Documentos de Académico
Documentos de Profesional
Documentos de Cultura
Metacogntion
Metacogntion
Chhaapptteerr 77::
M
ME
ETTA
AC
CO
OG
GN
NIITTIIO
ON
N
This chapter is devoted to discussion about metacogntion or simply put as thinking about
thinking. Metacognitive ability has been identified as a significant factor influencing
academic performance, especially in relation to reading. Learners with high metacognitive
ability are able to employ more effective metacognitive strategies than learners with weak
metacognitive ability. Metacomprehension is the process of extracting meaning from text
and involves two processes: awareness and action. Metacognition can be trained and
discusses are some techniques to enhance metacognitive ability. Also, metacognition can
be assessed and discussed are some methods.
Metacognitive
Knowledge
Thinking about Thinking
Metacognitive
Control
For example, you dislike a certain person and have been telling your friends
what a horrible person he is. One fine day you sit back and reflect on your thoughts.
You ask yourself why dislike that person. You realise that you formed an opinion of
that person based on what your friend told you. You start asking yourself whether
your friend was fair in his assessment of that person you dislike and whether he had a
motive for demeaning him. You are actually engaging in metacognition. You are
questioning the way you think! You are thinking about your thinking!
There is still much debate over exactly what is metacognition resulting in
several terms used to describe the same phenomena such as self-regulation, executive
control and metamemory. The term metacognition is most often associated with John
Flavell, (1976) who stated that
Metacognitive Knowledge
Knowing about
your thinking
METACOGNITION
Metacognitive Control
Controlling your
thinking
Knowledge of task variables refers to knowledge about the nature of the task
as well as the type of processing demands required. For example, you know
that it will take you more time to read and comprehend a science text than it
would for you to read and comprehend a novel.
I do not understand
what is e-commerce?
Perhaps I should reread this section.
Figure 6.3
Learner is aware and doing
something to overcome her
lack of understanding of ecommerce
SELF-CHECK
a) Explain what is meant by metacognition.
Imagine you are about to take a final examination. What are the metacognitive
strategies you may employ? See Figure 7.4 which describes some of the mental
strategies used by successful learner.
METACOGNITIVE KNOWLEDGE:
You begin by asking yourself what is your goal: To get an A in next weeks
exam.
You identify what you already know about the first 6 chapters of the textbook
that is to be tested.
You do not understand completely Chapter 3. You need to get to the library or
access the internet.
You consider the task requirements: The exam will consist of 4 essay
questions and the time allotted is 2 hours.
You plan the study time required to revise the 6 chapters.
You plan to create graphic organisers for each of the chapters to show
relationships between concepts and principles.
METACOGNITIVE CONTROL
If a student realises that she does not know very much about a particular topic,
she might pay more attention to the topic while reading and use different
strategies to make sure she understands the topic being studied.
If a student is aware that she has difficulties on certain tests (e.g., mathematics
versus history tests), then she can prepare for an upcoming mathematics test in
an appropriate manner.
[source:
Huitt, W. (1997). Metacognition. Educational Psychology Interactive.
Valdosta, GA: Valdosta State University. Retrieved [June,2008], from
http://chiron.valdosta.edu/whuitt/col/cogsys/metacogn.html.
Students who lack knowledge of their own strengths and weaknesses will be less
likely to adapt to different situations and regulate their own learning.
If a student reads a text and thinks he understands it, but in reality does not,
then he will be less likely to go back and re-read or review the text to make
sure it is understood.
If a student who believes he understands the material thoroughly will not study
for an upcoming test to the same extent as a student who knows he does not
understand the material.
If a student believes he understands the material when he does not will not do
well on the test of that material because he did not study as well as the student
who had an accurate perception of his lack of knowledge.
ACTIVITY
school students?
b) Were you an efficient learner while you were in university or secondary
and understanding of the texts read. The behaviours that good readers use help them
to construct meaning while reading, make evaluations of text and make connections
with prior knowledge and experiences. Metacognitive strategies increase a readers
ability to construct meaning and to evaluate the text he or she is reading. The
following is a list of metacognitive skills exhibited by a skilful reader:
textbooks and related prose materials. The dominance of the textbook is most evident
in Malaysian secondary schools and the printed page continues to be the major source
of information for students whether they are in the form of books, journals,
magazines, pamphlets, or presented on a computer screen. Reading comprehension or
understanding written content is the crux of the reading act. Students cannot learn
unless they can comprehend reading material, and they cannot remember what they
read unless they understand it. The poor reader may be summarised as one who is:
Less able to take charge of his or her own cognitive processes while reading.
They are not as flexible as good readers in adapting their processing to the
demands of the task and to capitalise on the structure or contextual
constraints inherent in texts.
Less efficient in monitoring their understanding of the material read or are
deficient in metacognitive skills.
ACTION
Checking
Planning
Evaluating
Revising
Remediating
[Source: Brown, L (1982). Learning how to learn from reading. In J. Langer and
M. Smith-Burke (Eds.), Reader Meets Author/Bridging the Gap: A
sycholinguistic and Sciolinguistic Perspective. Newark, Del.: International Reading
Association]
The successful reader is one who is able to monitor his or her understanding of
what is being read and this metacognitive skill is apparently not developed in
all students. Linked to reading, metacognition involves `knowing what you know',
`knowing what you need to know' and `knowing the utility of active intervention'
(Sanacore, 1984). In other words, to be an efficient and effective reader, the person
should be able to monitor his or her degree of understanding, be aware of the
knowledge possessed, be conscious of the task demanded and know the
strategies that facilitates comprehension. However, Brown (1987) points out that
though,
.... it is tempting to conclude that ineffective monitoring of one's
cognitive processes during reading is the cause of poor
comprehension, we caution against such precipitous conclusion. The
majority of studies have shown that ineffective monitoring is associated
with poor comprehension, but not that it is the cause. It may be that poor
comprehension reduces the ability to monitor one's ongoing activities; or
perhaps a third factor such as impoverished background knowledge,
responsible for both problems (p.44).
ACTIVITY
General strategies for thinking and problem solving can be taught in English,
mathematics, science, geography, history, economics, art, music, and even
physical education courses.
Science teachers can teach general scientific methods and procedures, but
learning will likely be more effective when it is tied to specific science
content, not taught in the abstract.
Reading and writing lessons could focus on different general strategies for
reading comprehension or writing.
real problems. In addition, the teacher also might discuss why he is using this
particular strategy for this specific problem, thereby also engaging students in issues
concerning the conditional knowledge that governs when and why to use different
strategies. As experts in their field, teachers have all kinds of implicit knowledge
about strategies and when and why they are appropriate to use; however, students
often lack the means to gain access to this knowledge. If the knowledge is never
shared through discussion, modelling, or explicit instruction, it is difficult for students
to learn.
SELF-CHECK
a) Do you agree metacognitive abilities can be enhanced.
SUMMARY
Metacognitive knowledge of strategies and tasks, as well as selfknowledge, is linked to how students will learn and perform in the
classroom
KEY TERMS
Metacognition
Metacognitive knowledge
Metacognitive control
Metacognitive training
Modelling
Think aloud
Metacomprehension
Automaticity
Self-regulation
Conscious constructive responses
REFERENCES
Borkowski, J., Carr, M., & Pressely, M. (1987). "Spontaneous" strategy use:
Perspectives from metacognitive theory. Intelligence, 11, 61-75.
Pressley, M., & Afflerbach, P. (1995). Verbal protocols of reading: The nature
of constructively responsive reading. Hillsdale, NJ: Erlbaum.
Ridley, D.S., Schutz, P.A., Glanz, R.S. & Weinstein, C.E. (1992). Selfregulated learning: the interactive influence of metacognitive awareness and
goal-setting. Journal of Experimental Education 60 (4), 293-306.