Está en la página 1de 5

PERSPECTIVES

Dalit Political Imagination on the other. Taking our cue from the
timely editorial we wish to use this article

and Replication in to outline some of the reasons behind


the continuing marginality of dalits in

Contemporary Tamil Nadu the state, reflect on current dalit politics


and conclude by considering some of the
possible alternatives and avenues that
are open to dalit parties today.1
D Karthikeyan, Stalin Rajangam, Hugo Gorringe
Dalit Politics in Context

T
Tamil politics is dominated by the he editorial, Dalits in Tamil Nadu If we are to understand dalit politics in
Dravidian parties and it is an featured in the 21 July issue of the Tamil Nadu, then we should first stop
Economic & Political Weekly high- expressing surprise and disappointment
indictment of their rule that
lights some of the difficulties faced by, that untouchability persists in the land
untouchability and caste and the shortcomings of, dalit politics in of Periyar. We need, at the outset, to
discrimination continue unabated Tamil Nadu. It rightly notes how prac- appreciate that caste continues to be
in the state. Dalit movements tices of untouchability and casteist dis- central to politics in the state not despite
crimination not only continue, but are but because of the Dravidian parties.
arose in opposition, and as an
often unchallenged in the cradle of the Numerous studies2 have demonstrated
alternative, to Dravidianism but Dravidian movement. It cannot be gain- that the non-brahmin movement in south
have been shaped by their political said that much dalit politics revolves India was precisely that: non-brahmin
context. A dalit-left alliance might around issues of identity and occurs in rather than anti-brahmin. Having wrested
the symbolic sphere. Likewise, the lack political power from the stranglehold of
offer one way out of the current
of adequate dalit leadership in the Com- the brahmin minority, the backward and
impasse in dalit politics. munist Party of India (Marxist) CPI(M) intermediate castes monopolised power
is a major omission that has prevented in their turn. They used their dominance
the communist party from emerging as a to stall ambitious land reform programmes
significant dalit force. The editorial, and adi-dravidar welfare schemes, whilst
however, does little to explain why Tamil retaining a veneer of social radicalism
dalits face this predicament and, short of thanks to schemes such as the nutritious
an implicit call for dalit-communist unity, mid-day meal programme for school-
it does little to suggest a resolution. going children.
Dalit politics in the state, furthermore, The fractured nature of caste domi-
currently stands at a crossroads. As some nance in the state, where no one caste
sub-dalit groups are just starting to mo- cluster is socially, numerically or politi-
bilise and organise themselves, existing cally pre-eminent, has veiled the extent
dalit parties are attempting to embrace to which social and political power are
the wider politics and identities of Tamil intertwined (Lakshman 2011). Thevars,
nationalism. Bhimrao Ambedkar, Karl Gounders, Naickers, Nadars and Vanniyars
Marx and Vladimir Lenin are neither all have pockets of dominance across the
unknown nor unread here though Jyotiba state and have been assiduously wooed
Phule is less prominent, and all four by the Dravidian parties. Caste majori-
are less familiar than Periyar E V Rama- tarianism is writ large in the prominence
samy. Pandit Iyothee Thass and Ret- accorded to members of these castes in all
taimalai Srinivasan in the past and a government posts from police through
host of dalit intellectuals from the 1980s panchayat leaders to ministerial berths.
D Karthikeyan (karthik.guevara@gmail.com) is onwards have articulated a coherent Post the decline of the dominance of the
a journalist working for The Hindu newspaper counter-hegemonic discourse but they Congress Party, dalit MLAs have tended
and is based in Madurai, Tamil Nadu.
have been joined or even replaced on to attain distinction within adi-dravidar
Stalin Rajangam (stalinrajangam@gmail.com)
is a dalit writer and teaches at contemporary dalit banners by Vellupillai welfare or minor departments. In a state
the American College, Madurai. Prabhakarans (of the Liberation Tigers governed by the non-brahmin parties
Hugo Gorringe (Hugo.Gorringe@ed.ac.uk) of Tamil Eelam) image on the one hand we can have a brahmin chief minister
teaches sociology at the University of and a host of caste-specific characters but it is still almost unthinkable that a
Edinburgh, UK.
from history or mythological history dalit could attain that position.
30 september 8, 2012 vol xlviI no 36 EPW Economic & Political Weekly
PERSPECTIVES

Thus it is that the biggest freebies As Dravidian hegemony has been it is less top-down and entails making
associated with Tamil elections tend to challenged by the rise of smaller parties demands of elite groups, Harriss (2000)
go unremarked. Whilst the press goes to over the past two decades, elections have argues, it tends to be the preserve of
town on the schemes to hand out colour come to be associated with vote-buying, upwardly mobile social groups. Populism,
TVs, laptops, mixies and cheap or free massive expenditure and corruption on a however, as Swamy (1998) notes, is
rice, much less attention is paid to the grand scale (EPW 2010). Even local council often observed more in the sphere of
subsidies such as cheap electricity hand- and panchayat presidential candidates rhetoric than programmes. It is this
ed out to farmers and landlords. When currently spend several lakhs of rupees rhetoric, Bate (2009) argues, that has
programmes like the National Rural Em- in expectation of the commissions that dominated Tamil politics for the past
ployment Guarantee Act (NREGA) have they will receive once elected to the four decades.
threatened to deprive these dominant post. It is within this context that we Political challengers, thus, face an
landowning castes of their supply of cheap need to engage with and voice our criti- uphill struggle to get their voices heard
labour they have vented their anger cisms of contemporary dalit and left poli- let alone persuade voters to switch alle-
through protests and the formation of tics. It is an oft-repeated-truism that had giance. Lacking resources and access to
caste-based organisations (De Neve and communist or Dravidian parties imple- state benefits successive political chal-
Carswell 2011). Populist rhetoric and mented their promises, they would have lengers in the state have had to take
Dravidian oratory, as Bate (2010) shows, rendered the emergence of the dalit par- recourse to assertive forms of populism
work by emphasising the honour and ties redundant. It is a measure of their urging particular sub-sections of the
glory of pure mother Tamil and gloss- failings in this regard that such mobilisa- population to assert themselves against
ing over uncomfortable ground realities. tion was and is still necessary. Indeed, discrimination and marginalisation. These
It is only the mobilisation of hitherto ex- dalit movements emerged with an infor- appeals, perforce, hinge on identity. The
cluded castes that has revealed the caste med, well-articulated and clear-sighted Pattali Makkal Katchi (Toiling Peoples
character of state politics (Gorringe 2012). critique of existing politics (Karthikeyan Party), thus, emerged from the mobilisa-
Dravidian politics, in other words, has 2009; Roberts 2010; Rajangam 2011). It tion of Vanniyars and demanded most
masked the caste basis of social structures is not in ideology or analysis that they are backward caste status for the group as
and appealed to dalit voters using populist lacking so much as in the implementation. well as benefits in proportion to their
imagery, symbolism and rhetoric espe- Whilst we have no desire to exonerate numerical strength. The Puthiya Tami-
cially as translated to the public through dalit politicians for moving away from lagam (PT New Tamil Society) fol-
the medium of Tamil cinema. When the these founding principles, it is impor- lowed with calls for Pallars (a scheduled
Dravida Munnetra Kazhagam (DMK) split, tant to bear this socio-political context caste) to be recognised as Devendra Kula
with the formation of the All India Anna in mind when assessing their perfor- Vellalars and provided with various ben-
Dravida Munnetra Kazhagam (AIADMK) mance. Few institutions or organisa- efits. Shortly thereafter the Viduthalai
in 1972, the presence of two rival Dravidian tions in the state political or otherwise Chiruthaigal Katchi (VCK Liberation
parties further reduced voter options are immune from the culture of imme- Panthers Party) mobilised mainly Parai-
by turning Tamil elections into bipolar diate rewards and fewer still articulate a yars as first dalits, then the cheri-people
contests. Unlike in Uttar Pradesh, for politics that breaks with Dravidian pop- and now the downtrodden Tamils. In most
instance, votes here tend to be split two ulism. Appraisals of Tamil dalit politics cases caste-based mobilisations have
ways, meaning that a fairly high share should be rooted in an understanding of aspired to positions from which they
of the vote is required to win in each this backdrop. could dispense paternalist largesse. Lack-
constituency. This makes it exceedingly ing the means to become patrons, they
difficult for third parties to have an elec- Populism, Identity and Symbolism have time and again been forced back
toral impact. The first-past-the post elec- Subramanian (1999) notes how Dravidian onto their identity to mobilise support.
toral system similarly favours established politics rests upon populist appeals to Dalit politics, however, has always
parties (CERI 2009; Wyatt 2009). The the people. He differentiates between combined identity-based demands with
upshot is that even national parties with paternalist and assertive forms of calls for a more equitable distribution
effective party organisation and finan- populism. The former revolves around a of resources. Whilst the mainstream
cial clout like the communists fall in benevolent leader or patron who acts as discourse casts the dalit parties merely
line with one or the other of the DMK or a benefactor and protector of the needy. as an extension of Dravidian politics, in
AIADMK come election time, leaving M G Ramachandran the three-time actual fact they arose in opposition to
newer or smaller parties with few if any chief minister of Tamil Nadu is held up the dilution of Periyarist ideals by the
viable allies. In terms of dalit politics as the archetype of such politics and very parties that claim to carry forward
more specifically, the above issues com- was routinely portrayed as the champion his legacy. The key motto of the VCK, for
bine to mean that even in reserved of the poor and vulnerable. Assertive instance, is the Ambedkarite assertion
constituencies non-dalits tend to decide populism, by contrast, makes demands that: caste annihilation is peoples liber-
which dalit will contest, let alone win on behalf of excluded groups who wish ation. They emerged seeking an alter-
(Gorringe 2005). to be admitted into the mainstream. As native politics rather than a continuation
Economic & Political Weekly EPW september 8, 2012 vol xlviI no 36 31
PERSPECTIVES

of the status quo. Backed into a corner party as evidence of how far such organi- Sekaran recognised as a major figure
on the question of caste, existing parties sations still have to travel to truly repre- as was brutally demonstrated in the
have been forced to give ground or ad- sent their concerns and voices. At least, police firing on participants gathered in
dress hitherto neglected issues. their response has been a positive attempt Paramakudi in 2011. Even though dalit
While the CPI(M) has worked with to address caste discrimination. A more parties lack political power or influence
dalits since the outset on a class basis, paradoxical outcome of dalit mobilisa- and even though ordinary dalits still
its Tamil Nadu Untouchability Eradica- tion has been the way in which the domi- struggle to get cases filed or registered,
tion Front (TNUEF) is a direct product of nant castes have recently embraced vic- the mere fact of their political parti-
the dalit upsurge. It is only following timisation and portrayed themselves as cipation has sufficed to create such
autonomous dalit mobilisation that the at the receiving end of reverse casteism counter-mobilisation.
communists came to the realisation that (De Neve and Carswell 2011). Hence That dalits are subjected to severe
caste had to be tackled head on. Even there are calls for the repeal of the SC/ST social repression today, thus, is not sur-
so, the TNUEF demonstrates the limita- Prevention of Atrocities Act 1989 and prising, but there are two points to make
tions of their approach to caste-based demands for party members to avoid here. First, the stark violence that culmi-
inequalities in that the focus is on tangi- cross-caste marriages. Recently such castes nated in major riots and murders such
ble instances of untouchability rather have also mobilised around this new- as the murder of seven dalits in broad
than on the underlying structures of found victim mentality mustering around daylight in Melavalavu in 1997 has
caste. They can, thus, mobilise to bring banners like the Thevar Protection declined as dalits have fought back in
down a caste wall, but are much less Front, or the Non-Dalit Common Peoples kind or in court. Second, that acts of
effective at bringing down the walls Association. The lack of substance be- untouchability continue to be raised is
that exist within peoples minds. In hind such demands, however, is seen in also, in some ways, a sign of change.
other words, their actions are every bit the respective significance accorded to Mendelsohn and Vicziany (1998) point
as symbolic as those of the dalit parties the memorial days of Muthuramalinga towards the emergence of new forms of
but are placed within a different frame Thevar and Immanuel Sekaran.3 Where caste violence that arise in response to
of reference. the city of Madurai is atypically shut the subaltern challenge. On the one
Activists point to the absence of dalits down for the celebration of the former, hand, dalit activism brings issues to
in the upper echelons of the communist dalits still struggle to have Immanuel light in a way that has not happened

EW
N The Adivasi Question
Edited By
INDRA MUNSHI
Depletion and destruction of forests have eroded the already fragile survival base of adivasis across the country,
displacing an alarmingly large number of adivasis to make way for development projects. Many have been forced to
migrate to other rural areas or cities in search of work, leading to systematic alienation.
This volume situates the issues concerning the adivasis in a historical context while discussing the challenges they
face today.
The introduction examines how the loss of land and livelihood began under the British administration, making the
adivasis dependent on the landlord-moneylender-trader nexus for their survival.
The articles, drawn from writings of almost four decades in EPW, discuss questions of community rights and ownership,
management of forests, the states rehabilitation policies, and the Forest Rights Act and its implications. It presents
diverse perspectives in the form of case studies specific to different regions and provides valuable analytical insights.

Authors:
Ramachandra Guha Sanjeeva Kumar Ashok K Upadhyaya E Selvarajan Nitya Rao B B Mohanty Brian Lobo K Balagopal Sohel Firdos
Pankaj Sekhsaria DN Judy Whitehead Sagari R Ramdas Neela Mukherjee Mathew Areeparampil Asmita Kabra Renu Modi M Gopinath
Reddy, K Anil Kumar, P Trinadha Rao, Oliver Springate-Baginski Indra Munshi Jyothis Sathyapalan Mahesh Rangarajan Madhav Gadgil
Dev Nathan, Govind Kelkar Emmanuel DSilva, B Nagnath Amita Baviskar
Pp xi + 408 ISBN 978-81-250-4716-2 2012 Rs 695
Orient Blackswan Pvt Ltd
www.orientblackswan.com
Mumbai Chennai New Delhi Kolkata Bangalore Bhubaneshwar Ernakulam Guwahati Jaipur Lucknow Patna Chandigarh Hyderabad
Contact: info@orientblackswan.com

32 september 8, 2012 vol xlviI no 36 EPW Economic & Political Weekly


PERSPECTIVES

before and brings everyday repression (EPW 2010), their lack of self-reliance politics in the state has tended to be
into the open. Their role in spreading a serves to curb their radicalism. ideologically inspired, but event sensitive.
legal awareness and rights conscious- Dalit political parties, thus, are caught For all the theoretical and rhetorical com-
ness amongst the oppressed cannot be in a double bind. Either they follow the mitment to land reforms, caste eradica-
over-stated. On the other, the sort template set by others or are condemned tion, class equality and womens rights,
of counter-mobilisation described above to remain bit-part players in a system for instance, the emphasis of each party
pits socially-dominant intermediate castes that favours the resource-rich. They are, tends to be on day-to-day issues of dis-
against those who dare to question then, impotent paternalists reduced to crimination with a few big conferences
their dominance. feeding from the scraps distributed by on the core themes to emphasise com-
As Pandian (2000) and Rajangam the two main parties. For example, VCK mitment. From this perspective the dalit
(2011, 2012b) highlight, most anti-dalit MLA Ravikumar, in this vein, hailed movements continue to be shaped by the
violence in the state is perpetrated by the DMK scheme to replace mud huts imperatives of the present, responding
the intermediate castes and occurs to with concrete houses as a triumph of to one crisis after another rather than
demonstrate that they are of higher status political participation (New Indian Express, building up an alternative (Karthikeyan
than their victims. In Parali Puthur 28 February). Failing this, they can focus 2009). Now that they have contested
(in southern Tamil Nadu) for instance, upon assertive, identity-based rhetoric elections and gained a number of politi-
intermediate caste Mutharaiyars ran- that is either symbolic such as the furore cal victories, however, voters expect more
sacked and set light to dalit homes, beat over the Ambedkar cartoon, or is rarely than empty or aggressive rhetoric. One
villagers and threatened children due realised in practice. Whether standing unintended consequence of dalit asser-
to the fact that VCK cadre dared to hoist alone or in alliance, dalit parties require tion was to compel communist parties to
their flag near the main road. In the the votes of other communities to stand take dalit issues more seriously. Now
neighbouring Pudukottai district, how- any chance of winning (Karthikeyan 2011; ironically, it is the grass-roots campaigns
ever, tea shops serve both Mutharaiyars Roberts 2010). They have, to this end, of TNUEF amongst dalits across the state
and dalits with separate glasses because increasingly adopted an assertive Tamil that has forced the dalit parties to recon-
they are seen as lower than, and as a identity and offered posts in the party nect with their own constituents.
threat towards, Kallar supremacy. Marx to non-dalits in a bid to broaden their The VCK, thus, has embarked on a
is certainly not irrelevant in this context vote-base. process of wholesale restructuring in
but it is, we would suggest, the inter- This has created a gap between the a bid to reach out to the mainstream.
mediate castes who have greater need parties and their core dalit constituents, The demand for gold to celebrate
to absorb his lessons. but has failed to expand their vote-base Thirumavalavans 50th birthday arises
significantly. In the current political dis- at this juncture. The comparison with
Caste-ing Votes pensation this means that dalit parties former UP chief minister Mayawati here
It is important to note that Tamil dalit can either stand alone and win nothing is unfair. Whilst there is an element of
politics cannot be viewed in isolation. but respect from supporters, or they self-aggrandisement, a better point of
Although it is a huge disappointment can ally with various other parties and reference might be the Bahujan Samaj
that the VCK and the PT have not been compromise on their core principles in Partys motto one member, one rupee,
able to bring about more change or apply search of political power. That allying in that the object of the gold is to bolster
pressure on their coalition allies to do so, with Dravidian parties should entail a party finances so as to launch a TV channel
we need to recognise that they operate dilution of anti-caste radicalism is, of that will provide them with a media
in a political environment that severely course, a major indictment of those parties presence. In a state where the reach of
limits their options. Dalit parties cannot but it is a pressing problem for dalit television is remarkably high due to free
win on their own in this state in part due politics. This is not, of course, a purely distribution and where each political
to the bipolar nature of politics. Where Tamil issue as seen in Campaign for party has their own channel such a focus
votes are split two or, even, three-ways Electoral Reforms in Indias (CERI) call for is understandable. Whether it should be
dalit parties simply do not have the proportionate representation to: ensure their primary focus or not is another
numbers to succeed. They need, therefore, the participation of all communities in question, but setting that aside, the call
to find likely allies. Unlike Vijayakant governance, and check all tendencies to for gold has been too easy a target for
the latest film star to enter politics they usurp...power by some caste groups in many commentators. It certainly carries
also lack the financial clout to compete. India (CERI 2009: 15). the whiff of dowry especially when party
They are therefore reduced to seeking leaders urge members to treat this as the
coalition partners who will not only New Directions? unmarried Thirumavalavans wedding.
grant them a reasonable number of con- Over the course of the past few years Take away the ever-present contradic-
stituencies from which to contest but these contradictions have increasingly tions around womens rights and the
will help bankroll their campaigns as been acknowledged by the various dalit talk of treasure, though, and what you
well. Given the high degree of monetisa- leaders who have sought to rethink and have is a party transparently seeking to
tion of Tamil politics over the past decade reconfigure where they stand. Dalit raise resources from its members. How
Economic & Political Weekly EPW september 8, 2012 vol xlviI no 36 33
PERSPECTIVES

many other parties could offer as clear a in itself (Karthikeyan 2011). More ener- Gorringe, H (2005): Untouchable Citizens: The
Dalit Panthers and Democratisation in Tamil
trail to the assets that finance(d) their gy and money is expended on seeking
Nadu (New Delhi: Sage).
media enterprises? The call for gold not elections than realising the movements (2012): Caste and Politics in Tamil Nadu,
only carries a novelty factor that encour- objectives. There is a need for clarity of Seminar, 633, May (Special Issue: Caste Matters).
ages donations, according to several res- purpose and a longer term vision that Harriss, J (2000): Successful Populism?, Frontline,
4 March, 17(5), viewed on 27 July 2012, http://
pondents it is more easily accounted for extends beyond the coalition partners www.frontlineonnet.com/fl1705/17050770.htm
than cash donations. The issue for us is of tomorrow to consider dalit liveli- Karthikeyan, D (2009): Tamil Nadus Dalit Vote,
less the emphasis on gold than whether hoods. Rather than running after and The Hindu Verdict 2009, 12 May, viewed on
27 July 2012, http://blogs.thehindu.com/elections
the money thus raised will be used to trying to please and appease potential 2009/?p=2860
good effect. The fear is that the acquisi- allies by cheering them on, offering (2011): How Dalit Politics in Tamil Nadu Lost
tion of a media channel will simply fuel them support or awarding them prizes, Track, The Hindu, 2 April, viewed on 27 July
2012, http://www.thehindu.com/news/cities/
the short-term emphasis of dalit politics dalit and communist parties could then
Madurai/article1592230.ece
in the state when it is crying out for a formulate a coherent and radical pro- (2012): Remembering the Precursor of Dravidian
longer-term vision. gramme of action that combines the Movement, The Hindu, 20 May, viewed on
In short, it would be fair to say that demands of recognition with those of 27 July 2012, http://www.thehindu.com/todays-
paper/tp-national/tp-tamilnadu/article3438425.
the dalit movement in Tamil Nadu edu- redistribution. Clearly there are com- ece
cated its constituents to some degree monalities of interest between the Lakshman, N (2011): Patrons of the Poor (New Delhi:
and agitated society for a time but has communist and dalit parties but the Oxford University Press).
Mendelsohn, O and M Vicziany (1998): The
failed to properly organise itself. Dalit onus must be on the former with their Untouchables (Cambridge: CUP).
parties still lack infrastructure, estab- national level standing and resources Pandian, M S S (2000): Dalit Assertion in Tamil-
lished secondary leaders, local offices to take the lead. It is perhaps from nadu: An Explanatory Note, Journal of Indian
School of Political Economy, XII(3 & 4): 501-17.
and sustained, ideologically-driven cam- meetings such as that at W Pudhupatti
Rajangam, S (2011): Rise of Dalit Movements and
paigns. As such they have failed to move that an alternative politics which chal- the Reaction of Dravidian Parties in K Satya-
onto next level as they promised to do lenges the hegemony of the Dravidian narayana and S Tharu (ed.), No Alphabet in
Sight: New Dalit Writing from South India (New
when they entered elections as a Third parties and truly addresses the needs
Delhi: Penguin).
Front in 1999. Unless this period of of the impoverished and subordinated (2012a): Villupuram Padukolai, 1978 (Villu-
introspection results in a change of masses can emerge. puram Murders, 1978) (Nagercoil: Kalachuvadu).
direction, dalit politics will continue to (2012b): Dalit Identity: Shades of Approval
in D Ravikumar and R Azhagarasan (ed.), The
be characterised by an emphasis on Notes Oxford Anthology of Tamil Dalit Writing (New
symbolism and identity. Worse still, 1 The empirical detail in this article is drawn Delhi: Oxford University Press), pp 194-208.
from recent research carried out by the three
even as caste walls between dalits and authors. Gorringe has conducted research on
Roberts, N (2010): Language, Violence, and the
State: Writing Tamil Dalits, South Asia Multi-
caste Hindus have been dismantled, Tamil dalit politics (ESRC Grant RES-062-23- disciplinary Academic Journal 3: http://samaj.
new walls have taken root between dif- 3348), as a reporter for The Hindu Karthikeyan
revues.org/index2952.html
frequently covers issues related to dalit politics,
ferent dalit castes. The absorption of and Rajangam has conducted extensive research Subramanian, N (1999): Ethnicity & Populist
on dalits and dalit politics across the state most Mobilisation (New Delhi: OUP).
brahminical values of hierarchy and un-
recently for his 2012 book on the Villupuram Swamy, A (1998): Parties, Political Identities and
touchability by dalits represents per- riots in 1978 (Rajangam 2012a). the Absence of Mass Political Violence in South
haps the single biggest failure of, and 2 For detailed accounts of the interplay between India in A Kohli and A Basu (ed.), Community
caste and Dravidianism see: Karthikeyan 2009, Conflict & The State in India (New Delhi:
challenge to, Tamil dalit movements. 2011, 2012; Lakhsman 2007; Rajangam 2012b; Oxford University Press), pp 108-48.
Adversity can occasionally lead to Subramanian 1999; Wyatt 2009.
Wyatt, A (2009): Party System Change in South
opportunities, however, and recent intra- 3 Pasumpon Muthuramalinga Thevar was a India (Abingdon: Routledge).
Forward Bloc leader who mobilised members
dalit caste violence in W Pudhupatti of the intermediate Kallar, Maravar and
compelled dalit leaders to come together Agamudayar castes who comprise the Thevar
caste category. Immanuel Sekaran was a Pallar
with the CPI(M) in July 2012 in search of dalit leader who fought against caste discrimi- Style Sheet for Authors
possible solutions. This meeting was nation and dominance and was murdered
during caste clashes in 1957. While preparing their articles for submission,
hosted by Yakkan, a dalit intellectual,
contributors are requested to follow EPWs
who is one step removed from the com-
References style sheet.
pulsions of politics. His intervention re-
minds us that dalit liberation cannot Bate, B (2009): Tamil Oratory and the Dravidian The style sheet is posted on EPWs web site at
Aesthetic: Democratic Practice in South India http://www.epw.in/terms-policy/style-
and should not be left in the hands (New York: Columbia).
of dalit parties alone. Dalit unions, CERI (2009): Manifesto (Tumkur: CERI).
sheet.html
intellectuals, administrators and organ- De Neve, G and G Carswell (2011): NREGA and the It will help immensely for faster processing
Return of Identity Politics in Western Tamil
isations have a key role to play too. Dalit Nadu, India, Forum for Development Studies,
and error-free editing if writers follow the
movements need to accept practical 38(2): 205-10. guidelines in the style sheet, especially with
guidance and advice from outside since EPW (2010): Perfecting Patronage, Editorial, regard to citation and preparation of
Economic & Political Weekly, Vol XLV(50): 9.
electoral politics, which was initially references.
(2012): Dalits in Tamil Nadu, Economic &
seen as a tactic, has now become an end Political Weekly, 21 July, Vol XLVII(29): 9.

34 september 8, 2012 vol xlviI no 36 EPW Economic & Political Weekly

También podría gustarte