Markets Chapters 8 and 10 Financial Markets and Institutions R. Sverdlove 1 Common Stock Equity securities represent an ownership interest in a corporation. Common stockholders are the residual owners. ! Right to income ! Right to assets ! Voting rights (to elect board of directors) ! Limited liability Financial Markets and Institutions R. Sverdlove 2 # Common Stock (2) Some firms have more than one class of common shares outstanding, with different voting rights assigned to each class ! One class of shares may have more votes per share ! One class of shares may elect a separate set of directors larger than that elected by the others. A proxy vote allows stockholders to vote by absentee ballot (e.g., by mail) Straight voting is one vote per share per seat on the board to be elected. Financial Markets and Institutions R. Sverdlove 3 Cumulative Voting With cumulative voting, the number of votes assigned to each stockholder equals the number of shares held multiplied by the number of directors to be elected ! Provides for minority representation on board Number of shares needed to elect p directors is: Financial Markets and Institutions R. Sverdlove 4
p ! number of votes available number of directors to be elected +1 +1 $ Preferred Stock Hybrid security with some features of debt and some of equity Equity features are ! May be perpetual ! Residual claim on corporate assets ! Income taxed as dividends Bond-like features are: ! Usually fixed dividend rate ! Senior to common stock (but junior to bonds) ! Usually no voting rights Financial Markets and Institutions R. Sverdlove 5 Preferred Stock (2) Dividends are usually cumulative: if a payment is missed, it must be made up later before any additional common dividends can be paid Tax exemption for 70% of dividend income makes them attractive investments for corporations May have a sinking fund provision Recent issues often have floating rates Financial Markets and Institutions R. Sverdlove 6 % Stock Returns The returns on a stock over one period (R t ) can be divided into capital gains and dividend returns: ! P t = stock price at time t ! D t = dividends paid over time t 1 to t ! [(P t P t
1 ) / P t ] 1 = time t1 to t capital gain ! D t / P t 1 = time t 1 to t dividend return 1 1 1 ! ! ! + ! = t t t t t t P D P P P R Financial Markets and Institutions R. Sverdlove 7 Primary and Secondary Markets Primary stock markets allow suppliers of funds to raise equity capital ! Initial public offering (IPO) ! One of the principal functions of investment banks Secondary stock markets are the most closely watched and reported of all financial markets Financial Markets and Institutions R. Sverdlove 8 & Secondary Trading Locations Stock Exchanges ! trading floors ! auction system ! central auction specialist (market maker) system Over-The-Counter (OTC) Market ! no trading floor ! negotiated system ! multiple market maker system Electronic Communication Networks (ECN) Financial Markets and Institutions R. Sverdlove 9 U. S. Stock Exchanges Major National Stock Exchanges ! New York Stock Exchange (NYSE or Big Board) ! American Stock Exchange (AMEX, ASE or Curb) Regional Stock Exchanges ! Boston, Chicago, Pacific (San Francisco), Philadelphia OTC Market ! NASDAQ ! NASD Financial Markets and Institutions R. Sverdlove 10 ' U. S. Stock Exchanges (2) Consolidation of exchanges NASD owned AMEX from 1999-2004, when it again became independent NYSE http://www.nyse.com/ ! Merged with Euronext in 2007 ! NYSE Euronext merged with the American Stock Exchange in 2008 ! Acquired by Intercontinental Exchange (ICE) 2013 Financial Markets and Institutions R. Sverdlove 11 Categories of Traded Stocks Defined by Securities Act of 1934 Exchange-traded (listed) stocks ! traded on national and regional exchanges Over-the-counter (non-exchange-traded, unlisted) stocks ! NASDAQ listed OTC stocks " Large " Small ! Non-NASDAQ OTC stocks " Bulletin Board " Pink Sheets Financial Markets and Institutions R. Sverdlove 12 ( Types of Markets First Market ! trading on exchanges of stocks listed on an exchange Second Market ! trading in OTC market of stocks not listed on an exchange Third Market (dark pools) ! trading in OTC market of stocks listed on an exchange (usually used by institutions) Fourth Market ! private transactions between institutional investors (no intermediary) Financial Markets and Institutions R. Sverdlove 13 Exchanges Formal organizations approved and regulated by the SEC Members ! can only trade listed stocks ! must buy a seat or trading license on the exchange Listing requirements ! minimum capitalization, shareholder equity, average closing share price, etc. Financial Markets and Institutions R. Sverdlove 14 ) NYSE Centralized continuous auction market Exchange participants: ! commission brokers ! independent floor brokers " Work for other brokers ! registered traders " Trade for themselves ! Specialists " one for each stock at a trading post " Market makers: provide liquidity Financial Markets and Institutions R. Sverdlove 15 NYSE (2) SuperDot ! Electronic order system connecting member firms to trading posts Major roles of specialists ! Dealer: make market ! Agent: execute orders ! Catalyst: match buyers and sellers ! Auctioneer: quotes prices Commissions Financial Markets and Institutions R. Sverdlove 16 * NYSE (3) Before 2006, private company owned by members who held seats, which had to be purchased for prices as high as $4 million. Public company since 2006. Seat owners received cash and stock Access to trading floor now requires purchasing a trading license for $40,000 per person per year. Financial Markets and Institutions R. Sverdlove 17 NYSE (4) Currently about 4000 securities are traded on the NYSE ! Common stock ! Preferred stock ! Closed-end and exchange-traded funds ! Corporate bonds About 500 securities houses employ stockbrokers Financial Markets and Institutions R. Sverdlove 18 !+ Financial Markets and Institutions R. Sverdlove Trading on an Exchange 19
Order Order Order
Investor Shares Broker Shares Comm. Shares Market or Maker or
Cash Cash Floor Cash Other Floor Broker Broker
Financial Markets and Institutions R. Sverdlove Stock Market Quotes Name Symbol Open High Low Close Net Chg % Chg Volume 52 Wk High 52 Wk Low Div Yield P/E YTD % Chg 20 !! AMEX (NYSE Alternext) National market for smaller stocks ! About 700 companies listed ! Now includes European issues as well Options Exchange-traded funds Closed-end funds Structured products Financial Markets and Institutions R. Sverdlove 21 U. S. OTC Market Trading unlisted stocks Listing requirements NASDAQ market tiers ! NASDAQ National Market (3600 securities) ! Small Capitalization Market (800 securities) NASDAQ market makers Other OTC markets ! OTC Bulletin Board (3700 securities) ! Pink Sheets (5500 securities) Financial Markets and Institutions R. Sverdlove 22 !# Third Market Listed stocks traded in OTC market NYSE Rule 390 ! Dealers could not be NYSE members ! Repealed in 1999 Network of broker-dealers regulated by the NASD Used by institutions to lower costs and facilitate large trades Upstairs market for block trades Financial Markets and Institutions R. Sverdlove 23 Fourth Market Direct trading of stocks between two investors, using an electronic system ! Lower costs Reporting through NASDAQ Alternative trading systems (ATS) ! electronic communications networks " Use NASDAQ to post actual orders " Like an open limit-order book ! crossing networks Financial Markets and Institutions R. Sverdlove 24 !$ Order Execution Brokers are required to get the best deal for their customers Different markets may offer incentives to brokers to route orders through them. ! Broker must get permission to do this. Customers may instruct broker to carry out the order in a particular market. ! Broker may charge a higher fee for this. Brokers may fill orders themselves ! This is called internalization Financial Markets and Institutions R. Sverdlove 25 Dealers vs. Specialists Specialists are required to maintain fair and orderly markets ! Market can be closed if this is impossible Dealers do not have to maintain markets in particular stocks ! News announcements may cause problems SEC studies have found that trades are cheaper on NYSE, but faster on NASDAQ Financial Markets and Institutions R. Sverdlove 26 !% Regulatory Issues To make markets fair to all traders, everyone must have access to reporting of all trades and execution must be uniform ! Fragmentation of markets works against this. Securities Act of 1975 directed the SEC to establish a national market system ! Intermarket Trading System (ITS) " Quotes for all exchanges and OTC, intermarket execution of trades ! Consolidated Quotation System " Reporting of all trades across markets Financial Markets and Institutions R. Sverdlove 27 Regulatory Issues (2) NASDAQ bid-ask spreads ! In 1994 Christie and Schultz showed that most quotes were in quarters even though eighths were possible ! This was evidence of implicit collusion or price fixing leading to many Wall Street firms being fined by the SEC. ! After their publication, more bid and ask quotes moved to odd eighths, making trading cheaper for investors. ! Regulatory functions of NASD were moved into a new subsidiary, NASDR, in 1996 Financial Markets and Institutions R. Sverdlove 28 !& Regulatory Issues (3) Decimalization ! NYSE price quotes moved from eighths to sixteenths (of a dollar) in 1997 and then to pennies in 2001. ! This again benefits most investors ! In some cases it may benefit specialists, since large trades will be broken up into a larger number of small trades at slightly different prices. Financial Markets and Institutions R. Sverdlove 29 Regulatory Issues (4) Regulation FD ! SEC ruled in 2000 that all information disclosures by companies must be made simultaneously to all interested parties ! Previously analysts and professional money managers would have private meetings with companies and learn about earnings and other announcements before the general public. Financial Markets and Institutions R. Sverdlove 30 !' International Stock Trading Global Depository Receipt (GDR) ! Bank-issued title to shares of stock traded in a foreign country. American Depository Receipt (ADR) ! Tradable right to a foreign share held in trust by a U.S. financial institution that issues the ADR. Depository Receipt ! combination of GDRs and ADRs Euroequity ! Stock issued outside the companys home country Financial Markets and Institutions R. Sverdlove 31 American Depository Receipt Types: ! nonsponsored (created by banks) ! Sponsored (created by the company and 1 bank) Trading Location ! NYSE ! ASE ! OTC market Advantages ! trade stocks on U.S. exchanges ! payments made and received are in U.S. dollars ! avoid some country-specific taxes Financial Markets and Institutions R. Sverdlove 32 !( Trading Mechanisms Types of Orders ! market order: buy now ! limit order: buy if low, sell if high ! stop order: buy if high, sell if low Limit-order book ! List of requested transactions maintained by a specialist ! Execution priority " First come, first served " Public orders ahead of member orders Financial Markets and Institutions R. Sverdlove 33 Trading Mechanisms (2) Short Selling ! Borrowing shares through a broker ! Before July, 2007, only allowed on an uptick to reduce downward momentum Margin Transactions ! Borrowing from a broker to buy stock ! Limit on percent borrowed set by the Federal Reserve Board and exchanges " initial margin (50%) " maintenance margin (25%) " different for different types of transactions Financial Markets and Institutions R. Sverdlove 34 !) Trade Size Stocks are normally traded in multiples of 100 shares or round lots. Any part of an order less than 100 shares is an odd lot and has a higher commission A block trade is for a large number of shares, defined by the NYSE as at least 10,000 or $200,000. Small orders can be sent electronically to the floor by systems such as SuperDot. Financial Markets and Institutions R. Sverdlove 35 Transaction Costs Explicit costs ! Commission ! Transfer and other fees or taxes ! Soft dollars: higher commissions are offset by provision of other services, such as research, for free. ! This is a form of payment for order flow: the broker provides the investor with incentives to use his trading services. Financial Markets and Institutions R. Sverdlove 36 !* Transaction Costs (2) Implicit costs ! Bid-ask spread (part of quoted price) ! Impact cost: large trade can affect price up or down by changing supply or demand ! Timing cost: price change that results from a delay in execution because of trade size ! Opportunity cost: trades not made because of delays and resulting price changes Financial Markets and Institutions R. Sverdlove 37 Transaction Costs (3) Empirical facts ! Implicit costs are economically significant ! More difficult trades to carry out cost more ! Type of market and investment affects cost ! Costs vary among managers ! Trading process has too many variables for accurate prediction of costs What is best execution for institutional traders? Financial Markets and Institutions R. Sverdlove 38 #+ Retail Trading Full service brokers ! Advice and research Discount brokers ! Trading only ! Online accounts Compared to institutional trading: ! Higher explicit costs ! Lower impact cost ! Faster execution Financial Markets and Institutions R. Sverdlove 39 Institutional Trading Most of the market: 97% of trading both by number of trades and by volume Block trades Program trades Negotiated commission arrangements ! Fees depend on success of trade ! Broker-dealer may participate in the risk of the trade ! Brokers asked to bid on commissions may frontrun: buy or sell ahead of the institution " Avoid by specifying trades in general terms Financial Markets and Institutions R. Sverdlove 40 #! Block Trades In 1961, about 9 per day In 2007, 4000-5000 per day on the NYSE Large trades that cannot be filled directly may be broken up into smaller blocks to lower price impact Order of execution ! Upstairs market first (27% of volume) ! Brokerage firm may take a position ! Specialist and floor trading Financial Markets and Institutions R. Sverdlove 41 Program (Basket) Trades Simultaneous purchase or sale of shares in a large number of different stocks, which is computer-assisted. Used by mutual funds to rebalance portfolios for asset allocation or index matching Index arbitrage is a strategy involving simultaneous trading of futures contracts on an index and the underlying stocks of the index Financial Markets and Institutions R. Sverdlove 42 ## Program Trade Execution Agency basis: lowest commission Agency incentive arrangement ! Use benchmark price for each security ! If better prices are obtained, broker gets additional compensation Principal basis: broker buys or sells the portfolio for its own account immediately Financial Markets and Institutions R. Sverdlove 43 Controversial Trading Practices Flash Trading ! Some traders have early access to incoming orders Naked Access ! brokers and exchanges allow some traders to engage in high frequency trades anonymously using the brokers access code Dark Pools ! trades that occur on alternative trading platforms (such as electronic communication networks) that do not report the details of the trade on order books Financial Markets and Institutions R. Sverdlove 44 #$ Flash Trading Flash traders see incoming orders milliseconds ahead of other traders, then use computerized statistical analysis to generate high frequency trading strategies that are executed by computer as well Pro: Flash trading creates more liquidity and the possibility of price improvement Financial Markets and Institutions R. Sverdlove 45 Flash Trading (2) Con: ! Creates a disadvantage for regular traders and investors who are not allowed to view incoming orders ! High volume of trading generated by multiple computers can lead to events like the so called flash crash " On May 6, 2010, markets fell about 5% in a very brief time, only to just as quickly recover most of the loss. " Definitive cause unknown, but supposedly trades of $4.1 billion S&P500 futures contracts by a Kansas City based mutual fund, Asset Strategy Fund, triggered the crash Financial Markets and Institutions R. Sverdlove 46 #% Price Change Limits Stock Market Crash of 1987 ! Market lost almost 25% in one day New regulations to prevent recurrence (Rule 80B) ! Levels for the S&P 500 are set at the end of each day to restrict trading on the following day ! Levels are 7%, 13%, and 20% of the close. ! Trading can be halted if too large a drop occurs in one day: circuit breakers. Financial Markets and Institutions R. Sverdlove 47 Circuit Breakers Financial Markets and Institutions R. Sverdlove 48 Levels 1 and 2 (7% and 13% declines) result in a 15 minute trading halt, at most once per day. Level 3 (20% decline) results in a trading halt for the rest of the day. No halts after 3:25 PM. These rules were revised in 2013. #& Stock Market Indexes Exchange Indexes ! NYSE Composite ! AMEX ! NASDAQ Composite Subjective Selection ! Dow Jones Industrial Average (DJIA) ! S&P 500 ! Value Line Composite Average (VLCA) Selection by Rule (Market Capitalization) ! Russell 1000, 2000, 3000 (large, small, all) ! Wilshire 5000, 4500 (all actively traded stocks) Financial Markets and Institutions R. Sverdlove 49 Stock Market Indexes (2) DJIA is a price-weighted average, adjusted for stock splits and dividends ! Company size has no effect. ! Returns are those of a portfolio with one share of each stock in the index VLCA is an equal-weighted average ! Returns are those of a portfolio with the same number of dollars invested in each stock. ! This portfolio must be rebalanced. Financial Markets and Institutions R. Sverdlove 50 #' Stock Market Indexes (3) Other indexes such as the S&P 500 are value-weighted (by market capitalization) ! Returns are those of a portfolio consisting of all the stock of all the companies in the index. Foreign market indexes ! Japan: Nikkei 225 ! U. K.: FTSE 100 ! Germany: DAX 30 Financial Markets and Institutions R. Sverdlove 51 Stock Market Pricing Efficiency Forms of Efficiency ! Weak form " Prices reflect past price and trading history " Supported by empirical evidence ! Semistrong form " Prices reflect all publicly available information " Supported by some empirical evidence ! Strong form " Prices reflect all information, public or not " Not supported by empirical evidence Financial Markets and Institutions R. Sverdlove 52 #( Stock Market Pricing Efficiency (2) Implications for Investing in Common Stock ! Weak form efficiency means that technical analysis does not work ! Semistrong form efficiency means that " no active strategy, including fundamental analysis, will work " Passive strategies are best (indexing) ! Strong form is not true because insider trading is profitable Financial Markets and Institutions R. Sverdlove 53 International Investing For investors, provides more diversification since national economies are not highly correlated For issuers, provides a larger market for their securities and publicity for their products Financial Markets and Institutions R. Sverdlove 54 #) Multiple Listings Some company stocks are listed on exchanges in several countries These are usually large companies, because of the costs involved ! Must satisfy different accounting and disclosure rules Companies have significant international sales, particularly in countries where they are listed Financial Markets and Institutions R. Sverdlove 55 Multiple Listings (2) Prices are approximately the same in all markets Prices vary with exchange rates If prices were not equivalent, arbitrage would bring them back to equality ! Buy where the price is low, sell where the price is high ! Changing supply and demand brings the prices into line Financial Markets and Institutions R. Sverdlove 56 #* Trading Costs Trading costs vary significantly from one country to another. Costs in the highest-cost markets are about five times the lowest-cost. Costs are higher for small stocks. ! Liquidity premium U. S. costs are about average. Financial Markets and Institutions R. Sverdlove 57 Global Diversification Economic policies and macroeconomic factors are different in each country, so markets are not highly correlated. Closely linked countries have higher correlations, such as U. S. and Canada or Germany and Switzerland. Japan is not highly correlated with any of the other major economies. Financial Markets and Institutions R. Sverdlove 58 $+ Global Diversification (2) Low correlations allow the creation of portfolios with higher returns and lower risk. Increasing globalization of markets may tend to increase correlation between different national markets. ! A larger part of each country's economy is related to global business. ! Correlation may increase in times of crisis: flight to quality Financial Markets and Institutions R. Sverdlove 59 Stock Exchange Ownership Privately Owned Markets ! United States, United Kingdom, Hong Kong, Canada, Japan, Australia Public Institutions ! France, Spain, Italy, Belgium ! Move toward private ownership Banks ! Switzerland, Austria, Germany Financial Markets and Institutions R. Sverdlove 60 $! Stock Market Trends Institutionalization ! Great majority of stock is now held by institutions, not individuals Deregulation ! Happening in many countries Technology ! Trading is moving more and more to electronic media Financial Markets and Institutions R. Sverdlove 61 Derivatives Markets Financial Markets and Institutions R. Sverdlove 62 $# Derivatives A derivative is an instrument whose value depends on the values of other more basic underlying variables. Great variety in todays market. More being developed all the time. The underlying asset can itself be a derivative. Derivative sales involve transfers of risk. Financial Markets and Institutions R. Sverdlove 63 Types of Derivatives Forwards Futures Swaps Options ! Differ from the others in that the underlying transaction may not take place Financial Markets and Institutions R. Sverdlove 64 $$ Underlying Assets Commodities ! Agricultural products ! Minerals Interest rates Foreign currencies Stocks and Stock Indices Financial Markets and Institutions R. Sverdlove 65 Uses of Derivatives To hedge (insure against) risks To speculate (take a view on the future direction of the market) ! Create leverage To lock in an arbitrage profit To change the nature of a liability To change the nature of an investment without incurring the costs of selling one portfolio and buying another Financial Markets and Institutions R. Sverdlove 66 $% Futures Contracts A futures contract is an agreement to buy or sell an asset at a certain time in the future for a certain price By contrast in a spot contract there is an agreement to buy or sell the asset immediately (or within a very short period of time) The contract is guaranteed to be carried out by the exchange and clearinghouse Contract specifies ! Underlying Asset ! Futures Price ! Settlement Date or Delivery Date, usually quarterly Financial Markets and Institutions R. Sverdlove 67 History of Futures Markets Originally developed for agricultural products ! Stabilize income of farmers ! Stabilize prices for users of products Known in some form since middle ages. Chicago Board of Trade founded 1848 ! Futures contracts on grains ! Speculators began trading ! Now includes futures on Treasury securities Financial Markets and Institutions R. Sverdlove 68 $& History of Futures Markets (2) Chicago Mercantile Exchange ! Organized from earlier exchanges in 1919 ! Futures contracts on perishable agricultural products CME started trading in currency futures in 1972 for many major currencies. Trading system ! Traditionally open-outcry: floor traders ! Moving toward more electronic trading Financial Markets and Institutions R. Sverdlove 69 Commodity Futures Agricultural ! Sugar ! Corn ! Soybeans ! Orange Juice ! Pork Bellies ! Wheat ! Lumber ! Financial Markets and Institutions R. Sverdlove 70 $' Commodity Futures (2) Mineral ! Crude oil ! Natural gas ! Heating oil ! Unleaded gasoline ! Gold ! Silver ! Aluminum ! Financial Markets and Institutions R. Sverdlove 71 Financial Futures Financial Instruments ! U.S. Treasury bonds, notes, and bills ! Other government bonds: " U.K., Japan, Germany ! LIBOR ! Eurodollar deposits ! Individual stocks ! GNMA Financial Markets and Institutions R. Sverdlove 72 $( Financial Futures (2) Indices ! Dow Jones Industrial Average ! S&P 500 ! Other country stock indices " U.K., France, Germany, Japan, Europe Currencies ! Euro ! Yen ! Financial Markets and Institutions R. Sverdlove 73 Futures Exchanges Chicago Board of Trade (CBOT) Chicago Mercantile Exchange (CME) London International Financial Futures and Options Exchange (LIFFE) Eurex BM&F (Sao Paulo, Brazil) TIFFE (Tokyo) . . . Different commodities are traded on different exchanges. Two exchanges may offer different contracts on the same commodity. Financial Markets and Institutions R. Sverdlove 74 $) Futures Price The futures price for a particular contract is the price at which you agree to buy or sell It is determined by supply and demand in the same way as a spot price Financial Markets and Institutions R. Sverdlove 75 Futures Contract Examples Agreement to: ! buy 100 oz. of gold @ US$1000/oz. in December (COMEX) ! sell 62,500 @ 1.4537 US$/ in March (CME) ! sell 1,000 bbl. of oil @ US$38/bbl. in April (NYMEX) Financial Markets and Institutions R. Sverdlove 76 $* Futures Positions The party that has agreed to buy (buyer) has a long position The party that has agreed to sell (seller) has a short position To close a position, enter a contract for the opposite position Open interest is the total number of long (= short) positions held at a given time. Financial Markets and Institutions R. Sverdlove 77 Futures Trade Example January: an investor enters into a long futures contract on COMEX to buy 100 oz. of gold @ $925 in April April: the price of gold is $935 per oz. What is the investors profit? Financial Markets and Institutions R. Sverdlove 78 %+ Role of Clearinghouse Functions of Clearinghouse ! guarantees that both parties to futures contracts satisfy their obligations ! simplifies the unwinding of futures positions prior to the settlement date When an investor takes a long (short) position, the Clearinghouse takes the opposite position ! Investor does not make the contract directly with another investor Financial Markets and Institutions R. Sverdlove 79 Futures Regulation Regulation is designed to protect the public interest Regulators try to prevent questionable trading practices by either individuals on the floor of the exchange or outside groups. ! Cornering the market ! Overcharging ! Insider trading Financial Markets and Institutions R. Sverdlove 80 %! Futures Regulation (2) Commodity Futures Trading Commission ! Independent Agency of U.S. government ! Founded 1974, role expanded several times ! Oversees derivatives markets " Exchanges " Clearing organizations Exchanges enforce speculation controls ! Daily price movement limits (like stocks) ! Position limits Financial Markets and Institutions R. Sverdlove 81 Mark-to-Market Futures contracts are marked-to-market (settled) on a daily basis ! a buyer (seller) realizes a profit if the futures price increases (decreases) ! a buyer (seller) realizes a loss if the futures price decreases (increases) Daily price limits restrict the maximum daily price moves Financial Markets and Institutions R. Sverdlove 82 %# Mark-to-Market Example Farmer agrees to sell 100,000 bushels of wheat for $2.80 a bushel in a specified future month. Next day, wheat futures price is $2.75. Farmers profit is 100,000 x $0.05 = $5000, credited to his account. Farmer now has an agreement to sell 100,000 bushels of wheat at the specified time for $2.75 a bushel. Financial Markets and Institutions R. Sverdlove 83 Principle of Convergence At the delivery date, the futures price must equal the cash price. As the delivery date approaches, the futures price converges to the cash price. ! The financing cost approaches zero ! The yield approaches zero ! The cost of carry approaches zero Financial Markets and Institutions R. Sverdlove 84 %$ Financial Markets and Institutions R. Sverdlove Convergence of Futures to Spot 85 Time (a) Futures Price Spot Price Time (b) Futures Price Spot Price Margin The amount (percentage) of a Futures Contract Value that must be on deposit with a broker in cash or marketable securities (e.g., Treasuries). The balance in the margin account is adjusted to reflect daily settlement Margins minimize the possibility of a loss through a default on a contract Financial Markets and Institutions R. Sverdlove 86 %% Margin (2) Since a Futures Contract is not an actual sale, you need only pay a fraction of the asset value to open a position. This fraction is the margin requirement. Minimum margin requirements are set by the exchange. Broker may require a higher level of margin Financial Markets and Institutions R. Sverdlove 87 Margin (3) Initial margin is required when opening a position. Initial margin level depends on the particular contract. Maintenance margin is required later, usually about 75% of initial margin. Variation margin is the amount necessary to bring equity account back to initial margin level Financial Markets and Institutions R. Sverdlove 88 %& Margin (4) Investing on margin creates leverage. For example, with a 30% margin requirement, you can control $100,000 of assets with only $30,000. Gains and losses are magnified. Higher risk, higher potential return. Financial Markets and Institutions R. Sverdlove 89 Margin Call If you have a margin account, and your balance falls below the maintenance level, you must put in enough cash to bring your account back up to the initial margin level. Financial Markets and Institutions R. Sverdlove 90 %' Margin Call Example An investor takes a long position in 2 December gold futures contracts on June 5 ! contract size is 100 oz. ! futures price is US$400 ! Initial margin requirement is US$2,000/contract (US$4,000 in total) ! maintenance margin is US$1,500/contract (US $3,000 in total) Financial Markets and Institutions R. Sverdlove 91 Financial Markets and Institutions R. Sverdlove Margin Call Example (2) 92 Daily Cumulative Margin Futures Gain Gain Account Margin Price (Loss) (Loss) Balance Call Day (US$) (US$) (US$) (US$) (US$) 400.00 4,000 5-Jun 397.00 (600) (600) 3,400 0 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 13-Jun 393.30 (420) (1,340) 2,660 1,340 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 19-Jun 387.00 (1,140) (2,600) 2,740 1,260 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 26-Jun 392.30 260 (1,540) 5,060 0 + = 4,000 3,000 + = 4,000 < %( Market Structure Exchange Trading (like stock exchange) ! Pit ! Seat on the exchange Floor Traders ! Locals " Trade for their own accounts ! Floor or pit brokers ! Futures commission merchant " Trade for paying customers Electronic Trading Systems Financial Markets and Institutions R. Sverdlove 93 Forwards Forwards are over-the-counter contracts negotiated directly between the parties. No money changes hands when the contract is first negotiated. ! Initial contract value is zero The contract is settled once at maturity. ! Usually no marking to market ! Delivery is made at settlement All profit or loss occurs at settlement. Financial Markets and Institutions R. Sverdlove 94 %) Forward Price The forward price for a contract is the delivery price that would be applicable to the contract if it were negotiated today (i.e., it is the delivery price that would make the contract worth exactly zero) The forward price may be different for contracts of different maturities Financial Markets and Institutions R. Sverdlove 95 Forward vs Futures Contracts Forwards Futures Private contract between 2 parties Exchange traded Non-standard contract Standard contract Usually 1 specified delivery date Range of delivery dates Settled at maturity Settled daily Counterparty credit risk Clearinghouse provides guarantee Delivery or final cash settlement usually occurs Usually closed out prior to maturity Financial Markets and Institutions R. Sverdlove 96 %* Forward and Futures Example Investor A enters into a long forward contract to buy 1,000,000 @ 1.4381 US$/ in 90 days Investor B enters into a long futures contract to buy 1,000,000 @ 1.4381 US$/ in 90 days The exchange rate is 1.4600 US$/ in 90 days Both investors make a profit of $21,900 ! Investor A receives all profit on day 90 ! Investor B receives some profit or loss on each of the 90 days. Financial Markets and Institutions R. Sverdlove 97 Hedge Positions Short Hedge ! protects against a decline in the cash price of a financial asset or portfolio ! sell hedge Long Hedge ! protects against an increase in the cash price of a financial asset or portfolio ! buy hedge Financial Markets and Institutions R. Sverdlove 98 &+ Commodity Hedge Example In June, farmer John Smith expects to harvest 10,000 bushels of corn during the month of August. In June, the September corn futures are selling for $2.94 per bushel (1 contract = 5,000 bushels). Farmer Smith wishes to lock in this price. What happens if the September spot price drops to $2.80? Financial Markets and Institutions R. Sverdlove 99 In June, farmer John Smith expects to harvest 10,000 bushels of corn during the month of August. In June, the September corn futures are selling for $2.94 per bushel (1 contract = 5,000 bushels). Farmer Smith wishes to lock in this price. Revenue from Crop: 10,000 x 2.80 28,000 June: Short 2K @ 2.94 = 29,400 Sept: Long 2K @ 2.80 = 28,000 . Gain on Position------------------------------- 1,400 Total Revenue $ 29,400 Commodity Hedge Example (2) Financial Markets and Institutions R. Sverdlove 100 &! Revenue from Crop: 10,000 x 3.05 30,500 June: Short 2K @ 2.94 = 29,400 Sept: Long 2K @ 3.05 = 30,500 . Loss on Position------------------------------- ( 1,100 ) Total Revenue $ 29,400 Commodity Hedge Example (3) What if the spot price rises to $3.05 in September? Financial Markets and Institutions R. Sverdlove 101 Commodity Hedge Example (4) Farmer John Smith has succeeded in locking in the June price. He gets that price whether the spot price increases or decreases. In fact, he gets slightly less because of transaction costs. Financial Markets and Institutions R. Sverdlove 102 &# Cross Hedge A cross hedge is one where the asset underlying the futures contract is similar, but not identical, to the asset in which the investor holds a long or short position. Example: to hedge a position in a diversified stock portfolio, one could take a futures position in the S&P 500 index. A cross hedge is perfect when the ratio of cash asset prices remains the same. Financial Markets and Institutions R. Sverdlove 103 Futures Quotes Financial Markets and Institutions R. Sverdlove 104 &$ Futures Quotes (2) Heading ! Underlying asset ! Exchange ! Contract size ! Price quote units Summary at end ! Estimated volume for day, actual for previous day. ! Total open interest for all contracts and change from previous day. Financial Markets and Institutions R. Sverdlove 105 Futures Quotes (3) Individual contracts ! Maturity date ! Opening, high, and low prices for the day ! Settlement price " Average price of trades just before closing " Used for marking to market ! Change in settlement price ! Lifetime high and low price ! Open interest Financial Markets and Institutions R. Sverdlove 106 &% Futures Quotes Questions When a new trade is completed what are the possible effects on the open interest? Can the volume of trading in a day be greater than the open interest? Financial Markets and Institutions R. Sverdlove 107 Futures Role in Financial Markets More efficient and liquid than asset market Altering exposure to asset risk (hedging) More efficient price discovery Arbitrage process brings prices in line Increased underlying asset price volatility ! Faster reactions to changing information ! Are markets destabilized? Financial Markets and Institutions R. Sverdlove 108 && GAO Financial Derivatives Study Principal Conclusions (1994) ! A legal framework is needed which will set basic standards to effectively manage derivative risk. ! Financial reporting requirements are inadequate for derivative instruments. ! Coordination with foreign regulators is needed. ! Policymakers and regulators should not stifle the use of derivatives. No action was taken but financial market events of 2007-2008 confirm these conclusions Financial Markets and Institutions R. Sverdlove 109 Options The right, not the obligation, to buy or sell a specified amount of a specific asset at a specified price within a specified time period In a futures contract, both parties have an obligation; in an options contract only the seller has an obligation and then only if the buyer asks the seller to do it. Option buyer has a limited, known maximum loss. Option position risk/return profile is asymmetric, while that of a futures position is symmetric. Financial Markets and Institutions R. Sverdlove 110 &' Financial Markets and Institutions R. Sverdlove 111 Mechanics of Options Markets Assets underlying exchange-traded options ! Stocks ! Stock indices ! Foreign currency ! Futures ! Interest rates Specification of exchange-traded options ! Expiration date (maturity) ! Strike price (exercise price) ! European or American: exercise at maturity or any time ! Call or put (option class): option to buy or sell ! Expiration date+strike price+class = option series Option Listings Option/Strike Exp. Vol. Last Vol. Last IBM 130 Oct 364 15.25 107 5.25 138.3 130 Jan 112 19.5 420 9.25 138.3 135 Jul 2365 4.75 2431 0.81 138.3 135 Aug 1231 9.25 94 5.5 138.3 140 Jul 1826 1.75 427 2.75 138.3 140 Aug 2193 6.5 58 7.5 --Put-- --Call-- Financial Markets and Institutions R. Sverdlove 112 &( Moneyness An option is in the money if exercising it now would give a positive cash flow. An option is at the money if exercising it now would give a zero cash flow. An option is out of the money if exercising it now would give a negative cash flow. Financial Markets and Institutions R. Sverdlove 113 Moneyness Examples A call is in (out of) the money if the current stock price is greater (less) than the strike price. A put is in (out of) the money if the current stock price is less (greater) than the strike price. A call or a put is at the money if the current stock price is equal to the strike price. Financial Markets and Institutions R. Sverdlove 114 &) Commissions Commissions on option trades are usually a fixed base plus a percentage of the trade value. Exchanges set maximum and minimum commissions. Another commission must be paid to close out a position. If an option is exercised, the usual stock transaction commission is paid. Financial Markets and Institutions R. Sverdlove 115 Margin Requirements Options cannot be bought on margin since they are already highly leveraged investments. Full payment is required. Margins are required when options are sold, as protection against default by the writer, who has an obligation. Covered options (with corresponding positions in the underlying stock) have lower margin requirements. Financial Markets and Institutions R. Sverdlove 116 &* Risk and Return of Options The purchase of a call (put) is like taking a long (short) position in the underlying asset with a fixed maximum loss. ! Benefits the buyer if the price of the underlying asset rises (falls). ! Benefits the seller if the price of the underlying asset falls (rises) or is unchanged. Financial Markets and Institutions R. Sverdlove 117 Profit from Options Buying a call option produces a profit if the stock price at maturity is more than the strike price plus the option price. Buying a put option produces a profit if the stock price at maturity is less than the strike price minus the option price. Selling a call or put produces a profit when these relations are reversed. Financial Markets and Institutions R. Sverdlove 118 '+ Option Value at Maturity The value of an option at expiration is a function of the stock price and the exercise price.
Example - Option values given an exercise price of $55 Financial Markets and Institutions R. Sverdlove 119 0 0 0 5 15 25 Value Put 25 15 5 0 0 0 Value Call 80 70 60 50 40 $30 Price Stock Long Call Option Payoff Call option payoff to the buyer given a $55 exercise price. Share Price C a l l
o p t i o n
v a l u e
55 75 $20 $0 payoff profit option price Financial Markets and Institutions R. Sverdlove 120 '! Financial Markets and Institutions R. Sverdlove Long Put Option Payoff 121 Put option payoff to the buyer given a $55 exercise price. Share Price P u t
o p t i o n
v a l u e
50 55 $5 $0 option price payoff profit Financial Markets and Institutions R. Sverdlove Short Call Option Payoff 122 Call option payoff to the seller (writer) a $55 exercise price. Share Price C a l l
o p t i o n
$
p a y o f f
55 $0 option price profit payoff '# Financial Markets and Institutions R. Sverdlove Short Put Option Value 123 Put option payoff to the seller (writer) given a $55 exercise price. Share Price P u t
o p t i o n
$
p a y o f f
55 $0 option price profit payoff Profit and Loss Limits Long position has loss limited to option price Short position has profit limited to option price Long call has no theoretical limit to profit Short call has no theoretical limit to loss Long put has profit limited to strike price - option price Short put has loss limited to strike price - option price Financial Markets and Institutions R. Sverdlove 124 '$ Option Leverage If stock price goes up, the profit from a call option is less than the profit from buying a share of the stock by the option price. However, cost of investing in the option is much lower than cost of buying a share. Therefore, the option investment has a much higher return. If the stock doesnt go up and the option expires unexercised, the loss on the investment is 100%. Financial Markets and Institutions R. Sverdlove 125 Economic Role of Options Market Hedging With Futures ! Minimizes the risks of adverse price movements. ! Gives up the benefits of favorable price movements. ! No initial investment required Hedging With Options ! Limits price risk. ! May benefit from favorable price movements. ! May mold a risk/return relationship. ! Investor must pay a premium for this insurance policy Financial Markets and Institutions R. Sverdlove 126 '% Pricing of Options The price of an option consists of two components: the intrinsic value and the time premium. Intrinsic value ! the economic value of the option if exercised immediately, if it is positive. or else zero Time premium ! amount by which the option price exceeds the intrinsic value Financial Markets and Institutions R. Sverdlove 127 Factors Influencing Option Price Current price of the underlying asset Strike price Time to expiration of the option Expected price volatility of the underlying asset over the life of the option Short-term, risk-free interest rate over the life of the option Anticipated cash payments on the underlying asset over the life of the option Financial Markets and Institutions R. Sverdlove 128 '& Variable Effects on Option Values Option Type Variable Eur. call Eur. put Am. call Am. put Stock Price + - + - Strike Price - + - + Maturity ? ? + + Volatility + + + + Interest Rate + - + - Dividend - + - + Financial Markets and Institutions R. Sverdlove 129 + (-) means when variable goes up, option value goes up (down). Option Pricing Models The theoretical option price is determined on the basis of arbitrage arguments. Option Pricing Models ! Binomial Option Pricing Model ! Black-Scholes Option Pricing Model ! Call Price: Financial Markets and Institutions R. Sverdlove 130
C = N(d 1 )S ! E(e !rT )N(d 2 ) d 1 = ln(S / E) + (r +" 2 /2)T " T d 2 = d 1 !"T '' Exotic Options Over the counter options created by dealers to meet specific needs of customers Since they are not exchange traded, they can have any conditions ! Different rules for exercise " Bermuda option can be exercised on a specific set of dates ! Different rules for payoffs Financial Markets and Institutions R. Sverdlove 131 Exotic Option Examples Compound option: option on an option Binary option: fixed payment if price is on the right side of the strike, zero otherwise Lookback option: payoff based on the maximum asset price during the term Asian option: payoff based on the average asset price during the term Exchange option: option to exchange one asset for another asset Financial Markets and Institutions R. Sverdlove 132 '( Swaps A swap is an agreement to exchange cash flows at specified future times according to certain specified rules. Most common types of swaps are those of ! Different interest rates (fixed and floating) on the same principal (notional amount) " Notional is not exchanged ! Cash flows in two different currencies " Notional is exchanged at beginning and end Financial Markets and Institutions R. Sverdlove 133 Other Types of Swaps Cash flows can be based on the returns on two different stock indexes A fixed or floating interest rate can be exchanged for the return on a stock index Credit default swap: a fixed rate is exchanged for a guarantee on the face value of a bond. Financial Markets and Institutions R. Sverdlove 134 ') Swap Markets Swaps are not standardized contracts Swap dealers (financial institutions) keep markets liquid by matching counterparties or by taking positions themselves The International Swaps and Derivatives Association (ISDA) is an association of over 840 members from 58 countries that sets codes of standards for swap documentation Financial Markets and Institutions R. Sverdlove 135 Uses of Currency Swaps Conversion from a liability in one currency to a liability in another currency Conversion from an investment in one currency to an investment in another currency Comparative advantage may lead a borrower to borrow in one currency when it needs the other one. Financial Markets and Institutions R. Sverdlove 136 '* Interest Rate Caps Floating rate loans often have a limit on how much the rate can be increased in each loan period. This limit is called a cap It is a kind of insurance against large rate increases. It is common to have a per-period cap and an overall cap on a floating-rate home mortgage. Financial Markets and Institutions R. Sverdlove 137 Floors and Collars A floor is the opposite of a cap: a limit on how low a floating interest rate can go during a given period. A floor is a put option on the interest rate, where a cap is a call. A collar is a combination of a cap and a floor: the interest rate is limited to a range. Financial Markets and Institutions R. Sverdlove 138 (+ Option Markets Regulation The primary regulator of futures markets is the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) The Securities Exchange Commission (SEC) is the primary regulator of stock options and stock index options The CFTC is the regulator of options on futures contracts Financial Markets and Institutions R. Sverdlove 139 International Derivative Markets The U.S. dominates the global derivative securities markets ! North America accounted for $57.94 trillion of the $96.67 trillion contracts outstanding on organized exchanges in 2007 The euro and European exchanges are expanding ! Europe accounted for $32.28 trillion of the $96.67 trillion contracts outstanding on organized exchanges in 2007 Financial Markets and Institutions R. Sverdlove 140