Documentos de Académico
Documentos de Profesional
Documentos de Cultura
April 16, 2010 Issue
April 16, 2010 Issue
vol. cxlv, no. 50 | Friday, April 16, 2010 | Serving the community daily since 1891
Corp. fellow Over 700 visit the Hill for a taste of Brown
investigated By Ana Alvarez
Senior Staff Writer
prised me so far is how smoothly
everything is going,” Re said.
C ampus N EWS “It can turn you into a monster or back into a human again too.”
— Daria Marinelli ’12 on the power of love in “Red”
sudoku
Daily Herald
the Brown
C ampus N EWS “We are not training engineers, we are training whole people.”
— Cherry Murray, Dean of Harvard’s School of Engineering
U. invested
in embattled
firm
continued from page 1
Rattner’s lawyer, Jamie Gorelick,
was quoted by the Times and other
media outlets saying, “Mr. Rattner
does not agree with the characteriza-
tion of events released today, includ-
ing those contained in Quadrangle’s
statement.”
The Chronicle of Higher Educa-
tion reported last month that the
University had invested with Quad-
rangle, according to its 2008 federal
tax forms. The University could not
be reached for comment.
Page 4 THE BROWN DAILY HERALD Friday, April 16, 2010
C ampus N EWS “No one sits around as a child and dreams of being homeless.”
— Jessica Salter, Vice President of Development at Amos House
A rts & C ulture “That’s what theater should be. Theater for fun.”
— Kate Doyle ’12, director of “As You Like It”
l e t t e r to t h e e d i to r
No apartheid here
is strikingly different whether the separation is major breakthrough is there. is pure hypocrisy.
between peoples in different countries or with- The international consensus has continu- The problem with repainting history is the
Ethan Tobias in a single country. When fences attempted to ally been for the creation of separate states for tendency to subsume the individual nuances
divide a unified country, as in South Africa, it Israelis and Palestinians. The Peel Commis- of different situations. The situation in Israel/
Opinions Columnist made sense to protest, support sanctions and sion of 1937 recommended separate Jewish Palestine is very different from the border
encourage divestment. However, when fences and Arab states. The United Nations in 1948 fence between the U.S. and Mexico or the
serve to maintain existing national boundar- voted on a resolution establishing the creation systematic segregation along racial lines in
If it walks like a duck and quacks like a duck, ies and provide security, as in the case of the of two separate states. Even today, leaders apartheid South Africa.
don’t call it a chicken. Yet this is exactly what U.S.-Mexico border, protests and divestment from all across the world, from President You do not have to agree with everything
those who constructed a makeshift wall on the campaigns are misguided. Obama to the Arab League, have endorsed that the U.S. or Israeli governments do, but
Main Green last week were doing. The wall Given the importance of distinguishing some version of a two-state solution. sincere criticism and protest go a lot further
stood as a protest to both “Apartheid in the between fences within a nation and fences Given the overwhelming belief that a two- than name calling and guilt by association.
Occupied Territories” of Israel/Palestine and between nations, how can we understand the state solution is the best way to resolve the It is easy to write off those we disagree with
the U.S.-Mexico border fence. situation in Israel/Palestine? conflict in Israel/Palestine, it is clear that the as acting like “Hitler” or “Stalin,” as the Tea
Whatever you may think about South Af- Partiers do, but doing so is not intellectually
rica, Israel/Palestine or the U.S. southern honest. Instead, we should be debating policy
border, the fact is that these situations are respectfully. By associating the U.S. and Israel
very different. Building a wall that conflates The situation in Israel/Palestine is very different with the policy of apartheid in South Africa,
the nuances of the three, rather than having a
civilized discussion about the effects of certain
from the border fence between the U.S. and those students on the Main Green chose to
polarize the debate by brushing over impor-
policies, paints history with a broad brush. Mexico or the systematic segregation along racial tant distinctions.
It serves to poison the discourse by making The image that the word “apartheid” brings
weak associations. lines in apartheid South Africa. to mind is a harsh one. Those using such load-
The fact is that while some similarities do ed language must make a clear and concise
exist — there were fences in all these places argument explaining why the word applies.
— there are more fundamental differences Israelis and Palestinians are very much two situation is much more similar to the fence Conflating apartheid in South Africa with the
among these situations. One of the most im- different peoples, with their own individual separating the U.S. and Mexico than the state U.S.-Mexico border and Israel/Palestine situ-
portant is that the U.S. and Mexico are two national aspirations. They differ in religion, of affairs in apartheid South Africa. ations diminishes the suffering that millions
separate countries. The system of apartheid in language and culture. More importantly, they If the students who made the comparison of South Africans endured. It is an affront to
South Africa worked to separate people within consider themselves to be separate nations. A between apartheid and the U.S.-Mexico bor- them and to every self-respecting person who
a single country based on race, while the fence two-state solution has majority support among der really believe their own rhetoric, then values historical accuracy.
on our southern border separates peoples liv- both Israelis and Palestinians in polls con- they must accept that they are citizens of an
ing in different countries. It is internationally ducted of both populations. apartheid state, currently dividing the U.S.
agreed that nations have the right to control The leaders of the Palestinian Authority and Mexico. If I believed I were living under Ethan Tobias ’12 likes the view from
who can cross their borders. This right is es- and the Israeli government both support a a system of apartheid, I would make sure I this side of the Van Wickle gates. He
sential for protecting countries from terrorists, two-state solution. They agree that any solution was doing everything in my power to end it can be reached at
criminals and drug smugglers. will be based on the pre-1967 borders, give or before I started criticizing a foreign country
Ethan_Tobias@brown.edu.
These two examples show how the situation take a few land swaps. The groundwork for a for doing the same thing. Anything otherwise
Shakespeare al fresco
5
Friday, April 16, 2010
49 / 42 46 / 38
Page 8
s p o rt s a ro u n d t h e b e n d d i a m o n d s a n d c oa l
M. lacrosse will host Yale Saturday schedule from the men as it visits Har- Diamond to the class of 2014 and prospective stu- But diamonds to the majority of you who said you’re
at 1 p.m. The Bulldogs come after de- vard today at 2 p.m., returning home to dent William Ryan, who told The Herald Brown was in favor of eliminating tableslips. Our domination of
feating Penn and Dartmouth, putting face Dartmouth Sunday at noon. “more chill” than other universities. Just wait until your breakfast table will soon be complete!
them 2-2 in Ivy League play. Equestrian competes in Hanover, February.
W. lacrosse will host two games N.H. all day Saturday. A muddy old diamond to the College Hill ’Dependent
this weekend, starting today at 4 p.m. Baseball and softball travel to Cam- Coal to Art Speigelman P’13 for letting us put a photo of for being good sports at kickball last weekend. You
against Cornell, and continuing 1 p.m. bridge for a four-game series against him smoking on the front page. Don’t said the rain and mud conflict with your
Sunday against Boston College. Harvard Saturday and Sunday. you know there are impressionable “aesthetic ideology” — looks like win-
M. tennis hosts Harvard today at Both m. and w. crew will race in young pre-frosh around? ning does, too.
2 p.m. The team will then travel to Massachusetts Saturday. The men will
Hanover, N.H., to face off against Dart- take on Northeastern and the women Cubic zirconium to the Wickenden Coal to UFB Secretary Tyler Rosen-
mouth Sunday at noon. will go head-to-head against Boston Street “snuggery” Duck and Bunny — baum ’11 for telling the board that it
W. tennis features the opposite University. we like the sound of it, but aren’t those needs to “improve relationships” with
illegal now in this state? the community. We don’t think your
board’s lack of communication is the
c a l e n da r Coal to the Rhode Island state senators reason you’re all single.
who want to ban tanning for minors.
How will this state ever produce another Pauly D And coal to Sofia Pellon ’10, who has “been notic-
Today, April 16 tomorrow, april 17 now? ing recently a lot of the people (she’s) living with are
coupled up.” What did you think all those extra tooth-
4:30 P.M. — “Audience, Aesthetics, 2:00 P.M. — Tamora Pierce Book Cubic zirconia to the majority of you who told us you brushes were for?
Assumptions: Putting the Groove into Reading and Signing, Brown were attractive in our recent poll. We applaud you for
Classical Music,” - Steinert Hall Bookstore your confidence, and would give you diamonds, but Want more D&C? Check out a retro-diamond
it looks like you think you’re pretty enough all on at blogdailyherald.com, and write your own at
7:00 P.m. — Latino Gala, Andrews 8:00 P.M. — RED, a new play at PW, your own. diamondsandcoal.com.
Dining Hall T.F. Green Hall
menu comics
Dot Comic | Eshan Mitra and Brendan Hainline
Sharpe Refectory Verney-Woolley Dining Hall
crossword
Frutopia | Andy Kim