Documentos de Académico
Documentos de Profesional
Documentos de Cultura
1449
DOI: 10.1002/mame.200600260
Summary: More than twenty years have passed since we invented PCN, in which only a few wt.-% of silicate is randomly
and homogeneously dispersed in the polymer matrix. When
molded, these nanocomposites show superior properties compared to those of pristine polymers. The number of papers on
PCN has increased rapidly in recent years, reaching over 500
in 2005 alone. Being pioneers of this new technology, we
review its history relative to the following epochal events:
In 1985 we invented nylon 6-clay hybrid (NCH), the first PCN.
In 1989, cars equipped with a NCH part were launched.
Received: July 2, 2006; Revised: September 25, 2006; Accepted: September 25, 2006; DOI: 10.1002/mame.200600260
Keywords: clay; hybrids; molecular composites; nanocomposites; NCH
1. Introduction
2. Nylon-Clay Nanocomposites
2.1 Nylon 6-Clay Hybrid (NCH)
2.1.1 Dry Polymerization Method
Dry polymerization method
Characterization of NCH
2.1.2 Wet Polymerization Methods
Wet polymerization method
Wet lactam polymerization method
One-Pot polymerization method
Diamine addition polymerization method
Polymerization/Compounding method
2.1.3 Compounding Methods
Dry compounding method
Wet compounding method
1450
A. Okada, A. Usuki
1. Introduction
In polymer clay nanocomposites (PCN), a few wt.-% of
each silicate layer of clay mineral is randomly and
homogeneously dispersed on a molecular level in the
polymer matrix. When molded, the mechanical, thermal
and barrier properties of these materials are superior to
those of pristine polymers and/or conventional composites. The effects are very striking, and have become well
known since many excellent reviews have been
published.[1]
In 1985 PCN was invented at Toyota Central R&D Labs,
Inc. (Toyota).[2] It bore a new concept of polymer
nanocomposites, expanded the field of polymer science
including preparation, structure and interfaces and led to
new applications for automotive, electric and food
industries. Passenger cars equipped with a PCN part were
launched in 1989, only 4 years after this discovery. Since
then, extensive worldwide research on PCN has been
conducted not only in the industrial sector but also in the
academic sector. Currently, there are international conferences on PCN every year, and papers on PCN in major
journals exceeded 500 in 2005 alone, according to
Thomsons Web of Science (WOS).
As pioneers of PCN, we believe that it is our
responsibility to review the 20-year history of its
Akane Okada graduated at Kyoto University in 1969. In 1974 he received a Doctor degree of Science in the
research of Trialkylsilyl Anions Synthesis, Reactions and Application to ESR Spectroscopy from
Tohoku University. In 1974 he joined Mitsubishi Chemical Industry. In 1985 he has joined Toyota Central
R&D Labs., Inc. In 2000 he won jointly the Chemical Engineering Award by the Chemical Society of Japan
for Development of Clay Mineral/Organic Polymer Nano-Hybrid Materials. His major interests are
polymer nanocomposite, organosilicon chemistry, and organic opt-electro materials. He has published 94
papers which cover polymer nanocomposites, organosilicon chemistry, polymer gel actuators, organic
nonlinear optical materials, organic electroluminescence, electroviscoelastic materials, ESR spectroscopy,
organic photochemistry and so on. He has filed 161 patents which cover electrophotographic materials,
vesicular photography, synthesis of phenylacetylens, secondary batteries and gasoline vapor absorbers in
addition to the subjects of papers above. He is now Fellow of Toyota Central R&D Labs., Inc. and belongs
to its Material Department.
Arimitsu Usuki graduated at Nagoya University in 1978. He also received a M.S. degree in Synthetic
Chemistry in 1980 from the same university. The thesis was study of Substitution Reaction of Adamantane
Bridgehead Using Allyl Trimethylsilane Compounds. He joined Toyota Central R&D Labs., Inc. in 1980.
Since then, he has been working in the field of synthesis of polymers, especially p-conjugated polymers,
polymer nanocomposites, functional polymers and biopolymers. In 1996, he received a doctor of
engineering degree from Nagoya university, on the thesis titled Study of Nylon6 Clay Hybrid. He is
especially interested in research and development of polymer materials, extremely useful for weight
reduction of automobiles. He is now research manager of organic materials laboratory of Toyota Central
R&D Labs., Inc.
Macromol. Mater. Eng. 2006, 291, 14491476
www.mme-journal.de
1451
Figure 1.
2. Nylon-Clay Nanocomposites
2.1 Nylon 6-Clay Hybrid (NCH)
2.1.1 Dry Polymerization
Dry polymerization method: We initially discuss nylon
6, since it is a typical engineering polymer in the auto
industry, reinforced by glass fiber.[7] In order to obtain
NCH, we needed to make MMT organophilic.[8] v-Amino
acid (AA) hydrogen chloride with carbon numbers from 2
to 18 was chosen as a swelling agent because the proton of
the carboxyl group ( COOH) of AA initiates polymerization of e-caprolactam (CL), the monomer of nylon 6. From
X-ray diffraction (XRD) studies (see Figure 3), the basal
spacing of AA from C2 to C8 (interlayer distance, ) is the
Structure of montmorillonite.
www.mme-journal.de
1452
A. Okada, A. Usuki
Figure 2.
Figure 3.
www.mme-journal.de
(1)
1453
Figure 4.
NCH2
NCH5
NCH8
NCH15
NCH30
NCH50
NCH70
12-Mt
Nylon 6
a)
b)
c)
Clay content
CNH2a)
CCOOHa)
M n b)
Basal spacing
wt.-%
105 eq g1
105 eq g1
kg mol1
nm
1.5
3.9
6.8
13.0
26.2
42.8
59.6
78.7
0
3.85
4.86
6.70
8.04
12.6
12.1
6.64
5.69
5.69
9.49
14.4
22.9
44.3
70.6
86.7
5.41
17.2
10.0
6.34
3.80
1.66
0.810
0.466
(0.216)c)
12.1
6.0
4.4
2.6
1.7
www.mme-journal.de
1454
A. Okada, A. Usuki
Figure 7.
Figure 5.
Figure 6.
www.mme-journal.de
1455
Comment
Unit
NCH2
NCH5
NCH8
Nylon 6
23 8C
120 8C
23 8C
120 8C
23 8C
120 8C
23 8C
120 8C
23 8C
120 8C
MPa
76.4
29.7
>100
>100
1.43
0.32
107
23.8
2.99
0.75
102
118
97.2
32.3
7.30
>100
1.87
0.61
143
32.7
4.34
1.16
52.5
152
6.3 105
13.1 105
93.6
31.4
2.5
51.6
2.11
0.72
122
37.4
5.32
1.87
16.8
153
68.6
26.6
>100
>100
1.11
0.19
89.3
12.5
1.94
0.29
>150
65
11.7 105
11.8 105
Flow direction
Perpendicular direction
www.mme-journal.de
%
GPa
MPa
GPa
kJ m2
8C
cm 8C1
1456
A. Okada, A. Usuki
Comment
Unit
NCH-1/4h
NCH-1/2h
NCH-1h
NCH5
23 8C
120 8C
23 8C
23 8C
120 8C
23 8C
120 8C
23 8C
120 8C
MPa
104
33.0
9.10
1.90
0.57
147
30.9
4.20
1.37
77.7
149
93.6
31.4
78.8
1.80
0.46
134
30.3
3.96
1.09
87.1
143
89.9
31.4
>100
1.65
0.56
125
27.9
3.55
0.95
100
142
97.2
32.3
7.30
1.87
0.61
143
32.7
4.34
1.16
52.5
152
%
GPa
MPa
GPa
kJ m2
8C
Figure 8.
Clay content
Organic modifier
Tensile strength
Elongation
Tensile modulus
Heat distortion
temperature
Comment Unit
www.mme-journal.de
RT
RT
RT
NCH
2.95
Dibenzylamine
MPa
80
%
44
GPa
3.37
8C
72
Nylon 6
66
26
2.41
55
1457
Comment
Clay content
Organic modifier
Preparative method
Tensile strength
Tensile modulus
Heat distortion temperature
23 8C
23 8C
Unit
NCH
NCH
Nylon 6
MPa
GPa
8C
1.8
C18-amine
Dry compound
82
1.41
135
1.6
Wet compound
82
1.38
102
Polymer
69
1.1
75
Comment
Unit
NCH
Nylon 6
MPa
GPa
MPa
GPa
J m1
4.0
Tetraphenylphosphonium
107
2.1
150
0.2
26.0
60
1.1
93.5
2.4
28.0
8C
112
62
Clay content
Organic modifier
Tensile strength
Tensile modulus
Flexural strength
Flexural modulus
Notched Izod
impact strength
Heat distortion
temperature
RT
RT
RT
RT
RT
www.mme-journal.de
1458
A. Okada, A. Usuki
Unit
NCH/MMT
NCHM/mica
NCHP/saponite
NCHH/hectorite
Nylon 6
MPa
97.2
32.3
7.3
1.87
0.61
152
61.1
63.6
93.1
30.2
7.2
2.02
0.52
145
57.2
59.6
84.7
29.0
>100
1.59
0.29
107
51.5
53.4
89.5
26.4
>100
1.65
0.29
93
48.4
50.4
68.6
26.6
>100
1.11
0.19
65
70.9
70.9
Clay
Tensile strength
Elongation
Tensile modulus
23 8C
120 8C
23 8C
23 8C
120 8C
%
GPa
8C
J g1
J g1nylon
indicated that the nylon 12 unit was not at the terminal but
inside the nylon 6, so that the spectrum was that of
co-polymer of nylon 6 and nylon 12.[29] This means that
the NH
3 group of the nylon 12 unit originally bound to
Figure 9.
Figure 10.
www.mme-journal.de
15
1459
Table 8.
15
Compound
ppm
ClNH
3 CH2COOH
Montmorillonite NH
3 CH2COOH
CH
COOH
Mica NH
2
3
Saponite NH
3 CH2COOH
Hectorite NH
3 CH2COOH
HMDA
a)
ppm relative to
15.6
11.2
9.4
8.4
8.3
7.0
15
NH4NO3.
NCH is very anisotropic, as seen from thermal expansion coefficient in Table 2. These results excited our
interest in the orientation of both clay and nylon 6 in NCH.
We studied a 3 mm thick injection-molded bar, which is a
standard shape for tensile testing,[30] conducting XRD
measurements while cutting from the surface (0 mm) into
the center (1.5 mm) in detail. Figure 13 shows six
diffraction patterns for two specimens of the surface area
(00.5 mm in depth) and inner area (0.51.5 mm in
depth). The diffraction photographs are terminated through
(thru)-, edge-, and end-view patterns with the x-ray beam
incident on the NCH bar along the x-, y-, and z-axes. In the
edge- and end-view patterns of the surface and inner layers,
a pair of strong streaks can be seen in the horizontal (x)
direction from the center, which suggests a planar
orientation of silicates to the bar surface. The streaks in
the end-view of the inner layers become slightly broader in
the azimuthal direction, suggesting the degree of planar
orientation is somewhat broader than the surface area.
In NCH, nylon 6 is a g-form crystal, whose orthorhombic lattice is shown in Figure 14.
Figure 11.
www.mme-journal.de
1460
A. Okada, A. Usuki
Figure 13.
While the pristine nylon 6 bar showed no axis orientation in any area, NCH shows very peculiar orientations of
both silicate and polymer axes. The fact that the orientation
of silicates, which are more rigid than in nylon 6, is parallel
to the flow direction explains the decrease in the thermal
expansion coefficient for that direction (Table 2). The
orientation of the silicate and nylon 6 molecular axes
parallel to the surface on the skin surface may explain the
smooth surface of the bar, which is similar to brilliant,
shining marble or porcelain.
Gilman et al. found that NCH5 had revolutionary fire
retardant (FR) properties,[31a] and showed that the peak
heat release rate is decreased by 63% compared to nylon 6.
They explained that silicate works as an insulator and as a
mass transport barrier for volatile products from the
decomposition of nylon 6. Another advantage is that clay
does not cause deterioration of polymer properties, instead
improving them, while other FR additives have a negative
effect. In addition, clay does not produce hazardous
Figure 14.
www.mme-journal.de
1461
Figure 15.
surface.
Figure 16.
test piece.
Polyimide-clay hybrid films were prepared by: 1) blending N,N-dimethylacetamide (DMAC) solutions of 4,4dimethylaminodiphenyl ether and pyromellitic anhydride;
2) addition of DMAC suspension of MMT intercalated with
dodecylammonium salt (C12-MMT) to the above solution;
3) casting of the mixture to a glass plate; and, 4) heating at
300 8C for 2 h, as shown in Figure 17.[36]
To prepare PI hybrid, no shear is needed, but the clay is
perfectly exfoliated and the transparency of the hybrid film
is almost the same as that of pristine PI. Silicates in the film
are oriented completely parallel to the surface. While we
tested nine kinds of long-chain ammonium salt, only
www.mme-journal.de
1462
A. Okada, A. Usuki
Comment
Unit
MXD6 nanocomposite
MXD6
RT
RT
RT
RT
23 8C, 60% RH
23 8C, 60% RH
40 8C, 60%RH
MPa
%
GPa
%
cm3 mm m2 d1 atm
cm3 mm m2 d1 atm
g mm m2 d1
83
2.9
3.5
1.5
0.02
0.10
0.28
85
3.3
3.1
1.3
0.08
0.20
0.62
(2)
www.mme-journal.de
1463
Figure 18.
film.
4. Polyolefin-Clay Nanocomposites
4.1 Poly(propylene) (PP)-Clay Nanocomposites
Poly(propylene) is the most widely used polymer in the
automotive industry and in commodity products. While it
is less expensive, its mechanical and thermal properties are
inferior to engineering plastics such as nylons. However,
there is a strong need to improve the mechanical properties
of poly(propylene), owing to its low price. After nylon 6
was successfully developed, various research efforts were
made worldwide to reinforce PP using clay, but to the best
of our knowledge no successful examples of reinforced
PP-clay nanocomposites (PPCN) have yet been reported.
Since clay is hydrophilic and PP is hydrophobic, there is
enormous difficulty in making PPCN. In order to do this, a
different method was applied from that of nylon and PI
synthesis, using a third component, a compatibilizer with a
functional group and polyolefin unit. Specifically, we
chose maleic anhydride (MA)-grafted PP oligomers
(PP-MA). The PP-MAs we used, from Sanyo Chemical
Ind., Ltd. are shown in Table 10.
First of all we prepared MMT organized with octadecylammonium salt (C18-MMT), and compounded
PP-MA using an extruder, successfully giving MMTintercalated PP-MA. This was then compounded with
pristine PP, also using an extruder. All final products
contained 5 wt.-% of clay. Among the products, PPCN
(U1010 C18-MMT) had a peak of 6.0 nm in XRD,
and PPCN (U1001 C18-MMT) had a shoulder around
45 nm but no clear peak, while C18-MMT had a peak at
2.2 nm. TEM micrographs of PPCN (U1001 C18-MMT)
are shown in Figure 20; these indicate that exfoliation was
just attained. Compounding of C18-MMT, PP-MA and PP
at the same time also proved to give an exfoliated product.[42]
Observation of photographs from a polarized microscope shows that there was macro-phase separation in
PPCN (U1010 C18-MMT) but PPCN (U1001
C18-MMT) had no such separation and was homogeneous.
The TEM and microscope studies indicated that while the
MA unit is necessary for exfoliation, its presence in excess
amounts seems to decrease compatibility with the pristine
PP. The relative storage moduli of two PPCN samples to
pristine PP are plotted in Figure 21.
The moduli of both samples were 1.51.8 times as
high as that of the pristine PP from 5080 8C, but at
other temperatures they were lower than that of the
pristine PP. This may be caused by the fact that PPCN
Table 10. Properties of poly(propylene) modified with maleic
anhydride.
PP-MA
U1010
U1001
U1004
Figure 19.
a)
b)
www.mme-journal.de
Maleic Anhydridea)
Melting Pointa)
wt.-%
8C
4.5
2.3
2.3
145
154
155
M w M w b)
30 000
40 000
80 000
Catalog data.
Catalog data determined by GPC measurements.
2006 WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim
1464
A. Okada, A. Usuki
Figure 20.
Figure 21.
www.mme-journal.de
PE
PE-MA
PE1
PECH1
PECH2
PECH3
PECC
Clay
C18-MMT
C18-MMT
C18-MMT
MMT
Composition
PE
PE-MA
wt.-%
wt.-%
100
0
70
70
70
0
70
0
100
30
30
30
100
30
Clay
wt.-%
0
0
0
5.4
3.5
5.2
5.7
1465
Figure 22.
PE
PE-MA
PE1
PECH1
PECH2
PECH3
PECC
Tensile Strength
Elongation
Tensile Modulus
MPa
MPa
7.3
9.3
7.510.5
9.4
12.5
7.9
>500
180
>500
>500
>500
155
>500
102
118
99
180
140
157
103
5.26
5.46
5.32
3.79
3.01
3.48
5.48
www.mme-journal.de
1466
A. Okada, A. Usuki
Figure 25.
Figure 24.
Structure of EPDM.
www.mme-journal.de
Vulcanization accelerators.
1467
kneaded at 8090 8C. The product was compressionmolded into test pieces of 4 10 80 mm3 for the flexural
test. Although, among many organized clays, only
C18-MMT could be completely dispersed in the resin,
the flexural strength of PRCN was lower than that of PR,
and the nanocomposite reinforcing effect was not
observed. However, heat resistance was improved. The
heat-resistance properties of PRCN were evaluated by the
following method: the test pieces were kept at 200 8C in a
dry oven and flexural strength was measured at fixed
intervals; strength retention was then compared with the
initial strength. The strength retentions of PRCN and of PR
were plotted against time (Figure 26(a)).
The retention of flexural strength by this PRCN at 500 h
and 1 000 h at 200 8C was significantly higher than that of
the PR. In order to investigate the reason for this, we
measured the penetration of O2 gas by electron probe
microanalysis (EPMA). Depth profiles for oxygen atom
distribution in the PRCN as a function of exposure time are
shown in Figure 26(b), along with profiles of PR. In the PR
sample, oxygen atoms of oxidized PR reached the center of
the test piece by 1 000 h, but in PRCN, these oxygen atoms
were distributed to a depth of about 600 mm but stopped at
700 mm at 1 000 h. In other words, the gas barrier property
of clay suppressed oxidation of the polymer.[65]
www.mme-journal.de
1468
A. Okada, A. Usuki
Figure 28.
Figure 27.
and specific network structures may be formed. Observation by XRD, TEM and DSC of dried NC gels proved that
silicates are homogeneously dispersed in PNIPA.
NC gels showed a clear change in transparency and
volume around the lower critical solution temperature
(LCST, ca. 32 8C). A reversible change in transparency
was obtained independently of the clay content from
15 wt.-%, in contrast to OR gels (Figure 29). Here the
size of all samples was 26 mm (35 mm in length).
Shrinking speed is critically important for application in
a DDS or as an actuator. NC gels showed much higher
shrinking speeds than OR gels. While OR gels took one
month to shrink, NC gels completed shrinkage in about
10 min, as shown in Figure 30. Here, the sample size was
5.5 mm in diameter 30 mm in length.
NC gels have overturned the conventional wisdom of
hydrogels. They have been released from their traditional
limitations, and are expected to be used widely for many
applications which were previously thought impossible.
Coupled with micro-fabrication techniques,[66b,c] hydrogels are expected to be useful as practical materials.
Unit
Transparency at 1 8C
%
98
94
96
94
4
71
48
29 14
Swelling Ratio
Ww/Wdry 110
Tensile Strength
kPa
27
69
88
Elongation
%
1 308 1 112 1 035
Tensile Modulus
kPa
1
4
8
Tg of Dried Gela)
8C
141 141 142 145 152
a)
Figure 29.
www.mme-journal.de
1469
Figure 30.
www.mme-journal.de
1470
A. Okada, A. Usuki
Figure 33.
shear.
Macromol. Mater. Eng. 2006, 291, 14491476
www.mme-journal.de
1471
Figure 34.
www.mme-journal.de
1472
A. Okada, A. Usuki
Figure 36.
field.
Figure 37. TEM dyed with RuO4: (a) SEBS, and (b) SEBS-CN; black line (with a white
arrow) indicating silicate, gray PS and white PEB domain.
Macromol. Mater. Eng. 2006, 291, 14491476
www.mme-journal.de
1473
Figure 38.
Conclusion
Based on twenty years of research on polymer-clay nanocomposites, the following conclusions may be drawn:
A. Titration, NMR, GC-MS, and detailed XRD results
revealed that PCN is an entirely new chemical species
and not just a composite. The first applied PCN
material was a nylon 6-clay hybrid (NCH), the properties of which were so eminent that passenger cars
containing a NCH timing belt cover were launched
into the market within four years (1989).
B. Addition of only a small amount of clay to pristine
polymers imparts the following characteristics to the
resultant PCN:
www.mme-journal.de
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
1474
A. Okada, A. Usuki
www.mme-journal.de
[1] [1a] L. A. Utracki, Clay-Containing Polymeric Nanocomposites, Rapra Tech. Ltd., London 2004;
[1b]
M. Okamoto, Advance in Polymeric Nanocomposites,
CMC Publishers, Tokyo 2004; [1c] T. J. Pinavaia, G. Beall,
Polymeric Clay Nanocomposites, Wiley, New York
2000;
[1d] A. Okada, A. Usuki, T. Kurauchi,
O. Kamigaito, Hybrid Organic-Inorganic Composites,
in: ACS Sym. Ser. No. 585, Am. Chem. Soc. 1995, pp. 5565.
[2] [2a] A. Okada, M. Kawasumi, T. Kurauchi, O. Kamigaito,
ACS Polym. Prepr. 1987, 28, 447; [2b] U. S. 4739007
(1988, priority date: Sep. 30, 1985), Toyota Chuo Kenkyuusho, invs.: A. Okada, A. Fukushima, M. Kawasumi,
S. Inagaki, A. Usuki, S. Sugiyama, T. Kurauchi,
O. Kamigaito; Chem. Abstr. 1987, 107, 60084.
[3] [3a] M. Takayanagi, Kobunshi 1984, 33, 615; Chem. Abstr.
1984, 101, 231305; [3b] M. Takayanagi, T. Ogata,
M. Mohkawa, T. Kai, J. Macromo. Sci., Phys. 1980, B17,
591.
[4] H. van Olphen, An Introduction to Clay Colloid Chemistry, 2nd edition, Wiley-Interscience, New York 1977.
[5] [5a] H. Z. Friedlander, J. Polym. Sci. 1964, 2, 475; [5b]
A. Blumstein, J. Polym. Sci. 1965, 3A, 2653; [5c]
H. G. G. Dekking, J. Appl. Polym. Sci. 1967, 11, 23.
[6] Jpn Tokkyo Koho 1204305 (1983, priority date: March, 24,
1975), Unitika Ltd., invs.: S. Fujiwara, T. Sakamoto; Chem.
Abstr. 1997, 86, 141002.
[7] M. I. Kohan, Nylon Plastics, John Wiley & Sons, New
York 1973.
[8] A. Usuki, Y. Kojima, M. Kawasumi, A. Okada, T. Kurauchi,
O. Kamigaito, J. Mater. Res. 1993, 8, 1174.
[9] A. Usuki, Y. Kojima, M. Kawasumi, A. Okada, Kurauchi,
O. Kamigaito, J. Mater. Res. 1993, 8, 1179.
[10] A. Usuki, N. Hasegawa, H. Kadoura, T. Okamoto, Nano
Letters 2001, 1, 271.
[11] A. Okada, M. Kawasumi, unpublished results.
[12] U. S. 4810734 (1989, priority date: March, 26, 1987),
Toyota Chuo Kenkyuusho, invs.: M. Kawasumi,
M. Kohzaki, Y. Kojima, A. Okada, O. Kamigaito; Chem.
Abstr. 1989, 110, 115983.
[13] [13a] Y. Kojima, A. Usuki, M. Kawasumi, A. Okada,
T. Kurauchi, O. Kamigaito, J. Mater. Res. 1993, 8, 1185;
[13b] Y. Kojima, A. Usuki, M. Kawasumi, A. Okada,
T. Kurauchi, O. Kamigaito, Material Life 1993, 5-1, 13;
[13c] K. Yasue, K. Kojima, S. Katahira, Plastics 1997, 47,
100; [13d] A. Yamashita, A. Takahara, T. Kajiyama, Nihon
Reoroji Gakkaishi 1996, 24, 117; Chem. Abstr. 1996, 125,
330347.
2006 WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim
1475
www.mme-journal.de
[31]
[32]
[33]
[34]
[35]
[36]
[37]
[38]
[39]
[40]
[41]
[42]
[43]
[44]
[45]
[46]
[47]
[48]
[49]
[50]
[51]
[52]
[53]
[54]
[55]
[56]
1476
A. Okada, A. Usuki
www.mme-journal.de