Documentos de Académico
Documentos de Profesional
Documentos de Cultura
Molecular Magnetism and Materials-Theory and Applications
Molecular Magnetism and Materials-Theory and Applications
Beng
Department of Chemistry
MOLECULAR MAGNETISM
AND MATERIALSMATERIALSTHEORY AND APPLICATIONS
Professor Boris Tsukerblat
tsuker@bgu.ac.il
@ g
Beer--Sheva
Beer
2006
SYLLABUS
I. Scope of molecular magnetism. Diversity of the field. Main
kinds of magnetic systems and the main types of the
magnetic
ti ordering.
d i
II. Spin, fundamental equations in molecular magnetism.
Magnetic susceptibility , magnetic moments
moments. Curie-Weiss low
low,
magnetization. Electron paramagnetic resonance.
III. Magnetic properties of a free ion, molecules containing a
unique
i
magnetic
ti center
t without
ith t first-order
fi t d orbital
bit l magnetism
ti
and EPR of transition metal ions and rare-earths, spin-orbital
interaction.
IV. Effects of crystal field. Group-theoretical introduction. Ground
terms of the transition metal ions in the crystal fields.
Anisotropy
py of the g
g-factor. Zero-field splitting:
p
g q
qualitative and
quantitative approaches. Covalence and orbital reduction.
EPR of the metal ions in complexes.
SOURCES
SOURCES:
1) CD
D
Oliver Kahn
Kahn, Molecular Magnetism
Magnetism, VCH,NY(1993).
VCH NY(1993)
Alessandro Bencini, Dante Gatteschi, Electron Paramagnetic
Resonance of Exchange Coupled Systems, Springer-Verlag,
Berlin (1990)
(1990).
F.A.Cotton, Chemical Application of Group Theory,
2nd Edition, Interscience, New York (1971).
B.S.Tsukerblat, Group Theory in Chemistry and Spectroscopy.
A Simple Guide to Advanced Usage, Academic Press, London
(1994).
J.J.Borras-Almenar, J.M.Clemente-Juan, E.Coronado, A.V.Palii,
B.S.Tsukerblat, Magnetic Properties of Mixed-Valence
Clusters:Theoretical Approaches and Applications, in:
M
Magnetism:
ti
Molecules
M l
l tto M
Materials,
t i l
( J.Miller, M.Drillon, Eds.), Wiley-VCH (2001) p.p.155-210.
Chapter 5
Chapter
p I
Scope of molecular magnetism.
Diversity of the field. The main kinds of
magnetic systems and the main types
of the magnetic ordering
Metal--(Ligand)
Metal
( g
)6
NH3
NH3
NH3
Cr
NH3
NH3
NH3
[Cr (NH3)6]3+ or
[Cr(NH3)6]Cl3
Central metal ion
ion- Cr3+
surrounded by six ammonia
molecules, Cr3+ contains three
unpaired d-electrons
NH3
OH Co
NH3
Co
OH
NH3
NH3
NH3
[(H3N)4Co(OH)2Co(NH3)4]4+
NH3
Co2+(d7-shell)C
h ll)
bearer of
magnetism
NiO6
3Ni2+magnetic
g
fragment
Na
AsO4
Polyhedral representation
Two 3Ni2+T
magnetic
f
fragments
t
WO6
NiO6
AsO4
P l h d l representation
Polyhedral
t ti
B ll and
Ball
d stick
ti k representation
t ti
Structure of donor-acceptor
compound (TTF)+[CuS4C4(CF3)4]with TTF+= tetrathiafulvalinium.
Phys.Rev.Lett.,35(1975) 744
Material
sciences
Biology
Molecular
magnetism
Molecular
M
l
l
electronics
NanoN
Nanoscience
Molecular
electronics
NanoNanoscience
i
Mn4+
Mn 3+
MANGANESE--12 CLUSTER
MANGANESE
eight Mn3+ ions (Si =2) and four Mn4+(Si =3/2)
Thermal activation
E
y
x
En
nergy
0
2
DS
z
DS2
- Sz
Magnetization vectors
-4 -2 0 +2 +4
Direction of magnetization
Sz
+Sz
If tthe
e Mn12-ac
ac molecule
o ecu e is
s magnetized
ag et ed by a
an app
applied
ed
field, the molecule retains magnetization for a long time ,
approximately 108 seconds = 3 years at 1.5K
A li ti
Applications:
quantum computing , memory storage elements in one molecule
MULTIFUNCTIONAL MATERIALS
Molecular
electronics
Material
sciences
DISCOVERY OF MULTIFUNCTIONAL
MOLECULE--BASED MATERIALS
MOLECULE
Nature 408, 447 - 449 (2000)
CARLOS J. GME
Z-GA RCA*
&
VLADIMIR LAUKHIN*
* Instituto de Ciencia Molecular, Universidad de Valenc ia, Dr. Moliner 50, 46100 Bur jjasot, Spain
p
Present addresses: Department of Chemistry, Texas A&M University, College Station, Texas, USA (J.R.G.- M.); ICMBCSIC, Campus de la UAB, 08193 Bellaterra, Spain (V.L.)
Crystal engineering
engineeringthe
the planning and construction of crystalline supramolecular
architectures from modular building blockspermits the rational design of functional
molecular materials that exhibit technologically useful behavior such as conductivity
and superconductivity,
superconductivity ferromagnetism and nonlinear optical properties.
properties Because the
presence of two cooperative properties in the same crystal lattice might result in new
physical phenomena and novel applications, a particularly attractive goal is the design
of molecular materials with two properties that are difficult or impossible to combine
in a conventional inorganic solid with a continuous lattice.
Molecular
components:
( ) The
(a)
organic
molecule
BEDT TTF
BEDT-TTF
bis(ethylenedithio)
tetrathiafulvalene
Di--iron cluster
Di
S-cys
S
Fe
paramagnet
ferromagnet
antiferromagnet
Disordered
directions of
the magnetic
moments,,
macroscopic
magnetization
is zero
Long-range
collinear
alignment of all
moments in the
substance,
spontaneous
magnetization
Long-range
interaction
interaction,
moments are
aligned
antiparallel to
each other, no
magnetization
ferrimagnet
Antiparallel
different
magnetic
moments,
spontaneous
macroscopic
magnetization
Two sub-lattices
with non-collinear
non collinear
magnetic
moments, weak
spontaneous
magnetization
Triangular
configuration
of the
magnetic
g
moments
simple helix
ferromagnetic
helix
complex
helix
static
longitudinal
spin wave
Chapter II
Spin, fundamental equations in
molecular magnetism.
Magnetic susceptibility , magnetic
moments, electron paramagnetic
resonance
North
South
Magnetic
g
field H
F
N
F
Turning moment acting on a magnetic stick
in a homogeneous magnetic field
Classical image
image-rotating
rotating spherical charge,
this picture fails in the evaluation of spin magnetic moment.
Adequate
q
description
p
-q
quantum--mechanical
quantum
concept.
MAGNETIC MOMENT
Magnetic moment associated with the spin (mechanical
angular momentum) of the electron can have two projections
on the direction of the external magnetic field H:
Magnetic
field H
S
S
e
2mc
spin down S
e
2mc
N
N
S
spin up
up
e
2mc
GENERAL PROPERTIES :
S 2 S , M S S S 1 S , M S
S S , M M S , M
z
1
2
and ms 12
spin " up
up" and spin " down
down"
s operator of spin - 21 , s s 1 12 32
Main properties :
s 2 34 , s 2 43
s z 12 , s z 12
3
4
1
2
MS
MS 1
3
2
MS
1
2
MS 0
M S 12
M S 12
1
2
M S 1
M S 32
S 1
3
2
Classical
C
ass ca mechanics
ec a cs all
a d
directions
ect o s for
o tthe
e magnetic
ag et c
moment in the space are allowed.
allowed
Quantum mechanics only selected directions for the
magnetic moment in the space are allowed
allowed-spatial quantization. Arbitrary z-axis.
SZ
S
S S S 1
2
SY
squared
d absolute
b l t value
l
SX
(length) of the vector S.
Y
Spatial quantization
X
Classical picture
selected directions (MS):
MS
Mean values: <SX > = <SY> =00
cos
S S 1
<SZ> = Scos
PRECESSING SPIN
CLASSICAL PICTURE ILLUSTRATING
THAT:
Z
mean values
<SX > = <SY> =0,
0
but <SZ> = Scos 0
X
SPATIAL QUANTIZATION:
ILLUSTRATION for S=1/2
Z
MS
1
2
projections
S 12 M S 12 and M S 12
S S S 1
54.7
MS
cos
S S 1
125.3
M S 12
cos
1
3
M S 12 cos
M S 12
1
2
3
2
54.7
1
3
125.3
SPATIAL QUANTIZATION:
ILLUSTRATION for S=1
Z
S 1 M S 1 , M S 0 , M S 1
MS 1
45
S 2
cos
MS 0
90
135
M S 1
MS
S S 1
M S 1 cos
1
2
45
M S 0 cos 0 90
M S 1 cos
S 1
1
2
135
Zeeman Hamiltonia n :
H Z g e sH
E H ,
Z
H Z g e S H g e S xH x S yH y S zH z
Important
p
remark:
z-axis is chosen arbitrary, free atom is spherically symmetric
g e Hz S z SM S g e Hz M S SM S
S li i under
Splitting
d the
h action
i off magnetic
i field
fi ld
(Zeeman levels) :
E M S g e H z M S
2S 1
1 eigen - values
Magnetic field removes (2S+1)-fold degeneracy of spin level
For a free atom ( ion) Zeeman splitting is independent of
the direction of the field - isotropic in space
1960
English theoretical physicist known for his work in quantum mechanics and
for his theory of the electronic spin . In 1933 he shared the Nobel Prize with
the Austrian physicist Erwin Schrdinger .
H 0 E 12 E 12
H 0 E 12 E 12
ene
ergy
E(mS)
mS 12
S
N
S 1/2
S=1/2
mS
1
2
splitting
mS
magnetic field Hz
1
2
N
S
Pieter Zeeman
Born May 25, 1865,
Zonnemaire, Netherland.
Died Oct.
Oct 9,
9 1943,
1943 Amsterdam
Nobel Winner, 1903 :
for his discoveryy of the Zeeman effect
Magnet of
Pieter Zeeman
John H.
H Van Vleck
American physicist and mathematician who shared the Nobel Prize for Physics in
1977 with Philip W. Anderson and Sir Nevill F. Mott. The prize honoured Van Vleck's
contributions to the understanding of the behaviour of electrons in magnetic,
noncrystalline solid materials.
Van Vleck developed during the early 1930s the first fully articulated quantum
mechanical
h i l theory
th
off magnetism.
ti
L t he
Later
h was a chief
hi f architect
hit t off the
th ligand
li
d field
fi ld
theory of molecular bonding. He contributed also to studies of the spectra of free
molecules, of paramagnetic relaxation, and other topics. His publications include
Q ant m Principles and Line Spectra (1926) and the Theory
Quantum
Theor of Electric and
Magnetic Susceptibilities (1932).
ZEEMAN SPLITTING,
ILLUSTRATION FOR SPIN S=1
E M S g e Hz M S , M S 1, 0 , 1
Enerrgy
M S 1 E 1 g e Hz
S 1
M S 0 E 0 0
M S 1 E 1 g e Hz
M
Magnetic
ti fi
field
ld
Y
X
Rotating field produces a turning momentmoment
to align spin in the plane XY, i.e. parallel to Hr !
precessing
spin
force
Resonance condition:
frequency of rotating field=
frequency of spin precession
H0
0
turning
moment
Hr
Rotating field
Electron paramagnetic
resonance (EPR), or electron
spin
i resonance (ESR) .
Eugenii Zavoisky, Kazan, 1944
Frequency of precession
in the constant field H0 :
g H0
g H0
0
or 0
h
H X cos t
Spin up
up
Spin down
down
Zeeman interaction
S=1/2
M S 12
EPR
transition
M S 12
H0
E M S g H0 M S
Important rule -" selection rule" for quantum transitions
b t
between
Z
Zeeman
l
levels
l :
only the transitions between " neighborin g" Zeeman levels are allowed
M S M S 1 and
d M S M S 1 or M S M S 1
Resonance condition (energy conservati on low) :
increase of spin energy energy of quantum of alternating field
E M S E M S 1
E M S g H M S for
f an arbitrary
bit
spin
i value
l S
g H M S g H M S 1 g H0
Th resonance condition
The
di i within
i hi quantum - mechanical
h i l approach
h:
g H0
g H0 quantum energy for an allowed transition,
But
g H0
0 cyclic frequency of classical
spin
p p
precession in magnetic
g
field H0 .
g H0
0
Resonance: = 0
resonance frequency
12 g H
g Hres
12 g H
EPR line
Hres
Resonance equation:
g eff
Hres
E M S g H0 M S
3
S
2
Forbidden
t
transitions
iti
3
2
g H0
1
2
g H0
1
2
g H0
3
2
g H0
Hres H0
EPR line
In the case of
S>1/2 all allowed
transitions have the
same resonance
fields and for this
reason give the
only
l EPR line.
line
li
Thi
This
is valid in the case
of isotropic Zeeman
interaction (free
atoms or the case
of a cubic crystal
field).
g
Hres
1) g Hres M S 2 g Hres M S
2 g Hres
g
2 Hres
and
2) g Hres M S 3 g Hres M S
3 g Hres
g
3 Hres
MAGNETIZATION OF A SUBSTANCE
A single spin- up or down
mS 12
mS 12
magnetic
ti fifield
ld ((spins
i up and
d d
down):
)
N- number of spins up, N- number of spins down
N+N=N
Magnetic moment of N spins :
N N N N
Main question: numbers N and N - ?
BOLTZMAN DISTRIBUTION
molecules in the medium (ensemble):
(each molecule having, let say, three levels):
3
2
1
Due to interaction with the medium (thermostat or bath) electrons
(bolls-) jump up (absorption of heat) and down (emission of
heat) traveling among the levels 1,
1 2 and 3.
3 These jumps are very
fast, so one can say about the distribution of the electrons over the
levels in the thermodynamic equilibrium of the ensemble.
N1-mean number of the molecules with the energy E1
N2 -mean number of the molecules with the energy E2
N3 -mean number
b off th
the molecules
l
l with
ith th
the energy E3
N= N1+ N2+ N3-total number of the molecules.
p1= N1/N- p
probability
y to find a molecule with the
populated level 1 (i.e. with the energy E1), etc
The main question: what are these probabilities?
1 Ei / kT
pi e
Z
k B lt
k-Boltzman
constant
t t, T-absolute
T b l t temperature
t
t ,
kT
summation over
all levels
Probability pi depends on
the energy Ei and on the temperature T
E excited
E
0 ground
p1
1
E
1 e kT
, p2
E
kT
1 e kT
onlyy
E
kT
Z 1 e
E1 0 , E2 E
energy
gy is counted
from the ground level
T 0, p1 1, p2 0
level "1" is p
populated
p
1
T , p1 p2
2
(levels "1" and "2" are equally populated)
Ene
ergy E
E5
1 Ei
pi T e
Z
E4
E3
E2
E1
population
kT
Z e
i
Ei kT
E M S g e HM S , M S S , ..., S
Z exp g e HM S kT
S
ge H
x
kT
Sinh 12 e e
MAGNETIZATION QUANTUM
QUANTUM--MECHANICAL
EXPRESSION
In classical mechanics,
when a sample is perturbed by an external magnetic
field, its magnetizat ion is related to its energy variation through
E
M
H
Using
g the language
g g of q
quantum mechanics
we consider a molecule with an energy spectrum
E i 1, 2 ,,...
in the presence of a magnetic field H.
For each energy level we can define
i
MAGNETIZATION QUANTUM
QUANTUM--MECHANICAL
EXPRESSION, MEAN VALUE
and then
N E H exp E kT
M
exp E kT
i
MAGNETIC SUSCEPTIBILITY
Molar magnetic susceptibility (isotropic system) :
M
M H, or
H
Expressions through the partition function :
N i Ei H exp Ei kT
ln
l Z
1 kT
H
i exp Ei kT
Ei functions
f
ti
off the
th magnetic
ti field,
fi ld Ei Ei H
This leads to the following expressions for magnetizat ion and
magnetic
i susceptibi
ibility
li through
h
h derivative
d i i s off the
h partition
i i function
f
i :
ln Z
M N kT
H
2 ln Z M
N kT
2
H
H
H
2kT
ge H
x
kT
2S 1Coth 2S 1x 2 Coth x 2
This can be rewritten as :
ln Z g e
H
2kT
2S 1Coth 2S 1 y
2 S Coth y 2 S
with
ge S H
y
kT
Cosh e e
Hyperbolic cotangent : Coth
Sinh e e
MOLAR MAGNETIZATION
Th molar
The
l magnetizat
ti t ion
i is
i then
th :
ge SH
M Ng
N e S BS y , y
kT
BS y is the Brillouin function defined as :
2S 1
2S 1 1
1
BS y
Coth
y
Coth
y
2S
2S
2S
2S
Cosh e e
Coth
Sinh e e
Two extreme cases for the Brillouin function :
1) y 1, low temperatur e, kT Zeeman splitting
2) y 1, high temperatur e, kT Zeeman splitting
BS
S
7/2
5/2
3/2
1/2
ge H
kT
High
Hi h temperature or/and
/ d weak
k magnetic
i fifield:
ld BS 0
Msat M T 0 Ng e S N 2 S
g e 2
Maximum magnetization
magnetization-all
all spins along magnetic field
1.38 10 23 J K
g H
H
T
4
.
1
0
7
,
1
T
(T
(Tesla)
l
)
10
gauss
27 J
kT
T 2 9.27 10
K
T
Paramagnetic-disordered
g
Ordered (p
(parallel to field))
MS
1/2
1/T
-1/2
E 12 12 g e Hz
E 12 12 g e Hz
E 12 12 g e Hz
E 12 12 g e Hz
p 1
2
1
ge H
1 e kT
, p1
2
ge H
e kT
ge H
1 e kT
g SH
y
kT
g SH
smallll y
1 high
hi h temperatur
t
t e and/or
d/ low
l
fi ld
field
kT
(under standard experimental conditions this means T 1 5K )
g SH S 1
BS y
kT
3S
Molar magnetization in this limit :
ge S H S 1
M Ng SBS y Ng S
3S
kT
Ng 2 2
M
S S 1 H
3kT
k
In all expressions : g e g (more general)
Ng 2 2
M
S S 1 H
3kT
Weak field
disordered
Strong
g field
fullyy ordered
S S 1
H
3kT
Magnetic susceptibility varies as a function of temperatur e C
C
Ng 2 2
S S 1
, C
T
3k
This is the Curie low which was proposed in 1910 from experiment al
data before the introduction of quantum mechanics.
mechanics
Experiment al verification :
to measure T as a function T , this should be a horisontal straight line :
T C
S S 1
3kT
The value g 2 2 S S 1 is the squared value of the
magnetic moment for a particle with spin S :
2 g 2 2 S S 1
Experiment al magnetic susceptibility data can be presented
in the form of the temperatur e dependence of the so - called
effective magnetic
g
moment :
effff 3kT
1
2
N 2
eff 8T
1
2
Operator
p
of the magnetic
g
moment :
g S
2 g 2 2 S 2
with
ith the
th wave - function
f
ti n r
operator of A :
should be calculated as A
r d n A
n Dirac' s notation
A r A
MAGNETIC MOMENT
The mean value of squared magnetic moment of a particle
with spin S should be calculated as :
2 g 2 2 SM S 2 SM
S
Pierre Curie
Curie,
1903 Nobel Laureate
in Physics
Experimental data:
Henry W., Phys.Rev.,88 (1952) 559
H/T, Tesla/K
Strong field and/or low temperature Msat=2S
Weak
W k field
fi ld and/or
d/ high
hi h temperature M=0
Chapter III
Magnetic properties of a free ion,
molecules containing a unique magnetic center
without first-order
first order orbital magnetism and EPR of
transition metal ions and rare-earths, spin-orbital
interaction.
interaction
QUANTUM--MECHANICAL DESCRIPTION
QUANTUM
OF A FREE ATOM
Erwin Schrodinger
Born: 12 Aug 1887 in Erdberg, Vienna, Austria
Died: 4 Jan 1961 in Vienna,, Austria
In 1945 he was awarded the Nobel Prize for decisive contribution through his discovery in
1925 of a new low of Nature, Pauli exclusion principle. He had been nominated for the
Prize by Albert Einstein
QUANTUM NUMBERS
FOR ONE ELECTRON IN A SPHERICAL POTENTIAL
(HYDROGEN ATOM,
ATOM ONE ELECTRON IONS)
ml l , l 1,...,l 1, l 2l 1 values
l
ms spin projection quantum number
spin
s 1 2, ms 1 2 :
spin " up
up"- and " down
down"-
SPECTROSCOPIC NOTATIONS:
l 0 , 1, 2 , 3, 4 , 5 ,...
s
f g
even
even and odd
odd states:
seven (l=2), p-odd ( l =1), d even (l=2)
n 3, l 2
Closed d-shell
contains 10 electrons:
(2l+1)2=10
d Ti
1
d V
2
d 3 Cr 3 ,V 2 ,
d
d7
d
Mn , Cr ,
Fe , d Fe ,
Co , d Ni ,
Cu
3
unfilled
shells
S s1 s2 , s1 s2 1,...,| s1 s2 |
L QUANTUM NUMBER OF THE
ORBITAL ANGULAR MOMENTUM
OF THE ELECTRONIC SHELL
S FULL SPIN OF THE
ELECTRONIC SHELL
P L 1, S 1 ,
F L 3, S 3 2
ELECTRONIC
CONFIGURATION
Ti3+, V 4+
3d1
V 3+
3d2
Cr3+, V 2+
3d3
Mn3+ Cr
M
C 2+
3d4
Fe3+, Mn2+
3d5
Fe2+
3d6
Co2+
3d7
Ni2+
3d8
Cu2+
3d9
GROUND
TERM
2D
(L=22, SS=1/2)
(L
1/2)
3F
4F
(L=3, S=3/2)
5D
6S
(L=3, S=1)
(L 2 S=2)
(L=2,
S 2)
((L=0,, S=5/2))
5D
4F
(L=3, S=3/2)
3F
2D
(L=2, S=2)
(L=3,
(L
3, SS=1)
1)
(L=2, S=1/2)
SOME OBSERVATIONS
Transition metal complexes
Partiall filled d
Partially
d--shell
shell,, li =2
=2,
2
10 n shells
dn andd d10-n
h ll (complimentary
(
li
t
configurations)
fi
ti
) have
h
MANY--ELECTRON IONS
MANY
In many-electron atoms the value of L (total
orbital angular momentum of all electrons in the
unfilled shells) is the appropriate quantum
number that enumerates the energy levels.
The multiplicity of the orbital degeneracy is (2L+1).
The full multiplicity of the LS term is
(2L+1) (2S+1).
,
L
S .
Example :
T
Term
F L 3, S
3
2
M L 3, 2, 1, 0, 1, 2, 3
S z 3, 32 , M L M S M S 3, 32 , M L M S
M S 32 , 12 , 12 , 32
LSM L M S
L 2 LSM L M S LL 1 LSM L M S
vector L has a definite length
g LL 1
2
S 2 LSM L M S S S 1 LSM L M S
vector S has a definite length S S 1
2
LZ LSM L M S M L LSM L M S
Precession L around Z axis : LZ M L ,
LX LY 0
S Z LSM L M S M L LSM L M S
Precession S around Z axis : S Z M L ,
S X S Y 0
CLASSICAL ESTIMATION
Magnetic field H created by the moving
electron: proportional to the orbital angular
momentum
t
L.
Energy of interaction spin-magnetic field
E =-S H
HL S S
HL,
Energy of spin orbital coupling=
coupling
const LS ,
Hamiltonian of spin orbital coupling=
coupling
S ,
const L
and
L
d S are operators
SPIN--ORBITAL INTERACTION
SPIN
Interaction of the spin magnetic moment with the magnetic
field created by the orbital motion (current) of the electron
Orbital motion
spin
H
spin
spin
H
Energy of the system does depend on the
mutual orientation of the full spin
p and
magnetic field created by the orbital motion
of the unpaired
p
electron ((electrons).
)
Configuration
Term
,cm-1
Ti3+
3d1
2D
154
V 3+
3d2
3F
104
V 2+
3d3
4F
55
Cr3+
3d3
4F
87
Mn3+
3d4
5D
85
Fe33+
3d5
6S
Fe2+
3d6
5D
-102
Co2+
C
3d7
4F
-180
180
Ni2+
3d8
3F
-335
Cu2+
3d9
2D
-829
COMMENT
Spin-orbital
p
interaction is p
positive for d1,,d2 ,
d3 , d4 ions.
Spin-orbital
Spin orbital interaction is negative for d6,dd7,
d3 , d4 ions, for the complimentary
configurations
fi
ti
dn and
d d10-n constants
t t off spini
orbital coupling are of the opposite signs.
Spin-orbital interaction is zero for d5 , i.e.
for 6S term - S state does not carry orbital
angular momentum.
J z J , M J M J J , M J
M J J , J 1, ... , J 1, J 2 J 1 values
J , M J Dirac' s notation for the atomic wave - function
with a definite total angular
g
momenum J and p
projection
j
MJ,
i.e. quantum states with coupled spin and orbital angular momentum
LS J MJ
Important:
this state with a definite J and MJ is a state with the definite
L and S but not (!) with the definite projections ML and MS
LABELS--Q
LABELS
QUANTUM NUMBERS
Total orbital
angular momentum
Total spin
p
angular momentum
LS J MJ
Total
angular momentum
CLARIFICATION
J 2 L S J M J J J 1 L S J M J ,
J z L S J M J M J L S J M J
S 2 L S J M J S S 1 L S J M J
J
L
S
S L
X
Vector J is in a precession
about arbitrary direction Z at
the conical surface, so that
the mean values of the
projections of J onto the
plane p
p
perpendicular
p
to Z
axis are zero (JX , JY).
Good quantum numbers:
J and MJ
JZ
J
JY
JX
X
J J J 1
cos
MJ
J J 1
SPINSPIN
-ORBIT COUPLINGCOUPLING-CLASSICAL ILLUSTRATION
Z
L
Vector model:
JZ
Good
quantum
numbers:
b
LS J M J
Y
X
Vector J is in a precession around Z-axis and at the same time L
and S precess around J. Length of |L| and length of |S| have definite
values but not their projections MS and ML on Z axis.
axis Vector J has a
definite length and projection MJ but mean <JX > and <JY> vanish.
SPIN--ORBIT SPLITTING
SPIN
SLJ- multiplets
p
J 2 L
S 2 L 2 S 2 2 L
S
S 1 J 2 L 2 S 2
L
2
V SO L S J M J 12 J J 1 L L 1 S S 1 L S J M J
Enegies of the multiplets - energy as a function of J
( definite L and S ) :
EJ
J J 1 L L 1 S S 1
MULTIPLETS--TERMS OF
MULTIPLETS
>0
2
d
3F
J=4, 3F4
<0
-4 J=2, 3
F2
3||
4||
-
3||
d8
d2 AND d8 IONS
- J=3, 3
F3
3F
J=3, 3F3
-4 J=2, 3
F2
4||
3
J=4, 3F4
J J 1 J 1 J
2
E J E J 1 J Lande' s rule
E J E J 1
Rare--Earth IonsRare
Ions-Strong SpinSpin-Orbit Coupling
l 2s
Total magnetic moment (one - electron ion) :
Total magnetic moment of a many - electron ion :
2 S , L
l , S s
L
i
i
J
Lz
Sz
L S cos 12 J J 1 LL 1 S S 1
y
x
J J 1 LL 1 S S 1
cos
LL 1 S S 1
B
2S
M
C
S
S
S- angle
l
between S and J
L- angle
between L and J
L 2J
L cos L J 2 L2 S 2 2 J
S cos S
S2
3 2 S
EZ J 2 L2 S 2 2 J 2 J 2 S 2 L2 2 J H
2
L2 2 J 2 J H
LSJ-TERM
E Z 3 2 S 2 L2 2 J 2 J H
This is a classical ( but not a quantum - mechanical !!! ) expression ,
all vectors are classical values but not operators.
operators
Quantum - mechanical expression
according to the rule of quantum mechanics,
mechanics
classical values should be substitute d by their operators :
2 , J 2 J 2 , J J .
E Z H Z , S 2 S 2 , L2 L
In this way one obtains the Hamiltonia n
instead of classical energy :
2 2 J 2 J H
H 3 2 S 2 L
Z
LSJ-TERM
2 2J 2 J H
H Z 3 2 S 2 L
Z axis can be chosen along the direction of the magnetic field H0 :
Z 2 2 J 2 J H .
H 3 2 S 2 L
values)
Th energy levels
The
l
l (mean
(
l
)
E
L S J M H L S JM
JM J
2 are S S 1 and LL 1,
The eigen - values of S 2 and L
the eigen - values of J 2 and J are J J 1 and M .
Z
3 S S 1 LL 1
gJ
2
2 J J 1
Limiting cases:
pure spin state L=0 and J=S (orbital angular
momentum=0):
gJ= gS=2
pure orbital state S=0 and J=L (spin angular
momentum=0):
gJ= gL=1
gJ -SHARP
SHARP DISTINCTION FROM ge !
Rare-earth ions-strong spin-orbit coupling:
1
5
4 f , CeIII , ground term F5 2 S , L 3, J
2
2
1 3
3 4
3 2 2
6
g5 2
5 7
2
7
2
2 2
4 f 2 , Pr III , ground term 3H 4 S 1, L 5, J 4
1
4
g4
5
g Hres
S 1 2
g
Free electron :
g e 2
Hres
ge
Hres
M S 1 2
MJ 5 2
MJ 3 2
J 5 2
2
F5 2
MJ 1 2
M J 1 2
M J 3 2
M J 5 2
g J 2, g J 2
Hres
gJ
The main result :
EPR line is shifted
in the region of a strong field
Ng J2 2
J J 1
3kT
3kT
CJ
with C J
This leads to the Curie low:
T
Magnetization:
3k
3k
M Ng J J BJ y ,
Ng 2J 2
J J 1
gJ J
BJ y Brillouin function with y
kT
Important: the results are valid for a well isolated LSJ term
Rare--Earth IonsRare
Ions-Strong SpinSpin-Orbit Coupling
S7 2 J 7 2 , L 0, S 7 2 and J S
MAGNETISM OF RARE
RARE--EARTH IONS SOME EXAMPLES (Sm(II)
(Sm(II) and Eu(III)
Eu(III)))
The main feature of these ions: the dependence T vs. T does not follow
th C
the
Curie
i llow as one can expectt ffor a LSJ ground
d state:
t t
7F
0
(L=S=3)
In fact
fact, the situation is different due to the presence of
thermally populated excited states (J=1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6):
7F , 7F , 7F , 7F , 7F , 7F
1
2
3
4
5
6
J J 1
2
where
h
the
h energy off the
h 7F0 ground
d state is
i taken
k as an origin.
i i
Eu III and SmII special cases, excited states are close to
J
6
4
3
2
1
0
Energy
pattern
pJ J
J 0
pJ Z 1 exp EJ kT
J susceptibility of a quantum state with a given J :
2 2
Ng
J J J J 1
3kT
Partition function includes summation over all J 0,...,6 :
exp EJ
kT
J 0
Energy levels EJ :
E0 0, E1 , E2 3 , E3 6 , E4 10 , E5 15 , E6 21
k
2 J 1 J exp J J 1 2kT
J 0
2 J 1exp J J 1 2kT
J 0
The factor
2 J 1 multiplici
p tyy of the degeneracy
g
y of the
3 S S 1 LL 1
gJ
2
2 J J 1
3
All g - factors for the excited states are equall to .
2
(T)
3 N
T
4kT
J J 1 2 J 1exp J J 1 kT
J 0
2 J 1expp J J 1 kT
J 0
T versus
Chapter IV
Effects of crystal field.
Group theoretical introduction.
Group-theoretical
introduction
Ground terms of the transition metal
ions in the crystal fields
fields. Anisotropy of
the g-factor. Zero-field splitting:
qualitative and quantitative
approaches. Covalence and orbital
reduction EPR of the metal ions
reduction.
in complexes.
Me
Free metal ion
Men+ in a LS or
LSJ state
Me
Coordinated ion
M (li
Me(ligand)
d)6 -ligand
li
d
surrounding in a complex
compound or in a crystal
Hans Bethe ,
Nobel winner,1967
German-born
G
b
A
American
i
theoretical physicist who helped
to shape classical physics into
quantum physics and increased
the understanding of the atomic
processes responsible
p
p
for the
properties of matter and of the
forces governing the structures of
atomic nuclei.
nuclei He received the
Nobel Prize for Physics in 1967
for his work on the production of
energy in stars
stars. Moreover
Moreover, he was
a leader in emphasizing the social
responsibility of science.
American physicist and mathematician who shared the Nobel Prize for
Physics in 1977 with Philip W. Anderson and Sir Nevill F. Mott. The prize
honoured Van Vleck's contributions to the understanding of the behaviour of
electrons in magnetic, noncrystalline solid materials.
Van Vleck developed during the early 1930s the first fully articulated
quantum mechanical
h i l theory
h
off magnetism.
i
L
Later
h was a chief
he
hi f architect
hi
off
the ligand field theory of molecular bonding. He contributed also to studies
of the spectra of free molecules, of paramagnetic relaxation, and other
topics. His publications include Quantum Principles and Line Spectra (1926)
and the Theory of Electric and Magnetic Susceptibilities (1932).
bi-dimensional irrep
T1u , T2u - tri-dimensional
tri dimensional irreps
Important notation: g-even (gerade), u-odd (ungerade)
(parity of the crystal field states
states, for the
point groups with the inversion symmetry)
CN-group
eg-orbitals
z
3z2-r2
zx
x2-y2
t2g-orbitals
yz
xy
Shape of d
d-orbitals
orbitals and splitting
L irreps
D 0 A1g
S A1g singlet
g
D 1 T1g
P T1g triplet
D 2 E g T2 g
D E g T2 g doublet
d bl triplet
l
r wave function
r spatial distributi on
2
SHAPES OF THREE
p-ORBITALS
dumbbell-shaped
electronic clouds
p-ORBITALS IN THE
OCTAHEDRAL
O
AHEDRAL (Oh)
CRYSTAL FIELD
Positive
(black) and
negative
(light) petals
of the wavewavefunctions
Five d-orbitals
dxz
dxz
two dumbbells in
each: (yz,xz,xy)
(3z2-r2, x2-y2)
y
z
x
dxz
y
y
(yz,xz,xy) T2-orbitals
2S 1
2T
Irreducible
representation
Rnl r Ylm ,
Five d-functions (angular parts): Y2,-2, Y2,-1,Y2,0,Y2,1 Y2,2
d level (l=2)
d-level
d yz , d xz , d xy T2 g
and d
x2 y2
,d
z2
E g
E g T2 g D E g T2 g doublet triplet
2
Eg
T2 g
2D
2D
10Dq
10Dq
T2 g
d1- electron
l t
(Ti
(T 3+)
Eg
d9-hole
h l (C
(Cu2+)
D
Dq
eq r 4
5
6R0
q*
Metal
<r4>
R0
Ligand
Point
P
Pointi t-charge
h
model
d l for
f
the crystal fieldfield-ligands
are the point charges
(covalency is not taken
into account):
q* -charge of the ligands
(point charges,
R0-metal-ligand
distances in the
octahedral surrounding
10Dq- crystal field
splitting of the
one-electron d- level
<r4>-mean value of r4
for the d-electron
10Dq
8Dq
3
T2 g
T2 g
3F
8D
8Dq
10D
10Dq
3
T1g
d 2 (V 3+)
3
2 electrons
A2 g
A2 g
d 8 ( Ni 2+)
2 holes
holes in d10
d 8- two holes in the closed shell d 10 (reversed order of the levels: in V 3+ground triplet,
triplet in Ni 22+-ground
ground singlet ) 10Dq
10Dq- cubic crystal field parameter =
splitting of the one-electron level (d1) in a cubic crystal field
Ti3+
V3+
Cr3+
Mn3+
Fe3+
Co3+
Dq cm-1
Dq,
2030
1860
1720
2100
1350
1920
Ion
Cr2+
Mn2+
Fe2+
Co2+
Ni2+
Cu2+
Dq, cm-1
1390
1230
1030
840
820
1220
Some conclusions:
1) crystal field splitting is of the order of 10,000-20,000cm-1(visible
region the light);
2) empirical rule: irrespective of the ligand and metal 10Dq in
the systems with divalent ions is around 10,000 cm-1 metal
ions and in those with trivalent metal ions around 20,000cm-1.
SPECTROCHEMICAL SERIES
When the metal element is fixed and the ligand is varied,
the magnitudes of 10Dq may be arranged
in the following order:
OhD4h
Elongated
octahedron
Compressed
octahedron
Mixed-ligand MeA4B2 complexes
(Oh-group)
(D4h-group)
T2 g
Dd
10Dq
2
free
Cu II
E g yz , xz
Eg
Oh
B2 g xyy
A1 g 3 z 2 r 2
2
B1g x 2 y 2
Energy pattern
for an elongated
g
octahedrally
coordinated or
square-planar
Cu(II) complex .
D4 h
Problem:
evaluation
l ti off th
the g-factor
f t for
f the
th ground
d state
t t in
i a crystal
t l field
fi ld
Compressed
octahedron
Y
3z 2 r 2 A1g
Elongated
octahedron
x y
Compressed
p
conformati on :
efficient attraction of d
z2
" cloud"
to the apical
p
ligands
g
Elongated conformati on :
Y
X
B1g
efficient attraction of d
x2 y2
" cloud"
E -orbitals in a
cubic field (one
half-filled orbital)
x2-y2
z2
10Dq
10D
T2 -orbitals in a
cubic field (fully
occupied)
i d)
xy
xz, yz
xy
xz, yz
|x2-y2>
|z2>
unpaired electron
|
|xy>
|
|yz>
|
|xz>
Degenerate, 2E
Degenerate
1
2
S i - matrices
Spin
i
| Su | | Su |
This matrix (for each operator Su ) has two rows and two columns 2x2 - matrix (second order matrix) in the two - dimensional basis a and .
| S u | | S u |
| Su | | Su |
One can see that | S x | 0 , | S x | 1 2 , etc.
The matrices :
x
0 1
1 0
y
,
0 i
i
z
,
0 1
x2 y2
x2 y2
2i
d xz | L y | d
x2 y2
Important remark :
the matrix elements connecting d
x2 y2
and d
z2
Physical conclusion :
cubic crystal field " kills
kills" orbital magnetic contributi on
in the ground state E g of the " hole" (the case of Cu 2 ion).
x2 y2
state.
state
x2 y2
x2 y2
and d
x2 y2
x2 y2
Zeeman interaction :
2 S H
H Z B L
H,,
Orbital
O
b ta pa
partt B L
Spin pa
Sp
partt 2 B S H
vanish :
Matrix elements of L
x2 y2
d
L
x2 y2
Result :
mean value of the orbital part of Zeeman interaction 0
x2 y2
2 B H0 S z d
E d
x2 y2
2 B H0 S z d
B L z 2 S z H0 d
x2 y2
x2 y2
x2 y2
Normalizat ion : d
x2 y2
x2 y2
1
2 B H0
2
B Lz 2 S z H0 d
d
x2 y2
x2 y2
1
2 B H0
2
x2 y2
This can b
Thi
be expressed
d as :
E M S 2 B H0 M S g B H0 M S
Conclusion :
g 2 pure spin value,
orbital contributi on has dissapered
due to action of the crystal field of D 4h symmetry
:
this function is the eigen - function of the unperturbe d Hamiltonia n H
0
0 E 0 0
H
0
gr
gr
gr
to be calculated .
This means that the ground state should be well isolated from the excited ones ,
i.e. absolute values of all matrix elements n | V | gr are much smaller
0
than the energy gaps E gr
En0 .
x2 y2
and d
x2 y2
x x
z z
Mean value of spin - orbital interaction in the ground state 2B1g is zero,
due to the fact that all matrix elements of Lu vanish :
d
x2 y2
Lx S x d
x2 y2
x2 y2
Lz S z d
x2 y2
x2 y2
Lx d
x2 y2
S x 0,
x2 y2
Lz d
x2 y2
S z 0,
etc.
For this reason the mean value of the
orbital part of the Zeeman interaction vanishes.
x2 y2
and d
x2 y2
x2 y
2 d yz | Lx | d
| i 1 i
|
S
x
x2 y2
2
2
x2 y2
Energy
pattern
2
d xy | L z S z | d 2 2 1 d xy
x y
d yyz | Lx S x | d 2 2 2 d yyz
x y
d xz | Ly S y | d 2 2 2 d xz
x y
d 2 2 d xy | Lz S z | d 2 2 1 d xy
x y
x y
d yz | L x S x | d 2 2 2 d yz
x y
d xz | L y S y | d 2 2 2 d xz
x y
10Dq
E g yz , xz
B2 g xy
A1 g 3 z 2 r 2
B1g x 2 y 2
2
1
D4 h
Energy gaps
1 and 2
d xz
xy
2 yz
x2 y2
1
2
2 2
i
i
d yz
d xz
d 2 2 d xy
1
2 2
2 2
The function shows that the ion exists not only in the state d
x y
x2 y2
1,
HOW TO EVALUATE g
g--FACTORS?
I order
In
d to
t calculate
l l t the
th g - factors
f t
we mustt
calculate the Zeeman splitting
with
ith the
th use off the
th first
fi t order
d ground
d state
t t
wave functions and .
2 S H
Zeman operator : H Z B L
Operators S and L have only diagonal matrix elements,
H
Z
H
Z
H
Z
H
Z
H Z E
H Z
H Z
0
H Z E
ANISOTROPY OF THE g
g--FACTOR SECULAR EQUATIONS
FOR TWO PRINCIPAL DIRECTIONS
We shall consider this equation in the cases of two orientation
of the magnetic field along principal directions - parallel to C4 axis
and in the equatorial plane C4 , let say, parallel to X axis.
The case of " parallel" field H || C4 :
B LZ 2 S Z HZ E
0
0
0
B LZ 2S Z HZ E
B L X 2S X H X
E
8
,
1
g X gY g e
2
2
8
2
and
1
2
anisotropic contributions,
x2 y2
g|| g
is always valid. In fact,
8
2
8
2
and
are p
positive 0 for d 9 ion and
1
2
1
2
Typical values for Cu(II) complexes : g|| 2.20, g 2.08
1 2
S S 1
3kT
1
Anisotropi c systems (axial symmetry, S ) :
2
Ng||2 B2
H || C4 ||
4kT
Ng 2 B2
H C4
4 kT
Powder (polycryst alline) samples - in the analysis of the magnetic data
the averaged values of the g factors are usually used :
1 2 2 2
g|| g
3
3
1
Tri - axial symmery : g 2 g x2 g 2y g z2
3
Axial symmery : g 2
+
S
1
2
g|| g e
1
2
+
H||
H H
8
1
Hres,||
2
g ge
2
Hres,
g||
g|| g , H H||
C
Conclusion:
l i
position
iti off th
the EPR line
li d
does d
depend
d on th
the
direction of the field respectively of crystal axes.
B LZ 2S Z HZ E
B LX 2S X H X
HX H sin cos ,
B LX 2S X H X
B LZ 2S Z HZ E
HY H sin sin , HZ H cos
In fact p
point symmetry
y
y is D 4h ,,meanwhile
g - factor is axially symmetric.
This is valid for all point groups
involving axes Cn with n 3,
C3v , C4v , D4 h , etc.
=0
Right
bound
=/2
Left
bound
H|| H H
EPR line of a
powder sample
has left and right
bounds, i.e.
values of the
resonance field
corresponding to
principal directions
of the applied field
respectively ZZ
axes of randomly
oriented
molecules.
l
l
g||
g||
gZ
gY
gX
Axial symmetry,
shape of the line - sharp peak
at the right bound
(bounds are smoothed)
Axial symmetry,
derivative of the line
Tri-axial symmetry,
symmetry
derivative of the line
2
2
8
g|| g e
1
Hres,
Hres,||
right bound
bo nd of the line
g
1
1
g g||
g g||
TRI--AXIAL SYMMETRY
TRI
SYMMETRY--SOME RESULTS
In the case of triaxial symmetry g - factor has three different components :
g X gY g Z
g 2 g x2 cos 2 x g 2y cos 2 y g z2 cos 2 z
C2Z
B
C
C2Y
C2X
Application of the EPR technique to a single
crystal as well as to a powder sample
YZ c1d yyz c2 L yz
REDUCTION FACTOR
Calculation of the matrix elements
of the orbital angular momentum shows
that this physical value is reduced ,
should be substituted by a new effective value :
the operator L
kL
, with k 1
L
Very roughly : k c12 2c1 c2 ML ,
PHYSICAL CONSEQUENCES
OF THE REDUCTION EFFECT
Spin - orbital interactio n is reduced :
S , k
H kL
SO
2 S H ,
H Z B kL
L
k
L
2k
g X gY g e
, k
2
For the transition metal ions the reduction factor can be estimated as :
0.6 k 0.9
A more precise consideration shows that the reduction factors
are anisotropic.
ZERO-FIELD SPLITTING
ZEROSPLITTING-GROUND STATE OF Ni2+ COMPLEXES
x2-yy2
T1g
3F
10Dq
z2
3
T2 g
8D
8Dq
3
A2 g
d 8 ( Ni 2+)
2 holes
holes in d10
t 26 e 2
10Dq
xy
xz, yz
Octahedral crystal
y
field, ground
g
state 3A2g orbital
singlet (orbitally non-degenerate) and full spin S=1 ( spin triplet)
A2 g
From the symmetry point ov view the wave - function of the ground state
can be represented as a product :
(orbital part,
part A2 g ) (spin part,
part S 1
1)).
From the tables of characters one can see that three functions corresponding
to S 1 ((or L 1,, or J 1)) form a basis for the irrep
p T1g of a cubic p
point g
group.
p
So the full ground state in spin and orbital spaces
of a nickel(II) ion in a perfect octahedral surrounding can be found
as a direct product of two irreps :
(orbital part, A2 g ) (spin part, S 1) A2 g T1g
F
From
th table
the
t bl off characters
h
t one can fnd
f d this
thi product
d t:
A2 g T1g T2 g
This is a regular rule to find qualitatively spin - orbit components in a crystal field.
field
The existence of the only irrep shows that spin - orbit coupling does not split term 3 A2 g
A2 of a cubic system.
The trigonal field iself can not also split the ground state crystal field dos not affect spin direcly.
When spin - orbital coupling is taken into account
(like in the procedure of th evaluation of the g - factors)
the ground state gets some admixture of the excited states and
gives rise to a small orbital contribution.
In this way the ground state can be split by the trigonal
crystall field
fi ld accordingl
di ly to the
h group - theoretica
h
i l analysis.
l i
Calculation of the splitting requires application of the perturbation theory
t the
to
th degenerate
d
t ground
d state.
t t
S
S
1
D
ZFS
z 3
Notations:
1) H
ZFS zero - field splittingHamiltonian,
2) S z2 operator acting on the spin - functions of the ground state,
S spin of the ground state, S 1 for Ni2 ion
3) D zero - field splitting parameter.
H ZFS D S z2 S S 1
3
MS 1 ,
MS 0 ,
M S 1 .
Three 3 3 matrices :
0 1 0
0 i
1
1
S x
1 0 1 , S y
i
2
2
0
0 1 0
1 0
i , S z 0 0
0 0 1
E
Examples
l off the
th matrix
t i elements
l
t :
1
M S 1 S x M S 1 0 , M S 1 S x M S 0
,
2
M S 1 S z M S 1 1, M S 0 S z M S 0 0 , M S 1 S z M S 1 1,
etc...
The SM S functions are the eigen - vectors of S z and S z2 ,
so the matrix of the operator S z2 is diagonal and
so,
the diagonal matrix elements are : M S2 ( in the adopted basis).
1 0 0
1 0 0
Matrix S 0 0 0 , Matrix S 2 0 0 0
z
0 0 1
Matrix of H ZFS H Z || in the basis
H ZFS H Z ||
0 0 1
MS 1
MS 0
1
g|| BHz D
3
2
D
3
M S 1 :
1
g|| BHz D
3
The sum of the diagonal matrix elements (trace of the matrix) is zero,
0
1
this is due to the constant term S S 1 specially added .
3
2
DE
3
1
DE
3
The energy levels (quantum number M S ) : E EM S :
0
2
1
E0 D ,
E1 E1 D ,
3
3
Triply degenerate level is split into a singlet ( M S 0) and a doublet ( M S 1).
This is in agreement with the group - theoretica l conclusion.
MS=0
|MS|=1
S=1
S=1
D
MS=0
D>0, ground singlet
D
|MS|=1
1
g|| BHz D E
3
0
2
DE
3
1
g|| BHz D E
3
The energy levels EM S in parallel field
0
1
DE
3
2 g x BH x 2
2
DE
3
2 g x BH x 2
2 g x BH x 2
DE
2 g x BH x 2
0
2 g x BH x 2
E
2 g x BH x 2
0
2 g x BH x 2 0
1
DE
3
0
2 g x BH x 2 0
DE
1
4 g x2 B2 H2x D 2 D
2
The zero - field energy of the M S 0 component is taken as the energy origin
E1 D ,
E 2 E3
2
D is added to all diagonal matrix elements, i.e. to all energies).
3
D>0 H||C4,4
D>0,
Linear field
dependence
D>0, H||X,
Quadratic field
dependence at
low field
vs. T
D=5 cm-1
gx= gz=2
D=-5 cm-1
gx= gz=22
T vs. T
+1
0
-1
+1
S 1, D 0
-1
+1
spherical symmetry
S 1, D 0
0
-1
-11
axial symmetry
oscillating (radiofrequency) field generating EPR transition in plane, i.e. is perpendicu lar to the main axis
Selection rules for the EPR transitions :
M 0 M 1
M 1
M 0 M 1
Forbidden transitions :
M 1 M 1 M 2
Two kinds of spectra :
1) D
and
2) D
I both
In
b th cases the
th full
f ll spectrum
t
consists
i t off two
t lines.
li
Difference :
positions
iti
off lines
li
and
d the
th changes
h
off the
th spectrum
t
with the change of frequency
RESONANCE FIELDS
R
Resonance
conditions
diti
- generall :
E M E M
M M allowed transitions
Zeeman levels : E0 0 , E1 D g BH
Case 1) D
First resonance condition :
E1 E0 D g BHres - 0 Hres
g B
D
g B
Case 2) D
First resonance condition :
E1 E0 D g BHres - 0 Hres
D
g B
D
g B
+1
high-frequency
EPR
+1
-1
2
-1
H
1 , 2 D
field
1 2
1 , 2 D
1 2
MS
3
2
2|D|
1
MS
2
Three lines,,
1
1
MS ,
2
2
1
3
1
3
MS MS , MS MS
2
2
2
2
allowed transitions : M S
3
2
H ZFS D S z2 S S 1
3
2 5
E M S D M S
4
MS
1
2
Cr
1
MS
2
3
MS
2
3
t2 g
Chapter
p V.
Exchange interaction in clusters.
Exchange
E
h
effect,
ff t the
th nature
t
off the
th
potential exchange.
p
g
Magnetic properties of binuclear
compounds dimers of Cu(II)
compounds,
Cu(II), EPR
EPR,
magnetic anisotropy.
TWO ONE
ONE--ELECTRON IONS - HAMILTONIAN
The aim of this Section :
to demonstrate the main physical idea of the
exchange
h
Hamiltonian
H ilt i
( W.Heisenberg, 1926; P.A.M.Dirac, 1929)
System under consideration
two interacting hydrogen-like atoms or ions containing one
electron each over closed ((filled)) shells.
Hamiltonian:
H H 0 V ,
H 0 Hamiltonia n of non - interactin g ions (main part)
sum off two
t intra
i t - atomic
t i interactio
i t
ti ns
V interactio n (perturbat ion)
inter - atomic interactio ns
rA1
rB2
RAB
2
2
2
Ze
Ze
2
2
H 0
1 2
2m
rA1 rB 2
2 2
1 operator
t off the
th kinetic
ki ti energy off the
th electron
l t
"1" , etc
t
2m
Ze 2
Interatomic interaction
1
rA2
A
r12
rB1
rAB
2
2
2
2 2
e
Ze
Ze
Z
e
V
r12 rB1 rA2
rAB
e2
interelectronic ((Coulombic ) interaction ((repusion)
p
)
r12
Ze 2
Wave--functions of a bi
Wave
bi--atomic system
Wave - functions of the ions : A r1 and B r2 ,
these one - electron orbitals are supposed to be non - degener ate
(like 1s - orbital of a hydrogen atom ).
) They are eigen - func tions of two
Hamiltonians for two identical non - interacting ions and obey two
identical Schrodingerr' s equations
E A and EB
2 2 Ze 2
2m r A r1 E A A r1
1A
2 2 Ze 2
2m r B r2 EB B r2
2B
electron "1" is " attached" to the nucleus " A" and electron "2" - to " B"
A r1 B r2 ,
electron "1" at the nucleus " A", electron "2" at the nucleus " B".
The probability to find the electron "1"
1 in the vicinity of the point r1
(near " A" ) and the electron "2" in the vicinity of the point r2
(near " B" ) is this product raised to the second power :
| A r1 B r2 |2 | A r1 |2 | B r2 |2
In fact,
fact in the non - interacting atoms the electrons move
mo e
independently
A r1 B r2 eigen vector of H 0 :
H 0 A r1 B r2 E A EB A r1 B r2
Notation : A r1 A 1, B r2 B 2, etc.
P12 A 1 B 2 A 2 B 1
Due to indistingu ishibility of the electrons the energy
of the system with the transposed electrons
A 2 B 1
will have the same zeroth order energy 2 E0 .
The parturbati on will be :
2
2
2
2 2
e
Ze
Ze
Z
e
r12 rB 2
rA1
rAB
A 1 B 2 A 2 B 1 symmetric
A 1 B 2 A 2 B 1 antisymmet ric
They are eigen - functions of the permutation operator P12
with the eigen values : 1 and -1 respectively.
AB A r B r d
E
Electron
ic densities
A r
B r
RA
A , B
Region of
overlap
RB
1,2
2 1 AB
A 1 B 2 A 2 B 1 antisym.
W
Wave
functions
f
ti
include
i l d only
l electronic
l t i coordinates.
di t
N
Now we
should remember about the electronic spin.
M 1, S 1
1
1 2 1 2 S 1, spin - triplet states
1,0
2
1,1 1 2
1
1 2 1 2 S 0, spin - singlet state
0,0
2
, Mrepresented
the operatorSzSis
by the diagonal matrix within the basis set
S , M
Important observation:
three spin functions belonging to S=1 are symmetric,
spin-function belonging to S=0 is antisymmetric
coordinate
di t function
f
ti
spin
i - function
f
ti
1,2 1, M , 1,2 0 ,0 4 functions
symmetric
1,2 1, M , 1,2 0 ,0 4 functions
f ti
antisymmet ric
Pauli p
principle
p
Only those quantum states of a many-electron system are
allowed for which the full wave-functions are antisymmetric
with respect to permutation in any pair of electrons.
y
symmetric
antisymmet ric
antisymmet ric
antisymmet ric orbital part S 1
symmetric orbital part S 0
This is a consequense of the Pauli principle.
Energy
gy of the states becomes dependent
p
of the
full spin of the system.
E S 1 1,2 1, M H 1,2 1, M
E S 0 1,2 0 ,0 H 1,2 0 ,0
1,2 H 1,2 1, M 1, M
1,2 H 1,2
We have taken into account the normalization condition :
1, M 1, M 1
For the sake of the simplicity one can neglect the overlap :
AB 0
In this approximat
pp
ion one can find the following
g expression
p
s for
the energies of spin - triplet and spin - singlet states :
1,2 H 1,2 2 E K J S 0
1,2 H 1,2 2 E0 K J
S 1
Notations :
K Coulomb integral,
g
J exchange
g integral.
g
The main conclusion :
the energy does depend on the full spin of the molecule.
COULOMB INTEGRAL
2
2
K A 1 B 2V A 1 B 2 d 1d 2 A 1 V B 2 d 1d 2
2
2
2
2 2
electrosta tic Coulomb intercente r interactio n
e
Ze
Ze
Z
e
V
at instant positions of the electrons "1"
1 and "2"
2
r12 rB1 rA2
rAB
2
Coulomb integral K A 1 V B 2 d 1d 2
off intercente
i
r Coulomb
C l b interactio
i
i n
EXCHANGE INTEGRAL
J A 1 B 2V A 2 B 1 d1d 2
Dirac's notation :
J A 1 B 2 V B 1 A 2 , or, very short : A B V BA
2
Physical
h i l sense:
A 1 B 2 V B 1 A 2
Initial B 1 A 2
Final A 1 B 2
Exchange
E h
of the electrons
SPIN
S
N DE
DEPENDENCE
ENDEN E
The energy of non - interactin g atoms : 2 E0
The energy of interactio n :
E S 0 K J
E S 1 K J
K spin independen
d
d t contributi
t ib ti on,
J and J spin dependent contributi ons
The energy gap depends
on the EXCHANGE INTEGRAL only :
E S 0 E S 1 2 J
e A 1
e B 2
exchange
h
Quantum effect,
spin dependent
+
R
RAB
Bethe s dependence (1933) of the
Bethes
exchange integral upon the distance
between the magnetic
g
centers:
short distance negative,
negative
long distancedistance-positive .
I
Important:
t t role
l off bridging
b id i liligands
d
mediate exchange
E S 0 E S 1 2 J
Let us introduce the " effective" Hamiltonia n acting in spin - space :
H 2 J S A S B
The following notations are used :
S A spin operator for the ion A, S B spin operator for the ion B ,
J exchange integral, S S scalar product,
A
d as :
Scalar p
product S A S B can be represente
p
S S 1 S 2 S 2 S 2
A B
A
B
2
so that the exchange Hamiltonian becomes :
H J S 2 S 2 S 2 .
ith S S A S B , S A S B 1,..., S A S B
with
S 2 S A S B S M S S 1 S A S B S M ,
S Z S A S B S M M S S A S B S M .
S A S B S M - are also eigen - vectors of S A2 , S B2 ( but NOT!!! S AZ and S BZ ) :
S A2 S A S B S M S A S A 1 S A S B S M ,
S B2 S A S B S M S B S B 1 S A S B S M .
This means that the lengths of S A and S B remain constant
but they have no definite projection s
( just like vectors L and S in the case of spin - orbit coupling).
SPIN-COUPLING SCHEME
SPINA CLASSICAL PICTURE
SA
SA
S A S B S M J S 2 S A2 S B2 S A S B S M
Using
g the p
properties
p
operators
p
S 2 , S A2 , S B2 one finallyy finds :
E S J S S 1 S A S A 1 S B S B 1
The energy levels are enumerated
by the quantum number of the full spin S ,
they DO NOTdepend on the spin projection M .
1
S 0 and 1.
2
3
1
E 0 J , E 1 J
2
2
The gap between two levels : E 0 E 1 2 J
S A SB
S=0
S=1
2J
2J
S=1
1
E 1 J
2
1
E 1 J
2
J>0- ferromagnetic
coupling,
p g high-spin
g p
ground state
S=0
3
E 0 J
2
J<0, antiferromagnetic
coupling,
p g low-spin
p
ground state
Important
p
p
preliminary
y note:
exchange interaction is magnetically isotropic
MOLECULAR STRUCTURE
OF A DINUCLEAR Cu(II) ACETATE
bridging ligands
d A2
Cu
x y2
XA
YA
XB
Cu
YB
d B2
x y2
x y2
J Cu Cu d A2
x
and d B2
x y2
of Cu(II) ions :
B
B
dA
1
d
2
H
2
d
1 d 1 d 2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
y
x y
x y
x y
A tif
Antiferromagnetic
ti
E S
exp
S
S
1
2
S
1
p
kT
S
E S
2
1
S
exp
kT
S
S
S
1
2
S
1
exp
kT
2 2
Ng B S
T
3kT
J S S 1
2
1
exp
S
kT
This expression is valid for all dimeric systems, S A and S B are so far arbitrary.
Ng 2 B2
T
3kT
2J
6 exp
kT
2 Ng 2 B2
kT
2J
1 3 exp
kT
2J
3 exp kT
Magnetic
g
moment p
per a dimeric cluster
2
Neff
3kT
T g
2
B2
6
2J
3 exp
kT
S 1 g 2 B2 1 2 2 g 2 B2
S=1
2J
S 0
S=0
Antiferromagnetic
interaction
LIMITING CASES
CASES--PHYSICAL SENCE
Low temperatur e :
T 0 2 0 0 only the ground level with S 0 is populated,
High temperatur e :
Both S 0 and S 1 are equally populated
3
T 2 g 2 B2
2
Thi is
This
i just
j t the
th value
l off 2 for
f two
t
non - interactin
i t
ti g
1
Cu(II) ions S A S A ,
2
2
4
High
g - temperatur
p
e limit is jjust doubled value, this means that equal
q
population of the levels kills the exchange effect.
2 S g 2 B2 S S 1 g 2 B2
Magnetic
g
susceptibility
Magnetic
moment
E 0
3
J
2
1
E 1 J
2
J<0
J>0
J
Antiferromagnetic
substances, J<0
Ferromagnetic
substances, J>0
Chapter VI
VI.
Heisenberg-Dirac-Van
g
Vleck model
of the exchange interaction.
Conceptt off spin-Hamiltonian.
C
i H ilt i
M
Manyelectron p
problem of the exchange.
g Spinp
coupling scheme for the polynuclear
compounds Kambes
compounds,
Kambe s approach.
approach Trimeric
and tetrameric clusters: basic chromium
and iron acetates. EPR spectra of
polynuclear compounds
compounds.
H 2 J S A S B
and
d S are the
th operators
t
B
of the full spins of multi - electron ions and the energies are :
E S J S S 1 S A S A 1 S B S B 1
Homonuclear dimer
Me
Me
Heteronuclear dimer
Me1
Me2
Fe(III)( ) orbital p
picture
(high spin ion)
5
S A S B , S 0, 1, 2 , 3, 4 , 5
2
antiferrom agnetic
5
S A SB ,
2
full spin :
S 0 , 1, 2 , 3, 4 , 5.
Antiferrom agnetic
exchange coupling
HETERO--BINUCLEAR MULTIELECTRONIC
HETERO
SYSTEMS
Cu 2 Ni 2
1
S A , SB 1
2
Cu 2 Fe3
1
5
S A , SB
2
2
Fe3 Ni 2
5
S A , SB 1
2
Generalization II
The exchange
g spin-Hamiltonian
p
is applicable
pp
not only
y for
the dimeric systems but also for the polynuclear clusters.
clusters
The general form contains summation over all pairs of the
ions in a polynuclear system:
H 2 J ij S i S j ,
i, j
12 1 2
13 1 3
23 2 3
J23
J12
1
J13
J
J
H 2 J S 1S 2 S 1 S 3 S 2 S 3
J1
1
J2
3
J2
H 2 J1 S 1 S 2 J 2 S 1 S 3 S 2 S 3
J12
J23
J13
H 2 J12 S 1 S 2 J13 S 1 S 3 J 23 S 2 S 3
H 2 J ij S i S j
i, j
Heisenberg - Dirac
Dirac-- Van Vleck model
model,
HDVV--model
HDVV
Important: this model describes molecules
(finite number of magnetic centers)
and magnetic solids
HIGH--SPIN DIMERS
HIGH
S A
H 2 J S A S B
and S are the operators
B
of the full spins of multi - electron ions and the energies are :
E S J S S 1 S A S A 1 S B S B 1
Ni
S A SB 1
Ni 2 dim er ,
S 0 , 1, 2
S A SB 3 2
Cr
Cr 3 dim er ,
S 0 , 1, 2 , 3
Intervals between the exchange levels for the dimeric clusters :
E S E S 1 J S S 1 S 1S 2 JS
E S E S 1 2 JS
Lande' s rule
6J
S 2
S 2
4J
S 1
4J
S 1
2J
S 0
2J
S 0
2
Ni Ni
S A SB 1
Cr 3 Cr 3
S A SB 3 2
+1
S=1
2|J|
0
-1
EPR-transitions,
EPR
t
iti
low frequency
case
S=0
S
0
Exchange Exchange Exchange+
zero field zero
zero-field+
field
+zero-field
Zeeman
S Cr
S Fe3
2
5
-metal
-O, C
POLYOXOANION [NiNa(H2O)2(AsW9O34]11WO6
NiO6
Na
AsO4
Trimeric
3Ni2+magnetic
f
fragment
m t
S Ni 2 1
S1 S 2 S3 1
Polyhedral representation
SPIN-COUPLING SCHEME
SPINFOR A TRIMERIC SYSTEM
Three spins : S1 , S 2 and S3
Successive spin coupling according to the general rule :
Stage 1. Coupling of two spins S1 and S 2
to get spin S12 int ermediate spin :
S12 S1 S 2 , S1 S 2 1, , S1 S 2
Stage 2. Coupling of two spins S12 and S3
to get spin S123 S full spin :
S S12 S3 , S12 S3 1, , S12 S3
S12 S M
2 2
Eigen functions of S12
, S and S z
S12 S M
2
eigen - vectors of three operators S 2 , S12
and S z :
S 2 S12 S M S S 1 S12 S M ,
2
S12 S M S12 S12 1 S12 S M ,
S12
S z S12 S M M S12 S M
These equations mean that full spin ,
intermedia te spin and
full spin
p p
projection
j
have definite values
in S12 S M state of a three spin system
NOTE : S12 S M is
i not an eigen
i
- vector
t off S12 z operator
t
1
3
J
HDVV Hamiltonia
a to an for
o a sy
symmetric
et c ttrimeric
e c ccluster
uste :
H 2 J S S S S S S
1 2
1 3
2 3
2
S 2 S 1 S 2 S 3 S12 S22 S32 2 S 1S 2 S 1S 3 S 2 S 3
2 S S S S S S S 2 S 2 S 2 S 2
1 2
1 3
2 3
S12 SM
C l l ti n off the
Calculatio
th energy levels
l
l :
S12 SM H S12 SM S12 SM J S 2 S12 S 22 S32
J S S 1 S1 S1 1 S 2 S 2 1 S 3 S 3 1
12
SM
1
1
3
S12 0 S ; S12 1 S
and S
2
2
2
Full set of quantum numbers
defining
d
fi i full
f ll spin
i off a trimer
ti
:
S12 S int ermediate spin full spin
3
S
2
3||J||
Zero-field splitting
1
S
2
(a) The molecular structure of Cu3(O2C16H23)6.
The arrows indicate the equilateral triangle formed by three Cu2+ ions separated
by 3.131 and bridged by two carboxylate groups.
(b) Energy level diagram and the expected EPR transitions
in the HDVV scheme for a symmetric tri-cooper cluster.
Excited state
Ground state
3
1 3 5
Stage 2. S12 0 S ; S12 1 S , , ;
2
2 2 2
1 3 5 7
3 5 7 9
S12 2 S , , , ; S12 3 S , , , .
2 2 2 2
2 2 2 2
F ll sett S12 S int
Full
i ermediate
di spin
i full
f ll spin
i :
For a tri - chromium(I II) cluster :
S12 S
1
1
3
3 3
3
5
5
5
7
7
9
1 , 2 ; 0 ,1 2 , 3 ; 1 ,2 , 3 ; 2 ,3 ; 3 .
2
2
2 22
2
2 2
2 2
2
2
1
2
3
2
5
2
7
2
1
3
, four states with S ,etc
2
2
9
2
J S S 1
4
L d rule:
Landes
l
E S E S 1
2 JS
_____________
Degeneracy with
respect to the
intermediate
spin value
9
2
3 9
9J
S
2 7 ,3 7
7
2
7J
S
5
2
3
2
1
S
2
1 5 ,2 5 , 3 5
5J
3J
0 3 ,1 3 ,2 3 , 3 3
2
1 1 , 2 1
2
SPIN LEVELS
FOR
FO A HE
HETERONUCLEAR
E ON LE
TRIMER
ME Me2 Me
Me
2
J1
J2
3
J2
1 3
2 3
:
Equivalent
E
i l t form
f
H 2 J 2 S 1 S 2 S 1 S 3 S 2 S 3 2 J1 J 2 S 1 S 2
S 2 S S S 2 S 2 S 2 S 2 2 S S S S S S
1
2
3
1
2
3
1 2
1 3
2 3
2 S S S S S S S 2 S 2 S 2 S 2
1 2
1 3
2 3
S 2 S S 2 S 2 S 2 2 S S
12
1
2
1
2
1 2
2 S S S 2 S 2 S 2
1 2
12
H 2 J 2 S 1 S 2 S 1 S 3 S 2 S 3 2 J1 J 2 S 1 S 2
2
J 2 S 2 S 12 S 22 S 32 J1 J 2 S 12
S 12 S 22
:
Eigen values
Ei
l
E S12 , S J 2 S S 1 S1 S1 1 S 2 S 2 1 S3 S3 1
J J S S 1 S S 1 S S 1
1
12
12
J1
distorted
J1
J
J2
S12 1
S12 1 , S12 1
2
1
S12
2
REVIEW OF THE
ANISOTROPIC
EXCHANGE
INTERACTIONS
AND EPR
BIOLOGICAL
BIOLOGI
L SYS
SYSTEMS
SYSTEMSEMS-TWO
WO EX
EXAMPLES
M LES
S-cys
S
Fe
MnCu oxpn 3
Idealized structure:
A C
NiO6
AsO4
Polyhedral representation
Two coupled
T
l d
trinuclear
3Ni2+magnetic
fragments
Cr8-MOLECULE,
MOLECULE GROUND STATE
STATE--S=0
http://cmpweb.ameslab.gov/magnetic_molecules/cr812.html
Chapter
Ch
t VII
VII.
Single molecule magnets.
magnets
Physical principles- quantum tunneling,
relaxation Mn12
relaxation.
Mn12-ac
ac molecule
molecule.
Applications in molecular electronics.
SINGLE MPLECULAR MAGNETS (SMM) EXCELLENT REVIEW OF THE FOUNDERS OF THE FIELD
Fundamental physical
concepts needed to
understand the
phenomena of single
molecular
l
l magnetism
ti
and
d
quantum size effects
Present day state off the
field: what has been done
and critical discussion
discussion,
correlation between
structure and p
properties
p
of
the molecules
Perspectives
Perspectives
Hereunder in the description of SMM problem I follow mainly this paper
SHORT
PRESENTATION
OF THE
UNDERLYING
CONCEPTS
RELAXATION--CLASSICAL
RELAXATION
H
Isolated spins,
p
molecular systems
y
short time ( 10-6 sec),
)
solid state magnets
magnets-- long time ( practically- infinite).
object)- forgets
forgets the direction of the
Isolated spin (quantum object)applied field during the time about 10-6 sec
Solid state magnet (classical object) - memorizes
memorizes applied
field forever
forever
4 S Mn 4
ferromagne tic
Antiferromagnetic
coupling between
M 3+ and
Mn
dM
Mn4+
Mn4+
Mn 3+
8 S Mn 3
f
ferromagne
ti
tic
MANGANESE--12 CLUSTER
MANGANESE
eight Mn33+ ions (Si =2)
and four Mn4+ ions (Si =3/2)
DISCOVERY
OF SINGLE MOLECULAR MAGNETISM
Basic papers:
A.Ganeschi,
AG
hi D
D.Gatteschi,
G tt
hi R
R.Sessoli,
S
li
A.L.Barra, L.S.Brunel, M.Guillot,
J.Am.Chem.Soc, 113 (1991) 5873.
R.Sessoli,
R Sessoli D
D.Gatteschi,
Gatteschi M
M.A.Novak,
A Novak
Nature, 365 (1993) 141.
Mn12--ac MOLECULE
Mn12
MOLECULE--SLOW RELAXATION
Large molecule object possessing intermediate properties,
between quantum and classical ones.
ones Mn12-ac
Mn12 ac molecule
shows slow relaxation of the magnetization at low temperature.
If the Mn12-ac molecule is magnetized
g
byy an applied
pp
field,,
the molecule retains magnetization for a long time,
approximately 108 seconds = 3 years at 1.5K . Under this
condition a single molecule becomes like a tiny magnet, in
the sense that if magnetized by an applied field it remember
magnetization for days or months.
months Under this respect
therefore Mn12-ac molecule behaves like a classical magnet.
Applications-molecular electronics:
memory storage elements in one molecule
potential energ
gy
QUANTUM TUNNELING
IN A DOUBLE WELL SYSTEM
a) non
non--interacting states
states, double
degenerate quantum level, each
corresponding
di tto a localized
l
li d state
t t
in the left and in the right wells
b) interacting states,
states giving rise to
tunnel splitting
p
g T:
T=h, - is the frequency of
tunneling through the barrier.
Double-well potential:
Doublequantum and classical pictures
Example
E
l off quantum
t
tunnelingg
ammonia molecule,
two positions of N, inversion of
the molecule.
The ground state is splitinversion splitting
splitting,
IR spectroscopic manifestation.
H
H
Tunneling from a
metastable state.
In the case of strong coupling with the environment , that is
much larger than the tunnel splitting, the particle will stay
localized in one of two wells, and will not be able to tunnel.
F the
For
th intermediate
i t
di t coupling
li
th
the particle
ti l can ttunnell b
butt th
the
coherence of the motion between wells will be lost.
JAHN-TELLER DISTORTIONS IN
JAHNM
Mn12
Mn1212-ACETATE
CET TE MOLECULE
2 1
2 110
D S z S S 1 H ZFS D S z
3
3
E M S D M S2
S MS S
,
3
ENERGY LEVELS
2 110
E M S D M S
,
3
S MS S
Set of 2 S 1 21 levels,,
10 double degenerate levels
M S 6
M S 7
M S 8
M S 9
M S 10
non degenerate .
D negative for Mn12 - ac,
ground state with M S 10
H ZFS D S z S S 1 g B S zHz
3
M S 8
110
E M S D M S2
g B M S H z
3
M S 10
M S 9
negative D ,
maximum spin projection
in the g
ground state :
M S 10
D 0,
S MS S
M S 10
t
M z t M z t 0 exp
where is the relaxation time-characteristics of the rate.
Mechanism of the relaxation- interaction of spin with the
environment
i
t ( phonons
h
lattice
l tti vibrations).
ib ti
)
Fe4-molecule
Fe8-molecule
Energy of mag
gnetic a
anisotrropy
DS2
M=-S
M=0
M=S
(spin projection
projection-magnetic
magnetic moment)
Barrier U(M)
( )
for the reversal of
magnetization
g
in a
high-spin magnetic
molecule,
height of the barrier
2.
U(M=0)=DS
(
)
In the absence of
the magnetic
g
fieldfieldtwo minima:
U(M=-S)=
(
) U(M=S)
(
)
The
e iron
o atoms
ato s (ye
yellow
o )
carry the magnetic moments
that in the ground state are
arranged
g to give
g
S=10. The
shadows around the cluster
represent the actual dimensions
of the atoms and give an idea of
how the central magnetic core is
surrounded by an organic
shell.
Single
g Molecule Magnets
g
(SMMs):
Bistable Magnetic Units
SMMs
are magnetically
ll
bistable systems that
require an applied field to
invert their magnetization
direction below a
bl ki temperature.
blocking
t
t
Bistability
Frozen superparamagnetic
p p
g
states
Mn21--clusterMn21
cluster-Single Molecule Magnet
behavior,
behavior
Inorg Chem, Ceorge Chritou, 2004,v.43,pp 4137-44
George Christou,
Christou Inorg Chem
Chem, 2004
2004,v.43,
v 43 p
p. 4203
Cr4-molecule
Cr8-molecule
HIGH--SPIN Fe MOLECULES
HIGH
Fe8-molecule
Fe10-molecule
V15-molecule
Fe8-wheel
Anisotropy
Michel Verdaguer, University Pierre&Marie Curie, Paris
Search for single molecular magnets
magnets--cyanometalates family
CoCu2
CoCo2
CoNi2
CrNi
C
N2
High spin
CrNi
7/2
5/2
CoCu3
C
Cyanometalates
t l t
CrMn6 27/2
CoCo3
CoMn6
CoNi3
CrCu6 9/2
CrNi6 15/2
CoCo6
CoNi5
CoCu6
CN
CN-group
Mn(III),
( ), d4, S=1
Molecular structure
Mn5-cyanometalate
y
fragment
g
http://66.102.9.104/search?q=cache:1cV6p8iEycYJ:www.europhysicsnews.
com/full/24/article4/article4.html+Molecular+Magnetism&hl=en&ie=UTF-8
/f ll/24/ ti l 4/ ti l 4 ht l M l
l M
ti &hl
&i UTF 8
Dante Gatteschi
N
New
T
Trend
nd of
fN
Nanochemistry
n h mist
A. Mller,
A
Mll E
E. B
Beckmann,
k
H
H. B
Bgge, M
M.
Schmidtmann, A. Dress
Inorganic Chemistry Goes Protein
Size:
S
e A Mo368
o368 Nano-Hedgehog
a o edge og
Initiating Nanochemistry by Symmetry
Breaking
Breaking
Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. 41, 1162-1167
(2002)
Angew. Chem. 114, 1210-1215 (2002)
Wheel-Shaped [Mn12]
Single-Molecule Magnets
Evan M.
M Rumberger,
Rumberger Sonali J
J.
Shah, Christopher C. Beedle,
Lev N. Zakharov,
Arnold L. Rheingold,
g
and David
N. Hendrickson*
Mn84
Mn
84 - cluster
G.Christou
http://66.102.9.104/search?q=cache:1cV6p8iEycYJ:www.europhysicsnews.com/full
/24/article4/article4.html+Molecular+Magnetism&hl=en&ie=UTF-8
Fe2+-C-N-Co3+ - Fe3+-C-N-Co2+
A schematic drawing of the light induced transformation is shown in the
previous slide. The material orders as a bulk ferrimagnet below 50 K. If the
irradiation is performed below this temperature we observe a transition to
bulk magnetic
g
order induced by
y light.
g Therefore these materials can be
considered as magnetic switches operated by light. t is also possible to
perform the opposite transition by irradiating the Fe3+-Co2+ pairs with blue
light: the electron is back transferred from cobalt to iron and the system
reverts to the diamagnetic state.
Chapter
Ch
t VIII
VIII.
Mixed-valence
Mixed
valence compounds.
The phenomenon of mixed valency.
Spin dependent delocalization
Spin-dependent
delocalization-double
double
exchange- classical and quantummechanical description (Andersons
theory). Robin and Day classification of
mixed-valence
i d l
compounds.
d IIntervalence
t
l
light absorption (light induced electron
t
transfer).
f ) Magnetic
M
ti properties.
ti
d An d Bn 1 and
d An 1 d Bn
Simplest case:
electron delocalized over spinless
p
metal sites, d0 d 1 cluster.
Assume that a and b are the orbitals of the electron at the
corresponding sites, the energies are equal. The trapped
states are unstable, the kinetic energy and Coulomb
attraction to the alien site promote the electron transfer
process with the rate t which can be associated with the
transfer integral.
SPLITTING
S h
Scheme
off the
th molecular
l
l orbitals
bit l stationary
t ti
delocalized states:
2|t|
g
Providing t 0 :
1
g a b bonding
g orbital
2
1
u a b antibondin g orbital
2
g and u symbols of parity
t
(
(napy)=
)
Molecular structure of a
binuclear Fe(II)-Fe(III)
mixed-valence dimer
Molecular structure of a
binuclear Mn(III)-Mn(IV)
mixed-valence dimer
Octahedral ML6
complex:
coordinate
system and
enumeration of
the ligands
3
4
1
6
R>R0
Q
y
R0- equiliblium M-L
distance
Xi, Yi, Zi displacements
di l
t
R=R0
R<R0
1
X 1 X 4 Y2 Y5 Z 3 Z 6
6
N
N
N
N
N
N
N
Q>0
q>0
N
N
N
N
N
N
N
N
N
N
Q=0
N q=0
Out-ofOutof-phase mode of
a dimeric moiety:
N
N
N
N
A
N
N
N
N
N
N
N
Full-symmetric
breathing local
vibrations of
independent
fragments AN6
and
d BN6 off a
dimeric unit
Q<0
N q<0
1
2
QA QB
Q
Class A
strongly localized
Q
Class B
partially delocalized
Q
Class C
fully delocalized
a
adiabatic
c potenttial
-2
-2
-2
-4
4
-4
4
-4
4
-4
0
q
uncoupled sites,
full localization
-4
0
q
Intermediate vibronic
coupling, moderate
electron
l t
ttransfer,
f
partial delocalization
-4
0
q
SB
S0
S0
Spin core
B
ELECTRON TRANSFER
BETWEEN LOCALIZED SPINS
Let us consider now the general case of a
mixed valence dimer dn-dn+1.
The first problem in question is how the magnetic moment of
th metal
the
t l iions affect
ff t the
th electron
l t
transfer.
t
f It happens
h
that,
th t in
i
this case, electron transfer is spin-dependent. The main
features of the phenomenon can be understood in the
framework of the classical spin model developed by
Anderson and Hasegawa: Phys.
Phys Rev
Rev.10 (1955) p.675
Rev.10
p 675.
As distinguished from a quantum spin, which can be
oriented in the space
p
in 2S+1 directions,, a classical spin
p
represents the infinite spin limit for which
all the directions in the space are allowed
(illustration-next Slide).
m=+1
m=5/2
m=3/2
m=1/2
m=0
m=-1/2
m=-3/2
m=-1/2
1/2
S = 1/2
m=-1
1
S=1
m=-5/2
5/2
S = 5/2
S =
Quantum spin-distinct
spin
effect of spatial quantization,
classical spin (high spin) all directions in the space are
allowed
ll
d - smallll angles
l b
between
t
th
the vectors
t
S.
HUNDS
HUND
S RULE
Let us consider a high-spin state (Hunds configuration)
for the dn+1 ions.
ions From the classical point of view,
view that
means that the extra electron lines up its spin, parallel
to the spin core
core, taking thus the gain in energy from
the intraatomic exchange.
s
S0
extra electron
spin core
S0
A
=0
Smax?S 0
int er m ed iat e
=
Smin
i ?
S
/2
S
t S t
2S0
SB
The main physical result:
Rate of the electron transfer proves to be spindependent and increases with the increase of the full
spin of the systems
High-spin states are stabilized more strongf
ferromagnetic
ti effect
ff t
A*B
AB*
double exchange
g splitting
p
g ((Anderson(Anderson-Hasegawa):
g
)
S 1/ 2
E S t
2 So 1
S=3/2
SA=1, SB=1/2
(S=1/2, 3/2)
A*B
localized
u
S=1/2 g
t 2t
S=1/2 u
S=3/2
S
/ g
delocalized
SA=1/2, SB=1
(S=1/2, 3/2)
AB*
localized
Ferromagnetic
g
g
ground state,, rule of p
parity
y alternation.
d1-d
d2
d2-d
d3
d3-d
d4
d4-d
d5
2/3t
1/2t
2/5t
S=9/2
+t
2t
-t
S=1/2
S=3/2
S=5/2
S=7/2
S0=0
S0=1/2
S0=1
S0=3/2
S0=2
S0=
Energy in
n the units of tran
nsfer para
ameter
The main
observations:
g
u
g
u
g
u
g
u
g
-1
0
spin multiplicity
10
2S+1
1) Ferromagnetic
effect of the double
exchange
2)) Rule
ueo
of a
alternation
te at o
for the even and
odd spin-levels
(S=3/2,1/2)
S
3/2
1/2
t
2t
1/2 3/2
1/2
3/2
1/2
3/2
t=1
t=1
=0
v=0
t=1
t=1
=2
v=2
t=1
t=1
=4
v=4
1/2
3/2
-3
-2
-1
Ferromagneticfully delocalized
-4
-2
4 -6
Weakly
ferromagneticpartially localized
-4
-2
q
4
Paramagneticfully localized
Mixed-valence
polyoxometalates,
18 Sites
Sites, 1
1- 8 moving
electrons
t'
Network
et o o
of tthe
e
exchange and
electron transfer
parameters
Model
system
y
Antiferromagnetic
effect of delocalizationS=0- ground state