Documentos de Académico
Documentos de Profesional
Documentos de Cultura
A Sustainable Solution
BACKGROUND
East Africa has a history of relatively poor roads infrastructure :
Poor road conditions
Road congestion
Transport economic challenges
Superficially, East Africa appears to be doing well. Annual economic
growth rates are averaging around 6%, and trade and foreign
investment are rising. This economic growth isnt matched
infrastructure development.
This is evident in the deterioration of both urban and rural roads
Better road networks will lead to
Increased economic activity
Linking economic trade between countries
Better efficiencies
Governments across the region are investing in expanded
roads infrastructure program to address the current backlog
and shortage
Current road building method have significant challenges:
High cost of bitumen
Roads constructed have short lifespan
High cost of maintenance
BACKGROUND CONTD
Governments
paved roads
Concrete roads will offer:
Availability of materials (All materials will be
proudly East African)
Low cost of maintenance (Virtually no costs in
the first 25 years)
Road drivability
Environmentally sustainable
Usage of concrete roads will help curb unemployment
through job creation at construction phase
Opportunity is Knocking
$
The Shift
CONCRETE
ASPHALT
OVERVIEW
South Africa
Kenya
Zambia
8
Use of paved roads worldwide {in millions of square meters per annum}
9
Economic activity
More Paved Roadways = STRONGER ECONOMY
10
South Africa
Kenya
11
13
14
Concrete Pavement
Asphalt Pavement
Quiet ride
In a five year study the concrete pavements roadside noise level was on average 2-4
decibels higher than the asphalt pavement. To put this into perspective, normal
conversation registers at 60 to 70 decibels and a human whisper registers at 20 decibels
15
Economic Aspects
Source: (Leif Wathne, P.E., ACPA.) Introduction to Concrete Pavements (Part II)
16
Economic Aspects
LCCA compares the total discounted cost of each design over a specific
analysis period to minimize the financial burden of the roadway on
taxpayers.
17
City of Milwaukee
LCCA Example
Concrete vs Asphalt bids
18
Hot Mix Asphalt (HMA) bid prices from recent City of Milwaukee
projects
19
Roadway Scenario:
Length = 2000 LF
Roadway SY = 7111 SY
4.5-Inch HMA = 1840 Ton
Pavement Width = 32 LF
Excavation Width = 41 LF
Concrete Alternative #1
Concrete Alternative #2
7-Inch Concrete over Existing
7-Inch Concrete over 3-Inch CABC
$127,856
$155,656
$938
$938
$2,015
$2,015
$0
$0
***
***
***
***
***
***
$0
$0
$130,808
$158,608
$65
$79
100%
121%
HMA Alternative #1
4.5-Inch HMA over 6-Inch CABC
$139,923
$3,917
$73,797
$0
***
***
***
$0
$217,637
$109
166%
HMA Alternative #2
5.5-Inch HMA over 8-Inch CABC
$181,938
$3,917
$73,797
$0
***
***
***
$0
$259,652
$130
198%
20
21
Environmental Aspects
Source: http://www.pavements4life.com/QDs/Environment_1HeatIsland.asp
23
25
Overlays
Inlays
26
Cons
Quick construction Possibility of
Sustainable
construction
Reduced lighting
costs.
Lower whole-life
cost
cracking
Asphalt
Pros
Lower initial
construction cost
Cons
Need to seal every
3-5 years
Development of
potholes.
Rutting
Higher whole-life
cost
Easy maintenance
Deteriorates quickly
Environmentally
unfriendly
Re-usable &
recyclable
Shortage of
materials
Involves
importation of binder
material
27
28
29