Documentos de Académico
Documentos de Profesional
Documentos de Cultura
In the criminal justice system, the people are represented by two separate
yet equally important groups- the police who investigate crime, and the
district attorneys who prosecute the offenders.
These are their stories.
Attendant: Must've been a good party.
All parties are good after 12:00 and before 3:00.
woman: You think Sara-Louise drinks too much? You were counting? Just
jealous.
I can't touch a drop if we're really going to start trying.
You really want to? Don't you? As long as I don't have to do the 2:00 feeding.
Honey, the flowers.
My brother, he said ain't no woman good enough for him.
Including his wife.
Attendant: It came from the garage.
Can she talk? Yeah, at the hospital.
Yeah, the good citizens outside, they heard screams.
And they fell all over each other trying to help, right? Robbery? Her purse
was empty and his wallet's gone.
It's probably in a garbage can a block away.
ID? Car registration.
Ralston, Janet, Alan.
They live a block away.
In the stairwell.
Crack pipe.
Still warm.
witnesses? all blind.
Car like that? Should've bought a clunker, spent the money on a better
neighborhood.
Or one at least more than a half a block from a police precinct.
Those people, how much paper they got? A couple of hundred grand? I was
them, I'd have me a driver.
You don't even have a car.
If I had a car.
And if I did, it wouldn't be no Lincoln.
Ladies, you see anybody at all? No, I ain't hear nothing, I ain't seen nothing.
That's what she's good at- nothing.
Man: He was black.
A kid.
Came out that door running.
Max: You get a look at him? The designated driver says he saw a kid.
How many fingers? Three.
Doctor:.
Mrs.
Ralston was very lucky.
Lucky? She lost her husband.
Ralston.
Excuse me.
Could you help us out here, Mrs.
Ralston? Mr.
Himes was in the garage that night.
He got home late.
Logan: You know what I think? I think you and Mr.
Himes are having an affair.
I think your boyfriend shot your husband.
I think the DA is going to charge you as an accessory to the crime.
I think you're too smart not to cooperate.
Oh God.
I was having an affair, but I broke it off.
Something must have happened, because he got really enraged and he
snapped.
He came after Alan and I, and he shot us.
Judge: The charges are murder in the second degree and assault in the first
degree.
Does the defendant wish to enter a plea? Lawyer:.
Your Honor, if we may, we question whether the prosecutor's information
merits our client being held.
Mr.
Shell, you got to the door, but you didn't knock.
If you're questioning the merits, does that mean you want a hearing? No.
No, Your Honor.
Then let's have the defendant enter a plea.
Mr.
Himes? Not guilty.
Shell: Your Honor, Mr.
Himes is a substantial member of the community, and has no criminal
record.
we ask that he be released on- If you're suggesting "own recognizance," the
answer is no.
This is two felonies, one of them a homicide.
Mr.
Stone? we'd like to guarantee Mr.
Himes appears, Your Honor.
Bail is set at $200,000.
Cash or bond.
Murder in the second degree, Stone? You have to show the public you go
after the rich? Your client killed in cold blood- I don't care if he's homeless or
owns Grand Central Station.
You get murder two from the grand jury - it's abusive.
Under extreme emotional disturbance, you're lucky if you get manslaughter
two, and you know it.
Emotionally disturbed do not plan as well as Himes did.
The gun? we got word from Kentucky, Tennessee, Delaware and North
Carolina.
No luck.
And that leaves? we'd better get lucky with Virginia.
A year ago, right after Janet was mugged.
Richmond, Virginia.
Tracy's Field and Sports Shop.
A sporting gun? If you're hunting people.
Beretta model 94, blowback semi-automatic.
9mm.
Sold to Himes, Gilbert? And not to Ralston, Janet, either.
Ralston, Alan? They stick to their stories, the worst we get him for is maybe
man two.
She still gets a walk.
She's already set up a diminished capacity defense for him.
She said he looked crazy.
Stone: You used Alan's gun, didn't you, Mr.
Himes? I love Janet Ralston.
Shell: You want to talk a deal? I want to talk guns.
How'd you get the Beretta? Did she give it to you before the party? No more
questions, Stone, till you put a proposal on the table.
He rolls on Mrs.
Ralston, comes up with some evidence, manslaughter one.
That's not a proposal.
That's an insult! Come on, Gil.
Himes really does love her.
Maybe he loves manslaughter two more.
we don't find out how it went down, we may have to offer it to him.
Then let's find out how it went down.
Max: Let's start over, Willie.
Look, how many times I got to tell you? Max: The lights go out, then what? I
hear a scream, then a shot.
Right after the lights went out? Huh-uh, same time.
Run that past me again.
Look, the lights went off.
I hear a shot.
The door opens, what, a couple seconds later? I hear two more shots, I get
the hell out of there.
If the light was out, how do you know the door opened? 'Cause light came in
from the garage.
After the first shot? Am I talking too fast? That's what I said.
Lights off, then bang.
Door opens, bang, bang.
Logan: willie fires up a rock, the light goes out.
The first shot came before the door opened.
Then the door opens, then there's two more shots.
But if it's Himes coming down the stairs, and it is, he goes to the light- He
unscrews it.
Stone: He hasn't opened the door yet.
A gun goes off.
So who shot Alan Ralston? Max: Is Willie a good enough witness? Good
enough for me.
Pick her up.
Janet Ralston, you're under arrest for the murder of Alan Ralston.
You have the right to remain silent and refuse to answer questions.
Anything you do say may be used against you in a court of law Stone: So
you're saying the first shot came before the door opened.
Mm-hmm.
Lights out, bang.
Then door opens.
But after the lights went out, a couple of seconds later, another two shots.
Bang, bang.
Thank you.
No further questions, Your Honor.
Mr.
Tivnan- what were you doing on the stairs of the garage? Smoking crack.
Uh-huh.
Your habit, how much does it cost? $200 a day.
Oh.
Do you have a job, Mr.
Tivnan? Objection, Your Honor, his employment has nothing to do with his
testimony.
Mr.
Tivnan's state of mind is at issue here.
Overruled.
The witness will answer.
I sell books, magazines on the streets.
Does that pay for your crack habit? People do a lot of reading.
Thank you, Mr.
Tivnan.
In your autopsy, you examined the entrance wound on Mr.
Ralston's body? Yes, I did.
what were your findings? Light powder burns on Mr.
Ralston's tux indicated the gun had fired at a distance of approximately three
feet.
The bullet entered Mr.
Ralston at the bottom of the Thorax.
It traveled upward.
It pierced his right lung and then entered his heart.
From that description, Mr.
Borak, can you tell the height of the person who fired the gun? Yes, I could.
From the angle of the bullet's entry, The person who shot him would have to
be no taller than 5'6".
In other words, someone shorter than Mr.
Ralston.
Yes, that's right.
Nothing further, Your Honor.
If I told you the floor of that garage slopes, would that affect your estimation
of the height of the gunman you described? Yes, yes, it would.
Good.
It slopes.
So it's possible Mr.
Ralston was shot by a 6' man standing at the bottom of a sloping floor? Yes,
that is possible- Thank you.
Nothing further, Your Honor.
Mrs.
Stark, this was some months ago.
Do you remember the Ralstons? Yes.
They were a nice looking couple on vacation.
Just come from the mountains.
Did Mr.
Ralston knowwhat kind of gun he wanted to buy? He didn't know anything
about guns, so I showed him some nice personal weapons.
And he picked one out? The missus, she kept telling him that they had to
have it.
He told her he did not want the gun in the house- that one of the kids might
get his head blown off.
She kept reminding him that she had been mugged on the street.
So Mr.
Ralston didn't want to buy a gun? No, it was Mrs.
Ralston who was all steamed up.
She insisted that he buy the Beretta.
Thank you.
No further questions.
It's your meeting.
Himes battered Mrs.
Ralston emotionally, but she never believed him when he said he would kill
her and her husband.
After he shot you, Mrs.
Ralston, you didn't go to the police.
I told you- I was frightened.
The only thing Mrs.
Ralston might've done wrong was to mention where Mr.
Ralston kept his gun.
Nevertheless, we will plead criminal facilitation four, conspiracy five, and
she'll testify against Mr.
Himes.
Stone.
Oh, yes, I do, Mrs.
Ralston.
I scare you a great deal.
And I should.
There's another offer on the table from Mrs.
Ralston.
This is an idiotic game.
She's up from two misdemeanors to jail time.
we'll take manslaughter two.
You'll have to do better than that.
Manslaughter one, he produces the weapon, and he tells the jury how he
planned it.
whoever gets to my door first.
You knowwhy we're here.
You can't do this, Stone.
Last chance, ladies and gentlemen.
You've got nothing.
Manslaughter one.
Sold.
You damn fool! we would've been acquitted.
They've got nothing.
God, you are a pathetic, limp- Oh God! You are a such a gutless-! Himes: She
came to me with the plan.
Stone: What did Mrs.
Ralston suggest? Himes: She would tell Alan she had been mugged- would
force him to buy a gun.
was there more to the plan? Yes.
She told me I would have to shoot her, too.
I said, "what?" She said I would shoot her after she shot him.
Stone: On the night of the shootings, did the plan go awry? I was supposed
to be there before she shot Alan.
But he saw the gun in her hand, so she had to shoot him before he came into
the stairwell.
who shot Mrs.
Ralston? I did.
Is this gun, marked "People's Exhibit 26," the one you used the night of the
shootings? Yes.
Now, Mr.
Himes, please tell the jury what happened after Mrs.
Ralston talked to the police at the Hamstead Hotel.
She called me - Janet called me from a payphone.
Told me I was going to be arrested and I should go along with it.
I said she was going to hang us both.
Stone: What were her exact words? She said, "You dumb son of a bitch.
You'll get manslaughter two.
Minimum sentence.
Out in a third.
Less than two years.
" "we'll have each other, " she said.
"And the money.
" Has the jury reached a verdict? we have, Your Honor.
will the defendant please rise? On the first count of the indictment, the
charge of murder in the second degree, how does the jury find? we find the
defendant guilty.
Judge: On the second count of the indictment, j conspiracy in the first
degree, how does the jury find? we find the defendant guilty.
Janet Ralston's planning to sue her lawyer.
She doesn't quit.
You reach any conclusions? I'm trying to forget her.
Two men in love with her.
Kills one, ready to sell out the other.
what is it? Greed? Power? Evil? I thought you didn't believe in evil.
I never met Janet Ralston before.
She's either evil or she's two years old.
She wants what she wants when she wants it.
That's cute.
Episode 6
Narrator:.
In the criminal justice system, the people are represented by two separate
yet equally important groups- the police who investigate crime, and the
district attorneys who prosecute the offenders.
These are their stories.
I want the Caddy.
I ' m happy with the velour, not even leather.
I'm happy.
What do I end up with? A damn Asian ant-box.
Must have forgot their keys.
Hold it, we got a vic.
Cop #2: Watch it, Eddie, he's got a gun! Cop #2: Eddie, forget the kid! This
guy's checking out.
Since when's a ham sandwich $2.
75, Jesus? Since last Friday.
I didn't know ptomaine had gone up.
we don't use none of that.
It's all homemade.
what? we got a 10-20.
Could be a homicide.
Vic conscious? Nope.
we always arrest innocent people, huh? who's this jerk hang with? How's
Tremaine these days? I ain't seen him.
It's amazing how you homeboys are always apart.
Tremaine Lewis- I got his address upstairs.
Simonize lives with his grandmother.
Grandmother? You the man? we sure are, honey.
woman: Who is it? Max: Police, Mrs.
Jackson.
You sure this paper says you can do that even when he ain't here? Yes,
ma'am.
That's a search warrant signed by a judge.
Mrs.
Jackson: First time the police ever brought up a search warrant.
Simon done something real bad this time, huh? Yes, ma'am it looks that way.
Lots of noise.
Plenty of warning.
Tremaine Lewis- NYPD! Max: Drop the gun, Tremaine! Max: Give it up! Max:
Look at me when I'm talking to you! If the councilman croaks, you guys move
up to the bigs- murder two.
we're telling you the truth.
we didn't do nothing to him.
You guys willing to swear you two were together the whole night? You got
that right.
You knowwhat we found in Simonize's apartment? I ain't never seen that.
Simonize, you holding out on your main man? That is the vic's watch.
Anybody want to make a deal? You didn't plead these guys, did you? we're
still talking.
Stop.
The councilman? Nowwait a damn minute! He's saying the dude croaked? I'm
saying, you blew it.
Look, he was already cut when we got there.
we took him off, but we didn't do nothing to him.
He started to choke.
He was just lying there bleeding.
It was that white cat in the Benz.
He got out as soon as the truck pulled off.
what truck? I've been thinking about yesterday.
That was great.
I thought Halsey had croaked.
Max: Tony Hallowell? Yeah? I'm Detective Greevey, this is Detective Logan.
Is there a problem? Dispatcher said you made a late delivery on Tuesday
night.
Uh-huh.
Max: Anybody else here when you arrived? Just the night man.
He was inside.
Outside? Yeah.
Then mention to Stone that Deputy Commander Jefferson has been nosing
around.
Tell him I thought he'd like to know.
You're new, aren't you? How long you been with Stone? Eight months.
Must be a record.
See you in court.
Must be out.
No answer.
You guys just got lucky.
Here he comes.
I hate pit bulls.
If he drops the leash, shoot the dog first.
Go over there.
Anthony Scalisi I have a warrant for your arrest.
Don't move.
what's the charge? Assault with a deadly weapon, and the attempted murder
of Charles Halsey.
"Spuds" moves, you're history.
Criminal possession of a weapon in the third degree, criminal possession of a
weapon in the second degree, assault in the second degree, assault in the
first degree, attempted murder in the second degree.
Counselor, waive reading of the rights and charges? Attorney: So waived.
How does your client plead? Not guilty.
Judge: People on bail? Your Honor, the defendant has been convicted of
murder once before, he is a repeat offender, he's a soldier in the Masucci
family, and is considered a flight risk.
This office requests that he be held without bail.
Afraid I'm loath to withhold bail on all except homicide cases, Counselor.
$100,000, cash or bond.
Short date.
I thought Stone would be here.
At a button man's arraignment? Have no fear, Stone's looking forward to
seeing you in court.
what's his schedule like? Depends on who's coming to call.
Come on, Paul, this whole thing's just one step above a roust.
It's a two-minute negotiation.
I wouldn't count on it.
Halsey's still touch and go.
Give me a break - nobody dies of a knife wound a week later.
Predicate violence? Stone hates pleading on predicate violence.
Cosmatos.
Call me irresponsible, Eddie, but I like you.
You're a hell of a lawyer, that's why I'm amazed how incredibly guilty your
clients are.
Scalisi is lower than snake spit.
You want to waste more of your client's money, come on down Thursday.
But with what's going to come out, he'll never be able to get a Congressional
appointment.
Mr.
Halsey never wanted Mrs.
Halsey to be burdened with unnecessary business details.
Is there anything else you'd like to know.
Her coat size? I wear a 12.
Thank you, Mrs.
Halsey.
One more thing- did you ever hear of somebody called Anthony Scalisi? No, I
don't recall that name.
why? He was the man we suspect attacked your husband.
A black boy named Scalisi? Two blacks in custody confessed to robbing your
husband, but Scalisi was the one who slashed him.
Do you have any idea why somebody might want to attack M r.
Halsey? Mrs.
Halsey already told you she didn't know Tony Scalisi.
Mr.
wentzel, we won't take up any more of Mrs.
Halsey's time, but why don't you let us buy you a cup of coffee? Stone: Mrs.
Halsey wears a size 12.
And the coat is an eight.
who is she, Mr.
wentzel? You can't be serious.
I can't tell you- You're going to make me very angry if you finish that
sentence.
what is this? we're talking privacy here.
No, we're talking obstruction here.
wait a damn second - No, you wait.
This case stinks.
Your friend was a bagman long before he was a councilman.
Old habits die hard.
I'm going to start sending out subpoenas.
If I find out you had knowledge of person or persons who were involved with
your friend in illegal activity, I'll have your butt.
Now what's her name, Mr.
wentzel? Alicia Heslin? Um she's in Sweaters.
Miss Heslin? Yes? My name's Paul Robinette.
I'm from the District Attorney's office.
Yes? I'd like to ask you a few questions.
About what? Charles Halsey.
Oh I've been expecting you.
Stone: I like the story you wrote on Congressman MacGruder.
So what do you want? Everything you got on Charles Halsey.
How much do you know about parking meters? They all run fast.
And a lot of people who get tickets don't pay them.
Collecting all that money for all those unpaid tickets is a very big headache
for the head of the Parking Violations Bureau.
He has to get a little "outside help.
" That means a big contract.
Very big, very lucrative contract.
who has it? Interesting little company called, "Carnegie Collections.
" She's got "champagne tastes"- Cartier watch, alligator shoes.
when she first heard about it, she thought he might have been trying to
commit suicide.
why, was he depressed? He'd been subpoenaed- Federal Grand Jury on
Municipal Corruption.
Oh, and how's this grab you? Her apartment lease is made out to "Carnegie
Collections.
" She wear a size eight coat? Right off the rack.
He tell her names? Last month, it was all he talked about- who had done
what to whom and how they had done it.
will she testify? Most of it's unusable anyway.
"Chuck told me that Scalisi told him that Van Damme told him " That kind of
thing.
She did say he couldn't figure out how this was happening since he had "a
Deputy Police Commander in his pocket.
" Man: I can tell you now that six days of jury deliberation did have me
worried.
Reporter:.
You must be pleased with the verdict, Deputy Commander.
I am, Chuck, I truly am.
Our high schools must be protected from the drug-dealing scum trying to
poison our children.
Reporter:.
Mr.
Jefferson - ? Deputy Commander, can I ask you this? Do you feel the impact
of this verdict will be felt on the streets? How deep does this go? It's not
confined to the Parking Violations Bureau, that's for sure.
why not? Halsey's been the bagman for 20 years.
There's police he's mobbed up, and according to a reporter I know, several
other councilmen and politicians are stockholders in Carnegie Collections as
well as the Deputy Police Commander, one william Jefferson.
Is this personal? Is that why you want to bring the feds in? I'd love to nail the
bastard.
But with him involved, one surveillance leak, we're dead.
we're secure with the Bureau doing it.
Let the feds have the ink on municipal corruption.
They may even help me get a conspiracy to murder on these bozos.
You never knowwhose pants are going to get dropped in a corruption
scandal.
Hey, this started out j as a mugging.
I'll back you, but don't bring me any names unless they're dead-bang guilty.
I want a smoking gun.
I want it in somebody's hand.
Are you telling me tape? Tape would be a start.
Can I offer Scalisi immunity? Nope, it'll look like he's naming people to save
himself.
I wouldn't want you to go out on a limb here, Alfred.
That's not what I get the big bucks for.
Yes? Secretary: Mr.
Stone has an urgent call.
A lawyer named Cosmatos? Somebody wants to make a deal.
Cosmatos and Scalisi are in your office.
Call Judge Ichazo.
Get warrants for Halsey, Scalisi, Jefferson's phone records, and talk to
Halsey's doctors.
See when we can interrogate him.
So while we steadfastly maintain that the slashing was done by the youths
seen fleeing the scene, you never know what'll happen with the jury, so we
would be willing to negotiate some sort of an agreement.
Don't do me any favors.
I'm more than willing to let the people decide.
Bottom line what do you want? who paid you to do Halsey? Look, you want to
talk city corruption? No deal without the name.
Pass.
Stone: What's up? Hospital just called- Charles Halsey died half an hour ago.
we'll get back to you.
I haven't even made an offer.
Trust me, you wouldn't like the counter.
I can tell you things.
Are you going to tell me about parking tickets? Yours is already punched.
we know all about Carnegie Collections.
I got a lot of names.
I'll see you in court.
I'm not talking G-4's here.
These are your basic elected officials and a Deputy Police Commander.
Don't have him make me call Security.
Come on, Tony.
There is no way that I'm going down alone behind this.
what do you want? want? I want it all.
You testify.
Give names, dates, amounts.
You flush all those true-blue public officials.
And that gets me a walk? Only way you walk is you say who gave the order.
You know I can't do that.
No Masucci, no free lunch.
But the public officials could lead to a plea of let's say "assault"? Let's say,
"voluntary manslaughter.
" Say "involuntary.
" Then he wears j a wire.
Are you crazy? They'll know I've been popped.
They'll smell it.
You let me worry about that.
what kind of sentencing recommendation? Depends on what's on the tape.
"Tick-tock," gentlemen.
write it up.
The guy had arteries the diameter of capillaries.
with the traumatic loss of six units of blood, there was a causative
connection between the assault and the coronary? Come on, guys, you don't
want to ask me that.
"Causative connection"? whoa, wait a minute.
Mr.
Halsey had a regular physician, didn't he, Dr.
Goldberg? Yes, he did.
And he described Halsey as being in good health? Uh-huh.
He was alive a week ago, correct? As far as I could tell.
Somebody cut his throat with a straight razor- severing an artery and vocal
cords? And other connective tissue.
And now Mr.
Halsey's dead? Yes, that's correct.
Thank you, Dr.
Goldberg.
It's neat, it's clean.
It's interagency cooperation.
And we may get a murder-for-hire j conspiracy while you get another nail for
your RICO.
How did I get so lucky? A high-level cop is involved.
I can't run this through the PD.
The DA know about this? Has his full approval.
we go to trial first.
You want to win your RICO, go in with one of five counts having already been
proven in state court.
what do you need? An FBl surveillance team.
Get me Jackson at the Bureau.
Let me see if I've got this.
Halsey's been called before the grand jury, big names figure he's going to
name them, give the contract to Scalisi.
But Scalisi screwed up.
The black kids come along.
And we got lucky, they came up with the ID.
So why are you kicking? I told you, It's a weak case.
It's all circumstantial, and they're no choirboys as witnesses.
Spare me the waltz, all right? This is all off the record until after an
indictment.
But I get an exclusive on the arrest? I can't promise you that.
Sure you can.
You get an exclusive on the highest ranking defendant's arrest site will you
run it? "Assistant District Attorney Benjamin Stone stated that his office did
not feel that Scalisi's causative role in Halsey's death could be proven
beyond a reasonable doubt.
" A tad doctrinaire, but not too bad.
Scalisi comes out smelling like a rose.
So long as they buy he held his mud.
Jefferson called me for a status report.
You told him about this case? I had to.
He would have been suspicious if I didn't talk to him.
I gave him the "we had to let Scalisi walk" rap.
How did he take it? He was absolutely furious.
I'm sure it was an Oscar performance.
You're certain he's guilty, right? I'm not certain, I'm positive! You take her
through her testimony? She's still upset about not having a lawyer with her.
Did you explain to her how the grand jury works- no lawyer unless you're a
defendant- that we need her testimony to get a wire-tap? She understands.
She's not happy about it, but she gets it.
All right.
Stone: Did Charles Halsey tell you of other officials who were involved in this
conspiracy to award the Traffic Violation Bureau's collection contract to
Carnegie Collections? Heslin: He mentioned people that I knew as well as
people that I had never heard of.
which people that you knew personally? Anthony Scalisi and william
Jefferson.
And did he tell you the amount of money involved? He said that there was
over a million dollars available to pay off city officials per year.
See who your client drew?.
No, I haven't seen the calendar.
"Let-'em-walk" Falk.
Hey, I didn't want him to plead.
It was his own decision.
Anyway, he got the call.
From whom? Scalisi wants it to be a surprise.
This isn't a parlor game, Eddie.
He's worried somebody might not show up and you'll think he's lying.
where's the meet? "Cafe Bruxelles.
" when? Tomorrow night, Bring him to the Bureau at 6:00.
You know who's coming? Mm-hmm.
Bad? I hope you don't have any political aspirations.
Just make sure he's on time.
I'll start with you, take you through the arrest of Lewis and Jackson.