Documentos de Académico
Documentos de Profesional
Documentos de Cultura
reticuloperitonitis are
non-specific and often
vague
In Practice: first published as 10.1136/inpract.30.10.544 on 1 November 2008. Downloaded from http://inpractice.bmj.com/ on 21 January 2019 by guest. Protected by copyright.
Clinical management of traumatic
reticuloperitonitis in cattle
PETER ORPIN AND DAVID HARWOOD
TRAUMATIC reticuloperitonitis, colloquially referred to as ‘hardware’ or, more recently, ‘tyre wire’
disease, has become increasingly common and is particularly challenging to manage because the
clinical presentation is often vague. This article discusses the diagnosis and treatment of the condition,
and considers the changing clinicopathological pattern of the disease, including penetration of the
rumen wall by migrating metallic fragments. It also suggests some preventive measures that may
be easily implemented on-farm.
Peter Orpin
graduated from 7·0
Bristol in 1983.
AETIOLOGY AND INCIDENCE
He is a partner in 6·0
a 23-vet practice
in Leicestershire
Traumatic reticuloperitonitis (TRP) is caused by frag- 5·0
ments of metal inadvertently eaten by cattle, which
Percentage
where he is primarily
involved in dairy work then progress into the reticulum and may penetrate the 4·0
and management.
He is also a veterinary rumenoreticular wall and migrate through the surround- 3·0
business consultant ing areas of the abdomen and thorax, thus producing
for Anval, a tutor 2·0
for the British clinical signs of local peritonitis/pericarditis. In recent
Cattle Veterinary years, radial steel wire from disintegrating tyres on 1·0
Association’s (BCVA’s)
herd health planning
silage clamps has been incriminated most frequently, but 0
courses, director other metallic fragments such as nails, bits of fencing or 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008*
of a herd health Percentage of diagnoses of traumatic reticuloperitonitis
other wire and metal shards have all been implicated. in adult cattle carcases submitted to the VLA. *January
planning website and
a special lecturer in Data from the Veterinary Laboratories Agency (VLA) to May inclusive
cattle medicine at suggest that the incidence of tyre wire disease has been
Nottingham. He is a
past-president of the increasing steadily since the early 1990s. VLA surveil- Starcross and Penrith) reported considerably fewer cases,
BCVA. lance data for England and Wales for 2004 to 2008 show the reason for which remains unclear. A total of 86 per
that each of the VLA’s regional laboratories reported cent of all recorded cases occurred in dairy cows and
at least one confirmed case of TRP during this period. 6 per cent in suckler cows (the remaining cases involved
There was, however, marked geographical variation, with either fattening cattle or the class was not recorded).
a particularly high incidence in the Langford and Thirsk Herd outbreaks of significant mortality and mor-
catchment areas. Conversely, other cattle-dense areas (eg, bidity are not uncommon. Monies (2004) described a
Cornish incident in which, over
DIAGNOSES OF TRAUMATIC RETICULOPERITONITIS FROM 2004 TO 2008 a six-month period, approxi-
David Harwood Total adult (>2 years Total TRP Percentage of adult carcase mately 30 per cent of a herd of
graduated from Year old) carcase submissions diagnoses made submissions with diagnosis of TRP 170 cows were affected. Eleven
London in 1974 and
worked in mixed, 2004 458 19 4·1% cows were subjected to postmor-
mainly farm animal,
2005 505 28 5·5%
tem examination, all of which
practice. He works
showed lesions consistent with
at the Winchester 2006 695 40 5·8%
Regional Laboratory tyre wire perforation and peri-
of the Veterinary 2007 674 41 6·1% tonitis. By extrapolating these
Laboratories Agency
(VLA). He is a 2008* 377 13 3·4% figures, it was suggested that the
member of the VLA problem was likely to be wide-
Total 2709 141 5·2%
Cattle Group and
a past-president spread in the affected herd.
From VIDA data. *January to May inclusive. TRP Traumatic reticuloperitonitis
of the BCVA. TRP may be under- or misdi-
In Practice: first published as 10.1136/inpract.30.10.544 on 1 November 2008. Downloaded from http://inpractice.bmj.com/ on 21 January 2019 by guest. Protected by copyright.
the initial stages may potentially mask its early develop-
ment, making clinical recognition more difficult.
Clinical signs depend on the organ penetrated by the for- CHRONIC LOCAL PERITONITIS
eign body and the resulting sequelae, but are often very If the acute condition progresses or recrudesces after a
vague and easily overlooked. In the early stages, many period of initial resolution, chronic peritonitis develops
cases present with ill-defined pyrexia of unknown origin. with localised adhesions. Signs of chronic local perito-
When a carcase is submitted to the VLA, the clini- nitis include:
cal signs described by the veterinary surgeon (or owner) ■ Disappointing milk yield;
are recorded. An analysis of these signs in the 141 cases ■ Loss of body condition;
referred to in the table and graph on page 544 is given in ■ Arched back, tense abdomen, smaller rumen, reduced
the table on the right and confirms the wide variation in rumen motility;
presenting signs that a practitioner may be faced with in
confirmed cases of TRP.
PRESENTING CLINICAL SIGNS IN 141 CASES SUBMITTED TO THE VLA
There are initially four potential outcomes of
perforation: Main clinical sign described Number of animals Percentage of total
before death/euthanasia showing the clinical sign showing the clinical sign
■ Acute peritonitis;
■ Chronic local peritonitis; Found dead 38 26·95%
Rupture of
In Practice: first published as 10.1136/inpract.30.10.544 on 1 November 2008. Downloaded from http://inpractice.bmj.com/ on 21 January 2019 by guest. Protected by copyright.
Perforation
gastroepiploic artery
Chronic
pericarditis Cardiac
Vagus
tamponade
indigestion
Culling due to
poor health
DIFFUSE PERITONITIS
In rare cases, a generalised severe peritonitis may develop.
This typically occurs in recently calved animals (possibly
due to the physical expulsive efforts of calving breaking
down localised peritoneal adhesions), which may have
presented previously with signs of either acute or chronic
In Practice: first published as 10.1136/inpract.30.10.544 on 1 November 2008. Downloaded from http://inpractice.bmj.com/ on 21 January 2019 by guest. Protected by copyright.
heart itself, which can lead to massive haemorrhage into diagnosis and treatment is extremely challenging. The
the pericardial sac and cardiac tamponade. Death may most consistent findings are:
also occur due to sudden cardiac failure caused by over- ■ History of abrupt and sudden milk drop over a
whelming pathology such as pericarditis or myocarditis. 24-hour period with no other identifiable cause;
An increase in unexplained deaths such as this should ■ Reduced ruminal movements, rumen size and appe-
always be investigated. tite, typically with changes in faecal consistency (firmer,
porridge-like faeces or more undigested particles);
■ Reluctance to repeatedly allow the back to be hyper-
DIAGNOSTIC APPROACH extended as part of the withers pinch test. The abdomen
may be guarded and repeated pinching of the withers
Examination of the bovine abdomen, based on cow- may produce a pain response, which manifests as exces-
side and laboratory tests, is described by Cockcroft and sive salivation;
Jackson (2004). ■ Elicitation of a grunt following the bar test. This
involves placing a bar under the xiphisternum with two
COW-SIDE TESTS operators on either side of the animal who first lift the
Examination of adult cows in modern farm practice can bar slowly and then lower it rapidly. This should be per-
often be difficult. Typically, cows may be presented as formed at least four times;
part of a herd examination and the facilities and ambient ■ Muffled heart sounds on cardiac examination, which
noise (eg, vacuum pumps) can make diagnosis difficult. are suggestive of traumatic pericarditis. In one study,
The animal is seldom in an isolated examination box muffled heart sounds were recorded in 20 of 28 con-
and is often kept back for examination within a group of firmed cases of traumatic pericarditis (Braun and others
cows. A systematic examination should always be car- 2007) and it was suggested that a heart rate of over 80
ried out, preferably with a well-restrained cow in a quiet bpm could be considered significant in the diagnosis of
environment. pericarditis;
By employing a systematic approach to examination, ■ Distension of the jugular veins. In a standing cow,
a veterinary surgeon presented with an animal early with its head held in the normal position, the pulse should
in the acute phase within 24 to 48 hours of the initial be visible in the lower third of the neck only with no dis-
signs occurring and before treatment should be able to tension cranially. In cases of chronic pericarditis with
Sudden death and cardiac tamponade in an animal, caused ‘Bread and butter’ heart due to
by a 10 cm length of tyre wire (arrow) that was extracted severe organising fibrinopurulent
following postmortem examination pericarditis. Picture, VLA
Wire (arrow) penetrating both the pericardial sac (causing Wire (arrow) embedded in the myocardium, which caused
pericarditis) and the myocardium. Picture, VLA local necrosis and abscess formation. Picture, VLA
In Practice: first published as 10.1136/inpract.30.10.544 on 1 November 2008. Downloaded from http://inpractice.bmj.com/ on 21 January 2019 by guest. Protected by copyright.
tests may increase the sensitivity of these tests. A
manual exploration of the outer surface of the reticulum
spontaneous grunt may be identified on rare occa-
and abdomen. If there is evidence of perforation, the sur-
sions to coincide with the reticulorumen contrac-
geon can simply proceed to rumenotomy to explore the
tions, an observation referred to as the Williams
contents of the reticulum;
test (Williams 1975).
■ ABDOMINAL PARACENTESIS. Analysis of the fluid
obtained may reveal evidence of peritonitis.
TYRE WIRE
The most common cause of traumatic reticulitis is frag-
ments of tyre wire. Tyres are commonly used to weigh
down silage sheets and are generally removed after they
show signs of disintegration. This retrospective removal
combined with the risk of tyres entering feeder wagons
(not an uncommon occurrence and a serious problem if
the feeder is fitted with knives) contributes to the con-
tamination of the feed.
Cramers and others (2005) examined the reticulum of
1491 slaughter cows in Denmark and found metallic for-
eign objects in 16 per cent of the animals. Although only
11 per cent of the metallic objects were tyre wire, 81 per
cent of these generated lesions in the reticulum. The over-
all incidence of foreign body lesions within the reticulum
(which included anything from internal reticular scars
to massive adhesions) was 10 per cent, five times higher
In Practice: first published as 10.1136/inpract.30.10.544 on 1 November 2008. Downloaded from http://inpractice.bmj.com/ on 21 January 2019 by guest. Protected by copyright.
within the reticulum. cal wound in a standard manner.
The surgical procedure is simple and involves a left ■ Administer pre- and postoperative antimicrobial
flank incision in the cranial aspect of the paralumbar treatment and NSAIDs for a minimum of five days.
fossa close behind the last rib. The challenge in large
cows is having sufficient reach to fully explore the retic-
ulum. This must be considered before embarking on the PREVENTIVE APPROACHES
procedure.
HIGH-RISK FARMS
Technique Veterinary surgeons dealing with untidy farms using
■ Make an incision in the cranial, mid/upper third part total mixed rations (especially feeders with knives) and/
of the paralumbar fossa. The objective of the incision or those with disintegrating tyres on the clamps, or any
is to ensure that the operator has maximum reach and farm with a history of suspected traumatic reticulitis,
that the risk of abdominal contamination is kept to a should:
minimum. ■ Administer a ruminal magnet to all cows and heifers
■ Manually inspect the exterior of the reticulum, which on the farm and all heifers entering the herd thereafter.
should reveal the likely site of penetration and whether This costs less than £2/magnet and will greatly help to
there is any peritonitis. In the absence of any signs reduce the incidence of the disease;
References and
of penetration, close the wound, as further surgical ■ Proactively remove all suspect tyres and ensure that further reading
exploration is not required. these are stored or disposed of correctly to prevent them ASHDOWN, R. R. & DONE,
S. (1996) Colour Atlas of
■ Before performing a rumenotomy, protect the lower being used again or inadvertently burned resulting in a Veterinary Anatomy. Vol 1:
part of the surgical wound with a sterile drape and, with large amount of lethal tyre wire in the ash; Ruminants. Edinburgh, Elsevier
BRAUN, U., GANSOHR, B.
the help of a surgical assistant, exteriorise and incise the ■ Discuss with farmers how best to manage the silage & FLUCKIGER, M. (2003)
rumen. The assistant should be tasked to keep the rumen face, stressing the importance of avoiding tyre wires Radiographic findings before
and after oral administration
exteriorised at all times. entering the clamp. This is particularly important where of a magnet in cows with
■ Suture the rumen wall to the skin or use a special- ‘shear grabs’ are being used because tractor operators traumatic reticuloperitonitis.
ist rumenotomy set (Weingart Rumenotomy Set; Kruuse are unable to see if a tyre is caught in the grab; American Journal of Veterinary
Research 64, 115-120
UK) to fix the rumen wall while a rumenotomy is ■ Review the feed types and straights fed to cows to BRAUN, U., ISELIN, U.,
performed. minimise the introduction of metallic objects; LISCHER, C. & FLURI, E. (1998)
Ultrasonographic findings
■ The procedure can usually be safely performed with- ■ Ensure that feeders and rotating tyre feed devices that in five cows before and
out resorting to extra surgical aids. Hold the cranial part push feed up are regularly inspected for decay; after treatment for reticular
abscesses. Veterinary Record
of the rumen with the left hand and introduce the right ■ Prevent cows from accessing any potentially contam- 142, 184-189
hand to explore the left side of the reticulum. An assistant inated bonfire ash. BRAUN, U., LEJEUNE, B.,
should be asked to hold the caudal aspect of the rumen. SCHWEIZER, G., PUORGER,
M. & EHRENSPERGER, F. (2007)
The positions are reversed to explore the right side of the LOWER RISK FARMS Clinical findings in 28 cattle
reticulum. In this way, abdominal contamination from In the case of extended grazing farms and tidy farms with traumatic pericarditis.
Veterinary Record 161, 558-563
rumen contents is avoided without prolonging the opera- with limited exposure to tyres, veterinary surgeons COCKCROFT, P. & JACKSON,
tion unduly. should: P. (2004) Clinical examination
of the abdomen in adult cattle.
■ Ensure farmers are aware of the risk factors; In Practice 26, 304-317
■ Focus on general farm husbandry to control disease. CRAMERS, T., MIKKELSEN,
K. B., ANDERSEN, P.,
ENEVOLDSEN, C. & JENSEN,
H. E. (2005) New types of
SUMMARY foreign bodies and the effect
of magnets in traumatic
reticulitis in cows. Veterinary
TRP caused by tyre wire may be underdiagnosed on Record 157, 287-289
DANIEL, R. & SMITH, G.
many farms. The risk of this disease has increased over (2008) Suspected bovine
the years, which, combined with less opportunity for reticuloperitonitis associated
with the metal components
veterinary surgeons to make diagnoses early in the dis- of a mixer wagon. Veterinary
ease process, can result in significant losses. A proactive Record 162, 563-564
HARWOOD, D. G. (2004)
approach, based on a sound risk assessment, detailed
Alimentary tract perforation
culling reviews, and clinical and postmortem examin- in cattle caused by tyre wire.
ations, will often reveal the underlying problem within Veterinary Record 154, 574-575
HATELEY, G. (2007) Traumatic
a herd. reticuloperitonitis in cows.
Veterinary Record 160, 882
Acknowledgements McNAMARA, S. & BAKER,
The authors would like to thank Iain Piggot, Tracy Bainbridge, I. (2007) Traumatic
Jon Huxley, Eamon Watson and colleagues at the VLA for their reticuloperitonitis in cows.
assistance in preparing this article. VLA input was undertaken Veterinary Record 160,
as part of the scanning surveillance work funded by DEFRA’s 882-883
Food and Farming Group. MONIES, B. (2004) Alimentary
tract perforation in cattle
caused by tyre wire. Veterinary
A Weingart Rumenotomy Set (Kruuse UK) can be used Further information Record 154, 735
to exteriorise and fix the rumen when performing a ■ Used Tyre Working Group data. www.tyredisposal.co.uk/cms/ WILLIAMS, E. I. (1975) The
rumenotomy in order to avoid contamination of the index.php ‘reticular grunt’ test for
peritoneal cavity by spillage of the rumen contents. ■ My Healthy Herd website. www.myhealthyherd.com traumatic reticulo-peritonitis.
Reproduced from Cockcroft and Jackson (2004) ■ Veterinary Laboratories Agency. www.defra.gov.uk/vla Bovine Practitioner 12, 40-47