Documentos de Académico
Documentos de Profesional
Documentos de Cultura
- versus -
COMMISSIONER OF INTERNAL
REVENUE,
Respondent_
Promulgated:
OCT 06 19!li
X- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - X
DECISION
f:r r<:>funJ ,:f th<? 2()% final ':Nithhc,lding tax on interest earned
ftrt-,.-1
L
.1
~
:jTYl.
.:>- ~ 1ln,....
0~
~ni
;:'.
...
.-jo.r'f)Ct't
- -.. 1.....
titllO.
~.
-..1
..
rar-r'r'U!"lt'"'
....,. ._. .
..~:11
t"tl
tho.....
SPffi
:.J..
of
P:!, 1~l, 171.f:.i) f,:r tl1<? p<?ric..:l ccvt;>ring thE> years 1991 tc 1992.
t
T.),:::.
tt' ;;!" .:;:.
J. .. Ml .... J. .. J.,,
;::o~,,,.-l~y -:7![1
O,:..~,::::.::"Jt"<"ll
.1. .. 1- !~ .. ~---~
,.... ~-----~~
1tho.;:}t
A .~1 Cat"l
... s_ . ;J..; .&.J.::)
~ rV
._.. '--
11. 11 J.~;::rAcrr1.''1ll._llf"A
.. ._. 1_._.__ -
1.!l'=Jl.
tJJ t1 {,t"l
r- ' -- .. - <:;- ;ln
' ...c::j- t1
- ,,t"'
- !;-ll!
..
- - -
j',t"."f j ;_
J.
R"""b
f'-01" ,,nal
r.......c.ntc.r
- .:;
-..
(<::'E.~<P,i~"
\
~.-"
.&.""1 .. _.J.""l.l,
1-S
.
tlf"!l-,....tr-,r-k
'..r
.;, ____ ,_,
1 fiAfi--
0~
.t, f'JC>rtt'
-. - ft' C.(l
-- ;l'=:
-
(.J11!] j"
1303
tc.
fr-.r
~Tr-~
f 11 1a
._..
J
- ...J.L.t .......
c;pJ. (1"1
-
t')T.Y
-
t.ll~
- -
- Page2-
Februar~
Banl~.
Branch~
and Citibank -_l. .'latati. For the years 1990 to 1992, these banks
>;Nithheld from petitioner the corresponding 20% final tax on
interest earned from these deposit.s in the sum of P2,761 . 627.75.
Fetitioner submits that it is exempt from the 20% final
Vlithholding ta.x on interest on savings and time deposits as
.provided for under the follov..ring:
a.
b.
c.
1304
- Page3 -
d.
12 5-oo.. 169-oo. 11.3-33, 176-&o, 11(~-3&, 262 -a&, 32 4-&&, 431o<'). 471-33. 4(12 -30, 495-oo . 496-o&, 515-63 and
5.39-3(~.
tll~
collected and paid. The presumption being tl1at the taxes were
properly collected in accordance witl1law.
After tl1e issues llaT1e been joined, tl1is case was set for
llt?aring on September
o.
1993.
Revi~ed
Rules of
Court. Petitioner added that the Court can take judicial notice of
1305
- Pa.ge4 -
~Nit:
1306
- Paff5-
e~-tistence
of the
''E")
O"Wll
revive the original petition praying for the refund of the original
amount of PZ,761,627.7).
petitioner
'WaS
Instead_.
Resolution, dated May 3, 1994, tl1e Court ruled t11at tl1e claim
for refund for the 1990 final withholding tax is already barred.
1307
Onl~T
(()urt.
~viddKe t()
1308
DEL~10N-
Pa~7-
The
The specification of
t;).
1309
-PageS-
Franl~lin
M.
t..) register Vvitll tl1e SEC in order to obtain loans from private and
government
banks..
tl1at
petitioner
is
an
international
organization. to v.Jit: (Exhs. C, C-1 and C-2, DOJ Opinion No. 71; S.
1994)
1310
Industrial
Relations~
Appeals~
Philippines~
1311
192
Inc. v _ Court of
DHCISION-
()f
1312
UFL~10N-
- PafF11 -
e~{clusively
be exempt from taxes and duties" and in line with the various
rulings of respondent T+litll respect to non-stock, non-profit
educational institution in relation with said constitutional
pr\)Vision, t11e case of petitioner falls squarely within this
mandate. It is a well established rule in statutory consu-uction
that t11e language of t11e Constitution, as much as possible should
be understood in t11e sense it has in common use and tllat the
words used in constitutional provisions are to be given their
ordinary meaning except v.,here technical terms are employed,
must t11en. be applied in this case. (Ordillo v_ Commission on
Elections, 192 SCRA lOOJ The Court is left with no other
taxes and
duties
non-stock,
1:113
~-
Pa~t2-
Ta1~
30540
352757
14932
36708
o:;,8172
09::974
Withheld
by t11e Banks
Central Bank
Confirmation
Receipt No.
(Exh. N-4)
P20,366.67
17,025.11
.35.812.50
20,168.51
3? ?5? 3c:)
~,..)
._}.
B20211&91
B20211891
B20213142
B20213142
35,410.82
.3.3,.3.1 &.6)
1314
X-1
X-1
Y-1
y -1
051113
54083
560(38
55484
1,.H)?:
'j
; ~ .) .j
06550 1
7020001245
6")4
<.
~> ~
350947
.354056
3491.3
05.3205
6344
36961
059&97
095975
Ptt~13-
"6..,...,.1
.. 1
,t. i
..
17)80.72
}?
'10
.j, po
.... () . .:.
34,442.72
59,026.83
34/:t73.11
.30.455.0.3
26,866.67
)4 } 40')w ..\.JoC
.....
"()/1:)?4?
i. ,"t_,.J . .)
24)30.89
34,179.29
12,638.89
20,8.30.76
19,741.60
1q 767.74
B20210o.3&
B21211891
B20211o91
B2o211a9 1
820213142
X-1
X-1
X-1
Y-1
B20210838
B20211391
B2021.3142
B20214362
X-1
Y-1
Z-1
B20210838
B20214362
Z-1
B2179.3413
B22966&28
B22973374
B2179.3413
B22966o28
B22973374
B22983285
EE-2
FF-2
GG-2
EE-2
FF-2
GG-2
HH-2
B22966828
B22966828
B2297.3374
B22966&2&
B22966828
B22973374
822389235
FF-2
FF-2
GG-2
FF-2
FF-2
GG-2
HH-2
B21793413
EE-2
P640.225.11
LOS BANOS
RURAL BABK
27704
2.3598
23357
24110
2365.3
24048
24252
24490
274600
27872
2.3714
2 ~\9fl6
)
24177
(Exh. 0-2)
p 31970.59
51,250.00
61.429.17
34,626.99
150580.08
69,476.20
55555.01
h?
~- .. , 3?
"'5 ..32
66,012.32
!:)!:)
-
..n~~9'
lf._)2
24489
30.102.51
20,232.19
17,713.41
43)29.17
19,923.97
15,9.31.74
17,873.29
27Y~9
18,9~~0.77
27t\71
2 -\6fl..H)C
277.39
\")'~)3?
_.iJ,_
--. _)
")?6).-,
w ...}
-"
24047
242)"~
396.39
'14
066
i.
v .4"
i
1
1315
- Page14-
.30517
2414~
24245
24405
27584
27862
.30560
j~'01:;,6'"~
___ t.
6,610.11
40,000.00
10.125.00
20336.41
21,538 46
18,060.00
3,656.25
\900.00
B2297.3374
B22973.374
B22389285
GG-2
GG-2
HH-2
B22982998
B22982998
NN-2
NN-2
B22982998
NN-2
B21802174
B22973066
LL-2
MM-2
B22982998
B22982998
NN-2
NN-2
B22982998
B22982998
NN-2
NN-2
p 1.019.6 )3.17
PNB-
LOS BANOS
996091
(~q7?.,77
.r
~
'1..'
997992
998742
~\3
\)9?'1
..)t.. ~
/. "f. . 6 - 5--:.c. 10,...,5
...
"i
c. - t.
997714
99o36.3
999lt5
t)"
~'"'71
-Y~t.
995777
996008
996.359
996781
998550
999407
997004
q97525
99810&
QQfl992
- - )
09.3065
446-521025
997715
998402
9991(.6
~CP2T:r
\,
.- -'
t..
(Exll. K-4)
p 19,740.74
25,90 I.4e)
"5
(. . .. 1"fc:~). 2(~
-
37..271.61
1{),431.70
12.340.45
12,577.67
12,91.3.07
11.301.95
4,660.(!.4
93.. 14&.36
8,050.00
6,67.3.57
"')1/?')9?
c. "i..)<.o.- .)
J
7,729.28
5,92.3.46
26,346.67
.31,.3::11..159
29. 113..37
28,790.01
.....,3
(. ' OS''"')"
- "i.t..j
p..), "fJjJ
-~ . . ?3
1.3,691.56
14,056.66
1')... ,..)J.,)
} oj tJ 6
I)
07 ~.61
pr::,2 0. 41)').2 \~
1316
DHtlSION-
- Pa1f15-
p
p
TOTAL
1,131.61
(J7Q.6')
PP-2
B24603786
MC#002969
QQ-2
2J 11.26
P2.132.729.8)
~ tJ.J.r,t
AMON 0. DE VE
Associate Judge
WE CONCUR:
/
~y.J-:;:-tQ ~
ERNHSTO D. ACOSTA
MANUEL
_ GRUBA
Associatfl Judge
1317
.....
- Page16 -
CERTIFICATION
fl,~Q. a'-'-(~
ERNESTO D. ACOSTA
Court of Tax Appeals
Presiding Judge
1318