Documentos de Académico
Documentos de Profesional
Documentos de Cultura
12 Physics
EEI Report
Graphite Resistance
Joseph McGorry
Fabian Petroni
8/6/2017
Mr McLaughlin
Abstract
This experiment investigates the resistance of lead pencils and how changing thickness and
length influences the resistance. Pencils of varying thickness (HB to 8B) were connected into
a circuit therefore changing the resistance. It was found that resistance was proportional to
the thickness of the pencils and that when the amount of graphite found in lead pencils
increased the resistance of the pencils decreased proportionally. The higher the
concentrations of clay and the longer the resistor (i.e. the pencil) the more resistance there
was in the circuit
1. Introduction
1.1 Background theory review
Resistance is the measurement that a substance offers in opposing a flow of electrons in an electric
circuit (tech target). It is the prevention of the flow of charge in a circuit. Resistance can be calculated
through Ohms law which describes the relationship between resistance, voltage and current. Ohms
law, which is given by the formula = . , can be rearranged to calculate resistance, this formula is
(
= .
)
(Formula 1) Where V =voltage, I = Current and R = Resistance (Nave, 2001)
A resistor purposely induces a resistance in an electrical component. Resistors are used in electrical
circuits to limit the flow of current through the circuit. Resistors can be produced in multiple ways,
the most common resistor found in electronic devices is the carbon-composition resistor (teach target,
2017). This resistor is made from fine granulated carbon, mixed with clay and then hardened.
Graphites structure is made from flat layered Carbon atoms which are called graphene sheets
(gcscience, 2015). Three of its valence electrons form strong covalent bonds to the three other carbon
atoms. The fourth electron is delocalised which means it is a free
electron. The fourth free electron allows graphite to conduct
electricity and heat (gcscience, 2015). When a voltage is applied to
the graphite an electrical field in the graphite causes these electrons
to move. They move from the negative side of the conductor to the Figure 1 Graphites structure
positive side carrying an electrical charge with them. This allows (gcscience, 2015)
graphite to easily conduct electricity making it a suitable resistor
(BBC, 2014).
Lead pencils used to be made from lead, now due to health and safety concerns a lead pencil is made
up of a combination of graphite, clay and wax. Different hardness of pencils have different amounts
of graphite and clay present, a softer pencil such as a 9H has 53% clay and 41% graphite. A harder
pencil being 9B has greater amounts of graphite 93% to clay which is 2% as seen in the figure below.
Figure 2 percentages of graphite and clay found in lead pencils (senior physics)
1.3 Hypothesis
It is hypothesised that as the length and concentrations of clay in lead pencils are increased then the
resistance of the pencil increases. As graphite levels are increased then there will be a decrease in
resistance. This is due to clay being a better resistor than graphite and greater length equalling
greater resistivity.
1.4 Variables
In the experiment the controlled variable which is the variable that doesnt change was the voltage
through the circuit and the cross sectional area. The manipulated variable is the variable that is
changed in the experiment which is being tested by the hypothesis, this was the length and type of
lead pencil. The dependant variable which is being tested in the experiment is the resistance and
electrical conductivity.
2. Method
2.1 Materials
2 x multimeters
6 alligator clip wires
6 x pencils (Ranging from 2H 8B)
Light bulb
Power pack
III. The length of the pencil was measured using a ruler from
tip to tip.
calculate resistance
Inhaling potentially toxic A precaution for this potential risk is using a voltage that does not result in the
smoke produced from the smoking of the lead pencil. If smoke is produced gloves, eye protection and masks
pencils when they are should be worn at all times. If the smoke is very strong then the experiment should
connected to the power be conducted in a fumigation cupboard.
pack.
Using electricity causes A precaution for this potential risk is to prepare before the experiment, all
many potential risks, they equipment should be checked and made sure it isnt faulty and none of the wires
include being electrocuted are broken or damaged.
or causing a fire.
4V 172mm
HB Test 1 Test 2 Test 3 Test 4 Average
Voltage (V) 0.005 2.93 2.94 2.95 2.94 2.94
Amps (A) 0.0005 1.632 1.634 1.628 1.630 1.631
Resistance (W) 1.795 1.799 1.812 1.804 1.803
4V 172mm
2B Test 1 Test 2 Test 3 Test 4 Average
Voltage (V) 0.005 2.71 2.79 2.74 2.70 2.735
Amps (A) 0.0005 1.656 1.652 1.656 1.649 1.65325
Resistance (W) 1.697 1.688 1.715 1.698 1.654
4V 172mm
4B Test 1 Test 2 Test 3 Test 4 Average
Voltage (V) 0.005 2.50 2.46 2.48 2.46 2.475
Amps (A) 0.0005 1.674 1.664 1.669 1.666 1.66825
Resistance (W) 1.493 1.478 1.486 1.476 1.484
4V 172mm
6B Test 1 Test 2 Test 3 Test 4 Average
Voltage (V) 0.005 2.11 2.13 2.15 2.10 2.0975
Amps (A) 0.0005 1.679 1.682 1.683 1.678 1.6805
Resistance (W) 1.257 1.266 1.277 1.192 1.248
4V 172mm
7B Test 1 Test 2 Test 3 Test 4 Average
Voltage (V) 0.005 1.87 1.88 1.92 1.89 1.89
Amps (A) 0.0005 1.692 1.690 1.694 1.691 1.69175
Resistance (W) 1.105 1.112 1.133 1.118 1.117
4V 172mm
8B Test 1 Test 2 Test 3 Test 4 Average
Voltage (V) 0.005 1.62 1.66 1.64 1.63 1.6375
Amps (A) 0.0005 1.702 1.704 1.700 1.702 1.702
Resistance (W) 0.952 0.974 0.965 0.958 0.962
HB Pencil Lead with 4V
Length of pencil (mm) 0.5mm Voltage (v) 0.005 Amps (A) 0.0005 Resistance (W)
175 2.78 1.648 1.687
145 2.72 1.628 1.671
125 2.67 1.615 1.653
105 2.68 1.604 1.640
85 2.59 1.595 1.624
R = 0.9946
1.6
Resistance (W)
1.4
1.2
0.8
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7
Hardness of pencil
1.67
1.66
1.65
1.64
1.63
1.62
1.61
1.6
0 1 2 3 4 5 6
Length of pencil (mm)
1.3
1.2
1.1
1
0.9
0.8
0.7
0.6
0.5
60% 65% 70% 75% 80% 85% 90% 95% 100%
Graphite percentage
Resistivity calculation HB pencil
*+
= ,
Resistance = 1.802 W
Length = 0.172 m
Area = 7 = 3.14 x 0.0012 = 3.14 x 10-6 m2
Resistivity = ?
B,
= +
1.802 3.14 106
= 0.172
= 3.29 10FP Wm
4. Discussion
4.1 Interpretation of Data
Throughout the experiment two variables were manipulated, the hardness and length of pencil lead
to test if there was a relationship between the variables and resistance. In the first part of the
experiment the variable that was changed was the pencil hardness or type of pencil (HB to 8B) and
the length was kept constant. Each pencil has different amounts of graphite and clay, these amounts
are a factor in determining the resistance and resistivity of the pencil lead. The results obtained were
used to calculate resistance and then were plotted in graph 1. This graph shows the relationship
between the different lead pencils and the changing resistance. There is one anomaly in graph 1 which
is seen with the 6B pencil resistance, the value is slightly below the trend line however the graph still
follows a straight linear line which is supported by the R2 value. The R2 value of the linear trend line is
0.989, the closer to 1 the R2 value is the more accurate the results are. This means that the pencils
resistance can be accurately modelled by a linear equation, when the hardness of the pencil increases
the resistance decreases in a linear fashion. This coincides with the hypothesis given that 8B has the
least resistance at 0.962 W, the 8B pencil has the most amount of graphite or carbon at 90% and the
least amount of clay at 5%. The clay is more resistive than graphite so as clay decreases so will
resistance. This is also seen in graph three when the percentage of graphite increases the resistance
decreases, thus supporting the hypothesis. The hypothesis stated that as the concentrations of clay
are increased then the resistance will also increase, this is seen in graph 1 with HB having the most
resistance and the greatest amount of clay at 26%. When graphite is increased the resistance
decreases, this is because graphite has a lower resistance than clay. The resistivity of graphite is much
more than clay which can be seen in the table above.
In the second part of the experiment a different manipulated variable was changed. This was the
length of the pencil or resistor, however, the thickness of the pencil stayed constant at HB. The HB
pencil was used because research suggests that the length will always have an effect on each pencil
no matter what the thickness is. This was done to see if changing the length also influenced the
resistance. It was hypothesised that as length increases the resistance would also increase, this was
hypothesised given that the resistivity is directly proportional to the length as demonstrated in the
formula for resistivity (see formula 2). Therefore as the length increases or decreases then the
resistance would also increase or decrease proportionally. This can be seen in graph 2 which compares
the resistance to the changing length of a HB pencil, this graph has a linear trend and proves that
resistance and length are proportional. This is supported with the calculated R2 which is 0.998. This
value is exceptionally close to 1 which shows that resistance and length are linear and proportional.
Using graph 1 an equation was calculated from the linear trend line, this was y = -0.1767x + 2.0041 it
accurately represented the resistance of pencil lead in each pencil and was used as the theoretical
value. From this graph exact values or theoretical values for the resistance of the graphite could be
calculated and then compared against the recorded values. The theoretical value and recorded values
were then used to gain the percentage error of the resistance by using the percentage error formula
stated above. It was seen that most of the percentage errors were below 2% seen below indicating
that the results were accurate and linear only having slight variance. However there was one anomaly
in the results, this was the resistance for a 6B pencil, it can be seen clearly in graph 1 that the 6B result
is below the trend line which was support by its error which was 3.7%.
Pencil Theoretical resistance W Recorded Difference % Error
y = -0.1767x + 2.0041 Resistance W Absolute values
HB 1.827 1.802 0.025 1.3684 %
2B 1.651 1.654 0.003 0.1817%
4B 1.474 1.483 0.009 0.6106%
6B 1.297 1.248 0.049 3.7779%
7B 1.121 1.117 0.004 0.3568%
8B 0.944 0.962 0.018 1.9068%
Using graph 2 an equation was calculated from the linear trend line, this was formula y = -0.0157x +
1.7021, it accurately represented the resistance of pencil lead in each pencil and was used as the
theoretical value. From graph 2 exact values or theoretical values for the resistance of the graphite
could be calculated and then compared against the recorded values the same as the previous errors.
It was seen in the table below that all percentage errors are under 0.2%, this means that the error for
results is quite small which supports the fact that the R squared value is very close to 1.
Length of pencil (mm) Resistance (W) Theoretical Percentage error
0.5mm resistance (W)
175 1.687 1.6864 0.03558%
5. Conclusion
When pencils of varying thickness of HB, 2B, 4B, 6B 7B and 8B were connected into a circuit, it was
found that these pencils had varying resistance. This resistance was proportional to the thickness of
pencil, it was found that as amounts of graphite found in lead pencils increases then the resistance
of the pencils decreases linearly. It was also found that as length of a pencil was decreased than
*+
resistance also decreased proportionally, which is supported by the equation of = . The
,
hypothesis was proved and supported because it was found through the results that clay is a more
effective resistor than graphite.
6. References
About Conductivity . (n.d.). Retrieved May 21, 2017, from
http://www.lehigh.edu/~amb4/wbi/kwardlow/conductivity.htm
Conductivity. (n.d.). Retrieved May 19, 2017, from
https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/conductivity
Factors that affect the resistance of a wire. (n.d.). Retrieved May 25, 2017, from
http://www.cyberphysics.co.uk/topics/electricity/higher_electricity/resistance.htm
GCSE Bitesize: Graphite. (n.d.). Retrieved May 22, 2017, from
http://www.bbc.co.uk/schools/gcsebitesize/science/add_ocr_gateway/chemical_economics
/nanochemistryrev2.shtml
Graphite Grading Scales Explained. (2016, November 09). Retrieved May 22, 2017, from
https://pencils.com/hb-graphite-grading-scale/
(n.d.). Retrieved May 21, 2017, from
https://www.mathsisfun.com/numbers/percentage-error.html
Resistance: Temperature Coefficient. (n.d.). Retrieved May 22, 2017, from
http://hyperphysics.phy-astr.gsu.edu/hbase/electric/restmp.html
Shaik, A. (n.d.). Carbon composition resistor. Retrieved May 23, 2017, from
http://www.physics-and-radio-electronics.com/electronic-devices-and-circuits/passive-
components/resistors/carboncompositionresistor.html
What is resistor? - Definition from WhatIs.com. (n.d.). Retrieved May 20, 2017, from
http://whatis.techtarget.com/definition/resistor
What Is the Difference Between Resistivity & Conductivity? (n.d.). Retrieved May 21, 2017, from
http://sciencing.com/difference-between-resistivity-conductivity-8221785.html
Why Pencil "Lead" is Called "Lead". (2015, January 28). Retrieved May 21, 2017, from
http://www.todayifoundout.com/index.php/2010/11/why-pencil-lead-is-called-lead/
7. Log Book
Friday 5th of May
Lesson 1: Research was undertaken and a EEI experiment was chosen, this was to test the Resistance
in a lead pencil.
7/5/17
Lesson 2: Research was started on the topic
Graphite is a better conductor of electricity than clay, this means as the concentration of graphite
increases, the resistance of the circuit should decrease because conductivity and resistivity are
inversely proportional.
Formulas V=IR
*+
=
,
9/5/17
The introduction was also started
Hypothesis started and completed
It is hypothesised that as the length and concentrations of clay in lead pencils are increased then the
resistance of the pencil increases. This is due to clay being a better resistor and greater length
equalling greater resistivity.
11/5/17
Materials started and completed and ordered
2 x multimeters
6 alligator clip wires
6 x pencils (Ranging from 2H 8B)
Light bulb
Power pack
12/5/17
Lesson 3: Experiment was started with testing the resistance in different thickness of pencil leads.
The circuit was set up and seen above.
15/5/17
Lesson 4 5: The experiment was continued with more tests being conducted, the introduction was
continued. Data was collected from these experiments and put into tables.
16/5/17
Lesson 6: The experiment was concluded with the final experiment being changing the different
lengths in a HB pencil.
y = -0.1727x + 1.9824
1.8
R = 0.9946
1.3
0.8
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7
Hardness of pencil
22/5/17
Lesson 8: The introduction was finished and calculations of resistivity and errors were calculated
Resistivity calculation HB pencil
*+
= ,
Resistance = 1.802 W
Length = 0.172 m
7 2 -6
Area = = 3.14 x 0.001 = 3.14 x 10 m 2
Resistivity = ?
B,
= +
1.802 3.14 10 6
= 0.172
FP
= 3.29 10 Wm
25/5/17
Lesson 9: Discussion was started, different types of errors were established;
The errors that effected this experiment was random errors, more specifically environmental errors.