Está en la página 1de 8

International Journal of Heat and Mass Transfer 44 (2001) 931±938

www.elsevier.com/locate/ijhmt

Enhancing heat transfer in parallel-plate channels by using


porous inserts
M.K. Alkam, M.A. Al-Nimr *, M.O. Hamdan
Mechanical Engineering Department, Jordan University of Science and Technology, P.O. Box 3030, Irbid 22110, Jordan
Received 7 December 1999; received in revised form 20 April 2000

Abstract
In the present work, transient forced convection in the developing region of parallel-plate ducts is numerically in-
vestigated. A high-thermal conductivity porous substrate is attached to the inner wall of one plate in order to enhance
the heat transfer characteristics of the ¯ow under consideration. The Darcy±Brinkman±Forchheimer model is used to
model the ¯ow inside the porous domain. The present study reports the e€ect of several operating parameters on the
¯ow hydrodynamics and thermal characteristics. Mainly, the current study demonstrates the e€ects of porous layer
thickness, Darcy number, thermal conductivity ratio, and microscopic inertial coecient on the thermal performance of
the present ¯ow. It is found that the highest Nusselt Number is achieved at fully porous duct. Results show that for
Darcy number less than 10ÿ4 , the e€ect of microscopic inertial coecient can be eliminated while for large microscopic
inertial coecient, higher than 103 , the e€ect of Darcy number is observed to be insigni®cant. Heat transfer can be
enhanced by: (1) using high thermal conductivity inserts, (2) decreasing Darcy number, and (3) increasing microscopic
inertial coecient. Also, the study shows that in the developing region, Darcy number and microscopic inertial coef-
®cient have higher e€ect on the thermal and hydrodynamic behavior of the ¯ow than that in the fully developed re-
gion. Ó 2001 Elsevier Science Ltd. All rights reserved.
Keywords: Enhancement; Forced convection; Porous media

1. Introduction tivity porous substrates are also used to enhance forced


convection heat transfer in many engineering applica-
The investigation of forced convection ¯ows in tions such as, nuclear cooling, heat exchangers, and
saturated porous media is required in many thermal- solar collectors, Alkam and Al-Nimr [3].
engineering applications. Several numerical and experi- Recently, heat transfer in channels partially ®lled
mental studies have been conducted in order to provide with porous media has received considerable attention
a deeper understanding of the transport mechanism of and was the focus of several investigations, Al-Nimr and
momentum and heat transfer in porous media. Porous Alkam [4], Chikh et al. [5], Vafai and Kim [6], and
media has a wide range of applications such as catalytic Poulikakos and Kazmierczak [7]. As previously men-
and inert packed bed reactors, enhancing drying e- tioned, the need for better understanding of heat
ciency such as food drying, ®ltering, geothermal energy transfer in porous media is motivated by the numerous
management and harvesting, insulation, lubrication, engineering applications encountered.
Kaviany [1], laser mirrors and powerful electronics, Ji- In general, most analytical studies of ¯uid ¯ow and
ang et al. [2], ground water and oil ¯ow, and enhancing heat transfer adopt DarcyÕs law. Carman [8] and Collins
oil and natural gas production. High thermal conduc- [9] have investigated the ¯uid ¯ow through porous ma-
terial using Darcy's law. In recent research conducted by
Al-Nimr and Alkam [10,11], there appears to be very
*
Corresponding author. Tel.: +962-2-295111; fax: +962-2- limited research on the problem of forced convection in
295123. composite ¯uid and porous layers. Beavers and Joseph
E-mail address: malnimr@just.edu.jo (M.A. Al-Nimr). [12] ®rst investigated the ¯uid mechanics at the interface

0017-9310/01/$ - see front matter Ó 2001 Elsevier Science Ltd. All rights reserved.
PII: S 0 0 1 7 - 9 3 1 0 ( 0 0 ) 0 0 1 5 5 - 1
932 M.K. Alkam et al. / International Journal of Heat and Mass Transfer 44 (2001) 931±938

Nomenclature u axial velocity


u0 inlet axial velocity
A microscopic pinertial or form drag coecient, U dimensionless volume averaged axial velocity,
…eF `†=…qR K † u`=m1
C speci®c heat U0 dimensionless inlet axial velocity, u0 `=m1
Da Darcy number, K=`2 v transverse velocity
e dimensionless porous substrate thickness, `1 =` V dimensionless transverse velocity, v`=m1
F Forchheimer coecient, 1:8=…180e5 †0:5 x dimensional axial coordinate
h convective heat transfer coecient X dimensionless axial coordinate, x=`
K permeability of the porous substrate Xd axial distance that is longer than hydrody-
k1 thermal conductivity of the ¯uid. namic entrance length.
k2 thermal conductivity of porous domain, y dimensional transverse coordinate
kf e ‡ ks …1 ÿ e† Y dimensionless transverse coordinate, y=`
kr thermal conductivity ratio, k2 /k1
` duct height Greek symbols
`1 porous substrate thickness q density
L dimensionless duct height, L ˆ 1 h dimensionless temperature, (T ) Ti )/(T0 ) Ti )
Nu local Nusselt number, 2h`=k2 hm dimensionless mixing cup temperature,
P dimensionless pressure, p`2 =q1 m21 (Tm ) Ti )/(T0 ) Ti )
p pressure s dimensionless time, tv=`2
Pr Prandtl number of the ¯uid, C1 l1 /k1 l dynamic viscosity
Q dimensionless accumulated heat transfer con- r heat capacity ratio, ‰qf Cpf e ‡ qs Cs …1 ÿ e†Š=
ducted from walls, eqf Cpf
Z Xd D increment in numerical mesh network space
kw oh
dX m kinematics viscosity
0 T w ÿ T 0 oY e porosity
T temperature at any point mR kinematics viscosity ratio, m2 /m1
Tm mixing cup temperatures over any cross-sec-
Subscripts
tion, MCT,
R l1 Rl 0 inlet properties
0
C2 q2 u2 T2 dy ‡ l1 C1 q1 u1 T1 dy 1 or f ¯uid domain properties
Tm ˆ 2 or p e€ective porous domain properties
q0 u0 `
R the ratio of a parameters in porous domain to
T0 initial temperature the same parameters in ¯uid domain
Tw temperature of the isothermal wall s solid matrix properties
t time w wall conditions

between a ¯uid layer and a porous medium over a ¯at the Darcy±Brinkman model, analytical solutions were
plate. Vafai and Thiyagaraja [13] obtained an analytical obtained by Chikh et al. [5] for the problem of forced
approximate solution for the same problem based on convection in an annular duct partially ®lled with a
matched asymptotic expansions for the velocity and porous medium. The same problem was investigated
temperature distributions. Later on, Vafai and Kim [14] numerically by the same group using the Darcy±Brink-
presented an exact solution for the same problem. man±Forchheimer model [18]. Chen and Vafai [19] in-
Closed form analytical solutions for forced convection vestigated free surface momentum and heat transfer in
in parallel plate ducts and in circular pipes partially ®lled porous domain using a ®nite di€erence scheme. Nield
with porous materials were obtained by Poulikakos and [20] discussed the limitation of the Brinkman±Forch-
Kazmierczak [7] for constant wall heat ¯ux. The same heimer model in porous media and at the interface, be-
previous group presented numerical results computed tween the clear ¯uid and porous region.
for constant wall temperature but for completely ®lled The transient response of circular and annular
ducts [15]. Using Darcy±Brinkman±Forchheimer model, channels partially ®lled with porous materials under
the problem of forced convection in channels partially forced convection conditions were investigated numeri-
®lled with porous media was numerically investigated by cally by Alkam and Al-Nimr [4,21], respectively. The
Jang and Chen [16]. Rudraiah [17] investigated the same same two authors have used porous substrates to
problem using the Darcy±Brinkman model. Also, using improve the thermal performance of solar collectors,
M.K. Alkam et al. / International Journal of Heat and Mass Transfer 44 (2001) 931±938 933

Alkam and Al-Nimr [3], and heat exchanger Alkam and oh1 oh1 oh1 1 o2 h1
‡ U1 ‡ V1 ˆ ; …3†
Al-Nimr [22], Also, they have investigated the transient os oX oY Pr1 oY 2
behavior of a channel partially ®lled with porous sub-
strate from hydrodynamic point of view [10]. oU2 oV2
In this work, it is intended to study the problem of ‡ ˆ 0; …4†
oX oY
transient forced convection ¯ow in parallel-plate chan-
nels partially ®lled with single porous substrate depos- oU2 oU2 1 oP o2 U2 mR
ited on the channel wall using Brinkman±Forchheimer U2 ‡ V2 ˆÿ ‡ mR ÿ U2 ÿ AU22 ;
oX oY qR oX oY 2 Da
model. The e€ect of di€erent operating and ¯ow
…5†
parameters on the thermal performance of the channel
will be investigated. These parameters include the po-
rous substrate thickness, the thermal conductivity of `the oh2 oh2 oh2 kR o2 h2
‡ U2 ‡ V2 ˆ : …6†
porous substrate, the microscopic inertial coecient, os oX oY Pr1 oY 2
and the Darcy number. In Eqs. (1)±(6), subscripts 1 and 2 refer to the clear ¯uid
and porous substrate, respectively. It is important to
2. Mathematical model mention that the value of e€ective viscosity ratio lR is
not settled. however, the value of lR ˆ 1 have been used
A schematic diagram for the problem under consid- successfully in several studies by Poulikakos and Kaz-
eration is shown in Fig. 1. The Figure presents a two- mierczak [7] and Chikh et al. [5]. In fact, lR ˆ 1 is a good
dimensional through an isothermal parallel-plate chan- approximation in the range of 0.7 < e < 1. It is noticeable
nel. A porous insert of prescribed thickness is deposited that the transverse momentum equation has been elim-
at the inner wall of the lower plate. A sudden change in inated due to the boundary layer simpli®cation. Refer-
the boundary temperature, occurs at the channel walls. ring to Bodia and Ostrele [23] and due to the lack of
At the entrance of the duct, the ¯uid velocity is kept at a transverse momentum equation, the integral form of
value of u0 and the ¯uid temperature is kept at T0 . continuity equation is used to compensate for such
Forchheimer±Brinkman Darcy model is adopted as- equation.
suming laminar, single phase, boundary layer ¯ow with Z e Z L
no internal heat generation, and neglecting viscous dis- qR U2 dY ‡ U1 dY ˆ U0 L: …7†
0 e
sipation. Also, it is assumed the porous medium is
homogenous, isotropic, consolidated, saturated with The hydrodynamic boundary conditions at the walls, at
¯uid, with invariant thermal properties, and chemically the inlet of the duct, and at the porous±clear ¯uid in-
stable. The ¯uid is homogenous, incompressible and in terface are:
local thermal equilibrium with the solid matrix. Using the
dimensionless parameter given in the nomenclature based at X ˆ 0 and 0 < Y < L
on the viscous-velocity scale, the equations of continuity,
U1 ˆ U2 ˆ U0 and V1 ˆ V2 ˆ 0 …8†
momentum, and energy, for both clear and porous do-
mains, reduce to the following dimensionless equations: for X > 0 and Y ˆ 0
oU1 oV1 U2 ˆ V2 ˆ 0
‡ ˆ 0; …1†
oX oY
for X > 0 and Y ˆ e
2
oU1 oU1 oP o U1 oU1 oU2
U1 ‡ V1 ˆÿ ‡ ; …2† U1 ˆ U2 ; and ˆ lR
oX oY oX oY 2 oY oY
for X > 0 and Y ˆ L
U1 ˆ V1 ˆ 0:

The energy equation has the following initial conditions:


at s ˆ 0 h1 ˆ h2 ˆ 0 …9†

for s > 0, the thermal boundary conditions at the walls,


at the inlet of the duct, and at the porous±clear ¯uid
interface are:
Fig. 1. A schematic diagram of the problem under consider-
ation. at X ˆ 0 and 0 < Y < L
934 M.K. Alkam et al. / International Journal of Heat and Mass Transfer 44 (2001) 931±938

h1 ˆ h2 ˆ 0 …10† In order to check the validity of the present code, Figs. 2


and 3 are plotted. Fig. 2 shows comparison between the
for X > 0 and Y ˆ 0 present fully developed axial velocity pro®le and the
h2 ˆ 1 analytical one presented by Poulikakos et al. [7]. In
Fig. 3, the variation of the fully developed Nusselt
for X > 0 and Y ˆ e
number with the thickness of the porous substrate is
oh1 oh2 plotted. On the same ®gure, the present results are
h1 ˆ h2 ; ˆ kR
oY oY compared to those obtained by Poulikakos et al. [7].
for X > 0 and Y ˆ L The e€ect of the porous substrate thickness on the
axial velocity pro®le is shown in Fig. 4. It is clear that
h1 ˆ 1:
increasing porous layer thickness forces more ¯uid to
The local Nusselt number and mixing cup temperature escape to the clear region. It is clear in Fig. 4 that the
are de®ned as follows: velocity distribution in the porous substrate is almost a
uniform slug pattern except near the boundary at which
2h` 2 oh Tm ÿ T0
Nu ˆ ˆ ; where hm ˆ : the ¯ow satis®es the no-slip boundary condition. The
k e 1 ÿ h oY
m T ÿT w 0
Y ˆ0 developing velocity pro®le is traced in the axial direction
in Fig. 5. It is noticed and due to microscopic forces that
the magnitude of the axial velocity is relatively low in the
3. Numerical solution porous substrate especially at fully developed region.
The magnitude of the axial velocity, U, decreases upon
The independent variables of this problem are: X, Y marching along the channel. The ¯ow retarded from the
and s. The governing di€erential equations have been porous substrate, enhances the ¯ow in the clear region,
transformed into the corresponding ®nite di€erence as a result, the velocity increases in the clear region. As
equation and then applied to a three dimensional uni- shown In Fig. 5, the axial velocity exhibits very steep
form grid. The three dimensions of the grid under con- gradient near the entrance region of the duct. This is due
sideration simulate the axial, the transverse, and the time to elimination of the transverse momentum equation as
variations. The nonlinear terms in momentum equation a result of the boundary layer approximation which is
were linearized by using the lagging technique, Ho€man not valid very near the entrance of the duct. In reality,
[24]. The linearized implicit ®nite di€erence equations this steep gradient in velocity will be partly compensated
are derived using a second-order central di€erence by a transverse momentum transfer. In addition, the
scheme for the transverse derivatives, and ®rst-order hydrodynamic behavior at the interface between the
backward scheme for both the axial and time deriva-
tives. The convergence analysis of the present numerical
scheme has been performed, and it is found that the
derived ®nite di€erence equations resemble a consistence
representation of the di€erential equations and yet the
solution is unconditionally stable.
The solution procedure introduced by Bodoia and
Osterle [23] and reused by El-Shaarawi and Alkam [25]
has been applied to the present problem. The linearized
momentum ®nite di€erence equation, together with the
boundary conditions, are transformed to a set of algebraic
equations. This set of equations was solved by using
Guass±Jordan elimination method [24]. The ®nite di€er-
ence energy equation is transformed to tridiagonal set of
algebraic equations that is solved by Thomas algorithm
[24]. A grid re®nement procedure has been performed
through numerical experimentation. The optimum choice
was DX ˆ 10ÿ4 , DY ˆ 0.005, and Ds ˆ 0.001.

4. Discussion of results

The present results have been computed using the Fig. 2. Comparison of present fully developed axial velocity
following operating and design parameters: pro®le, U, with the analytical solution given by Poulikakos and
Kazmierczak [7], for Da ˆ 1 ´ 10ÿ4 , A ˆ 1, and 20% porous
Pr1 ˆ 0:72; kr ˆ 1; lR ˆ 1; qR ˆ 1; CR ˆ 1; U0 ˆ 100: substrate.
M.K. Alkam et al. / International Journal of Heat and Mass Transfer 44 (2001) 931±938 935

Fig. 5. Axial velocity pro®les in the developing region for


Fig. 3. Variation of the present fully developed Nusselt number
Da ˆ 1 ´ 10ÿ4 , A ˆ 1, and e ˆ 0.2.
with the thickness of the clear region, compared with the nu-
merical solution given by Poulikakos and Kazmierczak [7], for
Da ˆ 1 ´ 10ÿ4 , A ˆ 1.

Fig. 6. Dimensionless fully developed pressure drop versus


thickness of the clear regioin for Da ˆ 1 ´ 10ÿ4 , and A ˆ 1.
Fig. 4. E€ect of porous substrate thickness on the axial velocity
ro®le, U, at X ˆ 2, and for Da ˆ 1 ´ 10ÿ4 , and A ˆ 1, at X ˆ 2.
forces decrease, and as a result, the pressure drop re-
duces. The microscopic shear and inertial drag terms in
porous and clear domains depends strongly on the type the momentum equation has a negative sign and they
of boundary conditions used at the interface. As men- resemble a retarding forces for the ¯uid ¯ow. Also,
tioned previously, the continuity of axial velocities and Fig. 6 shows that after certain thickness, approximately
shear stresses are assumed at the interface. However, the 50%, the pressure drop increases rapidly with thickness
validity of this assumption is not settled yet. It is obvious of porous substrate.
from Fig. 6 that as the thickness of the porous substrate The mixing cup history is shown in Fig. 7 for di€erent
decreases, both shear and inertial microscopic drag values of thermal conductivity ratio, kr . Obviously,
936 M.K. Alkam et al. / International Journal of Heat and Mass Transfer 44 (2001) 931±938

Fig. 7. E€ect of thermal conductivity ratio on the mixing cup Fig. 9. Nusselt number versus dimensionless clear region
temperature history, for Da ˆ 1 ´ 10ÿ4 , and e ˆ 0.2, at X ˆ 2. thickness for di€erent values of form drag coecient, for
Da ˆ 1 ´ 10ÿ4 , and kR ˆ 1.

Fig. 8. Nusselt number versus dimensionles axial direction for Fig. 10. Nusselt number versus Darcy number, for di€erent
di€erent porous substrate thickness, Da ˆ 0.01, A ˆ 1, and values of porous substrate thickness, for A ˆ 1, and kR ˆ 1.
kR ˆ 1.

selt number versus porous substrate was plotted and


using porous substrate of high thermal conductivity explained by Poulikakos et al. [7] and Lauriat and Vafai
improves the heat transfer from the boundaries by al- [26]. Fig. 9 shows that the form drag coecient has
lowing more heat ¯ow to be conducted to the ¯uid ¯ow. relatively limited e€ect on the fully developed Nusselt
Fig. 8 shows that Nusselt number decreases along the number. Fig. 10 shows how Nusselt number changes
channel. This reduction in Nusselt number is due to the with Darcy number. As Darcy number increases its ef-
increase in the boundary layer thickness. There is no fect is vanished and the duct behave as a clear duct,
clear trend in the e€ect of the porous substrate thickness while for a small value of Darcy number implies that the
on Nusselt number. The non-monotonic trend of Nus- substrate behaves as a solid one, these e€ects gave the
M.K. Alkam et al. / International Journal of Heat and Mass Transfer 44 (2001) 931±938 937

conductivity allows more heat ¯ow to be conducted to


the ¯uid. Small Darcy numbers or large values of mi-
croscopic inertial coecient reduces hydrodynamic
boundary layer thickness. The e€ect of Darcy number
and microscopic inertial coecient in the developing
region is higher than that in the fully developed region,
because as one marches through the channel, the mag-
nitude of the pore velocity in the porous domain de-
creases.
Generally, forced convection can be signi®cantly
enhanced by depositing of porous substrate on imper-
meable heated walls, provided that high e€ective thermal
conductivity and dense porous substrate are used.

References

[1] M. Kaviany, Principle of Heat Transfer in Porous Media,


2nd ed., Springer, New York, 1995.
[2] P.X. Jiang, B.X. Wang, D.A. Luo, Z.P. Ren, Fluid ¯ow
Fig. 11. Nusselt number versus form drag coecient for dif- and convection heat transfer in a vertical porous annulus,
ferent values of porous substrate thickness, for Da ˆ 0.1, and Numer. Heat Transfer A (1996) 305±320.
kR ˆ 1. [3] M.K. Alkam, M.A. Al-Nimr, Solar collectors with tubes
partially ®lled with porous substrate, ASME J. Solar
Energy Eng. 121 (1999) 020±024.
asymptotic behavior of the Nusselt number with respect [4] M.A. Al-Nimr, M.K. Alkam, Unsteady non-Darcian forced
to the Darcy number. As was previously mentioned that convection analysis in an annuls partially ®lled with a porous
Darcy number has inverse trend with microscopic iner- material, ASME J. Heat Transfer 119 (1997) 001±006.
tial coecient, A, this is noti®ed from Figs. 10 and 11. [5] S. Chikh, A. Boumedien, K. Bouhadef, G. Lauriat,
Therefore, asymptotic behavior of the Nusselt number Analytical solution of non-Darcian forced convection in
with respect to the microscopic inertial coecient is an annular duct partially ®lled with a porous medium, Int.
J. Heat Mass Transfer 38 (1995a) 1543±1551.
expected. For certain thickness, the increasing of mi-
[6] K. Vafai, S.J. Kim, Fluid mechanics of interface region
croscopic inertial coecient will enhance heat transfer
between a porous medium and ¯uid layer ± an exact
while more than these values, increasing microscopic solution, Int. J. Heat Mass Transfer 11 (1990) 254±256.
inertial coecient will reduce heat transfer. This non- [7] D. Poulikakos, M. Kazmierczak, Forced convection in a
monotonic relation of the Nusselt number with thick- duct partially ®lled with a porous material, ASME J. Heat
ness was explained previously by the non-monotonic Transfer 109 (1987) 653±662.
trend of the velocity with thickness which resulted from [8] P.C. Carman, Flow of Gases through Porous Material,
compromising occurred between microscopic inertial Academic Press, New York, 1956.
force, microscopic viscous drag force, macroscopic in- [9] R.E. Collins, Flow of Fluids through Porous Material,
ertia force and macroscopic viscous force. Reinhold, New York, 1961.
[10] M.A. Al-Nimr, M.K. Alkam, Unsteady non-Darcian ¯uid
¯ow in parallel channels partially ®lled with porous
materials, Heat Mass Transfer 33 (1998) 315±318.
5. Conclusions [11] M.K. Alkam, M.A. Al-Nimr, Z.N. Mousa, Transient
forced convection of non-Newtonian ¯uid in the entrance
The present numerical solution is carried out for region of porous concentric annuli, Int. Numer. Meth.
transient developing forced convection between two Heat Fluid Flow 8 (5) (1998) 703±716.
isothermal parallel-plates channel partially ®lled with [12] G.S. Beavers, D.D. Joseph, Boundary conditions at
porous substrate. The Brinkman±Forchheimer±extended naturally permeable wall, J. Fluid Mech. 13 (1967) 197±
Darcy model was used to modeling the ¯ow inside the 207.
porous domain. The present study reports the e€ects of [13] K. Vafai, R. Thiyagaraja, Analysis of ¯ow and heat
transfer at the interface region of a porous medium, Int. J.
porous layer thickness, Darcy number, thermal conduc-
Heat Mass Transfer 30 (1987) 1391±1405.
tivity ratio, and microscopic inertial coecient on the
[14] K. Vafai, S.J. Kim, On the limitations of the Brinkman±
thermal performance of the system under consideration. Forchheimer±extended Darcy equation, Int. J. Heat Mass
Heat transfer can be enhanced using higher thermal Transfer 16 (1995) 11±15.
conduction ratio, decreasing Darcy number, and in- [15] D. Poulikakos, K. Renken, Forced convection in a channel
creasing microscopic inertial coecient. Higher thermal ®lled with a porous medium, including the e€ect of ¯ow
938 M.K. Alkam et al. / International Journal of Heat and Mass Transfer 44 (2001) 931±938

inertia, variable porosity, and Brinkman friction, ASME J. [21] M.K. Alkam, M.A. Al-Nimr, Transient non-Darcian
Heat Transfer 109 (1987) 880±888. forced convection ¯ow in a pipe partially ®lled with a
[16] J.Y. Jang, J.L. Chen, Forced convection in a parallel plate porous material, Int. J. Heat Mass Transfer 41 (1998) 347±
channel partially ®lled with a high porosity medium, Int. 356.
Com. Heat Mass Transfer 19 (1992) 263±273. [22] M.K. Alkam, M.A. Al-Nimr, Improving the performance
[17] N. Rudraiah, Forced convection in a parallel plate channel of double-pipe heat exchanger by using porous substrates,
partially ®lled with a porous material, ASME J. Heat Int. J. Heat Mass Transfer 42 (1999) 3609±3618.
Transfer 107 (1985) 331±332. [23] J.R. Bodoia, J.F. Osterle, Finite-di€erence analysis of
[18] S. Chikh, A. Boumedien, K. Bouhadef, G. Lauriat, Non- plane Poisseuille and Couette ¯ow developments, Applied
Darcian forced convection analysis in an annular partially Science Research, A101961, pp. 265±276.
®lled with a porous material, Numer. Heat Transfer A 28 [24] J.D. Ho€man, Numerical Method for Engineering and
(1995) 707±722. Scientists, Purdo University, 1992.
[19] S.C. Chen, K. Vafai, Analysis of free surface momentum [25] M.A. El-Shaarawi, M.K. Alkam, Transient forced convec-
and energy transport in porous media, Numer. Heat tion in the entrance region of concentric annuli, Int. J. Heat
Transfer A (1996) 281±296. Mass Transfer 35 (1992) 3335±3344.
[20] D.A. Nield, The limitation of the Brinkman±Forchheimer [26] G. Lauriat, K. Vafai, Convective Heat and Mass Transfer
equation in modeling ¯ow in a saturated porous medium in Porous Media, Kluwer Academic Publishers, Dordrecht,
and at an interface, Int. J. Heat Mass Transfer 12 (1991) 1991, pp. 289±328.
269±272.

También podría gustarte