Documentos de Académico
Documentos de Profesional
Documentos de Cultura
in Canada 2016
Final Report
April
2016
olive tree
FOUNDATION
This study was conducted by the Environics Institute for Survey Research, in partnership with the
following organizations:
Contents
Introduction ..................................................................................................................................................................... 1
Executive Summary ..................................................................................................................................................... 3
Personal Connection to Canada .......................................................................................................................... 7
Introduction
Muslims in Canada
Until fairly recently, followers of the religion of Islam were
practices (e.g., Sharia law, the niqab). While Canada has yet to
pervasively negative.
Much of the problem stems from the fact that the Muslim
Report Synopsis
Muslim.1 The
have changed over time, how they vary across key segments
Acknowledgements
of the population).
has changed (or not) over the past decade. This survey was
culture).
1 It is worth noting that the survey field period occurred shortly after the 2015 federal election in which the Harper Conservative government was
roundly defeated by the Liberal Party led by Justin Trudeau. The Conservative Party was criticized for negatively portraying Canadian Muslims
leading up to and during the campaign.
Executive Summary
their own.
(84% say they are treated better, versus only 2% who believe
and (among women) are wearing the hijab. In both cases the
divided.
integrate.
and hold this view even more strongly than 2006. The
radicalization, and for the most part are comfortable with the
out as follows:
ways. On the one hand they are the most integrated into
it stands for.
than isolated.
C-51. They are among the most positive about how future
men to visit mosques for prayers, but also are more likely
The vast majority of Muslims feel very proud to be Canadian, and this
sentiment has strengthened since 2006, especially among Muslims
in Quebec. The greatest sources of pride continue to be the countrys
freedom and democracy, as well as its multiculturalism and diversity.
2006
83
77
73
2016
78
83
85
90
74
73
47
TOTAL
Quebec
Ontario
West
TOTAL
NON-MUSLIMS
Q.3/FC Q.3
Would you say you are very, somewhat, not very, or not at all proud to be a
Canadian?
among the most proud (91%), with this view less evident
four percent who are not very or not at all proud. These
(84%), but it is the latter group that has shown the most
Canadian identity.
Top mentions
33
Free country/democracy
24
17
Multiculturalism/diversity
22
10
Peaceful/stable country
Humanitarian/caring/friendly people
human rights.
7
3
2006
Equality/human rights
Opportunities/standard of living
2016
Q.4
What is it about Canada that gives you the greatest sense of pride?
Q7-201
by 43%).
Top mentions
24
Climate/cold weather
31
6
Lack of jobs/economic
opportunities
7
13
Discrimination/treatment
of Muslims/others
Taxes
2006
2016
4
None/Don't know
dislikes.
Q.5
And what do you like least about Canada?
21
25
stronger over the past five years. Very few (5%) report
Q6-7-2016
55
39
33
3
Very
strong
Generally
strong
Generally/very
weak
Became
stronger
Became
weaker
No
change
Q.6
Would you describe your sense of belonging to Canada today as very strong,
generally strong, generally weak or very weak?
Q.7
And would you say your sense of belonging to Canada has become stronger,
become weaker, or hasnt really changed since five years ago?
89
81
61
56
2006
2016
MUSLIMS
2006
2016
NON-MUSLIMS
Q.1/FC Q.1
Thinking about Canada, overall, are you satisfied or dissatisfied with the way
things are going in our country today?
federal election.
By comparison, the rest of the population is not nearly as
positive about the direction of the country today, with just
over half (56%) feeling satisfied, compared with 37 percent
who are dissatisfied. This general sentiment is somewhat
lower than in 2006 when 61 percent expressed satisfaction.
As before, positive views are most evident among younger
Canadians, those with the most education, and those born
outside the country (63%).
10
overall).
income.
Q2-2016
Top mentions
mentions
Top
34
35
13
7
Immigration/refugees
3
3
Terrorism/security
3
3
Education
Taxes
Muslims
2
2
Non-Muslims
18
6
5
Q.2/FC Q.2
In your opinion, what is the most important problem facing CANADIANS today?
11
Political engagement
A large majority of Muslims report to have voted in the recent federal
election, at levels comparable to or higher than the non-Muslim
population. Two-thirds of this support went to the Federal Liberal Party.
Results from the survey reveal that the Federal Liberal Party
this election, with16 percent saying they did not vote, and
not yet
citizens).2
Q37-38-2016
79
65
Yes
16
No
Not
eligible
Liberal
10
NDP
Conservative
Other
2 There is evidence demonstrating that voter turnout tends to be overstated in surveys, in part because some people will respond as they felt they
should have acted rather than how they did. For this reasons, surveys do not provide a definitive measure of actual turnout but these results
suggest that turnout among Muslims was likely similar to the population-at-large. The 79% turnout figure in this survey exactly matches the
figure reported in a post-election survey of Muslims conducted by Mainstreet Research on behalf of The Canadian Muslim Vote. Elections Canada
determined the official voter turnout rate in this election to be 68.5%.
12
Year
Number of Muslims
in Canada
1871
1931
1971
1981
1991
2001
2011
13
645
33,430
98,165
253,265
579,600
1,054,945
% of total
population
--0.1%
0.3%
0.9%
1.8%
3.2%
13
Muslim Identity
Most strongly identify as both Muslim and Canadian, although the
Muslim identity tends to be the stronger of the two, especially among
individuals under 35 years of age. Among immigrants, attachment to
Islam is more likely to have strengthened than weakened since moving
to Canada.
Importantpart
partofofpersonal
personalidentity
identity
Important
Being member of
ethnic/cultural group
Q8-9-2016
84
Being Muslim
81
Being Canadian
48
Very important
15 3
32
15
Not very/not at
all important
Somewhat important
Q.8
Do you consider each of the following to be very important, somewhat
important or not very important as part of your own personal identity?
ago.
Muslims
43
Non-Muslims
28
27
24
15
Follower of
religion
Canadian
Ethnic/cultural
group
Both/all equally
important
Q.9/FC Q.6
And which one of these would you say is the most important part of your
personal identity?
15
Q13-
Islam? About half (52%) report that living in Canada has not
really made a difference, but among the rest most (41%)
say the move has strengthened their connection to their
religion, compared with only five percent who report it
has become weaker. Stronger attachment is most widely
TOTAL
41 5
In Canada less
than 10 years
40 5
In Canada
10-19 years
In Canada 20
years or more
37 4
52
55
56
47 6
42
Hasn't changed
Q.13
Since moving to Canada, has your personal attachment to Islam become
stronger, become weaker, or hasnt really changed?
16
Muslim Practice
An increasing proportion of Muslims regularly visit mosques for prayers,
with attendance for education or social functions much less frequent.
The wearing of head coverings (in most cases the hijab) has also
increased over the past decade, especially among younger women.
once a week, while one in four (24%) does so only for special
percent in 2006.
18
20
2006
23
25
2016
24
15
5
More than
once a week
Q15ab-2016
Once a
week
Every 2 to 3
weeks
10
Once a month
or less
Only at
special times
Q.15
How often do you attend a mosque or Muslim community centre for prayer?
3 The religious requirement to attend prayer at a mosque is stronger for men than for women.
17
Never/almost
never
Women
42
48
38
2006
2016
Hijab
3
Chador
Q.10
Do you wear a hijab, chador, or niqab in public?
18
1
Niqab
Sources of guidance
Muslims are most likely to look for religious guidance from local Muslim
organizations, local leaders or their own family. Four in ten, however, do
not rely on any particular sources of guidance for their faith.
guidance as a Muslim.
Sources of guidance are generally similar across the
22
Family
11
Local Imam/Sheikh
10
National Muslim
organizations
Quran/Holy Book
Friends/community members
Self guidance/research
Other sources
3
2
4
None
42
Q.11
What individuals or organizations, if any, do you personally look to to offer you
guidance as a Muslim? Anyone else?
19
28
Muslim leaders
27
28
32
27
32
25
15
20
16
22
37
36
34
21
16
14
19
25
28
Very satisfied
Somewhat satisfied
Q.18a-e
From what you know or have heard, are you very, somewhat, not very, or
not at all satisfied with each of the following aspects of your local Muslim
community? Muslim leaders, including Imams and clergy ... Programs for
Muslim youth ... Programs for Muslim families ... Outreach to other religions
and the wider community ... Opportunities for women to play leadership roles
in Muslim organizations?
provides.
Across the five areas, satisfaction with community supports
is most widely expressed by individuals in the youngest
age cohort (18 to 34), along with those who are Canadianborn, and those who visit mosques at least once a week.
Dissatisfaction with Muslim leaders is most pronounced
among individuals 60 years and older (28%) and those in
the top income bracket (with $80K or more in household
income) (24%). Dissatisfaction with community outreach to
other religions and the wider community is most evident
among those with the most education and income (but
doesnt exceed 20% in either group). Men and women are
equally satisfied with the opportunities for women to play
leadership roles in their community.
21
are (51%).
Q17-2016
Treatment/discrimination
by broader community
35
Violent extremism/radicalization
Unemployment/lack of jobs
Influences on youth
Events overseas
Other
15
None/don't know
31
Q.17
What do you believe are the most important issues facing Muslims in your
local community today?
22
2016
Discrimination
against Muslims
2006
2016
27
2006
26
Unemployment among
Canadian Muslims
2006
Canadian Muslims (53%, down 10). Fewer than half are very
or somewhat worried about the influence of music, movies
and the Internet on Muslim youth (43%, down 6), a decline
in the importance of religion among Canadian Muslims
(42%, down 6), and being stereotyped by neighbours and
colleagues (39%, new item).
30
2016
2016
35
28 6
36
31 2
32
34 4
35
27
31
32
30
40
21
33
23
41 6
31 4
36
11
Very worried
Somewhat worried
Depends/don't know
Q.25,d,e,f,h
Please tell me how worried you are about each of the following issues related
to Muslims living in Canada. Are you very worried, somewhat worried, not too
worried, or not at all worried about...?
23
22
27
21
50 1
49
22
26
27
31
21
41
40
16
23
56 4
Very worried
Somewhat worried
Depends/don't know
Q.25a,c,g
Please tell me how worried you are about each of the following
issues related to Muslims living in Canada. Are you very worried,
somewhat worried, not too worried, or not at all worried about...?
24
one in four (23%) believe youth are about the same as their
The belief that youth are more religious than their parents
and those with the lowest incomes (53%), and least evident
38
23
15
15
10
More
religious
Less
religious
About
the same
Depends
(e.g. on parents)
dk/na
Q.21
Do you believe that Muslim youth today tend to be more religious, less
religious, or about the same as their parents?
youth are less religious than their parents (38%), with fewer
than half as many taking the opposite view (15%). However,
25
Canadian Muslims
55
53
2006
2016
23
17
Want to
adopt customs
Want to
remain distinct
16
13
Both
equally
14
Depends/
dk/na
although fewer now take the view that most Muslims want
to remain distinct from larger the Canadian society and
Non-Muslim Canadians
57
2006
34
2016
25
customs and way of life (34%), but the gap between these
Want to
adopt customs
Want to
remain distinct
12
Both
equally
12
Depends/
dk/na
Q.19/FC Q.11
Do you think most Muslims coming to our country today want to adopt
Canadian customs and way of life, or do you think that they want to be
distinct from the larger Canadian society?
27
for the law, respect for other religions and cultures, general
and respect for human rights and freedoms. Few (7%) did
26
15
17
22
13
15
12
12
9
Civility/mutual respect
4
9
Need to assimilate
10
9
Q20-FC Q12
19
8
8
1
Muslims
Non-Muslims
7
2
3
5
Q.20/FC Q.12
What do you consider to be the values most important for immigrants to
learn and adopt when they move to Canada?
28
Muslims
75
Non-Muslims
60
31
13
12
No
10
Depends/dk/na
29
either way.
and won the case, but the issue became political during the
older, those born in the Middle East or West Asia, and those
While the court case appears to have settled the legal rights
for niqab-wearing women to take the citizenship oath (they
but one in four (24%) does not agree, while the remainder
Q31bc-FCQ13bc
60
65
56
50
45
32
24
16
Yes
No
21
15
Depends/dk/na
Yes
No
13
Depends/dk/na
30
Q40bc
22
29
23
34
17 10
17
61
26 4 4 5
62
26 2 2 9
Totally agree
Somewhat disagree
Somewhat agree
Totally disagree
23
19
Depends/dk/na
Q.40b-c
Now Id like to read you a list of opinions that we often hear expressed.
For each one, please tell me whether you totally agree, somewhat agree,
somewhat disagree or totally disagree. ... Other cultures have a lot to teach
us; contact with them is enriching ... Immigrants of different races and
backgrounds should set aside their cultural backgrounds and try to blend into
Canadian culture?
statement.
Agreement with this statement has increased most
significantly since 2006 in Quebec, among Muslims 45 years
and older, among those who frequently pray at mosques,
and immigrants who have been in the country either less
than 10 years or more than 20. Agreement is now most
4 Unless other indicated, these social values measures are drawn from the Environics Research Groups Social Values Research Program, which is
31
20 4 4 1
70
76
16
24
17
15 3 3 5
32 10
51
28
17
Totally agree
Somewhat disagree
Somewhat agree
Totall disagree
Depends/dk/na
* Non-Muslims
Q.40a-d
Now Id like to read you a list of opinions that we often hear expressed.
For each one, please tell me whether you totally agree, somewhat agree,
somewhat disagree or totally disagree. Taking care of home and kids is as
much mans work as womans work ... The father in the family must be the
master in his own house?
5 This statement was developed by the Environics Research Group as a measure of the social value defined as patriarchy.
32
Opinions of homosexuality
80
Muslims
43
36
20
14
Homosexuality
SHOULD be
accepted by society
Homosexuality
SHOULD NOT be
accepted by society
Depends/
no answer
Q.41
Which of the following comes closer to your own opinion: Homosexuality
should be accepted by society ... Homosexuality should not be accepted by
society?
57
Yes, by age
36
32
acceptable.
26
18
18
21
No
Depends/
dk/na
18 to 34
35 to 44
45 to 59
60 or older
Q.42
Do you think it should be possible to be both an observant Muslim and to live
openly in a lesbian or gay same-sex relationship?
33
those who are not religious (50%), while this view is least
(down 7), and another one in six who cannot say either way.
Q22-2016
Mainstream opinion
54
49
2006
42
2016
39
32
38
33
18
7
Generally
positive
Generally
negative
Neither
dk/na
Generally
positive
Generally
negative
Neither
dk/na
Q.22/FC Q.7
Do you think Canadians impression of the religion of Islam is generally positive or generally negative?
35
Canadian Muslims
2006
2016
49
35
27
Most
12
Many
Just some
Very few
dk/na
Non-Muslim Canadians
2016
44 43
18
4
Most
24 26
Many
Just some
Very few
dk/na
Q.24/FC Q.9
In your opinion, how many Canadians do you think are hostile toward
Muslims? Would you say most, many, just some or very few?
and the west, among those in the top income bracket, those
Canadian-born, and infrequent prayer goers. This view is least
apt to be shared in Quebec (70%, down 9 points since 2006),
77
84
2006
2016
Treated
better
Treated
worse
17
Treated about
the same
3
dk/na
Q.23
Do you think that the way that Muslims are treated in Canada is better, worse,
or about the same as they are treated in other western countries?
36
90
who say less), while those born in other countries are less
apt to hold this view (especially among those who have
immigrated in the past 10 years). Expectations for rising
discrimination are also more evident among younger
Muslims, individuals with higher incomes, those who identify
primarily as Muslim, and those who have experienced
discrimination. By comparison, belief in a future with less
discrimination is most evident in Quebec (40%) and among
Optimistic
Pessimistic
Depends/
too early
dk/na
Q.39
With a new majority Liberal government led by Prime Minister Justin Trudeau,
are you optimistic or pessimistic that relations between Muslims and other
Canadians will improve?
34
29
32
21
19
15
Will face
more
Will face
less
Will face
the same
dk/na
18 to 34
35 to 44
45 to 59
60 or older
Q.30
Do you believe the next generation of Muslims in Canada will face more, face less, or
face about the same level of discrimination and stereotyping as Muslims do today?
37
reasons:
those 35 to 44
Muslims
21
22
General population*
22
11
5
NET
(any reason)
Q26a-d-2016
Because of
your religion
Because of your
ethnicity/culture
13
7
Because of
your language
11
6
Because of
your sex
7 Source: GSS 2013 Survey. Note that the data for the Muslim subsample from this larger survey show incidence levels very close to the results of
this survey (net discrimination 34%; discrimination by religion 22%; by ethnicity/culture 28%; by language 13%; by sex 7%).
38
35
In the workplace/
job applications
22
34
Public spaces
(streets, parks)
12
25
In stores/banks/restaurants
16
18
19
At school/university
On public transit
16
0
10
8
At airports/borders
Other settings
Due to religion
6
6
Due to ethnicity/culture
4
4
2
3
9
13
Q.27
In what types of situations have you experienced discrimination in the past
five years due to your religion?
27b.
In what types of situations have you experienced discrimination in the past
five years due to Q27-28-2016
your ethnicity or culture?
Country of birth
Age
35
25
23
TOTAL
Male
26
23
Female
18 to 34
28
26
22
20
35 to 44
45 to 59
60 or older
Canada
Other
Q.28
Have you ever experienced difficulties travelling across the border or through airports because of your
race, ethnicity or religion?
39
issues of the day? One in six (17%) says he or she has felt
education and income, and those born in the Middle East, Asia
Q29-2016
Country of birth
Age
32
24
17
15
TOTAL
Male
18
Female
18 to 34
13
11
11
35 to 44
45 to 59
60 or older
14
Canada
Other
Q.29
Have you ever felt inhibited about expressing your opinions on social or political issues because of your
race, ethnicity or religion?
40
Very few Muslims believe there is much if any support within their
community for violent extremist activities at home or abroad. At the
same time, there is almost universal agreement on the importance of
actively working with government agencies to address any potential
threats.
Canadian Muslims
2006
2016
61
44
37
11
Most/many
support
Just some
15 13
11
6
Very few
None
dk/na
Canadian Non-Muslims
2006
2016
51
56
26
13
Most/many
support
22
Just some
Very few
None
dk/na
Q.33/FC Q.14
In your opinion, how many Muslims in Canada do you believe support violent
activity of extremists abroad like ISIS? Would you say most, many, just some,
very few, or none?
(12%).
41
79
Somewhat
important
Not very/
not at all
important
Depends
dk/na
Q.35
How important do you believe it is for Canadian Muslim communities to
work actively with government agencies to address radicalization activities
that may lead to violent extremism either in Canada or abroad?
42
Government policy
Opinion of Bill C-51
Muslims are more likely than not to oppose Bill C-51 because it infringes
on the civil rights of citizens. At the same time, most are comfortable
with the powers currently held by the agencies like the RCMP and CSIS
to protect Canadians from security threats.
48
17
Neither/depends on charges 2
Not familiar/dk/na
33
Q.36
As you may know, the previous federal government passed new antiterrorism legislation that known as Bill C-51. Some say [ROTATE] Bill C-51
provides the government with the appropriate level of power and authority
to counter terrorist activities in Canada. Others say [ROTATE] Bill C-51 infringes
too much upon the civil rights of ordinary Canadians. From what you know
or have heard, which view is closer to your own?
57
22
17
Too much
power
4
About the
right amount
of power
Too little
power
Depends/
dk/na
Q.36.1
Generally speaking, do you believe that the countrys national security
agencies like the RCMP and CSIS have too much power, about the right
amount of power, or too little power, to carry out their responsibilities to
protect Canadians from potential threats?
says these agencies have too much power, while very few
(4%) maintain they have too little power. Another one in five
(28%).
43
www.environicsinstitute.org