phenytoin and
phenobarbital can be associated with rickets. More recently, established agents such as
carbamazepine and valproate have been shown to be associated with decreased bone
mineral density. The literature related to bone health in pediatric epilepsy is reviewed.
Semin Pediatr Neurol 14:196-200 © 2007 Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
196 1071-9091/07/$-see front matter © 2007 Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/j.spen.2007.08.006
Bone consequences 197
the impact of epilepsy and its associated social and physical persons with epilepsy, seizure-related fractures accounted for
burden on bone health is likely to be additive to the indepen- 33.9% of all fractures (95% confidence interval, 25.3%-
dent effect of AEDs on future osteoporosis and fracture risk. 43.5%). Fractures of the spine, forearms, femurs, lower legs,
and feet and toes were significantly increased after the diag-
Pathophysiology of Bone Disorders in Epilepsy
nosis of epilepsy. Phenytoin use was also associated with an
At birth, bone is minimally mineralized. With development,
increased fracture risk in this study. In a case-control study
bone becomes progressively more mineralized until a plateau
evaluating fractures in patients with epilepsy taking AEDs,
is attained in the third decade of life. In otherwise healthy
risk factors for fracture were prolonged seizures, long-term
people, at the sixth decade of life bone lost is a result of
AED use (either enzyme-inducing AEDs or nonenzyme-in-
involutional osteoporosis.11 Reduced bone accumulation in
ducing AEDs), AED polypharmacy, and female gender.24
children, adolescents, and young adults with epilepsy as well
Therefore, seizure control is of clear importance in prevent-
as progressive bone loss may increase fracture susceptibility.
ing fracture in persons with epilepsy. However, because
A lower peak bone mass in adolescence is associated with
emerging evidence indicates an adverse effect of AEDs on
greater involutional osteoporosis and increased fracture risk
bone metabolism, in particular the enzyme-inducing AEDs,
during adulthood.12
the choice of an AED to both prevent seizures and to protect
Chronic illness, particularly renal disease and other dis-
bone health is important. The most critical decision is at the
eases that impair constitutional development, adversely af-
initiation of therapy because AEDs are likely to be a long-
fects the mineralization process. Furthermore, many of the
term therapy.
medications used in the treatment of chronic disease also
Generally, there are 3 main situations that predispose pa-
adversely affect bone mineralization. There is increasing ev-
tients with epilepsy to fractures.1 Another factor is incoordi-
idence suggesting that epilepsy and comorbid conditions that
nation associated with either a coexisting comorbid condi-
frequently coexist, such as cerebral palsy, a hypoactive state,
tion or AED drug-induced ataxia. Other factor is
and depression, may adversely affect bone mineralization in
incoordination associated with either a coexisting comorbid
childhood. Cerebral palsy, which frequently is associated
condition or AED drug-induced ataxia.25,26 Thus, fractures
with epilepsy, is a powerful predictor of muscular and skel-
result from the interplay between accidental trauma, seizure-
etal hypoplasia.13 A study performed at our institution found
related falls, and bone strength.13
that children treated for epilepsy for more than 1 year had
significant lower BMD than controls. These findings suggest
AED and BMD Relationship
that children with epilepsy may be more vulnerable to frac-
Bone density reduction has been found in patients using
tures.14
enzyme-inducing AEDs. Phenytoin, phenobarbital, and car-
Bone is a complex dynamic tissue that responds to external
bamazepine appear to be associated with reductions in bone
and internal forces. Accordingly, body weight, exercise, and
mineralization by virtue of their enzyme-inducing proper-
calcium homeostasis can alter bone structure and architec-
ties.27 Induction of the CYP450 enzyme system results in in-
ture.15 These changes are complex and involve osteoclast and
creased clearance of vitamin D, which results in secondary
osteoblast dynamics, vitamin D, calcium, and phosphorous
hyperparathyroidism and consequent increased bone turn-
homeostasis as well as connective tissue arrangements. Tra-
over and reduced bone density. Although enzyme-inducing
becular bone comprises about 20% of all bone and is meta-
AEDs have often been associated with increased bone turn-
bolically more active because of a larger surface area. Regions
over, nonenzyme AEDs can also produce osteopenia.18,28
rich in trabecular bone such as the hip and spine are partic-
Souverein et al24 did not find a difference in fracture risk
ularly susceptible to fractures.
between hepatic enzyme-inducing and non– enzyme-induc-
Enzyme-inducing antiepileptics alter vitamin D concentra-
ing AEDs. This finding is in agreement with a recent Danish
tions and may predispose to reduced bone mass,16 although
case-control study including 124,655 fracture cases in which
nonenzyme-inducing AEDs may also affect bone density by
it was concluded that liver-inducing potential per se was not
possibly altering osteoblastic function.17,18 Premenopausal
responsible for the increased fracture risk.29 Also, no differ-
women treated with enzyme-inducing AEDs had lowered
ence in bone density was found between users of inducing
vitamin D concentrations as well as increased markers of
and noninducing AEDs in a case-control study in Scotland
bone turnover.16,19
among men and women aged 47 years and older.30 It has
Pathological Fractures in Epilepsy been described that sodium valproate, the main nonenzyme-
Patients with epilepsy frequently experience injuries result- inducing AED drug, can also affect bone metabolism.31
ing from seizure-related falls20 or trauma occurring in the Therefore, hepatic enzyme-inducing properties of AEDs are
context of seizure-related impairment of consciousness.21,22 likely to account for just a part of the association between
A retrospective 7-year analysis found a 61% of traumatic AED use and reduced BMD.
seizure-related fractures.23 Interestingly, traumatic fractures Children treated with valproate have a 10% or greater
were more likely to occur in men (55%), whereas patholog- reduction in BMD compared with controls.18 Considering
ical fractures were more likely in women (57%). that a 7% reduction of BMD in healthy adults is associated
Patients with epilepsy have an increased risk for fracture with a 50% increase in osteoporotic fractures,32,33 valproate
because of trauma injury incurred during seizures them- use in children might be expected to increase the risk of
selves. In the report by Vestergaard et al20 on fracture rates in future fractures.
198 E.A. Samaniego and R.D. Sheth
The pathogenesis of valproate-associated reduction in bone mass was physical inactivity. However, only total BMD
BMD remains undefined. Valproate has been associated with was measured. This study design may account for the differ-
reversible Fanconi syndrome,34,35 suggesting that valproate ences noted from other studies that used a more standardized
may cause renal tubular dysfunction with increased urinary approach of measuring bone density in the distal third of the
loss of calcium and phosphorus. Sato et al28 found that 23% radius, the lumbar spine, and the femoral neck. The authors
of patients taking valproate for more than 1 year had a reduc- reasonably suggest that calcium homeostasis would be ex-
tion in BMD in the osteoporotic range. This effect was present pected to be more generally linked with whole-bone miner-
despite increased weight, which is typically associated with a alization rather than site-specific changes. A limitation of this
protective effect on bone mineralization. study is the presence of a lower range of body height (below
A 2-year longitudinal study performed by Verrotti et al27 in the 10th percentile) in 43% of the patients. This raises the
60 adolescents taking carbamazepine compared serum interesting issue of the role of growth in bone mineralization.
markers of bone formation and resorption after starting car- The authors suggest that lower physical activity in their co-
bamazepine in normal subjects with epilepsy. Subjects hort accounted for most of the observed reductions in BMD.
achieved typical serum concentrations of carbamazepine. Growth stature and pubertal stage were studied in girls
They were age and gender matched with controls and divided receiving oxcarbazepine and carbamazepine.43 The authors
by developmental status into 3 groups: prepubertal, puber- did not study bone mineralization directly but looked at body
tal, and postpuberty. After 2 years of carbamazepine treat- height as an indirect measure of bone growth. The drugs
ment, they found that several serum markers of collagen and appeared not to affect linear growth or pubertal develop-
bone turnover were significantly increased. A urinary cross- ment.
linked N-telopeptide of type 1 collagen excretion, a marker of
osteoclastic activity, was increased 10-fold. Interestingly, this Dual-Energy Radiograph Absorptiometry
effect occurred despite a normal calcium intake and in the Dual-energy radiograph absorptiometry (DEXA) scans are a
face of similar parathyroid hormone and vitamin D serum cost-effective method of quantitatively evaluating BMD. The
concentrations. Furthermore, pubertal stage did not influ- hip and lumbar spine are the sites most frequently measured
ence the association. These findings suggest that increased for central mineralization and are most frequently involved in
bone turnover occurred despite normal vitamin D levels. involutional fractures. Measures of the distal third of the ra-
Increased bone turnover during a critical period of miner- dius determine the “peripheral” mineral content. Between
alization can have long-lasting consequences on bone health. 30% and 40% of mineral content must be lost before a rou-
A recent cross-sectional study of patients on AEDs under age tine radiograph can shows osteoporosis. In contrast, DEXA
50 years showed that 40% were osteopenic, whereas 10% can detect 2% to 5% of bone mineral loss.
had osteoporosis.36 These rates are considerably higher than Standardized normative data are available for most bone
the incidence in the general population. sites at risk of fractures. Patients with 1 to 2.5 standard devi-
Other models attribute bone loss to the high-turnover state ations below normal mineralization are considered to have
that results from drug-induced interference with calcium ab- osteopenia, whereas 2.5 standard deviation below normal is
sorption as well as direct effects on osteoclasts and osteo- defined as osteoporosis.36 BMD measures are strongly corre-
blasts. The resultant hypocalcemia can exacerbate seizures lated with risk of osteoporotic fractures. For each decreased
that are treated with higher doses of anticonvulsants, which standard deviation in BMD, there is a doubling of the fracture
sets up a vicious cycle.37 There might be other mechanisms rate.44
by which the use of AEDs leads to changes in bone compo- The National Osteoporosis Foundation cites the following
sition, including effects on intestinal calcium absorption, in- risk factors for the development of osteoporotic fractures in
hibition of the cellular response to parathyroid hormone, the general population: a history of fracture as an adult, his-
hyperparathyroidism, and calcitonin deficiency.38-40 tory of fragility fracture in a first-degree relative, low body
Despite the emerging concern of epilepsy treatment on weight (⬍58 kg), current cigarette smoking, female gender,
bone health, few neurologists routinely screen for osteoporo- estrogen deficiency at an early age (menopause before age 45
sis.41 Earlier suggestions for vitamin D supplementation36 years or bilateral ovariectomy or prolonged premenopausal
may not be enough to overcome the enzyme-inducing effects amenorrhea [greater than 1 year]), white race, advanced age,
of AEDs.6 The newer AEDs may be less likely to have a neg- lifelong low calcium intake, alcoholism, inadequate physical
ative impact on bone, although this remains to be studied. activity, recurrent falls, dementia, impaired eyesight despite
Unfortunately, this issue is even less well addressed in chil- adequate correction, and poor health/frailty. Medical condi-
dren with epilepsy. tions such as chronic obstructive pulmonary disease, gastrec-
Of the newer AEDs used in the treatment of pediatric ep- tomy, hyperparathyroidism, hypogonadism, multiple my-
ilepsy, only lamotrigine has been evaluated regarding BMD. eloma, celiac disease, the use of glucocorticoid therapy for
Guo et al42 examined the effect of lamotrigine (16 children), more than 3 months, or the use of anticonvulsants are also
valproate (28 children), or a combination of the 2 (4 chil- risk factors. Patients with any of these conditions are classi-
dren) on children aged 3 to 17 with epilepsy.42 They found fied as high risk and should be screened with a DEXA scan.
that treatment with valproate or lamotrigine for more than 2 Currently, it is not clear if children with epilepsy should
years was associated with short stature, low bone mass, and routinely be screened with DEXA scans; nevertheless, DEXA
reduced bone formation. The major predictor of lowered is being used increasingly in children.45
Bone consequences 199
27. Verrotti A, Greco R, Latini G, et al: Increased bone turnover in prepu- 40. Ali II, Schuh L, Barkley GL, Gates JR: Antiepileptic drugs and reduced
bertal, pubertal, and postpubertal patients receiving carbamazepine. bone mineral density. Epilepsy Behav 5:296-300, 2004
Epilepsia 43:1488-1492, 2002 41. Valmadrid C, Voorhees C, Litt B, et al: Practice patterns of neurologists
28. Sato Y, Kondo I, Ishida S, et al: Decreased bone mass and increased regarding bone and mineral effects of antiepileptic drug therapy. Arch
bone turnover with valproate therapy in adults with epilepsy. Neurol- Neurol 58:1369-1374, 2001
ogy 57:445-449, 2001 42. Guo CY, Ronen GM, Atkinson SA: Long-term valproate and lam-
29. Vestergaard P, Rejnmark L, Mosekilde L: Fracture risk associated with otrigine treatment may be a marker for reduced growth and bone mass
use of antiepileptic drugs. Epilepsia 45:1330-1337, 2004 in children with epilepsy. Epilepsia 42:1141-1147, 2001
30. Stephen LJ, McLellan AR, Harrison JH, et al: Bone density and antiepi- 43. Rattya J, Vainionpaa L, Knip M, et al: The effects of valproate, carbam-
leptic drugs: A case-controlled study. Seizure 8:339-342, 1999 azepine, and oxcarbazepine on growth and sexual maturation in girls
31. Boluk A, Guzelipek M, Savli H, e al: The effect of valproate on bone mineral with epilepsy. Pediatrics 103:588-593, 1999
density in adult epileptic patients. Pharmacol Res 50:93-97, 2004 44. Elliott ME, Binkley N: Evaluation and measurement of bone mass.
32. Matkovic V, Kostial K, Simonovic I, et al: Bone status and fracture rates
Epilepsy Behav 5:S16-S23, 2004 (suppl 2)
in two regions of Yugoslavia. Am J Clin Nutr 32:540-549, 1979
45. Fewtrell MS: Bone densitometry in children assessed by dual x
33. Allen JR, Humphries IR, Waters DL, et al: Decreased bone mineral density
ray absorptiometry: Uses and pitfalls. Arch Dis Child 88:795-798,
in children with phenylketonuria. Am J Clin Nutr 59:419-422, 1994
2003
34. Lande MB, Kim MS, Bartlett C, et al: Reversible Fanconi syndrome
46. Russell RG: Bisphosphonates: Mode of action and pharmacology. Pe-
associated with valproate therapy. J Pediatr 123:320-322, 1993
35. Hawkins E, Brewer E: Renal toxicity induced by valproic acid (Depak- diatrics 119:S150-S162, 2007 (suppl 2)
ene). Pediatr Pathol 13:863-868, 1993 47. Whyte MP, Wenkert D, Clements KL, et al: Bisphosphonate-induced
36. Pack AM, Morrell MJ: Treatment of women with epilepsy. Semin Neu- osteopetrosis. N Engl J Med 349:457-463, 2003
rol 22:289-298, 2002 48. Pedrera JD, Canal ML, Carvajal J, et al: Influence of vitamin D admin-
37. Klein GL, Bachrach LK, Holm IA: Effects of pharmacologic agents on istration on bone ultrasound measurements in patients on anticonvul-
bone in childhood: An editorial overview. Pediatrics 119:S125-S130, sant therapy. Eur J Clin Invest 30:895-899, 2000
2007 (suppl 2) 49. Silver J, Davies TJ, Kupersmitt E, et al: Prevalence and treatment of
38. Pack AM: The association between antiepileptic drugs and bone dis- vitamin D deficiency in children on anticonvulsant drugs. Arch Dis
ease. Epilepsy Curr 3:91-95, 2003 Child 49:344-350, 1974
39. Pack AM, Morrell MJ: Adverse effects of antiepileptic drugs on bone 50. Mikati MA, Dib L, Yamout B, et al: Two randomized vitamin D trials in
structure: Epidemiology, mechanisms and therapeutic implications. ambulatory patients on anticonvulsants: Impact on bone. Neurology
CNS Drugs 15:633-642, 2001 67:2005-2014, 2006