Documentos de Académico
Documentos de Profesional
Documentos de Cultura
art ic l e i nf o
a b s t r a c t
Article history:
Received 20 October 2014
Accepted 11 March 2015
Available online 27 March 2015
The 4th block Ordovician fractured-cavity carbonate reservoir of Tahe oil-eld consists of high-density
fractures and large caves which are well developed. The oil is stored in fractures and caves, rather than
carbonate rock matrix. In other words, the carbonate rock matrix has no oil storage capability and
permeability is extremely low. The fractured-cavity carbonate reservoir possesses the features of severe
heterogeneity, complex structure of reservoir space. During the development, many shortcomings such
as short period of stable production, early water breakthrough, fast increasing of water cut, high natural
decline rate and low degree of development are exposed gradually. The well which cannot achieve
effectiveness by water injection was selected to carry out N2 ooding experiments in Tahe oil-eld. By
the end of September 2012, the total injection volume of high pressure N2 was 700 m3 and the
incremental oil production was 2600 t. However the displacement mechanism was still poorly understood. In this paper, a two-dimensional visual fractured-cavity carbonate reservoir model was developed
based on the distribution feature, space structure and connection type of fractures and caves in reservoir
space. Four main types of residual oil i.e., attic oil, locked oil, bypassed oil and residual oil trapped in the
lled area were determined from the water ooding experiments. Also, their formation mechanism was
investigated. In addition, the recovering mechanism of residual oil was claried on the basis of N2
ooding experiments. The results show that N2 ooding can signicantly increase the oil recovery by
more than 40% after water ooding, and it mainly mobilized attic oil and partial locked oil. The entire
experiment process was recorded by video, therefore the displacing process of residual oil can be
observed directly. These results in this study indicate that N2 ooding has a broad application prospect in
fractured-cavity carbonate reservoir.
& 2015 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
Keywords:
Carbonate reservoir
Residual oil
Recovering mechanism
Nitrogen ooding
Enhanced oil recovery
1. Introduction
With the increasing energy demand and deepening exploration
and development for oil all over the world, carbonate reservoir
which becomes increasingly important possesses about 60% of
global hydrocarbon resources. While the fractured-cavity carbonate reservoir has a broad prospect for development due to the
fact that fractured-cavity reservoir represents more than 30% in
carbonate reservoirs (Xiao et al., 2003). Many of the world's large
oil and gas elds are composed of fractured-cavity carbonate
reservoir (Rosales et al., 2002). In recent years, China has made
some breakthroughs on exploration and development of carbonate
reservoir, e.g., billion tons level Tahe oil-eld is discovered at Tarim
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.petrol.2015.03.016
0920-4105/& 2015 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
Basin. Currently Tahe oil eld has proven oil area of 704 km2;
discovered original oil in place (OOIP) has exceeded 500 million
tons; recoverable oil area is 381 km2, recoverable oil initially in
place (OIIP) is 224 million and annual production capacity reaches
3.5 million tons (Chen et al., 2005). Tahe oil eld is gradually
becoming the main battleeld of oil and gas development of
China. In this background, the investigation of fractured-cavity
carbonate reservoir draws much attention from industry and
academia.
The 4th block Ordovician carbonate reservoir of Tahe oil eld
consists of high-density fractures and large caves which are well
developed. Due to the extremely low permeability of carbonate
rock matrix (between 0.1 and 1 mD), it has no storage capability
and oil is stored in fractures and caves (Zheng et al., 2010; Du et al.,
2011; Xu et al., 2010). Strong heterogeneity of reservoir, complex
structure of reservoir space and oil/water ow relationship is main
characteristics of fractured-cavity carbonate reservoir. Moreover
16
D. Yuan et al. / Journal of Petroleum Science and Engineering 129 (2015) 1522
the main storage space and seepage path possesses the features of
discontinuous and random distributions of fractures (width in
millimeter level) and caves (diameter in meter level), big scale
difference of caves and large dip angle of fractures (Popov et al.,
2007; Lu et al., 2010; Chen et al., 2010). With the development,
many shortcomings such as short period of stable production,
early water breakthrough, fast increasing of water cut, high natural
decline rate and low degree of development are exposed gradually.
This brings many technical problems to the development (Lu,
2003).
Specialist and experts did a lot of researches on enhanced oil
recovery (EOR) for conventional sand reservoir, but not much for
fractured-cavity carbonate reservoir. Most researches studies
were conducted by creating specic physical models and building
mathematical models. Generally these physical models were in
regular structure, xed special distribution or simple sand-packed
model (Hernandez and Juarez, 2001; Wang et al., 2011; Li et al.,
2008a, 2009). However these simple physical models could not
reect the distribution of fractures and caves correctly, which
brought great difculty to the development of formulation and
adjustment. As a secondary recovery method, water ooding is the
most common application for development of carbonate reservoir.
But the recovery is still in a low level because of uncertainty of oil
ow discipline and residual oil distribution. N2 ooding can be
used for EOR of fractured-cavity carbonate reservoir because of its
high oil displacement efciency (Poole, 1986; Karpov and Kokorev,
2008). At present, in terms of the recognition of N2 ooding
mechanism, some main aspects are listed as following (Li et al.,
2008b):
Fig. 1. The stratigraphic prole of well S48 and well TK467 in 4th block Ordovician
fractured-cavity carbonate reservoir of Tahe oil eld.
2. Experimental
2.1. Designing and making of two-dimensional visible physical
model
The two-dimensional visible physical model was developed
based on the stratigraphic prole of well S48 and well TK467 in
4th block Ordovician fractured-cavity carbonate reservoir of Tahe
oil eld, as shown in Fig. 1.
Small-scale fractures and cavities were etched on the bulk
articial carbonate core. The model was lled with sand and
sealed by transparent epoxy resin. The size of the model is
30 cm 30 cm 5 cm, the articial carbonate core is 3 cm-thick,
entire volume of fractures and cavities is 345 ml, and lling degree
is 30%. By water saturation test, porous volume (PV) is 290 ml. An
illustration of this model is shown in Fig. 2.
The model design strictly complies with the following principles (Liu et al., 2012): (1) ensure the actual fracture-cavity
combinations on the basis of reservoir; (2) maintain the reasonable fracture and cavity size and coordination number accordance
with reservoir space characteristics. Visualization is the most
advantaged characteristic of this model. The migration and distribution of oil in the fractures and cavities can be observed clearly.
D. Yuan et al. / Journal of Petroleum Science and Engineering 129 (2015) 1522
17
(B1) N2 injected to well TK467 after its water cut reached 100%,
well S48 worked as production well;
(B2) N2 injected to well S48 after water ooding was over, well
TK467 worked as production well;
(B3) N2 injected to well TK467 after water ooding was over,
well S48 worked as production well.
The entire experimental process was recorded by video, and all
the data was analyzed after experiment.
18
D. Yuan et al. / Journal of Petroleum Science and Engineering 129 (2015) 1522
was produced by well S48. But oil above the junction of cave D3
and fracture L4 could not be displaced. Therefore the attic oil was
formed (Fig. 5h). When the oil/water interface in cave D9 went up
to the bottom of well S48, the water cut reached 100%. Since the
gravity difference effect of water and oil, oil at the bottom of well
S48 could not be displaced. Therefore the attic oil was generated
and water ooding was over (Fig. 5i). From Fig. 5i, it was noticed
that oil in cave D6 and D8 was not mobilized effectively. The
reason was that the connectivity of cave D6 was poor and its
position did not match the mainstream line. Therefore much attic
oil was generated in cave D6 and D8.
D. Yuan et al. / Journal of Petroleum Science and Engineering 129 (2015) 1522
19
cut of well S48 appeared uctuation, and the well produced both
oil and gas. Therefore the oil production declined (Fig. 7h). With
the water cut of S48 increasing to 100%, the oil/water interface and
oil/gas interface disappeared gradually, N2 ooding was over
(Fig. 7i). From water ooding to N2 ooding, oil/water interface
switched to oil/gas interface and most residual oil was mobilized
and displaced, which resulted in the signicant increase of the
nal recovery. However because the connectivity of cave D4 and
D5 cave was poor and the junction of them with the mainstream
line was lower than bottom of well TK467, N2 was difcult to enter
these areas. Therefore the residual oil in cave D4 and D5 could not
be mobilized.
20
D. Yuan et al. / Journal of Petroleum Science and Engineering 129 (2015) 1522
Fig. 7. The mobilizing process of residual oil by N2 injected to TK467 after the water cut of well TK467 reaching 100%.
4. Conclusion
Fig. 8. The recovery and water cut versus total injected volume.
through fracture L3 to displace the residual oil (Fig. 10e and f).
With the oil/gas interface declining further, the attic oil in cave
D2 was displaced completely (Fig. 10g). Soon afterwards N2
migrated into cave D9 and mobilized the attic oil (Fig. 10h).
When gas breaks through, the water cut of well S48 started rising
up until to 100%, thus N2 ooding was over (Fig. 10i).
The nal recovery of experiment B1 is 82.31%, which increases
the oil recovery by 44.39% compared with that of water ooding of
37.92%. The nal recovery of experiment B2 is 80.22%, which
increases the oil recovery by 42.30%. The nal recovery of experiment B3 is 81.16%, which increases the oil recovery by 43.75%.
Comparing these results, it can be seen that these three kinds of N2
ooding methods can all increase the nal recovery signicantly
and the increasing rates are also close. Also in fact, the injection
volumes of N2 injection are the same in these three experiments.
D. Yuan et al. / Journal of Petroleum Science and Engineering 129 (2015) 1522
Fig. 9. The mobilizing process of residual oil by N2 injected to well S48 after water ooding.
Fig. 10. The mobilizing process of residual oil by N2 injected to well TK467 after water ooding.
21
22
D. Yuan et al. / Journal of Petroleum Science and Engineering 129 (2015) 1522
water in Experiment B1 is much less than the ones in Experiments B2 and B3 and the ultimate recoveries of these three
experiments are almost the same. Therefore in terms of N2
injection timing, it is better to conduct N2 injection when the
water cut of well TK467 reached 100%. In addition, because
the regions where N2 displaced the residual oil are almost
the same, N2 ooding efciency for fractured-cavity carbonate reservoir has little relationship with the selection of
injection well.
Acknowledgments
The authors gratefully acknowledge nancial support from
National Science and Technology Major Project of China
(2011ZX05014-003), National Basic Research Development Program (973) of China (2011CB201006), and Science Foundation of
China University of Petroleum, Beijing (2462014YJRC053).
References
Chen, Z.H., Liu, C.H., Yang, J., Huang, G.T., Lu, X.B., 2005. Development strategy of
fractured-vuggy carbonate reservoirs-taking Ordovician oil/gas reservoirs in
main development blocks of Tahe oileld as examples. Oil Gas Geol. 0253-9985
(2005) 05-0623-07.
Chen, Z.J., Liu, L., Wang, W., 2010. Characteristics and controlling factors of the
upper Ordovician petroleum reservoirs in the Tazhong No. 1 fault belt, Tarim
Basin. Pet. Explor. Dev. 1000-0747 (2010) 04-0409-07.
Du, J.H., Zhou, X.Y., Li, Q.M., Wu, G.H., Pan, W.Q., Yang, T., 2011. Characteristics and
controlling factors of the large carbonate petroleum province in the Tarim
Basin, NW China. Pet. Explor. Dev. 1000-0747 (2011), 06-0652-10.
Hernandez, J.C.; Juarez, R.I. (2001): Oil Displacement by Water in Vuggy Fractured
Porous Media. SPE-69637
Karpov, V.B.; Kokorev, V.I. (2008): Gas Utilizing MethodsA New Technology of Oil
Recovery Factor Improvement, SPE-117373.
Li, J., Peng, C.Z., Wang, L., Sun, L., Lin, T., 2008a. Simulation experiment of waterdisplacing-oil mechanism in fractured-cavity carbonate oil reservoirs. Nat. Gas
Explor. Dev. 31 (4), 4144.
Li, J.J., Jiang, H.Q., Xu, H., Qin, J.S., Chen, M.F., 2009. Experiment on production laws
for single well in vuggy carbonate reservoir. J. China Univ. Pet., 16735005. ) 020085-05.
Li, J.Y., Jiang, H.Q., Li, J.J., Chen, M.F., Tu, X.W., Ren, W.B., 2008b. The feasibility study
for fractured and vavernous carbonate reservoir by injection nitrogen. Inn.
Mongolia Petrochem. Ind. 23, 8487.
Liu Z.C.; Hou J.R.; Li J.L.; Cheng Q. (2012): Study of Residual Oil in Tahe 4th Block
Karstic/Fractured Heavy Oil Reservoir, SPE-151592.
Lu, M.H., Zhang, C., Xu, J.X., Wang, S.D., Wei, J.X., Song, X.J., 2010. Inverse-scattering
imaging of cavern models. Pet. Explor. Dev. 100020747 (2010), 0320330208.
Lu, X.B., 2003. Heterogeneity of Karst-vuggy carbonate reservoir rocks. Xinjiang Pet.
Geol. 10013873 (2003), 04-0360-03.
Poole, E.S. (1986): Evaluation and Implementation of CO2 Injection at the Dollarhide Devonian Unit. SPE-17277.
Popov, P.; Bi, L.F.; Efendiev, Y.; Ewing, R.E.; Qin, G.; Li, J.L.; Ren, Y.L. (2007):
Multiphysics and Multiscale Methods for Modeling Fluid Flow Through
Naturally Fractured Vuggy Carbonate Reservoirs. SPE-105378.
Rosales, C.P.; Diaz, A.M.; Hernandez, J.C.; Juarez, R.I. (2002): Electric Resistivity of
Vuggy Fractured Media. SPE-74340 .
Wang, L., Dou, Z.L., Lin, T., Zhao, H.Y., Luo, J., 2011. Study on the visual modeling of
water ooding in carbonate fracture-cavity reservoir. J. Southwest Pet. Univ.
16745086 (2011) 02-0121-04.
Xiao, Y.R.; He, F.Y.; Sun Y.M. (2003): Reservoir characteristics of paleocave
carbonates-a case study of Ordovician paleocave in Tahe oileld, Tarim Basin.
Oil Gas Geol., 02539985 (2003) 01-0075-06.
Xu, T.; Lun Z.M.; Zhang, X.H.; Lv, C.Y. (2010): Gravity drainage in oil-wet carbonate
matrix rock system. Pet. Explor. Dev., 10000747(2010) 03-0358-05
Zheng, S.Q.; Li, Y.; Zhang H.F. (2010): Fracture-cavity network model for fracturecavity carbonate reservoir. J. China Univ. Pet., 16735005( 2010) 03-0072-04.