Dont be artistic

Rengo2212 Master file

Resolved: The United States should end Plan Colombia

Dont be artistic
Topic facts
President-Juan Manuel Santos
FARC Commander in Chief- Fidel Castro
Plan Colombia signed in 1974
Plan Colombia 2.0 (Paz Colombia)- focused on
strengthening security and combatting drugs with US$450
billion over the next 10 years in the post-conflict era
Colombia.
Plan Colombia 2.0 The new Peace Colombia will see
US$450 billion transferred to Colombia annually over the
next 10 years.

Dont be artistic
Pro

Dont be artistic
Argument 2 Con

Dont be artistic
Pulling Out Bad
1. This is simply not true because Pablo Escobar is
dead, no drug group poses a threat to Colombia
2. Shanlar in 2016 finds that you dont need Plan
Colombia at all Conflict Colombia solves meaning you
can non- unique their argument on face.
3. Even if pulling out is bad, we would contest US
involvement only makes the situation worse, look at
Fidel, the US backed out of Cuba and it became a
regional power house

Dont be artistic
Still Have Work
1. You can turn the argument, the whole point of a goal
is to finish a problem, in so far as the logic is true
doing more work is only contradictory to whole
reason why we even do work
2. Renegro Juan Turuwantu from the University of San
Pao finds, we have no obligation in the 21st century
to help Colombia
3. But even if you dont buy that the IoT solves, Lester
brown explains that the IoT can make Colombia solve
back all its poblems.

Dont be artistic
Drugs
We have 4 responses
1. They dont show you why drugs are bad and the US
needs to be involved.
2. You can turn the argument this is because Forbes
finds the drug industry has generated Colombia over
30 billion dollars, thats critical because Business
insider finds, money being generated in Colombia
can help the people
3. You can turn it again, this is because the DEA finds
cocaine can improve energy and focus, we contend a
more focused Colombia is a better Colombia
4. Pablo Escobar helped create 100s of homes and
communities for Colombia, continuing a plan that
could hurt this hero is never a good idea.

Dont be artistic
Resulted in FARC peace deal
1. This is not true at all Fidel Castro notes in 2016, It
was the good intention of the FARC to sign the deal
as they were crushing Colombia in the war
2. If anything this is a reason to vote pro, if the
problems are done why should we continue it

Dont be artistic
Economic Development via aid
1. You can impact turn the argument, this is because in
like the US welfare makes people dependent its
making Colombia dependent as well.
2. Developmental aid never solves the problem in the
long term, this is because Bryan Borize from troll
economics notes, aid is aid not a house not food and
not medical supplies.

Dont be artistic
Leads to Peace Colombia
1. Dont let them deceive you Peace Colombia doesnt
exist
2. Even if they dont prove it, you can impact turn the
argument this is because Fidel Castro finds, anytime
the US is there things go bad

Dont be artistic
Hegemony
1. Good our entire thesis is US is a regional devil

Dont be artistic
Ariel Fumigation Good
1. This is not true, like fluoride in water this is a plot to
cancer innocent Colombians
2. You can turn the argument if anything people will
protest

Dont be artistic
Oil Interests
1. This argument no longer holds any water this is
because Venezuela has way more oil than Colombia

Dont be artistic
Con

Dont be artistic
A/2s

Dont be artistic
Airiel Fumigation Bad
1 You can impact turn the argument, insofar as
America is the best taking down as many Colombians
is always the best thing to do
2. Ending Plan Colombia wont do anything to stop it.
We could literally tell Colombia we will build a wall
and they will do what ever the US asks

Dont be artistic
US Imperialism
1. I have no idea as to why they are running this, US
imperialism is a good thing as it allows for 1 major
world empire.
2. This is good because as Dr. Mearshimer writes, IF the
US ends Plan Colombia, then Canada becomes the
regional hegemon, this is bad because USA Today
finds, Canada is the largest country filled with
artistic liberals.

Dont be artistic
Lost Cause (No Goals)
1. This is not true, the US can have a beach party in
Colombia, this is still a goal.

Dont be artistic
Risks FARC Deal
1. This is not true, unfortunaly FARC signed it last week

Dont be artistic
Plan Colombia (Short term)
1. Recognize even if Colombia wanted to stand on its
own 2 feet it wouldnt be able 2 as Colombia is a
Country of artists

Dont be artistic
Human Rights Abuses
1. I talked to Trump he said he has no idea what this is

Dont be artistic
Balloon effect (Relocation of drugs)
1. You can impact turn this, balloons are good there for
when more balloons are created better thins occur.

Dont be artistic