Documentos de Académico
Documentos de Profesional
Documentos de Cultura
265
VOL.694,APRIL1,2013
265
onespouseandthebloodrelativesoftheother.Ahusbandisrelated
by affinity to his wifes brother, but not to the wife of his wifes
brother.Thereisnoaffinitybetweenthehusbandsbrotherandthe
wifessister;thisiscalledaffinitas affinitatis.
266
SUPREMECOURTREPORTSANNOTATED
Tiggangay vs. Wacas
ducedwinningmarginof97votes.Tiggangayappealedthe
RTC Decision before the Commission on Elections
(COMELEC) Second Division which dismissed the appeal
throughanOrderissuedonNovember4,2008.Tiggangays
motion for reconsideration of the COMELEC Second
Divisions dismissal of his appeal was likewise rejected by
the COMELEC En Banc on January 12, 2011 on the
groundofmootness.
On July 31, 2009, Tiggangay filed his verified letter
complaint charging Judge Wacas with Impropriety and
Partiality.Tiggangayallegedthat,duringthecourseofthe
proceedingsinElectionCaseNo.40,helearnedthatJudge
Wacas is Dagadags second cousin by affinity, the formers
aunt is married to an uncle of Dagadag. The relationship
notwithstanding,JudgeWacasdidnotinhibithimselffrom
hearingsaidelectoralcaseinviolationoftheNewCodeof
Judicial Conduct and Rule 137 of the Revised Rules of
Court. Moreover, after ruling in favor of Dagadag, so
Tiggangayalleged,JudgeWacasandhiswifeattendedthe
VOL.694,APRIL1,2013
267
_______________
4Id.,atpp.2526.
5Id.,atpp.2728.
6Id.,atpp.2930.
7Id.,atpp.3132.
8Id.,atp.35.
268
268
SUPREMECOURTREPORTSANNOTATED
Tiggangay vs. Wacas
dered by the RTC and after the Comelec in its Order dated
November4,2008dismissedtheappeal.
14)ThatFidelGayudan,oneofthewitnesses,isaconstantcompanion
ofthecomplainant.
15)That Corazon Somera is the sister of the mother of the
complainant.9
VOL.694,APRIL1,2013
269
270
SUPREMECOURTREPORTSANNOTATED
Tiggangay vs. Wacas
other.Theconnectionexisting,inconsequenceofmarriage
betweeneachofthemarriedpersonsandthekindredofthe
other. The doctrine of affinity grows out of the canonical
maxim that marriage makes husband and wife one. The
husbandhasthesamerelationbyaffinitytohiswifesblood
relativesasshehasbyconsanguinityandviceversa.22
Indeed,thereisnoaffinitybetweenthebloodrelativesof
onespouseandthebloodrelativesoftheother.Ahusbandis
relatedbyaffinitytohiswifesbrother,butnottothewifeof
his wifes brother. There is no affinity between the
husbands
_______________
inferior court when his ruling or decision is the subject of review,
without the written consent of all the parties in interest, signed by
themandenteredupontherecord.
A Judge may, in the exercise of his sound discretion, disqualify
himself from sitting in a case, for just and valid reasons other than
thosementionedabove.
19B.A.Garner,BLACKSLAWDICTIONARY67(9thed.,2009).
20 Intestate Estate of Manolita Gonzales Vda. de Carungcong v.
People,G.R.No.181409,February11,2010,612SCRA272,285.
21People v. Atop,G.R.Nos.12430305,February10,1998,286SCRA
157,169.
22 People v. Berana, G.R. No. 123544, July 29, 1999, 311 SCRA 664,
675676.
271
VOL.694,APRIL1,2013
271
electoralprotest.Besides,asaptlyputbyJusticeInting,a
litigantcannotbepermittedtospeculateupontheactionof
thecourtandtoraiseobjectionsonlyafteranunfavorable
decisionhasalreadybeenrendered.24
We find no reason to disturb Justice Intings succinct
observationthattheaffidavitanduncorroboratedtestimony
of Tiggangays driver, Gayudan, is incredulous and not
worthy of credence. Gayudan supposedly followed Judge
WacasandwifetotheranchofDagadagwherethealleged
victory party was celebrated on August 23, 2008 and
observedforfour
_______________
23BLACKSLAWDICTIONARY,supra note19.
24Report,p.9.
272
272
SUPREMECOURTREPORTSANNOTATED
Tiggangay vs. Wacas
VOL.694,APRIL1,2013
273