Está en la página 1de 4

suits of his research on the involvement of the pitui- concerned parties.

They regard this kind of meeting


tary and the adrenal cortex in the anesthetic effect as a means to improve the welfare of everybody and
induced by acupuncture in white rats. We also met prevent the emergence of an elite group of people who
Professor Chang Hsiang-Tong (a Yale University enjoy special privileges. At the same time this lets
PhD) and his co-workers in the Shanghai Institute of people know of others' needs and feelings so that they
Physiology of the Academy of Sciences. They are become more concerned and sensitive toward each
actively engaged in neurophysiological research. other and the society. This I feel is not unlike what
The Chinese use the shuttle box or Skinner box to we aim to accomplish in our sensitivity or encounter
study memory and retention. The EEG is used for sessions.
localization studies of brain functions, and analyses Psychology is well and vigorously alive in China.
of chemical changes, particularly of neurotransmitters Although there is no comparison to psychology in the
and maoromolecules such as RNA and protein, have United States in terms of multiplicity of areas, the
been done. They also use drugs to analyze the brain Chinese beliefs that science should serve people and
functions related to learning and memory. that the researcher should never become divorced from
One final observation is that almost every week the masses are something all of us can understand.
the Chinese have political meetings where the par-
ticipants can express their gripes and criticize the
REFERENCES
system, people, or themselves. They often criticize
the way the profit is distributed, those who are not Dimond, E. G. Medical school curriculum in the People's
working hard, the responsible person who is uncon- Republic of China. Journal of the American Medical
cerned about their welfare, the quality of the doctor's Association, 1976, 236, 1489-1491.
service, or even that a woman's husband is not co- Kessen, W. Childhood in China. New Haven, Conn.:
Yale University Press, 1975.
operative enough in household chores. The group tries Walls, P. D., Walls, L. H., & Langsley, D. G. Psychiatric
to solve the problems by changing the system or by training and practice in the People's Republic of China.
criticizing, persuading, and mediating between the American Journal of Psychiatry, 1975, 132, 121-128.

Mental Health Care in the USSR

VYTAUTAS J. BIELIAUSKAS Xavier (Ohio) University

ABSTRACT: The author received a scientist exchange some aspects of research in the area of mental health.
grant from the National Institutes of Health and visited Mental health services in the USSR are provided primarily
the USSR as a health-science representative from May 29 by the medical profession through state mental hospitals
to July 1, 1976. He had an opportunity to work with the and psychiatric sections in general hospitals and clinics.
University of Vilnius and to visit the Bekhterev Institute Drug therapy is the main treatment method used there,
in Moscow, the University of Moscow, and the Institute but psychotherapy is beginning to make some inroads.
of Psychiatry of the Academy of Science of the USSR. Relationships between psychiatry and psychology are
His special interests dealt with mental health care, aca- experiencing some problems in the USSR, but in some
demic and professional status of clinical psychology, and republics they seem to progress amicably. Family therapy
settings are the newest additions to preventive mental
health care.
Preparation of this article was made possible through a
travel grant from the John E. Fogarty International Cen- Since 1957, when a document of cooperation in health
ter of the National Institute of Health, U.S. Department programs was signed by the United States and the
of Health, Education, and Welfare.
I wish to express my appreciation to the authorities of USSR (see Quinn, 1969), individuals and delegations
the United States and the USSR for their support of my from both countries have been able to exchange visits,
travel and for their hospitality and cooperation. A special learn about methodologies and health care procedures
note of thanks belongs to my professional colleagues in from each other, and exchange ideas in the areas of
Lithuania, Moscow, and Leningrad.
Requests for reprints should be sent to Vytautas J. research and prevention. Most visitors have been
Bieliauskas, Department of Psychology, Xavier (Ohio) members of the medical profession, with the exception
University, Cincinnati, Ohio 45207. of representatives of the mental health professions

376 MAY 1977 AMERICAN PSYCHOLOGIST


which, at least from the American point of view, which implements directives from Moscow, sometimes
include psychologists and social workers. Inclusion of in a semiautonomous manner (Storey, 1970). In
a representative of other than the medical profession Lithuania (as in the other republics), the Ministry of
is still the exception in this program, because the Health includes a section dealing with mental health.
healing arts of all types in the USSR are in the hands This section operates under the direction of the Neuro-
of its medical profession, which has a difficult time pathologist of the Republic. Since mental health
understanding that nonphysicians (e.g., clinical psy- services are provided through state hospitals, the main
chologists) can be involved in independent diagnosis, task of the Neuropathologist is to supervise these
treatment, and research in mental health. hospitals. However, under the newest five-year plan
There are also problems with governmental sub- ("The Soviet Five-Year Plan for Public Health,"
divisions that do not follow parallel lines in both 1973), some ambulant treatment is being provided in
countries. Our Department of Health, Education, and the polyclinics, the network of which is being expanded.
Welfare (DHEW) has partial counterparts in various Therefore, a position of the Psychiatrist of the Re-
independent departments of the USSR such as the public has recently been established in the Ministry
Ministry of Health, the Ministry of Education, and the of Health, and the holder of this post is specifically
Ministry of Higher Education. Since the ministries concerned with organization of the mental health units
in the USSR are quite independent in their bureauc- in the clinics. The psychiatry section seems to be
racies, communication problems are presented when very much concerned with treatment and prevention
DHEW tries to deal with its counterparts in the in the area of mental health and is therefore much
USSR, especially when interests cross the boundaries more open to alternative treatment methods. In the
of different ministries. My own peculiarly "complex" area of prevention, strong interests were shown in
status can be given as an example of one such problem. adolescent therapy, family therapy, and coping with
I was interested in visiting the University of Vilnius, drug abuse. Lithuania is proud of being the first re-
which belongs to the Ministry of Higher Education public to establish a family therapy center (in
and works also with clinical psychologists and psychia- Vilnius). In the area of drug abuse, probably the most
trists in health installations under the jurisdiction of abused drug is alcohol, and the Ministry of Health is
the Ministry of Health. My original invitation came embarking on a strong campaign to curb alcoholism.
from the University of Vilnius, but my travel as an
exchange scientist was approved by our National Insti-
MENTAL HOSPITALS
tutes of Health (NIH). For some time it looked as if
all our efforts would be lost in what appeared to be According to statistics in 1960, there were 2,425 hos-
insurmountable bureaucratic chaos. However, to my pital beds for mental patients in Lithuania, located in
great surprise, the red tape was cut with the greatest six institutions (Kleiza, 1972). No new statistics were
of ease in a very brief time. made available to me, but my educated guess would be
I had an opportunity to spend brief periods of time that in 1976, there were at least 3,500 mental patients
in Leningrad and Moscow, which was very beneficial in various mental hospitals. The equivalents of our
and interesting, but my mastery of the Lithuanian lan- state mental hospitals appear well-kept on the outside,
guage enabled me to be a much more active participant but a foreign visitor is carefully prevented from having
in the exchange program in Lithuania. There is no much of an opportunity to see the inside of an institu-
doubt that there are differences among Soviet republics tion. From what little I was able to see, the mental
not only in language and culture, but also in scientific hospitals there did not differ much from our state hos-
achievements and methods of service delivery. How- pitals, but the staff members were somewhat embar-
ever, the similarities surprisingly surpass the differ- rassed that their hospitals didn't look any better (one
ences. The main training and research centers in the would wish that the staff of some of the state mental
USSR are in Moscow and Leningrad, and this is where hospitals in the United States would feel justifiably
the beginnings of innovations and new trends come more embarrassed because of the status of their
from. From these centers, the knowledge is then dis- institutions).
tributed to all the republics. This pattern of dis- The main method of treatment in these hospitals is
semination of knowledge applies not only to health drug therapy. The USSR's pharmaceutical factories
care and mental health care but to all other areas of produce their own psychotropic drugs, which, in many
Soviet life as well. respects, are similar to tranquilizers, psychoenergizers,
etc., produced in the United States. These drugs are
Mental Health Care used extensively in the treatment of mental patients.
Schizophrenia and depression are apparently the most
Mental health care in the USSR is under the juris- frequently encountered diagnostic categories. If, after
diction-of the Ministry of Health. The Central Min- a prolonged period of time, a patient's condition
istry of Health has its counterpart in each republic, doesn't improve or if a patient becomes chronic, he

AMERICAN PSYCHOLOGIST MAY 1977 377


is usually transferred to special centers for "invalids," tween psychology and psychiatry. They are not
where drug therapy is continued as an auxiliary to greatly concerned with who is doing what but are
custodial care. rather interested in developing better skills and pro-
viding better service to the patients. This cooperation
PSYCHIATRIC SECTIONS AT CLINICS AND HOSPITALS
again is coming from Leningrad; the situation in
Moscow is completely different. There, psychologists
Psychiatric sections at various clinics and general hos- administer some tests and do researchany kind of
pitals can be looked upon as Soviet counterparts to therapy is strictly the domain of the physician.
the community mental health centers in the United
States. These sections are only in an initial stage at UNIVERSITIES
present. Since this represents innovation, new treat-
ment methods are also being searched for. Psycho- Universities are the training and research centers for
therapy is beginning to make some inroads, but at professionals in the field of mental health. However,
present there is only one school attempting to develop due to the complicated structure of Soviet ministries,
training programs for psychotherapists. These at- training and research can be conducted by the Insti-
tempts are being made at the Psychology Department tutes of the Academies of Science of the USSR and
of the University of Leningrad. of different republics. Therefore, some training and
Psychology itself has only recently gained recogni- research takes place under university auspices and
tion in the USSR (cf. Brozek & Mecacci, 1974), and some takes place under the auspices of different
clinical psychology is fighting for its recognition within institutes subject to different ministries. Students and
the profession. The Soviet scene is still dominated faculty members are very much interested in foreign
by Pavlovian thinking radiated from Moscow, and this scientists and especially in their lectures. I gave a
does not provide a good atmosphere for psychotherapy. series of 10 lectures at the University of Vilnius, the
However, Leningrad is slowly 'becoming a center for Medical Institute of Kaunas, and the Ministry of
applied psychology, while Moscow remains the strong- Health. No restrictions were imposed on my lectures,
hold of the "purists-scientists." Therefore, testing and the questions were interesting and the discussions
and psychological diagnostic methods have much more lively. My lectures included such topics as motivation
fertile ground in Leningrad. Younger professionals and the will, sociopsychological bases in psychiatry,
have become familiar with Western diagnostic tech- recent research findings concerning psychological as-
niques such as the Minnesota Multiphasic Personality pects of sexual differences, projective testing and the
Inventory (MMPI), the Wechsler intelligence scales, House-Tree-Person Test (H-T-P), etc., which have
the Science Completion Test (SCT), the Rorschach obvious humanistic overtones and which I delivered
Test, and the Thematic Apperception Test (cf. Jovaisa, with the same content as I would have done at home
1975). At present, they have translated some of these in the United States. This fact led me to conclude
techniques, but they need to restandardize them in that there is probably greater freedom for exchange of
order to be able to use them locally. Younger psy- information in the USSR than we are accustomed to
chologists and psychiatrists are very much interested believe. My audience showed a great deal of familiar-
in psychotherapy, but it will be some time before ity with our literature and with the literature of the
training programs can be developed for young profes- West in general. My hosts gave me to understand
sionals. They all know that it is very difficult to that they would appreciate it if I would avoid political
learn the skills of psychotherapy from books only. and theological topics in my discussion, which I had
Clinical psychology is quite new in Lithuania because no difficulty doing because these topics are not in the
psychology is new. The University of Vilnius has only field of my expertise. There is no question that a
in recent years opened a psychology chair in the certain amount of suspicion and paranoia tended to
Department of Journalism. Among a teaching staff of develop on both sides, but such experience is inevi-
two dozen, there is not a single faculty member in table in a closed political system such as that of the
psychology with a PhD. Most of these faculty are USSR. This is associated with the level of insecurity
young scientists preparing their dissertations to be we all experienced. In the centers such as Leningrad
defended at either Leningrad or Moscow Universities. and Moscow, my hosts were more secure and more re-
Undoubtedly, many of them will complete their work laxed, and therefore I felt the same way in those cities.
soon, and this is only a temporary situation.
There is an interesting phenomenon concerning RESEARCH IN MENTAL HEALTH
training in clinical psychologynamely, the fact that
several physicians, upon receiving additional training, The most impressive research is conducted not in the
have switched from medicine to psychology and are provinces but in the centers. In Leningrad, the
working as clinical psychologists. Therefore, there Bekhterev Institute represents the avant-garde in ap-
seems to be a very pleasant working relationship be- plied research in mental health. Bekhterev Institute

378 MAY 1977 AMERICAN PSYCHOLOGIST


is a treatment and training center that includes a and interest in it represents a more recent priority in
mental hospital, a rehabilitation training center, and the USSR. The equivalents of our state hospitals are
research and diagnostic facilities. Neuropsychology is primarily dependent upon drug therapy, but the newly
still the most predominant field of interest. The developing psychiatric units in clinics and general hos-
preferred research uses physiological and psychophys- pitals are searching for alternative methods of treat-
ical measures and involves problems of cerebral local- ment. This trend is also beginning to spread among
ization, the organic basis of schizophrenic hallucina- the state mental health institutions. Interest in
tions, and patterns of perception (Bazhin, Meerson, psychotherapy is vivid, but training centers for profes-
& Tonkonogii, 1973; Bazhin, Wasserman, & Tonkonogii, sional psychotherapists are lacking. Once psycho-
197S; Gorian, Meyerson, Tonkonogii, & Tsukerman, therapy achieves more acceptance, the problem will
1972). At the same time, a great deal of interest is be one of how to fit this method of therapy into the
being shown in restandardization of the local versions Soviet system, which emphasizes group rather than indi-
of the MMPI, SCT, and the H-T-P, which I brought vidual values. Clinical psychology and psychiatry are
with me (cf. Bieliauskas, 1972). very young disciplines in the USSR, and they are rep-
The University and the Institutes in Moscow are resented by young professionals who are enthusiastic
dominated by the "purists." An excellent experimen- and forward looking.
talist, Bluma Zeigarnik (known in the United States This attempt to appraise mental health care in the
as the discoverer of the Zeigarnik effect), is carefully USSR is based primarily on the author's experience in
researching thinking patterns in schizophrenics. Her the Republic of Lithuania. However, since there is
former student Yury F. Polyakov, now chief of the a surprising uniformity in the application of the prin-
Pathopsychology Laboratories of the Institute of ciples developed in Moscow in all republics, one can
Psychiatry of the USSR Academy of Sciences, is in safely assume that the above observations do apply to
charge of a research project dealing with cognitive all other parts of the USSR. Lithuania is an active
disturbance in schizophrenia, and some of his 'findings participant in medical research and treatment innova-
will be published soon in the NIH Schizophrenia Bul- tions, and therefore, mental health care may be even
letin. Both Zeigarnik and Polyakov are excellent re- more advanced there than in other Soviet republics.
search scientists, but they are "purists" in the sense
that they show very little interest in the treatment of REFERENCES
mental illness. Treatment, in their opinion, belongs to
physicians. They could not see how a clinical psy- Bazhin, E. F., Meerson, Y. A., & Tonkonogii, I. M. On
distinguishing a visual signal from noise by patients with
chologist could do anything else except research and visual agnosia and visual hallucinations. Neuropsycho-
diagnostic testing. Of course, this point of view would logia, 1973, 11, 319-324.
be supported by A. R. Luria, B. F. Lomov, and others Bazhin, E. F., Wasserman, L. I., & Tonkonogii, I. M.
who are also professors at the University of Moscow. Auditory hallucinations and left temporal lobe pathol-
The "purist" approach in the academies of sciences ogy. Neuropsychoiogia, 1975, 13, 481-487.
Bieliauskas, V. J. House-tree-person (H-T-P) research
and in the university-sponsored health and mental review (3rd ed.). Los Angeles: Western Psychological
health research is quite in agreement with the research Services, 1972.
philosophy of these institutions. Applied health re- Brozek, J., & Mecacci, L. New Soviet Research Institute
search belongs to the domain of the Ministry of of Psychology. American Psychologist, 1974, 29, 475-478.
Health. However, the Ministry of Health priorities Gorian, I. S., Meyerson, J. S., Tonkonogii, I. M., &
Tsukerman, I. I. On perception of pattern with sta-
do not include psychological problems (cf. Quinn, tistical characteristics. Neuropsychoiogia, 1972, 10,
1973). Psychology must find a "piggy-back" place 97-102.
among work on cardiovascular research projects or Jovaisa, L. Psichologine diagnostika, Kaunas, Lithuania:
projects dealing with oncology, genetics, and social Sviesa, 1975.
hygiene. There are indications that future priorities Kleiza, V. Health services in Lithuania. Vilnius, Lith-
may involve psychology, but this, again, will take time, uania: Gintaras, 1972.
Quinn, J. R. Anatomy of east-west cooperation: U.S.-
because everything requires time and a great deal of VSSR public health exchange program, 1958~>1967.
patience in the USSR. Bethesda, Md.: John E. Fogarty International Center
for Advanced Study in the Health Sciences, 1969.
Summary and Conclusions Quinn, J. R. Soviet medical research priorities for the
seventies (DREW Publication No. NIH-74-422).
Mental health care, as general health care, in the Washington, D.C.: U.S. Government Printing Office,
USSR is free and supposedly accessible to everyone. 1973.
Since all the health facilities are state-owned and all The soviet five-year plan for public health (DHEW Publi-
the practitioners are state employees, it is very diffi- cation No. NIH-74-59). Washington, D. C.: U.S. Gov-
ern Printing Office, 1973.
cult to compare the Soviet system with our own sys- Storey, P. B. (Ed.). Medical care in the USSR (DHEW
tem, which depends to a large extent upon the con- Publication No. NIH-72-60). Washington, D.C.: U.S.
tributions of the private sector. Mental health care Government Printing Office, 1970.

AMERICAN PSYCHOLOGIST MAY 1977 379

También podría gustarte