Documentos de Académico
Documentos de Profesional
Documentos de Cultura
4, November 1996
2024
Gilles Trudel
Member
Hydro-Quebec
Montreal, Quebec
Guy Scott
Member
Hydro-Quebec
Montreal, Quebec
ABSTRACT
In recent years, Hydro-Quebec has undertaken a major
program to upgrade the reliability of its transmission system.
Much efforts have been directed toward increasing the
system's capacity to withstand extreme contingencies,
usually caused by multiple incidents or the successive tripping of transmission lines.
In order to counter such events, Hydro-Quebec has adopted
a defensive scheme. Based entirely on automatic action, this
scheme will mainly rely on:
- a 735 kV shunt reactor switching system (called MAIS);
- a generation rejection and/or remote load-shedding
system (called RPTC);
- an underfrequency load-shedding system.
The MAIS system, which is the subject of this paper, will be
implemented in 22 substations and is required to control
voltage on the system after a severe event. Each MAIS
system, acting locally, is entirely independent and will close
or trip shunt reactors in response to local conditions.
Keywords: extreme contingencies, shunt reactor tripping,
shunt reactor closing, stability, modes of oscillations, voltage
measurement.
2025
[
I
**
**
*
*
*
*
GA
I RLS
* * .*
* * *
*
*
*
I
ij
TABLE 1
POSSIBLE OPERATION OF AUTOMATIC ACTIONS FOR
EXTREME CONTINGENCIES
f :Possible operation for worst conditions
MAIS: shunt reactor switching (closing or tripping)
UFLS: underfrequency load shedding
RPTC : generation rejection (GR) and/or remote load
shedding (RLS) system.
2026
SUBSTATIONS
Albanel
Abitibi
Chibouuameau
La Verendrye
$$%
!\:
Chamouchouane
Duvernay
Levis
Manicouagan
Boucherville
Carianan
Laurentides
JaWes-Caher
Sasuenav
Monta nais
Arnaui
Micoua
75 % I 20 sec
75 % I 2 5 sec
75 Yo I 20 sec
75 % I 2 5 Sec
75 YOI 20 sec
7 5 YoI 25 sec
75 % I 20 sec
7 5 % 125 sec
nominal rating
Note 3 : based on substations initial voltage
parameters are used to provide this coordination: the overvoltage (or undervoltage) amplitude and its duration.Table 2
shows the selected substations and the preliminary settings for
each substation.
The basic operating principle for MAlS is to switch only one
reactor at a time when a set of conditions are met. If this action
is not sufficient, MAlS will then switch another reactor, after a
new verification of the conditions, until the total preset number
of switchable reactors in the substation has been reached,
In order to make safe and extensive use of the automatic
switching of shunt reactors in a system like Hydro-Quebecs, it
is necessary for reactor operations to be selective and limited to
what is required for each extreme contingency. It is, therefore,
essential that the MAlS action be regionalized according to the
various extreme contingencies possible in the system. To
obtain the required level of selectivity, a precise voltage reading
is necessary in each substation where MAIS is installed.
2027
.,
..
12
13
.,
.,
16
TIME (seconds)
..............................
....
8
MAIS has been designed to order the closing or tripping of shunt
reactors according to a number of variables, the most important of
which is voltage amplitude. MAlS is intended to be adaptable and
can order:
-Closing of shunt reactors in overvoltage condition:
-Tripping of shunt reactors in undervoltagecondition;
-Tripping of shunt reactors in response to voltage variation from
a mean value;
-Closing or tripping of shunt reactors in frequency variation
conditions;
-Tripping of shunt reactors in function of the reactive power
produced by local dynamic compensators;
-Local and remote reactor tripping from external signal when
there are loss of line;
-Remote reactor tripping from external signal when there is loss
of Radisson Nicolet DC link;
-Closing or tripping of shunt reactors as a function of a combination of any or all of these previously processed signals.
MAlS evaluates the availability and the state of all reactors in its
substation and includes several supervision function among which
a anti-hunting function. All operation orders are subjected to
adjustable time delays. The MAlS functional diagram appears in
Figure 4.
...........
........... .................
40
60
ID
100
120
140
160
200
180
TIME (seconds)
Voltage amplitude
Frequency
Timer
External signal
Execution of shunt
reactor switching
Status, availability
and restriction
Hunting supervision
Orders to 4
reactor's breaker
2028
in reference [6]. It was necessary, among other things, to
overdimension the magnetic core and reduce the load burden
on this equipment, in order to obtain a higher saturation point
and better precision than provided by standard PTs.
*E
I.
06
I.
5,
l2
* L o
-0 2
-c
36
15
05
Time(seconds)
FIGURE 6 Voltage wave form after fault clearing
5.3 Filtering Requirements
HeHz
TYPE
(W
(P.U.)
Subs nchronous
paralh resonances
5 to 20
0.25
Series resonances
about 30
-0.03
lntermodulation
Oversynchronous
parallel resonances
60+/-(5 to 20)
70 to 100
Harmonics
TABLE 3
1
'1
2029
6.
SWITCHING CONTROL
2030
7. SYSTEM IMPLEMENTATION
Each of the MAlS found locally in the 735 kV substations
consists of one precision voltage measurement transformer,
one measurement unit and a man-machine interface. MAlS is
designed to easily allow the modification of the existing functions and the addition of supplementary functions. Each
MAlS includes one programmable unit that provides this
adaptability.
Design and development are achieved and MAlS units installation will be realized in 1996.
8. CONcLUSION
A 735 kV automatic shunt reactor switching system (MAIS) is
required to control voltage on the Hydro-Quebec power
system after an extreme contingency. Implemented in twentytwo 735kV substations, each MAlS system is entirely independent and will be able to close or trip shunt reactors in
response to local conditions. In spite of the problems caused
by the presence of subsynchronous oscillations, MAlS is a
selective and reliable means to control voltage within the
desired operating ranges following extreme contingencies in
order to ensure proper system behavior.
9. ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
MAlS achievement was made possible by the collaboration
of several Hydro-Quebec employees who specialize in
various technical aspects of the study of power systems and
systems design. We would like to thank them and acknowledge their contribution in particularly Danielle Mc Nabb and
Normand Legault, engineers with Hydro-Quebecs Planning
Department, and Jocelyn Lambert, Rene Lord and Yves
HBbert engineers with Hydro-Quebecs Automation and
Protection Department.
REFERENCES
[ l ] J.P. Gingras, D. Laurin, J. Potvin, Une fiabilite accrue
chez Hydro-Quebec, ClGRE Symposium (S38-91), La
f iab i I it e des reseaux e Iec t r i q u e, M o nt rea I(Ca n ad a),
September 1991.
essentiel pour ameliorer l a fiabilite du reseau dHydroQuebec, CIGRE Symposium (S38-91), La fiabilite des
reseaux electrique, Montreal(Canada), September 1991.
[3] L. Gerin-Lajoie, Guy Scott, S. Brault, E.V. Larsen,
D.H.Baker, A.F. Imece, Hydro-Quebec Multiple SVC Application control stabilite study, IEEE, 90 WM 079-4 PWRD.
[4] E.V. Larsen, D.H. Baker, A.F. Imece, L. Gerin-Lajoie,
G. Scott, Basic aspect of applying SVCs to series-compensated AC transmission lines, IEEE, 90 WM 080-2 PWRD.
BIO GRAPHlES
Serge Bernard received a 6.Sc.A in electrical engineering in
1980 from Universite Laval(Quebec City), Quebec. Since
1980, he has worked in system planning for Hydro-Quebec
where he has been involved in several projects concerning
control, potection and special protection systems. Mr.
Bernard is registered professional engineer in the province of
Quebec.
Gilles Trudel received his B.SC.A. (1978) and M.lng (1986)
in Electrical Engineering from Ecole Polytechnique , University of Montreal, Canada. In 1978, he joined Hydro-Quebec
where he has been involved in the design of control and
protection for substations and power stations. Eight years
later, he moved to the System Planning departement where
he is now involved in planning high-voltage network, in
different aspects of power system security and in design of
special protection systems. Mr. Trudel is a member of the
IEEE Power Engineering Society and a registered professionnal engineer in the province of Quebec.
Guy Scott received a 6.Sc.A and M.Eng. in electrical engineering from Ecole Polytechnique (Universite de Montreal) in
1975 and 1980 respectively. Since 1975, he has worked in
system planning for Hydro-Quebec where he has been
involved in several projects concerning control, protection,
special protection systems, static vars compensators, series
compensation and dc interconnection. Mr. Scott is a menber
of IEEE and a registered professional engineer in the province of Quebec.