Documentos de Académico
Documentos de Profesional
Documentos de Cultura
Dr. Isra
Israr Ah
Ahmad
ISBN: 978-0-9845941-2-2
2
Table of Contents
Contents
Translator’s Note (4)
'&% !"#$
1. The Pervasive Ascendancy of Western Thought (5)
'/% )*+,-.$(
2. The Fundamental Point of View (8)
'<% 1234+#5678!"9:;$0
3. Political and Intellectual Onslaught of the West on the Islamic
World (11)
'FG% >?@2356ABC56DE$=
4. Early Defensive Attempts and their Outcome (14)
'G/% $l
9. The Real Task Ahead (40)
'pp% !?no $m
10. A Blueprint for Action (46)
3
Translator’s Note
More than four decades ago, the late Dr. Israr Ahmad wrote a short
treatise in Urdu, titled “Isl┐m k┘ Nash’at-e Th┐niyah: Karnay k┐ A╖l
K┐m.” He published this treatise in the editorial pages of the June 1967
issue of “M┘th┐q,” a monthly journal that he also edited at the time.
The treatise was subsequently printed as a monograph, first by D┐r al-
Ish┐‘at al-Isl┐m┘yyah Lahore and later by Markaz┘ Anjuman Khudd┐m
al-Qur’┐n Lahore. An English translation was published in 1980, under
the title Islamic Renaissance: The Real Task Ahead.
The present edition of “Islamic Renaissance” includes the original
Urdu text as well as a new English translation. While the previous
translation faithfully conveyed the gist of the primary text, the
sophistication of its language tended to discourage many lay readers.
Furthermore, Dr. Israr Ahmad was highly meticulous in his choice of
words, so that rendering his key terms according to their general or
approximate sense did not always capture the very specific meanings
he seemed to have in mind. The new translation has benefited from
the video recordings of the sessions held during the 1990s in the
Qur’┐n Auditorium, Lahore, in which Dr. Israr Ahmad went over the
entire Urdu text of “Islamic Renaissance” in a classroom setting, often
explaining the significance of individual words. The present translation
aims at preserving the author’s unique voice while communicating as
coherently as possible what is most likely to be his intended meaning.
We are convinced that “Islamic Renaissance” has lost none of its value
and relevance since its first appearance in 1967. If anything, the events
and trends of the last half century have vindicated the arguments
presented in this treatise. We hope that the present edition will reach a
wider audience, including a new generation of Muslims, and that it
will facilitate a deeper insight into the modern predicament that Islam
is facing, thereby encouraging appropriate efforts, insh┐ All┐h.
Ahmed Afzaal
Rama╔┐n 1432/August 2011
4
ِ بِس ِْم ﷲِ الرﱠحْ مٰ ِن الر
ﱠح ِيم
!"#$
q
923 Pr23st u2356v2356,-w,-d@x565IJK2356#56yz"923{|2356,- ,-}~
cct+23s!23Q 56r23
!2356@
!)5623z"
1 }2356!2 3456,- t u
£ @] 2378,-t u$ ¡¢@5692356
£)¤!¥¦§¨2356©ª2356v@«9 ,-+23s)*2356#23 ]
2356) *¬56,-B923{®®$v@5623,-+23s¯°@±56²³]
23
º
¹ ,-23+,h»¼ ½2 ¾ ¿ÀÁ23´1µv¶·¸#
@ÂÃ
2356Ä?
!,-856!,-ÅÆ}ǽ2 ¾ ¿!"ÈÉÊ2356 $v
ÏÐÑÒ
Î Î
Ë23]£Ì Í
Í 56v23?23! Ó
12356ÀÁ23ÔÕ
Øv2356,hÙ23n1ÚP J
×#56y2356@±56²³z"$cÖ23
PÛ q
z"Äàáâ}c¶ã )ä ,-¸· Ü2 ݶ)*
@µÞ@ߪ
å!æ
!"· 56Øvçµ23 uèéê
@P±56²³
ë
$vz"£íî#23 @ ,-2356¹eì
5
number of nation-states or political blocs in which the contemporary
world is divided, it is more or less the same style of thinking—or the
same point of view—that prevails all over the world. Disregarding a
few superficial and trivial differences, it is the same cultural currency
that holds value across national, ideological, and societal boundaries.
While we do sometimes encounter alternative perspectives or
viewpoints, the combined significance of these is no more than that of
a peripheral trail compared to the central highway of human
civilization. In both the East and the West, the mindset of the ruling
and leading classes—those who control the collective affairs of their
respective societies—seems to have been dyed in exactly the same hue.
The pervasive ascendancy of Western thought and culture has become
so formidable that even anti-Western movements in different parts of
the world have not been able to remain completely free of its
influence. Upon closer examination, the perspective of the social
forces struggling to resist the West turns out to be quite Western itself.
)*+,-.$(
B]Ê2356vïð@,-£BµÊ 56vÃ23#},-.,h,hê²³
º º q
!2 34#ñÃäÝò]
ó@2356,-
@ô56,-õ2ÜÝ-, @ö÷ vøÎ ù2356 ,-
gû#5623ü9ÀÁ23M
2356@
@ý
úcÃ×5632 ]2356cð
923{|þ2356ïê})*£@2356,-
+#56,-r23s1
!23PQ b2356?b2356bb1Øv× 56v¶,-232 Û1#r23s1
2356#5623üB!
´23
562Ü23
56t 5656b1 bc|
23PQ
ÀÁ23
!~2356÷ ,-P ?c|
t5623÷!c|
,hê2356v
§Øï׸µ9$vï,-232 Û~ B+,-!R c|
!2356232 Û" 1÷23Ê232 ÛÊ!à !R2356÷t5623÷,hê
2356#5623ür23
@
2356 32 t23$%23%23b!23PQb×Ø#
×
$ 23(+,-!R 2356÷ ,-P ?÷!23
56Ü2 &56'
6
·@)*¹ 56v32 ý@+,2356@µÞ -./01B@
q º º
2356' 2ÜÝ,-44d56,h5,-½2 ¾ ¿235665623 78r9
@56 56>!t*Øv?·×=$ v1:,- ;<
q
23P ,-b £¸D u¹) ,-23bM¥ 23P ,-b£A5656´@B23,-C 23
F!G56>b@B23,-C b,-c| 56µc¶û23ü9E?56?bM¥
÷!HI
,hêvJ23
+dK?t7$;(<v u)
.]2356L]M+,-!R HI
+56N!R 2356÷ ,-P ?HI
t5623
S@OP2356@.Q56@,-µc¶,-3B 2 9RB@ú¸÷@A56
$T u)
WWrX,-YµZ~356'b ,-P ?b2356 b!bͦ!2 34UV
2356@µÞ[\\@56,-9
!23n½2 ¾ ¿] ^56_½2 ¾ ¿`2356c!¥a[
!d
£,-h56i2356j 23Áklú2356Ë,-b cdeØf¬@gµ
st Ý
!,-p2äÝ2356÷qr @µPÞ!m÷n23,-oÞ
!23n$ï2ÜÝ
×r,-P ?é+¬56,-2356,-y!PÞuv w£B!2 34µé£!;x56
q Î
ø !zv wØ{|}~,-1,-c|!G×@µÞ12356>
_!56!,-12356,hêØÊoÞ56"Þ
12356!2356÷t5623ØÊv ,-P ?
º º
'% ,-2·,-B@ô56,h5,- ;<
q q
'æB% @B23,-C ÷M¥ 23P ,- g M¥ 23P ,-÷@B23,-C
;(<
'
% Y -, r23P ,-¸
23
7
2. The Fundamental Point of View
The ideas and conceptions behind modern civilization did not come
into being overnight, nor should they be mistaken as constituting a
simple and monolithic entity. During the last two centuries or so,
practically countless schools of thought have emerged in the West, and
human beings have inquired into human nature and existence from
virtually innumerable points of view. Throughout this variegated
intellectual journey, however, a single viewpoint has become
increasingly established. Thus, while modern thought is both complex
and diverse, it is nevertheless possible to identify a particular
viewpoint as forming its essential foundation. This viewpoint may be
stated as follows: The central axis of human reflection and
investigation should consist of “solid facts” and actual, observable
events—as opposed to “imaginary” or “transcendent” notions.
According to this viewpoint, the legitimate objects of human inquiry
should be the physical universe, as opposed to God; the material body,
as opposed to the spirit; and the life of this-world, as opposed to the
life hereafter. Though at a purely academic level the reality of God,
the spirit, and life hereafter was neither confirmed nor denied, this
avowedly agnostic position has led, quite understandably, to the
gradual elimination of these “concepts” from the domain of legitimate
human inquiry. Because of this viewpoint, all of human curiosity and
concern become focused upon and restricted to the realm of the
material universe, the physical body, and the life of this-world.
Consider the fact that Divine Providence has bestowed upon
humankind a great many capacities, the disciplined use of which in
any field is bound to produce definite results. By applying these
capacities, all manners of seekers and explorers can potentially
discover entirely new worlds in their respective fields of inquiry.
Consider also that a single atom appears trivial when compared to the
mighty sun, but if some of the divinely bestowed human capacities
were to be focused on the exploration of that trivial atom, it would
reveal itself as a magnificent and glorious sun in its own right. On the
same analogy, the material universe, the physical body, and the life of
this-world appear to possess no ontological value when we compare
these to the reality of God, the spirit, and the life hereafter; and yet, if
8
all the human capacities for acquiring knowledge were to be focused
solely upon the physical and material reality, even this otherwise
insignificant realm would seem to possess an endless span and a
bottomless depth.
This is precisely what happened in the West. When “the universe” and
“matter” were brought under the lens of scientific inquiry, the result
was a chain reaction of discoveries and innovations. Clues were
revealed that pointed to immense sources of energy that have so far
been lying hidden or dormant behind the veils of nature. These
developments astonished the world and brought about revolutionary
transformations in all areas of arts and sciences.
Two important consequences followed this revolution: First, a series
of continuous breakthroughs in deciphering the laws of nature, a
harnessing of natural forces and their use as efficient sources of energy,
and an uninterrupted stream of innovative tools and techniques—all of
this led to the rise of Europe as an invincible power. Second, the
immense power and grandeur of “matter” came to be seen as an
irrefutable argument in favor of focusing the human gaze on the
physical universe, as opposed to God. The marvelous success of
science itself became a veritable proof that the truly important object
of human inquiry was matter and its physical and chemical properties,
rather than God and the attributes of God.
1234+#5678!"9:;$0
,-],- µ 2356 u 9ÈÉͦ!"@µÞ Ùqý@!m
q
23565Iê[@2356ÞÉ2356ï923 Pr23s?
!Σ
k23CP56!Î1$j|t@56Á56 P
äÝ23!Î1
235612341h, / ÷,- u@@/56ÈÉ
2356²2 ÛÈÉ
$ï¡32
!2 34:;23s23Á23Á
@ô] 23569
9
!2 34$·+#56,-2356·7856+¢÷SÊ£56,- ×!"9:;
ðéê
1¤,-P 23}:;h, / 78k1234@62356CP56
!2 34Ø1§ ¨1
TÍ P Jf $v u)䥦1§7d5 6·1
vãy©-r,-9
äÝàª56«56!¬®23562356®ÍÎ23 2ÜÝ®
,-23,- Ã23÷v,- 23 23B³!í5 61
¯@56°±²±²2356
56>2356 b%23N b ´,-+µ!¶?23Á4235623·!23¸@ô¹
º
-.ôé½B b1, -¸b2356 º,hÙn23
»¼!G
j£ V¿2356 23Â,-!5 623Ã156!ÄMÅPÀÁ,hP ο ¾ ;<
78!"2356¢¯Ò!¾Æ56!,hê23½2 ¾ ¿÷23·!23¸nê
${|D23·!23¸Ç56 ÙÈ£%23%23w,-d
4235623J9!)56234c,-!2 34]B®784
ú$,-56f· g Êq+#56,-g É#3 2 2356) *
M
+,-.ÍÎ@~Þ Á23=÷ÏÐ Ë]Ì+,-P ?!"
u2356!Ñ£Ò $ÓÔÕÑ9y@Í÷]?3d 2 éÖ56
×@µ@}B!)5623z"Ø ,-
:;@ Ù
Ú,- ,-23
.!",-kµ@)
!N56y$,-56fy@¶3Û 2 2356
tn56,-P 232356w56Ý23n·=µr23
@ ,h/ ,-}~#ñÃäÝò23Ü
12356bäb2356bãb$kÞ$ïû¯cfß!à56áâ32 â
1 h, / ÷¹,-}~çèé56@k@)12356,-å561æ$78
,-P ?2356)*Êí923{+23î¨ï
12356 tMê u ë
56$ì
êäݬ@ð,-
@£ôñ56òóô
:;%23%23#23 Êõ9
+,-!R c|
+56N!R 2356÷r,-P ?c|
t5623÷!c|
,hê2356$ï
P ÷ Ò
r ·£,-2ÜÝ
@£ô
t2 áøù235623ú,-û
1ØüýÍ P Ò+23sö
${|D
10
'+þ% ,- 32 56 u B %23 N
23,- g ,-32 +1 ;<
º
'% µP1,
-¸ré½352 6,-
12
>? @2356ABC56DE$=
7·ABDEäݶHI
231#56yz"
q
@@£ôñ562356
;Æù56,-2356,-23,-î2356:@2356,-
9« 56£÷Ït56,-AB×DE56«$«
23·1562323
562356ÙÙ
DE 56+¬56,-2356{Íe
${
÷
ÍPj! Md~þ 56B
q º º
235656¶t @5623 @ýBÍ¾Æ ½2 ¾ ¿ÀÁ23ØS×y+,-.*2356v¶
D u)#äÝ232 !+"½2 ¾ ¿`¸AB 1$56#
B@k56,-4
231!"Ø9é$12356+%?1@?23,-
'
1Ø× 562356v& (23]£h, / ÷v¹:;äÛ561)HI*
º
@kc¹B-56+
t½2 ¾ ¿2356c¶¶Í¾Æ,23
!Î
º
7é.µB¸î+23·z/Øv×Ç562356$c¶#0
ÍÒ·@k2£
ÍP Òï
12356B@ô5623·
231
2356÷j 237®®·895623@56½2 34Á!5 6
w9 ,-P ?֕ 23
ë º q
1$ï 23eì·UÂ,-:f56,-@56Xسول ؐ ّقال وقال الر
1<56S =123,-£é.µB>}÷S?4,-@23,-A2ÜP Ý;# B
$Êât£V[£´
·C,-2356c¶,-·Ù?23ØS×y+,-. @BB+¬56,-
º
BDE56F
!)5623,h,hêé£G
H1$c¶3²
2 ÊÙÃ
º
91*c¶ ^,h,hê\é+¬56,-2356c¶û IäÝ
î!æ
À,-23u2356ÕÑP56P56@BB1 $c¶äÝ
TU Í
V56W9X5IY'KLMNOPLQNRS%w9J!"UV÷@6
13
2356äÝZ[\]TÒ$û56f^9B!k2356!,-_T@£ô
ºq
,hP ά@õ56W$:56f`µ£a ÑÝ!,-_DbÑc¥2356?
1
jd ù
@2356 efg
V2356@£ô
æh
@2356@i
2356^,h,hêØBÙ
k5IJê]@5Il2356@]23£Ý·
º
1mh
12356nr,-Ù?23 56Øc¶yvw1
oµ@23,-?
×$Sû23·!2 34þp@2á=9 231ñÙ4
Êõ9 ,-P ?!"2356{ 23q@¶Í¾Æù56,-@BB@@ßØvÇ56
º
Ø×é.µ \¥B¸*$23rsh, øùdt56â£Í¾ÆùG
Ú-,
ë
·ev
@±56²³¹]23
#56u,-}B@£ôWî
w
xÞy 562356+zÊ!2356{23|9564}(~234
º
b!23b23ÍÒ,hê!"äݶ@sh, ,h,hê×,-2356 23F
$ï
4. Early Defensive
Defensive Attempts and their Outcome
Numerous endeavors of a defensive nature were initiated on behalf of
Islam, through which many concerned and devout Muslims attempted
to safeguard their faith and religious tradition against the onslaught of
Western thought and philosophy. These defensive attempts were of
two main varieties—first, attempts aiming at preservation alone; and
second, attempts aiming at protection along with some compromise
and concession.
Borrowing the analogy used by Man┐╘ir A╒san G┘l┐n┘, the first of the
two varieties can be described as similar to the strategy adopted by the
“People of the Cave.” This refers to the story of A╖'╒┐b al-Kahf as
narrated in the Holy Qur’┐n: a group of young men flee from society
when their faith was threatened, seeking refuge in an isolated cave (cf.
S┴rah al-Kahf 18:9-26). In the nineteenth-century, the essence of this
approach was to focus upon preserving one’s faith and religiosity by
removing oneself from the mainstream of social life and thereby
14
avoiding its challenges and temptations. Even though this attitude may
appear to be sheer escapist in motivation, it was based on the realistic
acknowledgement that the Islamic world did not have the capacity to
survive in a face-to-face encounter with Western thought and
philosophy. The onslaught of the West was like an enormous tidal
wave, and the only practical option for Muslims was to move out of its
way as quickly as possible. In this approach, top priority was given to
the task of preserving the integrity of Islamic faith and tradition, even
at the cost of having to retreat from the mainstream of society and
becoming, as a result, the targets of its derision and ridicule. Indeed,
whatever success was achieved during that period was the result of this
very approach. Thanks to those who followed the example of “People
of the Cave,” religious faith stayed alive in at least one section of the
ummah; a few candles of spirituality were left burning in the
otherwise dark night of disbelief and materialism; and the basic
structure of religiosity and religious practice survived through the
preservation and transmission of traditional Islamic sciences. In the
Indian Subcontinent, this kind of defense was epitomized by the D┐r
al-‘Ul┴m at Deoband, a religious seminary that was also the vanguard
of a great movement.
The second variety of Muslim defense was characterized by protection
of the self as well some conciliation with the other. Its essence was a
desire to keep up with changing times without losing the commitment
to Islam. The approach was two-fold; first, to critically examine
Western thought and philosophy in order to sift the grain from the
husk, and, second, to construct a new interpretation of Islam in order
to establish its veracity in the modern world.
Initial efforts of this kind were marked by an excessive awe and
admiration for the West along with a sense of resigned acquiescence. In
India and Egypt, a number of quasi-theologians began to evaluate the
fundamental tenets of Islamic faith and doctrine on the touchstone of
Western rationalism. In their attempt to fit a square peg in a round
hole, as it were, these reformers were forced to trim down Islamic
metaphysical beliefs, often by explaining them away in purely
scientific terms. Sayyid A╒mad Kh┐n in the Indian Subcontinent and
Muft┘ Mu╒ammad ‘Abduh in Egypt, as well their disciples and
followers, epitomized this variety of Muslim defense. These reformers
15
wanted the ummah to follow the same path of material progress that
Europe had pioneered, and to keep Islam with them as a supportive
and accommodating companion in this journey.
Regardless of how sincere and well-intentioned these reformers may
have been, the fact of the matter is that their efforts literally squeezed
the life out of religious faith and tradition. Launched under the
pervasive influence of Western thought and philosophy, these
defensive attempts at compromise and concession ended up producing
a more or less secularized version of Islam.
If there was any useful outcome of this variety of defensive efforts,
perhaps it was this: Muslims who were already westernized in their
thinking and life-style did not have to repudiate their connection to
Islam. For such Muslims, this modernist and secularized version of
Islam became the “apology” that they would humbly offer to the West
in exchange for maintaining their Muslim identity.
L23MN5IJK $H
"
! ê
à !R2356÷t5623÷,h 1#z"vl¶ûk1Ø
t56232356!c|
,hêµé£UV923?23,-r,-9
2356232 Û
56!,-p56!¥aï
*Z23
562Ü356' ,-P ?c|
2356{23t23r¬+56N!R é+¬56,-2356
56fÊ!;x
,hÙ2356#5623ürP+,-!R
MNâï
*~23
56t
cÃSâ5656@2356c u,-}56!)ß56782356!23Q
/56 ¯
Ò32 UV$c56f,h 23Ç56:;=23569+#56Ì!R
º
,-32 23,-UÂ,-ß5678}G
'LQ RRMS%S+23,-¶
@)ß2356t5623äÝ232356÷äÝ u÷w9Þ@)78Ç1S723
$23¦ u@Vß5678â2356c23¬2ÜÝ2356+23,-×?¬
16
5. The Development of the Social Sciences
As already mentioned, while claiming to suspend any final judgment
on God, the spirit, and the life hereafter, Western thought nevertheless
amounted to a practical denial of these metaphysical realities. As God
and the spirit became marginalized as subjects of legitimate concern
and inquiry, human attention was increasingly focused on the physical
universe and the material body, initiating a chain-reaction of scientific
discoveries and innovations. In the same way, as the life hereafter
ceased to be at the center of legitimate concern and inquiry, human
attention was increasingly focused on the immediacy of worldly life
and earthly existence. As a result, temporal and mundane aspects of
human life became topics for profound reflection and in-depth
analysis, leading to an explosive growth in new conceptions and
theories relating to the social, political, and economic spheres of life.
Through the process of synthesis and integration, these conceptions
and theories gave rise to systematic programs for organizing human
life at the collective level. Initially confined to academic and
theoretical discussions, such systematic programs inspired new
ideological movements that caused these programs to start manifesting
in the domain of historical reality as well. The political and economic
structures associated with medieval feudalism gave way to modern
ideological systems, such as nationalism, fascism, and democracy in the
political realm, and capitalism and socialism in the economic realm.
UVT+W+XYZ235623Q!RST $O
ë
:;æ @,-
56e2 ! FeL23+#1
!"@)
!N
2356û56f#5623üÀÁ23S
!R 3
2 9@£ô·@Øz9
b!RS Tb56@Ï+,-!}
@â
+,-
Äàáâ
à,-BÀÁ23S 1]Ù235656
$56fÊ@V
17
º
Äàá@,-P £V¡56h, }÷ UVT×+W+XYZ
q
¢×2356£¤îr¬56,-£@65 ¥î÷:56fäÛ56]£
@£h, ê]£2356vÃ239¦@,-23 PQ]£ØvF£íî
¨£â23â9:;©56@ØvF·×=
vc§äݬ
q
@ð,-
ª@}ý2356÷vÓÔ,-«T¬23
!R¯
Ô
$v¯56°Ô±®Õ Ñ;!"
$·!²r¬56,-Í
°T¬Õ Ñ@P±56²³2356#56yz"
Ø×é.Ê 56S u+³!Î}®+¢2356øÑ´ JK 78
!"Ø×£ Ò
78´!"2356v,-µt23ß 1@VTÞÄàáâövï¶23ß
r,-9
äÝàª56«¸2356 $ ;<vï23·9¸%23%23e¹w,-d
§÷·º?
+2ÜÝ56È» P ßr,-9
,-E56@5602356w,-d78
$vl+,-32 uT©ÍÎ23 2ÜÝ@¼½z":;23s
'
1æ!",-2356ïäÝ.¾¿& À@P±56²³z"Ø×r¬56,-
12356ÁBÂôͦ,-vÊõ9 ,-P ?Ö Ä÷vÅÆ2356E,-.1Øïû
Ì '
·B23nË Ê9
@5Il2356ãÇÜ2 ÝÈ2356ÉB
é.Ê·@Ã562356ï@Í9!",-µû56f¢ÎÏßb1 b
Þ,-Ø×é.ÊØ×rÐ$ ¶ã£956232356 uz,-ö9
W7Ô2356!ÕÖ!)ÑÍ2356{ÒÍ ÑÏt¦2356Ó
÷ï23·!23¸! PÞ×2356Ã23Ê1 ,-P ?,-öY,-É23¾¿Y,-.
$f23Ø23nÔ±®B;Æù2356ï@ u Ù232 Û\]DÚ Ñ¥2356?UV
UVTÞ
+23Û,-2356+,-32 uͦÄàá@âØ×k
tß
ÜÝd
ÍÞ TÞ£h, êh, / v9;Æù 1xÞykµà
$áäÝâB23Q
cR*ïûãB!,hêøù
18
Ý
S b2356 ÷b¯l/ Í Ò5IêÅ
,-ä b÷bcRbä âFÑ2356!²d©23
56£h, ê2356@5656!Þ:23¬2ÜÝÄàá@âUV bT
#eæ23561 £§االخوان المسلمونV23
å
$SI@6BbTÍ eÁbW56¶A2ÜÝ23
F
@}ýTç 2356¤¬ 2ÜÝ@è@â+XéUV×
z/@6BB@ àv uæ32
@ê-, v wÖ£ª
2356Ð23säÛ56-UV×Øv1æëö÷ì¹
í@5 623Áاالخوان المسلمونVUV$ u¹·äÛ56^!
12ÜÝ56 uð!5 6,-ß :;
ñ56ê!vïP ¥!Å
12356vlî
23,h
ÍÎ8MóØ56D1µTj£ VA2ÜP Ý]23÷v23òr23Ø
$Ã23¹Í ,-23+23,-2ÜÝôäÝ23j£ VI1!2356vl
@è442356ã+õ.@5IlØv×µ½2 ¾ ¿`ÍT@V@
,-É23n@)
ÍÎ8öñ÷B@ð,-
,-ø£ù@£ôñ56òó
÷{ uäÝý,-ûäÛ5632 b.ú%b2356@µ,-ÅTÞï
*÷
q
$ü
¯Ú¥ý2356T,-23 PQ
@v!ÍÎ23 2ÜÝT@?23,-
¥
$vÇ56þ u!]äÝ£2356,-1µ 56ve¹>´%23%32 t*½2ÜÝä 56,- ;<
20
humanity at the altar of the much more “concrete” economic realities.
The resulting panic in the West led many people to revert back to the
notion of humanism; and even the idea of spirituality began to be
mentioned in somewhat muffled tones.
Third, modern science began to lose some of its previous claim to
finality and conclusiveness. New theories shook the foundations of
Newtonian physics and Euclidian geometry; matter lost its rock-solid
permanence and revealed itself as a form of energy. As a result of these
developments, the affirmation of metaphysical doctrines became
somewhat easier and, on the whole, the foundation of religion began
to be strengthened once again.
Fourth, the concept of Islamic revival received indirect support from
nationalist and anti-colonial movements. The sense of communal
solidarity among Muslims is based on religious affiliation;
consequently, when movements for liberation and self-determination
were launched in various Muslim countries, they inevitably appealed
to people’s religious sentiments in order to arouse a sense of
nationhood. These nationalist feelings, in turn, nourished the desire
for a rebirth and revitalization of Islam.
Supported and encouraged by the above factors, Islamic movements
with the avowed goals of “Islamic Revival,” “Establishment of God’s
Kingdom,” and “Enforcement of the Islamic System” became active in
different Muslim countries. Of these, al-Ikhw┐n al-Muslim┴n of Egypt
was most distinguished in terms of its strength, extent, and fervor. By
offering a robust and vigorous intellectual framework, however, the
Jam┐‘at-e Isl┐m┘ of the Indian Subcontinent occupies a prominent
place among all the Islamic movements.
These revivalist movements have been active in different countries for
the last three decades, influencing a substantial segment of the younger
generation of Muslims. In practice, however, none of them has
achieved any remarkable success anywhere in the Islamic world.
Rather, it seems that these movements have outlived their allotted
time, and that the moment is not yet ripe for the realization of the
hope and vision of an Islamic renaissance. Egypt’s al-Ikhw┐n has met
almost complete disintegration within the country, and its few
remaining members are scattered in exile, many of them surviving on
21
the basis of the mutual rivalry among Arab states. As for the Indian
Subcontinent’s Jam┐‘at-e Isl┐m┘, most of its potential has been lost in
the quagmire of Pakistani politics, and it has now been largely reduced
to a mere addendum in the struggle for the restoration of democracy.
On the surface, the cause of the failure of these revivalist movements
appears to be their impatience and strategic hastiness. They jumped
into the political arena too soon, without having changed the minds of
a substantial number of thoughtful and perceptive individuals in their
respective countries. This resulted in a premature clash between the
Islamic movements on the one hand and the secular political
leadership as well as the various “progressive” elements on the other
hand.
Upon deeper reflection, however, the actual cause of the failure of
these twentieth century revivalist movements turns out to be entirely
different. In reality, their failure is the direct result of an immaturity in
their conception of religion and of a deficiency in their understanding
of Islam.
1. The way in which the British Empire had to withdraw from her vast
dominion is a truly eye-opening phenomenon of the twentieth century.
_]B^ $\
q q PÛ
)*z"7¯Ú¥ý@V@Øvçµc¶ã Ü2 ݶ)ä ,- 23,-
UV$vB+,-!R 9+56N!R 2356r,-P ?9t5623*v9
÷v@k±
v,-}~@
@µ232Û!,-_Db Ñ¥2356?@
3B
2 92356äÝ1ß J
ú2356÷ï¹!zd235623 23,-͹
Tb±
2356+,-
@â
+,-!R }
Ø 56 إيمان باv,-}~µ232 Û
/01$vï23 bÀÁ23S
,-$÷ u b)b!²d2356÷æ÷¥]56K56È¥ u
ٌ ُکن فِی ال ُّدنيا َکا َ َّنکَ َغ ِريبØ@k ë91v¶ûµ232 Û!N u$v
22
23Í PÑÞáv µ232 Ûä¥23$vð÷c¶ð ;<يل َ َا
ٍ وع ِابرُ َس ِب
º
2356r232½¾¿
¶-, µ£,-2ÜÝ
@£ô% ,-2323PQä¥23I 2356¹,-}~B
I
ÍP}2356 ÷;(<¹ ,-23ý56232Ü
ÍP JfÀÁ23´é.
vãð 32 5623,-23kë¯ä¥23 ÍP2356!,-;ÍP·@5Il = u ,-23
£ _v23232 Û2ÜÝ+,-32 u,-Ù?23£í@Á23´â32 â*
@
@kØ×2356v,-.Mýw }v¶232 Û 56é. b@kb
·1§ö56!2356{1öv¹,-}~Ø×é.Êc¶(bb
_vr¬
Íe½!,-#2356v232 Û"§ '!MLM%,-Øv )*7
$@úv;0< معراج المؤمنين56ØI×236$v{ 23é,-$
ð;=< ُقرَّ ةُ َعينِی فِی الص َّٰلو ِةØ%ë1M
K2356v&56
232 Û"§
rfß (µ£,-2ÜÝ
@£ô% ,-23'2ÜÝ
1$vð÷n
rfß@ 56Øv´1ö1·£,-2ÜÝ
@56¬56,-2356
+,2356À-t5623Ø ¥× /jB23t7 _v¸569)¶£*56t,
$v@0§1
T×Ø´×12¹é56.23n1v/23,-
623567 'RQ
5OPMKOQ%K3 ×Øv¶û@4!µ×r23
352 623
1æ b!8b@4
1v¹]¶23,-r¬µ?11v
$v/23,-23569Bn¸91M:;2356@?äÝât5623×Øv
9<=12356;H< اَلصَّو ُم جُ َّنةØvD@4;56VµäÝí×UV
Ý
]âµP56;O< اجزی ِبه ٰ اَلصَّو ُم لِی َواَ َناØ7nä í×$v¶,-235632 !
ç×µr23
?t7 $;\<923{+¬¬>µv·D¸2356vD@4
@ u 1vD*+23,-2ÜÝA;£923
w9,hêB23,-
1Øv
$¹ ,hB!2ÜÝM56231
23
cÃC*®
#56y
!"v!ÍÎ23 2ÜÝ^2×
q
,-P ?2356D32 t23ñ!R 12356t5623Ò$,-É23yÊõ9 ,-P ?56ÊíB)
2356~#5623ür23]+,-!R
·Í¾Æù56,-UV$ZÜ2 23
56t 2356
jtE*v¸569)¶M
jtEØ u ¸µ>2356^+,-P ?
3B
2 9+,-!R é.¯ôfikúF@ý56,-+,-jtE2356+56N
q
( 'JOQNMN5O
RO5NLQ RRMS%bSMN5678b £øÑÝH I+N u h, / G
ÀÁ23UV $;a<]23Ê ,-23br,-9b £´ b!Kb2356g ï 23
12356ÍPÑÞá56n.,hê]23$c¶û56723 àBÀÁ23S 1Ø232 Û×H
fiÔ56+ý$´@µ½2 ¾ ¿}b!,-#b }!N 56L P M
$;l<{ 23
5678b ,-23øù¯ôfiUV×Øvçµc¶û23ü231
@Vß5678+¬56,-PI+N u2356$b+,-b ,-23 O,-2356bMN
cÃS¨QRäÝ23Ê23,-×?¬£,-2ÜÝ
@ß Øâ231é.
£ gvS923{¨BTUÓ
ÀÁ23M
£,-2ÜÝ
@ 2356!R
V ¹]56f·µR
23n;Æù?23,-
1 ,-X Ô23 Ê WÊ
· v1@÷Èf t5623Ø
½2 3Y@2356]23Z[,-ß[,-?
@563 2
\.UV×ØvÍ]
V Sû@56fØÃ23,-]×Ê2356Ã23^]_µÊþv2 !U1`56
b 56 23£. Í ÑP Ò 56 ò aµ § M¥
º
ï!²·c562356 uÊ123B*äÝd
24
Ý
b2 !Ufg32 W ,-b +eä í_ ;<
Ý
×é.ñ
#k 1@$vB2Ü 569iK!h@r23iéfÀj623,-235623k1 ;(<
_v_lm7 ,^·×Øñ¶n 56×Øv,-o
Ý
_vt.@p~36 2 bالصلوة معراج المؤمنين ٰ " +eä í ;0<
Ý
b$ v32 6¶q@r u+sb +eä í ;=<
º Ý
b_v?
Â,- 352 623b +eä í ;H<
v Û Ý
2356vtrs 352 623buý
!2 +¬56,-£ b$=@56,- D1,-2356vtrs 352 623 b 7nä í ;O<
b$@D1],-
Ý Ý
ä ,-P ?9?,-56,-
¹]v>
@£ôW 23£wF
7nä í1Øv×Ç 56 ;\<
_rrzr,-9
Ý ºÝ
M N5678£ 23,- bØûä 5623+5632 x£ y× z ,-2356TrÜ2 î£
2356,-1UV ;a<
º
!ِ ﻋﺮﺑﯽ ﺍﺳﺖj ﭼﻪ ﺑﻲ ﺧﺒﺮ ﹺﺯ ﻣﻘﺎ ﹺﻡ ﻣﺤﻤﺪb$vï,- -, ,-9!K9*vS
Ã!"# µ@£ôb%b ,-23Ê2356 gv@
@VTb%ÍÒnb{·!2 3¸× ;l<
ºÝ Ý
@$v,-É23y¸569bßb£ õÜ2
u·MN5678B æ32
2Ü È2356Â
~¬@
@µ!k56!,-_v23÷bÕ}23S b k|£v!2 3#£,-2ÜÝ
^ÍÒÅ23565632 5623 u56
,-7 ^t2356-, 56ÍѦ2356@5Il @Ã56Â
;Æù÷vbÂÃb]^+,-P ?·× ú+23iØ
1 ,-}56§$,-Ò]¯cfß32
@Bà,-
@ u2 Ûé ê2356+,-P ?1 ï ,-Ê@
]b#M u2 ÛbvJØt1¹~ 23i^×
Æ Ý
+,-P ?Í ù56,-Øñ¶n 56×Ø923{µ·+r23Íä ¶b#b1§2356$vC
¾
Vv¶£@NuÊ^
ﻝ ﭼﻮﻥ ﻧﻬﺪ ﻣﻌﻤﺎﺭ ﻛﺞ ﺍﻭﺧﺸﺖ
ﺎ ﻣﻲ ﺭﻭﺩ ﺩ ﻳﻮ ﺍ ﺭ ﻛﺞﺗﺎ ﺛﺮﻳ
26
of ritual prayer becomes a source of inner peace and joy. Carrying this
trend to its logical conclusion, some of the more “progressive”
elements have gone so far as to identify ╖al┐h with the social order of
the Muslim community! Others have recognized the value of ╖al┐h
only at an exoteric level; in their view, the Islamic ritual prayer is
important mainly because it offers a comprehensive program for the
reform and organization of the Muslim community. Similarly, the
power of zak┐h to develop and purify the soul is much less known or
appreciated than its role as an important pillar of the Islamic economic
system. Fasting is readily acknowledged as an exercise in self-control;
its power to strengthen the spirit and relax the shackles of bodily
demands, however, is either not recognized at all or is deliberately left
unexpressed because of a certain embarrassment. The Prophetic saying
“fasting is a shield” is often reiterated and a good deal of time is spent
in its explanation. On the other hand, the highly significant holy
tradition “fasting is for Me . . .” is either skipped altogether, or is
mentioned only in passing.2 Finally, it is well known that the ritual of
╒ajj provides an important means through which a monotheistic
community is organized on a global level. Beyond this, no mention is
ever made of the deeper religious significance of the pilgrimage or of
its numerous spiritual blessings.
The above features of the revivalist interpretation of Islam are direct
consequences of the pervasive ascendancy of Western thought and
philosophy, the influence of which has pushed the viewpoint in the
direction of disbelief and materialism. Consequently, in the revivalist
discourse the spirit and its inner life have been excluded from the
discussion, while the material reality and the life of this-world have
been elevated as the central topics of reflection and inquiry. This has
produced what amounts to a materialistic understanding of religion. In
theory, the revivalist discourse affirms that Islam is a comprehensive
program for human flourishing and that it aims at human welfare in
this-world as well as in the life hereafter. In practice, however, Islam is
approached entirely as a political and social system, while the status of
theology and metaphysics is reduced to that of a façade or veil.3 This
happens because the gaze of the revivalist interpreters is firmly fixed
on the life of this-world. The real purpose of life, according to this
understanding of religion, is to enforce the Islamic political and social
27
system in the world. As for personal knowledge and intimate love of
God—and the attitude of loving adoration, humility, supplication, and
yearning for communion that form the essence of ‘ib┐dah—all of these
have been relegated to a secondary and peripheral status.4
When examined from this perspective, it becomes clear that the
essence of these twentieth century Islamic movements is more socio-
political than religious. They are more this-worldly than other-
worldly. As such, the revivalist movements are distinguished only in
claiming that the Islamic code of life offers a better solution to the
problems of temporal human existence; whereas other ideological
movements make the same claim for capitalist democracy, socialism,
and so on.
The above analysis is tantamount to saying that the task of reviving
the real values of religion has not even started!
It is precisely for this reason that the predicament of the revivalist
movements is comparable to that of a ship without a rudder, one that
drifts aimlessly at the mercy of winds and waves. Or it is like that of a
traveler who becomes a victim of amnesia, unable to recall the
whereabouts of either his native land or his destination.
28
As for religious doctrines and metaphysical beliefs, these authors take their
first step from the point where Sayyid A╒mad Kh┐n’s theological project had
culminated; by interpreting Paradise and Hell in terms of this-worldly
pleasure and pain, and the Resurrection in terms of nuclear explosions, have
sought to eliminate the very subject of metaphysics! This mode of thought is
an extreme but perfectly logical consequence of the tendency towards a
materialistic understanding of religion. A full criticism of this view is not our
objective here; even though it presents itself as “Qur’┐nic thought,” both its
grossly materialistic nature and its antagonism to the spirit of the Qur’┐n are
self-evident. We have referred to this variety of “thought” merely as an
example of how far a materialistic interpretation of religion can reach in only
a few steps. The following Persian couplet eloquently depicts this situation: If
the very first brick is laid crooked / the entire wall is deformed to the
summit!
b@k,h ib g23de fbcRb $a
q
Ê^ f¿ö
,hiT¬@k!cR2356v9@k,-.
$=n
£í£·12356v§îd
·+23·,-56+,-32 u78Äàá@
!RS Tt7$v23 23
¨£ 91235623PQÀÁ23S
ð×B23,-
@V2356v23nv w2356£í£·,-«23
º
§2356$v+Ü2 £
]cR·56@vÃ23
1ôñ56òóô
:;Øv1!2356{2356v·
3B
2 91B56ô´ 56c¶1§ö12356@©äݶ
bwb2356232Ûr"@k23562ÜÝ£V[£@k,h iÍP ÒØY,-
º
$ñ23·!23¸bbõ2ÜÝ
,-@@
Øv×n 2312356v9DÚ Ñ¥2356?ÍÜÝd@k
@µ56¶@ý
¬235623 ,-23@5656,-,-9@
إيمان£$¶@ý
,-é.}r9@µ@,-« ,-23®
29
2356)*2356!
×)56#
12356$vCP56ef 231 بالغيب
#23 d
+Á56,hê! ,-c u)56ð562356¨!Øv+÷d56T3d 2 ×
q
?ÍÊçw,-23ÊÊ23s! $ç?,h56¶ Á23£
q
561æ?2!23+,-2ÜÝ¡56+Á56,hê ,-23½2 ¾ ¿56@ u½2 ¾ ¿öc u)б
oÞ
@ $ç/ +¢? £t5623c u)A56.56L ,-P ? $c¶,-å
q
b£f,- £b 56ä¥56÷*c¶û9MP23jt56231öÊ9M:;
1Ƚ
+÷+56N!R 2356çA56.56¨$¹]23¤56M¥+,-!R $;<
دنياHI
+,-¦56Ô23/012356÷ u)¥56562356+E¬56
Ý
¨!×$Ê1æ ,-239
©uý
§+eä íA56ومافيہا
×)*ø¬P ¦æ2356,-vw£
ÍP ңͦØvª«t
q
$ÀnÊ® f¼½2 ¾ ¿ 56322 3 ubcRb c¶Êð56
¤56i! j W/23,-æ~+234 u2356+2ÜÝ23¯@k!°±
Ñ
232356÷³÷´÷¢øÑH÷23PpMk23 ý56MP23n .@Ã,-56!°
v²
نھاج
ِ م
ِ ٰ
علی خالفة $:
u ) -
, j
Í
P ¦ 3
2 6
5 ÷ ¶ d ÷ µ÷ kÛ @ïÁ2 3 2356÷¶
·56¸÷¹56ɺn1» ]W
¶§2Üݧ23,-
S
ال ّنبوة
,-P ?56,-v!"ͦ¸2356$v]23¼½5623@kB23,-
²56Õ2356÷
q
§÷z,-¬£íî·2332 ×
56@k 235623@56¾½2 ¾ ¿32
w9
b¸Kb235623 ýb¿5623,- b
:¹ð$ ·\ شخصيّتيں
\ 5623 ;£56@kØv1!2356{!2356 ÷;(<23ÀMk!2 3Û
Ä56H@Á23@,-}~ôÂÃÍ j ¦ÖWÁÁ2356×2Û×2ÛØ
¶23Æ@?2 !1
§Å}2356÷ +,-¦12356}Ô23,hê
Ç ;0<حُمرال َّن َع َم ِ ِی ِبکَ ُ َرجُ الً َّواحِداً َخيرٌ َلکَ ِمن َ إلَن َيھدØuý
÷º2356BÀÁ23@
12356Èr,-232 Û¤É dí56ÀÁ23B2356äÝ
$v23Êå56Ê÷ 56322 3 u
30
23
*vзðÌÛ\9ÍÎ56£ W56¶A2Ü P Ë1
Ý
t5623 ,-23r,-P ?÷!jÐ ,-23!2356v]23vÏ ½5623@kÑæ
ÍeÁÑ,-+23i$vÃ23¸¶1§ö+56N!R ,-23+,-!R 2356÷
WÍÒ*2356÷v¶,-232 Ût£?4,-j£ V923{|þv
,-}56
¶23¼ ,-23+XÓt uØv@ÂÃ
56@k!
ÈÔ P J
§231
1Ø,-}56
12356÷ u¹°B156N561}
1
@£ôæ32
1Øv ¤23i÷¹
T¬\£) *2356#23
!´ØÕ1æ× 56ï
*vD¶ð56
¹Ö¶×$v!²dß ¹!²ö2356v!jй
º
±²
,- _vÙ/0+23@, -¹M1Ú2356vtf+Á56,hêØ
wB1D
ÀÁ23S 9ydÛùܱ²
X² §Å2356Õ u)Ëفی نفسِ ٖہö¹´Ý23,-
9â32 â!
!?23ô
ÀÁ232356÷TçM23ý,-c|ÞX²
ß56
,-Í e56É91k|£¯ïP ¦£ù!w564 56
Íe
$,-
i112356v!,hê¹àáâ£V1k
9!,hê@
Æ 56
rfß2356,-56ã!æ
1h, / v9¤¹9
yͦ-, ´ôW $¹h, æ1väP56Bi9¤2356à
ô,-N2356æ23n+,-56ç
å@,-56ÓàØ23·9
é
1Øv?¯àP ÷Ò£·×= $;=<@b@êÍ ¦Öb
è@&
,-32 } 'NPMQQ5MLQ SNPOKNM% ëì,- 56rfß½2 ¾ ¿23562356,-½2 ¾ ¿ô
º q
@,h/ _îw92356,-+23sïÕ23562ÜÝ¥9í
23rfß
¸2356$vöC56B!
)56#
@2356#3
d 2 2356)*
Êd@ðñ¶56䥹2356òÊY¼¶@ô,-
@@k(ó,hê
31
¹¯µ23¤2356æ@Ã,-56!°
1P ¥Ñé.µò¶
$¶
q
' % _v,- u]65 ×£f,- £}S ;<
Ý
َت فِي ِه مِن رُّ وحِي َف َقعُوا َل ُه سَا ِجدِينُ َفإِ َذا سَوَّ ْي ُت ُه َو َن َف ْخMu2 Ûä u
$ õt
1 ¶¸µ@56,-£öt65 23´12356@÷yt+23sͦ ô
'%¸K ÷¿5623, -ä¥56,--, 23 u ;(<
Ý
,-23·@ø56t¬tr32 & ×µr,-r,-äÝ·Bù£ B23,-r23& / 01¸ b +eä í;0<
b$v¨
l è @ú ,-N ;=<
' % @êͦÖd~rs
32
ensure that ┘m┐n is not just a verbal affirmation (q┐l) on a person’s lips,
but that it grows into a genuine conviction that defines the very state
of one’s being (╒┐l).
In its essence, religious faith involves an inner state of confidence in
certain metaphysical realities. To develop such faith, one must have
the ability to experience a much higher level of certitude in
transcendent truths than the certitude one experiences in the facts
revealed by ordinary sense perception. One must have the ability to
invest a far greater amount of trust in realities that are knowable only
through one’s heart, as compared to realities knowable through one’s
physical eyes or ears. This means that a capacity for ┘m┐n bil-ghayb or
“faith in the unseen” is the foremost condition of this path. The
flowering of genuine religious faith in a person’s heart is necessarily
accompanied by a radical change in thinking and a profound
revolution in viewpoint.
As a result of the inner transformation that faith brings, a person
comes to see the material universe as entirely insignificant and even
unreal; while, in sharp contrast, the presence of God is experienced as
a living and eternal reality. For a person of faith, the empirical world is
neither a self-governing chain of cause and effect nor is it under the
determining control of rigid mechanical laws; instead, faith allows the
witnessing of God’s will and purpose in each and every moment. The
world of matter becomes worthless and inconsequential, but the spirit
appears as an almost tangible reality. As faith grows, a person no
longer attributes the term ins┐n (human being) primarily to the
physical body, but applies it in the first place to the divine spirit that is
the real essence of humankind—the same divine spirit whose presence
made Adam worthy of the angels’ prostration. For a person of faith,
the life of this-world appears not only transient and ephemeral, but
also utterly unreal and trifling; one comes to realize that in
comparison to the fleeting life of this-world, only the life hereafter is
ultimately real, worthwhile, and everlasting. The goal of pleasing God
becomes infinitely more valuable than the entire world and all of its
treasures. In accordance with a saying of Prophet Mu╒ammad (╗), a
person of faith assigns no more value to the totality of worldly riches
than the worth of a gnat’s wing.
33
Let it be clearly understood that unless a significant and influential
portion of the Muslim ummah undergoes this kind of profound
transformation in its thinking and viewpoint, the hope of an Islamic
revival will not be realized.
The most effective means for cultivating faith in the hearts of the
Muslim masses involves the fellowship of persons who are
significantly advanced in religious knowledge and practice. These are
the individuals whose hearts and minds are radiant with the light of
gnosis and faith; whose souls are free of conceit, jealousy, rancor, and
hypocrisy; whose lives are devoid of greed, covetousness, and the love
of this-world. In the aftermath of the collapse of khil┐fah ‘al┐ minh┐j
al-nubuwwah, it was mainly through the instruction, exhortation, and
fellowship of pious souls who embodied these qualities that the light
of ┘m┐n continued to spread and illuminate the world. More recently,
the poisonous winds of Western disbelief and materialism have had a
chilling effect on this dimension of Islamic culture as well; yet, such
personalities are not completely extinct in the Muslim ummah whose
hearts are luminous with the light of faith and whose passions are
ablaze with the warmth of conviction. What is needed in the present
moment is a powerful wave that sweeps through every part of the
ummah, so that no city or town is left without such resolute and
steadfast individuals whose sole aim in life is to please God, and whose
hearts are free of all desires and ambitions other than the noblest aim
of bringing divine guidance to humanity.
Fortunately, a mass movement has already emerged in the Indian
Subcontinent, under the influence of which the radiance of religious
faith is disseminating among the multitudes on a large scale. The
Jam┐‘at-e Tabl┘gh, which is an off-shoot of the movement associated
with the D┐r al-‘Ul┴m at Deoband, is raising the awareness among the
Muslim masses that God, the spirit, and the life hereafter are infinitely
more important than the physical universe, the material body, and the
life of this-world. The movement of the Jam┐‘at-e Tabl┘gh was
initiated by persons of such deep faith and conviction that, despite the
passing of more than a third of a century, there has been no
diminishment in the movement’s fervor and zeal. Though we do not
completely agree with its approach and methodology, it remains an
observable fact that the influence of the Jam┐‘at-e Tabl┘gh leads to a
34
profound transformation in people’s thinking and viewpoint. As a
result of this transformation, individuals begin to experience that
reality is an attribute of the Creator and not that of the creation, that
the One who controls all the causes is incomparably more real than all
the finite causes put together. They realize that it is not food that
overcomes their hunger, nor is it water that quenches their thirst, but
that such finite causes become efficacious only through the will and
permission of God. They begin to see even the minor injunctions of
Islam as having intrinsic value, without needing to be convinced
through logical arguments that such injunctions are parts of a larger
code of life or the means for establishing an ideological program. The
smallest details of the Prophetic sunnah begin to appear luminous, for
no other reason except their association with their beloved Prophet
Mu╒ammad (╗). Thus transformed in their inner lives, people who
come under the influence of the Jam┐‘at-e Tabl┘gh frequently limit
their material consumption to a bare minimum and spend a significant
part of their time in religious propagation and preaching by following
a typical method and routine.
Despite its achievements, the actual effectiveness of the Jam┐‘at-e
Tabl┘gh is destined to remain limited; the main reason being that this
movement primarily addresses the sentiments rather than the intellect,
and that it is founded upon religious practice and rituals as opposed to
knowledge and understanding. Consequently, those sections of society
are not likely to come under the influence of the Jam┐‘at-e Tabl┘gh in
which intellect takes precedence over feelings and knowledge is
privileged over practice. Such individuals are compelled, by virtue of
their temperament, to first traverse the realm of reason and critical
inquiry before they can whole-heartedly step into the domain of love
and passion. Their natural constitution is such that they cannot reach
the deeper levels of the spirit without having untangled the knots of
their analytical and inquisitive minds. It is an established fact that
individuals of this temperament, taken as a whole, constitute the
intellectual minority of a society. All over the world, and in every
historical period, it is this minority that quite naturally comes to play
a leadership role in setting the direction and priorities of society. As a
result, paramount importance must be given to bringing about a
revolutionary transformation in the thinking and viewpoint of those
35
who belong to this intellectual minority. If ┘m┐n could not be kindled
in the hearts of such individuals, and if they could not be rescued from
the darkness of spiritual ignorance, then changing the hearts and
minds of the masses alone will not bring about any substantial and
lasting transformation.
$l
û
ü}ý\£VÍÎ,-2ÜÝ32 £Øv×!2356{§äÛ56Y2ÜÝy
¹2356 ÷r,-2ÜÝ!d
)56#
.úì-,
rfß!þ
7,-56w9,hê2356c uñ½562356@k@56½2 34Á
,-v56äÝ,-P ?
,-P ?56,-v2356!vP E
!,-_T9$r,-?d?ä¥56,-
kØJ23n56·×]Ù$vݬ1ö
2356232Ü Ýß
w9
Ð23·´£M
ý +23s2356 23".¥2356,- ,-}~
23
û
,-+23sö¹23
í£ h, / v
×v2356
Â×ØvF$׸2356$=uý
¦
Í ,-!
ö
1Øv?,h,-vw£·
Ñ
$vé,-$
23
=1B@ý}ýÍ Ñ¦,2356ì-, WÌÍÎ
£V)
.56232356!!°
÷,-}~923{+m1Ú,hÙ£i
î@56í¬1?Øc u),-}~1§×23Á4,-B÷@
1 56Øc¶,hÙ,-n23,-561?2356÷v¯56r9
Æ'5LKK%2356
ç u5623 u 2356@23rBß56@ïÁ23
2 .
$:¶3
36
q
=+2356{
12356= Ü2 ݶ23
56t £t u@
jd56B@ý}ýW
P
¥
÷!Ú Ñ 2356?÷231$YýP23+23s#M
56Ø
¸%@@@)#5623ü2356ý
@!56232356÷ !Åê÷!
1
M
#$ 'À¼·!?ç+2356{!b ѽ2356!N923{
)¶+N u
12356Mê ujë56 56Ø=+2356{
@Ù
ý!2356rP
º
n23,-+dK?23561?ýP"@ u2 Ûsh, 2356
$Y ú*
#1÷c¶n569@½5623@ u 2 ÛØë¸=
!°
@23ý
1֍2356 u !
56!° !m m´¹
r23
E?56?K56È¥ u ÷:¶23p@Ã,-
e2356÷c¶F¹!}$%@ô+,-.ô
'2356C1»
@ n.
@& @&56@
@'
_v@k7µ÷c¶ð
c|
À2356 uê56,-i÷=b رسوخ فی العلمb@@]=
َ (=÷شخص ّيتيں إِ َّن َما َي ْخ َشى9)*56/ +â
; <
مِنْ عِ َبا ِد ِه ْال ُع َل َما ُء
1 $ ;(<À@Qo b@ u2 Ûv?v u)+23wb 2356+,
:f56@ýw$v@k¬56,-*vb?ib]23,- b-b@ u2 ÛØ
Ú.56´@HI
1v[äݸ,-c|ö
Û ÞtÎ
@4
@ u2 ö
Mk1Øv×?2356 g vb@5I b ;0<
Þ1
/1#(!0}v2á23]$v23.$#5623ü9:f56@ýw ,-
$;=< تعلمنا االيمان ثم تعلمنا القرآنØ@4
37
@é.
1¥56
@P±56²³12356æ
#56y
!"
÷K
"@ u2 Û}@!2t¨@3@
b? r b }v>
@£ô
2£
6E
t u 56Ø=4
] @$@5623!23¸!5! u
7cÑÒ
9fi2356p b ردb ý¬
;O<
239b
t u2356p8 bتہافتb
;H<
,-@4X56,-}Y,-µt23ß !Î1
w9 ,-P ?56,-v
êc:BM
u
$vÃ23¶
÷23Ø=·b;bÒ# i,h,hê¹Ù
²2ÜÞ 1
¥
;\<v£t un23,-@)
!2356÷!rR÷!<÷!Õ
S
\]T¹÷v@k;#!OD/jM,-=?1}2356
bAP K>J?t u$n¶û@9I44
!K
:f}v)Dê 561Sû}
b,h,hêBC
·FÍÎ23 2ÜÝb!Kb ¯ôfi}2356%v,-E56Á2356@ýw56
º
2356¹#+Ü2 ÝB×AP K23
~4§ 'v¹
º
2356Ü2 Ý@ uiggØvb ØS?2!G,-
!HAP K,-Ø
F@ö 56K
@c@4!d}!H)32 ÷I232#
ë
ú*+J,-23 u£L23
#M
§Øv×k2!23i$@½2 ¾ ¿½!d
q
¦
@ïÁ23´
1ôMÍ2356N23+23¶9e5I R¸ b$ L L L 23K Ü2 ݶ
c
æh
AP K,-Ø1O¶23nv w2356P56,-ß56
$û¹Q
RMd}´B@)1·
d5623S5623n¥56@ )1£Í¦
ì,-
rf ßØ)׶¹£ í,-vw£
fß
©23,-!¬=n¶ûT23é;Æù !þ
ùB!þ
$vU23
38
q
@6¥ 5 â
+,-!R Øvק¬56,-
b,h,hêB C!K
b
n56vïP V 56vP EB2356äÝ!
156!fß2356@ýw56ÍÎ8
Ò
Öû
W1XYØvl¶ûkØ1$c¶û
االخوان المسلمون2356TÍ eÁÖ Ä÷vW¶56WA2ÜP Ý2356V
+Ü2 568B bعدالة االجتماعيه فی االسالمb2356b!RS Tb
Í[,-2356÷v¶,-232 Û¨£>Br231§$vy~
Ý@~â!Z23
£23567£2356,-23?[9[
}v+,-Ò·ö71£íî1v#
\Ê},-
ÁUØvª«t¨!×1$S23nvwÖ,-c|
B23,-
^k£!Z56!_@£ô b ,-23]âzb ë,d~
B,-÷vS2356{µ`ß@£ôªÍ¦562 !wk|£
ñ5623a,-, û ÖÄ,-t u$v¹4ÍÒ,hê23¤2356;
cPѬÒ56cP ¥
@£ôñ5623bw¯àP ÷Ò 56عäÛ561
@£ô
,-23d2356+23
56c¶û·}Øv3d 2 ,h/ $p!zäݶ
$v23)
ë
!N2356eF!fß56TU
,- ,-}~é£Øv½2 ¾ ¿½·
1
ÍP56@ u2 Ûé+¬56,-2356v+2356{iÍÎ23 2ÜÝ!f23,h,hê@ý)â
äP Û,-@gýé@ý56,-@ØÊ!23¸×£Í¦2356÷vT3d 2 ÍÎ23àá+P
$vh¯µ78+23
c¶ûÙ
)
Ý
b_vD@ô,-
]@56?i
1 Í Ñ¦1b M u2 Ûä u ;<
C~ Ø ç¹ B 32 23 × ;(<
% @ u2 Ûv?v u)+23w
'
; ﻣﺎ ﹺﺯ ﻗﺮﺁﻥ ﻣﻐﺰ ﻫﺎ ﺑﺮﺩﺍﺷﺘﻴﻢ0<
'T5623% ﺶ ﺳﮕﺎﻥ ﺍﻧﺪﺍﺧﺘﻴﻢ ﺍﺳﺘﺨﻮﺍﻥ ﭘﻴ ﹺ
b$@ u2 Û=2356i@ķb ô ;=<
39
j k? ÷; تھافة الفالسفهH<
jl(?÷على المنطقيين ٰ ; الرّدO<
vö +,-.B23f56È2 !m?
b!)b2356bb1Øv32 n 56 ;\<
40
veiled reality should be so intense as to create a burning desire for
dedicating their lives to this end—disregarding in the process all the
worldly ambitions of status, comfort, and attractive careers.
These young inquirers will have to review the entire range of human
thought, which will involve a thorough and penetrating study of
intellectual history from its earliest stages to the present day. In this
regard, the main arenas for their research and reflection will include
the disciplines of logic, metaphysics, psychology, ethics, and theology.
In addition, they will complement their main inquiry by giving due
attention to what is indispensable in the social and physical sciences.
Along with this deep and critical examination of human thought, they
will undertake a focused and thoughtful study of the Holy Qur’┐n—
the last and most comprehensive of divine revelations—with the aim of
discovering for themselves the true nature of reality.
And if, after a laborious study of human thought and revealed
guidance, the radiance of the Qur’┐n comes to illuminate their hearts,
if its message sounds like the voice of their own souls, if their
innermost beings resonate with its teachings, if they find compelling
answers to all of their fundamental questions about the nature of
reality, and if, in the ecstasy of this enlightenment, they experience a
profound inner satisfaction and fulfillment—then they will know that
they are tasting the sweetness of ┘m┐n.
Only such individuals will be capable of acquiring rus┴kh f┘l ‘ilm, i.e.,
a firm and authentic grounding in the knowledge of reality (cf., └l-
‘Imr┐n 3:7). Instead of moral waywardness and intellectual caprice,
their knowledge will lead them to ever greater piety and fear of divine
judgment. Their personalities will bear witness to the Qur’┐nic ┐yah:
“. . . verily, those who fear God from among His servants are the ones
who possess abundant knowledge . . .” (Al-F┐═ir 35:28). Their
characters will be such that instead of being mere readers of the
Qur’┐n, they will become the living embodiments of divine revelation.
This is so because the essence and core of the Qur’┐n is precisely this
“knowing” of reality which is otherwise called ┘m┐n. While the laws
and practical injunctions of the Qur’┐n—collectively known as the
Shar┘‘ah—are definitely of great importance when considered in their
own right, they are of much less significance when judged against the
41
immense value of ┘m┐n. The ╗┴f┘ poet R┴m┘ has even used the
metaphor of “marrow” to emphasize the primacy of faith, while
referring to the debates and controversies surrounding the law as mere
“bones.” The truth of the matter is that any intellectual inquiry into
the laws and practical injunctions of the Qur’┐n is completely futile so
long as such activity is not preceded and accompanied by the
cultivation of a deep and authentic religious faith. It is this subtle point
that has been very aptly conveyed in the following statement by ‘Abd-
All┐h bin ‘Abb┐s (R): “We acquired ┘m┐n first, and learned the Qur’┐n
later.”
A convincing refutation of Western thought and a demolishing
critique of Western culture can only be produced by individuals who
have thoroughly imbued the refreshing knowledge of reality that
flows from the Holy Qur’┐n. Only such individuals will find it
possible to write a new “incoherence” in response to today’s
philosophers and mount a crushing “refutation” upon the claims of
today’s logicians.1 It will be the efforts of these individuals alone that
will finally check the flood of disbelief and materialism—the same
flood whose momentum has been carrying the human mind for the
last two hundred years.
Besides this negative work of demolition, they will have to undertake
the positive task of laying down the foundations for a new
philosophical theology of Islam, otherwise known as kal┐m. The aim
of the latter enterprise is to allow the facts that have been discovered
so far in the domains of mathematics, physics, cosmology, biology,
and psychology to occupy their proper places within the framework
of Isl┐mic beliefs.2 After all, these facts are nothing other than partial
details of the same Reality whose fullest manifestation is found in the
“knowing” that we call ┘m┐n.
About thirty-five or forty years ago, Mu╒ammad Iqb┐l initiated this
task through his work The Reconstruction of Religious Thought in Islam.
A portion of this work dealing with religious law and the issues of
ijm┐‘ and ijtih┐d is rather controversial; but that discussion is not
directly related to the main topic of the book. Concerning the
reconstruction of the philosophical theology of Islam, Iqb┐l’s work is
very important and thought-provoking. He himself observed in the
42
preface: “As knowledge advances and fresh avenues of thought are
opened, other views and probably sounder views than those set forth
in these lectures, are possible. Our duty is to watch carefully the
progress of human thought and to maintain an independent critical
attitude towards it.” Had other scholars pursued this task by
continuing to reflect along the lines suggested by Iqb┐l, and had only a
few steadfast individuals devoted their lives for this purpose, a great
deal of valuable and substantial work would have been produced. It is
regretful that not even a single individual from Iqb┐l’s own circle of
influence chose to enter this arena. In any case, unless a considerable
amount of truly high quality work is accomplished in the field of
philosophical theology, the hope of attracting the intelligentsia
towards religion will be nothing more than a mirage.
After the “reconstruction of religious thought in Islam,” the second
most important task is to elaborate in a cogent and coherent manner
the practical guidance of Islam concerning the various spheres of
human life, such as politics, jurisprudence, culture, and economics. As
mentioned earlier, a substantial amount of work has been
accomplished in this field during the last fifty or sixty years,
particularly in Egypt and the Indian Subcontinent. The Jam┐‘at-e
Isl┐m┘ and al-Ikhw┐n al-Muslim┴n have given particular attention to
themes like the “Islamic way of life” and “social justice in Islam.”
However, all of this work can be described only as a useful beginning
or merely as an initial step in the right direction. More recently, the
tendency of mindlessly repeating the same ideas—and publishing them
under different titles—has diluted the significance of even that earlier
effort, which was quite valuable in itself. The enterprise of publishing
unoriginal works by amateur authors and self-proclaimed scholars, and
selling them within a niche market, may bring economic benefit to a
few but does not accomplish any positive and lasting service to Islam.
In today’s world, persons of high intellectual caliber do not have the
leisure to study the writings of unqualified authors, i.e., those who
lack the appropriate academic training and the relevant credentials. It
is imperative, therefore, that a high academic standard is maintained in
whatever intellectual work is brought out, and that quality—as
opposed to quantity—is given maximum attention.
43
To engage in this kind of work, it is obviously essential to have an
accurate understanding of the affairs and problems of the
contemporary world, as well as first-hand knowledge of the latest
trends and developments in the various fields of social sciences. Side by
side with this modern knowledge, one must have deep familiarity with
the primary sources of Islam, i.e., the Qur’┐n and the Sunnah. It is
futile to expect high quality results without the application of the same
degree of meticulous attention and analytical rigor to both sides of the
equation.
!?no $m
2 Y56,-923{+23
n
£Vd o
$T3d
,2356@k
t ,h iBѵé£}w 23,-ë£É56!Ñ,-T¬Ø×£
Õo56ê2356+#56-, @@©äݶ1ô}2356r,-!Ñ,-p
2356k5IJê}rn569@£ô@ö1]Ù2356 ;<rq56?
1@}ýì-, Wé+¬56,-235656322 3 u
Ù
+,-23,-
äÝ,-P ?r2356,-
t u$@23rBß56@ïÁ23
) }r
vï
`1߯ôfiµÍ2356vÚP J
9@Ã,-56!°w9,-2356
=÷DzO,-23B9S
7@Oµ2356a,+23´B@£ô½2 3YØ
sBÀÁ2323
91vs123-, }Øvï×@f23;rfß
×?$v u )ݽ2 ¾ ¿`t@ý}ý
1÷vD¶23º,-
5IY-, ôÂÃÍ ¦Ö56v͸2356¹¿@5623u,-Øv
44
@+,û2356ì-, îrfß71
wµÈxy1Ù
َخي ُر ُکم َمن َتعلَّ َمØB¶23ÆÞ 1
§Å}@:¶FW@}ýÄ?
$Y,-ß56ÀÁ23
Íe56@ u2 Ûjiy¤Éd- ;(< رآن وعلَّ َم ُه
َ ال ُق
@
G
56£,hêØvD1é.!2356{Øv23n56·×
56¯~ô2356vzð,-23,-×=÷c¶23^,-£923{{,-
!2356{12356;B1Øv1!2356{h, / $vz|,-!#YÒ
ñ56
}~2356û1ع©56B=c¶û¸¶ßB1§
$pÊ!,-
56T¬M u2 Û5 IJKé£}
c¶d¤ÅT@ u2 Û£Ø×r¬56,-
+¬56,-235623 u 9@£ô>12356;23ý@ u2 ÛØrq56?Íe
@2356 · ,h,hê5 IJKäÛ56}rÕ56¹@ý}ýWé
23 23
@~d oØ@ = uÍÎ23 2ÜÝ·
56i
@ u2 Û2356
$n
"@ u2 Û!µ@£ô;Ø=×!§Íe56T¬M u2 Û5 IJK
÷ÀY¼¶1@ô,-÷=w>19@ð,-÷À@23Bé
@}ýñ5623a,û2356ì,-îÒ$=ð!z;£äݶ12356
@ý}ýW,-ø÷& ¨£@ع©56B2356@@é231·
56i
1BÀÁ23+23sØ:¶ = u©23,-1S5623n1}c uqÊ
T1Õ56¹@ý}ýW$Y,-ß56
Íe562356
@Ø£@c¶+,-¹z9@56,-.B@Ø=+2356{
12356=
dd"@ u2 Û23s¹=$c¶ðÈ56-, !,-
12356eP@ 23
Ý
}@=$c¶+,-¹¸ 2356÷÷+eä í]Ù2356c¶Âz
Û
½5623"@ u2 56Ø=4
@@@ñ5623È56,-!K56yô
â
!N}2356÷æ23,-.#¥i,h,hê2356YJE9!f23Ê,h,hê
45
@â
ÀÁ23 56Ø=4
@@@ñ5623È56,-@
$p9ûBäÝ5623
$ï u¤ÅbT*
bl \Ht
XI@Ø1 ;<
Ý
b_2356@ u2 Û} 56ô¨;b +eä í;(<
47
The primary function of the proposed academy would be the
education and guidance of such individuals. To execute this function,
Arabic language will be taught on sound foundations, with the aim of
developing in the students a deep appreciation for the language as well
as a refined taste in classical literature. They will then go over the
entire text of the Qur’┐n in a formal academic setting, while also
undertaking the study of ╓ad┘th, Fiqh, and U╖┴l al-Fiqh.
Subsequently, those with an aptitude for philosophy and theology will
be able to offer a cogent critique of modern philosophical trends in the
light of the Holy Qur’┐n, as well as to lay down the foundations for a
modern philosophical theology or kal┐m. Those inclined towards the
various fields of social sciences will be able to present the guidance of
Islam concerning the different spheres of human life at the highest
intellectual level.
1. With the grace of All┐h, Tan╘┘m-e Isl┐m┘ came into being in 1975 to
achieve these aims.
48