Está en la página 1de 32

HAZOP RECORD FORM

Facility/Project
MEG Reclamation Pilot Plant

Date
10/12/2014
Team Members
Ana Carmem G. B.; Ana Maria G. L.;
Bernardo de Sa R.; Gabriel V. S.; Gabriela F.
F.; Maximiano K. F.; Raphael de Souza R.

Drawing No./Procedure
26164_P&ID_001
Subject
From Chemical Dosing Tank (F100) to the Flash
Separator (K200), passing through Pump J100

DEVIATION

CAUSE

High Mixing

Agitator failure (1)

Low Mixing

As for (1);
paddle stirrers corrosion
and/or erosion
High feed rate to dosing
tank (F100)

High Level

Low Level

High Flow

EFFECT

SAFEGUARDS

Temperature rise; salts


properties alteration; vortex
formation; paddle stirrers
corrosion and/or erosion
Desired homogeneity not
achieved; pumps erosion

Speed indicator (SIC100);


mixing motor (M100); hand
switch (HS100) (2)

Flooding; pressure surges (4)

Level transmitter (L100);


manual drain connected to a
valve (V100) (5)

Pump (J100) or valve


(V101) failure

As for (4)

As for (5);
Flow controller (FC102);
hand switch (HS102) (6)

Low feed rate to dosing


tank (F100)
Pump (J100) racing

Paddle stirrers corrosion;


sludge formation (8)
As for (8)

Level transmitter (L100)

Pump (J100) racing

Dosing tank (F100) pressure


lost; flash separator (K200)
pressure gain; low level on
dosing tank; high level on
flash separator (K200); pump
(J100) cavitation

As for (6);
valve (V103) and manual
drain point valve (V100)

As for (2)

As for (6)

ACTION
Send a specialist to fix
the motor in order to
control the agitators
velocity (3)
As for (3)
Install a high level
alarm; automatic
switch of valve (V100)
connected to level
transmitter (L100)
Pump and valve
regular maintenance;
install a speed
frequency controller (7)
Install a low level
alarm
As for (7)
Install a flow
transmitter (9);
pump regular
maintenance (10)

DEVIATION

CAUSE

EFFECT

Low Flow

Pump (J100) racing;


pump (J100) cavitation;

High level on dosing


tank(F100); low level on flash
separator (K200); dosing tank
pressure gain; flash separator
pressure lost (11)
As for (11)

As for (6)

As for (9);
as for (10)

As for (6)

As for (9);
valve regular
maintenance (12)

As for (11)

As for (6)

As for (9);
as for (12)

As for (11);

As for (6);
manual drain point from
valve (V100) (13)
Chemical dosing tank mixing
motor controller (SIC100)

As for (9);

No Flow

Manual drain point


failure (valve V100
failure : opened all
time);
Valve
(V101,V102,NRV201)
failure: obstructed route
Pump (J100) failure

Commissioning

Wrong installation of an
equipment or instrument
such as a mixing motor,
a pump or a valve

Dosing tank (F100) mixing


motor failure; Pump (J100)
failure; valve (V100, V101,
V102, NRV201) failure

Contaminants

Paddle stirrers
corrosion; pump (J100)
corrosion; pump (J100)
erosion;

Contaminate the solution;


change solutions properties;

SAFEGUARDS

No safeguards

ACTION

Install a motor
controller on pump
J100;
pump and valve
regular maintenance
(14)
As for (14)

HAZOP RECORD FORM


Facility/Project
MEG Reclamation Pilot Plant

Date
10/12/2014

Drawing No./Procedure
26164_P&ID_001

Team Members
Ana Carmem G. B.; Ana Maria G. L.;
Bernardo de Sa R.; Gabriel V. S.; Gabriela F.
F.; Maximiano K. F.; Raphael de Souza R.

Subject
From Pump J100 to the Pump J101 passing
through the Feed Tank (F101)

DEVIATION

CAUSE

High Level

Increase in the input


flow on the feed tank
(F101) due to the higher
pump (J100) race

Low Level

EFFECT

SAFEGUARDS

ACTION

Flooding; pressure surges

Hand switch on pump J100


(HS102); flow controller on
pump J100 (FC102) (1);
manual drain connected to a
valve (V107); manual drain
connected to a valve (V109) (2)

Pump (J101) or valve


(V108) failure

Flooding; pressure surges

As for (2);
feed pump (J101) over
temperature; feed pump (J101)
motor controller

Low feed rate on the


feed tank (F101) due to
a failure on pump J100

Process inefficiency since the


feed tank F101 is the mainly
tank in the system (6)

Pump J101 failure

As for (6)

As for (1);
level switch indicating the feed
tank F101 low level (LSL101)
(7)
As for (7);
feed pump (J101) over
temperature; feed pump (J101)
motor controller

Install a level
transmitter; install a
high level alarm on
the feed tank F101
(3);
pump regular
maintenance (4)
As for (3);
install an automatic
switch of valve
(V107,V109)
connected to level
transmitter;
as for (4);
valve regular
maintenance (5)
Increase the inlet
flow of reagents (8)
As for (8)

DEVIATION

CAUSE

High Flow

Pump (J100) racing

Low Flow

Pump (J100) racing;


valve V103 failure;
pump (J100) cavitation

No Flow

Pump (J100) failure;


closed valve

High Concentration

Low Concentration

EFFECT
Feed tank (F101) pressure
gain; high level on feed tank
(F101); pump (J101)
cavitation
Feed tank (F101) pressure
lost; low level on feed tank
(F101) (9)

SAFEGUARDS

ACTION
Install a flow
transmitter

As for (9)

As for (1);
manual drain connected to a
valve (V107); manual drain
connected to a valve (V109);
As for (1);
Level switch indicating the feed
tank F101 low level (LSL101)
(10)
As for (10)

Pump J100 racing (12)

Flash separator inefficiency


(13)

Valve V103 and flow controller


FC102 (14)

As for (12)

As for (13)

As for (14)

Install a flow
transmitter before
entering the feed
tank (15)
As for (15)

Commissioning

Wrong installation of an
equipment such as a
pump or a valve

Pump (J100,J101) failure;


valve failure
(V103,V107,V108,V109)

Feed pump (J101) over


temperature alarm (TSH101)

As for (11)

Contaminants

Pump (J100) corrosion;


pump (J100) erosion;
valve (V103,V108)
corrosion due
mechanical friction

Contaminate the solution;


change solutions properties

No safeguards

As for (11)

Pump and valve


regular maintenance
(11)
As for (11)

HAZOP RECORD FORM


Facility/Project
MEG Reclamation Pilot Plant

Date
10/12/2014

Drawing No./Procedure
26164_P&ID_001

Team Members
Ana Carmem G. B.; Ana Maria G. L.;
Bernardo de Sa R.; Gabriel V. S.; Gabriela F.
F.; Maximiano K. F.; Raphael de Souza R.

Subject
Feed recycle loop from the Pump J101 back to the
Feed Tank (F101)

DEVIATION
High Flow

Low Flow

No Flow

CAUSE

EFFECT

SAFEGUARDS

ACTION

Pump (J101) racing

Increase in the recycle flow (1) Feed pump (J101) over


temperature sensor (TE101),
feed pump (J101) motor
controller (SIC101) and feed
pump (J101) over temperature
alarm (TSH101) (2)

Install a flow
transmitter (3);
pump regular
maintenance (4)

Valve (V111,V112)
failure: opened route

As for (1)

As for (3);
valve regular
maintenance (6)

Pump (J101) racing;


pump (J101) cavitation

Decrease in the recycle flow


(6)

The valve type can be


considered a safeguard since a
globe valve uses a plug closing
against the flow being good for
regulating flow while the ball
valve has a gate that closes
across the flow that is better for
on/off control without pressure
drop (5)
As for (2)

Valve (V111, V112)


failure: obstructed route

As for (6)

As for (5)

As for (4)

As for (2);
as for (5)

Pump and valve


maintenance (7)

Pump (J101) or valve No recycle loop back to the


(V111,V112) failure
feed tank (F101)

As for (3)

DEVIATION

CAUSE

Commissioning

Wrong installation of an
equipment such as a
pump or a valve
Pump (J101) corrosion;
pump (J101) erosion;
valve (V111,V112)
corrosion due
mechanical friction

Contaminants

EFFECT
Pump (J101) failure; valve
failure (V111,V112)

SAFEGUARDS
As for (2)

Contaminate the solution;


No safeguards
change in solutions properties

ACTION
As for (7)
As for (7)

HAZOP RECORD FORM


Facility/Project
MEG Reclamation Pilot Plant

Date
10/12/2014

Drawing No./Procedure
26164_P&ID_001

Team Members
Ana Carmem G. B.; Ana Maria G. L.;
Bernardo de Sa R.; Gabriel V. S.; Gabriela F.
F.; Maximiano K. F.; Raphael de Souza R.

Subject
Feed line from the Pump (J101) up to the Flash
Separator (K200)

DEVIATION
High Flow

CAUSE
Pump (J101) racing

No Flow

SAFEGUARDS

ACTION

Feed tank (F101) pressure


lost, flash separator (K200)
pressure gain, low level on
feed tank, high level on flash
separator (K200) and pump
(J101) cavitation (1)
As for (1)

Feed pump (J101) over


temperature sensor (TE101),
feed pump (J101) motor
controller (SIC101) and feed
pump (J101) over temperature
alarm (TSH101) (2)
No safeguards

Pump (J101) racing;


pump (J101) cavitation

Feed tank (F101) pressure


gain, flash separator (K200)
pressure lost, high level on
feed tank and low level on
flash separator (K200) (7)

As for (2)

Install a flow
controller; install a
flow transmitter;
valve regular
maintenance (4)
As for (3)

Valve (V113, NRV200)


failure: obstructed route

As for (7)

No safeguards

As for (4)

Pump (J101) failure

As for (7)

As for (2)

As for (3)

Valve (V113,NRV200)
failure

As for (7)

No safeguards

As for (4)

Valve (V113, NRV200)


failure: opened route

Low Flow

EFFECT

Install a flow
controller, install a
flow transmitter and
pump regular
maintenance (3)

HAZOP RECORD FORM


Facility/Project
MEG Reclamation Pilot Plant

Date
10/12/2014
Team Members
Ana Carmem G. B.; Ana Maria G. L.;
Bernardo de Sa R.; Gabriel V. S.; Gabriela F.
F.; Maximiano K. F.; Raphael de Souza R.

Drawing No./Procedure
26164_P&ID_001
Subject
From Storage Tank (R500) to the Feed Tank
(F101)

DEVIATION

CAUSE

EFFECT
Flooding; high pressure on
storage tank (R500)

SAFEGUARDS

High Level (R500)

Failure of pump J400

Valve leaving the storage tank

Low Level (F101)

Failure of pump J500 (1) Inefficiency of the process


since feed tank (F101) must
always have a minimum level

Level control with pump J101

High Flow

As for (1)

Level rise on feed tank (F101)


and level drop on storage tank
(R500)

Valves installed before and


after pump J500 allow regular
maintenance of the pump; flow
transmitter (FT101) (2)

Low Flow

As for (1)

Failure to increase the level


on feed tank (F101) and/or
failure to decrease the level
on storage tank (R500)

As for (2)

ACTION
Install a level
transmitter and
controller on storage
tank (R500),
connected to pump
J500
Install a level
transmitter and
controller on feed
tank (F101),
connected to pump
J500 as a second
alternative
Regular
maintenance of the
pump (3)
As for (3)

DEVIATION

CAUSE

EFFECT

Contaminants

Corrosion/erosion of
pump J500 and/or
corrosion/erosion of
valve leaving the
storage tank (R500) and
valve V106

Inefficiency of the process


since it wont have pure MEG

SAFEGUARDS
Valves installed before and
after pump J500 allow regular
maintenance of the pump

ACTION
Regular
maintenance of the
valves and the
pump

HAZOP RECORD FORM


Facility/Project
MEG Reclamation Pilot Plant

Date
10/12/2014
Team Members
Ana Carmem G. B.; Ana Maria G. L.;
Bernardo de Sa R.; Gabriel V. S.; Gabriela F.
F.; Maximiano K. F.; Raphael de Souza R.

Drawing No./Procedure
26164_P&ID_001
Subject
From the Flash Separator (K200) to Valves V200,
V201 and V203

DEVIATION

CAUSE

High Temperature

Failure in
communication between
controllers of the flash
separator with
controllers of the heat
exchanger (H300) (1);
overheat in the flash
separator due to:
heat exchanger (H300)
and/or HS204, TE211,
TT211, TIR211, TE212,
TSH212, TZAH212
malfunction
As for (1);
heat exchanger (H300)
and/or HS204, TE211,
TT211, TIR211, TE212,
TSH212, TZAH212
malfunction; malfunction
of valves V309 and/or
V310, PCV300

Low Temperature

EFFECT
Change in solution and salt
crystals properties; MEG
degradation

SAFEGUARDS

Valve V204; instruments


HS204, TT211, TIR211,
TSH212, temperature
sensors (TE211,TE212),
high temperature alarm
(TZAH212) and
communication between
controllers of the flash
separator with controllers of
the heat exchanger (H300);
temperature sensor TE202
and transmitter TT202 could
predict this outcome
Inefficient MEG separation;
Instruments HS204, TT211,
lower salt concentration due
TIR211, TSH212;
to the higher presence of
temperature sensors
MEG, leading to a salt
(TE211,TE212) and
solution provided by the pipe
communication between
containing the valve V203 with controllers of the flash
less salt than expected for the separator with controllers of
heating recycle flow, and
the heat exchanger (H300)
probably more water and
MEG

ACTION
Decrease the
temperature by less
steam input into the
heat exchanger
(H300); maintenance
and, if that is the case,
fixing of the pipelines

Increase the
temperature by more
steam input on heat
exchanger H300;
maintenance and, if
that is the case, fixing
of the pipelines

DEVIATION
High Pressure

High Level

Low Level

CAUSE
Failure of the vacuum
system; high flow into
the flash separator
(K200) from heat
exchanger (H300) and
from the feed and
dosing tank (F101 and
F100 respectively)
combined or not with
failure (not opening) of
the valves V200, V201,
V202, V203 (2);
malfunction of the
safeguards related to
pressure, temperature
and level (3)
As for (2);
as for (3)

As for (3);
pump racing (J300); low
flow into the flash
separator (K200) from
heat exchanger (H300)
and from the feed and
dosing tank (F101 and
F100 respectively)
combined or not with
failure (not closing) of
the valves V200, V201,
V202, V203, V302,
V303, V305;
failure (closure) of valve
NRV200

EFFECT

SAFEGUARDS

A flammable atmosphere at a
temperature above the flash
point may be created in the
gas space within the Flash
Separator, which can result in
explosions

Valve V222; pressure


instruments PI202, PT203,
PIR203 and PIC203
connected to the pressure
control valve PCV203;
level instruments LT200,
LTC200, LR200 and level
controller LTC200 connected
with heat exchanger (H300)
controllers (4)

Can lead to a high pressure


problem, as stated above;
flooding

As for (4);
valve V200 leading to a
manual bleed point; flow
transmitter FT200 and
controller FCT200
Vortex breaker connected with As for (4);
valve V202 may not deliver
flow transmitter FT200 and
the correct amount and
controller FCT200
concentration of solution for
the heating recycle flow;
corrosion of equipment

ACTION
Use the valve V222
and the vacuum
system, always
avoiding sources of
ignition anywhere
within the flash
separator (K200)

Maintenance of the
valves of the MEG Rig
plant
Maintenance of the
valves of the MEG Rig
plant; fix the pump
J300

DEVIATION

CAUSE

Static Build-up

Presence of salts and


variations in pressure,
temperature and
composition of
liquid/gas
Vortex formation due to
vortex breaker
malfunction

High Mixing

EFFECT

SAFEGUARDS

ACTION

Source of ignition

Instruments CT200, TI200,


TIR200, CI200, CIR200

Correct concentration
of salts into the
solution

Vapour may go into the liquid,


which make the separation
process not as efficient as it
would and should be

Vortex breaker located inside Maintenance and fixing


the Flash Separator (K200)
of the vortex breaker

HAZOP RECORD FORM


Facility/Project
MEG Reclamation Pilot Plant

Date
10/12/2014
Team Members
Ana Carmem G. B.; Ana Maria G. L.;
Bernardo de Sa R.; Gabriel V. S.; Gabriela F.
F.; Maximiano K. F.; Raphael de Souza R.

Drawing No./Procedure
26164_P&ID_001
Subject
From the Valve V202 to the Heat Exchanger
(H300)

DEVIATION

CAUSE

High Temperature

Overheat in the flash


separator due to:
heat exchanger (H300)
and/or HS204, TE211,
TT211, TIR211, TE212,
TSH212, TZAH212
malfunction;
failure in communication
between Controllers of
the flash separator with
controllers of the heat
exchanger (H300) (1)
The overheat in flash
separator (K200) leads
to a high temperature
liquid arriving into the
recycle pump
Recycle pump (J300)
racing (4)

EFFECT

SAFEGUARDS

ACTION

Change in solution and salt


crystals properties; MEG
degradation (2)

Valve V204; hand switch


HS204; temperature
instruments TT211, TIR211,
TSH212; temperature
sensors (TE211,TE212);
communication between
controllers of the flash
separator with controllers of
the heat exchanger (H300);
high temperature alarm
(TZAH212)

Decrease the
temperature by less
steam input into the
heat exchanger
(H300); maintenance
and, if that is the case,
fixing of the pipelines
(3)

As for (2)

Temperature Instruments
TE315, TSH315 and high
temperature alarm
(TZAH315)

As for (3)

High flow of a liquid with


higher temperature

Temperature instruments
TW322, TE322, TIR320,
TDIR321, TIR322 and
temperature controller
TDCR321 (5)

Fix the recycle pump

DEVIATION

CAUSE

EFFECT

SAFEGUARDS

Low Temperature

As for (1);
heat exchanger (H300)
and/or HS204, TE211,
TT211, TIR211, TE212,
TSH212 malfunction;
malfunction of valves
V309 and/or V310,
PCV300

Inefficient MEG separation;


lower salt concentration due
to the higher presence of
MEG, leading to a salt
solution provided by the pipe
containing the valve V203 with
less salt than expected for the
heating recycle flow, and
probably more water and
MEG
High flow into the heat
exchanger (H300) may lead to
an insufficient heating of the
solution

As for (4);
As for (5);
temperature sensor (TE315)

Increase the
temperature by more
steam input on heat
exchanger H300;
maintenance and, if
that is the case, fixing
of the pipelines

Flow control instruments


SIC300, SIR300, HS304,
FT302, DIR302, FIR302,
TIR323 (6);
valves V303, V305 (leading
to a manual drain point)
As for (6);
level controllers connected to
the flash separator vessel
(K200)
As for (6)

Maintenance and fixing


of the pump, the last
one only if its
necessary

As for (6)

Maintenance of the
pipeline, paying
special attention to the
valves V303 and V305,
that shouldnt be
always opened, and
the valve V302 that
mustnt be always
jammed or closed

High Flow

As for (4)

Low Flow

Low Level in Flash


Separator (K200)

Pump failure

Recycle pump (J300)


failure related to poor
suction conditions

Cavitation; low flow into the


heat exchanger (H300) may
lead to a solution overheated;
cavitation inside the recycle
pump (J300)
Low flow into the heat
exchanger (H300) may lead to
a solution overheated;
cavitation inside the recycle
pump (J300)

Drain leaking; valve


jammed

ACTION

Look for problems


related to the level of
solution inside the
flash
Maintenance and fixing
of the pump, the last
one only if its
necessary

DEVIATION

CAUSE

EFFECT

Low Flow

High concentration of
salt due to low level
inside the flash or errors
related to the
concentration of salt
given by the dosing tank
Recycle pump (J300)
failure
Valve V302 jammed and
not opening at all

Blockage of pump and/or


valves; low flow into the heat
exchanger (H300) may lead to
a solution overheated;
cavitation inside the recycle
pump (J300)
Failure of all the heating
system of the flash
Failure of all the heating
system of the flash

As for (6)

Gas locking due to


presence of gas if the
vortex breaker doesnt
work properly
Recycle pump (J300)
failure (pump reversed)

Heating system inefficient

As for (6)

Failure of all the heating


system of the flash

As for (6)

No Flow

Reverse Flow

SAFEGUARDS

As for (6)
As for (6)

ACTION
Maintenance of the
system and attention
to the concentration of
salt measured in the
bottom part of the flash
separator
Fix the pump
Change or
maintenance of the
valve V302
Maintenance of the
vortex breaker
Fix the recycle pump
(J300)

HAZOP RECORD FORM


Facility/Project
MEG Reclamation Pilot Plant

Date
10/12/2014
Team Members
Ana Carmem G. B.; Ana Maria G. L.;
Bernardo de Sa R.; Gabriel V. S.; Gabriela F.
F.; Maximiano K. F.; Raphael de Souza R.

Drawing No./Procedure
26164_P&ID_001
Subject
From the Heat Exchanger (H300) to the Flash
Separator (K200)

DEVIATION

CAUSE

EFFECT

SAFEGUARDS

ACTION

High Temperature

Overheat in the flash


separator due to:
heat exchanger (H300)
and/or HS204, TE211,
TT211, TIR211, TE212,
TSH212, TZAH212
malfunction

Change in solution and salt


crystals properties; MEG
degradation; If the fluid is
overheated, the flash
separator (K200) may have its
temperature risen, which can
cause high pressure problems
into the vessel

Valve V204; hand switch


HS204; temperature
instruments TT211, TIR211,
TSH212; temperature
sensors (TE211,TE212) (1);
high temperature alarm
(TZAH212);
communication between
controllers of the flash
separator with controllers of
the heat exchanger (H300)
(2)
temperature instruments
TE315, TSH315, TW322,
TE322, TIR320, TDIR321,
TIR322, TW320, TE320,
TW319, TE319, TSH319 and
temperature controller
TDCR321 (3);
high temperature alarm
TZAH315; high temperature
alarm TZAH319; valve V205

Decrease the
temperature by less
steam input into the
heat exchanger
(H300); maintenance
and, if that is the case,
fixing of the pipelines

DEVIATION

CAUSE

EFFECT

High Temperature

Failure of
communication among
the following controllers:
TDCR321, LTC200 and
PCV300 (4)

If the fluid is overheated, the


flash separator (K200) may
have its temperature risen,
which can degrade MEG and
cause high pressure problems
into the flash vessel as well
(5)

Failure (not opening) of


valves V311, V312 and
V313
As for (4)

As for (5)

Failure (not closing) of


valves V311, V312 and
V313
Not enough steam from
building supply into the
heat exchanger (H300)
due to: pressure
indicator PI204
malfunction; valves
V309 and/or V310
jammed or fail to open

As for (9)

Low Temperature

If the fluid is not hot enough,


the flash separator (K200)
may not be efficient to
vaporize the MEG/water
mixture (9)

As for (9)

SAFEGUARDS
Temperature controller
TDCR321, temperature
instruments TIR320,
TDIR321, TIR322, TW320,
TE320, TW319, TE319,
TSH319 (6);
high temperature alarm
TZAH319 (7);
valve V205 (8)
As for (6);
as for (8)
Temperature instruments
TW322, TE322, TIR320,
TDIR321, TIR322, TW320,
TE320, TW319, TE319,
temperature controllers
TDCR321 (10)
As for (10)
As for (10);
pressure indicator PI204

ACTION
Maintenance and if it is
necessary, change or
fix the controllers

Maintenance and if it is
necessary, change of
fix the valves
Maintenance and if it is
necessary, change or
fix the controllers

Maintenance and if it is
necessary, change of
fix the valves
Maintenance and if it is
necessary, change or
fix the controllers and
valves

DEVIATION

CAUSE

EFFECT

Low Temperature

Heat exchanger (H300)


and/or HS204, TE211,
TT211, TIR211, TE212,
TSH212, TZAH212
malfunction

As for (1);
as for (2);
as for (3)

Increase the
temperature by more
steam input on heat
exchanger H300;
maintenance and, if
that is the case, fixing
of the pipelines

High Flow

Leak in heat exchanger


(H300), promoting
steam and solution
mixture

Inefficient MEG separation;


lower salt concentration due
to the higher presence of
MEG, leading to a salt
solution provided by the pipe
containing the valve V203 with
less salt than expected for the
heating recycle flow, and
probably more water and
MEG
Solution overheated,
composition changed, ingress
of steam can lead to presence
of contaminants that can react
with the solution or
equipment, damaging the
operation
As for (9);
high flow into the heat
exchanger (H300) may lead to
an insufficient heating of the
solution

Pressure indicator PI204;


speed viewing device
SG301; temperature
instruments TE320, TW320,
TW319, TE319, TSH319;
high temperature alarm
TZAH319; valve V205
As for (10);
speed/frequency instruments
SIC300, SIR300, hand
switch HS304 and flow
control instruments FT302,
DIR302, FIR302, TIR323
(11);
valves V303, V305 (leading
to a manual drain point)

Fix the heat exchanger

Pump failure

As for (11);
level controllers connected to
the flash separator Vessel
(K200)

Look for problems


related to the level of
solution inside the
flash

Recycle pump (J300)


racing

Low Flow

Low level in flash


separator (K200)

SAFEGUARDS

ACTION

Maintenance and fixing


of the pump, the last
one only if its
necessary

DEVIATION
Low Flow

CAUSE
Recycle pump (J300)
failure related to poor
suction conditions

High concentration of
salt due to low level
inside the flash or errors
related to the
concentration of salt
given by the dosing tank
Valve V205 malfunction,
half or completely
opened when it
shouldnt be
Drain leaking

No Flow

Valve V302, V304 or


V204 jammed and not
opening at all
Gas locking due to
presence of gas if the
vortex breaker doesnt
work properly
Heat exchanger (H300)
leaking all the fluid
outside the system

EFFECT

SAFEGUARDS

ACTION

As for (5);
cavitation; low flow into the
heat exchanger (H300) may
lead to a solution overheated,
which can rise the pressure in
the flash vessel (K200);
cavitation inside the recycle
pump (J300)
As for (5);
blockage of pump and/or
valves; low flow into the heat
exchanger (H300) may lead to
a solution overheated, which
can rise the pressure in the
flash vessel (K200)
Less volume of heated
solution into the flash vessel
can lead to an inefficient
separation of MEG/water from
salt
As for (5);
low flow into the heat
exchanger (H300) may lead to
a solution overheated, which
can rise the pressure in the
flash vessel (K200);
Failure of all the heating
system of the flash (13)

As for (6);
as for (7);
as for (11)

Maintenance and fixing


of the pump, the last
one only if its
necessary

As for (6);
as for (7);
as for (11)

Maintenance of the
system and attention
to the concentration of
salt measured in the
bottom part of the flash
separator

Level controller LTC200 and


level recorder LR200 (12)

Maintenance and if it is
necessary, fix the
valve

Flow control instruments


FT302, DIR302, FIR302,
TIR323

Check valves V303


and V305

As for (11)

As for (13)

As for (11)

Change or
maintenance of the
valve V302
Maintenance of the
vortex breaker

As for (13)

As for (12)

Fix or change the heat


exchanger (H300)

DEVIATION
Reverse Flow
High Pressure

CAUSE
Recycle pump (J300)
reversed
High temperature

EFFECT

SAFEGUARDS

As for (13)

As for (12)

Rise of pressure in the flash


separator (K200)

As for (6);
as for (7);
as for (8)

ACTION
Maintenance of the
plant
Use valve V222 and
check possible
problems in the plant
that led to high
temperature

HAZOP RECORD FORM


Facility/Project
MEG Reclamation Pilot Plant

Date
10/12/2014
Team Members
Ana Carmem G. B.; Ana Maria G. L.;
Bernardo de Sa R.; Gabriel V. S.; Gabriela F.
F.; Maximiano K. F.; Raphael de Souza R.

Drawing No./Procedure
26164_P&ID_001
Subject
From the Separation Column (E200) to the Bleed
Down (R403) and the Sampling Receiver (R404)

DEVIATION

CAUSE

EFFECT

SAFEGUARDS

ACTION

Temperature sensors
(TE306,TE308,TE310,TE312);
high temperature alarms
(TZAH306,TZAH308,TZAH310,
312)
Temperature sensors
(TE306,308,310,312); sampling
receiver (R404)

Decrease the
temperature by less
steam input on heat
exchanger H300

High temperature

Overheat in the flash


separator

Change in solution and salt


crystals properties; MEG
degradation

Low temperature

Flash separator
temperature under set
point

Inefficient MEG separation;


lower salt concentration due
to the higher presence of
MEG

Blockage in separation
column due to
incrustation and/or salt
accumulation
Failure in vacuum pump
(J200); failure in valves
V409 and/or V411

Flooding; corrosion; erosion;


break of salt loop operation.

Bleed down (R403); high level


alarms (LZAH300,
LZAH301,LZAH302,LZAH303)

No testing (no sample


collection due to the lack of
pressure difference). The
separation column (E200) will
be at the same pressure as
the bleed down (R403) and
the sampling receiver (R404)
Motor temperature rise; vortex
formation

Pressure indicators
(PI400,PI401,PI402,PI403).

High level

High pressure testing

High speed

Motor malfunction
(M300,301,302,303) (1)

Temperature controllers
(TIC305,307,309,311); hand
switches
(HS300,HS301,HS302,HS303)

Increase the
temperature by
more steam input on
heat exchanger
H300
Regular
maintenance of the
separation column
(E200)
Install high pressure
alarms; vacuum
pump (J200) regular
maintenance; valves
V409 and V411
regular maintenance
Motor
(M300,M301,M302,
M303) regular
maintenance (2)

DEVIATION
Low speed

CAUSE
As for (1)

EFFECT
Insufficient wash of the MEG
residue from the salts

SAFEGUARDS
Conductivity transmitters
(CT300,CT301,CT302,
CT303,CT304); sampling
receiver (R404) to analyse
MEG concentration

ACTION
As for (2)

HAZOP RECORD FORM


Facility/Project
MEG Reclamation Pilot Plant

Date
10/12/2014
Team Members
Ana Carmem G. B.; Ana Maria G. L.;
Bernardo de Sa R.; Gabriel V. S.; Gabriela F.
F.; Maximiano K. F.; Raphael de Souza R.

Drawing No./Procedure
26164_P&ID_001
Subject
Salt loop (from R400 to R401 and back to R400)

DEVIATION
No Flow

CAUSE

EFFECT

SAFEGUARDS

No feed to salt tank

No production of brine (1);


column full of salt

Conductivity control in the


column

Pump J401 failure

As for (1)

Speed frequency control,


temperature control and
pressure control in the pump
Flow rate transmitters
(FT400,401,402)

No water feed into the


brine tank; valve V428
closed in error
Line blockage/closed
valve
Line fracture
High Flow

Pump J401 racing

Low Flow

Pump J401 failure

ACTION
Install level alarm on
R400 (2)

As for (2);
regular maintenance in
the pump
As for (1);
Regular maintenance
high salt concentration in the
in the valve (3);
stream
install level alarm on
R401; composition
transmitter in pipelines
As for (1);
Temperature sensor (TE403); Regular maintenance
overload of the pump J401
FT400,FT401,FT402
in the valves
As for (1);
FT400,FT401,FT402
Regular inspection in
leakage
the lines
Low level of salt tank; high
Speed frequency control,
Regular maintenance
pressure stream in brine tank;
temperature control and
in the pump (4);
low pressure in salt tank; pump pressure control in the pump; open valves V416,
temperature rise
manual drain;
V419 or V420
FT400,FT401,FT402
Low production of brine (5)
Speed frequency control,
As for (4)
temperature control, pressure
control in the pump;
FT400,FT401,FT402

DEVIATION

CAUSE

Low Flow

Sedimentation of salts
in pipes

High Concentration
Low Concentration

High Level (R400)

High Level (R401)

EFFECT

SAFEGUARDS

As for (5);
line blockage; change in
desired fluid properties and
concentration
As for (5)

FT400,FT401,FT402

As for (5)

FT402

High water feed to


R401
J401 failure

Change in desired fluid


properties (6)
As for (5);
as for (6)

FT402

High feed to R400


from the column

Flooding in R400 (7)

High feed from brine


tank
J401 failure

As for (7)

Line blockage

As for (7)

High water feed

Flooding in R401 and change


in brine composition (9)

Low water influx to


R401
Low water feed to
R401

As for (7)

Flow transmitter (FT402)

Speed frequency control;


temperature control; pressure
control in the pump
Conductivity control in the
column; manual drain point
(V416)
FT400;
Manual drain point (V416)
Speed frequency control,
temperature control and
pressure control in the pump;
manual drain point (V416 and
V419)
FT400,FT401,FT402; manual
drain point (V416, V419 and
V420)
FT402; manual drain point
(V425); valves V428 and
V429

ACTION
Regular inspection in
the lines; install
composition
transmitter in pipelines
Increase water feed
Increase water feed;
install composition
transmitter in pipelines
Decrease water feed
As for (4)
Install high level alarm
in R400 (8);
open drain point
As for (8);
open drain point
As for (4);
as for (8);
open drain point
As for (8);
regular inspection in
the lines; open drain
point
Install high level alarm
in R401 (10);
open drain point;
close V428 or V429

DEVIATION

CAUSE

EFFECT

High Level (R401)

High feed from salt


tank (J401 racing)

As for (9);
pump temperature rise

Low Level (R400)

Low feed from the


column

Change in brine composition


(11)

Low feed from brine


tank
J401 racing

As for (11)

Low water feed

As for (11);
accumulation of salt in
pipelines
As for (11)

Low Level (R401)

Low feed from salt


tank (J401 failure)

As for (11);
pump temperature rise

SAFEGUARDS

ACTION

Speed frequency control,


temperature control, pressure
control in the pump; manual
drain point (V425); valve
V417
Conductivity control in the
column; level switches in
column
FT400

As for (4);
as for (10);
close V417; open drain
point

Speed frequency control,


temperature control, pressure
control in the pump
FT402

As for (12)

Speed frequency control,


temperature control and
pressure control in the pump

As for (12);
regular maintenance in
the pump

Install low level alarm


in R400 (12)
As for (12)

As for (12);
increase water feed

HAZOP RECORD FORM


Facility/Project
MEG Reclamation Pilot Plant
Drawing No./Procedure
26164_P&ID_001
Subject
From the Flash Separator (K200), to the
Condensate Separator Tank (K300) passing
through condenser C201 and sub-cooler C301

DEVIATION

Date
10/12/2014
Team Members
Ana Carmem G. B.; Ana Maria G. L.;
Bernardo de Sa R.; Gabriel V. S.; Gabriela F.
F.; Maximiano K. F.; Raphael de Souza R.

CAUSE

High Flow

Pump (J200) racing

Low Flow

Pump (J200) failure

High Temperature

Low/no flow of chilled


water input on
condenser C201 and
sub-cooler C301;
valves jammed (V221
and V306)

Low temperature

High flow of chilled


water input on
condenser C201 and
sub-cooler C301

EFFECT
Inefficient process of
condensation in condenser
C201 and sub-cooler C301
(1);
leak in condenser C201 and
sub-cooler C301; flash
separator (K200) pressure
loss
Flash separator (K200)
pressure gain; cavitation in
pipelines; presence of foreign
body from corrosion;
sedimentation; leak in
condenser C201 and subcooler C301
As for (1);
change in solution properties
(4)

As for (4)

SAFEGUARDS

ACTION

Hand switch (HS200);


vacuum control valve
PCV203 (2)

Install a speed
frequency controller in
pump J200 and a flow
transmitter (3)

As for (2)

As for (3);
regular maintenance of
condensers

Flow indicators (FI202,301);


temperature sensors
(TE204,205,316,317),
transmitters
(TT204,205,316,317) and
indicators & recorders
(TIR204,205,316,317) (5)
As for (5)

Install a flow controller


in the chilled water
feed associated with
the temperature
indicators & recorders
(TIR204,316) (6)
As for (6)

DEVIATION

CAUSE

High Pressure

Failure of condenser
C201 and/or sub-cooler
C301 in cooling the
solution of MEG/water

EFFECT
Insufficient MEG/water
solution recovered; high
pressure in condensate
separator tank (K300)

SAFEGUARDS
No safeguards

ACTION
Install a high pressure
alarm; install a
pressure indicator on
K300

HAZOP RECORD FORM


Facility/Project
MEG Reclamation Pilot Plant
Drawing No./Procedure
26164_P&ID_001
Subject
From Condenser 201 to Storage Tank (R500),
passing through Vacuum Trap (K201), Vacuum
Receiver (K202) and Condensate Separator Tank
(K300)

DEVIATION
High Temperature

Low Temperature
High Pressure

Date
10/12/2014
Team Members
Ana Carmem G. B.; Ana Maria G. L.;
Bernardo de Sa R.; Gabriel V. S.; Gabriela F.
F.; Maximiano K. F.; Raphael de Souza R.

CAUSE

EFFECT

SAFEGUARDS

ACTION

Ventilated place without hot


surfaces for the J200 pump
work
Ventilated place without hot
surfaces for the J400 pump
work
Temperature indicators
TW318, TE318, TT318,
TIR318, valve V431
Presence of vacuum trap K200
and receiver K201

Install temperature
indicator in the pump
(2)
As for (2)

No ventilation around
the J200 pump

Pump damage and/or


malfunction (1)

No ventilation around
the J400 pump

As for (1)

Failure of sub-cooler
C301, leading J400
pump to heat
Cold fluid entrance in
J200 pump

As for (1)

Obstruction in the line


connected to the J200
pump

Pump damage; failure of J200 Valves V213 and V214,;


to provide vacuum
vacuum trap K200 and receiver
K201 (3)

Liquid entrance in the


J200
Water vapour entrance
above J200 pump
capacity
Obstruction in the line
connected to the J400
pump

J200 pump damage,


lubrication oil compromised
Condensing fluid dissolves in
pump oil; pump corrosion

J200 pump damage,


condensing fluid

As for (3)
As for (3)

Pump damage; failure of J400 No safeguards


to drive the MEG/water liquid
mixture

Regular maintenance
of sub-cooler C301
Temperature control
of the air entering the
pump
Install relief valve
downstream from the
pump (4)
Install extra pressure
indicator/controller
No action
As for (4)

DEVIATION
Low Pressure

Failure of Vent
Failure of Power

Failure of Vacuum

Reverse Flow

CAUSE

SAFEGUARDS

ACTION

Low flow and poor efficiency


of J200
Risk of J400 pump to air
suction; cavitation

Vacuum control valve PCV203

Correct dimensioned
pipes
Regular maintenance
(5)

Rise in J200 pump


temperature and pressure
Failure of J200 to provide
vacuum and drive the
MEG/water mixture (6)

Vent to a safe location

As for (5)

Computer monitoring of the


hand switch

Electrical failure of hand


switch HS400

Failure of J400 to drive the


MEG/water mixture (7)

Computer monitoring of the


hand switch

Internal/component
problem of J200 pump

As for (6)

Obstruction in line
near J200 pump

As for (6)

Respect the working


conditions, lifetime and
lubrication of the pump
No safeguards

Install backup
generator; check the
connection between
the switch and the
J200 pump
Install backup
generator; check the
connection between
the switch and the
J400 pump
Regular
maintenance, testing
and lubrication
As for (4)

Failure of valves V411


or V409

Failure of J200 to provide


vacuum to bleed down R403
and sampling receiver R404
As for (7)

Narrow diameter pipes


High flow in J400 pump,
stoking so fast that the
fluid cant be pulled or
sucked into the
chamber as fast as the
diaphragm is
withdrawing, lowering
pressure
Failure of vent to drive
the output of J200 pump
Electrical failure of hand
switch HS200

Failure of J400
diaphragm pump
internal check valves

EFFECT

Hand switch HS400

Pressure indicators PI400,


PI401, PI402, PI403

As for (5)

No safeguards

Install check valve


before the entrance
of the J400 pump

DEVIATION

CAUSE

Reverse Flow

Sudden power cut to


J200 pump leads to low
inertial force of rotating
parts, that cant
overcome system head
(blowback)
Overpressure in
pipeline; failure of
vacuum
Line blockage near
J200 pump
Line blockage near
J400 pump

No Flow

High Flow

Low Flow

Vapour appearance
near J400 pump,
cavitation
Failure of valve V222
Failure of vacuum
control valve PCV203
Failure of speed
indicator controller
SIC400
Partial blockage near
J200 pump
J200 pump malfunction
Partial blockage near
J400 pump
J400 pump malfunction
Failure of speed
indicator controller
SIC400 (jammed low)

EFFECT

SAFEGUARDS

ACTION

As for (6)

No safeguards

Install check valve


before the entrance
of J200

As for (6)

As for (3)

Install extra pressure


indicator/controller

As for (6)

As for (3)

As for (4)

Danger to the process


No safeguards
stability and continuation, as it
stops the MEG/water drive
Pump damage, stop to the
Speed indicator controller
process
SIC400 (8)

As for (4)

Vacuum control valve


PCV203 wont control the
adequate level of vacuum (9)
As for (9)

Hand switch HS200 (10)


As for (10)

Install flow rate


controller/transmitter
(11)
As for (11)

Risk of J400 pump to air


suction, cavitation

Hand switch HS400

As for (5)

As for (6)

Vacuum control valve PCV203

As for (11)

As for (6)
As for (7)

Vacuum control valve PCV203


As (8)

As for (11)
As for (5)

As for (7)
Low J400 pump efficiency

As (8)
No safeguards

As for (5)
As for (5)

Install temperature
indicator

DEVIATION

CAUSE

Contaminants

Failure of sintered filter


Z203, allowing
contaminated air to
enter the vacuum
system
Water or any other
liquid entering the pump
J200
Contaminant in the oil
lubricant of the J200
pump

As for (1)

Valve V205

As for (5)

As for (1)

As for (3)

As for (5)

As for (1)

Check lubricant and clean


filters regularly, replace when
necessary

As for (5)

Contaminant in the oil


lubricant of the J400
pump
Corrosion of vessels or
instrument near J400
pump, contaminating
fluid
Condenser C201, flash
separator K200 or
mixing tank F101 failure

As for (1)

Check oil level and clean filters


regularly, replace when
necessary
Valve V205

As for (5)

Temperature indicators and


transmitters in the condenser
C201 and flash separator K200
(12)
As for (12)

As for (5)

Valve V205; vacuum control


valve PCV203 (13)

Install level indicator


(14)

As for (13)

As for (14)

Valves V408 and V433

As for (14)

High Concentration

Low Concentration

Condenser C201, flash


separator K200 or
mixing tank F101 failure

High Level

Failure of valve V213 to


open
Failure of valve V214 to
open
Failure of valve V412 to
open

EFFECT

As for (1)

High concentration of
MEG/water vapour (>90%)
causes J200 pump to fail to
drive the mixture
Low concentration of
MEG/water vapour (<20%)
causes J200 pump to fail to
drive the mixture
High level of liquid in K201
vacuum trap, danger to J200
pump
High level of liquid in K202
vacuum receiver, danger to
J200 pump
High level in R403 bleed
down, unable to take sample

SAFEGUARDS

ACTION

As for (5)

As for (5)

DEVIATION

CAUSE

High Level

Failure of valve V413 to


open
Failure of speed
indicator controller
SIC400, lowering speed
of J400 pump
Failure of discharge
valve after storage tank
R500

EFFECT

SAFEGUARDS

ACTION

High level in R404 sampling


receiver unable to take
sample
High level in condensate
separator tank K300

Valves V410 and V434

As for (14)

Valve V307; level indicators


LSL305 and LSL306

As for (5)

High level in storage tank


R500

Valves V431 and V432

As for (14)

También podría gustarte