Article Review Rubric

Level 1 Level 2 Level 3 Level 4

Comprehension Student lacked Student Student Student
and response to clear evidenced some evidenced evidenced clear
article understanding of understanding of considerable comprehension
the article and parts of the comprehension of the article and
(Thinking/ may or may not article or did not of the article and articulated a
Inquiry) have expressed a express a articulated a thoughtful
personal personal thoughtful response.
10 Marks response. response. response.
Summary for No summary is Some details Most of the main All main ideas
Article provided OR a from article are ideas and facts and facts from
verbatim of the missing. Summary from the article the article are
(Knowledge/ text is provided. is not objective are included. included.
Understanding) Author and OR minimal Summary is Summary is
source are not referencing to the presented in presented in
Summarize the named. article is objective view objective view
main ideas and provided. Author and referencing and referencing
facts in the OR source are not to the article is to the article is
article. named. provided. Author provided. Author
and source are and source are
10 Marks named. named.
Presentation Student gave a Student vague Student Student engaged
disorganized about main somewhat audience in
(Communication) presentation with points of article. engaged presentation and
main points of audience in highlighted main
10 Marks article lacking. presentation and points of article.
highlighted most
of the main
points of article.
Conclusions No personal Few personal Personal Personal
comments are comments. comments are comments are
(Application) provided. No Student clearly stated. clearly stated.
relationship demonstrates Student clearly Student clearly
Provide personal between article some working demonstrates a demonstrates a
comments and class material knowledge of working strong working
pertaining to the is provided. No class material knowledge of knowledge of
article and how it references are relative to the class material class material
relates to the given. article. Few relative to the relative to the
course material. references are article. Some article.
made to the references are References are
10 Marks course materials. made to the made to the
course materials. course materials.