0 calificaciones0% encontró este documento útil (0 votos)
30 vistas4 páginas
A letter to the editor suggests that residents of Clearview should vote for an environmentalist. Julian zelizer says the letter assumes that as a member of the good earth coalition, she will take care of environmental problems. Zelizer: No evidence has been provided on how Ann Green typifies a responsible member. He says the argument is questionable in the sense that Ann Green will be the sole effort to solve pollution problems.
A letter to the editor suggests that residents of Clearview should vote for an environmentalist. Julian zelizer says the letter assumes that as a member of the good earth coalition, she will take care of environmental problems. Zelizer: No evidence has been provided on how Ann Green typifies a responsible member. He says the argument is questionable in the sense that Ann Green will be the sole effort to solve pollution problems.
Copyright:
Attribution Non-Commercial (BY-NC)
Formatos disponibles
Descargue como DOC, PDF, TXT o lea en línea desde Scribd
A letter to the editor suggests that residents of Clearview should vote for an environmentalist. Julian zelizer says the letter assumes that as a member of the good earth coalition, she will take care of environmental problems. Zelizer: No evidence has been provided on how Ann Green typifies a responsible member. He says the argument is questionable in the sense that Ann Green will be the sole effort to solve pollution problems.
Copyright:
Attribution Non-Commercial (BY-NC)
Formatos disponibles
Descargue como DOC, PDF, TXT o lea en línea desde Scribd
The following appeared in a letter to the editor of the Clearview
newspaper.
1. "In the next mayoral election, residents of Clearview should vote
for Ann Green, who is a member of the Good Earth Coalition, rather than for Frank Braun, a member of the Clearview town council, because the current members are not protecting our environment. For example, during the past year the number of factories in Clearview has doubled, air pollution levels have increased, and the local hospital has treated 25 percent more patients with respiratory illnesses. If we elect Ann Green, the environmental problems in Clearview will certainly be solved."
The author of this letter propose that Ann Green
should be voted, rather than Frank Braun, as the next mayor of Clearview, because she will help solve pollution problems in Clearview as a member of Good Earth Coalition. This recommendation for Ann Green depends on the assumption that as a member of the Good Earth Coalition, she will take care of the environmental problems. To justify that poor environmental conditions is attributable to Braun’s inability to solve those problems, tThe letter also cites the evidence supporting the poor environmental conditions of Clearview, including twice as many more factories built in Clearview, increased air pollution, and the uprising percentage of hospital patients with respiratory illnesses being treated. A closer scrutiny on the assumption and evidence of this letter suggest a lack of credibility.
First of all, this argument assumes that Ann Green's
membership in the Good Earth Coalition renders her the most qualified person to help improve the poor environmental conditions. No evidence has been provided on how Ann Green typifies a responsible member of Good Earth Coalition, for example, her previous role and contribution in tackling pollution. Without such evidence, it is likely that another member of Good Earth Coalition, other environmentalist, or even Frank Braun, are equally qualified as a potential leader to help reduce pollution in Clearview. Similarly, the mere fact the Frank Braun is a member of the Clearview town council does not indicate that he is not aware of pollution in Clearview and will not take action to protect the environment if he is elected as a mayor.
Second, the argument is questionable in the sense
that Ann Green will be the sole effort to solve pollution problems. After all, the effectiveness of environmental protection programs depends not only on the effort mayor, but also the collective force of the whole community in terms of factors likes the resident's awareness to the severity of pollution, and the compliance of factories to reduce emission of pollutants. Therefore, it is doubtful whether Ann Green, as the future mayor, will sufficiently guarantee that pollution problems be solved.
Third, the author falsely infers casual relationships
between increased number of factories in Clearview, hightened air pollution rate, and the 25- percent increase in the number of patients with respiratory illnesses treated by local hospital that the worsening environmental situation is accountable to the city-council’s decision. The city council might have taken considerable measures to oppose establishment of factory or emission of pollutants; but lacks the compliance of factory owners and automobiles drivers to allow improvements in environmental condition. Without clear information on how the council has viewed and issued any protective measures, one cannot conclude that the council has been indifferent or incapable to protect the environment. Nor The mere fact that the increased respiratory illnesses cases that has been treated in local hospitals indicate the worsening of environmental conditions. is discovered together with air pollution and establishment of local factories during last year does not indicate cause-and-effect among them. Other factors, like the awareness of the consequences of respiratory illnesses among local residents and the efficiency of medical services in local hospital, will as likely contribute to the increase in the number of local respiratory illnesses cases being treated. Thus, I remain unconvinced about the actual severity of environmental problems in Clearview.
As a conclusion, the argument is not sufficiently
supported by sound assumptions and clear evidence. Clearview's resident needs further evidence on the Ann Green's past contribution on solving environmental problems, information of other mayor candidates who is potential qualifies to lead environmental protection, and also clearer studies on the severity of pollution and the major cause of pollution-related health problems among Clearview residents.