Documentos de Académico
Documentos de Profesional
Documentos de Cultura
Questions/Scenarios to Consider
Vocal Health/Pedagogy
Non-Musical Considerations
Demorest, 2000
Harrison, 2004
Warzecha, 2013
Defense of Girls
Gauthier, 2005
WHAT HAS MUSIC RESEARCH SAID
SO FAR ABOUT GENDER?
Instruments and Gender: Studied continually since the 1970s
e.g., Abrahams, 2012; Freer, 2009; Gates, 1989; Harrison, 2007, 2010;
Kennedy, 2002; Koza, 1993a, 1993b; Legg, 2013; Manovski, 2013
Gendered participation in music
Silveira & Goff, 2016 Survey Study gauging attitudes of music educators
about teaching trans students
Sweet & Bergonzi, 2016 Exploring the voice change with adolescents using a
trans vocal perspective
OUR PURPOSE
Bergonzi, 2009 Music Educators Journal
Heterosexual privilege
This slide was Jakes idea when he and
I did the session in Michigan. Not sure
What does gender variance look like in a Bergonzi-like framework?
we need it but something along these
lines might be helpful- especially the
stu in the notes about masculinity/
Masculinity/femininity in choir
Musical Issues
Non-Musical/Social
Issues
TRANS VOCAL HEALTH &
PEDAGOGY
MUSICAL CONSIDERATIONS
TRANSGENDER STUDENTS
AND MUSICAL ISSUES
Language in Rehearsal
Standing Formations
Taylor
Cisgender-centric
Heteronormative
Gendered choirs?
NON-MUSICAL
CONSIDERATIONS
OBAMA ADMINISTRATION
RECOMMENDATIONS
(a) not discriminate against trans students and take steps to prevent
[discrimination],
(b) treat trans students in keeping with their gender identity, which
includes giving access to the appropriate gendered bathroom,
changing room, and overnight accommodation;
(c) [use] the name and pronouns used by the student; and [allow]
them to dress in accordance with their gender identity, and
(d) keep a students trans status, birth name, and gender assignment
at birth confidential.
--Genny Beemyn, personal communication, 7/27/16.
Caveat:
New Administration,
New Policies
2/15/2017 Trump Drops Defense of Obama Guidelines on Transgender Students - The New York Times
https://nyti.ms/2kxH36S
POLITICS
Gender-neutral pronouns:
Uniforms
Pronouns
Rosters
Programs
LARGER ISSUES OF GENDER
Binary to Ternary - Problem Solved?
Gender
Voice
Identity
(c)
(b)
Gender
Identity
Gender Voice
Voice
Identity
Recommendations for teachers (these assume that
the choir teacher knows that they have a trans
student):
(1) speak with the student and ask about their name
and pronouns
Billy Sauerland
Chabot College
Teachers College, Columbia University
wmopera@yahoo.com